California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 22, 2003

Student v. Bishop Union Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1291-03 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda

Bishop Union Elementary's offered San Bernardino deaf education class met the prior order; parent wins extra summer camp and sign instruction.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision enforces and applies the prior decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243 (February 27, 2003) and Hearing Officer Redmon's clarification order. Footnote 7 notes that the parties were appealing that previous decision.

Summary

The parent of a six-year-old student who needed a deaf and hard-of-hearing (DHH) program filed this follow-up case against Bishop Union Elementary School District and the Inyo County Office of Education. A February 2003 SEHO decision had ordered the agencies to provide a specific class. It had to be a self-contained total communication class using Signing Exact English (SEE Sign) with an emphasis on listening. A DHH-credentialed teacher had to teach it, and at least two DHH classmates had to use SEE Sign. If no local program met these terms, the agencies had to arrange an interdistrict transfer or a nonpublic school. They offered a transfer to Brenda Broadway's class at Newmark Elementary in San Bernardino. The parent rejected it.

The Hearing Officer found that Newmark met every criterion. He believed speech-language pathologist Patricia Balthazor, who worked in the class four days a week, over witnesses who had watched briefly or never. He refused to consider whether Newmark was the least restrictive environment because that question belonged in the earlier hearing. Because Newmark met the order, he did not decide whether the parent's preferred programs qualified, and he awarded no compensatory education for the placement. The agencies did break the prior order in two ways. The overnight summer camp they offered ignored the student's young age, and the parent's SEE Sign teacher was not proficient. The Hearing Officer ordered an extra summer of camp in 2005 and a new year of instruction from a proficient SEE Sign teacher.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO handled a follow-up dispute over whether an offer complied with an earlier order. The Hearing Officer checked the offer only against that order's stated criteria and would not reopen least restrictive environment arguments. He still awarded compensatory education where the agencies did not properly carry out ordered services.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the LEAs offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243?

    The Newmark DHH class met all four criteria of the prior order (total communication with SEE Sign and emphasis on audition, DHH-credentialed teacher, two qualifying SEE Sign peers, rest of IEP implementable); LRE could not be relitigated in this limited enforcement-related proceeding.

  2. Issue 2. If the LEAs failed to offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, do the programs identified by STUDENT's mother meet the criteria?

    Not reached because the LEAs' Newmark offer met the prior decision's criteria.

  3. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

    No compensatory education for the placement offer, which was timely and compliant; but the LEAs violated the prior order by offering an overnight summer camp without considering the student's age and by providing a SEE Sign instructor for the parent who was not proficient, so an added summer camp and a new year of instruction were ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. Brenda Broadway's CH class at Newmark meets the prior decision's criteria; the LEAs shall comply with the previous decision and immediately try to secure an interdistrict transfer to Newmark.
  • Compensatory education. One additional year of total communication summer camp during summer 2005, in addition to summer 2004, as described in Paragraph 6 of the previous decision.
  • Compensatory education. One year of SEE Sign instruction for the parent, starting within 20 days of the decision, complying with Paragraph 5(b) of the previous decision (two hours per week); the instructor must be proficient in SEE Sign.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education

