California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · 1999-09-39
Student v. Las Virgenes Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1268-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Las Virgenes Unified denied FAPE in fifth and sixth grades and must provide two hours of daily reading remediation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
This is an Amended Decision. According to its footnote, the only change from the original decision was correcting the hearing date "September 39, 1999" to September 30, 1999.
Summary
A student with a specific learning disability and an attention disorder filed for due process against Las Virgenes Unified School District. He claimed he was denied FAPE from fourth through sixth grade and sought reimbursement and compensatory occupational therapy (OT). The Hearing Officer declined to decide his placement for the following year, because no offer had yet been made for it.
The Hearing Officer found the district provided FAPE in fourth grade (1996-97). His resource specialist used the Herman Method, a systematic reading program, and he gained about a year and a half in reading and writing over two years. The district missed some OT sessions, but this did not deny FAPE.
In fifth grade (1997-98), the district went along with repeated parent-requested switches between resource and special day class programs. It did so even though its own staff believed he needed the special day class. The Hearing Officer held that a district must offer what it considers appropriate and file for due process if parents refuse. The frequent changes and mixed methods denied FAPE.
In sixth grade (1998-99), the special day class used a "multi-model" approach. It did not provide the systematic phonemic-awareness program described by Dr. Sasha Borenstein of the Kelter Center, so FAPE was again denied.
Reimbursement for tutoring, therapy, and audio books was denied. The district must provide up to two years of two-hour daily remedial instruction, make up missed OT, continue weekly OT, and hold an IEP meeting within two weeks.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district that kept agreeing to parent-requested program changes it did not believe were appropriate. The Hearing Officer held that the district still had to offer the program it believed was appropriate and file for due process if the parents refused. A series of changing, inconsistent programs counted against the district.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District provide Student with a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year (fourth grade)?
RSP support with the systematic Herman Method reading program met Student's needs and gave educational benefit; missed OT sessions did not deny FAPE, though the district must make them up.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District provide Student with a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year (fifth grade)?
The district denied FAPE by agreeing to frequent parent-requested program changes against its staff's view that Student needed the SDC, giving up a systematic reading method; it should have filed for due process instead.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c. Did the District provide Student with a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year (sixth grade)?
The SDC's eclectic 'multi-model' approach did not provide the systematic, intensive phonemic-awareness remediation Student needed, several goals were inappropriate, and he did not receive meaningful benefit.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained educational services (tutoring and therapy) and materials during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?
Reimbursement denied: fourth-grade tutoring came in a FAPE year and did not help, therapy was not shown to be educationally necessary, and the district supplied books on tape.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to compensatory OT services (and other relief)?
Because FAPE was denied in 1997-98 and 1998-99, Student gets two hours daily of systematic remedial instruction for up to two years, plus make-up of all missed OT sessions.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. Specific remedial program, two hours per day, in individual or small-group sessions, addressing phonemic awareness and sound/symbol correspondence. It continues until Student reaches grade equivalency or objective measures show he cannot be remediated, but for no more than two years from implementation. It is in addition to FAPE, and the district chooses the methodology.
- Compensatory education. Make-up OT for every session the district failed to provide to date, to be completed before the end of the 1999-2000 ESY unless the parties agree to extend for a reasonable period.
- Order to provide or change services. Continue OT one time per week for fifty minutes for as long as the IEP team decides it is necessary.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within two weeks of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to offer a placement with the components described in the decision, draft a consistent IEP, and set goals addressing Student's deficits.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School District v. Smith; Seattle School District v. B.S.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Bend-Lapine School District v. D.W.; Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education; Wilson v. Marana Unified School District; Murphy v. Timberlane Regional School District; Ridgewood Board of Education v. N.E.; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Todd v. Andrews
People named in the decision
- Sasha Borenstein, Director, independent assessor (obtained by District) and witness for Student, The Kelter Center
- Leah Ellenberg, Neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student, Private
- Renee Lewis, Marriage, family and child counselor (MFCC), witness for Student, Private
- Carl Goodman, Director, witness for Student, Summit View School
- Lynn Scar, Resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Cheryl Miller, School psychologist, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Gloria Myerson, Fifth grade general education teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Judi Underwood, Special day class teacher (fifth grade), Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Alyssa Williams, Special day class teacher (sixth grade), Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Abbe Shorr, Assistant principal, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Linda Jacobsen, Teacher of the visually impaired, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Bethany West, Speech and language pathologist, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Barbara Starr, School psychologist, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Joseph Nardo, Director of pupil services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Mary Ann Lowry, Resource specialist, academic assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Ms. Colbert, RSP aide, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Nancy Milburn, Educational advocate for District, Filarsky & Watt
- Janet Levine, Private tutor, Private
- Andrew Wang, Private therapist, Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1268-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Designated Instructionand Services Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-64683 District: Las Virgenes Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Calabasas, California, on July 14, 15, 16, 27, 28, 29, 30, September 28, 29, 30 (Footnote 1), October 1 and November 4 and 5, 1999.
Student (hereinafter Student or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Alexis Kashar with the law firm of Newman, Aaronson, Vanaman. Student's parents, Mr. and Mrs. Parent, were also present for the hearing.
Las Virgenes Unified School District (hereinafter Las Virgenes or District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arczynski with the law firm of Filarsky & Watt. Nancy Milburn, an educational advocate with the law firm of Filarsky & Watt, was present for a portion of one day of the hearing. Also present on Las Virgenes' behalf was Joseph Nardo, Las Virgenes' director of pupil services.
The Petitioner called the following witness to testify: Mrs. Parent, mother of Petitioner; Mr. Parent, father of Petitioner; Sasha Borenstein, director of the Kelter Center; Leah Ellenberg, PhD, neuropsychologist; Renee Lewis, marriage, family and child counselor (MFCC); the Petitioner; Carl Goodman, director of Summit View School; Lynn Scar, District resource specialist; and Cheryl Miller, District school psychologist. Dr. Ellenberg was recalled by the Petitioner on rebuttal. (The parties stipulated that those witnesses each intended to call would be subject to both direct and cross-examination at the same time to avoid the necessity of recalling them at a later date.)
Las Virgenes called the following witnesses to testify: Gloria Myerson, fifth grade regular education teacher; Judi Underwood and Alyssa Williams, special education teachers; Abbe Shorr, assistant principal; Linda Jacobsen, teacher of the visually impaired; Bethany West, speech and language pathologist; Barbara Starr, school psychologist; and Joseph Nardo, director of pupil services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received, the record was closed, and the issues were submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Petitioner's request for a due process hearing was filed on August 27, 1998. In a timely manner before the hearing, the Petitioner submitted his Statement of Issues listing the following issues to be adjudicated: (1) whether the District provided him with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the school years of 1996-97 through 1998-99, inclusive, (2) whether he was entitled to compensatory occupational therapy services (OT), and (3) whether he was entitled to reimbursement for private educational expenses. Although an IEP meeting had not yet been held, nor had a placement offer been made for the 1999-2000 school year, the Petitioner claimed for the first time when the hearing began that a further issue for the instant proceeding was whether he was entitled to a determination that he required placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) for the upcoming school year, 1999-2000. To support this contention, the Petitioner argued that the placement offer made by the District at the IEP meeting of September 28, 1998, as well as all modifications agreed to in subsequent IEP addendums for Student's sixth grade year, should also be construed as the placement offer for his seventh grade (1999-2000).
Las Virgenes responded that because placement for the 1999-2000 school year had not been placed at issue when this due process request was filed in August 1998, and had not been identified as an issue ten days before the hearing, it was not obligated to respond at the time of the hearing to this issue. Moreover, an offer of placement and services made for the Petitioner's sixth grade school year (1998-99) could not be construed as a placement offer for his seventh grade (1999-2000) school year.
The Hearing Officer agreed that a placement offer for one school year could not also be construed as the offer of placement for the following school year. The Hearing Officer therefore declined to address the issue of whether the Petitioner was entitled to placement in an NPS for the 1999-2000 school year.
