California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 15, 2002

Student v. Encinitas Union School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1293-02 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke

Encinitas Union must add a temporary shadow aide for mainstreaming; Hearing Officer otherwise upholds special day class placement offer.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 11 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the District's motion to reconsider the June 25, 2002 stay put order issued by Hearing Officer Geary. No remand, court order, vacatur, or correction is noted.

Summary

The parent of a first-grader eligible under multiple disabilities filed for due process. Encinitas Union School District then filed its own case to defend its placement offer, and the two cases were combined. The student attended a regional special day class (SDC) for students with severe disabilities at Skyline Elementary in the Solana Beach School District. At first he spent half his day in general education. In January 2002 the parent initialed an IEP change that raised his special education time to 63 percent. She later said she signed under duress. The Hearing Officer found no duress or misrepresentation. The student also made strong progress with small-group instruction, so the 2001-2002 program provided a FAPE in the LRE. For 2002-2003, the district violated a stay put order by cutting his general education time for about two weeks. Separately, an administrator wrongly told the parent she would owe the district's attorney fees if she filed for due process. Neither violation denied FAPE. The district did not have to transport him to private therapies that were not in his IEP. The offer was a mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia Elementary for 70 percent of the day. The Hearing Officer found it appropriate and the LRE, but it lacked a shadow aide to help him learn routines when he first joined general education classes. The Hearing Officer ordered that aide and denied reimbursement and compensatory education.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a stay put order based on an incomplete record. The order stood because the district did not seek reconsideration in time, so departing from it was a violation. The decision also shows a Hearing Officer upholding a more restrictive SDC on Rowley-era benefit evidence while requiring an aide to support the transition.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1A(1). Did the District fail to provide FAPE procedurally from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year by making unilateral changes to Student's placement and program (increasing special education time to 63 percent through an IEP addendum allegedly obtained by misrepresentation, manipulation, and duress)?

    Parent observed the class and then initialed the January 17, 2002 addendum; no misrepresentation, duress, or promise to restore 50/50 inclusion, and the District reconvened the IEP team when the parent raised concerns.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1A(2). Did the District fail to provide FAPE from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year by failing to consider private assessments?

    No evidence of private assessments other than the Regional Center consultant's report, which he presented to the IEP team.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B. Did the District substantively provide FAPE from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year (63 percent special day class placement and aide support in regular education)?

    The 63 percent SDC placement, with one-on-two or one-on-one aide support in regular education, met the student's needs; he made significant progress with small-group academic instruction.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the District place Student in the least restrictive environment from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

    Student could not access the curriculum or make adequate progress in 50 percent regular education even with aide support, so an SDC with mainstreaming for nonacademic subjects was his LRE.

  5. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEStay put

    Issue 3A(1). Did the District make unilateral changes to Student's placement and program and violate the June 25, 2002 stay put order during the 2002-2003 school year?

    The stay put order named the 50/50 August 28, 2001 IEP; placing Student at about 30 percent inclusion for the first two weeks violated it, but no educational opportunity was lost and 50/50 was restored by September 23, 2002.

  6. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 3A(2). Did the District violate procedural safeguards when its director of pupil personnel services told the parent that if Student filed for due process, Student would have to pay the District's attorney fees?

    The statement was legally incorrect and entirely inappropriate, but it did not stop the parent from going forward with due process, so there was no denial of FAPE.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3A(3). Did the District fail to consider private assessments during the 2002-2003 school year?

    Student offered no evidence that the District failed to consider any private assessment.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3A(4). Did the District deny FAPE by denying the parent's request for transportation to privately obtained therapies?

    The District does not have to transport Student to private OT, PT, and speech therapy that are not in his IEP, and Student did not show he needed those extra therapies.

  9. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3B. Was the District's offer in the June 4, 2002 and June 21, 2002 IEPs (mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia Elementary for 70 percent of the day, with no regular education aide) substantively appropriate for the 2002-2003 school year?

    The mild/moderate SDC was designed to meet Student's needs and to provide educational benefit, but the offer lacked a shadow aide for his first period in regular education while he learned class routines.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. Did the District's offered placement contained in the June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 IEPs constitute the least restrictive environment for Student?

    Because Student could not get academic benefit in a 50/50 inclusion setting even with an aide, the mild/moderate SDC for 70 percent of the day was his LRE.

  11. Issue 5. If the District failed to provide and offer Student a FAPE in the LRE, is he entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services procured by the parent or compensatory education?

    FAPE was offered, and the District had in fact provided aide support in regular education, so no tutoring reimbursement or compensatory education was owed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District shall provide Student with a shadow instructional aide during his time in the regular education classroom until he has learned routine class activities (the decision also directs that the IEP be revised to add this aide).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District

People named in the decision

  • Beverly Barrett, director of pupil personnel services, Encinitas Union School District
  • Janet Berggren, special day class teacher (regional SDC for students with severe disabilities), Skyline Elementary School, Solana Beach School District
  • Lisa Helwig, principal, Skyline Elementary School, Solana Beach School District
  • Mark Luciano, educational consultant (also described as Regional Center psychologist), San Diego Regional Center
  • Sharon Loveman, school psychologist, Solana Beach School District
  • Cindy Frazee, director of pupil services, Solana Beach School District
  • Germaine Palmore, special day class teacher (mild/moderate SDC), Mission Estancia Elementary School, Encinitas Union School District
  • Robin Baldwin, special day class teacher / instructional aide support, Skyline Elementary School
  • Ms. Lawson, regular education first-grade teacher, Skyline Elementary School
  • Ms. Cortney, regular education first-grade teacher, Skyline Elementary School
  • Mr. Darlin, first-grade general education teacher (mainstreaming), Mission Estancia Elementary School
  • Geary, Hearing Officer who issued the June 25, 2002 stay put order, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Robert Roice, educational consultant representing the District, Encinitas Union School District
  • Ellen Dowd, attorney for Student
  • Children's Solana Beach Center, private provider of speech-language therapy, OT, and PT
  • Winston School, nonpublic school requested by the parent
  • Flora Vista School, school proposed by the parent for full inclusion

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encinitas, California, on October 3, 4, and 8, 2002.

STUDENT (hereafter, Student or STUDENT ) was represented at the hearing by attorney Ellen Dowd. Also present on behalf of the Student was MOTHER, STUDENT ’s mother. Encinitas Union School District (hereafter, District or Encinitas) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District was Beverly Barrett, director of pupil personnel services for the District.

The following witnesses were called by Student to testify: Beverly Barrett; Janet Berggren, STUDENT ’s current special education teacher; Lisa Helwig, principal at Skyline Elementary School; Mark Luciano, educational consultant with the San Diego Regional Center; Sharon Loveman, school psychologist for the Solana Beach School District; Cindy Frazee, director of pupil services for the Solana Beach School District; and MOTHER.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Germaine Palmore, special day class teacher at Mission Estancia Elementary School.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), both procedurally and substantively, from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

2. Did the District place STUDENT in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

3. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, during the 2002-2003 school year?

4. Did the District’s offered placement contained in the June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 individualized education programs (IEP) constitute the least restrictive environment for STUDENT ?

5. If the District failed to provide and offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, is he entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services procured by STUDENT ’s parent or compensatory education?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a six year eleven-month-old student who initially received special education services on the basis of a speech/language impairment. STUDENT ’s district of residence is the Encinitas Union School District. STUDENT currently attends school in the Solana Beach School District at Skyline Elementary School (Skyline), where he is a first-grade student in Janet Berggren’s regional special day class (SDC) for severely handicapped students in grades kindergarten and first.(Footnote 2)

Pursuant to a Hearing Officer stay put Order, which identified STUDENT ’s August 28, 2001 IEP as his stay put placement, STUDENT is mainstreamed into regular education classes for 50 percent of his school day, and receives designated instruction and services (DIS) in the areas of occupational therapy (OT), adaptive physical education (APE), and speech and language. STUDENT also receives transportation to and from school and extended school year (ESY) services. During his time in the regular education class, STUDENT , along with one other student, has the support of an instructional aide. However, the services of the aide are not indicated as part of his IEP.