People named in the decision

  • Howard Lehwald, special projects administrator and special education director, Bishop Union Elementary School District
  • Nan Gering, secretary, Bishop Union Elementary School District
  • Joen Painter, superintendent, Bishop Union Elementary School District
  • Stephanie Sheltz, secretary, Bishop Union Elementary School District
  • Alvin Sasuga, director, SELPA director and program specialist, Inyo County Office of Education
  • Lynne Clark, speech and language pathologist, witness for Student
  • Kathy Lehnert, speech and language pathologist, witness for Student
  • Patricia Balthazor, speech and language pathologist working in Newmark DHH class, witness for Respondents
  • Judy Dore, special education principal, witness for Respondents, Crown Valley
  • Marilou Lundberg, former director of special education, witness for Respondents, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Brenda Broadway, DHH-credentialed teacher of CH class, Newmark Elementary School, San Bernardino City Unified School District
  • Kit Niehans, signing aide who provided SEE Sign instruction to parent, Bishop Union Elementary School District / Inyo County Office of Education
  • Redmon, Hearing Officer in prior case SN02-2840/0243, Special Education Hearing Office
  • House Ear Institute, private testing provider (May 2002 testing of a peer)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Bishop, California, on July 10, 22, 23, and 28, 2003. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Geralyn Clancy. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was her mother, PARENT. Respondent Bishop Union Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney H. Gregory Scharff. Also present on behalf of the District on the first day of hearing was Howard Lehwald, special projects administrator and special education director, and Nan Gering, secretary. Joen Painter, superintendent of the District, and Stephanie Sheltz, secretary, were present in place of Mr. Lehwald and Ms. Gering on the second and third hearing days. Alvin Sasuga, the Inyo County Office of Education director, was present on behalf of Respondent Inyo County Office of Education (Inyo County). Inyo County was also represented by Mr. Scharff.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: PARENT, STUDENT’s mother; Lynne Clark, speech and language pathologist; Howard Lehwald, special education director; Kathy Lehnert, speech and language pathologist. Respondents called the following witnesses: Alvin Sasuga, SELPA director and program specialist for Inyo County; Patricia Balthazor, speech and language pathologist; Judy Dore, special education principal in Crown Valley; Marilou Lundberg, former director of special education in the Ocean View Elementary School District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the closing briefs, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on August 5, 2003, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

1. Did the LEAs offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243?

2. If the LEAs failed to offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, do the programs identified by STUDENT’s mother meet the criteria?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a six-year-old child who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Bishop Union Elementary School District (District) and Inyo County Office of Education (Inyo County).

The parties were involved in a prior due process hearing that resulted in a decision dated February 27, 2003. The issues in that hearing involved generally whether STUDENT had received a free and appropriate public education from April 2000 up through the date of the decision. The Hearing Officer ordered Bishop Union Elementary School District and Inyo County Office of Education (the “LEAs”), in pertinent part, to either develop a program that would meet STUDENT’s needs, or locate one outside of the District. The decision order states:

1 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision STUDENT’s IEP team must meet to amend her December 19, 2002 IEP as follows:

a. STUDENT must be placed in a self-contained total communication class utilizing SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition; b. the class must be taught by a DHH credentialed teacher;

c. STUDENT must have a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign; d. All other aspects of STUDENT’s IEP, including program modifications identified in the December 19, 2002 IEP, are to remain the same.

2 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision STUDENT’s amended IEP must be implemented.

3 If, within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team determines that the LEAs are not able to provide a program that meets the criteria identified above, the LEAs must immediately secure an inter-district transfer to a district with an appropriate program or locate and enroll STUDENT in a non-public school that can implement the program.

4 If STUDENT is placed outside the county in a non-residential placement, then the LEAs will be responsible for providing all reasonable costs related to her placement including tuition, transportation, and associated living expenses.

5 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this decision STUDENT’s IEP team must meet to develop a plan for implementing the following compensatory education remedies and incorporate them into her IEP:

a. Placement in a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign through the 2003-2004 school year; b. Two hours per week for one year of SEE Sign sign language instruction for PARENT that may be attended by STUDENT and other family members.

6 By April 1, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team shall identify and incorporate into her IEP an appropriate total communication summer camp for STUDENT to attend during the 2003 and 2004 summers. In selecting a summer camp, the IEP team must keep in mind STUDENT’s age and consider arranging for PARENT to attend the summer camp.

7 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision, the LEAs will reimburse PARENT in the amount of $40.00 for a sign language class.

