California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 4, 2000

Student v. Kelseyville Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1298-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

California School for the Deaf, Fremont, need not keep student; Kelseyville Unified's local special day class offer found appropriate.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision refers to the prior due process matter (SN 1224-98 / SN 1294-98) that was resolved by the January 22, 1999 settlement, and to an unsuccessful CSDF application to federal district court in December 1998.

Summary

The foster parents of an 11-year-old deaf girl with significant developmental delays filed for due process. Her IEP team had recommended that she leave the California School for the Deaf, Fremont (CSDF) and return to Kelseyville Unified. Kelseyville joined the parents in asking that she stay at CSDF, and CSDF opposed. A January 1999 settlement let her attend CSDF three days a week. Two assessors were to check her progress on new goals after 90 days. The Hearing Officer found that the settlement did not require CSDF to keep her. Both assessors signed the June 1999 IEP, which found that she had not made "measurable progress." Nothing showed that the agreement ran past the 1998-99 school year. Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer found CSDF was not an appropriate placement. After three years she still needed one-to-one help with self-care and getting around campus. Her behavior problems continued, and she faced a bus ride of three hours or more. Assessors testified that she learns best in her home community because she has trouble transferring skills to new settings. The district's offer met her needs: a class for students with severe disabilities at Gard Street School, a language role model five hours a day, and a deaf peer group twice a week. The order requires an IEP meeting within 15 days, a teacher who signs, specified services by the start of the 2000-01 school year, a toileting plan made with medical input, a functional analysis assessment and behavior plan, and no placement with her sibling.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO read a settlement's "measurable progress" condition using California contract law. It also shows that a state special school was not required to keep a student when the home district offered an appropriate local program. Even so, the Hearing Officer ordered specific program parts, including an ASL-signing teacher, a behavior assessment, and a toileting plan.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Does the agreement reached by the parties on January 22, 1999, obligate the California School for the Deaf in Fremont to maintain STUDENT as a student?

    Both assessors chosen under the settlement signed the IEP concluding the student had not made measurable progress, and the agreement did not extend past the 1998-99 school year, so CSDF was not obligated to keep her.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. If not, what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

    CSDF was not appropriate given the student's functional level, need for one-to-one care, long bus ride, and difficulty generalizing; the district's SDC-SH offer with a language role model and deaf peer group met Rowley, with added components ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, the District must convene an IEP meeting with the required participants, including the parents, District and Lake County SELPA representatives, and at least the CSDF classroom teacher and residential supervisor who have been responsible for the student.
  • Placement ordered. The IEP team must conform the IEP to the decision and place the student in a structured SDC-SH class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, taught by an SH teacher who signs ASL and has training in educating deaf children.
  • Order to provide or change services. By the first day of the 2000-01 school year, the District and Lake County SELPA must provide a functional curriculum at her developmental level; community-based instruction; one-to-one instruction with group opportunities; specific ASL language instruction paired with a picture communication system; group social and language experiences with deaf peers; direct instruction in play and social skills with structured play; and a self-help skills program.
  • The District shall not place the student with her deaf sibling.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must develop a program to address incontinence in consultation with appropriate medical personnel.
  • Order to assess. The District must complete a functional analysis assessment meeting 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3052 within 20 days after the student's placement in the SDC, considering behavior in the classroom, DHH group, home, and other relevant environments.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 15 days after the functional analysis assessment is completed, the District must develop a behavioral intervention plan meeting 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3052, and must implement it within five days after it is completed.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gruen Watch Co. v. Artists Alliance, Inc. (1951) 191 F.2d 700; Folden v. Lobrovich (1959) 171 Cal.App.2d 627; Cal. Civil Code §§ 1636, 1638; Cal. Educ. Code § 59020; 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3052; 20 U.S.C. § 1401; Cal. Gov. Code § 11135

People named in the decision

  • Cindy Ustrud, Director of student support services, Kelseyville Unified School District
  • Michael Oken, SELPA director, Lake County SELPA
  • Debra Sue Guthmann, Ed.D., Director of pupil personnel services, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • John R. Winslow, II, Ph.D., Private psychologist; witness on behavior intervention, Private practice, Kelseyville
  • Todd McGough, School psychologist; developed behavioral intervention plan, Kelseyville Unified School District
  • Spectrum Center for Educational and Behavioral Development, Nonpublic agency; developed behavior "User's Guide", Contracted by District
  • Susie Sakamoto, Teacher (1997-1999), California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Diane Muscadine, Teacher (1999-2000), California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Jennifer Simmons, Psychologist and settlement assessor selected by CSDF, Formerly employed by California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Joe Schmitz, Deaf and hard-of-hearing specialist; settlement assessor selected by parents, Lake County Office of Education
  • Nichola (Nikki) Schmitz, Deaf/hard-of-hearing specialist; leads deaf peer group, Lake County Office of Education
  • Rico Castillo (formerly Barlow), Language role model (LRM), Kelseyville / Lake County
  • Ann Moxley, Ph.D., Assessor, Northern California Assessment Center for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing
  • Amy Pederson, Cottage counselor, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Bobbie Alexander, Assistant to the dean; transportation supervisor; occasional cottage aide, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Ronald Stern, Director of instruction, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Ms. Kordus, Psychologist; former behavioral intervention specialist, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Redwood Regional Center, Regional center funding one-to-one cottage aide

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Kelseyville, California, on October 21 and 22, 1999, January 19, 20, and 21, February 23, 24, and 25, March 29, 30, and 31, and April 6 and 7, 2000. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by advocate Constance Pomery Sabin, J.D. Petitioner's foster parents were present throughout the course of the hearing.

Respondents Kelseyville Unified School District and the Lake County Special Education Local Plan area (SELPA) were represented at the hearing by attorney John Drummond. Also present on behalf of the District was Cindy Ustrud, director of student support services. Also present on behalf of Lake County SELPA was Michael Oken, director.(Footnote 1) Greg Rousseve, deputy counsel for the California Department of Education, represented Respondent California School for the Deaf, Fremont (CSDF). Debra Sue Guthmann, Ed.D., director of the division of pupil personnel services, was also present on behalf of CSDF.(Footnote 2)

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments and replies thereto, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.(Footnote 3)

ISSUES

(1) Does the agreement reached by the parties on January 22, 1999, obligate the California School for the Deaf in Fremont to maintain STUDENT as a student?

