California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 6, 1997
Student v. Bonita Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1333-96 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
Bonita Unified must reimburse $2,600 for an independent evaluation and write behavior and transition plans; neither proposed placement approved.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 17-year-old student eligible for special education because of learning disabilities and serious emotional disturbance filed for hearing against Bonita Unified School District. After discipline incidents at San Dimas High School in 1996, he was on home instruction. The District proposed a county-run special day class (SDC) for students with serious emotional disturbance at Charter Oak High School. The student wanted to stay at San Dimas High with a behavior intervention plan (BIP), a computer, a one-to-one aide, and work experience.
Hearing Officer Keltie Jones found too little evidence to approve either side's placement. Instead, she listed what any placement must include: a low student-teacher ratio, oral instruction in reading and math, mainstreaming, peers of similar maturity, individual and family counseling, and a BIP. She faulted the District for proposing a more restrictive setting before trying a BIP. She noted that the student never physically attacked anyone at school and that his behavior had since stabilized with treatment. She ordered a spell checker, calculator, tape recorder, and taped books, but denied the computer and aide. She found the transition plan inadequate. She also found the District's assessments inappropriate because they included no direct social-emotional testing. She ordered $2,600 reimbursement for Dr. David Brendel's independent evaluation. The IEP team must meet within 15 days, invite the student, and write a detailed transition plan. A functional analysis assessment and BIP must follow within 30 days after he starts his new placement.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's push to move a student with behavior problems to a separate emotional-disturbance program without first trying a behavior plan. It also shows an assessment found inappropriate for lacking direct social-emotional testing, which led to an order to reimburse the parents for an independent evaluation.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Evidence did not show that either the student's proposed San Dimas High program or the District's county SED special day class at Charter Oak High was appropriate or the LRE; the Hearing Officer listed required placement elements, including counseling and a behavior intervention plan, and found the District should not have proposed a more restrictive setting without first trying a BIP.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. What learning aids are necessary to assist STUDENT in learning?
Student needs a spell checker, calculator, tape recorder and access to tape-recorded books, but a computer and a one-on-one aide were not shown to be necessary.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue 3. What services are necessary to assist STUDENT in transitioning from high school to a work environment?
The District's transition plan only recorded skills and interests and was inadequate; the student is entitled to transition services including community experiences such as a work experience program and development of employment and adult-living objectives.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Should Mr. and MOTHER be reimbursed for the assessment prepared by Dr. David Brendel?
The District's September 1996 and February 1997 assessments were inappropriate because they lacked direct social-emotional assessment and relied on no or a single procedure; Dr. Brendel was a qualified specialist, so parents get $2,600 reimbursement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. Appropriate placement must include a low student-teacher ratio; an oral instructional approach for math and reading deficits; a spell checker, calculator, tape recorder and access to tape-recorded books; mainstreaming opportunities; a class with peers of comparable maturity and academic instruction at his level; a definite BIP; and individual and family counseling.
- Order to assess. District shall arrange a functional analysis assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan within the first 30 calendar days of the student's attendance at his new placement; BIP terms to be included in the IEP.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team shall meet within 15 calendar days of the order to select a placement consistent with the decision and agree on goals and objectives for 1997-98; District must invite the student; team must prepare a detailed transition plan including investigation and provision of a work experience program.
- Reimbursement. District shall reimburse the parents $2,600 for Dr. David Brendel's independent assessment.
Total: $2,600 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5); Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320; Education Code §§ 56520-56524; Education Code § 56345.1
People named in the decision
- Cathy Shehan, coordinator of special education, Bonita Unified School District
- Dr. David Brendel, independent psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
- Dr. Said Jacob, treating psychiatrist; witness for Student, Private
- Nan Ralls, witness for District (role not stated), Bonita Unified School District
- Beth Birnbaum, home instruction teacher, Bonita Unified School District
- Karen Oaks, teacher, San Dimas High School
- Donna Slagle, teacher, San Dimas High School
- Nicholas Reynolds, school counselor, San Dimas High School
- Sandy Foster, mental health assessor (AB 3632), County mental health
- Cathy Callen, campus supervisor, San Dimas High School
- Geoff Carr, campus supervisor, San Dimas High School
- Richard Bremer, cabinetmaking teacher, San Dimas High School
- Laura Dodds, witness for District (role not stated), Bonita Unified School District
- Ellen Valentine, vice principal, San Dimas High School
- Ilona Kupecz, school psychologist, Bonita Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on June 5 and 6 and July 22, 1997, in San Dimas, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.
