California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 12, 2002
Student v. Buckeye Union Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 1277-01 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Red-track placement offer by Buckeye, Rescue and El Dorado County Office of Education upheld; IEP team ordered to add transition-plan goals.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
A June 29, 2001 interim stay put order kept the student on the green track during 2001-2002. The Hearing Officer held the 2001-2002 claims moot.
Summary
The parents of a third grader with orthopedic and visual impairments filed for due process in June 2001. The El Dorado County Office of Education had moved its program for orthopedically impaired (OI) students at Silva Valley Elementary from the green track to the red track. Silva Valley is a year-round school in Buckeye Union Elementary School District, and the student lives in Rescue Union Elementary School District. She spent about 80 percent of her day in general education. Her parents wanted her to stay on the green track with her long-time friends. A stay put order kept her there for 2001-2002, so the Hearing Officer treated that year as moot and decided only the 2002-2003 offer.
The Hearing Officer found that friendships with typical peers were a real need tied to her disability. Her parents had been meeting that need in place of the districts. Still, the offer's transition plan was likely to meet the need on the red track. The plan included friendship groups, weekly lunch groups, disability awareness training and a student biography. Staying on the green track would cut her off from OI teacher Ruth Kauer for up to a month each trimester, which would not meet her orthopedic needs. The offer was found to provide a FAPE in the LRE, except that it had no present levels or goals for the transition plan. The IEP team was ordered to meet within 15 days to add them. All other relief was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a student's need for peer friendships as a unique need tied to her disability, even though no IEP had named it. The Hearing Officer still upheld a track change supported by a structured transition plan. He also required present levels and goals tied to that plan.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue I. s the Respondents' program offer for 2002-2003, which moves the student from the green track to the red track, designed to meet her unique needs, including social and emotional needs for friendships and positive interaction with typical peers?
The student has unique social and emotional needs, and the red-track offer with its transition plan is designed to meet them and her orthopedic needs. However, the offer lacked present levels and goals for the transition plan, as Title 5, C.C.R. section 3040(c) requires.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue II. Is the Respondents' program offer reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit?
The offer is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, except that the IEP team must develop present levels and goals for the transition plan.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue III. Does the Respondents' program offer satisfy the requirement for providing the student with an education in the least restrictive environment?
The parents' green-track alternative would cut off access to the OI teacher and classroom for up to a month each trimester, so it was not appropriate. The red-track offer meets LRE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days from the date of the decision, the IEP team must meet to determine present levels of performance and goals and objectives that support implementation of the transition plan to the red track. The plan must be implemented in a way that addresses the student's unique needs without drawing excessive or inappropriate attention to her. All other requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3040(c); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345(a)
People named in the decision
- Lola Westphal, director of special education, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Irene Elliott, director of student support services, Rescue Union Elementary School District
- Betsy Christ, executive director of special services, El Dorado County Office of Education
- Emi Johnson, SELPA director, El Dorado County SELPA
- Ruth Kauer, credentialed teacher for orthopedically impaired students (OI teacher), El Dorado County Office of Education OI program, Silva Valley Elementary
- Kelly McDonald, 1:1 instructional classroom assistant, Silva Valley Elementary
- Alexa Lopez, third-grade general education teacher, Silva Valley Elementary
- Janice Glaser, student's optometrist (witness for Student), Private provider
- Leslyn Shortes, social services coordinator (witness for Student)
- Lynne Castellucci, educational advocate for Student, Developmental Disabilities Area Board III
- Michael Rosenberg, educational advocate for Student, Developmental Disabilities Area Board III
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on May 9 and 10, 2002, in Rescue, California.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by educational advocates Lynne Castellucci and Michael Rosenberg from Developmental Disabilities Area Board III. Also present on behalf of the Student were her mother, MOTHER, and her father, FATHER. Respondents/Cross-Petitioners (collectively referred to herein as “Respondents”) Buckeye Union Elementary School District (Buckeye), Rescue Union Elementary School District (Rescue), and El Dorado County Office of Education (EDCOE), were represented by attorney Elizabeth Lind from the office of Girard and Vinson.(Footnote 1) Also present on behalf of the Respondents were Lola Westphal, director of special education for Buckeye; Irene Elliott, director of student support services for Rescue; and Betsy Christ, executive director of special services for EDCOE. Emi Johnson, director for the El Dorado County SELPA, also attended the hearing.
