California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 1998

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1258-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

San Diego Unified must fund Dr. Jennifer Oke's behavioral therapy for a 3-year-old with autism; parents' requests for more speech and OT denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 4 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. Footnote 1 notes that the Regional Center had continued funding Dr. Oke's services under an informal stay-put agreement.

Summary

Parents of a 3-year-old boy with autism and apraxia filed against San Diego Unified School District. Their son attended a District preschool special day class with a shadow aide. They argued he needed much more speech and occupational therapy (OT), and that the District should fund the behavioral therapy he was already receiving from private psychologist Jennifer Oke, Ph.D. The District had the burden of proof.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the District's speech services were appropriate under the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard. These were two 45-minute individual sessions a week, plus classroom support and collaboration with the teacher. One hour a week of individual OT was also appropriate. She relied on the student's current teacher and therapists, who reported progress. She ordered the IEP revised to describe these services more precisely.

The District lost on behavioral services. Its IEP offered only "12 to 15 hours of autism services." That was not a clear written offer under Union School District v. Smith, and a later letter did not cure it. The Hearing Officer also found the proposed program unsuitable: rotating paraprofessionals, no transition plan, and an unreliable aide history. She found Dr. Oke's work critical to the child's ability to attend and learn. The District must contract with Dr. Oke for 12 hours a week through the 1997-98 school year, including extended school year (ESY). It must also reimburse transportation to her sessions from the child's third birthday on, but not to private speech or OT.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to a vague offer of "autism services." It also shows how evidence about a young child's difficulty with transitions, and the lack of a transition plan, supported keeping an established private provider. Requests for more related services still had to meet the Rowley benefit standard.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(A). To receive a FAPE, does Student require one hour daily for four days per week of speech and language therapy with at least one half of the therapy provided one-to-one?

    The District's two 45-minute individual speech sessions per week, plus classroom support and collaboration with the teacher, met Student's needs and provided benefit under Rowley; the IEP must be revised to reflect this level of service and the PECS duties.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(B). To receive a FAPE, does Student require forty-five minutes daily for four days per week of occupational therapy with at least two hours of the therapy provided one-to-one?

    One hour per week of individual OT, plus classroom support and consultation, was appropriate; no occupational therapist recommended the level the parents sought. The IEP must be revised to state that sessions are individual.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(C). To receive a FAPE, does Student require behavioral intervention therapy provided by Jennifer Oke, Ph.D.?

    An IEP offer of '12 to 15 hours of autism services,' even with the October 1 letter, was not a clear written offer under Union v. Smith. The proposed services from rotating paraprofessionals, with no transition plan, were not appropriate. Dr. Oke's services were necessary for Student to benefit, so the District must fund them.

  4. Issue 2. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of transportation to speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral intervention therapy?

    The parents get transportation costs to Dr. Oke's sessions from Student's third birthday on. There is no reimbursement for transportation to private speech or OT, or for any services before age three, when the Hearing Office lacked jurisdiction.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to revise the IEP as ordered.
  • Order to provide or change services. Speech and language: individual 45-minute sessions two times per week; small-group and other classroom support two days per week; weekly consultation with the teacher; and speech pathologist support coordinating, developing, maintaining and supervising use of PECS with classroom staff, the autism specialist and the parents.
  • Order to provide or change services. OT: individual 30-minute sessions two times per week; classroom support from the occupational therapist two days per week; weekly consultation with the classroom teacher.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. IEP to provide 12 hours per week of autism services from Jennifer Oke, Ph.D. From the date of the decision, the District assumes responsibility for Dr. Oke's services and, as soon as practicable, must contract with her for the rest of the 1997-1998 school year, including ESY.
  • Reimbursement. Within 15 days of receiving proof from the parents, reimburse transportation costs to Student's sessions with Dr. Oke from his third birthday on, at the District's standard reimbursement rate (amount not stated).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Union School District v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Education Code § 56363; Education Code § 56441.2

People named in the decision

  • Sheila Weinberg, program manager for due process, San Diego Unified School District
  • Jennifer Oke, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, private behavioral therapist (nonpublic agency); witness for Student, Private practice
  • John Fontanesi, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; witness for Student, Center for School Problems, Kaiser Permanente San Diego
  • Angela Kilman, Ph.D., psychologist who assessed Student for the Regional Center, Regional Center
  • Prem Bhola, infant program teacher, San Diego Unified School District, Alcott Infant Program
  • Joseph Marsella, preschool special day class teacher, San Diego Unified School District, Dingeman School
  • Lynn Kirsch, private speech-language pathologist, Regional Center-funded provider
  • Barbara Shelosky, speech-language pathologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Anda A. Imhoff, speech-language pathologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Rachelle Rosin, occupational therapist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Concepcion Davila-Kurth, occupational therapist (OTR), report author, Kaiser Permanente Medical Group
  • Mary J. Kawar, private occupational therapist (OTR), Regional Center-funded provider
  • Beth Hannaman, preschool teacher and case manager, San Diego Unified School District
  • Mary Sue Glynn, SEEC program manager, San Diego Unified School District
  • Mary Lou Evans, SEEC itinerant teacher for students with autism (autism specialist), San Diego Unified School District
  • Siri Martin, autism services 'professional expert' (paraprofessional), San Diego Unified School District
  • Karla Wares, autism services 'professional expert' (paraprofessional), San Diego Unified School District
  • Dr. Dores, Ph.D., psychologist, District consultant; expert witness for District, Private practice; contracted with District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on December 4 and 5, 1997, and January 6 and 7, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathleen Murphy Mallinger. Attorney William Hook was present for a portion of the hearing to assist Ms. Mallinger. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents. Respondent San Diego Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by District deputy general counsel, Ricardo Soto. Also present on behalf of the District was Sheila Weinberg, program manager for due process.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on January 23, 1998, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require:

(A) one hour daily for four days per week of speech and language therapy with at least one half of the therapy provided one-to-one?

