California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 5, 2002
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1345-02, SN-1345-02 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Los Angeles Unified must provide 42 hours of speech therapy and 21 hours of OT consultation to a preschooler; assessment claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
At the hearing, the District acknowledged that it had not provided OT and speech-language therapy under stay put. It agreed to provide the requested compensatory amounts (18 hours of speech-language therapy and 38 hours of OT), so no findings were made on that issue. A separate District-filed case, SN02-01751 (decision dated September 25, 2002, by a different hearing officer), authorized the District to assess without consent; consolidation with this case was denied. The parents' earlier case, SN02-00442, was withdrawn on May 30, 2002. Any disputes about the October 15, 2002 IEP were reserved for a separate hearing.
Summary
The parents of a four-year-old girl filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. Their daughter was eligible for special education under "mental retardation" (now called intellectual disability). When she turned three, the district placed her in a preschool special day class with adapted physical education and later added an assistant. It did not continue the individual speech-language therapy and occupational therapy (OT) she had received through the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center. The family challenged the 2001-2002 program, the June 20, 2002 IEP (through October 15, 2002), and the district's July 2001 OT and speech-language assessments.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found no procedural denial of FAPE. The district did a physical therapy assessment before getting written consent. But the mother brought her daughter and took part, so the error was technical. On the program itself, the five IEP goals were too few and too vague for a child functioning at the 12- to 24-month level. No goals covered attention, toileting, or safety. Her speech made little progress without therapy, so she needed two 30-minute speech sessions a week. She also needed OT, but as consultation to her teacher, not direct therapy. She did not need more aide support. Her needs stayed the same under the June 2002 IEP. The district's play-based assessments were appropriate, so the parents were not reimbursed for their independent OT assessment. The district must provide 42 hours of speech therapy and 21 hours of OT consultation.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a toddler moving from Regional Center services to a district preschool. A language-enriched classroom was not enough when the child made little measurable progress without therapy. The decision also accepted play-based assessments for a very young child who would not take standardized tests.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-Pa. Did the District provide adequate notice of IEP meetings on July 30, 2001, and September 28, 2001?
The mother attended the July 2001 meeting after oral notice, and the September 2001 written notice was timely and complete under Ed. Code 56341.5; any lack of written notice did not cost the child educational opportunity or seriously infringe on parent participation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-Pb. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT's parents with a copy of parental rights?
No clear evidence that the parents' rights notice was not provided; the assessment plan cover sheet and the signed consent showed the parent guide was included.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-Pc. Did the District implement the IEP dated September 28, 2001, without parental consent?
The mother signed and returned the September 28, 2001 IEP consenting to it, so the services were not implemented without consent.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment
Issue 1-Pd. Did the District conduct a physical therapy (PT) assessment on June 29, 2001, prior to obtaining parental consent?
The District assessed before getting written consent, but the mother voluntarily brought the child and took part, so the violation was technical and did not deny FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1-Sa. Do the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated July 30, 2001, adequately address STUDENT's identified needs?
Five vague goals did not address the child's extensive needs, such as attention, cognition, toileting, dressing, stairs and gait, or safety awareness, so the goals were not designed to meet her needs.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-Sb. To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require 20 minutes each school day of LAS therapy?
The child made little or no language progress in a language-enriched class without therapy and needed individual speech-language therapy; the Hearing Officer adopted Ms. Faller's recommendation of two 30-minute sessions weekly rather than the frequency requested.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-Sc. To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require one hour each week of OT?
The child needed OT to benefit from her education, but consultation from a qualified occupational therapist was enough; the Hearing Officer did not find that direct OT was required.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-Sd. To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require a trained one-to-one aide?
The District had added an assistant under the IEP from October 2001, and there was no persuasive evidence that the child needed more aide support.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the individualized education program (IEP) and the placement proposed on June 20, 2002, offer Petitioner a FAPE? (limited to June 20, 2002 through October 15, 2002)
The child's needs were substantially unchanged, so she still needed one hour weekly of speech-language therapy and one-half hour weekly of OT consultation; the District prevailed on the one-to-one aide.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
The Hearing Officer awarded 42 hours of compensatory speech-language therapy and 21 hours of OT consultation, not the 88 hours of each that were requested.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 4. Did the District conduct appropriate occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech (LAS) assessments of Petitioner on July 10, 2001?
Play-based assessments using observation, parent interview, and informal tasks were appropriate for a young, low-functioning child who would not take formal tests, and the reports met Ed. Code 56327.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. If not, are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent OT assessment completed by DeAnna Caudillo, OT, on August 9, 2002?
Because the District's OT assessment was appropriate, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement for the independent OT assessment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to decide how to deliver the compensatory speech-language therapy and OT consultation, considering the child's age, attention, developmental level, tolerance for services, and possible delivery during intersessions or other times when school is not in session.
- Compensatory education. Within 20 calendar days, begin providing 42 hours of compensatory speech and language therapy, to be completed before the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
- Compensatory education. Within 20 calendar days, begin providing 21 hours of compensatory OT consultation to the child's teacher from an appropriately qualified occupational therapist, to be completed before the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
Total: 63 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Cal. Educ. Code 56341.5; Cal. Educ. Code 56321; Cal. Educ. Code 56320; Cal. Educ. Code 56327; Cal. Educ. Code 56345; 34 CFR 300.502(b)
People named in the decision
- Dawn James, pediatric physical therapist (PT assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
- C. Valerie Gangui, school psychologist, preschool assessment team, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Amy M. Gray, occupational therapist (OT assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District (former)
- Marilyn Muir, speech and language specialist (LAS assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Marina Tiffany Pender, occupational therapist, assessment for Regional Center, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
- Cathie Campbell Faller, bilingual speech-language pathologist in private practice; Regional Center assessor; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Amy Cotton, special day class teacher, Wilshire Crest, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Salimu Autry, administrator, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Carolyn Hashiba, special day class teacher, LaFayette Park Place Primary Center, Los Angeles Unified School District
- DeAnna Caudillo, independent occupational therapist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Andrea Gulius-Straw, transition service facilitator, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Janet Fang, Regional Center liaison, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
- Pablo Pauig II, occupational therapist (OTR), witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Karen Krische, District coordinator of staff development; speech pathologist; witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Patricia Wilson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Leonard Studley, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center, regional center (prior early intervention services)
- Child and Family Services (PASIT), early intervention program provider
- Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, prior early intervention therapy provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on August 13 and 14, October 16, 17, and 18, 2002.
On August 13 and 14, 2002, Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Lillian M. Meredith.(Footnote 1) On August 13, 2002, Attorney Paul M. Roberts, from the law firm of Roberts & Adams, also was present on STUDENT’s behalf. Attorney Scott Ayers of Roberts & Adams was present on August 14, 2002, and represented STUDENT on all the remaining hearing dates. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, was present during the course of the hearing. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District was represented at the hearing by attorney Peter A. Sansom from the law firm of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District at various times during the hearing was Patricia Wilson or Leonard Studley, who are due process specialists.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the District offer Petitioner STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
(2) Did the individualized education program (IEP) and the placement proposed on June 20, 2002, offer Petitioner a FAPE?
(3) If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
(4) Did the District conduct appropriate occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech (LAS) assessments of Petitioner on July 10, 2001?