(2) If not, what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is an 11-year-old deaf student. She also is developmentally disabled.(Footnote 4) On Mondays, STUDENT receives one-to-one instruction from a language role model (LRM) in Kelseyville.(Footnote 5) On Tuesdays, the LRM drives STUDENT to the California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSDF). STUDENT attends the CSDF three days each week (Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday). She stays in a CSDF cottage with six other students while attending CSDF. The District pays for a full-time aide to accompany STUDENT during the school day, and the Redwood Regional Center pays for a one-to-one aide to help STUDENT in the cottage. On Fridays, STUDENT rides a bus from the CSDF accompanied by an aide.(Footnote 6) STUDENT is seen privately in Kelseyville by psychologist John R. Winslow, II, Ph.D. He has diagnosed STUDENT with an oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) secondary to severe neglect and abuse by her birth parents for the first five years of her life. Resperitol is currently prescribed to reduce STUDENT's anxiety and to increase her ability to focus. DDAVP is prescribed for night time incontinence.

STUDENT came to the attention of Child Protective Services (CPS) in 1995 when she was found by a sheriff wondering in the street. STUDENT was approximately six years old at the time. Thereafter, STUDENT was temporarily placed with the PARENTS, who provided foster care. STUDENT was placed briefly in another foster home before spending a successful year with the Jackson family. Unfortunately, the Jacksons were transferred out of the country before adoption procedures were completed, and they were unable to take STUDENT with them. STUDENT then was placed with the PARENTS. STUDENT's older hearing sister also is placed with the PARENTS. Parental rights for her birth parents have been terminated, and the PARENTS have initiated adoption proceedings.

STUDENT previously attended school in Lake County. She was in a special day class (SDC) and also mainstreamed in a regular education class with the assistance of a one-to-one aide. STUDENT's former foster family completed an application for STUDENT to attend the California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSDF). In March 1997, Ms. Pomeroy Sabin filed a compliance complaint with the State of California for the purpose of, among other things, seeking an order to compel the District to place STUDENT at the CSDF for a 50-day extended assessment period (EAP). The Compliance Complaint Unit issued such an order and, on September 9, 1997, STUDENT entered the CSDF for an EAP.

STUDENT was assigned to Susie Sakamoto's class. During the 1997-1998 school year, Ms. Sakamoto's class consisted of three students and their one-to-one aides. STUDENT experienced difficulty transitioning to the CSDF. For a period, MOTHER and one of her daughters stayed with STUDENT. In October 1997, the District and Regional Center agreed to pay for one-to-one aides in the classroom and cottage respectively. The CSDF agreed to extend the assessment period to the end of the winter break. The meeting to discuss STUDENT's progress was delayed several times. On March 25, 1998, the CSDF representatives met with the PARENTS to discuss STUDENT's placement. The CSDF representatives concluded that the CSDF was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT; however, STUDENT continued to attend the CSDF. At another IEP meeting on June 25, 1998, the CSDF representatives recommended that STUDENT return to school in Kelseyville.

In August 1998, the PARENTS requested a special education due process hearing regarding placement (SN 1224-98). The Hearing Office granted Petitioner's motion for stay put to allow STUDENT to remain at the CSDF pending resolution of due process proceedings. In November 1998, Todd McGough, school psychologist, developed a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for STUDENT. The District contracted with Spectrum Center for Educational and Behavioral Development, a nonpublic agency, to work with Mr. McGough and to devise a "User's Guide" for working with STUDENT. In December 1998, the CSDF applied to Federal District Court to obtain an order prohibiting STUDENT from attending CSDF. No order was issued and STUDENT remained at the CSDF.

On January 22, 1999, the hearing in SN 1294-98 convened; however, prior to taking evidence, the parties reached an agreement whereby STUDENT would attend the CSDF three days each week and receive additional services in Kelseyville. The agreement also called for assessments to be completed by the end of February 1999 by one person selected by the parents and one by the CSDF. The agreement also called for goals, objectives, and a program to be developed 10 days following completion of the assessments, and for reassessments by the same two assessors to be completed at the CSDF 90 days after implementation of the goals, objectives, and program at the CSDF. The purpose of the initial evaluations was to establish baselines from which to develop goals and objectives. The parties agreed that, if the reevaluation concluded that STUDENT was not appropriate for the CSDF because she had not made measurable progress on the goals and objectives, the parties would set the matter for hearing or agree to a change in placement for STUDENT. Additionally, the District agreed to provide an aide to accompany STUDENT on the bus, and the PARENTS agreed to pick up STUDENT in Ukiah.

The CSDF selected Jennifer Simmons, a psychologist formerly employed by the CSDF, and the parents selected Joe Schmitz, deaf and hard-of-hearing specialist for the Lake County Office of Education (COE), to conduct the assessments called for by the settlement agreement. Once the initial assessments were completed, the IEP team developed goals and objectives, which were implemented at the CSDR. At the end of 90 days, Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz observed STUDENT on a nonschool day with her aide to evaluate STUDENT's progress.

As to STUDENT's meeting the goals and objectives, Ms. Simmons found that STUDENT partially met receptive language and transition goals, did not meet the expressive language goal, and met the play goal. Ms. Simmons concluded that STUDENT's greatest gains were in the area of performing new sets of behaviors that had been modeled for her. Less progress was observed related to use of sign language and photos to enhance communication. In her report, Ms. Simmons commented that STUDENT continued to exhibit oppositional behavior and a limited attention span. Mr. Schmitz stated in his report that he found it difficult to measure progress. He noted that STUDENT was signing more than when he observed her in March and concluded that STUDENT benefitted from the program and instruction that she had received over the prior 90 days.

The IEP team met on June 8, 1999, to review the findings of Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz. IEP team members from the CSDF, the District, and the two assessors recommended placement in a special day class for severely disabled students (SDC-SH) at Gard Street School in Kelseyville, with a five-hour-per-day LRM, and services from a deaf/hard of hearing specialist two days per week for two hours. The parents disagreed with the recommendation that STUDENT return to school in Kelseyville and filed for due process. During the summer of 1999, STUDENT worked with Rico Castillo, LRM, in Kelseyville and attended camp for one week.(Footnote 7)

STUDENT has continued to attend the CSDF pursuant to stay put. During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was in Diane Muscadine's class at the CSDF for Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. Ms. Muscadine's class consists of five female students who were 10 or 11 years old. According to Ms. Muscadine, all of the students are below grade level academically and are functioning at a first- or second-grade level. STUDENT functions well below all of the other students. The students receive approximately 33% of their instruction individually and the remainder is spent in group activities. Ms. Muscadine follows the curriculum of the Fremont Unified School District. On Monday afternoons, STUDENT continues to work with Mr. Castillo. The parties were unable to reach agreement as to STUDENT's placement, which resulted in the instant hearing.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSDF) offers her an appropriate placement. In particular, she asserts that the CSDF is the only placement that provides her with an appropriate peer group and opportunities to develop language. Petitioner asserts that she meets the criteria set forth in California Education Code § 59020 for attendance at the CSDF. Petitioner asserts that she has demonstrated the ability to learn and to make educational progress when provided with an individualized program at CSDF.