(B) forty-five minutes daily for four days per week of occupational therapy with at least two hours of the therapy provided one-to-one?

(C) behavioral intervention therapy provided by Jennifer Oke, Ph.D.?

(2) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of transportation to speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral intervention therapy?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT turned three years old on October 3, 1997. He is eligible for special education because of a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT has also been diagnosed with apraxia, which impacts motor planning and his ability to form words. STUDENT is described as “high-functioning, strong-willed, and motivated to learn.” STUDENT currently is enrolled four days per week in a District special education early childhood (SEEC) special day class (SDC). STUDENT is entitled to extended school year services (ESY). The District provides STUDENT with two sessions of occupational therapy (OT) for a total of one hour per week, and two sessions of speech and language therapy for a total of one and one-half hour per week. The appropriate level of speech and language therapy and OT is in dispute. The District also provides STUDENT with adaptive physical education (APE) and a shadow aide to assist him in the classroom. STUDENT’s individualized educational program (IEP) also calls for 12 to 15 hours of “autism services.” STUDENT’s parents have not consented to implementation of these services. Instead, STUDENT receives individual behavioral therapy from Jennifer Oke, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist in private practice.(Footnote 1)

STUDENT’s parents became concerned about his communication and socialization skills when STUDENT was approximately two years old. He was seen by John Fontanesi, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist and director of the Center for School Problems at Kaiser Permanente, San Diego. Dr. Fontanesi confirmed the parents’ concerns regarding STUDENT’s delayed language and social skills; however, he did not make any diagnosis at that time. Dr. Fontanesi referred STUDENT for neurophysiological and neuroimaging assessments. STUDENT was also referred to the Regional Center for an assessment and to determine whether he would qualify for services. In April 1997, Angela Kilman, Ph.D., performed a psychological assessment of STUDENT for the Regional Center. Dr. Kilman gave STUDENT the initial diagnosis of autism. (Petitioner’s Exhibits C and F.)

On March 5, 1997, an individualized family service plan (IFSP) was developed for STUDENT by the District and the Regional Center. Thereafter, STUDENT attended the District’s Alcott Infant Program two half days per week. The program also included two home visits per month by the teacher, Prem Bhola. (Respondent’s Exhibits 8 to 11.) On April 19, 1997, STUDENT’s parents arranged for him to receive four hours per week of individual behavioral therapy from Dr. Oke.

In May 1997, the Regional Center began funding services for STUDENT, including one hour per week of speech and language therapy and 10 hours per week of Dr. Oke’s services. Dr. Oke has continued to provide STUDENT with approximately eight hours of individual behavioral therapy at her office and to provide two hours of consultation and coordination to STUDENT’s parents and other service providers at his home. Dr. Oke employs the following techniques with STUDENT: pivotal response training (PRT), picture exchange communication system (PECS), and floor play. In July, STUDENT’s speech and language therapy was increased to two hours per week, and the Regional Center also began funding one hour per week of OT.

The District assessed STUDENT in July 1997 in the areas of preacademic skills; social, emotional, and adaptive behavior; motor and perceptual development; communication; intellectual development; and health. The assessment of STUDENT’s motor and perceptual skills included OT, APE, and physical therapy (PT) evaluations. The report of the District’s assessment includes the following recommendations: placement in a structured environment; a predictable routine both at home and school; a sensory organization program at school and at home with direct OT intervention once weekly; APE to develop group and play skills, attending to and following directions, safety awareness, locomotor, and ball skills; and intervention to improve language and communication skills. PT was not recommended. (Respondent’s Exhibits 13 to 18.)

On July 18, 1997, the IEP team convened to draft goals and objectives, to make recommendations for services and placement, and to develop a transition plan in anticipation of STUDENT’s entering the District’s SEEC program in the fall of 1997. The SEEC program offers services to children when they turn three years old. In STUDENT’s case, since his third birthday fell in October, it was concluded that he would enter the program when the school year began in September 1997. At the IEP meeting, the parents presented goals and objectives they had developed in consultation with Dr. Oke. The IEP team met for some three to four hours. Following the IEP meeting, the completed draft of goals and objectives was transcribed onto the IEP form. The IEP includes 11 pages of goals and objectives. The goals are to develop interactive turn taking skills; to develop imitation skills; to increase comprehension skills; to develop use of spoken words; to improve sensory organization, anti-gravity, bilateral, and upper extremity skills; to improve motor planning, upper and low extremity strengthening, and movement organizational abilities; to improve compliance to classroom directions; to increase attending to preacademic tasks; to begin to play with peers; to listen to a story; to use social greetings; to increase his preferred play activities; to engage in appropriate activities; to engage with a peer; to respond to his name; to increase attending to manipulative tasks; to increase self-care skills--eating, toileting and dressing; and to improve gross-motor skills. (Petitioner’s Exhibit J.)

On July 21, 1997, Ms. Bhola delivered the IEP document to the PARENTS’ home. After reviewing the completed IEP, the PARENTS concluded that the IEP was not appropriate and requested a second IEP meeting. The District responded by telling the parents that the appropriate recourse was to file for a due process hearing. (Testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Glynn; Petitioner’s Exhibits T and U.) STUDENT’s parents consented to implementation of portions of the IEP, including placement in a District SDC and APE services. They did not consent to speech and language therapy or OT. The Regional Center continued to fund these services for STUDENT through December 1997.

In September 1997, STUDENT entered the SDC at Dingeman School. The SDC is taught by Joseph Marsella. Mr. Marsella has eight years of teaching experience; however, this is the first year he has taught a preschool SDC. Mr. Marsella was familiar with STUDENT because STUDENT’s parents had arranged for Mr. Marsella to provide them with respite services during the summer of 1997.

