California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 3, 2003

Student v. Anaheim Union High School District et al. (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1316-02, SN02-01316, SN02-02533 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Anaheim Union High must keep student at Lexington, redo behavior assessment and add self-help goals; assessment claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 10 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

On reconsideration, the Hearing Officer granted a motion to exclude the mother's testimony about the terms of the student's settlement with Magnolia District (footnote 38). Magnolia District had been dismissed as a party after a reported settlement. No remand or appeal is noted.

Summary

A 12-year-old seventh grader, eligible under "significantly below average intellect" (now intellectual disability), sued Anaheim Union High School District and the Greater Anaheim SELPA when he moved up from an elementary district. He communicates mainly through gestures, pointing, and picture exchange, and his family speaks Korean at home. The District filed its own case to defend its assessments and its offer of a special day class at Hope School, a separate campus. The two cases were consolidated.

The Hearing Officer found all of the District's assessments appropriate. Testing in Korean was not feasible, and nonverbal tests did not need it. The District also did not have to remove earwax to finish the hearing test. The parent was not reimbursed for private speech and occupational therapy (OT) evaluations obtained before the District assessed, and no further IEEs were ordered. The District denied FAPE in two ways: it made no clear written ESY offer for summer 2002, and it did not implement the IEP from September to November 6, 2002. The November offer was mostly appropriate but lacked self-help goals. Direct therapies and a one-to-one aide were not required. Hope School was more restrictive than Lexington Junior High, so the District could not move him before trying a behavior plan there. The Hearing Officer kept him at Lexington. The order also required an IEP meeting, a new behavioral assessment and plan, and weekly OT consultation to his teacher.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the LRE requirement between two special day class settings. A district could not move a student to a separate campus before trying supplementary supports, such as a behavior plan, in the less restrictive setting. It also shows that an IEP note "recommending" a school was not treated as a clear written offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District and SELPA conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT? This covered the Korean translation of the assessment plan, the 50-day IEP timeline, assessor knowledge, primary language, all areas of suspected disability, and each assessment: psychological, speech-language/oral motor, OT, PT, vision, health, audiology, APE, and behavior.

    The assessments were appropriate. Testing in Korean was not feasible or not needed for nonverbal tests. Any lapses in the plan translation or the 50-day timeline caused no prejudice. The District did not have to remove earwax to finish the hearing test. Health and APE were not areas of suspected disability.

  2. Issue 2. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Kleiman and Associates and by Gallagher Pediatrics?

    No reimbursement. The parent obtained the private evaluations before the District assessed, so they did not arise from disagreement with a District assessment, and the District's assessments were appropriate.

  3. Issue 3. If the District and SELPA failed to conduct appropriate assessments and/or failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, is STUDENT entitled to additional independent assessments?

    No additional IEEs at public expense, because the District appropriately assessed in all areas of suspected disability.

  4. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4 (2001-2002 ESY). Did the District and SELPA offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 ESY?

    The March 2002 IEP only 'recommended' Hope School for summer or fall and referred to ESY 'in AUHSD' without naming a school. That was not a clear written offer, so the student was denied FAPE for ESY.

  5. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 4 (September 2002 - November 6, 2002). Did the District offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year from September through November 6, 2002?

    The Lexington teacher had not seen and was not implementing the current IEP goals, which denied FAPE for about two months.

  6. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 4(a). Was the District's program (November 7, 2002 offer) designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs? This covered goals and objectives and requested services: direct oral motor, speech-language, OT, PT, and AT services, and a one-to-one aide.

    The proposed goals and consultative services were appropriate, and direct speech, oral motor, OT, PT, and AT services and a full-time one-to-one aide were not needed. The offer lacked self-help goals for toileting, buttoning/zipping, and shoe tying.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4(b). Is the District's offer of placement at the Hope School reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

    The Hope School offer was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, given the student's cognitive level.

  8. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue 4(c). Does the offer comport with his IEP?

    Not in dispute, because the parent did not accept the Hope placement offer.

  9. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4(d). Is the District's offer of placement at the Hope School STUDENT's LRE?

    Hope's separate campus is more restrictive than Lexington's comprehensive campus. The District could not move the student there until it had implemented a behavior plan at Lexington and that plan proved unsatisfactory.

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If the District and SELPA failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the aforementioned periods, is he entitled to compensatory education?

    No direct compensatory services, because of the Magnolia settlement and uncertain benefit. Instead, the Hearing Officer ordered 30 minutes per week of OT consultation to the teacher for the rest of 2002-2003 and ESY to support the self-help goals.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. The District shall keep the student in his present placement (Lexington Junior High special day class) during the '2003-2003' school year unless the parties agree otherwise. This is likely meant to be 2002-2003.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to: (a) write self-help goals and objectives (toileting, buttoning/unbuttoning and zipping trousers, tying shoes); (b) provide weekly OT consultation to the special education teacher; and (c) give Student a written report of Ms. Lee's oral motor diagnostic findings.
  • Compensatory education. OT consultation to the special education teacher, 30 minutes per week, for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year and for 2002-2003 ESY, to address implementation of the self-help goals.
  • Order to assess. Within 21 calendar days of the IEP meeting, the IEP team must conduct and complete a functional behavioral assessment that includes observations of the student and an interview with his mother.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must develop a behavioral intervention plan within 5 calendar days after the FBA is completed and begin implementing it within 5 calendar days after it is developed.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Benjamin Y. Kim, attorney for Student
  • Patricia Combs, attorney (observer)
  • Cynthia Yount, attorney for District and SELPA, Parker & Covert, LLP
  • Dr. Michael Shelton, director of special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Linda Gaston, program administrator for special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Dawn Walsh, SELPA director, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Cherie Bauer, SELPA program specialist, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Young Soon Suh, Korean interpreter
  • William Kim, Korean interpreter
  • Thomas Yi, Korean interpreter
  • Aeryong Kim, Korean interpreter
  • Younghee Park, private speech-language pathologist (independent assessor), witness for Student, Larry Kleiman & Associates
  • Larry Kleiman & Associates, private speech-language assessment provider
  • Misuk Yang, Saturday church school teacher, witness for Student, Wheat Mission
  • Bonnie Freeman, independent occupational therapist, witness for Student
  • Charmaine La Capria, private occupational therapy assessor, Gallagher Pediatric Therapy
  • Gallagher Pediatric Therapy, private occupational therapy provider
  • Rebecca Bush, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessment, FBA and BIP), Anaheim Union High School District
  • Lisa Lee, Korean-speaking school psychologist who assisted with assessment, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Stefanie Lee, speech-language specialist/assessor, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Marilyn Miller, principal, Hope School, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Donna Erickson, school psychologist/assistant principal, Hope School, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Patricia Ann Polcyn, SELPA occupational therapist/assessor, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Kathleen McLean, program specialist and speech-language pathologist, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Jane R. Vogel, vision specialist (functional vision assessment), Anaheim Union High School District (part-time consultant)
  • Kathleen Strobel, coordinating nurse, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Jim Miller, behavior specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Susanne Treacher, pediatric physical therapist/assessor, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Dennis Coleman, special education (SDC) teacher, Lexington Junior High School, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Mary Olander, audiologist, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Kathy Lewis, assistive technology specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Amber, classroom aide (first name only), Lexington Junior High School
  • Lorraine, classroom aide (first name only), Lexington Junior High School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This consolidated matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Anaheim, California, on November 19-22, 2002, and December 5, 6,(Footnote 1) and 12, 13, and 17, 2002.

STUDENT (Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Benjamin Y. Kim. Also present at the hearing on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, PARENT. Attorney Patricia Combs observed on December 5, 6, and 13, 2002. The Anaheim Union High School District (District) and Greater Anaheim SELPA (SELPA) were represented by attorney Cynthia Yount of Parker & Covert, LLP. Also present at the hearing on the District’s behalf were Dr. Michael Shelton, director of special youth services, and on some hearing days, Linda Gaston, program administrator for the District. Dawn Walsh, director of the Greater Anaheim SELPA, was present on behalf of the SELPA.

Ms. Young Soon Suh acted as the Korean interpreter on the first and last hearing days. William Kim and Thomas Yi acted as the Korean interpreters on November 20 and December 12-13, respectively. Ms. Aeryong Kim acted as the Korean interpreter on all other hearing days.

Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Younghee Park, speech and language pathologist; PARENT, STUDENT’s mother; Misuk Yang, teacher at the Saturday school of the Wheat Mission; Bonnie Freeman, occupational therapist; Rebecca Bush, District school psychologist; and Stefanie Lee, District speech and language specialist. The District and SELPA called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Marilyn Miller, principal of the Hope School; Patricia Ann Polcyn, SELPA occupational therapist; Kathleen McLean, program specialist for the District; Jane Vogel, vision specialist; Kathleen Strobel, coordinating nurse for the District; Jim Miller, behavior specialist for the District; Susanne Treacher, physical therapist; Dennis Coleman, a District special education teacher; Linda Gaston, the District’s program administrator for special youth services; and Cherie Bauer, program specialist for the SELPA.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 2)

1. Did the District and SELPA conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT?

2. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Kleiman and Associates and by Gallagher Pediatrics?

3. If the District and SELPA failed to conduct appropriate assessments and/or failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, is STUDENT entitled to additional independent assessments?

4. Did the District and SELPA offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 ESY and for the 2002-2003 school year?

5. If the District and SELPA failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the aforementioned periods, is he entitled to compensatory education?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

STUDENT is a twelve-year-old (STUDENT turns age thirteen on February 26), seventh-grade student who resides with his parents and two sisters within the District. STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services under the eligibility category “significantly below average intellect.”(Footnote 3) STUDENT is currently placed within a special day class (SDC) at the Lexington Junior High School at his mother’s request and as agreed to by the District pending the outcome of assessments and due process. Previously, STUDENT attended the Salk Elementary School within the Magnolia Elementary School District (Magnolia District).(Footnote 4)

According to a Magnolia District psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT at age three years, STUDENT was diagnosed with cri du chat syndrome (CDC), a rare genetic disorder that involves chromosome number 5.(Footnote 5) (Student Exh. 2) At the time of the evaluation, STUDENT according to his father, said just two words, “papa” and “mama.” STUDENT was not walking. STUDENT was found to qualify for special education placement as a person with below average intellectual functioning. STUDENT was also found to be 50 percent below his chronological age in communication, daily living skills, socialization, and motor skills. On April 30, 1998, STUDENT at age eight years, was given the designation “limited English proficient” (LEP) as a result of an oral proficiency score of level one in English. (Student Exh. 14)

STUDENT attended elementary school as an SDC student within the Magnolia District from March 1993 (when STUDENT attained age 3) through June 2002 (at age 12).

The Magnolia District conducted a triennial assessment of STUDENT in the spring of 2002. The IEP team met on March 13, 2002, and identified present levels of performance and developed annual goals and objectives for the period March 2002 through March 2003 in the following areas: self-help and independent living, social, community based instruction (CBI), and motor. The team also agreed upon a program and services. (Dist. Exh. 7) Anaheim District school psychologist Donna Erickson was present at the meeting to discuss STUDENT’s transition into the District from Magnolia beginning 2001-2002 ESY and continuing through the 2002-2003 school year. The District recommended that STUDENT be placed in the Hope School for the 2001-2002 ESY and the 2002-2003 school year. Hope is a special education school on a small campus and is comparable to a nonpublic school. (Test. of Ms. Miller)

On May 13, 2002, the Magnolia IEP team reconvened to review the placement option for STUDENT’s next school year and to address his mother’s concerns about STUDENT’s goals, assessments, safety, and classroom behavior. STUDENT’s mother requested that a new psychological assessment be conducted to include cognitive, academic, and social adaptation and also requested assessments in occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT) and speech and language. STUDENT’s mother consented to the IEP and to the special education program placement in an SDC for the severely handicapped. The IEP notes indicate that STUDENT’s mother would visit Hope School “tomorrow” and that SELPA program specialist Cherie Bauer would “set up visits for Lexington in the next few weeks.” The notes further indicate that “as of June 19, 2002, STUDENT will become an Anaheim Union student” and that STUDENT’s mother requested “the new school to assess STUDENT’s cognitive, OT and PT and speech” and that a meeting be held in September at the “new school.” STUDENT’s mother also expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s toileting at home and at school. The IEP team developed two new goals and objectives in math and academics. (Dist. Exh. 8) STUDENT’s mother visited the Hope School in May 2002 and decided that Hope was not appropriate for STUDENT. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Miller)

On June 12, 2002, the Hearing Office received the Student’s written request for a due process hearing (Case No. SN02-01316). Student named the Anaheim and Magnolia Districts and the Greater Anaheim SELPA as respondents and raised assessment and program issues.

