California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 18, 2001
Student v. San Diego Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 123-01, SN 216-01 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
San Diego Unified denied FAPE for three years; Hearing Officer orders residential placement, compensatory education, and mental health assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 17-year-old eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed filed for hearing against San Diego Unified School District and San Diego County Mental Health. The District filed its own request, and the cases were consolidated. For years the student moved among interim and part-time programs. These included library tutoring three hours a week, short stays at Del Sol Academy and the Metro program, and later the Moyers Program and the District's Learning Center. The District held no IEP meetings for more than a year, did no triennial assessment from 1991 to 2000, and never assessed speech and language. Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found a denial of FAPE in every period reviewed from January 1998 on. His IEPs had no goals for social, emotional, behavioral or attendance needs. They lacked a proper transition plan and offered too little counseling, and services were not delivered or coordinated. Witnesses on both sides, including District staff, supported a structured residential program, and the Hearing Officer ordered one. She found he needs mental health services, including counseling. Mental Health had found him ineligible three times. Because new evidence showed counseling helped him, she granted the District's and Mental Health's request for a full assessment. She ordered compensatory education until he ages out, with the IEP team setting its form. She denied services beyond age 22 and also ordered a speech and language assessment.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated years of interim tutoring, missed triennial assessments, and IEPs without behavioral or transition goals as a denial of FAPE. It also shows a Hearing Officer ordering a residential placement and a county mental health assessment, while leaving the form of compensatory education, ending at age 22, to the IEP team.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Has the San Diego Unified School District provided Student with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
District denied FAPE in every period from January 1998 on: no annual IEPs or triennial assessment, a 3-hour-a-week tutoring placement, IEPs lacking behavioral, emotional, attendance and transition goals, no speech-language assessment, too little counseling, and services not delivered as the IEP required.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Does Student require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?
Based on witnesses who knew him best, including District staff, the student needs a structured residential placement that integrates academic, social, behavioral, emotional and vocational services to benefit from his education.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does Student require mental health services to benefit from his education?
The student needs mental health services that include counseling to benefit from his education; the specifics of other services must be decided after further assessment.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Is Student entitled to compensatory educational services?
Student is entitled to compensatory education, designed by the IEP team, until he ages out of eligibility; the request for five years of services beyond age 22 was denied as too speculative.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue District/Mental Health issue. Should an AB2726 assessment of Student be undertaken by San Diego County Mental Health?
Over the student's objection, the student meets all referral criteria and new evidence that counseling helped him justifies a full Mental Health assessment with specified components.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, District must convene an IEP meeting to (a) designate District personnel responsible for identifying an appropriate residential placement that provides a structured environment integrating services for academic, social, behavioral, emotional and vocational needs, and (b) determine appropriate compensatory educational services.
- Compensatory education. IEP team to determine the form of compensatory education, weighing the student's needs and tolerance for a longer school day against his right to compensation for at least three years of FAPE denial, and considering additional counseling, vocational services and individual tutoring coordinated with the residential program. Services must be implemented within 15 calendar days of the IEP meeting and continue until the student ages out of eligibility. No hours specified.
- Placement ordered. No later than 35 calendar days after the IEP meeting, District must place the student in a residential placement meeting the criteria in order 1.
- Order to assess. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, San Diego County Mental Health must present an assessment plan including information from the District and parent, updated history, psychological testing, a mental status examination, and interviews and observations; Mental Health must complete the assessment and convene an IEP meeting with the District within 30 days of the decision to set mental health services.
- Order to assess. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, District must present a speech and language assessment plan, complete the assessment within Education Code timelines, and convene an IEP meeting to decide whether speech and language services are needed.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm.; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; W.B. v. Matula; State of Conn. U.S.D. No. 1 v. State Dept. of Education; Gov. Code § 7576 (AB 2726); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1
People named in the decision
- Joan Landguth, volunteer advocate for Student; witness
- Bernice Stanley, program manager for due process, San Diego Unified School District
- Joe Concellosi, program manager; issued 2000 eligibility denial memo, San Diego County Mental Health
- Thomas Nelson, attorney observer at hearing
- Eugene Shiller, Ph.D., mental health assessor (1994 assessment); witness on mental health assessment components, San Diego County Mental Health
- Max Warren, L.C.S.W., mental health assessor (1999 records review), San Diego County Mental Health
- Lorraine Jeanes, OCIIP supervisor; witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Shirlee Gibbs, special education administrator; witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Roxie Jackson, program manager, Del Sol Academy; witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Mike McCarthy, vocational resource teacher, Metro program; witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Malkeia Cheketchsha, school psychologist; conducted March 2000 psychoeducational assessment, San Diego Unified School District
- Ms. Faris-Cole, coordinator, Learning Center; witness, San Diego Unified School District
- John Coombs, vocational rehabilitation counselor, San Diego Unified School District
- Greg Bisbee, school-to-work transition specialist, Learning Center / San Diego Unified School District
- Lindy Smith, MFT, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; conducted behavioral assessment; expert witness for Student
- Stein School, certified nonpublic school (prior placement)
- Moyers Program, certified nonpublic agency (reading program)
- Del Sol Academy, District alternative program
- New Dawn, District transition program
- Metro program, District vocational training program
- Hungry Tiger ROP, Regional Occupational Program food preparation class at Morse High School
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on February 8, 9, 27, and 28, and March 21, 22, 23, and 26, 2001.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael S. Cochrane. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was volunteer advocate Joan Landguth. STUDENT was present at the hearing on March 21, 2001. STUDENT’s mother was present at the beginning of the hearing on February 8, 2001, and on March 21, 2001. STUDENT’s grandparents were present at the beginning of the hearing on February 8, 2001. The San Diego Unified School District was represented at the hearing by assistant general counsel Ricardo Soto. Also present on behalf of the District, except for February 27 and 28, was Bernice Stanley, program manager for due process. San Diego County Mental Health was represented at the hearing by Lisa M. Macchione, senior deputy county counsel for the County of San Diego. Also present on behalf of Mental Health was Joe Concellosi, program manager. Attorney Thomas Nelson was present as an observer on March 21, 22, and 23, 2001. STUDENT Johnson, legal intern with the District, was present as an observer on March 22, 2001.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following oral closing arguments by telephone on March 26, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
The Student’s Issues(Footnote 1)
(1) Has the San Diego Unified School District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
(2) Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?
(3) Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from his education?
(4) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
The District and Mental Health’s Issue
Should an AB2726 assessment of STUDENT be undertaken by San Diego County Mental Health?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 17-year-old student. He is eligible for special education because of an emotional disturbance (ED). STUDENT’s cognitive skills are estimated to fall in the borderline range.(Footnote 2) However, his academic skills are minimal. He reads at a beginning second-grade level. He is able to add and subtract without borrowing or carrying. His fund of knowledge is limited.(Footnote 3) STUDENT’s current individualized educational program (IEP) calls for placement in the Learning Center and Morse High School with counseling and social work services. STUDENT also is eligible for Regional Center services because of a diagnosis of epilepsy. STUDENT has not experienced seizures for several years and he does not presently take any medication to control seizure activity.
STUDENT’s mother reported that STUDENT began having behavioral difficulties at home and school when he was three years old. At home, STUDENT hit and picked on his younger siblings and threatened his mother. STUDENT is one of six children in the family. At school, STUDENT threw scissors and rocks, kicked and fought with other children, and ran off the school campus. The IEP team initially determined STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria because of a specific learning disability and speech and language deficits. STUDENT attended a specific language program while in kindergarten and the first grade. In the second grade, STUDENT’s special education designation was changed to emotionally disturbed and he was placed in a special day class (SDC) for students with emotional disturbances. The school reduced the length of STUDENT’s school day because of his behavior. STUDENT got in fights at school, ran off the school campus, and had out-of-control tantrums. STUDENT also was placed on home study for a period of time.
