California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 9, 1997
Student v. Oakland Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1366-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Oakland Unified need not serve student whose family residence stayed in Pleasant Hill; IEP meeting claim not reached.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Interim rulings before the decision: SEHO denied District dismissal requests on January 23, 1997 and June 30, 1997. It issued a stay put order on February 6, 1997 requiring reenrollment at Crocker Highlands Elementary. On September 3, 1997, it denied the District's requests to reconsider both rulings. No later history is noted.
Summary
A mother filed for due process in December 1996 after Oakland Unified School District told her that her eight-year-old son would be dropped from enrollment because the family did not live in the District. The boy has Down syndrome and was in a special day class at Crocker Highlands Elementary. His mother worked for the District. Before the hearing, SEHO denied two District motions to dismiss and issued a stay put order that kept the boy enrolled.
The main question at hearing was whether the student lived in Oakland. The mother showed a rental agreement for an Oakland apartment and rent receipts. She later added a phone bill, a bank statement, and a new voter registration, but she got most of these only after the District pressed her for proof. The family owned a home in Pleasant Hill and claimed the homeowner's exemption there. The student spent most weekends and most of the summer in Pleasant Hill, and his teacher testified that only his father brought him to school. Under Government Code section 244, a residence is the place a person returns to "in seasons of repose," and changing residence takes both act and intent. Applying that rule, the Hearing Officer found that the family's residence remained in Pleasant Hill. He therefore did not decide whether the District had to hold an IEP meeting, and he denied all relief. He noted that an interdistrict transfer based on the mother's District job was still an option.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO decided residency disputes under Government Code section 244. It looked at where the family spent weekends and summers. It also gave less weight to proof of residence gathered only after the district challenged enrollment. Separately, the decision points to Education Code section 48204, which lets a child attend school in a district where a parent works.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Is Student a resident of Oakland Unified School District, thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to Student?
Under Government Code section 244, the family's residence stayed in Pleasant Hill. The mother returned there in seasons of repose, and her Oakland apartment was not backed by enough evidence of both act and intent, so the student was not a District resident.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue 2. If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for Student?
The Hearing Officer did not reach this issue because he found the student was not a District resident.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
Key authorities
Education Code § 48200; Government Code § 244; Welfare & Institutions Code § 17.1(a); Education Code § 48204
People named in the decision
- Barbara Wagner, special day class teacher (District witness), Crocker Highlands Elementary School, Oakland Unified School District
- Samuel Webster, private investigator (District witness), Webster & Associates
- Lynne Ono, program manager, elementary special education program, Oakland Unified School District
- Fred Turner, director of student services, Oakland Unified School District
- Regional Center of the East Bay, regional center (named on a release of information form)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Oakland, California, on September 23, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocate Beverlyn Lee. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Oakland Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Tanya Russell. Also present on the District’s behalf was Lynne Ono, program manager of the District’s elementary special education program.
MOTHER was the only witness who testified on STUDENT’s behalf. The District’s witnesses were Barbara Wagner, special day class teacher, and Samuel Webster, investigator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District, thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
MOTHER requested a due process hearing on behalf of her son, STUDENT, on December 18, 1996. MOTHER named the District as respondent and indicated she was requesting a hearing to address STUDENT’s “release” from school.
On December 20, 1996, Lynne Ono, program manager for the District’s elementary special education program, requested that this matter be dismissed on the ground that STUDENT was not a resident of the District. On January 15, 1997, MOTHER submitted a response to the District’s request. MOTHER provided a copy of a rental agreement showing that she had rented an apartment in Oakland as of December 16, 1996. Based on the rental agreement provided by MOTHER, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request on January 23, 1997.
At the same time that MOTHER submitted her response to the District’s dismissal request, MOTHER also requested a stay put order requiring the District to maintain STUDENT in his placement at Crocker Highland Elementary. On January 22, 1997, Ms. Ono responded and opposed the stay put request on the ground that MOTHER had not established residency within the District. On February 6, 1997, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order requiring the District to reenroll STUDENT in Crocker Highlands Elementary.
On June 18, 1997, Ms. Ono again requested on behalf of the District that this matter be dismissed. Ms. Ono contended that STUDENT was not a resident of the District as demonstrated by MOTHER’s jury service in Contra Costa County. Ms. Ono also contended that MOTHER returned to her Pleasant Hill home each evening with STUDENT. On June 19, 1997, MOTHER responded to the District’s dismissal request. MOTHER, in support of her contention that she was a resident of the District, provided a copy of the rental agreement and copies of rent receipts for January through June 1997. MOTHER contended that she resided with STUDENT in Oakland while her husband continued to reside in their home in Pleasant Hill. MOTHER stated that “I reside with STUDENT at the Oakland residence during most school days; however, during most weekends I take STUDENT to our Pleasant Hill home so we can spend time with the rest of the family (my husband and another son).”