On June 20, 2002, Ms. Younghee Park (of Larry Kleiman & Associates) conducted an independent speech-language assessment of STUDENT at the request of STUDENT’s mother.(Footnote 6) On the Nonspeech Test (multi-handicapped norms), STUDENT’s age equivalency for expressive language ability was found to be within the 22- to 25-month range. On the Michigan Early Intervention Development profile, STUDENT was found to be functioning at the 20- to 23-month level in expressive and receptive language in both the Korean and English languages. Ms. Park found STUDENT’s age equivalents on the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test to be four years, ten months in the English language and five years, ten months in the Korean language. (Student Exh. 33)

STUDENT did not attend ESY 2002. The District contends that STUDENT was offered an ESY placement at the Hope School, but his mother would not agree to the placement. STUDENT instead attended a church-operated summer camp program. (Test. of Ms. Yang)

On August 13, 2002, Gallagher Pediatric Therapy conducted an occupational therapy evaluation of STUDENT at the request of STUDENT’s mother. The Gallagher assessor, Ms. Charmaine La Capria, did not testify at the hearing. According to the report, STUDENT’s mother requested the evaluation to determine if OT services “would facilitate the further development of STUDENT’s gross motor, fine motor, and overall behavioral organization skills.” The report indicates that standardized testing could not be performed because of STUDENT’s difficulty following directions and “decreased communication skills” and that the evaluation was conducted through clinical observations and parent report. The report also indicates that an educational-based evaluation could not be adequately performed. (Student Exh. 34)

The Gallagher evaluator determined that STUDENT, at age twelve and one-half, had gross motor skills at the 30-month level and had fine motor skills at the 24-month level. The evaluator also noted that STUDENT had “mild” difficulties organizing his behavior during the evaluation and remained in constant motion. STUDENT was also unable to maintain a seated position to engage in fine motor tasks, requiring several visual and physical prompts to initiate many tasks presented to him. The evaluator did not make specific recommendations regarding whether STUDENT would benefit from OT services. However, the evaluator noted that if the IEP team determined his difficulty processing sensory information “seems to be more of an issue than his cognitive limitations,” then a “trial period” of direct OT one time per week “may be appropriate.” (Student Exh. 34)

The Student and the Anaheim District entered into a confidential mediated interim agreement in late August 2002, and STUDENT was enrolled in the Lexington Junior High School pending assessments to be conducted by the District.(Footnote 7) STUDENT’s mother consented to the District’s assessment plan on September 6, 2002.(Footnote 8) (Student Exh. 45) STUDENT began attending a Lexington SDC for the severely handicapped taught by special education teacher Dennis Coleman the first week of September 2002. In September, the class had fourteen students, and at the time of hearing contained ten students. In September, the class had a single aide, but at the time of the hearing, there were three instructional aides. (Test. of Mr. Coleman)

On September 30, 2002, and October 3, 2002, Rebecca Bush, a nationally certified school psychologist, assessed STUDENT’s social/adaptive behavior and intellectual functioning and issued an undated, written report of the “multidisciplinary psychoeducational evaluation.” The evaluation also included speech-language pathologist Stefanie Lee’s evaluation of STUDENT’s communication skills. (Dist. Exh. 11)

In the area of social/adaptive skills, Ms. Bush reported that STUDENT’s teachers completed the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale (Burks’), which indicated consistent, significant or very significant concerns in the areas of intelligence, attention, resistance, and withdrawal. Ms. Bush also reported that she (and a Korean-speaking school psychologist) had observed the following behaviors in the classroom: crawling, distractibility, inattentiveness, biting/sucking on his chair, resistance to change, and some quiet keening (mournful or complaining) noises. STUDENT did not initiate socialization with his peers and was “basically” unresponsive during group activities.

Ms. Bush was unable to administer standardized cognitive test instruments to assess STUDENT’s cognitive functioning. On the Uniform Nonverbal Intelligence Test (UNIT), STUDENT“often appeared to be making random guesses” and threw some of the manipulatives on the floor. Because of STUDENT’s very limited responses, a valid score could not be obtained. At the request of STUDENT’s attorney, Ms. Bush also attempted to administer the verbal portions of the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI), both in Korean (with an interpreter) and in English, but STUDENT was unable to respond verbally in either language and was also unable to respond through gestures or signs. (Test. of Ms. Bush) Ms. Bush concluded that “since STUDENT is basically nonverbal, a verbal IQ test would not be an appropriate tool for assessing his intellectual ability level.” Ms. Bush completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales by interviewing STUDENT’s teacher and STUDENT’s mother (with an interpreter) and found STUDENT to be in the low range of adaptive behavior functioning. Ms. Bush could not obtain valid test results of STUDENT’s psychomotor skills. In academic achievement, the results of the Brigance and classroom observations indicated that STUDENT was able to recognize some letters and sight words and could pick out his name when presented three choices. He could count up to three items and knew “some numbers,” but could not write. After making observations of STUDENT in the classroom and conducting a records review and parent and teacher interviews, Ms. Bush determined STUDENT to be in the deficient range of intelligence and to meet state criteria as a student with “significantly below average intellect.” Ms. Bush testified that her findings were consistent with STUDENT’s low-range performance on the Vineland and past psychoeducational assessments of STUDENT in February 1993, April 1996, March 1999, and March 2002.

Speech-language pathologist Stefanie Lee assessed STUDENT’s communication skills and administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test and the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test. Ms. Lee determined STUDENT’s performance on the two receptive vocabulary tests to be lower than those obtained on similar tests administered by Ms. Younghee Park and well below STUDENT’s chronological age. Ms. Lee determined STUDENT’s speech abilities to be “very limited, consisting of random vocalizations and very occasional words or approximations of words.” Ms. Lee also noted that STUDENT’s ability to attend to tasks was limited to 5 to 10 minutes when he was cooperative. Ms. Lee testified that she had completed administering diagnostic oral motor therapy to STUDENT and had determined that he was not showing any improvement in this area, notwithstanding her services. (Dist. Exh. 11)

On October 10, 2002, Susanne Treacher, a pediatric physical therapist, issued a written report of her physical therapy evaluation. After conducting observations and completing portions of a School Functional Assessment (SFA), Ms. Treacher concluded that physical therapy services were not necessary for STUDENT to benefit fully from his educational placement. Ms. Treacher stated that STUDENT’s gross motor needs could be met through the adapted physical education (APE) services he was currently receiving. (Dist. Exh. 14 and Test. of Ms. Treacher)

Also on October 10, Patricia Ann Polcyn, a SELPA occupational therapist, issued a written OT assessment report of STUDENT. After administering the SFA, Ms. Polcyn determined that STUDENT is functioning at below age level in school and requires “excessive” prompting and supervision to perform most school tasks. Ms. Polcyn identified understanding the use of materials, social conventions including eating manners, toileting, written work, communication, and productive use of time as “possible” areas of concern. Ms. Polcyn also completed a Short Sensory Profile, a standard method for measuring sensory processing abilities on daily functional performance, by observing STUDENT’s school functioning. Ms. Polcyn identified taste/smell sensitivity, movement sensitivity, underresponsiveness, and low energy as “possible” areas of concern in sensory processing. (Dist. Exh. 13 and Test. of Ms. Polcyn)

Ms. Polcyn testified that her findings were consistent with the Gallagher assessment skill findings and that STUDENT’s delays resulted from his chromosomal abnormality (CDC), low cognition, and lack of behavioral intervention. She identified behavioral control as STUDENT’s greatest area of need. However, Ms. Polcyn concluded that STUDENT’s behavioral issues do not require OT intervention and that STUDENT’s needs are not directly related to poor motor and/or sensory processing. Ms. Polcyn observed that she had known STUDENT for many years and that his behaviors can be controlled in a structured environment with direct supervision and instruction. Ms. Polcyn recommended consultative OT services, “if the need arises.” (Dist. Exh. 13)

On October 15, 2002, special education consultant Jane R. Vogel issued a written Functional Vision Assessment. After administering the Peabody Model Vision Project Functional Vision Screening Test (Peabody Vision Screening Test), Lighthouse Symbol Cards, and observing STUDENT in the classroom, Ms. Vogel concluded that STUDENT is using his vision “very well” and is a “visual learner” who appears to have learned to compensate for any problems he had in the past to correct ptosis (drooping eyelid) and strabismus (squinting). Ms. Vogel determined that STUDENT has near acuity of 20/25 vision (better than average) when matching Lighthouse symbol cards and has distance acuity of “at least” 20/80 vision “using both eyes together.” Ms. Vogel further concluded that STUDENT’s vision is not adversely affecting his educational performance at this time. Ms. Vogel recommended that STUDENT be monitored once a year to make sure that the ptosis had not worsened to cause “possible slightly reduced distance acuity.” (Test. of Ms. Vogel and Dist. Exh. 12)

On October 22, 2002, audiologist Mary Olander issued a written assessment report. Ms. Olander found “grossly normal hearing sensitivity” of “fair reliability,” but was unable to complete the testing because of a build-up of earwax in STUDENT’s ears. Ms. Olander’s report recommended an audiologic reevaluation following cerumen removal. (Dist. Exh. 15)

An IEP team meeting first convened on October 23, 2002, to review District assessment reports, all of which had been completed with the exception of the audiology assessment.(Footnote 9) (Dist. Exh. 16) Assistive technology specialist Kathy Lewis reviewed her AT assessment and recommended that STUDENT continue training with picture communication, use of a computer, and a voice output device. Ms. Lewis did not recommend individual instruction for the equipment. After meeting for four hours (STUDENT’s mother was assisted by an interpreter and STUDENT’s attorney), the IEP team decided to reconvene to November 7, 2002, to discuss the assessment results, services, and programming. (Test. of Ms. Gaston) STUDENT’s attorney provided a written dissent to the incomplete October 23 IEP, asserting disagreement with the assessment results, stating that STUDENT’s unique needs required direct services and parent training in the areas of assistive technology three times per week, OT three times per week, daily speech and language, and community-based instruction (CBI) services ten hours per week. The dissent also asserted STUDENT needed a one-to-one behavioral and instructional aide (preferably “bilingual”) during all school and CBI activities. (Dist. Exh. 16)

On November 7, 2002, the IEP team met again to respond to STUDENT’s October 23 request for independent assessments, to develop goals and objectives (based upon the information received from the District’s assessments) and to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The goals and objectives from the March and May 2002 IEP were reviewed. District IEP team members came to the meeting to discuss new goals and objectives, the proposed placement at Hope School and a proposed FBA and BIP. However, the parties disagreed over whether an FBA could be done at the meeting. Student contended that an FBA could not be done at the meeting. (Test. of Ms. Gaston)

The District offered to continue STUDENT’s adapted physical education (APE) services one time per day through March 13, 2003, and weekly speech & language consultation of thirty minutes each to the classroom beginning on November 7, 2002, through March 13, 2002. STUDENT was also offered assistive technology including communication pictures, a single switch output device, and an alternative keyboard with cause/effect software. Under placement rationale, the IEP indicates STUDENT’s disability requires specialized instruction and services not available in the regular class program and that the severity/complexity of his disability requires special instructional/material and equipment not available at his home school. The IEP notes indicate the following reason for offering to place STUDENT at Hope School: “Due to having a significantly below average intellect, STUDENT requires support provided by staff with special training.” STUDENT was to spend one hundred percent of the day in special education with program participation at lunch, recess, passing periods, assemblies, field trips, school activities, extracurricular activities, and CBI.

The District members of the IEP team developed proposed goals in the following areas (with a November 7 start date): social skills, domestic, writing, self-help, pre-vocational, mathematics, reading, and communication skills. The IEP also includes a report of a functional behavior assessment and a behavioral intervention plan prepared by District psychologist Rebecca Bush. In dissenting notes, STUDENT’s mother requested that a “functional analysis and behavior assessment be conducted prior to developing a positive behavior plan.” (Dist. Exh. 17) The November 7 IEP meeting was not completed and an additional meeting was not held prior to the due process hearing. After the meeting, on November 7, District IEP team members prepared a daily schedule for STUDENT at Hope School, and a formal written offer of program and services at the Hope School that was faxed to STUDENT’s mother and attorney. (Dist. Exh. 17 and Test. of Ms. Gaston) The offer includes attendance in an SDC from 8:30 to 3:05 daily, a program that will address STUDENT’s goals and objectives, transportation, community based instruction experiences, a picture communication system “to meet communication needs,” and class field trips. The offer also included DIS of APE 42 minutes daily in a group setting, and speech/language consult to the classroom teacher once time per week for thirty minutes. Student did not dispute that Hope was the offer.

On November 8, 2002, the Hearing Office received the District’s written request for a due process hearing (Case. No. SN02-02533).(Footnote 10) The District asserts that its assessments were appropriate and its offer of a program and placement at Hope School is appropriate. (Dist. Exh. 18)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSION

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District and SELPA conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT?(Footnote 11)

Special education law provides that a student must be tested in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision (including low vision), hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of that disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g).) The purpose of the assessment is not only to determine an eligibility category for the student, but also to help determine a student’s unique educational needs. The assessment tools and strategies used must provide relevant information that will directly aid in the determination of the educational needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D).

An assessment must conform to the relevant provisions of California Education Code sections 56320 and 56322. Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; be provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible;(Footnote 12) and that the tests be selected and administered to best ensure that, when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.

Title 5, C.C.R. section 3022, provides, in pertinent part, that the proposed written assessment include information indicating the pupil’s primary language and the pupil’s language proficiency in the primary language as determined by Education Code Section 52164.1.

Education Code section 56344 provides that an IEP be developed as a result of an assessment within fifty days from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for an assessment, “unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension.”

