California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 19, 2004

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1296-04 · Hearing Officer My T. Huynh

San Diego Unified and County Mental Health's residential placement offer upheld; all of parent's FAPE claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's mother represented him herself. She filed against San Diego Unified School District, San Diego County Mental Health, and the San Diego Center for Children. The Center runs the Children's Learning Academy, the nonpublic school he attended. The 11-year-old fifth grader was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance. Starting in December 2003, his behavior got much worse, and staff had to restrain him again and again. In March 2004, County Mental Health recommended residential placement. Instead, the IEP team agreed to try a day treatment program with in-home therapeutic behavioral services. The mother ended the in-home services within a month, and his behavior kept getting worse. The team offered residential placement in May and June 2004. The mother first agreed, then withdrew her consent and kept him home after June 8.

The Hearing Officer found that the program from December 2003 to May 11, 2004 met his behavior and social skills needs. He did not need a psychiatrist to provide therapy or a one-to-one aide. The February 2004 IEP did not require the team to supply Odyssey Ware software. Only the school had offered to buy it. Under the April 2004 IEP, a functional analysis assessment was due once he entered a new placement, not right away. Because the day treatment trial had failed, residential placement was the least restrictive appropriate setting. It also included a space where he could calm down. The Hearing Officer denied all relief and ruled that the respondents may carry out the June 15, 2004 IEP without the mother's consent.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a residential placement dispute. The team's documented trial of a less restrictive day treatment program supported finding residential placement to be the least restrictive environment. A parent's view that a service would be "helpful" did not prove the student needed it. Signed IEP notes outweighed later testimony about what the team had agreed.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1a(i). Did Respondents deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide appropriate services from December 2003 to May 11, 2004 in the area of behavior, including frustration?

    The structured small-class program, behavior plan, medication monitoring, and therapy met Student's behavior needs; a psychiatrist was not required to provide his therapy.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1a(ii). Did Respondents deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide appropriate services from December 2003 to May 11, 2004 in the area of social skills?

    Counseling on conflict resolution and the school's social skills training met his needs; low staff ratios meant a one-to-one aide was not necessary.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1b(i). Did Respondents fail to comport with Student's IEP by not providing him with Odyssey Ware software in conformance with the February 26, 2004 IEP addendum?

    The IEP said only that the nonpublic school was willing to buy the software as a supplement and referred Student for an AT assessment, so the IEP did not require Respondents to provide it.

  4. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1b(ii). Did Respondents fail to comport with Student's IEP by not conducting a functional analysis assessment (FAA) in conformance with the April 23, 2004 IEP addendum?

    The signed IEP notes called for an FAA once Student entered a new placement; Mother's contrary testimony was not credible, so no FAA was due yet.

  5. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the Respondents' May 12, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement deny Student a FAPE because it failed to consider other less restrictive options and provide for psychiatric monitoring?

    The team had tried the less restrictive day treatment program for over two months without success, so residential placement with intensive therapy and monitoring was the LRE.

  6. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3a. Did Respondents deny Student a FAPE in his June 15, 2004 IEP by offering residential placement?

    Events after May 12, including inconsistent messages between home and school, confirmed that residential placement was appropriate and the LRE.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3b. Did Respondents deny Student a FAPE in his June 15, 2004 IEP by failing to provide a one-to-one aide?

    Uncontradicted staff testimony showed no need for an aide; Mother said only that one would be 'helpful,' which is not the Rowley standard.

  8. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3c. Did Respondents deny Student a FAPE in his June 15, 2004 IEP by failing to provide access to a counseling office?

    Student needs a supervised space to calm down, and the residential offer included one.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of a home remediation program with a teacher providing instruction, four days a week for four hours per day?

    No FAPE denial was found, so no compensatory education was awarded.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. As a prospective remedy, is Student entitled to an alternative placement including (a) a special education day program; (b) home instruction during illness of five school days or more; (c) an FAA; (d) a one-to-one aide for the entire school day; and (e) access to a counseling office?

    Because Respondents offered a FAPE at all times, the residential placement in the current IEP stands and the request for an alternative placement was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. Respondents may implement the June 15, 2004 IEP (residential placement) over Petitioner's objection without parental consent.
  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied, including compensatory home instruction and an alternative placement.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; Cal. Educ. Code § 56520 (Hughes Bill); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001; Gov. Code Chapter 26.5 (AB 2726)

People named in the decision

  • Eve-Michelle Dreyfus, M.D., treating psychiatrist; witness for Student, County mental health clinic (medical director)
  • Kirsta Tierney, special education teacher, Children's Learning Academy, San Diego Center for Children
  • Celia Engelman, licensed clinical psychologist; day treatment therapist; witness for Student, San Diego Center for Children day treatment program
  • Bryan Love, special education teacher (primary classroom teacher), Children's Learning Academy, San Diego Center for Children
  • Cynthia Cox, Ph.D., principal; representative for San Diego Center for Children, Children's Learning Academy, San Diego Center for Children
  • Stephanie Lohse, licensed clinical social worker; outpatient therapist, AB 2726 outpatient mental health services
  • Corey Straily, occupational therapist, District witness
  • Terre Chapman, nonpublic schools case manager, San Diego Unified School District
  • Kettrell Berry, classroom aide, Children's Learning Academy, San Diego Center for Children
  • Susan Deininger, case manager; AB 2726 mental health assessor, San Diego County Mental Health
  • Joseph Concellosi, program manager, San Diego County Mental Health

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on June 17, 18, 22, 23, and 28, 2004.

Petitioner (Petitioner or Student) was represented by his Mother. Respondent San Diego Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Amy Bozone. Also present on the District’s behalf was non-public schools case manager Terre Chapman. Respondent San Diego Center for Children (CFC) was represented by Children’s Learning Academy principal Cynthia Cox, Ph.D. (Footnote 1) Respondent San Diego County Mental Health (CMH) was represented by attorney Lisa Macchione. Also present on CMH’s behalf was program manager Joseph Concellosi.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Eve-Michelle Dreyfus, M.D.; Mother; teacher Kirsta Tierney; psychologist Celia Engelman; and teacher Bryan Love.

The District called the following witnesses: Children’s Learning Academy principal Cynthia Cox, Ph.D.; social worker Stephanie Lohse; occupational therapist Corey Straily; non-public schools case manager Terre Chapman; and classroom aide Kettrell Berry.

CMH called only, one witness, case manager Susan Deininger. CFC did not call any witnesses.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon the completion of closing arguments on June 28, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the Respondents deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:

a. Provide appropriate services from December 2003 to May 11, 2004 in the areas of i. Behavior, including frustration; and ii. Social Skills b. Comport with his IEP by not i. Providing him with Odyssey Ware software in conformance with the February 26, 2004, IEP addendum; and ii. Conducting a functional analysis assessment (FAA) in conformance with the April 23, 2004, IEP addendum?

2. Did the Respondents’ May 12, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement deny Student a FAPE because it failed to consider other less restrictive options and provide for psychiatric monitoring.

3. Did the Respondents deny Student a FAPE in his June 15, 2004 IEP by:

a. Offering residential placement, as discussed in Issue Number 2;

b. Failing to provide a one-to-one aide; and c. Failing to provide access to a counseling office?

4. Is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of a home remediation program with a teacher providing instruction, four days a week for four hours per day?

5. As a prospective remedy, is Student entitled to an alternative placement including:

a. A special education day program;

b. Home instruction during periods of illness of five school days or more where Student is medically unable to attend school due to a psychiatric disorder;

c. An FAA;

d. A one-to-one aide for the entire school day; and e. Access to a counseling office?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner Student (Petitioner or Student) is an eleven-year-old boy who resides within the geographic boundaries of the San Diego Unified School District (District) and San Diego County Mental Health (CMH). He is currently in the fifth grade at the San Diego Center for Children’s (CFC) Children’s Learning Academy (CLA), a non-public school (NPS). He is currently identified as eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance (ED).