On June 30, 1997, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request. Although the Hearing Officer determined that MOTHER had not established a residence in Oakland, the dismissal was denied because the District had not fulfilled certain requirements required when a student’s parent works within the District’s boundaries, as MOTHER does.
On August 13, 1997, Ms. Ono requested reconsideration of the stay put order and, on August 25, 1997, requested reconsideration of the denial of the District’s dismissal request. On September 3, 1997, the Hearing Office denied Ms. Ono’s request because she had failed to raise new grounds to reconsider the prior rulings.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old boy eligible for special education as a result of Down’s Syndrome. In September 1996, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, obtained a job with the District. On October 31, 1996, STUDENT enrolled at Crocker Highland Elementary School in the District.(Footnote 1) At the time, his placement was a 30-day placement. Since enrolling in the District, STUDENT has also attended a day care facility after school in Oakland.
On December 9, 1996, MOTHER was notified by Fred Turner, director of student services, that STUDENT’s enrollment in the District would end on December 20, 1996. The reason cited by Mr. Turner was that the FAMILY were not residents of the District and that the District required an interdistrict transfer permit from STUDENT’s home district if he was to continue in the District. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 1)
In response to Mr. Turner’s communication, MOTHER submitted a letter stating that she was a resident of the District and resided at MOTHER’S ADDRESS in Oakland, California.(Footnote 2) MOTHER also changed her address to the [address redacted] address in her personnel records. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Nos. 2 and 3)(Footnote 3) In addition, MOTHER, on December 17, 1996, requested a due process hearing to address STUDENT’s release from school as proposed by the District.
On December 17, 1996, MOTHER completed a release of information form for the Regional Center of the East Bay. On that form, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s home address was [address redacted].(Footnote 4)
At some point during the winter or spring of 1997, MOTHER reported for jury duty in Contra Costa County. (Testimony of MOTHER, District’s Exhibit U) On May 30, 1997, Mr. Turner sent a letter to the PARENTS again stating that STUDENT was not a resident of the District and would not be allowed to enroll in the District in September. Mr. Turner indicated that STUDENT would have to produce three “pieces of proof of residence as required by district policy.” (District’s Exhibit U). In response, in August 1997, MOTHER submitted her phone bill, bank account statement, and voter registration information.
District policy with regard to enrollment of a student who has a parent who works within the District’s boundaries requires a transfer application from the student’s home district. (District’s Exhibit Y) MOTHER has never asked for such a transfer. (Testimony of MOTHER)
In March 1997, the District hired a private investigator to obtain information regarding the FAMILY’s residence. The investigator, Samuel Webster, conducted several surveillances of different addresses and produced three reports as a result of his work. (District’s Exhibits S, T, and DD) During the months of March, April, and September 1997, Mr. Webster conducted several surveillances of [address redacted], [address redacted], and STUDENT’s day care in Oakland. Mr. Webster observed STUDENT at both addresses several times, observed MOTHER at both addresses several times, and also observed STUDENT at the day care facility.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner’s Witness
MOTHER
MOTHER is STUDENT’s mother and a special education teacher employed by the District since September 1996. MOTHER testified that she has resided with STUDENT at [address redacted] in Oakland, California, since December 1996.
MOTHER testified that she refers to Pleasant Hill as her “home” because that is where she owns a house. However, Pleasant Hill is not the place where she lives. MOTHER stated that she lives in Oakland and intends on remaining there. MOTHER also testified that she has another child who lives at the Pleasant Hill address with FATHER and that she returns there occasionally to care for the child. MOTHER also has an older daughter who became ill last year, and MOTHER returned to Pleasant Hill to help care for her. MOTHER also returns to Pleasant Hill to collect mail that is sent there. MOTHER has not notified the postal service of a change of address.
MOTHER testified that she did not change her voter registration until August because as a property owner in Contra Costa, she felt she had a greater interest in Contra Costa than in Oakland. MOTHER changed her voter registration when she was advised by the District that voter registration was one means of establishing residency. MOTHER also testified that she did not have a telephone or bank account until advised by the District that having a telephone or bank account would help her establish residency.
MOTHER testified that, during summer 1997, she spent most of her time in Oakland because she continued working during the summer session. STUDENT, however, spent much of his time in Pleasant Hill while school was not in session.
District’s Witnesses
Barbara Wagner
Barbara Wagner is a special day class teacher at Crocker Highlands Elementary School. STUDENT enrolled in her class on October 31, 1996, and remained there for the duration of the school year. Ms. Wagner testified that when STUDENT started school his father dropped him off and picked him up every day. Either just before or just after the winter break, STUDENT started using the bus to come to school. However, for the remainder of the school year, on days when STUDENT missed the bus, his father brought him to school. STUDENT’s father also picked STUDENT up after school on occasion. According to Ms. Wagner, MOTHER never dropped STUDENT off at school or picked him up. Ms. Wagner also testified that the emergency telephone number she had for MOTHER was MOTHER’s work number and, when she asked for a home number, MOTHER told her to contact her at work.
