California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 19, 1996
Student v. Santa Cruz City Schools
SEHO Case No. SN 1234-95 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel
Santa Cruz City Schools offered a blind student FAPE in ninth and twelfth grades; private tuition and compensatory claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
No subsequent history is noted. The decision refers to a prior SEHO decision (SN 748-94, Hearing Officer Mary Cote, December 23, 1994) that found FAPE for 1993-94 and 1994-95, and to a January 1995 mediation agreement in SN 942-94.
Summary
The parents of a 17-year-old high school senior who is blind filed for due process against Santa Cruz City Schools. The student attended regular education classes and received vision, orientation and mobility, counseling and assistive technology services. Kidney failure, followed by a transplant in August 1995, also affected his schooling. He did well academically at Santa Cruz High School in ninth grade. He returned there for twelfth grade but missed many classes for medical reasons and struggled with depression. In December 1995 his parents moved him to Traveling School International, a small private school. They sought reimbursement for that tuition and two years of compensatory services after graduation. They argued that the District did not meet his social-emotional needs and that his transition planning fell short.
Before the hearing, the Hearing Officer ruled that a 1994 SEHO decision finding FAPE for 1993-94 and 1994-95 barred compensatory claims for those years. The 1992-93 claim was allowed to go forward. After six days of hearing, the Hearing Officer found that the ninth and twelfth grade IEPs met procedural requirements and provided educational benefit. The student earned about a B average and made progress on his goals. His social-emotional struggles did not prevent academic benefit. The District also offered counseling, a resource room "safe haven" and flexible deadlines. His transition services were adequate. These included career surveys, computer training, mobility lessons in the community and a connection to the Department of Rehabilitation. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's educational-benefit standard to a student who did well academically but struggled emotionally. It also shows that an earlier hearing decision can bar later claims about the same school years. Finally, it shows how SEHO judged the transition services offered to a student who chose not to pursue work or college activities yet.
Issues and holdings
Issue Prehearing order. District motion to limit compensatory education claim to 1995-96 based on collateral estoppel from the decision in Case No. SN 748-94
In a February 13, 1996 order, the Hearing Officer barred compensatory claims based on 1993-94 and 1994-95, which a prior SEHO decision found were FAPE years. The 1992-93 claim was allowed to proceed because it had not been fully litigated.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education during the 1992-93 school year?
The ninth grade IEP met procedural requirements. The student earned a B average and progressed on his goals, and his social-emotional difficulties did not interfere with educational benefit, so he received a FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education during the 1995-96 school year?
The twelfth grade IEP and transition plan were procedurally and substantively appropriate. The student received educational benefit, and the District addressed his social-emotional and health needs, so tuition reimbursement for the private school and two years of compensatory transition services were denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Each of Petitioner's requests for relief (tuition reimbursement for Traveling School International and two years of compensatory education after graduation) was denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Chuhran v. Walled Lake Consolidated School District; Bertolucci v. San Carlos Elementary School District
People named in the decision
- Andrew Todd, director of special education, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Badri Dass, private psychotherapist (counseling funded through IEP); witness for Student, Private practice
- David Gilbertson, educational psychologist; expert witness for Student, SELPA director, Alameda County
- Oscar Salvatierra, renal transplant surgeon; witness for Student, Stanford University Medical Center
- Steve Myers, director of private school; witness for Student, Traveling School International
- Connie Unsicker, teacher of visually impaired students (itinerant special day class teacher), Santa Cruz County Office of Education
- David Shaw, orientation and mobility instructor, Santa Cruz County Office of Education
- Rebecca Cole, transition specialist / post-school transition case manager, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Jim Goodwin, resource specialist, Santa Cruz High School
- Kevin Drinkard, math teacher, Santa Cruz High School
- Jim Dietz, social studies (economics) teacher, Santa Cruz High School
- Robert Nation, school psychologist; special education administrator at IEP meetings, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Christine Hertel, director of special education, Santa Cruz County Office of Education
- Pat Dougan, transition consultant; witness for District, California Department of Education
- Jill Tardiff, orientation and mobility instructor (through ninth grade)
- Char Goode, VI computer teacher
- Len Burns, therapist and adapted computer trainer
- Diane Deese, school nurse, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Jack Hazekamp, state expert on education of blind and visually impaired students, California Department of Education
- Ed Guldich (also spelled Gulditch), Department of Rehabilitation counselor, California Department of Rehabilitation
- Mary Calloway, Department of Rehabilitation counselor, California Department of Rehabilitation
- Sandy Augustine, high school counselor, Santa Cruz High School
- Mary Cote, Hearing Officer in prior case SN 748-94, Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Cruz, California, on February 15, 16 and 20 and March 14, 15 and 18, 1996.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Kathryn Dobel. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his father, PARENT. Respondent Santa Cruz City Schools ("the District") was represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds. Also present on behalf of the District was Andrew Todd, director of special education.
The following witnesses were called to testify by Petitioner: PARENT; Mr. Todd; Dr. Badri Dass, psychotherapist; Dr. David Gilbertson, educational psychologist; Dr. Oscar Salvatierra, renal transplant surgeon; and Steve Myers, director, Traveling School International. The following witnesses were called to testify by the District: Mr. Todd; Connie Unsicker, teacher of visually impaired (VI) students; David Shaw, orientation and mobility (OM) instructor; Rebecca Cole, transition specialist; Jim Goodwin, resource specialist; Kevin Drinkard, math teacher; Jim Dietz, social studies teacher; Robert Nation, educational psychologist; Christine Hertel, director of special education, Santa Cruz County Office of Education; and Pat Dougan, transition consultant, California Department of Education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties the record was left open until April 5, 1996, for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education during the 1992-93 school year?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education during the 1995-96 school year?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
These same parties were involved in a previous due process hearing regarding STUDENT's education that resulted in a written Decision. (See Decision issued by Hearing Officer Mary Cote on December 23, 1994, in Case No. SN 748-94.) In her Decision, Hearing Officer Cote found that the District had offered STUDENT a free, appropriate education (FAPE) for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years. (Cote Decision, p. 17) Whether or not the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for 1992-93 was not specifically at issue in that case. Nevertheless, Hearing Officer Cote heard evidence regarding STUDENT's District placement during that year, and made factual findings that STUDENT had made "considerable academic achievement" in and had "benefitted" from that placement. (Id., p. 13) In fact, the legal conclusion that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for 1993-94 and 1994-95 was based, in part, on the factual finding that it was the same placement STUDENT had attended and benefitted from in 1992-93.
In its prehearing statement of issues filed in the present case (Case No. SN 1234-95), Petitioner indicated it was seeking a compensatory education remedy for the District's failures to properly serve STUDENT "over time." The District submitted a pre-hearing motion to limit the compensatory claim to the 1995-96 school year. The District argued that Hearing Officer Cote's Decision in Case No. SN 748-94 should have a collateral estoppel effect here.
Hearing Officer Garfinkel found that (1) an award of compensatory education must be based upon a finding of a denial of FAPE; (2) Hearing Officer Cote had already ruled that the District offered a FAPE for 1993-94 and 1994-95; and (3) based on the doctrine of collateral estoppel, compensatory education cannot be awarded based on an argument that STUDENT was denied FAPE during those two years. Therefore, the District's motion to preclude Petitioner from seeking compensatory education based on an argument that STUDENT was denied FAPE in 1993-94 and 1994-95 was granted. (See Order dated February 13, 1996, pp. 4-5.)
Conversely, the Hearing Officer found that the issue of whether STUDENT was offered a FAPE during 1992-93 had not been fully litigated in the previous case. The Hearing Officer found that Petitioner was not collaterally estopped from further exploring that issue. Therefore, the District's motion to preclude Petitioner from seeking compensatory education based on an argument that STUDENT was denied FAPE in 1992-93 was denied. The Hearing Officer indicated that he would retain discretion to consider, along with all the other evidence presented at the hearing, Hearing Officer Cote's factual findings with respect to the 1992-93 school year. (See Order dated February 13, 1996.)