The Student called the following witnesses: FATHER; Janice Glaser, STUDENT’s optometrist and parent of one of STUDENT’s friends; Isabel Francisco, parent of a student in the EDCOE program for orthopedically impaired students; Leslyn Shortes, social services coordinator; Deborah DeVries, parent of one of STUDENT’s closest friends; and MOTHER. The Respondents called the following witnesses: Betsy Christ; Lola Westphal; Ruth Kauer, STUDENT’s credentialed teacher for orthopedically impaired students; Kelly McDonald, STUDENT’s instructional classroom assistant; and Alexa Lopez, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of closing briefs, received by the Hearing Officer on May 20, 2002.
ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Have the Respondents offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2002-2003 school year?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student’s objection to the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year arises from the Respondents’ proposal to move her to a new “track.” The proposed track change would result in STUDENT attending a fourth-grade regular education class that most likely would contain none of the friends that she has developed throughout prior school years. The Student asserts that the separation from her friends would prevent her social and emotional needs from being met. The Student also asserts that because her social and emotional needs are such an important component of her desire and motivation to succeed academically, the failure of the program to meet her social and emotional needs would render her unable benefit academically from her educational program.
The Respondents disagree with the Student’s contentions regarding the consequences of the proposed track change. The Respondents assert that STUDENT has never been identified in an IEP as requiring services to address social and emotional deficits or needs. They also assert that STUDENT is a very social person who, with the support of a transition plan proposed in the Respondents’ program offer, would be able to make new friends and have successful social interactions with typical peers in her new track.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], is eligible for special education because of orthopedic and visual impairments. She has been diagnosed with cerebral palsy, spastic diplegia, optical atrophy, alternating visual etropia, and cortical visual impairment. STUDENT resides in the Rescue Union Elementary School District. Beginning with kindergarten and continuing through the present, STUDENT has attended Silva Valley Elementary School (Silva Valley) in the Buckeye Union Elementary School District. Her attendance at Silva Valley was established so that she could participate in the “OI” program. The OI program is a special program for orthopedically impaired students operated by EDCOE at Silva Valley. The OI program includes a classroom and a specially credentialed teacher for children with orthopedic impairments (OI teacher). Among other duties, the OI teacher provides one-on-one instruction to orthopedically impaired students, and she provides support for the integration of her students into regular education classes.
Although STUDENT participates in the OI program, she has always been mainstreamed with regular education students for a substantial portion of her school day. In the 2001-2002 school year, about 80 percent of STUDENT’s time at school was with typical peers in regular education settings. For about 20 percent of her time she was in the OI classroom or receiving special pull-out services.
STUDENT is unable to walk or stand. At school, she has a full-time one-on-one assistant and relies upon a wheelchair. Her one-on-one assistant consults with the OI teacher, when available, regarding STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT’s vision impairments are severe, although she does have the ability to read enlarged letters (1.5 inches) at close distances. She has deficits in articulation and expressive language. Listeners often have difficulty understanding her if the topic of discussion is unknown. When assessed in November 2001 at the age of 8 years and 11 months, her “language structure ability” in creating sentences to describe a picture story was at about the 4 to 5 year old level. Academically, her standardized test scores have generally been in the first (lowest) percentile range, although test results have been viewed with caution by her assessors due to the effects of her physical limitations on test procedures. (Resp. Ex. 67, 68.)
To understand the contentions in this case, one must understand the multiple-track schedule at Silva Valley. Silva Valley has one “traditional” track and four separate year-round tracks, referred to as “blue,” “green,” “yellow,” and “red.” Each student is assigned to one of the tracks. Each year-round track is divided into trimesters. When a trimester for any particular year-round track is in session, that time is referred to as “on-track.” The end of each trimester is followed by a vacation period of about 4 weeks, referred to as “off-track.” The year-round tracks are staggered in their trimester starting dates, resulting in some overlap of the on-track and off-track dates for students who are on different tracks.