8 All of STUDENT’s other requests for relief are denied. (Footnote 3)

On March 21, 2003, the District and Inyo County convened an IEP team meeting and determined that there was no local program that met the decision criteria. The LEAs offered to immediately secure an interdistrict transfer to a CH class in San Bernardino, California, at a school called Newmark taught by Brenda Broadway, a DHH-credentialed teacher. Ms. PARENT rejected the offer and requested that her daughter be transferred to a different school district. Thereafter, the Petitioner requested the present hearing.

The central question in this limited proceeding is whether the placement at Newmark meets the criteria in the previous decision.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the LEAs offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243?

The LEAs offered to pursue an interdistrict transfer to the Newmark Elementary School program in the San Bernardino City Unified School District. (Footnote 4) The question is whether this program meets the criteria in the previous decision. Again, the critical elements of the previous order are as follows: (a) STUDENT must be placed in a self-contained total communication class utilizing SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition; (b) the class must be taught by a DHH credentialed teacher; (c) STUDENT must have a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign; (d) All other aspects of STUDENT’s IEP, including program modifications identified in the December 19, 2002 IEP, are to remain the same. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will discuss each of the above factors in relation to the Newmark program offered by the District. The Hearing Officer will then determine if he must consider matters not specifically delineated in the previous decision.

(a) Is the Newmark CH program a self-contained total communication class utilizing SEE Sign with emphasis on audition?

Petitioner argues that Newmark does not meet these criteria because American Sign Language (ASL) is used in addition to SEE sign in the classroom. The District’s special education director, Howard Lehwald, testified that the DHH teacher, Brenda Broadway, used SEE sign and ASL in the classroom during his observation. All other District witnesses who observed Ms. Broadway’s class testified that only SEE sign is used by Ms. Broadway. Alvin Saguga, the Inyo County SELPA director, testified that Mr. Lehwald was mistaken and that he could not distinguish between ASL and SEE sign. Patricia Balthazor, a speech pathologist who was present during Mr. Lehwald’s observation and has worked in Brenda Broadway’s classroom for one hour, four days each week during the entire 2002-2003 school year, testified that only SEE sign is used in the classroom. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Balthazor’s testimony persuasive: only SEE sign is used in Brenda Broadway’s classroom.

Petitioner also argues that the above criteria are not met because total communication is not used and the program lacks the requisite emphasis on audition. In support, Ms. PARENT testified that total communication was used during her observation (which lasted about an hour) only 85 percent of the time. Ms. Balthazor, who was present during Ms. PARENTS’s observation, explained that Ms. Broadway was engaged in a highly repetitive, language-based activity during Ms. PARENT’s observation. She further testified that Brenda Broadway emphasizes audition and uses total communication continuously. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Pat Balthazor persuasive over that of Ms. PARENTS because Ms. Balthazor has been in Ms. Broadway’s class on almost a daily basis for over a year. Ms. Balthazor was in a better position to know how Ms. Broadway’s class is taught, including whether it is a total communication classroom with emphasis on audition.

In short, the Hearing Officer finds that Newmark meets the criteria identified in part (1)(a) of the order in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, i.e., it is a self-contained total communication class utilizing SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition (b) Is the Newmark CH program must be taught by a DHH credentialed teacher?

It was not disputed that the teacher of the Newmark CH program offered by the LEAs is taught by a credentialed DHH teacher. Brenda Broadway has such a credential. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Newmark meets the criterion identified in part (1)(b) of the order in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, i.e., the class is taught by a DHH credentialed teacher.

(c) Does the Newmark CH program have a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE sign?

The next criterion is whether Brenda Broadway’s class has two peers who utilize SEE sign. After the prior decision was rendered, the LEAs sought clarification regarding “who constitutes DHH peers for STUDENT.” Hearing Officer Redmon provided the following clarification:

The District and COE also seek to have the Hearing Officer identify who constitutes DHH peers for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer directs the parties’ attention to page nineteen of the Decision. The Hearing Officer analyzes the issue of STUDENT’s peers for three paragraphs. In relevant part, the Decision states that “one to two other children who rely on total communication and are proficient in SEE sign would have constituted a ‘critical mass,’ thereby meeting STUDENT’s needs... .” The ages and grade levels of potential other students in STUDENT’s class was not raised at hearing. However, any other students in STUDENT’s class must rely on total communication and be at least as proficient as STUDENT in SEE sign. There is nothing further for the Hearing Officer to clarify.

