California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 3, 1996
Student v. Lodi Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1242-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Lodi Unified must place a student at Devereux residential school after the Hearing Officer rejects its North Valley School offer.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a March 26, 1996 court order, obtained by the district, excluding the student from Lodi High School, and an agreed interim placement at Central Valley Training Center pending the decision.
Summary
A 17-year-old Lodi High School junior filed for due process after Lodi Unified School District offered a day placement at North Valley School, a nonpublic school. The student has developmental delays, with test scores in the mild to moderate mentally retarded range, plus several medical and neurological conditions. His behavior at school had escalated, including assaults on his aide. A December 1995 IEP team found his placement no longer appropriate. His parents then sought Devereux School in Santa Barbara, a residential school for developmentally disabled students. Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found North Valley inappropriate. Most of its 54 students had serious emotional disturbance, none were diagnosed as developmentally delayed, and its staff had no training in developmental disabilities. It also had no life skills curriculum in use. The student would be isolated. Key services would be a patchwork supplied by the district and the county, with no one named to coordinate them. The Hearing Officer also found that the student needed one consistent behavior program across school and home to benefit from his education, so he required a combined residential and educational placement. Devereux met his needs and could carry out his IEP. The Hearing Officer rejected the district's cost and distance objections because the district offered no appropriate alternative and the roughly $50,000 residential cost was not prohibitive. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and enroll the student at Devereux within 30 days.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to a proposed nonpublic school. The placement failed because the student would be isolated among peers with different disabilities and his services were split across agencies. It also shows a Hearing Officer ordering a residential placement because the student needed one consistent behavior program at school and at home.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
North Valley, a nonpublic school serving almost entirely higher-functioning students with serious emotional disturbance, was not designed to meet the student's unique needs, did not conform to his IEP (life skills curriculum, transition plan, speech), and offered no reasonable prospect of educational benefit.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. If North Valley is not an appropriate placement, is Devereux School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
The student needed an integrated residential and educational placement with one consistent behavior program to benefit from his education; Devereux met his needs and IEP, and cost and distance did not make it inappropriate since the district offered no appropriate alternative.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the decision to conform the IEP to the decision.
- Placement ordered. District to enroll the student at Devereux School (residential and educational program, Santa Barbara) within 30 days of the decision.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Kruelle v. New Castle County School District; Christopher T. v. San Francisco Unified School District; Abrahamson v. Hershman; Clovis Unified School District v. California Office of Administrative Hearings; Letter to Van Wart (OSEP 1993)
People named in the decision
- Wilma Poage, SELPA director, Lodi Unified SELPA
- Espen Jensen, residential care provider/manager, Casa de Mansano
- Victor Olandesca, residential care facility manager, Melmar
- Dr. Allison Hall, psychiatrist (evaluator), Children's Hospital Oakland, Department of Psychiatry
- Dr. Patricia Mittelstadt, clinical psychologist; neuropsychological evaluator; expert witness for Student, Child Development Center, Children's Hospital Oakland
- Stephanie Ennis, special day class teacher, Lodi High School
- Robert Rivas, assistant principal, Lodi High School
- Debra Staley, principal, Lodi High School
- Anthony, "hot spot" 1:1 aide, Lodi Unified School District
- Ronnie Dietrich, behavioral specialist; functional analysis assessment, Spectrum Center
- Dr. John Gerdtz, behavioral consultant, Spectrum Center
- Tom Johnson, speech-language therapist, Lodi Unified School District
- Beverly Johnson, regional center case manager, Valley Mountain Regional Center
- Dr. Franklin Bernhoft, school psychologist, Lodi Unified School District
- Irene Ishida, program specialist, Lodi Unified School District
- Shirley Podesta, supervising nurse, Lodi Unified School District
- Elizabeth Whitmore, program specialist, vocational programs, Lodi Unified School District
- Tim Foster, principal, North Valley School (nonpublic school)
- Mark Edelstein, staff psychiatrist, North Valley School
- David Lichti, admissions social worker, Devereux School, Santa Barbara
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Lodi, California, on February 27, 28, March 18, 19, 20, and April 9 and 10, 1996.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Joyce Carrillo. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER.
Respondent Lodi Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jan Damesyn. Also present on the District's behalf was Wilma Poage, SELPA director.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties, the record was left open for telephone testimony of one witness and the submission of written closing briefs. The telephone testimony was received, and the closing briefs were submitted to the Hearing Office on May 13, 1996. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
(2) If North Valley is not an appropriate placement, is Devereux School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
EVIDENTIARY ISSUES
A significant amount of testimony was introduced relating to the appropriateness of STUDENT's placement in the special day class at Lodi High School over the past three years. Petitioner argues in his closing brief that this is relevant to whether the District has proposed an appropriate placement at North Valley School. Petitioner states that he has "lost out of many years of programming from which he could derive educational benefit. The patchwork, piecemeal program being offered will not remedy what he has lost. Again, STUDENT cannot afford to be the subject of an experiment at North Valley. Too much time has been lost. In addition this history demonstrates the District's inability to carry out the recommendations of various experts..."
The District did not address this issue in its closing brief. However, during the hearing, the District contended that the appropriateness of the special day class was not relevant to the issues before the hearing officer.
While information regarding STUDENT's past placement may relate to his educational needs, information about the past placement does not specifically relate to the issues identified for this hearing -- whether North Valley is an appropriate placement and, if not, is Devereux an appropriate placement. The relevant testimony to be summarized is that relating to North Valley, Devereux, and STUDENT's educational needs. The testimony relating to North Valley and Devereux provides sufficient information regarding STUDENT's educational needs. The testimony regarding STUDENT's past placement is redundant and does not need be considered in depth in this decision.
The Hearing Officer also notes that the parties attempted to introduce evidence relating to other placements they looked into when searching for a placement for STUDENT. However, this evidence was not allowed in because the issues as identified at the beginning of the hearing related to two specific placements -- North Valley and Devereux -- and did not allow for an examination of other placements.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old young man with a wide range of disabilities. STUDENT has been diagnosed with Tourette's Syndrome, oppositional defiant disorder, attention deficit disorder, Klinefelter's Syndrome, developmental delays, and a structural brain defect(Footnote 1). STUDENT is currently taking Haldol and receives testosterone injections. STUDENT's most recent agreed upon IEP, dated December 11, 1995, indicates the rationale for his eligibility for special education as being "delays in cognition, achievement, language, psychomotor areas and adaptive behavior."
When STUDENT was eleven years old, his parents placed him in a residential care facility, Solstice II, funded by the Valley Mountain Regional Center (VMRC). STUDENT resided at Solstice for approximately two and a half years until 1993, when his parents moved him to Casa de Mansano, another residential care facility. Casa de Mansano is managed by Espen Jensen. In February 1996, STUDENT left Casa de Mansano and was placed at another residential care facility, Melmar. (Testimony of Espen Jensen.) By the time STUDENT left Casa de Mansano, the staff there had been able to bring his behaviors under control.
