California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 24, 2003

Chula Vista Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1375-03, SN-1375-03 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz

Chula Vista Elementary wrongly found student ineligible in 2001; must reimburse $3,920 in tuition and provide tutoring and counseling.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 6 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that a related district-filed case to assess without consent (SN03-01376) was withdrawn after the parents consented to assessment in February 2003. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.

Summary

Chula Vista Elementary School District filed for hearing. It asked the Hearing Officer to confirm three things: that it correctly found an 11-year-old boy with ADHD ineligible for special education in January 2001, that it properly reassessed him in 2003, and that its June 2003 IEP offered a FAPE. That IEP found him eligible under other health impairment and offered a fifth-grade special day class with occupational therapy. The family accepted the placement. It argued that the IEP also needed speech-language services, counseling and adapted physical education, and it asked for private school tuition.

Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz found that the 2000–2001 and 2003 assessments were appropriate and that the district met its child-find duties. However, she held that the January 2001 IEP team was wrong to find the student ineligible. His IQ scores, adaptive behavior scores, failing grades and first-grade retention showed that he qualified under both mental retardation and other health impairment, and classroom modifications were not working. She gave little weight to the district coordinator's opinion because the coordinator never met the student.

For 2003–2004, the IEP needed small-group behavioral counseling and a new speech-language assessment focused on receptive language. Adapted PE was not needed. Tuition for the 2001–2002 Montessori school was denied because there was no proof he benefited there. Balboa City School tuition was reimbursed but cut to four months ($3,920) because the parent delayed the reassessment. The district must also provide one-on-one tutoring by a credentialed teacher for the 2003–2004 school year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed test scores and a classroom teacher's first-hand account against a district witness who never met the student. It treated grade retention as relevant to whether a disability affects educational performance. It also cut tuition reimbursement where a parent's delay in consenting to assessment held up the district's offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District properly assess STUDENT in November 2000 and January 2001?

    The 2000-2001 assessments met federal and state standards in all significant respects. The student did not show the tests were unreliable, and his late request to be reimbursed for a private evaluation was denied.

  2. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 2. Should STUDENT have been found eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability, mental retardation, or other health impairment at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting?

    The student met the criteria for both mental retardation and other health impairment (ADHD) and needed special education, so the IEP team was wrong to find him ineligible. The Hearing Officer did not decide specific learning disability because the parties agreed it did not apply.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Did the District properly reassess STUDENT in the spring of 2003?

    The 2003 assessments were appropriate. No language sample was needed because no one claimed a speech-language eligibility, and adapted PE was not an area of suspected disability that required assessment.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and extended 2003 school year as described in the June 2, 2003 IEP, when it failed to include designated instruction and services in the areas of speech and language, behavioral counseling and adapted physical education?

    Leaving out small-group behavioral counseling denied FAPE, and the district did not prove the student had no speech-language need, so a new assessment was required. Adapted PE and a behavior support plan were not needed. With these amendments, the IEP offered FAPE.

  5. Issue 5. If the District incorrectly found STUDENT ineligible for special education in January 2001, is the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT's parents for tuition expenses incurred at the nonpublic schools STUDENT attended during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, or to provide any other remedy?

    Montessori tuition for 2001-2002 was denied because there was no proof of benefit. Balboa City School tuition was reimbursed but cut to four months ($3,920) because of the parent's delay in consenting to and allowing the reassessment. The student was awarded one-on-one tutoring as compensatory education.

  6. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 6. Did the District fulfill its search and serve obligations with regard to STUDENT from June 23, 2000 to the present?

    The district met its child-find duties by sending notices to nonpublic school administrators, publishing annual notices, and assessing the student promptly when asked. The student offered no contrary evidence.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, reconvene the IEP team to amend the 2003-2004 IEP, schedule the speech-language assessment, and decide the areas of need and the nature, extent and schedule of one-on-one tutoring in consultation with the parents.
  • Order to provide or change services. Amend the 2003-2004 IEP to include behavioral counseling in a small-group setting by a qualified counselor, with frequency and duration set by the IEP team. Provide this counseling within 15 calendar days after the IEP meeting.
  • Amend the 2003-2004 IEP to include the district's transition plan (District Exhibit 43), with updated dates.
  • Order to assess. Complete a thorough speech-language assessment by a qualified assessor, focused on receptive language, with the report given to the family within 30 calendar days of the decision. The parents must make the student reasonably available. The IEP team must reconvene within 20 calendar days after the report to consider the results.
  • Compensatory education. One-on-one tutoring by a credentialed teacher for the 2003-2004 school year, starting within 15 calendar days after the IEP meeting. The IEP team may extend it beyond one year as needed. No number of hours was specified.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse the parents $3,920 for Balboa City School tuition ($980 per month for October 2002 through January 2003).

Total: $3,920 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Adams v. Oregon; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16

People named in the decision

  • Susana Waisman, Director of pupil personnel services and special education, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Debora Rocha Munoz, Speech, language and hearing specialist; 2003 speech-language assessor, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Dr. Pam (Pamela) Espinoza, School psychologist and coordinator of special education; district witness, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Heather Wolff, School psychologist; conducted 2000-2001 psychoeducational assessment, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Marcia Cockrell, School psychologist; conducted 2003 psychoeducational assessment, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Linda Dickerson, First grade teacher; witness for Student, Chula Vista Christian School (private school)
  • Patricia Wagner, Second grade teacher; witness for Student, Chula Vista Christian School (private school)
  • Dr. Karen Zappone, Independent evaluator (private evaluation, October 2002), Private
  • Dr. Kathleen Edwards, Educational advocate for Student, Non-attorney advocate
  • Michael Cochrane, Attorney for Student
  • Deborah R. G. Cesario, Attorney for District, Lozano Smith
  • Balboa City School, Certified nonpublic special education school (unilateral placement), Nonpublic school
  • College Center Montessori, Private school attended in 2001-2002, Private school
  • American Center for Learning, Private tutoring provider, Private provider
  • Southwestern Christian School, Private kindergarten attended, Private school

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Petitioner Chula Vista Elementary School District (Petitioner or District) was represented at the hearing by Deborah R. G. Cesario of the law offices of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District was Susana Waisman, director of pupi This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Chula Vista, California, on August 14-15, and 19-20, 2003. l personnel services and special education. Respondent STUDENT (Respondent or STUDENT) was represented on the first day of hearing by educational advocate Dr. Kathleen Edwards. After she withdrew, STUDENT was represented for the remainder of the hearing by attorney Michael Cochrane. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER, and, with the exception of August 15, 2003, his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Debora Rocha Munoz, speech, language and hearing specialist for the District; and Dr. Pam Espinoza, school psychologist and coordinator of special education for the District. Respondent called the following witnesses: his mother; Linda Dickerson, STUDENT’s first grade teacher at the Chula Vista Christian School, a nonpublic school; and Patricia Wagner, STUDENT’s second grade teacher at the Chula Vista Christian School.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the parties’ written closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

District’s motion to disallow representation by STUDENT’s attorney.

On the first day of hearing, STUDENT was represented by his educational advocate, Dr. Kathleen Edwards. At the close of the day, Dr. Edwards stated that the issues for hearing were more complex than she had anticipated and reported that STUDENT would be represented by attorney Michael Cochrane starting the next day. On the following morning, Mr. Cochrane appeared on STUDENT’s behalf and stated that he was ready to proceed. The District did not oppose the attorney’s presence but objected to Mr. Cochrane acting as STUDENT’s legal counsel because he had failed to provide ten days notice of his intent to represent STUDENT. The District refused the Hearing Officer’s offer of a continuance. See, Cal. Education Code § 56507(a). Consequently, the Hearing Officer permitted Mr. Cochrane to substitute for Dr. Edwards to represent STUDENT, and the matter proceeded without interruption.

District’s motion to disregard portions of Patricia Wagner’s testimony.

The District asserts in its closing brief that the Hearing Officer should disregard portions of the testimony of Patricia Wagner, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher at his nonpublic school. In particular, the District asks that Ms. Wagner’s description of STUDENT’s attentional problems as manifested in her classroom should not be considered because it was not provided to the January 2001 individualized education program (IEP) team. The District argues that its determination that STUDENT was ineligible for special education under the category of other health impairment should not be judged by information it did not have at the time the decision was made.

The Hearing Officer will consider the entirety of Ms. Wagner’s testimony for several reasons. First, the Hearing Officer construes Ms. Wagner’s testimony at hearing quite differently. While Ms. Wagner acknowledged that she did not offer her opinion that STUDENT needed special education, Ms. Wagner testified only that she could not recall whether she told the team about STUDENT’s behaviors. However, the District failed to call a single District staff member who was present at the meeting. Consequently, the District’s argument that Ms. Wagner did not reveal STUDENT’s classroom behaviors is speculative. Notably, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wagner’s testimony was merely supplemental to information she had clearly already provided. The IEP team had Ms. Wagner’s progress report indicating STUDENT’s poor and failing grades, his inability to participate in the regular education curriculum, and his poor work habits (District Exh. 9), Ms. Wagner’s rating of STUDENT’s adaptive functioning in various domains where she scored him with significant deficits (District Exh. 15; Respondent Exh. G), and the report of her interview with school psychologist Heather Wolff where Ms. Wagner described STUDENT’s short attention span. (District Exh. 15.)

