California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 4, 1997
Student v. Anaheim Union High School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1309-96 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
Anaheim Union High School District prevails on parent's claims for a nonpublic school, an IEE and a behavior plan; IEP meeting ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A ninth-grade student eligible for special education as other health impaired due to attention deficit disorder filed for due process through his mother, who represented him. Anaheim Union High School District filed a cross-action asking the Hearing Officer to set an appropriate placement, and the cases were consolidated. At the parent's request, the student had moved from a special day class into resource and general education classes at Loara High School, where he failed or nearly failed his courses. He later received home teaching. The District proposed a special day class for learning handicapped students (LH-SDC).
Hearing Officer Keltie Jones could not order a nonpublic school because the parent named no school and described no program. The District gave no details about its proposed class, so the Hearing Officer could not find that class appropriate either. She did find that the student needs most classes in a single, small classroom on a regular campus, with instruction in reading comprehension, math computation and written language. She ordered the IEP team to meet within 15 days to choose a placement and write 1997-98 goals, including behavioral goals. She denied a requested apology as outside her jurisdiction. She found the District's 1995 assessment appropriate, so no IEE at District expense. No formal behavioral intervention plan was needed because the student's mostly passive defiance was not a serious behavior problem. The law also does not require a single "specialist" to write an IEP. The District prevailed on all issues.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a placement dispute where neither side proved its proposal. The parent named no specific nonpublic school, and the District gave no details of its proposed class. The Hearing Officer described the features the placement must have and sent the matter back to the IEP team. It also shows how the Hughes Bill "serious behavior problem" threshold was applied.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Is a nonpublic school (NPS) the appropriate school placement for Student? (Considered together with the District's consolidated cross-action asking the Hearing Officer to determine an appropriate placement, where the District proposed an LH-SDC.)
The parent named no specific NPS or type of program, so the Hearing Officer could not find a generic NPS appropriate. The District offered no details about its proposed LH-SDC, so the Hearing Officer could not find it appropriate either. The Hearing Officer held that Student needs a small, single-classroom program on a regular campus and ordered the IEP team to meet.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 2. Should the District be required to apologize to Student for its negligence and the mental anguish it caused Student?
The issue is beyond the Hearing Officer's jurisdiction and seeks a remedy that cannot be ordered, so the request was denied.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to an independent educational evaluation at District expense?
The 1995 triennial assessment was appropriate. A supervised intern performed it, a credentialed school psychologist approved it, and it was supplemented at the parent's request. The parent already had a no-cost independent evaluation, and nothing showed a new evaluation was needed before the May 1998 triennial.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 4. Does Student need a behavioral specialist to develop a behavioral intervention plan for him?
Student's mostly passive defiance was not a 'serious behavior problem' under 5 CCR § 3001, so no Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan was required. Behavioral goals in the IEP can address his behavior.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5. Does Student need a "specialist" to write his IEP?
The law requires an IEP team, not a single specialist, to write the IEP, and Student's team included the required members.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. Student's appropriate placement shall include having most of his classes taught in a single classroom, a small class size, and a curriculum that addresses his reading comprehension, math computation and written language deficits.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team shall meet within fifteen calendar days of the order to determine Student's appropriate placement and prepare an IEP with current goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year, including behavioral goals and objectives.
Key authorities
Rowley; Larry P. v. Riley; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320; 5 CCR § 3001(f), (y); Education Code §§ 56341, 56345
People named in the decision
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant and District representative, Anaheim Union High School District
- Barry Escoe, director of special youth services; former principal of Loara High School, Anaheim Union High School District
- Frances Correia, school psychologist; chair of IEP meetings at Ball Junior High, Anaheim Union High School District
- Donna Erickson, school psychologist (intern psychologist at time of 1995 triennial assessment), Anaheim Union High School District
- Dr. Joyce Fancher, supervising school psychologist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Jim Miller, behavioral specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- David E. Smith, RSP teacher and special education department chair, Loara High School
- Don Popovich, RSP teacher (English and science), Loara High School
- Marsha Wagner, assistant principal, Loara High School
- Mrs. Spiker, teacher, Ball Junior High School
- Dr. J. Shohet, independent evaluator obtained by parent, Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on June 24 and 25, 1997, in Anaheim, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.