Melmar is an adult care facility managed by Victor Olandesca. STUDENT has remained at Melmar during the pendency of these proceedings. During the short time STUDENT has been at Melmar, he has been involved in only one major behavioral incident at the home, and that was a result of a suspension he received from school. (Testimony of Victor Olandesca.) While STUDENT has been at Casa de Mansano and Melmar he has continued to attend school at Lodi High School.
In the fall of 1993, STUDENT was evaluated at Children's Hospital in Oakland. Dr. Allison Hall, who is with the Department of Psychiatry at Children's Hospital, recommended the testosterone therapy which STUDENT is currently receiving. Dr. Hall also recommended discontinuing Tegretol which STUDENT was on at the time and decreasing STUDENT's dosage of Haldol.
Dr. Patricia Mittelstadt, a clinical psychologist with the Child Development Center at Children's Hospital, conducted a neuropsychological examination of STUDENT. Dr. Mittelstadt concluded that STUDENT was functioning in the moderately retarded range based on global delays in every area of functioning, including cognition, academic achievement, and adaptive skills. Dr. Mittelstadt also noted STUDENT's difficulties with coping and impulse control and stated that the testosterone therapy could decrease his aggressive behaviors. Dr. Mittelstadt stated that, without significant improvement in his behaviors, STUDENT would need to be placed in a day treatment program. Dr. Mittelstadt also recommended that STUDENT remain in a residential home such as the one he was in at the time (Casa de Mansano). Other recommendations made by Dr. Mittelstadt included an educational program which focuses on adaptive functioning and prevocational skills, an extensive behavior management program, and involvement in a structured and activity-oriented social skills group.
On March 28, 1994, Dr. Mittelstadt sent MOTHER a letter to explain in more detail some aspects of her report. In her March 1994 letter, Dr. Mittelstadt emphasized the importance of school personnel who could address STUDENT's developmental disability and his need for behavioral management. Dr. Mittelstadt also stated that STUDENT should be in a program close to home because of his need to see his family on a regular and frequent basis. In addition, Dr. Mittelstadt stated that STUDENT should not be in a program with severely emotionally disturbed children because his primary disability is a developmental disability, not an emotional disturbance.
STUDENT is currently in his junior year of high school. He has spent most of the past three years in a special day class taught by Stephanie Ennis at Lodi High School(Footnote 2). STUDENT has experienced numerous behavioral incidents at school which have increased in severity, especially during the current school year. During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT was suspended for 13 1/2 days and sent home through formal and informal suspensions a total of 25-30 days. During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT's behavior improved in response to a consistent approach to behavioral management between home and school, and he was informally sent home early nine times. (Testimony of Stephanie Ennis)
During the current school year and up until the first day of hearing, STUDENT was suspended 13 times for a total of 19 1/2 days, although it is unclear whether all suspensions were actually implemented. The number of physical assaults have increased with seven assaults occurring between December 11, 1995 and February 26, 1996. Most of these assaults have been directed towards the "hot spot" aide. (Testimony of Robert Rivas)
During STUDENT's first two years at Lodi High School, Ms. Ennis and Mr. Jensen had an agreement, formalized in an IEP dated April 21, 1994, which called for Mr. Jensen to bring STUDENT home early from school if his behavior got out of control. The April 1994 IEP also called for a daily communication book between school and home, verbal reminders of appropriate behavior at school, and a "responsibility statement" for each disruptive incident. Although not indicated in the IEP, Mr. Jensen also would keep STUDENT home from school in the morning if he was uncooperative, in an attempt to avoid problems developing at school. Once STUDENT's behaviors were under control, Mr. Jensen would then bring STUDENT to school. At school, STUDENT received verbal praise and favored activities to reinforce appropriate behavior. However, the plan outlined in the April 1994 IEP called for STUDENT to receive the negative consequences of his behavior at home rather than at school.
During the Spring 1995, Mr. Jensen decided he no longer wanted to be responsible for imposing the negative consequences (described by Mr. Jensen as "weed therapy") of STUDENT's school behavior. As a result, the District agreed in June 1995 to hire a behavioral specialist to conduct a functional analysis assessment and to develop a behavioral intervention plan. In addition, in August 1995, the District hired a "hot spot" aide to work with STUDENT. Although the evidence was unclear, it appears that the aide was a one-to-one aide assigned to STUDENT to help him control his behaviors by intervening when it appeared that he was losing control.
The functional analysis assessment was completed by Ronnie Dietrich of the Spectrum Center on September 7, 1995(Footnote 3). The report identified STUDENT's target behaviors as sleeping in class and disruptive behaviors extending from noncompliance to assaultive behavior toward staff. The assaultive behavior includes incidents when STUDENT has struck members of the staff. Mr. Dietrich determined that STUDENT became sleepy when his schedule called for a low-energy activity, such as reading, immediately following a high-energy activity, such as adaptive physical education. Mr. Dietrich recommended revising STUDENT's schedule to provide STUDENT with more high-energy activities during the times he complains about being sleepy.
With regards to STUDENT's disruptive behavior, Mr. Dietrich determined that STUDENT typically became disruptive when he was asked to perform academic tasks or when he received a low behavior rating and his attempts at negotiation to avoid the task or receive a higher rating failed. Mr. Dietrich suggested teaching STUDENT appropriate behaviors to replace the disruptive behaviors he was engaging in to avoid activities. In addition, Mr. Dietrich suggested that STUDENT be offered choices about which work to do and his activities be in five-minute increments with high-preference activities interspersed with low-preference activities. Finally, Mr. Dietrich recommended establishing clear standards and criteria for ending activities.
Mr. Dietrich found the same behaviors in STUDENT's group home environment. However, he determined that the staff was more successful at managing STUDENT's behaviors by engaging him in activities throughout the day and establishing clear criteria and end points for the work STUDENT was to do. STUDENT's caregivers also provided STUDENT with choices between tasks.
STUDENT also received a speech and language evaluation on September 11, 1995, from Tom Johnson, speech and language therapist for the District. Mr. Johnson found that STUDENT's language processing was significantly delayed. STUDENT's age equivalent scores on the Language Process Test ranged from 5.7 years to 8.5 years. Mr. Johnson recommended that STUDENT continue to receive language skill training in the classroom and that staff use redundancy to assist STUDENT in understanding misinterpreted information. Mr. Johnson also recommended that STUDENT be isolated from discussions of controversial or emotionally laden topics because of STUDENT's tendency to misinterpret information and focus or perseverate on inappropriate aspects of discussions.