At an IEP team meeting held on January 17, 2002, the District members of the team recommended that STUDENT increase the amount of time he spent in the special education classroom to 63 percent and begin receiving most of his academic subjects, including language arts and math, in the special education class. His speech and language services also were increased by fifteen minutes a week. The recommendation was based on the team’s belief that STUDENT needed increased opportunities for learning in a small-group setting with specialized instruction. STUDENT ’s mother, MOTHER, indicated that she wanted to first observe STUDENT in class before adding three hours of special education each week to his IEP. Consequently, some time after the January 17, 2002 IEP meeting, MOTHER observed STUDENT in the special education class, and later initialed the IEP to agree to increase the amount of time STUDENT would spend outside of regular education to 63 percent. MOTHER also agreed to increase STUDENT ’s speech and language services by fifteen minutes and to move the dates of the annual and triennial IEPs to April 2002. According to MOTHER, however, she initialed the changes to the IEP under duress and not by her choice. Notwithstanding MOTHER’s testimony that she actually did not agree with the change in STUDENT ’s inclusion time, STUDENT ’s time in special education was in fact increased to 63 percent sometime after the January 17, 2002 IEP team meeting, and remained that way until the end of the 2001-2002 school year.

A total of four additional IEP meetings were held within the months of March, April, and May 2002, during which the results of assessments in the areas of OT, APE, speech and language, achievement, development, psycho-educational, and health were all shared and discussed, and STUDENT ’s disability eligibility category was changed from speech and language to multiple disabilities. Currently, STUDENT receives services under the eligibility category of multiple disabilities. STUDENT has global developmental delays accompanied by gross motor and visual motor delays. He also has delays in language and his pragmatic language is atypically developed. During an IEP meeting held on March 25, 2002, MOTHER stated that she observed at home that STUDENT ’s increased time outside the regular education class was having a negative effect on his health. She also shared with the IEP team a prescription from STUDENT ’s doctor which stated that STUDENT ’s then-current placement (63% special education/37% regular education) was having a negative effect on his health. No changes, however, were made to his inclusion time.

At approximately 7:52 a.m. on June 4, 2002, Regional Center psychologist Mark Luciano called the school on behalf of MOTHER to cancel the previously scheduled 8:00 a.m. IEP meeting for that day because she was unable to attend due to a family emergency. The District called MOTHER to notify her that the meeting would be held without her to put a placement and services offer in writing, that the IEP document would be sent home, and that the team would be happy to reconvene to explain and discuss the offered placement and services.(Footnote 3) At that meeting, the District members of the IEP team recommended placement for STUDENT in a mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia Elementary School (Mission Estancia) in the District for six and one-half hours per day, five days a week (70%); DIS of speech and language, OT, and

APE; ESY in the Encinitas Union School District during the summer of 2002, and transportation.(Footnote 4) The IEP document was forwarded to MOTHER.

On June 11, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT . Within that request was a motion for STUDENT to “stay put” in his current placement at Skyline. On June 25, 2002, the Hearing Office issued an order indicating that the August 28, 2001 IEP was the last implemented placement, which included the combined SDC/general education placement at Skyline. However, the June 25, 2002 Hearing Office stay put Order did not reference the amount of time STUDENT was required to be in either the special education or regular education classrooms, nor did either party dispute that issue at the time the motion was addressed.

On June 17, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request for due process on behalf of the District, seeking to determine the appropriateness of its June 4, 2002 placement offer. The District also requested that its case be consolidated with the previously filed Student’s case. The matters were consolidated by an Order of the Hearing Office dated July 1, 2002.

The last IEP meeting for STUDENT was held on June 21, 2002. During that meeting, the IEP team discussed MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT had regressed. However, the educational members of the IEP team, including STUDENT ’s SDC teacher, Janet Berggren, did not share MOTHER’s concern, particularly because Ms. Berggren had seen STUDENT make substantial progress on his goals and objectives since increasing the amount of time that he spent in special education for academics. (Pet.’s Exh. 28, pg.1 of IEP team meeting notes.) MOTHER suggested a full inclusion program for STUDENT at Flora Vista School with a one-on-one aide. The educational members of the IEP team believed that this placement would be inappropriate and that it would not provide STUDENT with a FAPE because mainstreaming had not been successful in kindergarten that year. MOTHER also requested that STUDENT be placed in the nonpublic Winston school; however, the District members of the IEP team responded that Winston was extremely restrictive, would not provide STUDENT access to typical peers, and that the teachers there would potentially not be trained in special education, all of which would also create transition problems beyond which STUDENT would experience in a special education supported classroom. Additionally, MOTHER requested a behavioral program for STUDENT ; however, the rest of the IEP team felt that the interventions listed on the IEP’s Special Factors page were appropriate and that STUDENT responded well to the present program. MOTHER also requested that STUDENT have a one-on-one aide for academic support and DIS. However, the educational members of the team also did not believe STUDENT required this level of support.

The educational members of the June 21, 2002 IEP team did, however, agree with MOTHER’s request that STUDENT be taught and treated as a typical child, that one-on-one instruction be added to his IEP as deemed appropriate by instructional staff, and that he be given access to computers as appropriate. According to the IEP Addendum, the entire IEP, including the goals and objectives, were to be reviewed thirty days after STUDENT changed placements. MOTHER chose not to sign the June 21, 2002 IEP Addendum and indicated that she did not agree with the changes in placement proposed in the June 4, 2002 IEP.

During the summer of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received ESY services in the special day class at Skyline in the Solana Beach School District. STUDENT resumed his instruction in the fall of the 2002-2003 school year by continuing in Ms. Berggren’s SDC; however, STUDENT was now in the first grade and placed in the special education classroom for approximately 70 percent of his school day, and in Ms. Lawson’s and Ms. Cortney’s shared regular education class for approximately 30 percent of his school day for mostly nonacademic subjects.(Footnote 5) He participated with typical peers for recess, lunch, wheel activities, computer lab, art, physical education, science, media center, and music.

On August 27, 2002, MOTHER sent a letter to Ms. Berggren advising her that the stay put order required the school to provide STUDENT with inclusion with typical students for 50 percent of his school day and placement in the SDC for the remaining 50 percent. Ms. Barrett responded to MOTHER by letter dated August 29, 2002, stating that the addendum to the IEP written on January 17, 2002, identifies that STUDENT is to spend 63 percent of his school day outside of the regular classroom and be mainstreamed for 37 percent of his school day. MOTHER then retained attorney Ellen Dowd, who forwarded a letter dated September 19, 2002, to Ms. Berggren requesting that the District place STUDENT back in his 50/50 inclusion placement pursuant to the stay put order indicating that the August 28, 2001 IEP was the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP. As a result of this exchange of letters between the parties, STUDENT ’s program was reinstated to the 50/50 level and has remained that way to date.

Additionally, on August 30, 2002, MOTHER submitted a transportation application to the District requesting a change in STUDENT ’s bus schedule. Specifically, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be picked up in the mornings at Flora Vista (where STUDENT ’s younger sibling attends school) and be returned two days a week to his daycare, and three days a week to Children’s Solana Beach Center, where he received privately obtained speech and language therapy, OT, and physical therapy (PT). By letter dated September 5, 2002, from Ms. Barrett, the District denied MOTHER’s request to have STUDENT transported to Children’s Solana Beach Center and also denied the request to have the morning bus pick up STUDENT at Flora Vista. By letter dated September 10, 2002, Ms. Dowd wrote Ms. Barrett, that because STUDENT ’s therapies were medically necessary, STUDENT had the right to transportation one way after school to Children’s Solana Beach Center. The District did not grant STUDENT ’s transportation request.