The Petitioner/Cross-Respondent (Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Also present for portions of the hearing on Petitioner’s behalf was M. C., a family friend. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Anaheim Union High School District (District) was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District’s behalf was Barry Escoe, director of special youth services for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of additional evidence and closing briefs. Upon receipt of closing briefs, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the opening of the hearing, Petitioner moved for a continuance, asserting that Petitioner had not had sufficient notice of the hearing and was not prepared to go forward. The District objected to a continuance, noting that this was a consolidated case and it had the right to a hearing unless good cause for a continuance was shown. The notice of the hearing date was sent to Petitioner on May 23, 1997. On June 18, 1997, a conditional continuance was granted with the provision that the parties were to set a date for mediation by June 20, 1997, or the hearing would go forward on June 24, 1997. The parties did not set a mediation date, and Petitioner did not provide good cause why the hearing should be continued. Therefore, the motion to continue was denied.
The Petitioner did not provide the District with a statement of issues and proposed resolutions ten days before the hearing, and did not provide a witness list and copies of evidence five days before the hearing, as required by law. In fact, on the first day of the hearing, the Petitioner was not prepared to put on any evidence or witnesses. The District waived objections as to disclosure of the issues and evidence and agreed to put its case on first to allow Petitioner more time to prepare for the hearing. The Hearing Officer advised MOTHER that if she wanted to have documents admitted into evidence, she had to have a copy to give to the Hearing Officer and one to give to the District. The District finished its case before lunch on the second day of hearing, and the Hearing Officer advised MOTHER that she must be prepared to put on her case after lunch. MOTHER indicated that she did not have a chance to make copies of her evidence the night before, and the District agreed to let her use a photocopier during lunch.
After lunch, Petitioner’s exhibits A-Z were admitted, but MOTHER indicated that she had additional documents she wanted admitted into evidence. After several lengthy delays in the proceedings to allow MOTHER to locate documents, the District proposed that the Petitioner be allowed to submit evidence after the hearing to allow the testimony to proceed. The Hearing Officer agreed to allow Petitioner to submit additional documents to the Hearing Office by the close of business on July 2, 1997, and the testimony proceeded without the need to search for documents. On July 2, 1997, MOTHER contacted the Hearing Office and the District to request an extension of time to file the documents. The District agreed to extend the deadline, allowing the documents to be admitted if they were postmarked by July 3, 1997. On July 8, 1997, the District requested that the record be closed because it had not received any additional documents from the Petitioner. The Hearing Office contacted MOTHER, who stated that she had not yet mailed the documents, but was ready to do so. At that point, the Hearing Office informed MOTHER that no additional documents would be accepted from the Petitioner because the deadline of July 3 had not been met.
At the end of the hearing, the parties agreed that written closing arguments would be mailed to the Hearing Office no later than July 16, 1997. The Hearing Officer explained on the record to MOTHER that a closing argument should summarize the evidence presented at the hearing and discuss how the evidence supported her position. The Hearing Officer also informed MOTHER that she must send a copy of the closing argument to the District’s representative. On July 18, 1997, the Hearing Office received a package from MOTHER that contained a typewritten document, many pages of handwritten notes, an “Exhibit log,” and many documents that were not admitted into evidence at the hearing. The Hearing Office contacted MOTHER to determine if any of the documents submitted contained the Petitioner’s closing argument. MOTHER stated that the entire package was her closing argument and that another package was on its way. On July 21, 1997, the Hearing Office received the second package. The Hearing Office confirmed with the shipper that the second package was sent on July 17, 1997; therefore, the Hearing Office did not open the package. The Hearing Office also confirmed that the District’s representative did not receive copies of the documents sent by MOTHER on July 16 and 17. Therefore, the Hearing Officer did not review or consider any of the documents received on July 18 and July 21.