The Petitioner was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman. The Petitioner was present at the hearing, as was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Bonita Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen Gilyard of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Cathy Shehan, coordinator of special education for the District, was present on the District’s behalf.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, STUDENT, Dr. David Brendel, and Dr. Said Jacob.
The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Nan Ralls, Beth Birnbaum, Karen Oaks, Donna Slagle, Nicholas Reynolds, Sandy Foster, Cathy Callen, Geoff Carr, Richard Bremer, Laura Dodds, Ellen Valentine, Ilona Kupecz, and Cathy Shehan.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. Upon receipt of the closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the commencement of the hearing, the District objected to the admission of Petitioner’s exhibits A, H, I, N, O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, and W as being irrelevant and hearsay. In its closing argument, the District asserted that the Hearing Officer admitted all of those documents over its objections. However, in fact, the Hearing Officer excluded exhibits H and I because they referred to statements made during confidential mediation.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT?
2. What learning aids are necessary to assist STUDENT in learning?
3. What services are necessary to assist STUDENT in transitioning from high school to a work environment?
4. Should Mr. and MOTHER be reimbursed for the assessment prepared by Dr. David Brendel?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner asserts that he should be placed in the least restrictive environment, which he contends is San Dimas High school. The Petitioner argued that the District should develop a behavior intervention plan (BIP) to help him remain in the least restrictive environment. At various different times during the hearing, the Petitioner appeared to be proposing that he be placed in “regular classes” and, at other times, he seemed to be seeking a combination special day class (SDC) and resource specialist program (RSP) placement. The Petitioner also asserted that he requires a computer both at home and in the classroom with appropriate computer software to assist with reading, as well as a one-to-one aide. The Petitioner also stated that he needs a work experience program to help him transition out of high school.
The District asserted that the best placement for STUDENT is a county-run SDC program for seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) students located at Charter Oak High School.(Footnote 1) The District opposed providing any learning aids and services other than a calculator and a tape recorder for recording classes.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old boy who qualifies for special education due to learning disabilities and serious emotional disturbance. STUDENT has been diagnosed as having attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and bi-polar disorder. STUDENT is entering his senior year in high school.
STUDENT first qualified for special education services in third grade. During elementary school, STUDENT participated in the RSP classes in Pomona Unified School District. At the end of sixth grade, STUDENT’s IEP team recommended that he be placed in an SDC. STUDENT entered the Bonita Unified School District in seventh grade, and was placed in an SDC. (Pet. Exh. D.)
STUDENT entered San Dimas High School in ninth grade in September 1994. An IEP meeting was held in October 1994 to discuss his triennial assessment. At that meeting, the team agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to a combination of SDC and RSP classes because STUDENT was suffering from low self-esteem. STUDENT was ashamed of his disabilities; he did not want to be associated with the SDC. STUDENT completed his ninth grade year, and received tutoring over the summer in math and reading. In the tenth grade, STUDENT continued to attend both RSP and SDC classes.
During the summer in between ninth and tenth grade, STUDENT became very depressed. This depression continued into tenth grade. In October 1995, STUDENT was hospitalized, and was placed on Zoloft to treat his depression. When Zoloft proved ineffective, he was placed on Prozac. STUDENT admits using marijuana on a regular basis, which some professionals believe is a form of self-medication. (Testimony of Dr. Brendel.) STUDENT’s emotional problems escalated during the spring of 1996. During that time, STUDENT and his mother discussed a home instruction program with Mr. Reynolds, STUDENT’s school counselor. STUDENT had several disciplinary referrals during the 1995-96 school year, including referrals for profanity and disruption of class. A few of those referrals involved incidents in Mr. Richard Bremer’s cabinetmaking class. In one incident, on March 12, 1996, STUDENT lifted up a girl in the class and held her upside down. Mr. Bremer yelled at him to stop because such horseplay is dangerous around woodworking tools. He suspended STUDENT from class the next day. On April 16, 1996, Mr. Bremer again referred STUDENT for discipline and suspended him from class because STUDENT had misused the bandsaw by repeatedly jamming a piece of wood into it. (Dist. Exh. 21, 26, 27; Testimony of Mr. Bremer.)