There are nine students in Mr. Marsella’s SDC. Four of the students, including STUDENT, are diagnosed with autism, one student is visually impaired, one has speech and language delays, one has cerebral palsy, and two are developmentally delayed. Mr. Marsella is assisted in the classroom by two special education technicians (SET). Some students have shadow aides, as well. The speech and language and occupational therapists are available in the classroom two days per week to work with the students and to consult with the teacher.

In a letter dated October 1, 1997, the District supplemented its original offer of services and placement. The District’s letter, Petitioner’s Exhibit X, describes the individual services it was offering and reiterates its offer to provide an extra paraprofessional (commonly referred to by the District as a “shadow aide”) in the classroom. The letter states that the shadow aide will:

(1) provide STUDENT with individual attention to keep him focused and engaged in classroom activities; (2) implement the Picture Exchange communication System (PECS) with the speech therapist and other staff throughout the day; and (3) daily carry out the sensory program and vestibular activities as written and directed by the occupational therapist.

The District also offered to increase STUDENT’s speech and language therapy to one and one-half hours per week, with the speech and language pathologist having responsibility for coordination, development, maintenance, and supervision of the use of PECS with the classroom staff, the autism specialist, and the parents. (Petitioner’s Exhibit X.)

In a letter dated October 3, 1997, the parents agreed to the District’s offer of a shadow aide in the classroom, to one and one-half hour of speech and language therapy per week, and to OT at the level set forth in the IEP, pending resolution of due process proceedings. They did not concede to the appropriateness of the services offered by the District. The parents also continued to assert that STUDENT’s behavioral intervention services must be provided by Dr. Oke and rejected the District’s offer of “autism services.”

On October 3, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for hearing from Ms. Mallinger on behalf of STUDENT. The parents contend that the levels of speech and language and OT provided by the District do not meet STUDENT’s needs. They also assert that STUDENT should continue behavioral intervention therapy with Dr. Oke. The District contends that it has offered an appropriate placement and services for STUDENT. The District asserts that because its personnel are qualified to provide autism services to STUDENT, it is not required to fund the services STUDENT receives from Dr. Oke.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education.(Footnote 2) Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(A)-(D), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are provided at public expense, meet the standards of the State educational agency, and conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

“Related services” include transportation, psychological services, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and other services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be available when necessary for the student to “benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Section 56363(a) further provides that instruction and services “shall be provided by the regular class teacher, the special class teacher, or the resource specialist if the teacher or specialist is competent to provide such instruction and services and the provision of such instruction and services by the teacher or specialist is feasible. If not, the appropriate designated instruction and services specialist shall provide such instruction and services.”

California special education law additionally provides that for students between the ages of three and five years, special education shall include “specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. [Emphasis added.] To meet this purpose, the program focus is on the young child and his or her family and shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement.” Education Code § 56441.2.

ISSUE NO. 1(A): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require one hour daily for four days per week of speech and language therapy with at least one half of the therapy provided one-to-one?

STUDENT’s parents contend that to benefit from his education, STUDENT requires one hour daily of speech and language therapy for four days per week with at least one-half of the therapy provided one-to-one. The District contends that the two sessions of speech and language therapy, totaling one and one-half hours per week, that it currently provides to STUDENT are appropriate. Under the District’s proposal, the speech and language pathologist additionally is responsible to “coordinate, develop, maintain and supervise use of the PECS with the classroom staff, the autism specialist and parents.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit X)

Lynn Kirsch, who provided STUDENT’s speech and language therapy through the Regional Center from May through August 1997, described STUDENT’s communication disorder as “severe.” She testified that he has oral apraxia, which means that his brain has difficulty telling his muscles how to move. Dr. Kirsch testified that STUDENT also has a phonological disorder, which means that he has difficulty with speech production even though he is able to make sounds in isolation. Ms. Kirsch testified that in STUDENT’s favor is the fact that he has the desire to communicate.

Ms. Kirsch stated that STUDENT’s significant improvement in behavior management, attending, and participating in activities allows STUDENT to make greater gains in individual therapy than when she initially worked with him. For this reason, Ms. Kirsch had recommended increasing STUDENT’s therapy. She also stated that increased individual therapy is important because STUDENT is at a critical developmental period. In August, when Ms. Kirsch last saw STUDENT, her recommendation was for two, one hour sessions of individual therapy per week, plus approximately two hours per week of group therapy with a few peers who have good language skills. She made the same recommendation during testimony at the hearing. Ms. Kirsch stated that the purpose of group therapy is to provide opportunities for STUDENT to practice skills he has learned during individual therapy. Ms. Kirsch testified that a decrease in STUDENT’s speech and language therapy was not warranted even though his time in school has increased. She also recommended that sessions be provided by a speech and language pathologist.

Dr. Oke also testified that because STUDENT’s ability to attend has improved, he is now able to benefit from more intensive speech and language therapy. In her opinion, STUDENT should receive at least one hour of individual speech therapy on a daily basis at school because expressive language is his greatest area of need. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibit P.)

Barbara Shelosky, District speech and language pathologist, provides consultative and collaborative speech and language services to infants in the Alcott program. Ms. Shelosky testified that because of apraxia, STUDENT requires individual therapy that provides intensive repetition and practice to improve speech production. He also requires small-group therapy to provide him with opportunities to generalize skills he has learned in one-to-one sessions. Ms. Shelosky testified that STUDENT’s speech and language therapist should determine what portion of the therapy is spent individually with STUDENT and what portion is spent in consultation with the classroom teacher. Ms. Shelosky concluded that one hour of services per week is sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs because he is participating in an integrated preschool program in which the service providers collaborate with each other, with the teacher, and with the parents.