STUDENT’s access to the OI program is subject to the track schedule. STUDENT started her kindergarten year in the green track because green was aligned with the OI program. She has remained in the green track through the present time without interruption. However, in January 2001, EDCOE informed the parents of all children in the OI program that both the OI program and the green track students attending the OI program would be shifted to the red track, effective July 2001. STUDENT’s parents opposed the attempt to remove her from the green track. They asserted that removing STUDENT from the green track would substantially isolate her from the core group of typical peer friends that STUDENT had acquired during her years in the green track. They asserted that her isolation from those friends would result in such a diminution of social and emotional support and be so devastating to STUDENT that she would not be able to receive educational benefit at school.
STUDENT filed the current due process matter in June 2001, seeking a decision that would allow her to remain in the green track. She also made a motion for an interim order that, pending the outcome of the due process hearing, the green track would be part of her “stay put” placement.(Footnote 2) On June 29, 2001, the Hearing Office granted STUDENT’s motion for stay put. When the OI program was shifted to the red track in July 2001, STUDENT remained in the green track pursuant to the stay put order. During the months in the 2001-2002 school year when red and green were both on-track, STUDENT still participated in the OI program, going to the OI classroom daily and receiving about 30 minutes of individual instruction, plus other support, from the OI teacher. However, support from the OI program was unavailable to STUDENT and to her one-on-one aide during the months that red was off-track. For those occasions when red was off-track, STUDENT remained in the regular education classroom during the times that she otherwise would have been in the OI classroom.
When the due process hearing commenced on May 9, 2002, the 2001-2002 school year was nearly concluded. Meanwhile, the June 29, 2001 stay put order had operated to provide the Student with relief equivalent to what she had sought for the 2001-2002 school year, that sought relief being a decision and order to keep her on the green track. Consequently, the issues raised by the Student in her due process hearing request are now moot with respect to the 2001-2002 school year.
The remaining issue concerns the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year, in which they have again proposed moving STUDENT to the red track.(Footnote 3) The offer includes placement in the OI program at Silva Valley where STUDENT would be mainstreamed in a fourth-grade general education class, on the red track, for about 80 percent of each day. During the remaining 20 percent of each day, STUDENT would receive individualized instruction and services, including instruction and services in the OI classroom from an OI teacher. STUDENT’s general education curriculum would be modified and adapted as determined through consultation with the OI teacher and a qualified teacher of visually impaired students. The offer includes a full-time one-on-one trained aide, with additional aide support as needed for personal maintenance and for positioning, lifting, and transferring STUDENT. Also included as part of the program offer are speech and language services, adaptive physical education, vision services, transportation services, extended year services with the OI teacher for 20 days, and transitional services that the Respondents state are designed to integrate STUDENT into the fourth-grade general education classroom and provide her with supported opportunities to establish friendships with her new (red track) peers.
STUDENT’s parents are in general agreement with the program offer for the 2002-2003 school year, except that they oppose the continuing attempt by the Respondents to move STUDENT from the green track to the red track. The dispute in this case concerns the social and emotional consequences to STUDENT that would result from moving her out of the green track.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The overall issue to be resolved is whether the Respondents have offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2002-2003 school year.
Under federal and State law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and related services, available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8). The term “special education” is more particularly defined in State law as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and related services that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.
To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides her some educational benefit, and comports with her IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
In summary, under the IDEA , State law, and Rowley, the program proposed by the Respondents for the 2002-2003 school year must be shown to meet the following requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for the Student: (I) It must be designed to meet her unique needs. (II) It must be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. (III) It must provide her an education in the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 4)
I. Is the Respondents’ program offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
The Student’s objection to the program offer for the 2002-2003 school year arises from the proposal to switch her from the green track to the red track. The Student asserts that if she is removed from the green track, the separation from her friends in the green track would prevent her social and emotional needs from being met.