Procedural and/or substantive challenges to the assessments conducted by the District

Student contends that the District violated the following procedural and/or substantive requirements: failed to translate the assessment plan into his and his parent’s primary language, Korean;(Footnote 13) failed to fully develop his IEP within fifty days from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, (unless the parent agrees, in writing to an extension); failed to assess him with qualified personnel who have a knowledge and understanding of his cultural and ethnic background and who have a knowledge of his disability;(Footnote 14) failed to select and administer tests to best ensure that when administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect his aptitude, achievement level or any other factors the test purports to measure and not his impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure; failed to use a variety of assessment tools and strategies that provide relevant information directly related to determining his educational needs; failed to assess him in Korean; and failed to use a bilingual Korean interpreter during the assessment. Student also contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability by not assessing his vision, language function, health and development, and hearing (audiological).

The District contends that it conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The Ninth Circuit has held that procedural violations of the IDEA do not automatically result in a denial of FAPE unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e., a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). With regard to Student’s assertion that the District failed to translate his assessment plan into his parent’s primary language (per Education Code § 56321(b)(2)), the Hearing Officer notes that an assessment plan in the Korean language was not entered into evidence. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s attorney speaks both Korean and English and participated in the development of the assessment plan with STUDENT’s mother, and that STUDENT’s mother and an interpreter (and STUDENT’s attorney) participated in the subsequent October and November IEP meetings. (Test. of Ms. Bush) The Hearing Officer finds that there has been no showing of prejudice to Student as a result of the District’s failure to establish that it translated the plan into Korean. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s mother participated in the October and November IEP meetings with an attorney and with a Korean language interpreter. There was no showing of a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s right to participate in the IEP process relating to the plan.

Student also contends as a procedural violation of special education law that the District failed to develop an IEP within 50 days of his mother’s consent to the assessment plan on September 6, 2002, in accordance with California Education Code section 56344. The Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team initially convened on October 23, 2002, within 50 days of the parent’s consent (on September 6) to the assessment plan. The parties agreed to reconvene the IEP meeting to November 7, 2002. (Test. of Ms. Gaston and Dist. Exh. 16) There is no evidence that Student objected to a continuance of the fifty-day timeline and to reconvening the IEP meeting. At the November 7 IEP meeting, the District members of the IEP team offered him a placement and services at the Hope school.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District substantially complied with section 56344 and also finds that there has been no showing of prejudice to Student. It is undisputed that the IEP team met for four hours on October 23 and an additional four hours on November 7 (just two weeks later) to discuss assessment results further and to develop present levels of performance and goals and objectives in accordance with California Education Code section 56345. The Hearing Officer finds that the conduct of his mother in concluding the October 23 IEP meeting without objection to reconvening the IEP meeting to November 7, just two weeks, establishes that Student did not suffer a loss of educational opportunity and that his parent did not suffer a serious infringement of her opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

Regarding the assertion that District personnel who conducted the assessments lacked knowledge and understanding of STUDENT’s cultural and ethnic background, the Hearing Officer notes that the District assessors who testified all stated that they were aware that his parents and STUDENT were of Korean descent and that Korean was spoken in his home. There was no showing that a greater degree of understanding of STUDENT’s cultural and ethnic background than that possessed by District assessors was needed to conduct appropriate assessments. Other than making the general assertion that the assessors lacked sufficient understanding of Student’s cultural background, Student provided no specific evidence to suggest that the District’s assessments were culturally biased. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District assessors’ knowledge and understanding of STUDENT’s cultural and ethnic background was adequate for the purposes of conducting the various assessments of STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive Student’s assertion that the District’s assessments are not appropriate because the District assessors did not have sufficient knowledge about his disability. District assessors all testified to a knowledge about his qualifying disability for special education and related services - that his cognitive functioning is significantly below average. Each witness also testified to a knowledge about his underlying diagnosis, cri du chat syndrome. However, Student provides no authority for the proposition that the assessors are obligated to be knowledgeable about CDC, which is acknowledged to be a rare medical diagnosis but is not a separate (or distinct) qualifying basis for eligibility under special education law.

District psychologist Rebecca Bush credibly testified that she selected and administered tests that accurately reflected STUDENT’s aptitude, achievement level, and any other factors the tests purported to measure, and did not reflect STUDENT’s impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills. The other District assessors either conducted nonverbal tests that did not reflect STUDENT’s impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills, or tested in those areas because those skills are the factors the tests purported to measure.

The credible evidence establishes that the District assessors used a variety of assessment tools and strategies to provide relevant information for determining STUDENT’s educational needs. None of the District assessors relied on a single test instrument.

The Hearing Officer will address within the discussion for each assessment Student’s contentions that the District failed to assess him in Korean and failed to use a bilingual Korean interpreter during the assessment. Student’s contention that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability will be addressed within each area Student asserts the District failed to assess him.

The Hearing Officer addresses each assessment separately to determine the appropriateness of each assessment conducted by the District. It is undisputed that the parties agreed to an assessment plan on September 6, 2002 (the plan was signed by STUDENT’s mother and given to school psychologist Rebecca Bush on that date). It is also undisputed that STUDENT was to be assessed in accordance with the agreed-upon assessment plan in the following areas: achievement, psycho-motor, adaptive behavior, psycho-motor, and cognitive (psychological assessment), language/speech (speech-language assessment), occupational therapy (OT assessment), physical therapy (PT assessment), assistive technology (AT assessment), and a health assessment (audiological assessment, functional vision assessment, and a “health”assessment).(Footnote 15)

Psychological Assessment

Student contends that the psychological assessment conducted by Rebecca Bush, a credentialed school psychologist, was inappropriate because it was not conducted in STUDENT’s primary language “even though it was feasible” and that the District’s opinion of his cognitive ability is speculative.(Footnote 16)

It is undisputed that Ms. Bush conducted the psychological assessment with the assistance of a Korean-speaking school psychologist (Lisa Lee), who sat next to her during the formal assessment, assisted her with the manipulatives during the nonverbal portion of the assessments, and also participated in the observations of STUDENT in the classroom. (Test. of Ms. Bush) Moreover, Ms. Bush testified that she also used a Korean language interpreter to administer the verbal cognitive portion of the assessment to STUDENT. Ms. Bush stated that she was in contact with STUDENT’s mother and attorney to make changes in the assessment plan and assisted in the development of the assessment plan in the areas of cognitive abilities, adaptive behavior and visual motor.(Footnote 17)) Ms. Bush stated that although an interpreter was available, she was unable to conduct a visual motor assessment of STUDENT because of his behavior (“out of his seat, biting on the back of his chair, trying to leave the room, walking around the room”). Student did not challenge the qualifications of Ms. Bush.(Footnote 18) Ms. Bush conducted the adaptive behavior portion of the assessment (Vineland) by interviewing STUDENT’s English-speaking special education teacher (Mr. Coleman) and STUDENT’s mother (through a Korean-speaking interpreter). (Test. of Ms. Bush)

The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Student’s contention that assessing him in his primary language was feasible in any event, even with an interpreter. STUDENT’s expressions or vocalizations generally follow prompts. STUDENT generally does not initiate communication by verbalizing, and then his vocalizations are limited to a few words. (Test. of Stefanie Lee) Witnesses who testified on STUDENT’s behalf opined that STUDENT has a Korean vocabulary of ten to fifteen words and an English vocabulary of several words. (Test. of STUDENT’s mother, Ms. Younghee Park, and Ms. Yang(Footnote 19)) Ms. Bush testified that he “just doesn’t verbalize in the classroom” and that she had never observed him able to answer a “yes” or “no” question, either by verbalizing or by gesture (nodding or shaking his head). Moreover, Ms. Bush’s testimony, that the use of Korean to cue STUDENT during the nonverbal testing would not have been appropriate (resulting in an invalid administration) was unrefuted. Given STUDENT’s extremely limited vocabulary (both receptive and expressive in Korean and in English) and the issue of test validity, the Hearing Officer finds that assessment in Korean was not feasible in any event.(Footnote 20)

The Hearing Officer also notes that C.C.R. Section 3023(a) provides for assessments in the student’s primary language or mode of communication. (emphasis added) Abundant credible evidence establishes that STUDENT’s primary mode of communication is through facial gesture and pointing, supplemented by occasional or random vocalizations that may or may not approximate the sounds of words and that STUDENT also uses the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) to indicate his needs. (Test. of Ms. Stefanie Lee, Mr. Coleman, Ms. Polcyn, Ms. McLean, and Ms. Bush). The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bush’s use of gestures or signs in an effort to communicate with STUDENT during the nonverbal assessment was an appropriate method of communicating with STUDENT in his primary mode of communication.

The Hearing Officer addresses Student’s contention that the District’s opinion of his cognitive level is speculative because Ms. Bush could not give an opinion as to precisely how far below 70 STUDENT’s IQ is. Ms. Bush stated that she included the verbal IQ testing of STUDENT at the insistence of STUDENT’s attorney, even though she believed that “since STUDENT is basically nonverbal, a verbal IQ test is not an appropriate tool for assessing his intellectual ability level.” (Dist. Exh. 11) Several attempts to administer the verbal IQ test (WASI) were unsuccessful because STUDENT was unable to respond verbally in Korean or English and was also unable to respond through gestures or signs. (Test. of Ms. Bush and Dist. Exh. 11 Ms. Bush credibly testified that she needed only to address whether STUDENT continued to qualify for special education and related services as a student with a significantly below average cognitive ability, and that once that determination was made, it was unnecessary to make a precise IQ finding. Student called no witnesses qualified to conduct psychological assessments to refute Ms. Bush’s findings.

The Hearing Officer also finds that although STUDENT’s limited expressive and receptive language abilities (and other CDC traits) make it difficult to determine his precise intelligence level, the District appropriately determined STUDENT’s cognitive ability to be within the deficient range (an IQ less than 70) and that STUDENT has adaptive skills at the two-year age level or lower. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bush’s professional opinion has a rational basis and is not speculative. The evidence establishes that her opinion is the product of professional experience and judgment, classroom observations, interviews conducted with STUDENT’s special education teacher regarding his academic performance in the classroom, and a review of Vineland scores that place STUDENT’s cognitive ability within the deficient range (an IQ less than 70 and adaptive skills at the 2-year-old age level or lower). Moreover, Ms. Bush’s opinion is consistent with each of the past Magnolia District psychoeducational assessments conducted of STUDENT since 1993. Ms. Bush’s opinion also is supported by STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Coleman, who stated that STUDENT functionally is “very definitely” within the bottom third of his Lexington severely handicapped SDC, cannot write, has shown very, very little progress, and that although he has attempted to get STUDENT to trace, he hasn’t shown progress. Mr. Coleman also stated that he doesn’t expect STUDENT to be able to learn how to read and that “we are not seeing him effectively counting to three.” Ms. Bush testified that STUDENTis cognitively and functionally within the “lower third” of his SDC and that all of the students in his class are “mentally retarded or in the mentally deficient range.”

Ms. Bush also stated that she reviewed the videotape (Student Exh. 42) that depicts STUDENT responding to questions, in English, from his sister and from Ms. Yang, and that she did not change her opinion of STUDENT’s cognitive ability.(Footnote 22) The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the opinions of STUDENT’s church school teacher, Ms. Yang, and his mother that STUDENT’s ability to remember, point to and express words indicates that STUDENT has a higher cognitive ability level than that found by the District. Ms. Yang did not observe STUDENT in the classroom either at the Salk School (Magnolia District) or at the Lexington School, and STUDENT’s mother provided no detail regarding any classroom observations she may have made of STUDENT. Although Ms. Freeman, an OT, described STUDENT as “very trainable” after observing him for approximately forty-five minutes at his home, Ms. Freeman is not a psychologist and is not qualified to test a person’s cognitive ability.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the professional opinion and experience of Ms. Bush, and less weight to the opinions of STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Yang, regarding STUDENT’s cognitive level.(Footnote 22) The credible evidence establishes that Ms. Bush’s psychological assessment of STUDENT was appropriate.

Speech and Language Assessment

Student contends that the District’s speech and language assessment conducted by Stefanie Lee was not appropriate because it was not conducted in STUDENT’s primary language, Korean, and because it did not assess him in the area of oral motor.(Footnote 23)

The District contends that the Ms. Lee’s speech and language assessment was appropriate because it was conducted in accordance with the assessment plan consented to by STUDENT’s mother, which specifically provided that STUDENT’s language/speech assessment was to be conducted in the English language for educational planning purposes and that oral peripheral/oral motor evaluation was to be conducted for baseline therapy planning. The District further contends that an assessment in Korean was unnecessary because the District already had the Kleiman & Associates private assessment conducted in the Korean language, the validity of which the District questioned. The District also contends that Ms. Lee’s observations during her direct diagnostic oral motor services constituted an appropriate oral motor assessment for STUDENT.

It is undisputed that the assessment conducted by Ms. Lee was not conducted in the Korean language. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that with regard to the Peabody and Receptive vocabulary tests, the parties had agreed that the assessments would be conducted in English. According to the credible testimony of Ms. McLean and Ms. Lee, both experienced licensed speech-language pathologists, testing in those areas in the Korean language was not feasible because there are no speech-language assessments normed in Korean for American educators. Without normed tests, simply translating the Peabody and Receptive vocabulary tests into the Korean language would not lead to valid standard score test results, thereby raising issues of validity, because many words do not translate from English to Korean. For example, the word dromedary would translates into the Korean word for camel, a word much easier than dromedary. (Test. of Ms. McLean and Ms. Lee) Moreover, Ms. Lee questioned how the independent assessor, Younghee Park, the Kleiman assessor, could have determined standard scores for the Peabody and for the One-word Receptive vocabulary tests. Ms. Lee’s unrebutted testimony was that Younghee Park’s questioning of STUDENT alternating between Korean and English would not lead to valid or reliable test scores.(Footnote 24)

Ms. Lee testified that prior to assessing STUDENT, she spoke with his mother through an interpreter. Ms. Lee determined after administering the Peabody and Receptive vocabulary tests and observing STUDENT in the classroom that STUDENT has severely impaired speaking skills. Ms. Lee stated that STUDENT needs to use a picture exchange communication system (PECS) and that she also recommended direct consultative assistance (once per week in thirty-minute sessions) to STUDENT’s classroom teacher.