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner asserts that although STUDENT did well academically during the ninth grade and the first half of the twelfth grade at Santa Cruz High School (SCHS), the District did not meet his social-emotional needs during those times. Petitioner further asserts that STUDENT has not received sufficient post-school transition planning and services. Petitioner requests, as remedies, that the District be ordered to (1) reimburse the parents for tuition at the private Traveling School International (TSI), where they unilaterally placed STUDENT for the second half of his twelfth grade year, and (2) provide STUDENT with two years of compensatory educational services following his anticipated graduation from high school in June 1996.
Respondent District asserts that STUDENT received educational benefit at SCHS despite any social-emotional difficulties he experienced while attending there. Respondent further asserts that STUDENT has received appropriate post-school transition planning and services. Respondent contends, therefore, that (1) the parents are not entitled to private school tuition reimbursement for the latter part of twelfth grade, and (2) there is no basis upon which to award compensatory education following graduation.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE
A. Chronological Summary
1. Introduction
STUDENT is seventeen years old and a senior at Traveling School International ("TSI"), a small, regular education, private school in Santa Cruz.(Footnote 1) He is expected to graduate in approximately two months, in June 1996.
STUDENT, who is blind, began attending Santa Cruz County schools as a preschooler. He has above-average intelligence and has always attended regular education classes. STUDENT did well academically at Pacific Elementary, a small, rural, public school in Davenport. There he received specialized services from a teacher of the visually impaired (VI) and an orientation and mobility (OM) instructor.
STUDENT next attended Mission Hills Junior High, a large, urban, public school in Santa Cruz, within the District. He again did well academically, and continued to receive VI and OM services. At Mission Hills, STUDENT was a student body officer and participated in wrestling. He was an outgoing and popular student, well known for singing "rap" tunes on campus.
In June 1992 the IEP team met to plan for STUDENT's upcoming move to high school in the fall. At the IEP meeting, progress reports were submitted by (1) Connie Unsicker, VI teacher, regarding academics, braille, and organization, (2) Jill Tardiff, OM instructor, regarding mobility and personal and daily living skills, and (3) Char Goode, VI computer teacher, regarding use of braille word processors. Annual goals with corresponding short-term objectives were established in the areas of computers, achieving independence, fostering independence in written work, study skills, and OM. (P A17)(Footnote 2) Although no specific goals or objectives were set in the area of social-emotional needs, Ms. Tardiff recommended that STUDENT "explore stress management techniques, possibly meditation, to help him handle better the pressures he will undoubtedly be under in the coming year."
The IEP provided that STUDENT would receive daily VI services, twice weekly OM services, and possibly a tutorial with Mr. Goodwin, the resource specialist.(Footnote 3) The IEP also provided for the use of taped books and brailled materials. (P A17)(Footnote 4) It was determined that STUDENT would again attend all regular education classes in ninth grade at SCHS, a large, urban, comprehensive public high school in the District.
2. Ninth grade (the 1992-93 school year)
STUDENT did well academically during the ninth grade, achieving a B average and making progress on his IEP goals and objectives. (P A17)(Footnote 5) Socially, he established a good relationship with the resource specialist, Mr. Goodwin, and a small group of Mr. Goodwin's students. On the other hand, he experienced some social-emotional difficulties adjusting to high school, as well as low energy and frequent early morning vomiting for reasons that were, at the time, unknown. That year, the parents obtained for STUDENT private tutoring in French, as well as counseling from Len Burns, a therapist who is blind and who had counseled STUDENT in the past.(Footnote 6) At an IEP meeting in June 1993, STUDENT's ninth grade year was reviewed. (P A19) Ms. Unsicker, the VI teacher, noted that STUDENT maintained a good grade-point average, participated in discussions, did well in oral French, and had success in math despite its visual emphasis. She noted, however, that STUDENT expressed frustration with various aspects of his classes.
Ms. Tardiff, the OM instructor, wrote with respect to social-emotional issues:(Footnote 7)
Very difficult freshman year. Very depressed and unmotivated. Not successful at making new friends although he didn't really try. APE [adapted physical education] teacher reports he did very well. Has the attitude of not feeling entitled to assistance or attention. He likes to keep an extremely low profile in public -- so low to the point of being invisible if it were possible. When relaxed and centered he is loads of fun to be with. Has a great sense of humor. Is extremely sensitive and perceptive with great communication skills. (P A19)
The IEP document summarized:
STUDENT had done well academically as a freshman. He especially excelled in oral French. However, STUDENT was frequently frustrated with certain classes (math -- due to its visual emphasis), especially related to teachers' assignments and his interaction with some of his peers and teachers. STUDENT has had a hard time adjusting to SCHS. He has been depressed and unmotivated much of this school year. He tends to avoid asking for help or assistance. (Id.)
3. Tenth and eleventh grade (1993-94 and 1994-95 school years)
During the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years, STUDENT attended TSI at his parents' expense. He received specialized services from the District, including VI teaching from Ms. Unsicker, OM instruction from Dave Shaw, APE, adapted computer equipment, counseling with psychotherapist Dr. Badri Dass, and computer training with Mr. Burns. As noted above in "Procedural Matters", it was previously determined in Case No. SN 748-94 that the District offered STUDENT a free, appropriate education during 1993-94 and 1994-95. Certain evidence regarding events of these two school years was received at the hearing from both parties for the purpose of providing background and context for evidence regarding the 1995-96 school year. That evidence is summarized below.
In December 1993 STUDENT was diagnosed with advanced kidney failure. It was determined that undiagnosed kidney failure had been the cause of STUDENT's feeling poorly during much of ninth grade. In early 1994, midway through tenth grade, STUDENT wrote an essay titled "Eighth Grade Sucked." (P G1) In the essay, STUDENT stated that although he had done extremely well academically during eighth grade at Mission Hills Junior High (1991-92), he had experienced depression that year. The depression, STUDENT wrote, was rooted in a feeling that he was an "outsider" and didn't "fit in." He wrote, "I began thinking of suicide daily, not contemplating, but thinking." (P G1) STUDENT did not address the events of ninth grade in that essay.
In the fall of 1994, the District began post-school transition planning for STUDENT. In January 1995 STUDENT experienced total kidney failure and began dialysis treatments for three hours, three times weekly. Early that spring STUDENT decisively expressed the desire to return to SCHS for his senior year in 1995-96.(Footnote 8)
In the spring of 1995, the District conducted a series of three IEP meetings to plan for STUDENT's return to SCHS. STUDENT attended each meeting. The first meeting was held on March 2, 1995. (R 3) By this time STUDENT's disabling conditions included not only blindness but also kidney failure.(Footnote 9) For that reason, the IEP team was expanded to include the District's school nurse, Diane Deese. Based on reports from STUDENT's doctors, Ms. Deese indicated that there was no health reason why STUDENT could not return to SCHS. (R 3) At the time, it was contemplated by all parties that STUDENT would receive a kidney transplant in approximately early 1996 (that is, early in the final semester of his senior year). The IEP team discussed the importance of a flexible approach to accommodate STUDENT's health.
Status reports were also submitted by the VI teacher, Ms. Unsicker; the computer trainer, Mr. Burns; and the OM instructor, Mr. Shaw. Mr. Shaw indicated that STUDENT had become very familiar with the SCHS campus by the end of the ninth grade, and would require only brief, refresher mobility lessons during the summer to become reacquainted. During this time, Mr. Goodwin, the SCHS resource specialist, visited STUDENT at TSI to re-establish their relationship. Additionally, the District solicited further input from Jack Hazekamp, the state department of education expert on the education of blind and visually impaired students.
