California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 14, 2001

Student v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1313-99, SN-1313-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Manhattan Beach Unified must reimburse Utah residential treatment costs and half of boarding school costs for a student found emotionally disturbed.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (1 in part)Vanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's parents filed for due process against Manhattan Beach Unified School District. The student is a bright 16-year-old eleventh grader who had never been found eligible for special education. In eighth grade, during 1997-1998, her grades, behavior, and mood declined sharply. In July 1998 her parents placed her at Sorenson's Ranch, a residential treatment program in Utah. In January 2000 they moved her to the Oakley School, a private therapeutic boarding school in Utah. The district assessed her after the parents asked in October 1998, and it found her not eligible.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found the student eligible as emotionally disturbed. She showed inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances and a pervasive mood of depression. Both lasted a long time, were marked, and harmed her schoolwork. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to treating therapists than to the district's assessor, who wrongly required bizarre or psychotic behavior. The district also failed its "search and serve" duty. Staff knew about her falling grades and emotional problems in 1997-1998 but never referred her for assessment. Sorenson's Ranch was an appropriate placement, so the district must reimburse those costs, up to $62,872.77, subject to proof. The evidence did not show she needed a boarding placement at Oakley. But because the district offered nothing, it must pay half of Oakley's costs, about $965 a month. The district must also hold an IEP meeting within 20 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the emotional disturbance criteria. It held that "inappropriate behavior or feelings" does not require bizarre or psychotic behavior, and it gave weight to long-term treating therapists. It also shows search-and-serve liability when staff knew of a decline and did not refer, and how equitable considerations led to partial reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Has STUDENT met special education eligibility as a student with an emotional disturbance since the 1997-1998 school year?

    Student met emotional disturbance criteria by July 1998: she showed inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances and a general pervasive mood of depression, over a long period and to a marked degree, which hurt her educational performance and required services beyond a modified regular program. She did not meet the interpersonal-relationships criterion. The district assessor wrongly required bizarre or psychotic behavior, and the treating therapists were more persuasive.

  2. Issue 2. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placements they procured for STUDENT beginning in July 1998 and continuing to the date of the decision?

    The district failed its search and serve (child find) duty in 1997-1998. Sorenson's Ranch was an appropriate residential placement, so the district must reimburse its costs in full. An out-of-state boarding placement at Oakley was not shown to be necessary, but because the district offered no program, it must pay half of Oakley's costs on equitable grounds. The prevailing-party section says Student prevailed on Sorenson's Ranch and 'substantially prevailed' on Oakley.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to reflect the finding that the student meets special education criteria because of an emotional disturbance.
  • The IEP team must develop a legally sufficient IEP with present levels of performance, annual goals, and benchmarks or objectives. It must offer placement and services designed to meet the student's current needs and develop a plan to transition the student to an appropriate placement and services within the District.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the costs of Sorenson's Ranch, including tuition, required parent visits, and a home visit, not to exceed the father's calculations in Petitioner's Exhibit 32 ($62,872.77 per the findings: $59,470 board, tuition and services; $2,902.77 for five required parent visits; $500 for a home visit).
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof (receipts or canceled checks) from the parents, the District must reimburse one-half of the costs of tuition at the Oakley School from January 2000 to the date of the decision. The findings set this as $965 per month.

Total: $62,872.77 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300-56302; 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c)

People named in the decision

  • Linda Jones, director of pupil personnel services, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Matthew Wunder, middle school advisor, Manhattan Beach Middle/Intermediate School
  • Melinda Decker, physical education teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Ro Schreiner, social science teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Kevin Post, English teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Ralph Ford, computers teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Ms. Post, teacher (testified student appeared unhappy and moody), Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Ms. Doll, teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
  • Jack Schnel, Ed.D., clinical and educational psychologist; District assessor, Private practice; part-time with Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
  • Teri Solochek, Ph.D., independent assessor; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Barbara Stapleford, LCSW, private counselor, Private
  • Alann D. Dingle, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; private therapist, South Bay Youth Project
  • Michael Ballue, substance abuse treatment provider, Peninsula Recovery Center
  • Peter Ampudia, M.D., treating physician, Del Amo
  • Andrea Fuller, MFT, former clinical director and primary therapist; witness for Student, Sorenson's Ranch (now director of Crater Lake School)
  • Shane Sorenson, director, Sorenson's Ranch
  • Elizabeth Cazier, registrar and academic advisor, Sorenson's Ranch
  • Arch Egbert, advisor and counselor, Oakley School
  • W. Dean Belnap, M.D., child psychiatrist and behavioral pediatrician; medical director, Oakley School
  • James Meyer, witness describing the Oakley program, Oakley School
  • Sorenson's Ranch, private residential treatment program (Utah)
  • Oakley School, private therapeutic college preparatory boarding school (Utah)
  • Del Amo, private psychiatric facility
  • Los Angeles County Mental Health, county mental health agency (declined to assess)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Manhattan Beach, California, on April 27 and 28, August 16, September 14, and December 12 and 13, 2000.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Jodi F. Ossen Bynder. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were STUDENT’s parents. Respondent Manhattan Beach Unified School District (District) was represented on the first four days of hearing by attorney Sharon Watt. On the last two days of hearing, the District was represented by attorney Nancy Stephens. Also present on behalf of the District at the beginning of the hearing was Linda Jones, director of pupil personnel services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Has STUDENT met special education eligibility as a student with an emotional disturbance since the 1997-1998 school year?

(2) Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placements they procured for STUDENT beginning in July 1998 and continuing to the date of the decision?(Footnote 1)

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a 16-year-old student in the eleventh grade. She has never been found eligible for special education. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was attending the Oakley School, a private therapeutic college preparatory boarding school in Utah. STUDENT’s parents enrolled STUDENT in the Oakley School following a stay of 17 months at Sorenson’s Ranch, a residential treatment program, also in Utah.