The LEAs identified two peers who they contend meet the above requirement, a six-year ten-month-old DHH student and a ten-year two-month old DHH student. Given the prior decision and clarification order, two questions must now be answered: (1) whether the two peers are each at least as proficient in SEE sign as STUDENT and (2) whether the two peers rely on total communication.

Regarding the first question, whether the two peers are “at least as proficient as STUDENT in SEE sign,” the Respondents provided persuasive testimony from Pat Balthazor that both potential peers are currently learning SEE sign and are at least as proficient as STUDENT. Ms. Balthazor is familiar with STUDENT’s SEE sign proficiency (according to the previous decision) as well as the SEE sign proficiency of the two potential peers. The Petitioner presented no credible evidence to contradict Ms. Balthazor’s testimony. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the two potential peers are at least as proficient in SEE sign as STUDENT.

The next question is whether the two peers rely on total communication. Kathy Lehnert testified that the two potential peers are inappropriate for STUDENT because they lack “strong” oral communication skills. Ms. Balthazor, who is vastly more familiar with the two potential peer models, having worked with them during the 2002-2003 school year four days each week, testified that both are at or above STUDENT’s level in the area of total communication.

Ms. Lehnert’s testimony is not persuasive. First, the prior decision and clarification order require that the potential peers rely on total communication (signing and speaking). It does not require that they have “strong” or age-equivalent oral communication skills. Second, with regard to one of the children (the ten-year-old), Ms. Lehnert’s testimony was based on testing conducted by the House Ear Institute in May 2002, more than a year before the hearing. Ms. Lehnert had no current knowledge of the ten-year-old’s total communication skills. Third, Ms. Lehnert has never observed the two children in Ms. Broadway’s class (she has never observed the Newmark program at all).

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Balthazor’s testimony persuasive: the two potential peers rely on total communication. Ms. Balthazor, who testified in the previous hearing on behalf of STUDENT, and whose testimony the hearing officer relied upon heavily in drafting the pertinent criteria, is far more familiar with the language skills of the peers in Ms. Balthazor’s class than Ms. Lehnert. She has seen and worked with the subject students four days each week during the entire 2002-2003 school year.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that Newmark meets the criterion identified in part (1)(c) of the order in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, i.e., STUDENT will have a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign.

(d) Can the other aspects of STUDENT’s IEP, including program modifications identified in the December 19, 2002 IEP, be implemented if STUDENT is placed in the Nemark CH program?

It was not disputed that the other requirements of the December 2002 IEP can be implemented if STUDENT is placed in the Newmark CH program, and that the Respondents will supplement STUDENT’s placement if any of the portions of the December 2002 IEP are not currently available. (Testimony of Sasuga). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Newmark meets the criterion identified in part (1)(d) of the order in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243.

In sum, it has been found above that the District’s offered program at Newmark meets the decision criteria identified in the previous hearing officer’s decision. One question remains: Whether the Hearing Officer must also address other criteria not specifically delineated in the prior order of the prior decision. One such criterion is whether the Newmark program is the least restrictive environment (LRE) for STUDENT. (Footnote 5) The Hearing Officer asked the attorneys to address this issue in their closing briefs.

The Petitioner generally argued in her closing brief that IDEA mandates that disabled children be educated in the LRE, and therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine if Newmark is the LRE for STUDENT. She seeks an order requiring the LEAs to pursue an interdistrict transfer to Crown Valley in Laguna Niguel or Ocean View instead of Newmark. The LEAs failed to squarely address the issue in their closing brief. Instead, the LEAs argue that the parent’s preferred programs are inappropriate and one of the programs was rejected in the previous decision.