Next, there was no evidence in support of the District’s contention that the District staff had a “different picture” of STUDENT than what Ms. Wagner’s testimony portrayed. To the contrary, the parties stipulated that the District knew at the time of the IEP meeting that STUDENT was diagnosed as a child with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and, accordingly, it was on alert that STUDENT had attentional problems. Moreover, the resource specialist teacher who administered the achievement tests, reported that oral directions had to be repeated several times and that STUDENT “needed to be kept on track.” Ms. Wolff observed STUDENT in his classroom and reported that he was unable to follow directions presented to the entire class, and continued to misunderstand the assignment even after the teacher repeated the directions to him one-on-one. (District Exh. 15.) Other information in the District’s possession at the time, included reports from STUDENT’s private tutors, that corroborated STUDENT’s attention problems. (District Exh. 9.)

To the extent the District argues that consideration of Ms. Wagner’s testimony was unfair, the Hearing Officer disagrees. Under both federal and State special education law, to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education, the District had the duty to conduct both complete assessments and a collaborative IEP meeting. These obligations included obtaining and giving careful consideration to teacher observations and ensuring meaningful participation by those in attendance with knowledge of the pupil. See, Cal. Education Code §§ 56340; 56341(6); 20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(b)(4)(A); 1414(c)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.533; 34 C.F.R. § 300.535(a)(1) and (2); see, for example, W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No.23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). Ms. Wagner attended the IEP meeting and, as STUDENT’s teacher for five months, was the person who possessed the best first-hand knowledge of STUDENT’s attentional problems in the classroom. (District Exh. 2.) There was no indication that Ms. Wagner deliberately withheld information from the IEP team. If, as the District asserts, Ms. Wagner did not volunteer her first-hand observations of STUDENT, then the District violated its burden of inquiry. (Footnote 1a) The District cannot neglect its duty to obtain Ms. Wagner’s input in 2001 only to later claim it was unfairly disadvantaged by consideration of her testimony. (Footnote 2b)

ISSUES

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District properly assess STUDENT in November 2000 and January 2001?

ISSUE NO. 2: Should STUDENT have been found eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability, mental retardation, or other health impairment at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting?

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District properly reassess STUDENT in the spring of 2003?

ISSUE NO. 4: Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and extended 2003 school year as described in the individualized education program (IEP) dated June 2, 2003, when it failed to include designated instruction and services in the areas of speech and language, behavioral counseling and adapted physical education?

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District incorrectly found STUDENT ineligible for special education in January 2001, is the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for tuition expenses incurred at the nonpublic schools STUDENT attended during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, or to provide any other remedy?

ISSUE NO. 6: Did the District fulfill its search and serve obligations with regard to STUDENT from June 23, 2000 to the present? (Footnote 1)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District’s contentions are as follows: The District first learned about STUDENT, who had been attending nonpublic schools, when it received a request from STUDENT’s parents to evaluate their son. The District conducted a timely and thorough assessment. It convened an IEP meeting in January 2001, and the team appropriately found that STUDENT was ineligible for special education. STUDENT returned to his nonpublic schools and did not communicate with the District again until October 2002. The District appropriately reassessed STUDENT and this time found him eligible for special education under the category of other health impairment (OHI). The District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year in the program described in its June 2, 2003 IEP. STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the nonpublic schools he attended in 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, or any other remedy, because the District correctly found STUDENT ineligible for special education in 2001, appropriately reassessed STUDENT in 2003, and offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year after its timely determination that STUDENT was eligible for special education. At all times, from June 23, 2000 through the present, the District met its child-find obligations to STUDENT.

Respondent asserted that at the January 2001 IEP meeting, the District should have found STUDENT eligible for special education and related services, either as a child with mental retardation or under the category of other health impairment. STUDENT’s inattentiveness, and cognitive and adaptive functioning deficits, as measured by the District’s assessments, taken together with his failing school performance, rendered him eligible for special education. STUDENT’s parents claim they are entitled to reimbursement for tuition they paid for the nonpublic schools he attended in the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years because the District offered only a general education placement when STUDENT needed a special education program, or other remedies. The District’s reassessment of STUDENT in 2003, was inappropriate. The placement offered by the District was not a FAPE because, although STUDENT agreed with the special day class placement, the District did not offer goals and objectives or related services in three areas of need, namely, behavioral counseling, and speech and language.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eleven-year-old boy who was diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD) when he was in preschool during the 1995-1996 school year. STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the District with his parents and younger brother. STUDENT has attended various nonpublic schools from preschool to the present. In January 2001, the District assessed STUDENT, but the individualized education program (IEP) team found him ineligible for special education and related services. The District first found STUDENT eligible for special education and related services in June 2003 under the category of other health impairment (OHI) and has offered STUDENT a District placement for the upcoming 2003-2004 school year in a fifth grade special day class. Most recently, STUDENT completed the fourth grade at the Balboa City School, a nonpublic special education school.

STUDENT had a history of complications at birth. He crawled and walked within normal developmental limits but his language acquisition was delayed. STUDENT spoke a few words when he was eighteen-months-old, used single words at age three, and put words together to form sentences when he turned four. Starting with preschool, when STUDENT was two-and-one-half years old, he began attending nonpublic schools. In his kindergarten year in the 1997-1998 school year at Southwestern Christian School, his teacher reported that STUDENT had difficulty looking at the board, staying on task, completing assignments, and participating in group activities. In 1998, at the start of the first grade, STUDENT’s parents transferred him to Chula Vista Christian School where the curriculum was “less difficult.” (MOTHER’s testimony.) Linda Dickerson, STUDENT’s first grade teacher, reiterated the kindergarten teacher’s concerns and suggested private tutoring which STUDENT’s parents provided at the American Center for Learning (Center) starting in September 1999.

STUDENT had to repeat the first grade (1999-2000). A January 2000 progress report from the Center indicated that STUDENT needed guidance to stay on task and he performed more successfully with one-on-one assistance. The Center recommended a full battery of tests to determine if there were any “learning disabilities” accounting for STUDENT’s school difficulties. (District Exh. 9.)

In the second grade (2000-2001 school year), STUDENT struggled with the regular education curriculum. Either MOTHER, or STUDENT’s grandmother, came to school daily and provided STUDENT with one-on-one help with class assignments in a separate room apart from his classmates. The principal at the nonpublic school assumed the private tutoring duties from the Center. The principal reported that STUDENT had difficulty focusing and frequently needed redirection. Patricia Wagner, STUDENT’s second grade teacher, testified that STUDENT learned more slowly than his second grade classmates. Ms. Wagner noted on his report card that STUDENT was unable to progress in the regular second grade curriculum. STUDENT’s grades were not based upon the second-grade general curriculum but rather reflected his own individual progress on modified work assignments. For the first quarter of the second grade, STUDENT received C- grades in Bible, phonics/reading, English, spelling, penmanship, mathematics, F grades in health/science and social studies, and B+ in physical education and A in fine arts. STUDENT was easily distracted, sat or scribbled, looked off into space, and moved a lot. STUDENT’s teacher recommended testing. (District Exh. 9.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT floundered in the second grade and continued to fall behind.

In November 2000, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District conduct an assessment of STUDENT. (District Exh. 45.) MOTHER signed the District’s assessment plan and the District tested STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, social/emotional adaptive behavior, and health. (District Exh. 28.)

School psychologist Heather Wolff performed the psychoeducational assessment for the District. In her report, she indicated that on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), STUDENT received a full scale intelligence quotient (IQ) score of 64, and on the Leiter International Performance Scale-Revised (Leiter-R), which assessed nonverbal intelligence, STUDENT’s full scale IQ score was 74. The adaptive behavior scales showed significant deficits in social and practical living skills. Observing STUDENT in his classroom, Ms. Wolff reported that STUDENT copied a list of words several times but could not follow the repeated instructions or carry out the assignment. (District Exhs. 15, 28.) A District resource specialist teacher administered the Woodcock-Johnson achievement test. STUDENT scored in the third percentile in Broad Reading, in the seventh percentile in Basic Reading, in the first percentile in Broad Math, and in the sixth percentile in Broad Written Language. The assessor noted that STUDENT required repeated instructions and extended work time. (District Exh. 13.)

At the January 20, 2001 individualized education plan (IEP) meeting, MOTHER expressed her concerns that STUDENT might need to repeat the second grade because the curriculum was too demanding, and STUDENT had difficulty remembering. The parties stipulated that MOTHER told the IEP team that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD. According to the IEP report, Ms. Wolff reviewed her assessment results, recited the eligibility criteria of a specific learning disability (SLD) and mental retardation, and related her opinion that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was ineligible for special education and offered STUDENT a regular education placement. STUDENT’s parents checked the box indicating their agreement. (District Exh. 2.) The District offered to meet with the staff at STUDENT’s nonpublic school to develop support strategies. The District met with the PARENTS again at the end of January 2001 and discussed the need for additional assessments. (District Exh. 3.) STUDENT’s parents requested further assessments in the area of speech and language in February 2001 and a new assessment plan was signed. (District Exh. 30.) Soon thereafter STUDENT’s parents revoked their consent and no additional assessments were conducted at that time. (District Exh. 46.)

STUDENT remained at the Chula Vista Christian School. At the end of the school year, even though his teacher expressed concern about his abilities, STUDENT was promoted to the third grade because of his age. However, for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s parents transferred him to another nonpublic school (NPS) that had more one-on-one help and less rigorous curriculum demands; STUDENT attended the College Center Montessori school for the third grade. STUDENT was expelled from that school at the start of the next school year in September 2002 after he threatened to shoot a classmate who had been teasing and bullying him. MOTHER home schooled STUDENT for six weeks. During that time, she took STUDENT to his psychiatrist for a reevaluation. The psychiatrist prescribed a new medication, referred STUDENT’s parents to an educational advocate and recommended that an independent educational assessment be performed.