PARENTS adopted STUDENT when she was two days old. STUDENT’s developmental history is unremarkable. From kindergarten through the third grade, STUDENT attended American Martyrs School, a private parochial school. From grades four through six, STUDENT attended Grand View Elementary School in the District. STUDENT’s parents described her as “loving, bright, articulate, and socially involved” while in elementary school. She also received good grades commensurate with her above-average cognitive abilities. STUDENT transitioned to Manhattan Beach Intermediate School for the seventh and eighth grades.

STUDENT’s parents report that STUDENT changed remarkably while in the eighth grade during the 1997-1998 school year. Following the death of a friend’s mother in October 1997 and her grandmother’s diagnosis and ultimate death from cancer, STUDENT began sleeping excessively. On other occasions, she would stay up all night. STUDENT would not follow limit-setting at home. She acted defiantly toward her parents and stayed out all night. STUDENT engaged in promiscuous behavior with boys unknown to her parents. At school, STUDENT’s grades fluctuated and she had many conflicts with her physical education (PE) teacher. She also was disciplined for wearing provocative clothing and being tardy to school. STUDENT had emotional outbursts at school that on at least one occasion, resulted in MOTHER’s having to pick up STUDENT from school because she was unconsolable.

In February 1998, STUDENT told her parents that she had a drug problem. The PARENTS sought counseling from Barbara Stapleford, LCSW. The adoption agency referred the PARENTS to Ms. Stapleford. Matthew Wunder, Manhattan Beach Middle School advisor, also referred the PARENTS to the South Bay Youth Project, where STUDENT saw Alann Dingle, Ph.D., for counseling. In April 1998, while in the girl’s restroom at school, STUDENT took an unknown quantity of Zoloft, an antidepressant, in an apparent suicide attempt. When confronted by her parents, she ran away from home for the entire weekend. Mr. Wunder then recommended that the PARENTS take STUDENT to Peninsula Recovery Center for substance abuse treatment. STUDENT participated in treatment with Michael Ballue from May to July 1998. However, STUDENT apparently took drugs and again ran away from home. Her parents found her four days later at a house with four boys. Thereafter, the PARENTS hospitalized STUDENT at Del Amo, a psychiatric facility. STUDENT remained at Del Amo for 11 days. On the advice of Del Amo, STUDENT was discharged on July 25, 1998, to Sorenson’s Ranch in Utah. Sorenson’s Ranch is a working ranch that provides a residential treatment program for students who have not been successful in their comprehensive high school programs.

In October 1998, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District assess STUDENT for special education. The District prepared an assessment plan for the parents’ approval and requested a concurrent assessment by Los Angeles County Mental Health (Mental Health). On November 19, 1998, the parents consented to the District’s proposed assessment plan and, in December 1998, Jack Schnel, Ed.D., assessed STUDENT at Sorenson’s Ranch. Dr. Schnel is a clinical and educational psychologist in private practice. He also holds a part-time position with the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District. In December 1998, the parents obtained an independent assessment from Teri Solochek, Ph.D.(Footnote 2)

On January 15, 1999, the individualized educational program (IEP) team met and reviewed the results of Dr. Schnel’s assessment. District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education as emotionally disturbed (ED). Also on January 15, 1999, Mental Health notified the District that it would not be assessing STUDENT because she was not then eligible for special education. The PARENTS disagreed with the findings of the District members of the IEP team and requested a due process hearing to resolve the issue of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education.

In August 1999, STUDENT’s parents obtained a second independent assessment from Dr. Solochek. Dr. Solochek continued to recommend that STUDENT receive therapeutic intervention. However, she concluded that STUDENT would benefit from placement in a “transitional boarding program” rather than returning to her home upon release from Sorenson’s Ranch. In January 2000, STUDENT transferred from Sorenson’s Ranch to Oakley, a private therapeutic college preparatory boarding school in Utah. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT’s parents continued to fund STUDENT’s attendance at Oakley.

Petitioner contends that during the 1997-1998 school year the District should have identified her as eligible for special education because of an emotional disturbance. Petitioner asserts that her parents repeatedly contacted school personnel regarding STUDENT’s declining school performance and worsening emotional state. However, the District neither referred her for special education nor assessed her until November 1998. Petitioner asserts that because the District failed to identify her as eligible for special education and to provide her with a special education placement and services, her parents have had to procure private placements to address her special education needs. Petitioner further asserts that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at Sorenson’s Ranch and Oakley as compensatory educational services.

The District contends that at no time has Petitioner met eligibility criteria for special education because of an ED. The District asserts that Petitioner has always done well in school and does not have social or emotional problems that rise to the level of an ED. For this reason, the District asserts that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Petitioner’s attending private placements.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Has STUDENT met special education eligibility as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) since the 1997-1998 school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE).(Footnote 3) 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d) (1997) (formerly found at 20 U.S.C. §1400(c)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(3)(A)(1997)( formerly found at 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(a)(1)(A)). A student is eligible for special education and services when, as a result of the student’s disability, the student requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b).

Serious Emotional Disturbance (ED) Eligibility Criteria

A student meets eligibility criteria as ED when he/she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:

(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. Tit.5 § 3030(i).

The student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED if the student is socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that the student has a serious emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(ii).

Petitioner contends that she meets ED eligibility under three of the categories above because she has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations, and exhibits a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

Petitioner asserts that her relationships with other students and staff at Manhattan Beach Middle School, Sorenson’s Ranch, and the Oakley School have been unsatisfactory. The District asserts that Petitioner is able to make and sustain friendships with peers, and is able to get along well with teachers.

Petitioner’s parents testified that STUDENT’s peer group changed during the eighth grade and that the people she “hung out” with were not known to the family. For example, on one occasion when STUDENT ran away, MOTHER found her with people STUDENT described as friends although they were unknown to MOTHER. However, MOTHER testified that she picked up STUDENT from a familiar friend’s house on another occasion. MOTHER expressed concern about the quality of STUDENT’s new friends who apparently were involved in taking illegal drugs. MOTHER testified that STUDENT also had difficulty getting along with her teachers. MOTHER recalled a number of conversations with school personnel regarding STUDENT’s difficulties, particularly with the physical education (PE) teacher. MOTHER stated that she also met with STUDENT’s Spanish teacher because of concerns regarding her school performance. Dr. Solochek, who assessed STUDENT at the request of her parents, concurs with STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT’s selection of friends has been questionable and not always in her best interest.