Petitioner contends that an appropriate placement is not available to her in Kelseyville, Lake County, or the surrounding counties. Petitioner asserts that the special day class (SDC) at Gard Street School in Kelseyville does not offer her an appropriate peer group, in part, because there are no deaf students in the class. Rather, the students have a wide range of disabilities. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the class is not appropriate because neither the SDC teacher nor aide signs proficiently. Petitioner asserts that deaf peers are necessary for her to learn the subtleties of signing, such as facial and body language. Finally, Petitioner asserts that any placement that includes her biological sister would be inappropriate because, when the sisters are together, Petitioner's appropriate behavior deteriorates and she reverts to frenzied, inappropriate behavior.

The District joins Petitioner's request for placement at the CSDF. In addition to the reasons set forth above, the District contends that Petitioner is entitled to remain at the CSDF pursuant to an agreement ("Hearing Resolution") executed by the parties on January 22,1999. The District and Petitioner assert that she met one goal and demonstrated progress on two goals, which, by the terms of the agreement, would allow Petitioner to remain at the CSDF. Finally, the District contends that the CSDF, as part of the public school system, cannot use admissions criteria to exclude Petitioner because of developmental disabilities and behavioral problems. The District also asserts that the CSDF admissions criteria are subjective and were not developed according to legal requirements.

Should it be determined that placement in the CSDF is not appropriate, the District contends that it can provide Petitioner with an appropriate placement in the special day class (SDC) at Gard Street School with supplemental services of a language role model (LRM) for five hours daily and twice weekly participation for two hours in a group setting with deaf peers.

The CSDF contends that Petitioner does not meet eligibility criteria for placement at the CSDF for the following reasons: she lacks requisite self-help skills; needs one-to-one assistance; is unable to respond to life-threatening situations; is incapable of learning simple mobility patterns; and cannot function independently in the residential component of the CSDF. The CSDF asserts that its program merely is an option for some of California's deaf children who meet its admissions criteria.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Does the agreement reached by the parties on January 22, 1999, obligate the California School for the Deaf in Fremont to maintain STUDENT as a student?

Special education statutory law does not address how to resolve disputes regarding interpretation of a settlement agreement. Absent special education rules for the interpretation of contracts, the Hearing Officer turns to California law regarding the interpretation of contracts. Pursuant to California Civil Code § 1638 and case law, when the language of the contract is clear and unambiguous, the provisions of the contract as written are enforced. See Gruen Watch Co. v. Artists Alliance, Inc. (1951) 191 F2d 700; Folden v. Lobrovich (1st Dist. 1959) 171 Cal App 2d 627; Witkin, Summary of California Law (9th ed. 1997) § 681. When the terms of the contract are ambiguous, however, a contract must be interpreted to give effect to the intention of the parties as it existed at the time of contracting. California Civil Code § 1636.

The nucleus of the disagreement regards the statement "[i]f the joint evaluation concludes that STUDENT is not appropriate for the program at CSDF because she has not made measurable progress on the goals and objective identified in the IEP, the parties will either set the matter for fair hearing or agree to a change in placement. Specifically, the parties dispute whether STUDENT made "measurable progress."

The Hearing Resolution drafted on January 22, 1999, includes the following relevant terms:

CSDF and Petitioner will jointly assess STUDENT in the classroom and the cottage environment by the end of February 1999. . . .

An IEP meeting will then be held within 10 days following the assessment report, at CSDF, to draw goals and objectives and to design a program for STUDENT.

STUDENT's program will be reevaluated, by original assessors, ninety days after implementation. If the joint evaluation concludes that STUDENT is not appropriate for the program at CSDF because she has not made measurable progress on the goals and objective identified in the IEP, the parties will either set the matter for fair hearing or agree to a change in placement.

Petitioner's Exhibit QQ

The IEP team drafted the following goals and objectives to measure STUDENT's progress:

Receptive language: Given a sequence of pictures for a given task paired with directions in sign language, STUDENT will follow two consecutive steps of the sequence of directions 3 out of 5 times. Expressive language: Given a sequence of pictures paired with directions in sign language of a preferred activity, STUDENT will be able to use expressive communication (name the item, describe a characteristic of the item, etc.) In sign language in response to an adult or student in the classroom either prior to initiating the activity or while engaged in the activity 3 out of 5 times; Given the choice of two activities (preferred reinforcing choices, i.e., object, food, game), STUDENT will be able to indicate her choice by signing "want," "don't want" and then initiate that activity consistently 3 out of 5 times. Given the choice of two objects or activities (preferred reinforcing choices), STUDENT will be able to give a 2 word response, "want (name of object)," for 3 different objects. Transition: Given a picture schedule and a verbal or physical (pointing to the schedule) prompt to indicate time for a new activity, STUDENT will be able to transition into 2 consecutive activities independently within 2 minutes. When moving from one campus area to another throughout the school day, STUDENT will decrease her transition time of 3 identified transitions by 30% as determined by baseline data collected during the days of March 17, 18, and 19. Play: STUDENT will engage in purposeful autosymbolic play with a life like toy using 4 different interactions; STUDENT will remain on task for a minimum of 5 mins. With no more than 3 prompts.

Petitioner's Exhibit RR

Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz simultaneously observed STUDENT perform tasks with her one-to-one aide at the CSDF. As a result of the observation, Ms. Simmons concluded:

STUDENT appeared to have benefitted from the individualized specific instructional program implemented over the past 90 days. Her greatest gains appeared to be in the area of performing new sets of behaviors that had been modeled for her (play behaviors, two-step tasks). Less progress was observed in her sign language use. It was also unclear how much STUDENT benefitted from the use of photos to augment signed communication. STUDENT's task avoidance and oppositional behavior were not addressed in the goals and were therefore beyond the scope of this report. However, it is important to note that STUDENT exhibited resistant behavior consistent with the behavior she exhibited in February 1999, and that STUDENT's behavior and limited attention span did not appear to interfere with her performance of the tasks presented to her during the current observation. . . . .

