California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 1, 1998

Student v. Redlands Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1254-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Redlands Unified and San Bernardino County Office of Education must fund 3-year-old's in-home autism program and private speech assessment.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 3-year-old girl with autism and apraxia (difficulty planning the mouth movements for speech) filed for due process. After she left the Early Start program, Redlands Unified and the San Bernardino County Office of Education offered a SELPA preschool autism special day class at Bloomington Middle School. Their offer also included 10 hours a week of in-home services through the regional center. The parents instead paid for about 40 hours a week of one-to-one behavioral therapy at home, supervised by Autism Partnership, a nonpublic agency, plus private speech therapy from Kelli Wilms.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the offer was not designed to meet the student's needs. It had no direct speech therapy, and the class relied on a picture-exchange system that her speech therapist said would set back her emerging speech. Her attention problems kept her from benefiting from group instruction at the time. The class also did not provide the active parent involvement that state preschool law requires. The class was full when it was offered, so the offer was not valid. The home program met her needs and she made clear progress there. Respondents must reimburse the program's 1997-1998 costs and fund it for the rest of the year, including extended school year. They must also reimburse the private speech-language assessment, because they never formally assessed her speech after the parents asked. Under their agreement at the hearing, they must also complete occupational therapy and adapted physical education assessments.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley and Education Code section 56441.2 to a preschooler with autism. A full classroom offered "when a seat opens" was not a valid offer. Parents' preference for private therapy did not excuse the district from offering needed speech services. An assessment with no formal language testing supported reimbursement for a private assessment.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did Respondents offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program for the summer of 1998?

    The SELPA autism preschool class offer was not designed to meet the student's needs: it had no direct speech therapy for severe expressive language delays and apraxia, a group setting she could not yet benefit from given her attention problems, and too little parent involvement under Education Code 56441.2. The class was also full when offered, so the offer was not valid. The ESY offer was not shown to be appropriate.

  2. Issue 2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent educational services they have provided for STUDENT?

    The parent-funded in-home program (one-to-one behavioral therapy supervised by Autism Partnership, plus private speech therapy) met the student's needs, carried out her IEP goals, and gave her educational benefit. The parents are entitled to reimbursement and to continued funding, including ESY.

  3. Issue 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent speech and language assessment by Kelli Wilms?

    The County Office's July 1997 assessment included no speech-language pathologist and no formal language testing. The district never assessed after the parents asked at the IEP meeting, so the parents must be reimbursed for the private speech-language assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, reimburse the actual, proven costs of the in-home program for the 1997-1998 school year. This covers the one-to-one therapists, Autism Partnership consultation and supervision, speech and language therapy by Ms. Wilms, and start-up costs listed in Petitioner's Exhibit 29.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. Continue to fund the in-home program for the rest of the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program. The ESY funding lasts as long as the ESY available to students in the Bloomington class.
  • IEE at public expense. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, reimburse the cost of Kelli Wilms' independent speech and language assessment (October 1997).
  • Order to assess. Within 25 calendar days of the decision, conduct occupational therapy and adapted physical education assessments, as Respondents agreed at the start of the hearing.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Education Code § 56441.2; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320

People named in the decision

  • Kelli Wilms, private speech-language pathologist; assessed student and provides therapy; witness for Student, Private practice; Children's Hospital
  • Korena Lyn Saunby, senior therapist/supervisor of in-home program; also consultant to Bloomington class; witness for Student, Autism Partnership
  • John J. McEachin, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, program director and clinical supervisor; witness for Student, Autism Partnership
  • Autism Partnership, certified nonpublic agency supervising the in-home program
  • Carol Burmeister, special education teacher, Bloomington autism class, East Valley SELPA / San Bernardino County Office of Education
  • Pamela Bender, SELPA program specialist supervising discrete trial training in the class, East Valley SELPA
  • Nelson Silva, special education teacher, new Bloomington classroom, East Valley SELPA / San Bernardino County Office of Education
  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager; Respondents' representative, East Valley SELPA
  • Janice Billings, director of special education services, Redlands Unified School District
  • Cheryl Sjostrom, principal, San Bernardino County Office of Education
  • Darlene Fischer, program manager, Early Start Program, East Valley SELPA
  • Dwight Sweeney, Ph.D., psychologist; expert witness for Respondents, California State University, San Bernardino
  • Frank Gresham, Ph.D., school psychology professor; expert witness for Respondents, University of California, Riverside
  • Stephen Ashwal, M.D., pediatric neurologist (report in evidence), Loma Linda University
  • Nan Neighbors, speech-language pathologist who treated student in 1996-1997 (letter in evidence), Loma Linda University
  • Carlos Fayard, Ph.D., consulting psychologist who assessed student (report in evidence), Loma Linda University
  • Loma Linda University Psychiatric Medical Group, private provider; independent assessment August 1997
  • Outpatient Rehabilitation Center, Loma Linda University Medical Center, private provider of speech and occupational therapy
  • East Valley Regional Center, regional center coordinating Early Start services

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redlands, California, on December 16 and 17, 1997, and February 10, 11, and 12, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorneys Shelli J. Lewis and Cristy Coyne. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her parents. Respondents were represented at the hearing by Gail Lindberg, program manager, East Valley SELPA. Also present on behalf of Respondent Redlands Unified School District was Janice Billings, director of special education services. Cheryl Sjostrom, principal, was also present on behalf of Respondent San Bernardino County Office of Education (COE).

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Did Respondents offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program for the summer of 1998?

(2) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent educational services they have provided for STUDENT?