The picture of STUDENT while attending Manhattan Beach Middle School is that of a social student with friends. The testimony of Manhattan Beach teachers establishes that STUDENT had friends at school and maintained satisfactory relationships with at least some of her teachers. Matthew Wunder, STUDENT’s school advisor in the eighth grade, testified that friends and having a “social life” were important for STUDENT. STUDENT’s seventh and eighth grade teachers (Melinda Decker, physical education, Ro Schreiner, social science, Kevin Post, English, and Ralph Ford, computers) testified that STUDENT was social and got along well with peers in their classes. They also observed STUDENT to have friends outside of the classroom during nutrition break, lunch, and after school. As to relationships with teachers, Mr. Wunder testified that if STUDENT liked a teacher, they got along wonderfully. However, if STUDENT did not like a teacher, she would engage in a power struggle with the teacher. In particular, numerous witnesses testified that STUDENT had ongoing difficulties with her physical education teacher in the eighth grade. Mr. Post stated that STUDENT “tolerated” him. The remaining teachers generally described STUDENT’s relationships with them as “normal.”

Andrea Fuller, marriage family therapist (MFT), formerly served as Sorenson’s Ranch clinical director and as STUDENT’s primary therapist.(Footnote 4) Ms. Fuller described STUDENT’s relationships with female students at Sorenson’s Ranch as “contentious” and her relationships with male students as “sexualized and self-destructive.” On the other hand, Shane Sorenson testified while he questioned STUDENT’s selection of friends, she did have peer relationships and established some positive relationships with teachers while at Sorenson’s Ranch. Mr. Sorenson is the director of Sorenson’s Ranch and holds a Master’s degree in psychology.

As to STUDENT’s relationships at Oakley, Arch Egbert, STUDENT’s advisor, generally characterized STUDENT’s peer and teacher relationships as “poor.”(Footnote 5) However, it is reported that STUDENT presently has a boyfriend.

The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers and others who have worked with STUDENT establishes that she does not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. STUDENT’s friends may not be in STUDENT’s best interest from the perspective of her parents or therapists. However, the fact that STUDENT has developed peer relationships while attending school at Manhattan Beach, Sorenson’s Ranch, and Oakley, presently has a boyfriend, and also has had positive relationships with some teachers establishes that she does not meet ED eligibility under category one.

Does STUDENT exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations?

Petitioner asserts that running away, engaging in sexually provocative behavior, using drugs, arriving at school late, and failing to complete school work are examples of inappropriate behavior she engaged in while at Manhattan Beach Middle School and Sorenson’s Ranch. Additionally, she also exhibited inappropriate behavior including outbursts of profanity and excessive anger, defensiveness, and highly emotional responses to normal circumstances while attending Manhattan Beach Middle School, Sorenson’s Ranch, and Oakley. The District asserts that STUDENT has not engaged in any bizarre or outrageous behavior that would make her eligible under the ED category above.

Petitioner’s witnesses, including her parents and therapists, described the following inappropriate types of behavior or feelings that STUDENT has exhibited under normal circumstances: excessive emotional responses, highly sexually provocative behavior, inappropriate sexual relations, perceptions of rejection, and impulsivity. As to STUDENT’s excessive emotional responses, witnesses including MOTHER, described STUDENT’s loss of emotional control during the 1997-1998 school year. MOTHER recounted being called to pick up STUDENT from Manhattan Beach Middle School because STUDENT was sobbing and unconsolable. Other witnesses who treated STUDENT in a therapeutic setting supported STUDENT’s assertion that she demonstrated inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances while attending Manhattan Beach Middle School. A letter from Alann D. Dingle, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, states that STUDENT had chronic feelings of emptiness and abandonment. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 6.) Dr. Dingle treated STUDENT in the spring of 1998. A letter from Michael Ballue of the Peninsula Recovery Center describes STUDENT’s lack of self-control. Mr. Ballue treated STUDENT from May to July 1998. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 8.) During testimony, Dr. Solochek described STUDENT’s behavior when STUDENT was required to wait in the doctor’s office prior to testing. Dr. Solochek first spoke with MOTHER. When she called STUDENT to begin testing, STUDENT was described as “extremely” upset and unable to participate in testing on that date. Dr. Solochek’s testing supported observations made by teachers and parents of STUDENT’s difficulty responding to feelings and coping, and tendency to be impulsive. STUDENT’s scores on the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) showed STUDENT to be emotionally reactive, sensitive to criticism, and lacking in solid resolution skills. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.)

When testifying, STUDENT’s teachers and advisor in the District did not recall STUDENT engaging in bizarre or unusual behavior. However, their answers to questions contained in a teacher’s response form used by Dr. Schnel in his assessment of STUDENT indicated several areas of concern. Areas marked by teachers or Mr. Wunder as “very true or often true” included the following: demands a lot of attention; feels worthless or inferior; apathetic or unmotivated; feels hurt when criticized; stubborn, sullen, or irritable; temper tantrums or hot temper; seems preoccupied with sex; and overly anxious to please (boys). (Petitioner’s Exhibits 17-21.) Additionally, Mr. Wunder was so concerned about STUDENT that he recommended that the parents seek personal counseling for STUDENT outside the school environment. Mr. Wunder testified that he first referred STUDENT for personal counseling and then recommended her for addiction counseling. Mr. Wunder, testified that while STUDENT was attending Manhattan Beach Middle School, she wore sexually provocative clothing. Her clothes were tight and revealing. She also engaged in sexual relations with older boys. STUDENT was then thirteen years old. Mr. Wunder testified that STUDENT’s engaging in unsafe sexual activity constituted inappropriate behavior. He also was aware of STUDENT’s strong emotional responses.