(5) If not, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent OT assessment completed by DeAnna Caudillo, registered occupational therapist (OTR), on August 9, 2002?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
During a prehearing telephone conference on August 9, 2002, Petitioner identified the following issue for hearing: Is Petitioner entitled to 18 hours of compensatory language and speech (LAS) therapy and 38 hours of occupational therapy (OT) for the District’s failure to adhere to stay put from the date of filing to the date of the stay put order? At the reconvened hearing on October 16, 2002, the District acknowledged that it had failed to provide OT and LAS pursuant to stay put and agreed to provide compensatory OT and LAS from the date of Petitioner’s filing for due process until services are provided. Because the District has agreed to provide the compensatory OT and LAS in the requested amount, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to make any findings on the issue initially raised by Petitioner regarding the District’s obligation to provide OT and LAS from the date of filing to the date of the stay put order.
As a remedy for the alleged denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner initially sought to have the District convene an IEP meeting. On October 15, 2002, during the pendency of the hearing, the District convened an IEP meeting. The Petitioner disputes whether the meeting was properly noticed and convened. Additionally, at the end of the hearing, Petitioner’s parent had not yet had an opportunity to determine whether she would consent to the IEP. However, Petitioner agreed to limit the period of time addressed by Issue No. 2 from the date of the IEP meeting on June 20, 2002, to October 15, 2002, and, if necessary, to address any disputes related to the IEP developed on October 15, 2002, in a separate due process hearing.
The issue related to whether the parent is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent OT assessment originally was raised in a due process hearing requested by the District, SN02-01751. Consolidation of SN02-01751 with this case was denied. At the instant hearing, the parties agreed and the Hearing Officer concurred that for purposes of judicial efficiency and to avoid inconsistent decisions, the parents’ right to reimbursement for the OT assessment (Issue 5) should be heard and decided with the issue raised in this hearing regarding the appropriateness of the District’s OT assessment.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a four-year-old student who qualifies for special education because of mental retardation. STUDENT exhibits delays in all areas of development. For example, STUDENT learned to walk at age two and one-half years. STUDENT’s expressive language skills are limited to a small vocabulary of single words. STUDENT occasionally puts two words together but she does not speak in sentences. She is not toilet-trained. STUDENT presently attends a special day class (SDC) at LaFayette Park Place Primary Center. STUDENT receives the services of transportation and adapted physical education (APE).
Prior to turning three years old, STUDENT received services authorized by the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center, including weekly sessions of two hours for each of the following: occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT) and language and speech therapy (LAS). STUDENT also participated in an early intervention program three days each week for sessions of approximately three and one-half hours each. STUDENT’s services initially were provided at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center. However, STUDENT’s mother had difficulty providing STUDENT’s transportation because of her work schedule. The Regional Center then arranged for STUDENT to receive services as well as preschool through Child and Family Services’ early intervention program, PASIT.
The District undertook an initial assessment of STUDENT in June and July 2001, when STUDENT was nearly three years old. Dawn James, pediatric physical therapist, conducted a physical therapy (PT) assessment of STUDENT on June 29, 2001. Ms. James concluded that STUDENT could access her educational environment with accommodations (holding her hand to assist her on stairs) and did not recommend PT. On July 10, 2001, the remainder of the assessment was completed by the preschool assessment team, consisting of C. Valerie Gangui, school psychologist, Amy M. Gray, registered occupational therapist (OT), and Marilyn Muir, speech and language specialist. Because STUDENT generally refused to participate in any formal tasks, the assessors relied on observations of STUDENT, her ability to complete informal tasks presented to her, and parent interview to determine STUDENT’s current levels of functioning. Pursuant to the Preschool Team Assessment Test III, STUDENT’s vocabulary skills reached the 18-24 month level, communication and sensory-motor skills reached the 22-month level, gross-motor skills reached the 20-month level, self-help skills reached the 18-month level, and fine-motor skills ranged from the 12-month level to the 24-month level. Ms. Gray concluded that STUDENT’s motor, sensory processing, self-help, and social skills generally were adequate. Ms. Gray identified following through with adult direction as an area of need, which Ms. Gray concluded could best be met in a classroom setting. The report of the District’s assessment noted that STUDENT sat at approximately eight months, crawled at 18 months, and walked at two and one-half years. At the time of testing, STUDENT was able to finger-feed herself, drink from a sippy cup, and take off her shoes and socks with assistance. She was not toilet-trained.
STUDENT’s initial IEP occurred on July 30, 2001. The IEP includes goals and objectives to address deficits in language, communication, self-help, and gross-motor skills. The IEP team reached consensus as to STUDENT’s placement in a “preschool mixed” SDC, transportation, and APE. District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s motor skills were commensurate with her overall level of developmental functioning and that her motor, speech, and language needs could be met within her educational setting with APE. STUDENT’s parents requested that the District provide STUDENT with two hours each of OT and language and speech therapy (LAS), comparable to the services she had been receiving pursuant to her individual family service plan (IFSP) developed by the Regional Center.
On August 29, 2001, Marina Tiffany Pender, OT, completed an OT assessment at the request of the Regional Center. Ms. Pender concluded that STUDENT was demonstrating global delays in developmental skills and additionally noted that STUDENT exhibited a great deal of difficulty with attention and focusing, delayed visual-perceptual skills, “dyspraxic-like” symptoms during fine- and gross-motor activities, and motor-planning problems. Ms. Pender described STUDENT as “clumsy” and stated that she fell a lot and was unable to perceive obstacles in her path. Ms. Pender recommended continued OT with sensory integration treatment and LAS therapy.
On September 11, 2001, Cathie Campbell Faller, bilingual speech-language pathologist, assessed STUDENT at the request of the Regional Center. Results of Ms. Faller’s testing indicated that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language development was at approximately the 16- to 20-month level with some emerging abilities into the 24-month level. Ms. Faller noted that STUDENT’s oral-motor function appeared to be weak. She recommended twice weekly sessions of thirty minutes each of speech and language therapy.
On September 12, 2001, STUDENT entered the SDC taught by Amy Cotton at Wilshire Crest. A second IEP meeting took place on September 28, 2001, with Ms. Cotton and Salimu Autry, an administrator, present. Ms. Cotton had requested the IEP meeting to add the services of a temporary support assistant (TSA) to STUDENT’s IEP. The purpose of the assistant was to ensure STUDENT’s safety in the classroom, help STUDENT follow routines, walk with STUDENT and other class members through campus to lunch and play areas, and assist STUDENT with eating and toileting routines. STUDENT’s mother was unable to attend the meeting but, on October 10, 2001, gave written consent to the IEP amendment providing for STUDENT to receive support from the assistant.
Because STUDENT’s parents moved, STUDENT’s last day in Ms. Cotton’s class was December 13, 2001. STUDENT was assigned to Carolyn Hashiba’s SDC at LaFayette, which also is within the District. In January 2002, STUDENT attended an intersession with Ms. Hashiba’s class(Footnote 2). The regular school year resumed in March 2002. The class meets Monday through Thursday of each week.
On January 15, 2002, the parties participated in an “informal conference,” which is a procedure set up by the District to help resolve disputes related to IEPs. The District offered to conduct OT and LAS assessments and convene an IEP meeting. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to further assessment, noting that STUDENT already had been through several assessments.(Footnote 3) On January 24, 2002, STUDENT’s parents filed a special education due process hearing regarding whether STUDENT requires OT and LAS (SN02-00442). On May 30, 2002, STUDENT’s parents withdrew case number SN02-00442.