The credible evidence establishes that Ms. Lee’s speech-language assessment in the area of receptive and expressive language was appropriate.

In the area of oral motor, Ms. Lee testified that she assessed STUDENT’s oral motor ability for baseline therapy planning. The parties agreed to the assessment at the October 23, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Lee credibly testified that she had provided direct oral motor diagnostic services to STUDENT“every single week” since October 23 (approximately ten to twelve sessions) and that she also observed STUDENT in the classroom to develop a baseline. Ms. Lee stated that she was able to communicate with STUDENT in a manner sufficient to determine his level of oral motor functioning. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lee’s observations of STUDENT while she provided direct diagnostic oral motor services for a two-month period of two months was an appropriate method of assessing STUDENT’s oral motor needs. Ms. Lee found that STUDENT has severe oral motor deficits, not just in the area of motor strength, but also with initiation and motor coordination.

The Hearing Officer finds that the direct, diagnostic oral motor assessment conducted by Ms. Lee, was nonverbal and therefore did not need to be conducted in the Korean language. However, Ms. Lee did not present a written report to the IEP team that documents her diagnostic oral motor findings because she did not complete her direct diagnostic testing until she returned the second time to complete her testimony during the hearing. The District must report its complete oral motor findings in writing to the IEP team.(Footnote 25) California Education Code § 56327. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer is able to determine from the weight of the evidence that Ms. Lee conducted an appropriate speech-language and oral motor assessment of STUDENT.

Occupational Therapy Assessment

Student contends that the occupational therapy assessment conducted by Patricia Polcyn was not conducted in the Korean language.(footnote 26)

The District contends that Ms. Polcyn’s OT assessment was entirely nonverbal and that assessment of STUDENT in the Korean language was therefore unnecessary. The District also contends that Ms. Polcyn’s assessment was appropriate.

It is undisputed that Ms. Polcyn’s OT assessment of STUDENT was not conducted in the Korean language and that a Korean interpreter was not used. The Hearing Office finds that the District nevertheless conducted an appropriate OT assessment of STUDENT because Ms. Polcyn credibly testified that the standardized test instruments she used, the School Functional Assessment (SFA) and the Short Form, did not require STUDENT to follow verbal directions or to give verbal responses. Ms. Polcyn testified that she is a certified occupational therapist and has known and observed STUDENT(and provided consultative services to STUDENT’s teachers) for several years at the Salk elementary school and has been in and out of STUDENT’s classroom once per week.(Footnote 27) Ms. Polcyn stated that in her OT assessment, she reviewed STUDENT’s file, observed him in the classroom and around campus for a minimum of three and a half to four hours, interviewed his teacher and aide, and conducted formal standardized testing including the SFA and the Short form by completing questionnaires after interviewing the teacher and aide in STUDENT’s classroom. Ms. Polcyn further stated that she did not use the adolescent version of the Short Sensory Profile because STUDENT would not have been able to complete the questionnaire, given his limited cognitive and communicative abilities.

Ms. Polcyn’s testimony and report identified many areas of strength for STUDENT. The following are examples: STUDENT is able to move around the campus environment independently, sit at a table and a desk independently without any adaptive equipment with adequate postural control and balance; STUDENT is able to maneuver safely around objects and congested areas on campus and participates in his APE program and in classroom activities (assembly or community outings); STUDENT can eat independently with typical (not adaptive) utensils, and is able to communicate by gesturing and by pulling over to an object that he desires; STUDENT has adequate strength and muscle tone to carry his backpack independently and to access things within his backpack and is able to seek assistance when he needs it; STUDENT gathers needed materials such as paper and a crayon in front of him and can put his jacket on and off independently and put his shoes and socks on, with prompting.

Ms. Polcyn described STUDENT’s areas of weakness as his lack of ability to communicate and the frustration he feels because he cannot speak verbally; his limited willingness to engage in the classroom routine because he lacks behavioral control; his “medically-based” areas of weakness and lack of coordination and refined motor skill; his limited cognitive level; his limited level of understanding about the trial and error method of learning and the need for persistence; his dislike of using the toilet; his lack of understanding of written language and the purpose of lines on a piece of paper; and his lack of understanding of more advanced types of cause/effect problem solving.

Ms. Polcyn credibly testified to a thorough and appropriate occupational assessment of STUDENT in the educational environment. Although independent OT assessor Bonnie Freeman testified that Ms. Polcyn’s assessment was negatively biased and was based on “low expectations,” the Hearing Officer has noted numerous examples of STUDENT’s strengths cited within Ms. Polcyn’s report. No credible evidence was introduced to establish that Ms. Polcyn’s OT assessment was not appropriate, nor did the evidence show a negative bias. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Polcyn conducted an appropriate OT assessment of STUDENT and that STUDENT does not need another OT assessment at this time.

Physical Therapy Assessment

Student contends that the physical therapy assessment conducted by Susanne Treacher was not conducted in the Korean language and disputes the conclusion Ms. Treacher reaches that STUDENT does not need physical therapy to receive an educational benefit.

The District contends that Ms. Treacher’s assessment was entirely nonverbal and therefore an assessment in Korean was unnecessary. The District also contends that Ms. Treacher’s assessment was appropriate. The credible evidence establishes that Ms. Treacher was able to conduct an appropriate nonverbal physical therapy assessment of STUDENT through observation and completion of a portion of the SFA.

Ms. Treacher stated that she assessed STUDENT to determine if he could access the educational environment with sufficient mobility and had the physical skills necessary to benefit from a classroom setting. The assessment included a review of STUDENT’s reports, classroom observations, and observations of him moving about at school. (Test. of Ms. Treacher and Dist. Exh. 14) Ms. Treacher also completed a School Functional Assessment (SFA), a standardized assessment tool that determines if STUDENT’s self-help areas and independence at school are currently being addressed in his educational plan.

Ms. Treacher noted in her observations that STUDENT moves constantly about the classroom but “does not comply with directed activities not of his choice.” Under the category of Task Supports, Ms. Treacher determined that STUDENT scored low in the area because he needed constant supervision and that his limited cognitive skills, not his physical ability, were hindering his progress. Under the section of Physical Tasks, Ms. Treacher determined that STUDENT was able to ambulate independently on uneven surfaces, up and down inclines and ramps, through doorways, congested areas, and narrow openings without falling, but that STUDENT needed supervision to maneuver around ruts, holes or dangerous surfaces due to his limited judgment. Ms. Treacher also noted that STUDENT is able to rise from the floor independently and seat himself in a chair and rise from the chair independently and sit with adequate posture.

In summary, Ms. Treacher indicated that STUDENT exhibits “good physical skills, independent mobility, and independent sitting and standing balance.” Under recommendations, Ms. Treacher concluded that physical therapy services are not necessary in order for STUDENT to benefit fully from his educational placement. Ms. Treacher noted that under his current IEP, STUDENTreceives APE for interactive ball activities and gross motor skills.

STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Mr. Coleman, testified that he had only seen STUDENT fall once after he tripped. Ms. Yang indicates in an April 2002 letter that even though STUDENT has physical problems with walking and with body posture and fine motor skills, “he always” participates in field study and camping activities “without problems.” (Student Exh. 31) The Hearing Officer also notes that assessors and STUDENT’s SDC teacher generally describe STUDENT wandering, walking or pacing about the classroom, but none described a single falling incident within the classroom, except for instances of resistive conduct when he drops to the floor intentionally. (Test. of Mr. Coleman and Ms. Treacher) The November 7 IEP meeting notes indicate STUDENT’s mother reported that “STUDENT is able to walk up and down stairs at home and in the community” and that she believed that the stair goal from the March 13 IEP was “too low.” (Dist. Exh. 17) The weight of the credible evidence establishes that Ms. Treacher’s physical therapy assessment of STUDENT was an appropriate assessment.

Vision Assessment

Student contends that the functional vision assessment conducted by educational specialist Jane Vogel was not conducted in the Korean language and was not an appropriate assessment of STUDENT. Student contends that STUDENT needs a vision assessment conducted by an ophthalmologist or optometrist. The District contends that Ms. Vogel’s functional vision assessment was nonverbal and (conducted with clear short directions and relevant gestures) and therefore an assessment in Korean was unnecessary. The District also contends that Ms. Vogel’s assessment was appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that a functional vision assessment of STUDENT in the Korean language was unnecessary. Ms. Vogel, who observed that STUDENT did not speak during the assessment, essentially conducted a nonverbal functional vision assessment of STUDENT with gestures and vocal commands. (Test. of Ms. Vogel)

Ms. Vogel testified that she specializes in vision and visual processing as an educational specialist and works part-time in this capacity for the District, is also under contract with a number of other school districts within San Diego County and has conducted numerous vision assessments. Ms. Vogel performed a functional vision assessment to determine if STUDENT’s vision adversely affects his educational performance. Ms. Vogel conducted an extensive records review and administered nonverbal testing of STUDENT for visual acuity, field testing, how he uses vision for school work, and his motility. Ms. Vogel used the following assessment instruments: Peabody Model Vision Project Functional Vision Screening Test and the Lighthouse symbol cards. Ms. Vogel also conducted observations of STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Vogel and Dist. Exh. 12)

Ms. Vogel found that STUDENT has better than average vision (20/25) when matching Lighthouse symbol cards and that his vision is not adversely affecting his educational performance at this time. Ms. Vogel asserted that her testing was valid (“it was like playing a game with STUDENT”) but recommended that STUDENT’s vision be monitored once per year.

Student did not call a witness with qualifications in vision testing to refute the findings of Ms. Vogel, and Student cites no authority for the proposition that special education law requires that a district use the services of an opthalmologist or optometrist to conduct an appropriate vision assessment. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of Ms. Vogel, who was able to elicit the cooperation of STUDENT(by making the testing into a game) to complete a valid assessment, and less weight to anecdotal testimony that, because of past eye surgeries, the state of STUDENT’s vision adversely affects his educational performance. (Test. of STUDENT’s mother). Even STUDENT’s mother acknowledged that she did not notice any problems with STUDENT’s ability to see at her home, but only raised the concern when STUDENT was outside playing in the park.

Additionally, Ms. Vogel’s findings are corroborated by those of other assessors. The Kleiman assessor’s report indicates that STUDENT has functional eye contact with persons and objects, “if cooperative,” and that STUDENT was able to track an item visually in all directions, “especially with a preferred item” and that he “turned his head” in the direction of sound and when called by name. (Dist. Exh. 12) During the independent OT assessment conducted by Bonnie Freeman, STUDENT demonstrated the visual acuity to see which side of the block had the “x” on it and then placed the block properly within a 5 X 5 inch grid with the “x” side up. (Test. of Ms. Freeman and Ms. Polcyn) STUDENT was able to locate a ½” beige rubber band on a beige floor under a chair 5 feet away from him, suggesting a distance acuity better than 20/80 (Dist. Exh. 12) There was no credible evidence to support the contention that STUDENT frequently trips and falls or bumps into objects (to suggest a vision problem) (Test. of Ms. Treacher, Mr. Coleman, and Ms. Polcyn) The video of STUDENT engaged at home and at church in various activities indicates that STUDENT is able to use his vision functionally. The weight of the credible evidence establishes that Ms. Vogel conducted a valid and appropriate functional vision assessment and that STUDENT does not need another vision assessment at this time. Health and Development

Student contends that he needed an assessment in the area of health and development -- a “medical assessment” -- because Student’s health condition has affected attendance at school. The medical condition referred to by Student is “not necessarily CDC” but other “incidental” medical conditions. Student contends that he is basically very weak and gets “sick a lot” and that oftentimes he needs to be hospitalized. The District contends that health is not a suspected area of disability. The Hearing Officer finds that no persuasive, credible evidence to establish that Student’s parent ever requested a health assessment (the assessment plan refers to a functional vision assessment and an audiological assessment only) or that school records indicated a need for a health assessment. Mr. Coleman testified that STUDENT’s attendance at Lexington (except for the five-day suspension) has been good and that he arrives to school on time.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that health and development is not an area of suspected disability. Moreover, Student’s attorney, during the extensive discussion of issues, did not assert as an issue for hearing that STUDENT is other health impaired (OHI).

Audiological Assessment

Student contends that the District failed to complete an audiological assessment of him as agreed upon in the assessment plan. The District asserts that the issue is premature because the audiological examination conducted by audiologist Mary Olander could not be completed due to a wax build-up in STUDENT’s ears. Student contends that for purposes of assessment, the District was required to remove the wax build-up in his ears in order to complete the audiological assessment.

