California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 13, 2000

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1300-00 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

San Diego Unified must return a student with Down syndrome to full inclusion at his school of choice; SDC offer rejected.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A family filed for due process after San Diego Unified proposed moving their eight-year-old son, who has Down syndrome, out of full inclusion. The District offered an independent life skills special day class (SDC) at Kate Sessions Elementary, with mainstreaming as tolerated. In first grade, the student was placed in an English-learner combination class taught by Daniel Hayes, who had no special education training. His permanent inclusion specialist did not start until late October. He spent most of each day working alone with his one-on-one aide. The District argued that he could not access the curriculum even with modifications and that his behaviors disrupted the class. Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara applied the four Holland factors and found that the District had never given inclusion a real chance. It never modified the curriculum so he could take part alongside his peers. It also refused the parents' repeated requests for a functional behavioral assessment while calling his behavior disruptive. The evidence showed clear social benefit from his classmates, so removing him was premature. The Hearing Officer also held that his acceptance through the District's Choice Program entitled him to attend his chosen school, and that he could repeat first grade in an English-language class. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 10 days and place him in a general education first grade class at that school. His supports had to include an inclusion specialist, an aide, a modified curriculum, assistive technology, a social skills program, and his existing related services. The District also had to complete a functional analysis assessment and behavior plan within 50 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Holland factors when a district sought to end full inclusion. It treated removal as premature where the district had not modified the curriculum, provided consistent inclusion support, or assessed behavior. It also held that a special education student accepted through an intra-district choice program could attend that school when it could implement the IEP.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Does the District's offer to place STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) with mainstreaming constitute an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year?

    Applying the Holland factors, the Hearing Officer held that removing the student to an ILS SDC was premature. The District had never provided a properly modified curriculum, adequate inclusion support, or a behavioral assessment and BIP, and the student received academic and social benefit from inclusion.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to enroll in a general education class and repeat first grade at an elementary school that is not his home school following his acceptance through the District's "Choice Program"?

    Because general education was the LRE and no evidence showed the school of choice could not implement his IEP, the student could attend the school of choice like any other accepted student. He could also repeat first grade in an English-language classroom.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within ten calendar days of the decision, the District must hold an IEP meeting.
  • Placement ordered. Place the student in a regular education first grade class at his school of choice.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must implement these supports: (1) a consulting inclusion specialist; (2) an individual aide to assist the student and his classroom, supervised by the classroom teacher; (3) a modified first grade curriculum designed and supervised by the inclusion specialist; (4) assistive technology; (5) a social skills program; and (6) all DIS services identified in his current IEP.
  • Order to assess. Within fifty days of the decision, the District must conduct a functional analysis assessment that results in a behavioral intervention plan. It must then convene an IEP meeting to address behaviors that interfere with full inclusion or disrupt the class, including behaviors interpreted as fatigue or unwillingness to continue tasks.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel Holland; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Roland v. Concord School Comm.; Poolaw v. Bishop; Barnett v. Fairfax County School Board; Fisher v. Rochester Community Schools; Murray v. Montrose County School Dist.; Schuldt v. Mankato School Dist.; Murphy v. Timberlane Regional School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Bernice Stanley, due process and compliance program manager, San Diego Unified School District
  • Bob Morris, independent living skills program manager, San Diego Unified School District
  • Kristen Green, itinerant inclusion specialist / independent life skills specialist (District witness), San Diego Unified School District
  • Shelly Plumb, 1:1 instructional aide (District witness; also spelled Shelley), San Diego Unified School District
  • Patricia Laurick, diagnostic resource specialist teacher (District witness), San Diego Unified School District
  • Daniel Hayes, general education first/second grade teacher (District witness), San Diego Unified School District
  • Dr. Mary Falvey, inclusion expert witness for Student, California State University, Los Angeles

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on August 10 and 11, and September 26, 27, 28, 29, 2000.

Petitioner STUDENT(hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Michael S. Cochrane. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS.

Respondent San Diego Unified School District (hereinafter District or Respondent) was represented by attorney Ricardo J. Soto. Also present on the Respondent’s behalf was Bernice Stanley, due process and compliance program manager, and Bob Morris, independent living skills program manager.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: FATHER, Petitioner’s father; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; and Dr. Mary Falvey, professor, special education, California State University of Los Angeles.

The Respondent called the following witness to testify: Kristen Green, independent life skills specialist; Shelly Plumb, instructional aide; Patricia Laurick, diagnostic resource specialist teacher; and Daniel Hayes, elementary school teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Officer received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the commencement of the hearing, the Petitioner asked that the burden of going forward shift to the District as it was proposing the change in placement for the Petitioner. The District did not contest this motion and agreed that it would present its evidence first. The Petitioner also objected to the admission of all of the Respondent’s evidence. The Petitioner correctly maintained that it had not been submitted in a timely manner pursuant to the statutory provision requiring the exchange of evidence five business days before the hearing. The District acknowledged that it erroneously submitted its evidence and list of witnesses five calendar rather than five business days before the hearing. It claimed that the Petitioner would not be prejudiced by its late submission as it was introducing limited evidence that the Petitioner had received before filing his request for a due process hearing. Following discussion, the Petitioner acknowledged that granting his motion would merely result in a postponement of the hearing until a future date that complied with the five-business-day rule. He therefore withdrew his objection to the admission of the Respondent’s evidence and, instead, asked that the late submission of evidence be noted on the record. The Hearing Officer granted this request.

ISSUES

l. Does the District’s offer to place STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) with mainstreaming constitute an offer of a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2000-2001 school year?

2. Is STUDENT entitled to enroll in a general education class and repeat first grade at an elementary school that is not his home school following his acceptance through the District’s “Choice Program?”

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner filed for this due process hearing contending that he was entitled to remain fully included in a general education elementary school program. He maintains that the District’s offer to place him in an independent life skills (ILS) special day class (SDC), with a portion of his day in a mainstreamed environment, violated his right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). The Petitioner further states that he was accepted through the District’s “Choice Program” to attend an elementary school other than his home school. The SDC offered by the District is not on his chosen campus. STUDENT therefore seeks a determination that he should be fully included in a general education class at his chosen school.