The Respondents disagree with the Student’s contention. The Respondents assert that STUDENT has never been identified in an IEP as requiring services to address social and emotional deficits or needs. They also assert that STUDENT is a very social person who, with the support of the proposed transition plan, would be able to make new friends and have successful social interactions with typical peers in the red track.
To resolve this dispute, the Hearing Officer will first determine whether STUDENT has unique social and emotional needs that must be addressed in her educational program. If she does have such social and emotional needs, then the Hearing Officer will examine the Respondents’ program offer to determine whether that offer is designed to meet those social and emotional needs.
A. Social and emotional needs.
Although STUDENT’s parents offered no expert witness testimony, their assertion that STUDENT’s social and emotional status is critical to the success of her educational program was abundantly supported by the oral and documentary evidence presented by both sides at the hearing. Both sides presented undisputed evidence showing that STUDENT has a strong desire to do her best academically and a strong desire to interact socially with her typical peers. Meanwhile, STUDENT’s pursuit of academic success and social interaction is hampered by her multiple impairments. STUDENT’s severe orthopedic impairments comprise only some of the obstacles to success that she faces daily at school. As the oral and documentary evidence showed, STUDENT must also contend with her severely impaired vision, her impairments in speech and language, and her limited academic skills. Her impairments inevitably affect how she is perceived and treated by her mainstream peers, both inside and outside of the classroom. For example, her parents testified that during one school year, a dispute arose as to whether STUDENT should even be included in her annual class photograph. Her parents also testified that STUDENT’s ability to maintain the interest of her typical peers is adversely affected by her inability to engage in the same activities that typical peers enjoy on the playground or elsewhere, such as walking, running, or playing various games. To date, the parties agree that STUDENT has been successful in developing some strong friendships with her typical peers in the green track and that she has been assisted in great measure by intensive efforts from her parents to help her establish and maintain those friendships. STUDENT’s parents testified that, in their opinion, her close friendships with a core group of typical peers in the green track during her years at Silva Valley have been crucial in providing STUDENT with the inspiration that she needs to overcome the challenges that confront her, thereby enabling her to successfully work toward the goals and objectives in her IEPs. As STUDENT’s father testified, her friends are her foundation for being able to thrive at school.
The Respondents’ assertion that STUDENT has never been identified in an IEP as requiring services to address social and emotional deficits or needs is disingenuous. In prior school years, STUDENT’s parents helped to promote and maintain friendships for STUDENT through methods such as the hosting of parties, recreational activities, and sleepovers. Her parents’ extensive efforts were made in lieu of support that the Respondents likely should have been providing. Moreover, the fact that the Respondents have offered a moderately detailed transition plan for the change to the red track confirms their recognition that STUDENT does have unique social and emotional needs.
On the basis of the above factors and giving weight to the parents’ special knowledge of their own daughter, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has unique social and emotional needs arising from her disability. More specifically, friendships and positive social interaction with typical peers are essential components of her ability to receive educational benefit. Therefore, any proposal to remove STUDENT from the green track must be designed to meet her social and emotional needs for friendships and positive social interaction with typical peers.
B. The program offer.
Social and emotional needs. The next question to be resolved by the Hearing Officer is whether the Respondents’ program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs for friendships and positive social interaction with typical peers. The proposed change in tracks would eliminate STUDENT’s contact in the classroom with her friends on the green track, although she would still have the potential for seeing those friends at lunch and recess while red and green were both on track.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s parents assert that the social and emotional affect upon STUDENT by that level of isolation from her friends in the green track would cause STUDENT to lose her motivation and her ability to benefit from her educational program at school. The Respondents assert that STUDENT’s social nature, especially in combination with the proposed transition plan, would enable her to have friendships and positive social interaction with typical peers on the red track.(Footnote 6)
Testimony of witnesses from both sides confirmed that STUDENT’s social nature is an area of strength, meaning that she has a desire to be social and she has the ability to draw people to her because of her cheerfulness and enthusiasm. Witnesses called by the Respondents, including Ms. Christ, EDCOE’s executive director, Ms. Lopez, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, and Ms. Kauer, STUDENT’s OI teacher, testified that, in their opinion, STUDENT’s social nature would enable her to make friends easily on the red track. Given the seriousness of STUDENT’s disabilities, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that making new friends and being socially accepted by her new red track peers would be easy for STUDENT. However, as will be discussed below, the evidence showed a strong likelihood that STUDENT would have her social and emotional needs met on the red track.