(3) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent speech and language assessment by Kelli Wilms?(Footnote 1)

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a three-year-old child with autism. She also has apraxia (oral-motor planning difficulties). On July 15, 1997, STUDENT commenced an intensive, in-home intervention program, which is supervised through Autism Partnership, a certified nonpublic agency (NPA). STUDENT’s parents fund the program for her. STUDENT receives approximately 40 hours per week of services including discrete trial training (DTT), which is provided one-to-one by therapists trained by Autism Partnership, and “play dates,” during which STUDENT and her playmate engage in structured activities that have been selected and set up by the senior therapist from Autism Partnership and the speech and language pathologist. STUDENT’s program also includes speech and language therapy, which, since November 1997, has been three hours per week. Approximately one hour per week is direct speech and language therapy. The remaining two hours are devoted to parent training and coordinating with the DTT therapists.

Prior to turning three years old, STUDENT received early intervention services. From December 1996 through July 1997, STUDENT’s Early Start program, which was coordinated by the East Valley Regional Center, included weekly home visits of approximately one hour each and a COE school program at the Mission Educational Center for one to two hours per week. In November and December 1996, and from May 1997 through July 1997, STUDENT received approximately 20 speech and language therapy sessions from the Outpatient Rehabilitation Center at Loma Linda University Medical Center. STUDENT’s parents also provided her with two to three sessions per week of occupational therapy at Loma Linda beginning in December 1996.

The COE conducted a multidisciplinary assessment of STUDENT in July 1997. STUDENT demonstrated below age-level expectancies in all areas of development. STUDENT’s language and social skills were particularly low and fell within the zero to eight-month range. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 9, 10, and 11.) An independent assessment conducted in August 1997 by Loma Linda University Psychiatric Medical Group obtained similar results. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 11.)

On September 9, 1997, STUDENT turned three years old. The District then became responsible for her education.(Footnote 2) On September 11, 1997, the individualized educational program (IEP) team met to discuss STUDENT’s transition from the Early Start program to a preschool program. The goals and objectives submitted to the team by MOTHER were accepted, for the most part, by the rest of the IEP team. The IEP team did not, however, reach agreement regarding STUDENT’s placement. Respondents offered to place STUDENT in the East Valley SELPA autism class located at Bloomington Middle School with 10 hours per week of in-home intensive behavioral intervention services through the Regional Center. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 14.) MOTHER agreed to visit the preschool programs available within the SELPA. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 16.) The parents concluded that none of the programs would meet STUDENT’s needs and requested funding from Respondents for the in-home program they were providing for STUDENT, including the costs of the one-to-one therapist, supervision and consultation by Autism Partnership, and speech and language therapy.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did Respondents offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program for the summer of 1998?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

California special education law additionally provides that for students between the ages of three and five years, special education shall include “specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. [Emphasis added.] To meet this purpose, the program focus is on the young child and his or her family and shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement.” Education Code § 56441.2.

The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and comport with the IEP.

In order to determine whether Respondents’ placement satisfies the requirements of Rowley and IDEA, it is necessary to first have an understanding of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in September 1997, when the initial placement offer was made. All of the witnesses described STUDENT’s language as significantly delayed. The consensus was that her expressive language skills have always been more severely delayed than her receptive language skills. STUDENT’s mother testified that in September 1997, STUDENT’s expressive language was limited to labeling a few objects. As for STUDENT’s behavior, MOTHER testified that STUDENT engaged in tantrums whenever she was asked to transition to anything she did not like. She also hit her head on the wall or on other surfaces. STUDENT’s attention span was very poor and she engaged in repetitive, nonmeaningful activity to the exclusion of other activities. At times, STUDENT would hum, make a clicking noise, laugh inappropriately, and cry or sob for no apparent reason. Korena Lyn Saunby, who supervises the in-home program provided to STUDENT through Autism Partnership, testified that STUDENT also exhibited self-stimulating behaviors that were more subtle. For example, STUDENT would “zone out” and not be aware of anything going on around her. She also would pick at her face and lip. According to Ms. Saunby, all of these behaviors interfered with STUDENT’s ability to focus. John J. McEachin, Ph.D., also testified regarding STUDENT’s needs. Dr. McEachin, a clinical psychologist with Autism Partnership, provides supervisory services to STUDENT’s in-home program. He testified that STUDENT’s needs include developing social functioning, language, self-help, cognitive, play, and behavioral skills.

There was no evidence to contradict the descriptions of STUDENT’s needs provided by MOTHER, Ms. Saunby, and Dr. McEachin. These needs existed in September 1997 and have continued. Therefore, to summarize, STUDENT has significant deficits in language, particularly in expressive language. She has also been diagnosed with apraxia--difficulty with oral motor planning. STUDENT has delays in all other areas of development including self-help skills, behavior, play, cognitive, and social skills. STUDENT’s attention span is limited, she engages in some self-stimulatory behavior, and she has difficulty making transitions from one activity to another, which may result in tantrumming.

The first requirement of an appropriate placement is that the placement must be designed to meet the unique and individual needs of the student. Placement decisions are based on the student’s unique and individual needs and the IEP goals and objectives that are drafted to address those needs. The IEP goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s IEP from September 1997 call for STUDENT to do the following: receptively identify objects, action labels, colors, shapes, numbers and categories; expressively identify objects and actions; be toilet trained; follow action instructions; use a spoon and fork when eating; put on pants, socks, and shirt; brush her teeth; stay with an adult in a variety of environments; follow two-step directions; engage in functional toy play, cooperative block play, roll a ball; engage in eye contact; imitate a block structure; attend to an independent task; pedal and steer a tricycle; imitate facial gestures and simple actions; string beads; twist a nut onto a bolt; color shapes; wait independently; stop climbing; accept transitions without engaging in tantrums; and sit cooperatively during preschool activities. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 14.) The only apparent disagreement by the parents with the goals and objectives is related to their proposed goal number 14, which calls for STUDENT to stay with an adult during “community” outings. The Respondents revised this goal to read that “STUDENT will stay with adults in a variety of environments.” Based on the testimony of MOTHER, it is concluded that STUDENT experiences difficulty staying with an adult in a variety of environments. Therefore, it is appropriate to include in STUDENT’s IEP a goal to address her staying with an adult in a number of environments, including the community. There was no evidence that the goal as written by Respondents’ members of the IEP team is inappropriate for STUDENT or that it precludes addressing the goal in the community. Therefore, the parents’ objection to this goal is unsupported. There were no other valid concerns raised in relation to the appropriateness of the goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s identified needs. The goals and objectives address the areas of deficit identified above. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives, as written, are designed to address STUDENT’s identified areas of need.

