California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 9, 2004
Student v. Covina-Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1262-04 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Covina-Valley Unified may resume expulsion; Hearing Officer finds no basis of knowledge of disability and no child find violation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The District had stayed the expulsion proceedings while the due process case was pending.
Summary
The family of a 13-year-old seventh grader asked for an expedited hearing to stop Covina-Valley Unified School District from expelling him. He had never been assessed for special education. In April 2004 he brought a knife to Sierra Vista Middle School and displayed it to another student. The principal then recommended expulsion. The family argued that the District already had a "basis of knowledge" that he had a disability, so special education discipline protections applied. They pointed to his tardies, talking in class, use of profanity, and poor grades in earlier districts. They also said the District violated child find by not assessing him after the April 2 profanity incident. They asked for a psychiatric assessment and one-to-one tutoring.
The Hearing Officer ruled for the District on every issue. His Sierra Vista teachers testified that his work was average or better and that he followed redirection. They saw no signs of ADHD. His low grades mostly came from choosing not to turn in work, and his behavior incidents were minor social ones. So the District had no basis of knowledge and no child find duty, and it may resume expulsion. The Hearing Officer added that even a basis of knowledge would lead to an assessment and manifestation review, not an automatic end to expulsion. The District had already agreed to a psychoeducational assessment, and the order directs an expedited assessment in all areas of suspected disability. The psychiatric assessment and tutoring requests were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA "basis of knowledge" rule to a student never found eligible. It gave weight to current teachers' testimony over older records from other districts. It also reasoned that a basis of knowledge leads to an assessment and manifestation review, not an automatic end to expulsion.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue I.A. Did the District have a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with a disability before April 8, 2004, when he brandished a knife at school?
Satisfactory grades, teacher testimony, and minor, situational misconduct (mostly tardies and talking) did not show a need for special education, so the District had no basis of knowledge under 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8).
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue I.B. Must the District terminate expulsion proceedings against STUDENT?
Without a basis of knowledge, Student may be disciplined like a nondisabled student; even a basis of knowledge would trigger assessment and a manifestation review, not automatic ending of expulsion.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue II. Did the District violate "child find" by failing to initiate a special education assessment of STUDENT on or after April 2, 2004?
The information available from December 2003 through April 2004 did not suggest a need for special education, so the District had no duty to start an assessment.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue III. Should the District be ordered to conduct an assessment, including a psychiatric assessment, of STUDENT?
The District had already agreed to a psychoeducational assessment, so there was no dispute on that point; a psychiatric evaluation was denied because ADHD and behavior can be assessed in a psychoeducational assessment and no need for more was shown.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue IV. Is STUDENT entitled to one-to-one tutoring services?
No compensatory tutoring was awarded because the District did not violate child find and no denial of special education services was shown.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District may resume expulsion proceedings. In a footnote, the Hearing Officer encouraged the District to consider its offer to stay the expulsion until the assessment and eligibility decision were complete.
- Order to assess. The District shall conduct an expedited assessment of Student in all areas of suspected disability. The request for a psychiatric assessment was denied.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8) (1997); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; Todd v. Andrews; Student v. Jurupa Unified School District, SN00-01885
People named in the decision
- Ann Jones, director of student services, Covina-Valley Unified School District
- Gayle Odell, assistant superintendent, Covina-Valley Unified School District
- Josie Paredes, assistant principal, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Marsha Evers, child welfare and attendance supervisor, Covina-Valley Unified School District
- Jody McCreery, home economics teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Erica Landmann-Johnsey, literacy teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Michael Westphal, physical education teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Christine Werner, science teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Aaron Cantu, substitute math (algebra) teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Willis Merrihew, language arts and social studies teacher, Sierra Vista Middle School
- Ms. Smith, English teacher (did not testify), Sierra Vista Middle School
- Gil Navarro, educational advocate for Student
- Graciela Hines, Spanish interpreter
- Ligia Saelim, Spanish interpreter
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Covina, California, on June 15 and 16, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was present at hearing and was represented by educational advocate Gil Navarro. STUDENT’s sister, SISTER, and his mother, MOTHER, were also present on his behalf. Respondent Covina-Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorneys Constance Taylor and Nectaria Belantis. Also present on the District’s behalf were Ann Jones, director of student services, and Gayle Odell, assistant superintendent. (Footnote 1) Graciela Hines and Ligia Saelim, Spanish interpreters, were present to interpret for MOTHER. FAMILY FRIEND, a friend of STUDENT’s family, was present as an observer.