Anda A. Imhoff, STUDENT’s current speech and language pathologist at the District, testified that Mr. Marsella does an excellent job of integrating speech and language into the classroom. Ms. Imhoff testified that the current level of services STUDENT is receiving meets his needs. She stated that it would be difficult to provide STUDENT with more individual time on drills, given his current functional and attentional level. In her opinion, STUDENT also needs to be in an environment, such as the classroom, where he can use his developing language skills.

Mr. Marsella, STUDENT’s teacher, testified that he incorporates speech and language activities into daily classroom activities. Mr. Marsella testified that based on the progress STUDENT is making, the program and services he is currently receiving are appropriate. Mr. Marsella testified that additional time with the specialists would be “OK”; however, he expressed concern that increased therapy time would not allow enough time for him to work with STUDENT in the classroom.

The testimony discussed above establishes that STUDENT has severe speech and language deficits. STUDENT’s expressive language skills are particularly delayed and he has difficulty with oral motor planning and formulating words. To address these deficits, the District provides STUDENT with two, 45-minute sessions of individual therapy. The District’s preschool SDC is based on a collaborative model whereby the speech pathologist and other specialists work with students in the class and consult with the SDC teacher to ensure that carryover activities are provided in the class. In fact, Ms. Imhoff, STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, is in the classroom two days per week and consults with STUDENT’s teacher on a regular basis.

Both STUDENT’s current teacher and Ms. Imhoff testified that the current level of services STUDENT is receiving is meeting his needs. They also testified that STUDENT is making progress. The Hearing Officer finds their testimony regarding the appropriate level of speech therapy for STUDENT more persuasive than the testimony of Dr. Oke, who is not a speech pathologist, and more persuasive than the testimony of Ms. Kirsch, who has not provided STUDENT with therapy since August, prior to his placement in Mr. Marsella’s class. Additionally, the District is not required to provide students with the best education or services or maximize a student’s potential. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. V. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now the IDEA 1997). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that the “basic floor of opportunity” provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)

The Hearing Officer concludes that speech and language services, as they are currently provided by the District, are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and he is benefitting from the services he is receiving, namely, two 45-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy, with support in the classroom from the speech pathologist and collaboration between the therapist and STUDENT’s teacher. STUDENT’s IEP must be revised to reflect this level of services and must also indicate that support by the speech pathologist includes all of the elements set forth in the District’s letter dated October 1, 1997.

ISSUE NO. 1(B): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require forty-five minutes daily for four days per week of occupational therapy with at least two hours of the therapy provided one-to-one?

No one disputes STUDENT’s need for OT. STUDENT’s parents contend that OT should be provided four days per week for 45 minutes per session, with at least two hours per week of the OT provided one-to-one. The District contends that one hour per week of OT that includes individual therapy, as well as consultation with STUDENT’s teacher, sufficiently meets STUDENT’s needs.

Dr. Oke recommended that STUDENT receive OT 30 to 45 minutes daily at school to address sensorimotor deficits.

Rachelle Rosin, District occupational therapist, currently provides OT to STUDENT two times per week in his class. She begins sessions in one area of the room with STUDENT and then transitions with him to activities set up in other areas of the classroom. Ms. Rosin testified that STUDENT needs to work on sensory and fine-motor deficits. She engages STUDENT in activities that involve deep pressure. For example, they do activities with cushions. She also works with STUDENT using therapy balls, a scooter board, and a tactile table. Ms. Rosin testified that the parents have not allowed her to do brushing activities with STUDENT. Because of this, Ms. Rosin testified that she is not able to provide a complete sensory treatment program for STUDENT, which she feels puts her at a disadvantage. Ms. Rosin testified that to supplement her individual work with STUDENT, she provides activities that STUDENT’s teacher and the aides can incorporate into the classroom. Ms. Rosin testified that since she began providing services to STUDENT, he has shown growth in fine-motor skills, and in his ability to sit and to participate in group activities. The number and intensity of temper tantrums have also reduced. Ms. Rosin testified that STUDENT does not need three hours of OT. She stated that one-hour sessions are more than sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs and that additional individual therapy is unnecessary.

Mr. Marsella testified that the current level of services appears sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs and expressed the same concern he had in regard to increasing speech and language therapy. Mr. Marsella testified that an increase in STUDENT’s OT would leave him with little time to work with STUDENT.

None of the other occupational therapists who have either assessed STUDENT or provided him with OT testified at the hearing. Reports submitted into evidence all recommended weekly, individual OT; however, none of the reports specifies the amount of time of OT STUDENT requires. In a report dated July 10, 1997, Concepcion Davila-Kurth, registered occupational therapist (OTR) for Kaiser Permanente Medical Group, recommended that STUDENT receive OT one to two times per week to improve “visual-motor/adaptive skills: paper/pencil skills, cause and affect, improvement of general fine motor strength, coordination, manipulation and dexterity skills.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit H) The District’s OT report completed on July 17, 1997, recommended a “complete sensory organization program both at school and at home, with direct O.T. intervention weekly.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit J.) In a report dated July 21, 1997, Mary J. Kawar, OTR, who provided OT to STUDENT through the Regional Center, identified the following as “major problems” for STUDENT: temper tantrums, which may include throwing things; auditory defensiveness; self-stimulation patterns; refusing to eat with a spoon; and avoiding crossing the midline of his body. Ms Kawar, recommended that STUDENT continue to receive services for one hour per week. (Petitioner’s Exhibit L)

Dr. Oke’s testimony is not persuasive on the issue of the appropriate level of OT. She is not an occupational therapist and she has not assessed his needs as they relate to OT. On cross-examination, Dr. Oke stated that she was unaware of any clinical research showing the effect of OT on young children with autism. There was no testimony or documentary evidence from an OTR recommending OT at the level requested by the parents. Based on the testimony of STUDENT’s current therapist and STUDENT’s teacher concerning the improvement he has made and the benefit he has derived from the level of OT he currently receives at school, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s services are designed to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer also concludes, based on the same testimony, that STUDENT is benefiting from the OT he is receiving. Therefore, the current level of OT provided by the District is appropriate. As stated above, the District is not required to provide the best services available or to maximize the student’s potential. The District shall continue to provide STUDENT’s therapy at the rate of one hour per week utilizing the current model of individual therapy in which STUDENT receives individual OT two times per week and also receives classroom support from the therapist. The therapist shall also continue to provide consultation and collaboration with STUDENT’s teacher. Because STUDENT’s IEP does not reflect whether the therapy is provided individually, in small-groups, or in consultation, his IEP must be revised to reflect that OT sessions are to be provided individually, with additional support provided by the occupational therapist to him in the classroom.