The District claims that STUDENT’s needs can no longer be met through the full inclusion educational program he was previously provided. It argues that his behaviors unduly burden the teacher and interfere with the education of the other students. He also requires greater special education support to meet his Individualized Educational Program (IEP) goals than can be provided in general education classes with supplemental aids and services. The District has therefore determined that STUDENT must be placed in a SDC to receive an appropriate education.

The District is offering to place STUDENT in an independent life skills (ILS) SDC for a total of seventeen hours per week to receive direct instruction on his IEP goals and his core curriculum. The remaining time STUDENT would be mainstreamed with his general education peers. His mainstreaming time would be increased as tolerated. The District also offers to provide the following services: speech and language, two times per week for thirty minutes per session; OT, one time per week for thirty minutes; APE, one time per week for thirty minutes; music therapy, forty-five minutes per week; and consultation with an assistive technology specialist three times per year. It is the District’s position that this program constitutes a free and appropriate education for STUDENT.

BACKGROUND FACTS

The Petitioner is an eight-year-old boy with a diagnosis of Down syndrome. STUDENT should have entered the second grade when the 2000-2001 school year began. However, he currently remains in his 1999-2000 school year placement while this hearing is pending to determine his appropriate program.

STUDENT attended a Head Start preschool program between the ages of two-and-a-half and three through the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). Approximately half of the preschool children were disabled and the other half were typically developing peers. At the age of three, STUDENT transferred to a regular preschool. He remained for two years and did well with no accommodations for his disability. When he was five years old, the Petitioner and his family moved to San Diego and he enrolled in a preschool class at his parents’s church. STUDENT entered kindergarten within the San Diego Unified School District when he was six years old. He was fully included in a general education class at Whitman Elementary School. STUDENT received the support of an inclusion specialist and a full-time one-on-one aide. The District also provided him with adaptive physical education (APE), occupational therapy (OT), and speech services.

During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s first grade placement was in a general education first/second grade “sheltered class” for students learning English as a second language (ESL). He remained assisted by the same individual aide who had worked with him in kindergarten. His speech, OT, and APE services continued. STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Daniel Hayes, is an experienced bilingual instructor. However, he does not have a special education background, he did not receive training to work with a disabled student before STUDENT entered his class, and he was initially without assistance from an inclusion expert. Although an inclusion specialist was designated for STUDENT, she was reassigned the second week of the school year after only one short visit to his classroom. A few weeks later, a temporary inclusion specialist was briefly assigned to work with the STUDENT. STUDENT’s permanent itinerant inclusion specialist, Kristen Green, began the last week of October 1999.

Mr. Hayes attempted to modify the curriculum to include STUDENT in the entire class schedule. However, he found it difficult to incorporate STUDENT into the regular classroom activities. Even when Mr. Hayes significantly lowered the academic level of the entire class, STUDENT could not participate. Additionally, STUDENT engaged in behaviors that interfered with the remainder of the class. He would lie on the floor, chew his tongue, make noises, grab things, and refuse to remain seated. Soon after the school year began, the teacher and aide determined that STUDENT needed the constant, direct supervision of his aide to provide his instruction and control his behaviors. Thereafter, STUDENT received all of his instruction from his aide, away from the rest of the class. His activities were not coordinated with those of the other students, so he would not be working in the same subject area at the same time as his peers.

When Ms. Green began providing inclusion services, she agreed that the normal class activities exceeded STUDENT’s abilities and that the curriculum could not be modified to accommodate him. She further concurred that his behaviors interfered with his own education as well as that of the other students unless he was constantly monitored by his aide. Ms. Green found that STUDENT’s needs required a disproportionate amount of the teacher’s time. Consequently, she developed a program for STUDENT that addressed his IEP goals but continued to be delivered by his one-on-one aide in isolation within the classroom. With the exception of morning circle, snack time and a reading group, STUDENT was excluded from his peers throughout his educational day. The District staff concluded that STUDENT’s behaviors had an adverse impact on the teacher and other students, and that his needs could not be met in an inclusion program.

Contrary to the opinion of his inclusion specialist, teacher and aide, PARENTS believe that STUDENT benefitted from his first grade year. They noticed that his social skills increased and reported that he learned to do such things in Mr. Hayes’s class as: greet his peers, assign classmates’s names to their photographs, play games on the playground, share lunch and snack, model his peers during circle time, interact during group and independent reading, and perform assigned classroom jobs such as ball monitor. STUDENT’s parents also believe that their son made academic progress while included in Mr. Hayes’s class. They state that STUDENT met many of his IEP goals, increased his ability to read sight words, began a spelling program, and progressed with phonics and decoding words. PARENTS acknowledge that STUDENT had some disruptive behaviors, and they requested a behavioral assessment to address them.

At the June 2000 IEP meeting to determine STUDENT’s placement for the 2000-2001 school year, the District maintained that STUDENT was not receiving educational benefit from an inclusion program. The District’s IEP team members agreed that he required the more intensive services of a life skills/special day class to meet his needs. The District describes this program as one that provides a functional/outcome-based curriculum that focuses on the skills a student needs to be independent in home, school community, and recreational environments. The independent life skills (ILS) program is a highly structured class with increased staff support. There is greater control of the schedule, environment, and curriculum. The ILS class offers smaller groups, decreased increments of lesson and work time, and an emphasis on functional academics, communication skills, technology, and sensory integration. As much inclusion as each ILS student can tolerate is provided to enhance language, social skills, and exposure to the regular curriculum. Access to appropriately modified regular curriculum is systematically provided. The students can be pretaught the upcoming regular education curriculum in the SDC to acquire familiarity with the concept. The ILS students can then join their nondisabled peers when that concept is introduced to the regular education class. With this method, the ILS/SDC students encounter the subject matter twice, thereby increasing their understanding and enabling greater participation when included with their regular education peers.

The District offered placement in a new ILS/SDC that was not currently in existence. The District anticipated that this SDC would be available at Kate Sessions Elementary when the 2000-2001 school year began. Kate Sessions Elementary is not STUDENT’s home school, nor is it his school of choice. The Petitioner’s parents filed a request for a due process hearing to dispute the District’s determination that STUDENT requires an SDC to receive an appropriate education during the 2000-2001 school year. It is their desire that STUDENT repeat the first grade and remain fully included in a general education classroom at his school of choice.

