California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 24, 2000
Student v. Stanislaus Union Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 1244-99 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Stanislaus Union Elementary denied FAPE for three school years and must reimburse parents for private Slingerland tutoring.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted.
Summary
The parents of a student with a specific learning disability filed against Stanislaus Union Elementary School District and the Stanislaus County SELPA. The student entered the district in second grade with pull-out resource help in reading, writing and math. His reading and writing scores fell that year. In November 1998 the team moved him to a special day class at Muncy school. There he was taught the same program as the other students and was never mainstreamed, even though his IEP allowed up to 49% of the day in general education.
The Hearing Officer found that the district denied FAPE in 1997-98. The IEP had no annual goals, staff wrote the short-term objectives in advance and never discussed them, and teachers did not track them, so no one noticed he was regressing. FAPE was also denied throughout 1998-99, and no extended school year program was provided even though the IEP found him eligible. For 1999-2000, none of the three options was appropriate: the same special day class; Valley Oaks private school, with no mainstreaming and a bus ride of 2.5 to 4 hours a day; or Dutcher School, about which there was no meaningful evidence. The parents won reimbursement at $40 an hour for Pat Diven's daily tutoring since October 1999. Further tutoring as compensatory education was denied because she was not state-certified. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 10 business days and hire Diven as a consultant.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated short-term objectives that were written in advance and never monitored as procedural violations that denied FAPE, because they hid a child's regression. It held that offering a range of placements did not meet the district's duty. It also shows how California's certification rule for nonpublic agencies limited prospective orders for private tutoring.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-1998 school year?
No annual goals were written, and the short-term objectives were prewritten, never discussed, not shared with or used by teachers, and later altered. These procedural violations hid the student's regression in reading, caused a loss of educational opportunity and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2(a). Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year: September 1998 to November 1998
Continuing the same resource program that had already failed was not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to give some educational benefit. The general education teacher was unaware of his IEP. FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2(b). Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year: November 1998 to June 1999
The special day class used the teacher's existing program without adapting it, ignored the Slingerland screening recommendations, and had no written language objectives. It never put in place the IEP's provision for up to 49% mainstreaming. The Hearing Officer gave the Woodcock-Johnson scores, which were given incorrectly, no weight. FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 2(c). The 1998-1999 extended school year
The IEP found him eligible for ESY, but the District developed and offered no specific ESY program for summer 1999. This failed to provide an appropriate ESY program.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year?
None of the three options was appropriate. The Muncy special day class had already failed. Valley Oaks offered no mainstreaming and required a bus ride of 2.5 to 4 hours a day. There was no meaningful evidence about Dutcher. A district may not meet its duty by offering a range of placements.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private tutoring services that they have procured during the pendency of the due process hearing?
Pat Diven's tutoring (four hours a day, including Slingerland language arts) met his unique needs and gave him educational benefit. Reimbursement was ordered at $40 per hour through the date of the decision. Further tutoring as compensatory education was denied because the tutor was not certified under Education Code section 56366.1.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 10 business days after receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the parents for all expenses incurred through the decision date for private tutoring by Pat Diven, from October 1999 (findings set the rate at $40.00 per hour).
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 business days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting and create an appropriate program for the rest of the 1999-2000 school year. The program should be identical or nearly identical to the current placement, use a simultaneous multi-sensory language arts method such as Slingerland, and address the eight listed considerations. The team must also consider whether ESY services are appropriate.
- Pat Diven shall be hired as a consultant to the IEP team, and her input shall be given considerable weight.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified; Cleveland Heights-University City Sch. Dist. v. Boss; Smith v. Ricker
People named in the decision
- Andrew Schindler, Superintendent, Stanislaus Union Elementary School District
- Patricia (Pat) Dimond, SELPA director; SELPA representative and District witness, Stanislaus County SELPA
- Linda Cox, SELPA program specialist; chaired November 1998 IEP, Stanislaus County SELPA
- Christie Carter, Third grade general education teacher, Agnes Baptist Elementary School
- Carline Pardina, Resource specialist, Agnes Baptist Elementary School
- Janet Ann Skooglund, General education teacher (described as first grade teacher; was student's second grade teacher), Agnes Baptist Elementary School
- Ann Velarde, Special day class teacher (learning handicapped), Muncy school, Stanislaus Union Elementary School District
- Celeste Palomino, Principal, Muncy school
- Lindy Santellon, Principal, Agnes Baptist Elementary School
- Bob Frioli, School psychologist, District
- Sharon Lee, Speech pathologist, District
- Bonita Colony, Slingerland program consultant; District witness
- Patricia (Pat) Diven, Private tutor; former director of Valley Oaks school; witness for Student, Valley Oaks school (former)
- Helen Katotakis, Slingerland screening assessor, Valley Oaks school
- Janet Bingham, Parents' advocate at November 1998 IEP
- Yvonne Cerrato, First grade teacher, Pleasanton Unified School District
- Laura Petersen, Resource specialist / assessor, Pleasanton Unified School District
- Valley Oaks school, Private school using Slingerland method (Turlock)
- Dutcher School, SELPA public school using Slingerland method (Turlock)
- Huntington Learning Center, Private learning center visited by parents (Modesto)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Modesto, California, on October 14, 15, November 9, 10 and December 7 and 8, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT II was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma. Also present on behalf or Petitioner were his parents, MR. and MRS. PARENT. (Footnote 1) Respondent Stanislaus Union Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Linda Simlick. Also present on behalf of the District was Andrew Schindler, superintendent of the Stanislaus Union Elementary School District. Respondent Stanislaus County SELPA (SELPA) was represented by Patricia Dimond, director of the Stanislaus County SELPA.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Christie Carter, third grade teacher at Agnes Baptist school; Carline Pardina, resource specialist at Agnes Baptist school; Janet Ann Skooglund, first grade teacher at Agnes Baptist school; Patricia Diven, former director of Valley Oaks school in Turlock as well as STUDENT's private tutor; Mr. PARENT; Andrew Schindler; and MS. PARENT.
The following witnesses were called by Stanislaus Union Elementary School District to testify: Ann Velarde, special day class teacher for the learning handicapped; Linda Cox, program specialist for the Stanislaus County SELPA; Bonita Colony, consultant regarding the Slingerland program; and Pat Dimond.
Stanislaus County SELPA called no witnesses.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. (Footnote 2)
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the Hearing, Petitioner requested that the Hearing Officer take judicial notice of statistical data compiled by the California Highway Patrol, which Petitioner included in his evidence packet (Petitioner's Exhibit Nos. 217-230). Petitioner argued that the statistics are relevant to the issue of whether the Valley Oaks and Dutcher schools were appropriate placements for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. According to Petitioner, the statistics "document the road conditions during the winter in the central valley, and how adverse conditions increase the danger on the central valley roads. The statiscal data pertain to the relative safety of a stretch of highway STUDENT would have to traverse each day if he had attended either placement." The Hearing Officer ordered the parties to brief the issue of whether a hearing officer may properly take judicial notice of statistical data compiled by the California Highway Patrol.