ISSUE NO. 1(C): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require behavioral intervention therapy provided by Jennifer Oke, Ph.D.?

The primary dispute concerns whether the District is required to fund the behavioral intervention therapy STUDENT receives from Dr. Oke. The PARENTS contend on various grounds that STUDENT should be entitled to continue services with Dr. Oke. First, the PARENTS contend that the District failed to follow procedural requirements of the IDEA and did not provide them with adequate information regarding the proposed autism services.(Footnote 3) Second, the PARENTS contend that the District has not established that the proposed autism services are appropriate for STUDENT. Finally, the PARENTS contend that STUDENT requires the services provided by Dr. Oke to meet his unique needs and to allow him to benefit from his education. The District contends that it has appropriate personnel to provide the 12 to 15 hours of autism services called for on STUDENT’s IEP and that the District, therefore, is not required to obtain the services for STUDENT from Dr. Oke.

Regarding the PARENTS’ contention that the District failed to follow procedural requirements, in Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of compliance with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated:

It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every state of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d) [now IDEA 1997], as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard. We think that the Congressional emphasis upon full participation of concerned parties throughout the development of the IEP, as well as the requirements that state and local plans be submitted to the Commissioner for approval, demonstrate the legislative conviction that adequate compliance with the procedures prescribed would in most cases assure much if not all of what Congress wished in the way of substantive content in an IEP.

458 U.S. 175, 205-206.

Based on the reasoning in Rowley, federal circuit courts have found that under certain circumstances violations of the procedural rights set forth in the IDEA may constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process “clearly result in the denial of FAPE.” See also Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) F.3d 1519, cert. denied, (1994) 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428. In Smith, the Court addressed the issue of whether the IDEA requires school districts to make a formal, written offer of placement. In concluding that it does, the Smith Court pointed to specific provisions in the IDEA that require written prior notice to parents whenever an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a child. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A) and (B). The Court in Smith went on to state that the requirement of a formal written offer should be “enforced rigorously” to alert the parent of the need to seriously consider whether the placement is appropriate, to help the parent determine whether to oppose or accept the placement, and to help the district be prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence at a hearing. (Smith at 1526)

The PARENTS testified that the IEP document was not completed at the meeting on July 18, 1997, and that when they received the draft of the IEP several days later, they did not understand what was meant by the term “autism services.” Several District witnesses, including Beth Hannaman, District preschool teacher and case manager, testified that autism services were discussed at the IEP meeting. Ms. Hannaman testified that she “typically” explains that autism services encompass shadow aides in the classroom and in-home services. Mary Sue Glynn, SEEC program manager, testified that the autism services were also discussed at an informal meeting with the parents and the parents’ and District’s attorneys on September 19, 1997. There is no explanation of the term “autism services”on STUDENT’s IEP. The IEP does indicate that the services will be provided 12 to 15 hours per week. (Petitioner’s Exhibit K.) The only written explanation of “autism services” is contained in a letter dated October 1, 1997, in which the District’s attorney stated:

The District’s autism specialist will coordinate the individual program, including the twelve hours of home services. The autism specialist will train classroom staff and consult with them bi-monthly. By mutual agreement, the autism specialist will observe one of STUDENT’s sessions with Dr. Jennifer Okes [sic], and will incorporate the developmentally appropriate and educationally relevant parts of Dr. Okes’[sic] program into STUDENT’s IEP.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit X.)

Without further specification, the initial IEP offer of autism services does not satisfy the requirements of a formal written offer under Smith. It was unclear whether any discussion took place at the IEP meeting regarding the nature of the services. In any case, any discussion regarding the proposed service does not satisfy the requirement of a written offer as discussed in Smith. The IEP statement does not clear up any confusion regarding the nature of the services. For example, does the 12 to 15 hours offered by the District include a shadow aide in the classroom, one-to-one service, or some combination thereof? Are the services to be provided in the classroom or at some other location? Or does the offer consist entirely of consultation and supervision by an unidentified person? The Hearing Officer finds that the mere statement “autism services” is insufficient to provide parents of a three-year-old student entering the preschool program with information that would allow them to determine the appropriateness of the services being offered.

The letter dated October 1, 1997, provides some information about the autism services; however, it does not sufficiently clarify the services the District was offering. In fact, the letter leaves the reader with the impression that an unnamed autism specialist will determine the program at some future date and will incorporate what that person deems appropriate into STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not make a written offer of placement that satisfies the requirements of Smith and, as a matter of law, has not complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA.