DISCUSSION

ISSUE ONE

Does the District’s offer to place STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) with mainstreaming constitute an offer of a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2000-2001 school year?

“Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . .” 20 U.S.C.§1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform to the student’s individual education program.

In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or whether that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir.1987). In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court held that “the basic floor of opportunity’s provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” Thus, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or ‘potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493 (9th Cir.1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C.§1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031. United States Code §1412(a)(5) sets forth the preference that handicapped students be provided with an appropriate education within the regular education setting.

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including childrenin public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal ofchildren with disabilities from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplemental aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The Court in the case of Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (1989), held that the law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” The courts have provided guidance for determining whether a proposed offer of placement is appropriate where the issue is the extent of a disabled child’s participation with his nondisabled peers.

In considering whether the District has proposed a placement for [Minor] that complies with the Act, the court must determine what is meant by the requirement that handicapped children be mainstreamed “to the maximum extent appropriate.” Because the Act does not define this requirement, cases interpreting the Act guide the court’s analysis. The federal appellate courts have recognized the following factors as relevant to determining if a placement is appropriate: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with non-handicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (1994).

The Ninth Circuit Court applies the above criteria when analyzing whether a placement offer complies with the federal and State preferences for mainstreaming and the specific language of United States Code §1412(a)(5), which allows a disabled student’s removal from the general education environment only when his or her needs cannot be met in the regular education classroom with supplemental aids and services. The District is proposing to remove STUDENT from full inclusion in a general education program and place him in a more restrictive SDC. The Hearing Officer will therefore apply the Holland factors to this case when analyzing whether or not STUDENT’s needs can be met in a full inclusion setting.

A. The academic benefits to STUDENT of placement in a full-inclusion setting.

The District maintains that STUDENT has unique needs in all academic areas that cannot be adequately met in an inclusion program and that STUDENT requires the more intensive services of an SDC staff. In support of its position, the District offered the testimony of STUDENT’s inclusion specialist, Kristen Green. Ms. Green testified that STUDENT was assigned to her in late 1999 as a first- grader in a first/second grade combination class for students who had limited English proficiency.(Footnote 1) According to Ms. Green, STUDENT was having a difficult time in his classroom because he had not had a consistent inclusion teacher to address his needs.

Because STUDENT had been without inclusion services, Ms. Green spent a significant amount of time in the classroom developing a program for him. It was her observation that when STUDENT was included in the activities of the remainder of the class, he communicated that he could not perform the work by “tuning out, losing interest, laying down, and making noises.” STUDENT’s attention span was less than that of his peers, so he could not stay on task and work with his classmates. Based upon these observations, Ms. Green concluded that the classroom teacher and aide were correct: even modified, the curriculum was not meaningful to STUDENT and he was not receiving academic benefit from his inclusion placement. She further agreed that the regular education curriculum could not be modified so that STUDENT could actively participate in the class.

Ms. Green testified that she created a modified curriculum for STUDENT that provided direct instruction from his aide on a one-on-one basis. STUDENT’s activities were not coordinated with those of the other children. For example, he might be working on writing while the rest of the class did math. Through the one-on-one instructional method, STUDENT met many of his IEP goals. In her progress report, Ms. Green wrote that STUDENT was progressing well in reading. He made little progress in math or money recognition.

STUDENT’s aide, Shelley Plumb, also testified on behalf of the District. Ms. Plumb was STUDENT’s full-time individual aide for kindergarten and first grade. Ms. Plumb said that first grade was very difficult for STUDENT. Unlike kindergarten, first grade was more structured with many transitions. It required greater comprehension skills and sustained attention to activities. Ms. Plumb initially tried to assist STUDENT with the regular education curriculum as modified by the classroom teacher. However, STUDENT was easily distracted, could not understand the concepts presented, and was unable to follow directions. Ms. Plumb stated that the regular class instruction had no meaning for STUDENT. Consequently, he would not attend and his problem behaviors increased. He ran around the classroom, grabbed things, made noises, and distracted the other students. When the staff determined that he was not gaining academically from exposure to a curriculum he could not grasp, Ms. Plumb took over STUDENT’s instruction and worked individually with him on his IEP goals. Ms. Plumb testified that even with direct instruction, STUDENT could not work independently. He required verbal and/or physical prompts for each aspect of every task. Ms. Plumb also described what she interpreted as “tired” behavior exhibited by STUDENT. He would lie down, refuse to sit up, and be unable to participate in any activity during portions of circle time and after lunch.

The teacher of STUDENT’s first-second grade combination class was Daniel Hayes. Mr. Hayes has been an elementary school teacher for a total of thirteen years. For the last three years, he has taught the ESL first-second grade combination class. Mr. Hayes testified that he has not had education, training or experience as a teacher for the severely disabled. He did not receive any training from the District before STUDENT was placed in his class. The only information he had when the school year started was from STUDENT’s IEP and conversations with MOTHER.

Initially, Mr. Hayes spent a great deal of time modifying STUDENT’s lessons and worksheets in an attempt to include STUDENT in all classroom activities. Mr. Hayes testified that, in math, STUDENT was not yet a symbolic learner. He had no knowledge of addition or subtraction concepts. To accommodate STUDENT’s math level, he unsuccessfully tried modified or reduced worksheets in addition to manipulatives. STUDENT’s math abilities were so far below those of the remainder of the class that he held back the other students. He placed STUDENT in his lowest reading group; however, while the other group members were reading words, STUDENT was still trying to learn the letter/sound relationships. STUDENT did not have the underlying skills necessary to participate in the phonics lessons. During class reading time, Mr. Hayes read while the children listened and answered questions about the story. They also worked on reading worksheets. Even when he tried partnering STUDENT with another student, STUDENT could not attend. He would get up, wander around the classroom, make noises, and inappropriately touch items. Mr. Hayes said that STUDENT did not understand the purpose of writing so he had no interest in the writing exercises. He could only be made to practice writing his letters with full hand-over-hand prompting. In all subject areas, Mr. Hayes found that the regular curriculum could not be modified in a way that would allow STUDENT’s participation.