A second meeting was held on May 23, 1995. (Exh. 5) Steve Myers, the TSI director, was invited but did not attend. Updated progress reports and recommendations were submitted by the four persons who had submitted status reports at the March IEP meeting: Ms. Deese (R 9), Ms. Unsicker (R 10, 12), Mr. Burns (R 8), and Mr. Shaw (R 11). Mr. Shaw noted that STUDENT was making good progress on mobility and independent living skills but that his performance n mobility lessons was often greatly affected by his health. (R 11) The IEP of May 23, 1995 established annual goals, with accompanying short-term objectives, in the following areas: high school graduation, study skills, organizational skills, OM, independent living skills, and computer technology. (R 5) Additionally, Dr. Dass prepared short-term objectives relating to the annual goal of social-emotional growth. (R 7) The IEP provided for the following related services: OM instruction with Mr. Shaw: VI services with Ms. Unsicker, counseling with Dr. Dass, assistive technology (computer equipment) at home and school, computer training with Mr. Burns, adapted physical education, vocational education, and resource specialist consultation by Mr. Goodwin with STUDENT's regular education teachers. (R 5) It was agreed that Mr. Goodwin's room would again be a "safe haven" for STUDENT, as it had been in ninth grade. It was further agreed that the parents would communicate with the school nurse regarding medical developments, and that the nurse in turn would communicate with other school staff as needed. (R 5)
A third IEP meeting was held on June 16, 1995. (R 16) There was further discussion of STUDENT's return to SCHS, and significant discussion of post-school transition. Attendees included Mr. Myers, TSI director; Rebecca Cole, District transition specialist; and Ed Guldich, state Department of Rehabilitation (DOR) counselor. A document titled Individualized Transition Plan (ITP) was appended to the IEP. The ITP identified goals in several areas including career exploration, college/vocational training exploration, graduation from high school, establishing eligibility for services with DOR, applying for college scholarships and financial aid, and applying to college. (R 16) The IEP team discussed the possibility of STUDENT participating in a two-week vocational training program sponsored by DOR that summer; however, STUDENT indicated he did not wish to participate.
Also in June 1995, STUDENT wrote a reflective paper for his English class at TSI entitled "Corrosion of Status." (P G2) In that paper he echoed, with respect to eighth grade, some of the sentiments of his previous essay "Eighth grade sucked." With respect to ninth grade, he wrote:
Things got worse. I was ridiculed at great length by jocks, surfers, and other such people. When that was not happening, I was just ignored by those around me. I was getting considerably more depressed. (P G2)
4. Twelfth grade (the 1995-96 school year)
In August 1995 STUDENT received a kidney transplant from his father. The surgery was performed by Dr. Oscar Salvatierra at Stanford University Medical Center. In September STUDENT began classes at SCHS. During most of the fall, he returned to Stanford approximately twice weekly so that Dr. Salvatierra could monitor his recovery. He also followed a prescribed medication regimen.
That fall STUDENT attended classes in economics, creative writing, math, and independent study, and received related services and transition planning. He missed approximately 25% of his classes due to illness and the Stanford visits. At Thanksgiving STUDENT expressed the desire to return to TSI. His parents informed the District that STUDENT would begin classes at TSI on December 5, 1995. (R 18, 19) STUDENT earned the following grades that fall at SCHS: cconomics: B, creative writing: B, math: Pass, independent study: Pass. (P D25)
An IEP meeting was held on December 7, 1995, to ensure the smooth transfer of all of STUDENT's related services to the private school setting. (R 21) STUDENT and his mother told the IEP team that there was nothing wrong with SCHS and that he was returning to TSI as a matter of choice. However, the IEP document noted that:
STUDENT identified he was ill and decided to leave [SCHS] because he was not excelling. He wanted more direct attention and the fast-paced schedule and number of people were factors. He was very sick but continued to attend. Students were aware of STUDENT and knew when he was away (hospitalized or ill). (R 21)
At the IEP meeting, STUDENT continued to express a desire for less adult involvement in his life. At STUDENT's request, the frequency of VI and OM services was reduced. STUDENT indicated he possibly would go on TSI's foreign tour in the spring. (R 21)
B. Testimony of Petitioner's Witnesses
1. PARENT
In ninth grade (1992-93) STUDENT had some problems in French because the accent marks used in written French were not easily transferrable to Braille. Both Jill Tardiff, STUDENT's OM instructor, and Connie Unsicker, his VI teacher, communicated some problems to PARENT. Ms. Tardiff said she was concerned about STUDENT's self-esteem and failure to ask for help when needed; she also noted that at times he seemed to "disappear". PARENT now believes that STUDENT was beginning to feel the physical effects of kidney failure that year; however, this medical problem was not known at the time.
In early 1995, STUDENT expressed the desire to return to SCHS for his senior year (1995-96). He told his father that his TSI friends would be graduating and that there would be no other seniors at TSI the following year. He said that he wanted to meet girls, and wanted to experience social success at the public high school where he felt he had failed to do so in ninth grade.
PARENT was opposed to such a move. He thought STUDENT was being stoic and courageous but unrealistic. He was concerned that STUDENT would withdraw and "fall in between the cracks" at the large public high school. He thought STUDENT required a smaller, more flexible and supportive school such as TSI. With extreme reluctance, PARENT supported STUDENT's decision because he believed it was important for STUDENT to take some control over decisions about his education.
During discussions of post-school transition in June 1995, STUDENT was physically unable to be a full participant. Although he attended the IEP meeting, he was uncomfortable because of dialysis treatments, and had to focus on his immediate health rather than long-range planning. STUDENT resisted the idea of college because he felt burned out by adults telling him what to do in school. He was coaxed into the idea of college by the IEP team, including his father.
After STUDENT's surgery in August 1995, PARENT wrote to Sandy Augustine, the Santa Cruz High counselor, describing STUDENT's medical condition. (B 60) He noted that STUDENT was doing well but that he would be susceptible to illness because his immune system was weakened by immunosuppressant drugs intended to prevent his body from rejecting the new kidney. That fall STUDENT was frequently absent because of illness and trips to Stanford Medical Center. On one occasion he was hospitalized due to flu. STUDENT became depressed and withdrawn. His speech became monosyllabic.
PARENT believes STUDENT's experience at SCHS in the fall of 1995 was not successful. He also noted that two of his (PARENT's) requests were not honored: the school nurse never called him, and the principal never advised STUDENT of club meetings. Further, he stated that the IEP team had no case manager (although he noted that STUDENT probably would not have wanted such additional adult interference). In late fall STUDENT expressed the desire to return to TSI. He told his father that he was lonely and bored, that he had not made friends or met girls, and that the fast academic pace was difficult for him.
Since his return to TSI, STUDENT has started to talk more -- even about his future. He has taken more responsibility for completing his homework and has made the honor roll. He has successfully campaigned for student body president, performed an extemporaneous skit in front of a group of peers, and asked girls on dates. Also, STUDENT's health has improved. His visits to Stanford have decreased in frequency. At TSI, his immune system is exposed to fewer students.
2. Dr. Oscar Salvatierra
Dr. Salvatierra is a professor at Stanford University Medical Center and the director of its pediatric renal transplant program. He performed the August 1995 surgery in which STUDENT received a kidney transplant from his father. The surgery was successful. Dr. Salvatierra made no recommendations for school placement upon discharge.
Dr. Salvatierra has continued to monitor STUDENT's recovery since the surgery. He prescribed immuno-suppressant drugs for STUDENT -- heavier dosages immediately after the surgery, and lower dosages after that. The drugs purposefully weakened STUDENT's immune system to prevent rejection of the kidney. STUDENT has consistently followed his medication regimen, and continues to make a satisfactory recovery. He has shown no signs of rejecting the kidney.