On April 17, 1996, when STUDENT was told he was suspended from Mr. Bremer’s class, he became very upset. He demanded to speak with Mr. Bremer, but was told he had to stay in the office. STUDENT spoke very angrily with Ms. Ellen Valentine, the vice principal, telling her that he wanted to speak with Mr. Bremer. Ms. Valentine testified that STUDENT shouted at her across her desk and jabbed his finger at her. Then STUDENT left her office, and Ms. Valentine spoke on the radio to the campus supervisors, telling them not to let STUDENT go to Mr. Bremer’s class. After STUDENT left Ms. Valentine’s office, he confronted a campus supervisor and appeared to be asking for a fight. Then he turned and went into the parking lot, where a friend was sitting in a car. At that point, there were two campus supervisors by the car, Geoff Carr and Cathy Callen, and Mr. Reynolds and Ms. Valentine were observing from the front steps of the school. STUDENT continued to shout obscenities at the campus supervisors and at Ms. Valentine. Eventually, Mr. Reynolds told STUDENT’s friend to take STUDENT off the campus, and the two drove away. Throughout this incident, STUDENT did not physically assault anyone. (Testimony of STUDENT, Ms. Valentine, Mr. Reynolds, Mr. Carr, Ms. Callen.)
The next day, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss the incident, and STUDENT was placed on home instruction for the remainder of the school year. At that time, according to MOTHER, STUDENT’s doctors had not found the appropriate combination of medications for him. STUDENT received home instruction from Ms. Beth Birnbaum through the end of the 1995-96 school year. MOTHER hired Ms. Birnbaum to continue tutoring STUDENT through the summer of 1996.
In September 1996, STUDENT was excited about going back to school. He was looking forward to participating in football that year. STUDENT was again placed in a combination of SDC and RSP classes.
STUDENT had five disciplinary referrals in September, for refusing to follow a teacher’s direction to leave the room, making inappropriate sexual gestures to girls in class, refusing to comply with dress code, fighting with his girlfriend (she physically attacked him), and making threats to a campus supervisor. The latter incident occurred on September 13, 1996, and resulted in STUDENT’s being suspended and recommended for expulsion. The incident began when STUDENT was arguing with his girlfriend after the lunch bell rang. Students who are not in class after the lunch bell must pick up trash. A campus supervisor ordered both STUDENT and his girlfriend to pick up trash. STUDENT refused because he did not want to remain with his girlfriend, so he went to the office instead. Ms. Valentine testified that STUDENT was very agitated and upset. She told him to calm down. He kicked a chair, announced loudly that he was going to class, and left the office to return to class. Ms. Valentine told the campus supervisors to let STUDENT go back to class. On his way back to class, STUDENT encountered Geoff Carr. Mr. Carr stated that he did not say anything to STUDENT, but STUDENT shouted obscenities at him. Mr. Carr stated that he turned toward STUDENT to keep him in sight, and STUDENT said, “I’m going to come back when I’m eighteen and fuck you up.” Mr. Carr responded, saying “STUDENT, you talk a lot of shit, just go to class.” STUDENT then came toward Mr. Carr and threw down his things. STUDENT did not attempt to attack Mr. Carr; STUDENT just stared at him and then sat down on the bench in front of him. The bell rang shortly after that, and STUDENT went to his next class. (Testimony of Ms. Valentine, STUDENT, Mr. Carr.)
STUDENT was suspended for three days for that incident, and an IEP meeting was held on September 17, 1996. This IEP was the first time STUDENT was identified as being eligible for special education due to a serious emotional disturbance. All other IEPs admitted into evidence identified the qualifying disability as learning disabilities only. At this IEP meeting, the District members of the team recommended a referral to mental health for an AB 3632 assessment and placement in the county-run SDC for SED students, with home study. The parents rejected these recommendations. (Dist. Exh. 11.) On September 18, 1996, STUDENT was recommended for expulsion, and his suspension was extended until the expulsion hearing. (Dist. Exh. 28.)