The District initially designated Student as eligible for special education as an ED student in June 2000. At that time, he exhibited maladaptive behaviors including refusing to complete schoolwork, being physically aggressive towards adults and peers, and having suicidal ideations. (Testimony of Mother.) In May 2001, Student was hospitalized for one month at Aurora Hospital due a psychotic episode. Specifically, while at school, he screamed uncontrollably, engaged in physical assaults, and suffered from hallucinations. He was diagnosed with major depression and childhood psychosis. (Testimony of Mother.)

Shortly thereafter, Student’s family moved to Liberal, Kansas. He attended school in Liberal from September 2001 until October 2002. In October 2002, he and his family returned to San Diego. In January 2002, Student began attending Baker Elementary School, a general education school within the District. However, Student’s prior maladaptive behaviors resurfaced and caused him to be removed from that educational setting in February 2003. Instead, he received his instruction through an “at home” program from February through April 2003.

Pursuant to a mediated agreement between Petitioner and the District, Student was placed at the CLA in May 2003. The CLA is a school specifically devoted to educating students with severe behavioral needs. (Testimony of Dr. Cynthia Cox.) CLA is part of the CFC’s larger NPS environment. (Footnote 2) CLA’s program focuses on activities and programs to improve students’ behaviors and social skills, and prepare them for return to a regular education environment. (Testimony of Dr. Cynthia Cox.) At CLA, Student primarily attended a classroom taught by Bryan Love. He also received instruction in mathematics and reading in another classroom from teacher Kirsta Tierney. Student performed well at CLA from May 2003 until December 2003. (Footnote 3) His daily conduct reports indicated that his conduct was at the “gold” or “silver” levels, which represented above average conduct.

However, from July 8 through 15, 2003, Student’s mother requested that he be hospitalized due to behavioral concerns at home. He exhibited “out-of-control aggressiveness” for the week leading up to the hospitalization. (Testimony of Mother.) On July 28, 2003, Student’s individualized education program (IEP) team met in response to this recent hospitalization. The team agreed to add one hour of weekly counseling services to assist him with his behavioral needs. (Dist. Ex. Y.)

In August 2003, Mother again hospitalized Student for behavioral escalation similar to the previous incident. As a result, his IEP team met again on September 23, 2004, and proposed mental health goals for Student. (Dist. Ex. U.) The team also agreed to add weekly outpatient-counseling services for six months from CMH under AB2726. (Footnote 4) (Dist. Ex. I.) During fall 2003, Student returned to CLA and maintained daily conduct marks of “gold” or “silver” throughout this period. He was very compliant and tolerant to class instruction over this period. (Testimony of Bryan Love.)

On December 10, 2003, however, Student became physically and verbally aggressive towards a fellow student and CLA staff. (Dist. Ex. M.) Specifically, he tore down a class poster and attempted to pull the classroom fire extinguisher off the wall. He then advanced towards and threatened a classmate. In response, staff members attempted to calm him, but Student pushed and yelled at the staff members. Ultimately, staff members physically restrained him within CLA’s designated personal safety room (PSR). Upon returning home from school, Student continued to exhibit agitation, anger, and aggression towards his family. Mother again requested that he be hospitalized for psychiatric care until December 17, 2003. (CFC Ex. 1.) During his hospitalization, Student was diagnosed with bipolar mood disorder (mixed type) and intermittent explosive disorder. (CMH Ex. 191.) On December 17, 2003, the IEP team met again and agreed to refer him for an AB2726 mental health assessment by CMH. (Dist. Ex. H.) Upon returning to school, Student again maintained consistent good daily conduct marks until February 2004.

In February 2004, Student was involved in two serious conduct incidents again resulting in his hospitalization for psychiatric care. On February 18, 2004, Student became frustrated with a class assignment and refused to follow directions. He entered a PSR to try to calm himself; however he began yelling that he wanted to “kill himself.” (Dist. Ex. M.) On February 23, 2004, in a separate incident, Student was agitated and became verbally and physically assaultive to staff members, including threatening to kill them. Staff members physically restrained him to prevent him from causing harm to himself or others. Further, CLA staff contacted the Aurora Hospital Mobile Assessment Team to respond to Student’s outburst. The Mobil Assessment Team’s evaluator observed Student at CLA and recommended hospitalizing him. The CLA agreed with the assessment and Student was again hospitalized for psychiatric care. He was hospitalized for almost one week.

During Student’s hospitalization, the IEP team met on February 26, 2004, at Mother’s request. (Dist. Ex. G.) During the meeting, Mother requested that a computer-based curriculum be made available to Student for math and writing assignments. In response, the IEP team recommended that Student be assessed for assistive technology (AT) needs to determine what, if any, equipment he required. In addition, CLA’s principal Cynthia Cox expressed her willingness, on the behalf of CLA, to purchase the requested software program as a supplemental curriculum.

On March 3, 2004, the IEP team met again to review the results of CMH’s AB2726 assessment report. (Dist. Ex. F.) The team discussed the report and different placement options for Student. Initially, CMH case manager Susan Deininger recommended that he be placed in a residential placement program; however, Mother requested a less restrictive setting. The team discussed these alternatives and then accepted the suggestion of Ms. Deininger that Student be placed on an interim basis at CFC’s day treatment program. (Dist. Ex. E.) The day treatment program consisted of a morning educational program followed by a partial hospitalization program (PHP) in the afternoon. On March 8, 2004, Student began attending CFC’s day treatment program at the CLA. Shortly thereafter, therapeutic behavioral services (TBS) were added to Student’s educational program. As part of the TBS, Student received home-based therapy for three hours per day, four days per week. The services included a therapeutic coach assisting Student to better cope with his frustration and anger. However, within one month, Mother terminated the TBS citing that Student was resisting the restrictions and rules placed upon him by the coach and this resistance caused Student to become aggressive towards his family.

Over the next month and a half, Student’s behavior did not improve in the day treatment program. (Footnote 5) Instead, he was involved in over a dozen serious behavioral incidents requiring CLA staff to physically restrain him. (Dist. Ex. M.) Student’s behaviors included slapping another student in the face, turning over desks, and verbally assaulting students and staff members. The behaviors culminated in several consecutive days of maladaptive behaviors from April 14 to 19, 2004. Consequently, on April 19, 2004, Mother again requested that Student be hospitalized for psychiatric care for approximately one week.

On April 23, 2004, Student’s IEP team met to discuss his ongoing, extreme behaviors at school and home and to review his then-current AB2726 services. (Dist. Ex. D.) The team agreed to another referral to CMH to conduct a second AB2726 mental health assessment. In addition, the team recommended an occupational therapy (OT) assessment. The team also discussed the need for a functional behavioral assessment and a one-to-one tutor for Student. The District agreed to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and develop a corresponding behavior intervention plan (BIP) upon Student’s entry into a new placement. Mother told the team that she felt that residential placement was the correct program at that time for Student.

Upon completion of the second AB2726 mental health assessment report, the IEP team met again on May 12, 2004. (Dist. Ex. B.) The team discussed the findings of the report, which concluded that Student required a residential level of care due to his behavioral history and current level of functioning. (Dist. Ex. C.) Again, Mother agreed to the recommendation for residential placement. On May 27, 2004, CMH informed Mother that a residential placement was available at the CFC. However, Mother expressed her disagreement with placing Student in a residential placement and withdrew her consent. Mother cited information she received from Student’s treating psychiatrist, Eve-Michelle Dreyfus, M.D., that Student may not have required residential placement at that time. Moreover, Mother instructed Student that he did not need to participate in the PHP or follow the directions of the CLA staff.