ISSUES
The Petitioner presented the following issues for resolution at the hearing:
1. Is a nonpublic school (NPS) the appropriate school placement for STUDENT?
2. Should the District be required to apologize to STUDENT for its negligence and the mental anguish it caused STUDENT?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational evaluation at District expense?
4. Does STUDENT need a behavioral specialist to develop a behavioral intervention plan for him?
5. Does STUDENT need a “specialist” to write his IEP?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old ninth-grade student who is eligible for special education under the category “other health impaired” due to his attention deficit disorder (ADD). STUDENT has been in special education programs since fourth grade. He was initially eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability. Dist. Exh. 28. In fourth grade, STUDENT was placed in a regular education class with pull-out for resource specialist program (RSP) services. In sixth grade, STUDENT was placed in a special day class (SDC).
STUDENT entered the District when he started seventh grade at Ball Junior High School. While at Ball, STUDENT was in an SDC for learning handicapped (LH) children. STUDENT performed fairly well at Ball. In seventh grade, STUDENT received three B-’s, two C’s, three C-’s, one D+, three D’s, and two F’s. In eighth grade, STUDENT received one B+, two B’s, one B-, four C’s, two C-’s, two D’s, and two F’s. Dist. Exh. 25. Although STUDENT did well academically at Ball, he had several disciplinary problems, including an assault on another student, theft, truancy, dress code violations, and defiance of authority that resulted in suspensions. In addition, several times STUDENT failed to serve detentions, resulting in Saturday school assignment, which he also failed to serve, resulting in in-school suspensions. Dist. Exh. 22.
In May 1995, during seventh grade, STUDENT was reassessed to determine if he continued to be eligible for special education. The assessor, Donna Erickson, was an intern psychologist under the supervision of school psychologist Dr. Joyce Fancher. The assessment report concluded that STUDENT’s scores did not indicate a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement, so he did not qualify for special education with a specific learning disability. Dist. Exh. 28. MOTHER objected to the original assessment report, and, as a result, the assessor conducted additional tests and prepared an addendum to the report; however, the conclusion did not change. Dist. Exh. 23. MOTHER then obtained her own independent evaluation, which was performed by Dr. J. Shohet in July 1995. Dr. Shohet’s report did not include any specific conclusion about STUDENT’s eligibility for special education, and did not include any recommendations. Subsequent IEPs indicated that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category “other health impaired” due to his attention deficit disorder. Dist. Exh. 8, 12, 26.
STUDENT stayed in the LH-SDC program at Ball for eighth grade and moved on to high school in ninth grade. Originally, STUDENT was to attend an LH-SDC at Loara High School for ninth grade. However, on September 13, 1996, an IEP team meeting was held at MOTHER’s request to consider placing STUDENT in the RSP classes at Loara. The IEP team agreed to place STUDENT in three RSP classes and three regular education classes and to meet again in November 1996 to review his progress and write new IEP goals.
STUDENT did not succeed in the RSP placement. When the IEP team met on October 30, 1996, STUDENT was failing RSP math, physical education (PE) and freshman focus. STUDENT was getting a D+ in RSP English and D-’s in RSP science and keyboarding. Dist. Exh. 25. In addition, STUDENT was late or absent frequently, and he repeatedly refused to dress for PE class. His failures to dress for PE resulted in referrals for detention, which he would not serve, leading to Saturday school, which he would not attend. His behavior finally resulted in an in-school suspension. While on in-school suspension, STUDENT was supposed to do his class work, but he would not do so. Therefore, STUDENT’s refusal to dress for PE was resulting in his falling behind in his other classes. The District members of the IEP team proposed transferring STUDENT out of PE to eliminate one of the “stressors” contributing to his failure. MOTHER refused the transfer, but did not propose any other way to address the problems STUDENT was having. MOTHER would not sign the IEP. In fact, MOTHER had refused to sign STUDENT’s IEPs since May 19, 1995, asserting that the IEPs were incomplete. As a result, the IEP team continued to carry over, with minor modifications, goals and objectives that were written in May 1995 because they did not feel comfortable making any major changes to STUDENT’s program without parental approval. (Testimony of Frances Correia.)