Following the completion of Mr. Dietrich's report and Mr. Johnson's report, an IEP team was convened on September 18, 1995. The IEP team developed a comprehensive and detailed behavioral intervention plan and implemented speech and language therapy for STUDENT twice a week. (District Exhibit No. 8) In addition, the IEP team agreed on October 17, 1995, to develop a token economy program to reward appropriate behaviors and task completion. The token economy program was implemented in November 1995.
On November 28, 1995, STUDENT assaulted two staff members. According to Mr. Rivas, an assistant principal at Lodi High School, STUDENT walked out of class during sixth period. The "hot spot" aide, Anthony, followed STUDENT to the bus. On the way to the bus, STUDENT broke some branches off of a tree and threw the branches at Anthony. STUDENT also tried to hit Anthony with his backpack several times. As a result of the incident, Mr. Rivas and the principal, Debra Staley, decided to suspend STUDENT for five days and recommend him for expulsion.
A pre-expulsion IEP meeting was convened on December 11, 1995. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT's misconduct was caused by his disability and that he was no longer appropriately placed. As a result, the expulsion did not go forward. The IEP team agreed to "take 30 days to research appropriate public or nonpublic placements for developmentally delayed students similar to STUDENT."
On December 18, 1995, Dr. Gerdtz and Dr. Wilma Poage, the SELPA director, developed a "Criteria for Educational Placement" for STUDENT to use as a guide in the search for a placement for STUDENT. The list included the following components:
1. Modified Academic Curriculum a. Life skills based b. Time and money skills
2. Vocational-Transition program a. Supported employment goal b. Leisure skills development c. Career exploration
3. Intensive Behavioral Management Program a. Ability to provide prone containment as needed b. Ability to implement behavior intervention plan c. Monitor behaviors as it relates to medication
4. Peer Group a. Developmentally disabled b. Young adult social interaction
5. Speech Therapy a. Classroom-based communication skills b. Formula patterned dialog c. Labeling, attributes and differences
Following the December 1995 IEP, STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, and STUDENT's case manager with VMRC, Beverly Johnson, conducted a search of nonpublic placements. MOTHER and Ms. Johnson concluded that Devereux School in Santa Barbara, California, was the only appropriate placement for STUDENT because it is a residential and educational facility which focuses on students with developmental delays. The District conducted its own search and concluded that North Valley School, which is located outside of Lodi, California, could provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT. In January 1996, Dr. Franklin Bernhoft, school psychologist for the District, completed a triennial reevaluation that was started in December 1995 as a preexpulsion evaluation. Dr. Bernhoft reviewed the prior diagnoses of STUDENT and concluded from prior testing and his own testing that STUDENT is mildly mentally retarded. Dr. Bernhoft based his conclusion on a full scale score of 60 on the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised (WAIS-R). Many of the scores on other tests administered by Dr. Bernhoft were in the mild to moderate mentally retarded range, a significant number of which were in the moderate range. For example, in the area of receptive and expressive language, STUDENT received a standard score of 40 on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R), standard scores ranging from 46-52 on the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), and an Adaptive Behavior Composite standard score of 33 on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales.
In the Conclusions/Recommendations section, Dr. Bernhoft suggests that while much of STUDENT's oppositional behaviors may be organically driven rather than under his operant control, the increase in STUDENT's behaviors directed toward the "hot spot" aide may be an indication that he has some control over his behaviors. Dr. Bernhoft also recommends working on STUDENT's self-concept, teaching him appropriate self-assertion skills, and modifying classroom instruction to account for STUDENT's difficulties with auditory discrimination and relative strengths in short-term memory.
The District formally offered North Valley School as a placement option at an IEP meeting on February 9, 1996. According to that IEP, the District was proposing to have District staff provide vocational and career education on-site at North Valley. In addition, the District was willing to provide staff to manage STUDENT's medication and consult with North Valley personnel on monitoring STUDENT's behaviors as they relate to his medication. STUDENT's parents rejected the North Valley placement.
Devereux School in Santa Barbara offers residential, educational and adult vocational or day activity programs which "specialize in treating developmentally disabled persons who may have concurrent emotional, neurological or medical needs." (District's Exhibit No. 72) The residential component "concentrates on teaching life skills that help residents develop mastery of social behaviors and promote the building of individual self-esteem." (District's Exhibit No. 74) STUDENT's parents have requested placement in the residential and educational components of Devereux.
North Valley School's day program emphasizes "remedial education, vocational training readiness, independent living skills, and social skills training." North Valley's program is committed to serving SED children. The program consists of a special education program and an intensive mental health treatment component. (Petitioner's Exhibit No. 40)
The costs associated with the two proposed placements are the following:
Devereux $152 per day for education and speech therapy $4,423 per month for residential
North Valley $205.80 per day for education and mental health component (speech therapy would be provided by the District; services from the on-site psychiatrist would require an additional fee)
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
STUDENT's Educational Needs(Footnote 4)
There was general agreement regarding the following:
(1) STUDENT needs a curriculum that focuses on functional living skills, including prevocational training that will prepare him for independent living and supported employment in the future. Included in this area would be job opportunities both on and off campus.
(2) The placement criteria developed by Drs. Gerdtz and Poage, except for the developmental delayed peer group, are necessary components of any placement for STUDENT.
(3) STUDENT needs medication monitoring, especially since he will have to discontinue Haldol soon and also to monitor the testosterone therapy.
(4) STUDENT needs a clear and comprehensive behavioral management program in his educational environment.
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT needs to begin detaching himself from his family. MOTHER also testified that he needs a functional living skills curriculum that is realistic and that he needs his behavior to be under control before academics can be addressed.
Dr. Patricia Mittelstadt, the clinical psychologist who evaluated STUDENT at Children's Hospital in Oakland in 1993, testified that STUDENT needs a day treatment program for children with developmental delays and behavioral difficulties, but should not be in program for SED because staff would not be trained in developmental delays and the peer group would be inappropriate. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that STUDENT needs a peer group of all mild mentally retarded students because they would be at a similar level and using the same curriculum. In addition, STUDENT wouldn't feel isolated, and the peer group would foster social development and self-esteem. Dr. Mittelstadt stated that STUDENT's program should be implemented by staff trained to work with developmental disabilities.
Dr. Mittelstadt testified that functional living skills should be taught in the community because with STUDENT's retardation he cannot generalize what he is taught in the classroom. Finally, STUDENT needs group work on social skills, including role playing, rather than abstract teaching.
Dr. Franklin Bernhoft, the school psychologist who has assessed STUDENT, testified that STUDENT needs a structured environment and individuals working with him who understand the need to intervene immediately. The individuals who work with STUDENT also need to understand that he is at a level equivalent to a six-and-a-half-year-old and that he is not able to process information. Dr. Bernhoft testified that STUDENT needs visual, hands-on, and individualized instruction. STUDENT also needs role models he can relate to, including male peers with strength, empathy, and appropriate social skills.