On September 20, 1996, school psychologist Ms. Ilona Kupecz performed a pre-expulsion assessment, consisting of the following tests: the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) and the Beery Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI). The assessment report included handwritten summaries of STUDENT’s cognitive functioning and academic achievement, and a checklist of special education eligibility factors. The assessment concluded that STUDENT needed a “structured behavioral educational environment.” (Dist. Exh. 10.) Another IEP meeting was held on September 24, 1996, at which the IEP team determined that STUDENT’s emotional problems may have affected his reasoning during the incident with Mr. Carr. The District made the same placement recommendations, which the parents again refused. The FAMILY wanted STUDENT to continue in his placement at San Dimas High School or attend a similar placement at Chaparral High School, the District’s continuation school. (Dist. Exh. 9.)
On September 25, 1996, STUDENT appeared before an expulsion panel, which did not expel him, but which did recommend that he be transferred to Chaparral. On September 26, 1996, STUDENT was transferred to Bonita High School, because there was no room for STUDENT in the special education program at Chaparral. (Dist. Exh. 24.) STUDENT’s parents refused to enroll him in Bonita High School, and STUDENT stayed out of school. On December 5, 1996, another IEP meeting was held at which the parties agreed to place STUDENT on home instruction, one hour per day, five days per week. (Dist. Exh. 7.) MOTHER filed the request for due process hearing on December 11, 1996.
During December 1996, STUDENT worked with his father at a Christmas tree lot. While working there, he became involved in an altercation with some men. Although STUDENT was charged with assault in the incident, the charges were dropped because STUDENT had been acting in self-defense. (Testimony of STUDENT, MOTHER.)
The home teacher assigned to STUDENT, Ms. Birnbaum, was unable to arrange any home instruction sessions until January 1997. From the time the home instruction sessions began through June 6, 1997, there were approximately fifty days of instruction. However, the FAMILY canceled the sessions on twenty-three of those days. (Testimony of Ms. Birnbaum.) During the time STUDENT received home instruction, he could have earned thirty credits, but he earned only six and one-half. Ms. Birnbaum testified that STUDENT completed only about five percent of the assignments she gave him.
In January 1997, STUDENT’s parents consented to the mental health referral, and Sandy Foster from mental health performed an assessment on January 14, 1997. At the time of the assessment, STUDENT was not taking any medication because his family did not have enough money to pay for the prescription. During his interview with Ms. Foster, STUDENT admitted using illegal drugs, including marijuana, cocaine, and LSD. STUDENT also made many grandiose statements about his sexual abilities, and discussed being in a gang when he was living in Pomona. Ms. Foster concluded that STUDENT required mental health treatment to benefit from his special education program and recommended that he receive individual and/or group therapy on an outpatient basis, family therapy, and medication evaluation and monitoring. Ms. Foster did not make a recommendation regarding STUDENT’s educational placement.
On February 12, 1997, Ms. Kupecz prepared a psychoeducational assessment report which included the information presented in the September 1996 report, with additional behavioral observations by STUDENT’s teachers, a summary of behavioral interventions used with STUDENT, a behavior evaluation scale completed by two of STUDENT’s teachers, and a speech and language assessment performed on January 24, 1997. Ms. Kupecz again recommended that STUDENT be placed in a “special class at a restricted center with an emphasis on consistent, structured behavioral, educational intervention and socialization.” (Dist. Exh. 6.)
In February 1997, STUDENT got into a fight near his mother’s house. STUDENT stated that the fight occurred because another boy was trying to sell him drugs and he refused to take them. STUDENT received a ticket for that fight. STUDENT received another ticket in March 1997 for violating curfew. When he appeared in juvenile court in May for those tickets, he was remanded to juvenile hall for about two weeks because he had received two tickets within a thirty-day period. STUDENT’s stay in juvenile hall accounts for some of his absences from home instruction. While in juvenile hall, STUDENT attended what he described as “regular school.”