Thereafter, Student returned to CLA’s day treatment program but continued to struggle with his maladaptive behaviors because of his refusal to follow staff directions. On May 28, 2004, he engaged in another serious behavioral incident wherein he acted physically aggressive toward a peer and was non-compliant with staff directives. He again was physically restrained in an attempt to control his behaviors. (Dist. Ex. M.) Student attended CLA only twice after that incident. He returned on June 2, 2004, and was involved in another serious behavioral incident where he threatened other students and failed to comply with staff directions. He also attended school on June 8, 2004. On that day, he ignored staff directions and became involved in an altercation where he pushed two peers, pushed teacher Kirsta Tierney, and struck another staff member. (Dist. Ex. X.) Following Student’s assault, Ms. Tierney required medical attention from a physician. Thereafter, Mother refused to allow Student to return to school. Student has not attended any educational program since June 8, 2004.

On June 9, 2004, the IEP team met again to discuss Student’s placement. (Dist. Ex. A.) The team, with the exception of Mother, again recommended residential placement as Student’s educational program. Mother reiterated her dissent to the proposed placement and again cited Dr. Dreyfus’s opinions. On June 15, 2004, the IEP team met for Student’s annual IEP meeting. Except for Mother, all members of the team again agreed that Student should be placed in a residential treatment center. In addition, the results of Student’s AT and OT assessments were discussed. The District found needs in the area of OT and developed additional goals and offered services to respond to those needs. Further, the District agreed to provide additional AT services for Student. Nonetheless, the parties were unable to agree to a proposed placement for Student.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the Respondents deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 2003 to May 11, 2004?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.

To determine whether the Respondents provided Petitioner a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the Respondents’ offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Rowley Court concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). Furthermore, the amended IDEA specifies additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE that is not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the Respondents’ proposed program must have met the following substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP. In addition, Respondents must also have educated him in the least restrictive environment. Notably, the local education agencies (LEAs) have the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that they have complied with the IDEA, including that they offered an appropriate educational program for the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

The Hearing Officer now turns to the determination of whether the Respondents offered a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley. Petitioner contends that in December 2003, his educational placement at CLA was not designed to meet his unique needs in behavior and social skills. At that time, Student’s educational placement consisted of Respondents’ June 12, 2003 IEP and its subsequent addenda. (Footnote 6) Petitioner asserts that because his behaviors deteriorated in December 2003, his educational placement was inappropriate to meet his needs in behavior and social skills. However, Petitioner does not challenge the appropriateness of his day treatment program that commenced on March 8, 2004. Thus, to determine the appropriateness of the Respondents’ program, the Hearing Officer must first determine Student’s unique needs in December 2003.

Student’s Unique Needs

Behavior, including Frustration

There is no dispute regarding the appropriateness of Student’s placement from the time the IEP was developed in June 2003 through December 2003. Mother testified that in December 2003, Student’s needs changed requiring additional services. The Respondents acknowledge an escalation of behavior in December 2003; however, they contend the IEP remained appropriate to meet Student’s needs. In December 2003, the parties agree that Student engaged in various maladaptive behaviors associated with his bipolar mood disorder. Kirsta Tierney, Student’s teacher since May 2003, testified that she observed Student demonstrating difficulty with frustration and often struggling to verbalize his feelings. (Footnote 7) He exhibited his frustration in the form of both violent physical and verbal outbursts. Mother, Student’s mother, stated that she observed him lacking self-control with his anger. Further, she testified that he could not control his anger once set into motion. She added that his behaviors also included threats to kill himself and others. Student’s treating psychologist Celia Engelman testified that Student’s bipolar disorder caused him to be unable to control his behaviors and also affected his mood. (Footnote 8) CLA staff had also identified that schoolwork and teasing were often antecedents to Student’s behavioral outbursts. (Testimony of Bryan Love.) (Footnote 9)

The parties also concur that Student required an educational program that addressed his behavioral deficits on several fronts including (1) structured and consistent school and home environments, (2) medication monitoring, and (3) therapy. With respect to the first component, Ms. Engelman testified that because Student suffered from bipolar disorder, he required a consistent environment both at school and at home. She stated that differences in expectations in behavior between home and school led to his confusion and ultimately behavioral outbursts. Further, Student required a highly structured environment in the scheduling of activities and classroom setting. To that end, Student’s classroom required a small staff-to-student ratio. In addition, he required a behavior plan that provided for positive behavior interventions including a separated area where he could take “time out” to de-escalate from anger or frustration.

Second, Dr. Eve-Michelle Dreyfus testified that Student required medication monitoring to treat his bipolar disorder. (Footnote 10) Over the last year, Student was prescribed a combination of five or six medications that included anti-psychotics, mood stabilizers, and thyroid gland regulators. Given the powerful nature of these drugs, the monitoring of their effectiveness was crucial.

As to the third component of Student’s educational program, the parties disagree as to the qualifications that were necessary to provide him with psychological therapy. Petitioner contends that Student required a psychiatrist, not a therapist, to administer therapy to him. In support of this position, Petitioner offered only the testimony of Mother. She testified that Student has a severe psychiatric illness that required a psychiatrist to conduct his therapy sessions. In response, the District asserts that Student did not require a psychiatrist to conduct his therapy sessions; rather a licensed psychologist or therapist was sufficient to perform this service. Ms. Engelman testified that a psychologist or therapist would have been able to use individual therapy with Student to talk to him and engage him personally. Further, Ms. Stephanie Lohse, Student’s outpatient therapist until March 8, 2004, testified that a therapist could have worked with Student on his aggression, non-compliance, peer relationship, and home conflict issues. (Footnote 11) Moreover, Ms. Deininger testified that in Student’s case, a psychiatrist’s role was only supervisory with the exception of monitoring his medication. (Footnote 12) Instead, she stated that it was proper for a therapist to conduct family and individual therapy for Student. She added that it was not necessary for a psychiatrist to provide general therapy.

The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require a psychiatrist to conduct his therapy sessions. The District offered the testimony of three qualified professionals each of whom agreed that therapy could have been provided by a psychologist or therapist alone. Witnesses Engelman, Lohse, and Deininger each practice extensively in the area of psychology and have worked with Student intimately over the past school year. Both Ms. Engelman and Ms. Lohse were his treating therapists. Both treating therapists spent several hours per week working on Student’s behavioral and social skills needs. In addition, Ms. Deininger spent several hours on two separate occasions interviewing Student and reviewing his records in preparation for her two AB2726 assessments. Given the three witnesses’ expertise and extensive time spent observing and working with Student, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony credible. On the other hand, Petitioner offered only the testimony of Mother. She admitted that she had no training in the areas of medicine. She offered no evidence that she had any expertise in the field of psychology or therapy. Given Mother’s lack of expertise or other evidence in support of his position, the Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s assertion unpersuasive that a psychiatrist was required. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer finds that a therapist or psychologist was sufficient to conduct Student’s therapy sessions.

Social Skills

The parties also agree that Student had needs in the area of social skills. Specifically, as described by Mother and Ms. Engelman, that he struggled to express himself when frustrated or angry. This struggle manifested itself in his inability to positively resolve conflicts between himself and others. It also affected his ability to develop and maintain relationships with peers and adults. (Dist. Ex. P.) Because of these social skills needs, the parties agree that Student would have benefited from conflict resolution services. The parties also concur that Student required counseling to address this need.

Petitioner contends, however, that Student also required a one-to-one aide throughout the school day. In support of his position, Petitioner again offers only the opinion of Mother. She testified that she believed a one-to-one aide would have been “helpful” to monitor Student. In response, the Respondents disagreed and asserted that Student did not require a one-to-one aide to assist him with social skills. Specifically, Ms. Tierney rejected the idea that Student required a one-to-one aide. She stated that having an individual “attached” to Student would have been unnecessary. Instead, he required a school environment that was structured and that allowed him to receive assistance with his behaviors and academics.

Ms. Tierney added that Student was able to receive necessary assistance from her and her classroom staff. Depending on the subject being taught, Ms. Tierney’s class had between nine and thirteen students. At any given time, her class had a ratio of no more than one staff member to every four students. Ms. Tierney testified that this was sufficient for Student to work on his academic and social skills. Mr. Love testified similarly that Student did not require a one-to-one assistant. He noted that his classroom with Student had five staff members working with no more than nine students. He also stated that this was a sufficiently staffed environment to assist Student with his needs. In addition, classroom aide Kettrell Berry testified that Student did not require an individual aide. He stated that Student was able to perform in the classroom without a personal assistant.