The District referred STUDENT to San Diego County Mental Health for an assessment in 1994. Eugene Shiller, Ph.D., completed the assessment and concluded that “due to the presence and overwhelming organic brain condition, STUDENT does not appear appropriate for the mental health services provided by AB 3632.”(Footnote 4) Mental Health’s Exhibit 2I. STUDENT attended the Stein School, a certified nonpublic school (NPS) from approximately April 1994 until his mother removed him in April 1997 to visit family members living out of state. Stein serves students with mental retardation or emotional disturbances who also have behavioral issues. STUDENT’s IEP placing him at Stein called for counseling sessions twice weekly for thirty minutes each. When STUDENT’s family returned to San Diego in September 1997, STUDENT was not readmitted to Stein. STUDENT’s mother attempted to enroll him in his neighborhood school without success. The school told PARENT that STUDENT was already enrolled at Stein. On December 18, 1997, the District placed STUDENT in its Off Campus Interim Instructional Program (OCIIP) while awaiting placement at Stein.(Footnote 5) Through OCIIP, STUDENT received tutoring three times each week for one hour each session at the public library. Tutoring was provided by college students under the supervision of a credentialed teacher.
STUDENT continued in the OCIIP program until January 14, 1999, when the IEP team met to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT. STUDENT had not been attending the tutoring sessions for several months. STUDENT’s IEP included two goals--to attend and participate in school and to comply with school rules. The IEP also included a plan to transition STUDENT to his dual placement in New Dawn and the Del Sol Academy. The IEP document states that the placement was a “trial program” to be evaluated by the IEP team by April 30, 1999. New Dawn is a program designed to assist students returning from an NPS placement who continue to have behavioral issues that make it difficult to immediately enter a comprehensive high school. Del Sol is designed as an alternative to placing students in an NPS. Del Sol targets students with complex learning disabilities requiring intensive instruction. The students generally are functioning significantly below grade level and have been in a variety of placements or are returning to the District from an NPS. The Del Sol staff includes teachers, a speech and language pathologist, an occupational therapist, a counselor, and a psychologist. There are 10 students in a class with a teacher and up to three instructional assistants. Students receive individualized instruction in specific basic skills. Lorraine Jeanes, OCIIP supervisor, implemented the transition plan. She took STUDENT to visit New Dawn and Del Sol, and accompanied him to class following his enrollment. On his first visit to New Dawn, STUDENT had a confrontation with another student over the color of his clothes and refused to attend New Dawn. STUDENT attended Del Sol for approximately eight days.
In February 1999, the District made a second referral to Mental Health for an assessment of STUDENT’s eligibility for mental health services. Max Warren, L.C.S.W., determined from a review of available records that STUDENT was not eligible for mental health services. Mr. Warren concluded that STUDENT would not benefit from insight oriented therapy, counseling, or group therapy because of his diagnosis of a conduct disorder and lack of cognitive ability.
STUDENT’s next IEP, developed in March 1999, called for him to receive tutoring three times each week through the Options program pending placement in an unspecified NPS “as soon as possible.” STUDENT infrequently participated in tutoring. In March 1999, PARENT filed for a due process hearing (SN 311-99). A mediated agreement dated April 8, 1999, states that the District would continue to look for a nonpublic school placement. At a second mediation on June 23, 1999, the District agreed to place STUDENT in the Metro vocational training program. Metro serves high school students with emotional disturbances or learning disabilities who have not been successful on comprehensive high school campuses. Metro operates seven classes located on five different sites. Students in the transitional skills program receive instruction in core subjects such as reading and mathematics. Speech and language and counseling services are available. Some students are placed in jobs, and others do voluntary community service. Students engage in recreation and leisure activities to build social skills. STUDENT first attended Metro on January 11, 2000.(Footnote 7) He was placed in the transitional skills program and received individualized instruction in applied mathematics and English. He attended Metro for 11 or 12 days.
In March 2000, Malkeia Cheketchsha, school psychologist, completed an assessment of STUDENT. The District’s previous psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT had been conducted in 1991.(Footnote 8) Ms. Cheketchsha’s assessment identified significant processing, social, and academic deficits. (Student’s Exhibit 33) Ms. Cheketchsha made a third referral to Mental Health for an assessment of STUDENT. The IEP team reviewed Ms. Cheketchsha’s assessment on March 27, 2000. (District’s Exhibit 8) The IEP developed on that date called for STUDENT’s placement in a special day class at Morse High School, STUDENT’s neighborhood high school, to include physical education and study skills, and placement in the Moyers Program, a nonpublic agency. The IEP also called for counseling. However, the frequency or duration of counseling is not indicated on the IEP document.
Reports resulting from investigations of compliance complaints filed with the California Department of Education on behalf of STUDENT were issued in April and November 2000. The CDE found the District out of compliance in many areas related to assessing STUDENT, developing IEPs, and providing STUDENT with a free appropriate public education. (Students’ Exhibits 9 and 14)
In a memo dated May 4, 2000, Mr. Concellosi denied STUDENT’s eligibility for Mental Health services stating that it is “unlikely this student would benefit from a cognitive, insight oriented psycho therapeutic program.” (Mental Health’s Exhibit 1)
At an IEP meeting on May 16, 2000, the IEP team reiterated its agreement to place STUDENT at the Moyers Program and Morse High School. (District’s Exhibit 7) The IEP states that STUDENT would enroll in an SDC on a comprehensive school site for 5 to 10 hours each week and at Moyers for 4 to 6 hours daily. The IEP also calls for 15 minutes of counseling each week. STUDENT initially attended Moyers one hour daily for instruction in reading. In June, STUDENT’s program at Moyers increased to two hours daily. He did not enroll in a comprehensive school and he did not receive counseling. On September 16, 2000, Moyers closed and students attending Moyers, including STUDENT, were transferred to the District’s Learning Center.(Footnote 9) The District provides STUDENT transportation to the Learning Center by taxi. The Learning Center is a part-time program that provides systematic direct instruction to remediate underlying processing problems and to address deficits in basic reading, writing, and mathematics skills. STUDENT’s program at the Learning Center is approximately three hours daily. Following his enrollment at Learning Center, STUDENT was frequently absent due to seven root canal dental procedures. STUDENT then had good attendance for approximately eight weeks.
An IEP drafted on October 16, 2000, again calls for STUDENT to also attend Morse High School. This IEP indicates that the Morse placement would consist of two periods in the Regional Occupational Program (ROP) and one period in a physical education class. Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT was to receive one hour per week of counseling, a one-to-one aide, and social work services. The IEP also includes a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) to address verbal aggression toward adults. Another IEP meeting was convened on November 17, 2000, to explore the reasons STUDENT was not attending Morse. Apparently, Morse would not accept STUDENT until he had disenrolled at Del Sol. John Coombs, vocational rehabilitation counselor, met with STUDENT at his home to identify STUDENT’s interests and to develop a transition plan. STUDENT expressed an interest in food services. Once the enrollment problems were cleared up, STUDENT enrolled in the Hungry Tiger ROP for two hours daily. Students in the Hungry Tiger program learn to prepare food. The one-to-one aide walked to school with STUDENT on the first day and remained with him during the Hungry Tiger program. STUDENT did not return the next day. The aide called STUDENT and encouraged him to attend. STUDENT then attended the Hungry Tiger program another day or two. The aide continued to contact STUDENT on a daily basis but he did not again attend the Hungry Tiger program. STUDENT was to receive federal minimum pay for his work at the Hungry Tiger.