There is no provision in the education code pertaining to whether a hearing officer may properly take judicial notice of such records. Therefore, the Hearing Officer looks to State law for guidance. Section 452 of the California Evidence Code identifies areas where courts are permitted to take judicial notice. Cal. Evid. Code § 452. This section permits a court to take judicial notice of "official government acts," among other things. Courts have interpreted this provision to include records of the State Highway Commission. Smith v. Ricker (1964) 37 Cal.Rptr. 769.
The Hearing Officer finds that the records at issue are relevant to whether the two proposed placements, Valley Oaks and Dutcher, are appropriate, as the records tend to make a fact of consequence more or less probable, whether the road STUDENT is required to traverse each day is safe, a concern STUDENT's parents repeatedly expressed to the District. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer will take judicial notice of these California Highway Patrol statistics because they are similar to records of which California Courts have taken judicial notice in the past, were compiled by a public agency, and are easily accessible to the public. (Footnote 3) See, Smith v. Ricker (1964) 37 Cal.Rptr. 769. ISSUES (Footnote 4)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-1998 school year?
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-1999 school year?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year?
4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private tutoring services that they have procured during the pendency of the due process hearing?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], was first found eligible for special education at an IEP meeting in June 1997 as a student with a learning disability. STUDENT was found eligible due to a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of reading, written language, and math. (Footnote 5)
STUDENT attended school in the Pleasanton Unified School District (Pleasanton) during the 1996-1997 (first grade) school year. Although he did not receive special education services, he received additional support in the area of reading, including "an extra twenty minutes of trimodal (auditory, visual and kinesthetic) instruction" three times each week in the Kindergarten room. He also received extra help in the Reading Recovery program, including one-to-one tutoring from a reading specialist, "intensive" tutoring from his classroom teacher, and "small group guided reading sessions" led by his classroom teacher. Additionally, his parents read to STUDENT daily during the first grade, both outside and inside the classroom. (Footnote 6) District's Exhibit No. 7.
In about April 1997 (the second semester of STUDENT's first grade school year), STUDENT was referred to the student study team at his school by his first grade teacher, Yvonne Cerrato, and his parents. An assessment plan was developed and approved by STUDENT's parents and STUDENT was assessed by Laura Petersen, a resource specialist. STUDENT was also assessed by a speech pathologist. As part of her assessment, Ms. Petersen administered the Woodcock-Johnson Revised (WJ-R). STUDENT's scores on that test were as follows:
April 1997 Standard Score Grade Equivalent Percentile Broad Written Language 78 1.1 7 Broad Reading 75 1.1 4 Broad Math 89 23 23 Broad Knowledge 112 3.4 78
The Pleasanton district held an IEP team meeting on June 11, 1997. The team found that STUDENT displayed a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement due to low visual-perceptual skills, and as such, qualified for special education as learning disabled. The areas of severe discrepancy included reading, written language and math, based in large part on STUDENT's comparatively high verbal reasoning skills. The team recommended that STUDENT be placed in the regular second grade class (80 to 99% mainstreamed), with resource support in language arts and mathematics. (Footnote 7) Additionally, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT should receive 40 to 60 minutes of speech and language services each week. District's Exhibit No. 7.
Annual goals and measurable short-term objectives were developed at the June 1997 IEP meeting. STUDENT's annual goal in reading and written language was to "increase language arts skills and visual perceptual skills." His corresponding objectives were to identify letters by name and sound, write letters after hearing their sound, spell words on weekly tests, "use picture clues, beginning and ending sounds, context clues, predicting and memory as strategies for reading," read from a first-grade basal reader, read at home 10-15 minutes each day, and write one or more sentences on a topic given help in spelling upon request. STUDENT's annual math goal was to "increase math skills," and the corresponding objectives included adding and subtracting, counting, naming and valuing coins, identifying consecutive numbers, and telling time. Although the measurement and method are provided for each discrete objective, the service provider responsible for each objective is not specified. District's Exhibit No. 7.
On August 29, 1997, just before the beginning of STUDENT's second grade school year, his parents moved from the Pleasanton area to Modesto, California, and enrolled him in the Stanislaus Union School District. STUDENT was placed in his neighborhood school, Agnes Baptist Elementary School. Testimony of Mr. PARENT.
Upon enrollment, STUDENT's parents notified that District that STUDENT had been found eligible for special education services as a child with a learning disability by the Pleasanton Unified School District. On September 2, 1997, the District developed a thirty-day interim placement for STUDENT. District's Exhibit No. 6. The interim placement developed by the District was substantially similar to the program developed by the Pleasanton district, consisting of 40 to 60 minutes of pull-out resource instruction, three to five days each week, in the areas of reading, written language and math, along with speech and language services. District's Exhibit No. 6.
On September 23, 1997, after STUDENT had been in his interim placement for less than a month, the District convened an IEP team meeting to review STUDENT's interim placement and to develop a permanent placement. District's Exhibit No. 5. The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability and determined that "STUDENT should remain in the RS program and the speech/lang. specialist program" and "attend the RS program for the following academic areas: Reading, Written Language, and Math." The IEP specifies that STUDENT is to receive resource pull-out instruction in reading, math and written language three to five times a week, for 40 to 60 minutes each session, and speech and language services one time each week for a total of 10 to 30 minutes. STUDENT's program was based in large part on the assessments and the IEP completed by the previous (Pleasanton) school district. The only new assessments the District conducted were in the areas of speech and language and adaptive physical education. District's Exhibit No. 5.
Ms. Pardina, STUDENT's resource specialist teacher, prepared short-term objectives in the areas of reading skills, written language and math. Testimony of Pardina. The short-term objectives were written prior to the September 23, 1997 IEP meeting on preprinted checklists and were not discussed at the IEP meeting. Testimony of PARENT and Pardina and District's Exhibit No. 5. No annual goals were developed for STUDENT in any area for the 1997-1998 school year.
STUDENT was placed in the regular second grade class taught by Ms. Skooglund, with pull-out resource services in written language, mathematics and reading, taught by Ms. Pardina. STUDENT also received speech and language services. (Footnote 8) STUDENT's program remained the same over the entire 1997-1998 school year.