In October 2002, STUDENT’s parents enrolled STUDENT in the Balboa City School, which is a certified NPS for children with disabilities, for the remainder of the fourth grade. On October 7, 2002, Respondent’s educational advocate, Dr. Kathleen Edwards, asked the IEP team to reconvene in order to consider the results of several independent educational evaluations that had been conducted and to reconsider its eligibility and placement decisions. (District Exh. 35.) STUDENT was independently evaluated by Dr. Karen Zappone on October 18, 2002 when he was nearly eleven years old. Dr. Zappone noted that on measures of cognitive skills, STUDENT performed better than he had on the District’s evaluation, but concluded that his intellectual functioning skills remained below or well below average. On achievement tests, STUDENT performed relatively well on a test of general information but he scored one year below his chronological age. STUDENT received middle of first grade level scores on both reading recognition and reading comprehension. Word attack skills, spelling and written arithmetic also placed him at the first grade level. Dr. Zappone observed that STUDENT needed to have items repeated and that he tended to misunderstand directions. The evaluator noted planning problems and impulsivity consistent with difficulties with sustained attention. (Respondent Exh. A.)

Dr. Edwards notified the District, on October 24, 2002, that STUDENT had been unilaterally placed by his parents at a “Special Education School” and that STUDENT’s parents would file for a due process hearing to seek “reimbursement and placement.” (District Exh. 37.) In November 2001, the District offered to conduct a complete reassessment of STUDENT. (District Exhs. 38 and 39.) When STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the evaluations, the District filed for a due process hearing (SN03-01376). After STUDENT’s parents ultimately provided their consent in early February 2003 (District Exh. 33), the District withdrew the matter.

In April and May 2003, the District performed an occupational therapy evaluation, a speech, language and hearing assessment, and a psychoeducational evaluation. The occupational therapist concluded that STUDENT had delays in visual motor integration and fine motor skills. STUDENT’s rate of writing was poor for his age and grade, and his writing quality was below average. Occupational therapy was recommended. (District Exh. 24.) The speech and language assessment evaluated STUDENT’s functioning level in the areas of language, auditory processing and central auditory processing skills. The speech therapist reported no difficulties and recommended that STUDENT not receive speech and language therapy.

The psychoeducational evaluation was conducted during April and May 2003. A battery of standardized tests was administered to assess STUDENT in the areas of communication development, emotional status and psychological adjustment, intellectual functioning and adaptive behavior, academic achievement, psychomotor and sensory development, and visual and auditory processing. In addition, school and health records were reviewed and interviews with STUDENT’s parents and teachers were conducted. Ms. Marcia Cockrell, a school psychologist for the District, observed STUDENT in his school environment. The resource specialist teacher administered an achievement test.

As a result of these assessments, Ms. Cockrell found that STUDENT performed in the borderline range of cognitive ability and exhibited deficits in adaptive functioning behaviors. STUDENT received a full scale IQ score of 70 on the WISC-III, placing him within the intellectually deficient range of cognitive ability. On a nonverbal IQ test (Universal Nonverbal Intelligent Test), STUDENT received a full scale score of 76. Significant deficits were noted in the area of cognitive attention. Ms. Cockrell also reported that STUDENT’s academic achievement, visual-perceptual, sensorimotor, and fine motor skills were significantly delayed. STUDENT achieved significantly below grade level in reading, math and written language. Ms. Cockrell concluded that “STUDENT demonstrate[d] limited ability in the area of attention, due to a chronic health impairment (ADHD) which adversely impact[ed] his educational performance.” (District Exh. 26, pg. 8.)

The IEP team met on June 2, 2003 to discuss the assessment results. This time the IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services under the category of OHI. (District Exh. 4.) The team proposed placement in a special day class for non-severely handicapped students at STUDENT’s neighborhood school and offered to provide occupational therapy. Goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of written language, phonetic development, math calculation, reading comprehension, visual motor integration, and attention/focus. The IEP meeting notes described STUDENT’s good command of language and appropriate use of syntax and morphology. It was also noted that STUDENT had age appropriate ambulation, ball handling, and athletic skills. The IEP team concluded that a behavior intervention plan was not required. STUDENT’s parents did not sign the IEP or otherwise indicate that they agreed with the placement.

Contending that its current placement offer constituted a FAPE and that it had acted appropriately in first finding STUDENT eligible for special education in June 2003 rather than in January 2001, the District sought this due process hearing. On August 14, 2003, on the first day of hearing, Respondent indicated that he agreed with the District’s placement offer, except insofar as it failed to provide certain designated instruction and services.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District properly assess STUDENT in November 2000 and January 2001?

To determine whether a child is a child with a disability and to determine the educational needs of such a child, a full and individual assessment must be conducted. 34 C.F.R. § 300.531; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A)(B); Cal. Education Code § 56320(f). Initial assessments must be conducted by individuals who are both “knowledgeable of the student’s disability” and “competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.” Cal. Education Code §§ 56320(g), 56322; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(B)(ii). Tests and assessment materials must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; must be selected and administered so as not be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication unless this is clearly not feasible; and must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of such tests. 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Education Code § 56320(a), (b). No single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Education Code § 56320(e). A psychological assessment must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Education Code § 56324. A student must be assessed in all areas of disability. Cal. Education Code § 56320(f).

After his parents’ request, STUDENT was assessed by the District in November 2000 and January 2001. The assessment reports were presented through the testimony of Dr. Pamela Espinoza, special education coordinator for the District. (Footnote 2) Respondent did not dispute either that the tests lacked the requisite validity or otherwise failed to comport with the statutory requirements, with one limited exception. Respondent asserted that since Dr. Espinoza did not personally perform or observe the assessment, she had no basis for her opinion whether the tests were administered in conformance with the test instructions as required. Cal. Education Code § 56320(b)(3). Dr. Espinoza testified that because of Ms. Wolff’s extensive experience and training and from her own review of the test results, she assumed the tests’ protocols had been followed.

The Hearing Officer is troubled by the lack of direct evidence by the author of the report and believes that Ms. Wolff would have shed light on the question whether the tests were administered according to the protocols. (Footnote 3) Respondent neither presented any evidence nor identified any specific problems that called into doubt the reliability or validity of the test results. (Footnote 4) Instead, Respondent quarreled with the District’s interpretation of the test scores and the finding by the IEP team that STUDENT was ineligible for special education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessments were appropriate and comported with all federal and State special education standards in all significant respects. See, Cal. Education Code §§ 56320, 56322, and 56324. (Footnote 5) The Hearing Officer will next determine whether the finding of ineligibility, based upon these assessments, was correct.

ISSUE NO. 2: Should STUDENT have been found eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability, mental retardation, or other health impairment at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting?

To be eligible for special education, a student must have a disability as defined by federal law and, because of the disability requires instruction, services or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Education Code § 56026(a) and (b).

Here, when the IEP team met in January 2001 after a review of the assessments, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was ineligible for special education. Respondent asserted that STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education under the categories of mental retardation and OHI. The IEP meeting notes reflected that the team considered whether STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation and the Hearing Officer will address that eligibility category. (Footnote 6)

However, the IEP meeting notes did not reflect whether the IEP team considered the OHI category. The parties generally agree that STUDENT is a child who was diagnosed with ADHD and that it is chronic. Although Ms. Wolff briefly noted on her report that “attention” was looked at because of concerns expressed by MOTHER (District Exh. 15, pg. 7), Ms. Wolff’s writtenopinion omitted any mention of OHI. Dr. Espinoza was not present at the January 2001 IEP meeting and admitted under cross-examination that she did not discuss the meeting with anyone who was present. No District witness who was present at that IEP meeting testified. Both MOTHER and Ms. Wagner testified that they could not recall whether OHI was addressed. Nevertheless, because there is no dispute the IEP team knew that STUDENT had been diagnosed as a child with ADHD making OHI a potential eligibility category (see, Cal. Education Code § 56339(a)), and because Dr. Espinoza addressed this eligibility category at hearing, the Hearing Officer will also decide whether STUDENT was eligible for special education as a pupil with OHI.

The Hearing Officer will next consider whether STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education under the categories of mental retardation or OHI. Mental Retardation.

Under the IDEA, a child qualifies for special education if he is mentally retarded, and if, by reason of that disability, he needs special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i)(ii). State special education law defines a pupil as eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation when the “pupil has significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, which adversely affect a pupil’s educational performance.” C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3030(h); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(6).

(1) Was STUDENT’s intellectual functioning significantly below average?

The District, through Dr. Espinoza’s testimony, relied on the psychoeducational assessment report authored by Ms. Wolff in December 2000 and January 2001 in support of its contention that STUDENT was ineligible for special education under the category of mental retardation. Two tests were administered to measure STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. On the WISC-III, STUDENT received a verbal IQ score of 67, a performance IQ score of 65, and a full scale IQ score of 64. On the Leiter-R, STUDENT received an full scale IQ score of 74. (District Exh. 15.)

Based upon these test results, Ms. Wolff concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive ability fell within the “Intellectually Deficient range.” (District Exh. 15.) Dr. Espinoza conceded under cross-examination that these two tests which were administered to measure intellectual functioning have a high correlation between each other, and conceded further that both test results were consistent with a finding of “significantly below average cognitive ability.” Dr. Espinoza also agreed that several scores that STUDENT received on other tests, including those that measured STUDENT’s visual perception, memory, visual-motor skills, and communication, were commensurate with his low IQ scores. On the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TVPS-R) that measured visual perception, STUDENT’s scores fell in the 1st percentile. The assessor noted that STUDENT’s scores on the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R) indicated relative strength in the area of auditory perception with a score in the 26th percentile. According to the report, STUDENT did better remembering details of stories (standard score of 10), but had particular difficulty remembering abstract designs (standard score of 3). At the age of nine-years, one-month when the test battery was administered, STUDENT received scores that were below average and equivalent to a five-year, two-month-old child on the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) that measured eye-hand coordination. On the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test that measured eye-hand coordination, the assessor reported that STUDENT’s scores were significantly below average and equivalent to a child of five-years, six-months to five-years, eleven-months old. STUDENT demonstrated difficulty spelling words phonetically, reading words, and performing single digit addition and subtraction on the Wide Range Achievement Test-R3 (WRAT-3).