STUDENT, his sister, and his mother all testified on his behalf. Testifying on behalf of the District were: Josie Paredes, assistant principal; Marsha Evers, child welfare and attendance supervisor; Jody McCreery, home economics teacher; Erica Landmann-Johnsey, literacy teacher; Michael Westphal, physical education teacher; Christine Werner, science teacher; Aaron Cantu, substitute math teacher; and Willis Merrihew, language arts and social studies teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Additionally, oral closing arguments were made on the record. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
I. May the District expel STUDENT, who has never been found eligible for special education services, based on the alleged conduct that occurred on April 8, 2004?
II. Did the District violate “child find” by failing to initiate a special education assessment of STUDENT on or after April 2, 2004?
III. Should the District be ordered to conduct an assessment, including a psychiatric assessment, of STUDENT?
IV. Is STUDENT entitled to one-to-one tutoring services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old seventh grade student who has never been assessed, or found eligible, for special education services. STUDENT lives with his adult sister and her family in Covina, California. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was on summer vacation from school.
At the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT lived with his mother within the Downey Unified School District and attended the seventh grade at Downey’s East Middle School. During the first two months of school, STUDENT was often truant and was disciplined on at least six occasions for defiance, disruption, and vandalism. (Student Exhs. A29-A31.) By mid November, STUDENT was failing two of his classes. (Footnote 3) (Student Exh. A-32.) Then, on November 26, 2003, STUDENT was suspended from school for possession of pornographic material on campus and recommended for a transfer to Griffith Middle School for “social adjustment.” According to STUDENT’s school records from Downey, STUDENT was allowed to return to East Middle School on December 1, 2003.
Rather than return STUDENT to school in Downey, STUDENT’s mother moved him to Covina to live with his sister, SISTER, and she appointed SISTER as STUDENT’s legal guardian. According to SISTER, she believed at the time that many of STUDENT’s problems stemmed from a lack of structure and discipline and his move to Covina would allow her to provide him closer supervision. In light of the move, STUDENT was enrolled at Sierra Vista Middle School (Sierra) within the Covina-Valley Unified School District on December 2, 2003. (Dist. Exh. 1.) Around this time, SISTER discussed with the Sierra assistant principal, Josie Paredes, STUDENT’s disciplinary problems from Downey and his need for close supervision. Together, SISTER and Ms. Paredes planned STUDENT’s class schedule to include a seventh period study skills class and arranged for SISTER to be provided weekly reports of STUDENT’s progress.
During his initial months at Sierra, STUDENT’s grades improved significantly from those in Downey. According to a transcript from May 2004, STUDENT’s grades ranged from an “A” to two “D’s.” (Footnote 4) However, STUDENT continued to exhibit negative behaviors at school, although his negative behaviors were fewer and less frequent. Between December 2003 and early April 2004, STUDENT received nine notations in his discipline record, mostly relating to his more than twenty tardies. His other behaviors included two violations of class rules for talking in class, a violation of class rules for snapping a towel at a female classmate, and the use of profanity in class. Because of STUDENT’s use of profanity, which occurred on April 2, 2004, STUDENT was assigned two days of in-house suspension and his sister was contacted for a meeting with District personnel. With SISTER’s permission, STUDENT was signed up for the school’s voluntary probation program where an on-site probation officer would monitor STUDENT’s progress and behaviors at school. It is undisputed that STUDENT was not referred to a student study team or for a special education assessment at any time during this four-month period.
On April 8, 2004, STUDENT brought a locking blade knife to school, brandished it at another student, and asked the student if he wanted to be “shank[ed].” (Footnote 5) When the student called STUDENT’s bluff, STUDENT walked away. The student then notified school personnel about the incident and STUDENT was suspended for five days from school, specifically from April 9 through April 22. (Footnote 6) On April 9, 2004, the principal at Sierra recommended STUDENT for expulsion. (Student Exh. D58.) As a result, STUDENT’s suspension was extended pending his expulsion proceedings. While out of school, STUDENT was placed on the District’s Independent Study Program to complete his coursework. By letter dated April 22, 2004, the District notified SISTER and STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, of the expulsion hearing scheduled for May 18, 2004. Then, by fax on May 11, 2004, to the District, MOTHER requested a thirty-day postponement of the expulsion proceedings.