Although an audiological assessment report was admitted into evidence, the audiologist was not called by the District to testify at hearing. (Dist. Exh. 12) According to the October 23, 2002 IEP meeting notes, the audiologist explained her findings at the meeting and indicated that STUDENT demonstrated “grossly normal hearing sensitivity” and that the testing was of “fair reliability” but suggested further testing “after STUDENT consults with his physician for ear wax removal.”(footnote 29) (Dist. Exh. 12)

STUDENT’s mother testified that in the past, she has removed earwax from STUDENT’s ears and that she brought STUDENT to his doctor after the October 23 IEP meeting, but the doctor failed to remove the earwax. Ms. Kathleen Strobel, the District coordinating nurse for health services, credibly testified that excess earwax could affect an assessor’s ability to complete the assessment and that the proper procedure for the assessor is to refer the student to his family doctor. Ms. Strobel further stated that earwax removal is a medical procedure that the school nurse is not qualified to perform. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is not obligated to remove earwax from STUDENT’s ears to complete the audiological examination. Student provides no persuasive legal authority to the contrary. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District assessor assessed STUDENT to the extent it was possible to do so.

Adapted Physical Education (APE) Assessment

Student asserted during the issues discussion that the District had failed to include an APE assessment in the parties’ assessment plan but later agreed (at the November 7 IEP meeting) to conduct an APE assessment. The District contends that the issue is not ripe because it has already consented to conduct an APE assessment of STUDENT(at the November 7 IEP meeting).(footnote 30)

It is undisputed that the District agreed to conduct an APE assessment at the parties’ last IEP meeting held on November 7, just two months after the District agreed to a detailed formal assessment plan. There is no credible evidence to show that Student requested an APE assessment prior to the November IEP meeting, and no further IEP meetings were held during the course of the hearing. Moreover, APE was not, and is not an area of “suspected” disability because the District was, and is providing STUDENT with daily APE services (as a DIS). Student did not contend that he was not receiving APE services during the fall 2002. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not legally obligated to conduct an APE assessment prior to the November 7, 2002 IEP meeting.

Behavioral Assessment

It is undisputed that STUDENT has increasingly engaged in the following behaviors: pinching, scratching, pulling hair, resistive conduct such as dropping to the floor in the classroom, and biting. It is also undisputed that the behaviors are impeding STUDENT’s ability to receive an educational benefit. Although the parties’s agreed-upon assessment plan did not contain a behavioral assessment, the District’s psychologist, Ms. Bush, prepared a Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA) and presented it at the November 7 IEP meeting.

The parties acknowledge that STUDENT needs a behavioral intervention plan. The dispute is over the adequacy of the District’s response so far to STUDENT’s behavior and whether the District needs to conduct an FAA or FBA prior to preparing a BIP. The District contends that the FBA that was presented at the November 7 IEP meeting was an appropriate one. The District also contends that it also offered, at the November 7 IEP meeting, to conduct another FBA (including observations of STUDENT and an interview with STUDENT’s mother) and then to formulate an appropriate BIP through the IEP process.

STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Mr. Coleman, testified that on the first day STUDENT attended class (first week of September), he “put his teeth on my arm and one of the assistants” and also attempted to scratch, and that since that first day, we have had a “constant” problem. Mr. Coleman also stated that STUDENT attempts to scratch “pretty much” every day, “particularly Amber [aide] and that he usually begins “around” 11:00 a.m. and continues through the afternoon. Mr. Coleman also stated that STUDENT has even “gone after perfect strangers” while on class field trips, and that most of the biting incidents have occurred on the bus with bus aides. Mr. Coleman stated that STUDENT also pulls hair, and that it had happened on the very morning of the day Mr. Coleman testified, and that he has also observed STUDENT pull his mother’s hair and that she appeared to be angry and scolded him. STUDENT’s mother testified that this is STUDENT’s way of showing affection or his way of communicating that he likes someone. (see also Dist. Exh. 17) Generally, STUDENT grits his teeth just prior to engaging in scratching or hair pulling and nothing in his demeanor shows that he “likes” that person [Amber]. (Test. of Mr. Coleman)

It is undisputed that STUDENT was suspended from school for five days following an early November biting incident that occurred a few days before the November 7, 2002 IEP meeting. (Test. of Mr. Miller and Ms. Gaston) In response to the incident, Mr. Jim Miller, the District’s behavior specialist, testified that he provided consultative support to the classroom teacher and to aides and that the aides began wearing arm pads to prevent injury. Additionally, school psychologist Rebecca Bush prepared an FBA and presented it at the November 7 IEP meeting. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s mother did not consent to the IEP and did not consent to the FBA prepared by Ms. Bush and that a BIP was never implemented.

Student contends that the FBA was inappropriately developed outside of the IEP process and without IEP team involvement. This contention is unavailing. Mr. Miller, a behavior specialist with twelve years of experience as a behavior specialist and with experience as a Behavioral Intervention Case Manager (BICM), testified that it was entirely appropriate for Ms. Bush to develop the FBA on her own and then to present a developed BIP at the IEP meeting. Ms. Bush testified that she does not need parental consent to conduct observations of a student in the classroom. Student did not call any witnesses to refute the testimony of Ms. Bush and Mr. Miller regarding the appropriateness of the FBA and BIP. The testimony of District witnesses establishes that the District appropriately attempted to address escalating behaviors by seeking consultative support for staff from an experienced behavior specialist and by preparing an FBA and developing a BIP that was proposed to the IEP team at the November 7, 2002 IEP meeting. (Test. of Ms. Bush, Ms. Gaston, and Mr. Miller). The BIP identifies inappropriate behaviors, describes the setting conditions and functions of those behaviors, identifies behavioral goals and objectives, the behavior interventions to be employed, and timelines for achieving each goal. (Test. of Mr. Miller) However, the BIP could not be implemented without parental consent. (Test. of Mr. Miller)

It is undisputed that the District offered to conduct a second FBA, including observations of STUDENT and an interview with STUDENT’s mother. The assessment plan dated November 7, 2002, is attached to the IEP and is signed by Ms. Gaston.(footnote 32) Although the FBA is typically conducted in the school environment because STUDENT’s behavior problems are occurring at school, the parties may agree to include home-based as well as school-based observations. The FBA will be developed within the IEP process.

The Hearing Officer now addresses Student’s contention that the District erred in not developing or agreeing to the development of an FAA rather than an FBA. The November 7 IEP notes indicate the following: “Mr. Kim [attorney] is requesting a complete functional behavioral analysis (FBA) of STUDENT’s behavior. The District believes that we can develop a behavior intervention plan today. Mr. Kim’s request for an FBA will be addressed later in the meeting.” On the IEP signature page, at the bottom right corner, a notation reads: “Parent requests a Functional Analysis of Behavior Assessment be conducted prior to developing a positive behavior plan.” The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP language indicates that Student agreed to an FBA, but not to the FBA presented by Ms. Bush at the November 7 IEP meeting. Student appears to misunderstand the type of behavioral assessment available to the District under California law and federal law as of the November 7 IEP meeting.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District could not develop an FAA as of November 7, 2002. It is undisputed that STUDENT entered the District the first week of September 2002 without a behavioral plan and that the “current” IEP from the Magnolia District (Dist. Exhs. 7 and 8) does not specify any instructional or behavioral approaches for STUDENT.. Although STUDENT’s prior Magnolia District school records indicate behavioral concerns, Magnolia IEPs do not indicate that Magnolia ever prepared or implemented a behavioral plan or developed IEP instructional or behavioral approaches to address behavioral issues.

Moreover, Student cites no persuasive authority or evidence for the contention that the District was obligated to complete an FBA as soon as he arrived at Lexington the first week of September 2002, given that the District had no experience with him in the classroom. Mr. Miller testified that the FBA conducted by Ms. Bush was an appropriate first response to a single biting incident by STUDENT as of November 7, 2002, and that the single incident did not warrant an FAA (commonly referred to as a “Hughes Bill assessment”). Ms. Gaston stated that she was aware of one behavioral incident at Magnolia and that she had heard nothing from STUDENT’s mother regarding past incidents at Magnolia. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated by law to conduct an FAA as of November 7, 2002, because the IEP team had yet to develop and implement approaches instructional/behavioral) on STUDENT’s IEP, for example a BIP, that proved to be ineffective.

Additionally, Student provides no credible evidence and cites no persuasive authority for the proposition that Ms. Bush must have had prior experience with a student diagnosed with CDC in order to conduct an appropriate FBA. (Test. of Mr. Miller) It is undisputed that STUDENT’s behavior is impeding his learning and the learning of others, thereby requiring an FBA and a BIP. Ms. Bush credibly testified that she made two classroom observations of STUDENT for the psychological assessment and numerous weekly observations of his behavior up to the day before she testified (December 4). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the FBA conducted by the District and presented to the IEP team on November 7 was an appropriate initial functional analysis to address STUDENT’s behaviors and that a second FBA, proposed by the District, to be based upon classroom observations and parent interviews, is warranted. The IEP team that meets pursuant to the order of this Decision shall conduct an FBA and then prepare and implement a BIP. As will be discussed more fully below in Issue No. 4(d), an important issue in this case is whether the District can place a child in a more restrictive environment prior to providing supplementary aids and services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; and Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s behavior is interfering with his education and that a behavior intervention plan is required to meet his needs. It is also undisputed that a BIP was never implemented at his current placement at Lexington.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District conducted appropriate psychological, speech and language, vision, OT, PT, behavior, and audiological (to the extent the District was able to complete one) assessments of STUDENT. The weight of the credible evidence also establishes that the District tested STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, including behavior, and that the District has agreed to an APE assessment of STUDENT.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Kleiman and Associates and by Gallagher Pediatrics?

California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for an independent assessment. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the speech-language assessment conducted by Ms. Lee and the occupational therapy assessment conducted by Ms. Polcyn were appropriate. Moreover, the District fulfilled its obligations to develop an assessment plan within ten (10) days after commencement of the school year. California Education Code § 56321(a). Prior to the District’s development of an assessment plan, STUDENT’s parent had already obtained a speech-language assessment from Kleiman and Associates (June 20, 2002), and an occupational therapy assessment from Gallagher Pediatrics (August 13, 2002)(footnote 33). The Hearing Officer finds that the Kleiman and Gallagher assessments were not obtained because of a disagreement with the District’s assessments. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Kleiman and Associates and by Gallagher Pediatrics.

ISSUE NO. 3: If the District failed to conduct appropriate assessments and/or failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, is STUDENT entitled to additional independent assessments?

A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). An IEE means an evaluation conducted by a qualified examiner who is not employed by the public agency responsible for the education of the child in question. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(a)(3)(i). The phrase “at public expense” means that the public agency either pays for the full cost of the evaluation or ensures that the evaluation is otherwise provided at no cost to the parent. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(a)(3)(ii). If the parent obtains an IEE at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency and may be presented at the due process hearing. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)

The Hearing Office has found that the District conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENTin all areas of suspected disability. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parent is not entitled to additional independent assessments at public expense.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District offer STUDENT a program for the 2001-2002 ESY and a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(D); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards and conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a) and (b).

To determine whether the District offered or provided STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs and placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Board of Educ. Of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 and 207-08, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982); Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide to a child with a disability a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2nd Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2nd Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by the child’s disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 92nd Cir. 1997). The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.

In addition, the IDEA also provides that “to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are to be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. A child’s appropriate placement is commonly referred to as the child’s Least Restrictive Environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; and Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational placement: (a) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (b) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (c) comport with his IEP; and (d) be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE).

Student contends (1) that the goals and objectives drafted during the March 13 and May 13, 2002 IEP (“current IEP”) meetings and the November 7, 2002 IEP meetings are inappropriate and are either too challenging for STUDENT or have already been accomplished, or are vague and not measurable. Student also contends (2) that the District has failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate program or services at the Hope School and that it is not his least restrictive environment and that (3) STUDENT’s needs can be met at Lexington with a one-to-one aide and direct services in speech-language, occupational therapy, and physical therapy.

The District contends (1) that the goals and objectives for STUDENT in the current IEP and the November 7, 2002 IEP were appropriate at the time they were developed, and (2) that STUDENT does not need direct services in the areas of speech-language, occupational therapy, and physical therapy that (3) STUDENT’s appropriate placement is at the Hope School and that the Hope School is STUDENT’s LRE.

During the period 2001-2002 ESY

Student contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT a program for 2001-2002 ESY. The District contends that it offered STUDENT a program at the Hope School for 2001-2002 ESY.

ESY programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the regular school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s current IEP of March 2002 provides for ESY. The March 13 IEP meeting notes indicate the following: “The team recommends that STUDENTcontinue in SH/SDC at this time and transition to Hope school in summer or fall. The program at AUHSD (Hope School) was recommended and reviewed for parent. Donna Erickson, assistant principal/psychologist from Hope school, offered visitation days for Hope. Extended school year in AUHSD was offered.” It is undisputed that Ms. Erickson attended the IEP team meeting.

The District has not established that it made a clear written offer of placement at Hope School for 2001-2002 ESY. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994). The IEP language indicates that Hope was recommended for summer or fall and that ESY in the District was also offered. The Hearing Officer does not find that the terms “recommended” and “offer” can be used interchangeably, as was suggested by Ms. Miller. “Recommended” implies a choice for Hope enrollment, and the term “or” indicates an option of ESY attendance at Hope either in the summer or fall. The IEP language that indicates ESY was also offered in the District is not sufficient, because it does not identify the school location, either at Hope or at another school within the District. An ESY offer in the District suggests that the District operated other ESY programs available to STUDENT. The parties subsequent conduct supports that interpretation of the IEP language, because the District’s program specialist, Cherie Bauer, testified to unsuccessful attempts to arrange for a visitation by STUDENT’s mother at Lexington two weeks after the May 2002 IEP meeting. This suggests that Lexington was also under consideration. Because the District failed to establish that it made a clear written offer of ESY at the Hope School or at a specified alternative school, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for 2001-2002 ESY.