Dr. Espinoza conceded that all these scores taken together suggested that STUDENT was a child with mild mental retardation. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s intellectual functioning was significantly below average.

(2) Did STUDENT exhibit deficits in adaptive behavior?

In order to measure STUDENT’s adaptive behavior, Ms. Wolff administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales -- Interview Edition Survey Form to STUDENT’s mother and second grade teacher. These surveys assessed STUDENT’s social and practical living skills. Scores on both Vineland scales indicated that STUDENT’s adaptive behavior was significantly below what would be expected for children his age. On the Vineland administered to MOTHER, STUDENT scored in the 1st percentile on the communication, daily living skills and socialization domains. The classroom edition of the Vineland rating scale administered to Ms. Wagner, rated STUDENT’s adaptive functioning with similar low scores. The actual questionnaire added age equivalent scores to the adaptive levels quoted above and reflected that at the chronological age of nine years, one month, STUDENT’s adaptive behaviors in the communication domain were: receptive communication, one year, nine months; expressive communication, four years, seven months; and written communication, five years, ten months. STUDENT’s adaptive behaviors in the daily living skills domain were: personal, five years, three months; domestic, two years, one month; community, four years, two months; interpersonal relationships two years, seven months; play and leisure time, two years, four months; and coping skills, four years, one month. (Respondent Exh. G.) Ms. Wagner testified that her responses reflected her first-hand observations and experience with STUDENT.

Ms. Wolff concluded in her report under each of these test results that “STUDENT’s adaptive behavior is significantly below what would be expected for a student his age.” (District Exh. 15; emphasis added.) Dr. Espinoza testified that the two Vineland test results were consistent with each other. She admitted under cross-examination that these adaptive behavior ratings were “very commensurate” with STUDENT’s IQ scores. Dr. Espinoza conceded that the full score communication domain scores were consistent with someone of significantly below average intelligence. However, the District pointed to the IEP meeting notes which reported that STUDENT could independently take care of some daily living skills, such as going to the restroom, making a sandwich, combing his hair, brushing his teeth and getting dressed, in support of its contention STUDENT had no adaptive functioning deficits. At nine years of age at the time of the testing, STUDENT’s highest score on the Vineland rating scales was equivalent only to a five-year-old and many of the ratings lagged seven years behind his chronological age. STUDENT’s ability to perform these isolated tasks did not diminish the significance of these very low scores. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that, based upon the weight of the evidence, STUDENT exhibited deficits in adaptive functioning.

Interpretation of test scores.

Despite STUDENT’s low intellectual functioning scores and adaptive functioning deficits, Dr. Espinoza testified that in her opinion, the decision to find him ineligible for special education as a child with mental retardation in 2001 was correct. According to Dr. Espinoza, both the Diagnostic Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) and an unnamed textbook on assessments by Dr. Sattler, advise that where as here, the student received a “scatter of scores” on the various IQ subtests, a “profile” of the child should be considered rather than the test scores alone in making the determination. (Footnote 7) Applying this approach, Dr. Espinoza concluded that STUDENT did not “present” as a child with mental retardation. Respondent asks the Hearing Officer to reject this method of interpretation.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Espinoza’s method of interpreting STUDENT’s test scores and the opinion she offered applying this approach is unconvincing for several reasons. First, while the DSM-IV may provide supplemental information, it is not correlated to the IDEA. Accordingly, while the Hearing Officer may consider the DSM-IV, it is not determinative of eligibility criteria; the Hearing Officer must apply the federal and State special education law criteria as written. Thus, for example, in Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals relied solely on the Washington state statutory criteria and determined that the student was eligible for special education as a child with mild mental retardation. Second, the District did not provide the Hearing Officer with any reference material or make the unnamed Sattler text part of the record. Absent the text and considering that Respondent had no opportunity to effectively cross-examine Dr. Espinoza regarding its contents, the Hearing Officer is unable to assign it any evidentiary value.

Finally, even if it was legitimate to look beyond the specific test scores, Dr. Espinoza lacked the necessary foundation to provide a persuasive opinion concerning STUDENT’s learning ability. Dr. Espinoza did not assess STUDENT in 2001, did not meet or observe him in 2001, did not supervise Ms. Wolff, did not attend the IEP meeting where STUDENT’s eligibility was discussed, did not communicate with any District staff who had attended the IEP meeting, and did not talk to STUDENT’s teachers or parents in 2001. In reaching her conclusion that STUDENT did not carry the “flat profile” consistent with a mentally retarded child, Dr. Espinoza relied on Ms. Wolff’s written report. Contained within the report were remarks by STUDENT’s parents and the resource specialist teacher who conducted the achievement tests suggesting that STUDENT was friendly and affectionate. (District Exh. 15.) The Hearing Officer finds that the argument that STUDENT was friendly and affectionate did not address STUDENT’s ability to learn in school or nullify the IQ test scores.

In contrast, based upon her five months of experience as STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Wagner delivered a credible portrayal of STUDENT’s performance in the classroom and shed much more light on STUDENT’s ability to learn. STUDENT could not work independently, required one-on-one attention, worked more slowly than her other students, required simplification of all mathematics problems, needed close monitoring, and was emotionally immature. Ms. Wagner testified that it was clear to her that STUDENT “did not learn like other children,” that he had “very low academic skills” and that STUDENT was “far below the mark.” STUDENT did poorly in spelling and might know a word one day, but then would forget it the next. He reversed letters and numbers. He was a very slow reader and stumbled over words. STUDENT was not able to manage the regular education second-grade curriculum. In addition, STUDENT acted younger than the other children. He brought small action figures from home and made up incredible stories. This method of play was at a lower level than STUDENT’s other classmates. According to Ms. Wagner, STUDENT “did not fit in.” He “hung out” with kindergarteners instead of his second-grade classmates at recess. Ms. Wagner reported to Ms. Wolff that STUDENT had difficulty making age-appropriate judgments in social situations. (District Exh. 15.) Because of Ms. Wagner’s teaching experience and first-hand familiarity with STUDENT’s classroom performance, the Hearing Officer accords her testimony great weight. (Footnote 8) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s learning ability as just described was consonant with his IQ test scores.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Espinoza’s approach and opinion unpersuasive. The DSM-IV is not correlated to the IDEA and the unnamed text had no evidentiary value. Even if the Hearing Officer accepted Dr. Espinoza’s premise, the Hearing Officer finds that the facts of STUDENT’s classroom behavior presented a more accurate measure of STUDENT’s learning ability than Dr. Espinoza’s selective reading of Ms. Wolff’s report. As the Hearing Officer found in Issue No. 1, the District’s assessment of STUDENT was valid and reliable. The Hearing Officer finds no justification to disregard STUDENT’s test scores in favor of Dr. Espinoza’s approach. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer adheres to the earlier findings that STUDENT’s intellectual functioning was significantly below average and that he exhibited deficits in adaptive behavior.

(3) Did these deficits adversely affect STUDENT’s educational performance?

A key dispute in this case was whether STUDENT’s intellectual functioning scores combined with his deficits in adaptive behaviors adversely affected his educational performance. The evidence plainly established that STUDENT had to repeat the first grade. STUDENT’s second grade teacher described STUDENT as a very slow learner. STUDENT was not able to function within the second grade curriculum even though he had already been retained in the first grade and was provided with significant one-on-one assistance by his mother and grandmother, private tutoring, and other accommodations including preferential seating and assignment modifications. MOTHER testified that if she had graded STUDENT like his second grade classmates, he would not have progressed to the next grade. The IEP team was fully aware that STUDENT’s first quarter grades in his second grade class were either well below average or failing. The progress report added that STUDENT was not able to perform the second grade work and was being graded, not compared to his classmates, but rather on his own progress. The District resource specialist who administered the academic achievement tests reported that STUDENT was a very slow reader and had no concept of money. The resource teacher who administered the test noted that STUDENT required repeated instructions and extended work time. (District Exh. 13.) Even with this added help, STUDENT scored very low on these measures. On the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, STUDENT received a broad reading score in the 3rd percentile, a basic reading score in the 7th percentile, a broad math score in the 1st percentile, and a broad written language score in the 6th percentile.

Nevertheless, Dr. Espinoza testified that in her opinion, STUDENT’s deficits did not adversely affect his educational performance. According to Dr. Espinoza, STUDENT was able to function successfully in the general education second grade curriculum because his achievement scores exhibited skills at the first grade level. The fact that STUDENT had repeated the first grade and was the chronological age of third graders was of no consequence in the framing of her opinion. The Hearing Officer simply cannot disregard an event of this significance. The Hearing Officer finds that the statute plainly requires consideration whether the student’s significantly below average general intellectual functioning and deficits in adaptive behavior were manifested during the developmental period. Implicit in this requirement is a consideration of the student’s chronological age. The Hearing Officer finds that omitting from the equation a comparison of STUDENT with children of his own age, ignored a crucial component of the statutory definition of mental retardation. There is no dispute that STUDENT lagged far behind children his own age.

The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Espinoza’s opinion implausible for additional reasons. As discussed above, Dr. Espinoza had no first-hand knowledge of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer further finds that if Dr. Espinoza’s opinion is carried to its logical conclusion, a student who had been retained one grade or more might never be eligible for special education because the “adverse affect on educational performance” prong could never be satisfied. Such a student would be “functional” in the grade level in which he had been placed no matter how many grades he repeated or how much older he was than his classmates. The Hearing Officer finds much more credible Ms. Wagner’s testimony based upon her first-hand experience with STUDENT that he was completely unable to participate in the regular second grade curriculum.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria as a child with mental retardation. The IEP team’s conclusion otherwise was incorrect.