In May 1998, in preparation for STUDENT's annual IEP, Ms. Pardina administered the Woodcock Johnson- Revised (WJ-R) test. STUDENT received the follow scores on that test:
May 1998 WJ-R Standard Score Grade Equiv. Percentile Broad Written Language 50 1.1 Broad Reading 54 1.0 Broad Math 85 2.2
STUDENT's standard scores on the May 1998 Woodcock-Johnson in the areas of Broad Written Language and Broad Reading dropped by 28 and 21 points, respectively, when compared to his April 1997 test results on the same test. Petitioner's Exhibit Nos. 28, 29 and 77.
An IEP meeting was convened in May 1998 to discuss STUDENT's progress and to develop STUDENT's placement for the following (third grade) school year. District's Exhibit No. 4. Prior to the IEP meeting, Ms. Pardina again developed short-term objectives in the area of reading skills. She used the same type of "checklist" that she had used in September 1997. Testimony of Pardina.
There are numerous discrepancies between the short-term reading objectives Ms. Pardina developed in September 1997 and the objectives she developed in May 1998. Some of the "pretest data" from the September 1997 checklist do not match the corresponding pretest data on the May 1998 objectives. For example, under the objective "sequence the letters of the alphabet," the September 1997 checklist indicates that STUDENT could successfully sequence 24 out of 26 letters in the alphabet at that time. The corresponding short-term objective on the May 1998 checklist indicates that STUDENT could only sequence 13 of 26 correctly as of September 1997. Another objective was added under the subheading "vocabulary skills." That objective purportedly includes data from September 1997, although the objective does not appear on the September 1997 checklist.
In any event, the short-term reading objectives that Ms. Pardina prepared in May 1998 show that STUDENT's reading skills had not improved over the course of the year. This finding is consistent with STUDENT's scores on the Woodcock-Johnson, which show that he regressed in the area of broad reading between April 1997 and May 1998. STUDENT remained the same on one short-term reading skills objective, regressed on three others, and improved slightly on the remaining two objectives. STUDENT did not reach the success criteria on a single short-term reading skills objective. Additionally, Ms. Pardina developed short-term objectives before the May 1998 IEP meeting in the areas of written language and math on preprinted checklists. Like STUDENT's reading objectives, his written language and math objectives are riddled with discrepancies when compared to the corresponding objectives prepared in September 1997. Regarding STUDENT's written language objectives, one objective was added which was not included on the September 1997 checklist, and another bears no relation to its September 1997 counterpart. Overall, STUDENT showed slight improvement on three of four written language skill objectives, but did not meet the success criteria on a single objective. (Footnote 9) STUDENT's math objectives are also inconsistent when compared to their September 1997 counterparts. However, unlike his reading and written language objectives, STUDENT actually made progress towards his math objectives from September 1997 to May 1998. District's Exhibit Nos. 4 and 5.
Annual goals were developed at the 1998 IEP meeting which indicate only that STUDENT will improve, or continue to improve, his written language, reading and math skills. District's Exhibit No. 4.
STUDENT was placed in the regular third grade classroom taught by Ms. Carter, with the same special education services as provided during second grade (pull-out resource in written language, reading and math provided by the resource teacher, Ms. Pardina). According to Ms. Carter, she knew that STUDENT was in the resource program, but she did not see or have a copy of his short-term objectives.
In November 1998, an IEP meeting was convened. STUDENT's parents were present, along with their advocate, Janet Bingham, Ms. Carter, Ms. Pardina, Linda Cox (the SELPA program specialist), a school psychologist (Bob Frioli), a speech pathologist (Sharon Lee), and principal Lindy Santellon. The IEP document provides that the purpose of the IEP team meeting was as follows:
This review was initiated by STUDENT's parents. STUDENT was recently assessed by Valley Oaks school for Dyslexia. STUDENT's parent's wish to share test results and conclusions with the IEP team. The purpose of this meeting is to discuss these results; determine which special education services would continue for STUDENT and to determine the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT.
The IEP further reflects that STUDENT was not making progress in Ms. Carter's third grade class in the areas of reading and spelling. Petitioner's Exhibit No. 20.
The November 1998 IEP team recommended a change in placement for STUDENT from a resource program at his neighborhood school to a special day class at the Muncy school, located elsewhere in the District. In that regard, the IEP reads, "the IEPT considers a special day class with speech and language to be the least restrictive environment based on visual auditory processing deficits and language delays resulting in academic delays." The IEP also indicates that the "IEPT will investigate a Slingerland program/teacher if STUDENT is not demonstrating progress in the special day class." It also reflects that the IEP team discussed "a nonpublic school (Footnote 10)," that STUDENT was to "begin special day class November 16, 1998," and that the placement was to be re-evaluated by December 18, 1998. (Footnote 11) Finally, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in the regular education classroom "up to 49%" of the day and found STUDENT eligible for extended school year. (Footnote 12)
Prior to the November 1998 IEP team meeting Ms. Pardina prepared the same short-term objective checklists which she had prepared prior to the September 1997 and May 1998 IEP meetings, in the areas of reading and math. However, no short-term objectives were developed in the area of written language, even though development of STUDENT's written language skills was identified as the area of "highest priority" on STUDENT's May 1998 IEP.
STUDENT was placed in Ann Velarde's special day class at the Muncy school beginning in mid-November 1998, where he remained for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year. Ms. Velarde reviewed the November 1998 IEP approximately two weeks after STUDENT entered her classroom. (Footnote 13) According to Ms. Velarde, she did not adapt the program that was in place in her classroom to STUDENT; rather, she utilized the program she had in place. She did not develop short-term goals and objectives in the area of written language skills.
From November 1998 to June 1999, STUDENT was never mainstreamed for any class other than physical education. Ms. Velarde did not understand that STUDENT was to be mainstreamed in any subject. Ms. Velarde could not recall disussing – with Ms. Cox, or anyone else – whether STUDENT was to be mainstreamed. She further testified that she felt that STUDENT could have been mainstreamed in math and that he would have faired "well," but did not feel STUDENT could have been successfully mainstreamed in social science. Regarding mainstreaming STUDENT in social science, Ms. Velarde testified as follows:
[Mainstreaming STUDENT in] social science would have been difficult if he was required to read the book or take the test or do any worksheets because of the reading, but if that wasn't required of him, I think he would do well because he could absorb the information, he could share in the discussions, he could share in the activities, he was very capable of doing that.
Regarding whether STUDENT could successfully be mainstreamed the following (1999-2000) school year, Ms. Velarde testified that STUDENT "might" succeed if he was mainstreamed in math and social science. (Footnote 14)
Ms. Velarde met with STUDENT's parents in December 1998; however, no IEP meeting was held until May 1999. According to Ms. Velarde, she relayed to the PARENTs prior to the meeting that Linda Cox would not be able to attend, and as such, the meeting would not be a "formal IEP meeting," but, instead, would be a parent-teacher conference-type meeting. Ms. Velarde also indicated that Linda Cox told her to relay to the PARENTs that Linda Cox had "checked with teachers that taught the Slingerland method," and that "they were not available or a program was not available at that time." Ms. Velarde met again with the PARENTs again in March 1999 to discuss STUDENT's progress. Testimony of Velarde.