All District witnesses testified that they believed that the best placement for STUDENT was an ILS/SDC with a staff trained to work with severely handicapped children on functional, academic and life skills. Ms. Patricia Laurick is the resource specialist teacher (RSP) who evaluates District students for placement in its independent skills program. Ms. Laurick participated in STUDENT’s IEP meeting and concluded that his inclusion program was not providing him with educational benefit. She testified that the ILS class is designed to respond to STUDENT’s particular areas of instructional need, which cannot be adequately addressed in a full inclusion setting. The general education curriculum required such modification that it no longer had academic meaning for STUDENT or targeted his IEP goals. According to Ms. Laurick, the majority of STUDENT’s academic goals should be to acquire functional, not conceptual skills. Rather than expose him to paper/pencil conceptual tasks, STUDENT should be taught the application of concrete principles such as practical math and reading abilities (i.e. adding prices of grocery items, currency use, reading signs, bus schedules, etc.). STUDENT also must learn independence in fundamental areas that include eating and bathroom proficiency.

The Petitioner parent’s presented a different perception of STUDENT’s achievements and the benefits he obtained from a full inclusion program. FATHER testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT met most of his IEP goals. In math, with full prompts, STUDENT can draw the correct number of circles to correspond to numbers on a worksheet, then solve an addition problem by counting the number of circles he drew. FATHER stated that because math is more abstract, STUDENT requires instruction with the use of manipulatives. Academically, STUDENT has a good memory and learns through repetition and the use of familiar items. FATHER said that STUDENT is now learning with less repetition. He also finds that STUDENT’s reading ability has improved and that STUDENT attends longer when they read books together and he can now anticipate some words.

MOTHER has a master’s degree in social work. For eight years, she was employed by Regional Center as an early intervention service coordinator to work with families with special needs children. She has read extensively about and attended several conferences on Down syndrome and full inclusion. MOTHER testified that the inclusion specialist did not modify the general education curriculum for STUDENT during the first grade. Instead, she provided him with an alternate curriculum directed toward his IEP goals. MOTHER was pleased with the progress her son made while in Mr. Hayes’s class. However, she felt that he would have benefitted more if he had a consistent inclusion specialist from the beginning of school. She testified that her son’s performance increases in response to higher expectations, and he may have been using his tired behaviors to avoid undesired activities. The appearance that STUDENT was tired and unable to perform academically may also have been caused by his low muscle tone that makes it difficult for him to sit unsupported for long periods of time. She also said that she thought that STUDENT would have made additional progress had he been given more prewriting activities and an assistive technology evaluation to respond to his fine motor weakness.

MOTHER reported that STUDENT had made satisfactory progress on his IEP goals. He had increased his ability to read Edmark sight words from 40 to 60 in three months. He is learning phonics and its use in decoding words. He progressed with his reading skills in a pre-primer, but did not meet his IEP goal to improve his reading skills to a primer level. He did not increase his ability to count objects beyond five, and he did not learn to recognize numbers between twenty and forty with consistency. STUDENT memorized some addition facts up to five, but did not reach his goal of adding up to ten. When given one simple spelling word per week, he could orally spell the word fifty percent of the time. STUDENT could tell time to the hour, inconsistently to the half-hour. He did not meet his IEP goal of recognizing coins. STUDENT learned to spell his first name orally, inconsistently write his first name, and trace two to three word sentences. He did not fulfill his goal to write his first and last name and a two to three word sentence. He could not go to the restroom independently. With cues for each step, he could toilet himself, with the exception of wiping. The Petitioner’s expert on the inclusion of disabled students in regular classes was Dr. Mary Falvey. Dr. Falvey has a Ph.D. in special education and is a professor at California State University at Los Angeles. She teaches classes in the area of special education for the moderately and severely handicapped to students in the masters and doctoral programs. She also consults with some school districts on inclusion strategies and has written a textbook on inclusion. Dr. Falvey testified that she first met STUDENT when he was a three-year-old preschooler. She did not see STUDENT again until the first week of the 2000-2001 school year when she observed him at school and conducted a home visit. She also reviewed his prior IEP documents, school psychoeducational reports, progress notes, and his functional analysis, OT, and assistive technology reports.

Based upon this information, it was Dr. Falvey’s opinion that STUDENT could be very successful in a full inclusion program with the proper supports. She stated that he required a preplanned modified curriculum, assistive technology in the form of a personal computer similar to an Alpha Smart, a behavior intervention plan, a social skills program, speech therapy to increase his expressive language, OT, APE, and an assigned aide (preferably assigned to the class). From her school observation of STUDENT, Dr. Falvey concluded that he did not need a constant aide. An aide should be assigned to his class to monitor STUDENT’s needs and provide one-on-one assistance when necessary. She agrees that STUDENT needs some one-on-one instruction. However, once he has learned a concept, he should rejoin the class. Dr. Falvey stated that STUDENT must learn to take his directions primarily from the general education teacher, and not from an aide who conducts a separate class for him within the regular education classroom. In Dr. Falvey’s opinion, STUDENT’s IEP goals were compatible with a first grade curriculum. Thus, with appropriate modifications to the regular curriculum, he could be working on his goals in a natural setting.

The Hearing Officer understands the Respondent’s argument that STUDENT is capable of learning more, and he would be more likely to reach his potential in an ILS/SDC. The District has concluded that his individual needs cannot be appropriately addressed through full inclusion in a regular education classroom, even with modifications and special education support and services. The District is also concerned that individually educating STUDENT in an isolated area of a general education classroom is a very restrictive environment and that he is becoming aide dependent. It is the consensus of District staff that STUDENT would receive a more appropriate education in a less restrictive environment if his academic needs were met in a small, structured class taught by trained special educators. He could then be integrated into the general population for as much of the day as he could tolerate.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District is sincere in its desire to provide STUDENT with a beneficial education, and concurs that receiving a portion of his curriculum from trained special education staff would benefit STUDENT academically. Academic superiority, however, is not the only consideration when determining placement for a disabled student. The Courts have consistently found that a program that provides academic superiority does not trump the value of integration with nondisabled peers. This issue was addressed by the district court in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (supra). The court held “the Acts requirement of integration, based on recognition of the nonacademic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom.” See also Roland v. Concord School Comm., 910 F.2d 983 (1990).