On November 17, 2000, STUDENT was released from probation. Since then, his attendance at the Learning Center has been sporadic. He attended one time in December, five times in January, and one time in February. STUDENT has received “informal” counseling at the Learning Center. He has not received social work services. Through the Learning Center, STUDENT was referred to Greg Bisbee, a school-to-work transition specialist, who has arranged for STUDENT to work at the naval base stocking warehouse shelves. STUDENT has worked approximately ten days since November. Mr. Bisbee provides STUDENT with transportation to the base.
On January 18, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT (SN 123-01). On February 2, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for hearing from the District (SN 216-01). Both requests named Mental Health as a Respondent. On February 5, 2001, the cases were consolidated and proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
THE STUDENT’S ISSUES
ISSUE NO. (1): Has the San Diego Unified School District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that is provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000, 56031. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
In summary, the inquiry is twofold. The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. The second inquiry under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley is whether the proposed educational program is designed to meet the student's unique needs and to provide the student with some educational benefit, and whether the program conforms with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
January 1998 to January 1999(Footnote 10)
Procedural Appropriateness
Among the procedural rights that extend to parents is the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the student; the right to participate in the development of the student’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S. C. § 1415(b).
STUDENT contends that the school failed to review his IEP annually and failed to develop an IEP when he was placed in the District’s OCIIP. The IEP team must meet whenever there has been an initial formal assessment, when a student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress, when there is a request to develop, review, or revise, the IEP, and “at least annually, to review the pupil’s progress, the individualized education program, including whether the annual goals for the pupil are being achieved, and the appropriateness of placement, and to make any necessary revisions. Ca. Educ. Code § 56343 (a) - (d). When STUDENT entered the OCIIP in December 1997, his most recent IEP had been developed in 1996 and called for placement in an NPS. The next IEP meeting did not occur until January 1999. Thus, the District failed to convene an IEP team meeting to revise STUDENT’s IEP to reflect a change in placement or to conduct the annual review of STUDENT’s progress. Because there were no IEP meetings, STUDENT’s parent was denied the opportunity to participate in the development of an educational program and placement for STUDENT.
Additionally, STUDENT’s progress or lack thereof had not been evaluated for an extended period of time, making it difficult to know whether the services he was receiving were addressing his needs. The District is required to assess a special education student at least once every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). When STUDENT entered the OCIIP in December 1997, he had not been assessed by the District since 1991. Because the District failed to conduct timely triennial assessments of STUDENT, the IEP team lacked contemporary information regarding STUDENT’s present level of performance and objective measures of his achievement from which to develop goals and objectives and determine an appropriate placement. As discussed more fully below, STUDENT’s needs were not addressed in the OCIIP and he was not making educational progress. Therefore, the failure to timely assess and convene IEP meetings resulted in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
Off Campus Interim Instructional Program (OCIIP)
It is necessary to have some understanding of STUDENT’s educational needs as they existed in 1998 to determine whether the program and placement offered by the District were appropriate. PARENT described STUDENT’s behavior. Her testimony as to STUDENT’s behavior at home and at school was undisputed. STUDENT exhibited explosive and aggressive behavior that was directed both at other children and at adults. STUDENT’s IEP drafted in November 1996 also states that STUDENT had significant learning deficits in addition to behavioral, social, and emotional problems that required intensive special education services. STUDENT’s reading skills were then at a primary/beginning level. He had some computational math skills. However, STUDENT’s math skills were below grade level as were his spelling and writing skills. STUDENT then was 13 years old.
STUDENT’s 1996 IEP states that STUDENT’s behavior interfered with the acquisition of academic skills. The IEP also states that STUDENT did well with direct one-to-one instruction using a multisensory approach. STUDENT’s IEP also indicates that he required a structured schedule and environment, and a behavioral intervention plan to address behavioral difficulties. To address emotional problems, STUDENT required individual and group counseling. (Student’s Exhibit 19) The testimony of Ms. Landguth, PARENT, and Lorraine Jeanes establishes that STUDENT continued to have the same needs during the time period of January 1998 to January 1999 as were identified on his 1996 IEP. Ms. Jeanes’ testimony is compelling because of her familiarity with STUDENT and the OCIIP. Ms. Jeanes shared responsibility for supervision of the OCIIP tutors during 1998 and 1999. Therefore, it is concluded that to address academic deficits, STUDENTrequired specific instruction utilizing a multisensory approach in reading, writing, spelling, and mathematics. To address social and behavioral deficits, STUDENT required a structured environment and implementation of a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). Finally, to address emotional difficulties, STUDENT required counseling.
The last IEP, developed in November 1996, included goals and objectives to improve social behaviors, social/emotional/behavioral skills, and reading and math skills. Because there was no later IEP to update STUDENT’s functional levels, it is difficult to determine the appropriateness of those specific goals and objectives. However, the testimony of both STUDENT’s and the District’s witnesses establishes that the goal areas remained appropriate for STUDENT. (Student’s Exhibit 19)
STUDENT contends that the OCIIP was not designed to meet his needs and did not provide him with educational benefit. The District essentially concurs. Ms. Jeanes and Shirlee Gibbs, District special education administrator, testified regarding the OCIIP. Ms. Jeanes and Ms. Gibbs both had responsibility for the OCIIP. Both testified that the OCIIP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Their testimony establishes that the OCIIP program was designed to address the educational needs of students on an interim basis and for no longer than one semester. STUDENT was in the OCIIP for more than one year awaiting placement in an NPS. While in the OCIIP, STUDENT received tutoring three times a week from college students at a public library. Thus, STUDENT received significantly less instruction than his chronological peers.(Footnote 11) STUDENT recalled that a majority of the instruction was in mathematics, while some instruction addressed reading. There is no evidence that STUDENT received instruction in content areas. Given STUDENT’s learning deficits, three hours weekly was insufficient to address his academic deficits. Additionally, STUDENT had significant social and behavioral difficulties. Ms. Jeanes and Ms. Gibbs testified that the OCIIP did not address STUDENT’s behavioral and social skills deficits. He did not receive counseling while in the OCIIP. The OCIIP also did not provide STUDENT any opportunities to interact with peers to develop appropriate social skills. Therefore, it is concluded that the District did not offer STUDENT a program that was designed to meet his needs.
Prior to STUDENT’s placement in the OCIIP, his behavioral and social difficulties were pervasive and interfered with his education to the extent that he was removed from a District SDC to a more restrictive private school placement, Stein, where he received counseling and participated in an educational program designed to assist students with learning and behavioral difficulties. The OCIIP did not include social or behavioral programs, and provided him with limited academic instruction. Since STUDENT required intervention to ameliorate his behavioral, emotional, and social problems, it is concluded that the OCIIP was not designed to provide him with educational benefit. Additionally, the testimony of Ms. Jeanes and Ms. Gibbs establishes that, in fact, STUDENT did not receive meaningful educational benefit from the OCIIP. Specifically, STUDENT did not maintain the minimal reading skills he had prior to entering the OCIIP and he continued to exhibit social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties.
The OCIIP placement also did not conform with STUDENT’s last IEP, which called for placement in an NPS with counseling and a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). STUDENT did not receive counseling while in the OCIIP. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s tutors implemented a BIP. Additionally, STUDENT’s IEP did not specify that his school day would be shorter than that of his chronological peers. See Cal. Code Regs. § 3001(q).
Finally, STUDENT’s placement in the OCIIP was not in the least restrictive environment. Special education must be provided in a manner that promotes maximum interaction between children with disabilities and children with their typically developing peers. STUDENT did not have any opportunities to interact with peers during his lengthy stay in the OCIIP.
In summary, for the period January 1998-1999, the District’s offer of placement in the OCIIP did not conform with the requirements of an appropriate placement pursuant to Rowley and the IDEA. The placement also did not satisfy LRE requirements.
