California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 30, 1998

Student v. Fremont Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1246-97 · Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan

Fremont Union High School District correctly found 17-year-old not eligible as seriously emotionally disturbed; CEDU reimbursement denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 17-year-old filed for due process against Fremont Union High School District. In May 1997, the district had found that she did not qualify for special education. In summer 1996, after her tenth-grade year at the district's Monte Vista High School, the parents placed her at CEDU, a private residential school in Running Springs. They argued she qualified as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) because she had a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. They asked for reimbursement of CEDU costs and an order keeping her there.

All the experts agreed she had dysthymia, a long-lasting depressive disorder. Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan held that a clinical diagnosis does not by itself meet the educational standard. The mood must also be pervasive, exist to a marked degree, and adversely affect educational performance. The evidence showed her difficulties appeared mainly at home. She kept friendships, enjoyed many activities, and related well to teachers. Her grades stayed strong at Menlo School, Monte Vista, and CEDU, and Monte Vista never disciplined her. The Hearing Officer found that the family chose the treatment program and CEDU, and that she was not sent there because of problems at school. Expert predictions about what might happen if she returned to public school were speculation, not a basis for eligibility. Because she was not eligible, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement and the request to keep her at CEDU. The district prevailed on all three issues.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO separated a clinical depression diagnosis from the educational SED standard. A dysthymia diagnosis showed the mood had lasted a long time. It did not show that the mood was pervasive or marked, or that it harmed school performance. Strong grades and calm behavior at school weighed against eligibility and reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Should the Fremont Union High School District have found STUDENT eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) as of May 1997?

    A diagnosis of dysthymia showed long duration, but the evidence did not show a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression to a marked degree that adversely affected educational performance, so the student was not SED.

  2. Issue 2. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with CEDU?

    Because the student was not eligible for special education, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement for CEDU.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Is the Fremont Union High School District required to maintain STUDENT's placement at CEDU until such time an IEP meeting is convened and a new placement is determined for her?

    Because the student was ineligible, the district did not have to maintain her placement at CEDU.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