Although sign language paired with picture communication continues to be the recommended mode of instruction for STUDENT, the extent to which she currently requires a deaf milieu to meet her educational needs is debatable. . .

Petitioner's Exhibit SS

As a result of the observation, Mr. Schmitz drew the following conclusions:

Although I couldn't formally measure STUDENT's progress on the objectives set for her in March, I did notice that STUDENT is doing a lot more signing than she did in March and she seems to understand more of what other people say. Although her sentences still consist of one or two words only, she seems to like signing for its own sake and has increased the number of signs she uses regularly. Based on my observations, I would say that STUDENT has benefitted from her program and the instruction provided to her over the last ninety days.

Petitioner's Exhibit UU

It can be surmised from the above that both assessors observed some progress by STUDENT during the 90-day period. Neither assessor made a specific finding as to whether STUDENT had made "measurable progress." Dr. Guthmann testified that the IEP team jointly concluded that STUDENT did not make "measurable progress" In support of her testimony, Dr. Guthmann pointed to the fact that the two assessors, Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz signed in agreement that STUDENT did not meet the terms of the Hearing Resolution. The evidence establishes that, after considering reports prepared by Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz, IEP team members from the District and the CSDF, and the two assessors rejected STUDENT's continued placement at the CSDF for the 1999-2000 school.(Footnote 8) With the exception of Ms. Pomery Sabin, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT return to her District and be placed in an SDC at Gard Street with the assistance of an LRM, and DHH services. Thus, it was the conclusion of the assessors and a majority of the IEP team, including Ms. Ustrud and Mr. Schmitz, who have supported STUDENT's placement at the CSDF, that STUDENT had not made progress on the goals and objectives that rose to the level of "measurable progress."(Footnote 9) At the hearing, Ms. Simmons confirmed that she concluded from the results of her assessment that STUDENT should not be placed at the CSDF. Mr. Schmitz did not testify at the hearing.

Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that by their signing the IEP, both assessors charged with determining whether STUDENT made sufficient progress to satisfy the terms of the Hearing Resolution affirmed their conclusion that STUDENT did not make measurable progress. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the conclusion of the expert assessors. Therefore, because STUDENT did not make sufficient progress to satisfy the terms of the agreement, STUDENT is not entitled to remain at the CSDF pursuant to the Hearing Resolution dated January 22, 1999.

Additionally, the Hearing Resolution did not indicate how long STUDENT would remain at the CSDF if she met the criteria set out in the Hearing Resolution. There is no persuasive evidence that the Hearing Resolution was a multi-year agreement that would extend beyond the 1998-1999 school year. Moreover; because IEPs are developed and placement decisions are made annually, a Hearing Resolution should not have the effect of overriding IEP team decisions and determining STUDENT's placement indefinitely. STUDENT did continue to attend the CSDF for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year and for the entire1999-2000 school year. Thus, even if STUDENT had satisfied the Hearing Resolution, there is no evidence that the agreement would extend her placement at the CSDF to the 2000-2001 school year.

ISSUE NO. 2: What constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

STUDENT's unique and individual needs:

In order to determine what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is necessary first to have an understanding of STUDENT's unique and individual needs. STUDENT has been described as having intricately interrelated disabilities. She is deaf and developmentally delayed or mentally retarded.(Footnote 10) She also has what numerous witnesses described as "behavioral challenges." The most contemporary assessment of STUDENT was completed in June 1999 by Ms. Simmons. Ms. Simmons concluded that, overall, STUDENT was then functioning between 18 and 24 months or at what Ms. Simmons described as the "developmental stage of emerging mental representations." STUDENT's teachers and other CSDF staff testified that STUDENT functions at a toddler level. Their estimates of STUDENT's functional levels are consistent with assessments by Ann Moxley, Ph.D., and Ms. Simmons. Dr. Moxley is an assessor for the Northern California Assessment Center for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing.

The witnesses agreed generally that, because of STUDENT's limited cognitive functioning, the following are essential elements of an appropriate educational placement for her: a teacher with a severely handicapped (SH) credential who signs using ASL and whose training includes the education of deaf children; a functional curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level; a structured class; a low student-to-teacher ratio; one-to-one instruction with some opportunities to participate in group activities; and community-based instruction.

As to specific skills, it is undisputed that STUDENT's language skills are significantly depressed. There are reports of STUDENT's "finger babbling," which, according to Nichola (Nikki) Schmitz is a precursor to language; however, Ms. Simmons' assessment found STUDENT's language skills significantly delayed.(Footnote 11) She estimated that STUDENT's language skills fell between 13 and 17 months. Estimates of STUDENT's signing vocabulary ranged from five words (Ms. Muscadine) to 200 words (MOTHER). Both Mr. Castillo and Ms. Schmitz, who work with STUDENT in Kelseyville, estimated that STUDENT's signing vocabulary is 100 words. The testimony establishes that STUDENT's meaningful use of signs is significantly less than her vocabulary. For example, Ms. Pedersen testified that STUDENT uses only 15 to 20 signs appropriately in the cottage and Ms. Muscadine testified that STUDENT uses three to five signs appropriately in the classroom. At other times, STUDENT randomly signs. Regardless of which estimate of STUDENT's signing vocabulary is accurate, the witnesses concurred that the acquisition of language is a primary goal for STUDENT.

The parties disagree as to how to improve STUDENT's expressive and receptive language. MOTHER and Dr. Winslow expressed the opinion that STUDENT will develop appropriate language skills only by placement with signing peers. Witnesses testifying on behalf of the CSDF, Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons in particular, testified that STUDENT does not pick up language incidentally. Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons testified that in the three years that STUDENT has attend school and lived in a deaf and signing mileau, she has shown little, if any increase in attaining language. They attributed STUDENT's inability to pick up language incidentally to her limited cognitive skills. For these reasons, Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons testified that to develop language, STUDENT requires specific instruction in language from a qualified person. The testimony of Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons, who have assessed STUDENT, was supported by STUDENT's teachers for the past three years. Moreover, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's sign language vocabulary has increased when she has received direct instruction. For example, working individually with Mr. Castillo, STUDENT has learned to identify 100 pictures he presents to her, thereby demonstrating her ability to learn language by direct instruction. For these reasons, it is concluded that STUDENT requires specific instruction in language.(Footnote 12)

Ms. Simmons, as well as other witnesses, recommended that STUDENT's sign language instruction be paired with a picture communication system. The evidence also suggests that STUDENT benefits from a picture communication system. In fact, Mr. Castillo has created a picture schedule that he successfully uses with STUDENT.