In order to determine whether the program offered by the SELPA preschool special day class (SDC) program at Bloomington is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, it is necessary to have an understanding of the proposed class. For this reason, the testimony of Respondents’ witnesses is addressed initially. At the beginning of the school year, Carol Burmeister was the classroom teacher. Ms. Burmeister holds special education and standard teaching credentials, and has a master’s degree in education. She has been a teacher for 23 years and has specific training in the methodologies employed in the class. Pamela Bender, SELPA program specialist, was responsible for supervision of the DTT provided in the classroom. Ms. Bender holds a master’s degree in special education and is in the process of obtaining a master’s degree in education administration. Ms. Bender taught the Bloomington class from August through December 1996 and “on-and-off” through August 1997. She participated in two training sessions sponsored by Autism Partnership in the fall of 1995 and in the training provided at the PARENTS’ home. There were five instruction assistants in the classroom. All of the instructional assistants participated in eight days of staff development training during the school year. Training covered topics related to specific teaching methodologies that are utilized in the classroom. The teaching assistants also participated in the training provided by Autism Partnership at the PARENTS’ home. Since November 1997, Dr. McEachin has been under contract to provide two hours per month of consultation services to the class and Ms. Saunby was responsible for providing three hours per month of consultation services to the students receiving DTT in the class.

In September 1997, when the class was proposed for STUDENT, there were seven students in the class. All of the students were boys. One of the students was nine years old. Ms. Lindberg, SELPA program manager, testified that the cap of seven students cannot be exceeded. She testified that another class was scheduled to open in January 1998. Ms. Bender testified that one of the boys in the class was going to be transitioned out if STUDENT entered the class and that his parents had agreed to the transition. Ms. Bender anticipated that it would take approximately two weeks to transition the student from the class. As discussed more fully below, the classroom make up did not change until late in January 1998 or early February 1998.

Regarding the functional levels of the students in the class at the beginning of the school year, Ms. Bender testified that two students had expressive language and one could carry on a conversation. One student was able to respond to questions. Several children in the class exhibited tantrums and some children engaged in self-abusive behaviors, including hitting and biting themselves and head-banging

The testimony of Ms. Lindberg, Ms. Bender, Ms. Burmeister and Ms. Billings, District director of special education, establishes the following additional information regarding the Bloomington class. The class is located on a middle school campus. A head start preschool class is also located on the school. The class offers a year-round program for a total of 225 days. The school day begins at 8:30 a.m. and ends at 2:30 p.m., for a total of six hours daily. When students arrive in the morning at 8:30 a.m., they go to assigned areas according to their individual schedules. The students work for 25 to 30 minutes, transition to circle time, transition from circle time to another activity period, and then transition to a third activity period. At 10:40 a.m., the students have a snack and then go to recess with the Head Start students. After recess, there are three more rounds of activities. At 1:15 p.m., the students have a 30-minute lunch period. All of the staff members eat lunch with the students. The students then participate in the final activities. Each round of activities is approximately 30 minutes. The length of the round may be adjusted to meet the needs of an individual student.

Ms. Bender testified that the class curriculum integrates programs that are based on research and that have been determined to be educationally sound. The primary instructional methods employed during the rounds are Treatment and Education of Autistic and related Communication Handicapped Children (TEACCH), Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), Social Stories, and Discrete Trial Training (DTT). (See Respondents’ Exhibit 20.)

TEACCH is a structured model for working with persons with autism. TEACCH methods include designing an appropriate physical layout of the classroom and work areas, developing structured schedules for daily activities and individual work systems for the student, defining structured routines, and providing visual cues and organization. Teaching methods include providing directions for tasks, offering prompts, and delivering reinforcers. TEACCH techniques help to reduce anxiety by providing structure to each task. (See Respondents’ Exhibits 2.) Ms. Bender described the use of the TEACCH program in the Bloomington classroom. All of the students in the class have a schedule. Some of the students have object schedules and others have picture schedules. One student has a word schedule. The schedules are used to transition students from one place to another or from one activity to the next. Students on the object schedule are each given an object that lets them know where to go for their next activity. Students on picture schedules go to their personal schedules and retrieve a picture telling them where to go for their next activity. They may also be given a picture telling them to leave a particular area and to move to another area. The pictures all have words beneath them; however, the students are not required to say aloud or read the words or pictures. TEACCH also defines a work system wherein the students learn to complete activities independently. For example, students are taught that the activities go from top to bottom and from left to right.

PECS offers an alternative way to communicate. It involves specific training with a student wherein the student initially learns to exchange a picture for a desired item. PECS may later be expanded to allow for communication in sentences. PECS is used throughout the school day and students are provided specific training in the use of the PECS. (Respondents’ Exhibit 5.) Ms. Bender testified that all students use PECS. They initially receive training in small groups and are utilizing PECS at snack and lunch periods.

Social Stories is a formula for writing stories from the child’s point of view to help the student learn social behavior, routines, or rules. A personalized story is written and read to the student to provide repetitive positive feedback. (See Respondents’ Exhibit 6.)