In the interest of judicial economy, the Hearing Officer offered to postpone the current hearing to allow the parties to hold an IEP meeting to discuss next year's placement. The hearing could then reconvene following this IEP meeting and the issue of placement for the 1999-2000 school year could be joined as an additional issue, if necessary. The Respondent agreed to a postponement of the hearing and offered to convene an IEP meeting within twenty-five days. The Petitioner declined a postponement and elected to proceed with the hearing. He reserved the right to submit a legal brief on whether the current hearing could determine an appropriate placement for the 1999-2000 school year before a placement offer had been made at an IEP meeting. No brief was submitted by the Petitioner.
During the course of the hearing, the Petitioner's parents unilaterally placed him in a nonpublic school (NPS). The Parties stipulated that if either party filed another due process request for the 1999-2000 school year, that case would also be assigned to the current Hearing Officer, and all relevant evidence presented in the instant hearing would be incorporated into the future hearing to save time and avoid duplication.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District did not provide him with a FAPE for the 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. The Petitioner contends that he should be reimbursed for educational expenses privately provided in the past, and should receive compensatory occupational therapy (OT).
The District contends that at all times it provided Student with an appropriate education and that he made educational progress during the years at issue. It maintains that it has provided, and can continue to provide, Student with an appropriate program in the public school setting. Thus, it is not obligated to reimburse Mr. and Mrs. Parent for any private educational services. The District also asserts that numerous meetings were convened to address concerns raised by the parents and that changes were made to Student's program to accommodate parental demands. It argues that Student would have made even greater educational progress had his parents not repeatedly changed his programs, had they ensured compliance with homework assignments, and had they required Student to attend the before-school tutoring offered to him. The District further maintains that Student was frequently taken off the medication for his attention deficit disorder (ADD) and that this adversely impacted his education.
ISSUES
1. Did the District provide Student with a FAPE during the 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?
2. Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained educational services (tutoring and therapy) and materials during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?
3. Is Student entitled to compensatory OT services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is currently enrolled in the seventh grade for the 1999-2000 school year. He has been provided with special education services by Las Virgenes since he was identified with an attention disorder and a specific learning disability in the first grade. The last IEP fully agreed to by the parties was signed on April 28, 1997. Despite the parties' agreement with the IEPs in effect for the 1996-97 school year, the Petitioner contends that he has been denied a FAPE since that year (fourth grade).
Fourth Grade
When Student began the fourth grade, he was placed in a general education class with resource assistance in his classroom as needed. He also received pull-out services through the resource specialist program (RSP) for language arts and, if necessary, math. In March 1997, Student's IEP was changed through an addendum to add OT services one time per week to address visual-motor deficits. To respond to his academic difficulties, Student's RSP time for reading, math, and language arts was increased to 49% of the school day and the RSP teacher began modifying his homework assignments. He was also referred for a County Mental Health (CMH) assessment following the District's receipt of a report from Renee Lewis, MFCC. Ms. Lewis stated that Student displayed symptoms of depression, poor peer interactions, somatization, poor school performance, anger, and confusion. On April 29, 1997, Student's annual IEP meeting was held. At this meeting, it was specified that Student would be in an RSP class for language arts four times per week for forty-five minutes per session. He would spend another forty-five minutes, four times per week, in RSP for math. OT services remained once a week for fifty minutes. Goals and objectives were written and curriculum modifications were established. Student's parents agreed with, and signed, this IEP. At this meeting, Mr. and Mrs. Parent withdrew their consent for the CMH referral.
An addendum to the April 29, 1997 IEP was signed on June 2, 1997. This addendum continued Student's OT services during the extended school year (ESY). His parents asked that the District reactivate the referral for a CMH assessment, revoked their consent to the placement agreed upon at the April 29, 1997 IEP, sought funding for placement at an NPS, and requested additional support for keyboarding skills. The District agreed to make the CMH referral, maintained that its placement offer was appropriate, refused the request for an NPS, and advised the parents that it would explore the request for more keyboarding time.
Fifth Grade
When Student was in the fifth grade, his IEP of April 29, 1997 and its addendum of June 1997, were modified through another addendum dated November 20, 1997. This addendum provided that core literature books on tape be provided by the District for Student's use at home. He was also changed from an RSP class to a special day class (SDC) so that he could be provided with greater assistance in reading, writing, and spelling instruction (language arts). Mr. and Mrs. Parent agreed to initial Student's daily homework and to provide his teacher with information concerning difficulties with homework completion. Student's percentage of integration with the regular education students remained at 51%.
On January 28, 1998, Student's IEP was again modified. At this meeting Mr. and Mrs. Parent advised the IEP team that Student was taking a new medication, Wellbutrin, and that he had not been medicated for his ADD since October 1997. His OT time was rescheduled so that he would not miss recess with the regular education students. Because of increased difficulties and resulting frustration with the academics in the general education fifth grade class, Student was placed in the SDC for 88% of the school day. He remained integrated for science (with aide assistance provided in the regular class), physical education (P.E.), computers, and special activities and projects.
The next annual IEP meeting was held on April 24, 1998, when Student was in the eighth month of his fifth grade year. The District offered continued placement in the SDC, with OT services, and integration into general education 30% of the school day. It also offered an ESY program in an SDC. Mr. and Mrs. Parent rejected the District's placement offer and again requested funding for an NPS, which the District refused. On April 30, 1998, Student's parents sent the District the following demands: (1) ten hours per week of remediation in language arts, (2) five hours per week of math remediation, (3) five hours per week of computer technology, (4) one hour of one-on-one OT once a week, (5) all core social studies, literature, and science materials to be provided on tape, written assignments and testing to be dictated to an aide outside the classroom, integration with aide support in the regular education class for all core curriculum discussions, and homework to be limited to listening to tapes with modified assignments, (6) provision of a laptop computer, calculator, and tape recorder, (7) preferential seating, (8) modification of all of Student's assignments and tests as to length, format, time provided, completion of assignments/tests on a computer or audio tape, and (9) all of the above services to be provided in a general education class, not an SDC.
An IEP meeting was convened on May 14, 1998, to respond to the parents' requests. The District offered to return Student to RSP pull-out services for one hundred and twenty minutes per day, five days per week. In the RSP class, he would receive instruction in language arts and math. With special education support from the SDC and RSP staff, he would attend the general education class for core literature and language. His OT would remain one time per week for fifty minutes. As a result of the proposed program change, his integration with the regular education students would increase to 49% of the school day. Mr. and Mrs. Parent authorized this placement through June 10, 1998, but continued to express their disagreement and to request an NPS placement.
The IEP team met again and drafted another IEP on June 4, 1998. This IEP returned Student to the SDC each day for math, language arts, social studies, and science. His daily integration with his general education peers was reduced to 33%. The OT services remained unchanged. Pursuant to his parents' request, the District also agreed to conduct a complete assessment of Student to determine his needs as he transitioned to middle school the following year. Although Mr. and Mrs. Parent did not agree that the SDC was an appropriate placement for their son, they consented to its implementation pending due process proceedings.
The District's multi-disciplinary psychoeducational report was completed on July 15, 1998. The psychologist found a marked discrepancy between Student's verbal intelligence quota (IQ) score (101) and his performance IQ score (84) on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - III (WISC-III). She also noted a marked discrepancy between Student's current and prior IQ scores. When comparing IQ scores on the WISC-III to those of prior years, she found that Student had previously obtained the following scores: 1994 - verbal IQ of 126, performance IQ of 93; 1995 - verbal IQ of 112, performance IQ of 95; and 1997 - verbal IQ of 115, performance IQ of 93. The psychologist stated that Student was not medicated for his attention difficulties at the time of her testing, and hypothesized that the decline in his IQ scores was a consequence of ADD. She indicated that she had reviewed the literature and found that children with problems attending often showed variability in intellectual functioning. Discussions with Student's teacher confirmed that his classroom performance varied from day to day. The psychologist concluded that Student's actual intellectual functioning was within the above-average range for verbal and the average range for performance abilities, with significant problems in visual processing, attention, motor, and sequencing skills. She further noted a significant strength in Student's vocabulary, but significant weaknesses in arithmetic, visual sequential reasoning abilities, understanding of social situations, visual alertness, memory, and attention to detail. He displayed a very significant weakness in acquiring new symbolic material and utilizing visual motor coordination. It was noted by the psychologist that these are skills necessary for coding. Student also demonstrated very weak graphic-motor functioning. The psychologist concluded that Student continued to qualify for special education with a disorder in the basic psychological processes governing attention and visual processing. She did not find that he met the criteria for a seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) student.