Despite MOTHER's testimony that STUDENT demonstrates appropriate self-care skills at home (showers, brushes her teeth, dresses herself, gets milk from the refrigerator, eats, and cleans up after herself), the evidence establishes that she continues to require a great deal of monitoring at the CSDF to do self-care tasks. Amy Pederson testified regarding STUDENT's self-help skills in the cottage environment. Ms. Pederson has been a cottage counselor since 1997. She testified that STUDENT requires one-to-one supervision to turn on the shower water, to show her where to wash herself, to help her get dressed, to clean her up after wetting incidents, and to wipe herself. Bobbie Alexander testified that, when no one else is available, she has served as STUDENT's aide in the cottage. She also sees STUDENT weekly in the cottage as part of her responsibilities as an assistant to the dean of CSDF. In addition to overseeing the cottages, she directly supervises transportation for the CSDF students. On those occasions when Ms. Alexander served as STUDENT's aide, STUDENT required prompting to get up in the morning and to wash herself in the shower. She was only able to partially dress herself, and her attempt at making the bed was limited to her pulling the bedspread over the lumpy sheets, blanket, and pillow. Ms. Alexander testified that STUDENT refused to leave the cottage and screamed all the way to the cafeteria. For the most part, STUDENT was able to get her food and signed "milk" in response to Ms. Alexander's inquiry about what drink she wanted. When STUDENT went to the restroom, she inadequately wiped herself and washed her hands over and over. Moreover, STUDENT continues to be incontinent in class, in the cottage, and on the bus, even when she is on a rigidly enforced toileting schedule. The Hearing Officer concludes that, as a part of her educational program, STUDENT requires a component that addresses self-care skills and, in particular, toileting. Because STUDENT's incontinence may have a medical or psychological basis according to the testimony of MOTHER, a plan to address incontinence must be developed in consultation with qualified medical persons. If a physician is needed to assess STUDENT's incontinence and to develop an appropriate plan, federal law makes it clear that school districts must use physicians when necessary for diagnostic and evaluation purposes. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).

Witnesses from the CSDF testified that STUDENT has poor play and socialization skills. Ms. Simmons found STUDENT's play and social skills fell generally below 17 months. As discussed above, interactions with peers at the CSDF cottage and class have been minimal. Ms. Muscadine went as far as testifying that STUDENT's only contact with her classmates is hitting them. STUDENT's teachers and cottage counselor testified that STUDENT's play rarely, if at all, involves anything other than her doll. For the above reasons, Ms. Simmons and Ms. Muscadine concluded that an appropriate education program for STUDENT includes structured play. Ms. Ustrud, whose background includes educating developmentally disabled students, concurred and testified that because of STUDENT's cognitive level, STUDENT requires direct instruction in play and social skills. The Hearing Officer finds this testimony persuasive and concludes that an appropriate program for STUDENT includes direct instruction in play and social skills, with opportunities for structured play with peers. A majority of the witnesses testified that STUDENT requires at least some opportunity to socialize and interact with signing peers to enhance both her social skills and language development.

Another area of concern centers on STUDENT's behavior. While STUDENT's behavior at home, in the Kelseyville community, and with Mr. Castillo is generally compliant and nonthreatening to others, the testimony of STUDENT's teachers and staff working with her at the CSDF establishes that STUDENT continues to exhibit behavioral problems in the educational environment. STUDENT's current teacher, Ms. Muscadine, and her teacher for the prior two school years, Ms. Sakamoto, the cottage counselor, Ms. Pedersen, and the transportation supervisor described multiple incidents of STUDENT's inappropriately engaging other students by hitting, biting, or grabbing them. STUDENT also engages in self-stimulating and self-injurious behavior. She bites her hand, picks at sores, hits herself in the head, and bangs her head on walls and elsewhere. At the CSDF, STUDENT also is described as "obstinate" and "oppositional." These behaviors are consistent with Dr. Winslow's diagnosis of ODD.

The evidence establishes that while there have been several BIPs drafted, none has been successful, and all were criticized in some manner by witnesses. For example, Dr. Winslow's plan was drafted in Kelseyville and implemented at the CSDF. According to Dr. Winslow, the plan was a preliminary plan and was not drafted with any data collection or input from the CSDF. The plan developed by Mr. McGough and the User Guide developed in consultation with the CSDF and Spectrum were described as "unwieldy" or calling for interventions above STUDENT's present abilities. Mr. McGough expressed concern regarding the ability of the CSDF to vigorously implement the BIP. Mr. McGough's concerns were well-founded given that, at the hearing, the persons working with STUDENT at the CSDF were unable to identify antecedents to STUDENT's behavior. Moreover, from the multiple recitations by the CSDF witnesses of STUDENT's behavioral difficulties, it is concluded that none of the BIPs has been successful.

Nevertheless, Dr. Winslow, who has expertise in developing behavioral intervention programs, testified that STUDENT's maladaptive behavior can be eliminated or replaced with positive behavior that is reinforcing to STUDENT. To address STUDENT's behaviors, Dr. Winslow testified that a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) needs to be developed following a comprehensive functional analysis assessment (FAA) that determines antecedents to the behavior, the purpose of the behavior, and appropriate replacement behaviors. The FAA must be completed in the environments in which the BIP will be implemented. Dr. Winslow additionally testified that for a BIP to be successful, it must be implemented consistently across all environments.

Because of Dr. Winslow's expertise in behavior management, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Winslow's testimony persuasive. Additionally, the evidence establishes that a BIP is necessary because of the persistence of STUDENT's maladaptive behavior. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that a BIP is an essential element of an appropriate education for STUDENT. Because of the deficiencies in any current behavioral plans for STUDENT, it is concluded that a comprehensive FAA must be undertaken and a BIP developed according to the requirements set forth in 5 Cal. Code. Regs. § 3052.

In summary, an appropriate education program for STUDENT must include a structured class with a low student-to-teacher ratio that is taught by an SH teacher who signs ASL and who has training related to educating deaf children; a functional curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level; community-based instruction; one-to-one instruction with opportunities for group activities; specific language instruction in ASL paired with a picture communication system; opportunities to participate in social and language experiences with deaf peers; a behavioral intervention program; direct instruction in play and social skills with opportunities for structured play; and a program to develop self-help skills that particularly addresses incontinence.