DTT is an intensive behavioral intervention program used to teach specific skills to the student. The discrete skills are broken down into smaller tasks. For example, before a student is to write, the student must be able to pay attention and hold a writing instrument. Students are provided reinforcers for correct responses such as treats, hugs, or something else that is motivating to the student. The student’s progress is individually documented daily. The program is reevaluated every 16 weeks. The length of DTT students receive daily is dependent upon the individual student’s needs. Services may range from one hour to four hours each day. Ms. Bender testified that DTT is generally employed with children who have severe behavioral and compliance issues that interfere with their learning. Ms. Bender testified that she employed a DTT curriculum based on a book by Kathryn Maurice entitled Behavioral Intervention for Young Children with Autism. Ms. Bender testified that, at that time, she was consulting in the classroom and reviewing the children’s programs weekly.

Additional techniques that may be employed in the class include sensory integration brushing and rhythmic entrainment, which is based on research showing that the beat of a drum can calm and reduce acting out behaviors. Ms. Burmeister testified that additional techniques include use of naturalistic teaching strategies and opportunities for generalization during circle time, outdoor play time, and activities at the end of the school day. Ms. Burmeister testified that the manner of addressing the behavior depends upon the nature of the behavior and the manner in which the behavior interferes with the learning process. Ms. Bender testified that students’ tantrumming is handled through redirection, by making different offers in PECS, by shortening the number of tasks that need to be completed in TEACCH, by shortening the stimuli in DTT, and by physically motoring the student through the tantrum.

Ms. Bender and Ms. Billings, the District’s director of special education, testified that the amount of time each methodology would be employed with STUDENT would be determined in consultation with the parents and the IEP team when she actually entered the program. Ms. Bender testified how STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives could be met utilizing a combination of DTT, TEACCH, and PECS. For example, to implement the first goal, Ms. Bender would use DTT, TEACCH, and PECS. DTT would also be utilized to implement all of the other goals. She would also use PECS to implement STUDENT’s fourth goal related to attributes. Ms. Bender described how social stories could be used to implement goal number 14 related to STUDENT’s running away. She would have a photograph of STUDENT accompanying the following text: When I run away, my parents worry. When I am in the mall, I will hold onto my mommy’s and my daddy’s hands.

When the hearing reconvened in February, the class split into two classrooms. One class had four students and there were two in the other. There was a total of seven adults available to work full-time with the students. The classroom with four students has four adults, including a new teacher--Nelson Silva. The four students are three- and four-years old. The classroom with two students has two adults in the classroom and the students are “older.” One student “went elsewhere” after winter break. Ms. Burmeister oversees the entire program. Ms. Burmeister described her duties as lesson planning, compiling data, consulting with staff, and implementing some programs during the school day. Ms. Burmeister testified that she spends all but approximately one and one-half hour daily in the smaller classroom. Ms. Burmeister described the functional levels of the students in the class. The students’ communication skills range from none to having sufficient verbal skills that allow them to express their needs most of the time. The students’ self-help skills range from not being able to toilet independently to being able to put their jackets on and get their lunches independently. One student is able to recognize the letters of the alphabet and another is able to recognize sounds. One student recognizes numbers to 20 and another student can rote count to 25. Four students are able to work independently at the computer. Ms. Burmeister testified that all of the students have shown an increase in communication skills, verbal expression, and socialization skills. The students are able to sit longer at circle time. One student has learned to go up and down stairs. Another has learned to hold a pencil and to write his name, and one student has learned to feed himself. The students’ inappropriate behaviors have decreased as well. They engage less frequently in tantrumming, shouting during circle time, and refusing to go to an activity.

Darlene Fischer, program manager for the East Valley SELPA’s Early Start Program, testified that at the September 1997 IEP meeting STUDENT was offered two hours daily of in-home services to address socialization, adaptive skills, and community integration skills. Ms. Fischer testified that the Regional Center has funded similar services in conjunction with the program offered by Respondents. She testified that the services are coordinated through regular meetings with the SELPA and school and Regional Center staff.

Respondents called two expert witnesses to discuss the appropriateness of the class proposed for STUDENT. Neither had met STUDENT, observed her, nor spoken with any of the persons providing STUDENT with services. Neither observed the Bloomington class in the fall of 1997 and, therefore, their testimony was based on their observations that took place in early 1998. Dwight Sweeney, Ph.D., psychologist, is a professor at California State University, San Bernardino, and teaches courses in special education and counseling. Dr. Sweeney also oversees a support program for 76 families with children with autism. Dr. Sweeney observed the Bloomington class in early February 1998. Dr. Sweeney testified that the strength of the program is its ability to serve children with different needs and to determine what programs most effectively address the students’ needs. Dr. Sweeney testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives could be met in a classroom setting and that methods other than DTT could be employed to meet her needs.

Frank Gresham, Ph.D., is a professor and director of the school psychology program at the University of California, Riverside. After observing the Bloomington class in February 1998, Dr. Gresham drew the conclusion that the class offers an appropriate educational program for children with autism. In addition to the use of DTT and PECS techniques, Dr. Gresham observed interactions between the whole group and the staff. Dr. Gresham concluded that the techniques he observed could be used to meet STUDENT’s goals and objectives. In his opinion, the variety of techniques employed would be more beneficial for STUDENT than the use of a single technique such as DTT.

All of the witnesses testifying of behalf of STUDENT concluded that the Bloomington class would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT at any time during the 1997-1998 school year. MOTHER described the overall atmosphere of the class as “chaotic and confusing.” Students in the class are engaged in a number of different activities in different areas. During some activities, such as DTT, students are expected to sit and be compliant, whereas during PECS training, the students are allowed to run around the classroom. MOTHER testified that this would be confusing and distracting to STUDENT. On the other hand, MOTHER stated that because the class schedule is always the same, STUDENT would not learn how to deal with changes in daily activities. MOTHER prefers that STUDENT’s daily activities vary. MOTHER testified that the Bloomington class is also not appropriate because of the use of PECS. MOTHER does not want STUDENT to rely on visual prompts for every activity. She believes that this would be a “set back” for STUDENT because she is able to communicate verbally and by gestures and her repertoire of communication skills is presently expanding. MOTHER testified that it also did not appear that there were any plans in the class to fade visual prompts. MOTHER testified that she was uncertain what proportion of STUDENT’s day would be spent in DTT. MOTHER was critical of the way DTT is administered at the school. She testified that DTT is done in two small four-by-seven-foot cubicles. MOTHER testified that the instructional assistants administering DTT do not use interesting materials or provide motivating reinforcers to the students, the walls of the cubicles are barren, and the staff does not cuddle or show enthusiasm toward the students when they respond appropriately. MOTHER additionally testified that the pace of the lessons is slow and the lessons are not interspersed with “fun” activities. MOTHER expressed concern regarding the length of time (eight hours) that STUDENT would have to be away from home, when the time spent on bus transportation is taken into consideration, for her to receive only four hours of DTT.