5 C.C.R. § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d); IDEA

People named in the decision

  • Polly Bove, director of educational services, Fremont Union High School District
  • Walter Donahue, school psychologist (district assessor), Fremont Union High School District
  • Pat Viera, special day class teacher (district assessor), Fremont Union High School District
  • Lise Gabet, general education French teacher, Monte Vista High School
  • Rhonda Hardy, assistant principal, Monte Vista High School
  • Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., private assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Rebecca Powers, private assessor and witness for Student, Private
  • Zakee Matthews, M.D., assessing physician and witness (District exhibit), Not stated
  • Russ Decker, team leader, CEDU
  • Judith Siegel, private evaluator and family therapist, Private
  • Ann Martini, L.C.S.W., private individual therapist, Private
  • Wanda Dean-Hunter, private Marriage and Family Child Counselor, Private
  • Michael Wachter, evaluating psychiatrist, Thunder Road
  • CEDU, private residential school (parent placement), Running Springs, California
  • Ascent, wilderness program, CEDU (Idaho)
  • Therapeutic Health Services, private therapy provider, Contracted by parents
  • Thunder Road, private treatment program, Private
  • Alta Bates, hospital, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case No: Sn 1246-97 This matter was heard before Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Sunnyvale, California on May 28 and 29, June 11 and 12, and by telephone conference on June 29, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Michael Zatopa. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner were her parents, PARENTS. Respondent Fremont Union High School District was represented by attorneys Elizabeth Estes and Bridget Flanagan. Also present on behalf of the District was Polly Bove, director of educational services. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the submission of written closing briefs on July 20, 1998, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES 1. Should the Fremont Union High School District have found STUDENT eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) as of May 1997? 2. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with CEDU? 3. Is the Fremont Union High School District required to maintain STUDENT's placement at CEDU until such time an IEP meeting is convened and a new placement is determined for her? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student who has not been found eligible for special education. STUDENT currently attends CEDU in Running Springs, California, where she was placed by her parents in August 1996. STUDENT attended private elementary schools where she excelled academically. When STUDENT was eleven years old, her nanny since birth moved out of the state, and when STUDENT was thirteen years old and in the eighth grade, her nanny died. This loss apparently affected STUDENT greatly. STUDENT attended Menlo School, a private college preparatory school for her ninth-grade year (1994-95). STUDENT took seven classes a day, six of which were academic, and received a grade point average (GPA) of 3.61. During her ninth-grade year, STUDENT began experimenting with drugs, primarily LSD and marijuana. Her drug use resulted in a five-day suspension from school in the spring semester as the result of an incident in which STUDENT and some friends had been smoking marijuana. STUDENT stated to her parents that she would not use drugs again. After consulting with the family physician, STUDENT began seeing Wanda Dean-Hunter, a Marriage and Family Child Counselor, to address her drug use and family conflict. This therapy ended just prior to STUDENT's tenth-grade year. In order to receive a "fresh start," STUDENT and her parents decided that she would transfer to Monte Vista High School (Monte Vista), a college preparatory public high school, for her tenth-grade school year (1995-1996). STUDENT enrolled in seven courses, including six academic courses. STUDENT's first-semester G.P.A. was 3.0 and her second-semester G.P.A. was a 2.73. The only grade of STUDENT's to change between the semesters was French, which dropped from an A to a C. During the spring of 1996, Lise Gabet, STUDENT's French teacher, contacted the PARENTS because STUDENT's demeanor and class participation had changed. In April 1996, the PARENTS contacted Dr. Judith Siegel to seek assistance with STUDENT. Dr. Siegel evaluated STUDENT and recommended both family and individual therapy. Dr. Siegel provided the family therapy and STUDENT saw Ann Martini, L.C.S.W., for individual therapy six times during May and June 1996. STUDENT was diagnosed with dysthymic disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, and polysubstance dependence. STUDENT's drug use continued as well as her opposition in the home. STUDENT had been under a contract with her parents concerning drug use. If she refrained from using drugs, she would be allowed to go on a trip to Israel. In May 1996, STUDENT informed her parents that she had broken the contract by using LSD. STUDENT requested that her parents allow her to go on the trip because she had been honest with them in reporting her drug use. The PARENTS told STUDENT that she would not be allowed to go on the trip, at which point STUDENT lost control and broke property in the PARENTS' home, including a picture frame that contained a photo of her nanny. For the summer of 1996, STUDENT's parents gave her the choice of attending summer school or Thunder Road, an inpatient drug and alcohol treatment program. STUDENT