The relevant question, therefore, is not whether STUDENT can receive a better education in an SDC program, but whether he can receive an appropriate education in the least restrictive environment with the use of supplemental aids and services in a general education program. U.S.C.§1412(a)(5)(A).

Without exception, STUDENT has been integrated with his nondisabled peers since preschool. During the prior years, he has made progress on his IEP goals and improved his classroom behavior and social skills. His aide confirmed that he had had a very productive kindergarten year and his parents described his success in regular preschools. Until the conclusion of his first grade year, no educator disputed the appropriateness of his full inclusion placement with his nondisabled peers. On March 27, 2000, an annual IEP meeting was held that continued STUDENT’s placement in the general education class. At that time, it was noted that STUDENT appears to be frustrated and “tuning out” when working with his aide. However, it was also noted that “STUDENT has made some great progress” in his inclusion classroom. Although it was agreed that the team would meet again to determine placement for the 2000-2001 school year, there was no discussion of ending STUDENT’s full inclusion program.

On June 9, 2000, another IEP meeting was convened as agreed to discuss STUDENT’s placement for the following school year. Less than three months after the prior IEP meeting where the subject of a more restrictive placement was not broached, the District first insisted that STUDENT could not continue in a full inclusion program. Two days before the scheduled meeting, Ms. Green telephoned MOTHER to advise her that the District would offer an SDC placement at the IEP meeting. The District had made this determination before the IEP meeting, without the input of STUDENT’s parents. Contained within the IEP notes is the basis for the District IEP team members’s conclusion that STUDENT cannot be successfully included in a regular education class. The District staff reported the following: the curriculum required such significant modification that it no longer resembled the curriculum of the rest of the class; the activities of the other students were so beyond STUDENT’s abilities that attempts to include him increased his frustration and disruptive behaviors; he required a shortened day to accommodate his frustration and fatigue; he required a toileting schedule and lunch with the SDC to provide the supervision he needed; his IEP goals were primarily to develop functional skills; and assessments established that his cognitive, developmental, and adaptive abilities were within a range appropriate for functional academics. The District therefore recommended a highly structured ILS/SDC placement that could provide a balance between inclusion and systematic instruction.

The Hearing Officer agrees with the District’s contention that STUDENT will need to learn functional academic skills to increase his independence. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT requires functional and self-help skill instruction that can only be provided in an ILS/SDC. STUDENT’s IEP goals include money recognition, reading and math skills, telling time, spelling, and writing his name and short sentences. These all appear to be goals compatible with a first or second grade curriculum, which could be addressed in a regular education setting. STUDENT’s aide can discretely address his restroom goal. Exposure to typical peers in a natural setting will provide STUDENT with the best opportunity to meet his goal of improving peer interaction by initiating greetings and playing with his classmates. The District’s argument that the Petitioner’s goals are primarily functional is therefore not a persuasive reason to place him in an SDC program.

The testimony of the District’s own witnesses establish that STUDENT was not given a reasonable opportunity to succeed in his first grade classroom. He was enrolled in a combination classroom with limited English speaking students and a teacher with no background or training in special education. STUDENT was also deprived of an effective inclusion specialist for several weeks after school began. Without the assistance of special education staff, STUDENT’s teacher was unreasonably required to adapt curriculum and attempt to include him in a general education ESL class. By the time a permanent inclusion teacher was assigned to STUDENT, his teacher and aide had already concluded that he could not be assimilated into the class and he was receiving his instruction in isolation. The inclusion expert did not address this situation by providing STUDENT’s teacher and aide with a strategy and program designed to include STUDENT. Instead, she instituted a program intended to be implemented by his one-on-one aide in isolation away from the other students.

It is inevitable that STUDENT would fail in a regular education classroom when he was not provided with a program designed by an inclusion expert that allowed him a genuine opportunity to be a class participant. Systematic responses to his shortened attention span and interfering behaviors, which may have allowed him to remain within the group, were not implemented. He was not given activities in the same subject area as his peers, but appropriate to his ability, to alleviate his tendency for boredom and misbehavior when confronted with tasks beyond his capabilities. Instead, he was removed from the activity by his aide to receive his instruction alone.

Performing the same level of work as the general education students is not a prerequisite to inclusion. STUDENT may be capable of working on his IEP goal of writing his name while the other students are writing sentences. He could be using manipulatives or drawing circles corresponding to numbers to learn addition while his classmates complete math worksheets at a more advanced level. He could be reading sight words or his pre-primer while his peers read books that are more advanced. In a reading group, STUDENT could provide letter sounds even if the other children are sounding out words.

The District may be correct in its assessment that STUDENT would make greater academic progress in a special education class. It is also conceivable that even with special education services, support, and an appropriate inclusion plan, STUDENT will not be able to successfully participate in a regular education setting. However, since steps were not taken to provide STUDENT with behavioral interventions and a modified curriculum that addressed his needs and abilities while including him with his peers, it is premature to remove him from an inclusion setting and place him in an ILS/SDC program. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT can receive educational benefit from a program of inclusion with appropriate supplemental aids and services. He will require the availability of an individual aide to support and reinforce his academics. STUDENT’s services must also include an inclusion specialist, appropriate curriculum modifications, a behavioral plan, social skill interventions, and all DIS services listed in his current IEP.

B. The nonacademic benefits to STUDENT of a full-inclusion program

STUDENT’s opportunities to interact with his nondisabled peers during the first grade were severely restricted. Ms. Green continued the program begun by Mr. Hayes that limited STUDENT’s involvement with the other students to inclusion in the morning calendar, snack, and participation in a reading group. Ms. Plumb testified that STUDENT spent eighty-five percent of his day with her, and fifteen percent integrated with the regular education students. STUDENT initially also ate lunch with his regular education classmates. This changed when the school staff felt he required more supervision. Therefore, he was assigned to lunch with the ILS-SDC students who had aide supervision in a segregated area of the lunch and playground. After lunch, STUDENT spent the remainder of his shortened day with his aide. The District witnesses testified that STUDENT became very fatigued after lunch and could not stay focused on school activities. They proposed that his school day be shortened by an hour each day. The parents accepted the District’s recommendation that STUDENT end his school day at 1:30 p.m.