STUDENT received no extended school year services during the summer of 1999, although the November 1998 IEP indicates that STUDENT was eligible. The only discussion after the November 1998 IEP meeting regarding extended school year services was an informal discussion which took place some time in the spring during which Ms. Velarde asked Ms. PARENT if the PARENTs were interested in summer school for STUDENT. Testimony of Velarde and Mrs. PARENT.
In May 1999, Ms. Velarde administered the Woodcock Johnson to STUDENT. Petitioner's Exhibit Nos. 11, 12. STUDENT's scores on this test were as follows: (Footnote 15)
May 1999 Standard Score Grade Equivalent Percentile Broad Written Language 66 1.6 1 Broad Reading 60 1.4 .4 Broad Math 84 3.0 15
According to Ms. Velarde, based on her observations and STUDENT's Woodcock-Johnson test scores, she believed that STUDENT made progress in her class in the areas of reading, written language and math.
The IEP team met again on May 18, 1999. Present at the meeting were Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, Ann Velarde and Celeste Palomino, principal of Muncy. The IEP reflects that the District members of the IEP team offered STUDENT continued placement in the special day class for the learning handicapped located at the Muncy school because of STUDENT's "cognitive and academic achievement." Ms. Velarde had prepared short-term objectives for STUDENT in the areas of written language, broad reading and math, prior to the IEP meeting. (Footnote 16) The IEP does not reflect that STUDENT was to be mainstreamed in any classes for the 1999-2000 school year. No extended school year services were offered. The meeting ended abruptly at the request of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, after they expressed concern about STUDENT's progress in his current placement and the proposed placement for the following year. The IEP meeting was continued to June 1999. Testimony of Mr. PARENT and District's Exhibit No. 2.The IEP team reconvened on June 4, 1999. Program specialist Linda Cox was in attendance, along with Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, and Ms. Velarde. No regular education teacher was in attendance. The IEP team reflects that a "multi-sensory program would serve STUDENT's processing needs as the least restrictive environment." The face page of the IEP lists only continued placement in the special day class at Muncy Elementary school as the District's offer of placement. There is no indication that STUDENT would be mainstreamed in any classes and no indication that STUDENT was eligible for extended school year services. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT refused to sign the IEP.
Although there is no indication of other placement offers on either the May or June 1999 IEP documents, testimony established that the District verbally offered additional placements at Valley Oaks and the Dutcher school, both located in Turlock, California. By letter dated September 1, 1999, the District's attorney offered the Valley Oaks and Dutcher schools as alternative placements for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year:
As your clients have requested STUDENT be specifically taught using a "Slingerland" methodology, and while the District believes that [continued placement in a special day class at Muncy offers] STUDENT FAPE in the least restrictive environment, the District also offered educational services for STUDENT at either (1) the Stanislaus SELPA public school – Dutcher School – in Turlock, or (2) private placement in Valley Oaks school, (also located in Turlock), both of which employ the Slingerland methodology. Each of these educational placements is appropriate, offers STUDENT FAPE, and employs the specific methodology your clients have demanded. District's Exhibit No. 19.
No evidence was provided regarding to what extent (if any) STUDENT would be mainstreamed in either of the Valley Oaks or Dutcher school placements, whether he would be receive extended school year services, or whether the goals and objectives developed by Ms. Velarde in conjunction with the May 1999 IEP meeting for STUDENT's continued placement at the Muncy school special day class were appropriate for either of the Turlock programs.
Beginning in October 1999, STUDENT's parents retained the services of a private tutor, Pat Diven. (Footnote 17) According to Ms. Diven, when she first began tutoring STUDENT, he could not read at the first-grade level, and he had difficulty writing a single sentence. (Footnote 18) Ms. Diven testified later in the Hearing that, after she had tutored STUDENT approximately 20 hours each week for one month, STUDENT showed significant progress in the areas of reading and written language as a result of their work together. For example, she testified that by the second day of tutoring, STUDENT had learned seven letters and had begun using the blending chart. After one month, according to Ms. Diven, STUDENT was "seeing" the sounds of letters, was blending consonant-vowel-consonant words, and had reached the four-letter word blend level. She maintained that STUDENT could be successfully mainstreamed in math and science with a trained aide.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-1998 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be (1) designed to meet the student's unique needs, (2) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (3) conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. 1415(b)(1994)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990). Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
Regarding procedural appropriateness, Petitioner alleges that the District committed several procedural violations that led to the loss of educational opportunity for him during the 1997-1998 school year, all of which are related to his goals and objectives (or lack thereof): (1) failure to draft annual goals; (2) developing prewritten short-term IEP objectives and then failing to discuss these pre-written short-term objectives at the IEP meeting; (3) failure to report progress towards goals and objectives and failure to communicate the short-term objectives with the regular education teacher; (4) failure to identify the person or persons responsible for implementing objectives; and (5) altering the criteria for the objectives during the year and adding new objectives without an IEP meeting.