The PARENTS also contend that the District has not established the appropriateness of the autism services it offered by its presentation of evidence at the hearing.(Footnote 4) First, the PARENTS dispute the District’s contention that recent high school graduates can provide STUDENT with services similar to the services STUDENT receives from Dr. Oke. John Fontanesi, Ph.D., is a pediatric neuropsychologist and director of the Center for School Problems at Kaiser Permanente, San Diego. He has seen STUDENT two times at his office. Dr. Fontanesi echoed the parents’ concern and testified that adjunct staff cannot replace Dr. Oke. Dr. Oke is a psychologist in private practice. She has more than 14 years of experience working directly with young children with autism and has provided one-to-one services to STUDENT since April 1997. Dr. Oke expressed the opinion that an instructional aide would not be able to meet STUDENT’s needs because “typical” behavioral interventions do not always work with STUDENT and the person delivering his program needs to employ flexible and creative strategies on a “moment’s notice.” (See also Petitioner’s Exhibit P.) Dr. Oke testified that paraprofessionals generally have limited training and experience and, therefore, rely on rote programs when working with children with autism. STUDENT does not require rote discrete trial training, which is typically used by paraprofessionals. Dr. Oke testified that STUDENT benefits from use of a number of different teaching techniques. Dr. Oke testified that paraprofessionals without sufficient experience and training may actually be harmful for STUDENT, particularly when they do not receive adequate training and supervision. Dr. Oke recommended that STUDENT continue to receive 12 to 15 hours per week of an intensive one-on-one behavioral program provided by an individual with expertise in both autism and a variety of appropriate treatment programs.

FATHER testified that other parents of young children with autism have tried District in-home services and have found them to be unsuccessful. FATHER pointed out that no aides were in class to help STUDENT on two of the hearing days. FATHER also understood from other parents that the aides are unreliable.

MOTHER testified that she observed one young aide working with a student with autism at his home. She testified that the aide was robotic and did not stop the student from self-stimulatory behavior. The aide also left one-half hour early. MOTHER observed a second aide whom she described as acting more like the student’s peer than an instructor. MOTHER testified that neither of these aides is supervised by Ms. Evans because they did not “get along” with her. A third parent has shared her concerns with MOTHER regarding the techniques, such as locking arms around the child, that are employed by an aide. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s shadow aides have been unreliable and that one has frightened children in STUDENT’s class because of her use of disciplinary measures. MOTHER testified that Ms. Evans has failed to respond to concerns expressed by Mr. Marsella concerning the classroom aides.

The testimony of District witnesses described a program generally that is supervised by Ms. Evans and implemented by paraprofessionals. The testimony also established that the program would ultimately be designed by Ms. Evans, who has not yet been involved in STUDENT’s IEP. Mary Lou Evans, SEEC itinerant teacher for students with autism, holds an M.A. in special education and a special education teaching credential. Ms. Evans has received training in a number of strategies employed with young children with autism including PRT, PECS, DTT, and TEAACH. Ms. Evans testified that “autism services” are defined by the needs of the individual student. Ms. Evans testified that autism services may include providing a shadow aide in the classroom and/or in-home services. Ms. Evans testified that she assesses the student’s needs, designs the program, works with the student, trains the aide, shadows the aide when he/she begins working with the student, provides weekly consultation with the aide and the parents, and provides weekly clinics and training to the aides. Ms. Evans testified that 45 students in the District receive autism services. (Ms. Glynn testified there were 20.) Ms. Evans testified that the aides are selected because of the interest in working with young children with autism and also because they have a major or a degree in special education, child development, or psychology.

The District called two witnesses who currently provide autism services for the District. Both witnesses described themselves as “professional experts.” Siri Martin, a junior at San Diego State University, has been a teacher’s assistant and a special education technician for the District. Ms. Martin began working in the fall of 1996 as a one-to-one aide for a child with autism. She also provided him with DTT and PECS. In November 1996, when her responsibilities increased, her title changed to “professional expert.” Ms. Martin testified that her current responsibilities include training new people, developing lessons, providing in-home services, and making materials. Ms. Martin is supervised by Ms. Evans and has weekly training and/or meetings with her. Ms. Martin testified that personally, she would rather not work with a child at both home and at school. She stated that students sometimes get “burned out” and that she sometimes gets “burned out” as well. Ms. Martin testified that she has been trained by MaryLou on TEAACH, PRT, DTT, PECS, and floor time techniques. Ms. Martin testified that she “probably” would be STUDENT’s in-home therapist.

Another professional expert, Karla Wares, testified regarding her experience with young children with autism. Ms. Wares graduated from high school in 1995 and has worked with Ms. Evans since February 1996. Ms. Wares initially worked in Ms. Evans’ classroom that served as a pull-out program for children with autism. She also provided in-home services. Ms Wares previously was a nanny for a family who has a child with autism. Ms. Wares testified that she has taken classes in child development and has participated in seminars and conferences regarding children with autism. Ms. Wares testified that she has also received training in PRT, DTT, TEAACH, and floor time techniques. She stated that new aides now observe her to learn appropriate techniques. Ms. Wares testified that she changes strategies as appropriate for individual children, particularly if they are not responding to the program.

STUDENT Dores, Ph.D., was called to testify by the District. Dr. Dores is a psychologist in private practice. Dr. Dores has worked with children with autism, completed his doctoral dissertation on autism, and contributed to other works, including the Me Book by Dr. Ivar Lovaas. The District has contracted with Dr. Dores to help develop an in-home program for children with autism. He has consulted with Ms. Evans and provided training to some staff. Dr. Dores observed STUDENT’s SDC on November 25, 1997, which was Thanksgiving Pageant Day. Dr. Dores testified that STUDENT is benefitting from his class placement and would also benefit from intensive individual therapy. Dr. Dores testified that the District’s program is good because it offers a number of techniques to meet the individual needs of the children in the program. Dr. Dores testified that it may be to STUDENT’s benefit to work with more than one therapist so that one person does not have operant control over STUDENT.