In March 1997, Dr. David Brendel met with STUDENT twice to conduct a psychological evaluation and testing. Dr. Brendel also met with STUDENT’s parents and reviewed documents from the District and STUDENT’s doctor. Dr. Brendel performed the following tests on STUDENT: Bender Gestalt Visual Motor Test, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT), IPAT Anxiety Inventory, Beck Depression Inventory - 2, and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory - 2 (MAPI-2). Dr. Brendel concluded that STUDENT’s behavior had stabilized due to regular usage of medications in appropriate doses and that he should be able to perform within the school setting.
DISCUSSION
Issue 1: What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25). In addition, special education services must be provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5); California Education Code § 56031.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Among the factors to be considered in analyzing each proposed placement to determine which is appropriate for STUDENT are whether the placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and whether the placement is the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 2) The Petitioner has proposed either “regular” school or a combination of SDC and RSP classes at San Dimas High School. The District has proposed a county-run SDC for SED students located at a comprehensive high school campus, Charter Oak High School.
A. Is the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
Before examining whether the proposed placements meet STUDENT’s unique needs, those needs must be determined.
Academically, STUDENT’s main areas of need are reading and math. STUDENT’s teachers testified that his reading and math skills are at about a third or fourth grade level. Dr. Brendel reported that STUDENT’s WRAT reading score indicated that he is reading at a third grade level. STUDENT’s problems with reading appear to affect his ability to perform in other subjects, such as science and history. STUDENT learns best orally. (Testimony of Ms. Birnbaum, Ms. Slagle, Ms. Oaks.) Ms. Birnbaum, the instructor with the most recent contact with STUDENT, testified that he needs a class with a low student-teacher ratio so that he may receive as much one-on-one assistance as possible. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs include instruction aimed at improving his reading and math skills, an oral approach to learning, and a low student-teacher ratio.
With respect to class environment, STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT’s skills are below those of most RSP students, but that his maturity is above that of most of the students in the San Dimas High School SDC. The witnesses consistently testified that STUDENT suffered from low self-esteem because of his disabilities, which was aggravated by his embarrassment about being in the SDC. It was to alleviate this embarrassment that STUDENT was placed in RSP classes that were above his academic abilities. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs to be in a class with peers of similar maturity in which the academic instruction is at his level.
STUDENT’s teachers also testified that STUDENT has behavior problems that have disrupted their classes in the past. (Testimony of Ms. Slagle, Ms. Oaks, Mr. Bremer.) STUDENT’s behavior included shouting out in class, making comments unrelated to the topics being discussed, defying authority, and making inappropriate sexual gestures and comments. The District staff asserted that STUDENT needs a very structured environment with counselors on call to deal with his emotional outbursts. However, Dr. Brendel testified that STUDENT could perform properly in a regular school environment as long as his medication is maintained appropriately and he is given an auditory approach to learning. According to Dr. Said Jacob, STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist, STUDENT’s current combination of Prozac, Buspar, and Deseryl has improved his mood and behavior problems. Testimony from STUDENT and MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT’s behavior has stabilized. The testimony established that STUDENT was not on this combination of medications when the incidents occurred in April and September 1996. Both Dr. Brendel and Ms. Foster recommended that STUDENT receive both individual and family counseling to enable him to benefit from his education. Dr. Brendel also recommended that STUDENT’s substance abuse problems be addressed. The Petitioner further asserted that a BIP should be implemented to help him remain at the San Dimas High School campus rather than excluding him from that campus for past behavior problems. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs include use of a BIP and individual and family counseling.
As to the proposed placements, there was no testimony regarding what type of “regular school” program the Petitioner proposed for STUDENT. In light of STUDENT’s very poor reading and math skills and the lack of testimony about how a regular education program could address those needs, the Hearing Officer finds that a regular education, twelfth grade program would not serve STUDENT’s unique needs and is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
The other placement the Petitioner proposed, a combination of SDC and RSP classes at San Dimas High School, is the only program in which STUDENT actually participated. However, the evidence established that that program, as implemented in the past, did not meet STUDENT’s needs. Because STUDENT was in an unusual combination of classes, his schedule placed him in the SDC for English while all the other SDC students were studying math. As a result, STUDENT received very limited instruction in English and was left to work independently for the majority of that class. Moreover, the testimony established that his math skills were below those of the other students in his RSP math class. There was no testimony on the combination of classes STUDENT would take in the future, nor on how those classes could serve his needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the RSP/SDC combination implemented in the past did not meet STUDENT’s needs and that there is insufficient evidence to make a finding on whether such a program could meet STUDENT’s needs at the present time.