Samuel Webster
Samuel Webster is the owner of Webster & Associates, a private investigation firm hired by the District to gather evidence relating to STUDENT’s residency status. Mr. Webster’s testimony essentially confirmed the content of the reports he provided to the District. However, he also provided some additional information. Mr. Webster testified that none of the mailboxes he saw at [address redacted] had “STUDENT’s LAST NAME” on them. Mr. Webster testified that he conducted a real property search and was unable to locate [address redacted] in the property database. According to Mr. Webster, a property search also showed that Mr. and MOTHER were the owners of the property at [address redacted] in Pleasant Hill and that they claimed the homeowner’s exemption, an exemption claimed by individuals who use the property as their primary residence. Mr. Webster testified that he never saw STUDENT at [address redacted] until August 1997.
Mr. Webster stated that he believed that MOTHER resides at the [address redacted] address based on the records of property ownership, the homeowner’s exemption, and the behavior of MOTHER at both residences. Mr. Webster testified that he observed MOTHER drive into the garage, close the garage door at [address redacted], and not leave. However, Mr. Webster also stated that he did not observe the house later than 8:00 p.m.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
Education Code § 48200 provides that a child shall attend school in the district “in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located.” A child’s residency is based upon “the residence of the parent with whom the child maintains his or her place of abode.” Welf. & Inst. Code § 17.1(a). Further guidance on the definition of residence may be found in Government Code § 244, which states:
In determining the place of residence the following rules shall be observed:
(a) It is the place where one remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. (b) There can only be one residence.
(c) A residence cannot be lost until another is gained.
(d) The residence of the parent with whom an unmarried minor child maintains his or her place of abode is the residence of such unmarried minor child. (e) The residence of an unmarried minor who has a parent living cannot be changed by his or her own act. (f) The residence can be changed only by the union of act and intent. (g) A married person shall have the right to retain his or her legal residence in the State of California notwithstanding the legal residence or domicile of his or her spouse.
In the present case, MOTHER testified that she has lived in Oakland since September 1996 and intends on remaining there. However, for much of the time that MOTHER testified she lived in Oakland, she did not have a phone or a bank account, and had not changed her voter registration. In other words, MOTHER did not make many of the changes individuals make with a change of residence until pressured to do so by the District. MOTHER also acknowledged that she had not yet changed address with the Department of Motor Vehicles.
Additional evidence was presented that raises doubts about where STUDENT was living and whether MOTHER has, in fact, established a residence in Oakland with the intent to stay there. The unrefuted testimony of Ms. Wagner establishes that the only individual who brought STUDENT to school was his father. Additionally, MOTHER testified that she returned to the house in Pleasant Hill on most weekends during the 1996-97 school year and that STUDENT spent most of the summer at the Pleasant Hill house.
Government Code § 244(a) provides that an individual’s residence is that place where he or she remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. The testimony of MOTHER establishes that her residence was in Pleasant Hill because she intended to return there during the summer when school was not in session. Furthermore, STUDENT spent most of his time when school was not in session, both on weekends and during the summer, in Pleasant Hill. The evidence establishes that MOTHER may have rented an apartment in Oakland for work purposes and for her son to attend school in Oakland, but she has consistently returned to Pleasant Hill “in seasons of repose” for purposes of § 244.
It is also important that § 244 requires a combination of both the intent to reside in a place and the act of actually residing there. As already stated, while MOTHER stated that she lived in Oakland and intended on remaining there, many of the things that individuals do to establish residency were not done by MOTHER until she was pressured to do so by the District. While MOTHER now has documentation in the form of a phone bill, voter registration, and a bank account to demonstrate that she rents an apartment at [address redacted], these documents are not accompanied by significant evidence of both an intent to reside there and the actual act of residing there. There was no corroborating testimony from any witness other than MOTHER regarding her living arrangements. Furthermore, MOTHER stated that while she lived in Oakland during the week, she returned to Pleasant Hill most weekends and also during summer when school was not in session.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that he is a resident of the Oakland Unified School District. Although there is some evidence that MOTHER spends some time in Oakland, MOTHER’s own testimony and actions establish that her residence remains in Pleasant Hill.(Footnote 5)
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
Based on the finding in Issue #1, the Hearing Officer does not reach issue #2.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: October 9, 1997 _______________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Oakland, California, on September 23, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocate Beverlyn Lee. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Oakland Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Tanya Russell. Also present on the District’s behalf was Lynne Ono, program manager of the District’s elementary special education program.