Dr. Schnel, who assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District while she was attending Sorenson’s Ranch, testified that STUDENT has not exhibited odd, strange, or unusual behavior. She also has not exhibited signs of hallucinations or delusions. Dr. Schnel testified that STUDENT does not meet the above ED criteria because her behavior is “societally inappropriate but not bizarre or unusual.” Ms. Fuller also testified regarding STUDENT’s behavior while attending Sorenson’s Ranch. Ms. Fuller stated that STUDENT removed her clothing in public areas and in the boys’ restroom, and aggressively sought sexual contact. Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT later would cry and say that she had not planned her behavior and would not do it again. Ms. Fuller concluded that STUDENT’s sexual behavior was to gain acceptance and to connect with another person. Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT has a strong perception of rejection. Ms. Fuller stated that even in therapeutic situations, STUDENT perceived discussions of her behavior as a rejection of her. According to Ms. Fuller, STUDENT also viewed setting limits as an attack on her. Ms. Fuller testified that while at Sorenson’s Ranch, STUDENT would burst into tears and have angry outbursts. She also would withdraw, sulk, and pout. Ms. Fuller and others testified that STUDENT’s actions were not volitional.

Mr. Egbert described another concern regarding STUDENT’s emotional status while at Oakley. He testified that when STUDENT speaks of events that would normally evoke tears or sadness, such as the death of her grandmother, she has a flat effect.

There was no persuasive evidence that to satisfy the ED criterion number two–inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances–STUDENT must manifest bizarre, hallucinatory, psychotic, or delusional behavior, as Dr. Schnel testified. In concluding that STUDENT does not meet this criterion, Dr. Schnel apparently relied on interpretation of the ED criterion and improperly gave the interpretation the effect of law. Thus, Dr. Schnel drew conclusions based on erroneous requirements. Moreover, when compared to that of Ms. Fuller, in particular, Dr. Schnel has relatively limited knowledge of STUDENT. Dr. Schnel’s conclusions were based on testing, observations for a brief period, and discussions with some of STUDENT’s teachers, whereas Ms. Fuller was engaged in an ongoing therapeutic relationship with STUDENT. Ms. Fuller also had the opportunity to observe STUDENT in her therapeutic environment and to discuss her functioning with teachers at Sorenson’s Ranch. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Fuller’s testimony more persuasive as to STUDENT’s meeting the ED criterion above. Additionally, Ms. Fuller’s testimony is supported by Dr. Solochek’s testing and the observations of those treating STUDENT the prior school year. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT meets criterion for ED because of behavior or feelings that are inappropriate under normal circumstances. The observations of STUDENT’s teachers and treating mental health therapists establish that these behaviors existed while attending Manhattan Beach Middle School and the testimony of Ms. Fuller establishes that the inappropriate behaviors continued at Sorenson’s Ranch.

Does STUDENT exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?

Petitioner asserts that she meets ED criteria because of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. The District asserts that Petitioner’s sadness is situational and is not pervasive.

As to Petitioner’s assertion that she was depressed while attending Manhattan Middle School, Petitioner relied on the testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Solochek, and on reports prepared by therapists STUDENT saw during the 1997-1998 school year. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was depressed following the death of a friend’s mother. She also exhibited depression following her grandmother’s death in the spring of 1998. STUDENT’s depression was manifested by extended periods of sleeping at home. MOTHER testified that STUDENT also exhibited signs of depression at school and attempted suicide by taking an unknown quantity of Zoloft, an antidepressant. MOTHER further testified that she found a letter written by STUDENT on January 9, 1998, in which STUDENT expressed her feelings of depression. In pertinent part, STUDENT’s letter reads as follows:

I feel really depressed. I don’t know so many bad things are happening to me I feel so used by everyone I feel like someone could say one more mean thing to me and I would just go off and not be able to take it. . . Its not just like I have one bad day anymore its like every day I have a bad day. I just sit down and cry for no reason I mean I could break a pencil and cry. I don’t know sometimes I feel like I don’t want to go on . . .

(Petitioner’s Exhibit 29.)

MOTHER’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s depression is supported by documents submitted by the mental health therapists who treated STUDENT in the spring and summer of 1998. In a letter dated October 7, 1998, Alann Dingle, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, stated that during the course of therapy he provided for STUDENT, her “symptoms of depression intensified.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.) Dr. Dingle saw STUDENT for 15 individual therapy sessions and three family sessions in the spring of 1998. In July 1998, STUDENT was hospitalized at Del Amo. Medical records from STUDENT’s 11-day stay at Del Amo are contained in Petitioner’s Exhibits 2-4. Peter Ampudia, M.D., gave STUDENT the diagnosis of depression. The Del Amo records contain the following insightful statements made by STUDENT at the time of her admission to Del Amo:

She has been depressed since she was a small child. She cannot recall the last time that she has felt happy. She states that she feels depressed, sad, worthless, hopeless, helpless and has been having suicidal ideation. She stated that about two months ago she took an overdose of 15 to 20 Zoloft capsules in a suicide attempt, but received no treatment for it. She states that she has been having poor sleep and poor eating, as well. She states that she has been using drugs to try to make herself feel better. She feels estranged from the family and unloved.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.)

Petitioner asserts that her depression persisted at both Sorenson’s Ranch and Oakley despite treatment with medication to alleviate depression. Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT exhibited signs of depression, helplessness, irritability, and hopelessness while attending Sorenson’s Ranch. Mr. Sorenson additionally testified that STUDENT’s sexually acting out was also a sign of her depression. In her report completed in August 1999, Petitioner’s witness, Dr. Solochek, concluded that STUDENT no longer was experiencing significant symptoms of depression. However, because of Ms. Fuller’s ongoing therapeutic relationship with STUDENT at Sorenson’s Ranch, Ms. Fuller’s testimony is more persuasive on this issue than Dr. Solochek’s testimony.