On June 20, 2002, the District convened the annual IEP meeting for the purpose of reviewing STUDENT’s program and placement. STUDENT had met two of six speech and language objectives, both self-help objectives, and one of two gross-motor objectives. “Needing adult assistance and excessive absences” were noted as reasons for STUDENT’s not achieving all of her goals and objectives. The IEP notes that STUDENT missed 42 school days, or 26 percent of the school year. New goals and objectives were written to address deficits in speech, language, and gross-motor areas. District members of the IEP team continued to recommend the same SDC placement, Ms. Hashiba’s class, and APE services that STUDENT had received during the 2001-2002 school year at LaFayette. MOTHER consented to STUDENT’s continued placement in the SDC, the assistant, and APE. MOTHER also continued to assert that STUDENT was entitled to OT and LAS therapy.
District members of the IEP team recommended OT and LAS assessments. The IEP lists the following as reasons for an OT assessment: poor grip, development of small muscles in the hand and arms, and hand-eye coordination. The District provided an assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents on June 21, 2002. A second assessment plan of the same date additionally proposed to assess STUDENT’s perceptual development. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the requested assessments and on July 29, 2002, the District requested a special education due process hearing (SN02-01751) regarding whether it could undertake the proposed assessments without parental consent.
On August 9, 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent OT assessment from DeAnna Caudillo, OT. Ms. Caudillo found that STUDENT’s gross-motor skills were at the 14 ½-month level and her fine-motor skills were at the 24-month level. STUDENT then was four years, or 48 months old. Ms. Caudillo also concluded that STUDENT was having difficulty maintaining focus and filtering out pertinent information from extraneous background stimuli, which Ms. Caudillo stated was due to STUDENT’s having sensory integration difficulties. Ms. Caudillo recommended that STUDENT receive two weekly OT sessions of 30 minutes each.
This matter proceeded to hearing because of the ongoing disagreement over OT and LAS. On August 22 and 23, 2002, the hearing in SN02-01751 convened before a different hearing officer regarding the District’s right to undertake OT and LAS assessments over the objection of STUDENT’s parents. The District prevailed at hearing and, pursuant to the decision order, undertook OT and LAS assessments of STUDENT in October 2002. The District noticed an IEP meeting for October 15, 2002, to discuss the results of the assessments. The parents were unable to attend the IEP meeting due to work requirements and requested that the District identify a mutually agreeable date for the IEP meeting. The District did not accommodate the parents’ request and convened the IEP meeting without the presence of STUDENT’s parents and/or her attorney. District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive OT consultation weekly for one-half hour and LAS two times a week in sessions of thirty minutes each.
STUDENT’s parents continue to dispute the appropriateness of the program offered by the District during the 2001-2002 school year continuing from the IEP dated June 20, 2002, to October 15, 2002. Their primary dispute is regarding the determination by the District that STUDENT did not require OT and/or LAS to benefit from her education. STUDENT’s parents additionally raise issues regarding the appropriateness of goals and objectives. The District maintains that it has provided STUDENT with an appropriate education in all respects and that it conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
Petitioner contends that the District failed both procedurally and substantively to offer her a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, including the ESY. Petitioner asserts that the District committed procedural violations by (a) failing to provide her mother with adequate notice of IEP meetings on July 30, 2001, and September 28, 2001, (b) failing to provide her parents with a copy of parental rights, (c) implementing the IEP dated September 28, 2001, without parental consent, and (d) conducting a physical therapy (PT) assessment on June 29, 2001, prior to obtaining parental consent. Petitioner asserts that the District substantively failed to offer her a FAPE by (a) failing to develop goals and objectives to adequately address her needs and (b) inappropriately determining to discontinue services she received the prior school year including occupational therapy (OT), language and speech therapy (LAS), and a trained one-to-one aide. Petitioner asserts that to meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit educationally, she required (a) 20 minutes of individual LAS four days each week during the regular school year, (b) 20 minutes of LAS five days each week during the extended school year, and (c) one hour weekly of OT.
The District contends that it offered Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the ESY. The District asserts that it provided legally sufficient notice of IEP meetings and obtained parental consent prior to implementation of the IEP and undertaking a PT assessment. The District asserts that Petitioner did not require OT, PT, LAS, or an aide to benefit educationally.
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP)(Footnote 4). 20 U.S.C. § 14018. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. One of the rights afforded to parents is the right to be provided a formal written offer of placement by the school district. Union v. Smith, 157 F.3d. 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); cert.denied 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union noted that one of the reasons for a formal written offer is to provide parents the opportunity to decide whether the offer of placement is appropriate and whether or not to accept the offer.
Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F.3d 877.
In summary, to determine whether the District offered the student a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must analyze (a) whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and (b) whether the IEP and resulting placement were designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP according to the standards set forth in the IDEA and Rowley.
PROCEDURAL APPROPRIATENESS
(a) Did the District provide adequate notice of IEP meetings on July 30, 2001, and September 28, 2001?
Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide her parents with adequate notice of IEP meetings held on July 30, 2001, and September 28, 2001. The District asserts that the parents received notice of the meetings. California Education Code section 56341.5(b) provides that parents shall be notified of the IEP meeting “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend.” Subsections (c) and (e) further provide that the notice must include the purpose, time, and location of the meeting, who shall be in attendance, and any other local agency invited to attend. Federal law contains similar provisions.
MOTHER did not recall receiving written notice of the IEP scheduled for July 30, 2001. The documentary record in this case does not include a written notice for the IEP meeting. Andrea Gulius-Straw, transition service facilitator for the District, testified that her office customarily sends written notices of all IEP meetings and she had no reason to believe that the usual procedures were not followed in the case. Ms. Gulius-Straw recalled orally informing MOTHER of the scheduled IEP meeting. In fact, MOTHER attended the meeting. Additionally, MOTHER was aware that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss services and STUDENT’s initial placement in the District. Additionally, Janet Fang, STUDENT’s Regional Center liaison, testified that she had explained the process to MOTHER when she made the referral to the District for an assessment. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Gulius-Straw and Ms. Fang believable. Moreover, Petitioner provided no persuasive evidence that MOTHER was prevented from meaningful participation in the IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes the lack of written notice regarding the IEP meeting did not result in loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process.
On September 20, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parents a written notice of the IEP meeting scheduled for September 28, 2001. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 19.) This allowed eight days for the mail to get from the District’s offices to the parents’ home. Both are located in the city of Los Angeles. The record reflects that MOTHER returned the notice form to the District on September 25, 2001. Thus, it is clear that she received notice in advance of the meeting. During testimony, MOTHER stated that she and her husband both are employed and it is difficult for her to take days off from work. However, MOTHER had indicated on the form that she returned to the District that she would attend the meeting and did not request that it be rescheduled. Additionally, MOTHER checked the box on the form stating “I intend to be there; however, you may proceed without me if I am unable to attend. Please forward a copy of the individualized education program to me for my review and signature.” There are no provisions in special education law that define the phrase “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend.” However, the Hearing Officer concludes that under the circumstances described above, the notice of the IEP meeting was sent sufficiently in advance of the meeting to allow MOTHER to attend or to request that the meeting be rescheduled.