MOTHER was the only witness who testified on STUDENT’s behalf. The District’s witnesses were Barbara Wagner, special day class teacher, and Samuel Webster, investigator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District, thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
MOTHER requested a due process hearing on behalf of her son, STUDENT, on December 18, 1996. MOTHER named the District as respondent and indicated she was requesting a hearing to address STUDENT’s “release” from school.
On December 20, 1996, Lynne Ono, program manager for the District’s elementary special education program, requested that this matter be dismissed on the ground that STUDENT was not a resident of the District. On January 15, 1997, MOTHER submitted a response to the District’s request. MOTHER provided a copy of a rental agreement showing that she had rented an apartment in Oakland as of December 16, 1996. Based on the rental agreement provided by MOTHER, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request on January 23, 1997.
At the same time that MOTHER submitted her response to the District’s dismissal request, MOTHER also requested a stay put order requiring the District to maintain STUDENT in his placement at Crocker Highland Elementary. On January 22, 1997, Ms. Ono responded and opposed the stay put request on the ground that MOTHER had not established residency within the District. On February 6, 1997, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order requiring the District to reenroll STUDENT in Crocker Highlands Elementary.
On June 18, 1997, Ms. Ono again requested on behalf of the District that this matter be dismissed. Ms. Ono contended that STUDENT was not a resident of the District as demonstrated by MOTHER’s jury service in Contra Costa County. Ms. Ono also contended that MOTHER returned to her Pleasant Hill home each evening with STUDENT. On June 19, 1997, MOTHER responded to the District’s dismissal request. MOTHER, in support of her contention that she was a resident of the District, provided a copy of the rental agreement and copies of rent receipts for January through June 1997. MOTHER contended that she resided with STUDENT in Oakland while her husband continued to reside in their home in Pleasant Hill. MOTHER stated that “I reside with STUDENT at the Oakland residence during most school days; however, during most weekends I take STUDENT to our Pleasant Hill home so we can spend time with the rest of the family (my husband and another son).”
On June 30, 1997, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request. Although the Hearing Officer determined that MOTHER had not established a residence in Oakland, the dismissal was denied because the District had not fulfilled certain requirements required when a student’s parent works within the District’s boundaries, as MOTHER does.
On August 13, 1997, Ms. Ono requested reconsideration of the stay put order and, on August 25, 1997, requested reconsideration of the denial of the District’s dismissal request. On September 3, 1997, the Hearing Office denied Ms. Ono’s request because she had failed to raise new grounds to reconsider the prior rulings.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old boy eligible for special education as a result of Down’s Syndrome. In September 1996, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, obtained a job with the District. On October 31, 1996, STUDENT enrolled at Crocker Highland Elementary School in the District.(Footnote 1) At the time, his placement was a 30-day placement. Since enrolling in the District, STUDENT has also attended a day care facility after school in Oakland.
On December 9, 1996, MOTHER was notified by Fred Turner, director of student services, that STUDENT’s enrollment in the District would end on December 20, 1996. The reason cited by Mr. Turner was that the FAMILY were not residents of the District and that the District required an interdistrict transfer permit from STUDENT’s home district if he was to continue in the District. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 1)
In response to Mr. Turner’s communication, MOTHER submitted a letter stating that she was a resident of the District and resided at MOTHER’S ADDRESS in Oakland, California.(Footnote 2) MOTHER also changed her address to the [address redacted] address in her personnel records. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Nos. 2 and 3)(Footnote 3) In addition, MOTHER, on December 17, 1996, requested a due process hearing to address STUDENT’s release from school as proposed by the District.
On December 17, 1996, MOTHER completed a release of information form for the Regional Center of the East Bay. On that form, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s home address was [address redacted].(Footnote 4)
At some point during the winter or spring of 1997, MOTHER reported for jury duty in Contra Costa County. (Testimony of MOTHER, District’s Exhibit U) On May 30, 1997, Mr. Turner sent a letter to the PARENTS again stating that STUDENT was not a resident of the District and would not be allowed to enroll in the District in September. Mr. Turner indicated that STUDENT would have to produce three “pieces of proof of residence as required by district policy.” (District’s Exhibit U). In response, in August 1997, MOTHER submitted her phone bill, bank account statement, and voter registration information.
District policy with regard to enrollment of a student who has a parent who works within the District’s boundaries requires a transfer application from the student’s home district. (District’s Exhibit Y) MOTHER has never asked for such a transfer. (Testimony of MOTHER)
In March 1997, the District hired a private investigator to obtain information regarding the FAMILY’s residence. The investigator, Samuel Webster, conducted several surveillances of different addresses and produced three reports as a result of his work. (District’s Exhibits S, T, and DD) During the months of March, April, and September 1997, Mr. Webster conducted several surveillances of [address redacted], [address redacted], and STUDENT’s day care in Oakland. Mr. Webster observed STUDENT at both addresses several times, observed MOTHER at both addresses several times, and also observed STUDENT at the day care facility.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner’s Witness
MOTHER
MOTHER is STUDENT’s mother and a special education teacher employed by the District since September 1996. MOTHER testified that she has resided with STUDENT at [address redacted] in Oakland, California, since December 1996.