During the 2002-2003 school year

September 2002 through November 6, 2002

Student contends that certain March 13, 2002 IEP goals and objectives were not appropriate for STUDENT for various reasons. However, the Hearing Officer does not address this contention because the District failed to establish at hearing that it implemented the current IEP (March 13 and May 13) goals and objectives. Although STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Lexington, Mr. Coleman, testified that aides worked with STUDENT on math and reading, Mr. Coleman also stated that he had not seen, and had not been implementing, STUDENT’s current IEP. The District did not contend that it was not obligated to implement the current IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to comport with STUDENT’s current IEP resulted in a denial of a FAPE for the two-month period beginning the first week of September until November 6, 2002.

November 7, 2002 to the present

The Hearing Officer now evaluates the offer contained within the November 7, 2002 IEP to determine whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to provide him with an educational benefit.

(a) Was the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine whether the District’s offer of a program and placement at Hope was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT’s unique needs

The parties agree that STUDENT has low cognitive ability and that he has needs in the areas of communication, oral motor (to address his drooling), social skills development, behavior, fine motor, self-help, and assistive technology (AT). The parties also agree that STUDENT has a limited attention span and needs to be prompted about his learning and his behavior Student contends that he also has oral motor needs for developing his oral expressive language and has oral motor needs in feeding, chewing food, and swallowing. Student also contends that he has self-help/fine motor needs as follows: brushing his teeth properly, buttoning his shirts, and tying his shoelaces and that he has the following fine motor need: holding a pencil to write properly. Student also contends that he has gross motor needs in the areas of walking, standing, balancing and muscle training.

The Hearing Officer addresses Student’s contention that he has oral motor needs in the areas of feeding, chewing, and swallowing food. Not a single witness testified that STUDENT, at school, choked on food, or experienced difficulties feeding himself or chewing and swallowing food. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT can eat food and drink from a cup independently. Stefanie Lee testified that she observed STUDENT eat an apple without incident. The Hearing Officer finds that no credible evidence supports the contention that STUDENT has oral motor issues regarding feeding, chewing, and swallowing food.

The parties acknowledge that STUDENT has a severe impairment in oral expressive language. Because the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s primary mode of communication is by gesture, pointing, and picture exchange, the Hearing Officer finds that expressive language, that is, the development of nonverbal communication skills, is an area of need for STUDENT.

In the area of self-help/fine motor (the areas overlap), the District acknowledges that STUDENT at age twelve and one-half, is not fully toilet-trained and has difficulties buttoning and unbuttoning clothing and cannot tie his shoes. The Hearing Officer finds that toilet-training, buttoning and unbuttoning clothing, and tying shoes are areas of need for STUDENT. The District disputes that brushing teeth is an area of need for STUDENT No credible evidence was presented at the hearing in support of the contention that STUDENT cannot brush his teeth. In the area of gross motor, the District acknowledges that muscle training and coordination are deficits for STUDENT but disputes walking and standing as areas of need. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has areas of need in muscle training and coordination, but the Hearing Officer finds that no credible evidence was presented at hearing to support the contention that STUDENT trips and falls frequently at school, or that STUDENT has difficulty walking or standing. Mr. Coleman testified that he saw STUDENT trip and fall once. District witnesses testified that STUDENT often drops to the floor to resist a directive and often walks around in the classroom. (Test. of Mr. Coleman, Ms. Polcyn, Ms. Bush, and Ms. Treacher).

The Hearing Officer now analyzes the District’s proposed goals and objectives to determine their appropriateness in light of STUDENT’s needs.

Goals and Objectives

The District formulated the following proposed social skills development goal: “STUDENTwill allow other students to interact with him 50% of the time by March 13, 2003.” The objectives are as follows: 20%, 30% and 40% accuracy as measured by observation by school staff. Student contends that the goal is too vague and is not measurable. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is sufficiently detailed to be appropriate and is measurable. It is undisputed that STUDENT does not interact with peers in the classroom. (Test. of Mr. Coleman and Ms. Bush) The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives appropriately address STUDENT’s need to increase interaction with his peers.

In the area of domestic (self-help), the District proposed the following annual goal: STUDENT will demonstrate that he can use a sponge and water for cleaning with no more than one prompt by March 13, 2003. The goal is based upon the following performance level: “STUDENT will not at this time make any effort to do any type of cleanup work.” The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives appropriately address STUDENT’s need to develop a “self-help” skill of engaging in cleanup work.

In the area of fine motor, the District proposed the following annual goal: STUDENT will hold a writing utensil and trace three shapes or letters with minimal prompting by March 13, 2003 with 50 percent accuracy. The goal is based on a classroom performance description that STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to hold/grasp small objects. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives appropriately address STUDENT’s need to develop this important fine motor skill. Student’s contention that this objective is “demeaning” for him because of the degree of his fine motor deficits is unpersuasive because STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to hold/grasp a pencil and small objects. Moreover, the videotape shows STUDENT properly holding a crayon.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the proposed self-help goal (in oral motor) that STUDENT will learn to wipe his mouth with a cloth and/or to swallow by March 13, 2003, is sufficiently detailed and measurable and is appropriate for STUDENT The assertion that the goal and objectives do not address the underlying causes of drooling is unavailing. The underlying causes appear to be complex, and the condition may or may not be ameliorated through medical intervention. Moreover, Ms. Freeman testified to the appropriateness of developing an oral motor goal.

The District has proposed the following prevocational goal: that STUDENT will follow adult directives with only one reminder with 50 percent accuracy by March 13, 2003. The goal is based upon the observation that STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to follow verbal directives. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is appropriate and has a reasonable purpose: to develop STUDENT’s ability to follow the directives of District staff members so that he can work on his goals and objectives. The goal also addresses STUDENT’s attentional issues.

The Hearing Officer finds appropriate the following proposed mathematics goal: that STUDENT will demonstrate number recognition (up to 10) and will be able to count up to three objects by March 13, 2003 with 60 percent accuracy. The mathematics goal is based upon the understanding that STUDENT“appears” to be able to count up to three objects (inconsistently) and also seems to recognize some numbers. Student’s contention that this goal reflects the District’s lack of understanding regarding his memory skill, referring to his performance on the videotape, is unpersuasive. It is undisputed that STUDENT inconsistently counts up to three objects and seems to recognize some numbers. Moreover, District witnesses did not alter their opinions regarding STUDENT’s ability or skill level after reviewing the videotape.

The Hearing Officer finds appropriate the following proposed reading goal, that STUDENT will demonstrate letter recognition and first name letter recognition by March 13, 2003 with 50 percent accuracy. The reading goal is based on the following: STUDENT can recognize some letters of the alphabet and he can recognize his name at times. Although Student asserts that the goal regarding name recognition was “accomplished” in 1999 (the goal only addressed name recognition), it is undisputed that he does not always recognize his name and that he does not recognize all letters of the alphabet.

The Hearing Officer also notes that the District has offered goals and objectives for the development of STUDENT’s communication skills with a PECS program and in the using gestures. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are sufficiently detailed and measurable and are consistent with STUDENT’s developmental level in the area of communication. The Hearing Officer notes Ms. Younghee Park’s second recommendation within her report that “[d]ue to STUDENT’s increased picture identification ability, STUDENT will communicate using PECS in order to indicate his needs.” The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Student’s contention that he needs goals in the area of speech and language to learn to speak verbally. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Lee and Ms. McLean that STUDENT needs to develop his nonverbal communication skills through PECS.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the above proposed goals and objectives are appropriate ones for STUDENT and reflect unrefuted present levels of performance and address areas of need for STUDENT Moreover, the short-term objectives are concrete and measurable. Student offers no persuasive evidence that the proposed goals and objectives are set too low or too high or are too vague and not measurable or are not reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Additional self-help goals and objectives needed by STUDENT

Although the March 2002 IEP present levels of performance indicate that STUDENT was toilet-trained, it is undisputed that he is, at best, only partially toilet-trained. According to the testimony of STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Mr. Coleman, STUDENT comes to school in diapers and is only “partially” toilet-trained. Mr. Coleman stated that he viewed the videotape (Student Exh.42) brought to him by STUDENT’s mother and then “had a couple of successes” with STUDENT in this area, but on several occasions STUDENT would not go to the bathroom. It is unclear what the problem is. The videotape (Student Exh. 42) shows that STUDENT can use the toilet independently. However, STUDENT has difficulty buttoning (or zipping) his trousers independently. Ms. Freeman testified that STUDENT may be experiencing a problem transitioning into a new school environment (different bathroom location). The problem appears to be two-fold: a transitional one of helping STUDENT develop independence in going to the restroom on his own at a “new school” (Lexington or Hope), with or without prompting, and helping STUDENT learn to unbutton and button (zip and unzip) his trousers.(footnote 34) Ms. Freeman recommended that an IEP goal be developed to address this very important issue. The Hearing Officer agrees. Accordingly, the IEP team is directed to address this area of need by formulating an appropriate and measurable IEP goal and objectives both in the area of buttoning and unbuttoning (and zipping and unzipping) his trousers and in toilet-training.(footnote 35)

Although STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT can use a fork and knife and eat independently, it is unclear whether STUDENT has the cognitive ability to learn to tie his shoes. According to the testimony of Mr. Coleman, STUDENT’s only verbalization to him is to point to his shoes and says “sue” (for “shoe”). Because this is an area where STUDENT has the awareness to request that someone tie his shoes, a goal and objectives should be formulated to develop STUDENT’s independence in this area. Ms. Polcyn testified that tying shoes is very difficult for children. That may be true, but STUDENT should be given a chance to develop this very important assisted daily living (ADL) skill. Accordingly, the District is directed to formulate a goal and objectives for tying shoes.

Designated Instructional Services (DIS)

The Hearing Officer will now address the services requested by Student. Although the District has offered placement at Hope, the following determination applies as well to STUDENT’s current placement. The District’s contends that STUDENT does not require direct specialized services (DIS) from an OT for his oral motor and fine motor needs, a speech- language pathologist for oral motor needs and speech language therapy, a PT for gross motor needs, and an AT for AT needs.

California Education Code Section 56363(a) provides the following, in relevant part, in regard to the provision of Designated Instruction and Services (DIS), “related services” under the federal law: “[DIS] as specified in the [IEP] shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. The instruction and services shall be provided by the regular class teacher, the special class teacher, or the resource specialist if the teacher or specialist is competent to provide such instruction and services and if the provision of such instruction and services by the teacher or specialist is feasible. If not, the appropriate [DIS] specialist shall provide the instruction and services...” Section 56363(b) provides in relevant part that these services may include (but are not limited to) Language and speech development and remediation, Audiological services, Adapted physical education, Physical and occupational therapy, Vision services and Health and nursing services.

Oral Motor Therapy

Student asserts that he requires direct oral motor therapy to address his problems with drooling. It is undisputed that STUDENT drools frequently. There are several plausible, underlying causes for STUDENT’s drooling. Speech-language therapist Stefanie Lee testified that a contributing factor is that STUDENT’s top teeth “stick out very far” and it is hard for him to close his mouth, and that his posture is down ”a lot of the time,” and he does “a lot of chewing,” which stimulates the production of more saliva. Ms. Lee also stated that STUDENT doesn’t seem to have enough self-awareness (relating to his cognitive deficiency) to be able to wipe his mouth or to realize that he is drooling. Independent OT Bonnie Freeman stated that there is a medical basis for the drooling and that STUDENT’s needs to increase his oral motor strength “by chewing gum.” Private speech-language assessor PARENT identified oral motor as an area of need for STUDENT but acknowledged that she did not have sufficient time to conduct an oral motor examination of STUDENT

The Hearing Officer weighs the testimony of Ms. Park and Ms. Freeman, who did not conduct an oral motor assessment of STUDENT with that of Ms. Lee, who conducted direct oral motor diagnostic services to STUDENT over a two-month period. Ms. Lee concluded that she did not find any improvement from the direct services and did not believe that STUDENT would benefit from such services. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require oral motor therapy to meet his needs and to benefit from his educational program. As indicated above, the District has proposed an appropriate self-help goal in the area of oral motor.

Speech-language therapy

Student asserts that he requires direct speech-language therapy services to develop his oral expressive language skills. The District contends that STUDENT needs to develop his picture exchange system and will not progress adequately in speech production to warrant direct speech-language therapy services.

Ms. Younghee Park recommends direct speech-language therapy services to STUDENT three times per week, but Ms. Park’s recommendation is largely based upon receptive language scores in English and Korean that place STUDENT at the four to five-year-old performance level. The scores have not been corroborated by any other testing and appear unreliable because the testing can not be normed in Korean and the testing was conducted in an alternative English and Korean language format. (Test. of Ms. Lee) The results are not consistent with STUDENT’s performance on all other expressive and receptive speech and language testing that places him at the two-year-old performance level.