MOTHER also asserted that the class does not have appropriate peers for STUDENT. In fall, the class consisted of all boys, one of whom was nine-years old, whereas STUDENT was a very petite three-year-old female. MOTHER stated that some children were engaging in self-stimulatory behavior and having temper tantrums. She expressed concern that STUDENT would follow their inappropriate behavior. One student was physically “motored” through the activity by the teacher while the student continued to engage in a tantrum. MOTHER testified that she did not observe appropriate play areas for the students. She also did not observe students engaged in age-appropriate play. Finally, MOTHER testified that STUDENT cannot yet benefit from instruction in a group setting because of her limited attention span and the number of distractions a group presents for STUDENT.

Kelli Wilms, speech and language pathologist, also testified that the proposed placement was not appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Wilms maintains a private practice and is also employed by Children’s Hospital. She has received specific training in autism, which is the emphasis of her private practice. Ms. Wilms assessed STUDENT in October 1997 and has provided her with weekly speech and language therapy since November 1997. She testified that STUDENT would not benefit from a placement that consists entirely of participation in a classroom because of the difficulty maintaining STUDENT’s focus. A classroom placement would also not allow for the same level of parental participation in STUDENT’s education as is allowed for by her current program. Ms. Wilms testified that a PECS is not appropriate for STUDENT and would be a step backwards at this time because STUDENT is learning to speak and needs to practice oral language. Ms. Wilms testified that STUDENT’s speech production is increasing daily. Ms. Wilms testified that continuing therapy with STUDENT is important to her continued growth. Ms. Wilms testified that TEACCH provides some organizational strategies that may be useful; however, TEACCH is not an appropriate approach for STUDENT because it was developed for vocational training with older children.

Dr. McEachin testified that young children with autism, including STUDENT, need an intensive program in which progress is recorded on a daily basis so that informed judgments can be made to adjust the program and to determine if the child is making progress. Dr. McEachin testified that STUDENT requires a program of 35 to 40 hours per week to be able to accomplish her objectives and to reach the long-term goal of attending elementary school without the need for intensive services. Dr. McEachin testified that an appropriate program for STUDENT includes one-to-one DTT, appropriate supervision, one to two hours of consultation with a psychologist, and speech and language therapy. Dr. McEachin testified that consideration has been given to implementing a PECS with STUDENT because picture icons offer a “nice” way to prompt her for further communication; however, he stated that a PECS should not be a substitute for STUDENT’s learning to use speech. Dr. McEachin recommended that STUDENT be allowed to continue in her home program because home is the most natural environment for a child of STUDENT’s age. (STUDENT turned three-years-old in September 1997.) Dr. McEachin testified that the home program also allows for maximum parental involvement and provides the most opportunities for the student to generalize skills.

Dr. McEachin observed the Bloomington program in January and during the first week of February 1998 and testified that it does not currently offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Dr. McEachin testified that the problem with TEACCH and other components of the Respondents’ program is the lack of intensity and the need to physically structure the environment rather than allowing the child to function in the more natural home environment.

Ms. Saunby initially visited the Bloomington class with MOTHER in the fall of 1997. Based on her observation, Ms. Saunby concluded that the class would not be appropriate for STUDENT for the following reasons: the class was chaotic and noisy; the pervasive attitude in the classroom was not as positive as STUDENT has been used to; the area used for DTT was small and confined; few opportunities for generalization of skills were available; and little was done to promote the development of language skills. Pursuant to an NPA contract between the COE and Autism Partnership, Ms. Saunby has provided consultation services to the staff of the Bloomington since November 1997. Her responsibilities include visiting the class two times a month to address the behavioral program for three children in the class. Ms. Saunby also revises the DTT curriculum for some of the students and trains the staff.(Footnote 3) Ms. Saunby testified that when she began working with the Bloomington class, the students were working on a very basic behavioral program and some students were working on skills that were not at their current level of functioning. Ms. Saunby testified that students were stagnant and the staff did not appear comfortable or possess knowledge of how to move the program along so that the students would be introduced to new skills. Ms. Saunby testified that the school staff also did not know how to make the drills fun and reinforcing for the students. They also do not provide sufficient opportunities during the school day for the students to practice the skills they had learned during drills to new environments or activities. Based on her observations during a visit on January 6, 1998, Ms. Saunby testified that the class continues to be chaotic and noisy. She also observed that students engage in inappropriate behaviors and expressed the concern that STUDENT would imitate their behavior.