MOTHER testified that she refers to Pleasant Hill as her “home” because that is where she owns a house. However, Pleasant Hill is not the place where she lives. MOTHER stated that she lives in Oakland and intends on remaining there. MOTHER also testified that she has another child who lives at the Pleasant Hill address with FATHER and that she returns there occasionally to care for the child. MOTHER also has an older daughter who became ill last year, and MOTHER returned to Pleasant Hill to help care for her. MOTHER also returns to Pleasant Hill to collect mail that is sent there. MOTHER has not notified the postal service of a change of address.
MOTHER testified that she did not change her voter registration until August because as a property owner in Contra Costa, she felt she had a greater interest in Contra Costa than in Oakland. MOTHER changed her voter registration when she was advised by the District that voter registration was one means of establishing residency. MOTHER also testified that she did not have a telephone or bank account until advised by the District that having a telephone or bank account would help her establish residency.
MOTHER testified that, during summer 1997, she spent most of her time in Oakland because she continued working during the summer session. STUDENT, however, spent much of his time in Pleasant Hill while school was not in session.
District’s Witnesses
Barbara Wagner
Barbara Wagner is a special day class teacher at Crocker Highlands Elementary School. STUDENT enrolled in her class on October 31, 1996, and remained there for the duration of the school year. Ms. Wagner testified that when STUDENT started school his father dropped him off and picked him up every day. Either just before or just after the winter break, STUDENT started using the bus to come to school. However, for the remainder of the school year, on days when STUDENT missed the bus, his father brought him to school. STUDENT’s father also picked STUDENT up after school on occasion. According to Ms. Wagner, MOTHER never dropped STUDENT off at school or picked him up. Ms. Wagner also testified that the emergency telephone number she had for MOTHER was MOTHER’s work number and, when she asked for a home number, MOTHER told her to contact her at work.
Samuel Webster
Samuel Webster is the owner of Webster & Associates, a private investigation firm hired by the District to gather evidence relating to STUDENT’s residency status. Mr. Webster’s testimony essentially confirmed the content of the reports he provided to the District. However, he also provided some additional information. Mr. Webster testified that none of the mailboxes he saw at [address redacted] had “STUDENT’s LAST NAME” on them. Mr. Webster testified that he conducted a real property search and was unable to locate [address redacted] in the property database. According to Mr. Webster, a property search also showed that Mr. and MOTHER were the owners of the property at [address redacted] in Pleasant Hill and that they claimed the homeowner’s exemption, an exemption claimed by individuals who use the property as their primary residence. Mr. Webster testified that he never saw STUDENT at [address redacted] until August 1997.
Mr. Webster stated that he believed that MOTHER resides at the [address redacted] address based on the records of property ownership, the homeowner’s exemption, and the behavior of MOTHER at both residences. Mr. Webster testified that he observed MOTHER drive into the garage, close the garage door at [address redacted], and not leave. However, Mr. Webster also stated that he did not observe the house later than 8:00 p.m.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
Education Code § 48200 provides that a child shall attend school in the district “in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located.” A child’s residency is based upon “the residence of the parent with whom the child maintains his or her place of abode.” Welf. & Inst. Code § 17.1(a). Further guidance on the definition of residence may be found in Government Code § 244, which states:
In determining the place of residence the following rules shall be observed:
(a) It is the place where one remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. (b) There can only be one residence.
(c) A residence cannot be lost until another is gained.
(d) The residence of the parent with whom an unmarried minor child maintains his or her place of abode is the residence of such unmarried minor child. (e) The residence of an unmarried minor who has a parent living cannot be changed by his or her own act. (f) The residence can be changed only by the union of act and intent. (g) A married person shall have the right to retain his or her legal residence in the State of California notwithstanding the legal residence or domicile of his or her spouse.
In the present case, MOTHER testified that she has lived in Oakland since September 1996 and intends on remaining there. However, for much of the time that MOTHER testified she lived in Oakland, she did not have a phone or a bank account, and had not changed her voter registration. In other words, MOTHER did not make many of the changes individuals make with a change of residence until pressured to do so by the District. MOTHER also acknowledged that she had not yet changed address with the Department of Motor Vehicles.