Espen Jensen, STUDENT's care provider at Casa de Mansano, testified that STUDENT needs a setting that will encompass all of STUDENT's needs. Mr. Jensen testified that consistency is crucial for STUDENT because of the complexity of his behaviors.
Beverly Johnson, STUDENT's case manager at VMRC, testified that STUDENT needs activities that are balanced between sit-down academics and more high-energy activities. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT also needs more practical or community-oriented activities. Ms. Johnson agrees with the criteria developed by Drs. Gerdtz and Poage, but believes that STUDENT needs a residential educational placement. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT needs a strong educational program which emphasizes vocational skills, leisure time programs, and independent living skills, and which allows for modelling of older developmentally delayed students.
Regarding monitoring of medications, Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT needs more than just medication monitoring. STUDENT needs monitoring to assess subtle behavioral changes due to medication with on-site coordination and monitoring of testosterone therapy. Ms. Johnson also testified that STUDENT needs staff trained in developmental delays and behavioral management. Because STUDENT's behavior crosses over between school and home, he needs an interdisciplinary team that can adapt in both environments.
Dr. John Gerdtz, the behavioral specialist from Spectrum, testified that STUDENT's behavioral management plan should include teaching him how to negotiate for things in an appropriate manner. STUDENT's educational program should intersperse familiar activities with new activities. Dr. Gerdtz testified that the placement criteria he developed is still appropriate but he pointed out that there are some disadvantages to a peer group that is composed solely of students with developmental delays. Dr. Gerdtz testified that STUDENT needs interaction with other types of people in order to enhance his vocational and social skills training. Regarding staff training, Dr. Gerdtz testified that it is more important for staff to know STUDENT, his background and appropriate interventions, then to have training in developmental delays. Dr. Gerdtz testified that STUDENT's primary needs at this time are an intensive behavioral program and a life skills curriculum.
Tom Johnson, speech pathologist for the District, testified that STUDENT needs basic communication skills building in the classroom (eye contact, how to start and stop conversations, identifying signs of politeness and rudeness) and role playing for skill building in different contexts and for generalizing those skills. STUDENT's instruction should include redundancy through visual and words to keep him on task. Mr. Johnson testified that staff should avoid discussing emotionally laden issues around STUDENT because of his tendency to misinterpret and then perseverate on them.
Irene Ishida, program specialist for the District, testified that the behavioral area is STUDENT's primary need at this time. Ms. Ishida testified that the secondary needs include functional, vocational and community skills, and monitoring of medication. Ms. Ishida testified that STUDENT does not need a residential component to his placement. Ms. Ishida testified that because STUDENT is only mildly mentally retarded, he should be in a peer group that is as "normal" as possible.
North Valley School
MOTHER testified that she contacted North Valley when she was conducting her search for placements. MOTHER testified that she was told by a staff member there that North Valley would not be appropriate for STUDENT because he was not diagnosed with a severe emotional disturbance (SED).
Dr. Mittelstadt visited North Valley just prior to testifying at the hearing. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that North Valley would provide a good program with a strong behavioral management program for students with SED. However, Dr. Mittelstadt did not believe that North Valley was an appropriate placement for STUDENT because most of the students were higher functioning than STUDENT and most were SED. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that STUDENT needs a peer group of students who are developmentally delayed to foster social development with a similar group.
Dr. Mittelstadt also testified that it was important for staff working with STUDENT to be trained in working with students with developmental disabilities. The staff at North Valley does not have training with such students.
Dr. Mittelstadt observed the class that has been proposed for STUDENT. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that there were nine students in the class, none of whom had been diagnosed with developmental delays. She also noted that the students were functioning at a higher level than STUDENT and doing work in 15-30 minute segments, which would be too long for STUDENT. The net effect of enrolling STUDENT in the proposed class, according to Dr. Mittelstadt, would be that he would be isolated from the other students because of his lower functioning level and need to do work in much shorter segments of time. Dr. Bernhoft has visited North Valley several times. Dr. Bernhoft testified that North Valley focuses on social skills, reducing behaviors, and could meet STUDENT's needs. North Valley also provides therapeutic groups run by teachers and mental health professionals in the afternoons which work on social skills, interpersonal relationships, and coping skills. According to Dr. Bernhoft, although 86% of the students at North Valley have a primary disability of SED, the peer group would be appropriate because the students are at a cognitive level similar to STUDENT's. Finally, Dr. Bernhoft testified that the vocational program at North Valley provides opportunities for work-site visits and on-site jobs. Dr. Bernhoft also testified that North Valley's closeness to STUDENT's home is an issue because of STUDENT's concern about his family.
Stephanie Ennis, STUDENT's special day class teacher at Lodi High School, spent approximately 45 minutes at North Valley during a visit in February 1996. Ms. Ennis testified that the behavioral management techniques were appropriate and that staff dealt effectively with inappropriate behaviors. Ms. Ennis testified that the curriculum materials she saw were similar to those she uses in her class and that the students in the class she observed were similar to the students in her class. Ms. Ennis testified that she could provide additional materials and consultation to North Valley staff if necessary.
Shirley Podesta, a supervising nurse for the District, testified that all of the North Valley staff are trained in the administration of medication and general safety issues. Ms. Podesta testified that if STUDENT were placed at North Valley, the District could assign a nurse to work with the staff regarding administration of STUDENT's medications and observation for adverse symptoms and effects of medication changes. Ms. Podesta also testified that the District could monitor any medication changes and set up an emergency plan. Ms. Podesta testified that the District does not have an arrangement like this for any other student, nor has the District provided any medical supervision services for other students at North Valley.
Elizabeth Whitmore, a program specialist for the District who oversees vocational programs, testified that she can work with North Valley staff on a workability program. Ms. Whitmore described workability as a jobs program for severely and learning handicapped students who work with on-site job coaches. Ms. Whitmore testified that North Valley has a life skills program and work experience programs with plenty of on-site jobs at North Valley.
Tim Foster, principal at North Valley, testified that there are approximately 54 students at the facility, none of whom have been diagnosed as developmentally delayed. Mr. Foster testified that the student-teacher ratio is three students for each teacher or aide and that some students have 1-to-1 aides assigned to their classes. Mr. Foster testified that none of the staff has training in developmental disabilities. The staff is trained in behavioral management, including Managing Assaultive Behavior (MAB) training.
Mr. Foster testified that the curriculum is adapted to each student's individual needs and that the District would provide supplemental services, such as adaptive physical education. Regarding the therapeutic groups, Mr. Foster testified that the groups work on social skills and provide group counselling. Which group STUDENT would be placed in would depend on his needs but he should be placed in a group with students who are functioning at a similar level.
North Valley has a psychiatrist on staff, Mark Edelstein, who serves the students who reside in an affiliated residential program. Mr. Foster testified Dr. Edelstein could provide psychological services, if needed, and medication monitoring to STUDENT.