On November 19, 1996, STUDENT was caught smoking marijuana on school grounds. Pursuant to the standard procedure for student drug violations, STUDENT was suspended for five days, and the Local School Placement Committee recommended that he be transferred to Savanna High School for the remainder of the school year. Dist. Exh. 11. MOTHER did not send STUDENT back to school after the suspension. An IEP team meeting was held on December 20, 1996. MOTHER was notified of the meeting, but informed the school that she could not attend due to illness. Although she indicated to Marsha Wagner, the assistant principal, that she would call back with another date, she did not do so. (Testimony of Marsha Wagner, Dist. Exh. 12.) At that meeting, the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an LH-SDC at another campus due to his failure in the RSP placement and his recent drug violation. Dist. Exh.12.
On December 3, 1996, MOTHER filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. In January, MOTHER requested home teaching for STUDENT. Dist. Exh. 15. MOTHER provided a letter from STUDENT’s doctor indicating that “STUDENT does need more supervision and resource help. Career planning is also recommended. For the time being, home bound teaching may be beneficial and recommended for STUDENT.” Dist. Exh. 16. STUDENT was approved for home teaching on February 19, 1997, but the District continued to assert that the appropriate placement for STUDENT was an LH-SDC. Dist. Exh. 17, 18. STUDENT’s grade report for the end of the 1996-97 school year indicates that he failed all of his classes. Dist. Exh. 21.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner’s Witness
MOTHER
MOTHER testified that she has been trying to get services to meet STUDENT’s needs for more than five years. In that time, she has consulted many agencies and made compliance complaints against the District. MOTHER testified that the only action that resulted from her compliance complaints was a finding that the District was out of compliance because it held the IEP meeting of December 20, 1996, without MOTHER.
MOTHER stated that STUDENT has not succeeded in any of the programs the District has provided. She said that he received many failing grades in seventh grade. MOTHER testified that his teacher, Mrs. Spiker, said that STUDENT’s failures were due to his “spacing out.” At the end of the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT’s triennial assessment was done. MOTHER stated that the District’s psychologist concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and that he should be transitioned out. MOTHER testified that she thought the first assessment was incomplete because it did not include the parent’s portion of the Vineland test. She stated that the District performed additional tests and prepared an addendum to the assessment report. MOTHER stated that she wanted a “multi-modal” assessment approach, but did not describe what she meant by that term. MOTHER testified that she obtained an assessment from Dr. Shohet after the District conducted its assessment. Dr. Shohet did not charge any fee for the assessment. MOTHER testified that, although there were no written recommendations in Dr. Shohet’s report, Dr. Shohet attended an IEP meeting and recommended that the District address STUDENT’s language processing problems, prepare a behavior plan that calls for a reduction of assignments, change STUDENT’s tasks every ten minutes, use positive reinforcements, prevent detentions, and adjust standardized tests. MOTHER stated that she then requested a behavior analysis, which Jim Miller of the District performed, but nothing was done to follow up on the analysis.
MOTHER testified that she does not believe that all of STUDENT’s problems have been diagnosed. She stated that she thinks that STUDENT may have a seizure disorder and that “batteries of tests” showed left hemisphere brain damage.(Footnote 1) MOTHER asserted that she wants a medical doctor to diagnose her child properly. MOTHER testified that although STUDENT took Ritalin and Dexedrine in the past and the doctor recently prescribed medication for depression, he is not currently taking any medications. MOTHER stated that she requested an AB 3632 referral, but revoked her consent to the assessment when the people from mental health recommended putting STUDENT back on Ritalin.
MOTHER testified that she asked for STUDENT to be put in the RSP classes in ninth grade because she thought he was not performing in the SDC program. She stated that STUDENT wanted to be in the regular education classes, but she did not agree to request that placement. As a compromise, she agreed to ask for STUDENT to be placed in the RSP classes, although she stated she knew he would fail in that placement. She stated that she was willing to let him fail to prove that all of the District’s programs would not work so that she could remove him from District schools. She testified that she did not want to subject her son to the public school system.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT was sick for a while after his suspension in November 1996. She stated that after she requested home teaching in January 1997, STUDENT has been receiving one hour of home instruction about four times per week. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has had a lot of success with this one-on-one assistance and that the home teacher was teaching STUDENT algebra.
