California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 7, 1997
Student v. San Lorenzo Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1279-96 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson
San Lorenzo Unified must reimburse $550 for parent counseling and pay $90 for residential school haircuts; boxing training denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 16-year-old student eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed, represented by his mother, brought this case against San Lorenzo Unified School District. The district had placed him at Provo Canyon School, a nonpublic residential school in Utah, from December 1995 to December 1996. He now attends American Heritage High School, a nonpublic school the district largely funds. Several issues settled before the hearing. At the hearing, the district also agreed to fund future parent and family counseling, 75% of the mother's 1996 counseling costs, and some of the Provo travel and shipping costs.
Three disputes remained. First, the mother asked the district to fund the boxing and weight training she had arranged twice a week. The Hearing Officer applied Rowley, which does not require a district to maximize benefit. She held that the many team sports at Heritage met the student's need for a structured physical and social outlet. Second, the district refused to pay the last 25% of the mother's 1996 counseling with therapist Eileen Brooks, arguing that part of that time dealt with the mother's own issues. The Hearing Officer found that all of the counseling helped the student benefit from his education and ordered the full $550 reimbursed. Third, she ordered the district to pay Provo $90 for haircuts the program required. She denied the claims for "amenities" and "doctor transportation" because the evidence did not show what they covered or why the district owed them.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated parent counseling as a related service. The Hearing Officer ordered reimbursement for the parent's own counseling sessions because they helped the student benefit from his education. It also shows how the costs of a residential placement were divided: a grooming rule the program required was the district's cost, but ordinary personal and medical expenses were not.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Does STUDENT require boxing and weight training, twice a week, in 90 minute sessions, currently provided by his mother?
Under Rowley the district need not maximize benefit; the range of team sports and physical activities at the student's school met his need for a structured physical and social outlet, so boxing and weight training were not required.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue II. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parent for 100% of the cost of parent counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., in the amount of $550.00?
All of the mother's 1996 counseling, including time spent on her own issues, was necessary for the student to benefit from his education, so the district must reimburse the full $550, not only the 75% it conceded.
- Student prevailed in partResidential placement for mental health
Issue III. Should the District be required to pay for STUDENT's incidental expenses incurred for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation" while he was at Provo Canyon School, in the amount of $197.15?
Mandatory haircuts were an integral part of the residential program, so the district must pay $90; claims for 'amenities' and 'doctor transportation' were denied for lack of evidence of what they covered or why the district was responsible.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District shall immediately reimburse the parent for 100% of the cost of 1996 counseling with Eileen Brooks (not including missed sessions), $550.00. This includes the 75% ($412.50) the district had agreed to pay and the disputed 25% ($137.50).
- District shall pay Provo Canyon School $90 for the incidental expense of mandatory haircuts.
Total: $640 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; 34 C.F.R. § 300.16 (related services, parent counseling and training, recreation); California Education Code § 56363; California Code of Regulations § 3051.15
People named in the decision
- Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., private marriage and family therapist; witness for Student, Walnut Creek Counseling Associates
- Marlene Zuehlsdorff, District coordinator, special education; District representative and witness, San Lorenzo Unified School District
- Bill Mowery, District director of special services; District representative and witness, San Lorenzo Unified School District
- Craig Smith, student's therapist at residential placement, Provo Canyon School
- Provo Canyon School, nonpublic residential school (Utah)
- American Heritage High School, nonpublic school, current placement
- Alameda County Mental Health, county mental health agency (AB 3632 services)
- Golden Gloves, private boxing and weight training provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Lorenzo, California, on March 18, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER.
Respondent San Lorenzo Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented by Marlene Zuehlsdorff, District coordinator, special education, and Bill Mowery, District director of special services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed on March 18, 1997, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the hearing, before evidence was received or witnesses were called, the parties discussed settlement of the issues off the record. Upon going back on the record, the parties indicated that several issues listed in a mediation report from December 9, 1996, had been resolved and were withdrawn from consideration.
The issues remaining in dispute and submitted for decision by the Hearing Officer are listed below.
ISSUES
I. Does STUDENT require boxing and weight training, twice a week, in 90 minute sessions, currently provided by his mother?
II. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parent for 100% of the cost of parent counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., in the amount of $550.00?