This case proceeded to hearing on October 3, 2002.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), both procedurally and substantively, from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT ’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following three requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP.

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)

A. Procedural Appropriateness (1) Making unilateral changes to his placement and program

Student contends that the District unilaterally changed his placement without his parent’s consent when, pursuant to the IEP Addendum dated January 17, 2002, the IEP team increased the amount of time he would spend in the SDC to 63 percent after procuring his mother’s agreement with the January 17, 2002 IEP by “misrepresentation and manipulation.” Student contends that his mother relied upon the IEP team’s written and oral promises to change his placement back to a 50 percent inclusion placement if his mother was not happy with the placement. Additionally, according to Student’s mother, MOTHER, she wanted to place the word “temporary” next to her initials on the January 17, 2002 IEP; however, Ms. Helwig indicated that it was not necessary to do so. According to MOTHER, she was intimidated by Ms. Helwig’s hostile gesture and words, and initialed the lines of the IEP dated January 17, 2002, under duress. Student also argues that the District failed to later discuss his mother’s concerns about changing his placement back to the 50/50 inclusion program.

The District contends that MOTHER first observed the placement prior to consenting to the change in the inclusion time noted in the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum, and then initialed the IEP to agree to the reduction in general education time. According to the District, STUDENT ’s placement then changed and the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum was implemented for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year.

Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)

No student is required to participate in all or part of any special education program unless the parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the IEP, and thereafter, consents, in writing, to all or part of the IEP. (Ca. Educ. Code § 56346(a).) The Hearing Officer notes that the parties’ dispute does not involve whether MOTHER actually signed the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum. Rather, the dispute involves whether MOTHER’s signature was induced by misrepresentation and manipulation.

The evidence does not support MOTHER’s contention that the District misrepresented its intentions regarding changing STUDENT ’s program. In fact, the IEP notes of the January 17, 2002 IEP meeting state that “if staff or parent observe behaviors of concern, IEP will reconvene if difficulty occurs. Parent wants to observe prior to adding the 3 hrs. [each] week.” (Pet.’s Exh. 10.)

Thus, the IEP notes reflect that the IEP team was willing to reconvene if difficulty occurred. There is no indication in the notes that STUDENT ’s placement would automatically be changed back to 50 percent inclusion if MOTHER asked for that change. In fact, Skyline principal Lisa Helwig testified that she never indicated that the changes in the Addendum were temporary, and at no time did anyone request to put the word “temporary” in the IEP document. The evidence did not demonstrate that the District promised to change STUDENT ’s placement back to 50 percent inclusion upon the parent’s request. (Id.)

The evidence also indicates that the IEP team members understood that MOTHER was not pleased with STUDENT ’s increased time in special education. Although her concerns were noted on the March 25, 2002 IEP document, there were no lengthy discussions during IEP team meetings regarding MOTHER’s concerns, presumably because the District and school members of the IEP team knew that MOTHER would not agree to the team’s proposed change in placement. (Testimony of C. Frazee.) However, MOTHER’s concerns with the inclusion program were noted on the March 25, 2002 IEP document, and MOTHER discussed this matter with Ms. Frazee and Ms. Loveman. (Testimonies of C. Frazee & S. Loveman.) Therefore, it is found that the IEP team did exactly what the January 17, 2002 IEP document states -- it reconvened the IEP team in March 2002 once MOTHER expressed concern over STUDENT ’s increased time in the special education class and discussed her concerns with her.

The IEP team’s response to MOTHER’s concern was to conduct additional assessments, review those assessments at six additional IEP team meetings, and ultimately, come to a different conclusion than MOTHER -- that STUDENT ’s time in special education needed to be further increased rather than restored to the 50/50 inclusion program. MOTHER had the option of filing for a due process hearing if she disagreed with the IEP team’s January 17, 2002 recommendation that STUDENT be placed in special education for 63 percent of his school day. She chose to do so, but not until June 2002. The mere fact that the IEP team did not agree with MOTHER’s preference that STUDENT return to his 50/50 inclusion placement does not, in and of itself, “seriously infringe on the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process.” Nor was there any evidence that STUDENT lost any educational opportunity by remaining in the special education classroom for 63 percent of his school day for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year. In fact, the evidence indicated that STUDENT showed progress when his program was changed to increase his time in special education and receive more small-group instruction. (Testimonies of J. Berggren, L. Helwig, and B. Barrett; Resp.’s Exh. 21.)

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Helwig’s testimony to be credible as to the understanding between the District and the parent that the change in STUDENT ’s placement was not “temporary,” but that the IEP team could reconvene at any time to make changes. The evidence does not support a finding that MOTHER was under duress when she signed the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum, because she was given time to the review the IEP document and observe the actual placement, and she came back to the school to sign the document after having observed the classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not induce MOTHER to sign the IEP dated January 17, 2002, nor did it promise to change STUDENT ’s program back to the 50/50 inclusion program if MOTHER expressed concern. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District did not unilaterally make changes to STUDENT ’s program. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District responded to MOTHER’s concerns by conducting numerous assessments of STUDENT . After having convened numerous IEP team meetings to review and discuss the assessment results, the educational members of the IEP team ultimately had a different opinion as to what was the appropriate program for STUDENT .

(2) Failing to consider private assessments

Student alleges that he was denied a FAPE because the District failed to consider private assessments. However, Student failed to provide any evidence to support this claim. The only assessment performed by someone other that District or school personnel was an education consultation done by Mark Luciano, education consultant for the San Diego Regional Center. Based on his consultation, Mr. Luciano wrote a report that summarized what he does as an education consultant. In his report, Mr. Luciano specifically states that he presented the results of his observation of STUDENT to the IEP team during the April 23, 2002 IEP team meeting. Additionally, Mr. Luciano also attended STUDENT ’s May 15, 2002, June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 IEP team meetings, and during the last meeting he spoke on behalf of MOTHER. (Pet.’s Exh. 29.)

On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds there was no evidence that the District failed to consider private assessments. Other than Mr. Luciano’s education consultation report, there were no private assessments performed on behalf of STUDENT that were presented in evidence.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

As stated earlier, the standard for evaluating the substantive appropriateness of the District’s program involves three factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address STUDENT ’s unique needs, whether the placement and services were calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and whether the placement and services conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S. C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT ’s Unique Needs and Provide Educational Benefit

To determine whether the program and placement the District provided STUDENT from January 17, 2002, to end of the 2001-2002 school year constituted a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT ’s unique needs.

At the time of STUDENT ’s January 2002 IEP meeting, the educational members of the IEP team reported that STUDENT , overall, had been making some progress in most of his goal areas, but continued to experience significant difficulties in attending to task, working independently, paying attention and maintaining focus when working, and socially interacting absent adult prompt or facilitation.

Information available at the time of the January 2002 meeting, and later confirmed by additional evaluations completed in March 2002, showed that STUDENT exhibited delay in relation to all developmental domains. The parties do not dispute the deficits that resulted from STUDENT ’s disabilities. The parties agreed that STUDENT had delays in the development of cognitive abilities, which were reflected in delayed development of academic, linguistic, and social skills. STUDENT ’s academic skills were significantly below the expected level for his age and grade. His ability to apply academic skills was very low, and his level of academic knowledge was low average. His performance was low in basic reading skills and reading comprehension, and very low in math reasoning. His knowledge of phoneme-grapheme relationships was also very low. Additionally, although his fine motor coordination was developing nicely, his visual-motor integration was atypically developed for his age. Notwithstanding STUDENT ’s significant delays in the areas of receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language, language nevertheless appeared to be an area of relative strength for STUDENT . STUDENT appropriately greeted peers during speech sessions, but continued to need support in conversational turn-taking and topic initiation. (Pet.’s Exhs. 16, 19, & 20.)