chose to enter Thunder Road and she was admitted on June 13, 1996. Thunder Road provides a six-week inpatient program, followed by an outpatient program. Upon her admission, STUDENT underwent a psychiatric evaluation. The evaluating doctor, Michael Wachter, rendered a diagnosis of marijuana dependence, LSD hallucinogen dependence, and polysubstance abuse. The report indicates that STUDENT reported using marijuana, acid, mushrooms, cocaine, and alcohol. The discharge plan from Thunder Road was for STUDENT to return home and continue treatment on an outpatient basis. However, four days prior to her scheduled release, STUDENT had an outburst in which she destroyed property in her room, and made threats to hurt the staff and herself while holding a piece of broken class. STUDENT was placed in restraints and taken to Alta Bates, a psychiatric hospital, under a conservatorship, as a danger to self or others. In the Thunder Road discharge report, dated July 31, 1996, STUDENT's primary counselor described STUDENT's prognosis for successful abstinence and recovery as "fair." STUDENT remained at Alta Bates for five days during which time the PARENTS made arrangements for STUDENT to transfer to CEDU. On July 31, 1996, STUDENT went to CEDU. Upon enrolling at CEDU, STUDENT was hostile, defiant, and uncooperative with the staff. After approximately two weeks, STUDENT had an outburst and threatened to hurt herself. As a result, she was sent to Ascent, CEDU's wilderness program in Idaho. After six weeks in Ascent, STUDENT returned to CEDU. After returning from Ascent, in the fall of 1996, STUDENT began receiving individual therapy through Therapeutic Health Services. The therapy takes place at CEDU, but is provided under contract between parents and Therapeutic Health Services separately from CEDU. STUDENT's therapy sessions occurred on a weekly and sometimes twice weekly basis. In November 1996, at the PARENTS request, Dr. Vincent Nunno assessed STUDENT and concluded that she suffered from dysthymia and met the criteria for special education eligibility. The PARENTS requested that the District conduct an assessment, and in May 1997, Dr. Walter Donahue, District school psychologist, and Pat Viera, District special day class teacher, assessed STUDENT. The assessors summarized STUDENT as being an excellent to very good student despite a severe drug abuse problem, family discord, and several explosive incidents and they concluded that STUDENT did not meet the special education criteria for SED. On May 29, 1997, an IEP team meeting was convened and the District formally denied STUDENT's eligibility for special education. On October 3, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on STUDENT's behalf. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW The threshold issue presented for hearing is whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). Under the IDEA and California special education law, only individuals with certain disabilities, including SED, are eligible for special education services. ISSUE NO. 1: Should the Fremont Union High School District have found STUDENT eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) as of May 1997? In order to be found eligible for special education on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) the student must meet criteria set forth in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations. The regulations provide that a student is eligible as SED if he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. (5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. (5 C.C.R.  3030(i).) The parties stipulated that of the above mentioned criteria, the only one at issue in this case is a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will address only that criterion. Each of the clinical expert witnesses called on behalf of both parties stated that STUDENT suffered from dysthymia.(footnote 1) Although the experts agree that STUDENT has dysthymia, the parties disagree as to whether this diagnosis automatically meets the educational criteria of pervasiveness and to a marked degree. A general mood of pervasive unhappiness or depression is an SED characteristic that exists in special education law, and is not automatically proven by a diagnosis of dysthymia from the DSM-IV. To be diagnosed with dysthymia, a child or adolescent must exhibit a depressed mood for at least one year. Thus, a diagnosis of dysthymia meets one of the limiting factors for SED eligibility: that the unhappiness or depression must exist over a long period of time. However, a diagnosis of dysthymia does not per se meet other factors for special education eligibility including that the unhappiness or depression must be pervasive, to a marked degree, and adversely affect educational performance. In order for STUDENT's emotional condition to be pervasive it must spread throughout every part of her life, including home and school. Significant evidence was presented establishing that STUDENT's emotional condition almost exclusively manifested itself at home. MOTHER testified about "outbursts" that STUDENT had at home. For example, MOTHER testified that on one occasion when she asked STUDENT to get off the phone STUDENT threw a glass on the floor. On another occasion when STUDENT became angry she kicked a hole in a door. Another time she took picture frames off the wall and smashed them on the floor. MOTHER also testified about positive times STUDENT has with the family. Since being at CEDU, STUDENT has been on several home visits. MOTHER stated that the home visits have "gone well" and that STUDENT was happy to see her sister and her cat. Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., assessed STUDENT at CEDU on November 15, 1996, at the request of her parents. Dr. Nunno diagnosed STUDENT as suffering from dysthymia and stated that at the time of his observation she exhibited a depressed mood, low self-esteem, and feelings of hopelessness. Dr. Nunno testified that a diagnosis of depression from the DSM-IV must lead to a determination that STUDENT has a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. As stated above, a diagnosis of dysthymia does not by itself meet the educational requirement of a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Russ Decker, CEDU team leader, testified that STUDENT has developed friendships with other students at CEDU. Mr. Decker stated that STUDENT was sad at the end of the school year because many of the students she had befriended were graduating and would be leaving CEDU. Ms. Gabet taught STUDENT's tenth grade French class, French 3. Ms. Gabet testified that she felt close to STUDENT and found her to be friendly and bright. Ms. Gabet stated that STUDENT seemed to have friends in the class and that she worked well with the other students. In a conversation during an assessment with Zakee Matthews, M.D., STUDENT stated that she enjoys singing, reading, dancing, writing, being outside, and camping. When talking about school, STUDENT stated that she generally finds school intellectually stimulating and challenging, and she reported that it is an environment that she generally feels comfortable in. (Dist. Exh. 35.) Dr. Matthews testified that STUDENT is not pervasively unhappy or depressed because she has been able to function in various areas of her life. For example, Dr. Matthews stated that STUDENT is able to work in her therapy group appropriately, interact appropriately with teachers, and bond with people and develop relationships. Dr. Matthews reported that during his conversation with STUDENT, she stated that she would like to go to college after taking a year off to re-integrate with society. In summary, STUDENT participates in her educational program and in her therapy program. She has established and maintained friendships. She enjoys activities such as reading, dancing, and writing. She is able to participate in and enjoy family trips. Although STUDENT exhibits periods of unhappiness and depression, generally in relation to family issues, the evidence does not support a finding of pervasiveness that is necessary for special education eligibility. Moreover, to qualify as SED STUDENT's educational performance must be adversely affected. Academically, STUDENT has always excelled. During the first semester of ninth-grade (1994-95) at Menlo, STUDENT received a 3.67 G.P.A. During the second semester STUDENT received a 3.71 G.P.A. (Dist. Exh. 2.) For the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT attended Monte Vista, a District high school. STUDENT's first semester G.P.A. was a 3.0. During the second semester STUDENT's G.P.A. dropped slightly to a 2.73. (Dist. Exh. 2.) STUDENT's first academic period at CEDU was the fall of the 1996-97 school year. STUDENT was enrolled in four classes and received a B+, a B, a B-, and a P. (Dist. Exh. 13.) Russ Decker, CEDU team leader, testified that her academics were interrupted with her transfer to CEDU's Ascent wilderness program in Idaho. Upon her return to CEDU, STUDENT continued with her academic program. For the spring of the 1996-97 school year she received two As, one A-, one B+, one B, and a P. In the 1996-97 summer session, STUDENT took nine courses and received no grade lower than a B. (Dist. Exh. 13.) CEDU records reflect that for the fall of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in eleven courses and that her lowest grade was a C in pre-calculus. For the winter she was enrolled in seven courses and received three As, one B, one B-, and two Ps. (Dist. Exh. 13-A.) Looking at grades as an indicator, it can not be said that STUDENT's educational performance has been affected. Ms. Gabet reported that STUDENT was never disciplined in her class, did not have behavior problems, was never rebellious, never acted inappropriately, and never seemed depressed in class. Ms. Gabet stated that during the second semester, STUDENT began coming to class late and did not turn in her homework on several occasions. She testified that even with tardiness and missing homework assignments, STUDENT satisfactorily completed the class and was eligible to move on to French 4. Ms. Gabet testified that when she spoke to STUDENT, STUDENT stated that she was angry at her family and her mother. STUDENT also stated that she wanted to live alone. Rhonda Hardy, Monte Vista assistant principal, stated that one of her duties is discipline. She testified that STUDENT was never referred to her for any disciplinary action. There is no indication that STUDENT's educational performance was adversely affected to any significant degree while at the District high school. The Petitioner's argument that STUDENT's "deterioration" in French, which lead to a decrease in her G.P.A., is a result of her emotional condition is not persuasive. Further, although STUDENT had an "outburst" while at Thunder Road, this was not an educational setting--it was a drug treatment program. Therefore, it cannot be said that her educational performance was affected during the summer. The Petitioner contends that STUDENT is unable to attend a regular education program safely, and that, therefore her educational performance is affected. The Petitioner argues that if STUDENT had not received extensive professional treatment upon her release from Alta Bates, that she would have become self-destructive and unable to attend