Ms. Saunby concluded, as she had been following her visit to Bloomington in the fall, that STUDENT’s behavioral therapy could not be implemented in the Bloomington class for the following reasons: STUDENT’s program is individually designed and takes place in a number of environments; STUDENT’s attending skills are very poor and it would be difficult for her to attend in class; and STUDENT requires a quickly paced program to sustain her attention and to diminish self-stimulatory behaviors. Ms. Saunby testified that there is a lack of coordination between home and school for those students attending Bloomington. Ms. Saunby also noted that at school, data are collected after every trial, whereas the home program collects data after every drill. Ms. Saunby also found that the class does not have an appropriate peer group for STUDENT. All of the students have autism or developmental disabilities and have behaviors that STUDENT may imitate. Ms. Saunby testified that STUDENT has good imitative skills. As an example, Ms. Saunby related that STUDENT cried while watching herself crying in a video. Ms. Saunby testified that it would not be appropriate to put STUDENT on a picture schedule. The parents and therapists are trying to diminish STUDENT’s autistic characteristics and to teach her to be spontaneous. They also want her to develop skills to deal with transitions. Ms. Saunby recommended that STUDENT be allowed to continue with the current services she receives and that the current intensity, structure, and supervision of the program be maintained. Taking into consideration all of the testimony as discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program offered to STUDENT by Respondents in September 1997 was not designed to meet her unique and individual needs. It is undisputed that STUDENT has significant expressive language deficits and apraxia. STUDENT’s parents contend that an appropriate program for STUDENT must include direct and consultative speech and language therapy to address these needs. MOTHER testified that she requested speech and language services at the IEP meeting and reiterated her request in a letter of dissent to the IEP. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 14.) STUDENT’s need for speech and language therapy is supported by the testimony of Ms. Wilms and Dr. McEachin. Ms. Wilms is a speech and language therapist who is familiar with STUDENT’s speech and language needs because she has been working directly with her. Respondents did not call a speech and language therapist to challenge Ms. Wilms’ conclusion that STUDENT requires speech and language therapy. STUDENT’s need for speech and language therapy is also supported by Stephen Ashwal, M.D., a pediatric neurologist at Loma Linda University. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 8.)

Respondents contend that STUDENT’s speech and language needs can be met in the Bloomington class. The testimony by Respondents’ witnesses regarding the way in which speech and language needs are addressed was limited to a general description of PECS. The parents dispute the appropriateness of using a PECS with STUDENT. Ms. Wilms, who provides speech and language therapy to STUDENT, testified that PECS is not currently an appropriate methodology to employ with STUDENT because she has shown the ability to develop speech. MOTHER also does not want STUDENT to rely on a PECS when she is currently increasing her expressive language vocabulary. Dr. McEachin testified that a limited PECS may be useful for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer gives more weight to Ms. Wilms’ testimony on this the appropriateness of a PECS for STUDENT because she is a licensed speech and language pathologist, whereas Dr. McEachin is not. There was no additional evidence of a language program offered in the Bloomington class that would address STUDENT’s needs. There was evidence of regular consultation between the Bloomington teachers and a speech and language pathologist. The classroom staff does not include on its team a speech and language therapist. There was no evidence that the classroom teacher or any of the support staff possesses knowledge of appropriate ways in which to address STUDENT’s needs related to apraxia. Based on the testimony of Ms. Wilms, Ms. Saunby, and Dr. McEachin, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents’ classroom program does not adequately address STUDENT’s significant speech and language needs and that she requires direct speech and language therapy to address her needs.

Respondents argued that they are not required to provide STUDENT with speech and language therapy because at the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents clearly voiced their preference to continue with private speech and language therapy. Even if it were true that the parents prefer to continue independent speech and language therapy, the Respondents are not relieved of their obligation to offer all of the services STUDENT requires. Because the Respondents’ program is not designed to adequately address STUDENT’s speech and language needs and because they did not offer her direct therapy, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents’ program is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual speech and language needs.

All of the persons who have worked with STUDENT testified that her attentional problems preclude her from benefiting from a group instructional setting at this time. Two of these witnesses, Dr. McEachin and Ms. Saunby, provide services to STUDENT and also are under contract to provide services to Respondents. They also provide services to the program the Respondents have proposed for STUDENT. Therefore, Dr. McEachin and Ms. Saunby have a great deal of familiarity with STUDENT’s needs, as well as with the educational program proposed for her. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer gives substantial weight to their testimony and concludes that STUDENT’s attentional difficulties in the fall of 1997 and at the date the hearing concluded would not have allowed her to benefit from instruction in a group setting such as the one offered by the Respondents. Of concern are the distractions caused by the movement of children from one activity to another and the number of varying activities occurring in the classroom throughout the school day.

Dr. McEachin and Ms. Wilms both testified that the involvement of STUDENT’s parents is an important component of her program. The Hearing Officer notes that many of STUDENT’s goals and objectives are related to activities that occur in the home environment, including eating, dressing, and toileting. California Special Education law acknowledges the importance of parental involvement and calls for parental involvement in the educational program of preschool-aged children with disabilities that is above and beyond participation in the IEP process. Ms. Saunby testified that when she was working in the classroom, parents were discouraged from discussing their child’s DTT program with her. The testimony also establishes that when an in-home program is initiated with the Regional Center, the home and school components are not the same. The Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Respondents’ witnesses did not establish that their program meets STUDENT’s needs for parental involvement and also does not satisfy the requirement for active parental participation set forth in Education Code § 56441.2.

Based on the above discussion, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program offered by Respondents in September 1997 was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Moreover, when the program was proposed for STUDENT, it was not actually available to her. Respondents’ witnesses testified that the class had an established maximum of seven students and that the class already had seven students. Respondents indicated that, had STUDENT’s parents elected to place STUDENT in the class, another student would have been transferred out of the class. This does not alter the fact that the class was full and unavailable as a placement for STUDENT when it was offered as such in the September 1997. Respondents’ witnesses testified that it would have taken a minimum of two weeks to transition the student out of the class; however, there was no evidence that another placement was available for the student at that time, there was no agreed-upon date that the student was going to transition from the class, and there was no guarantee that the student’s parent would not have changed his/her mind about the move before it actually occurred.(Footnote 4) The evidence establishes that the earliest date the class potentially had an opening for STUDENT was at the first of February, when the class was divided into two classes and another teacher hired. The Hearing Officer finds that an offer that is unavailable when it is made and hypothetically may be available at some unspecified date in the future does not constitute a valid offer. Even if the classroom became available within a reasonable time after the offer, it has been concluded above that the program offered by Respondents was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Because one of the components of an appropriate placement has not been satisfied, and because a valid offer was not made, it is unnecessary to address the other requirements of Rowley. The Hearing Officer concludes that the Respondents did not offer STUDENT an appropriate placement during the 1996-1997 school year.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s IEP indicates that she is entitled to extended school year services (ESY). The Respondent’s program continues during the summer and is relatively similar to the program provided during the regular school year. There is no significant evidence that Respondent’s ESY is appropriate for STUDENT.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent educational services they have provided for STUDENT?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the private placement or services are determined to be appropriate under IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.