Thus, the parties generally agreed regarding the identification of STUDENT ’s needs. However, the parties did not agree on how STUDENT ’s needs could best be addressed. According to the educational members of the IEP team, STUDENT needed to increase his opportunities for learning in a small-group setting with specialized instruction, which could be found in an SDC. Those members of the IEP team also believed STUDENT needed to have his academic curriculum presented to him at his level and away from the regular education peers, because he would get frustrated when he could not do what they were doing. It bothered STUDENT tremendously because he knew he could not keep up with the typical peers. (Testimony of J. Berggren.)

However, STUDENT ’s parent did not believe that he needed the team’s recommended supplemental three hours of special education instruction because she believed he would not benefit from spending additional time with children who were severely handicapped. Specifically, Student contends that he should have remained in the regular education classroom for 50 percent of his school day. Student also argues that he was not provided one-on-one aide support or any other aids, services, or reasonable modifications that might have assisted him in attending to task, working independently, and interacting socially. (Student’s closing brief, pg. 19.)

The Hearing Officer now turns her attention to the placement and aide support provided by the District from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, to determine whether those aspects of his program were designed to meet STUDENT ’s needs and provide him with educational benefit.

Special Day Class placement

The Hearing Officer found above that the change made to STUDENT ’s placement pursuant to the January 17, 2002 IEP was not done unilaterally by the District and that there was no misrepresentation and manipulation. Notwithstanding that conclusion, the Hearing Officer now must determine whether the change to STUDENT ’s placement was appropriate to meet his needs and provide him with educational benefit.

When STUDENT ’s placement changed in January 2002 to a reduced 37 percent inclusion in regular education, the additional 13 percent of time that he spent in special education was in Robin Baldwin’s SDC with approximately four other special education students. (Testimony of MOTHER.) He received an additional 3 hours each week of his academic instruction, including language arts and math, in Ms. Baldwin’s SDC, instead of in the regular education kindergarten classroom. (Testimonies of MOTHER and L. Helwig.) He still, however, also spent 50 percent of his school day in Ms. Berggren’s SDC. Ms. Baldwin’s and Ms. Berggren’s classes were substantially similar in that they both included severely handicapped students. He participated with typical peers for recess, lunch, wheel activities, computer lab, art, physical education, science, media center, and music. (Testimony of J. Berggren.)

According to Ms. Berggren, the reduction of STUDENT ’s time in the regular education classroom was necessary because STUDENT was having a hard time maintaining his attention even when his instruction was modified. STUDENT would see what others were doing academically, and would become frustrated when he could not do the same activities. When STUDENT ’s activities were modified to a level at which he could perform, he did not want to do his work, but preferred to do what others were doing. STUDENT also was unable to address his academic goals and objectives and could not concentrate on what was being taught. (Testimony of J. Berggren; Resp.’s Exh. 5, pg. 1.) STUDENT was not mastering or retaining what was presented in the regular education kindergarten program. (Pet.’s Exh. 10, pg. 2.)

STUDENT ’s program changed pursuant to the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum. However, the difficulties with transition or change in expected routines that were reported by MOTHER in the home, were not evident at school. Ms. Berggren and Ms. Helwig both testified that STUDENT did not regress or withdraw when his routine changed and neither of them had seen him negatively affected by the change in personnel. Additionally, he made significantly more academic progress when he received mostly small-group instruction at his level in Ms. Baldwin’s severely handicapped special day class. Ms. Berggren, Ms. Helwig, and Ms. Frazee all persuasively testified that STUDENT made significant progress, academically and behaviorally, by receiving his academic instruction in the special education classroom in small groups.(Footnote 6) Their testimony was further supported by STUDENT ’s progress on his goals and objectives and improvement noted in his written work after being pulled out of regular education for language arts. (Testimony of L. Helwig.) By March 2002, STUDENT had either made partial progress or substantial progress on most of his goals. (Resp.’s Exh. 21.) Moreover, STUDENT ’s scores on the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development, administered between February and March 2002, indicated that he was functioning at approximately one year below his chronological age in basic reading, basic math, manuscript writing, and for general knowledge and comprehension. (Pet.’s Exh. 24.) This testing demonstrated significant progress in his discrete academic and functional skills from last year, when he was functioning 1 to 2 years below his then chronological age of 5 on academic skills. (Pet.’s Exh. 9, pg. 3; Testimony of S. Loveman.) All of the IEP team members, except MOTHER, believed very strongly that STUDENT ’s placement for 50 percent of his school day in the regular education classroom was not appropriate because he did not achieve academic growth in that setting.

The evidence discussed above leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that STUDENT was appropriately placed in special education for 63 percent of his school day. This placement in the SDCs addressed his academic needs and the time spent in regular education allowed him to have time with typical peers from whom he could learn appropriate learning behavior and work on social goals. There was also substantial evidence that STUDENT made progress on his goals and objectives when he received academic instruction in small groups while in the special education classroom. Thus, this placement was designed to meet his unique needs and provided him with educational benefit. Aide support in regular education

Student contends that the District failed to provide him appropriate aide support from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year when his placement was changed from the 50/50 inclusion program to increased time in special education at 63 percent. Student did not clearly articulate at hearing or in his closing brief, however, exactly how he believes he was denied appropriate aide support. Additionally, the record is not entirely clear as to what aide support STUDENT received during this specific time frame. However, the evidence did show that when STUDENT was included in the regular education class for 50 percent of his school day at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, Robin Baldwin provided instructional aide support to him while he was in the regular education classroom. (Testimony of J. Berggren.) It appears he continued to receive some aide support when his time in the regular education classroom was reduced. (See Pet.’s Exh. 17 - Loveman’s observation notes; Testimony of L. Helwig.) During this time frame, the evidence indicates that STUDENT regularly received one-on-two aide support while in the regular education classroom and often received one-on-one aide support when the other student who was normally in his group was pulled out of class to receive other services. (Testimony of J. Berggren.)

Because there routinely were times when STUDENT had one-on-one instructional aide support, the IEP team was able to conclude that one-on-one aide support had not made a difference in his ability to progress in the regular education classroom. Therefore, there was general agreement among the educational members of the IEP team at the January 17, 2002 IEP meeting that STUDENT ’s time in the regular education class would be reduced and that additional aide support was not appropriate. (Testimony of J. Berggren.)

From the information obtained through witness testimony and documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, the District provided STUDENT aide support necessary to meet his unique needs. STUDENT received aide support while in the regular education classroom on either a one-on-one or one-on-two basis, which allowed him to address his difficulties in attending to task, working independently, attention and focus, and social interaction. (Pet.’s Exh. 10, pg. 1.) There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required more aide support than what was provided in order to meet his needs and benefit from his education.

Comported with his IEP

Student claims that the District’s placement failed to comport with his IEP when it reduced his inclusion from 50 percent to 37 percent and misrepresented to his parent that it would be changed back to 50 percent if his parent had concerns. As decided above, the Hearing Officer found that the District did not promise to change the IEP back to a 50/50 inclusion program if the parent disapproved of STUDENT ’s progress, and the District did not manipulate the parent into signing the IEP document. Rather, the evidence indicated that the District would reconvene an IEP team meeting, which it did, and would consider changes if the parent expressed concern. Although the parent expressed concern and the IEP team reconvened on several occasions, the District members of the IEP team did not agree with MOTHER that STUDENT ’s program should be changed back to the 50/50 inclusion program. Given that disagreement, MOTHER was then free to file for a due process hearing as soon as she understood that the other members of the IEP team disagreed with her. She chose to do so in June 2002.