Although STUDENT spent limited time with his classmates, the testimony established that he received social benefit from association with typical peers. STUDENT’s teacher said that he quickly learned to enter the classroom in the morning, put his backpack away in the proper place, and go to the floor area for morning calendar time. He could actively cooperate with the group for ten minutes before he became distracted. STUDENT liked song time and participated for the full fifteen minutes. He became familiar with the songs and had favorites. He learned to choose a book and participate in silent reading. Some of his classmates would sit with him and read to him, which he enjoyed. STUDENT was part of the class “sharing time.” He had shared with his classmates by reading a book aloud. Mr. Hayes testified that the other students always accepted STUDENT. After Mr. Hayes made the suggestion, students would sit with STUDENT at snack time. STUDENT performed all of the class jobs Mr. Hayes requested of him. He assisted with overhead projector, held the flag, took the balls to the playground, and carried books to the library. STUDENT had preferred friends that he liked to play with and another friend who enjoyed reading with him.

According to Ms. Plumb, STUDENT’s classmates “loved him, they adored him, and I think he felt the same way.” She said that the other children would greet STUDENT, share snacks with him, and play in the sandbox with him. Ms. Green expressed her opinion that STUDENT received social benefit from his inclusion in the general education class.

Dr. Falvey observed STUDENT during the first week of the 2000-2001 school year in Mr. Hayes’s class, where STUDENT remains pending the resolution of the due process proceeding. Dr. Falvey found STUDENT very attentive and focused during circle time. He listened while his teacher read a story and required only one verbal redirection from his aide who remained in the back of the room. Another child joined STUDENT during snack. STUDENT then went to the playground, retrieved a ball, and played ball with the child who ate a snack with him. After recess, Dr. Falvey observed STUDENT sit attentively while his teacher played an audiotape of a story. Dr. Falvey testified that it was very important for STUDENT to remain in regular education so that he would have normally developing role models. She said children with Down syndrome model and imitate very well. Consequently, STUDENT will learn appropriate behavior by being in a normal peer environment. His nondisabled peers will expose him to such things as turn-taking, playground rules, and social interactions. Conversely, STUDENT could imitate the children in a special education classroom and develop undesired behaviors. He will also have a better opportunity to increase his speech if he is immersed in the language-rich general education environment. STUDENT’s communication skills could decrease if he were placed in a class with primarily nonverbal classmates. Dr. Falvey explained that if STUDENT attempted to speak to another student who did not respond, his efforts to initiate conversation would decline.

PARENTS spoke of the nonacademic benefits they believed STUDENT received from his full inclusion placement. STUDENT was described as a gentle, friendly child who makes friends easily. The parents testified that STUDENT’s use of language increased with his family and friends. They observed STUDENT’s classmates and saw that they liked him and always greeted him. Over the course of the first grade, they watched STUDENT progress from not returning the greetings of his classmates, to returning greetings with prompts, to spontaneous greetings. STUDENT learned the names of most of his classmates and could match their names to their photographs. He was attentive when a classmate read to him. PARENTS said that STUDENT’s school inclusion has had a beneficial affect on his social relationships. He now joins his peers at the neighborhood park and has been invited to play at the homes of classmates. His play skills have increased because he imitates the nondisabled children and he extends himself to comply with his peers’s requests that he play with them. The parents recalled that STUDENT had always refused to wear his glasses. They described an incident in which all of his classmates were wearing sunglasses for a special event. For the first time, STUDENT also put on glasses so he could be like his friends. PARENTS expressed their belief that STUDENT would have the best opportunity to develop fully as a member of society if he remains fully included with the regular school population. In their opinion, “he has consistently shown that he can make progress in general education and he is entitled to the same rights as other kids for regular education experiences and opportunities.”

The Hearing Officer concurs with Dr. Falvey and PARENTS regarding the social importance of allowing STUDENT to remain a participant with his regular education peers. Although the acquisition of academic and functional skills is very important to STUDENT’s independence, the value of familiarity with, and acceptance by the community in which he lives should not be diminished. STUDENT was given minimal opportunity to interact with nondisabled students during the 1999-2000 school year. However, despite this limited inclusion, the testimony established that he still received nonacademic benefits from his involvement in the regular classroom. With the collaboration of an inclusion specialist, strategies can be developed to provide STUDENT with opportunities to participate with his classmates, both academically and socially. All of these reasons are important nonacademic benefits to STUDENT as he learns to live in his community.

C. STUDENT’s effect upon the teachers and children in the regular education class

The District claims that one of the primary reasons STUDENT requires placement in an SDC is that his behaviors have a disruptive effect upon the regular education class. Mr. Hayes testified that STUDENT would not sit still during class activities and he would not remain in a group. His play was parallel rather than interactive. Despite the various accommodations Mr. Hayes tried, STUDENT could not participate in the regular curriculum without Mr. Hayes reducing the instructional level so much that it was far below the capabilities of the other students. This modification of the curriculum deprived the remainder of the class of a grade-level education. The full physical and verbal prompts STUDENT required from his aide to perform any activity disrupted the remainder of the class. When the aide provided direct instruction to STUDENT within the class group, but from a lesson individually designed for STUDENT, it was also disruptive to the other students.

Ms. Plumb testified that STUDENT’s classmates “loved him.” However, despite the children’s acceptance of STUDENT, she believed that his presence had an adverse impact on her, the teacher, and the other students. She testified that STUDENT began his day in morning circle with the other children. He would enjoy this time for awhile; then he would become tired and interfere with the group by lying down, rolling around the floor and making noises. This behavior necessitated his removal from the circle. STUDENT also participated in a reading group with some of the other students. Early in the year, this participation was productive, but soon the level of reading increased beyond STUDENT’s abilities and he distracted the group with his inattention. Ms. Plumb felt that the entire class curriculum was far beyond STUDENT’s capabilities. He could not pay attention to instruction that was meaningless to him and, instead, would engage in disruptive behaviors. Ms. Plumb confirmed that STUDENT’s behaviors of lying down, refusing to get up, grabbing things, and running to the front of the classroom were sometimes disturbing to the remainder of the class. Fortunately, STUDENT’s misbehaviors could be easily redirected with verbal prompts. Ms. Plumb believed that the teacher could not provide the degree of individual attention STUDENT required and still meet the needs of his other students. She also said that Mr. Hayes could not provide lessons that STUDENT was able to understand without depriving the rest of the class of appropriate instruction. Ms. Plumb believed that attempting to balance the conflicting needs of STUDENT and all of the other children placed a great deal of stress on Mr. Hayes. She testified that working with STUDENT in an inclusion setting was also hard for her. She said that she had tendered her resignation because she found the pressure and isolation of being STUDENT’s aide too difficult.