January 1999 to March 2000
Procedural Appropriateness
At the beginning of 1999, STUDENT’s triennial assessment remained well overdue. It is noted on his IEP developed on January 14, 1999, that “academic skill levels are significantly below grade level and diagnostic information is needed for programming in all areas.” (Student’s Exhibit 26) The IEP also states that an assessment plan would be developed by February 1999 and the assessment would be completed by April 1999. No assessment took place during this time period. Without accurate information regarding STUDENT’s abilities, the IEP team, including PARENT, was significantly hampered in its ability to develop goals and objectives and determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The failure to have accurate information regarding STUDENT’s present level of performance affected the manner in which STUDENT’s program was developed and seriously infringed on the parent’s right to participate meaningfully in the development of the IEP. Additionally, the lack of information led to an inadequate IEP. (See below for further discussion of STUDENT’s IEP.) STUDENT’s IEP does not include any academic goals and objectives. It also does not include services, such as counseling. Therefore, the failure of the District to conduct an assessment resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
Del Sol Academy/New Dawn
As to STUDENT’s needs as identified in January 1999, it is undisputed that STUDENT’s academic skills were significantly below grade level in mathematics, written language, and reading. STUDENT’s IEP states that he required intensive and supportive services from a nonpublic school. (Student’s Exhibit 26) The IEP states that STUDENT was violent and uncontrollable at home and that he refused to attend school. The testimony of Ms. Landguth and Ms. Jeanes, in particular, further establishes that STUDENTcontinued to have significant behavioral difficulties for which he required behavioral intervention and counseling.
As to whether the District offered an appropriate placement at the IEP meeting in January 1999, it is first necessary to review the IEP to determine whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The IEP includes two goals. The first is to “attend & participate in school.” The second is to “comply with school rules.” The first goal does not include any objectives or benchmarks and it is unclear how the goal was to be implemented. Several District witnesses testified that the goals and objectives were “entirely appropriate,” given that STUDENT had failed to attend the OCIIP tutoring sessions for the past several months. However, because the scope of the goals and objectives is limited, it is concluded that they were not designed to address STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in academics, social, behavioral, and emotional areas. The IEP does not address any of these areas. Additionally, STUDENT was nearly 16 years old and required a transition plan. When a student reaches age 14, a statement of the transition service needs of the pupil must be included in the IEP. The term “transition services” means a coordinated set of activities for the student that promotes movement from school to post-school activities, is based on the student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests; includes instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives and the acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1. STUDENT’s IEP is deficient in that it does not include a transition plan. There are two references to “transition” in the IEP. The first is related to assisting STUDENT’s transition from the OCIIP to Del Sol/New Dawn. The other reference to “transition” describes the transition service needs of STUDENT as “attend & participate in school program.” Neither of the above references satisfies the requirements of a transition plan as set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1.
STUDENT’s IEP dated January 14, 1999, called for placement in the Del Sol Academy and New Dawn. Roxie Jackson, program manager, testified that Del Sol offered STUDENT instruction appropriate to his academic level. However, she determined that STUDENT was not appropriately placed at Del Sol because there was insufficient support for him. While attending Del Sol, STUDENT was defiant, used profanity, and was disruptive to the other students. Ms. Jackson removed STUDENT from the program after approximately eight days.
To address STUDENT’s social and behavioral difficulties, the District offered STUDENT placement in the New Dawn program. New Dawn had available a school psychologist and a counselor to provide the students with support throughout the school day. However, Ms. Gibbs testified that New Dawn was designed for students who were on track to graduate from high school. STUDENT’s academic skills and lack of school credits would not place STUDENT on track to earn a diploma. Considering the testimony of Ms. Jackson and Ms. Gibbs, and the lack of sufficient goals, objectives, and services in the IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of placement on January 14, 1999, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
The District’s offer of placement also was not designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Ms. Jackson’s testimony is persuasive as to STUDENT’s need for more support to be able to benefit from the program. Ms. Jackson managed the Del Sol program and is familiar with the program and with STUDENT’s needs. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s needs had changed since the prior IEP wherein it was concluded that STUDENT required a structured program with the support services of counseling and a BIP to address behavioral issues that were impeding his ability to benefit from instruction. Additionally, without goals and objectives and services or contemporary levels of performance, there is no guidance to the staff working with STUDENT as to what instruction he requires to benefit from his education. Therefore, it is concluded that the District’s offer was not designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Because the Del Sol program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or to provide him with educational benefit, it is concluded that the District’s offer of placement contained in the IEP dated January 14, 1999, failed to satisfy the requirements of Rowley and, therefore, did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
The Options Program
When STUDENT was released from the Del Sol Academy, the District proposed in an IEP dated March 16, 1999, that STUDENT participate in the Options Program until an appropriate nonpublic placement could be identified. The Options Program as offered to STUDENT was virtually the same as the OCIIP. It has been determined above that the OCIIP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, it is concluded that the Options Program was not appropriate. Moreover, a specific nonpublic school was never identified or offered to STUDENT.
The Metro Program
As a result of mediation in June 1999, the parties agreed to place STUDENT in the Metro Program. However, STUDENT’s placement in the Metro Program did not occur until January 2000. The Metro program focused on older students with emotional and/or learning disabilities. STUDENT was scheduled to attend Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays from 10:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. STUDENT’s IEP was not modified, amended, or changed in any way to reflect his attending Metro. Thus, the deficiencies identified above related to the lack of goals, objectives, and services remained.
As to whether the Metro Program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs despite the lack of evidence of an appropriate IEP, Mike McCarthy, vocational resource teacher, testified regarding the Metro Program. STUDENT was placed in the transitional program that was designed to provide him with instruction in applied mathematics and reading, and to teach him job readiness skills. Thus, the Metro program was designed to address STUDENT’s need to develop vocational skills. However, the academic program, which was provided one-to-one, was not designed to meet his needs. Mr. McCarthy testified that STUDENT was not interested in completing the math or English packets. Ms. Landguth testified that the reading program was well above STUDENT’s reading abilities. STUDENT testified that his teacher at Metro also told him that the program was not appropriate for him because he could not read. The above testimony was not disputed.
Furthermore, Mr. McCarthy testified that STUDENT was not successful in the Metro program because he was “obviously emotionally disturbed” and living an “unstructured life.” Mr. McCarthy described STUDENT as “immature, explosive, and volatile.” For example, Mr. McCarthy stated that if anyone spoke to STUDENT, he would get angry. However, it was Mr. McCarthy’s testimony that students in the Metro program are not subject to Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plans. The District did not offer STUDENT any form of counseling. Thus, while STUDENT was attending Metro, there was no behavioral intervention plan or services in place to address his social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties. The above testimony establishes that the Metro program was not designed to address STUDENT’s needs because it lacked an appropriate academic program and services to address STUDENT’s social or behavioral deficits
The Metro program also was not designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Mr. McCarthy’s testimony establishes that for STUDENT to benefit from the program, he required a behavioral intervention program or counseling. No such program was available at Metro nor did the District offer behavioral or mental health services to STUDENT.
The last IEP includes a statement that STUDENT was placed in the Options program “until NPS placement is made” and that an NPS placement would be made “as soon as possible.” (District’s Exhibit 12) Metro is not an NPS. Thus, placement at Metro was not consistent with STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT’s placement at Metro resulted from a mediated settlement. Seven months passed before implementation of the agreement. STUDENT did not receive any services from the District during the seven months and, when ultimately placed in Metro, it did not offer him an appropriate placement.
In summary, from January 1999 to January 2000, the District’s procedural violations and its failure to offer a substantively appropriate program in New Dawn and Del Sol, in the Options program, or in the Metro program, resulted in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT.