W. Dean Belnap, M.D., testified as to whether STUDENT exhibited depression at Oakley. Dr. Belnap is a child psychiatrist and behavioral pediatrician. Dr. Belnap also is the medical director of Oakley and has met with STUDENT monthly since she entered Oakley. Dr. Belnap testified that STUDENT’s acting out is related to an attentional problem and an underlying psychological disorder of depression. Dr. Belnap’s conclusions were based on reports by Del Amo, Dr. Schnel’s testing (in particular, the results of the Auchenbach and Mellon), and on his own mental status examination of STUDENT. Dr. Belnap, as well as Mr. Egbert, testified that while attending Oakley STUDENT has continued to exhibit signs of depression. According to Mr. Egbert, STUDENT is withdrawn, moody, irritable, lethargic, depressed, exhibits a general mood of unhappiness, and shows a lack of interest in activities in which other students are involved. Mr. Egbert testified that STUDENT’s teachers have reported similar types of behavior.

The District asserts that STUDENT has not and does not suffer from pervasive sadness or depression. Staff at Manhattan Beach Middle School testified that STUDENT does not meet ED criteria because of pervasive depression. However, several teachers noted that STUDENT appeared sad in class. For example, Ms. Post testified that STUDENT appeared unhappy and moody. She noted that she never saw STUDENT smile. Ms. Doll testified that STUDENT appeared quiet on some days. She further stated that “STUDENT’s mood swings were a concern to me. She seemed really up-happy, excited or she seemed down-quiet, almost sullen.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 18.) One teacher described STUDENT’s pulling her knees up to her chest in what could be described as a “fetal position” while seated at her desk on days when she appeared “down.” Mr. Wunder testified that STUDENT at times appeared unhappy and irritable during their discussions.

As to the opinion of District personnel that STUDENT did not appear depressed all of the time and, hence, would not meet ED criteria, the Hearing Officer notes that persons without significant education and training in the field of psychology are not particularly suited to diagnosing depression and may not be aware of the ways in which depression is manifested by adolescents. Ms. Fuller testified that symptoms of depression in adolescents typically are manifested by sleeping difficulties, changes in eating patterns, irritability, acting out behavior, and experiencing a sense of helplessness, hopelessness, or worthlessness. Adolescents may also express suicidal ideation. Dr. Solochek also testified that adolescent depression is manifested by irritability, anger, moodiness, and an “I don’t care attitude.” No one disputed the testimony of Drs. Fuller and Solochek as to symptoms of depression in adolescents or that STUDENT has exhibited these characteristics to some extent. Therefore, the testimony of teachers and their comments made as part of Dr. Schnel’s assessment establish that STUDENT manifested many of the above characteristics while attending Manhattan Beach Middle School.

Dr. Schnel, who is a mental health professional, also testified that STUDENT did not meet ED criteria because of depression. He testified that STUDENT’s sad periods were situational. For example, she was sad when her grandmother was ill and ultimately died. Dr. Schnel testified that it also was expected that STUDENT would feel somewhat depressed while hospitalized at Del Amo since she was attempting sobriety or that she would feel unhappy when she had to pay the consequences for inappropriate behavior.

The Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Schnel’s testimony persuasive, given the testimony of Ms. Fuller, Dr. Solochek, and Dr. Belnap. Ms. Fuller and Dr. Belnap reviewed STUDENT’s medical and educational records and treated STUDENT for extended periods of time. Their testimony is supported by anecdotal records of STUDENT’s behavior while she was attending Manhattan Beach Middle School and the diagnosis of depression by mental health professionals treating STUDENT beginning in the spring of 1998 and continuing to the date of the hearing. The treating mental health professionals based their testimony on their respective ongoing relationships with Petitioner. Dr. Schnel, on the other hand, saw STUDENT for relatively brief periods of testing and observation at Sorenson’s Ranch.

In summary, witnesses persuasively testified to STUDENT’s sadness and depression while she attended Manhattan Beach Middle School, Sorenson’s Ranch, and Oakley. STUDENT herself commented in a letter she wrote in January 1998 and to Del Amo staff that she has been depressed since childhood. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT’s depression is not situational. The Hearing Officer finds that since 1998, STUDENT has suffered from a general mood of sadness or depression that satisfies the ED criterion set forth above

Has STUDENT exhibited characteristics of an ED over a long period of time?

Special education law does not specify a period of time that is necessary to establish a “long period of time.” Some witnesses have testified that a “long period of time” is at least six months. As discussed above, STUDENT wrote a letter expressing her ongoing feelings of depression in January 1998. STUDENT’s impulsivity, provocative dress and sexual activity, and explosive behaviors were documented in the second semester of the 1997-1998. Mental health therapists treating STUDENT in March 1998 clinically identified depression, and in July 1998 STUDENT was hospitalized at Del Amo and given the diagnosis of depression. Additionally, therapists treating STUDENT at Sorenson’s Ranch and Oakley concluded after a review of the records that STUDENT exhibited significant depression at least as early as July 1998. Using six months as a general guideline as to what constitutes a “long period of time,” it is concluded that STUDENT met the two criteria above by July 1998Has STUDENT exhibited these characteristics of an ED to a marked degree?

To meet eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance, STUDENT must have exhibited ED characteristics to a “marked degree.” That is to say, the characteristics must be pervasive and exhibited in more than one environment. STUDENT’s parents testified regarding STUDENT’s defiant and explosive behavior at home in the spring of 1998. They also described her running away from home and not returning for several days. The parents testified that STUDENT’s emotional problems were so severe that she required a residential placement to address her needs because they could not be met in the community where STUDENT was at risk to run away. At school, STUDENT engaged in behavior evidencing an emotional disturbance. Her school attendance and grades were negatively affected. For example, her grade point average (GPA) decreased significantly from the beginning to the end of the 1997-1998 school year. For the first trimester, STUDENT’s GPA was 3.29, which is better than a “B” average. Her GPA for the final trimester was 1.87, which is lower than a C average.(Footnote 6) (See also the following section below regarding STUDENT’s school performance.)

The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s ability to benefit from therapy was affected by the severity of her behavior. For example, therapy provided while STUDENT attended school in Manhattan Beach ended when she ran away from home and engaged in drug use Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT’s “intense inner world made it difficult to deal with the outer world” even six months after arriving at Sorenson’s. As a result, STUDENT stayed longer than expected at Sorenson’s Ranch. The average stay at Sorenson’s Ranch is 10 -12 months, whereas STUDENT stayed 17 months.