The California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSDF):

STUDENT has attended the CSDF for the past three school years and her parents seek to have her continue attending the CSDF. Pursuant to § 59020, "every deaf person between the ages of three and 21 years" and who meets certain criteria is entitled to an education at the California School for the Deaf.(Footnote 13) Thus, in determining the appropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer first addresses whether STUDENT meets certain eligibility criteria to attend the CSDF.

Section 5210 of the California Department of Education's Specialized Programs Branch Administrative Manual (hereafter CSD Manual) describes the admissions policy to State special schools, including the CSD. The following persons can be served by the CSD:

1. Deaf individuals with or without additional handicapping conditions. 2. Deaf individuals with moderate behavioral problems who are not considered a danger to self or others. . . . 3. Deaf individuals who are educationally deprived or from culturally different backgrounds, including recent immigrants. . . . 6. Hard of hearing individuals with an educationally significant hearing loss who live in rural or other areas without an appropriate educational program.

The Manual also states that the Schools for the Deaf cannot serve students with the following characteristics:

1. Those in need of a 24-hour psychiatric treatment program. . . . 2. Those developmentally delayed individuals who require a custodial program. Characteristics include: severe retardation, lack of self-help skills, or in need of one-to-one supervision. (Self-help skills include: ability to learn simple mobility patterns around campus, communicate basic needs to staff members, respond appropriately to life threatening situations, and function in a group setting; and demonstration of the potential to eat and dress without assistance and otherwise tend to personal care needs.) 3. Those with severe acting out/aggressive behaviors. Characteristics include: danger to self or others, assaultive, repeated contacts with law enforcement agencies, or in need of one-to-one supervision. . . .(Footnote 14)

(CSDF's Exhibit 1)

All of the CSDF witnesses concluded that STUDENT does not meet the criteria for admittance to the CSDF, including STUDENT's teacher during the 1999-2000 school year, Diane Muscadine, and STUDENT's teacher for the prior two school years, Susie Sakamoto. Both of these teachers have spent a great deal of time with STUDENT in the educational environment. Both teachers have multiple years of teaching experience and, therefore, are well qualified to comment on STUDENT's abilities.

CSDF personnel who work with STUDENT in the residential component also testified that STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria for the CSDF. Ms. Pederson, STUDENT's cottage counselor for the past two years, testified that STUDENT requires one-to-one supervision to get around the campus. She described STUDENT's running away from staff and hiding behind the building. Ms. Pederson and Ms. Alexander, assistant to the dean, testified that STUDENT also requires one-to-one supervision in the cottage. Their testimony establishes that STUDENT must be supervised while engaging in self-care tasks, including showering and dressing, and that STUDENT is unable to respond to fire and earthquake drills. According to Ms. Pederson, an aide has to take STUDENT by her hand to lead her to safety. STUDENT does not know the names of other students or staff in the cottage and does not function in group activities. Ms. Pederson testified that STUDENT strikes out at the other students.(Footnote 15)

Based on the reports of the CSDF staff and his observations, Ronald Stern, CSDF's director of instruction, testified that STUDENT requires custodial care. Mr. Stern testified that STUDENT does not, after three years at the CSDF, label objects, tell what is same or different, express her basic needs, identify colors and forms, sign classmates' names, or answer basic questions. For these reasons, he concluded that "it would be doing STUDENT a disservice" to maintain her at the CSDF. Mr. Stern has observed STUDENT on campus and recently spent one hour with her in her classroom.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the consistent testimony of STUDENT's teachers, cottage counselor, and transportation supervisor--who have observed and interacted with STUDENT over the past three years--that STUDENT does not meet the criteria for admittance to the CSDF.(Footnote 16)

Moreover, the CSDF does not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT, even if the CSDF were compelled by the Hearing Officer to provide STUDENT with a program that includes all of the components identified above that are necessary to address her needs.

First, despite evidence of STUDENT's improving behavior and language acquisition during the first semester at the CSDF, the evidence establishes that after attending the CSDF for three years, STUDENT does not know the names of her classmates or cottage mates, has not learned simple mobility patterns, lacks self-help skills, and continues to engage in inappropriate behavior. Ms. Muscadine and Ms. Pederson also testified that STUDENT does not functionally use sign language and does not socialize with the other students. Ms. Sakamoto observed no significant improvement during the two years STUDENT was in her class. Ms. Alexander testified that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior on the bus, which includes screaming, kicking, and grabbing other students and staff, persists to the extent that a restraining device is used on the bus.

Second, even if an appropriate educational program were implemented for STUDENT, other components of the CSDF placement remain very problematic for STUDENT. First, because STUDENT lives at least three hours from the CSDF, she is required to live at the CSDF in one of their cottages. As Ms. Simmons and others testified, STUDENT functions as a toddler, which results in her having multiple difficulties in the cottage environment. As a toddler, STUDENT does not understand what is expected of her. The CSDF witnesses testified that it is very difficult for a toddler to live in a group environment and to independently care for herself. In fact, the testimony of Ms. Alexander and Ms. Pederson establishes that STUDENT continues to require direct one-on-one supervision in all activities to get ready for school in the morning and to go to bed in the evening. STUDENT's difficulties are amplified by her maladaptive behavior and ODD. Moreover, because of STUDENT's functional level and behavioral problems, STUDENT also does not participate successfully in the afterschool activities with her cottage peers. Ms. Pederson's testimony on this point was persuasive. Ms. Pederson described the ways in which over the past several years she has attempted to integrate STUDENT into activities in the cottage and in the community. Ms. Pederson testified that throughout STUDENT's stay in the cottage, she and other cottage staff have consulted with Ms. Kordus at least weekly regarding STUDENT's behavior and implementation of the behavior plan to address STUDENT's maladaptive behavior. Ms. Kordus is a psychologist at the CSDF and previously served as a behavioral intervention specialist.

STUDENT continues to have behavioral problems on those days when she rides the bus from Fremont. Because STUDENT grabs, hits, kicks, bites other children on the long bus ride, STUDENT is physically isolated from the other students on the bus and has been required to wear a restraining device even when she is accompanied by an aide. A bus ride of three hours or more simply is not appropriate for a child of STUDENT's functional level.