regular school. MOTHER testified that prior to STUDENT leaving Thunder Road she and her parents were in the process of preparing a contract for her return home. MOTHER stated that at times STUDENT said that she was afraid to go home and that on more than one occasion she expressed that she would like to go to a boarding school. Thunder Road family therapy notes dated July 16, 1996, indicate that STUDENT was concerned about returning home because she felt that her parents had not changed and that things would be the same at home. The Alta Bates discharge summary states that STUDENT was discharged to her parents without incident and that arrangements had been made for her to go directly to CEDU. (Pet. Exh. 24.) MOTHER testified that CEDU had been recommended by Dr. Siegel, and that the PARENTS first looked into CEDU when STUDENT was at Thunder Road. Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT's educational performance was affected because she was not able to attend a regular school and because she had to go to Thunder Road and then to a residential school. However, the testimony presented by MOTHER was that STUDENT chose to go to Thunder Road--she was not sent there as a result of any problems at school. Likewise, STUDENT and her parents chose for her to attend CEDU; she was not sent there as a result of not being able to function on a regular school campus. Dr. Nunno testified that in his opinion, if STUDENT had returned to a District school after being released from Alta Bates, she would have continued to use drugs, possibly attempted suicide, and had unprotected sex. Dr. Nunno reported that he did not review any of STUDENT's educational records, and he stated that academics have never been a problem area for STUDENT, despite dysthymia. He stated that STUDENT can work around her disorder and function academically. According to Dr. Nunno, for a bright student like STUDENT, school can be a place to escape. Dr. Rebecca Powers, assessed STUDENT in April of 1998. Dr. Powers stated that based on her review of the records, she does not think that STUDENT could have returned to school after being at Alta Bates. However, Dr. Powers admitted that she did not review any of STUDENT's educational records and that she has no training in special education eligibility. Dr. Powers testified that because of STUDENT's strengths, she can do well in school. Dr. Matthews testified that, in his opinion, upon her discharge from Alta Bates, STUDENT should have been further evaluated and received some form of further treatment. He stated that, in his opinion, Thunder Road was a starting point for STUDENT's drug treatment, but that she needed then, and continues to need, drug treatment. Although several witnesses testified that STUDENT may not have been able to return to a regular school after Alta Bates, the fact is that in a regular educational environment, STUDENT has not had an "outburst." SED criteria look to a child's current behavior and functioning. Speculation as to what may occur in the future is not a basis on which to determine a student is eligible for special education. Understandably, the PARENTS are concerned with STUDENT's emotional outbursts and drug use. Although STUDENT may require therapy and a residential placement to address depression and drug use, special education does not require a school district to be responsible for providing for all of a student's psychiatric needs. If a student's emotional condition is not interfering with her ability to benefit from her education, she is not eligible for special education services. After considering the SED criteria along with the limiting conditions in the law, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not SED pursuant to the educational criteria. ISSUE NO. 2: Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with CEDU? Having found that STUDENT is not qualified for special education, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with CEDU. ISSUE NO. 3: Is the Fremont Union High School District required to maintain STUDENT's placement at CEDU until such time an IEP meeting is convened and a new placement is determined for her? Because STUDENT has been found ineligible for special education, the District is not required to maintain STUDENT's placement at CEDU. ORDER The Petitioner's claims for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to California Education Code  56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: 1. Should the Fremont Union High School District have found STUDENT eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) as of May 1997? The District prevailed on this issue. 2. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with CEDU? The District prevailed on this issue. 3. Is the Fremont Union High School District required to maintain STUDENT's placement at CEDU until such time an IEP meeting is convened and a new placement is determined for her? The District prevailed on this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code  56505(i). Dated: July 30, 1998 Jennifer Nolan Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Dysthymia is described as a "depressed mood for most of the day, for more days than not...." In children and adolescence the depressed mood must have a duration of at least 1 year. During the periods of the depressed mood, at least two of the following symptoms must be present: poor appetite or overeating, insomnia or hypersomnia, low energy or fatigue, low self-esteem, poor concentration or difficulty making decisions, and a feeling of hopelessness. (American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition. Washington D.C., American Psychiatric Association, 1994.)