An important component of the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year is a transition plan that, according to the April 30, 2002 letter from Rescue to STUDENT’s parents, “includes various structured activities designed to integrate STUDENT into the 4th grade general education classroom, and provide her with supported opportunities to establish friendships with her new [red track] peers.” The plan specifically provides for: (1) “Circle of friends/friendship groups” to facilitate scheduled opportunities for students to befriend STUDENT while expanding their own friendship skills, assisted by a school counselor or teacher utilizing structured activities with groups meeting once every week for approximately 45 minutes; (2) “Lunch bunch/meet” with fourth-grade teachers and students which would include weekly lunch sessions led by an instructional assistant trained in how to facilitate communication between STUDENT and her peers; (3) “Disability awareness training” which would involve activities derived from suggestions outlined in the El Dorado County Community Advisory Counsel Disability Awareness Handbook that address various disabilities and would include classroom presentations and a school-wide assembly; and (4) “Introductory ‘Bio’ of STUDENT” which would be done in collaboration with STUDENT’s parents. Proposals for the biography include a video of STUDENT and posters showing her various interests and activities.
STUDENT’s parents are highly skeptical of the transition plan. They believe that the plan would draw excessive attention to STUDENT and her disabilities, thereby exposing her to ridicule by her peers. Furthermore, they testified that STUDENT’s ability to attract new friends in each school year was dependent upon having her classmates see the example of STUDENT successfully interacting with her typical peer friends from the prior year that were also in her new class. They believe that if STUDENT is placed in a class on the red track with none of her green-track friends being in that class, she will lose the ability to attract new friends.(Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer has considered the parents’ opinion in this matter and has given due regard to the fact they know their daughter better than anyone. However, the weight of the evidence demonstrated areas of strength in STUDENT that, in combination with the transition plan, would result in STUDENT’s social and emotional needs being met on the red track. STUDENT’s social nature has already been mentioned above. An example of STUDENT’s social nature and her ability to attract people was provided by STUDENT’s one-on-one aide, Ms. McDonald, who testified about special playground activities STUDENT enjoys that engage the interest of her typical peers, such as holding one end of a jump rope. STUDENT’s social nature is complemented by her strong desire to be social. She is highly motivated to be accepted by her peers and to participate in the same activities, to the extent possible, as her typical peers. The magnitude of STUDENT’s desire and motivation was illustrated by her mother’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s cheerleading activities. STUDENT performed her cheerleading tryouts in front of hundreds of people, including some parents who appeared to be resentful that STUDENT might be awarded one of the available positions on the team. She was successful in tryouts that required her to show exuberance. At the same time that she displayed her joy in the cheerleading tryouts, she endured considerable physical pain while attempting activities far beyond her capabilities.
Importantly, STUDENT’s years at Silva Valley confirm her ability to develop and maintain close friendships with more than a few typical peers when given appropriate support. In the past, such support has largely come from STUDENT’s parents, who devise enjoyable and interesting activities for STUDENT and her friends, and from the positive example exhibited to new peers when they see STUDENT having fun with her previously established core group of friends. However, the success of those supports should not be viewed as a justification for refusing to consider new and different support strategies, especially as STUDENT and her peers are becoming older. No particular type of past support should be viewed as indispensable to STUDENT’s future success. Ultimately, the strength of STUDENT’s own personality is the preeminent factor in her ability to achieve social success. An appropriate support strategy will enable STUDENT to use her strengths productively. The nature of an appropriate strategy should be allowed to change in response to STUDENT’s changing circumstances and surroundings.