The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require a one-to-one assistant during his school day in December 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of his teachers and classroom aide are persuasive. These witnesses have been working daily with Student since March 2003 and are specifically trained and experienced in working with children with severe behavioral needs. Each testified that Student’s classroom with its small class size and student-to-staff ratio was adequate to assist him with social skills deficits. On the other hand, Petitioner offered no persuasive evidence that a one-to-one aide was necessary. Mother merely stated that she believed that a one-to-one aide would be “helpful.” As discussed above, the Rowley standard is not “helpful,” instead it requires Respondents to provide services appropriate to meet a child’s needs. Here, Petitioner offered no evidence that a one-to-one aide was a necessary means to address his social skills needs. Moreover, Mother testified that she has no qualifications in the area of teaching special education students to support her comments. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require a one-to-one aide, as a service, to meet his social skills needs.

As discussed above, the parties agree that Student had social skills deficits. The Hearing Officer finds that these deficits required Student to receive social skills services in the form of conflict resolution training and counseling. The Hearing Officer does not find that Student required a one-to-one aide as a service to address his social skills needs. Now, the Hearing Officer turns to the question of whether the Respondents designed a program to meet Student’s behavioral and social skills needs as of December 2003.

Designed to Meet Student’s Needs

Behavior, including Frustration

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student required an educational program that would address his behavioral needs by including (1) a structured school and home environment; (2) medication monitoring; and (3) therapy provided by a psychologist or therapist. Petitioner contends generally that the services provided by Respondents were not sufficient to meet his behavioral needs. Mother simply testified that Student’s services as of December 2003 “were not adequate.” However, Petitioner offered no other specific testimony or documentary evidence of what in particular was insufficient.

In contrast, the District offered evidence that it provided Student with services that met the above three areas of concern in December 2003. First, Ms. Tierney testified that the CLA classrooms were small, structured environments. She stated that her classroom had between nine and thirteen children. Further, the ratio was one staff member to every four students in her class. She also noted that CLA followed the District’s behavior intervention plan that included targeted behaviors and positive replacement behaviors. (Dist. Ex. Q.) In addition, Student was provided opportunities to use the PSP and take time to de-escalate during behavioral episodes. Moreover, she also worked with Student in developing behavior interventions that were suggested by him. Specifically, Ms. Tierney provided Student with an “Etch-a-Sketch” drawing tool, computer activity time, and Playdo. Ms. Tierney also used positive interventions such as a token economy program whereby Student could earn credits for good behavior and exchange the credits for prizes. Mr. Love related similar testimony about his classroom and added that Student was also given positive physical contact such as hugs and shoulder squeezes. (Footnote 13)

Second, Dr. Dreyfus testified that she performed the medication monitoring for Student. In working with Student, Dr. Dreyfus oversaw the distribution of medications to him and she monitored the levels of medication to determine their effectiveness. She also attended treatment team meetings where his medications were discussed with staff members. She also provided a weekly one-hour session for individual and family consultation regarding his medications. (Footnote 14)

Third, Student’s program in December 2003 also provided therapy sessions for him by Ms. Lohse. At the September 23, 2003 IEP, the Respondents agreed to provide AB2726 outpatient therapy services to Student. (Dist. Ex I.) Ms. Lohse testified that she provided these services pursuant to the IEP until March 8, 2004, when Student was placed in the day treatment program. Ms. Lohse testified that in their therapy sessions, she assisted Student with his classroom aggression, non-compliance to staff direction, development of peer relationships, and ability to resolve conflicts at home.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents developed and administered services designed to meet Student’s behavioral deficits including frustration. The Petitioner did not contradict the testimonies of Student’s teachers, psychiatrist, and therapist. Each witness testified within the scope of their observations and expertise about the needs of Student and the services he was given. On the other hand, Petitioner made only a blanket conclusory assertion that these services were somehow insufficient. Moreover, Petitioner offered no additional evidence in support of this conclusion. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds the evidence presented by the Respondents persuasive that the services provided to Student were designed to meet his behavioral needs.

Social Skills

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student required services to meet his social skills needs. Specifically, he required services in the areas of conflict resolution and the development of interpersonal relationships. The District offered uncontested testimony that Student received services in both of the above areas. In the area of conflict resolution, Ms. Lohse testified that her counseling sessions with Student emphasized conflict resolution skills. She stated that she and Student worked on improving his classroom aggression and non-compliance with staff directions. She also focused on improving his ability to deal with conflicts at home with his family. In the area of developing relationships, Ms. Lohse also testified that she counseled Student on improving his peer relationships. Further, Ms. Tierney testified that Student’s educational program included training known as “Building Effective Schools Together” (BEST). She stated that BEST training teaches students, including Student, to integrate appropriately into society by emphasizing life skills, learning to work with others, and developing relationships with staff and other students.

In response, Petitioner failed to offer any evidence that the above services were not designed to meet his social skills needs. Mother testified that she “could not think of any services to meet his social skills” needs. She simply noted that she believed that he needed encouragement in weekly counseling and throughout the school day. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s evidence completely unpersuasive. Mother’s conclusory statements offer no evidence that the services provided in Student’s program were not designed to meet his social skills needs. Instead, the overwhelming evidence indicates that Student received both training and services for his social skills needs in both the classroom and therapy sessions. Ms. Lohse and Ms. Tierney each testified that Student received services directly aimed at improving his conflict resolution deficits and developing his interpersonal relationships at school and home. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ program as of December 2003 was designed to meet Student’s social skills needs.

Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that the Respondents’ program in December 2003 was designed to meet Student’s behavior and social skills needs. Because of the structure and services included in the plan, Student’s needs in these areas were addressed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ plan was also calculated to provide educational benefit to Student.

Conforms to the IEP

Did the Respondents fail to comport with Student’s IEP by not providing him with Odyssey Ware software following the February 26, 2004 IEP addendum?

As noted previously, Petitioner contends that Respondents failed to provide him a program that comported with his IEP by failing provide Odyssey Ware software. Petitioner claims that at the February 26, 2004 IEP addendum meeting, the IEP team offered to provide Odyssey Ware software as part of Student’s educational program. The IEP meeting notes state in pertinent part that Mother “is requesting that a computer-based curriculum be available to [Student] for math and writing assignments. NPS is willing to purchase the program as supplemental curriculum – [Student] is very reluctant [to] produce written work via paper and pencil. Team recommends that he be referred for an AT assessment to see what equipment and/or software he qualifies for.” (Dist. Ex. G.) Petitioner asserts that this language constitutes an offer in the IEP that the Respondents would purchase the Odyssey Ware software. Mother testified that she brought some information regarding Odyssey Ware software to the IEP team meeting and made the request for its inclusion. (Pet. Ex. 21.) She believed that the IEP team was to purchase the software. To date, Odyssey Ware has not been provided to Student.

In response, the Respondents contend that the IEP team did not agree to purchase the software. Rather, the NPS, here CLA, agreed to purchase the software as a supplement to his already appropriate placement. District case manager Terre Chapman testified that she took the meeting notes during the February 26, 2004 IEP meeting. She recalled that the District did not agree to purchase the software. Instead, only the NPS offered to purchase Odyssey Ware. Moreover, she noted that the District sought to conduct an AT assessment to determine what, if any, equipment or software would be necessary for Student.