On May 25, 2004, SISTER requested from the Hearing Office a special education due process hearing to challenge the District’s ability to expel STUDENT. The District has since stayed all expulsion proceedings pending the outcome of the due process procedures.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student contends that the District had a “basis of knowledge” that he was a child with a disability prior to the incident involving his brandishing of a knife at school. Specifically, he contends that his history of discipline problems and failing grades at prior school districts and his behaviors within the District provided the District with a “basis of knowledge” of his disability. (Footnote 7) The Student contends that the District, under its “child find” obligations, should have referred him for a special education assessment when he was disciplined for using profanity at school on April 2. (Footnote 8) According to the Student, because the District had a basis of knowledge and failed to assess him for special education services, the District may not now proceed with the expulsion process. Hence, the Student requests an order prohibiting the District from expelling him. Moreover, the Student requests an order requiring the District to conduct a comprehensive assessment of him, including a psychiatric assessment, and requiring the District to provide one-to-one tutoring services, apparently as compensatory education.
The District contends that it did not have a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a child with a disability prior to the April 8 incident. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT was progressing steadily at Sierra and his negative behaviors were not so severe or frequent that an assessment for special education was needed. Thus, the District contends that STUDENT is not entitled to procedural protections for special education students, and it may proceed with its expulsion procedures. However, the District also stated that, because of the concerns expressed by SISTER and MOTHER regarding STUDENT’s ability to academically progress, it is willing to assess STUDENT to determine if he qualifies for special education services. Although the District is willing to assess STUDENT, it contends that it is not required to conduct a psychiatric assessment of STUDENT. Additionally, the District contends that it is not required to provide STUDENT one-to-one tutoring services.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. May the District expel STUDENT, who has never been found eligible for special education services, based on the alleged conduct that occurred on April 8, 2004?
Under federal and State special education law, students identified as eligible for special education are accorded certain rights in disciplinary matters. Among those rights is the right to a determination of whether the student’s misconduct arose from either a disability or an improper educational placement. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a).) Specifically, federal law provides that, if disciplinary action is contemplated involving a change of placement for more than 10 days, no Alater than 10 school days after the date on which the decision to take that action is made, a review shall be conducted of the relationship between the child=s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action.@ (20 U.S.C. ' 1415(k)(4)(A)(ii) (1997).)
In 1997, Congress amended the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) to extend the protections afforded to eligible students to some students not previously identified as eligible for special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527.) These protections extend to students not previously identified as eligible for special education services only if the following factors are met: (1) the student has engaged in behavior that violated any rule or code of conduct of the school district, and (2) the school district had knowledge, or is deemed to have had knowledge, that the student was a child with a disability “before the behavior that precipitated the disciplinary action occurred.” (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8)(A).)
The foregoing “basis of knowledge” or “deemed” knowledge exists when (1) the parent of the child expresses concern in writing to personnel of the appropriate educational agency that the child is in need of special education; (2) the behavior or the performance of the child demonstrates a need for such services; (3) the parent of the child has requested an evaluation; or (4) the teacher of the child or other personnel expressed concern about the behavior of the child to the director of special education or other personnel of the local educational agency. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8)(B); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527(b).)
As discussed above, it is undisputed that STUDENT had not been determined eligible for special education at the time he was found to have brandished a knife at school. However, the Student asserts that he should be entitled to the procedural protections of the IDEA because the District had a “basis of knowledge” that he was a child with a disability. Specifically, the Student contends that that, prior to the disciplinary incident, his behavior and academic performance demonstrated a need for special education services. Accordingly, the Student asserts that the expulsion proceedings against him must be “extinguished” or “dismissed.” The District disputes that it had a “basis of knowledge” and asserts that it may proceed with disciplinary proceedings against STUDENT.
A. Did the District have a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with a disability before April 8, 2004, when he brandished a knife at school?