The concern expressed by STUDENT’s parents about how some of STUDENT’s typical peers may react to the components of the transition plan may be true for some students. However, STUDENT’s history shows that, with appropriate support, a significant number of students have generally been open to the idea of socializing with STUDENT and befriending her. The proposed transition plan would provide a mechanism for facilitating successful social interaction in the 2002-2003 school year. For example, new peers wanting to approach STUDENT may be discouraged because of uncertainty regarding how to approach her or interact with her. The circle of friends and the lunch-bunch meeting strategies would be helpful to those situations.
Finally, the proposal to move STUDENT to the red track presents new opportunities for STUDENT to significantly expand her circle of friendships and also to develop new skills for that purpose. In contrast to the new opportunities for growth that would be presented by having STUDENT on the red track, adopting a strategy of continually attempting to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs by keeping her on the green track would likely be problematic, if not ill-advised. If she stayed on the green track, there would be no guarantee that a significant number of her friends from prior school years would be in her new fourth-grade class. The Respondents presented a chart, described by Ms. Westphall, showing how only a remnant of STUDENT’s prior classmates have continued into her new classroom during each progressive school year. Furthermore, as witnesses for both sides acknowledged, the interests of children change as they get older. There are no guarantees that STUDENT’s friends on the green track from prior years would continue to be her friends in the 2002-2003 school year, even if she remained on their track. Testimony showed that even STUDENT’s best friend over the past years is more recently spending less time with STUDENT. Testimony also showed that STUDENT will be placed in an entirely different school after fifth grade, and again there are no guarantees that some of her current friends from the green track would still be with her.
The Respondents’ proposed program does have one flaw that must be corrected. As stated in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3040(c), the IEP “shall show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided.”(Footnote 8) In STUDENT’s case, the program offer contains no mention of present levels of performance or goals and objectives related to the transition plan. The establishment of present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives will be important for the transition plan’s successful implementation. The ability to reference present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives will assist the IEP team in recognizing the necessity, if any, for adjustments or modifications to the transition plan. For example, during the course of the school year, it may be appropriate to phase-out certain aspects of the plan if the some of the purposes of the plan have been accomplished. Therefore, prior to the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year, the IEP team must meet to document STUDENT’s present levels of performance and establish goals and objectives as necessary to properly support the implementation of the transition plan. In developing goals and objectives and other details related to implementation of the transition plan, the IEP team must seek to implement the plan in a manner that addresses STUDENT’s unique needs without drawing excessive or inappropriate attention to her.
In summary, as STUDENT proceeds through the 2002-2003 school year and subsequent school years, even with the support of special education programs, she will inevitably be in situations where her own skills must be relied upon for successful social interaction. She presently has an opportunity to learn skills for doing exactly that, while still being in the surroundings of a school that is familiar to her, still having some access to her current friends, and still having the desire and ability to attract people to her. Accordingly, with the exception of the necessity for establishing present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to implementation of the transition plan, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year, in the red track, is designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs for friendships and positive social interaction with typical peers.
Needs arising from STUDENT’s orthopedic impairments. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the Respondents’ program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs. Furthermore, as discussed below, the evidence showed that granting STUDENT’s preference for remaining in the green track would result in a program not designed to meet her unique needs arising from her orthopedic impairments.
The evidence confirmed that STUDENT benefitted from her educational program in the green track for the 2001-2002 school year, meeting all but one of her academic goals and objectives. During that year, she had no access to the OI program in the months that red was off-track. However, the fact that the 2001-2002 school year ended with a measure of success does not require a finding that a repeat of the same placement situation for a new school year would be appropriate. To the contrary, the evidence showed that the nature and severity of STUDENT’s orthopedic impairments requires, for purposes of FAPE, that she be removed from the regular education class during a portion of each day for participation in the OI program.