March 2000 to September 2000
Procedural Appropriateness
Morse High School/Moyers Program
School districts are required to assess students with disabilities in all areas related to the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). STUDENT asserts that by failing to assess his speech and language skills, the District did not assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Ms. Landguth testified that a speech and language assessment was warranted because STUDENT has language and processing difficulties. He also does not read social cues. Ms. Landguth noted that STUDENT previously qualified for special education because of speech and language deficits. Ms. Landguth’s testimony was supported by the findings of language processing deficits on the District’s much belated triennial assessment in March 2000. However, because the District’s assessment did not include a speech and language assessment, the IEP team lacked sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s speech and language strengths, weaknesses, and present levels of functioning to make decisions regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs.(Footnote 12) Thus, PARENT’s participation in the IEP process was infringed upon. STUDENT had previously been eligible for speech and language services and further information gathered from an assessment may have entitled STUDENT to speech and language services. For these reasons, it is concluded that the failure to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability resulted in the loss of educational opportunity. Thus, the failure to assess in all areas of suspected disability resulted in a denial of FAPE pursuant to W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Substantive Appropriateness
In March 2000, Malkeia Cheketchsha, District psychologist, assessed STUDENT. According to Ms. Cheketchsha’s testimony, her assessment found STUDENT functioning at a kindergarten level in reading, a first grade level in spelling, and a second grade level in mathematics. STUDENT’s visual-motor, perceptual, and auditory processing skills fell within the borderline range. (See also Student’s Exhibit 33) Ms. Cheketchsha recommended structured and concrete learning experiences and “significant patience and instructional accommodation” to address STUDENT’s style of processing. The assessment found STUDENT had difficulty socializing. Ms. Cheketchsha described him as “very impulsive and [having] problems delaying his immediate gratification.” Ms. Cheketchsha recommended ongoing social skills training. She also recommended an eclectic, multifaceted curriculum with emphasis on life survival and independent living skills, prevocational and vocational development, and career exploration activities. Ms. Landguth and Ms. Cheketchsha testified that an appropriate vocational program should teach STUDENT skills such as showing up on time, making eye contact, and sequencing job steps. Additional difficulties included school attendance, concentration, and disruptive behavior. The results of the assessment were discussed and adopted at an IEP meeting on March 27, 2000. (District’s Exhibit 8)
In summary, because of academic deficits, attentional problems, and processing difficulties, STUDENT required structured and concrete learning experiences. To address social deficits, he required social skills training. STUDENT required a program to address school attendance, emotional, and behavioral difficulties. STUDENT also required instruction to develop job skills to prepare him to transition from school to work.
As to whether the program and placement developed at the IEP meeting on March 27, 2000, were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, Mr. McCarthy testified that the IEP contains a “sensible” number of goals given that STUDENT was just beginning to attend school. The IEP includes goals and objectives to improve time management, reading word recognition skills, attendance, attention span, and math skills. However, the goals and objectives are deficient given that there are no goals or objectives to address social, emotional, or behavioral difficulties. The lack of appropriate goals is significant given the finding of the IEP team that STUDENT had “severe difficulty with social and emotional issues affecting behavioral and school performance.” Moreover, to be substantively appropriate, a special education IEP must target all of a student’s unique educational needs, whether academic or nonacademic. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm., 998 F.2d 1083, 1089 (1st Cir. 1993). The IEP also is deficient in that is does not include any goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s need to develop skills to transition from school to work and does not include a transition plan as required under Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1.
As to services to address STUDENT’s needs, the IEP developed in March provides for counseling. However, the IEP fails to identify the time and frequency of counseling. The IEP must specify the amount of services. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 51. An IEP developed two months later states that counseling will be provided beginning on May 16, 2000, for 15 minutes weekly.(Footnote 13)
The IEP calls for placement at Morse High School for physical education and study skills, and at Moyers, a certified nonpublic agency (NPA), for a reading program. There was little testimony regarding the proposed placement at Morse. No one described the P.E. and study skills classes that had been proposed at various IEP meetings from March to November 2000. Due to the lack of information, it cannot be concluded that it was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or to provide him with educational benefit.
The testimony of Ms. Landguth and District witnesses establishes that the Moyers program employed appropriate techniques to address STUDENT’s reading deficits. The Moyers program used multisensory techniques and one-to-one instruction. STUDENT also participated in learning activities on the computer. To address reading goals, STUDENT received instruction using Lindamood-Bell techniques. To the extent that the Moyers program addressed STUDENT’s reading and processing deficits utilizing appropriate teaching techniques, the Moyers program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT testified that the Moyers program helped him learn to read. He also found the teacher helpful. Ms. Landguth also stated that STUDENT made some progress while attending Moyers. Based on their testimony, it is concluded that Moyers was designed to provide STUDENT benefit in that it offered a program to address processing deficits and to increase his reading skills.
As to whether the placement conformed to STUDENT’s IEP, the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not receive counseling during the period he attended Moyers. There was some confusion over whether Moyers would accept STUDENT because of a requirement that his parent participate in parenting classes. This requirement ultimately was waived. However, it delayed STUDENT’s placement at Moyers until May 2000. STUDENT’s placement in P.E. and study skills classes at Morse did not occur due to confusion regarding his enrollment and the availability of an aide.(Footnote 14) Therefore, the placement and services STUDENT received only partially conformed with his IEPs developed in March and May 2000.
In summary, procedural errors and substantive deficiencies, specifically the lack of goals, objectives, and services to address STUDENT’s needs, and the failure to provide a program that conformed to STUDENT’s IEPs, resulted in a denial of FAPE during the period from March 2000 to September 2000.
2000 to 2001 School Year
The Learning Center/Morse High School
STUDENT contends that the District has failed to offer him a FAPE for the current school year because he requires additional services and a more restrictive placement than the District has offered him. STUDENT asserts that he requires mental health services to address emotional and behavioral issues. These services may include medication and medication monitoring in addition to therapy. STUDENT asserts that he requires a behavioral intervention plan to address his lack of school attendance and inappropriate behavior at school, social skills training, vocational services, and instruction in the basic skills of reading writing, and mathematics. STUDENT additionally asserts that he requires a structured and integrated program. The District contends that it has offered STUDENT a FAPE and that STUDENT has not taken advantage of the placement and services available to him.
The testimony of witnesses called on behalf of STUDENT and the District establishes that STUDENT’s needs did not change appreciably for the 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Faris-Cole, Ms. Landguth, and Dr. Smith testified that an appropriate placement for STUDENT must be highly structured and the services must be integrated. Given their familiarity with STUDENT and his needs, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive on this issue. STUDENT continued to require structured and concrete learning experiences to remediate significant academic deficits, social skills training to address social difficulties, a program to address school attendance, emotional, and behavioral difficulties, and a vocational program to develop job skills to prepare him to transition from school to work. STUDENT’s lack of school attendance became of increasing concern. Prior to his release from probation in November 2000, STUDENT’s attendance at the Learning Center had been fair. Since that time, his attendance has been sporadic at best. Several witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s need for additional services, given that he is 17 years old, continues to exhibit emotional and behavioral difficulties, and has experienced relatively minimal success in school.