After a one-week post-operative stay at the hospital, Dr. Salvatierra saw STUDENT at Stanford approximately twice weekly for most of the fall of 1995. STUDENT was hospitalized briefly in November because of flu.
During the fall of 1995, Dr. Salvatierra observed STUDENT to be immersed in a deep depression. He had a very flat affect, and it was difficult to get him to talk. He seemed "totally down." Dr. Salvatierra testified that he was concerned that, because of his depression, STUDENT would fail to take his medication. However, STUDENT never failed to take it.
On December 1, 1995, when STUDENT had decided to return to TSI, Dr. Salvatierra wrote "to whom it may concern":
I believe that it is critical that STUDENT's educational placement during the time of . . . recovery from renal transplantation surgery be a consistently structured and stress-free environment with as few staff and peers and in as small a physical plant as possible, with maximum staff flexibility to address STUDENT's social, emotional and academic well-being and needs relative to his catastrophic medical condition. (P I9)
By January 1996 STUDENT was being seen at Stanford approximately once weekly or slightly less. By February, STUDENT was doing better emotionally. He was more interactive, and starting to consider his future.
3. Badri Dass
Dr. Dass, a private psychotherapist, has provided counseling to STUDENT once weekly for one hour since April 1994, when STUDENT was in tenth grade at TSI. Initially, the counseling was arranged and paid for by the parents. Since the fall of 1994, the counseling has been funded by the District as a related service contained in STUDENT's IEP.
In early 1995, STUDENT decisively expressed the desire to return to SCHS. Among his reasons were to be "just a normal kid" and not to have so much attention placed on him as he had at the smaller TSI. Dr. Dass had some reservations about such a move, and even wrote a letter advocating against it. (P B41) The concerns were based on emotional rather than academic issues. Dr. Dass wrote that STUDENT needed stability, not change. At the hearing, Dr. Dass testified that he was concerned that STUDENT might "disappear" in such a large school, that such a setting would not require him to interact with peers, and that he would not be encouraged to take interpersonal risks.
Despite his reservations, Dr. Dass ultimately supported STUDENT's decision. He believed it was crucial to STUDENT's development that he make decisions for himself. STUDENT had a lot of adults planning for him. In Dr. Dass' opinion, STUDENT needed to take more personal control of his own life.
In May and June, 1995, Dr. Dass participated in IEP meetings to plan for STUDENT's return to Santa Cruz High. Dr. Dass believed that, at those meetings, the District developed an appropriate plan for STUDENT's return. He believed that while STUDENT faced serious challenges in socialization, he could nevertheless receive educational benefit at SCHS. Dr. Dass prepared four objectives in the area of social-emotional growth for inclusion in the IEP:
1. articulate clearly what he is feeling and communicate to appropriate people;
2. assess when he can do something for himself and when he should ask for help;
3. assert himself in developing peer relationships; and
4. communicate his feelings and opinions regarding his education, medical issues and living situation. (P A25)
The spring of 1995 was difficult for STUDENT physically because of dialysis treatment. During the summer, he was apprehensive about his upcoming surgery. In the fall of 1995, following his surgery and return to SCHS, STUDENT exhibited significant depression during the counseling sessions. The depression was most severe in November and December. STUDENT showed extreme apathy, low energy, and listlessness. Based on his counseling sessions with STUDENT, Dr. Dass concluded that the causes of the depression were, in order of significance: (1) health concerns, including recognizing the possibility that he might have to maintain his medication regimen for a long period of time and (2) "high school senior stress"/uncertainty about his future. Neither the return to Santa Cruz High nor family changes and turmoil caused the depression. In December 1995 STUDENT told Dr. Dass he wanted to return to TSI because he wanted to graduate from TSI and believed, based on a conversation with TSI director Mr. Myers, that he would be challenged there. Dr. Dass supported the decision because it was made by STUDENT. By early 1996, following his return to TSI, STUDENT's general energy level increased and his depression became much less severe. Dr. Dass did not have an opinion as to whether this was because of the return to TSI. At TSI, STUDENT still experienced situational, reactive depression.
According to Dr. Dass, sometimes STUDENT believes TSI is better for him than SCHS, and sometimes he does not. When he was elected to a student government office at TSI, he stated that he felt he was able to "make a name" for himself there. On other occasions, he has indicated he would prefer not to receive as much attention as he does at the smaller school. And at other times, when he has not felt challenged or has been simply unhappy, he has stated, "This [TSI] may not be any better than Santa Cruz High."
Dr. Dass believes TSI is presently an appropriate setting for STUDENT's social-emotional growth. (He has no opinion on whether it is an appropriate setting with respect to academics.) TSI provides a small, structured environment within which STUDENT can confront interpersonal issues. TSI encourages STUDENT's participation and interaction, and requires his "presence."
STUDENT is very concerned about his future but tends to resist adult suggestions about it. His primary concerns are where he will live(Footnote 10) and what he will do with his time. He is not interested in going to college right away and doesn't feel ready to go to work. While he has some computer skills and has volunteered as a disc jockey at a local public radio station, he does not express interest in pursuing a career in computers or radio. He has expressed cautious interest in the possibility of helping out at TSI after graduation.
4. Steve Myers
Mr. Myers is the director of TSI, a small, private school with a total of forty students in grades 6-12 and three full-time teachers. (P F6-10) The school is not certified to provide special education services. TSI's program includes, for the older students, three to four-week educational tours of the Pacific Northwest during the fall semester and six to eight-week tours of foreign countries during the spring semester.
STUDENT first attended TSI during the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years. He went on the fall (domestic) tours in both years, but did not go on the spring (foreign) tours. He was quiet when he first arrived in 1993-94, but had opened up some and become a leader by 1994-95. While on tour, he did extremely well in shopping for and cooking his own meals and cleaning up afterwards. He also did well at getting on and off the tour bus.
When STUDENT returned to TSI in December 1995, he was quiet, withdrawn, not very communicative, and less open than he had been during 1994-95. He told Mr. Myers that he was looking for an academic challenge -- a "kick in the butt." He said he had had just one friend at SCHS that fall.
STUDENT is the only senior at TSI this year. The average number of students in his classes is fourteen. Academically, he is doing a lot of writing in his English class and is taking it seriously. Mr. Myers believes that STUDENT is a talented writer who could, someday, earn his living by writing.
Socially, STUDENT is well-liked and popular. Recently, he ran for a student government office and made a campaign speech to a group of students. Additionally, STUDENT is planning to go on the TSI tour of Ireland this spring. On tour, he will use brailled schoolwork and books on tape. He will not receive the specialized services that he receives from the District when he is in Santa Cruz.
STUDENT does not want to go to college next year, but is open to considering college for the future. Mr. Myers has described to STUDENT certain colleges with good writing and alternative learning programs, and STUDENT visited one -- Evergreen College in Olympia, Washington -- on a previous TSI tour. Mr. Myers and STUDENT have also discussed the possibility of STUDENT's returning to TSI after graduation as a staff member to assist with tours. STUDENT's most frequently expressed desire for the future is to "join a band and make music."
5. Dr. David Gilbertson
Dr. Gilbertson is an educational psychologist who currently serves as a SELPA director in Alameda County. He has extensive experience working with blind youth. He performed an assessment of STUDENT in June 1994 (P I6). He had no contact with STUDENT between 1994 and mid-February 1996, when he spoke to STUDENT by telephone in preparation for his testimony at the hearing. In that conversation, it was difficult to get STUDENT to say much. STUDENT's comments with respect to twelfth grade at SCHS included: (1) He drew some comfort from his relationship with the resource specialist, Mr. Goodwin, whom he had known in ninth grade and who frequently asked how he was doing, (2) the large school did not have a sense of "community", (3) math was "easy", economics "basic" and creative writing "OK", and (4) school gradually became monotonous and boring; once he became bored, he got depressed. (P I6A)
At the hearing, Dr. Gilbertson reviewed the social-emotional objectives prepared by Dr. Dass in the May 1995 IEP. He stated that although he believes Dr. Dass has addressed STUDENT's social-emotional needs effectively in one-to-one weekly counseling sessions, the IEP was deficient in that it did not indicate how STUDENT would work on these objectives on a daily basis at SCHS.