III. Should the District be required to pay for STUDENT's incidental expenses incurred for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation" while he was at Provo Canyon School, in the amount of $197.15?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 16-year-old male who is eligible for special education services as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). STUDENT's father abandoned him and his mother early in STUDENT's life. During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT was in and out of six different schools. That year, he was found eligible for special education services as learning disabled, but his eligibility was changed to SED in September 1995, after he had participated in incidents involving violence at a District high school in 1995, while he was on home study.
In December 1995, STUDENT was placed at Provo Canyon School (hereafter Provo), a nonpublic residential placement in Utah. He was discharged from Provo in December 1996. STUDENT is currently attending American Heritage High School (hereafter Heritage), a nonpublic school in California. The District pays for 6/7 of the tuition at Heritage.(Footnote 1) STUDENT works part-time while attending Heritage. STUDENT receives tutoring and resource specialist services from the District and participates in counseling with private practice therapist Eileen Brooks. There is no disagreement over the appropriateness of his current placement at Heritage.
Additionally, STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, pays for boxing and weight training provided to STUDENT through a Golden Gloves agency. STUDENT has been participating in this training since March 1997.
During 1995 and 1996, before and while STUDENT was at Provo, Ms. PARENT participated in counseling with Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C. The expenses for the 1995 sessions, for which she does not seek reimbursement, were paid by Ms. PARENT. The parties agreed at the hearing that the total cost for therapy during 1996 (not including missed sessions) was $550.00. At the hearing, the District agreed to begin paying for parent counseling (in addition to the student counseling to which STUDENT was already entitled) with Ms. Brooks for STUDENT and his mother, four sessions a month (individual and/or family therapy -- their choice as to each session), backdating to January 1997. Therefore, the related service of parent counseling from January 1997 onward is not at issue. Also not at issue is 75% of the cost of the 1996 parent counseling sessions ($412.50) for Ms. PARENT, for which the District agreed to pay. The only issue as to counseling is whether the District should be required to also pay the remaining 25% of those 1996 parental counseling costs (or $137.50).
While at Provo, STUDENT incurred various "incidental expenses." The District agreed at the hearing to pay for some of these expenses, including airport transportation, testing transportation, and shipping costs; therefore, these expenses are not at issue. Other expenses, which are at issue in this hearing, include expenses for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation," totalling $197.15.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
MOTHER
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified on behalf of her son. As to the boxing and weight training issue, Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT needs a structured, male-oriented outlet and a way to release energy and aggressions, especially given that he is 6'3" and weighs about 205 pounds. Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT gets frustrated and starts to engage in self-destructive behavior if he does not have a way to let go of his hostility. She said that once STUDENT took a knife and put holes in his hand because he had built up so much frustration.
Ms. PARENT indicated that STUDENT previously played basketball, which helped as an outlet for his frustrations, but that basketball season is over. Ms. PARENT said that she bought a weight set, a 13' trampoline, and a cardiovascular exercise machine for use at home. However, at home he is isolated from others. Ms. PARENT asserted that part of STUDENT's unique needs is to acquire social skills and to learn to deal with other people appropriately. Ms. PARENT said that in the boxing and weight training classes, STUDENT must deal with the coach and the other students in the group.
As to the counseling issue, Ms. PARENT indicated that she would continue in therapy with Eileen Brooks and that all of her services in 1996 were required to transition STUDENT successfully. Ms. PARENT stated that she had to deal with a lot of guilt for sending STUDENT to Provo, but that it was necessary and that the counseling helped her to understand this. Ms. PARENT felt that the counseling services helped her to help STUDENT. She said that the counseling assisted her in being able to look beyond the label of SED given to STUDENT, to provide appropriate consequences, and to learn to be firm with him, setting limits and providing structure. Ms. PARENT also stated that the counseling helped her to separate her own issues from those of STUDENT's.
As to the "incidental expenses," Ms. PARENT described haircuts as mandatory at Provo, done once a month. She stated that everyone's hair must be uniform with no style. Ms. PARENT felt that the District should pay for the haircuts because of the need for continuity and conformity to the program. As to "amenities," Ms. PARENT said these most likely described shampoo, soap, and other sundry items for which she felt the District should pay as part of his residential placement. Ms. PARENT stated that "doctor transportation" may possibly indicate charges for transporting STUDENT to a doctor for tests. She stated that Provo does a entire series of tests when a student first arrives to make sure that nothing physically wrong is interfering with the student's behavior.