An academic assessment was conducted by a District resource specialist. Student demonstrated strengths in both receptive and expressive language skills, with strong sequencing abilities. His composite scores on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) were: reading - 21st %, 3.9 grade equivalence; math - 13th %, 3.7 grade equivalence; language - 92nd %, 12.9 grade equivalence; and writing - 2nd %, 1.9 grade equivalence. According to the speech and language report, Student had average to above-average skills in expressive and receptive language when only auditory information was presented. However, when he was required to decipher written or visual symbols, his skills declined dramatically.
Sixth Grade
On August 31, 1998, the Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) received a request for a due process hearing from the Petitioner. While the case was off-calendar, the parties continued to participate in several IEP meetings. An IEP meeting was held when school resumed in the fall of 1998 to consider the assessments conducted during the summer. Student was beginning the sixth grade and had transitioned to his neighborhood middle school campus. At the IEP meeting of September 28, 1998, the District proposed placing Student in an SDC for social studies, language arts, science, and math. An elective and P.E. would be in general education classes. OT services would be provided for sixty minutes, one time per week. An assistive technology assessment had been conducted, and the District agreed to make appropriate software available to Student. Goals and objectives were written, and a list was developed specifying the curriculum modifications Student was to receive in each of his classes. Mrs. Parent signed the IEP, but wrote that she disagreed with the placement offered and was uncertain if she agreed with the goals and objectives proposed. Despite a disagreement with the tendered placement and an existing due process claim, the Petitioner did not seek a "stay-put" order from SEHO, nor did he immediately proceed with a hearing. Instead, Student attended middle school and the District provided the services enumerated in the IEP of September 28, 1998.
The parties met again on January 20, 1999, to draft an addendum to the September IEP. Although the District maintained that Student's existing program was appropriate, it consented to the parents' request to add science as an additional period in regular education. The special education staff would provide support and collaborate with the general education science teacher on the accommodations required by Student. The District agreed to obtain a screening for the FastForWord program as well as additional assessments from The Kelter Center, a vision specialist, and an assistive technology specialist. Las Virgenes again offered to refer Student to CMH for an initial assessment and to provide Student with school counseling once a week. The parents indicated that they would notify the District if they wanted either of these services. Three mornings a week, Student would receive forty-five minutes of before-school tutoring from the SDC teacher. The District also advised the parents that it would investigate the availability of additional lending libraries with books on tape and consider their request for two semesters of OT make-up sessions. The parties agreed that they would reconvene the IEP meeting after The Kelter Center had completed its assessment. Mrs. Parent signed this addendum without noting any disagreement.
On March 9, 1999, the parties reconvened the IEP meeting to review the assessment results and determine an appropriate placement. The assistive technology report was incomplete. It was determined that Student would be provided with an Alpha Smart computer until the technology evaluation was finished and additional recommendations were made. The vision specialist reported that Student was able to perform visual work very well. He had good tracking and scanning skills. He did have difficulty with losing his place when he did not know the words he was reading. Student's difficulties were found to be primarily the result of attention problems and an inability to decipher words, rather than vision deficits. A speech and language pathologist conducted the FastForWord screening and found that Student would not benefit as he had already mastered the tasks that are taught by the program. The Kelter Center reported that Student's phonemic awareness skills were very weak. His knowledge of sound symbol correspondences and phonology was adequate for consonants, but not for vowels. He did not know the rules that would assist him in deciphering the alphabetic code. When he was read to orally, his comprehension skills were age-appropriate. However, he was not accurate or fluent when reading and spelling words. Handwriting was very "labor intensive" for Student. Pursuant to the IEP addendum, the District agreed to investigate the personnel available to remediate Student's deficits in sound/symbol relationships and correspond with the Petitioner's attorney regarding an offer of placement and services.
When the parties were unable to agree upon an educational program for Student, this matter proceeded to hearing following Student's sixth grade year.
DISCUSSION
Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individual educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25).
In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or whether that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." Therefore, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or "potential-maximizing" education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) identifies and addresses the student's unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, and (3) conforms to the student's IEP. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et.seq.
ISSUE NUMBER ONE
Did the District provide Student with a FAPE during the 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?
1. 1996-97 School Year - Fourth Grade
Did the District identify and address Student's unique needs?
To determine whether the District addressed Student's needs during the 1996-97 school year, the Hearing Officer must first identify Student's unique needs during that time. Leah Ellenberg, PhD, is a board-certified neuropsychologist who first evaluated Student in 1995. During the 1995 evaluation, her testing revealed severe deficits in writing and perceptual motor integration, with moderate reading and spelling deficits. In February 1997, Mr. and Mrs. Parent again sought Dr. Ellenberg's opinion regarding Student's learning disabilities and requested her recommendations for his educational placement. Dr. Ellenberg testified that in 1997 Student continued to have a significant discrepancy between his verbal and performance abilities. He could read single words by sounding them out. However, he could not sound out nonsense words. Student did not always know the individual vowel sounds, and he had difficulties with the combination of two vowel sounds or two consonant sounds (i.e., ee or sp). He was not a fluent or functional reader for his grade level. He required three minutes to read an eight-sentence passage.
Dr. Ellenberg determined that Student had a moderate deficit in decoding and a severe deficit in his reading rate. Student's spelling skills were severely impaired and he displayed significant dysgraphia. It was very difficult for others to decipher Student's writing. He was unable to group letters to form words and there was no semblance of a narrative in his writing. Due to his good verbal skills, he could orally tell a story, but he was unable to write recognizable words. In all areas of written expression, Dr. Ellenberg testified that Student's scores were a least two standard deviations below his verbal potential. In the opinion of Dr. Ellenberg, Student had severe dyslexia and dysgraphia. She also testified that in contrast to Student's grade equivalent math skills in 1995, his math skills in 1997 had fallen below grade level. Student did not know all of his multiplication facts and he reversed numbers. Dr. Ellenberg did not conduct a formal psychological evaluation of Student in 1997, but noted that a familial history of depression was provided by the parents. Per parental report, he increasingly misbehaved at home, but not at school. Her observations during the evaluation were that he was a social and cooperative child. It was Dr. Ellenberg's opinion that Student's learning disabilities were too severe to be remediated through a public school program. She believed that he required placement at an NPS that specialized in learning disabilities. She stated that such nonpublic schools are designed to meet the academic, social, and emotional needs of bright children like Student with significant learning disabilities.
Renee Lewis, MFCC, first evaluated Student in 1994. He returned to see her in January 1997. At that time, Student scored within the depressed range on the Child Depression Inventory. Ms. Lewis stated that he demonstrated poor attention, listening ability, task initiation and completion skills, as well as distractibility. Student reported that his peers found his behavior inappropriate. Because he thought that his peers found him "stupid," he was experiencing negative interactions each school day. Consequently, he was lonely and despondent. Ms. Lewis testified that Student's difficulties in school caused him to be angry and frustrated. He behaved well in school, but at home he discharged his frustrations on his family. In her report dated March 5, 1997, Ms. Lewis stated that Student met the "criteria for Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and for severely emotionally disturbed (SED) designation." However, in her testimony she said that she was unaware of the legal definition of SED, and intended only to convey her finding that Student was "emotionally distraught, not legally SED." Ms. Lewis also reported that Student required preferential seating, "cueing" to refocus, a weekly assignment completion checklist, and test modifications such as tests read to him, oral answers allowed, and no time limitations. Additionally, he would benefit from access to a computer for written assignments, frequent breaks, shortened assignments, the use of a tape recorder, reduced class size, and one-on-one assistance. It was her opinion that Student needed an NPS to meet his emotional and academic needs. The Hearing Officer found that cross-examination decreased the persuasiveness of Ms. Lewis's testimony because it brought forth her limited involvement with Student. Ms. Lewis acknowledged that she did not conduct any testing on Student, other than the Child Depression Inventory. She also did not review any school psychoeducational reports, nor was she aware of the programs or modifications provided by the District. Her recommendations and opinions were based upon her sessions with Student, the report from Dr. Ellenberg, and information provided by Student and his parents. She did attend an IEP meeting and spoke with the school psychologist after her report was completed. The Hearing Officer therefore gives Ms. Lewis's testimony less weight then that of the witnesses who possessed greater knowledge of Student's actual school behavior and academic performance.