Ms. Faris-Cole testified that STUDENT’s biggest need is emotional support to address mental health deficits. She described STUDENT as “suspicious, fearful, and lacking self-esteem.” In Ms. Faris-Cole’s opinion, these mental health needs are interfering with STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education. STUDENT described himself as “short-tempered.” He also testified that he has difficulty sleeping. STUDENT described talking on the telephone nearly daily from 4:00 p.m. until he falls asleep at 4:00 a.m. STUDENT also testified that a doctor he recently saw diagnosed him as depressed. Additional witnesses, including Ms. Cheketchsha and Ms. Gibbs, also testified regarding STUDENT’s lack of self esteem. Other witnesses described STUDENT’s explosive behavior. Mr. McCarthy, PARENT, STUDENT’s mother, and Ms. Landguth testified that STUDENT is explosive and volatile. Lindy Smith, MFT, Ph.D., additionally identified issues related to anger, rage, attachment, depression, and loss. Dr. Smith is a clinical psychologist. She conducted a behavioral assessment that included a review of educational information, information from STUDENT’s mother, and behavioral observations of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds the testimony of Ms. Faris-Cole persuasive. Ms. Faris-Cole, as coordinator of the Learning Center, has had recent opportunities to observe STUDENT and to evaluate his school performance. Additionally, Ms. Faris-Cole has worked with students with emotional disturbances for 14 years. Her testimony is supported by the testimony of other District witnesses and witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT. Additionally, it is noted that the basis for STUDENT’s special education eligibility is ED. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT exhibits significant emotional difficulties that must be addressed.
The Hearing Officer turns first to STUDENT’s IEP to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a program that was designed to meet his needs. A review of STUDENT’s IEP and notes of IEP meetings held in October and November 2000 reveals that no new goals and objectives were added to STUDENT’s March 2000 IEP. Since the March 2000 IEP did not include goals or objectives to address social, emotional, school attendance, or behavioral difficulties, STUDENT’s goals and objectives continued to be inadequate to address STUDENT’s needs.
To address STUDENT’s need for remedial instruction, the District has placed STUDENT in the Learning Center. Ms. Faris-Cole’s testimony establishes that the purpose of the Learning Center is to provide systematic instruction to remediate academic deficits. At the Learning Center, STUDENT works on reading, writing, spelling and mathematics. To address language deficits, the Learning Center uses Lindamood-Bell programs designed to increase phonemic awareness, oral language, and reading comprehension. For example, LiPS is a multisensory program that works on developing sound-symbol relationships. Visualizing-Verbalizing addresses reading comprehension. The Learning Center also instructs STUDENT using Handwriting without Tears, Reading Mastery, a computer program, and Touch System Math, to develop math concepts. Based on Ms. Faris-Cole’s testimony, it is concluded that the Learning Center program provides STUDENT concrete redial instruction and is designed to address STUDENT’s academic needs.
As to the services offered to STUDENT to address social, emotional, and behavioral deficits, the October 2000 IEP calls for one hour weekly of counseling at the Learning Center. The District undertook a functional analysis assessment and developed a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). The BIP targets STUDENT’s verbal aggression toward adults, including profanity, disrespectful remarks to adults, and threats to cause harm. Ms. Faris-Cole testified that the staff also is working to replace four behaviors identified as interfering with his participation in the Learning Center. Those behaviors include: on-task behavior but only while doing work of STUDENT’s choice; off-task behavior such as engaging in conversations; nonresponsive behavior such as refusing to work; and negative comments to staff and students. (See District’s Exhibit 6)
Neither the BIP nor additional behaviors targeted at the Learning Center address STUDENT’s poor school attendance. Ms. Landguth and Ms. Faris-Cole testified that an appropriate program for STUDENT must address his poor school attendance. STUDENT’s IEP calls for social work services, which could be available to address attendance. However, the District has not provided STUDENT with social work services.
STUDENT’s IEP does call for counseling for a total of one hour weekly. Given STUDENT’s significant needs, the limited counseling services (one hour weekly) available to STUDENT, and the lack of any counseling goals or objectives, it is concluded that the counseling services offered by the District are insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs.
Regarding whether the District’s program addresses STUDENT’s vocational needs, on November 7, 2000, the IEP team reconvened to develop an individualized transition plan (ITP) for STUDENT. The plan included completing basic skills at the Learning Center, getting a California identification card from the Department of Motor Vehicles, and developing a resume. Neither the IEP nor the ITP includes goals and objectives that will address the skills that STUDENT needs to develop to be successful in a work environment. According to the testimony of Ms. Landguth, Ms. Faris-Cole, and others, STUDENT needs to first acquire skills that include showing up on time, making eye contact, and sequencing job tasks before he will be successful in a vocational program.
To provide STUDENT with opportunities to develop vocational skills, he was placed in the Hungry Tiger Program, an ROP program at Morse that teaches food preparation to the students. The District provided STUDENT with a one-to-one aide to work with STUDENT in the Hungry Tiger program. The teacher of the Hungry Tiger program expressed concern about the appropriateness of the program for STUDENT. First, he was uncertain whether or not STUDENT would be able to catch up with the rest of the class when he entered. Second, he was concerned about STUDENT’s ability to pass the required written safety test. Mr. McCarthy testified that STUDENT needed to develop transitional skills before he participated in the Hungry Tiger program. In fact, STUDENT attended the Hungry Tiger program only a few times. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Mr. McCarthy persuasive and concludes that the Hungry Tiger program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. More recently, STUDENT has worked stocking shelves at a warehouse. STUDENT has experienced some success in this program. However, STUDENT has missed some of the times he was scheduled to work, and he has relied on Mr. Bisbee to pick him up and transport him to the base. The Hearing Officer concludes that the limited vocational experiences offered by the District are not sufficient to address STUDENT’s vocational needs.
There is no evidence that the placement and services offered by the District are sufficiently integrated to address STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Smith and Ms. Faris-Cole testified persuasively that STUDENT requires an intensive integrated program. The evidence establishes that the program offered to STUDENT at the Learning Center is a part-time program. The Learning Center does not include a vocational program. There is no evidence that the program offered at Morse was implemented in coordination with the Learning Center or that the BIP was utilized at Morse.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of placement is not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because it lacks goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT’s needs, a plan to specifically address STUDENT’s poor school attendance, sufficient counseling to address significant emotional difficulties, and a plan to address social skills. The District has also failed to adequately integrate the services called for by STUDENT’s IEP.
Turning to whether the District’s placement is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, because STUDENT does not regularly attend school, he cannot benefit from his education. The District’s offer does not include a specific plan to address STUDENT’s poor attendance. District witness Ms. Faris-Cole testified that STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral problems interfere with his ability to benefit from his education. It has been concluded above that the District’s offer of placement does not adequately address STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral deficits. Given these deficiencies, it is concluded that the District’s offer of placement is not designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Finally, the District has not provided all of the components called for in STUDENT’s IEP. He has never received social work services and his enrollment in Morse did not occur as called for by the IEP drafted early in 2000. STUDENT never enrolled in P.E. Therefore, the program provided by the District did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP.
The failure of the District to design a program to address STUDENT’s needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and the failure of the District to provide a program that conforms with STUDENT’s IEP has resulted in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT during the current school year.
ISSUE NO. (2): Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?
Special education local plan areas (SELPAs) are required to ensure that a full continuum of placement options, including regular education, resource programs, designated instruction and services, special classes and centers, nonpublic, nonsectarian schools, State special schools, and instruction in settings other than classrooms are available to meet the needs of special education students. Cal. Educ. Code § 56360; 56361. Nonpublic, nonsectarian schools may be considered when no appropriate public education program is available. Cal. Educ. Code § 56365(a).
STUDENT’s advocates and mother contend that STUDENT presently requires a residential placement to meet his needs and to allow him to benefit from his education. The District contends that a residential placement is more restrictive than STUDENT requires to address his educational needs.