Ms. PARENT stated that she wants to work with the District as a team for STUDENT's benefit, but that she feels that the District has "procrastinated, manipulated, and delayed" implementing a support system for STUDENT. Ms. PARENT said that there has been a long history of adversarial behavior between her and the District.
Eileen Brooks
Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., testified on STUDENT's behalf regarding the counseling issue. Ms. Brooks is a therapist in private practice at Walnut Creek Counseling Associates, Walnut Creek, California. Ms. Brooks has a master's degree in Clinical Psychology from JFK University in Orinda, Contra Costa County, California. Ms. Brooks has been licensed as a marriage and family counsellor since 1991. Her specialty is working with children and adolescents, and she works in the field of abuse. She worked at Parental Stress Service in Oakland, Hayward, and Fremont for several years, dealing with parents and their children working through the effects of abuse. Ms. Brooks has also worked with the issues of domestic violence, depression, and anxiety.
Ms. Brooks has testified in judicial proceedings. She has written reports and attended IEP meetings through Parental Stress and Antioch Mental Health. Ms. Brooks also works as a child therapist part-time at Antioch Mental Health Clinic for Children. Ms. Brooks estimates that approximately four or five of her twenty private practice clients are adolescents.
Both STUDENT and Ms. PARENT previously received mental health services from Ms. Brooks, separately and in family therapy. Ms. PARENT received individual therapy from Ms. Brooks during 1996 while STUDENT was at Provo. Ms. Brooks stated that a lot of this individual work during 1996 dealt with the trauma of separation from STUDENT when he went to his residential placement in Provo and with his adolescent issues. Ms. Brooks said that the sessions were also for the purpose of working in conjunction with Craig Smith, STUDENT's therapist at Provo. Ms. Brooks indicated that the therapy she provided to Ms. PARENT helped her "put her stuff aside" so that she could be more "present" for STUDENT. Ms. Brooks stated that by helping Ms. PARENT improve, it helped stabilize STUDENT at Provo.
Ms. Brooks testified that in her professional opinion, the therapy provided to STUDENT's mother was necessary to stabilize the situation and help STUDENT readjust at Provo. In this manner, Ms. Brooks stated that the therapy to Ms. PARENT directly impacted STUDENT's psychosocial functioning and his ability to perform and be "present" in school. Ms. Brooks described the therapy she provided for Ms. PARENT as similar to that being provided to STUDENT at Provo by his therapist there, Craig Smith.
Ms. Brooks indicated that "at least 75% of the time" in individual therapy with Ms. PARENT was spent solely on STUDENT's educational issues, the issues of dealing with Ms. PARENT's parenting skills, and the trauma of STUDENT's school-related issues.
Marlene Zuehlsdorff
Marlene Zuehlsdorff, District coordinator, special education, testified on behalf of the District. Ms. Zuehlsdorff indicated that the District is providing for STUDENT's tuition at Heritage, except for the Bible class. She stated that the District is providing resource specialist services, tutoring, and a case manager to monitor STUDENT's progress.
As to the boxing and weight training issue, Ms. Zuehlsdorff contended that this additional program, which was initiated by STUDENT's mother outside the IEP process, is unnecessary because STUDENT can participate in physical education and various school-sponsored sports and physical activities at Heritage, just as he would in a District school. Ms. Zuehlsdorff said that it is baseball season currently, and although Ms. PARENT says that STUDENT isn't successful at baseball, it does exist as an outlet for him. Ms. Zuehlsdorff offered soccer as a possibility when that season begins, but she testified that it doesn't seem appropriate for the District to have to pay for the boxing and weight training when so many other activities are available at Heritage.
As to the counseling issue, Ms. Zuehlsdorff said that Ms. Brooks testified that only about 75% of the counseling taking place during 1996 related directly to topics that helped maintain STUDENT in his educational program and helped make his transition. Ms. Zuehlsdorff stated that, for this reason, the District should only be responsible for the amount it has agreed to pay (75% of the total of $550, which works out to be $412.50). The District contends that the amount that is in contention -- the other 25% (or $137.50) -- is not its responsibility because 25% of the time was spent solely on Ms. PARENT's issues.