PARENTS have consistently acknowledged STUDENT’s behavioral issues. They made several requests for a functional behavioral analysis to address the problems described by the District staff. Ms. Green disagreed that STUDENT needed a behavioral analysis. She testified that STUDENT’s conduct was not severe enough to necessitate a functional behavioral analysis. STUDENT did sometimes grab, run away and “tune out,” but he was not disruptive to the class. Ms. Green said that he responded well to positive redirection and his aide could successfully intervene to control him. Instead of conducting the behavioral assessment sought by the parents, the District provided a school psychologist who observed STUDENT and reviewed behavioral data collected by his aide. She did not conduct a complete behavioral assessment. The psychologist opined that STUDENT’s behaviors were developmental, not behavioral in nature. Rather than undesirable conduct, she found STUDENT’s actions to be consistent with the behavior of children with his cognitive, not his chronological age. The school psychologist also concluded that some of STUDENT’s behaviors were the result of exposure to curriculum that was too difficult for him.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s expressions of concern about STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors inconsistent with its actions and the testimony of its witnesses. In response to the staff’s complaints about their son’s actions, PARENTS repeatedly asked for a functional behavioral assessment. At the same time that the school staff were telling the parents that STUDENT was disruptive to his class, they were also denying the parents’s requests for a behavioral assessment. The District claimed that STUDENT’s behaviors were not severe enough to justify such an evaluation because they did not disrupt the class and were amenable to positive intervention and redirection. The District seems to maximize STUDENT’s disruptive effect to support his removal from the general education program, then minimize his behavior problems when explaining its failure to conduct a behavioral assessment and implement a behavior intervention plan (BIP).

It is the opinion of the Hearing Officer that the District’s plan to place STUDENT in an SDC is a response to the stress felt by his teacher and aide, rather than a move justified by STUDENT’s behaviors. The solution to this problem, however, is not to remove STUDENT to a more restrictive environment, but rather to provide STUDENT’s general education teacher and aide with effective assistance and collaboration. Mr. Hayes and Ms. Plumb were placed in the untenable position of being required to include STUDENT in a regular education setting without appropriate special education support or services. It is understandable that they felt overwhelmed by this task. The District never provided STUDENT’s teacher with the support of specialists to modify and adapt the curriculum so that STUDENT could be included at his level in the classroom activities. It did not fully evaluate STUDENT’s conduct or develop a systematic behavior plan to assist his teacher in addressing his disruptive behaviors. Instead, it simply placed STUDENT in a classroom with an unprepared regular education teacher and expected him to provide STUDENT with an appropriate inclusion program.

To remove STUDENT from the general education setting without appropriately modifying his curriculum and developing strategies to respond to the disruptive behaviors that only became problematic last year, would violate the rationale of utilizing BIPs to increase social interaction with the nondisabled population as set forth in California Code of Regulations, Title 5,§3001(f):

“Behavioral interventions” are designed to provide the individual with greater access to a variety of community settings, social contacts and public events; and ensure the individuals right to placement in the least restrictive environment as outlined in the individuals IEP.

D. The costs of mainstreaming STUDENT

This issue was not raised by either party. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider it as a relevant factor.

F. The least restrictive environment

The District offered testimony to establish that full inclusion offered STUDENT the most restrictive environment, rather than the least. Ms. Green testified that STUDENT spent most of his school day alone in the classroom with his one-to-one aide. She was concerned that the individual instructional method constituted an inappropriate and restrictive setting for STUDENT. Ms. Laurick stated that the regular education placement was very restrictive for STUDENT because he was only with his peers thirty minutes each day. The remainder of the time he was exclusively with his aide. This fostered aide dependence as evidenced by his complete reliance on his aide for all activities. Ms. Laurick also testified that STUDENT’s total subjection to the control of one adult also prevented him from developing internal controls and learning how to work with multiple people.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not made reasonable efforts to support STUDENT in a full inclusion program. Consequently, it is untimely to remove STUDENT from the general education classroom without first: attempting to include him with a modified curriculum designed to meet his needs; conducting an assessment to identify undesirable conduct and a BIP to change his problem behaviors; and providing the special education support and services he requires to have a meaningful opportunity to succeed as a full participant in a regular education setting.

ISSUE TWO

Is STUDENT entitled to enroll in a general education class and repeat first grade at an elementary school that is not his home school pursuant to his acceptance through the Districts Choice Program?

In this case, the parents want STUDENT placed in a regular education first grade class at the District elementary school they designated as their “school of choice.” The District has a policy that enables students to seek enrollment in a District school that is not their resident school. Using standardized criteria, each school allows intra-district transfers based upon available space. Assuming their son would continue his regular education placement, PARENTS made a timely application for STUDENT to attend their school of choice, rather than his home school. STUDENT was accepted into a regular education class by his choice school for the 2000-2001 school year, but could not attend when the District refused to continue his placement in the general education program. Instead, the District offered placement at Kate Sessions Elementary School, the location of the ILS/SDC that the District considers appropriate for STUDENT. The Petitioner contends that he followed District procedures and gained acceptance at his school of choice. In the event the Hearing Officer deems a general education placement appropriate for STUDENT, he requests that he be granted the same rights extended to all District students who have been granted an intra-district transfer and that he be allowed to enroll at his chosen school.