There was also very little testimony about the placement the District is proposing. Although many District witnesses testified that STUDENT needs to be placed in the county-run SED program, only Ms. Shehan provided testimony based on personal knowledge of the program. Ms. Shehan visited the SED SDC located at Charter Oak High School one time. Ms. Shehan testified that the maturity level of the students in the SED SDC is closer to STUDENT’s maturity level. She stated that the class had nine students with one teacher and one aide. The students received one-to-one assistance, had access to computers, and had opportunities for mainstreaming with other students in elective classes. According to Ms. Shehan, AB 3632 counselling services are provided at the Charter Oak campus. Ms. Shehan did not testify about the academic program offered in that SDC. There was no testimony from the staff who operate the program. Although the SED SDC program may be able to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that there is not sufficient evidence to establish that it will, in fact, do so. The Hearing Officer is also concerned that the District staff recommended this program as a solution to STUDENT’s behavior problems before STUDENT’s medication regimen was stabilized and without attempting to implement a BIP to determine if he could remain on his home school’s campus.
In spite of the fact that a finding cannot be made about which proposed placement would serve STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer does find that an appropriate placement for STUDENT would have a low student-teacher ratio, address his deficits in math and reading, include individual and family counseling, provide opportunities for mainstreaming to address his self-esteem problems, include peers who have a comparable level of maturity, and provide a definite BIP to address behavioral problems that may arise in the future.
B. Is the placement the least restrictive environment?
Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5), the District must ensure that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities ... are educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
See also Education Code § 56001(g); 56031, 56364. A behavioral intervention plan is a service that is often used to help a child with behavior problems remain in the least restrictive environment. Education Code §§ 56520-56524, 5 CCR § 3052.
The Petitioner argued that placing him in an SDC on a different high school campus would violate the least restrictive environment (LRE) requirement. Petitioner also asserted that a BIP should be implemented to enable him to remain at the San Dimas campus. However, there was no testimony on how the SED SDC was more restrictive than the SDC/RSP combination. Although some of the District witnesses stated that they believed a county-run SED program would be the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, and Ms. Shehan testified that students in that program may take regular education electives, the District’s closing arguments did not address the LRE issue at all. Neither did the District’s arguments address whether a BIP should be implemented for STUDENT. The District witnesses testified that a BIP was not implemented for STUDENT because he was no longer in school, but they did not explain why the District proposed removing STUDENT from the San Dimas campus before it even considered preparing a BIP for him. Only when a student’s behavior is so extreme and dangerous to himself and others would a school district be justified in removing the student to a more restrictive environment without implementing a BIP. The Hearing Officer is not convinced that STUDENT’s behavior rose to that level. Although STUDENT demonstrated significant defiance of authority, he never physically attacked anyone at school. Even his threat to Mr. Carr implied that an attack may occur more than a year in the future; it did not imply an imminent threat. Some of the District’s witnesses indicated that they were afraid of STUDENT’s volatile emotions, but those people have not had contact with STUDENT since his medication program has stabilized his emotions and behavior. The one District staff person who did have ongoing contact with STUDENT, Ms. Birnbaum, testified that she is not afraid of STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence failed to establish which proposed placement would be the LRE. However, the Hearing Officer does find that STUDENT should have as many opportunities to participate in classes and activities with regular education students as possible. To that end, the Hearing Officer finds that a behavioral intervention plan should be prepared and implemented for STUDENT to help him control his behavior.