The District attributes STUDENT’s problems to either differing parenting styles of her mother and father, conflicts with her parents, or drug use. Ms. Fuller and Dr. Solochek testified that STUDENT’s behavior was too extreme to solely be a result of her home environment. In fact, STUDENT’s depression was so severe that she expressed suicidal ideation and reportedly took excessive amounts of Zoloft in a suicide attempt. Additionally, STUDENT’s problems resulted in an 11-day hospitalization at a psychiatric facility. The difficulties STUDENT continued to experience while in residential placements away from her parents are well documented and also support Petitioner’s assertion that her emotional problems are not solely based on difficulties in the home environment. Dr. Solochek, Dr. Belnap, Ms. Fuller and Mr. Egbert testified that adolescents may abuse drugs in an effort to self medicate. Dr. Schnel did not disagree with Petitioner’s witnesses on this issue. Moreover, drug use does not preclude a finding of eligibility for special education under the category of ED.

Because the evidence establishes that STUDENT exhibited characteristics of an ED in a number of environments–home, school, and therapy–it is concluded that the characteristics were exhibited to a marked degree.

Has STUDENT’s condition adversely affected her educational performance?

To qualify for special education as ED, STUDENT’s inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances and depression must adversely affect her educational performance. 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. tit.5 § 3030(i).

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s emotional condition has adversely affected her educational performance. There is no dispute that STUDENT possesses above average cognitive potential and that she was not achieving to her potential during the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT’s parents testified that STUDENT did not experience difficulty in school until the eighth grade. It is undisputed that up to the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT performed as expected and received “A” and “B” grades. She also did not have significant behavioral problems. As discussed more fully above, STUDENT’s grades dropped significantly during the 1997-1998 school year, particularly following the death of two people in her life. Her marks in citizenship and work habits also deteriorated. For the first trimester of the school year, STUDENT received three each satisfactory (“S”) and outstanding (“O”) marks in citizenship. By the third trimester, STUDENT received some “S” marks. However, she also received marks of needs improvement (“N”) and unsatisfactory (“U”) in other classes. STUDENT’s marks in work habits also declined over the 1997-1998 school year. In the fall, she received Two “O” marks, four “S” marks, and one “N.” For the final trimester, STUDENT received one “N” mark, and two marks of “U.” (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 24.) STUDENT’s school attendance and tardies increased during the 1997-1998 school year.

Additionally, Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT’s education was affected at Sorenson’s Ranch by her emotional problems. At Sorenson’s Ranch, students do not receive credit for classes until they have achieved mastery. Ms. Fuller testified that scores of 90% are necessary to achieve mastery. Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT did not achieve mastery and, hence, did not earn credits at the expected rate. Ms. Fuller stated that it was difficult for STUDENT to work on academics because of her emotional turmoil. The testimony by Oakley staff that STUDENT’s class work is affected by her difficulty maintaining focus also was undisputed.

Does STUDENT require instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program?

STUDENT received counseling from a qualified mental health therapist during the spring of 1998 when she was experiencing difficulty with depression and her school grades were declining. She also participated in a drug rehabilitation program. Mr. Wunder informally counseled STUDENT at school. None of these interventions were sufficient to ameliorate STUDENT’s depression or to improve her school performance. Moreover, mental health services must be provided by an appropriately credentialed or licensed mental health professional. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s mental health needs could be met by a regular education teacher or by modification to her regular education program.

Conclusion

It has been concluded above that STUDENT met two of the ED characteristics above. She exhibits both (1) inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances and (2) a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. She has exhibited these characteristics for a long period of time and to a marked degree. STUDENT’s education has been affected by her condition and she requires services which cannot be provided with modification to the regular school program. Therefore, STUDENT meets special education eligibility because of an emotional disturbance.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placements they procured for STUDENT beginning in 1998 and continuing to the date of the decision?

A district may be required to reimburse parents for the costs of private placements they procured if it is concluded that the district failed to provide the student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in a timely manner prior to enrollment at the private school and the private placement is appropriate. 20 U.S. C.§ 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R § 300.403(c).

Because the District did not find STUDENT met eligibility for special education, it did not provide a FAPE to STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending Sorenson’s Ranch and/or Oakley if it is determined that the private placements were appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. To be appropriate, the services provided by a parent must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the student with educational benefit. Rowley 458 U.S. 176,200. However, parents are not required to provide the “perfect” placement for their children when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161. For purposes of reimbursement, the placement provided by the parent also need not meet every requirement to be appropriate. For example, the placement need not be state-certified as a nonpublic school. Florence County School District Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 14.

Sorenson’s Ranch Residential Treatment Center

STUDENT had not been referred to the District for a special education assessment nor had the District undertaken an assessment of STUDENT prior to her parents enrolling her in Sorenson’s Ranch. Nonetheless, Petitioner’s parents contend that they are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT attending Sorenson’s Ranch for the period beginning on July 25, 1998, because the District failed to fulfill search and serve obligations. The parents assert that the District should have assessed and identified Petitioner as a student eligible for special education because of an emotional disturbance when her grades declined and she exhibited emotional problems at school during the 1997-1998 school year. Additionally, the parents assert that a residential placement was necessary following STUDENT’s hospitalization because she was at risk to run away and other less restrictive therapy had been unsuccessful.

The District contends that it did not have an obligation to assess Petitioner prior to its receipt of a referral for special education from Petitioner’s parents in October 1998. The District asserts that Petitioner did not exhibit behavior or other signs at school warranting a referral for a special education assessment during the 1997-1998 school year.

California Education Code §§ 56300 - 56302 set forth the responsibility of local educational agencies (LEAs) including school districts, county office of educations (COEs), and special education local plan areas (SELPAs), to systematically seek out and identify students with disabilities.(Footnote 7) LEAs must identify, locate, and assess students with disabilities ages 0 through 21 years including children not enrolled in public school programs who are in need of special education and related services. Identification procedures include referrals from teachers, parents, professional persons, and other members of the public.