Other Health Impairment.

A student with ADHD is eligible for special education if the student meets the eligibility criteria for other health impairment, emotional disturbance, or specific learning disabilities. Cal. Education Code § 56339(a). A child meets eligibility criteria for special education as OHI when the pupil has: limited strength, vitality, or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment, that is due to chronic or acute health problems, such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which adversely affects a child’s educational performance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a)(9); C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3030 (f); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); see also Letter to Cohen, 20 IDELR 73 (OSEP 1993). Respondent maintains that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of OHI.

(1) Did STUDENT’s ADHD result in limited strength, vitality, or alertness?

The parties stipulated that at the time of the IEP meeting in January 2001, the IEP team was aware that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD and that his condition is chronic. According to STUDENT’s nonpublic school teachers and the District staff who completed the assessments in 2001, STUDENT had a great deal of difficulty paying attention, following directions, and focusing on the assigned task. According to the records in possession of the District at the time of the IEP meeting, the resource specialist teacher who administered the achievement tests included in her report that oral directions had to be repeated several times and that STUDENT “needed to be kept on track.” The nonpublic school principal, who tutored STUDENT privately, told Ms. Wolff that STUDENT had difficulty focusing and frequently needed redirection. Ms. Wagner reported to Ms. Wolff that STUDENT had a short attention span. The tutors at the Center reported that STUDENT required guidance to stay on task and needed frequent redirection and one-on-one assistance to keep him focused. STUDENT’s second grade report card referred to difficulties with self-control and poor work habits, including a lack of thoroughness, failure to complete class work, and failure to follow directions. MOTHER completed a developmental summary and noted that STUDENT had been an “extremely active” toddler. She also reported to Ms. Wolff that presently STUDENT focuses on one topic and it is difficult “to transition him.” (District Exh. 15.) Ms. Wolff observed STUDENT in his classroom and saw that he was unable to follow the teacher’s directions presented to the class and remained unable to follow the directions, even though the teacher repeated the directions to STUDENT individually.

Ms. Wagner’s testimony corroborated these reports. She testified convincingly that STUDENT stared off into space, fidgeted, bothered any classmates seated next to him by disrupting them and taking their things, and expressed frustration. STUDENT was unable to stay on topic when he spoke and frequently switched to many other subjects quickly. He needed instructions repeated many times but even with extra help was unable to complete an assignment unless someone worked with him one-on-one and encouraged him to focus. Ms. Wagner testified that STUDENT could not sit still, nor, on many occasions, could she get his attention. During instructional time, Ms. Wagner testified that it was like “talking to a wall.”

In her written report, Ms. Wolff concluded that MOTHER expressed no significant concerns in the area of attention. Although it was reported that MOTHER rated STUDENT within the “at-risk” range for attentional problems, Ms. Wolff remarked this result was “not significant.” In the face of the overwhelming evidence of STUDENT’s inability to focus and the attentional problems just discussed, the Hearing Officer cannot find support for this conclusion in any other part of the report or the record. Absent a direct explanation of this discrepancy by Ms. Wolff, the Hearing Officer will give this comment very little weight.

The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the credible evidence supports the finding that STUDENT’s chronic ADHD met the first criterion of both the federal and State special education law because his ADHD rendered him distractable and caused him to exhibit “limited alertness” to his educational environment.

(2) Did STUDENT’s ADHD adversely affect his academic performance?

The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT’s attentional problems adversely affected his academic performance. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD is a cause of STUDENT’s school problems, including his inability to pay attention, follow directions, and focus on the task presented to him. In addition, there was no evidence or suggestion that STUDENT was uncooperative or that he willfully refused to perform as an alternative explanation for his poor school performance. In fact, the District’s assessors found him to be quite the opposite, describing him as a willing participant who tried his best.

The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT had been retained in the first grade and was not succeeding in the regular second grade curriculum even with one-on-one assistance, substantial modifications and private tutoring. Dr. Espinoza offered the same opinion regarding whether STUDENT’s focus and attention problems adversely affected his academic performance as she did under the mental retardation category, namely that he was a “functional” second-grader. The Hearing Officer has already discussed above why this opinion is not supported by the evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s chronic ADHD resulted in limited alertness that adversely affected his academic performance and that he was eligible for special education under this category.

Having found that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation and OHI, the Hearing Officer will next determine whether he required instruction, services, or both which could not be provided in the regular school program. See, Cal. Education Code § 56026(a) and (b).

Did STUDENT demonstrate a need for special education and related services?

A pupil who meets the eligibility criteria as a child with a disability must also demonstrate a need for special education and related services. The District argued that STUDENT did not require special education because his needs were met with interventions that could be implemented in the regular education program including modified assignments, redirection, preferential seating, extended time to complete assignments and one-on-one assistance. According to the District, STUDENT failed to present evidence to the IEP team that these strategies were not working. Respondent asserts that he needs special education and related services. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s argument has little merit.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence established that the District knew, at the time of the January 2001 IEP meeting, that modifications to the regular education curriculum were not effective. The IEP team was aware that STUDENT’s nonpublic school had implemented substantial modifications to the curriculum, graded him based upon his own individual progress rather than comparing him to other second-graders, and provided one-on-one tutoring and extra instruction. Notwithstanding these modifications, the District also knew that STUDENT was in danger of repeating the second grade because the curriculum was too difficult for him and that he was receiving poor and failing grades. (District Exhs. 2, 9, 10, 15.) The resource specialist teacher who assessed STUDENT’s achievement in January 2001, reported that despite receiving extra time and repeated directions, STUDENT scored poorly on the Woodcock-Johnson test of achievement. (District Exh. 13.) Moreover, not only did the IEP team know that STUDENT was unable to manage the regular second grade curriculum, the IEP team was aware of the highly significant fact that, even with similar modifications, STUDENT had to repeat the first grade.

Linda Dickerson, who was STUDENT’s teacher both times he was in the first grade, testified convincingly that STUDENT was unable to independently handle the first grade regular education curriculum. In Ms. Dickerson’s opinion, based on her twenty years of teaching experience, STUDENT was unable to manage without special education and services. (Footnote 9) Ms. Wagner’s consistent testimony that STUDENT needed much more than modifications of assignments or preferential seating was very persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that modifications alone did not result in academic progress.

The Hearing Officer further finds that placed in the regular education curriculum, STUDENT was out of pace with his classmates academically and socially. Whether this was the result of his OHI or mental retardation is of little consequence; each supports STUDENT’s need for special education. The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence demonstrated STUDENT’s need for special education.

Summary.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a child with both OHI and as a child with mental retardation. Accordingly, the IEP team was incorrect when it found STUDENT ineligible for special education and related services in January 2001. Notably, on a similar presentation, the IEP team in June 2003 found STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of OHI. Upon reassessment, STUDENT’s test scores and academic progress continued to show significant cognitive delays, first grade achievement levels and attentional difficulties. The only difference between the District’s determination in 2001 from its decision in 2003 was that STUDENT was about to enter the fifth grade. Special education law does not contemplate waiting for the child to fall hopelessly behind before special education and services are provided. See generally, 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); Cal. Education Code § 56000.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District properly reassess STUDENT in the spring of 2003?

Respondent’s challenge to the reassessments conducted by the District’s assessors in the spring of 2003 relates, for the most part, to the interpretation of the test results rather than to a lack of compliance with federal and State special education testing standards. With limited exception, Respondent did not dispute that the test results were valid or reliable or administered appropriately. As will be addressed in the section to follow (Issue No. 4), Respondent asserts that STUDENT should have been offered designated instruction and services as part of its placement offer for the 2003-2004 school year, based upon these assessment results. The Hearing Officer will turn first to Respondent’s claims regarding these assessments.

Respondent contends that the speech and language assessment omitted a required language sample. In order for a student to be eligible for special education as a child with a speech and language disorder, the assessment should include the results of a language sample or an explanation why such sample was not obtained. See, C.C.R. tit., 5, § 3030(c)(4)(B). The Hearing Officer finds that there never was an assertion STUDENT was eligible for special education as a child with a speech and language disorder. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds no merit to this claim. There being no other challenge to this assessment, the Hearing Officer finds, from the testimony at hearing and documents, that the speech and language assessment conducted by Debora Rocha Munoz in March, April, and May 2003, met all federal and State special education standards. (District Exh. 25.)

Respondent argues that an adapted physical education assessment should have been conducted. However, no persuasive evidence was presented that STUDENT required assessment in this area. Ms. Wagner testified that STUDENT was a fast runner and was able to play soccer with his classmates. As the District correctly noted, an assessment schedule was difficult to devise because it interfered with STUDENT’s basketball games. MOTHER testified that STUDENT played golf with his father and skied during family vacations. In addition, the occupational therapist observed STUDENT’s gross motor skills and found this was not an area of need. The Hearing Officer finds adapted physical education was not an area of need or suspected disability that required assessment.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2003 assessments were appropriate and comported with all federal and State special education standards in all significant respects. (See, Issue No. 1.)

ISSUE NO. 4: Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and extended 2003 school year as described in the individualized education program (IEP) dated June 2, 2003, when it failed to include designated instruction and services in the areas of speech and language, behavioral counseling and adapted physical education?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), all students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including language and speech remediation, adapted physical education, counseling and guidance. Cal. Education Code § 56363(b)(1)(5)(9); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability. Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988); Cal. Education Code § 56345(3).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. (Rowley, at 198-200.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir.1998). However, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board ofEducation, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).