Also at the hearing, Dr. Gilbertson reviewed the Individual Transition Plan (ITP) included in the June 1995 IEP (P A26). He stated that while the ITP represented a "good start" and had some "good elements," it was insufficient. It was not clear that the ITP sufficiently involved or related to STUDENT's true feelings. The ITP should have been more "STUDENT-driven," and should have taken his depression into account. The ITP should have focused more on social skills STUDENT will need to function independently post-high school.
Dr. Gilbertson believes SCHS was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT for 1995-96 because STUDENT didn't like it. He stated that it has never been a problem for STUDENT, even when depressed, to work hard in school. He has never observed SCHS. Based on his observation of TSI in 1994, he believes TSI is presently an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it provides (1) group discussions which require STUDENT's presence, (2) small size that fosters a sense of community, and (3) academic challenge.
C. Testimony of District's Witnesses
1. Connie Unsicker
Ms. Unsicker is a teacher of visually impaired (VI) students for the Santa Cruz County Office of Education.(Footnote 11) She has provided daily services to STUDENT, in approximately one-hour sessions, since 1989. The services include teaching braille, adapting class materials to braille, and reteaching visual concepts from the school's curriculum with a nonvisual approach.
In ninth grade (1992-93) STUDENT did very well academically. He had some difficulty with written French because (1) the learning in French is cumulative and STUDENT was inconsistent in completing his homework, and (2) there is some difficulty in translating French accent marks into Braille. However, he received the highest grade in the class in oral French. In math, STUDENT got the highest grade in the class on the spring final exam, even though the class presentation was highly visual.
Socially, in ninth grade, STUDENT was less outgoing than he had been in junior high school. He was shier, engaged in less kidding and joking around in class, and often ate lunch with Mr. Goodwin's students in a classroom rather than out in the quad. He also at times showed low energy and was mumbly and lethargic. However, he made some friends.
In early 1995, STUDENT told Ms. Unsicker he wanted to return to SCHS so that he could spend his senior year in a larger, more traditional setting. Ms. Unsicker was not surprised because, no matter what school setting he is in, STUDENT often says he wants to be somewhere else, or that the work is too hard, easy or boring. She supported STUDENT's decision, That spring, Ms. Unsicker contacted SCHS teachers to get a head start on brailling materials for STUDENT's senior year. At the May 1995 IEP meeting, STUDENT expressed a desire for more independence and less adult involvement in his school life.
In the fall of 1995, STUDENT was able to achieve academically even though he was not feeling well. He was often mumbly and lethargic, and was impatient and angry with himself for being sick so often, missing school, and not being able to perform as he would like. As was his nature, STUDENT was quiet about his social-emotional needs. He was still friendly with students in Mr. Goodwin's room, where Ms. Unsicker worked with him.
That fall Ms. Unsicker worked with STUDENT on preparing a resume, attended a meeting with STUDENT and his DOR counselor, gave him a career survey, discussed possible careers, and reviewed the format of college catalogs. STUDENT was very busy with his math class and was not interested in getting a part-time job or investigating colleges.
In late fall, STUDENT told Ms. Unsicker he was returning to TSI. He told her there was nothing wrong with SCHS, but rather that he simply preferred to attend TSI. At the December 1995 IEP meeting he stated, generally, that he wanted less adult involvement in his life. In particular, he requested less service from Ms. Unsicker and Mr. Shaw. Ms. Unsicker supported his desire for more independence.
Ms. Unsicker believes SCHS is presently a more appropriate placement for STUDENT than TSI because it has a large number of seniors preparing for the future. SCHS has a Career Center and a lot of information, activities, meetings and workshops regarding the college application process: taking the SAT, applying for scholarships and financial aid, reading catalogs, and soliciting letters of recommendation. Ms. Unsicker noted that, at TSI, STUDENT is the only senior. She also noted that, in March, STUDENT told her he was bored and wished he was back at SCHS.
STUDENT has told Ms. Unsicker that he doesn't know what he wants to do in the future but that he thinks about it a lot. His greatest post-high school concern is making sure he keeps his computer equipment. Currently STUDENT is very motivated to use the Internet and E-Mail.
2. Dave Shaw
Mr. Shaw is an orientation and mobility (OM) instructor for visually impaired students with the Santa Cruz County Office of Education. OM instructors help students develop skills necessary to travel as independently as possible at school and in the community. Mr. Shaw has known STUDENT for many years. He was STUDENT's OM instructor in preschool, and resumed that role when STUDENT began tenth grade (the 1993-94 school year). He also provided some OM instruction to STUDENT during his ninth grade year (1992-93), when STUDENT's OM instructor was Jill Tardiff.
During ninth grade, Mr. Shaw assisted STUDENT with a particularly difficult street crossing near school. He also took him on a few trips to stores in the community. STUDENT made good progress on OM goals that year. He seemed to be a well-known, popular student, who had some typical complaints about school and his classes.
Mr. Shaw provided OM instruction to STUDENT during tenth and eleventh grade at TSI. In the spring of 1995 Mr. Shaw attended meetings to plan STUDENT's return to SCHS. Mr. Shaw noted that STUDENT had made a few inappropriate turns during mobility lessons on days when he was not feeling well. (P B53) That spring, Mr. Shaw accompanied STUDENT to a meeting with his DOR counselor. STUDENT told the DOR counselor he was not interested in working yet.
During twelfth grade (1995-96), Mr. Shaw took STUDENT on mobility lessons to such locations as Santa Cruz Free Radio -- where STUDENT volunteered as a disc jockey on Saturday mornings -- a shopping mall, and a laudromat. When they went on mobility lessons to a physical therapy clinic and a local newspaper, Mr. Shaw described what jobs at those places involved. STUDENT was good at communicating what mobility lessons he was interested in.
STUDENT did well on street crossings and told Mr. Shaw that he frequently walked to school on a route which included five or six intersections. He developed good basic caning skills and the ability to learn new bus routes, with repetition. He did well at asking the bus driver questions when necessary. OM activities that fall also included a visit to the local community college, Cabrillo College, where Mr. Shaw and STUDENT met with a representative of the campus' office of disabled student services, ate in the cafeteria, and investigated the campus shuttle bus service.
That fall STUDENT seemed to make friends with Mr. Goodwin's students. He told Mr. Shaw he was not ready to work or go to college but rather preferred to "kick back." STUDENT said he was not interested in school clubs. Rather, his interests included Free Radio, e-mail and the Internet. In December 1995, STUDENT told Mr. Shaw that that there was nothing wrong with SCHS, but rather that his return to TSI was simply a matter of personal choice. At the December 1995 IEP meeting, STUDENT asserted that he wanted to reduce the frequency of OM lessons from twice weekly to twice monthly. Both PARENT and Mr. Shaw opposed the reduction, but STUDENT's choice was honored.
In the spring of 1996, Mr. Shaw assisted STUDENT in obtaining a California identification card from the Department of Motor Vehicles and in learning to operate an automated banking machine. Over the years Mr. Shaw has provided numerous cooking lessons to STUDENT. STUDENT has developed extremely good cooking skills.
3. Jim Goodwin
Mr. Goodwin is a resource specialist at SCHS. In ninth grade STUDENT was assigned to Mr. Goodwin's room for one period daily, during which time he worked with Ms. Unsicker, the VI teacher. The room was also considered a "safe haven" for STUDENT. He stored his equipment there, and could go there at any time during the day to take a test or study or use the brailler. STUDENT established a rapport with Mr. Goodwin. He also made friendships, socialized, and ate lunch with a small group of students in the room. He was not ridiculed by his peers. He participated in discussions and on one occasion made a funny tape interviewing another student. However, STUDENT's transition to high school was somewhat bumpy socially, and at times he appeared to have limited energy.