STUDENT opposes a residential placement and testified that he wants to stay in his home environment. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT is out of control at home. She testified that STUDENT cannot learn because he will not attend school. PARENT stated that she is disabled and unable to enforce STUDENT’s attending school. Ms. Landguth, STUDENT’s advocate, testified that STUDENT requires a residential placement. Ms. Landguth testified that a residential placement is necessary “immediately” because of the lack of an appropriate program for STUDENT and also because STUDENT will be 18 years old in November. Ms. Landguth testified that she believes that it will take STUDENT a little while to become comfortable in a different environment. If STUDENT has not settled into a new placement prior to turning 18 years old, he may decline all services.(Footnote 15) Ms. Landguth was a credible witness. For some time now, Ms. Landguth has been advocating on behalf of STUDENT first as part of her responsibilities with a mental health organization and now as a volunteer. She also is familiar with STUDENT and his family. Dr. Smith also testified that STUDENT requires a residential placement. Dr. Smith recently assessed STUDENT. First, Dr. Smith testified that a residential placement is necessary to ensure that STUDENT attends school. If he is not in school, he will not have access to the instruction and services that he requires. Dr. Smith next testified that a residential placement also is necessary to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education by providing him a program designed to control his behavior, to address his mental health needs, to provide him appropriate and ongoing reinforcement praise, and attention. Finally, Dr. Smith testified that a residential placement would allow STUDENT’s services to be integrated.
Two District witnesses also testified that STUDENT requires a residential placement. Ms. Jeanes, who worked with STUDENT while he was in the OCIIP, testified that a residential placement would ensure STUDENT’s school attendance, which has been problematic for a number of years. Ms. Faris-Cole did not specifically recommend a residential placement. However, she testified that STUDENT needs a highly structured program and that she would not rule out placing STUDENT residentially.
STUDENT’s educational history in the District’s program has been set forth above. The District has failed for many years to offer STUDENT an appropriate placement that addresses his multiple and unique needs. The District’s programs have lacked adequate support for STUDENT’s mental health and behavioral needs. STUDENT’s placement this school year offers more services than previously provided. However, STUDENT’s behavior and emotional problems persist, and Ms. Faris-Coles testified that STUDENT has shown minimal academic progress. The witnesses who are most familiar with STUDENT and his current needs have recommended a residential placement. Their testimony is persuasive. Additionally, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has not been successful in other academic environments. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires a residential placement to benefit from his education.
ISSUE NO. (3): Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from his education?
Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a) states designated instruction and services as specified in the IEP shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.
STUDENT contends that he requires mental health services to benefit from his education. STUDENT asserts that there is sufficient information in the record from the hearing to determine STUDENT’s need for services. Mental Health contends that he does not meet eligibility criteria to receive services from Mental Health. Both Mental Health and the District assert that an assessment by Mental Health is warranted to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for services and, if he is eligible, to determine what services are appropriate.
Ms. Cheketchsha’s testimony regarding her assessment, as well as the testimony of Ms. Faris-Cole, establishes that STUDENT’s academic skills fall well below his chronological age and well below expectations, given his potential. Thus, STUDENT has not benefitted from his education.
STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral difficulties have been described above in Issue No. 1. To briefly summarize, STUDENT’s behavior is explosive and volatile. He has self-esteem issues and is reported by several witnesses to be depressed. He also lacks social skills. STUDENT has been involuntarily held for 72 hours in a psychiatric facility and hospitalized on one occasion for out-of-control behavior. His social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties have existed for a long period of time.
Ms. Faris-Cole, Mr. McCarthy, Ms. Cheketchsha, and other District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s social, behavioral, and emotional difficulties continue to interfere with his ability to benefit from his education. They consistently recommended counseling to address STUDENT’s needs. The counseling STUDENT has received this school year has been described as “helpful,” particularly in dealing with the loss of a close family member. However, the testimony of District persons working with STUDENT establishes that his emotional and behavioral difficulties have not been ameliorated by services available through counseling provided by the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires mental health services to benefit from his education.
It has been concluded that counseling is beneficial for STUDENT and that counseling must be a part of STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. Landguth testified regarding the many different types of mental health services that are available through Mental Health and other agencies. However, because there has not been a mental health assessment, and no one testified specifically regarding the types of services STUDENT specifically requires, it is impossible to make a determination at this time as to what services must be included in an appropriate program for STUDENT. For example, Ms. Landguth and others testified that medication and medication management may be helpful for STUDENT. There has not been a medical assessment to determine the efficacy of medical treatment for STUDENT. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires mental health services that include counseling. The specifics of other services must be determined by further assessment.
ISSUE NO. (4): Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the private placement or services are determined to be appropriate under IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497. (Footnote 16)
STUDENT contends that he is entitled to compensatory services that extend beyond the period he is eligible to receive special education services from the District. STUDENT’s eligibility for special education will extend until he is approximately 22 years old. See. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4). STUDENT asserts that the District should be required to provide him with compensatory services five years beyond age 22 because of its failure to provide him with FAPE for an extended period of time.
The District acknowledges that STUDENT may be entitled to a compensatory remedy. However, the District disputes that an award of compensatory educational services should extend beyond STUDENT’s twenty-second birthday. According to the District, it presently is required to provide 300 hours of compensatory educational services to STUDENT pursuant to a Compliance/Complaint investigation and report. The District asserts that there is ample time from the present to provide STUDENT with appropriate services. Additionally, the District asserts that it is impossible to speculate about STUDENT’s needs four years from now. Finally, the District asserts that compensatory educational services are not designed to punish the District but, rather, to compensate the student for missed services.
STUDENT’s parent has not provided him with any educational services that are reimbursable. It has been concluded that the District has not provided STUDENT with an appropriate education during all relevant periods. Because of the gravity of the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program for multiple years, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services. It is too speculative at this point in time to determine STUDENT’s need for an educational program beyond age 22 years, given that STUDENT is entitled to another four years of education from the District and will be placed in a residential program as soon as practicable. Additionally, witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT stated many times that it is critical for STUDENT to receive services as soon as possible.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District shall provide STUDENT with additional compensatory educational services for the remainder of this school year and until he no longer meets eligibility for special education because of his age. STUDENT’s request for compensatory education for five years beyond age 22 years is denied at this time. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team is in the best position to fashion the form of additional compensatory education that would adequately compensate STUDENT. (See State of Conn. U.S.D. No. 1 v. State Dept. of Education (Conn. Super. Ct. 1997) 699 A.2d 1077.) In determining additional appropriate forms of compensatory education to supplement STUDENT’s program, the IEP team shall first weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for at least three years. The IEP team shall then consider, as options, additional counseling and vocational services, and individual tutoring done in coordination with his residential program. The IEP team must also take into consideration the determination by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal that the right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. Parents of Student W. ex rel. Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. D. No. 3 (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489.
THE DISTRICT AND MENTAL HEALTH’S ISSUE
Should an AB2726 assessment of STUDENT be undertaken by San Diego County Mental Health?
Chapter 26.5 of the Government Code sets forth interagency responsibilities for providing mental health services for special education students in California. (Commonly referred to as AB2726 mental health services) An IEP team may refer a pupil who has been determined eligible for special education and who is suspected of needing mental health services to a community mental health service for assessment when the following criteria are met:
(1) The pupil has been assessed by school personnel in accordance with Article 2 (commencing with § 56320) of Chapter 4 of Part 30 of the Education Code . . . (2) The local education agency has obtained written parental consent . . . (3) The pupil has emotional or behavioral characteristics that: (A) Are observed by qualified educational staff in educational and other settings, as appropriate. (B) Impede the pupil from benefitting from educational services. (C) Are significant as indicated by their rate of occurrence and intensity. (D) Are associated with a condition that cannot be described solely as a social maladjustment or a temporary adjustment problem, and cannot be resolved with short-term counseling. (4) As determined using educational assessments the pupil’s functioning, including cognitive functioning, is at a level sufficient to enable the pupil to benefit from mental health services. (5) The local education agency has provided counseling, psychological, or guidance services to the pupil . . . and the services do not meet the pupil’s educational needs . . .