The evidence discussed in more detail above establishes that the District was aware that STUDENT was experiencing emotional difficulties and that her grades were declining during the 1997-1998 school year. It is concluded that the District had sufficient knowledge to warrant a special education referral. To reiterate, during the course of the school year, MOTHER met with several of STUDENT’s eighth-grade teachers to discuss STUDENT’s fluctuating grades and lack of academic achievement. MOTHER and Mr. Wunder met multiple times (as frequently as two to three times each month.) Additionally, on at least six occasions, STUDENT voluntarily came to Mr. Wunder to discuss various matters of concern to her. On many other occasions, STUDENT and Mr. Wunder met because of STUDENT’s conflicts with her teachers and for other disciplinary matters. It also should be noted that STUDENT attempted suicide at school by ingesting an unknown quantity of Zoloft. Mr. Wunder apparently was so concerned about STUDENT’s mental health that he referred STUDENT and her parents to the South Bay Youth Project for counseling. However, Mr. Wunder did not refer STUDENT to the student study team, which addresses concerns raised by school staff regarding the educational performance or behavior of individual students. He also did not refer STUDENT for a special education assessment. Given the information that was available to the District, it is concluded that the District failed in its search and serve obligations as they related to STUDENT.

To determine whether Sorenson’s Ranch offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is first necessary to have a general understanding of STUDENT’s needs. The evidence discussed above establishes that STUDENT is bright and can benefit from instruction in the regular education curriculum. She requires mental health services to address depression, impulsivity, excessive emotional outbursts, provocative and sexual behavior, and feelings of inadequacy and rejection. STUDENT also has issues related to drug use. The evidence establishes that STUDENT had received private counseling, family counseling, and drug treatment. These treatments were not successful and she was at risk to run away. She already had run away on several occasions from her parents’ home. While hospitalized in July 1998, STUDENT had “poor insight, continued social isolation and withdrawal and avoidance of her issues. . .The patient continued to have poor insight and would be superficial and have poor participation.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 5.) The recommendations of Dr. Ampudia upon discharge was a residential placement. Dr. Solochek concurred. She testified that a residential treatment center was necessary to provide STUDENT with 24-hour containment, firm boundaries, and consistency with known consequences for inappropriate behavior. Ms. Solochek testified that if STUDENT were not contained, she would not go to school. Ms. Solochek further testified that STUDENT initially needed a placement that was out of the area in which she lived because she was at risk to run away to where friends could harbor her. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Solochek’s testimony and the recommendations of Del Amo that STUDENT required a residential placement upon her release from Del Amo in July 1998.

Turning to the appropriateness of the placement provided by the parents, Ms. Fuller, Mr. Sorenson, and Elizabeth Cazier, registrar and academic advisor, testified regarding Sorenson’s Ranch. Their testimony establishes that Sorenson’s Ranch is a for-profit residential treatment center in Utah. It is a member of the Northwestern Association of Schools and Colleges. Sorenson’s Ranch is not certified by the state of California as a nonpublic school. Sorenson’s Ranch previously held California certification. However, its recent application for certification was denied. The student population includes 90-100 students in grades 7-12 who require a structured, therapeutic mileau to address behavioral and emotional difficulties. The program consists of educational, behavioral, and therapeutic components. Monthly reports are issued to monitor the students’ progress in each component. The students at Sorenson’s ranch participate in all aspects of the working ranch. They grow hay, care for the farm animals, and are responsible for typical ranch chores. The ratio of student-to-staff is five to eight students per staff person.

The students participate in an educational program from 8:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. The students are required to achieve mastery in each subject to earn credits toward graduation. Upon graduation, they earn diplomas from the state of Utah. Some of the teachers at Sorenson’s Ranch are credentialed and others are in the process of receiving certification. STUDENT participated in the educational program at Sorenson’s Ranch and was able to earn units toward graduation. Thus, placement at Sorenson’s Ranch addressed STUDENT’s educational needs.

A range of therapy and counseling services was available to STUDENT at Sorenson’s Ranch. There was a five-level behavioral system in place to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs. Her behavior was evaluated in academic, therapeutic, and behavioral components of the program. Students move from one level to the next based on the points they earn. Privileges are earned as the levels progress from one to five. STUDENT was placed on a contingency-based modification program that provided her with positive rewards such as participating in an art class or a shopping trip. The program included negative consequences such as loss of privileges, writing assignments, and removal from the student body. To address emotional needs, STUDENT received individual counseling from Ms. Fuller and met daily with a lay counselor. Ms. Fuller is a licensed MFT in California and Utah. During the course of STUDENT’s stay at Sorenson’s Ranch, sessions with Ms. Fuller ranged from a few minutes to several hours and occurred from one to three times per week. STUDENT’s emotional needs were also addressed through participation in the following groups: chemical dependency, peer, adoption, abuse, and anger. The peer group addressed relevant daily living issues. The adoption group addressed feelings of abandonment, rejection, and adjustment issues. The abuse group addressed sexuality and male-female relations. Family and relationship counseling were also available, as was medication management. Antidepressants were prescribed for STUDENT.

It is concluded that the combination of therapy, counseling, behavioral systems, and medication provided to STUDENT at Sorenson’s Ranch was designed to address her social, emotional, and behavioral needs.

As to whether STUDENT derived benefit from attending Sorenson’s Ranch, the testimony of Ms. Fuller established that STUDENT’s progress was slow. However, Ms. Fuller also testified that STUDENT made progress both academically and emotionally. For example, STUDENT was able to participate in an off-campus program. Ultimately, following her stay of 17 months at Sorenson’s Ranch, STUDENT had made sufficient growth to allow her to move to a less restrictive educational environment. Therefore, it is concluded that Sorenson’s Ranch provided an appropriate program for STUDENT and the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with STUDENT’s attending Sorenson’s Ranch.