As to other requirements of an appropriate notice, the notice form sent to STUDENT’s parents regarding the IEP meeting scheduled for September 28, 2001, states the time and location of the meeting and indicates that the purpose of the meeting is to “determine any changes or modification needed in the Individualized Education Program.” The form also indicates that an administrator and the special education teacher would be present at the meeting. Thus, the requirements of Education Code section 56341.5 were satisfied.
(b) Did the District fail to provide STUDENT’s parents with a copy of parental rights?
Petitioner asserts that her parents did not receive a copy of the notice of parent rights in advance of her initial assessment in June and July of 2001. The District asserts that a copy of the parent rights was sent to the parents with the assessment plan dated May 1, 2001.
California Education Code section 56321(a) requires that a copy of the notice of parent rights be attached to assessment plans provided to parents. The notice must include a written explanation of the procedural safeguards under the IDEA, information on procedures for requesting an informal meeting, prehearing mediation conference, mediation conference, and due process hearing, and timelines and other pertinent information for each procedure.
Ms. Gulius-Straw testified that her general routine is to include a copy of parental rights with the assessment plan provided to the parents. In STUDENT’s case, Ms. Gulius-Straw mailed the initial assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents. The cover sheet provided with the assessment plan contains a box that is checked indicating that the “Parent’s Guide to Special Education Services” was included with the assessment plan. In an area of the assessment plan entitled “PARENT/GUARDIAN CONSENT FOR ASSESSMENT,” is the statement that “I have received and understand the booklet entitled “A Parent’s Guide to Special Education Services.” MOTHER’s signature consenting to the assessment appears below the statement set out above. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 16.) During testimony, MOTHER acknowledged that she had received packets of information from the District related to various assessments and/or scheduling of IEP meetings. MOTHER testified that she did not always have time to read all of the documents and could not be certain whether or not the notice of parent rights was included in the documents. The Hearing Officer concludes that there is no clear evidence that the District failed to provide STUDENT’s parents with a copy of parental rights. Moreover, STUDENT’s parents filed for a due process hearing in January 2001, in response to their disagreement with the services offered by the District, which indicates their having received information regarding parent rights.
(c) Did the District implement the IEP dated September 28, 2001, without parental consent?
Amy Cotton, STUDENT’s teacher from September to December of 2001, testified that neither of STUDENT’s parents was present at the IEP meeting on September 28, 2002. However, Ms. Cotton testified that she mailed the IEP to STUDENT’s home and the IEP was returned to her with MOTHER’s signature indicating her consent to the IEP. Ms. Cotton’s testimony is supported by District’s Exhibit 2, the IEP dated September 28, 2001, which contains MOTHER’s signature and a check next to the statement indicating that she had received notice of the IEP meeting but was unable to participate, had received a copy of the IEP, reviewed the IEP, and consented to it. The evidence refutes the Petitioner’s assertion that the services called for by the IEP were implemented without parental consent.
(d) Did the District conduct a physical therapy (PT) assessment on June 29, 2001, prior to obtaining parental consent?
Petitioner asserts that the District undertook the June 29, 2001 PT assessment without first obtaining written parental consent to assess. The District acknowledges that it did not obtain written consent prior to the PT assessment, but asserts that the resultant procedural violation did not result in the denial of FAPE.
California Education Code section 56321(c) provides that written parental consent must be obtained prior to an initial assessment unless the district prevails at a due process hearing regarding the right to assess the student over lack of parent consent.
MOTHER signed the proposed assessment plan dated May 1, 2001. However, she signed the plan on either July 10, 2001, or July 30, 2001.(Footnote 5) The dispute regarding which date MOTHER signed the plan need not be resolved at this time because both of the July dates fall after the actual PT assessment. There is no dispute that the PT assessment took place on June 29, 2001. Therefore, the District did not obtain prior written consent to undertake the PT assessment.
As to whether the failure to obtain written parental consent prior to the actual assessment resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or seriously infringed on the parents’ participation in the IEP process, MOTHER testified that she brought STUDENT to a District school on June 29, 2001, in response to the District’s notifying her that an assessment would take place on that date and at that location. MOTHER remained with STUDENT throughout the testing session. Dawn James, physical therapist, testified that she explained the assessment process to MOTHER and that MOTHER voluntarily presented STUDENT for the assessment and participated in the assessment by responding to questions posed by Ms. James regarding STUDENT’s physical abilities. Ms. James testified that because STUDENT was uncooperative throughout testing, she enlisted MOTHER’s participation in the assessment process by asking her to respond to questions. During the course of MOTHER’s presence, Ms. James also attempted to engage STUDENT in some activities and made clinical observations of STUDENT. Thus, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s mother voluntarily allowed the assessment to take place, thereby giving her consent to assess. There is no evidence that the lack of written parental consent prior to the PT assessment was other than a technical violation of procedural requirements.
Summary
As to Petitioner’s assertions that the District committed procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year, it has been concluded above that the District failed to obtain written parental consent prior to undertaking a PT assessment of STUDENT. The other procedural errors alleged by Petitioner were not substantiated by the evidence. It also has been concluded that the failure to obtain prior written consent for the PT assessment was technical in nature and did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
SUBSTANTIVE APPROPRIATENESS
Petitioner raises four areas of concern regarding the substantive appropriateness of the program and services provided to STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner’s parents assert that (a) the goals and objectives did not adequately address all of STUDENT’s identified needs, (b) to address her needs and allow her to benefit from her education, STUDENT required 20 minutes of LAS each school day, (c) to address her needs and allow her to benefit from her education, STUDENT required one hour weekly of OT, and (d) to address her needs and allow her to benefit from her education, STUDENT required a trained one-to-one aide. Each of the four concerns will be addressed separately below.
What were STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?
Before the appropriateness of the goals, objectives, and services contained in STUDENT’s IEP dated July 30, 2001 (Petitioner’s Exhibit 5), can be addressed, it is necessary to determine STUDENT’s deficits at the time the IEP was developed. STUDENT then was three years old. The present levels of performance recorded on the IEP, which were based on the District’s initial assessment of STUDENT, are helpful in making this determination. MOTHER testified regarding STUDENT’s functioning in July of 2001, and Ms. Cotton, STUDENT’s teacher in the fall of 2001, provided additional testimony regarding STUDENT’s functioning when she entered her class. Ms. Muir and Ms. Faller provided insight into STUDENT’s speech, language, and communication skills. The following is a summary of STUDENT’s functional levels in light of their testimony and information from assessments available when the IEP was developed.
STUDENT’s cognitive skills were estimated to fall between the 12- and 24-month level. STUDENT’s school readiness skills fell at approximately the 18-month level. She was able to recognize two body parts. She could not state her first or last name, age, match or sort objects by two colors, recognize the concept of more, big, or little. She was unable to rote count to five. STUDENT was able to follow simple directions but needed frequent verbal and visual prompts to remain focused, easily became frustrated, and had a tendency to stop before completing challenging tasks. To improve school readiness skills, all of the assessors testified that STUDENT needs to increase her attention and receive prompting to complete tasks. STUDENT had a short attention span, which impaired her ability to interact with adults and other children. STUDENT showed limited interest in toys but engaged in some play with household items. Ms. Faller, Ms. Caudillo, and District assessors concluded that because of her cognitive abilities and poor attention, STUDENT required individual instruction, prompting to pay attention and to stay on task, and repetition of directions.