MOTHER stated that her son needs one-to-one attention all the time to help him get from one place to another. MOTHER could not identify a specific NPS that she believed was appropriate for STUDENT, nor did she describe the type of school or program she believes he needs. MOTHER did not identify a specific type of “specialist” that STUDENT needed to prepare his IEP, just that it should be someone familiar with learning disabilities, ADD, or any other problems STUDENT is diagnosed as having.
District’s Witnesses Frances Correia Ms. Correia has been a school psychologist with the District for five years. She does not know STUDENT personally, but she was the chair of his IEP meetings when he attended Ball Junior High School. Ms. Correia testified that at the IEP meetings, MOTHER would appear to be in agreement with the individual goals and objectives, but would refuse to sign the IEP at the end of the meeting. Therefore, according to Ms. Correia, the staff carried over the goals each year, with some modifications, because STUDENT’s mother had expressed agreement with them.
Ms. Correia testified that she thought MOTHER believed that the District was “missing something” with STUDENT and that he had not been properly evaluated. She stated that the IEP team made every effort to address her concerns. Ms. Correia stated that she did not believe that STUDENT needed a Hughes Bill assessment or plan, but STUDENT did receive behavior specialist services and had behavior goals in his IEP.
Ms. Correia testified about the District’s Exhibit 26, stating that the IEP document was used each year, and that the IEP team made changes on the document instead of preparing a new document. However, for each meeting a new final page, with signatures, was prepared. Dist. Exh. 27.
Donna Erickson Ms. Erickson has been a school psychologist with the District for one year. She served as a paid intern with the District during the 1994-95 school year and was supervised by school psychologist Dr. Joyce Fancher. Ms. Erickson assessed STUDENT in 1995 because he was due for his triennial assessment. After she prepared her initial report, she performed some additional tests on STUDENT at his mother’s request and prepared an addendum to her report. Dr. Fancher reviewed and approved both the report and the addendum. Ms. Erickson stated that she wanted to ensure that the parent was happy with the assessment process. She testified that STUDENT’s problems are not so complex that the District personnel could not adequately assess him.
Ms. Erickson testified that STUDENT did not qualify for special education as a child with a specific learning disability because there was not a difference of more that one-and-one-half standard deviations between his achievement and ability scores. Ms. Erickson testified that she used the intra-discrepancy model to come to this conclusion. Because STUDENT is African-American, she could not use standard IQ tests pursuant to the Larry P. v. Riley decision. This model is a method of comparing various achievement tests to determine if there is a discrepancy between achievement and ability.
Jim Miller Mr. Miller has been employed by the District as a behavioral specialist for seven years. Before becoming a behavior specialist, Mr. Miller was a special education teacher for severely handicapped children. Mr. Miller has worked in the field of education for twenty-three years. Mr. Miller’s duties include acting as the behavior intervention case manager for certain students. He also performs Hughes Bill functional assessments and writes behavioral intervention plans.
Mr. Miller stated that he assessed STUDENT by observing his behavior in class when STUDENT was at Ball Junior High School. Mr. Miller testified that the target behavior for his observation of STUDENT was inattention, or gazing off into space. Mr. Miller observed STUDENT more than once, and on each occasion, he observed the target behavior. According to Mr. Miller, when STUDENT became inattentive, he would stare into space and appear to be unaffected by background noises. Mr. Miller stated that this behavior did not appear to be linked to any persons or events in STUDENT’s environment. Mr. Miller testified that he described his observations to the IEP team, but the team did not seek a full functional behavior assessment or intervention plan.
David E. Smith Mr. Smith has been an RSP teacher at Loara High School since 1985 and is the chair of the special education department at Loara. He testified that he attended the September 1996 IEP meeting at which STUDENT was placed in RSP classes. According to Mr. Smith, STUDENT was given the maximum load of RSP classes allowed, and the team agreed to review his progress at the end of the first quarter.