Dr. Cynthia Cox, CLA principal, also testified that she attended the meeting. She recalled that the IEP team did not agree that Odyssey Ware was appropriate for Student. She explained that his program, at CLA, emphasized his behavioral needs and that Student’s academics were acceptable. Dr. Cox noted that Odyssey Ware is a computer-based curriculum, which is fully self-contained. The software program would allow Student to complete his entire academic program on the computer. However, she explained this would be counter-productive to Student’s behavioral and social skills needs. She stated that Student requires interaction with others to develop his behavioral and social skills. Nonetheless, Dr. Cox agreed to investigate and purchase the software as a gesture of generosity to Student.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents did not fail to comport with the February 26, 2004 IEP. The plain language of the document states that the “NPS school is willing to purchase the program as supplemental curriculum.” Nowhere in the document does it state that the Respondents agreed to provide Odyssey Ware. Moreover, the IEP states that the IEP “team recommends that he be referred for an AT assessment to see what equipment and/or software he qualifies for.” This sentence clearly indicates the intent of the IEP team, including Respondents, that further assessment would take place before the team made any recommendations regarding additional materials for Student’s program. The Hearing Officer also finds the explanations of Ms. Chapman and Dr. Cox credible. Each explained in detail the events of the meeting and also their understandings of whether Odyssey Ware was to be provided by the IEP team. In contrast, the Hearing Officer finds that Mother’s version of events is not supported by the IEP document. Instead, she misinterpreted the altruism of Dr. Cox as the actions of the entire IEP team, including Respondents. However, this generosity does not constitute an offer by the IEP team and therefore there was never a requirement of the team to provide Student with Odyssey Ware. (Footnote 15) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents did not fail to comply with the February 26, 2004 IEP, with respect to the provision of Odyssey Ware software.

Did the Respondents fail to comport with Student’s IEP by not conducting a functional analysis assessment (FAA) following the April 23, 2004 IEP addendum?

Petitioner also contends that Respondents denied him a FAPE by failing to perform a functional analysis assessment (FAA) following the April 23, 2004 IEP addendum meeting. (Footnote 16) The April 23, 2004 IEP addendum states in pertinent part that Student’s “mother is requesting that in the new setting a functional analysis of behavior and a SCIA assessment be completed. At this time, Mother feels that [Student] needs residential treatment level of mental health services.” (Dist. Ex. D. (emphasis added).) To date, no FAA has been conducted. Petitioner asserts that the IEP dictated that Respondents begin conducting an FAA immediately after the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting.

In support of his position, Petitioner offered the testimony of Mother. She testified that at the April 23, 2004, IEP meeting, the Respondents offered to conduct an FAA. She added that the FAA was not conditioned on first placing Student at a residential placement. Despite the language of the meeting notes, Mother also testified that during the meeting she informed Terre Chapman that she did not agree to the meeting notes as written. Instead, she stated that she understood that the FAA would be conducted regardless of whether Student was first placed at a residential placement.

In response, the Respondents cited the pertinent language above and the testimony of Terre Chapman. Ms. Chapman testified that at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting, the team discussed and agreed to conduct an FAA and develop a new behavior intervention plan (BIP) once Student began his residential placement. Ms. Chapman stated that Mother was provided the meeting notes and offered no dissent to the notes. Further, the Respondents note that Mother testified that she read the meeting notes and signed the IEP noting her agreement to the IEP as written. Ms. Chapman also noted that in other IEPs, Mother did memorialize in writing her dissent to a proposed plan and refused to agree to the IEP. (Dist. Ex. W.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the plain language of the IEP meeting notes indicate that an FAA would be conducted upon Student’s entry into a new placement. The Hearing Officer determines Mother’s testimony regarding the events of the meeting was not credible. Specifically, the Hearing Officer notes that her actions effectively contradict her testimony. She testified that she read the IEP meeting notes and vocalized her dissent to its contents. Yet, Mother signed the document and wrote no dissent to the IEP document. Mother offered no explanation for her inconsistent behavior. Mother’s veracity is further problematic because she has previously disagreed with an IEP and indicated her dissent on the meeting notes. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds Mother’s testimony unreasonable and, ultimately, unbelievable.

On the other hand, Ms. Chapman testified consistently that Mother never raised any concerns regarding the proposed plan for conducting an FAA. Moreover, as discussed above, the Respondents had numerous behavior-related services in place for Student that the Hearing Officer has already determined met his behavior needs. These services included, but are not limited to, a behavior intervention plan based on a prior FAA, a small classroom size with a low student-to-teacher ratio, psychological therapy, in-class behavioral interventions, and a PSR. As noted above, these services were designed to meet Student’s behavioral needs. Moreover, Student received some benefit as evidenced by his “gold” and “silver” marks on his daily conduct reports. Given Mother’s inconsistent behavior and noncredible testimony, and the behavioral services in place at the time, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents were not required to conduct an FAA prior to Student’s attendance at his new educational setting. Therefore, the Respondents did not fail to comply with the requirements of the April 23, 2004 IEP with respect to the timing to conduct an FAA.

Least Restrictive Environment

During this time period, the Petitioner did not raise the issue of whether the Respondents offered a placement in the least restrictive setting. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer refrains from analyzing this element of the FAPE test.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that from December 2003 to May 11, 2004, involving the June 12, 2003 IEP and its addenda, the Respondents offered Student a FAPE. The Hearing Officer specifically determines that the Respondents’ placements were designed to meet Student’s unique needs in behavior and social skills, were calculated and provided some educational benefit, and the program implemented comported with his IEP addenda of February 26, and April 23, 2004. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents demonstrated that they fulfilled the mandates of the IDEA and Rowley from December 2003 to May 11, 2004.

2. Did the Respondents’ May 12, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement deny Student a FAPE because it failed to consider less restrictive options and provide for psychiatric monitoring?

Petitioner contends that the May 12, 2004 IEP failed to consider less restrictive options to the offer of residential placement. In response, the Respondents assert that less restrictive alternatives including a day treatment program were considered prior to making the residential placement recommendation. The Hearing Officer will first briefly analyze whether the Respondents’ offer was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to allow him to receive educational benefit.

Student’s Unique Needs

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that Student had unique needs in the areas of behavior and social skills. The parties agree that these same needs continued to be problematic for Student in May 2004. The parties also concur that his deficits in these areas became worse over the period of time between December 2003 and May 2004. Moreover, the parties agree that the paramount area of concern was Student’s escalating behaviors.

In the area of behavior, the undisputed facts indicate that Student became increasingly aggressive and difficult to control between December 2003 and May 2004. On February 18 and 23, 2004, Student twice required physical restraint by the CLA staff to address his verbal and physical outbursts. (Dist. Ex. M.) During these outbursts, Student threatened to kill himself or others and physically attacked staff members. Ultimately, he was hospitalized under psychiatric care for almost one week following the incident on February 23, 2004.

From March 2004 until April 19, 2004, Student’s behaviors continued to deteriorate. During this period, he was involved in over a dozen incidents requiring CLA staff to physically restrain him. (Dist. Ex. M.) For instance, Student’s behaviors included verbally abusing staff members and other students, turning over desks, and slapping another student in the face. Again, Student required hospitalization for psychiatric care for one week.

It is undisputed that given the serious escalation of Student’s behaviors, he required more intensive psychological services and greater structure to his educational program. Mother testified that she believed that Student could only benefit from a program with greater consistency and structure. She also stated that Student required additional psychological and therapeutic services. Respondents agree that Student also required a more structured setting and intensive psychological services. Ms. Deininger testified that her initial AB2726 assessment indicated that to provide an appropriate education to address Student’s bipolar disorder, the setting required more structure and services in the areas of behavior management, medication monitoring, and therapy. Given the undisputed nature of Student’s growing behavioral deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that in May 2004, Student required a more structured educational setting with intensive services in the areas of behavior management, medication monitoring, and therapy than he was receiving at that time.

Designed to Meet Behavior Needs

Next, the Hearing Officer turns to whether the Respondents’ offer of residential placement was designed to meet Student’s behavioral needs. Prior to making the offer for residential placement on May 12, 2004, the Respondents offered a day treatment program for Student. On March 3, 2004, the IEP team met to discuss the results of Ms. Deininger’s AB2726 evaluation and recommendations. (Dist. Exs. E and F.) Ms. Deininger testified that she observed Student, reviewed his medical and school records, and interviewed school personnel, Mother and Student extensively in preparation of her report. During her interview with Mother, Ms. Deininger elicited from Mother that Student was very dangerous. In fact, Student had made threats against Mother and his younger sister. These threats caused Student’s sister to develop post-traumatic stress syndrome and anxiety. (CMH Ex. 160.) In reviewing Student’s medical history, Ms. Deininger noted that by the time she began her assessment in January 2004, Student had been hospitalized three times in less than one year. In addition, his medications indicated that his bipolar disorder was in flux. As a result of her research, Ms. Deininger stated she recommended at the March 3, 2004 IEP that Student be placed in a residential treatment facility.