Regarding STUDENT’s speech, language and communication skills, the evidence establishes that STUDENT was able to make eye contact and was beginning to show communicative intent. STUDENT’s vocabulary skills reached the 18- to 24-month level and her communication skills fell at the 22-month level. She was able to express herself using approximately 10 words and occasionally two-word phrases. Words STUDENT knew included “mommy,” “daddy,” “agua,” “no,” “eat,” “by,” “baby,” and “me.” She occasionally used a two-word phrase such as “bye Daddy.” STUDENT also knew the signs for “eat” and “more.” STUDENT mostly made vocalizations using consonant-vowel combinations. The testimony of LAS pathologists Ms. Faller and Ms. Muir establishes that STUDENT needs to develop age-appropriate speech sounds, expand her receptive and expressive vocabulary, and increase her ability to follow directions.
As to self-help skills, STUDENT was able to finger-feed herself and drink from a sippy cup. However, STUDENT was unable independently to use a spoon and showed little intent to feed herself. She was able to assist with dressing by taking off her shoes and socks and opening a jacket. She wore diapers at all times. STUDENT was unaware of dangers in her environment and functioned much like a toddler. Thus, STUDENT required individual assistance to address toileting, dressing, and eating issues and direct supervision to address safety concerns.
STUDENT’s fine motor skills fell between the 12- and 24-month level. She was unable to cut, string beads, or use glue. These skills also relate to school readiness activities. Regarding STUDENT’s gross-motor skills, STUDENT had begun walking within the prior six months and continued to exhibit a wide-based gait for additional support and balance. She frequently fell. With adult assistance and a handrail, STUDENT was able to go up one stair step at a time. She could not catch or kick a ball. Without assistance, STUDENT likely would crawl up stairs. The dispute regarding whether STUDENT requires OT or APE to address deficits in motor skills is addressed more fully below.
In summary, the witnesses and assessment findings similarly establish that STUDENT required instruction and services to address cognitive, expressive and receptive language, communication, school readiness, social, self-help, and fine-motor skills that fell well below the average range for a child of her age, and to address gross-motor skills that were significantly delayed. The decision will next address the adequacy of the goals and objectives contained in the IEP to address STUDENT’s identified needs.
(a) Do the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated July 30, 2001, adequately address STUDENT’s identified needs?
Pursuant to Rowley and the IDEA, the goals and objectives must be designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs as set forth above and to confer educational benefit. California Education Code section 56345(a)(2) further provides in pertinent part that the IEP must include:
The measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following: (A) Meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (B) Meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability.
All of the goals are for one year. Except for goal five, which addresses balance, the first incremental objectives were to be achieved by November 2001 and the second incremental objectives were to be achieved by March 2002. The first and second objectives for goal five were to be achieved by December and May respectively. The goals and objectives contained in the IEP developed on July 30, 2001, are as follows:
Annual Goal #1: Will independently follow a variety of teacher directions/simple commands during classroom activities with 80% accuracy. Incremental Objective #1: Will follow a variety of directions given modeling/initial physical prompts/visual cues 4/5 opportunities. Incremental Objective #2: Will follow a variety of directions given modeling verbal prompts 4/5 opportunities.
Annual Goal #2: Will verbally participate in circle time activities (Ie. [sic] will sing w/group, repeat rhymes/language patterns.) Incremental Objective #1: Same as above given verbal prompts/visual cues at least 3/5 x per week. Incremental Objective #2: Same as above at least 1x/day given verbal prompt/visual cues.
Annual Goal #3: Will use 10 target vocabulary words (nouns, verbs, etc.) independently each school day for a week. Incremental Objective #1: STUDENT will use 5 target vocabulary words after models during structured language activities. Incremental Objective #2: STUDENT will use 5 target vocabulary words independently during the school day over a weeks time.
Annual Goal #4: To improve self help skills, STUDENT will independently feed herself with a spoon when appropriate, 75% of the time, four of five trials. Incremental Objective #1: STUDENT will feed herself with a spoon when appropriate, 50% of the time, 3/5 trials. Incremental Objective #2: STUDENT will feed herself with a spoon when appropriate, 75% of the time, 3/5 trials.
Goal #5: Improve dynamic balance by stepping over a 2" high object independently 80% of the time. Incremental Objective #1: will stoop and recover an object from the floor independently 80% of the time. Incremental Objective #2: will step over 2" high object with assistance 80% of the time.
Petitioner’s witnesses testified that the goals and objectives were deficient because they did not address all of STUDENT’s identified needs. DeAnna Caudillo, registered pediatric occupational therapist (OT), testified that the goals and objectives do not address STUDENT’s needs related to fine-motor deficits, toileting, and poor equilibrium. Petitioner’s witnesses also testified that the goals and objectives are vague. For example, Ms. Faller testified that the first goal does not identify which directions or simple commands STUDENT would be expected to learn, nor does the goal indicate the quantity of directions of commands. Ms. Faller testified that no target words are identified for the third goal. Ms. Faller stated that identifying the words would have been important so that the family could follow up at home by using the same targeted words with STUDENT. Ms. Faller additionally testified that the vocabulary words should be accompanied by teaching STUDENT to sign.
District witnesses, including Ms. Cotton and Ms. Gulius-Straw, testified that the goals and objectives were designed to address STUDENT’s needs. For example, the first goal was designed to address STUDENT’s receptive language deficits and to foster socialization skills and independence. The second goal was designed to address STUDENT’s expressive language deficits and need to develop school readiness skills and independence. The third goal was designed to increase STUDENT’s expressive language delays. The fourth goal was designed to foster independence, following directions, and to develop fine-motor and self-help skills. The fifth goal addresses deficits in gross-motor skills.
The testimony of Ms. Cotton and Ms. Gulius-Straw establishes that the existing goals and objectives generally address areas encompassed by STUDENT’s needs. However, the paucity of goals and objectives in light of STUDENT’s extensive needs is startling. It should be noted that STUDENT was three years old when the goals and objectives were developed and by all accounts she was functioning from 12 to 24 months in all areas of development. A review of the goals and objectives and the testimony discussed above establishes that the five goals with their two objectives each address only a few of STUDENT’s identified needs. There are no goals or objectives to specifically address her short attention span or to improve her cognitive abilities. Learning to feed herself using a spoon is the lone self-help goal although STUDENT had other significant deficits in the area of self-help. She was not toilet-trained, was unable to dress and undress herself, or care for other personal needs. STUDENT also did not drink from a regular cup. The sole gross-motor goal calls for STUDENT to improve balance by stepping over a two inch object although she had not learned to use stairs independently and walked with an unusual gait. A concern to mother and teacher alike was STUDENT’s lack of understanding of danger in the environment. There are no goals or objectives to address this area of need.
Ms. Faller correctly noted that some of the goals as written are so vague that they would have been difficult to implement and to evaluate STUDENT’s progress. For example, no target vocabulary words are identified in the third goal. Ms. Cotton could not recall which words were targeted for STUDENT in her class. Ms. Hashiba testified that when STUDENT entered her class during the middle of the school year, she did not know which words Ms. Cotton had been targeting. Moreover, without identifying the targeted words, STUDENT’s family could not reinforce STUDENT’s learning the words at home. The term “variety of directions” in the first goal also is vague. For example, is STUDENT expected to follow one- or two-step directions? It is unclear which school readiness skills were to be addressed.