Lynn Scar is the District's RSP teacher who worked with Student in elementary school. Ms. Scar testified that Student's areas of disability were ADD and visual processing with fine motor deficits. These deficits caused difficulties with reading, writing, spelling, and handwriting. She stated that Student needed assistance with word practice, reading, following directions, locating clues in written material, vocabulary, and phonetic analysis. He also required extra help to grasp new math concepts, acquire better organizational skills, and respond to his fine motor difficulties. His homework, class assignments and tests required modifications.
Cheryl Miller, a District school psychologist, conducted a psychological evaluation of Student in April 1997. This assessment was part of a three-year reevaluation as well as a response to Ms. Lewis' report of January 1997 that stated Student qualified for §504 assistance as SED. Ms. Miller administered the following tests: Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (the WISC-III had recently been given by an independent evaluator and could not be reliably re-administered); Berry VMI, Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-R; My Self Check List; Burks' Behavior Rating Scale; Achenbach's Checklist; Reynold's Children Manifest Anxiety Scale; Behavior Evaluation Scale; Woodcock-Johnson Psycho- educational Battery Test of Achievement-R; Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test; and Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals 3. Ms. Miller also performed a classroom observation and obtained parent and teacher evaluations. On the Burks' Behavior Rating Scale, Student's mother gave him a very significant rating for poor academics and significant ratings in excessive dependency, withdrawal, poor physical strength, poor intellectuality, and poor attention. She rated all other areas as not significant. On the same rating scale, Student's teacher found Student to be in the average range in all areas except learning problems. She rated his behaviors in the average range. The results of the Children's Manifest Anxiety Scale indicated that Student was within the average range in all areas: physiological anxiety, worry/oversensitivity, social concerns/concentration, and life scale. Mrs. Parent responded that Student was not elevated in the Personality Inventory evaluation in any area other than adjustment and anxiety. On the My Self Checklist, Student denied any depression or concerns with school. He did indicate that he was concerned with social interactions and somatic complaints (stomachaches) were identified.
Based upon her assessment, Ms. Miller found that Student had been correctly diagnosed with ADD. She determined that he had some difficulties with listening skills, worked at a slower rate on paper/pencil tasks, reacted impulsively to difficult tasks, had visual processing deficits, low average visual motor skills, and problems with visual closure. Student's interaction with his classmates appeared positive and appropriate. His full scale cognitive score was within the average range, with a sixteen-point discrepancy between his above average verbal IQ score and his average performance score. Ms. Miller further concluded that Student was not depressed and he did not meet the California Education Code requirement for SED. He had no behaviors to a marked degree existing over a long period of time that interfered with his education, no learning difficulties that could not be explained by intellectual factors, and no inability to maintain interpersonal relationships. Consequently, it was the opinion of Ms. Miller that Student did not need consistent DIS counseling as part of his IEP. The parents were advised, however, that she was on campus two- and-a-half days per week, and "as needed" counseling was available if Student required it for any reason. Although Ms. Miller had found no indication of major emotional problems, in response to the independent report from Ms. Lewis regarding Student's emotional status, she offered the family a referral to County Mental Health (CMH). Mr. and Mrs. Parent first agreed to this referral, then withdrew their consent.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District witnesses who actually worked with Student more informative then that of Dr. Ellenberg or Ms. Lewis. The Petitioner's expert witnesses had comparatively infrequent contact with Student, limited educational information, and relied primarily on parental reporting concerning his status. Therefore, following a consideration of the above evidence, it is determined that the District correctly identified Student's unique needs in the areas of attention, visual processing, and fine motor skills. He had difficulties with decoding, phonetic analysis, graphic expression and math. As a result, Student required weekly OT and small-group instruction with intensive systematic remediation in phonemic awareness, sound/symbol relationships, phonics, and written language. He required assistive technology in the form of access, both at home and at school, to a computer with spell check, dictation equipment/tape recorder, and books on tape. Student also needed to participate with his regular education peers to challenge his normal cognitive abilities and encourage social relationships. Thus, he required a program that consisted of RSP pull-out and mainstreaming in a general education class. It was necessary to modify the general education curriculum to accommodate Student's disabilities. These modifications would include confirmation that he understood instructions and lessons, allowing him to provide oral rather than written responses, preferential seating, shortened and/or modified assignments, computer access, books on tape with a tape player, and extra time to complete his work when necessary.
To address these needs, the District initially provided small-group RSP pull-out from his regular education class four times a week for forty-five minutes per session in addition to forty-five minutes of one-on-one RSP twice a week. In April 1997, Student's RSP pull-out was increased to a total of ninety minutes per day, four times a week (49% of the school day) to provide reading, math and written language. His tests were given in the RSP room so the necessary modifications could be instituted. In the RSP class, Ms. Scar utilized the Herman Method reading program to systematically teach decoding skills. The Herman program is a multi-modality approach to remediate phonemic analysis and teach sight words. It also addresses fine motor handwriting difficulties, and responds to capitalization, spelling and punctuation needs. Ms. Scar worked with Student on coherent organization of his work papers. She testified that she provided Student with books on tape from the core curriculum, a tape recorder, and access to a computer with a spell check system. Because Student had strong verbal skills, he was allowed to dictate his ideas and test answers. In math, Ms. Scar provided additional assistance with the new concepts being introduced in the regular fourth grade class. She gave Student multiplication charts, a calculator, and shortened assignments. To develop better organizational skills, Ms. Scar created assignment sheets, supervised the categorization of his materials by subject, and helped him maintain his desk in a neat and assessable manner. Although Ms. Scar testified that Student's homework frequently was not done, she ensured that assignments went home with him, and provided any necessary books on tape or technical devices required to complete his homework. Ms. Scar also testified that she met daily with Student's general education teacher to analyze his current needs and modify his curriculum.
All parties agreed during an IEP meeting held in March 1997 that Student should also receive OT services to address his fine motor problems. At that meeting, OT for fifty minutes one time a week to respond to his visual motor deficits was added through an IEP addendum. Although this service was to be implemented upon its inclusion in Student's IEP, it was not immediately, or consistently, provided.
In summary, during the fourth grade, the District initially provided forty-five- minute small-group sessions of daily RSP four times per week, with two additional forty-five-minute individual RSP sessions weekly. When Student required more assistance, his RSP program was increased to 49% of his school day. At all times, the RSP teacher collaborated with his general education teacher, assisted in his class and modified his curriculum. Thus, he was receiving an appropriate combination of regular education and RSP support. Student's RSP teacher was also utilizing a specific program to address his difficulties in language arts entitled the Herman Method. This was important as Student required access to a systematic, coherent program that addressed his underlying deficiencies in phonemic awareness, sound/symbol relationships, phonics, and written language. Such knowledge is necessary to provide the foundation upon which more complex skills can be added in the higher grades. The Herman Method had not fully remediated Student's deficits by the end of fourth grade. However, it was providing him with access to the type of program he needed, and may have resulted in further success had it been continued during the subsequent school years. Student did not receive all of the OT services enumerated in his IEP. As will be discussed below, the Hearing Officer does not find that this alone resulted in a denial of a FAPE. It is therefore concluded that, with the exception of consistent OT services, the District identified and responded to Student's needs during the fourth grade.
Did the District's placement provide Student with educational benefit?