Here, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires a placement in a fifth grade special day class for nonseverely handicapped students in his neighborhood school. In addition, the parties agree that STUDENT required occupational therapy services. However, according to Respondent, STUDENT has receptive language deficits for which he requires speech and language therapy, social and emotional needs for which he requires behavioral counseling, and difficulty with group games for which he requires adapted physical education. Accordingly, in order for the District to demonstrate that it offered STUDENT a FAPE as described in its June 2, 2003 IEP, the District must establish that STUDENT’s unique needs did not require these additional services.

Speech and Language Therapy.

The threshold issue in determining whether STUDENT needs speech and language therapy is identifying STUDENT’s unique speech and language needs. Ms. Munoz conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT in the spring of 2003 over the course of several sessions. (Footnote 10) (District Exh. 25.) Ms. Munoz reported that STUDENT showed a good command of language skills and spoke on various topics using age appropriate syntax and morphology as measured by the expressive subtests results of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-3 (CELF-3) (Formulated Sentences, 5th percentile; Recalling Sentences, 63rd percentile; Sentence Assembly 25th percentile); Expressive One Word-Picture Vocabulary Test (23rd percentile, age equivalent 9.3 years); Language Processing Test (total test 90th percentile); and Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills-Revised (sentence memory subtest, 30th percentile; and interpretation of directions subtest, 34th percentile; auditory processing skills, 50th percentile). Ms. Munoz concluded that STUDENT did not need speech and language therapy.

Respondent argued that because STUDENT received scores on all three receptive language subtests and one expressive language subtest (concepts and directions) on the CELF-3 which fell below the 7th percentile, STUDENT needed speech and language therapy. Respondent asserted these scores were low enough to qualify him as a student with a speech and language disorder. See, C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3030(c). Ms. Munoz testified that STUDENT was fatigued on the day the subtests were administered and, in her opinion, STUDENT’s stronger expressive language skills and other test scores better demonstrated STUDENT’s receptive language skills. For example, according to Ms. Munoz, STUDENT scored in the 23rd percentile on the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test that measured expressive vocabulary, a result which was inconsistent with a receptive language problem and an indication that STUDENT did not require remediation. The Language Processing Test measured STUDENT’s overall ability to use language and several of STUDENT’s scores indicated strong skills. Ms. Munoz also interviewed STUDENT’s parents and grandparents, all of whom identified language as one of STUDENT’s strengths.

The Hearing Officer finds that the argument that STUDENT is expressive does not effectively address whether he has problems with receptive language. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs is conflicting. Ms. Cockrell observed STUDENT in his classroom and reported that STUDENT frequently commented off topic, saying such things as “Flu bugs are very small ... Gravity is what holds us down... I used to hypnotize my mom.” STUDENT’s teachers also reported to Ms. Cockrell that STUDENT talked about events unrelated to the subject being discussed. By STUDENT’s own report he found language to be his “hardest class.” (District Exh. 26.) STUDENT’s teacher, who completed the Vineland scale, noted that STUDENT “often seems to be talking about a topic no one else is aware of -- monologue type conversations” and rated him low on the receptive language scales. (Respondent Exh. H.)

Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that STUDENT does not need speech and language therapy and, at the same time, there is evidence to suggest that he needs these services. The Hearing Officer finds that an additional and thorough speech and language assessment, with particular emphasis on his receptive language abilities, is necessary in order to accurately determine whether STUDENT needs speech and language services.

Behavioral Counseling or Behavior Support Plan (BSP).

Respondent asserted that STUDENT needed behavioral counseling services and a behavior support plan as part of his IEP. The District maintained that the IEP it offered for the 2003-2004 school year contains a behavioral goal sufficient to address STUDENT’s needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence established that STUDENT’s unique needs included problems with social skills and difficulty relating to his peers. As part of the assessments performed by the District in April and May 2003, STUDENT and STUDENT’s teacher completed the Behavior Assessment for Children (BASC). STUDENT’s teacher identified somatization, withdrawal, adaptability and social skills as areas that suggested a high level of maladjustment. Notably, by self report STUDENT identified social stress, anxiety and depression as significant problems. STUDENT’s teacher also completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Classroom Edition that measures a child’s performance of the daily activities necessary for taking care of oneself or getting along with others. In 2003, STUDENT’s teacher assessed STUDENT similarly to the ratings that were received in 2001, which the Hearing Officer has already found supported a finding that STUDENT had deficits in adaptive functional behaviors, including social skills. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had been expelled in September 2002, from the College Montessori School after he apparently threatened to shoot a classmate. Although few details surrounding this incident were presented at hearing, it was clear from the testimony that STUDENT responded inappropriately to bullying by his classmates. The documents and testimony also demonstrated that STUDENT was taunted by his peers throughout most of his school career.

Turning to the District’s arguments, the Hearing Officer finds that the behavioral component in the IEP may be sufficient to deal with STUDENT’s behavioral and attending needs in the classroom, but will not effectively address the problems discussed above. “Counseling and guidance services may be provided to an individual with exceptional needs who requires additional counseling and guidance services to supplement the regular guidance and counseling program...” 34 C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3051.9; Cal. Education Code § 56363(b)(9). In addition, the Hearing Officer observes that although not made part of its formal written offer, the District has offered to provide some social skills training to STUDENT as part of a transition plan when he starts to attend the District school. (District Exh. 43.) While the Hearing Officer agrees that the transition plan should be included in the IEP for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of social skills training within the transition period is too limiting. When STUDENT attends the District school, he will transfer from a private placement for similarly situated youngsters to a school that includes typically developing peers. It is unreasonable to so dramatically change his placement without additional behavioral supports.

Because on at least one occasion STUDENT was removed from school due to his verbally aggressive reaction to peer taunting, and because both STUDENT himself and his teacher rated him with clinically significant behavioral issues, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had a unique need for behavioral counseling in order to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer observes that many of STUDENT’s behavioral problems involve his school mates. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the counseling services shall be provided in a small-group setting to assist him with social skills and peer relationships. The behavioral counseling shall be provided by a properly qualified counselor. See, C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3065(f)(2).

The Hearing Officer further finds that while STUDENT requires counseling services, there was no evidence that STUDENT’s behaviors rose to the level where he required a BSP. (Footnote 11) The Hearing Officer has found above that the failure to provide behavioral counseling services denied STUDENT a FAPE. However, the error is not fatal to the overall IEP. The IEP can be amended to provide this related service.

Adapted Physical Education.

Both the IDEA and its federal regulations specifically address physical education within the context of special education, which is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, including “instruction in physical education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); 34 C.F.R. § 300.26(a)(1)(ii). Physical education includes adapted physical education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.26(a)(2)(i). California regulations provide that “(a) adapted physical education is for individuals with exceptional needs who require developmental or corrective instruction and who are precluded from participation in the activities of the general physical education program, modified general physical education program, or in a specially designed physical education program in a special class.” 34 C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3051.5(a).

Here, there was no evidence that STUDENT was unable to participate in the regular education curriculum for physical education. As discussed in Issue No. 4 above, the convincing and uncontradicted evidence established that STUDENT was athletic and could run fast, swim, ski, and play golf. The District performed an occupational therapy assessment. Based upon the therapist’s clinical observations, STUDENT could run, jump with two feet together, hop, balance on either foot with eyes open or closed, throw and catch a small ball and imitate movements. (District Exh. 25.) Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a unique need for adapted physical education and did not require adapted physical education to benefit from his education.

MOTHER expressed her concern that STUDENT sometimes disrupted group sports activities. Recognizing the IDEA’s preference for mainstreaming, the Hearing Officer observes that if STUDENT had difficulty with group sports, placement in the regular physical education class with typically developing peers may likely provide appropriate modeling of sportsmanlike conduct. To the extent this problem is a manifestation of STUDENT’s social skills difficulties, the small-group behavioral counseling ordered above may address this problem. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs will be met by his participation in a regular physical education class.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that a thorough and complete speech and language assessment, focusing on STUDENT’s receptive language needs should be conducted; the IEP should be amended to include an updated transition plan set out in District’s Exhibit 43; and, the IEP should be amended to include the provision of small-group behavioral counseling as a DIS. With these amendments, the District’s placement contained within the June 2, 2003 IEP, offered STUDENT a FAPE.

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District incorrectly found STUDENT ineligible for special education in January 2001, is the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for tuition expenses incurred at the nonpublic schools STUDENT attended during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, or to provide any other remedy?

The Hearing Officer has found above that the District incorrectly determined that STUDENT was ineligible for special education in January 2001. Accordingly, when the District offered to place STUDENT in its regular education program rather than provide him with special education, it denied STUDENT a FAPE. When a school district denies a child a FAPE, the child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). The Hearing Officer will next address the appropriate remedy.

Is the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for tuition at the nonpublic schools he attended during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents’ placement still must meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement addresses the child’s needs and provides him with educational benefit. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).

2001-2002 school year.

STUDENT’s unique needs generally required that he have a program with an individualized curriculum based upon his significantly below average intellectual functioning. In addition, STUDENT required one-on-one assistance in a structured, small-group setting to help him with his attentional needs. Finally, STUDENT needed positive reinforcement and help with his self-esteem. (Wagner testimony.) Other than MOTHER’s testimony that STUDENT’s teacher at the College Center Montessori School (Montessori) provided STUDENT with a one-on-one assistance for one hour each day, there was scant evidence whether the Montessori school met STUDENT’s unique needs. Furthermore, Respondent presented no evidence that STUDENT received some educational benefit at this private placement. In fact, MOTHER testified that STUDENT continued to struggle academically at the Montessori school. Accordingly, absent any convincing evidence that the Montessori program met STUDENT’s needs or provided him with some educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the tuition expenses at the Montessori school.