Additional evidence was presented that raises doubts about where STUDENT was living and whether MOTHER has, in fact, established a residence in Oakland with the intent to stay there. The unrefuted testimony of Ms. Wagner establishes that the only individual who brought STUDENT to school was his father. Additionally, MOTHER testified that she returned to the house in Pleasant Hill on most weekends during the 1996-97 school year and that STUDENT spent most of the summer at the Pleasant Hill house.
Government Code § 244(a) provides that an individual’s residence is that place where he or she remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. The testimony of MOTHER establishes that her residence was in Pleasant Hill because she intended to return there during the summer when school was not in session. Furthermore, STUDENT spent most of his time when school was not in session, both on weekends and during the summer, in Pleasant Hill. The evidence establishes that MOTHER may have rented an apartment in Oakland for work purposes and for her son to attend school in Oakland, but she has consistently returned to Pleasant Hill “in seasons of repose” for purposes of § 244.
It is also important that § 244 requires a combination of both the intent to reside in a place and the act of actually residing there. As already stated, while MOTHER stated that she lived in Oakland and intended on remaining there, many of the things that individuals do to establish residency were not done by MOTHER until she was pressured to do so by the District. While MOTHER now has documentation in the form of a phone bill, voter registration, and a bank account to demonstrate that she rents an apartment at [address redacted], these documents are not accompanied by significant evidence of both an intent to reside there and the actual act of residing there. There was no corroborating testimony from any witness other than MOTHER regarding her living arrangements. Furthermore, MOTHER stated that while she lived in Oakland during the week, she returned to Pleasant Hill most weekends and also during summer when school was not in session.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that he is a resident of the Oakland Unified School District. Although there is some evidence that MOTHER spends some time in Oakland, MOTHER’s own testimony and actions establish that her residence remains in Pleasant Hill.(Footnote 5)
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
Based on the finding in Issue #1, the Hearing Officer does not reach issue #2.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: October 9, 1997 _______________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Oakland, California, on September 23, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocate Beverlyn Lee. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Oakland Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Tanya Russell. Also present on the District’s behalf was Lynne Ono, program manager of the District’s elementary special education program.
MOTHER was the only witness who testified on STUDENT’s behalf. The District’s witnesses were Barbara Wagner, special day class teacher, and Samuel Webster, investigator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District, thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
MOTHER requested a due process hearing on behalf of her son, STUDENT, on December 18, 1996. MOTHER named the District as respondent and indicated she was requesting a hearing to address STUDENT’s “release” from school.
On December 20, 1996, Lynne Ono, program manager for the District’s elementary special education program, requested that this matter be dismissed on the ground that STUDENT was not a resident of the District. On January 15, 1997, MOTHER submitted a response to the District’s request. MOTHER provided a copy of a rental agreement showing that she had rented an apartment in Oakland as of December 16, 1996. Based on the rental agreement provided by MOTHER, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request on January 23, 1997.
At the same time that MOTHER submitted her response to the District’s dismissal request, MOTHER also requested a stay put order requiring the District to maintain STUDENT in his placement at Crocker Highland Elementary. On January 22, 1997, Ms. Ono responded and opposed the stay put request on the ground that MOTHER had not established residency within the District. On February 6, 1997, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order requiring the District to reenroll STUDENT in Crocker Highlands Elementary.
On June 18, 1997, Ms. Ono again requested on behalf of the District that this matter be dismissed. Ms. Ono contended that STUDENT was not a resident of the District as demonstrated by MOTHER’s jury service in Contra Costa County. Ms. Ono also contended that MOTHER returned to her Pleasant Hill home each evening with STUDENT. On June 19, 1997, MOTHER responded to the District’s dismissal request. MOTHER, in support of her contention that she was a resident of the District, provided a copy of the rental agreement and copies of rent receipts for January through June 1997. MOTHER contended that she resided with STUDENT in Oakland while her husband continued to reside in their home in Pleasant Hill. MOTHER stated that “I reside with STUDENT at the Oakland residence during most school days; however, during most weekends I take STUDENT to our Pleasant Hill home so we can spend time with the rest of the family (my husband and another son).”
On June 30, 1997, the Hearing Office denied the District’s dismissal request. Although the Hearing Officer determined that MOTHER had not established a residence in Oakland, the dismissal was denied because the District had not fulfilled certain requirements required when a student’s parent works within the District’s boundaries, as MOTHER does.
On August 13, 1997, Ms. Ono requested reconsideration of the stay put order and, on August 25, 1997, requested reconsideration of the denial of the District’s dismissal request. On September 3, 1997, the Hearing Office denied Ms. Ono’s request because she had failed to raise new grounds to reconsider the prior rulings.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old boy eligible for special education as a result of Down’s Syndrome. In September 1996, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, obtained a job with the District. On October 31, 1996, STUDENT enrolled at Crocker Highland Elementary School in the District.(Footnote 1) At the time, his placement was a 30-day placement. Since enrolling in the District, STUDENT has also attended a day care facility after school in Oakland.