Dr. Ellenberg testified that when Student's 1997 test scores were compared to his prior test results, he had made "some progress" academically. She also stated that he remained two or more years behind his peers in reading and writing skills, and he was not making the academic progress that his peers had made in the same time period. On cross-examination, Dr. Ellenberg was asked to compare Student's scores on the Woodcock Johnson-R (WJ) from 1994 to those of 1997. She confirmed that in reading, his grade equivalence had increased from K.6 to 3.5; in math, his score had increased from a grade equivalence of 1.9 to 4.3; and in written language the increase in grade equivalence was from 1.0 to 2.9. Dr. Ellenberg acknowledged that this showed that Student had received educational benefit from the District programs. Dr. Ellenberg also testified that based upon the resources available, Student's school had done an outstanding job of modifying his curriculum and offering him the maximum resource assistance available. However, she testified that Student's disabilities were so severe that his needs could not be met through any public school program and that he required placement in an NPS that specialized in teaching dyslexic students.
Ms. Scar reported that, in comparing the Woodcock-Johnson given in April 1997 and the one administered in 1995, Student had made one and one-half years' growth in reading. However, when reading without contextual cues (sight reading or phonetically decoding), he could read only at the mid-second-grade level. His overall reading scores were in the low average range. Student easily comprehended fourth-grade literature. His math calculation and problem solving abilities were within the average range. Memorizing math facts and learning new concepts continued to be difficult for him. Although he showed one and a half year growth in written expression, written language continued to be Student's greatest difficulty. His spelling was slightly higher than the prior testing with a grade level of 2.8.
Student himself testified that he had a good fourth grade year. He said that both Ms. Scar and her aide, Ms. Colbert, provided him with beneficial RSP assistance. He also emphasized that his general education teacher "really applied herself" to helping him, so he "got it."
Ms. Lewis testified that public school was not meeting Student's psychological needs. In her opinion, Student had "given up" on school and was frustrated with his situation. He thought the other students found him "stupid" and, hence, he experienced negative interactions five days a week. She found that Student had decreased self-esteem, was frustrated, and felt hopeless that his school environment would improve. Based upon her experiences with other children with similar disabilities, she predicted that Student could develop problems with substance abuse or legal troubles as he aged. She also stated that, although he currently misbehaved only at home, he might begin to act out at school in the future. Thus, she recommended an NPS placement at a school where the students had difficulties similar to those experienced by Student.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Lewis' testimony extremely speculative in describing Student's potential emotional status. Moreover, Ms. Lewis acknowledged that Student did not currently display emotional or behavioral problems at school that comported with the SED requirements contained in California Education Code §3030(i). Her report was also contrary to the findings of the District's comprehensive psychological evaluation. The Hearing Officer accepts the testimony of the Petitioner's other expert witness, Dr. Ellenberg, as well as that of Ms. Scar, who found that, based upon objective criteria, Student had made some academic progress and, as a consequence, received educational benefit from the District's program.
The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Ellenberg and Ms. Lewis appeared to misinterpret the District's legal obligation to provide Student with an appropriate educational program. Both Dr. Ellenberg and Ms. Lewis opine that an NPS would have provided a better environment to address Student's emotional needs and his specific learning disabilities. However, provision of the best education is not what the law requires from public education. A school district is obligated to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to an education and some resulting benefit. A district is not obligated to provide the best education or to maximize a student's abilities. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (supra). Additionally, as long as a district offers a FAPE, it need not place a student in a program preferred by the parents, even if that program may provide greater educational benefit. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987).
The District admits that it failed to provide all of the OT sessions specified in Student's IEP. However, the Hearing Officer does not find that this failure to furnish all of the OT sessions constituted a denial of a FAPE. A failure to institute a portion of an IEP, which does not result in a denial of educational opportunity, does not rise to the level of a violation of a FAPE. Bend- Lapine School District v. D.W., 152 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. 1998). (See also Board of Education of Montgomery County v. Brett Y., 155 F.3d 557 (4th Cir. 1998); Burke County Board of Education v. Denton, 895 F.2d 977 (4th Cir. 1990); W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). Student's OT goals were primarily to assist him with fine motor handwriting skills and the use of scissors Although Student should have received the OT services as specified in his IEP, he did work on his fine motor skills in his classes on a consistent basis. Thus, the missed OT sessions are not found to have had such a severe impact that they caused a denial of a FAPE. OT was added to Student's IEP on March 5, 1997. His OT services did not begin until May 5, 1997, and thereafter sessions were periodically missed. Although the District provided a FAPE, the loss of OT services was an area of deficiency. Thus, the District must calculate the number of sessions that were not provided due to the District's unavailability, and make up those OT sessions in a manner that accommodates both the District's and the Petitioner's schedules before the end of the current extended school year (ESY), unless the parties agree to extend the time frame.
Did the District's services conform to Student's IEP?
It has previously been discussed that the District neglected to provide some OT services included in Student's IEP, and he is entitled to receipt of those missed sessions. The parties disagreed over relatively minor issues contained in the IEP, such as whether an adequate supply of books on tape was made available, and whether each and every classroom modification was consistently provided. However, there were no substantial contentions that the District failed to provide a program that comported with Student's IEP and its addendums. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the services given to Student by Las Virgenes adequately conformed to his IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Las Virgenes met the legal standards imposed upon school districts and provided Student with access to an education that met his needs and resulted in some educational benefit. Even if his progress was not as rapid as his parents would have wished, it is concluded that in the two years between the administration of the Woodcock- Johnson, Student made one and a half years of growth in overall reading and written language. This did not remediate him to grade level, but it also was not de minimis growth. That he missed OT sessions was not, in itself, a violation that deprived him of educational benefit. Because the District's services during Student's fourth grade met his needs, provided educational benefit, it is concluded the District provided Student with a FAPE for the 1996-97 school year.
2. 1997-98 School Year - Fifth Grade
Did the District identify and address Student's unique needs and provide educational benefit?
The primary controversy between the parties for this school year was the effectiveness of the various District programs offered to Student. The District contends that both the SDC and the RSP services met Student's unique needs and that either would have resulted in enhanced educational benefit had the parents allowed him to remain in one program or the other. It is the District's position that before either the SDC or the RSP program was given an opportunity for full implementation, the parents demanded frequent changes in Student's enrollment. The District further alleges that Student's progress was thwarted by his parents' failure to provide him with medication for his ADD and to ensure his completion of homework assignments. The parents maintain that they requested program changes because the District's services were inadequate to meet their son's needs. They also point out that the District consistently agreed to these changes, which indicates that they must have been appropriate. To provide a framework for addressing the educational benefit to Student from the District's programs, the Hearing Officer briefly revisits the IEP changes requested by the parents, and agreed to by the District, during Student's fifth grade year. (See the Background Facts for a more detailed discussion of Student's 1997-98 programs.)
Student began the fifth grade receiving weekly OT with ninety minutes a day of RSP pull-out services for language arts and math four days per week, as described in his fourth grade IEP of April 29, 1997. Throughout this school year, Mr. and Mrs. Parent repeatedly advised the District that they felt Student's program was inappropriate. The District responded by convening multiple IEP meetings which resulted in changes in Student's program. The IEP of April 29, 1997 was modified through an addendum dated November 20, 1997. This addendum changed Student's instruction in language arts from the RSP class to a special day class (SDC) following a determination by the IEP team that he required greater remediation in decoding and a higher level of teacher monitoring to meet his IEP goals. After this change, Student was mainstreamed for 51% of his school day.
On January 28, 1998, the IEP team again modified Student's IEP. Due to increasing difficulties with academics, Student was placed in the SDC for 88% of the school day to receive instruction in math, literature, language arts, spelling, and social studies. He was mainstreamed for science (with aide assistance provided in the regular class), physical education, computers, and special activities and projects. At the January meeting, Mr. and Mrs. Parent informed the IEP team that Student had been prescribed Wellbutrin by his physician. They further advised the school that they had stopped his medication for ADD in October 1997. Student's OT time was rescheduled so that he would not miss recess with the regular education students.