Under the unique facts and circumstances of this case, the Hearing Officer finds that he cannot consider other criteria, including whether Newmark is the LRE. (Footnote 6) First, the parties had the opportunity to address all other factors in the previous matter. The proper place for arguments such as LRE to be addressed was in the previous hearing, not belatedly in a limited proceeding related to enforcement of the prior decision. Second, the hearing officer in the previous decision noted that the window of opportunity for STUDENT to acquire language was rapidly closing. The decision sought to avoid another lengthy dispute regarding STUDENT’s compensatory education placement. It required the LEAs to quickly identify a program with, inter alia, two SEE sign peers who rely on total communication, not to “shop around” for an ideal program. (Footnote 7)

ISSUE NO. 2 If the LEAs failed to offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, do the programs identified by STUDENT’s mother meet the criteria?

Because it has been determined above that the program offered by the LEAs at Newmark met the criteria delineated in the previous decision, it is not necessary to determine if the programs preferred by the parent would have also met the criteria.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

Petitioner seeks compensatory education because of the LEAs’ alleged failure to offer a program that complied with the prior decision. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. Parents of Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). A hearing officer has broad authority to craft an appropriate equitable remedy. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497.

Petitioner requests compensatory education because of the LEAs’ alleged failure to timely offer a program that met the criteria in the previous decision. She seeks a day-for-day extension of her program described in the previous decision from the date the LEAs offered Newmark to the time she enters an appropriate program. However, because it has been found above that the LEAs timely offer of the Newmark program complied with the prior decision, Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory education.

Petitioner also alleges that the LEAs failed to offer her an appropriate summer camp during the summer of 2003 as ordered in the previous decision. She also alleges that they failed to provide Ms. PARENT with appropriate sign language instruction as ordered in the previous decision. She argues that she requires compensatory education because of these failures. (Footnote 8) Each request for compensatory education will be discussed below.

Total Communication Summer Camp

As described above, the Hearing Officer ordered STUDENT’s IEP team to identify and incorporate into her IEP an appropriate total communication summer camp for STUDENT to attend during the summers of 2003 and 2004. In selecting a summer camp, the IEP team was ordered to keep in mind STUDENT’s age and consider arranging for PARENT to attend the summer camp. Petitioner alleges that the Respondents failed to offer an appropriate program because the camp offered by the LEAs required her to stay overnight and be away from her mother. Ms. PARENT testified that her daughter was not emotionally ready to spend several nights away from her mother. The Respondents failed to provide any evidence, testimonial or documentary, to rebut Ms. PARENT’s testimony. The Respondents, however, had requested that the camp change its policy and allow STUDENT to stay overnight with her mother in a nearby hotel instead of at the camp. This request was denied.

The Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs, indeed, failed to take into consideration STUDENT’s age as ordered in the previous decision and failed to consider Ms. PARENT’s concern about being separated from her six-year-old daughter. They therefore failed to comply with paragraph six of the previous decision by offering an inappropriate summer camp and as a result, STUDENT lost educational opportunity. Based on the evidence and findings in the prior decision, STUDENT lost educational opportunity in the form of one year of summer camp. Therefore, the Respondents shall provide a total communication summer camp to STUDENT during the summer of 2005 in addition to the summer of 2004.