During the March 3, 2004 IEP meeting, Mother requested that Student not be placed in a residential placement. She requested that a less restrictive alternative be attempted before residential placement. The IEP team discussed this request and agreed to a day treatment program with outpatient therapy services on an interim basis to test its efficacy. On March 8, 2004, Student began attending the CLA’s day treatment program that consisted of a partial hospitalization program. In the day treatment program, Student received academic and behavioral instruction in the mornings. In the afternoons, he attended various psychological therapy and activity sessions. In addition, he received medication-monitoring services. As a necessary component to this program, CMH also provided at-home TBS with a coach. However, within one month, Mother terminated the TBS citing that Student was resisting the restrictions and rules placed upon him by the coach. (Testimony of Mother.) Further, the TBS was causing Student to become aggressive towards his family.

Despite the services of the day treatment program, Student continued to struggle with his behaviors and they became increasingly frequent and severe in nature. By April 2004, Student’s behaviors were to such a degree that he again was hospitalized. On April 23, 2004, the IEP team again met to discuss these difficulties and agreed to place Student in a residential placement facility. As part of the IEP team, Mother also desired a residential placement for Student and agreed to the offer. However, she later revoked her agreement prior to the actual placement of Student at a residential placement facility.

Consider Less Restrictive Alternatives

Petitioner contends that as of May 12, 2004, residential placement was not the appropriate program to address Student’s behavioral needs. Instead, he required continued placement at a day treatment facility, a less restrictive alternative. In support of this position, Petitioner offered the testimony of Dr. Dreyfus. Dr. Dreyfus testified on direct examination that leaving Student in the day treatment program was the appropriate setting. She qualified her testimony by stating that the day treatment program would be proper because Student’s behaviors had improved and there was no exacerbation of his behavioral deficits. However, on cross-examination, Dr. Dreyfus conceded that given his declining conduct, residential placement was appropriate. She admitted that she was not a member of the IEP team and was not privy to all the information regarding Student’s recent behavioral outbursts. Upon receiving additional facts, she reconsidered her initial opinion. She stated that Student’s decline was exemplified by his suicidal ideation and physical aggression towards others and the inability of the parties to work mutually on a consistent, structured environment at home and school. She also noted that the parent’s unilateral changing of Student’s medications without the consultation of a doctor was troubling and that having a structure to monitor his medications was necessary.

The Respondents assert that residential placement was the appropriate placement as of May 12, 2004, because they had attempted a less restrictive alternative to no avail. The Respondents emphasized the necessity of having a consistent and structured environment at school and home to effectively address Student’s behavioral deficits. Ms. Engelman testified that Student required residential placement as of May 12, 2004. She stated that Student was not safe under any less restrictive option. She testified that Student’s bipolar disorder required collaboration between both the school and home settings to achieve stability. Further, Ms. Lohse added that in residential placement, Student would have received a more intensive program including frequent group therapy, medication monitoring, and a stable routine and structure.

In addition, Ms. Deininger testified that Student required residential treatment because the day treatment program had not been effective for him. Because of Student’s continuing behavioral escalations and hospitalization in April 2004, she completed a second AB2726 assessment of Student. (Dist. Ex. C.) She stated that the day treatment program was predicated on the continued success of the at-home TBS. However, Mother’s termination of TBS disrupted the plan to have consistent rules of behavior at both school and home. Ms. Deininger testified that without the consistency between the settings, Student’s bipolar disorder was exacerbated causing greater behavioral problems. She concluded that residential placement was appropriate by May 12, 2004, because the day treatment program was being undercut by Mother’s termination of the TBS and therefore it had been rendered ineffective.

The Hearing Officer finds that the May 12, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement was designed to meet his behavioral needs. It is undisputed that the IEP team considered and agreed with Mother’s request to try day treatment at the March 8, 2004 IEP meeting. Further, this interim placement was contingent on the effectiveness of TBS at Student’s home. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Respondents’ witnesses persuasive. They each testified within the scope of their personal knowledge and expertise that day treatment had not been effective in addressing Student’s behaviors. Moreover, Petitioner’s witness, Dr. Dreyfus, also conceded that she would not have agreed to day treatment as appropriate given Student’s declining behavior. The Hearing Officer also gives great consideration to Dr. Dreyfus’ concerns about the advantages of residential treatment for medication monitoring. Because Mother has altered Student’s medications previously, the inability of medical professionals to monitor such ill-advised actions supports the necessity of having residential treatment. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer also finds that Student needed a consistent structure in all aspects of his daily life, not just in his school setting. Given the failure of Mother to allow TBS to take place, the day treatment program’s effectiveness in both settings was undermined. Accordingly, only a residential placement would allow the consistent structure required to address Student’s behavioral needs. The Hearing Officer finds that this initial effort to permit a day treatment program was proper under the circumstances of Student’s declining behaviors, but that as of May 12, 2004, Student required a residential placement to meet his needs.

In light of the Respondents’ efforts to implement a day treatment program prior to offering residential placement, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents did, in fact, consider less restrictive alternatives. The uncontradicted evidence is that the IEP team deliberated and agreed to Mother’s request for a day treatment program at the March 3, 2004 IEP. The IEP team tried the day treatment placement for over two months and determined that this program was not addressing Student’s behaviors. In response, the IEP team met on May 12, 2004, and again recommended residential placement and Mother agreed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents did not deny Student a FAPE in failing to consider less restrictive alternatives to residential placement.

Psychiatric Monitoring

Petitioner also contends that the Respondents failed to provide appropriate psychiatric monitoring as part of the May 12, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement. In response, the Respondents offered the testimony of Ms. Engelman. She testified that Student’s residential placement would have included a therapeutic process in all aspects of his day. She noted that unlike a day treatment placement, the residential placement would have provided a more intensive behavioral management programs and around-the-clock supervision by staff special trained in behavior management. Further, Ms. Lohse testified that Student would have received more frequent group therapy sessions with trained personnel to address his behavior and social skills needs. In contrast, Petitioner offered no evidence that these services were not designed to meet Student’s needs.

Given that both Ms. Engelman and Ms. Lohse are licensed psychologists with extensive experience in the areas of behavior and therapy, the Hearing Officer finds their undisputed testimony persuasive. Each testified as to how the structure of a residential placement and the connected therapy and psychological services were aimed at addressing Student’s behavioral deficits. The Hearing Officer finds that this undisputed testimony reflects how the proposed placement would have met Student’s severe behavioral needs with a consistent structure and intensive therapeutic services. Given the lack of any countervailing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the psychiatric monitoring services offered in the May 12, 2004 IEP were proper to meet his needs.

Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determines that the Respondents’ program in the May 12, 2004 IEP was designed to meet Student’s behavior and social skills needs. Because of the structure and services included in the residential placement, Student’s needs in these areas would have been addressed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ plan was also calculated to provide some educational benefit to Student.

Conforms to the IEP

The Petitioner did not raise the issue of whether the Respondents conformed to elements of the IEP plan as of May 12, 2004. Further, the Hearing Officer notes that the parent did not consent to the May 12, 2004 IEP and thus Respondents did not have authority to implement it. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer refrains from analyzing this element of the FAPE test.