Although STUDENT’s parents testified that there is only minimal need, if any, for STUDENT to receive services in the OI program, the weight of the evidence supported the opposite conclusion. STUDENT’s orthopedic impairments are severe. She requires special procedures for nearly every activity, including movement from place to place, bathroom procedures, sitting in class with proper physical support and positioning, and eating. These activities require specialized equipment that the OI teacher is specifically qualified to select, obtain, and adjust to STUDENT’s needs. These activities also require continual assistance and monitoring by a trained one-on-one aide. STUDENT’s aide, Ms. McDonald, testified that physically, STUDENT is fragile. The aide testified that she is heavily reliant upon the expertise of the OI teacher, Ms. Kauer. The aide testified that during the 2001-2002 school year she consulted daily with Ms. Kauer regarding STUDENT’s needs when red and green were both on-track. The aide testified that when red was off-track, she did not have access to Ms. Kauer and, consequently, those periods were difficult. The difficulties arose not only from an inability to consult with Ms. Kauer about adjustments to STUDENT’s equipment, such as straps, pads, armrests, etc., but also with respect to the ongoing necessity for adaptions and modifications that would enable STUDENT to access and benefit from the instruction in the third-grade regular education classroom taught by Ms. Lopez. In Ms. McDonald’s opinion, her access to consultation with a roving or “itinerant” OI specialist during Ms. Kauer’s absence did not prove to be an appropriate alternative. As STUDENT’s aide, Ms. McDonald was the witness most qualified to make that appraisal. Furthermore, testimony by Ms. Kauer and Ms. McDonald showed that having STUDENT in the OI classroom served at least two important functions. First, Ms. Kauer was able to observe STUDENT for a portion of every school day. Those observations enabled Ms. Kauer to address daily issues for STUDENT that were brought to Ms. Kauer’s attention, and those daily observations also enabled Ms. Kauer to detect problems that persons without her special credential might not have seen. Second, Ms. Kauer was able to provide daily individual instruction to STUDENT, especially in her weaker areas such as math. The daily instruction from a person with Ms. Kauer’s special credential in teaching children with severe orthopedic impairments is highly appropriate for STUDENT.
For all of the above-stated reasons, depriving STUDENT of access to the OI teacher and classroom for periods lasting as long as a month during each trimester would be inconsistent with a program designed to meet STUDENT’s multiple needs arising from her orthopedic impairments. Therefore, a program that kept STUDENT in the green track while the OI program was in the red track would not be designed to meet her unique needs.(Footnote 9)
II. Is the Respondents’ program offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The next question to be addressed is whether the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The program offer for the 2002-2003 school year is similar to STUDENT’s prior programs at Silva Valley. Testimony that STUDENT has received educational benefit from her programs over the past several years at Silva Valley was undisputed. In the 2001-2002 school year, all of her academic goals and objectives were met, except in math. In the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s OI teacher would address her deficits in math by giving her one-on-one instruction in the OI classroom. The Student’s only dispute regarding the program offer arises from the proposal to change tracks. Her parents assert that placement in the red track would so drastically fail to meet her social and emotional needs that she would lose her desire and ability to benefit from the academic portion of her educational program. The Hearing Officer has already ruled on that contention, finding that with the exception of the necessity for adding present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to the transition plan, the program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs. Having those needs met will enable STUDENT to focus on her academic program. Accordingly, except for the fact that the IEP team must develop present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to the transition plan, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some academic educational benefit.
III. Does the Respondents’ program offer satisfy the requirement for providing STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment?
To satisfy the requirements of LRE, the program offered by the Respondents must provide for removal of STUDENT from the regular education environment only when the nature and severity of her disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved.
In comparison to the Respondents’ red-track program offer, the Student’s proposal for remaining on the green track is, arguably, less restrictive because it would result in STUDENT not attending the OI classroom during the times that red is off-track. However, the placement sought by the Student is not an appropriate alternative. The Hearing Officer has already found that daily access to the OI classroom and teacher is important for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs. The Student’s proposal for staying in the green track would unacceptably result in the Student having no access to the OI program for periods lasting as long as a month during each trimester. Consequently, the placement proposed by the Respondents is the only placement presented for the Hearing Officer’s consideration that would be appropriate, and there has been no showing that a less restrictive placement would meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Accordingly, the placement proposed by the Respondents is hereby found to meet the requirements of LRE for STUDENT in the 2002-2003 school year.