It has been determined above that Respondents did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the costs of the program they have provided for her. To determine whether the program is appropriate for STUDENT, it must be determined whether the program is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, provides her with some educational benefit, and comports with her IEP.

STUDENT’s current program is approximately 40 hours per week of one-to-one behavioral intervention services provided in her home. This includes speech and language therapy provided by Ms. Wilms, a licensed speech and language pathologist. Ms. Wilms testified that she works with STUDENT’s therapy team on the goal of improving STUDENT’s expressive language skills. To that end, Ms. Wilms has been working with STUDENT to develop joint attention and turn-taking skills and has developed play scripts to enhance social language. Ms. Wilms also addresses STUDENT’s receptive language and is working on following two-step directions and identifying basic concepts and semantic relationships. STUDENT also participates in play dates and attends a gymboree and church classes weekly to enhance socialization and other skills. The program is coordinated and supervised by Autism Partnership, a certified nonpublic agency. Ms. Saunby provides six hours weekly of supervision. Her responsibilities are to provide training and feedback to the therapists, to work with the therapists and the parents, to monitor and adjust the curriculum and workbook on a weekly basis, to observe the program as it is being implemented, and to consult with any other persons involved in STUDENT’s treatment. She also writes progress reports and arranges for weekly clinic meetings. Dr. McEachin is the program director and clinical supervisor and supervises weekly team meetings of approximately one hour each.

Dr. McEachin testified that the program provided by Autism Partnership is based on research of the intervention model employed by Dr. Ivar Lovaas at the University of California, Los Angeles. The research supported that young children with autism achieved better when they were provided an in-home, intensive behavioral intervention program with parental involvement in the delivery of the program. Dr. McEachin testified that the program currently implemented by Autism Partnership has refined the original program model, and noted that one important change is the elimination of the use of aversives. One of the District’s witnesses, Dr. Gresham, disputed the validity of Dr. Lovaas’ findings. Dr. Gresham recently published a review of Dr. Lovaas’ original and follow-up studies related to the intensive treatment of persons with autism. Dr. Gresham testified that Dr. Lovaas’ study has neither internal nor external validity. As to the lack of internal validity, Dr. Gresham testified that the failure to randomly assign subjects to a group affects the extent to which conclusion can be draw regarding the responsibility of the treatment for the outcome. Regarding the external validity of the study, Dr. Gresham testified that the fact that the treatment program was delivered by trained and skilled graduate students affects the extent to which the results can be generalized and replicated. Dr. Gresham also stated that the Lovaas studies used contingent aversives and it is unlikely that the treatment would be as effective without the use of aversives because the behaviors of the child would interfere with learning. Dr. Gresham concluded that because of the problems with the original study, it is only hypothetical that similar results can be obtained by the use of the program. Dr. Gresham has neither met nor observed STUDENT or observed her in-home program. Therefore, his opinion regarding the efficacy of an in-home program is based on general information regarding in-home programs and not specifically on STUDENT’s needs or on the program she receives. It is also noted that the primary objection Dr. Gresham expressed related to STUDENT’s in-home program is the use of a DTT methodology that is based on a flawed study by Dr. Lovaas. It would appear that Dr. Gresham’s criticism must similarly apply to the program provided by Respondents, since Respondents’ program incorporates a similar methodology. Because Dr. Gresham’s testimony was general in nature rather than specifically regarding STUDENT’s in-home program, his testimony has minimal relevance to the issue of whether the program STUDENT receives is appropriate for meeting her unique and individual needs.

Turning to whether STUDENT’s in-home program is designed to meet her unique and individual needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Ms. Wilms establishes that STUDENT’s program, that includes speech and language therapy and consultation with the persons delivering the program, addresses her greatest area of need, namely expressive language. Ms. Saunby, MOTHER, and Ms. Wilms described the activities in which STUDENT is engaged. Their testimony, progress reports, and treatment logs establish that the program addresses the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP and provides her with daily activities to address language, self-help, cognitive, and behavioral deficits. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.) Her social skills are addressed by play dates and participation in gym and church classes with other three-year-old children. As for fostering generalization skills, MOTHER testified that the entire home environment and the community are used to provide STUDENT with opportunities to generalize what she has learned during therapy sessions. For example, MOTHER stated that while reading a story to STUDENT, she will ask her questions such as “what color is that?” to reinforce color concepts that she has been working on. The testimony of Ms. Saunby establishes that STUDENT’s program is modified and changed as appropriate, based on her progress as recorded by the trainers and reviewed by Ms. Saunby. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s in-home program is designed to meet her unique and individual needs.

STUDENT’s ability to benefit from the in-home program is documented by the progress that she has made since beginning the program. Ms. Saunby described STUDENT’s progress as “amazing.” She stated that at the beginning of the program, STUDENT could not imitate block design, whereas she currently makes designs from memory. STUDENT went from not being able to make nonverbal imitations to working on smiling, frowning, and other more socially appropriate skills. STUDENT was unable to match and not is working on sorting by categories. STUDENT receptively understands two-step directions. Ms. Saunby also described STUDENT’s growth in play skills and school skills, such as attending and sitting. Ms. Wilms testified that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills have increased. She is able to understand at the 24-month level and follow two-step unrelated commands. STUDENT’s expressive vocabulary of a few isolated words has grown to approximately 30 words, which she uses spontaneously and with increased frequency. STUDENT now imitates words, whereas initially she was nonverbal. Ms. Wilms also described STUDENT’s improved eye contact. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibit 27.)