Regarding the District's placement guidelines, Mr. Foster testified that North Valley is currently not using a life skills curriculum, but that the school does have the materials available and could implement such a curriculum for STUDENT. North Valley could provide job site visits and on-site jobs, but off-site jobs would have to be provided through the county vocational education program. Leisure skills could be worked on in the classroom and during the therapeutic groups. Medication monitoring could be handled by the psychiatrist, or with assistance from the District. Regarding a peer group of developmentally delayed students, Mr. Foster testified that there are probably one or two students at North Valley who are developmentally delayed and functioning at a lower level than STUDENT. North Valley has a speech and language therapist on-site one day per week and the District could provide its own therapy if necessary.
Regarding STUDENT's goals and objectives, Mr. Foster testified that North Valley could work on all of them. One goal is meal planning and cooking. Mr. Foster testified that meal planning could be handled in the life skills curriculum and the cooking could be done with the school's chef who has been trained in behavioral intervention. All of the other goals could be met through the vocational programs, the life skills curriculum, and the therapeutic groups.
Mr. Foster testified that, based on his review of STUDENT's IEPs, suspension notices, behavioral intervention plans, and observations of STUDENT at Lodi High School, North Valley could provide an appropriate educational program. Mr. Foster testified that North Valley has students with similar behavioral and educational needs.
Dr. Gerdtz testified that the class he observed at North Valley was well-structured with a variety of activities. He saw the life skills curriculum that North Valley could implement and testified that it would address community living skills, communication skills, and other areas that STUDENT needs to work on. Dr. Gerdtz testified that the life skills curriculum does not include time and money skills, so the District would have to provide additional materials and consultation in this area.
In the vocational area, Dr. Gerdtz testified that North Valley offers on-site jobs in a student-run business, which would help STUDENT gain skills in pre-employment, but that North Valley would need assistance in providing supported employment opportunities off-campus. Dr. Gerdtz testified that North Valley would need assistance in providing off-campus leisure activity and career exploration opportunities. Dr. Gerdtz also testified that North Valley's social skills program would address areas in which STUDENT has problems.
Dr. Gerdtz testified that the behavioral management program at North Valley is a comprehensive reinforcement system that could be adapted to STUDENT's needs, but that North Valley would need assistance with monitoring medications and behaviors associated with STUDENT's medications. Dr. Gerdtz testified that the make up of the peer groupat North Valley could have a positive effect on STUDENT because vocational and social skills training requires exposure to non-developmentally delayed peers.
Ms. Ishida has been involved in the placement of numerous students at North Valley and observed North Valley with Dr. Mittelstadt. Ms. Ishida testified that when the District considers a nonpublic school placement, North Valley is always the first option because of its proximity to the District and because other students placed there have been successful.
Ms. Ishida testified that the peer group at North Valley consists of appropriate intellectual role models because the students' cognitive functioning is in the borderline to normal range. Ms. Ishida testified that students with mild mental retardation should have a peer group that is as "normal" a population as possible. Ms. Ishida testified that North Valley is an appropriate placement and can meet STUDENT's behavioral needs and implement his behavioral intervention plan with coordination with Melmar. Ms. Ishida also indicated that North Valley could implement STUDENT's goals and objectives, and is in the least restrictive environment because it is community-based and does not include a residential component.
Devereux School
MOTHER visited Devereux in January 1996 with Ms. Johnson, FATHER, and STUDENT. The visit included a tour of the school site, four dormitories, and an off-site residence. MOTHER testified that the behavioral system is carried over from the school to the residence and that planned leisure activities take place in both environments as well. MOTHER testified that functional living skills are taught at Devereux and include such things as riding the bus, job-related skills, and coping with real-life situations. MOTHER testified that that she and FATHER would continue seeing STUDENT approximately once a month and talk with him by phone at least once a week if he were placed at Devereux.
Dr. Mittelstadt did not visit Devereux but did speak with an intake worker regarding the composition of Devereux's program and student body. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that Devereux is a residential placement for students with a primary diagnosis of developmental delays. Approximately 35-45 of the students are moderately retarded. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that Devereux has a community-based program for job training and that students with behavior that is under control spend one-half of the school day in the community. Dr. Mittelstadt testified that all of the staff at Devereux is trained in developmental disabilities and that each student is assigned a caseworker.
Ms. Johnson visited Devereux in January 1996 with the PARENTS. Ms. Johnson described Devereux as a residential school that addresses behavior throughout the day. Ms. Johnson testified that Devereux focuses on functional living skills and has a large recreation program. The transition program includes a continuum from on-campus jobs to community jobs to supported employment. Ms. Johnson testified that the community jobs and supported employment are offered only to students who have their behavior under control. Ms. Johnson testified that Devereux staff could address STUDENT's need for medication monitoring and testosterone therapy because there are a psychiatrist, psychologist, and medical doctor on staff. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT would fit in with the program at Devereux.
Dr. Gerdtz testified that Devereux could provide an appropriate placement and would meet the placement guidelines that he and Dr. Poage developed. Dr. Gerdtz testified that Devereux does have several disadvantages. First, STUDENT talks often about his family and he should stay in close proximity to his family. Devereux would not provide the necessary proximity. Second, Dr. Gerdtz testified that STUDENT should be in a peer group that provides him with a mixture of individuals, not just with peers who are developmentally delayed.
Dr. Gerdtz testified that Devereux's educational program focuses on functional living skills in which practical skills are first learned in the classroom and then utilized in community outings. Dr. Gerdtz also testified that Devereux has the materials necessary to implement a time and money program. Devereux also has a supported work program, career exploration program, including job visits, leisure skills program on campus and in the community, and a psychiatrist on staff who can monitor behaviors and medications. Dr. Gerdtz testified that the peer group at Devereux is developmentally delayed and that there is appropriate social interaction. Finally, Dr. Gerdtz testified that Devereux also has a speech and language therapist on staff.
Dr. Gerdtz testified that the range of disabilities served at Devereux is much broader than at North Valley. Devereux serves students from the profoundly mentally retarded to mildly mentally retarded. Dr. Gerdtz also testified that Devereux emphasizes basic living skills more than North Valley.
Ms. Ishida visited Devereux in December 1995 and January 1996. Ms. Ishida's primary concern with Devereux is that it is a "confined community" that would limit STUDENT to exposure to other developmentally delayed students. Ms. Ishida testified that STUDENT should be with a mixture of peers, including those who are higher functioning.
David Lichti, admissions social worker for Devereux School, testified at length regarding the composition of Devereux and its student body. Mr. Lichti reviewed information regarding STUDENT and shared it with a treatment team consisting of a residential supervisor, clinical case manager, counselling supervisor, education master teacher, and registered nurse. The treatment team concluded that Devereux could meet STUDENT's needs in the Del Sol (also referred to as Del Mar) residential program for mildly mentally retarded students with behavioral problems. Mr. Lichti testified that Del Sol is for students who have mastered community safety skills and have good personal hygiene. Mr. Lichti also indicated that a student with moderate mental retardation would be appropriate for Del Sol if he or she has good social and verbal skills.