Bill Mowery
Bill Mowery, District director of special services, testified on behalf of the District. As to the "incidental expenses" issue, Mr. Mowery stated that the District agreed to pay for the incidental expenses incurred at Provo indicated as testing transportation, airport transportation, and shipping, as put forth in the Provo billing. Mr. Mowery, however, indicated that the District would not agree to pay for STUDENT's haircuts, amenities, and doctor transportation. Mr. Mowery said that it was unclear to what the "doctor transportation" actually referred, but that districts should not be held responsible for normal medical care.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Does STUDENT require boxing and weight training, twice a week, in 90 minute sessions, currently provided by his mother?
Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards and are provided at public expense and in conformity with an appropriate individualized education program (IEP). 34 C.F.R. § 300.8.
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, whose educational needs cannot be met in a regular education program with modifications. 34 C.F.R. § 300.17(a)(1); California Education Code § 56031. This includes instruction at home or in hospitals and institutions, as well as instruction in physical education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.17(a)(1).
"Related services" (California's term is "designated instruction and services) is defined as transportation and other supportive services required to allow a student to benefit from special education, including therapeutic recreation and counseling services (which entails parent counseling and training). 34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a); California Education Code § 56363.
"Recreation" services include therapeutic recreation services and recreation programs in schools and community agencies. 34 C.F.R. § 300.16(b)(9). When appropriate, they may facilitate the student's integration back into regular education programs. California Code of Regulations § 3051.15(a).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Therefore, to analyze whether the District should be responsible for providing the related services of boxing and weight training to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer must analyze whether those related services are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to him.
Ms. PARENT contends that having STUDENT participate in boxing and weight training allows him to let off steam. She states that basketball season is now over and STUDENT needs a structured physical activity in which to participate.
The District contends that there are other physical activities in which STUDENT could participate at Heritage, much like at a District school, and that the boxing and weight training program is unnecessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.
Here, STUDENT, an SED student, has been described as needing a physical outlet in which he can release his hostility. STUDENT has participated in basketball, although that season is now over at Heritage. Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT is not interested in the baseball team and needs some other kind of structured physical activity to provide an outlet for his energy to avoid turning his hostility toward himself. However, as in most high schools, there is a wide range of physical activities available to all students. Although STUDENT is not as interested in baseball as he is basketball, it does exist as a very structured activity for him to explore and the sport does provide an opportunity for him to release his aggressions.
Ms. PARENT indicated that STUDENT is participating in boxing and weight training. Ms. PARENT's efforts at providing such an outlet for her son are laudable. Ms. PARENT has purchased a weight set for use at home, as well, although she states that this does not allow him any interaction with others. Apparently, boxing is not available at the high school.
According to Rowley, the District need not provide such services as to maximize STUDENT's benefit from special education. STUDENT has benefitted from his participation on the school's basketball team, and there is ample opportunity for him to join other teams and learn or become better at new sports, including baseball, soccer -- maybe football, track, or even cross-county running. Even "pick-up" basketball games certainly provide a healthy outlet for aggressions. It should be noted that what Ms. PARENT requests is a team-based, or at least group-based, activity in order to have STUDENT work on his social skills and his ability to deal with others. Providing a range of sports, as are available at Heritage, therefore, satisfies the need for an individually designed service.
Additionally, there is evidence that STUDENT was provided some benefit from his participation in basketball. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require boxing and weight training, twice a week, in 90 minute sessions, currently provided by his mother, in order to benefit from his education.
II. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parent for 100% of the cost of parent counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., in the amount of $550.00?
"Parent counseling and training" is defined as assisting parents to understand their child's special needs and providing child development information. 34 C.F.R. § 300.16(b)(6). Thus, individual counseling for a parent to help gain understanding about the child's unique needs can be a related service to which a special education student might be entitled.
STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP) dated May 6, 1996,(Footnote 2) indicates that the related services to which he was then entitled are described in a mediation agreement, dated May 7, 1996. Those services included AB3632 services from Alameda County Mental Health (Mental Health) and transportation to and from school (Provo). The documents note that the District was to assume the Provo tuition and residential costs (including counseling at Provo) until Mental Health assumed those costs. According to his latest IEP, dated January 28, 1997,(Footnote 3) STUDENT is entitled to receive counseling himself from Ms. Brooks. However, parental counseling was not included as a related service on any of STUDENT's IEPs.
Here, however, the District has agreed to provide counseling, backdating to January 1997, to both STUDENT and Ms. PARENT, to help her deal with STUDENT and help her with STUDENT's transition. The District indicated that this therapy could be used individually for either STUDENT or Ms. PARENT, or for family therapy. Therefore, parent counseling, beginning in 1997, is not at issue.
Additionally, the District has agreed that it is responsible for 75% of the parent counseling that took place in 1996. Therefore, the first 75% of the costs for 1996 parent counseling is not at issue. However, the District contends that the remaining 25% is not its responsibility because, according to Ms. Brooks' own testimony, only 75% of the parent counseling time was spent on issues directly relating to STUDENT. Ms. PARENT contends that the District should also be responsible for the remaining 25% of the counseling because the sessions were undertaken to help her better deal with STUDENT. She contends that even the time spent talking about her own issues provided STUDENT with assistance in dealing with his educational problems because she was better able to focus on him.
Despite Ms. Brooks' statement that "at least" 75% of the time spent in therapy sessions with Ms. PARENT individually was focused solely on STUDENT's educational issues, she also stated that by helping his mother to separate out her own issues, she would be better able to assist her son. Ms. Brooks indicated that all of the therapy was undertaken with STUDENT's educational interests in mind and that the help she provided to Ms. PARENT, even having to do with her own issues, directly affected STUDENT's ability to perform and be "present" at Provo.
Additionally, in a letter dated April 30, 1996, Ms. Brooks wrote to the District, giving a brief treatment summary regarding Ms. PARENT's participation in therapy. Ms. Brooks stated:
Since April, 1995, the presenting problem has been and continues to be the client's anxiety, frustration, and depression over her son's emotional stability and safety, his consequent placement at Provo Canyon, and future educational decisions. Client also continues to explore her own issues around being a "good enough" mother and the separation/ individuation issues that impact her relationship with her son.
Our treatment goals have included: 1) decrease anxiety/ depression; 2) increase/improve problem-solving techniques; 3) cognitive restructuring of negative belief systems; 4) improve interpersonal relationships; 5) identify and integrate adolescent stages of development and coordinate treatment goals/expectations with Craig Smith at Provo Canyon School.
It is my understanding that Craig Smith has recommended that MOTHER continue in individual counseling. I concur, and would further recommend that therapy be held once a week. Although MOTHER is insightful and resourceful, she continues to need a therapeutic setting in which to vent and explore her feelings and beliefs concerning her son so that she can remain "grounded" in the other areas of her life.
Pet. Exh. EE-1.(Footnote 4); Dist. Exh. 15.(Footnote 5)
Additionally, in an IEP addendum dated November 11, 1996, the team stated that STUDENT was maintaining a 'B' average and had experienced a successful trip home to visit his family. These successes indicate not only that STUDENT's placement and services were benefitting him educationally and emotionally, but also that his mother's issues were apparently not getting in the way of her dealing with STUDENT. The fact that Ms. PARENT has been better able to deal with STUDENT, to set limits and stay with them, and to understand his needs, establishes that all of her counseling has benefitted STUDENT. Although his IEP did not require parent counseling, the evidence shows that this related service was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.(Footnote 6) In fact, STUDENT was discharged from Provo to a less restrictive environment a little earlier than had been expected because he was so successful in the program. (Pet. Exh. B-2.)
In sum, that the parent counseling was necessary to help STUDENT benefit from his special education is clear from the evidence. Ms. PARENT testified that her ability to separate out her own issues from STUDENT's enabled her to focus on helping him with his transition. Ms. Brooks testified that by dealing with her own issues, Ms. PARENT was able to be "present" for her son and stabilize their relationship and her son's emotions. The District put on no evidence that parent counseling was not necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. The District simply argued that it should not be responsible for the period of time that Ms. PARENT was talking about herself instead of STUDENT.