CONCLUSION
With the exception of the necessity for the IEP team to determine present levels of performance and goals and objectives to support the implementation of the transition plan, the Hearing Officer has found that the Respondents’ program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, is consistent with the requirements of least restrictive environment, and constitutes an offer of FAPE in the LRE.
ORDERS
1. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet to determine present levels of performance and goals and objectives pertinent to supporting the implementation of the transition plan to the red track.(Footnote 10) In developing goals and objectives and other details related to implementation of the transition plan, the IEP team must seek to implement the plan in a manner that addresses STUDENT’s unique needs without drawing excessive or inappropriate attention to her.
2. All of the Student’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. With the exception of the finding that the Respondents must convene an IEP team meeting to develop present levels of performance and goals and objectives to support the implementation of the transition plan, the Respondents prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: June 12, 2002 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Attorney David Girard from the office of Girard and Vinson was present for the first one-half day of hearing. 2. Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, a special education student shall remain in her current educational placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures, unless the parties agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code Secs. 56346(b), 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. For purposes of stay put, the current educational placement is typically the placement agreed upon in an individualized education program (IEP) and implemented by the parties prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education (6th Cir. 1990) 918 F.2d 618. 3. The Respondents’ program offer for the 2002-2003 school year came after a series of IEP meetings and is delineated in an April 30, 2002 letter from Rescue to STUDENT’s parents. 4. Whether the Respondents’ program comports with STUDENT’s IEP is not at issue in this case. 5. The evidence showed that recess and lunch periods are taken at the same time by all of the tracks at Silva Valley. Red and green would be simultaneously on-track for about two-thirds of STUDENT’s school days. Silva-Valley’s calendar for the 2001-2002 school year showed that during the 177 school days that red was on-track, green was off-track for 60 of those days (3 blocks of 20 consecutive school days per trimester). 6. The Respondents assert that STUDENT’s opportunity for interaction with the green track at lunch and recess would give her sufficient interaction with her friends on the green track to meet her needs. Also, on the basis of testimony from Ms. Kauer and Ms. Lopez that STUDENT is at nearly full attention to task during her time in the regular education classroom, the Respondents assert that STUDENT would essentially have no opportunity for interaction with friends in the classroom, even if she did have friends among her new classmates. The Hearing Officer disagrees with both of those assertions. Although STUDENT would have access to her green track peers during lunch and recess, for approximately one full month of each trimester none of her friends on the green track would be at school. Also, the Hearing Officer cannot accept the Respondents’ argument that STUDENT would have no time to benefit from having friends in the classroom. If the tasks in a fourth-grade classroom were so onerous that a student had no time for interacting with classmates, then the appropriateness of such a fourth-grade classroom setting for any student would be suspect, especially for a child with STUDENT’s social and emotional needs.
7. STUDENT’s parents also asserted that if STUDENT is switched to the red track, the efforts they made in prior years to help STUDENT develop friendships could not be replicated with fourth graders. Her parents believe that fourth graders would have become less open-minded, compared to younger students, about knowing STUDENT and accepting her as a friend. However, the question of whether STUDENT’s parents could replicate their prior efforts by working with a new group of fourth graders is not relevant. The Respondents, not the parents, have the duty to provide a FAPE. Accordingly, the Respondents’ program must be evaluated without regard to whether STUDENT’s parents would be able to develop a network of friends for STUDENT or take other measures to meet STUDENT’s unique social and emotional needs. 8. The requirements for present levels of performance and goals and objectives in an IEP are also described in Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345(a). 9. Typically in due process decisions, if the hearing officer has determined that the program offered by a school district is designed to meet a student’s unique needs, the hearing officer will not engage in an analysis regarding whether an alternate proposal by a parent is also designed to meet a student’s unique needs. In the present case, that additional analysis has been done because it will bear upon the matter of LRE, discussed below. 10. The provisions of Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345.5 and 56344 acknowledge that IEP meetings may not be feasible during summer vacations. However, STUDENT is attending a year-round school, and red will be on-track for the 2002-2003 school year in the early part of July. Therefore, the time available for developing present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to the transition plan is short.