On December 9, 1996, MOTHER was notified by Fred Turner, director of student services, that STUDENT’s enrollment in the District would end on December 20, 1996. The reason cited by Mr. Turner was that the FAMILY were not residents of the District and that the District required an interdistrict transfer permit from STUDENT’s home district if he was to continue in the District. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 1)
In response to Mr. Turner’s communication, MOTHER submitted a letter stating that she was a resident of the District and resided at MOTHER’S ADDRESS in Oakland, California.(Footnote 2) MOTHER also changed her address to the [address redacted] address in her personnel records. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Nos. 2 and 3)(Footnote 3) In addition, MOTHER, on December 17, 1996, requested a due process hearing to address STUDENT’s release from school as proposed by the District.
On December 17, 1996, MOTHER completed a release of information form for the Regional Center of the East Bay. On that form, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s home address was [address redacted].(Footnote 4)
At some point during the winter or spring of 1997, MOTHER reported for jury duty in Contra Costa County. (Testimony of MOTHER, District’s Exhibit U) On May 30, 1997, Mr. Turner sent a letter to the PARENTS again stating that STUDENT was not a resident of the District and would not be allowed to enroll in the District in September. Mr. Turner indicated that STUDENT would have to produce three “pieces of proof of residence as required by district policy.” (District’s Exhibit U). In response, in August 1997, MOTHER submitted her phone bill, bank account statement, and voter registration information.
District policy with regard to enrollment of a student who has a parent who works within the District’s boundaries requires a transfer application from the student’s home district. (District’s Exhibit Y) MOTHER has never asked for such a transfer. (Testimony of MOTHER)
In March 1997, the District hired a private investigator to obtain information regarding the FAMILY’s residence. The investigator, Samuel Webster, conducted several surveillances of different addresses and produced three reports as a result of his work. (District’s Exhibits S, T, and DD) During the months of March, April, and September 1997, Mr. Webster conducted several surveillances of [address redacted], [address redacted], and STUDENT’s day care in Oakland. Mr. Webster observed STUDENT at both addresses several times, observed MOTHER at both addresses several times, and also observed STUDENT at the day care facility.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner’s Witness
MOTHER
MOTHER is STUDENT’s mother and a special education teacher employed by the District since September 1996. MOTHER testified that she has resided with STUDENT at [address redacted] in Oakland, California, since December 1996.
MOTHER testified that she refers to Pleasant Hill as her “home” because that is where she owns a house. However, Pleasant Hill is not the place where she lives. MOTHER stated that she lives in Oakland and intends on remaining there. MOTHER also testified that she has another child who lives at the Pleasant Hill address with FATHER and that she returns there occasionally to care for the child. MOTHER also has an older daughter who became ill last year, and MOTHER returned to Pleasant Hill to help care for her. MOTHER also returns to Pleasant Hill to collect mail that is sent there. MOTHER has not notified the postal service of a change of address.
MOTHER testified that she did not change her voter registration until August because as a property owner in Contra Costa, she felt she had a greater interest in Contra Costa than in Oakland. MOTHER changed her voter registration when she was advised by the District that voter registration was one means of establishing residency. MOTHER also testified that she did not have a telephone or bank account until advised by the District that having a telephone or bank account would help her establish residency.
MOTHER testified that, during summer 1997, she spent most of her time in Oakland because she continued working during the summer session. STUDENT, however, spent much of his time in Pleasant Hill while school was not in session.
District’s Witnesses
Barbara Wagner
Barbara Wagner is a special day class teacher at Crocker Highlands Elementary School. STUDENT enrolled in her class on October 31, 1996, and remained there for the duration of the school year. Ms. Wagner testified that when STUDENT started school his father dropped him off and picked him up every day. Either just before or just after the winter break, STUDENT started using the bus to come to school. However, for the remainder of the school year, on days when STUDENT missed the bus, his father brought him to school. STUDENT’s father also picked STUDENT up after school on occasion. According to Ms. Wagner, MOTHER never dropped STUDENT off at school or picked him up. Ms. Wagner also testified that the emergency telephone number she had for MOTHER was MOTHER’s work number and, when she asked for a home number, MOTHER told her to contact her at work.
Samuel Webster
Samuel Webster is the owner of Webster & Associates, a private investigation firm hired by the District to gather evidence relating to STUDENT’s residency status. Mr. Webster’s testimony essentially confirmed the content of the reports he provided to the District. However, he also provided some additional information. Mr. Webster testified that none of the mailboxes he saw at [address redacted] had “STUDENT’s LAST NAME” on them. Mr. Webster testified that he conducted a real property search and was unable to locate [address redacted] in the property database. According to Mr. Webster, a property search also showed that Mr. and MOTHER were the owners of the property at [address redacted] in Pleasant Hill and that they claimed the homeowner’s exemption, an exemption claimed by individuals who use the property as their primary residence. Mr. Webster testified that he never saw STUDENT at [address redacted] until August 1997.