At an IEP meeting on April 24, 1998, the IEP team reviewed Student's present levels of performance, drafted annual goals and continued his SDC placement with integration into the regular fifth grade class. An extended school year program (ESY) in an SDC class was offered. On April 30, 1998, Mr. and Mrs. Parent sent a letter to the District demanding that Student be removed from the SDC and returned to the general education class with specified support services. The parents testified that they were particularly concerned that the other SDC students' disabilities were more significant than Student's, and that consequently the academics and socialization were inappropriate. Student testified that in the SDC he "felt something was wrong with me because I was stuck with kids with really serious mental problems." Ms. Miller testified that the SDC was a "noncategorical SDC," which meant that the students had a range of disabilities. She also stated that there was only one SDC on campus and it serviced students from the first through the fifth grade. Judith Underwood, the SDC teacher, testified that her eleven students consisted of one with Down's Syndrome, three on the Autism spectrum, and the remainder diagnosed with various specific learning disabilities. She had two aides in her classroom and an additional aide assigned to one specific child.
An IEP meeting to respond to the parents' letter requesting that Student be exited from the SDC was convened on May 14, 1998. The District agreed that Student would be removed from the SDC and, instead, would receive RSP pull-out services for two hours per day, five days per week. In the RSP class, he would be provided with instruction in language arts and math. He would attend the general education class for core literature and core language with support from the special education staff. OT services would remain the same. As a result of the proposed program change, his integration with his regular education classmates increased to 49% of the school day. Mr. and Mrs. Parent authorized this placement through June 10, 1998, but continued to disagree with the District's placement offer and requested an NPS placement.
Following a determination by both the parents and the District that Student required greater remediation and support than was available from the RSP program and general education, the IEP team drafted another IEP on June 4, 1998, that returned Student to the SDC each day for math, language arts, social studies, and science. His integration with the general education students was reduced to 33%. The OT services remain unchanged. Mr. and Mrs. Parent agreed to this program pending the resolution of due process proceedings, which remained off calendar until the commencement of this hearing in July 1999.
The parties presented a great deal of evidence regarding whether or not various test results and evaluations established that Student had received some benefit from the education provided by the District during the 1997-98 school year. The District presented testimony and test scores intended to establish that he had received educational benefit from its services. The Petitioner's experts and lay witnesses countered that any benefit was inconsequential and the District did not respond to Student's underlying problems. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet Student's needs or provide Student with meaningful educational benefit during this school year. His program was changed too frequently and he did not receive a coherent methodology designed to address his specific disabilities. More importantly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not satisfy its duty to offer Student an appropriate placement.
The Hearing Officer provides the following detailed statutory authority and case law to emphasize that it has been firmly established by the courts that both federal and State special education legislation impose a duty upon school districts to offer appropriate educational placements to handicapped children. (See Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (supra) and its progeny.) California Education Code §56342.5 specifies that educational agencies "shall ensure that the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs." However, courts have repeatedly held that the requirement of parental participation in placement decisions does not relieve a district of its independent obligation to offer what it determines is an appropriate educational placement for a disabled student. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493 (9th Cir. 1996) and A.S. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 34 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir. 1994) each requires school districts to show the appropriateness of their proposed placement. Rowley, (supra), Bachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290 (7th Cir. 1988), and A.W. v. Northwest R-1 School District, 813 F.2d 158 (8th Cir.1987) are examples of cases that have upheld the principle that the responsibility for selecting educational methodologies rests with the school district, not the parents. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994) held that "a school district cannot escape its obligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate educational placement by arguing that a disabled child's parents expressed unwillingness to accept that placement." If a student is given an inappropriate program preferred by the parents over one that the District knows is appropriate, the student may be entitled to compensatory education. "A student's right to compensatory education accrues when the school knows or should have known that the student is receiving an inappropriate education." Rigewood Board of Education v. N.E., 30 IDELR 41 (3rd Cir. 1990). It has also been held that it is a district's responsibility to offer an appropriate education over a parental preference for another program that will not provide educational benefit. Wilson v. Marand Unified School District No. 6 of Pima County, 735 F.2d 1178 (9th Cir. 1984); Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290 (7th Cir. 1988).
In the present case, the District attempts to walk a fine line between alleging that Student's performance was less than anticipated because his parents repeatedly insisted upon changing his program, and contending that each of the parents' requested changes were acceptable and therefore the frequent IEP changes were appropriate. Contrary to this latter assertion, most of the District witnesses testified to the negative impact of the multiple IEP modifications. Ms. Miller, the psychologist, testified that the numerous changes in Student's delivery models resulted in inadequate time for him to benefit from any specific program and that it would have been better for him to have had a sustained delivery method. She further said that the SDC program was appropriate for Student and stated,"why move him if it was successful? It was the right program for him. For Student that (SDC) was the least restrictive environment based upon his needs in specific areas."
Ms. Miller testified that she never understood how Mrs. Parent could initially be satisfied with the SDC program, then only three weeks later want Student removed. She said that she personally observed, and the SDC teacher reported to her, that Student was happy and responsive in the SDC. His work samples also showed benefit. Based upon her experience as a school psychologist, she concluded that Student probably would have shown increased progress without so many program changes. When asked if she ever disagreed with any of the program changes requested by the parents, she responded that she had not because there were different ways of servicing students while accommodating the parents. However, she thought it would have been best for Student to have had less change, and the District staff felt Student's needs were too great to be met through RSP pull- out.
Ms. Underwood, Student's SDC teacher, testified that she believed that the SDC was appropriate for Student, that he should have remained in her SDC class, and that he should not have been returned to the RSP program. She found that while Student was in her class, his demeanor improved, he felt positive about himself, he was comfortable with the pace and not overwhelmed as he had been in his prior program, his handwriting was more controlled, and he became a stronger reader. Ms. Underwood further testified that her opinion that Student was appropriately placed in her program was strong enough to motivate her to write a letter to his file stating that it was inappropriate to change his SDC placement. She did not, however, assert her disagreement with Student's removal from her class at the IEP meeting that resulted in Student's change to a general education class with RSP services.
Beth West is a District speech and language pathologist who worked with Student in fifth grade as part of the special education staff who provided him with RSP support in reading and language arts. She testified that Student was having increasing difficulties in the regular education class even with substantial RSP support, and she agreed with his placement in the SDC. Joseph Nardo, the District's director of pupil services, testified that he advised the special education staff to consider Mr. and Mrs. Parents' requests for program changes and to implement them if they felt the changes were appropriate.
When specifically questioned concerning the agreement to IEP modifications that appeared contrary to the District's staffs' opinions regarding the appropriate educational program for Student, the District's witnesses stated that there were different methods of meeting a special education child's needs. Either the RSP or SDC program would have been beneficial to Student had they been sustained. The Hearing Officer is not at all persuaded by this explanation. Although it may be understandable for a district's staff to attempt to accommodate parental requests, this is not the criterion for determining whether a FAPE has been offered or provided. Whether the District felt that Student's needs could not be accommodated in his RSP class, or that either the SDC or RSP programs would have been beneficial if consistently implemented, it is clear that, at a minimum, it did not find it appropriate for his program to be frequently changed. Moreover, the Hearing Officer found the candid testimony by some of Student's educators compelling when they testified that Student needed to remain in the SDC to meet his unique educational needs. When Student's parents wanted to remove him from this program, the District should have asserted its position that Student's needs necessitated an SDC and filed for due process. California law mandates that a district institute a due process hearing if a parent will not consent to the proposed program that the District has determined "is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil." California Code §56346(b). See also Murphy v. Timberlane Regional School District, 22 F.3d 1186 (1st Cir. 1994).
Did the District's services conform to Student's IEP?
This is not an area of significant dispute.