In the spring of 1995, in preparation for STUDENT's expected return to SCHS in the fall, Mr. Goodwin visited STUDENT at TSI to re-establish their relationship. It was determined that STUDENT would have a relationship with Mr. Goodwin similar to the one he had had in ninth grade. That is, he would store his equipment in Mr. Goodwin's room, which would be a "safe haven" where he could come at any time during the day, and he would receive one hour of VI teaching there daily from Ms. Unsicker.
In twelfth grade STUDENT was absent a lot and often needed to make up assignments. At times he was discouraged about these absences and all of his medical appointments. Mr. Goodwin often checked with STUDENT's regular education teachers and STUDENT to see how he was doing. Mr. Goodwin attempted to keep STUDENT away from students who had colds. Mr. Goodwin's students liked and showed concern for STUDENT. He was one of the group and participated in discussions. He often ate lunch in Mr. Goodwin's room with these students.
Mr. Goodwin was surprised to learn that STUDENT would be returning to TSI. Things seemed to be going fairly well insofar as re-entering and getting to know people. STUDENT told Mr. Goodwin his decision to return to TSI had nothing to do with SCHS.
4. Andrew Todd
Mr. Todd is the District's special education director. He testified that at the December 1995 IEP meeting, STUDENT stated that his decision to return to TSI was a matter of choice. Because the parents had already enrolled STUDENT at TSI, the purpose of the meeting was simply to ensure the smooth transfer of all of STUDENT's related services to the private school campus.
5. Robert Nation
Mr. Nation, a District school psychologist, was the special education administrator at the IEP meetings in May and June 1995. Mr. Nation testified that at one point during the May meeting, PARENT expressed concern as to STUDENT's ability to return to SCHS. STUDENT said to his father, "You said you wanted me to be independent; let me do this." At the June 1995 meeting, the entire IEP team, including STUDENT, appeared supportive of the plan for STUDENT to attend college after graduation.
6. Kevin Drinkard
Mr. Drinkard was STUDENT's math teacher at SCHS during twelfth grade. The class was a college preparatory one which involved a lot of groupwork. STUDENT started out well. He participated in class, took notes, consistently turned in homework, and showed enthusiasm. He worked well with his group and seemed to enjoy the groupwork. During the first quarter, he earned a B.
As time went on that fall, however, STUDENT's performance deteriorated. He missed a lot of school because of illness and medical appointments. He no longer regularly participated in class, took notes, or turned in homework. He seemed to lose interest and at times appeared tired, withdrawn, and "out of it." When group assignments were rotated and STUDENT was placed with new group members, he complained that he had liked the first group better. STUDENT was permitted to turn in work late by e-mail from home.
During the second quarter STUDENT received a grade of "Pass." Mr. Drinkard stated that he rarely awards such a grade, but did so because of STUDENT's health. He believed STUDENT had learned a lot. STUDENT would have failed the class if regular grading criteria had been applied to him.
Each day Mr. Drinkard read announcements of club meetings contained in the school's Daily Bulletin to his class. He invited STUDENT to join the campus Internet club, for which he was the adviser, but STUDENT said he was "too busy." STUDENT often talked to Mr. Drinkard about Free Radio Santa Cruz. STUDENT made friends in class and was never ridiculed by his peers.
7. Jim Dietz
Mr. Dietz was STUDENT's economics teacher at SCHS during twelfth grade. STUDENT participated in class and completed the major assignments and tests. He was a typical student academically and received a "B" for the course. He made some friends and was not ridiculed by his peers.
8. Rebecca Cole
Ms. Cole is the District's post-school transition case manager. In the fall of 1994, when STUDENT turned 16, Ms. Cole met with STUDENT and prepared an Individualized Transition Plan (ITP). (R 35) She has met with STUDENT at least monthly since then. The ITP prepared that fall included the following objectives: (1) completing a career interest survey, (2) practicing typing, (3) participating in an internship, and (4) obtaining a summer job.
During 1994-95 STUDENT completed two career interest surveys which showed that he had a strong interest in music and a strength in persuasion. He also practiced typing. That year, Ms. Cole assisted STUDENT in establishing his eligibility for services with DOR.
Prior to the June 1995 IEP meeting, Ms. Cole met with STUDENT and his father to gather information and suggestions for updating the ITP. STUDENT, who was going through dialysis at the time, was not feeling well and was very quiet during the meeting. Based primarily on the input of PARENT, a greater college emphasis was added to the ITP. At the IEP meeting, a DOR counselor attended. That summer, STUDENT did not pursue a job or a two-week DOR vocational exploration program, because of health reasons and lack of interest.
During the fall of 1995 STUDENT had a lot of "ups and downs" because of health problems. Therefore, he did not pursue some transition goals (such as college and work). STUDENT made clear that he was not interested in going to college immediately after graduating from high school, and also indicated that he was not ready to participate in a school-sponsored work experience. Ms. Cole left it up to STUDENT to let her know when he felt physically ready to pursue these goals. However STUDENT continued to pursue career exploration in mobility lessons with Mr. Shaw and met with a DOR counselor, Mary Calloway, to discuss job training programs and funding for computer equipment.
Ms. Cole stated that STUDENT is not sure what he wants to do after graduation. In early 1996, he told Ms. Cole that he wanted to amend his ITP so that it focused on his researching careers, training programs and college scholarships on the Internet.
8. Christine Hertel
Ms. Hertel is the director of special education for the Santa Cruz County Office of Education, which has provided STUDENT's VI, OM and assistive technology services. She testified that in December 1995, PARENT, STUDENT's mother, contacted her to advise that STUDENT would be returning to TSI. PARENT stated that there was nothing wrong with SCHS, and that no one at SCHS was to blame, but rather that the decision to return to TSI was simply STUDENT's personal choice. At the IEP meeting of December 7, 1995, STUDENT expressed a desire to have less staff involvement.
9. Pat Dougan
Ms. Dougan is a transition consultant with the state department of education. In preparation for her testimony, she reviewed transition planning documents and spoke with the District's transition case manager, Ms. Coles. She stated that, in her opinion, STUDENT has received appropriate transition planning and services from the District. She noted that he has pursued a college preparatory curriculum and explored the possibility of attending college, received instruction in computers, taken career interest surveys, developed independent living skills such as cooking, received mobility lessons in the community, learned to use an automated bank teller, and obtained a California Identification Card from the Department of Motor Vehicles. She stated that, importantly, he has established a relationship with DOR, which will be his primary adult service agency and can assist him with job placement and job and college-related assistive technology after graduation.
DISCUSSION
A. Summary of Applicable Law
Under federal and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education which emphasizes special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §1401(a)(18); California Education Code §56000. Special education means specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16). Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17). See California Education Code §56363.
A description of the special education and related services to be provided to the student are contained in an Individualized Education Plan (IEP), which is revised annually. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20); §1414(a)(5). An IEP is a written statement developed in a meeting involving school representatives and the parents which must include:
(A) a statement of the present levels of educational performance of such child;
(B) a statement of annual goals, including short-term instructional objectives;
(C) a statement of the specific educational services to be provided to such child, and the extent to which such child will be able to participate in regular educational programs;
(D) a statement of the needed transition services for students beginning no later than age 16 and annually thereafter . . . including, when appropriate, a statement of the interagency responsibilities or linkages (or both) before the student leaves the school setting.
(E) the projected date for initiation and anticipated duration of such services; and (F) appropriate objective criteria and evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether instructional objectives are being achieved.
20 U.S.C. §1401(a)20); Education Code 56345.
In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982), the Supreme Court described a two-part inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided, one part procedural and one part substantive: (1) Has the school district complied with the procedures set forth in IDEA? and (2) Is the IEP reasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefit?