State law requires that an IEP contain, among other things, the present levels of a student's performance (including how the pupil's disability affects the pupil's involvement and progress in the general curriculum) and measurable annual goals, including benchSTUDENTs or short-term objectives related to meeting the student's needs that result from the student's disability to enable the pupil to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). Section 56347 requires that a district "ensure that regular education teacher or teachers, the special education teacher or teachers, and other persons who provide special education, related services, or both to the individual with exceptional needs . . . be knowledgeable of the content of the individualized education program" and that "a copy of each individualized education program shall be maintained at each site where the pupil is enrolled." The purposes of short-term objectives is to provide a mechanism for a child's teachers and parents to monitor the child's progress -- or lack thereof -- in special education over the course of the year. See 34 C.F.R. § 300, Appendix C to Part 300 of the Federal Regulations. (Footnote 19)
The evidence established that the District committed each of the alleged procedural violations during the 1997-1998 school year. First, no annual goals were developed for STUDENT in reading, writing, or math – all three identified areas where STUDENT displayed a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Second, the short-term objectives that were developed were written prior to the IEP meeting, according to the drafter, Ms. Pardina. While preparing "draft" objectives prior to an IEP is not a procedural violation, both Ms. Pardina and Mr. PARENT testified that Ms. Pardina's short-term objectives were not reviewed at the IEP team meeting. Thus, the IEP team as a whole had no meaningful input into STUDENT's short-term objectives. Third, regarding monitoring STUDENT's objectives, Ms. Skooglund, STUDENT's regular education teacher, testified that she did not use STUDENT's short-term objectives during the year to monitor STUDENT's progress. Although she was present at the September 1997 IEP meeting Ms. Skooglund was not "knowledgeable of the content" of the IEP, as required by state law, in part because the short-term objectives were not discussed at the meeting and, in part, because she did not refer to them during the course of the school year. Fourth, the IEP does not indicate who was responsible for implementation of STUDENT's short-term goals and objectives. (Footnote 20) Fifth, the evidence established that STUDENT's short term goals were "altered" prior to the May 1998 IEP meeting in that some were added and some were changed. (Footnote 21)
Moreover, the procedural violations caused STUDENT a loss of educational opportunity. The District's failure to ensure that STUDENT's teachers were knowledgeable regarding the content of his IEP and the IEP team's failure to discuss his short-term objectives contributed to the lack of monitoring and failure to track STUDENT's lack of progress in the resource program. As a result, no one noticed throughout the course of the year that, not only was STUDENT not progressing, he was regressing in the area of reading. (Footnote 22) Because the procedural violations resulted in a loss of educational opportunity, STUDENT was denied a free appropriate public education during the 1997-1998 school year. See, W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). Because it is has been established above that the District's procedural violations resulted in loss of educational opportunity, it is not necessary to discuss the substantive appropriateness of STUDENT's placement during the 1997-1998 school year. However, the Hearing Officer notes that there is also a procedural component to the substantive-FAPE analysis – whether STUDENT's placement conformed to his IEP. See, 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. STUDENT's placement did not comport with his IEP because the District failed to implement STUDENT's short-term objectives, and failed to develop annual goals. Ms. Skooglund, STUDENT's regular education teacher, testified that she did not use STUDENT's short-term objectives to track STUDENT's lack of progress. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Pardina also failed to monitor STUDENT's lack of progress. Her testimony that she discussed lesson plans on a weekly basis was directly contradicted by Ms. Skooglund, who testified that their contacts were infrequent.
The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the totality of the District's numerous procedural failures and substantive failure, that the District denied STUDENT a free and appropriate public education during the 1997-1998 school year.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-1999 school year?
(a) September 1998 to November 1998
STUDENT was initially placed by the IEP team in a program which was the same as his program the prior year (the only pertinent change was that he was placed in the third-grade regular education class room, taught by Ms. Carter), despite STUDENT's complete failure to progress in his second grade placement. As discussed above, to be appropriate, a program must be designed meet the student's unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comport with the student's IEP. STUDENT's placement fell well short in all three areas.
STUDENT's program from September 1998 to November 1998 was not designed to meet his unique needs nor was it reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The same program provided STUDENT with no educational benefit the previous year. Additionally, several witnesses, including Ms. Pardina, Ms. Carter and STUDENT's parents, agreed that STUDENT was not progressing during the first part of his third grade school year. Moreover, STUDENT's placement did not comport with his IEP. The third grade regular education teacher was not even aware that STUDENT had annual goals or short-term objectives, or even that he had an IEP. She knew only that STUDENT was in the resource program. Testimony of Carter.
Because the District placed STUDENT in a program which had previously failed to provide him with some educational benefit, the District failed to develop a program which was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Therefore, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education from September 1998 to November 1999.
(b) November 1998 to June 1999
As indicated above, an IEP team meeting was convened in 1998 because STUDENT's parents, Ms. Carter, and Ms. Pardina generally agreed that STUDENT was not making progress in his present special education placement.
Prior to the meeting, STUDENT's parents had looked into different schools which they hoped would enable STUDENT to benefit from his education, including two schools located in Turlock, California (Valley Oaks and the Dutcher School). Valley Oaks (a private school) and the Dutcher school (a public school) both utilize the "Slingerland" teaching method to teach learning handicapped students. STUDENT's parents also visited the Huntington Learning Center, located in Modesto, California, which uses a different method. Testimony of Mr. PARENT. (Footnote 23)
STUDENT's parents had him assessed at the Valley Oaks school in October 1998 by Helen Katotakis (Pat Diven, who was at the time the director of the school, reviewed the screening). According to Mr. PARENT, they sought the assessment because they were trying to determine why STUDENT was not progressing in reading and written language.
The assessment at Valley Oaks was a Slingerland screening to determine if STUDENT would benefit from the Slingerland teaching method. "Slingerland" is a presentation method used to teach language arts to children with processing disorders. Testimony of Diven. Slingerland is a "simultaneous multi-sensory approach" to learning, generally requiring a child to use all of his senses at the same time. Testimony of Diven, Colony and Cox. STUDENT "passed" the Slingerland screening at Valley Oaks; it was found that he could benefit from a simultaneous multi-sensory teaching method, such as Slingerland. Petitioner's Exhibit Nos. 54-60. The Slingerland screening report recommends that STUDENT be placed in a Slingerland-type (simultaneous, multi-sensory program), but also recommends modifications in the event STUDENT remains in a program which uses a multi-sensory (Footnote 24) approach, including: (1) cognitive strategies, rules and generalizations for phonetic elements, to support weak visual memory (necessary for accurate spelling); (2) specific strategies in encoding, decoding, and written expression; (3) specific copying strategies; (4) refining proofreading and editing skills to avoid omissions and increase accuracy; (5) a structured, sequential learning environment with support, for use of consistent organizational skills; and, (6) blank outlines, class notes, class outlines, a note taker, reader or peer help, a cassette recorder in class, extended time limits, oral administration of tests, a quiet place to take tests, text books on tape, and a lap top computer in class. Petitioner's Exhibit No. 60.
Linda Cox, a program specialist from the SELPA, chaired the November 1998 IEP meeting. Both the Dutcher school and Valley Oaks schools were discussed, but not offered, as possible placements at the November 1998 IEP meeting. Testimony of Cox, Pardina and Mr. PARENT. The PARENTs expressed concern about the amount of time STUDENT would have to spend traveling on the school bus each day if he attended either school in Turlock (at least one and one-quarter hours each way from their home in Modesto). The PARENTs also expressed safety concerns regarding the freeway on which the bus would traverse. At the request of the PARENTs, Ms. Cox promised to find out if there was an opening at a public school in the nearby Sylvan school district, which uses the Slingerland method to teach language arts to learning disabled students.