Dr. Dores testified that the strategies employed with young children with autism are not complicated. He testified that some people are more adept at implementing programs than other persons because of their temperament and tolerance, and because they are not easily manipulated by children. Dr. Dores testified that a successful program requires appropriate supervision and observations. Dr. Dores did not recommend that aides make changes to a student’s program. He testified that the role of the aide is to bring concerns to team meetings; however, subtle modifications such as pacing of tasks, giving breaks, and locating items in the student’s environment can be made by an aide. Dr. Dores testified that the training and supervision of District staff are appropriate. Dr. Dores testified that he is impressed with Ms. Evan’s skills and that persons working with her like her. Dr. Dores described Ms. Martin as “one of the better aides he has seen.” She has good rapport with the children and Dr. Dores likes her temperament.

The PARENTS also assert that the District’s autism program would not meet STUDENT’s needs because he has great difficulty with transitions and would likely regress if he has to change therapists. Dr. Oke testified that transitions and establishing rapport are difficult for STUDENT and that it would be detrimental clinically, educationally, and emotionally for him to sever their relationship. Dr. Oke also testified that STUDENT would not benefit from his services delivered by “rotating” personnel. In a letter dated September 3, 1997, Ms. Kirsch, who provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT, described the difficulty he has establishing rapport. She also expressed the opinion that until STUDENT has established trust, he will not make significant therapeutic gains. Ms. Kirsch went on to state that “STUDENT has established this rapport with Jennifer [Oke] and, in light of the excellent gains he has made with regards to behavioral intervention and the subsequent gains in other areas of therapy, continued therapy with this current behaviorist is highly recommended.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit N.)

Dr. Fontanesi testified that during STUDENT’s second visit to his office, STUDENT demonstrated a great deal of improvement in his ability to respond. Dr. Fontanesi recommended that STUDENT continue with the same services from which he currently is benefitting. He expressed the opinion that STUDENT’s progress should be the measure of when to modify or change services. Dr. Fontanesi testified that it is important to minimize the number of changes to STUDENT’s environment and to the personnel with whom he works. Dr. Fontanesi testified that transitions distract from STUDENT’s ability to focus.

District witnesses also were aware of STUDENT’s difficulty with transitions. Dr. Dores testified that STUDENT does have difficulty with transitions but that he appeared to have transitioned well to the SDC. Dr. Dores testified that STUDENT will require some adjustment to change to a new service provider. He would not venture whether it might take hours or weeks for the transition. Dr. Dores testified that STUDENT’s acquisition of skills could be slowed down and inappropriate behaviors could escalate during the transition. Prem Bhola, STUDENT’s teacher while in the District’s infant program, testified that when STUDENT entered her class, he had great difficulty transitioning form one activity to another. Ms. Bhola testified that STUDENT’s ability to make transitions improved and that he did not “fall out” every time he changed activities; however, because STUDENT continues to have difficulty transitioning, transitions need to be made slowly with him. Ms. Bhola also testified that STUDENT needs to learn to generalize and it is not in his best interest for him to work with one person all of the time.

Mr. Marsella, STUDENT’s current teacher, testified that STUDENT was familiar with him because he had provided respite services for him during the summer; however, when STUDENT entered his class in the fall 1997, he had great difficulty with transitions. For example, if Mr. Marsella varied a song during circle time, STUDENT would be upset. STUDENT’s speech and language and occupational therapists also described the difficulties they experienced establishing rapport with STUDENT. Mr. Marsella testified that STUDENT continues to need assistance transitioning to speech therapy sessions from the classroom.

The District is aware of the difficulty STUDENT has with transitions; however, the District’s offer of autism services does not include any provisions for transitioning STUDENT from Dr. Oke’s services. Moreover, given the difficulty STUDENT has with even slight transitions at this time, the use of multiple paraprofessionals at home and at school would not meet his needs. Mr. Marsella testified credibly regarding the fact that a number of different aides have been assigned to help STUDENT in his class and that there have been days when no aides appeared. He also described the lack of conformity in the aide’s implementation of PECS and to other difficulties he has experienced with autism services in general. Ms. Evans testified that she has had some difficulty locating aides for STUDENT. She stated that it takes approximately six to nine weeks to hire personnel and that several persons assigned to work with STUDENT did not feel comfortable or accepted in his class. There also was a consensus among District witnesses that Ms. Evans is overworked and has too many responsibilities.

The Hearing Officer finds that the majority of other persons called by the District to attest to the appropriateness of the District’s placement did not know STUDENT, have not observed him in his current program, and also did not participate in the IEP process. For this reason, the Hearing Officer relies more on the testimony of Dr. Oke, Mr. Marsella and Dr. Fontanesi concerning the lack of appropriateness of the use of multiple paraprofessionals to meet STUDENT’s needs. Mr. Marsella’s credible testimony is based on his experiences with STUDENT in the classroom and his experiences with the autism services. Based on the lack of specificity regarding the actual autism program, even as described at the hearing, the proposed use of multiple paraprofessionals, the lack of a transition plan, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered appropriate autism services to STUDENT.

As to the appropriateness of Dr. Oke’s services, MOTHER, who holds a B.A. in psychology, testified that STUDENT is now teachable because of the therapy provided by Dr. Oke. MOTHER described how, prior to therapy with Dr. Oke, STUDENT would tantrum “anywhere and anytime,” whereas at the time of the hearing, the number of tantrums declined to about two a day and his protests were more likely to be less demonstrative. FATHER testified that there is a window of opportunity during which children with autism can learn. That window is between the ages of two to six years. STUDENT falls within that age range. FATHER testified that Dr. Oke’s services are essential to allow STUDENT to make progress and to take advantage of the window that is available to him. FATHER testified that when STUDENT initially met with Dr. Oke, he had no eye contact and would spend a majority of the session tantrumming and lying on the floor. STUDENT would not sit at a table and would go “ballistic” if Dr. Oke, or anyone else, tried to read to him. FATHER testified that STUDENT would not eat with the other children the entire time he attended Alcott. FATHER testified that after STUDENT began seeing Dr. Oke, his tantrumming decreased and he learned to sit at the table for up to 45 minutes. He also is able to play appropriately with toys and will read stories with Dr. Oke. FATHER has observed positive changes in STUDENT at home, as well. FATHER testified that he has attended numerous workshops and has read extensively regarding autism. He testified that all of the information he has read recommends that “if something is working, do not change it.”