Mr. McGough, who has developed a BIP for STUDENT at the CSDF, also testified that the tasks required of STUDENT at the CSDF are above her functioning level. He expressed particular concern about the number of transitions and people involved in STUDENT's program. Mr. McGough testified that multiple changes are too difficult for STUDENT to adapt to. Even Mr. Castillo and Ms. Schmitz, who have worked with STUDENT for several years and have supported her request for placement at the CSDF, conceded that the CSDF does not presently have a class or residential component that meets STUDENT's needs.

A third reason the CSDF does not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT is related to her learning style as a child with limited cognitive functioning. Dr. Moxley initially assessed STUDENT in 1994 and concluded at that time that STUDENT was moderately mentally retarded. (CSDF Exhibit 12) Dr. Moxley presently believes that STUDENT is severely mentally retarded based on the lack of progress STUDENT has demonstrated since Dr. Moxley's prior assessment. Dr. Moxley, who has conducted many assessments as part of the California diagnostic system, persuasively testified regarding some of STUDENT's specific educational needs because of her low cognitive skills. Dr. Moxley testified that persons with mental retardation have difficulty generalizing and, for this reason, need to be taught in the environment where they will use the skills. Ms. Simmons, another experienced assessor, testified similarly. Because of STUDENT's difficulty generalizing, both Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons recommended that STUDENT be educated in her home community. As an example, it was agreed that STUDENT requires community-based instruction. Getting from one location to another and shopping are examples of activities that are taught in the community. If STUDENT were to be taught these skills in Fremont, she would have difficultly generalizing the skills in a different environment. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Moxley and Ms. Simmons persuasive on this issue because of their expertise and experience related to assessment of students with disabilities. Their testimony establishes that STUDENT, as a student with limited cognitive functioning, would benefit from being educated in her home community of Kelseyville. The successes that STUDENT has experienced over the past three years have been in the community in which she lives. STUDENT has shown progress with compliance, language acquisition, behavior, and attention while working with Mr. Castillo in Kelseyville. Mr. Castillo reports that STUDENT is able to go the restroom independently. Other witnesses observed STUDENT participating successfully in community outings. STUDENT's parents report that STUDENT participates as a family member in community outings. STUDENT is loved and cared for by her family and functions with much greater independence at home than she does in the CSDF cottage. STUDENT's successes in her home and community are not unexpected given that she is with a family who loves her and treats her with respect at her developmental level.

The District's placement:

As stated above, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. It was concluded above that an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT must include a structured class with a low student-to-teacher ratio that is taught by an SH teacher who signs ASL and who has training related to educating deaf children; a functional curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level; community-based instruction; one-to-one instruction with opportunities for group activities; specific language instruction in ASL paired with a picture communication system; opportunities to participate in social and language experiences with deaf peers; a behavioral intervention program; direct instruction in play and social skills with opportunities for structured play; and a program to develop self-help skills that particularly addresses incontinence.

The placement offered by the District includes the following:

(1) an SH class five days per week;

(2) a language role model five days per week for five hours daily; (3) deaf and hard-of-hearing services two times per week at two hours; (4) one hour daily in regular education; and (5) transportation.

Ms. Ustrud provided the bulk of the testimony regarding the District's offer of placement. Her testimony establishes that the District's SDC-SH at Gard School has a total of seven students ranging in age from 9 to 16 years. All of the students in the class are developmentally disabled or mentally regarded. Some students have medical needs. There are three assistants in the class. The teacher uses a picture schedule and assisted communication systems for the students. She has some signing skills. The class offers a functional living skills curriculum and includes community-based instruction. Regular education students spend time in the SDC (reverse mainstreaming). Ms. Schmitz testified regarding the deaf and hard-of-hearing services she would provide to STUDENT. Ms. Schmitz's testimony establishes that she meets twice weekly for approximately two hours with deaf students gathered from Kelseyville and surrounding school districts in Lake County. Ms. Schmitz provides the students with opportunities to socialize and to practice language skills with deaf peers. Mr. Castillo testified regarding his position as an LRM. Mr. Castillo is deaf and provides STUDENT with one-to-one instruction in ASL and also introduces her to deaf culture. He also teaches her specific skills. Mr. Castillo's role as an LRM would continue with STUDENT in Kelseyville.

Turning to whether the placement offered by the District is designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, the testimony of Ms. Ustrud establishes that the SDC would meet STUDENT's need for a low student-to-teacher ratio. The SDC has only seven students. There is one teacher and three aides. STUDENT's LRM would further reduce the student-to-teacher ratio. The evidence also establishes that the small number of students in the class would allow the teacher, as well as the aides and the LRM, to provide STUDENT with individual instruction. There also would be opportunities to group STUDENT with some of the other students because they have similar developmental levels in some areas. According to Ms. Ustrud, the SDC teacher holds an SH credential and possesses sign language skills. The testimony of Mr. Castillo, Ms. Ustrud, and Ms. Schmitz establishes that direct language instruction would be provided by the LRM in consultation with Ms. Schmitz. To further meet STUDENT's language needs, the SDC already has in place both picture schedules and communication systems. The picture communication system could be individualized for STUDENT by the LRM. STUDENT presently has a picture schedule that Mr. Castillo uses with her. The present schedule can be modified to reflect the activities in the SDC. Ms. Schmitz's testimony establishes that she would continue to provide support to the LRM. Ms. Schmitz is deaf and holds a credential authorizing her to teach deaf students. Ms. Schmitz also would lend her expertise in educating deaf children, and STUDENT in particular, to the teacher of the SDC. Finally, Ms. Ustrud's testimony establishes that the curriculum offered in the SDC is individually designed, is functional in nature, and includes community-based instruction in STUDENT's home community. There was no evidence to suggest that the individually-designed instruction in play, social skills, and self-help, as well as a BIP could not also be provided in the SDC.

STUDENT's participation in Ms. Schmitz's group would afford STUDENT opportunities to socialize and to increase ASL skills with deaf peers on a regular basis. However, the parents and others expressed concern that STUDENT would be placed in a group that includes her deaf sibling. MOTHER and witnesses associated with the foster care agency testified that it would be detrimental for STUDENT to have contact with her deaf sibling. MOTHER described the behavior that the siblings engage in when they are together as a "frenzy of inappropriate hitting and grabbing of a sexual nature." The Hearing Officer concludes that it would not be appropriate for STUDENT and her deaf sibling to be in the same group with Ms. Schmitz (or in the SDC).

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposal to place STUDENT in the SDC and Ms. Schmitz's weekly group with deaf peers, and to provide her with support from the LRM and the DHH specialist, is designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs.