B. The 1992-93 School Year
1. Procedural
In determining procedural compliance, one must look to whether the District has created an IEP which conforms with the requirements of IDEA. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20); Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206, n. 27. As explained below, the evidence showed that in June 1992 the District developed a procedurally appropriate IEP for STUDENT's upcoming ninth grade year (1992-93).
Detailed descriptions of STUDENT's then-current levels of performance were submitted to the IEP team by those District personnel who had provided specialized services to STUDENT pursuant to his IEP in eighth grade: (1) Ms. Unsicker, the VI teacher, regarding academics, braille, and organization, (2) Ms. Tardiff, the OM teacher, regarding mobility and daily living skills, and (3) Ms. Goode, the VI computer teacher. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20)(A); Education Code §56345(a)(1). Annual goals with corresponding short-term objectives were set in the areas of computers, achieving independence, fostering independence in written work, study skills and OM. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)20)(B); Education Code §56345(a)(2). The IEP provided for related services including VI teaching, OM, adapted physical education (APE), and possibly resource specialist assistance. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20)(C); Education Code §56345(a)(3).(Footnote 12) The IEP also provided for certain modifications to allow STUDENT to successfully participate in regular education: brailled materials, taped books and adapted computers. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48.
These specialized services mirrored those which had enabled STUDENT to have a successful experience in junior high school. Additionally, they were designed in accordance with California law, which notes that students with "low incidence disabilities," including vision impairments, require highly specialized services, equipment, and materials. Education Code §56000.5(a)(2); 56026.5.(Footnote 13) Finally, the IEP called for placement in the least restrictive appropriate environment: regular education classes in STUDENT's neighborhood high school. 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. §300.552; Education Code §56031. It is concluded that STUDENT's ninth grade IEP met IDEA's procedural requirements.
2. Substantive
Although the Supreme Court in Rowley declined to establish any one test for measuring the adequacy of educational benefit conferred on a student, it noted that one important factor is the achievement of passing grades. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 203, n.25. The evidence showed that STUDENT received educational benefit in ninth grade. He achieved a B average, received appropriate related services designed to meet his unique needs, and made good progress on his IEP goals and objectives.
STUDENT did experience some social-emotional difficulties adjusting to high school that year. These were documented by District staff in the June 1993 IEP (P A17), Mr. Burns in an August 1993 report, (P I3) and STUDENT himself in a reflective essay written two years later, in June 1995. (P G2). On the other hand, STUDENT had positive daily social interactions with Mr. Goodwin, the resource specialist, and Mr. Goodwin's students. In any event, STUDENT's social-emotional difficulties were not so severe as to interfere with or affect his academic performance or his ability to receive educational benefit. (The parties agree, in retrospect, that some of his difficulties were related to a physical cause that was simply not known at the time -- that STUDENT was feeling poorly and exhibiting low energy because he was experiencing kidney failure.)
Viewing the evidence in its entirety, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with a free, appropriate education during the 1992-93 school year.
C. The 1995-96 School Year
1. Procedural
The evidence showed that during the spring of 1995, the District developed a procedurally appropriate IEP for STUDENT's upcoming twelfth grade year (1995-96). The IEP formulation process was an exhaustive and extensive one. It involved three formal IEP meetings over a three-month period (March-June). It included input from a wide variety of persons knowledgeable about STUDENT, including District personnel, parents, STUDENT, medical personnel, and private school staff, as well as Jack Hazekamp, the state department of education's expert on the education of blind and visually impaired students.
Detailed descriptions of STUDENT's then-current levels of performance were submitted to the IEP team in March, and then again in May, by those persons who had provided specialized services to STUDENT pursuant to his IEP during his eleventh grade year at TSI: Ms. Unsicker, the VI teacher; Mr. Shaw, the OM instructor; Dr. Dass, the private psychotherapist; and Mr. Burns, the therapist and adapted computer expert who provided computer training services. (R 3, 8 and 10-12) Because STUDENT had experienced kidney failure, the IEP team was expanded to include Diane Deese, the District school nurse. She submitted health status reports in March and then again in May. (R 3, 9)
Annual goals with corresponding short-term objectives were set in the areas of high school graduation, study skills, organizational skills, OM, independent living skills, computer technology, and social-emotional growth. (R 5) The IEP provided for related services including VI teaching, OM instruction, counseling, assistive technology (computer equipment), computer training, APE, and vocational education. It also called for resource specialist consultation by Mr. Goodwin with STUDENT's regular education teachers, and it was contemplated that Mr. Goodwin's room would again be a "safe haven" for STUDENT, as it had been during his ninth grade year. Id. The IEP called for placement in the least restrictive appropriate environment: regular education classes in STUDENT's neighborhood high school. 20 U.S.C. §1412(2)(5); 34 C.F.R. §300.552.
The IEP also included a statement of needed transition services for STUDENT, who was then 16 years old. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20)(D). The term transition services is defined as a coordinated set of activities for a student, designed within an outcome-oriented process, which promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment (including supported employment), continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.
20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(19). The "coordinated set of activities" must be based upon "the individual student's needs, taking into account the student's preferences and interests" and must include "instruction, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational [education]." Id.
The evidence showed that, in developing the statement of needed transition services for STUDENT at the June 1995 IEP, the District met IDEA's procedural requirements. The District, appropriately, invited and procured the attendance of both STUDENT and Ed Gulditch, a DOR counselor. 34 C.F.R. §300.344(c)(1). By procuring the attendance of a DOR representative, the District facilitated a "linkage" with the adult agency most likely to have responsibility for providing services to STUDENT after graduation. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20); 34 C.F.R. §300.344(c)(1).
Prior to the June 1995 IEP meeting, Ms. Cole, the transition specialist who had been meeting with STUDENT monthly to discuss transition, solicited from STUDENT his "preferences and interests." 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(19). STUDENT, who was going through dialysis and was feeling poorly that spring, was unable to provide much input or focus on his future. (Primarily, STUDENT indicated that he wished to return to SCHS and to have fewer adults involved in his life.)
Given these circumstances, STUDENT's transition "needs" were determined, appropriately, based upon (1) what was known of STUDENT's preferences and interests and (2) all other available information. This approach complied with IDEA's requirements that the statement of needed transition services be based upon STUDENT's needs and that his preferences and interests be taken into consideration. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(19); 34 C.F.R. §300.344(c)(2).
The statement of needed transition services included career exploration, college/vocational training exploration, graduation from high school, establishing eligibility for services with the DOR, applying for college scholarships and financial aid, and applying to college. The college emphasis was based, to a large extent, on input from PARENT. Such an emphasis was not unreasonable given that STUDENT, who has above average intelligence and is a talented, insightful writer, had performed well academically in high school and was progressing well on fulfilling college entrance requirements for both the University of California and California State University systems. The evidence showed that all participants at the IEP meeting, including STUDENT, supported the college emphasis in the ITP.
It is concluded that in June 1995 the District developed a procedurally appropriate statement of needed transition services. 2. Substantive
The evidence showed that STUDENT received educational benefit during twelfth grade at SCHS. He achieved a "B" average, received appropriate related services designed to meet his unique needs, and made progress on his IEP goals and objectives. (P D25, R 21)
Petitioner asserts that, although STUDENT made academic progress, his social-emotional needs were not met at SCHS. The evidence showed that STUDENT experienced significant depression that fall. According to Dr. Dass, based on his counseling sessions with STUDENT, the primary reason was health concerns relating to recovery from kidney transplant surgery. STUDENT experienced frustration with his health status and frequent absences from school. The depression was most significant in November, during which time STUDENT was hospitalized with flu.