Regarding the makeup of the student population at Devereux, Mr. Lichti testified that approximately 3-5% of the students are severely mentally retarded, approximately 20-30% are moderately mentally retarded, and the rest are mildly mentally retarded. Approximately 98% of the students are diagnosed as developmentally delayed, and all of the students are dually diagnosed, meaning that they have other diagnoses, such as SED or specific learning disabilities. Mr. Lichti testified that Devereux does not take non-developmentally delayed students or students who are primarily SED. He testified that higher functioning students tend to lead lower functioning students astray. Mr. Lichti testified that the composition of students at Devereux is a primary reason why the program is successful because the students are able to build self-esteem. Mr. Lichti testified that it would be less likely that a student with developmental delays could build his self-esteem in a program for students with SED.
According to Mr. Lichti, STUDENT would spend 50% of his day in the community working on community safety skills, job training, vocational education, shopping, and transportation. The other 50% of the day would be spent on academics, art, and physical education. Mr. Lichti testified that if a student has assaultive behaviors such that he is a danger to himself or others, he would not be able to go on community trips. Instead, such a student would go to study hall or attend additional classes. In addition, if a student has a "blow out," he is not allowed to leave the campus for 24 hours. If that student then has a "good day," he can return to community trips.
Mr. Lichti stated that Devereux has over 20 job sites available for students and that STUDENT could start in a job placement with a job coach. Devereux would also be able to meet STUDENT's goals relating to cooking, laundry, telephone, and behavioral management.
Mr. Lichti testified that the residential and educational programs interact and both programs can work on skills identified in a student's IEP. Mr. Lichti testified that although the programs are run separately, a target behavior sheet is used throughout both programs to track behaviors and consistent behavioral goals are established in both environments. In addition, the teacher's aides in the educational program spend several hours each day in the residential program assisting the students in preparing for school.
All staff at Devereux complete two weeks of in-service training, including training in developmental disabilities. Devereux also has a psychiatrist on staff who could assist STUDENT when it comes time for him to discontinue Haldol. The psychiatrist sees each student on a quarterly basis.
Mr. Lichti indicated that, at the time of his testimony, Devereux did not have an opening for STUDENT. However, he expected there to be an opening in approximately 2-4 weeks.
DISCUSSION
1) Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free and appropriate public education. (California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC § 1400 et seq.) Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents or guardians, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings; and instruction in physical education." 20 USC § 1401(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the child. 458 U.S. 175,200.
The IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether a school district's proposed placement is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:
1. whether the placement is designed to meet the student's unique needs; 2. whether the placement conforms with the student's IEP; and 3. whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student.
For the following reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement at North Valley School is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and is, therefore, not an appropriate placement as defined by the IDEA.
Petitioner's witnesses testified that STUDENT needs a peer group of developmentally delayed students. While the Hearing Officer does not accept that STUDENT's peer group should be made up entirely of developmentally delayed students, the Hearing Officer does find that STUDENT needs to be placed in a facility which serves individuals with similar disabilities and which provides him with role models to whom he can relate. Such role models would help him develop socialization skills and build his self-esteem.
North Valley School is not such a facility. The witnesses testified that the primary disability of the students at North Valley is SED and that there are relatively few if any students with developmental delays. Mr. Foster, the principal of the school, testified that there may be one or two students with developmental delays, but that they have not received that diagnosis. All evidence regarding the training of North Valley staff indicates that none of the staff is trained in developmental disabilities. Finally, the North Valley brochure, submitted as Petitioner's Exhibit No. 40, establishes that North Valley is a facility that focuses on serving children with SED. Although the program brochure also mentions that North Valley is "specifically designed to treat children who are both deaf and emotionally disturbed or mentally ill," nowhere does the brochure mention serving children with developmental delays.
What is most compelling for the Hearing Officer is that all of the witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT needs a curriculum which focuses on functional living skills. Yet, North Valley is not currently using such a curriculum and the functional living skills curriculum that it has used in the past would need to be supplemented by the District. This indicates that the North Valley students are operating at a higher level than STUDENT and that if STUDENT were placed at North Valley, he would be isolated from the other students because he would be using a different curriculum.
The Hearing Officer also notes that some of the services STUDENT would need at North Valley may have to be provided by agencies other than North Valley, including the District, in the case of medication monitoring and speech and language services, and the county vocational education program. The picture presented by the testimony of the District's witnesses is of a unwieldy mix of services provided by District personnel or county personnel. The District did not identify the individual who would be responsible for overseeing STUDENT's program to ensure that all of the services would be provided in an appropriate manner. Nor did the District provide verification that the vocational services would be provided by the county. Considering the complexity of STUDENT's disabilities and behavioral needs, such a hodgepodge of services could result in STUDENT not receiving the consistency which he needs to succeed, thereby placing him at risk.
Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that were STUDENT to be placed at North Valley he would be isolated as virtually the only student functioning at his level and with his needs. In addition, the proposed program consists of a patchwork of services that may or may not be able to provide STUDENT with the consistency which he needs to get his behavior under control. In many respects, placing STUDENT at North Valley is analogous to placing a square peg into a round hole. STUDENT is a developmentally delayed student with a complex set of other disabilities. He has never been identified as SED. Yet, the program at North Valley is one which is geared almost entirely to SED children who are higher functioning than STUDENT.(Footnote 5)
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at North Valley does not satisfy the first factor of the previously identified test -- that the placement must be designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs -- and is, therefore, inappropriate.
Although the placement has already been found to be inappropriate, the Hearing Officer will briefly address the other two factors listed above. First, it is questionable whether the placement at North Valley School conforms to STUDENT's IEP. The last agreed upon IEP which spells out STUDENT's educational program is dated October 17, 1995. According to that IEP, STUDENT is to receive speech and language services twice per week. North Valley's speech and language therapist is at the site once per week and District personnel would need to complete the speech and language services.
The IEP lists a detailed set of goals and objectives regarding functional living skills and states that the "strategy for graduation" for STUDENT will be a certificate of attendance for a life skills curriculum. The IEP, as did the testimony of witnesses for both Petitioner and the District, places great weight on a functional skills, or life skills, curriculum. The evidence establishes that North Valley is not currently using such a curriculum and probably would need assistance from the District in implementing an appropriate curriculum for STUDENT. Considering the importance of a life skills curriculum for STUDENT, placing him in a school which does not have an operative life skills curriculum or staff which uses such a curriculum on a regular basis can not be considered to be in conformance which his IEP.
The IEP also provides for a detailed transition plan and vocational development. The testimony of witnesses for both Petitioner and the District establishes that North Valley can not provide services in conformance with the transition plan and, once again, would require assistance from the District and the county vocational education program.