FATHER testified regarding the costs of STUDENT’s stay at Sorenson’s Ranch. His calculations are contained in Petitioner’s Exhibit 32. FATHER testified that the total cost of board, tuition, and services at Sorenson’s Ranch is $59, 470. FATHER testified that Sorenson’s required parental visits and that the costs of five required visits totaled $2,902.77. STUDENT made a home visit as well for a total of $500.00. FATHER’s testimony establishes that the amount of reimbursement to which the parents are entitled is $62,872.77. Because FATHER did not provide copies of invoices or canceled checks, the amount of reimbursement is subject to proof. The evidence was not persuasive as to the parents’ reimbursement for other costs during the period STUDENT attended Sorenson’s Ranch.

The Oakley School

In January 2000, STUDENT entered the Oakley School. Her parents seek reimbursement for the costs they have incurred in STUDENT’s attendance at Oakley from December 1999 through the date of the decision.

In Dr. Solochek’s report of her assessment of STUDENT in August 1999, Dr. Solochek concluded that STUDENT did not then “demonstrate symptoms of a disorder in mood or thought. She no longer appears to be experiencing significant symptoms of depression as were reported prior to her stay at Sorenson’s Ranch. STUDENT appears to have made significant gains over the last year and demonstrates increased psychological insight.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.) Dr. Solochek went on to note that STUDENT continued to have problems with impulsivity and poor coping skills.

Dr. Solochek testified that STUDENT was not then ready to return home because she continued to lack behavioral controls and coping skills. Dr. Solochek testified that Oakley offered STUDENT a “step down” program to help her transition home. However, during testimony Dr. Solochek also acknowledged that by December 1999, STUDENT had completed her treatment program at Sorenson’s. It also should be noted that STUDENT remained in the Sorenson’s program four months following Dr. Solochek’s report and that during that period, she successfully lived off campus while continuing to participate in the therapy, educational, and counseling sessions offered by Sorenson’s Ranch.

There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to require mental health support upon her release from Sorenson’s Ranch. However, neither Ms. Fuller’s nor Dr. Solochek’s supports a finding that an out-of-state residential boarding school placement was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her education. As noted, STUDENT had been living off campus from Sorenson’s Ranch since September 1999. She had been making educational progress and home visits had been successful.

However, the District did not offer STUDENT special education services or placement. Therefore, the parents are entitled to some reimbursement for the expenditures they undertook in attempting to address STUDENT’s needs. As to Oakley’s ability to address STUDENT’s needs, James Meyer testified regarding Oakley. His testimony establishes that Oakley serves 76 students in grades 9-12. There are nine teachers who are certified or are in the process of obtaining certification. There are no special education teachers on staff. Mr. Meyers described Oakley as a “college preparatory boarding school with strong counseling and recreational components.” Oakley is not a state-certified special education school. Students served by Oakley require a structured environment and counseling. The students participate in a classroom educational environment from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Monday through Thursday. From Friday through Sunday, the students engage in recreational activities. To address social/emotional needs, the students receive 30 minutes weekly of individual counseling and one hour per week of group counseling. Some students, including STUDENT, receive medication management. Mr. Meyer testified that the students receive a traditional college preparatory education. Honors and advanced placement classes are available.

The Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to partial reimbursement for the costs of mental health services provided at Oakley. The Hearing Officer has balanced the fact that the evidence was not persuasive as to STUDENT’s need for an out-of-state placement in a college preparatory boarding school with the District’s failure to offer any program to address STUDENT’s mental health needs. In reaching an equitable resolution, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are entitled to one-half of the cost of Oakley. This amount is based on the evidence that Oakley provided an educational program that would also have been available in the District. However, Oakley also provided counseling and medication management that STUDENT required.

Consistent with FATHER’s testimony and his calculations contained in Petitioner’s Exhibit 32, the amount of reimbursement shall be one-half of the actual costs of placement or $965 monthly for the period of January 2000 to the date of this decision. Because FATHER’s testimony was based on his calculations, reimbursement shall be subject to proof in the form of receipts or canceled checks presented to the District.

ORDER

(1) Within 20 days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team to reflect the findings of this decision that STUDENT meets special education criteria because of an emotional disturbance.

(2) The IEP team shall develop a legally sufficient IEP including present levels of performance, annual goals, and benchmarks or objectives. The IEP team shall make an offer of placement and services designed to meet STUDENT’s current needs. The IEP team shall develop a plan to transition STUDENT to an appropriate placement and services within the District.

(3) Within 20 days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall reimburse the parents for the costs of STUDENT’s placement at Sorenson’s Ranch including tuition and parent visits and home visits for STUDENT that were required by Sorenson’s Ranch. The amount shall not exceed the calculations by FATHER contained in Petitioner’s Exhibit 32.

(4) Within 20 days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall reimburse the parents for one-half of the costs of tuition at the Oakley School from January 2000 to the date of this decision.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. 1: Has STUDENT met special education eligibility as a student with an emotional disturbance since the1997-1998 school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placements they procured for STUDENT beginning in 1998 and continuing to the date of the decision?

Petitioner prevailed as to reimbursement for the costs of Sorenson’s Ranch. Petitioner substantially prevailed as to reimbursement for the costs of the Oakley School.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: March 14, 2001 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues have been framed to reflect discussions between the parties at the hearing and for the purpose of facilitating analysis. Footnote 2: Dr. Solochek did not prepare a report following her assessment. Footnote 3: In 1997, the IDEA was amended. Most of the provisions became effective on June 4, 1997. Other provisions became effective January 1, 1998, or July 1, 1998. Petitioner’s claim of special education eligibility arose during the 1997-1998 school year. Under the 1997 amendment to IDEA, the disability category at issue in this case is known as “emotionally disturbed (ED)” whereas it previously was known as “seriously emotionally disturbed (SED).” The criteria that must be satisfied to meet special education eligibility as either ED or SED are similar. Footnote 4: Ms. Fuller presently is director of the Crater Lake School. Footnote 5: Mr. Egbert meets weekly with STUDENT for individual and group counseling. He also provides biweekly family counseling. Footnote 6: Some school districts in California require that students earn a minimum GPA of 2.0 to advance to the next grade. No testimony was given as to the requirements for advancement in the Manhattan Beach Unified School District. Footnote 7: This requirement commonly is referred to as the need to “search and serve.”