Typically, a special education student’s school site is not determined by the same residential boundary rules that require a regular education student to attend his designated neighborhood school. Placing a disabled student on a campus near his home is an important consideration. 34 C.F.R. §300.552(a)(3); Title 5 CCR §3042(b). However, the school site that provides the most appropriate placement for a special education student is that campus that offers the least restrictive environment (LRE), meets the child’s unique needs, and enables implementation of his or her IEP. See: Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830 (9th Circuit 1995) finding that placement 280 miles from the student’s home was necessary to accommodate his needs and not a violation of 34 C.F.R. §300.552(a)(3), which requires placement as close as possible to the child’s home; Barnett v. Fairfax County School Board, 927 F.2d 158 (4th Circuit 1991) rejecting the parents contention that placing their child in a school five miles farther from their home was inappropriate; Fisher v. Rochester Community Schools, 780 F. Supp. 1142 (Michigan 1991), which held that there was no home school entitlement for a special education child; Murray v. Montrose County School District, 51 F.3d 921 (10th Circuit 1995) finding that although the neighborhood school is preferred, it was appropriate to place a child in a school located ten miles from his home when the child’s IEP necessitated placement at that location; Schuldt v. Mankato School District, 937 F.2d 1357 (8th Circuit 1991) holding that the IDEA did not require school districts to place a disabled child in the school closest to his or her home, but rather, at a school that could implement his or her program.

In this case, the question is whether STUDENT, as a special education student, is entitled to attend his school of choice when he is accepted after fully complying with the District’s policy for intra-district transfers. The Hearing Officer begins with the general premise that a disabled individual is legally entitled to the same rights of access as a nondisabled person. Thus, STUDENT should be placed at his school of choice if he applies and is accepted in accordance with the District’s established school choice rules. However, based on the above cases, this general right is limited for a special education student by a second factor; whether the school of choice is the LRE, can met his unique needs, and can implement his IEP.

The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT must be returned to a general education classroom for the current school year. It has also been determined that a regular education class is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. There was no evidence presented to suggest that a regular education classroom at his school of choice cannot meet his unique needs as well as implement his IEP. The District did not contend that STUDENT’s school of choice cannot access an inclusion specialist and all other special education support and services required by STUDENT. There was no claim that STUDENT’s needs can be better met if he is returned to a regular education classroom at his neighborhood school. The District also did not argue that Kate Sessions Elementary School, the District’s tendered campus for a SDC placement, was also the campus where STUDENT should be placed to meet his needs in a general education class. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s school of choice is the LRE, and can meet his unique needs through implementation of his IEP. Consequently, he is entitled, like any other District student, to attend his school of choice pursuant to his acceptance.

The Petitioner also seeks placement in a regular education class as a repeat first-grader. PARENTS said that their son is very small for his age, so his size is consistent with first grade students. They see STUDENT’s skills at near a first grade level and believe he will have a better academic foundation if he is reexposed to the first grade curriculum in English. Dr. Falvey testified that STUDENT did not have an effective inclusion program last year, so he was not exposed through an appropriately modified curriculum to the information he should have acquired in the first grade. This factor was complicated by his placement in a classroom for limited English speakers. To prepare him for future academic success, Dr. Falvey stated that STUDENT should be given a fair opportunity to acquire first grade skills. The District pointed out that STUDENT began kindergarten at the age of six, a year later that most of his chronological peers. Thus, he would be two years older than most of the children if he repeats first grade. As STUDENT should be a third-grader by age, placement in first grade would separate him from his chronological peers.

The Hearing Officer agrees that it is important to place disabled students with their age-appropriate peers. However, STUDENT spent the 1999-2000 school year in a first/second grade combination class with students for whom English was a second language. Although STUDENT is Chinese by heritage, his first language is English. To place a disabled student like STUDENT, who has increased academic needs and language deficiencies, in a classroom designed for limited English-speaking students, seems an unusual choice. STUDENT was instructed by a teacher with an expertise in teaching students with decreased English skills and surrounded by peers who were not fluent in his language. This placement decreased his opportunity to succeed as a fully included student and increased the likelihood that he would not have access to a curriculum appropriately modified for his needs, not those of limited English speaking students. The testimony established that MOTHER chose this classroom from several offered by the District. However, it is the District, not the parent, who has the ultimate responsibility to offer an appropriate placement. Murphy v. Timberlane Regional School District, 22 F.3d 1186 (1st Cir. 1994). Consequently, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT will benefit from placement in the first grade with appropriate services in an English speaking classroom. The Hearing Officer further relies upon the testimony that STUDENT’s size and development are consistent with those of first grade students, as well as Dr. Falvey’s testimony that although chronological placement of a disabled student is crucial, a one- to two-year age difference is acceptable.

CONCLUSION

With the implementation of proper supplemental aids and services, STUDENT should be allowed an opportunity to succeed in a full inclusion placement. To date, STUDENT has spent his preschool and school years in programs in which he was included with his nondisabled peers. Neither party claims that he did not receive both academic and nonacademic benefit from these prior programs. It was not until the end of the 1999-2000 school year that the District determined that an inclusion placement was inappropriate for STUDENT. However, during the first grade, STUDENT did not have a modified curriculum intended to include him with his peers, nor were adequate supports consistently provided to his teacher and aide. STUDENT also did not have behavioral goals and objectives to address the conduct that decreased his inclusion and disrupted his class. Without first providing him with an opportunity to be included with appropriate support, services and a BIP that responds to his behaviors, it is premature to remove STUDENT from a regular education class and place him in an SDC.

ORDER

1. Because STUDENT currently remains in last year’s placement, an IEP must be swiftly convened. Within ten calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall hold an IEP meeting and place STUDENT at his school of choice in a regular education first grade class. The IEP team shall also implement appropriate supplemental aids and services which include the following: (1) a consulting inclusion specialist; (2) an individual aide to assist STUDENT and his classroom under the supervision of the classroom teacher; (3) a modified first grade curriculum designed and supervised by the inclusion specialist; (4) assistive technology; (5) a social skills program; and (6) all DIS services identified in his current IEP.

2. Within fifty days of the date of this decision, the District shall conduct a functional analysis assessment that results in a behavioral intervention program and convene an IEP meeting to respond to any behaviors STUDENT displays that interfere with his ability to be fully included in the general education class and/or disrupt his class. The assessment and BIP must also include strategies to respond to STUDENT’s behaviors that are interpreted as indicating that he is tired and unwilling to continue his assigned tasks.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement:

The Petitioner prevailed on the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: December 13, 2000 _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific

Footnote 1: Although STUDENT is exposed to some Chinese at home, his primary language is English.