Therefore, in light of all of the evidence as to the necessity of the parent counseling in order for STUDENT to benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer finds that the District shall reimburse STUDENT's parent for the remaining 25% of the cost of her counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Ms. Brooks, in addition to the 75% which was not in contention. The District shall reimburse the full amount of $550.00.
III. Should the District be required to pay for STUDENT's incidental expenses incurred for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation" while he was at Provo Canyon School, in the amount of $197.15?
Haircuts
The District has agreed to pay for some "incidental expenses," including testing transportation, airport transportation, and U.P.S. shipping (to send some of STUDENT's items home). The District contends that other incidental expenses (for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation") are not the responsibility of the District.
Ms. PARENT contends that the District should pay for the haircuts because they are mandatory at Provo, a very structured, regimented school. She stated that everyone's hair must be uniform, with no style, at Provo. Ms. PARENT felt that the District should pay for the haircuts because of the need for continuity and conformity to the program.
The cost for the monthly haircuts amounts to $90. (Pet. Exh. Z-1.) Normally, haircuts would be a personal grooming expense which is the responsibility of an individual and not the responsibility of a district. However, in this situation, STUDENT was at a residential placement described by his mother as requiring these haircuts as part of the conformity to the program. Ms. PARENT indicated that this conformity was an important portion of the program at Provo.
The Hearing Officer finds that, in this instance, mandatory haircuts were an integral portion of STUDENT's educational program at Provo. Therefore, the District is required to pay Provo for this incidental expense, in the amount of $90.
Amenities
Ms. PARENT contends that the District should pay for another incidental expense incurred at Provo, called "amenities." She was only able to describe these as "likely" covering shampoo, soap, and other sundry items. Ms. PARENT contends that the District should be responsible for this cost as a part of the residential placement. The District contends that this expense is not one for which it should be responsible.
The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence to require the District to pay for "amenities," especially considering that it is not even clear what items this category covers. Unlike the mandatory haircuts, required as a part of the regimented and controlled atmosphere at Provo, there was no such conformity argument made regarding this item. Additionally, STUDENT or his mother would have to buy soap, shampoo, and other personal care items if he were at home. There is no reason why the District should have to pay for these items, just because STUDENT was not at home. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to pay for STUDENT's "amenities" expenses incurred at Provo.
Doctor Transportation
Ms. PARENT contends that the District should be required to pay for this item, "doctor transportation," as a part of his educational program at Provo. The District contends that normal medical care is not its responsibility. Here, the Hearing Officer finds that it is unclear to what "doctor transportation" refers. The items indicated on the billing itemization from Provo did not explain this expense. (Pet. Exh. Z-1.) Nor could Ms. PARENT explain the expense. The "doctor transportation" expenses did not comport with any other listings (by date) relating to testing, either academic or medical on the billing sheet. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to pay for STUDENT's "doctor transportation" expenses incurred at Provo.
ORDER
1. The District shall immediately reimburse Ms. PARENT for 100% of the cost of counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Ms. Brooks, in the amount of $550.00.
2. The District shall pay to Provo $90 for the incidental expense of haircuts.
3. All of the Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Does STUDENT require boxing and weight training, twice a week, in 90 minute sessions, currently provided by his mother?
As to this issue, the Respondent prevailed.
II. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parent for 100% of the cost of parent counseling (not including missed sessions) during 1996 with Eileen Brooks, M.A., M.F.C.C., in the amount of $550.00?
As to this issue, the Petitioner prevailed.
III. Should the District be required to pay for STUDENT's incidental expenses incurred for haircuts, amenities, and "doctor transportation" while he was at Provo Canyon School, in the amount of $197.15?
As to this issue, neither party substantially prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 7, 1997 _________________________________ Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.The District does not pay for the other 1/7 of the costs, which cover a Bible class. 2.There are two addenda to this IEP, dated September 24, 1996, and November 27, 1996. 3.There is an addendum, dated March 12, 1997.
4.Pet. Exh." refers to Petitioner's exhibits, marked with letters from A through EE. 5."Dist. Exh." refers to the District's exhibits, numbered from 1 through 152. 6. It should be noted that the appropriateness of prior IEPs was not an issue in this hearing.