**** The District did not unilaterally change Student’s placement, nor was there evidence that the District failed to consider any private assessments and, therefore, that issue played no role in determining whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE. Additionally, the 63 percent placement in special education with one-on-two or one-on-one aide support while in the regular education classroom was designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Accordingly, the 63 percent placement in special education and the aide support that was provided were appropriate for STUDENT and constituted a FAPE from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year.

2. Did the District place STUDENT in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

The next analytical step is to determine whether, in the context of STUDENT ’s entire program, the 63 percent inclusion in the SDC portion of his placement was in STUDENT ’s least restrictive environment (LRE). Student alleges that the District failed to include him in regular education to the maximum extent possible by reducing his amount of inclusion from 50 percent to 37 percent.

Special education law requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT ’s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Ca. Educ. Code § 56031.) The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R. R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-1045.)

As discussed above, STUDENT ’s behavioral and academic needs made it difficult for him to learn in the regular classroom, despite the assistance of a one-on-two or one-on-one instructional aide. While STUDENT learned certain routine activities and imitated his typical peers’ behaviors, his behavior was negatively affected by his inability to perform academically compared with the other regular education students. Additionally, despite STUDENT ’s typically friendly demeanor, the quality of his social reciprocity was immature, resulting in some distancing from typical peers in this sense, which indicated a risk for withdrawal. STUDENT avoided competing with other children and tended to play alone. Thus, while there were some nonacademic benefits to STUDENT ’s placement in regular education, the negative effects were significant. There was no significant evidence that STUDENT ’s presence in the regular education classroom negatively affected the teacher or the other students in the classroom. Rather, his placement there had a much greater negative impact on himself. (Testimony of J. Berggren; Pet.’s Exhs. 17, 20, & 25.) Therefore, STUDENT needed the structure and small teacher-to-student ratio of a special education classroom, since he could not make satisfactory academic progress in the regular education classroom with aide support. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); see also Sacramento Unified School District v. Holland (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

The evidence has established that STUDENT ’s 50 percent inclusion in the regular education classroom was not his LRE because he was unable to access the curriculum and make adequate progress on his goals and objectives in that setting. Rather, STUDENT ’s LRE was in a special education classroom with mainstreaming for nonacademic subjects.

3. Did the District fail to provide and offer STUDENT a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, during the 2002-2003 school year?

A. Procedural Appropriateness

Student contends that the District committed a number of procedural violations during the 2002-2003 school year, all of which are discussed below.

(1) Making unilateral changes to his placement and program and violating the June 25, 2002 stay put Order

Student argues that the District misrepresented in writing the correct percentage of inclusion during STUDENT ’s stay put placement and failed to provide 50 percent inclusion in regular education until over two weeks after the 2002-2003 school year started.

The District contends that no unilateral changes were made to Student’s placement and program because the change to a 63 percent placement in special education was the last agreed upon and implemented placement, and thus the true stay-put placement, notwithstanding the Hearing Office’s June 25, 2002 Order.

The parties do not dispute that for the first two weeks of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was not provided with 50 percent inclusion in the regular education classroom. The Hearing Office’s stay put Order dated June 25, 2002, indicated that the August 28, 2001 IEP was the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP. However, after examination of the record, this Hearing Officer concludes that the June 25, 2002 stay put Order was based upon the limited record that was made available to the ruling hearing officer, which did not include a copy of the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum or any declaration referencing it. (Pet.’s Exh. 10.)(Footnote 7) When the Hearing Office requested that the parties provide it with Student’s last agreed-upon IEP and sworn declarations setting forth Student’s then-current educational placement, both parties responded by submitting the IEP dated August 28, 2001. The District made no misrepresentation when responding to Student’s stay put motion. However, neither party submitted the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum, or made any reference to the fact that the percentage of regular education inclusion time had been reduced to 37 percent pursuant to that IEP Addendum.

As concluded in Issue 1 above, the IEP dated January 17, 2002, was signed and agreed upon by MOTHER, and although she later disagreed with the change in inclusion time, the Hearing Officer found that her signature was not procured by misrepresentation or manipulation by the District. However, because the Hearing Office issued a stay put Order stating that the August 28, 2001 IEP indicated the stay put placement, and the District failed to move within a reasonable time for reconsideration of that Order based on information it believed that the Hearing Officer did not have when making that Order, that stay put order stands, even though it may be incorrect. Thus, the District was required to comply with the provisions of the June 25, 2002 stay put Order, unless the parties agreed otherwise.

Therefore, when the 2002-2003 school year began and the District placed STUDENT in a program with approximately 30 percent inclusion for the first two weeks, the District essentially unilaterally changed STUDENT ’s program and placement without the parent’s consent and consequently violated the June 25, 2002 Hearing Office stay put Order. However, notwithstanding the District’s procedural violation, there was no evidence that Student lost any educational opportunity by not being placed in his 50/50 inclusion program for the first two weeks of the 2002-2003 school year. (See FAPE discussion in Issue 1.) Additionally, by September 23, 2002, STUDENT ’s placement was changed back to the 50/50 inclusion program. (Testimonies of J. Berggren and L. Helwig.) Thus, the District’s failure to abide by the terms of the June 25, 2002 Hearing Office stay put Order for the first two weeks of the 2002-2003 school year did not result in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT .

(2) Stating to Student’s parent that “if Student files due process, Student will have to pay the District’s attorney fees”

Student argues that the District violated procedural safeguards when Beverly Barrett, its director of pupil personnel services, told MOTHER that if Student filed due process, Student would have to pay the District’s attorney’s fees. MOTHER testified that as a result of Ms. Barrett’s statements, she felt intimidated and did not want to move forward with the due process hearing. Nevertheless, MOTHER did proceed with the due process hearing. Ms. Barrett testified that she did not threaten MOTHER that she would have to pay the District’s attorney’s fees, but stated that she did tell MOTHER that she intended to pursue collection of the fees from her.

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Barrett’s actions were not only legally incorrect but also entirely inappropriate because they could have intimidated the parent into not proceeding with Student’s right to file for a due process hearing. However, because there is no evidence that Ms. Barrett’s actions affected Student’s willingness to proceed with the due process claim, there was no denial of FAPE for this procedural violation.(Footnote 8)

(3) Failing to consider private assessments

Student provided no evidence that the District failed to consider any private assessments. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no denial of FAPE by reason of the District’s alleged failure to consider private assessments.

(4) Denying the parent’s request for transportation to private therapies

Student contends that the District is obligated to transport him to his privately obtained therapies because they are identical to the DIS provided pursuant to STUDENT ’s IEP. The District argues that it is not required to transport Student to services not authorized by his IEP. According to the District, its only obligation is to transport the student to and from school.

The therapeutic services privately obtained by Student at the Childrens’ Solana Beach Center were not a part of any of STUDENT ’s IEPs. Although Student argues that the occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), and speech and language services are identical to the services listed under the DIS section on STUDENT ’s IEP, and that they support his education in the same fashion that his school therapies do, the District is not legally required to provide Student transportation to privately obtained services that are not authorized under an agreed-upon IEP. Like all related services, transportation must be provided when determined to be necessary to assist a student in obtaining benefit from his special education program. (34 C.F.R. § 300.24; Ca. Educ. Code § 56363(a).) However, STUDENT ’s IEP did not provide that any related services were to be provided by private therapists or that such supplemental therapeutic services were needed. Nor did his IEP provide for reimbursement for private services rendered by a private agency, including related travel expenses. All of the DIS that STUDENT receives pursuant to his currently implemented IEP are provided at the school site. (Pet.’s Exh. 9, pg. 1.) Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that the Student failed to prove that he required the supplemental therapies in order to meet his unique needs and provide him educational benefit and also did not show that the District’s DIS were not appropriate.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is not required to provide transportation for Student to the location of his privately obtained OT, PT, and speech and language therapy. Student was, therefore, not denied a FAPE by reason of the District’s denial of the parent’s request for transportation to private therapy services.