Considering the testimony of witnesses appearing for both Petitioner and the District, and a review of the existing goals and objectives in light of STUDENT’s needs, it is concluded that the goals and objectives were not designed to address STUDENT’s identified needs.
(b) To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require 20 minutes each school day of LAS therapy?
Prior to entering the District, STUDENT received individual LAS therapy. She asserts that she continued to require LAS therapy during the 2001-2002 school year to address her needs and to allow her to benefit from her education. The District asserts that STUDENT did not require LAS therapy and that her LAS needs could have been met by placement in a language-enriched educational program.
It was determined above that when STUDENT entered the District, her receptive and expressive language skills fell at or below the 24-month level. MOTHER testified that she has not noticed improvement in STUDENT’s communication skills since LAS therapy was discontinued. MOTHER stated her belief that STUDENT requires individual therapy to make progress. Ms. Faller, whose assessment on behalf of the Regional Center was completed in September 2001, testified that STUDENT required direct, one-to-one LAS therapy to be able to improve speech and language skills. In support of her recommendation, Ms. Faller noted STUDENT’s attentional problems and lack of focus to task. Ms. Faller additionally stated that STUDENT made good progress during the period she received individual LAS therapy, whereas her progress in the District’s program has been minimal at best. Prior assessments conducted on behalf of Regional Center and therapists who provided STUDENT’s speech and language therapy consistently recommended that STUDENT continue to receive individual speech and language. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 10, 31, 34, and 35.)
STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. Cotton and Ms. Hashiba, testified in support of the District’s position that LAS therapy was not necessary to address STUDENT’s needs or to allow her to benefit from her education. Each teacher testified that her program provided STUDENT with enriched language experiences. Ms. Cotton testified that she employed specific strategies to enhance language development during activities throughout the school day. Strategies employed by Ms. Cotton included repeating words used by the child and expanding on the words used by the child. It was unclear from Ms. Cotton’s testimony whether she employed these strategies with STUDENT, since Ms. Cotton recalled that STUDENT’s expressive vocabulary consisted of one or perhaps two words. An LAS pathologist visited Ms. Cotton’s class weekly and worked with the students in small groups. The LAS pathologist did not work individually with STUDENT. Ms. Hashiba testified that her class also provided STUDENT with a “language enriched” environment. Strategies employed by Ms. Hashiba included asking students questions and using rhymes, poems, and songs during circle time. Ms. Hashiba’s classroom also had interest centers, including blocks, dramatic play, a library, a house, and a listening center where students could engage in language-related activities. Both classrooms had a small number of students, which would allow the teacher time to work individually with the students.
However, despite the focus on developing language through a language-enriched curriculum, the evidence establishes that the programs provided by Ms. Cotton and Ms. Hashiba were not sufficiently designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or to allow her to benefit from her education. Neither Ms. Cotton nor Ms. Hashiba is a credentialed speech and language pathologist, and neither is trained to provide the type of services STUDENT required to address her speech and language deficits. For example, assessments by both Ms. Muir and Ms. Faller indicated that STUDENT needed to improve not only her vocabulary but also her production of speech sounds. Instruction to improve production of speech sounds is better left to appropriate qualified speech and language pathologists. (See 5 CCR §3051.1.)
Moreover, the evidence shows that STUDENT made little or no progress in speech and language during the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Cotton testified that STUDENT used a total of one or two words while in her class. She recalled that perhaps one of those words was “ball.” While Ms. Cotton appeared thrilled that STUDENT had sung “E-I-E-I-O” once during her class and considered this to be good progress, Ms. Cotton also testified that STUDENT was not using expressive language in her classroom and did not meet the objective of learning five target words by the time she left her class in December 2001.
STUDENT’s lack of progress without LAS therapy notable while in Ms. Cotton’s class. Ms. Hashiba testified that STUDENT still had not met her goal and objectives in language in June 2002. In fact, Ms. Hashiba testified in the due process hearing regarding the District’s right to assess STUDENT, SN02-01751, that an assessment was warranted because of STUDENT’s lack of progress in the development of language. (See SEHO Decision in SN02-01751 dated September 25, 2002.)(Footnote 6) On the other hand, the testimony of Ms. Fang and MOTHER, and progress reports form Child and Family Services substantiate that STUDENT progressed when previously receiving individual speech and language therapy. (See also progress report from Child and Family Services dated May 16, 2001; Petitioner’s Exhibit 35.) On the basis of the persuasive testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses and the supporting recommendations regarding STUDENT’s need for individual LAS therapy and the testimony of the District’s witnesses regarding the lack of progress without therapy, the HO concludes that STUDENT required individual LAS therapy to address her needs and to allow her to benefit educationally. As to the duration and frequency of LAS therapy STUDENT required, Ms. Faller recommended two sessions weekly of 30 minutes each. Ms. Faller is a qualified speech and language pathologist. No one else made any recommendations regarding the appropriate duration and frequency. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer adopts Ms. Faller’s recommendation.
(c) To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require one hour each week of OT?
STUDENT received individual OT services prior to entering the District. It is the position of Petitioner that a continuation of those services were required to allow her to benefit from her education. Ms. Caudillo testified in support of STUDENT’s need for OT. Ms. Caudillo testified that STUDENT’s deficits in fine- and gross-motor and self-help areas cannot be addressed solely by an aide or teacher and, therefore, must be provided by a qualified and trained professional OT. Ms. Caudillo testified that an occupational therapist has received special training to analyze tasks, break the task into smaller skills, and make adjustments as the student makes progress, whereas a teacher is not trained in the same manner. Additionally, Ms. Caudillo testified that because of STUDENT’s cognitive and attentional problems, STUDENT requires intensive one-to-one interaction with a therapist. Ms. Caudillo acknowledged that some of the activities STUDENT would benefit from could be carried out by a teacher or aide. Those activities include drawing a line and putting together a puzzle. Ms. Caudillo entertained the idea that an occupational therapist could be used to consult with the teacher. Ms. Caudillo’s assessment occurred following the 2001-2002 school year. However, as part of her assessment, she reviewed prior assessments of STUDENT’s motor skills and reports from other occupational therapists. Past recommendations from Cedars-Sinai Medical Center and Child and Family Services for OT support Ms. Caudillo’s testimony. The reasons indicated for OT on prior assessments include the need to address STUDENT’s significant deficits in fine-motor, self-feeding, and self-care skills, and decreased sensory processing. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 29 and 30)
Ms. Cotton testified that she addressed STUDENT’s fine-motor deficits by having STUDENT squeeze glue, string beads, pick up small objects, build with blocks, and use large snapping manipulatives. Ms. Hashiba testified that she addressed STUDENT’s fine-motor skills through STUDENT’s use of the sand box and water tables, coloring, cutting, and buttoning. Additionally, STUDENT received the services of APE.
The deficits for which OT has consistently been recommended since 2000 continued and were identified at the time of the District’s assessment and IEP in July 2001. Neither the District’s IEP nor the testimony of the teachers was sufficient to overcome the credible testimony of the only OT that has assessed STUDENT and was qualified to speak regarding STUDENT’s OT needs because of personal experiences with STUDENT. Additionally, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has made progress in the past while receiving OT, whereas she did not meet her one motor goal during the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT required OT services to meet her needs and to allow her to benefit educationally. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT required direct OT services. In reviewing Ms. Caudillo’s testimony and the goals she proposed would be addressed by OT, consult services from an appropriately qualified occupational therapist would have been sufficient to address STUDENT’s needs.