In addition to the persons involved in providing STUDENT’s current program and her parents, several other professionals have recommended that she continue with the in-home program because of their observation of the progress STUDENT has made since beginning the in-home program. Nan Neighbors, speech and language pathologist, Loma Linda University, provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy in 1996 and 1997. Ms. Neighbors wrote that “I recognize the design of this intensive early intervention program to be excellent. It provides a structural approach to learning that is developmental, repetitive, and addresses reinforcement of learning in a supportive and consistent, manner. It is appropriately designed around language as the basis of learning.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 12.) Carlos Fayard, Ph.D., consulting psychologist and assistant professor of psychiatry at Loma Linda University, and Dr. Ashwal, pediatric neurologist at Loma Linda, both recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in her in-home program. In July and August 1997, and again in January 1998, Dr. Fayard assessed STUDENT. Dr. Fayard noted that STUDENT had made “significant” gains since the prior assessment. All but one area--expressive communication-- on Dr. Fayard’s readministration of the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS), STUDENT showed growth since beginning the in-home program. Dr. Fayard particularly noted that STUDENT made significant progress in the areas of imitation, receptive language, nonverbal language, and use of verbal approximations to communicate. Dr. Fayard recommended continuation of STUDENT’s in-home program. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 28.) Dr. Ashwal noted improvements in eye contact, social integration, and language development when he re-evaluated STUDENT in November 1997. He recommended that STUDENT be allowed to continue her in-home program. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 21.) The evidence as discussed above, which is based on observations, on-going collection of data, and a checklist, all point to the conclusion that STUDENT’s in-home program is designed to provide her with educational benefit and that she is, in fact, benefiting from her current program. The testimony also establishes that the IEP goals and objectives can be and are being implemented in the in-home program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the in-home program as described at the beginning of the section, offers STUDENT an appropriate placement. Because Respondents did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the parents are entitled to reimbursement from the Respondents for the program they have been providing for her. Those costs include the actual costs of treatment sessions, including the one-to-one therapists, Ms. Saunby’s supervision, Dr. McEachin’s consultation, Ms. Wilms’ speech and language therapy, weekly group meetings, and reasonable start-up supplies as testified to by MOTHER and set out in Petitioner’s Exhibit 29. STUDENT is entitled to ESY pursuant to her IEP. Therefore, the Respondents are responsible for funding her in-home program for the ESY for the same duration of ESY available to Bloomington students.

ISSUE NO. 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent speech and language assessment by Kelli Wilms?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b). Special education students must be assessed every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant or if the parent requests an assessment. Education Code § 56381. For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320. Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. In this case, STUDENT was assessed by the COE in July 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 10 and 13.) The COE’s assessment was completed when STUDENT was less than three years old and it is noted in the text of the report that test data should be considered estimates and not accurate reflections of STUDENT’s true potential. The assessment team did not include a speech and language pathologist and no formal speech and language assessment was conducted. Conclusions regarding STUDENT’s speech and language were based on the observation of a school psychologist and school nurse, and on behavioral rating scales. The fact that STUDENT’s speech and language skills are delayed is well-documented; however, there was no formal measure of STUDENT’s specific language skills. For example, there was no documentation in the COE’s report of the number of words or the type of words that STUDENT understands or says. At the IEP, STUDENT’s parents requested a speech and language assessment. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 14.) Respondents did not thereafter undertake a speech and language assessment. Because there was no specific information regarding STUDENT’s speech and language skills and no formal assessment had been undertaken, the Hearing Officer concludes that a speech and language assessment was warranted at the time the parents so requested. Based on Respondents’ failure to conduct such an assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the speech and language assessment they procured in October 1997 from Ms. Wilms, a licensed speech and language pathologist. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 20.)

ORDER

(1) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, Respondents shall reimburse the PARENTS for the costs of STUDENT’s in-home program for the 1997-1998 school year. The costs are subject to proof and shall include the actual costs incurred by the PARENTS for therapy, including the one-to-one therapists, consultation and supervision provided by Autism Partnership, speech and language therapy provided by Ms. Wilms, and start-up costs set forth in Petitioner’s Exhibit 29.

(2) The Respondents shall continue to fund the costs of STUDENT’s in-home program from the remainder of the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program.

(3) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the Respondents shall reimburse the PARENTS for the costs of Ms. Wilms’ independent assessment.

(4) Within 25 calendar days of the date of this decision and pursuant to their agreement at the beginning of the hearing, Respondents shall conduct occupational therapy and adaptive physical education assessments of STUDENT.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: June 1, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1) The parents also raised as an issue whether Respondents are required to conduct occupational therapy (OT) and adaptive physical education (APE) assessments. At the beginning of the hearing, Respondents agreed to undertake OT and APE assessments. Therefore, issues relating to the need for OT and APE assessments are not addressed in this decision; however, the Hearing Officer notes that there was no indication that the parents had been provided an assessment plan or that the assessments had been undertaken. To the extent that this remains the case, the Hearing Officer will include an order that the District complete the assessments in accordance with their agreement at the commencement of the hearing.

2) The District does not provide services to special education students under the age of five years. All services for students between the ages of three and five years are provided by the COE.

3) At the time of her testimony in February 1998, Ms. Saunby had taken a leave of absence from her work with the District due to illness.

4) Had that student’s parent objected to the proposed change in placement and requested a due process hearing, the student would have been entitled to remain in the Bloomington class pending resolution of due process proceedings pursuant to stay put. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); California Education Code § 56505(d).)

5) Although the Respondents appear to be developing a viable program for young children with autism, the Hearing Officer concluded above that it does not constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year.