The placement and services described above also are designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The primary goal of improving STUDENT's language skills will be addressed in the SDC, by direct instruction from the LRM, and through the group experiences with deaf peers offered by Ms. Schmitz. An appropriate curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level will allow STUDENT to develop self-help and other functional-living skills. With an appropriate curriculum in place, it is anticipated that STUDENT's frustration level, attention, and behavior will improve. Community-based instruction will allow STUDENT to learn skills in the community in which she lives, which will increase STUDENT's independence. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's program is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

There is no dispute that the placement offered by the District conforms with the IEP. Because all three requirements set forth in the IDEA and Rowley have been met, it is concluded that the District has offered STUDENT an appropriate placement.

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting that includes the required participants, including the parents, representatives from the District and the Lake County SELPA, and additionally, at a minimum, the classroom teacher and the residential supervisor who have been responsible for STUDENT at the CSDF.

(2) The IEP team shall conform STUDENT's IEP to the findings in this decision and shall place STUDENT in a structured SDC-SH class with a low student-to-teacher ratio that is taught by an SH teacher who signs ASL and who has training related to educating deaf children.

(3) By the first day of school for the 2000-2001 school year, the District and Lake County SELPA must provide STUDENT with the following:

a functional curriculum at her developmental level;

community-based instruction;

one-to-one instruction with opportunities for group activities; specific language instruction in ASL paired with a picture communication system; opportunities to participate in group social and language experiences with deaf peers; direct instruction in play and social skills with opportunities for structured play; and a program to develop self-help skills.

(4) The District shall not place STUDENT with her deaf sibling.

(5) The IEP team must develop a program to address STUDENT's incontinence in consultation with appropriate medical personnel.

(6) The District must undertake a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT's maladaptive behaviors that conforms with the requirements set forth in 5 Cal. Code. Regs. § 3052. The FAA must be completed 20 days after STUDENT's placement in the SDC. The functional analysis assessment must take into consideration STUDENT's behavior in the classroom, DHH group, home, and any other relevant environments. (7) Within 15 days of completion of the functional analysis assessment, the District must develop a behavioral intervention program that conforms with the requirements set forth in 5 Cal. Code. Regs. § 3052.

(8) Within five days of completion of the behavioral intervention program, the program must be implemented.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the CSDF prevailed on issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: August 4, 2000 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: Mr. Castillo (formerly Barlow) has been STUDENT's LRM for three years. He works individually with STUDENT under the direction of Ms. Schmitz.

Footnote 2: A number of sign language interpreters were used throughout the hearing to interpret for witnesses.

Footnote 3: By agreement of the parties, the submission of closing briefs and reply briefs was delayed for three weeks because of an injury sustained by one of the attorneys.

Footnote 4: The parties dispute the extent of STUDENT's developmental disabilities. Assessors have described STUDENT as "moderately" to "severely" delayed. In February 1999, when STUDENT was nine years old, Jennifer Simmons, psychologist formerly employed by the CSDF, concluded that STUDENT was functioning between the 18- to 24-month level at the developmental stage of emerging mental representations, with language and play skills falling in the 13- to 17-month level and fine-motor skills at the 36-month level.

Footnote 5: A language role model or LRM teaches language and the cultural aspects of language to a deaf child.

Footnote 6: STUDENT's current placement is pursuant to an agreement reached in a prior due process hearing, SN 1294-98, on January 22, 1999.

Footnote 7: Mr. Castillo (formerly Barlow) has been STUDENT's LRM for three years. He works individually with STUDENT under the direction of Ms. Schmitz.

Footnote 8: Ms. Simmons and Mr. Schmitz attended the IEP meeting on June 8, 1999. Other persons in attendance from the District were Ms. Ustrud and Mr. McGough. Ms. Sakamoto and Dr. Guthmann were present from the CSDF and Ms. Pomery Sabin was present on behalf of the PARENTS.

Footnote 9: Ms. Ustrud explained at the hearing that she continues to support STUDENT's placement at the CSDF and also is ready to make an appropriate placement available to STUDENT at the District.

Footnote 10: The terms "mentally retarded" and "developmentally delayed" are sometimes used interchangeably to generally denote that a child is functioning below expected levels for his/her age. Federal special education law uses the term "developmentally delayed" for children aged three through nine years "experiencing developmental delays...in one or more of the following areas: physical development, cognitive development, communication development, social or emotional development, or adaptive development." 34 CFR § 300.7(b). "Mental retardation" means "subaverage general intellectual functioning, existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, that adversely affects a child"s educational performance." 34 CFR § 300.7 (c)(6).

Footnote 11: Ms. Schmitz is a deaf/hard-of-hearing specialist for the Lake County Office of Education. She has known STUDENT since the fall of 1996. Ms. Schmitz is deaf. Joe Schmitz is her father.

Footnote 12: The Hearing Officer notes that the conclusion that STUDENT requires direct instruction in language coupled with a picture communication system is not meant to exclude STUDENT's participation with deaf peers in both educational and social environments. Petitioner's and CSDF's witnesses, alike, testified that STUDENT needs opportunities to socialize and communicate with signing peers to enhance her acquisition of language, as well as social skills.

Footnote 13: Priority for admission to the CSDF is given to elementary age deaf minors residing in sparsely populated regions for "whom appropriate comprehensive educational facilities and services are not available or cannot be reasonably provided by their local school districts or county educational agencies." Cal. Educ. Code § 59020.

Footnote 14: The Superintendent of Public Instruction determines admission criteria to the CSDF. The Hearing Officer makes no finding as to whether the CSDF's admissions criteria were properly developed. The Hearing Officer notes that the posture of the California Department of Education through the Schools for the Deaf that it has no obligation to serve deaf children with disabilities unless mild, appears discriminatory. Both State and federal law preclude exclusion of individuals with disabilities who, with reasonable modifications, including provision of auxiliary aides and services, meet essential eligibility requirements for participation in programs funded by the State. Cal. Gov.Code § 11135; 42 U.S.C.

Footnote 15: Ms. Alexander recently worked directly with STUDENT in the cottage because no one else was available.

Footnote 16: It was concluded in another special education due process hearing that the failure to meet eligibility criteria did not relieve the CSDF from being compelled to accept a deaf and developmentally disabled student for whom the student's district did not offer an appropriate placement. However, as discussed in the second issue, this case differs because Kelseyville can offer a placement that meets STUDENT's needs.