It is concluded that during the fifth grade Student continued to have difficulties with visual processing, attending, and fine motor skills. Although the District began providing the systematic program in the fourth grade which Student needed to respond to his disabilities, this program was abandoned. Consequently, his severe deficiencies in decoding, phonetic analysis, graphic expression and math had not yet been adequately addressed or remediated and he continued to require a specific methodology designed to teach the skills he lacked. Student still did not possess an adequate foundation in fundamental reading and writing skills, and he did not have a solid basis upon which to add the skills required in each higher grade. This resulted in an increasing discrepancy between him and his age peers. Thus, Student's need for a consistent program that provided him with a genuine opportunity to remediate the basic reading and writing skills he lacked continued to be extremely important as the age-appropriate knowledge required of him became more demanding. (See the discussion below of the findings by Dr. Borenstein.) Arguably, an opportunity for intensive remediation in phonemic awareness, sound/symbol relationships, phonics, and written language became more critical each year because Student did not have the rudimentary knowledge upon which to add the more complex information presented in each upper grade. Thus, he fell farther behind as he advanced through the grades. Rather than continue a specific program designed to respond to Student's deficits and establish the foundation he lacked, the District agreed to multiple program changes and provided an eclectic methodology. The Hearing Officer finds that Student's unique needs were not addressed by this approach, nor did he receive educational benefit. For these reasons, it is concluded that the District did not provide Student with a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year.
3. 1998-99 School Year-Sixth Grade
Did the District identify and address Student's unique needs?
The District's witnesses testified regarding the multi-disciplinary psychoeducational report the District completed on July 15, 1998, which assessed Student's disabilities and consequent educational needs. Because this assessment was completed so late in the fifth grade, it actually provided information upon which to base an offer of placement for Student's sixth grade year. The school psychologist, Barbara Starr, testified that her tests revealed significant weaknesses in the skills necessary for coding and very weak graphic-motor functioning. Ms. Starr also testified that the 1998 WISC-III continued to show a discrepancy between Student's verbal and performance IQ scores. She further noted a decline each year in Student's IQ scores. In 1994 he had a verbal IQ of 126 and a performance IQ of 93. In 1995 his verbal IQ was 112 with a performance IQ of 95. His 1997 scores were a verbal IQ of 115 and a performance IQ of 93. By 1998, his verbal IQ was 101 and his performance IQ was 84. Ms. Starr testified that the decline in IQ could be the result of Student's being unmedicated for his ADD when the testing was conducted. Dr. Ellenberg disagreed with Ms. Starr's hypothesis and testified that it was not a valid explanation. Student had been off his ADD medication during prior IQ tests and his scores had not been adversely affected. Dr. Ellenberg believed the decline in Student's IQ scores was indicative of a failure to acquire additional knowledge. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Ellenberg's explanation more credible.
Mary Ann Lowry was the resource specialist who conducted the academic portion of the multi- disciplinary assessment. She found that Student demonstrated strengths in both receptive and expressive language skills, with strong sequencing abilities. On the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), his composite reading and math scores were within the range of a third- grader, his language grade equivalent was 12.9, and his writing ability was similar to that of a child in the ninth month of first grade. According to the speech and language evaluation, Student's expressive and receptive language was average to above-average when only auditory information was presented. However, when required to decipher written or visual symbols, his skills declined dramatically. The multi-disciplinary team determined that Student required weekly OT and small- group instruction with intensive remediation in phonemic awareness, sound/symbol relationships, phonics, and written language.
Again, the testimony of both parties' witnesses, and the July 1998 assessment, established that Student's unique needs were based upon the same disabilities and resulting deficits as previously identified. During this school year, additional information was also obtained when the District obtained an independent assessment of Student's needs from Sasha Borenstein PhD. Dr. Borenstein is the director of the Kelter Center, which works with adults and children with learning problems. She evaluated Student in February 1999 to determine what he required to gain reading fluency.
Dr. Borenstein explained that the "interface of language skills and reading" requires the following: phonology awareness; reading and spelling of individual words; morphology; an understanding of syllables and affixes which change the meaning of words such as plurals, tenses, semantics, syntax, and grammar; pragmatics; and discourse or understanding of complex information. She further clarified that phonology involves the process of phonemic awareness, blending, and sound/symbol correspondence which enables an individual to read and spell. Morphology is the understanding of the segments of words which modify the root word. Discourse is the more complex ability to link words into meaningful relationships to form sentences and paragraphs.
Dr. Borenstein testified that Student was deficient in the above-described skills. He lacked phonemic awareness and could not decode words. He could only read those words that he had memorized. He was not able to discriminate where or how sounds changed, nor was he able to map sounds and letters. Because he could not decipher words independently, he did not have the ability to "read to learn." He worked so hard at trying to decode words that his mental energy was depleted, which decreased his ability to comprehend the reading materials. The effect of these disabilities was that he required strategies and processes for reading that taught him phonemic awareness, the development of sound/symbol correspondence, phonics, and sight vocabulary. He then needed to practice these skills to gain reading fluently. Furthermore, these capabilities needed to be taught with a systematic, explicit methodology. Dr. Borenstein testified that the type of program Student required should initially focus on teaching him sound/symbol relationships in a multi-sensory manner. He must develop phonemic awareness that will enable him to pull words apart, then put the individual sounds back together, break sounds and words into segments, auditorily blend, and then be able to consistently apply these techniques to real words. When these skills are mastered, Student's program should next teach him the rules of phonics. After Student has learned to encode and decode phonetically, he will need to develop a sight vocabulary and visual memorization strategies to respond to phonetically irregular words. Another important aspect of Student's program will be to develop the ability to visualize and retrieve words quickly to enhance his spelling and reading fluency.
For writing remediation, Dr. Borenstein again recommended a program that emphasizes a sequential and systematic approach. She stated that such a program should focus first on the organization of ideas, then address sentence structure, followed by drafting paragraphs and then essays. It should also address editing and revision skills. Due to the physical difficulties Student has with writing, Dr. Borenstein recommended that Student be allowed to use a computer to type his work. These recommendations were not offered to Student or implemented by the District.
Alissa Williams, Student's sixth grade SDC teacher for 67% of his school day during most of the sixth grade, testified regarding the program Student received in the SDC. Rather than a program such as the one recommended by Dr. Borenstein, the District employed what Ms. Williams described as a "multi-model" approach to address Student's disabilities. She stated that she addressed Student's need to learn phonetic awareness by incorporating methods for sounding out words into her class language and social study lessons. During her lessons, she also discussed the sounds made by each letter in the alphabet and compared "sound families" to each other. The rules of phonics were incorporated into all class activities. Ms. Williams testified that she spent five to ten minutes of direct instruction with Student each day working on language arts. Because she felt that Student had greater potential than he displayed, she also offered additional small- group tutoring before school began. Student's attendance for this extra tutoring was very sporadic. This program did not provide the systematic approach that Student required to remediate his learning disabilities.
Dr. Borenstein identified and analyzed the source of Student's ongoing problems with a depth and knowledge that the Hearing Officer found extremely compelling. Dr. Borenstein was further found to be without bias toward either party, and that fact enhanced the believability of her testimony. She also added extensive information concerning Student's unique educational needs that was very helpful to the Hearing Officer. The Hearing Officer therefore accepts Dr. Borenstein's testimony as persuasive in providing an accurate depiction of the type of program Student required to address his unique needs. Following a consideration of all of the evidence, it is concluded that Student did not receive adequate basic reading remediation upon which he could build more complex skills. His immediate need was to first acquire a fundamental reading foundation to which he could later add more sophisticated knowledge. The District's eclectic remediation method, as described by Ms. Williams, did not effectively address the deficiencies underlying Student's learning disabilities. It also did not provide the systematic, structured program that he required to remediate the gaps in his reading. Consequently, the District did not adequately address Student's unique needs.
Although the District is entitled to determine the specific methodology to be utilized to address Student's needs (Lechman v. Illinois, 852 F.2d 290 (7th Cir. 1988), the Hearing Officer agrees with the testimony of Dr. Borenstein and finds that the program offered should have included two to three hours of intensive, daily remediation that addressed his needs as described herein. This instruction should have been provided either individually or in a small group through a specific, systematized program, and, because Student is older, also should have responded to any self-esteem issues. At the same time, he continued to require instruction in age-appropriate core curriculum. This could have been incorporated into the systematic program chosen by the District, with necessary modifications in the general education classes. The adaptations should have included extra time, someone to read information to him, test questions provided orally rather than in writing, recording oral answers to tests, and decreased assignments.
Did the District's placement provide Student with educational benefit?