The evidence has established that STUDENT communicates primarily through gesture, pointing and by using PECS. (Test. of Mr. Coleman, Ms. Lee, Ms. Bush, and Ms. Younghee Park). The fact that STUDENT soon to be age thirteen, may learn to speak an additional ten more words (paired with signs) in one year after intensive direct speech-language therapy services (Test. of Ms. Younghee Park), is not a reasonable basis for giving him direct speech-language therapy.

Ms. McLean, a program specialist and an experienced licensed speech-language pathologist (with seventeen or eighteen years of giving speech-language services), credibly testified that STUDENT’s prognosis for speech production is “very, very poor” because in her experience and based upon the available research, students who have not developed functional oral communication skills by the ages of “approximately five or six,” in the vast majority of cases, will not develop functional oral communication skills. Ms. McLean stated that the development of PECS arose out of this research and the finding that “you could do oral language drills forever” and you aren’t going to get progress, which led to the realization that functional oral communication is “impossible” and that students needed an alternative way of communication. Ms McLean added, “looking at speech as the primary mode of communication, if they haven’t established it early on, it does not come.” Ms. McLean, commenting on the Kleiman assessment, stated that the report indicates a “very, very limited repertoire of words” and that one of the best prognostic devices is the rate of learning to date and that the prognosis is very poor for a twelve-year-old child who has learned to pronounce fewer than ten words. Ms. McLean stated that the Kleiman report’s first recommended goal, that STUDENT will produce ten target words (paired with signs) in one year, did not change her prognosis.

Ms. McLean further stated that the oral motor part of the assessment conducted by the District was to provide a “baseline,” a brief time of speech diagnostic therapy to see if there is “any change whatsoever in those abilities.” Ms. McLean observed that cognitive ability is “incredibly important” to be able to work on oral motor and that “you have to have an intact memory to be able to do generalization, to be able to work on some of those skills.” Ms. McLean’s testimony was not refuted.

STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Mr. Coleman testified that in his experience working with STUDENT in the classroom, STUDENT’s communication skills are “as close to non-existent as you probably can get” and that STUDENT tries to “get you to understand by taking your hand and pointing to something,” or “taking your hand and leading you to it, and then you can “kind of figure out” what he wants. Mr. Coleman said that it’s “pretty hard” to make any kind of academic progress if a child can’t communicate and that STUDENT“does not communicate verbally.” Ms. Lee describes his speech as “very limited” and does not recommend speech-language therapy.

The evidence also indicates that STUDENT has been able to memorize a few words and to point to words on a tv screen after prompting.(Footnote 36) Moreover, the credible evidence, including STUDENT’s performance in response to promptings on the videotape (Student Exh. 42), do not persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT is reading but instead has memorized a few words. (Test. of Ms. McLean) Student’s contention that direct speech-language therapy was never given to him in the past, and that an effort should now be made is also unavailing. Past Magnolia District IEPs indicate that STUDENT was given direct speech-language therapy. (see Student Exhs. 7, 9, and 12, for the 3/95, 3/96, and 3/97 IEPs, respectively). For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of thirty-minute per week consultations from the speech therapist to STUDENT’s teacher is reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s need to develop an alternative mode of communication, PECS. A district is required by law to provide a program reasonably designed to meet a child’s unique needs but is not required to provide the best program or a program that maximizes a student’s education. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).

PT and OT services in the areas of gross and fine motor skills

Student contends that he needs direct PT and OT services. Student argued that he needs PT therapy two times per week in thirty-minute sessions to develop his gross motor needs, especially, his leg muscles because he has difficulty walking without tripping, falling and injuring himself. As indicated above, the Hearing Officer found that the PT assessment conducted by Ms. Treacher was appropriate and also found that there was no credible evidence that STUDENT has difficulty walking and that he falls often in the educational setting. The credible evidence establishes that STUDENT does not need physical therapy services to meet his needs and to provide him with an educational benefit. (Test. of Ms.Treacher)

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT needs direct OT services to develop his fine motor skills. Ms. Freeman recommended that STUDENT receive three forty-five minute sessions of OT services per week. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the opinion of Ms. Polcyn, who administered a school-based assessment, observed STUDENT in the classroom and on campus, and interviewed STUDENT’s teacher and aide, before concluding that STUDENT does not need direct OT services in order to receive an educational benefit. Moreover, Ms. Polcyn, who has known and observed STUDENT for several years, and conducted a four and one-half hours on her assessment. Ms. Freeman spent a fraction of an hour interviewing STUDENT’s mother, did not assess STUDENT in the area of gross motor, observed STUDENT at most, for a total of forty-five minutes “in segments,” did not observe him in the classroom setting and did not speak with his teacher or aide. Moreover, Ms. Polcyn’s findings are consistent with the findings of the Gallagher assessment that did not recommend direct OT services. Ms. Polcyn’s findings are also consistent with STUDENT’s overall low cognitive functioning and ability levels. The credible evidence establishes that STUDENT does not need direct OT services to meet his needs and to provide him with an educational benefit.

AT services

The District’s program offer at Hope also provides for the use of the following: communication pictures, a single switch output device, and an alternative keyboard with cause/effect software. It is undisputed that the equipment recommended within AT specialist’s Kathy Lewis’s report (Student Exh. 44) is reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs for developing alternative ways for him to communicate through the equipment. Student’s contention that he requires OT services and an OT specialist, and not an AT specialist or special education teacher, to train him on the use of the specialized equipment, and the contention that STUDENT requires direct AT services three times per week was unsupported by any credible evidence. (Test. of Ms. Polcyn) The credible evidence establishes that STUDENT does not need direct AT services to meet his needs and to provide him with an educational benefit.

One-to-one aide

Student contends that his needs can be met (with appropriate services and an appropriate BIP) only if he has the services of a one-to-one behavioral/instructional aide, preferably bilingual, at Lexington. STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Coleman, testified that STUDENT’s Lexington class contains only ten students and that he is assisted by three instructional assistants, but Mr. Coleman also stated that STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide to function in his classroom.(Footnote 37) The current classroom ratio is one adult to two students, approximately the same ratio as that provided for at the Hope school (one adult to two or three students). (Dist. Exh. 17) There is evidence that the District is currently providing STUDENT with a one-to-one aide at the present time at Lexington. (Test. of Mr. Coleman; see also Ms. Treacher’s PT report) Mr. Coleman testified that the one area he has seen growth in is STUDENT’s behavior and that “Lorraine [aide] does work very well with him.” It is undisputed that STUDENT’s attention span is limited to approximately fifteen to twenty minutes. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT’s unique behavioral and educational needs requires a full-time one-to-one aide as long as an instructional assistant or the classroom teacher is nearby. The low adult student ratio (one adult for two or three children) at Hope (and at Lexington) appears to be adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs for prompting, direction and behavioral control without the need for a one-to-one aide. Moreover, it is undisputed that STUDENT responds to visual and verbal prompting in the English language. (Test. of Ms. Polcyn). Accordingly, the credible evidence establishes that STUDENT does not need prompting from a bilingual aide.

The credible testimony concerning the qualifications, experience and training of Hope staff members, establishes that the District’s offer at Hope appropriately addresses STUDENT’s need for prompts given STUDENT’s attention deficits and that Hope staff members will have sufficient knowledge of STUDENT’s special education disability (significantly below average intellect) as well as his behavioral issues to meet his needs. (Test. of Ms. Miller) Because the order of this Decision provides that another FBA be conducted and that a BIP be implemented, it is premature to decide that STUDENT needs a one-to-one aide at this time.

The District’s offer of placement at Hope School

The District’s offer includes placement at the Hope School, a dedicated campus to meet the needs of severely handicapped students. The offer includes APE 42 minutes daily in a group setting (STUDENT received APE just twice per week under the March IEP); speech-language consultation to the classroom thirty minutes per week to assist the classroom teacher in providing a comprehensive communication system throughout STUDENT’s school day (including recommended AT including communication pictures, a single switch output device, and an alternative keyboard with cause/effective software; implementation of PECS throughout the day; and implementation of STUDENT’s behavioral intervention plan.) STUDENT’s class schedule provides that his goals in communication, reading, math, written language, social skills, domestic skills, self-help skills, and pre-vocational skills would be addressed and interwoven into all the lessons and activities throughout the school day. STUDENT also would be provided with community-based instruction experiences and class field trips. The SDC size is “eight to ten” students with a ratio of one adult to “two or three students.” The curriculum includes functional academic skills and computer skills to support academics. (Dist. Exh. 17)

Marilyn Miller, the Hope School principal, testified that Hope has approximately 260 special education students and that regular education students do not attend the school. Instead, the school has a “reverse inclusion” program by which non-disabled high school-age peers come to the campus and work with the students either as peer tutors, teacher assistants or work with the drama class and participate in a joint drama program. (Test. of Ms. Miller) Ms. Miller also stated that the school has a fine arts program offering art, drama, or music classes, and that each classroom is equipped with computers and programs so that students are able to work on computer activities to enhance their functional academics.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program at Hope addresses STUDENT’s unique needs for a small classroom environment with consistent and appropriate behavioral support and structure, with staff trained in behavioral intervention. Hope also provides trained staff to implement a picture exchange system to assist STUDENT in communicating his needs. STUDENT’s cognitive needs are met by Hope’s program for functional academics and opportunity to work with computers. Hope’s campus (260 students) is much smaller than Lexington’s (1,100 to 1,200 students) and would be more suitable for STUDENT given his overall functioning level.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of a program at the Hope School, together with the proposed goals and objectives and offer of daily A.P.E. services and speech-language consultation services to the special education classroom teacher once per week in thirty minute sessions, is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, except in the area of self-help goals and objectives as noted above.

(b) Is the District’s offer of placement at the Hope School reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

The District contends that its offer of placement at Hope is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit and that STUDENT does not need direct services (DIS) to benefit from his educational program. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and that STUDENT does not need direct DIS in speech-language, OT, AT, and physical therapy in order to benefit educationally from his program. Education Code Section 56363. The District contends that its offer of services and program are commensurate with STUDENT’s low cognitive ability level. The credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of placement at Hope is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

(c) Comport with his IEP

The issue was not in dispute. STUDENT’s mother did not accept the Hope placement offer.

(d) Is the District’s offer of placement at the Hope School STUDENT’s LRE?

The LRE requirement is set forth under federal law as follows:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities...are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; California Education Code § 56364.2.)

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.) In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test (omitted for reasons given below). (Sacramento Unified School District v. Holland (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 91994).)

In this case, the District contends that STUDENT’s appropriate placement is at the Hope School, and not at Lexington. The Hearing Officer notes that both educational environments are SDCs. However, the Hope School is on a segregated campus, with only an opportunity for “reverse inclusion,” of unknown frequency, whereas at Lexington, STUDENT is given an opportunity to interact with nondisabled peers at lunch and recess on a comprehensive campus. The Hearing Officer finds that the Hope School is a more restrictive environment. (Test. of Ms. Miller)

The Holland analysis does not apply directly to the facts in this case because STUDENT is not attending any regular education classes at Lexington. Moreover, applying the Holland test partially or by analogy to the facts of this case is not necessary because the District cannot show that supplemental aids and services specified in STUDENT’s IEP have proven unsatisfactory.

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Lexington, Mr. Coleman, has not implemented STUDENT’s BIP (drafted by Ms. Bush) because STUDENT’s mother would not consent to the District’s proposed FBA at the November 7, 2002 IEP meeting. Accordingly, the District cannot move STUDENT to a more restrictive environment (Hope) until it has provided “supplemental services and aids” that have proven unsatisfactory. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not, and cannot establish that Hope is STUDENT’s least restrictive environment until it has implemented an appropriate BIP for STUDENT at Lexington (that has proven unsatisfactory). The District and STUDENT’s mother are directed to cooperate in conducting another FBA and in implementing a BIP.

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a program or a FAPE during the aforementioned periods, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1). The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing a day for day replacement for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497.

The District denied STUDENT a FAPE for 2001-2002 ESY by failing to made a clear written offer of ESY at a particular school. The District also denied STUDENT a FAPE for the two-month period, September to November 2002 because it did not establish that it implemented STUDENT’s current IEP goals and objectives during that time period. The District also failed to provide goals and objectives in the self-help areas as indicated above for the 2002-2003 school year. The Hearing Officer found that the assessments conducted by the District were appropriate and that the District’s services and other goals and objectives for the school year were appropriate. However, the District was not able to establish that Hope is STUDENT’s LRE.

The Hearing Officer also notes that Student has agreed to unspecified compensatory education services from Magnolia as a result of a settlement agreement reached with the Magnolia District. The Hearing Officer also weighs the parties’ interest that the terms of the settlement agreement not be disclosed in this Decision, and therefore, considering all of the relevant evidence and factors, the Hearing Officer declines awarding compensatory education services directly to STUDENT but does award OT consultation services directly to the Lexington special education teacher in the amount of thirty minutes per week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year and to STUDENT’s District teacher for the 2002-2003 ESY.(Footnote 38) The consultation services will address implementation of the self-help goals and objectives developed by the IEP team, as referred to above. An appropriate award of direct compensatory education services would be speculative at this time, given the unknown nature and quantity of compensatory services that Magnolia District will be providing to STUDENT Moreover, it is a matter of conjecture whether STUDENT could reasonably benefit from additional compensatory services in light of his low cognitive ability, attentional issues, and current behavioral problems. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s behavior is impeding his ability to receive an educational benefit at this time. Implementation of a BIP following an FBA appears to be the number one priority for STUDENT The Hearing Officer has also considered the relatively limited time period, approximately three and one half months, that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE.