Mr. Smith testified that STUDENT was failing three classes and barely passing the others by the end of the quarter. The IEP team believed that STUDENT’s problems in PE were a major factor in his other failures and recommended transferring him out of PE to give him a chance to succeed in his other classes. Mr. Smith testified that MOTHER refused to take STUDENT out of PE.
Mr. Smith stated that at the IEP meeting of December 20, 1997, the IEP team recommended placing STUDENT in the LH-SDC program again because they believed that STUDENT was having some success in his special education classes, but was unable to function in his mainstream classes. According to Mr. Smith, STUDENT is not a self-starter and needs a push to begin a task. Mr. Smith believed that the LH-SDC program was the appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Mr. Smith testified that the IEP team continued the goals and objectives set while STUDENT was at Ball because they were still current. The IEP team planned to review them in November 1996.
Don Popovich Mr. Popovich has been an RSP teacher with the District for five years and was a learning handicapped specialist for ten years before that. Mr. Popovich taught STUDENT RSP English and RSP science. Mr. Popovich testified that STUDENT was tardy for most of his first period classes (English), but usually arrived at his third period class (science) on time.
According to Mr. Popovich, STUDENT needed a lot of one-on-one attention and did not work well on his own. Mr. Popovich tried using small groups with STUDENT, one-on-one instruction, and assigning small tasks. Mr. Popovich stated that he thought STUDENT was unwilling to do the work; he could do it, but only when the teacher was right there with him. Mr. Popovich testified that the more classes STUDENT missed due to his problems with PE and other absences, the more trouble he had with his work. However, Mr. Popovich did not agree with taking STUDENT out of PE because there were no other options presented. Mr. Popovich testified that at the October 1996 IEP meeting he asked MOTHER what she did to motivate STUDENT, but he did not get an answer from her other than “I work with my son.”
Mr. Popovich stated that he believed STUDENT needed a more self-contained program, such as the LH-SDC recommended at the December 1996 IEP meeting.
Marsha Wagner Ms. Wagner has been the assistant principal at Loara High School for one year. Before coming to Loara, Ms. Wagner was a principal at another District school for five years. Her duties include handling discipline for all students with last names beginning with A through G. She handled STUDENT’s disciplinary referrals and attended some of his IEP meetings.
Ms. Wagner testified that STUDENT’s discipline problems involved defiance of authority, such as refusing to dress for PE and refusing to serve detentions. STUDENT’s defiance was passive, not aggressive. Ms. Wagner stated that STUDENT’s mother thought that detention was not useful for STUDENT and that it was the school’s responsibility to get STUDENT to attend Saturday school, not hers. Ms. Wagner testified that she did not believe that STUDENT was being punished for his disability. She stated that STUDENT knew what was expected of him in PE, but refused to do it; STUDENT was not punished for an inability to perform in PE. Often STUDENT would suit up for PE; only about five of his disciplinary referrals were for PE nonsuits. Ms. Wagner also testified that STUDENT would not do his work while he was on on-campus suspension.
Ms. Wagner described the drug incident, stating that STUDENT admitted that he had shared a joint with about six other boys. As a result, the Local School Placement Committee, of which Ms. Wagner is a member, recommended that STUDENT be transferred to another campus. Ms. Wagner stated that she met with MOTHER to discuss the proposed transfer, and that MOTHER did not agree to it. Ms. Wagner said that STUDENT never returned to school after his five-day suspension ended.
Ms. Wagner testified that she spoke with MOTHER the night before the December 1996 IEP meeting, and MOTHER told her that she could not come because of an illness and that she would call Ms. Wagner with an alternative date. Ms. Wagner stated that MOTHER did not call with another IEP meeting date, so they held the meeting without her. At that meeting, the team determined that STUDENT was not functioning in the RSP program. Ms. Wagner stated that his teachers said that STUDENT seemed bright at times, and at others did not seem to process anything. STUDENT had problems focusing and being organized, which Ms. Wagner stated are skills essential to success in RSP classes. According to Ms. Wagner, one reason STUDENT did not succeed in PE was that it did not have enough structure, so STUDENT “got lost.”