The evidence showed that the District took appropriate steps to address STUDENT's social-emotional needs. STUDENT received counseling from Dr. Dass, who both parties agree has provided outstanding service. STUDENT had positive social interactions with Mr. Goodwin and a small group of Mr. Goodwin's students. Mr. Goodwin's room was a "safe haven" where STUDENT could go at any time. STUDENT also, at times, enjoyed working in a small group of students in his math class. Mr. Drinkard, the math teacher, read club meeting announcements daily and, based on STUDENT's strong interest in computers, invited STUDENT to join the campus Internet club.
Additionally, the evidence showed that STUDENT made some progress on the social-emotional objectives contained in his IEP. For example, he was assertive with Ms. Unsicker, Mr. Shaw, Ms. Cole, and the DOR counselor in identifying the type and amount of services he wanted. In any event, STUDENT's depression did not prevent him from achieving academically or receiving academic benefit. Even assuming TSI would have provided a better setting for working on his social-emotional IEP objectives, SCHS provided an adequate one.(Footnote 14)
Furthermore, there was no evidence that SCHS was inappropriate for physical health reasons. There was no evidence that STUDENT's poor health was either caused or exacerbated by interacting with the large student body. There was no evidence that STUDENT required any school health services that were not provided. Despite his depression, STUDENT continued to take his prescribed medication. He showed no signs of rejecting the new kidney and continued to make a satisfactory recovery. The District accommodated STUDENT's health by permitting him to turn in assignments late and by e-mail. While STUDENT's health has improved somewhat as his recovery period continues, there was no evidence that this was directly attributable to his return to TSI.
Based on all of the foregoing, it is concluded that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE at SCHS during twelfth grade. In determining whether the District has offered an appropriate education, the Hearing Officer focuses on the adequacy of the District's program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program is adequate, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program, and even if the parents' preferred program is better (i.e. would likely result in greater educational benefit to the child than the District's program.) Id.(Footnote 15) Because the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at SCHS, the parents' request for tuition reimbursement for TSI is denied.
The evidence also showed that STUDENT received appropriate transition services that fulfilled IDEA's requirement of a "coordinated set of [transition] activities." 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(19)(20). In the area of vocational skills, STUDENT received extensive training in computers -- a significant area of interest for him -- and was exposed to a variety of adaptive equipment both at home and school. He completed career interest surveys, discussed possible careers, and worked on resume preparation. STUDENT's many years of instruction in Braille from Ms. Unsicker also helped him develop an important vocational skill. The U.S. Department of Education's Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) has noted in a policy guidance memo that there is a strong correlation between knowledge of braille and a blind adult's ability to obtain employment. Policy Guidance on the Education of Blind and Visually Impaired Students, 23 IDELR 377, 379 (1995).
STUDENT also established eligibility for services with the state department of rehabilitation -- creating an important linkage to adult services following graduation. He met with DOR counselors on several occasions to discuss such issues as job training and placement services and funding for adapted computer equipment -- another significant interest of his. Although STUDENT indicated he was not interested in participating in a work experience while still in high school, having an open case with DOR means that should he develop such an interest after graduation, there should be no delay in obtaining DOR's assistance.
In the area of independent living skills, STUDENT has developed mobility skills in bus travel, caning, and crossing intersections. He has had mobility lessons to numerous places in the community, including a radio station where he volunteered, a variety of stores, a laundromat, a community college, and DOR. He has developed good cooking skills and has learned to use an automated banking machine.
In the area of college preparation, STUDENT is scheduled to graduate this spring having fulfilled requirements to enter either the University of California or California State University system. He has reviewed the format of college catalogs with Ms. Unsicker and visited a local community college with Mr. Shaw, where he met with a representative of the campus office of disabled student services, ate in the cafeteria, and explored the campus shuttle bus system. Although STUDENT has decided not to enter college in the fall of 1996, the evidence showed that college remains a possibility for him in the near future.
This case has some similarity to Chuhran v. Walled Lake Consolidated School District, 839 F. Supp 465 (E.D. Mich. 1993), aff'd, 22 IDELR 450 (6th Cir. 1995). There, a disabled student received the following transition services: (1) a vocational evaluation revealing a strong interest in computers, (2) one-on-one computer training, (3) exposure to adaptive computer equipment, (4) informal career and college counseling, and (5) assistance in opening his case with the state department of rehabilitation. It was held that these activities provided the student with adequate transition services. Id.
Viewing the evidence in its entirety, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has received appropriate transition services from the District. Although it is possible that, had STUDENT not experienced health problems, he would have chosen to participate in a work experience or apply to college with the District's assistance, the District has provided him with the tools to pursue such activities if and when he so chooses. Therefore, Petitioner's request for two years of compensatory transition services is denied.
ORDER
Each of Petitioner's requests for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated: April 19, 1996 ______________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1. TSI was formerly known as Global Youth Academy. For the sake of consistency the school will be referred to, throughout this Decision, as TSI.
2. Petitioner's exhibits are preceded by "P"; Respondent's exhibits are preceded by "R".
3. Resource specialists provide assistance to disabled students being served by an IEP who attend regular education classes for at least a majority of their school day. Education Code §56362.
4. Later in the school year, in March, 1993, STUDENT's IEP was revised to provide for consultation by Ms. Goode, the VI computer teacher, as needed. (P A18)
5. STUDENT's grades during ninth grade at SCHS were:
Fall 1992 Spring 1993 Indep. study B Indep. study B Math C Math B Adaptive PE A Adaptive PE A English B English C French C Theater Arts B World Civ. B Health B
6. In a January 1995 mediation agreement in a separate case involving these same parties (Case No. SN 942-94), the District agreed to reimburse the parents for some of the tutoring and counseling. (P C6)
7. Some of these ninth grade social-emotional issues were also discussed in an August, 1993 report by Mr. Burns. (P I3)
8. The parties referred to two types of "transition" planning in this case: (1) from eleventh grade at the private TSI to twelfth grade at the public SCHS; and (2) from high school to post-school life. The latter type of transition planning is specifically defined in IDEA. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(19), (20). The former is not. Therefore, to avoid confusion, use of the term transition in this Decision will refer to transition from school to post-school life as defined in the IDEA. The process of assisting STUDENT to move from eleventh grade at TSI to twelfth grade at Santa Cruz will be referred to as STUDENT's "return" to public school.
9. Petitioner asserts that STUDENT was therefore eligible for special education and related services not only not only because of his blindness but also because of "other health impairment" (OHI). 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(1). OHI is defined as "having limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems . . . that adversely affect a child's educational performance." 34 C.F.R. §300.7(b)(8).
10. This involves family issues that Dr. Dass addresses with STUDENT in their counseling sessions.
11. Ms. Unsicker's title is "itinerant special day class teacher." See Education Code §56364.1.
12. In March, 1993, towards the end of STUDENT's ninth grade year, the IEP was amended to include VI computer consultation from Ms. Goode. (P A18)
13. See also California Department of Education Program Guidelines for Visually Impaired Individuals, prepared pursuant to Education Code 56136.
14. The evidence regarding the feelings of STUDENT -- who did not testify -- towards SCHS and TSI was inconsistent. All of the following comments have been attributed to STUDENT: (1) there was nothing wrong with SCHS but he preferred TSI, (2) SCHS was too easy and boring, (3) SCHS was too fast-paced, (4) TSI was more challenging, (5) he wanted the larger amount of attention that he would receive at TSI, (6) TSI was boring, placed too much attention on him, and he would prefer to be back at SCHS.
15. The school district is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits to the child, but rather to provide a "basic floor of opportunity." Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200. Although Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(b) states that educational programs for disabled students must allow them the opportunity to "achieve [their] full potential", the Education Code provides that nothing in state special education law is intended to set a higher standard of educating disabled students than is required by the IDEA. Education Code §56000; see Bertolucci v. San Carlos Elementary School District, 721 F. Supp. 1150, 1156 (N.D. Cal. 1989).