Least Restrictive Environment

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has determined that Respondents’ offer of residential placement was appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the Respondents made every effort to provide Student with an appropriate day treatment program. However, given Student’s inability to benefit educationally from the day treatment program, the Respondents were unable to find a less restrictive alternative that would effectively meet his behavioral and social skills needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of residential placement was the least restrictive environment to meet the needs of Student.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ May 12, 2004 IEP offered Student a FAPE. The Hearing Officer specifically finds that the Respondents’ proposed placement was designed to meet Student’s unique needs in the areas of dispute and was calculated to provide some educational benefit. In addition, the offer of residential placement was the least restrictive environment to meet Student’s needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Office finds that the May 12, 2004 IEP fulfilled the mandates of the IDEA and Rowley.

3. Did the Respondents deny Student a FAPE in his June 15, 2004 IEP?

Petitioner contends that the Respondents’ reiterated offer of a residential placement for Student at the June 15, 2004 IEP is also inappropriate for the same reasons discussed above. Petitioner claims that the IEP fails to meet his needs by not providing a one-to-one aide. Petitioner also asserts that the Respondents’ offer fails to meet his needs by not providing access to a counseling office. Again, the Hearing Officer must look at Student’s needs to determine whether the Respondents’ offer of the June 15, 2004 IEP is appropriate to meet those needs.

Student’s Unique Needs

Student’s behavioral needs are again at the center of this dispute. The parties generally agree that Student continued to escalate behaviorally from May 12 to June 15, 2004. During this period, Student returned to the CLA day treatment program and struggled to follow directions of staff members leading to further behavioral escalations. Mother testified that during this period she instructed Student that he did not need to attend the afternoon PHP at CLA. She explained that in her opinion, the PHP was not appropriate and Student should not attend nor follow the instructions of staff members in contradiction of her judgment. In response, Student began refusing to follow staff members’ instructions. (Testimony of Ms. Tierney.) On May 28, 2004, he acted aggressively towards a fellow student and failed to heed CLA personnel’s directions to cease his aggression. Student failed to follow these instructions and became verbally and physically aggressive. Accordingly, staff members were forced to physically restrain him. (Dist. Ex. M.) Following this incident, Student attended school on only two more days. However, on those two days, Student engaged in further behavioral outbursts. In one incident, he pushed Ms. Tierney causing her to seek medical attention from a physician. (Testimony of Ms. Tierney.) After June 8, 2004, Student failed to further attend CLA. Mother testified that she no longer felt that Student was safe at school and instead kept him at home. She added that he is not currently receiving any educational programming while at home.

The parties agree that Student’s behaviors were similar to his behaviors before the May 12, 2004 IEP meeting and continued to worsen by the time of the June 15, 2004 meeting. The parties also offered the same evidence regarding his needs for the purposes of the June 15, 2004 IEP offer. Because the parties are in accord regarding their positions and evidence with respect to the offer of residential placement in June 15, 2004 IEP as with the May 12, 2004, the Hearing Officer need not repeat the prior evidence.

Petitioner also contends that Student requires access to a “counseling office” as a behavioral need. Mother testified that he requires specific techniques to deal with his frustration and an appropriate place to work on these techniques, namely a “counseling office.” She explained that Student is unable to control his anger or agitation; accordingly, he needs a place to accommodate his anger or agitation. She did not believe that the prior use of PSRs is sufficient to meet this need. Instead, she stated that he requires “a safe place to talk to someone.”

In response, the Respondents did not disagree with Petitioner’s contentions but noted instead that residential treatment would provide a “counseling office” space. Ms. Engelman testified that in a residential placement setting, Student would be provided an opportunity to make use of designated space to de-escalate. She explained that Student would be able to use the area to de-escalate with behaviorally trained staff monitoring and supporting him.

The Hearing Officer finds that Student requires a designated area to de-escalate from anger or agitation. The parties all agree that Student’s behavioral needs include a place designed as a “counseling office” space where he can calm himself with the supervision and support of school personnel. Because there is no disagreement as to this need, the Hearing Officer finds that the above-described “counseling space” is required to address Student’s behavioral needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student requires a highly structured and consistent educational placement with an emphasis on behavior management, medication monitoring, and therapy to address his behavior needs.

Designed to Meet Student’s Needs

Residential Placement

Petitioner again contends that the offer of residential placement is improper to meet Student’s needs. Petitioner bases his assertions on the same evidence as discussed regarding the May 12, 2004 IEP offer. Correspondingly, the Respondents claim that the June 15, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement is appropriate based on the same reasons and evidence discussed above. The Hearing Officer now turns to whether the events between May 12 and June 15, 2004, would affect Student’s needs and the adequacy of the Respondents’ offer in relation to those needs.

The undisputed testimony is that Student’s behaviors continued to deteriorate from May to June 2004. During this period, Student attended school only twice in the month of June and has not returned. Nonetheless, throughout this limited time frame, both Mother and Respondents’ witnesses have testified to his continuing behavioral outbursts. These behaviors were amplified by Mother’s instructions to Student not to follow the directions of CLA staff. Dr. Cox testified that these instructions caused a conflict in Student that could not be resolved by him due to his bipolar disorder. (Footnote 17) She added that this disparity between school and home only increased Student’s agitation and propensity for aggression. Ms. Lohse also testified that the lack of structure at home created further instability in Student. She agreed that without stability at home, Student would require a residential placement to provide order. In addition, Ms. Deininger testified that Student could not simply be placed back into another day treatment program. She stated that the disparity between school and home structures fostered unsafe instability. In response, Mother testified that she believed that Student should be allowed to stay in a day treatment program. She reiterated her reliance on Dr. Dreyfus’s remarks that Student could benefit from a day treatment program.

The Hearing Officer finds that events between the May 12 and June 15, 2004 IEP meetings support the necessity for residential placement. The Respondents’ witnesses each testified credibly that Mother’s instructions to Student to not follow the directions of school staff were detrimental to him. The Hearing Officer notes that stability and consistency are the hallmarks that allow Student to make progress with his education. Mother’s admissions that she told Student that he did not need to comply with school personnel directions caused increased confusion for Student. It also undermined any ability for the IEP team to keep Student in a less restrictive setting, by its incorporation of TBS with the day treatment program. As discussed above, Mother’s reliance on Dr. Dreyfus’s comments that Student could be educated in a day treatment program is unpersuasive. Dr. Dreyfus conceded that her opinions assumed that Student had proper structure at home without conflicts of inconsistency. These assumptions are not applicable here because the undisputed facts are that Student was receiving mixed messages from his mother and CLA causing him confusion and ultimately to engage in out-of-control behavior. In light of Student’s continuing need for a more consistent and highly structured environment, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 15, 2004 IEP offer of residential placement was proper.

One-to-One Aide

Petitioner also asserts that the June 15, 2004 IEP is an appropriate program because it fails to provide Student with a one-to-one aide. As discussed above, as of December 2003, the Hearing Officer determined that Student did not require a one-to-one aide, as a service, to address his social skills needs. For the time period at issue here, Petitioner took the same position and offered the same evidence in support of his assertion regarding the necessity of an aide as previously discussed above. Petitioner offered no evidence that Student’s needs changed from December 2003 to June 15, 2004, necessitating the provision of an aide.

In response, the Respondents assert that Student’s social skills did not require a one-to-one aide as part of his June 15, 2004 IEP. The Respondents offered the testimony of Ms. Tierney and Mr. Berry in support of their position. Both witnesses testified, as discussed above, that Student did not require a personal aide. Moreover, Ms. Engelman testified that a residential placement with its consistent monitoring of Student would provide Student with more intensive structure than his former day treatment program. Further, she stated that Student would receive greater behavioral management and therapy sessions to properly work on his social skills needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the undisputed testimony demonstrates that Student did not require a one-to-one aide in the June 15, 2004 IEP. The Respondents’ witnesses each testified without contradiction that Student did not require a personal assistant to be able to engage in the school curriculum. Moreover, Ms. Engelman testified without challenge that Student would receive proper behavior management and therapy services in the residential placement to address his social skills needs. On the other hand, Petitioner offered no further testimony as to the need for a one-to-one aide. As discussed above, Petitioner only suggested that a one-to-one aide “would be helpful.” (Testimony of Mother.) Petitioner did not offer evidence that it was necessary. As discussed above, the Rowley standard is not “helpful;” instead, it requires Respondents to provide services appropriate meet a child’s needs. Here, Petitioner again offered no evidence that a one-to-one aide was necessary, as a function of his social skills needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents did not deny Student a FAPE by not providing him with a one-to-one aid in the June 15, 2004 IEP.