*** In light of all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no denial of FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year based upon procedural violations of the IDEA.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

As previously stated, the standard for evaluating the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer involves three factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address STUDENT ’s unique needs, whether the placement and services would have provided him with educational benefit, and whether the placement and services conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT ’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the placement and program that the District offered STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year would have provided him a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT ’s unique needs at the time the offer was made.(Footnote 9)

By the time the District made its offer on June 4, 2002, and further modified it on June 21, 2002, the IEP team had reviewed the results of assessments done in the areas of occupational therapy, achievement, adapted physical education, speech and language, psycho-educational, early development, and health. (Pet.’s Exhs. 15-24.) Although there was no significant change in STUDENT ’s areas of needs from the date of January 17, 2002 IEP, additional information was available to the IEP team upon which to make its program and placement recommendations. STUDENT ’s special education eligibility category had since been changed from speech and language impaired to multiple disabilities, given his global developmental delays and gross motor delays. (Pet.’s Exh. 25, pg. 5.) Additionally, the educational members of the IEP team believed that STUDENT now needed the following:

1. access to a functional academic curriculum, 2. increased access to appropriate language models, 3. increased access to appropriate behavior models, 4. attendance at a local district school, 5. small staff to student ratio, and 6. specially trained staff.

STUDENT imitated peers linguistically and behaviorally. He was sociable and tried to please adults much of the time. He was highly distractable, a multi-sensory learner, and had strong imitative skills. (Pet.’s Exh. 25.)

Academically, STUDENT was reading at approximately the five and one-half-year-old level. In manuscript writing, STUDENT could print his name as “STUDENT ,” and could copy most letters from a sample, which was about equivalent to the performance of a five-year-three-month-old student. In math, STUDENT could rote-count to ten and knew the value “one more,” “just one,” and the value of two. His scores in this subject ranged from four years to five and one-half years old. (Pet.’s Exh. 24.)

Socially, STUDENT enjoyed being around other children, liked to play near them, and was very interested in what they were doing. He imitated their play and dramatized adult activities. He sometimes needed adult assistance to play cooperatively and he had a strong sense of routine and preferred that the routine be maintained. (Pet.’s Exh. 24.)

Psychologist Sharon Loveman testified that, given STUDENT ’s cognitive, linguistic and social needs, he required the following: small special day class with a teacher trained in significant differentiation of instruction (individualized instruction); direct instruction at a one-to-one to one-to-four student-teacher ratio for pre-academic and cognitive development; and mainstreaming opportunities to learn age-appropriate language and learning behavior patterns for the amount of time that is comprehensible to him. In STUDENT ’s case, since he learns routines, he should be mainstreamed during activities such as morning calendar and circle time during which he learns social behaviors. Ms. Loveman also explained that STUDENT should spend most of his school day in a learning setting where he is alongside peers who are cognitively more advanced than he and who can provide behavior, social, and language models and where he has a curriculum that is geared to his needs. Additionally, although STUDENT is typically good-natured, with a happy demeanor, he requires careful redirection when he exhibits negative behaviors, or a contingency program on the spot to bring him under instructional control.

The Hearing Officer found very persuasive Ms. Loveman’s recommendations regarding STUDENT ’s needs. Ms. Loveman based her recommendations on her observations and testing of STUDENT over the past year and during the current school year, including standardized testing; review of records; discussions with STUDENT ’s teachers, including the regular education kindergarten teacher, both of his special education teachers, the speech and language pathologist, adaptive physical education teacher, and the instructional aides with whom he works; input from MOTHER and Mark Luciano; and direct observations of STUDENT during testing.(Footnote 10) Ms. Loveman was knowledgeable about language, behavior, and academic issues of children with needs such as STUDENT ’s. Ms. Loveman’s experience includes working as a school psychologist for Solana Beach for the past thirteen years. She holds master’s degrees in education psychology and literacy acquisition, counseling/psychology, and holds a pupil personnel credential. The bulk of her experience has been working with children ages three through twelve. (Testimony of S. Loveman.)

Ms. Loveman’s recommendations were consistent with the testimony of STUDENT ’s current SDC teacher, Janet Berggren, who testified that STUDENT needed time with typical peers for non-academic activities and that STUDENT was now prepared to be educated in a higher functioning SDC than her class. As discussed in Issue 1, Ms. Berggren testified that STUDENT needs to be in an SDC for academics because he gets frustrated when given first-grade level material in the first-grade classroom and is unable to do the work. Since one of STUDENT ’s goal was to develop his academic skills, he needed to receive academic instruction in the special education setting, away from the regular education students who were distracting to him. Additionally, he could achieve more by being with higher functioning SDC students and in a setting where materials could be presented to him at his level and without the frustration and distraction of significant modifications. Since STUDENT imitates behavior and language, the students in Ms. Palmore’s class would provide higher functioning behavior language models. According to Ms. Berggren, the peers in her class are no longer appropriate for STUDENT to be around given his progress. Several of Ms. Berggren’s current students do not talk at all, and several others have behavioral problems that include hitting and kicking. (Testimony of J. Berggren.)

Similarly, STUDENT ’s principal, Lisa Helwig, who frequently observes all classes and students, including STUDENT , explained that STUDENT ’s significant learning needs could not be met in the general education class and that he needed the curriculum to be presented at a reduced pace. Additionally, Cindy Frazee, Solana Beach’s director of pupil services, who is familiar with STUDENT and has observed him in his special day class, testified that STUDENT would not need one-on-one aide support in the regular education classroom if he were mainstreamed for routine activities. However, Ms. Frazee testified that she believed STUDENT would likely initially need a shadow aide at the beginning of his new placement to ensure that things were going smoothly and until he learned to follow the routine of his classmates.

In light of STUDENT ’s global developmental delays, his academic deficits, and high distractibility, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT required a small, structured, predictable setting with a small student-to-teacher ratio, frequent instruction on a one-to-one to one-to-four basis, and students in the special education class who are more cognitively advanced than he and from whom he can model linguistically and behaviorally. Additionally, to support his ongoing participation in the regular education environment, upon his initial enrollment in a new placement, STUDENT also needs shadow instructional aide support while in the regular education classroom for purposes of prompting and redirection until he is able to learn class routines. STUDENT also needs socialization with nondisabled peers during his mainstreaming time for nonacademic activities.

Considering STUDENT ’s unique needs as identified above, the Hearing Officer must next determine whether the placement and services offered by the District in the June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 IEPs would have addressed those needs. The parties’ dispute involves his placement (including the amount of time STUDENT would be included in the regular education classroom -- which will be discussed in the next issue) and supplemental aids and services.(Footnote 11)

Placement at Mission Estancia

In the June 4, 2002 IEP, the District offered to place STUDENTin a mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia Elementary School for 70 percent of his school day, with small-group instruction for core curriculum presented at his instructional level. No instructional aide was offered. (Pet.’s Exhs. 25 and 28, pg. 6.)

Student alleges that the District’s offered placement in the SDC at Mission Estancia for 70 percent of his school day, with no instructional aide or any other supplemental aids or support services was more restrictive than his placement at Skyline in the 50 percent inclusion program. The District contends that the mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia will provide STUDENT with a FAPE in the LRE.

Germaine Palmore, SDC teacher at Mission Estancia, testified that her SDC this year includes eleven students (four girls and seven boys) who are developmentally delayed and whose range of cognition varies. All of the students in her class are verbal; some use one to two words, while others use more age-appropriate language. Ms. Palmore also testified that the students in her class have overlapping skill levels with STUDENT . There are two first-grade students who are academically more advanced than STUDENT, so STUDENT could participate in mainstreaming activities along with them for science, recess, snack, lunch, music, and art. Ms. Palmore has four aides, one who is full-time and is primarily assigned to one student, and the other three who are part-time, assigned to the classroom and work at staggering times throughout the day as functioning team members. One of the part-time aides is a credentialed teacher. (Testimony of G. Palmore.)