(d) To meet her educational needs and allow her to benefit from her education, did STUDENT require a trained one-to-one aide?
The report of the District’s preschool assessment team states that STUDENT required continuous adult supervision because she is unaware of basic dangers in her environment. Ms. Caudillo testified that because of STUDENT’s cognitive function and poor attention span, she required intensive one-to-one intervention. STUDENT also required supervision for safety reasons. Ms. Cotton acknowledged STUDENT’s need for individual assistance and, to that purpose, called for an IEP to add the services of an aide to STUDENT’s IEP. The IEP team adopted Ms. Cotton’s recommendation. Thus, the services of an aide have been provided pursuant to an IEP since MOTHER consented to the IEP amendment on October 10, 2001. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required further aide assistance than already has been provided by the District.
Summary
In summary, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives and failed to provide OT and LAS that STUDENT required to address her needs and to allow her to benefit from her education. Therefore, the District did not provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
ISSUE NO. 2 Did the individualized education program (IEP) and the placement proposed on June 20, 2002, offer Petitioner a FAPE?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer her a FAPE from the IEP meeting on June 20, 2002 to October 15, 2002, because she continued to require OT and LAS at the same frequency set out above for the 2001-2002 school year, and a trained one-to-one aide.
The District contends that it offered a FAPE. The District asserts that based on the information available to it when the IEP was developed on June 20, 2002, neither OT, LAS, nor an aide was necessary to address STUDENT’s needs.
Ms. Hashiba testified that STUDENT made some progress while in her class. However, most of the progress has been made during the current school year. Ms. Hashiba stated that STUDENT has gained confidence and trust. Despite STUDENT’s making some small gains, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s needs continued to be the same in June 2002 as they were at the IEP in July 2001. The June 2002 IEP states that STUDENT was dependent on adults for guidance in school, did not follow simple directions, parallel played with peers but did not initiate play, was unaware of safety and health issues, had difficulty with simple classroom tasks, had unsteady balance, poor balance, lacked fine-motor skills for school activities such as cutting, coloring, and writing, and did not communicate needs or wants. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7) Additionally, STUDENT had met only one goal from the July 2001 IEP, which was related to feeding herself independently with a spoon.
Because STUDENT’s needs remained substantially the same, it is concluded that she required the same level of support provided by OT and LAS therapy as determined necessary above regarding the 2001-2002 school year, namely one hour weekly of LAS therapy and one-half hour weekly of OT consultation. As to STUDENT’s need for a one-to-one aide, the IEP dated June 20, 2002, continued to provide the services of an assistant. There was no persuasive testimony that she required aide services above and beyond that which is presently called for by her IEP.
ISSUE NO. 3: Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services?
Petitioner asserts that she is entitled to 88 hours each of LAS therapy and OT for the District’s denial of FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.
Parents may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)
It has been concluded above that STUDENT required LAS therapy during the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner requested 88 hours each of compensatory LAS therapy for the District’s failure to provide these services. However, Ms. Faller, the only speech and language pathologist to testify regarding the amount of therapy STUDENT should have received, recommended two sessions each week for 30 minutes each. Thus, it is concluded that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory LAS therapy for a total of 42 hours. This figure is based on a school year of approximately 36 weeks and an extended school year of 6 weeks.
Regarding the appropriate compensatory remedy for the District’s failure to provide OT, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s request for 88 hours. Ms. Caudillo recommended varying amounts of OT from one hour to two hours. Given that consultation with STUDENT’s teachers would have addressed STUDENT’s OT needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate remedy is to provide OT consulting services to STUDENT’s teacher from an appropriately qualified occupational therapist for a total of 21 hours.
Petitioner did not seek an additional remedy for the failure to develop appropriate goals and objectives.
ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District conduct appropriate OT and LAS assessments of Petitioner on July 10, 2001?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct appropriate OT and LAS assessments of Petitioner on July 10, 2001. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to utilize appropriate tests in conducting its assessments. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the District’s written reports of OT and LAS assessments were incomplete because they do not properly identify Petitioner’s needs or discuss how those needs affect her education.(Footnote 7)
The District contends that its OT and LAS assessments were appropriate and that the written assessment reports comply with legal requirements.
Did the District conduct an appropriate OT assessment?
Turning first to Petitioner’s claim that the District’s OT assessment was not appropriate because the District failed to utilize appropriate tests, California Education Code section 56320 provides, in pertinent part:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist . . . . (d) Tests are selected and administered to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure. . . .
District occupational therapist Amy M. Gray completed an OT assessment of STUDENT on July 10, 2001.(Footnote 8) (Petitioner’s Exhibit 13) The District’s assessment consisted of clinical observations, parent interview, and a review of past records.
Ms. Caudillo testified on behalf of Petitioner regarding the adequacy of the District’s OT assessment. Ms. Caudillo is in private practice and conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT on August 9, 2002. She has been an occupational therapist for five years. Ms. Caudillo testified that the methods employed by the District to assess STUDENT were inadequate because the assessment did not provide “solid developmental baselines” from which goals and objectives could be developed. According to Ms. Caudillo, there are standardized instruments, including the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, that are appropriate to use with a preschool child and that can be modified to meet the student’s needs according to the test manual.
The assessment was conducted in English. Although STUDENT’s family speaks English, Spanish, and Armenian, no one argued or testified that the assessment should have been conducted in Spanish or Armenian rather than English. No one disputed Mr. Pauig’s testimony that the assessment materials and methods were not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Mr. Pauig testified that the District’s assessment is not invalidated by the fact that standardized assessment instruments were not employed to assess STUDENT. In fact, Mr. Pauig testified that because of STUDENT’s young age, cognitive level, and unwillingness to participate in formal testing, it was necessary for the assessors to employ methods other than administering standardized tests to assess STUDENT. For example, Mr. Pauig stated that STUDENT would not have understood the questions that would have been asked as part of a standardized assessment instrument and would not have been able to respond. Thus, an accurate assessment of her skills would not have been obtained by administering a formal test instrument. According to Mr. Pauig, it was within the professional discretion of Ms. Gray to employ alternative means to assess STUDENT. Karen Krische, District coordinator of staff development, concurred with Mr. Pauig and further testified that the underlying goal of a preschool assessment is to find out what the child can actually do. Thus, according to Ms. Krische, a play-based assessment, such as the one the preschool assessment team conducted with STUDENT, is an accepted method for assessing preschool-age children and was an appropriate means to assess STUDENT.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT was functioning well below average for her age at the time of the assessment, had minimal communication skills, and demonstrated limited interest in tasks. She also was shy and sat on her mother’s lap for most of the assessment. Additionally, STUDENT exhibited attentional difficulties. Because the Hearing Officer does not have the benefit of Ms. Gray’s testimony, it is unknown what instruments she may have attempted to use to assess STUDENT. However, Ms. Caudillo’s testimony that assessment instruments should have been used was based on her knowledge of STUDENT 13 months after the District assessment. Given these factors and relying on the credible testimony of Mr. Pauig and Ms. Krische that it was within the discretion of the assessors to employ alternative means to assess STUDENT and an appropriate testing method to assess STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concludes that the OT assessment met legal requirements.
Turning to the adequacy of the OT assessment report, special education law provides that the written report of the assessment must include:
(a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services. (b) The basis for making the determination.