Although Ms. Cox agreed that STUDENT would benefit from a program using Slingerland, she recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class which does not use Slingerland as a language arts teaching model. Testimony of Cox. The Muncy school is located in the Modesto area. The IEP team, including STUDENT's parents, agreed to place STUDENT in Ms. Velarde's special day class on a trial basis. Testimony of Mr. PARENT. STUDENT's parents understood that if STUDENT was not making progress, an alternative placement, possibly using the Slingerland method, would be explored. It was also agreed that an IEP meeting would be held in December 1998, after STUDENT had been in Ms. Velarde's class for about one month. (Footnote 25)
The November 1998 IEP reflects that STUDENT was eligible for extended school year services and that STUDENT could be mainstreamed "up to 49% of the day." Although short-term objectives were written (again by Ms. Pardina) prior to the IEP team meeting in the areas of reading and math, none was developed in the area of written language. There was conflicting testimony as to whether the objectives were ever discussed. Ms. Velarde, who was not present at the November IEP, received the document "a couple of weeks" after the IEP meeting and after STUDENT had been placed in her class.
No IEP meeting was held in December 1998. Instead, Ms. Velarde met with STUDENT's parents and discussed STUDENT's progress. Testimony of Velarde.
As discussed above, to be substantively appropriate, Ms. Velarde's special day class program at the Muncy school must be designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit and must comport with his IEP. (Footnote 26) Each will be discussed below.
STUDENT's program from November 1998 to June 1999 was not designed to meet his unique needs. The IEP itself is devoid of any helpful information about how Ms. Velarde's special day class would meet STUDENT's needs when the resource program in which he had been previously placed had failed. Ms. Velarde testified that she made no changes to the curriculum she used for the other sixteen students in her class; she essentially "plugged" STUDENT in to the same program that she used for the other students. None of the recommendations from the Slingerland screening report appear on the IEP, including the several proposed modifications, even though the report was presented and discussed at the IEP meeting and it was agreed by all that such an approach would benefit STUDENT. (Footnote 27) Moreover, STUDENT's parents testified, and it was confirmed by Ms. Velarde, that some of the students in her class exhibited frequent off-task behaviors, including standing up and walking around the class, and that STUDENT's parents expressed that it was not appropriate for STUDENT to be in an environment with such distracting behavior. Additionally, although the IEP indicates that STUDENT was to be mainstreamed "up to 49%" of the day, the IEP document does not elaborate in what subjects, for how long, and what modifications (if any) would be necessary. Linda Cox testified that mainstreaming was to be left up to Ms. Velarde, but Ms. Velarde did not know that STUDENT was even eligible for mainstreaming. Additinally, STUDENT had no short-term objectives in the area of written language skills, an area identified as the "highest priority" in his May 1998 IEP. Finally, STUDENT's reading and math short-term objectives were identical to those employed in his previous (and unsuccessful) placements; they were not evaluated or adjusted in any meaningful manner to fit his new placement.
STUDENT's program from November 1998 to June 1999 was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The only evidence offered by the District that STUDENT received educational benefit were his May 1999 Woodcock-Johnson scores (which show he improved) and Ms. Velarde's observations. Testimony of Velarde. First, with regard to the Woodcock-Johnson scores, the Hearing Officer gives those scores no probative value in his determination of whether STUDENT received educational benefit. During a lengthy cross-examination, Ms. Velarde admitted that she administered the assessment incorrectly by, among other things, failing to establish a basal on some portions of the assessment, failing to establish ceilings, giving credit for questionable responses. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that the Woodcock-Johnson scores are unreliable and provide an exaggerated portrait of STUDENT's then-present levels of performance. Second, regarding Ms. Velarde's belief that STUDENT made progress based on her observations, the Hearing Officer finds more persuasive the testimony of Pat Diven who began tutoring STUDENT in October 1999. She testified that STUDENT was below the first-grade level in reading as of that time. Moreover, as indicated above, STUDENT had no short-term objectives in the area of written language, and as a result, there is no documentation that STUDENT was progressing towards his annual goal in that area. Finally, although it was generally agreed that STUDENT would benefit from a program using a simultaneous multi-sensory language arts teaching model, STUDENT was placed in a program that used essentially the same model which had been unsuccessful over the previous eighteen months.STUDENT's program did not comport with his IEP. As indicated above, STUDENT was to be mainstreamed up to 49% of the day, pursuant to his IEP. Ms. Velarde, who apparently was not aware of the IEP team determination, testified that STUDENT could have been mainstreamed in math, where she estimated he would have done "well." She also testified that, with modifications strikingly similar to those contained in the Slingerland screening report, STUDENT could have succeeded in a social science in the regular education class room.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the entire 1998-1999 school year. STUDENT's initial program – resource pull-out services in reading, written language and math, was completely inappropriate because STUDENT had not progressed in a virtually identical program during the previous year. Ms. Velarde's special day class for the learning handicapped was also inappropriate because it was not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, failed to provide him with educational benefit, and did not comport with his November 1998 IEP.
(c) The 1998-1999 extended school year
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1999); compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2) (1999). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil's educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
Education Code § 56345(b)(5) provides that where, as here, a child has been determined by his or her IEP team to be entitled to ESY services, the written IEP must include an ESY program. See also Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043(f). There was no dispute that STUDENT was entitled to ESY services. The November 1998 IEP indicated that the District's offer included an ESY program. However, although he was found eligible, no specific program was developed or offered to meet STUDENT's unique needs, despite his lack of progress over the preceding two years. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT an appropriate extended school year program during the summer of 1999.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year?
At the May 1999 IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT the same program in which he was placed the previous year – a special day class program for the learning handicapped. As previously determined, this program failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, and thus, was equally inappropriate for the 1999-2000 school year.
Valley Oaks, located in Turlock, California, was orally offered as a placement for STUDENT at the June 1999 IEP meeting and later in writing in September 1999. All witnesses testified that the language arts (reading and written language) component of the Valley Oaks program was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Testimony of Diven and Cox. However, the program offers no opportunities for STUDENT to be mainstreamed. Several witnesses testified that STUDENT was capable of being mainstreamed in at least two subjects, math and social science, during the 1999-2000 school year. Testimony of Diven and Velarde. Moreover, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT should have been mainstreamed up to 49% of the day from November 1998 to June 1999, although this portion of his IEP was never implemented. No evidence was presented at the Hearing that STUDENT's unique needs had changed such that he no longer should be mainstreamed in at least math and social science during the 1999-2000 school year. Moreover, the time STUDENT would be required to ride the bus every day if he attended the Valley Oaks program – between two and one half and four hours – is inappropriate. The time STUDENT would spend riding the bus would preclude him from participating in extracurricular activities. (Footnote 28) In rebuttal, the District argued only that other children in the past have attended Valley Oaks from the Modesto area. While this may be true, it has no bearing on whether such a long commute is appropriate for STUDENT. (Footnote 29)
Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Valley Oaks program is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. It offers no opportunity for mainstreaming, and is located too far away from the PARENT's home in Modesto.
Regarding the Dutcher school, no meaningful testimony was provided at the Hearing regarding how the Dutcher program would provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that it is an inappropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year.
Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT with an appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year, as none of the three programs -- he special day class, the Valley Oaks school or the Dutcher School -- was appropriate for STUDENT. (Footnote 30)
ISSUE NO. 4: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private tutoring services that they have procured during the pendency of the due process hearing?
STUDENT's parents seek reimbursement for the tutoring services they procured for STUDENT from Pat Diven, former director of the Valley Oaks school, from October 1999 to the date of this decision. Ms. Diven has tutored STUDENT for four hours each day; two hours are spent on language arts using the Slingerland method and the remaining two hours are spent she tutoring him in math, social science and listening comprehension.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court's decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an "empty victory." [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if "appropriate relief" in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, "the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete." [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
In light of the conclusion reached in Issue Nos. 1, 2 and 3, that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 and 1998-1999 school years, and failed to offer a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer must now determine whether the program provided by STUDENT's parents was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student's IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents' placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district's must meet, the parents' placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student's needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Footnote 31) Id.
The evidence presented at hearing demonstrated that the tutorial service provided by Ms. Diven was an appropriate placement for STUDENT from October 1999 to the date of this decision because it addressed his unique needs and provided him with educational benefit. Ms. Diven testified during two days of the hearing approximately one month a part. The second day, she testified that STUDENT had made significant improvement in that brief period; he was able to blend consonant vowel consonant words, and he had reached the four-letter word blend level. Moreover, according to Ms. Diven, STUDENT had progressed in the other portions of his program, including math, science, social science and listening comprehension.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, as a matter of law, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to STUDENT's private tutoring from Pat Diven at a rate of $40.00 per hour up to the date of this decision.
*****
This decision has not thus far dealt with an additional remedy sought by the Petitioner for the District's three-year failure to provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education. In addition to reimbursement for Ms. Diven's tutoring through the date of this decision, Petitioner also seeks compensatory education as follows:
As compensatory education, STUDENT requests an order that requires the Respondents to pay for tutorial services by Ms. Diven up to the date of the decision, but no less than at least nine months of services. [Emphasis added.]
Nine months of tutorial services, beginning in October 1999 when STUDENT first began receiving tutoring from Ms. Diven, would expire in June 2000 (at the end of the regular 1999-2000 school year). In effect, Petitioner seeks a two-month continuation of his present program because of the District's three-year denial of FAPE. (Footnote 32)
As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e) (1991) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to "ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." Id.
Unfortunately, as modest and warranted as the compensatory education services sought by Petitioner may be, the relief sought by Petitioner is not available under the law. California Education Code section 56505.2 (a) provides:
A hearing officer may not render a decision that results in the placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a nonpublic, nonsectarian school, or that results in a service for an individual with exceptional needs provided by a nonpublic agency, if the school or agency has not been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1.
In this case, there was no evidence that Ms. Diven's tutorial service has been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1, and therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot render a decision that mandates a continued placement with Ms. Diven. (Footnote 33)
CONCLUSION
As ordered below, the Petitioner and the Respondents must develop an appropriate program for STUDENT at an IEP meeting to be convened within 10 business days from the date of this decision. The IEP team should be mindful of the following when crafting an appropriate program for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year: (1) Respondent's have failed to provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for three years; (2) the only meaningful academic progress that STUDENT has made in three years been in his current program (since October 1999) with Pat Diven; (3) the District-provided program should resemble, as closely as possible, STUDENT's present placement; (4) the language-arts portion of STUDENT's program should use a simultaneous multi-sensory teaching model, such as Slingerland, which has proven to be successful for STUDENT, and because no other teaching model has provided STUDENT with some educational benefit in this area; (5) the teacher responsible for the language arts portion of STUDENT's program shall be appropriately qualified (like Pat Diven) to provide such services and shall be experienced and knowledgeable of STUDENT's disability; (6) STUDENT's progress (or lack thereof) shall be tracked through appropriate short-term objectives or benchSTUDENTs; (7) all individuals involved in STUDENT's education shall be knowledgeable of the contents of STUDENT's IEP, including his short-term objectives or benchSTUDENTs; and, (8) removing STUDENT from his present program into a new environment with new teachers and a new school with little more than two months remaining in the present school year is likely to cause STUDENT to lose additional educational opportunity. As much as possible, additional loss of educational opportunity is to be avoided.
ORDER
1. Within 10 business days after receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for all expenses incurred to the date of this decision related to STUDENT's private tutorial services from Pat Diven.
2. Within 10 business days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting. The IEP team shall create an appropriate program for STUDENT in which he shall remain for the remainder of the present school year. In developing a program, the IEP team shall take into consideration the items, numbers one through eight, listed in the Conclusion section of this decision. As much as possible, the IEP team shall endeavor to create a placement identical or nearly identical to STUDENT's present placement, including the use of a simultaneous multi-sensory language arts teaching method, such as Slingerland. Pat Diven shall be hired as a consultant to the IEP team, and her input shall be given considerable weight. The IEP team shall consider whether extended school year services are appropriate for STUDENT.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 24, 2000 ________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. To avoid confusion, FATHER Sr. will be referred to as Mr. PARENT and STUDENT II will be referred to simply as STUDENT. STUDENT was also present for one day of the hearing. Although he did not testify, he sat patiently and remained attentive for several hours.
2. Stanislaus County SELPA provided an oral closing argument in lieu of a written closing argument.
3. The California Highway Patrol statistics are availble over the internet.
4. The issues here differ slightly in numbering and content from those noticed by Petitioner prior to the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification, and to reflect the discussions held on the first day of hearing.
5. There is no dispute among the parties that STUDENT was eligible for special education services due to a learning disability during all relevant years.
6. Both of STUDENT's parents have volunteered in STUDENT's classes consistently in the first, second and third grades.
7. The IEP does not specify the total number of hours each day that STUDENT would be placed in the resource specialist classroom, only that the total length of the placement is "40 weeks."
8. Speech and language services are not at issue during any of the relevant school years.
9. The IEP indicates that written language skill development was of the highest priority for STUDENT.
10. Testimony established that the nonpublic school the IEP team discussed was the Valley Oaks school, located in Turlock, California. Valley Oaks was not, however, offered as a placement for STUDENT at that time.
11. Ms. Cox and the PARENT's understood the "re-evaluation" to take place at an IEP team meeting in December 1998.
12. According to the District, students who are placed in a special day class are automatically eligible for extended school year services. Testimony of Pardina.
13. Ms. Velarde testified that she did not review STUDENT's May 1998 IEP until the spring of 1999. The May 1998 IEP was the last IEP that contained short-term written language skills objectives.