A typical day in Ms. Palmore’s SDC includes a morning routine and circle time as the main activity. One student is selected to be the person of the day who leads the pledge, conducts attendance, and does the language activity with her. The students have an activity during which they review language each day in the morning with the whole group. The students also do team building whereby they create a climate where students can feel safe and learn to support each other. Ms. Palmore divides her class into four groups, three of which each work with an adult, and the other which works independently. Her class program addresses reading, phonics, sight words, and visual motor integration. (Testimony of G. Palmore.) The students also go to one of three math groups and also receive four to five minutes of individual instruction on handwriting. Generally, in the afternoon, the first-grade students go to Mr. Darlin’s class for mainstreaming on Tuesdays and Thursdays for science with the typical first-grade students for approximately 45 minutes to 1 hour.(Footnote 12) On Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, the first-grade students stay with Ms. Palmore in the afternoon and work step-by-step on a drawing activity and a writing lesson. After the afternoon mainstreaming or other activities with her, the entire class comes together again and meets in a circle where they play a game geared toward teaching social skills, do one of the activities on the choice board, or practice a game. Ms. Palmore described methods she would use to address STUDENT ’s reading, math, auditory comprehension, pragmatics, and language needs, including utilization of the Goldman Lynch sounds and symbols program to teach phonics lessons.

The Hearing Officer found persuasive Ms. Palmore’s testimony that her class could meet STUDENT ’s needs. Ms. Palmore had reviewed STUDENT ’s records and IEPs and concluded that STUDENT ’s goals and objectives could be addressed in her class and that he would have an opportunity to integrate with other students and be more challenged than he would in a severely handicapped classroom. Ms. Palmore testified that STUDENT would be a “good fit” in her class.

According to Ms. Loveman, Germaine Palmore’s mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia is structured much like the SDC that STUDENT attended last year at Skyline. From her observation of the students in the Mission Estancia class, she concluded that about two-thirds of the students were more advanced than STUDENT . She also testified that she observed one of the first-grade mainstream settings that the teacher utilizes and was very impressed with the small regular education enrollment and the collaborative effort between that teacher and the SDC teacher.

Student argues that the District is violating the IDEA by categorically placing special education students with “like” students rather than educating students with disabilities in placements based on their individual needs. (Pet.’s closing brief.) However, witness testimony demonstrated that STUDENT ’s academic needs dictated that he be placed in an environment in which he has appropriate language and social models, and where he receives instruction in core subjects at his level and in small groups. (Testimonies of J. Berggren, S. Loveman, L. Helwig, & B. Barrett.) Although the Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT ’s placement in Ms. Berggren’s class for the 2001-2002 school year was appropriate, this new offer represents an improvement over last year’s. The District’s offered program would place him in a setting in which his peers are more cognitively, behaviorally, and socially developed than he. He needs more advanced models because he learns from them. The mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia would provide such a placement for STUDENT.

Student’s argument that STUDENT should receive the intensive academic instruction that he needs from a one-on-one aide in the regular education classroom is not persuasive.(Footnote 13) Ms. Loveman, Ms. Berggren, Ms. Helwig, and other witnesses all explained that the special education teacher is the individual qualified to deliver the student’s individualized program, and delivering instruction is generally outside of the aide’s role. In addition, as indicated above, STUDENT ’s frustration in the regular education classroom caused him to either withdraw or behave negatively. Therefore, Ms. Palmore’s class would have provided STUDENT with more behavior management and a smaller, more structured setting than he could receive in regular education.

Considering all of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the mild/moderate SDC portion of the June 4, 2002 offer was designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs. The SDC meets his needs because it has a highly structured environment with small group instruction and the small student-to-teacher ratio. These features would allow the teacher and aides to implement STUDENT ’s academic, language, and social pragmatic goals, to focus on his ability to work more independently, and to decrease his distractions. The setting also would provide him with repeated practice, immediate feedback, few distractions, and materials at his instructional level.

Aide support in regular education

The Hearing Officer next determines whether the aide support offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT ’s needs. As indicated above, the Hearing Officer found that one of STUDENT ’s needs includes shadow instructional aide support while in the regular education classroom until such time as he learns class routines. There are three classroom instructional aides in Ms. Palmore’s SDC. However, aide support in mainstream is provided to the first-grade students only as needed and as determined by the teacher. This is where the District’s offered program falls short in terms of its design. The June 4, 2002 IEP does not provide for any instructional aide support in the regular education classroom to assist STUDENT with learning routine activities. (Pet.’s Exh. 25, pg. 10.) Rather, the June 21, 2002 IEP states that STUDENT would receive “1:1 instruction as deemed appropriate from instructional staff.” (Pet.’s Exh. 28, pg. 6.) The Hearing Officer finds that the statement “1:1 instruction...” does not necessarily mean STUDENT would have received instructional aide support. Moreover, the offer was not specific as to how STUDENT ’s need for instructional support would be met in the regular education classroom. Additionally, the one-on-one instruction would not have been provided immediately upon his enrollment in the new placement. Witness testimony and documentary evidence indicated that STUDENT would need shadow aide support from the beginning of his participation in mainstreaming activities until he was able to learn certain class routines. (Testimonies of C. Frazee, MOTHER, & M. Luciano; Pet.’s Exh. 28, pg. 4.) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT ’s IEP should indicate the nature of aide support that will be provided to him in the regular education classroom for the purpose of learning class routines.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

The great weight of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT needed to be in a special education class for academics in order to make educational progress and not, as Student argues, in a regular education classroom for either 75 percent or 50 percent of his school day. STUDENT ’s academic skills were at the preschool level and his frustration in the regular education classroom, even with one-on-two or one-on-one aide support, made it difficult for him to benefit academically. Given that the SDC contained the basic necessary components for STUDENT to learn, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT would have been able to make educational progress in the SDC portion of his placement. Moreover, there was evidence that STUDENT previously made substantial growth when he was pulled out of the regular education classroom for academic skills and received that instruction in a small group. And since, according to Ms. Loveman, STUDENT is still on a learning curve, he could make more progress with this new program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

However, the District’s offer did not include shadow aide support upon STUDENT ’s initial enrollment in mainstreaming activities to assist him in learning routines, and the Hearing Officer finds that such support is necessary to provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, the District must revise STUDENT ’s IEP to add a shadow instructional aide that will assist him in learning routines upon his initial placement in the regular education class.

Comport with the IEP

There is no claim that the District would not have been able to comport with the IEP with respect to the offered placement or the instructional aide support. In fact, Ms. Palmore testified that a space had been reserved in her class for STUDENT at the start of the 2002-2003 school year.

*** In light of all the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer contained in the June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 IEPs, which would have placed STUDENT in the mild/moderate SDC for 70 percent of his school day, with the addition of individual aide support for his initial placement in the regular education classroom, provides a FAPE.

4. Did the District’s offered placement constitute the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

As discussed above, STUDENT ’s developmental delays, high distractibility and resulting frustration, and academic needs make it difficult for him to learn in the regular education classroom, despite the assistance of either a one-to-two or one-to-one instructional aide. As determined earlier in this Decision, because STUDENT had difficulty accessing the regular education curriculum and meeting his goals and objectives while in the regular education class, he needs the structure and small teacher-to-student ratio of a special education classroom for instruction in core curriculum subjects.