Sign Language Instruction

The fifth paragraph of the previous decision ordered the LEAs to, inter alia, provide Ms. PARENT with “two hours per week for one year of SEE sign language instruction.” The LEAs offered to provide sign language instruction from signing aide Kit Niehans. Ms. Niehans began providing signing instruction in the late spring of 2003, but Ms. PARENT missed several sessions and she eventually stopped attending altogether. (Testimony of PARENT). PARENT testified that she stopped going because Ms. Niehans was learning SEE sign herself and was not appropriately qualified to teach others. Petitioner also called as a witness Lynne Clark, a speech and language pathologist, who testified that she is familiar with Ms. Niehans’ signing ability. She testified that Ms. Niehans was learning SEE sign herself and that she had not mastered the vocabulary necessary to instruct others. However, Ms. Clark also testified that Ms. Niehans’s SEE signing abilities were better than either Ms. PARENT’s or Ms. Clark’s. The Respondents provided no persuasive evidence to contradict the testimony of either Ms. Clark or Ms. PARENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs failed to comply with paragraph five of the previous decision by failing to provide an instructor who was, at a minimum, proficient in SEE sign. The LEAs shall therefore, as compensatory education, provide one year of instruction from a SEE sign instructor to Ms. PARENT as ordered in the previous decision. The instructor shall be proficient in SEE sign. This instruction shall begin within twenty days of the date of this decision.

ORDER

1. Brenda Broadway’s CH class at Newmark meets the criteria described in the previous hearing officer’s decision. The LEAs shall comply with the previous decision and immediately endeavor to secure an interdistrict transfer to Newmark.

2. Petitioner shall receive the following compensatory education from the Respondents:

a. In addition to 2004, one additional year of summer camp during the summer of 2005, as described in Paragraph 6 of the previous decision; b. One year of signing instruction for Ms. PARENT, to commence within twenty days of the date of this decision, which complies with the previous decision, as described in Paragraph 5(b). The instructor shall be proficient in SEE sign.

3. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the LEAs offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243? The Respondents prevailed on this issue.

2. If the LEAs failed to offer a program that met the criteria in the decision in Consolidated Case No. SN02-2840/0243, do the programs identified by STUDENT’s mother meet the criteria? This issue was not reached.

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education The Respondents prevailed on this issue in part and the Petitioner prevailed in part. The Respondents prevailed with regard to STUDENT’s request for compensatory education stemming from the Respondents’ alleged failure to offer a program which complied with the previous decision. The Petitioner, however, prevailed with regard to the request for compensatory education stemming from the inappropriate offer of a summer camp, and the inappropriate signing instruction for Ms. PARENT.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: August 22, 200 Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. No substantive testimony was taken on July 10, 2003; PARENT was sworn in and the matter was then continued by mutual agreement of the parties to July 22, 2003. Additionally, on July 28, 2003, the matter convened via telephone conference for two rebuttal witnesses, Kathy Lehnert and Pat Balthazor.

2. The issues were discussed and clarified at length on the first day of hearing. They have been reorganized to facilitate appropriate analysis, but the substance remains the same.

3. Paragraph one of the order describes STUDENT’s appropriate placement for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, while paragraphs five and six describe compensatory education placements and services which span the period from the summer of 2003 through the summer of 2004 (including the entire 2003-2004 school year).

4. Presumably, the LEAs have discussed the possibility of obtaining an interdistrict transfer with the appropriate administrative personnel of the San Bernardino City School District.

5. The IDEA requires that disabled children such as STUDENT be educated with typically developing, non-disabled peers to the maximum extent appropriate. This is commonly referred to as the least restrictive environment or (LRE) requirement.

6. The arguments in the respective closing briefs were irrelevant.

7. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties are not without a remedy if they disagree with the prior decision. Their remedy, which they are currently exercising, is to appeal the previous decision.

8. The Hearing Officer notes that the compensatory education allegations stemming from the total communication summer camp and the signing instruction would not ordinarily be within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office because SEHO does not enforce its own orders. Enforcement of SEHO orders is one of the responsibilities of the California Department of Education. Under the unique circumstances of this case, the Hearing Officer had jurisdiction to decide these issues because the Hearing Officer was required to take testimony regarding the appropriateness of the summer camp offered by the LEAs as well as the qualifications of the SEE sign instructor. Moreover, the facts were intertwined (indeed, no additional witnesses were called) with the primary issue in this limited proceeding which was whether Newmark met the criteria in the prior decision. Moreover, as the previous decision indicates, STUDENT’s window of opportunity to acquire language is rapidly closing and, therefore, a clear and final decision addressing all matters was warranted.