The Student contends that his history of behavior problems and poor grades indicate that he may have an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and social/emotional difficulties that may qualify him for special education. Although the record does reflect that STUDENT exhibited some academic difficulty and behavior issues while at Sierra, the nature and severity of those difficulties did not rise to the level that would indicate that the District had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a student with a disability.
Academically, STUDENT was able to achieve satisfactory grades while attending Sierra Middle School. At the time he was suspended for brandishing a knife, STUDENT was earning two “B’s,” two “C’s,” a “C+,” and an “F.” (Student Exhs. 49-54.) The “F” was in English class, which was taught by Ms. Smith. According to the teachers that testified, STUDENT’s academic performance was at or above average and he was able to do the class work required of him. Additionally, they all testified that STUDENT did not exhibit any difficulties that would indicate a need for special education services.
Ms. McCreery testified that STUDENT received a “C” in her home economics class because he chose not to copy recipes into a notebook as required. Ms. McCreery testified that STUDENT’s work product was otherwise “good,” he was attentive during cooking demonstrations, he did well on the practical part of the class, and he was able to ask and answer questions about what he learned. Similarly, STUDENT’s literacy teacher, Erica Landmann-Johnsey, testified that STUDENT was able to work independently, that he was motivated to do his homework, and that his work product was “fine.” Mike Westphal, STUDENT’s physical education teacher, testified that STUDENT had leadership qualities and that STUDENT did not have problems following directions or behaving in class. Christine Werner, STUDENT’s science teacher, testified that STUDENT was at the same level academically as the rest of Ms. Werner’s class. Moreover, STUDENT’s algebra teacher, Aaron Cantu, and his social studies teacher, Willis Merrihew, both testified that STUDENT’s academic performance and work product were average as compared to the rest of the students in the class.
Many of STUDENT’s teachers commented that STUDENT had greater potential than he exhibited because he spent much of his time socializing with friends and “cute” girls rather than focusing on his schoolwork. STUDENT’s teachers also testified that, although STUDENT was often off-task because he socialized with his friends, STUDENT did not exhibit the characteristics of a child with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). All of the teachers testified that they had worked with ADHD students in the past and/or were familiar with the symptoms of ADHD. Although STUDENT’s sister testified that he is distractible and has difficulty following instructions, turning in his homework, and completing his class work, she never observed him at school or spoke to his teachers about his classroom performance. Additionally, although the Student presented evidence that he did not perform well academically in other school districts in the past, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to this fact in the absence of evidence explaining the reason for his academic difficulties. Because STUDENT’s teachers at Sierra have more direct knowledge of how STUDENT currently progresses at school, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony more persuasive regarding STUDENT’s academic performance at Sierra and more indicative of whether STUDENT’s recent classroom performance indicated a need for special education services.
The evidence indicates that part of the reason for STUDENT’s lower grades is that he did not complete or submit his assignments. (Footnote 9) Regarding his “F” in English, STUDENT’s progress report indicates that his grade was a result of his failure to submit four of five assignments. Ms. Smith also noted that STUDENT was absent on four days and was tardy for class three other days. At hearing, STUDENT testified that he refused to turn in his work in Ms. Smith’s class because he believed that Ms. Smith was “mean” and that she did not like him. Thus, according to STUDENT, he would not turn in his work as a way of retaliating against her. Regarding his other classes, STUDENT testified that he would not complete his homework because he was “lazy” and would rather watch television than do his work. STUDENT also testified that he sometimes did not do his class work because the teachers would be busy with other students and this gave him the opportunity to “mess around” with other students and not complete his work. Furthermore, STUDENT testified that he would do well in classes where he liked the teachers and the subject matter. Thus, while STUDENT had some difficulty with his academics, that difficulty did not appear to result from any disability but instead from STUDENT’s decision whether or not to complete his work.
Behaviorally, STUDENT received nine notations in his discipline record prior to the April 8 incident. Two of those incidents involved STUDENT not paying attention in class and talking with his neighbors. One incident involved STUDENT snapping a towel at a female classmate. One incident involved STUDENT using profanity in class. According to STUDENT, he and his friends were talking about a recent horror movie involving “Freddy” and “Jason” and his use of profanity was in response to a description of one of the scenes in the movie. The remaining five notations were for tardies to class. STUDENT testified that his tardies were primarily for the first period class because he had difficulty getting to school on time in the morning. Specifically, STUDENT stated that he often spent too much time styling his hair or taking a shower in the morning, which would delay him from getting to school. On one occasion, he was tired in the morning and decided to walk slowly to school.