2002-2003 school year.

STUDENT’s parents also seek reimbursement for tuition expenses they incurred at the Balboa City School, a certified nonpublic special education school from October 2002 through June 2, 2003, the date of the District’s placement offer. MOTHER testified that the Balboa City School (Balboa) is a certified, special education school with small classes for students with disabilities. Ms. Cockrell observed STUDENT as part of her 2003 assessment. She reported that STUDENT’s school day was divided into seven periods and that he had six teachers. STUDENT’s fourth grade mathematics class had four students. Ms. Cockrell observed STUDENT multiply without the use of a multiplication chart and demonstrate an understanding of “one-half.” STUDENT had a good sense of humor and interacted well with his teacher. According to Ms. Cockrell’s report, STUDENT’s teachers noted improving self-control and increasing motivation to do well in reading. MOTHER testified that STUDENT showed some advancement in ability and knowledge and that his self-esteem had improved because he no longer felt different from his classmates. The Hearing Officer finds MOTHER’s testimony credible because it was drawn both from her own observations of STUDENT at Balboa and tutoring of STUDENT on a one-on-one basis during the previous school years, and consistent with Ms. Cockrell’s report.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program at the Balboa City School (Balboa), which provided instruction in a small class setting with other disabled youngsters, and which provided a relatively low student-teacher ratio, met STUDENT’s unique needs as described above. Considering Ms. Cockrell’s written report together with MOTHER’s testimony as well as evidence of STUDENT’s cognitive deficits and attentional problems, the Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT derived some educational benefit at Balboa. (Footnote 12) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s unilateral placement at the Balboa City School.

Should the reimbursement award be reduced or denied?

Equitable considerations may be taken into account in fashioning a remedy, including the conduct of the parties, and courts have broad discretion in granting appropriate relief. Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., Com. of Mass., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994) ; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., supra, 960 F.2d at 1486. The District asserts that in the event the Hearing Officer found that reimbursement was appropriate, the amount should be reduced or denied in its entirety because of equitable considerations. In particular, the District argues that: (1) STUDENT’s parents failed to provide proper notice that they rejected the District’s proposed placement and intended to place STUDENT in a nonpublic school; (2) STUDENT’s parents did not seek suitable alternative placements before placing him at the Balboa City School; and (3) STUDENT’s parents’ conduct was uncooperative and dilatory starting with the initial assessments in 2000. STUDENT argued that the notice requirements do not apply in these circumstances where STUDENT was not rejecting a special education placement proposed by the District and that MOTHER’s actions were reasonable.

(1) Notice of placement in nonpublic school.

34 C.F.R. section 300.403(d)(i) provides that reimbursement for private school placement may be reduced or denied if “at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not inform the IEP team that they were rejecting the placement proposed by the public agency to provide FAPE to their child, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense.” 34 C.F.R. section 300.403(d)(ii) provides that reimbursement may be reduced or denied if “at least ten (10) business days ...prior to the removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not give written notice to the public agency...” of their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense.

Contrary to the District’s assertion, the Hearing Officer finds that neither of these requirements apply here because STUDENT was not removed from an appropriate public school placement. Moreover, at the January 2001 IEP meeting, the District was aware that STUDENT was enrolled in a nonpublic school. Some months after the IEP meeting, members of the District staff met with STUDENT’s teachers at his nonpublic school to recommend modifications to his program. Although not a requirement here, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was aware that STUDENT continued to attend a nonpublic school for the relevant time period. (Footnote 13)

(2) Seeking alternative school placements.

The Hearing Officer observes that after the District found STUDENT was ineligible for special education in January 2001, STUDENT continued to struggle in his nonpublic school placements. Even when STUDENT was expelled from the Montessori school, STUDENT’s parents did not communicate to the District either STUDENT’s continued academic struggles or the difficulties he experienced when placed with typically developing peers. On the other hand, the Hearing Officer finds that after MOTHER took STUDENT to a private psychiatrist for a medication reevaluation in September 2002 immediately after he was expelled, she followed up on the doctor’s referral for advocacy services. For the time period at issue here (2002-2003 school year tuition reimbursement) upon the advice of her advocate, MOTHER took steps to notify the District where STUDENT was placed (District Exh. 37) and enrolled STUDENT in an appropriate special education program, albeit in the nonpublic sector, while she followed up on efforts to obtain placement within the District. (District Exh. 35.) The Hearing Officer finds that it was not imprudent to place STUDENT in a nonpublic special education school that was recommended by her advocate and finds no reason to reduce tuition reimbursement on this basis.

(3) STUDENT’s parents’ conduct.

State special education law establishes timelines between the time an assessment is requested to the time the District must convene the IEP team meeting to discuss the assessment results and make an offer of placement. A proposed assessment plan shall be developed within fifteen calendar days of referral for assessment. Cal. Education Code § 56043(a). A parent or guardian has at least fifteen calendar days from the receipt of the proposed plan to arrive at a decision whether to provide her consent to the plan. Cal. Education Code §§ 56043(b); 56321. An IEP shall be developed within a total time not to exceed fifty calendar days from the date the district receives the parent’s written consent. Cal. Education Code §§ 56043(d); 56344. In sum, the statutes contemplate that approximately eighty days are available for this process.

The District maintains that MOTHER’s initial refusal to permit the reassessment, the strict time constraints she placed upon STUDENT’s availability for testing, and MOTHER’s failure to attend the scheduled May 2003 IEP meeting, caused a significant delay. The District argues that these delays deprived the District of the opportunity to offer its placement earlier. According to the District, because the PARENTS ultimately accepted its placement offer, STUDENT would have attended the District’s school sooner and its liability would have been reduced or eliminated.

A review of the chronology of events is helpful in determining whether Respondent acted reasonably. Dr. Edwards contacted the District to request reconsideration of its eligibility determination on October 7, 2002. (District Exh. 35.) On October 24, 2002, MOTHER notified the District that she had unilaterally placed STUDENT at the Balboa school. (District Exh. 38.) The District offered to hold an IEP meeting on November 1, 2002 to discuss its proposed reassessment plan. (District Exh. 38.) According to the credible testimony, MOTHER received the draft assessment plan on that day from her educational advocate. Although MOTHER had fifteen days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision whether to consent to the plan, that is November 18, 2002, the assessment plan was not signed until February 6, 2003. (Footnote 14) (District Exh. 33.) There was no credible testimony that explained the delay in consenting to the assessment plan. The Hearing Officer observes that in Gregory K., supra, at 1315, the court stated that “if the parents want Gregory to receive special education under the [IDEA], they are obligated to permit such testing.” Some of the delay was caused by MOTHER’s failing to make STUDENT reasonably available for testing and refusing to attend the first IEP meeting scheduled for May 2003. (District Exh. 48.) The Hearing Officer finds that the District made many attempts to schedule assessments with STUDENT and meetings with the PARENTS. (District Exhs. 38, 39, 40, 41, 46.) No convincing evidence was presented by Respondent to justify the substantial delays in completing the tests or attending the May 2003 IEP meeting. (Footnote 15)

If MOTHER had given timely consent to the assessment plan and made STUDENT reasonably available for testing, the IEP team meeting to discuss the assessment results would have been held fifty (50) days after November 18, 2002 or, on or about, January 7, 2003. (Footnote 16) However, the Hearing Officer observes that the District has offered STUDENT a transition plan of twenty days. Given the nature of STUDENT’s disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that a transition plan is necessary. Because a transition plan envisions ongoing contact with Balboa on a part-time basis, STUDENT’s parents continued to be obligated for the tuition payments through those additional days. The Hearing Officer calculates that STUDENT could have started at the District’s school on, or about, January 27, 2003.

The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP meeting was not held until June 2, 2003, after approximately four additional months had elapsed. The Hearing Officer further finds that this four month delay was substantial and attributable to MOTHER’s recalcitrance. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s liability ended on or about January 27, 2003. Accordingly, the reimbursement award for the tuition expenses at Balboa shall be reduced by four months to a total of $3920.00 ($980.00 per month X 4 months (October 2002 - January 2003)). (Respondent Exh. J.)

Is STUDENT entitled to any other remedy?

Based upon the principle enunciated in Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. 358, that a child with a disability is entitled to “appropriate” relief when a school district fails to provide a FAPE, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, for example, Puyallup., supra, 31 F.3d at 1496. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497. In addition, courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy which helps a student to overcome lost educational opportunity. Burlington; Puyallup.

The Hearing Officer has found above that the IEP team incorrectly determined that STUDENT was ineligible for special education and related services and that its offer of a general education placement was a denial of a FAPE. The District was responsible for the fact that STUDENT received no effective education for two years. MOTHER made a good faith effort to find a replacement program during that period, but failed. The Hearing Officer finds that as result of the failure of the District to find STUDENT eligible for special education, STUDENT lost two years of special education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services to make up for that substantial two-year loss.

The Hearing Officer observes from the record in this case that one-on-one tutoring has been effective to address STUDENT’s needs. The Center reported success when it provided one-on-one academic tutoring. (District Exhs. 9, 10.) Both Ms. Dickerson’s and Ms. Wagner’s testimony that STUDENT performed better with one-on-one attention, feedback and reinforcement, corroborated these reports. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires one-on-one tutoring by a credentialed teacher for at least one year.

The Hearing Officer notes from a review of the documents and testimony, that STUDENT may have needs in the area of communication and functional life skills to prepare for him independent living, which apparently have been omitted from the goals and objectives designed for the 2003-2004 school year. However, the IEP team is in the best position to determine, based upon the totality of the circumstances, the frequency of the tutoring and the areas in which STUDENT requires support. Although the Hearing Officer has ordered that the tutoring take place for at least one full school year, the IEP team will retain the discretion to extend that tutoring beyond one year, as necessary. The District shall implement the compensatory educational services in a manner that has minimal impact on STUDENT’s school day and ability to participate in his special education program. Nevertheless, the District must take cognizance of the fact that STUDENT’s two-year loss of educational opportunity was substantial.