Some of the most significant components of STUDENT's IEP -- the functional living skills curriculum and the transition plan -- are going to be provided in an experimental manner that may or may not not conform to his IEP. In many respects, the District's proposed program is simply a promise to provide services instead of a specific and certain program of services. Considering STUDENT's array of disabilities and needs, and the District's failure to provide him with an appropriate placement in the past, STUDENT's placement needs to be a consistent program which conforms to his IEP from the first day and not be an experiment in providing services. The experimental, jumbled nature of the proposed placement establishes that the placement is not in conformance with STUDENT's IEP.
Regarding whether the proposed placement at North Valley School will provide educational benefit to STUDENT, it is always difficult to determine whether a prospective placement in which the student has not already participated will provide educational benefit. As stated already, STUDENT would be isolated from his peers at North Valley, educated by staff not trained in handling his unique set of disabilities, educated in a peer group with markedly different primary disabilities, and educated in a manner that raises questions about the ability of North Valley to deliver the necessary services. Considering the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placement at North Valley does not offer a reasonable prospect of providing STUDENT with educational benefit.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement at North Valley School is not designed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate placement as defined by the IDEA and Rowley.
2) If North Valley is not an appropriate placement, is Devereux School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
To ensure that children are educated in the least restrictive environment, school districts are required to ensure a continuum of alternative placements to meet the needs of children with disabilities. The continuum must include instruction in regular classes, special classes, special schools, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions. 34 CFR § 300.551. This list, although not specifically mentioning residential placements, implies that residential placements are a part of the continuum by referring to "special schools" and "hospitals and institutions."Districts must provide a residential placement when such a placement is necessary for the student to benefit from his or her education as required by the Supreme Court in Rowley. See Kruelle v. New Castle County School District, (3rd Cir. 1981) EHLR 552:350; Christopher T. v. San Francisco Unified School District, (D.C.N.Cal. 1982) EHLR 554-351; Abrahamson v. Hershman (1st Cir. 1983) EHLR 554:403; Clovis Unified School District v. California Office of Administrative Hearings (9th Cir. 1990) 16 EHLR 944)
Petitioner contends that for STUDENT to succeed in school his behaviors have to be under control and for his behaviors to be under control he needs a behavior management program that is implemented consistently in both educational and residential environments. Furthermore, Petitioner contends that there can be no doubt his need for residential/educational setting is educational in nature. His behavioral needs are such that he can make no educational gains until his behaviors are under control. His history at school has amply demonstrated this need. Additionally, he needs medical monitoring of medications which affect his behaviors and thus his education.
The District contends that Petitioner's need for a residential placement is not educational in nature and the VMRC is providing him with the residential placement that he does need. The District further contends that there is no evidence that STUDENT's school and residence need to be at the same facility for him to derive educational benefit and that his primary need is for a day treatment program where his behavioral management program can be implemented.
For the following reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that an integrated residential and educational placement is necessary to address his unique needs and to allow for STUDENT to benefit from his education. First, the evidence establishes an interrelationship between STUDENT's education and home environment. For most of STUDENT's high school years, he has been in residential homes in which his care providers have taken an active role in working with the school to work on his behavioral problems. Espen Jensen, the care provider at Casa de Mansano, had regular contact with STUDENT's teacher for two and a half years, and had an active role in implementing negative and positive consequences for STUDENT's behavior at school.
The evidence establishes that Mr. Jensen's behavioral management techniques worked at the group home because STUDENT was essentially under control at Casa de Mansano. At the same time that STUDENT's behavior improved at home, his behavior continued to deteriorate at school. The reason for this deterioration was the District's failure to provide an appropriate and consistent behavioral plan to deal with his behavioral problems at school. At first, the District's behavior plan for STUDENT consisted primarily of verbal praise and rewards and any negative consequences were carried out at home. While this plan appeared to provide some benefit to STUDENT as evidenced by the reduced number of informal "suspensions" during his sophomore year, it also placed too much of the responsibility on a care provider whose responsibilities should not have included STUDENT's school behaviors.
The next step in the District's behavioral plans for STUDENT, and implemented only after Mr. Jensen withdrew from the previously described behavioral plan, was the assignment of a "hot spot" aide. According to Ms. Ennis, the "hot spot" aide could very possibly be the cause of much of STUDENT's increased behavioral problems since the summer of 1995. The aide has become the target of much of STUDENT's behavioral outbursts and has, in some respects, made STUDENT feel singled out for special treatment.
Finally, the District agreed during the summer of 1995 to hire a behavioral specialist to develop a comprehensive behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT. That plan was developed in the fall of 1995, and a token economy system was added to the plan in October of 1995. However, STUDENT's behaviors have continued to escalate to the point where he was recommended for expulsion in December of 1995 and, ultimately, excluded from public school by a court order on March 26, 1996.
The above description of the District's shifting behavioral plans and STUDENT's increased behavioral problems establishes that the District has failed to provide STUDENT with the opportunity to improve his behaviors. The testimony of numerous witnesses establishes that STUDENT's behavioral needs are his most important educational need at this time. If STUDENT does not get his behaviors under control, he will not be able to take advantage of the more important aspects of his education, such as functional living skills and vocational education. The District's failure to develop an appropriate behavioral program has resulted in a situation where STUDENT's behavioral problems have risen to the point where he can no longer be educated on a public school campus.(Footnote 6) The question then is whether STUDENT needs an integrated residential and educational placement to benefit from his education or whether a day treatment program would be appropriate.
The evidence establishes that there is an interrelationship between home and school. STUDENT has a complex array of disabilities. STUDENT is significantly developmentally delayed. He has Klinefelter's Syndrome which can cause aggression, immaturity, withdrawal, and apathy. He also has a partial aegenesis of the corpus callosum which inhibits communication between the hemispheres of his brain, also potentially impacting his aggressive behaviors. STUDENT has also been diagnosed with other disorders, including Tourette's Syndrome. The combination of these disorders have resulted in a student who has, in the words of Dr. Bernhoft, behaviors which are primarily organically driven and not under his operant control. As a result, STUDENT needs a comprehensive and consistent approach to his behavioral problems to bring them under control so that he can benefit from his education.
Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has spent the past 6 1/2 years in an environment that is almost as restrictive as that proposed by the District and that proposed at Devereux. STUDENT has been in residential group homes in which the care providers have taken an active role in working with school staff on his behaviors. In other words, STUDENT's care providers have been providing him with more than just a roof over his head. In many respects, STUDENT's care providers have taken an active role in the most important area -- STUDENT's behavioral problems. The effort by STUDENT's care providers has failed in helping with his behaviors at school. The reason is the lack of a consistent approach, both at school over the years and between the school and the home.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT needs a consistent behavioral approach both throughout the day in his school program and between his school program and his residential program. For three years, STUDENT has not had a consistent approach and his behaviors have continued to deteriorate. It is important to remember that STUDENT's most important educational need at this time is getting his behaviors under control. Placing STUDENT in a program which is not integrated would not provide him with the necessary consistency and coordination of programs that he would receive from an integrated residential and educational program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a residential placement to benefit from his education.(Footnote 7)
Turning then to the question of whether Devereux is an appropriate placement, the first question is whether the proposed placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. The testimony of the witnesses established that STUDENT needs:
(1) a comprehensive behavioral intervention plan that addresses his behavioral needs in all areas; (2) a functional living skills curriculum;
(3) vocational education and a transition program with the goal of supported employment and independent living; and (4) medication monitoring, particularly if he is taken off of Haldol.
Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a placement which will provide him with appropriate role models and a consistency of approach through the day and in different environments.
The evidence establishes that Devereux is designed to meet the unique needs listed above. Devereux has the ability to implement a comprehensive behavioral intervention plan, including prone containment, in both the school and home environments. Devereux has a functional living skills program and vocational education program that provides opportunities for on-campus and off-campus work. Devereux also has staff on hand that can monitor STUDENT's medication needs and assess his behavior for any medication-related changes. The peer group at Devereux is also designed to provide STUDENT with appropriate peer models and the opportunity for him to enhance his self-esteem and self-image. Finally, the staff at Devereux are trained to work with students who have similar disabilities.
With regards to whether the placement at Devereux is designed to conform to STUDENT's IEP, with the exception of Devereux being a residential placement and STUDENT's IEP not calling for a residential placement, Devereux has the ability to provide all of the services called for in STUDENT's most recent IEP, including speech and language services, behavioral management, vocational education and transition, and a functional living skills curriculum. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at Devereux conforms to STUDENT's IEP.
Finally, as noted earlier, it is difficult to determine whether a prospective placement will provide educational benefit to a child. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the program at Devereux is designed to provide STUDENT with a substantial likelihood of educational benefit. The program will provide STUDENT with a comprehensive behavioral management program to assist him in getting his behaviors under control. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT is reaching the age of adulthood and the goal for his education should be for him to obtain the skills necessary for him to live independently, or in a group home, and to work in supported employment. The program at Devereux is geared to working with developmentally delayed students and provide them with the necessary skills to function independently and work towards the goal of supported employment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the program at Devereux is designed to provide STUDENT with a substantial likelihood of receiving educational benefit.
The District contends that Devereux is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because of two reasons. First, the District contends that Education Code § 56505(h) requires the Hearing Officer to consider cost and that the cost of Devereux renders it inappropriate. The Hearing Officer notes that the District has not proposed an alternative appropriate placement to compare Devereux to. In addition, the cost of the residential component at Devereux, approximately $50,000, is not so prohibitive as to render it inappropriate solely on the basis of cost.(Footnote 8) It is important to note that STUDENT is an individual with a combination of rare and complex disabilities. These disabilities result in STUDENT having a unique set of behavioral and educational needs. These needs will not be met easily or at little expense. Also of significance is the fact that STUDENT is almost eighteen and has only a few years left in the educational system. His needs must be met soon if he is to achieve the goal of independent living and supported employment.
Considering the benefits of the program at Devereux, the Hearing Officer does not find that the cost of Devereux renders it inappropriate.
Second, the District contends that the location of Devereux is a factor which should be considered. The Hearing Officer acknowledges that Devereux is some distance from STUDENT's home, approximately 250 miles and is somewhat concerned regarding this factor. However, for two reasons the Hearing Officer finds that the distance from home does not render Devereux inappropriate. It is STUDENT's parents who have requested the placement at Devereux, and the District has not proposed an alternative appropriate placement that is closer to home.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed program at Devereux is an appropriate placement.
ORDER
(1) Lodi Unified School District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the date of this decision to conform STUDENT's IEP to this decision.
(2) Lodi Unified School District shall enroll STUDENT at Devereux within 30 days of the date of this decision.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue #1: Petitioner prevailed.
Issue #2: Petitioner prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: June 3, 1996 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Klinefelter's, Tourette's, and brain defect were diagnosed in 1987 when STUDENT was evaluated at the Diagnostic School for Neurologically Handicapped Children in Fresno, California. STUDENT's brain defect was described by several witnesses as being a partial aegenesis of the corpus callosum, a defect which inhibits communication between the hemispheres of the brain and which could cause STUDENT's impulsive behaviors. Klinefelter's is a chromosomal abnormality which most commonly causes problems in the areas of peer relationships, and may result in underachievement, aggressiveness, withdrawal, apathy, and immaturity. (Petitioner's Exhibit No. 38)
2. STUDENT was in Ms. Ennis class until March 26, 1996, when the District obtained a court order excluding STUDENT from Lodi High School because of the court's finding that he was a danger to himself or to others. At that time, the parties agreed to a temporary placement at the Central Valley Training Center (CVTC), a day treatment program for adults with developmental delays, pending the results of this hearing. Petitioner does not consider CVTC to be an appropriate permanent placement.
3. Once Mr. Dietrich completed the functional analysis assessment, Dr. John Gerdtz, a colleague of Mr. Dietrich's at Spectrum Center, replaced Mr. Dietrich as the behavioral consultant. Dr. Gerdtz has continued to work with the District and STUDENT since September 1995.
4. Interestingly, the witness who would probably be in the best position to testify regarding STUDENT's educational needs, Stephanie Ennis, stated that she had "no opinion" regarding his educational needs.
5. The District contends that the Office of Special Education Program has stated that school districts may combine disability categories so long as placement decisions are made on an individual basis. See Letter to Van Wart (1993) 20 IDELR 1217, 1218. However, the District's contention misses the point of the present case. The problem with North Valley is not necessarily the category of disability. Instead, the problem with North Valley is that it is entirely an SED facility, with virtually no students with developmental delays. As stated already, if STUDENT were placed at North Valley, he would essentially be the only student, out of 54 students, with his level of functioning and with his needs.
6. There are also other factors which establish that the District is incapable of providing, or developing, an appropriate placement for STUDENT. When confronted with STUDENT's obvious need for a nonpublic school placement, the District responded by proposing a placement at North Valley School that is wholly inappropriate, without providing for alternatives. In addition, the Hearing Officer questions the ability of the District to develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT when the individual who should be in the best position to determine what STUDENT's educational needs are, his classroom teacher, was not able to provide an opinion regarding those needs.
7. Because STUDENT needs a residential placement to benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer finds that a residential placement also satisfies the least restrictive environment requirements of special education law. See 20 USC § 1412(1)(B) and 34 CFR § 300.550.
8. Although the program at North Valley School is not an appropriate placement, the Hearing Officer notes that the entire program at Devereux would cost approximately $40,000 more per year than the day treatment program at North Valley School.