ORDER

1. The District shall maintain STUDENT in his present placement during the 2003-2003 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise.

2. Within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for the following purposes: (a) to formulate goals and objectives in the area of self-help; (b) to provide for weekly OT consultative services to STUDENT’s special education teacher as indicated within the body of this Decision; (c) to furnish Student with a written report containing Ms. Lee’s oral motor diagnostic findings.

3. Within twenty-one calendar days of the IEP meeting, the IEP team is directed to undertake and complete an FBA that will include observations of STUDENT and an interview with STUDENT’s mother.

4. Within five calendar days of the FBA’s completion, the District is directed to develop a BIP.

5. Within five calendar days of the BIP’s development, the District shall begin implementing the BIP.

6. All other claims for relief made by Student and the District are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District and SELPA conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT **The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.

2. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Kleiman and Associates and by Gallagher Pediatrics? **The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.

3. If the District and SELPA failed to conduct appropriate assessments and/or failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, is STUDENT entitled to additional independent assessments? **The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.

4. Did the District and SELPA offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 ESY and 2002-2003 school year? **The Student prevailed with regard to ESY 2001-2002 and the two-month period, September through November 6, 2002. The District/SELPA substantially prevailed with regard to the program and services offered to Student, except in the area of self-help goals and objectives. Student prevailed on the issue of placement at Hope and the LRE issue.

5. If the District and SELPA failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the aforementioned periods, is he entitled to compensatory education? **Student only prevailed to the extent of compensatory OT consultation services thirty minutes per week directly to the special education classroom teacher for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal.Educ.Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: March 3, 2003 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The hearing was continued for good cause on December 6, 2002, after one-half hour of testimony from the day’s first witness because of the illness of one of the attorneys. 2. Student’s issues were clarified following extensive discussions among the parties that took up the entire first hearing day. The District seeks an order, on its cross-filing, that it assessed STUDENT appropriately and in all areas of suspected disability, and that it offered Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 ESY and for the 2002-2003 school year. The issues have been revised and rearranged to facilitate analysis and discussion. The discussion is limited to issues properly raised during the discussion of issues on the first hearing day. 3. Section 3030(h) of the California Code of Regulations provides for special education eligibility for a pupil who has “significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, which adversely affect a pupil’s educational performance.” 4. Magnolia Elementary School District was dismissed as a party to this proceeding following a reported settlement agreement entered into between Student and the Magnolia District. 5. Cri du chat (CDC) syndrome refers to a combination of physical and developmental features resulting from the absence of genetic material in the short arm of chromosome 5. Cri du chat (“cry of the cat”) refers to the high-pitched mewing cries made by children with the syndrome. (Student Exh. 40) Children born with CDC exhibit delays in learning, mobility, speech, gross and fine motor skills and in toilet training. (Student Exh. 43). STUDENT appears to fit the classic picture of CDC in its more severe form of retardation including the absence of or very little speech. (Test. of Ms. Stefanie Lee) 6. STUDENT’s mother’s name is PARENT and the Kleiman speech-language assessor’s name is Younghee Park. To avoid confusion, the Hearing Officer refers within the Decision to PARENT as STUDENT’s mother and to the speech-language assessor as Ms. Younghee Park. 7. The Hearing Officer sustained the District’s objection to the admission into evidence of the interim agreement (Student’s Exhibit 36) on the grounds of confidentiality and relevance; see Section 3086 of Title 5 of the C.C.R. Moreover, mediated interim agreements are not binding final agreements, and Student has provided no authority for the extension of SEHO’s jurisdiction to the enforcement of nonbinding interim confidential agreements entered into at mediation. California Education Code § 56501(a). 8. The assessment plan provided for assessments in the following areas: achievement, adaptive behavior, cognitive, language/speech, psycho-motor, social/emotional, assistive technology, and health (audiological and functional vision assessments). (Student Exh. 45) 9. Speech-language pathologist Stefanie Lee also administered, by agreement of the parties, direct diagnostic oral motor services to STUDENT during the period October 23 to December 13, 2002. (Test. of Stefanie Lee 10. The caption for Case No. SN02-02533 initially identified the SELPA as a respondent. At hearing, the caption was corrected, without objection, to identify the SELPA as cross-Petitioner. Following the District’s unopposed motion for consolidation, Case Nos. SN02-01316 and SN02-02533 were consolidated by minute order. 11. References to the District within the area of assessments refer to the District and SELPA collectively, unless the term District or SELPA is used to identify a particular District or SELPA assessor. 12. C.C.R. Section 3023(a) provides that the assessments shall be administered by qualified personnel who are competent in both the oral or sign language skills and written skills of the individual’s primary language or mode of communication and have a knowledge and understanding of the cultural and ethnic background of the pupil. If it clearly is not feasible to do so, an interpreter must be used, and the assessment report shall document this condition and note that the validity may have been affected. 13. Primary language” means the language other than English, or other mode of communication, the person first learned, or the language which is spoken in the person’s home.’ Title 5, CCR section 3001(x). It is undisputed that STUDENT’s sisters speak to him in English, and STUDENT’s mother speaks to him in Korean. (Test. of STUDENT’s mother) The earliest documentary records refer to STUDENT saying “papa” and “mama.” The record is unclear whether STUDENT first learned the limited number of words that he is able to understand or express in the Korean or English language, or whether he learned the words he knows in both languages at the same time. IEP documents refer to Korean as STUDENT’s primary language. 14. Student did not place in dispute the qualifications of any of the District assessors. 15. Student did not assert as an issue for hearing the appropriateness of the assistive technology assessment conducted by assistive technology specialist Kathy Lewis. (Student Exh. 44). Ms. Lewis was not called by either party to testify at the hearing. Rather, Student contends that the District failed to offer an appropriate level of direct AT services to STUDENT. This contention is addressed under the FAPE analysis. 16. STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Yang testified that STUDENT demonstrates skill and ability levels higher than that found by the District. Independent OT, Bonnie Freeman, testified that STUDENT is “trainable” in OT areas. 17. As indicated earlier, Student’s attorney is bilingual (Korean and English) and participated in revisions for the assessment plan with Student’s mother and the school psychologist. 18. Ms. Bush stated that she is a licensed educational psychologist with a national certification, the credential that she operates under within the District since 1995. 19. Ms. Yang testified that “in most cases, STUDENT uses his body gestures for expressing something, but if he really needs to ask for something that he needs, he uses the words of his own vocabulary.” 20. The parties wrangled over whether STUDENT is verbal or nonverbal. Ms. Younghee Parks’ opinion that a child who speaks just two words is verbal is not persuasive, because it is undisputed that there is no standard definition followed by speech pathologists to determine whether a child is verbal.

21. District witnesses who viewed STUDENT’s performance on the videotape (Student Exh. 42) uniformly testified that it did not change their opinions of his ability or skill level. The videotape appeared to be edited and did not depict standardized testing in a controlled test environment. 22. The Hearing Officer nevertheless finds that the obvious love and care shown to STUDENT by his mother, and sisters and by Ms. Yang is appropriate to encourage STUDENT in the development of his life skills and his communicative skills. The Hearing Officer also notes the testimony of STUDENT’s special education teacher, Mr. Coleman, who stated that STUDENT may have greater ability than he is showing. However, the Hearing Officer must give appropriate weight to the conclusions of a trained and experienced licensed educational psychologist. 23. As noted within, the District’s speech-language assessor completed direct oral motor diagnostic assessment of STUDENT during the course of the due process hearing. 24.Ms. Stefanie Lee and Ms. McLean, both experienced speech-language assessors, consistently testified that standardized testing in the Korean language was not feasible and that the purpose of the District assessment was to determine the feasibility of teaching STUDENT in the English language (“for educational planning purposes”). 25.Ms. Lee presented some of her oral motor findings, through observations conducted prior to October 23, within the written assessment report. However, the report does not contain Ms. Lee’s findings beginning with her observations on October 23. 26. Student contention that the District should provide direct OT services is addressed within the FAPE analysis. The Hearing Officer addresses within the contention that the District assessor was biased against Student and did not find areas of strength and that the District expectations for Student’s ability to progress in motor functioning was too low. 27. Ms. Polcyn stated that she has a B.S. degree in OT and additional certification in sensory integration techniques and that she is the coordinator for OT/PT for the SELPA and has worked as an OT for the SELPA since 1983 or 1984. 28. Ms. Vogel stated that she has six credentials (Severely Handicapped, Learning Handicapped, Visually Handicapped, Orthopedically Handicapped, Student Elementary, and Administrative). 29. The Hearing Officer notes that even the witnesses who testified on behalf of STUDENT do not believe he has any difficulties hearing. (Test. of Ms. Yang and STUDENT’s mother). 30. As noted above, a proposed assessment plan signed by Ms. Gaston included an FBA assessment and an APE assessment. STUDENT’s mother did not sign the assessment plan. (Dist. Exh. 17) 31. A functional analysis assessment (FAA) is a behavioral assessment pursuant to California law. An FAA may be conducted whenever a student demonstrates a “serious behavior problem,” defined as behaviors that are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage, and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive “for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” A functional behavioral assessment (FBA) is conducted pursuant to federal law. Federal law requires, in pertinent part, that an IEP team consider, if appropriate, strategies, including “positive behavioral interventions,” and supports to address behaviors that impede a child’s learning or that of others.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.346. Federal law also provides that in response to certain disciplinary actions, a District must convene an IEP meeting and develop a “functional behavioral assessment” (FBA) plan, or, if a student already has an FBA and existing behavioral plan, the IEP team is required to meet and review the existing plan and to revise it, if necessary. 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(b)(i) and (ii). To summarize, an FAA is required when a student has a “serious behavior problem” as defined by California law. In contrast, an FBA is required in relation to certain disciplinary actions and whenever an IEP team determines that a student’s behavior “impedes his or her learning or that of others.” Under federal law, a student is not required to have a “serious behavioral problem” as a basis to develop an FBA and to implement a behavioral intervention plan. 32. The plan, never signed by STUDENT’s mother, also provided for an APE assessment. 33. Nor did Student call any witness from Gallagher Pediatrics to support the Gallagher assessment. 34. Consideration should be given to having STUDENT wear elastic trousers that do not require buttoning or zipping, if it is determined that STUDENT cannot remember to button or to zip his trousers. 35. The cognitive testing performed by the District psychologist does not persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT cannot, cognitively, learn the self-help skills of using the toilet independently, although there is an open question as to whether STUDENT will always remember the skills imparted to him, given his low cognitive ability. STUDENT may need to be prompted. According to the March 13, 2000 IEP, STUDENT met with 80 percent accuracy (by March 2001) the following goal: Given a toileting schedule, wearing pull-ups or underwear, the student will use the toilet to stay dry. According to the same IEP, STUDENT met with 50 percent accuracy by March 2001, the following goal: Using two hands, STUDENT will button and zip articles of clothing and/or buttoning and zipping forms. (Student Exh. 22) Moreover, a district is not obligated under the IDEA to guarantee success when it sets appropriate goals and objectives and implements them. Soon to be age thirteen, STUDENT should be given a reasonable opportunity to learn these important self-help skills. 36. The contention that STUDENT has a “remarkable memory” was not supported by testimony from either a licensed speech-language pathologist, school psychologist, or credentialed teacher. The videotape (Student Exh. 42) indicates that STUDENT is able to remember some words, but it is not known how long STUDENT is able to remember the words that he remembers, and whether he remembers the pictures accompanying the words or the words themselves. 37. Because the Hearing Officer finds within the LRE discussion that the District has failed to show that Hope is the LRE until it has conducted an appropriate FBA and BIP, and implemented the BIP at Lexington, it is unclear whether after completing the FBA and implementing the BIP, STUDENT will also need a one-to-one behavioral aide, resulting in a more restrictive environment for STUDENT within the Lexington SDC. 38. Although Student’s attorney initially objected to STUDENT’s mother testifying about the compensatory education terms of settlement with Magnolia District, he withdrew his objection once STUDENT’s mother had testified that she had not signed a written agreement and that the agreement was not yet a final one. She then gave testimony at the hearing concerning her understanding of what she expected STUDENT to receive from the Magnolia District as compensatory education services. On December 30, 2002, after the hearing had concluded, the Hearing Office received a written motion to exclude “confidential communications” from the attorney for Magnolia District. On January 13, 2002, the Hearing Office received Student’s written notice to join in the motion to exclude, and also received a written notice of “no objection” to the motion to exclude from the District (Anaheim). Although Magnolia District lacks standing to bring a motion to exclude, having already been dismissed as a party to this proceeding, the Hearing Officer treats Student’s joinder and the Anaheim District’s non-objection, as a motion to reconsider the Hearing Officer’s ruling on the matter, and thereby grants reconsideration. The Hearing Officer notes that assertions by Student’s attorney that Student and the Magnolia District had entered into a confidential settlement agreement led to the Hearing Officer’s reasonable inference that the agreement was in writing, contained a written confidentiality clause, and had been signed by the parties. Because Anaheim District has now interposed its non-objection to the motion to exclude, the Hearing Officer grants the motion (based upon facts unknown to the Hearing Officer at the time the objection to the testimony was initially made). Accordingly, the Decision does not refer to the testimony of STUDENT’s mother regarding what she expected STUDENT to receive as compensatory education services (in nature, amount, and frequency) from Magnolia.