Barry Escoe Dr. Escoe is the director of special youth services for the District. He has served in that position for about a year. Before taking that position, Dr. Escoe was the principal of Loara High School and has been employed by the District for about twenty-nine years.
Dr. Escoe was aware of the proposal to transfer STUDENT from Loara and of the fact that STUDENT was placed on home teaching. Dr. Escoe testified that he believed that the home teaching assignment was a temporary one, and that STUDENT should be in an LH-SDC class. Dr. Escoe testified that the District has behavior specialists and school psychologists that are capable of properly evaluating STUDENT and designing a program for him.
DISCUSSION
1. Is a nonpublic school (NPS) the appropriate school placement for STUDENT?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq.; Amendments to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), P.L. 105-17. Pursuant to P.L. 105-17, § 602(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” P.L. 105-17, § 602(25). In addition, special education services must be provided in the least restrictive environment. P.L. 105-17, § 612(a)(5); California Education Code § 56031.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley court’s interpretation of the IDEA provide the following four factors for analyzing whether a placement is appropriate for STUDENT:
1. whether the placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; 2. whether the placement conforms to STUDENT’s IEP;
3. whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; and 4. whether the placement is the least restrictive environment.
The Petitioner has not proposed a specific NPS for STUDENT, or even a general type of program that the NPS would offer. The Hearing Officer cannot make a finding that a generic, undefined NPS is the appropriate placement for STUDENT. However, the District filed a cross-action that was consolidated with this case in which the issue presented for hearing was to determine an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT. The District has proposed an LH-SDC on a District High School campus as being appropriate for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will determine if, based on the factors described above, an LH-SDC is an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
1. Is the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
Many witnesses, including MOTHER, have testified that STUDENT needs a lot of structure and one-on-one attention to succeed. (Testimony of MOTHER, Correia, Smith, Popovich, Wagner.) STUDENT’s goals and objectives identify needs in areas of reading comprehension, math computation, written language, and work habits. Dist. Exh. 26. The evidence also established that STUDENT had difficulty with the responsibilities involved in moving from class to class in a high school environment (tardiness, not bringing materials). Although MOTHER argued that STUDENT has some yet-undiagnosed brain disorder, she provided no evidence to support that assertion. In fact, there is evidence from her own doctor that indicates that such problems have already been ruled out. Dist. Exh. 16.
The District did not put on any evidence about the specific program it was proposing for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer has no information regarding the structure of the program offered, the academic curriculum, the teacher, the class size, or even the site of the proposed LH -SDC. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot find that an LH-SDC would meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, based on the evidence about the general type of program STUDENT needs and his failure in the high school RSP program, the Hearing Officer does find that STUDENT needs to have most of his classes taught in a single classroom, with a small class size. The curriculum should address STUDENT’s reading comprehension, math computation and written language deficits.
2. Does the placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT does not have a current, signed IEP, and he has not had one for some time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot make a finding that the LH-SDC placement conforms to STUDENT’s IEP. However, the inability to make that finding does not make the LH-SDC inappropriate. Rather, the IEP team will have to convene to draft an IEP that reflects what the Hearing Officer determines to be the appropriate placement.
3. Is the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
STUDENT was failing half of his courses and had no grades above D by the end of the first quarter of the 1996-97 school year and had failed all of them by the end of the year because of his lack of attendance. When STUDENT was in the SDC program in junior high, he earned mostly B’s and C’s, and failed only four classes out of fourteen attempted, with three of the failed classed appearing to be regular education classes (Beginning Woodwinds, Beginning Art, and DS 3D). Although there is evidence of STUDENT’s past success in an LH-SDC in junior high school, there is no information regarding the LH-SDC being proposed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot find that the LH-SDC proposed would provide educational benefit.
4. Is the placement the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?
Pursuant to P.L. 105-97, § 612(a)(5), the District must ensure that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities ... are educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
See also Education Code § 56001(g); 56031, 56364.