(c) The relevant behavior noted during the observations of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (d) The relationship of that behavior to the pupil’s academic and social functioning. (e) The educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any. . . . (g) A determination concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate. . . .
Cal. Educ. Code § 56327.
Ms. Caudillo characterized the District’s OT report as “contradictory” and “invalid.” Ms. Caudillo testified that Ms. Gray identified deficits within the body of the report but concluded that STUDENT’s skills fell within functional limits.
Mr. Pauig testified that the District’s OT assessment report met special education requirements. In pertinent part, on page three of the report, he pointed out that Ms. Gray wrote “LAUSD provides preschool for children who may need a head start in school readiness skills. Occupational therapy is considered a support service to address any needs the teacher, program or other disciplines may not be able to address, and would not necessarily address each area of concern identified in the assessment. In addition, all deficits are not able to be remediated by occupational therapy or are not appropriate for school related occupational therapy services.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 13) Thus, the report includes both recommendations and the basis for making the recommendation. The report also includes relevant behavior noted during the observations of STUDENT. Throughout the report are notes regarding STUDENT’s initial resistence to interaction with the assessors, lack of attention, reactions to materials introduced to her during the assessment, and decreased attention. As to the relationship of STUDENT’s behavior to academic and social functioning, some examples in the assessment report include STUDENT’s use of adequate pencil pressure, which is related to coloring and writing, and the effect of attentional problems on STUDENT’s ability to complete tasks. The report additionally notes that STUDENT has adequate strength, balance, and equilibrium to participate in school activities. There are other examples, as well. The report addresses relevant health and developmental factors including the results of hearing testing and medical findings. In summary, the assessment report sufficiently satisfies the report requirements set for in Education Code section 56327.
Did the District conduct an appropriate LAS assessment?
The District’s LAS assessment was conducted by Marilyn Muir, District LAS pathologist for the past 13 years. The result of her assessment is contained in Petitioner’s Exhibit 12.
Cathie Campbell Faller testified on behalf of Petitioner regarding the adequacy of the District’s LAS assessment. Ms. Faller is an LAS therapist in private practice. She assessed STUDENT on September 11, 2001, at the request of the Regional Center. Ms. Faller’s primary concern with the District’s LAS assessment was the failure of the District’s assessor to administer standardized instruments to assess STUDENT’s speech and language skills. In fact, Ms. Faller unequivocally stated that no assessment is valid unless it includes standardized instruments.
Ms. Muir assessed STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language, and voice and fluency. Ms. Muir testified that her assessment was play-based and included observation, parent interview, and informal tasks. Ms. Muir found that oral language activities were difficult for STUDENT and that STUDENT did not focus her attention to tasks during the assessment process. MOTHER provided information regarding STUDENT’s communication skills at home and STUDENT participated in a few simple tasks, which provided Ms. Muir with information regarding STUDENT’s language and communication skills.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District’s witnesses to be persuasive regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessment. Ms. Muir conducted the assessment and was in a better position to describe STUDENT’s behavior during testing. On the other hand, Ms. Faller’s opinion failed to take into consideration that some children may be difficult, if not impossible, to assess using standardized assessments. Ms. Faller did not take into account that there are circumstances wherein the person conducting the assessment needs to make professional decisions regarding the appropriate means to assess a child’s skills. Ms. Krische, who testified regarding the appropriateness of play-based assessments, is a speech pathologist, and has extensive experience regarding assessments. As discussed above regarding the OT assessment, at the time of the assessment STUDENT was functioning well below average for her age, demonstrated minimal communication skills, and had a short attention span. STUDENT also was hesitant to participate in activities and sat on her mother’s lap for most of the assessment. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s use of observation, interview, and informal tasks to assess STUDENT’s speech and language skills was appropriate.
As to the adequacy of the LAS assessment report, the evidence establishes that the report includes recommendations to improve STUDENT’s communication skills within the classroom setting. The report includes observations of STUDENT during the assessment including STUDENT’s lack of participation in all but a few tasks and her vocalizations during the assessment. The report relates STUDENT’s speech and language skills to her functioning in other developmental areas. It is the conclusion of the Hearing Officer that the District’s assessment report was adequate.
ISSUE NO. 5: If not, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent OT assessment completed by DeAnna Caudillo, OT, on August 9, 2002?
A parent may obtain reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 CFR § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5. It has been determined above that the District’s assessment sufficiently satisfied legal requirements as to the areas raised by Petitioner. Thus, Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Ms. Caudillo’s assessment.
ORDER
(1) Withing 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to determine how to implement the compensatory services of speech and language therapy and OT consultation called for by this Decision. In determining how to provide the services, the IEP team shall take into consideration STUDENT’s age, attention, and developmental level, and her ability to tolerate services in light of the services she presently receives. The IEP team shall also consider providing the services during intersessions or other times when school is not in session.
(2) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall begin providing STUDENT with the compensatory educational services of speech and language therapy for a total of 42 hours and OT consultation for a total of 21 hours. The services shall be provided prior to the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
(3) Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the District offer Petitioner STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)? The District prevailed as to the lack of a procedural denial of FAPE and Petitioner’s need for a one-to-one aide. Petitioner prevailed as to the District’s failure to develop appropriate goals and objectives and to provide speech and language therapy, and OT consultation.
(2) Did the individualized education program (IEP) and the placement proposed on June 20, 2002, offer Petitioner a FAPE? Petitioner prevailed as to the need for speech and language therapy and OT consultation. The District prevailed as the Petitioner’s need for a one-to-one aide.
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services? Petitioner prevailed as to her entitlement to compensatory educational services for the failure to provide LAS therapy and OT but not to the extent requested. Petitioner did not request any additional compensatory remedy for the District’s failure to provide appropriate goals and objectives.
(4) Did the District conduct appropriate OT and LAS assessments of Petitioner on July 10, 2001? The District prevailed on this issue.
(5) If not, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent OT assessment completed by DeAnna Caudillo, OT, on August 9, 2002? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: December 5, 2002 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
1. Ms. Meredith no longer was with the law firm of Roberts & Adams when the hearing reconvened in October 2. The school operates on a year-round calendar. Intersessions are scheduled between the regular school sessions and are somewhat similar to extended school year programs occurring during the summer between school years. 3. There is no evidence that an assessment plan was developed at the meeting on January 15, 2002. 4. The 1997 reauthorization of the IDEA additionally provides that an appropriate education for a student with a disability shall include reasonable access to the general education curriculum and instruction and related services designed to prepare the student for employment and independent living. These components of an appropriate education are not at issue in this hearing. 5. The date following MOTHER ‘s signature indicates the month of July and the year of 2001. However, the day is either 10 superimposed over 30 or vice versa. It is impossible to tell which date MOTHER wrote. The cover sheet to which the assessment plan is attached states that the assessment plan was received on July 10, 2001. 6. Although pursuant to stay put, STUDENT was entitled to LAS therapy during much of this period, the District did not provide her with LAS therapy. 7. Petitioner’s closing brief does not address the adequacy of the District’s assessment reports. The issue is addressed here because Petitioner raised the adequacy of the District’s OT and LAS assessment reports at the prehearing conference. 8. Ms. Gray no longer is employed by the District and was unavailable to testify. Pablo Pauig II, OTR, testified on behalf of the District regarding its OT assessment. Mr. Pauig has not assessed STUDENT.