Ms. Williams testified that Student met all of his math IEP goals and partially met his language arts goals. She stated that Student read at a second-to third-grade level when he entered her class and later read at a fourth-grade level. She found that before spring break (after which Student's attitude became negative), his work samples improved, as did his peer relationships and his attitude toward school. As a result, it was her opinion that Student gained educational benefit during his sixth grade year.
Mr. Nardo instructed Ms. Starr and Ms. Miller to compile charts to allow comparison of Student's various Woodcock-Johnson Achievement scores between the years of 1994 through 1997. These District graphs showed increased scores in broad math from 98 in 1994 to 100 in 1997; broad reading scores from 58 in 1994 to 93 in 1997; and broad written language from 70 in 1994 to 87 in 1997. Mr. Nardo, Ms. Starr, and Ms. Miller each testified that this showed academic growth over these years. However, the District's charts did not include the test results for 1998 (6th grade). This information was elicited through oral testimony. The July 1998 test results established that although Student's broad math score had been 98 in 1994, it had declined to 83 by 1998. His broad reading scores had increased from 58 in 1994 to 88 in 1998, and broad written language remained at 70 for both 1994 and 1998.
Dr. Borenstein found that Student's phonemic awareness skills were at a first-grade level. His score on the Woodcock-Johnson Word Attack subtest was also at a first-grade level. On spelling and oral reading tests, his grade equivalent was 3.6. He had adequate knowledge of phonology and sound/symbol correspondence for the majority of the consonants, but not for the vowels. His silent reading and comprehension scores were the equivalent of fourth- or fifth-grade students. His listening comprehension skills were average. On the Gray Oral Reading Test, his reading rate grade equivalency was 2.5, his accuracy was at a 2.9 grade level, his passage score was 2.7, and his comprehension rate was the equivalent of the fourth month of the fourth grade. However, he was neither an accurate, fluent, nor an effortless reader. Dr. Borenstein further testified that several of Student's 1998-99 IEP goals were inappropriate. As a result, he was working on IEP goals that did not address his unique needs, and consequently did not confer educational benefit. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's placement did not confer the benefit required by law.
Did the District's services conform to Student's IEP?
The District provided the services as specified in the IEPs and various addendums.
Based upon all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District again did not provide Student with the consistent methodology he required to address his unique needs. As discussed in the background facts, additional program changes were agreed to that contributed to the lack of a consistent program. Student began middle school pursuant to an IEP that provided all of his academics in an SDC. He was integrated into general education for two electives per day. In January 1999, an IEP addendum changed his science class from the SDC to regular education. Although these were not the frequent changes that occurred during prior years, they did cause disruption for a child who required consistency. Additionally, the absence of a specific remedial program two to three hours per day (such as the Herman Method provided in fourth grade) resulted in a failure to provide some meaningful educational benefit to Student during the 1998-99 school year. Because the District did not meet Student's needs or provide him with educational benefit, it is concluded that the District failed to provide Student a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.
ISSUE NUMBER TWO Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained educational services (tutoring and therapy) and materials during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?
To receive reimbursement for independent services provided, parents must establish that the services they obtained were appropriate under the IDEA and that they were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. IDEA § 1412 (a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. 300.403(c); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). When considering the appropriateness of the services obtained for their child for purposes of reimbursement, parents are not required to obtain the best possible services to be entitled to reimbursement. They also are not held to the same standard of providing an appropriate program as are school districts. Their choice must be designed, however, to meet the student's unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).
The Petitioner's request for reimbursement for the private tutoring provided by Janet Levine during the 1996-97 school year is denied. The District was found to have provided a FAPE during that school year. Morever, Mrs. Parent testified that Student did not benefit from Ms. Levine's tutoring. The Hearing Officer also does not find sufficient evidence that Student required psychological therapy and, therefore, reimbursement for the services provided by both Ms. Lewis and Dr. Andrew Wang is also denied. (It is noted that Dr. Wang did not provide evidence pertaining to any therapy provided to Student.) Moreover, the District offered a referral to CMH, which the parents ultimately declined, and counseling as needed upon parental request. The Hearing Officer also finds adequate evidence that the District provided access to educationally necessary books on tape and therefore does not find that reimbursement for any audio books purchased by the parents is justified.
ISSUE NUMBER THREE
Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory occupational therapy and other relief?
In his Statement of Issues the Petitioner only requested compensatory OT. However, courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court (and by extension, a hearing officer), to grant such "relief as it determines is appropriate." Thus, the fact that the Petitioner did not specify a request for other compensatory education does not preclude the Hearing Officer from awarding it if the facts so warrant. "The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services." Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. "Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court's resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." Student W. V. Puyallup, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child's lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
The Hearing Officer has determined that Student's unique needs were not properly addressed during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. Because the District did not provide Student with a FAPE during these two school years, he is entitled to compensatory education. The Hearing Officer finds, based on the persuasive testimony of Dr. Borenstein, that the compensatory education Student requires is two hours per day of individual or small-group instruction which provides a comprehensive, systematic remedial program to address his lack of phonemic awareness and other resulting deficits as discussed in detail above. The District may determine the specific methodology to provide this program. However, it must be a coherent, integrated, single program of the type described by Dr. Borenstein, which responds to Student's language art needs in a manner that begins with the basics and ascends to more complex skills until he attains grade equivalency or establishes that he is unable to fully acquire these skills. It is noted that Dr. Borenstein stated that Student will need two years of appropriate remediation. He will also require mainstreaming in a grade-appropriate general education classroom for the remainder of the day with adequate modifications and support from the special education staff. The Hearing Officer finds that it is inappropriate, both socially and cognitively, for Student to spend the majority of his school day in an SDC. Additionally, the District must make up those sessions of OT that were not provided to Student due to the District's unavailability. Those sessions must be made up in a manner that accommodates the schedules of both the District and the Petitioner before the end of the current ESY, unless the parties agree to extend the time frame. Finally, Student is entitled to an IEP which includes goals that address his lack of a foundation in phonemic awareness and sound/symbol relationships. The Hearing Officer understands that providing Student with two hours each day of remedial education, OT and access to grade-level core curriculum could create a demanding schedule for Student. The appropriate method and the time line for providing these services must be determined by the parents and the educators through an IEP meeting.
CONCLUSION
Student still does not posses adequate skills in phonemic awareness, sight vocabulary, sound/symbol correspondence, phonics, or written language skills. Without these skills, Student does not have the base upon which to build further academic skills. An attempt must be made to remediated these skills through a specific, systematic program. The crucial concern is the acquisition of the academic skills which Student will need to succeed. This will require the participation and cooperation of both the school and the home. To attain the skills necessary for success, Student will require two hours per day of intensive remediation with the proper program, as well as continued exposure to his grade level core curriculum with modifications, any necessary technical support, and special education assistance. OT services should also continue.
ORDER
1. The District shall provide Petitioner with compensatory education consisting of a specific remedial program, two hours per day, in individual or small-group sessions, which addresses his lack of phonemic awareness and sound/symbol correspondence as described in this decision. This remedial program shall be arranged by the District at the IEP meeting to be convened pursuant to order number three and continue until Student attains his grade equivalency or it is determined through objective means that he cannot be so remediated. However, in no event is the remediation program provided through this Order to extend beyond two years from the date of its implementation. The remediation program shall be in addition to the FAPE the District must provide to Petitioner.
2. The District shall continue to provide Petitioner with OT services one time per week for fifty minutes as long as such sessions are determined to be necessary by the IEP team. In addition, the District shall continue to provide compensatory OT services before the conclusion of the 1999-2000 ESY for each of the sessions the District has failed to provide to date. If the parties mutually agree, the time frame for providing the missed OT sessions may be extended for a reasonable period of time to accommodate Student's schedule.
3. Within two weeks of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to offer a placement that provides the components described herein, draft an IEP consistent with that program, and establish goals to address Student's deficits as determined by this decision.
4. The Petitioner's other claims for reimbursements are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on all issues except the provision of FAPE for the 1996- 97 school year, and reimbursement for psychological services, tutoring, and books on tape.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated:_________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Footnotes Footnote: 1)* The hearing date of September 30, 1999 was erroneous written as September 39, 1999. The date is the only change made to this Amended Decision.