Gov. Code § 7576 (b); Cal. Code Regs. § 60040(a).
Within five days of receipt of a referral, the community mental health services must review the referral and determine whether a mental health assessment is necessary. Cal. Code Regs § 60045(a).
The District has referred STUDENT to Mental Health on three separate occasions for an assessment to determine his eligibility for mental health services. Each referral has resulted in a finding that STUDENT is not entitled to services from Mental Health pursuant to AB 2627. The last referral to Mental Health was made in March 2000. Mental Health contends that it should be allowed to assess STUDENT because of changed circumstances. In the past, Mental Health concluded that STUDENT did not possess sufficient cognitive skills to benefit from cognitive insight therapy. Mental Health presently asserts that STUDENT has suffered the loss of a loved one, his uncle, and that he has shown the ability to benefit from counseling that he received to address his loss. The District joins in Mental Health’s request to assess STUDENT. STUDENT opposes allowing Mental Health further opportunity to assess STUDENT because of the delay an assessment would cause to STUDENT’s receipt of an appropriate program. STUDENT asserts that there is sufficient information available to conclude that he requires mental health therapy and that an assessment is unnecessary.
STUDENT satisfies all of the criteria for a Mental Health assessment. He has been assessed by school personnel. Ms. Faris-Cole and Mr. McCarthy, as well as other District witnesses have observed STUDENT’s significant emotional difficulties in educational settings. It has been concluded above that STUDENT’s emotional condition impedes him from benefitting from educational services. The testimony of STUDENT’s mother and District personnel working with STUDENT establishes that STUDENT’s emotional difficulties are significant and associated with a condition that cannot be described solely as a social maladjustment or a temporary adjustment problem, and cannot be resolved with short-term counseling.
A primary concern of Mental Health in the past, and the primary reason for rejecting the District’s referral of STUDENT for an assessment, was whether STUDENT’s functioning is at a level sufficient to enable him to benefit from mental health services. Testimony discussed earlier establishes that STUDENT benefitted from counseling provided at the Learning Center. STUDENT initially was hesitant to participate. Following the death of a family member, STUDENT sought out counseling. His attendance at the Learning Center increased as well as he began participating regularly in counseling. Finally, the District has provided some counseling that was helpful to STUDENT; however, the counseling was insufficient to meet his needs. Further testing will provide information necessary to the IEP team to determine appropriate mental health services for STUDENT. Given the above, particularly the new information regarding STUDENT’s ability to benefit from counseling, it is concluded that an assessment by Mental Health is warranted.
Dr. Shiller testified extensively regarding what constitutes an appropriate mental health assessment. He stated that a mental health assessment is designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder. An assessment should include gathering information from the referring source, updating STUDENT’s history, administering psychological testing, conducting a mental status examination, and interviewing and observing STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that Mental Health’s assessment shall include at least all of the components described by Dr. Shiller.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to: (a) designate District personnel responsible for identifying an appropriate residential placement for STUDENT that will provide a structured environment that integrates services to address STUDENT’s academic, social, behavioral, emotional, and vocational needs; and (b) determine appropriate compensatory educational services for STUDENT. In determining additional appropriate forms of compensatory education to supplement STUDENT’s program, the IEP team shall first weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for at least three years. The IEP team shall then consider, as options, additional counseling and vocational services, and individual tutoring done in coordination with his residential program.
(2) Within 15 calendar days of the date of the IEP meeting, the District shall implement STUDENT’s compensatory educational services. The District shall continue to provide compensatory education services until STUDENT reaches an age when he no longer qualifies for special education services from the District.
(3) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, Mental Health shall present an assessment plan to PARENT that includes at a minimum all of the following: information from the District and PARENT, updated information regarding STUDENT’s history, psychological testing, a mental status examination, and interviews and observations of STUDENT.
(4) Mental Health shall complete STUDENT’s assessment and convene with the District an IEP meeting within 30 days of the date of this decision to address the findings of the assessment and determine appropriate mental health services for STUDENT.
(5) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall present an assessment plan to PARENT to assess STUDENT’s speech and language functioning.
(6) Within the time lines required by the California Education Code, the District shall complete its speech and language assessment and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment and determine whether STUDENT requires speech and language services to benefit from his education.
(7) No later than 35 calendar days of the date of the IEP meeting, the District shall place STUDENT in a residential placement that meets the criteria set forth in order number 1.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The Student’s Issues (1) Has the San Diego Unified School District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(2) Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(3) Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from his education? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(4) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that he is entitled to services until he no longer is eligible for special education because of his age.
The District and Mental Health’s Issue
Should an AB2726 assessment of STUDENT be undertaken by San Diego County Mental Health? The District and Mental Health prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 18, 2001 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education
Footnote 1: STUDENT initially requested reimbursement for certain independent assessments. On the first day of the hearing, STUDENT withdrew the reimbursement issue. Footnote 2: An assessment by the Regional Center in December 1990 found that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning fell in the mild range of mental retardation. The assessment utilized the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R). (Mental Health’s Exhibit 3C) STUDENT is African-American and the WISC-R is not a valid measure of his cognitive skills. An assessment by the District in March 2000 found STUDENT’s potential higher than was found on the WISC-R. (Student’s Exhibit 33; District’s Exhibit 8) Footnote 3: STUDENT’s school attendance has been limited for reasons that will be discussed below. Footnote 4: AB2726 mental health services previously were known as AB3632. Footnote 5: According to District personnel, the District discontinued the OCIIP and Options, its successor, following a District audit that determined the programs were not effective and that too many students remained enrolled in the programs for extended periods of time. The programs were designed to serve students for brief periods of time and no longer than one semester. Footnote 6: In 1999, OCIIP merged with another program and became known as “Options.” Footnote 7: STUDENT was placed in juvenile hall in October 1999. Upon his release, he stayed with his grandparents. The fact that STUDENT was in juvenile hall for a period in October 1999 does not explain the delay until January 2000 in placing STUDENT at Metro. Footnote 8: In January 2000, Ms. Landguth, STUDENT’s advocate, had also requested that the District undertake an assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language. The District has not completed a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Footnote 9: The Learning Center is located on the Whittier Campus, which formerly served as an elementary school. The Del Sol Academy and the District’s Special Education Early Childhood (SEEC) program are also located at Whittier Footnote 10: STUDENT entered the OCIIP in 1997. However, because requests for hearing must be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request, issues related to the appropriateness of the placements offered by the District are limited to the period from January 1998 forward. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j). STUDENT remained in the OCIIP from December 1997 to January 1999. The District neither convened an IEP meeting nor assessed STUDENT during this period. For these reasons, the initial discussion regarding placement covers January 1998 through January 1999. Footnote 11: Cal. Code Regs § 3001(j) provides that the instructional day of a special education student shall be the same as the school day for the student’s chronological peers unless otherwise specified in the IEP. Footnote 12: Ms. Landguth testified that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s speech and language skills in response to her request on behalf of PARENT to the District in January 2000. Footnote 13: STUDENT did not receive counseling services until he entered the Learning Center in November 2000. Footnote 14: Ms. Faris-Cole testified that when STUDENT went to Morse, he was not properly enrolled. Although an aide was available the first day, he took another job and was not replaced until December. Footnote 15: At the age of 18, unless the student has been determined incompetent under state law, all rights transfer to the student. Cal. Educ. Code § 56042. Footnote 16: The Third Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that remedies available under the IDEA should not be limited; however, the Court cautioned that “in fashioning a remedy for an IDEA violation, a district court may wish to order educational services, such as compensatory education beyond a child’s age of eligibility, or reimbursement for providing at private expense what should have been offered by the school, rather than compensatory damages for generalized pain and suffering.” W.B. v. Matula (3d. Cir 1995) 67 F.3d 484.