The District attempted to serve STUDENT in a less restrictive environment during the 1996-97 school year, and STUDENT was unable to succeed in that environment. Many witnesses have testified that STUDENT needs structure and a low student-teacher ratio to keep him on task. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT cannot be served satisfactorily in an environment less restrictive than a segregated class on a regular school campus. However, without evidence regarding the structure of the LH-SDC proposed, the Hearing Officer cannot find that the LH-SDC proposed is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
Although the Hearing Officer cannot find that the LH-SDC class proposed is the appropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer is not finding that it is an inappropriate placement. The IEP team must meet and determine if a specific LH-SDC at a District high school campus would provide the appropriate structure, class size, and academic program for STUDENT.
2. Should the District be required to apologize to STUDENT for its negligence and the mental anguish it caused STUDENT?
This issue is beyond the jurisdiction of the Hearing Officer and seeks a remedy the Hearing Officer cannot order, even if it were warranted. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denies the remedy sought by this issue.
3. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational evaluation at District expense?
California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency and the assessment completed by the educational agency is inappropriate. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for an independent evaluation.
For the District’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. California Education Code § 56324(a).
The testimony established that MOTHER did not agree with the assessment the District performed in May 1995, even after it was supplemented at her request. MOTHER did not object that the evaluation was discriminatory. MOTHER appeared to believe that the assessor was not qualified to perform the evaluation and objected that certain portions of assessments were not performed. In response to her objections, the District assessor conducted additional assessments and prepared an addendum to the report. With respect to the assessor’s qualifications, although Ms. Erickson was an intern psychologist at the time she performed the assessment, she was working under the supervision of Dr. Fancher, the school psychologist. Ms. Erickson testified that Dr. Fancher reviewed and approved her report before it became final. The evidence also establishes that in July 1995 MOTHER obtained an independent educational evaluation performed by Dr. Shohet. MOTHER is not seeking reimbursement for that evaluation. In fact, she testified that Dr. Shohet performed the evaluation at no cost. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s disabilities have changed so that he would require a new evaluation at this time. STUDENT’s next triennial assessment is due in May 1998. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need an independent educational evaluation at District expense.
4. Does STUDENT need a behavioral specialist to develop a behavioral intervention plan for him?
Under California law, a student requires a formal behavioral intervention plan developed by a behavioral specialist when the student “exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” 5 CCR § 3001(f). A “serious behavior problem” is defined as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” 5 CCR § 3001(y).
Although STUDENT’s disciplinary history includes an assault on another student and possession of a knife, those incidents occurred in November 1994 and January 1996 respectively. STUDENT does not have a history of repeated violence, property damage, or self-injury. Most of his discipline is a result of passive defiance of authority. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have a serious behavior problem that would require a separate written behavioral intervention plan document. The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT’s behavior problems can be addressed by including behavioral goals and objectives in his IEP, such as the work habits objectives that have been part of his IEP in the past.
5. Does STUDENT need a “specialist” to write his IEP?
An IEP must be written by an IEP team. California Education Code § 56345(a). The IEP team must include an administrator, the student’s teacher, and the parents. The team may also include other individuals who possess expertise or knowledge necessary to develop the IEP. Education Code § 56341. Therefore, the law does not require the IEP to be written by a single person, whether or not that person is a “specialist.”
The District provided ample evidence that STUDENT’s IEP team included the necessary participants. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a single “specialist” to write his IEP.
ORDER
1. The appropriate placement for STUDENT shall include having most of his classes taught in a single classroom, a small class size, and a curriculum that addresses STUDENT’s reading comprehension, math computation and written language deficits.
2. STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet within fifteen calendar days of the date of this order to determine the appropriate placement for STUDENT and prepare an IEP setting forth current goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year, including behavioral goals and objectives.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the District prevailed on all issues presented for hearing.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: August 4, 1997 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Contrary to MOTHER’s assertion that there may be an undiagnosed seizure disorder or brain damage, the letter from her own doctor supporting home teaching states that another doctor “ruled out seizures” in February 1997, and that STUDENT’s EEG is normal. Dist. Exh. 16.