Dr. Oke also testified that STUDENT has made good progress during the period she has worked with him. For example, she stated that STUDENT’s vocabulary has gone from zero to more than 75 words and he now is able to respond to commands. Dr. Oke described the change in STUDENT’s behavior as “dramatic.” Dr. Oke testified that when she began working with STUDENT, he would tantrum 30 to 45 minutes of each session, whereas now he rarely tantrums. Initially, STUDENT would have “nothing to do” with sitting at a table, whereas now he goes to the table on his own and is eager and attentive. Dr. Oke testified that since the initial administration of the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, the number and severity of characteristics of autism exhibited by STUDENT have decreased when measured on the same Scale.

District witnesses concurred with Petitioner’s witnesses that Dr. Oke has successfully worked with young children with autism. Dr. Dores testified that Dr. Oke is respected and has a good reputation in the professional community. Mr. Marsella testified that Dr. Oke has provided him with valuable information to help him work with STUDENT. She has also provided him with toys and materials to use in his class. The District has, in fact, contracted with Dr. Oke to provide services.

There is no dispute that STUDENT has benefitted from Dr. Oke’s behavioral intervention services. Based on the testimony of the persons who have had the most direct involvement with delivering STUDENT’s program, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Oke’s services are critical to STUDENT’s benefitting from special education. Dr. Oke employs a number of different methodologies to improve STUDENT’s attending skills and his behavior. She coordinates her services with the parents and with STUDENT’s teachers so that there are follow-up activities for STUDENT in a number of different environments. The evidence establishes that STUDENT would not have been able to sit and attend and, thereby, benefit from a classroom setting without the services provided by Dr. Oke. He also would not have been attentive and available for instruction from the speech and language therapist and the occupational therapist. Therefore, the services provided by Dr. Oke are designed both to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Districts may be required to seek certified nonpublic agencies (NPA) to provide services when the District does not offer appropriate services. In this case, Dr. Oke is an NPA, and it has been concluded that the District did not offer appropriate autism services for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that these facts, as well as the lack of an offer of appropriate autism services by the District, establishes STUDENT’s entitlement to continue the services he currently receives from Dr. Oke.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of transportation to speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral intervention therapy?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Moreover, parents need not procure the best possible private placement or services in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.

Because Dr. Oke’s services were determined above to be necessary for STUDENT to benefit from special education, the parents are entitled to the transportation costs they have incurred in transporting STUDENT to Dr. Oke’s office for therapy. Reimbursement is limited to after STUDENT turned three. Prior to that date, the Hearing Office did not have jurisdiction over disputes concerning STUDENT’s education. See California Early Intervention Services Act, Title 14 Government Code § 95000 et seq.

Neither speech and language nor OT by private providers has been determined necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with providing transportation to those services.

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to revise STUDENT’s IEP to reflect the following:

(A) STUDENT shall receive individual speech and language therapy of 45-minute sessions two times per week; small-group and other appropriate support in the classroom two days per week from the speech pathologist; and weekly consultation by the speech pathologist with the classroom teacher.

(B) STUDENT shall receive support by the speech pathologist that includes coordinating, developing, maintaining, and supervising use of the PECS with the classroom staff, the autism specialist, and the parents.

(C) STUDENT shall receive individual sessions of occupational therapy of 30-minutes two times per week support from the occupational therapist in the classroom two days per week; and weekly consultation by the occupational therapist with the classroom teacher.

(D) STUDENT shall receive 12 hours per week of autism services from Jennifer Oke, Ph.D.

(2) From the date of this decision, the District shall assume responsibility for Dr. Oke’s services and, as soon as practicable, the District shall contract with Dr. Oke to provide STUDENT’s autism services for the remainder of the 1997-1998 school year, including the extended school year program.

(3) Within 15 days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall reimburse the parents for the costs of transportation to STUDENT’s sessions with Dr. Oke from the date of his third birthday at the District’s standard rate of reimbursement.

(4) Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1(A): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require one hour daily for four days per week of speech and language therapy with at least one half of the therapy provided one-to-one? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 1(B): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require forty-five minutes daily for four days per week of occupational therapy with at least two hours of the therapy provided one-to-one? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 1(C): To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require behavioral intervention therapy provided by Jennifer Oke, Ph.D.? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of transportation to speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral intervention therapy? The Petitioner prevailed as to reimbursement for transportation to behavioral intervention therapy. The District prevailed as to reimbursement for transportation to speech and language and OT and to any services prior to STUDENT’s third birthday.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: February 25, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1:STUDENT’s therapy with Dr. Oke began prior to STUDENT’s third birthday at which time the Regional Center for Developmental Disabilities of San Diego was responsible for his services. According to Ms. Mallinger, the Regional Center has continued to fund Dr. Oke’s services through an “informal” stay-put agreement. Footnote 2:In 1997, amendments to the IDEA were enacted (IDEA 1997). This case was filed after the effective date of the amendments and involves a dispute regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 1997-1998 school year. Based on these facts, the Hearing Officer applies the IDEA 1997, the law in effect at the time the dispute arose. Footnote 3:Petitioner contends that the District committed other procedural errors related to the development of goals and objectives and the gathering of information from Regional Center service providers at the IEP meeting. The evidence does not substantiate that these alleged procedural violations resulted in the loss of a free, appropriate public education. Footnote 4: In an order dated November 11, 1997, the Hearing Office determined that the District had both the burden of proof and the burden of going forward in this matter.