The Student contends that these behaviors, particularly the April 2 incident involving the use of profanity, should have put the District on notice that he had behavior issues that needed to be addressed with special education. The evidence does not support the Student’s contention. First, STUDENT was often tardy to class because he spent a long time grooming himself for school. There is no indication that STUDENT’s tardiness was due to any disability or deficit. Second, STUDENT’s other behavior incidents were infrequent and, according to his testimony, situational. STUDENT had only four notations over a span of four months and all of the notations involve him socializing with his peers. Moreover, STUDENT’s discipline record indicates weeks in which he would not have any disciplinary issues at all. Furthermore, there was no evidence that any of his behaviors were related to any disability for which he required special education services.
As is also reflected by his discipline record, STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT’s greatest problem was that he “loved the girls and the girls loved him.” All of his teachers testified that STUDENT was social, but his behaviors did not indicate to them that he had a disability that required special education services. They consistently testified that STUDENT was easily redirected and was compliant and respectful. Additionally, they all were confident that STUDENT could control his behaviors when asked and that he often complied with redirection. For example, STUDENT’s literacy and physical education teachers testified that STUDENT did not exhibit behavior problems in their classes. The other teachers testified that, when STUDENT would talk to his peers, they would ask him to stop and he would immediately comply.
STUDENT’s testimony was also consistent with that of his teachers. STUDENT testified that he liked to talk to his friends in class and did not think that it was a significant problem to do so. He also testified that, when asked, he would stop talking to his friends. As described above, STUDENT was often more responsive to teachers he liked and would have less behavior issues in their classes. Although SISTER and MOTHER testified regarding STUDENT’s long history of behaviors involving disruption, aggression with other students, and defiance of authority beginning in his first grade year, most of those behaviors were not observed while STUDENT attended Sierra. Additionally, the Student presented a significant amount of evidence on behavioral incidents that occurred while he was in the first grade. While his first grade discipline record does establish his behavioral history, the notations in the first-grade record are not similar to the behavior problems exhibited at Sierra and they occurred approximately seven years before he entered the District. Because evidence of STUDENT’s problems in the first grade have no clear connection to the behaviors he exhibited at Sierra, the Hearing Officer gives this evidence very little weight.
In conclusion, it was found above that STUDENT was performing satisfactorily in his classes and his academic problems primarily arose from his choice not to do his class work. Additionally, STUDENT’s behaviors in the District all involved socializing with his peers and did not appear to result from a disability that required special education services. Therefore, STUDENT’s behaviors and academic performance did not indicate a need for special education services that would have put the District on notice that he was a child with a disability at the time he brandished a knife at school.
B. Must the District terminate expulsion proceedings against STUDENT?
Because it was determined above that the District did not have a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a child with a disability, STUDENT is not entitled to the procedural protections of the IDEA for children eligible for special education services who are subject to disciplinary procedures. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.527(d)(1).) Thus, the District may discipline STUDENT in the same manner it would discipline a nondisabled child, including resuming expulsion proceedings.
The Hearing Officer notes that, even if it was determined above that the District had a basis of knowledge, that determination alone would not result in the complete extinction of the STUDENT’s expulsion proceedings in this case. To ensure that children with disabilities were not discriminated against and punished for their disability, Congress established a series of procedures that local educational agencies must follow prior to disciplining the disabled child. As discussed above, the IDEA requires local educational agencies to follow procedures, such as conducting a manifestation determination meeting, to determine whether the behavior precipitating the disciplinary action was related to the child’s disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4), (5).) If the behavior was a manifestation of the child’s disability, the local educational agency may not discipline the child but, instead, must revise the child’s individualized educational program (IEP) to address the inappropriate behavior resulting from his or her disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.523(d), (f).) If the behavior was not a manifestation of the child’s disability, the child may be disciplined in the same manner as nondisabled children because the child would not be punished for his or her disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.524.) Hence, the law protects disabled children from being disciplined because of their disability through its system of procedures that establishes the cause of the behavior; the law does not enable disabled children to automatically escape punishment for violations of school rules or codes of conduct.