*** Based upon the analysis above, the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate placement for STUDENT must have a low student-teacher ratio, address his deficits in math and reading, include individual and family counseling, provide opportunities for mainstreaming to address his self-esteem problems, include peers who have a comparable level of maturity, and provide a definite BIP to address behavioral problems that may arise in the future. The parties must determine whether such a placement is available at San Dimas High School or whether STUDENT should be placed elsewhere. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT should be involved in examining placement options. STUDENT is of an age that he should be invited to participate in establishing his educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B). STUDENT now has an opportunity to prove that his behavior has been controlled by his medications and that he is truly interested in getting an education. The Hearing Officer reminds STUDENT that with this opportunity comes responsibility; STUDENT must make an active choice to learn before he can benefit from whatever special education program is proposed.
Issue 2: What learning aids are necessary to assist STUDENT in learning?
Under both federal and California law, a special education student is entitled to receive related services that are necessary to allow the student to benefit from special education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a); California Education Code § 56363. At various times during the hearing, the Petitioner asserted that he needs a personal computer with appropriate software, a one-on-one aide to participate in regular education classes, a calculator, a tape recorder, and a spell-checker to benefit from special education.
STUDENT testified that he would like to have a computer. While several witnesses testified that a computer would be helpful to STUDENT, they did not testify that it was necessary for him to benefit from special education. (Testimony of Ms. Birnbaum, Ms. Kupecz.) In the absence of evidence that a computer is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from special education, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need a computer as a learning aid.
Several witnesses were asked if STUDENT could participate in regular education classes with a one-on-one aide. They responded that such assistance would not help STUDENT learn. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need a one-on-one aide to benefit from special education.
Ms. Oaks and Ms. Birnbaum testified that STUDENT needs a spell checker to benefit from his education. Ms. Oaks also testified that STUDENT should use a calculator. Ms. Birnbaum, Dr. Brendel, and Ms. Kupecz testified that STUDENT should use a tape recorder to record classes and have access to tape-recorded books to benefit from his education. An occupational therapy assessment conducted on February 10, 1997, also recommended that STUDENT use a spell checker and a tape recorder. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a spell checker, a calculator, a tape recorder, and access to tape-recorded books as part of his special education program.
Issue 3: What services are necessary to assist STUDENT in transitioning from high school to a work environment?
Under both federal and state law, by no later than age 16 a student’s IEP must include a statement of needed transition services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii); California Education Code § 56345.1. “Transition services” include “instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation.” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(30). A determination of appropriate transition services must be “based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests.” Id.
There was no testimony regarding any specific transition services that Petitioner believes should be provided. However, STUDENT did testify that his goals for the future are to study diesel mechanics and to join the Marine Corps. In addition, an individual transition plan dating back to the 1994-95 school year for STUDENT was admitted into evidence. (Dist. Exh. 4.) While this document records STUDENT’s existing skills and interests, it does not reflect any active transition planning on the part of the District other than an interest inventory given in tenth grade and a school-related job in the summer of 1995 (the notation of which was not made until 1997). The Hearing Officer finds this transition plan to be inadequate. Simply recording a student’s skills and work experience, which, in this case, consisted mostly of working on a Christmas tree lot with his father, is not providing transition services.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT, as a seventeen-year-old special education student is entitled to receive transition services, which should include community experiences such as a work experience program and the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives.
Issue 4: Should Mr. and MOTHER be reimbursed for the assessment prepared by Dr. David Brendel?
California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.
For the District’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a).
The District assessed STUDENT in September 1996 and supplemented that assessment in February 1997. The Petitioner’s parents disagreed with the results of the District’s assessments because both reports recommended that STUDENT be placed in an SED program. The Petitioner also asserted that the assessments were not thorough enough.
The September 1996 pre-expulsion assessment report consisted of a handwritten, fill-in-the-blank document prepared by Ms. Kupecz, who is a credentialed school psychologist. The only tests given for that assessment were a cognitive functioning test, the WISC-III, and the Beery visual-motor integration test. This is the first time STUDENT was found to be eligible for special education as an SED student, and that finding was made without performing any social-emotional psychological testing. Moreover, the recommendation that STUDENT be placed in an SED program was also made without performing any such testing. This is not a situation where a single procedure was used to determine the appropriate program; in this case, no procedure was used to determine the program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment performed in September 1996 was inappropriate.