STUDENT enjoys being around other children, and is seeking autonomy. He has also benefitted socially from the opportunity to be schooled alongside students who provide age-appropriate language, social, and learning behaviors. However, the benefit of STUDENT being around typically developing peers in the regular education classroom is diminished by the fact that STUDENT becomes frustrated and grows resistant when confronted with tasks that are difficult, and when he was in regular education for 50 percent of his school day, he was not mastering or retaining what he learned, even with instructional aide support. (Pet.’s Exh. 10.) If a child is in a placement where he can not access (benefit from) the curriculum, it is no longer the LRE. Additionally, the testimony of STUDENT ’s SDC teacher in particular has established that even with instructional aide support, STUDENT is not able to receive academic and nonacademic benefit in a 50/50 inclusion setting.(Footnote 14) Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer to place STUDENT in the mild/moderate SDC at Mission Estancia for academic instruction for 70 percent of his school day constituted the LRE for STUDENT .

5. If the District failed to provide and offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, is he entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services procured by STUDENT ’s parent or compensatory education?

Because the Hearing Officer found that the District provided and offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE, with the modest exception that the offered program did not provide for initial instructional aide support in mainstreaming, Student is not entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services procured by his parent or compensatory education. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).)

The District is not required to pay for the cost of private tutoring services if the District made FAPE available to the student and the parent elected not to accept that offer and instead procured private services for the student. Additionally, the District is not required to provide compensatory education to STUDENT since its offered program would have provided appropriate special education services. Although the Hearing Officer found that the June 4, 2002 and June 21, 2002 IEP offer lacked the provision of instructional aide support for STUDENT ’s initial placement in the regular education classroom, the District actually provided aide support to STUDENT in the regular education classroom to date. Therefore, compensatory education is not necessary because there was neither opportunity lost nor time missed. (Id.)

ORDER

1. The District shall provide STUDENT with a shadow instructional aide during his time in the regular education classroom until such time as he has learned routine class activities.

2. All of Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), both procedurally and substantively, from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

Respondent District prevailed on all elements of this issue.

2. Did the District place STUDENT in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from January 17, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year?

District prevailed on this issue.

3. Did the District fail to provide and offer STUDENT a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, during the 2002-2003?

District substantially prevailed on all elements of this issue, except to the extent that its offer failed to include initial instructional aide support for STUDENT during his attendance in the regular education classroom until he has learned class routines.

4. Did the District’s offered placement contained in the June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 IEPs constitute the least restrictive environment for STUDENT ?

District prevailed on this issue.

5. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services procured by STUDENT ’s parent or compensatory education?

District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: November 15, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Student before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis. 2. There is a consortium of fourteen school districts in San Diego County that agree to conduct reciprocal regional classes that children from consortium-member districts can attend. The class at Skyline is such a class, and because Encinitas is a part of the consortium, STUDENT is able to attend the regional SDC offered in the Solana Beach School District (Solana Beach) at Skyline.

3. The Hearing Officer notes that the fact that the District proceeded with the IEP meeting on June 4, 2002, without the parent was a major procedural violation of the IDEA. Although the District has characterized that meeting as an internal meeting, it essentially was an IEP meeting at which an offer was developed. Therefore, the meeting should have been postponed. It should be noted, however, that a continuation of the June 4, 2002 IEP meeting was held on June 21, 2002, and at that time the placement offer was revised and the parent was able to take part in the development of the IEP. Student did not raise this violation as an issue at the beginning of the hearing. However, it was mentioned in his closing brief and briefly discussed during witness testimony. 4. There was considerable discussion and questioning during the hearing about the integrity of the original IEP document and changes that were made to the face page of the IEP document first created at the March 20, 2002 IEP meeting. The document originally indicted that STUDENT ’s attending district and school were Solana Beach and Skyline, respectively. According to District director of pupil personnel services Beverly Barrett, during the June 4, 2002 IEP meeting, she used liquid paper to amend the face page of the IEP document to state that STUDENT ’s attending District was Encinitas and that his school was Mission Estancia. According to Ms. Barrett, this amendment merely reflected the District’s placement offer to the parent, not the actual school in which STUDENT was then placed, and was not done to deceive the parent. 5. Although the educational members of the IEP team had recommended at the June 4, 2002 IEP team meeting that STUDENT be placed in special education for 70 percent of his school day, that change had not been agreed upon by MOTHER. Notwithstanding the fact that MOTHER had only agreed to an increase from a 50/50 to 63/37 inclusion program, the District implemented the new 70/30 recommendation without the parent’s consent.

6. Lisa Helwig is the principal at Skyline and has worked in the education field for the last sixteen years. She testified that she has a master’s degree in school administration, and administrative services credential, and a certificate for teaching gifted children. Janet Berggren, STUDENT ’s SDC teacher, testified that she has been teaching special education at Solana Beach since 1990, but has worked in education for 30 years. She has master’s degree in special education, a lifetime teaching credential, and a severely handicapped credential. Cindy Frazee, the District’s director of pupil services, testified that she has worked in special education for twenty-three years. She has a master’s degree and credential in speech and language pathology, and she is a credentialed special day class teacher.

7. On the first day of hearing, the District moved for the Hearing Officer to reconsider the June 25, 2002 stay put Order based on the fact that the previous-ruling hearing officer was not provided with a copy of the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum at the time of his issuance of the stay put Order. The Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion for reconsideration on the grounds that it had ample time (almost four months) since the issuance of Hearing Officer Geary’s June 25, 2002 stay put Order to move for reconsideration and failed to do so within a reasonable time. Additionally, the Hearing Officer indicated that when the Hearing Office previously requested that the parties provide the Hearing Office with a copy of the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP, neither party provided the Hearing Office with a copy of the January 17, 2002 IEP Addendum. 8. The Hearing Officer notes that although Ms. Barrett’s actions did not result in a denial of FAPE to Student, the District should strongly condemn any employee’s actions that seek to intimidate a parent into not exercising his/her right to file for a request for a due process hearing.

9. The parties’ dispute over the LRE will be addressed in a separate issue below. 10. Ms. Loveman also testified that, typically, she would not administer the standardized measure of intelligence with a student who is in a severely handicapped program because these students are usually not capable of responding to such a measure. However, after speaking with MOTHER, they agreed she would use standardized testing and found that STUDENT was able to respond to every subtest that she administered, which told her that he understood the task that was given to him and understood there was problem that needed a resolution. According to Ms. Loveman, this is a high level of abstraction for a student in a program for severely handicapped students. 11. Student did not dispute the designated instruction and services, the goals and objectives, or any other aspect of the District’s June 4, 2002, and June 21, 2002 offer, and thus the Hearing Officer will only examine the appropriateness of the placement, supports & aides offered by the District.

12. According to Ms. Palmore and Beverly Barrett, Mr. Darlin has a credential in special education and makes every attempt to fully include special education students in his classroom.

13. While MOTHER testified that she shared with the March 25, 2002 IEP team a prescription from STUDENT ’s pediatrician stating that increased special education time was having a negative effect on STUDENT, there was no specific evidence about the doctor and the nature of his conclusions or prescription. (Pet.’s Exh. 25, pg. 3.) There was no evidence of the doctor’s name, whether this doctor had particular expertise in education or behavior management, or whether the doctor had ever observed STUDENT in the special education classroom. Moreover, the pediatrician’s statements, along with MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT had regressed since increasing his time in special education, were contradicted by the second half of STUDENT ’s 2001-2002 school year, when he spent 63 percent of his school day in special education. During that time frame, STUDENTexperienced progress in mastering and retaining the learning presented in the regular education kindergarten program. Additionally, school personnel who worked with STUDENT indicated that they did not see at school any of the problems that MOTHER indicated that she saw in STUDENT at home. 14. Ms. Berggren testified that she keeps a log of STUDENT ’s class activities, which she sends back and forth to his mother for her review. Ms. Berggren also stated that she was familiar with STUDENT ’s mainstream class work and is in communication with the regular education teachers. 15. The May 15, 2002 IEP also indicates that the District’s director of pupil services asked about STUDENT’s medical records and explained that those records were important to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. However, MOTHER declined to give the District access to all of STUDENT’s medical records and decided to have the current releases of information remain as they were with limitations.