Access to a Counseling Office

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer previously determined that Student requires a place designated as a “counseling office” space in times of anger and agitation. The Respondents’ offer of residential placement includes an area for this purpose. Ms. Engelman testified that Student would be provided with a “counseling office” space. She stated that Student could leave the immediate area of his program during times of distress, and use the space to de-escalate from his anger or agitation. She added that a member of the residential placement’s staff would monitor and support Student while in the space.

Petitioner offered no evidence that such a proposed “counseling office” space was not designed to meet Student’s needs. Mother simply testified that she believed Student’s residential placement would not have a “counseling space.” Given the testimony of Ms. Engelman, there is no significant difference in what Petitioner is seeking versus the Respondents’ offer in the residential placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 15, 2004 IEP includes a provision within its residential placement offer contemplating the availability of a “counseling space.” Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ residential placement offer is designed to address Student’s behavioral needs.

Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determines that the Respondents’ program in the June 15, 2004 IEP is designed to meet Student’s behavior and social skills needs. Because of the structure and services included in the residential placement, Student’s needs in these areas would be addressed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ plan is also calculated to provide some educational benefit to Student.

Conforms to the IEP

The Petitioner did not raise the issue of whether the Respondents conformed to elements of the IEP plan as of June 15, 2004. Since Petitioner’s parent refused to consent to this IEP, Respondents were not authorized to implement its plan. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer refrains from analyzing this element of the FAPE test.

Least Restrictive Environment

As discussed above regarding the May 12, 2004 IEP offer, the Hearing Officer has determined that Respondents’ offer of residential placement was appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the Respondents made every effort to provide Student with an appropriate day treatment program. However, given Student’s inability to benefit educationally from the day treatment program, the Respondents were unable to find a less restrictive alternative that would effectively meet his behavioral and social skills needs. There was no significant difference in his needs from May 12 to June 15, 2004 in this regard. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of residential placement is the least restrictive environment to meet the needs of Student.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 15, 2004 IEP offered Student a FAPE. The Hearing Officer also specifically finds that the Respondents’ proposed placement was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was calculated to provide some educational benefit. Lastly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ offer of residential placement in the June 15, 2004 IEP was the least restrictive environment to meet Student’s unique needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents demonstrated that they fulfilled the mandates of the IDEA and Rowley with respect to the June 15, 2004 IEP.

4. Is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of a home remediation program with a teacher providing instruction, four days a week for four hours per day?

Petitioner seeks compensatory education as a remedy for the Respondents’ alleged denials of FAPE. Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from United States Code title 20, section 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Ind. Sch. Dist. Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D.Minn. 1996).

Here, the Hearing Officer has determined that the Respondents did not deny Student a FAPE during any of the time periods raised by Petitioner. Because the Petitioner has failed to prevail on any of his issues, Petitioner has not shown that he lost any educational opportunity. Moreover, the Respondents demonstrated that they offered and provided Student a FAPE during all times at issue. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denies Petitioner’s above claim for compensatory education.

5. As a remedy, is Student entitled to an alternative placement?

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has determined that Respondents offered Student a FAPE during all time periods at issue. Therefore, the current IEP plan to place Student within a residential placement is also appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denies Petitioner’s request for an alternative placement.

ORDER

1. Respondents may implement the IEP of June 15, 2004, over the objection of Petitioner without parental consent; and

2. All of the Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

The Respondents prevailed on all issues heard and decided in this matter.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505 (i).

Date: August 19, 2004 My T. Huynh, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

The CLA is a non-public school (NPS) specifically devoted to educating students with severe behavioral needs. CLA is part of the CFC’s larger NPS environment.

2 In addition to the CLA, CFC also operates day treatment and residential placement programs at its facilities.

3 Student continued to attend CLA during a portion of summer 2003 as part of his educational placement.

4 AB2726 refers to Chapter 26.5, Division 7, Title 1 of the California Government Code, which provides for interagency responsibilities between local educational and community mental health agencies to refer children for assessments and deliver mental health services as part of their special education program.

5 Sometime in April 2004, Student was transferred from Mr. Bryan Love’s homeroom classroom to Ms. Kirsta Tierney’s classroom for his morning educational instruction.

6 Student’s IEP team held his triennial IEP meeting on June 12, 2003. (Dist. Ex. J.) There were additional services added to his IEP via later IEP team meetings on July 28 and September 23, 2003. (Dist. Exs. J and I.)

7 Ms. Tierney holds a bachelor’s degree and several teaching credentials including a special education credential. She has been working in the field of education for over fifteen years.

8 Ms. Engelman holds a master’s degree in psychology and is a licensed clinical psychologist. She has worked at residential treatment centers for over twenty years providing psychological services. Ms. Engelman has been Student’s day treatment therapist since March 9, 2004.

9 Mr. Love was Student’s primary classroom teacher from May 2003 until March 2004. He holds a master’s degree in special education.

10 Dr. Dreyfus holds a medical degree from Boston University Medical School. She has served as CMC’s medical director and treating psychiatrist since December 1994. She has served as Student’s treating psychiatrist since March 2003.

11 Ms. Lohse has been a licensed clinical social worker for the past four years.

12 Ms. Deininger holds a master’s degree in social work. She has worked in the field of social work for over thirty years.

13 Mr. Love qualified the physical contact as being initiated by Student. He testified that Student would ask for a hug or other physical contact from a staff member.

14 The Hearing Officer is gravely concerned about the testimony of Mother regarding the administration of Student’s medications. During her testimony, she stated that in August 2003, she altered the dosage of Depakote, a mood stabilization drug, without consulting a physician. She explained that she raised Student’s dosage of this medication based solely on “something she read in a book.” Mother admitted she has no training or education in the area of medicine or pharmacology. She also conceded that she was unaware that altering the dosage of one medication may adversely affect the effectiveness of Student’s other anti-psychotic or thyroid medicines. The Hearing Officer strongly urges Mother to not further modifying Student’s prescriptions without first consulting a medical professional. Given the nature of these powerful drugs, the results could be dangerous to Student.

15 Even if the Respondents had a duty to provide the Odyssey Ware software, the great weight of evidence indicated that Odyssey Ware, as a computer-based curriculum, would have caused Student to work exclusively on the computer to the detriment of developing his social skills. (Testimony of Dr. Cox.) The IEP noted that the program would be “supplemental curriculum” because it was not considered to be appropriate, as a full-day curriculum for Student and the IEP team did not believe that the software was central to his educational curriculum. In short, the evidence indicates that Odyssey Ware was not designed to meet Student’s needs in the area of social skills. Thus, the provision of Odyssey Ware was not necessary to provide Student a FAPE and the failure to purchase it would not have resulted in any appreciable harm to Student’s educational opportunities.

16 In California, specific legislation has been enacted to ensure that students with disabilities are not placed in an overly restrictive environment based upon behavior problems. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56520; Cal. Code Reg. tit. 5, §§ 3001, 3052. Pursuant to this legislation, otherwise known as the "Hughes Bill," a functional analysis assessment to be conducted and a behavioral intervention plan developed whenever a special education student "exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual's IEP." Cal .Code Reg. tit. 5, § 3001(f). In establishing mechanisms for developing behavioral interventions, the Legislature intended to "ensure a pupil's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56520 (b)(1). Such interventions "are designed to provide the individual with greater access to a variety of community settings, social contacts, and public events; and ensure the individual's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment as outlined in the individual's IEP." Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5 § 3001(d).

17 Dr. Cox holds a doctorate in philosophy in special education. She has worked in special education for twenty years with an emphasis in assisting students with psychological disorders.