Considering that children who are already determined eligible for special education may still be disciplined so long as the local educational agencies follow the IDEA procedures, it is illogical to conclude that a determination of a “basis of knowledge” would necessarily result in the complete extinction of pending expulsion proceedings regarding children not yet eligible for special education. Rather, a determination that a district had a “basis of knowledge” effectively would trigger a district’s obligation to assess the child for special education services and to convene an IEP meeting to determine eligibility. (Footnote 10) If the child is found eligible for special education services, the child would be entitled to the procedural protections described above. However, if the child is determined to be ineligible for special education services, the local education agency may proceed with disciplinary actions. Therefore, had it been determined in this Decision that the District had a “basis of knowledge,” STUDENT would be entitled to an assessment for special education services and, if he was determined to be qualified for special education, a meeting to determine if his behavior was a manifestation of his disability. He would not be entitled to a complete extinction of the expulsion process. Contrary to the Student’s arguments, even if it is determined at hearing that the District had a “reasonable basis of knowledge,” he may ultimately still be subject to the disciplinary proceedings. (Footnote 11)
From the above, and because it was determined that the District did not have a “basis of knowledge,” the Student’s request for a complete “extinction” of the expulsion proceedings is denied.
****
In conclusion, it was found above that STUDENT’s behavior and academic performance from his enrollment in December 2003 through April 2004 did not demonstrate a need for special education services. Additionally, there was no other basis to determine that the District had a “basis of knowledge.” Thus, the District cannot be deemed to have had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a child with a disability before the behaviors that precipitated the disciplinary action. Accordingly, the District may discipline STUDENT in the same manner as nondisabled children, including resuming his expulsion proceedings.
II. Did the District violate “child find” by failing to initiate a special education assessment of STUDENT on or after April 2, 2004?
Pursuant to State and federal law, school districts are required to “systematically seek out” all persons under the age of 22 who reside within their boundaries and have exceptional educational needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10).) To implement this “child find” obligation, “[e]ach district, special education local plan area, or county office shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.) Districts must conduct child find for all children residing in their jurisdiction, including those attending public and private schools. (34 C.F.R. § 300.451.)
The Student claims that the District failed in its child find obligations by failing to initiate an assessment of him by April 2, 2004, when he was disciplined for using profanity in class. As was found above, STUDENT’s behavior and academic performance from his enrollment in December 2003 through April 2004 did not demonstrate a need for special education services. Because the information available to the District did not indicate a need for special education services, the District was not required to initiate a special education assessment of STUDENT as part of its child find obligation. Accordingly, the District did not violate its child find obligations in this case.
III. Should the District be ordered to conduct an assessment, including a psychiatric assessment, of STUDENT?
The Student asserts that the District should be ordered to conduct a “comprehensive assessment” of him for special education services, which includes a psychoeducational assessment and a psychiatric evaluation. Pursuant to Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations at section 300.527(d)(2), if a parent requests a special education evaluation during the time period in which he is subjected to disciplinary measures, the evaluation must be conducted in an expedited manner. Additionally, the evaluation must assess the student in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) Until that evaluation is completed, the child remains in the educational placement determined by school authorities, which can include suspension or expulsion without educational services. (34 C.F.R. § 300.527(d)(2)(ii).)
In this case, the Student included a request for a “comprehensive assessment” in his request for hearing sent to the Hearing Office and the District. In response to the Student’s request, the District offered to conduct the requested psychoeducational assessments. However, the Student has withheld consent for the District to conduct the assessment. At hearing, the District reiterated that it would conduct the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT pursuant to his family’s request. Because the District has offered and agreed to conduct the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, there is no dispute and it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to order that assessment.
However, the District does not agree to conduct a psychiatric evaluation. The Student asserts that his history of behavior problems indicates a need for a psychiatric evaluation to assess his behavior. At hearing, the Student asserted only that he may have ADHD and that his behaviors were a concern. An assessment for ADHD and of behaviors can be completed as part of a district psychoeducational assessment. Although it is undisputed that STUDENT’s behaviors must be assessed, no evidence was provided to establish the need for a psychiatric evaluation in addition to the psychoeducational assessment offered by the District. Because the evidence does not support the Student’s request for a psychiatric assessment, that request is denied.