14. It is also unclear whether Ms. Velarde saw STUDENT's goals and objectives in the areas of reading and math until the spring of 1999. In any event, Ms. Velarde testified that she did not adapt her program to meet STUDENT's reading and math short-term objectives. She "used the program that was in place."
15. As discussed below, Ms. Velarde testified that she administered the Woodcock-Johnson incorrectly. She further testified that, based on her observations, she believed that the results or the Woodcock-Johnson, nonetheless, accurately reflect the fact that STUDENT made progress in her class.
16. The short-term objectives developed by Ms. Velarde are incomplete and bear little relationship to the short-term objectives developed for STUDENT in the past, except that they are written on the same type of checklist. Ms. Velarde testified that she looked at STUDENT's goals and objectives from previous IEPs when she prepared STUDENT's short-term objectives, and she did not speak with any of STUDENT's previous teachers regarding STUDENT's progress. In the area of written language, under the objective "write upper/lower case letters," Ms. Velarde indicated that the success criteria is "80%" and that STUDENT was "just beginning cursive." There is no indication of STUDENT's pretest score. Under the objective "write the consonant sounds," Ms. Velarde wrote "firm-up." There is no indication of STUDENT's pretest score or the appropriate success criteria. STUDENT's reading and math short-term objectives were prepared in a similar, incomplete and incorrect manner.
17. Ms. Diven was involved with STUDENT's assessment at Valley Oaks in October 1998.
18. According to Ms. Diven, STUDENT receives two hours each day of tutoring in the area of language arts using the Slingerland method. During the other two hours, Ms. Diven tutors STUDENT in the areas of math, social science, science and listening comprehension.
19. Appendix C of 34 C.F.R. § 300, provides detailed requirements in a question-and-answer format. Appendix C describes the purpose of goals and objectives as providing "a way for the child's teacher(s) and parents to be able to track the child's progress in special education." Appendix C further describes short-term objectives as "measurable, intermediate steps between the present levels of educational performance . . . and the annual goals" which can "serve as milestones for measuring progress toward meeting the goals," or "provide general benchSTUDENTs for determining progress toward meeting those goals." Id. Appendix A of the regulations accompanying the new Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400-1485, contains almost identical language regarding the purpose of annual goals and short-term objectives:
Each annual goal must include either short-term objectives or benchSTUDENTs. The purpose of both is to enable a child's teacher(s), parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child's IEP, to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward achievement of the annual goal. 34 C.F.R. 300, Appendix A, Measurable Annual Goals, Including BenchSTUDENTs or Short-Term Objectives. [Emphasis added].
20. There appeared to be a significant communication breakdown between STUDENT's resource teacher and his regular education teacher. According to Ms. Skooglund, her communications with Ms. Pardina regarding STUDENT over the course of the year were "random." According to Ms. Pardina, they met on a "weekly" basis regarding lesson plans for STUDENT.
21. Although some of the District witnesses testified that they used STUDENT's short-term objectives to "monitor" STUDENT's progress in special education during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years, the weight of the evidence established that the short-term goals were updated just prior to IEP meetings, the only apparent purpose being to establish that STUDENT had made "progress" since the last IEP meeting. Short-term objectives, properly used, provide a mechanism for determining whether the anticipated outcomes for a student are being met over the course of the school year. They are measurable, intermediate steps between the present levels of educational performance of a child with a disability and the annual goals that are established for the child. They are not to be examined only once per year (just prior to a child's annual IEP meeting).
22. An IEP team meeting must be convened when a "pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress." Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). Had STUDENT's short-term objectives been monitored, STUDENT's "lack of anticipated progress" would have been discovered, and an IEP meeting would have been convened. The IEP team, in turn, would have attempted to remedy the problem. As it stands, no one discovered that STUDENT was not benefitting from his program.
23. STUDENT has resided in Modesto, California since August 1997.
24. Ms. Diven testified that almost all teaching uses a "multi-sensory" approach, i.e., the student "hears" the teacher and "sees" what is written on the chalkboard. "Simultaneous multi-sensory" differs in that multiple senses are used at the same time, e.g., the student "writes" the letter in the air or on a piece of cloth with his or her finger while "seeing" the letter and "saying" its name.
25. There was some dispute at the Hearing whether the December meeting was intended to be an IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the testimony at the hearing, it was agreed by the IEP team that the December 1998 meeting was to be an IEP team meeting, not a parent-teacher conference. Testimony of Velarde, Cox and Mr. PARENT.
26. A placement must also be the "least restrictive environment" for the child. This issue was not raised by the parties.
27. The specific methodology utilized to teach a special needs child is left to the District. However, here, it was generally agreed that STUDENT would benefit from a Slingerland-type simultaneous multi-sensory approach and Ms. Cox indicated that she would investigate a local Slingerland program. Moreover, two Slingerland programs in Turlock (Valley Oaks and Dutcher) were discussed, if not encouraged, at the November 1998 IEP by the SELPA (they were not offered as placements at this time). While the District was not required to provide this specific methodology (which was not available in Ms. Velarde's special day class, as she is not Slingerland-trained), it was the only teaching strategy mentioned in the IEP document.
28. STUDENT's parents also expressed safety concerns regarding the highway over which the bus transporting STUDENT would traverse every day.
29. As the November 1998 IEP suggests, "STUDENT needs to have victories in the classroom." Riding the bus between two and one-half and four hours each day would not only seriously inhibit STUDENT's extracurricular activities, but would also negatively impact his ability to have "victories in the classroom."
30. Parents are not required to pick an "appropriate" program from a sampling of programs, at least one of which is not reasonably calculated to provide their child with some educational benefit. The District cannot avoid its responsibility to exercise its professional judgment in selecting and offering a specific educational placement by offering a "range" of placements.
31. Additionally, the requirement that a student be educated in the "least restrictive environment" is not a bar to reimbursement. As the Sixth Circuit recently noted, "It will commonly be the case that parents who have not been treated properly under the IDEA, and who exercise the right of parental placement, will place their child in a school that specializes in teaching children with disabilities and thus will not satisfy the mainstreaming requirement. Adopting such a limitation on parental placements would therefore effectively vitiate that remedy." Cleveland Heights-University City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 144 F.3d 391, 399 (6th Cir. 1998)(at n7); accord Warren G. v. Cumberland County Sch. Dist., 1999 WL 643168 (3rd Cir. 1999).
32. The Hearing Officer notes that if it were not for the parents serendipitous discovery of Ms. Diven, who has provided STUDENT with services which has enabled him to progress significantly in the areas of reading and written language, STUDENT would have fallen further and further behind during the present school year.
33. The Hearing Officer notes that nothing prevents the District from continuing STUDENT's present program through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, if all parties agree. It may well be appropriate to consider some continued relationship with Ms. Diven, at least through the end of the present school year.