The assessment report prepared on February 12, 1997, is, for the most part, a typewritten repetition of the September 1996 report. It did, however, include an additional section with background information, behavioral observations by STUDENT’s teachers, including a restatement of a memo from Mr. Bremer dated March 11, 1996, and a list of interventions attempted with STUDENT. The report also included WRAT-R results from September 1996 that had not been included in the earlier report. Two additional assessments were administered for this report: a behavior evaluation scale in which STUDENT’s behavior was rated by his teachers, who had not seen STUDENT for about five months, and a speech and language assessment performed on January 24, 1997.(Footnote 3) STUDENT’s teachers rated him in five areas (learning problems, interpersonal difficulties, inappropriate behavior, unhappiness/depression, and physical symptoms/fears), with the scores being below average, poor, or very poor in all areas. The results of the speech and language assessment showed that all areas of oral language were adequate. Once again, the report concluded that STUDENT should be placed in an SED program. The Hearing Officer finds that this assessment, too, is inappropriate. Although the assessment did include a social-emotional assessment, that assessment was less than thorough. It reflected only STUDENT’s teachers’ opinions of his social emotional state; at no time did Ms. Kupecz directly assess STUDENT in that area. Moreover, the assessment violates the provision prohibiting the use of a single procedure to determine a student’s program.
As the District has not proven that its assessments were appropriate, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist. The District asserts that Dr. Brendel was not a qualified specialist because he is not a school psychologist. However, Dr. Brendel’s vita and his testimony indicate that he holds an educational psychologist credential and a clinical psychologist license and that he has been employed as a school psychologist. (Pet. Exh. B.) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Dr. Brendel is a qualified specialist and that the FAMILY are entitled to reimbursement for the assessment he performed on STUDENT in the amount of $2,600, pursuant to the billing statement admitted into evidence. (Pet. Exh. C.)
ORDER
1. The appropriate placement for STUDENT shall include the following elements: a. a low student-teacher ratio, b. an oral instructional approach designed to address his deficits in math and reading, c. a spell checker, calculator, tape recorder and access to tape-recorded books, d. opportunities for mainstreaming to address his self-esteem problems, e. a class that includes peers who have a comparable level of maturity with academic instruction at his level, f. a definite BIP to address behavioral problems that may arise in the future g. individual and family counseling.
2. The District shall arrange for a functional analysis assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT within the first thirty calendar days of his attendance at his new placement. The terms of the behavioral intervention plan shall be included in STUDENT’s IEP.
3. STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet within fifteen calendar days of the date of this order to select an appropriate placement for STUDENT in conformance with this decision and to agree upon appropriate goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year. The District is ordered to invite STUDENT to attend the IEP meeting with his parents. The IEP team shall also prepare a detailed transition plan for STUDENT, including the investigation and provision of a work experience program.
4. The District shall reimburse MOTHER and FATHER in the amount of $2,600 for the assessment performed by Dr. Brendel.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue 1: Neither party prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: The District prevailed in part on this issue, and the Petitioner prevailed in part.
Issue 3: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 4: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: October 6, 1997 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.The testimony at the hearing did not establish where Charter Oak High School is located. 2.Whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student and whether the placement conforms to the student’s IEP are also generally considered in determining the appropriateness of a placement. However, these factors do not play a role in this decision. The evidence on the academic content of the placements proposed is insufficient to establish that they will provide educational benefit to STUDENT. As far as the Hearing Officer can tell, STUDENT has received little to no academic benefit over the past year. Not only did the home instruction placement provide minimal instruction time, but STUDENT missed a significant number of those sessions. Out of thirty credits STUDENT could have earned this year, he earned only six and one-half. Moreover, STUDENT does not have a current IEP with appropriate goals and objectives. The last IEP that updated STUDENT’s goals and objectives was written on February 12, 1997, but was not signed by the parents. The prior IEP was dated January 10, 1996. STUDENT’s goals and objectives in January 1996 included improving academic grades, improving his handwriting, completing assignments, and working on calculation of whole numbers and fractions. There were no social/emotional or behavioral goals. Moreover, there was no evidence that STUDENT had any goals relating to reading at that time. In the absence of an appropriate IEP, it is not possible to examine whether the proposed placements conform to STUDENT’s IEP. 3.The occupational therapy assessment was performed before this report was completed, but was not referred to in this report.