ISSUE NO. 6: Did the District fulfill its search and serve obligations with regard to STUDENT from June 23, 2000 to the present?

The IDEA and State special education law impose an affirmative duty on school districts to identify, locate, and evaluate all disabled children, including those who attend nonpublic schools, who are in need of special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3)(A); Cal. Education Code § 56300. Thus, both federal and California laws require districts to be proactive in seeking out and assessing children who may be disabled. This is referred to either as a district’s duty to “search and serve” or to “child-find.” Under State law, the school district must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system. Cal. Education Code § 56301. The policies and procedures must include written notification to all parents of their rights and the procedure for initiating a referral for assessment. Id. Identification procedures shall include systematic methods of referrals of students by teachers, parents,agencies, appropriate professional persons, and members of the public. Cal. Education Code § 56302.

Here, the District sent letters to the administrators of all the nonpublic schools that STUDENT attended informing them of the special education referral process. (District Exh. 50.) Included in the District’s letter to each NPS was a more detailed explanation of rights and the District’s request to the schools’ administrators to forward the information to the parents. There is no dispute that sending letters to the nonpublic school administrators was reasonably calculated to satisfy the District’s child-find obligations. Dr. Espinoza also testified that annual notices were published in daily newspapers informing parents to contact their local school district’s or special education local plan area’s office. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met its obligations to search and serve STUDENT. In addition, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District timely assessed STUDENT when requested to do so by the principal of the Chula Vista Christian School and STUDENT’s parents. (District Exhs. 34 and 45.) Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the District acted appropriately and timely convened IEP meetings to discuss the assessment results and provided appropriate notices of procedural safeguards to STUDENT’s parents during the time period at issue in this case.

Student provided no evidence at hearing regarding the purported failure of the District to seek out and serve STUDENT either prior to its assessment in November 2000 and January 2001, or during the interim until it found STUDENT eligible for special education in June 2003. Based upon the uncontradicted evidence presented by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that it complied with its “child-find” obligations to STUDENT throughout the relevant time period.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reconvene the IEP team to:

(a) amend the IEP for the 2003-2004 school year to include behavioral counseling in a small-group setting by a qualified counselor. The IEP team shall determine the frequency and duration of the counseling;

(b) amend the IEP for the 2003-2004 school year to include the transition plan provided for this hearing as District Exhibit 43. The dates in the transition plan shall be updated;

(c) schedule date(s) to conduct a complete and thorough speech and language assessment by a qualified assessor, with particular focus on STUDENT’s receptive language needs, so that the assessment report shall be completed and provided to Respondent no later than thirty calendar days from the date of this Decision; and (d) determine the areas of need for one-on-one tutoring by a credentialed teacher, and, in consultation with STUDENT’s parents determine the nature, extent and schedule for that tutoring.

2. STUDENT’s parents shall make him reasonably available for the speech and language assessment as ordered in Order No. 1(c).

3. Within fifteen calendar days, upon completion of the IEP meeting conducted in Order 1, the District shall provide:

(a) one-on-one tutoring for the 2003-2004 school year; and (b) small-group behavioral counseling.

4. Within twenty calendar days from the completion of the speech and language assessment and assessment written report ordered in Order No. 1 above, the District shall reconvene the IEP team to consider the results and take action, as appropriate.

5. Within thirty calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents in the amount of $3920.00, as reimbursement for educational expenses at Balboa City School in conformance with this Decision.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District properly assess STUDENT in November 2000 and January 2001? The District prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 2: Should STUDENT have been found eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability, mental retardation, or other health impairment at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District properly reassess STUDENT in the spring of 2003?

The District prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 4: Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and extended 2003 school year as described in the individualized education program (IEP) dated June 2, 2003, when it failed to include designated instruction and services in the areas of speech and language, behavioral counseling and adapted physical education?

The District substantially prevailed on this issue, except to the extent that it failed to provide behavioral counseling services for STUDENT and determine STUDENT’s need for speech and language services.

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District incorrectly found STUDENT ineligible for special education in January 2001, is the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for tuition expenses incurred at the nonpublic schools STUDENT attended during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, or to provide any other remedy?

Respondent prevailed on this issue to the extent that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reduced reimbursement for tuition at the Balboa City School, and STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services.

ISSUE NO. 6: Did the District fulfill its search and serve obligations with regard to STUDENT from June 23, 2000 to the present?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: September 24, 2003 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1a. Respondent was unrepresented at the IEP meeting and Ms. Wagner, as a nonpublic school teacher, was inexperienced in the IEP process. It was up to the more experienced members of the IEP team to ask Ms. Wagner for her input.

2b. The District’s reliance on Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999) is misplaced. Adams addressed placement decisions and is not analogous to the situation in the present case. Adams did not address how the events that occurred at the IEP meeting should be evaluated. Moreover, the Ninth Circuit held only that events which occurred after the placement decision should not be used “exclusively” to adjudge a placement’s appropriateness. Id., at 1149. Notably, the Court decided that events subsequent to the placement decision were relevant, just not dispositive. Here, Ms. Wagner testified about events that occurred before, not after, the IEP meeting. It should be noted that the District relied exclusively on the after-the-fact analysis of special education coordinator, Dr. Pamela Espinoza.

1. The issues have been reframed to reflect the discussion with the parties and for the purposes of analysis.

2. Dr. Espinoza is the coordinator of special education for the District. In her thirty years with the District, she has been a school psychologist, a school counselor, and a special education and general education teacher. Dr. Espinoza has degrees and credentials to teach severely handicapped students, mild to moderately mentally retarded students, and those with learning disabilities. She teaches assessment courses to prospective school psychologists and provides in-service training on new tests, revisions to tests, and test protocols.

3. The District’s attorney never called Ms. Wolff, the school psychologist who actually conducted STUDENT’s assessment, to testify.

4. For the first time in his closing brief, STUDENT raised several additional claims of error regarding the assessments. However, since none of these concerns were raised at hearing, the Hearing Officer will not reach them.

5. For the first time in his closing brief, STUDENT asserts that he is entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by Dr. Karen Zappone. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for this IEE because of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District’s assessment was appropriate. See, Cal. Education Code § 56329(c).

6. The IEP meeting notes reflect that the category of specific learning disability (SLD) was also discussed. Because the parties generally agree that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under that category, the Hearing Officer will not address whether STUDENT should have been found eligible as a child with an SLD.

7. On the WISC-III verbal subtests, STUDENT received scaled scores that ranged from 3 to 10. On the performance subtests, STUDENT received scaled scores that ranged from 1 to 8. Dr. Espinoza testified that this “scatter of scores” required a more “global view” of the child to determine whether he is a child with mental retardation. Apparently, Dr. Espinoza relied on a comment in the DSM-IV stating when there is a significant scatter in the subtest scores, a profile of strengths and weaknesses, rather than the mathematically derived full-scale IQ, will more accurately reflect the person’s learning abilities. Dr. Espinoza failed to explain, however, how such a profile of strengths and weaknesses is obtained.

8. Ms. Wagner has been a credentialed teacher for five years. She also tutored adults who needed special help. Ms. Wagner has a bachelor’s degree and has nearly earned her master’s degree in an education program. She has taken courses in special education.

9. Ms. Dickerson had a bachelor’s and master’s degree in education. Although all her teaching experience was in nonpublic schools, Ms. Dickerson had been a substitute teacher in public schools. Ms. Dickerson had taken courses in ADHD.

10. Ms. Munoz has a bachelor’s degree in speech pathology and audiology and possesses a restricted credential in speech therapy. Ms. Munoz was a special day class teacher for children with language impairments and academic delays. She has been conducting speech and language assessments for ten years for the District, and has assessed approximately 200-300 students each year.

11. California provides a behavior intervention plan if a student exhibits serious behavior problems. No one believed that STUDENT needed that much intervention. Behavioral interventions for individuals with exceptional needs are governed by California Education Code sections 56520-56524 (the “Hughes Bill”) and the implementing regulations set forth at C.C.R., tit. 5, section 3052. Behavioral intervention is defined to mean “the design, implementation, and evaluation of individual or group instructional and environmental modifications, including programs of behavioral instruction, to produce significant improvements in human behavior through skill acquisition and the reduction of problematic behavior.” C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3001(d). When “an individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP,” a “behavioral intervention plan” must be written and become part of the IEP. C.C.R., tit. 5, §3001(f).

12. The Hearing Officer considers that a child’s academic program must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, supra. Moreover, the term unique educational needs has been broadly construed to include the child’s academic, social, health, emotional, communicative, physical and vocational needs. See, Seattle School Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).

13. MOTHER signed the January 2001 IEP form, checking the box that she agreed with the general education placement offered by the District. MOTHER testified, however, that she thought that her check mark indicated only that she understood that the District was not offering a special education placement. Whatever MOTHER intended her mark to mean does not change the result that the statute is inapplicable here.

14. Fifteen days from November 1, 2002 was November 16, 2002 which fell on a Saturday.

15. MOTHER contended that she did not adhere to the District’s assessment schedule because she did not want to interfere with STUDENT’s instructional day or interfere with his other commitments, such as his basketball practice. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment schedule was reasonable. (District Exhs. 46; 49.)

16. Under the terms of the statutes, school vacations that are in excess of five schooldays and days between regular school sessions are excluded from the time periods. The District’s 2002-2003 school year calendar was not provided, but the Hearing Officer believes that there may have been some days in December 2002 and/or January 2003 that fell within these exceptions.