Mr. Webster stated that he believed that MOTHER resides at the [address redacted] address based on the records of property ownership, the homeowner’s exemption, and the behavior of MOTHER at both residences. Mr. Webster testified that he observed MOTHER drive into the garage, close the garage door at [address redacted], and not leave. However, Mr. Webster also stated that he did not observe the house later than 8:00 p.m.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Is STUDENT a resident of Oakland Unified School District thereby requiring the District to provide educational services to STUDENT?
Education Code § 48200 provides that a child shall attend school in the district “in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located.” A child’s residency is based upon “the residence of the parent with whom the child maintains his or her place of abode.” Welf. & Inst. Code § 17.1(a). Further guidance on the definition of residence may be found in Government Code § 244, which states:
In determining the place of residence the following rules shall be observed:
(a) It is the place where one remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. (b) There can only be one residence.
(c) A residence cannot be lost until another is gained.
(d) The residence of the parent with whom an unmarried minor child maintains his or her place of abode is the residence of such unmarried minor child. (e) The residence of an unmarried minor who has a parent living cannot be changed by his or her own act. (f) The residence can be changed only by the union of act and intent. (g) A married person shall have the right to retain his or her legal residence in the State of California notwithstanding the legal residence or domicile of his or her spouse.
In the present case, MOTHER testified that she has lived in Oakland since September 1996 and intends on remaining there. However, for much of the time that MOTHER testified she lived in Oakland, she did not have a phone or a bank account, and had not changed her voter registration. In other words, MOTHER did not make many of the changes individuals make with a change of residence until pressured to do so by the District. MOTHER also acknowledged that she had not yet changed address with the Department of Motor Vehicles.
Additional evidence was presented that raises doubts about where STUDENT was living and whether MOTHER has, in fact, established a residence in Oakland with the intent to stay there. The unrefuted testimony of Ms. Wagner establishes that the only individual who brought STUDENT to school was his father. Additionally, MOTHER testified that she returned to the house in Pleasant Hill on most weekends during the 1996-97 school year and that STUDENT spent most of the summer at the Pleasant Hill house.
Government Code § 244(a) provides that an individual’s residence is that place where he or she remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. The testimony of MOTHER establishes that her residence was in Pleasant Hill because she intended to return there during the summer when school was not in session. Furthermore, STUDENT spent most of his time when school was not in session, both on weekends and during the summer, in Pleasant Hill. The evidence establishes that MOTHER may have rented an apartment in Oakland for work purposes and for her son to attend school in Oakland, but she has consistently returned to Pleasant Hill “in seasons of repose” for purposes of § 244.
It is also important that § 244 requires a combination of both the intent to reside in a place and the act of actually residing there. As already stated, while MOTHER stated that she lived in Oakland and intended on remaining there, many of the things that individuals do to establish residency were not done by MOTHER until she was pressured to do so by the District. While MOTHER now has documentation in the form of a phone bill, voter registration, and a bank account to demonstrate that she rents an apartment at [address redacted], these documents are not accompanied by significant evidence of both an intent to reside there and the actual act of residing there. There was no corroborating testimony from any witness other than MOTHER regarding her living arrangements. Furthermore, MOTHER stated that while she lived in Oakland during the week, she returned to Pleasant Hill most weekends and also during summer when school was not in session.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that he is a resident of the Oakland Unified School District. Although there is some evidence that MOTHER spends some time in Oakland, MOTHER’s own testimony and actions establish that her residence remains in Pleasant Hill.(Footnote 5)
(2) If yes, must Oakland Unified School District convene an IEP meeting to develop a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
Based on the finding in Issue #1, the Hearing Officer does not reach issue #2.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: October 9, 1997 _______________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.Prior to enrolling in the District, STUDENT attended school in Vallejo. 2.MOTHER owns a home with her husband at MOTHER’S ADDRESS in Pleasant Hill, a community in Contra Costa County. 3.Petitioner also submitted additional documentary evidence to demonstrate MOTHER’s residence at MOTHER’S ADDRESS. These documents include: a rental agreement dated December 16, 1996; receipts for rent paid from January through September 1997; a change of voter registration completed on August 21, 1997; a phone bill dated August 22, 1997; and a bank statement from Bank of America in Oakland. The bank account was not opened until August 1997. (Testimony of MOTHER) 4.Pleasant Hill is not within the District’s boundaries.
5. The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner is not without other options. Education Code § 48204 allows children to attend a school district in which one of his parents works. Considering that MOTHER works for the District, an interdistrict transfer could be a means to allow STUDENT to continue attending school in the District.