IV. Is STUDENT entitled to one-to-one tutoring services?
The Student asserts that he should be provided one-to-one tutoring services for the District’s failure to comply with its “child find” obligations and for inappropriately disciplining him, apparently as a form of compensatory education. Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from section 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii) of Title 20 of the United States Code, which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” (Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D. Minn. 1996).) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).)
As was found above, the District did not have a “basis of knowledge” and was not required to initiate an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to its “child find” obligations. Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT was entitled to any special education services of which he was denied and required remediation. Because the District was found to have complied with the law, it is not required to provide STUDENT with any compensatory remedies.
ORDER
1. The District may resume expulsion proceedings of STUDENT. (Footnote 12)
2. The District shall conduct an expedited assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
3. All of the Student’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).)
Date: July 9, 2004 Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer
In his request for hearing, the Student also named the Downey Unified School District (Downey) as a respondent to this matter. Upon Respondent Downey’s motion and over the Student’s objection, Downey was dismissed during a telephonic prehearing conference on June 14, 2004, by the undersigned Hearing Officer. Specifically, the Hearing Officer determined that the Student’s issues and proposed resolutions as noticed to the parties did not pertain to Downey and Downey was not a necessary party to this matter. Although the Student sought to expand his issues from those stated in his issue statement to involve “child find” issues relating to a past time period when he was a resident within Downey, the Hearing Officer denied the Petitioner’s request to add unrelated past FAPE issues to the current expedited matter.
2 The issues here differ in wording and numbering from the Student’s issue statement dated June 1, 2004. The issues were restated based on the clarification of issues between the parties and the Hearing Officer during the telephone prehearing conference on June 14, 2004, and during the first day of hearing.
3 The records indicate that STUDENT was absent from those two classes five to nine times
4 These grades vary slightly from the grades reported by STUDENT’s teachers in progress reports that were completed in April around the time of the knife incident.
5 For purposes of expulsion matters, the School Board makes the ultimate determination as to whether or not the misconduct occurred. In this case, evidence at hearing established that STUDENT pled guilty to the charges and was placed on probation by the juvenile court.
6 It appears that the Sierra school calendar included a spring break during this time because the stated time period for STUDENT’s 5 day suspension covered more than 5 school days,
7The written record indicates that STUDENT has attended school within at least four school districts since the first grade. Those school districts include the El Rancho Unified School District, the Downey Unified School District, the Little Lake City School District, and the Covina-Valley Unified School District.
8The Student does not assert that, by the time of the hearing, he should have been determined to actually be eligible for special education services. Rather, the Student contends that an assessment must be conducted prior to any determination of eligibility.
9 s discussed below, other reasons for STUDENT’s lower grades are his frequent tardies and absences and his inclination to socialize rather than complete his class work.
10 nceivably, a party may establish eligibility at hearing and render the need for an assessment moot. As discussed above, in this case, the Student is not contending that he should be determined at hearing to be actually eligible for special education services.
11he Student cited a Hearing Office decision in Student v. Jurupa Unified School District, SN00-01885, in support of his contention that a finding of a “basis of knowledge” alone could result in the rescission of a student’s expulsion. However, the Jurupa case is distinguishable from this case. In the Jurupa case, the Student had already been expelled by the District over four months prior to the hearing. Thus, there was an actual expulsion decision to rescind. Because the parties had already agreed to initiate special education assessments, it was unnecessary for the hearing officer to order the Jurupa District to conduct the assessments after she found that the District had a “basis of knowledge” at the time of the disciplinary incident. In this case, STUDENT has not yet been expelled, and there is no expulsion to rescind. Thus, the only question in this case is whether STUDENT should be entitled to the procedural protections of the IDEA before the District proceeds with his expulsion.
12 ough the District is legally entitled to expel STUDENT at this time, the District asserted at hearing that it was willing to stay STUDENT’s expulsion pending an assessment and determination of special education eligibility. The District is encouraged to further explore this alternative. Should the District expel STUDENT prior to completing the assessment, as discussed above, STUDENT must remain expelled until the assessment is completed.
