California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 30, 1997
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 139-97, SN 97-97 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Long Beach Unified's assessment and IEP offer of general education with daily resource support upheld; late IEP meeting found but no remedy.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
This case combined two filings. The student's non-attorney advocates filed for hearing, and Long Beach Unified School District filed its own case. The student was an 11-year-old fifth grader whose primary language was Spanish. He qualified for special education under specific learning disability because of severe gaps between ability and achievement in reading, math and written expression. His parent and advocates refused to attend four scheduled IEP meetings. The District then held the meeting without them and offered regular education plus 90 minutes of daily resource specialist program (RSP) support. The student's advocates raised eight issues about consent, translation, written notice, IEP contents and transportation. Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain found no evidence for any of them. She noted that the District had provided interpreters and a Spanish translation of the IEP. The student's side stopped taking part partway through the hearing. On the District's issues, the Hearing Officer held that the assessment plan was timely and validly consented to by the parent's authorized representative. She found the assessment appropriate and held that the District could properly meet without the parent after repeated refusals. The District did miss the deadline for holding the IEP meeting. She found no remedy was warranted because the student was not harmed. She held that the IEP offered a FAPE under Rowley and ordered the District to implement it at the start of the 1997-98 school year.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled parents who repeatedly refused to attend IEP meetings. The district could meet without them after documented attempts to involve them. It still had to meet the statutory deadline for holding the IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer also upheld a district's request for an order to implement its IEP offer without parent consent.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Shall the District recognize that parent is primarily Spanish-speaking and learning disabled, with a disability affecting her ability to comprehend legalistic documents, small print and handwriting? How?
The District already recognized the parent's Spanish-language needs by providing interpreters and a Spanish IEP translation; no evidence was offered that the parent has a learning disability.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend, and be subject to Ed. Code 56346(b) as the automatic consequence of refusing to sign?
No evidence showed the District compelled the parent to sign anything; the assessment consent was signed by her authorized representative.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3. Shall the District comply with Ed. Code 56346 (meaning of 'informed, in writing')? How shall the District comply?
No evidence of noncompliance with section 56346(a); the student had not been placed in any special education program.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4. Shall the District comply with 56346 regarding 'components'? How shall the District write documents so a disabled parent can consent or not consent to components?
Hearing Officers resolve disputes rather than instruct districts on document drafting, and no evidence showed the parent has a learning disability.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5. Shall the District comply with 56506(d) in writing as part of the IEP document; must the District inform parent of 'all' public and nonpublic options?
The law does not require the IEP to list all public and nonpublic options; the IEP showed the team considered general education, RSP, SDC and nonpublic school, and no failure to inform the parent was shown.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 6. Shall the District comply with 56345(b)(3), (b)(5) and (d) in writing as part of the IEP document?
Subsection (b)(3) does not apply to a fifth grader, and no ESY need was shown; leaving out the differential proficiency standards determination was a procedural flaw with no shown impact on FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7. Shall the District comply with 56342 regarding transportation? Must the parent specifically request compliance?
No allegation or evidence that the student needed transportation or was denied it.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 8. Shall the District supply all documents for parent in both English and Spanish?
No evidence that the District failed to provide documents in English or Spanish or violated the primary-language notice requirement.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 9. Did the District provide STUDENT with the opportunity to develop an appropriate assessment plan in response to the referral for assessment?
The District invited the parent, included the requested Lindamood-Bell testing, and provided the assessment plan within 15 days of the referral.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 10. Was an assessment plan consented to on behalf of STUDENT?
The parent's authorized representative validly consented to the assessment plan.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 11. Did the District properly assess STUDENT?
The assessment met Ed. Code 56320: it was nondiscriminatory, used validated tools given by qualified staff, and used several measures, including Spanish testing; English testing was appropriate because the student functioned higher in English.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 12a. Was the IEP team meeting timely?
The District missed the statutory IEP deadline of about 30 days into the new school year, even though it postponed meetings for the parent; no remedy because no harm to the student's education was shown.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 12b. Was the IEP team meeting appropriate?
After four written invitations and phone calls that the parent and advocate refused, the District properly held the IEP meeting without them, with all other required members present.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 13. Has the District offered STUDENT an educational program which will provide a free appropriate education?
Under Rowley, regular education with 90 minutes of daily RSP small-group instruction met the student's needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit; the consultant's recommendation of a nonpublic program got little weight.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. When the 1997-98 school year begins, the District is ordered to implement the IEP it developed by providing the student with regular education and ninety minutes of daily RSP small-group instruction.
- All of Student's requests for relief were denied, including a District-funded advocate and instructions to the District on the IEP process. No remedy was given for the late IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Burger v. Murray County School District
People named in the decision
- Eloise Thompson, Director of special education and student support services, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Jean Saunders, School psychologist, assessor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Hope Goss, Regular education fifth-grade teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Marianne Steverson, Individual and small group instruction (ISGI) teacher and reading assessor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Maureen Gorman, School counselor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Bertha Sightler, Special education program facilitator, district representative at IEP meeting, Long Beach Unified School District
- Jessica Petit, RSP teacher, IEP team member, Long Beach Unified School District
- Rosa Marino, Spanish-speaking student evaluation technician, Long Beach Unified School District
- Alice Sexton, Spanish language translator at IEP meeting, Long Beach Unified School District
- Rita Marrs, Private education consultant for Student (testimony stricken)
- R.A. Drew, Non-attorney advocate for Student
- Reyna Akers, Non-attorney advocate for Student; former chair of District Community Advisory Committee
- Flor Boyadjian, Spanish language interpreter at hearing
- Richard A. Simmons, Interpreter at hearing
- Yolanda Arriola, Interpreter at hearing
- Peterson, SEHO Hearing Officer who denied a prehearing scheduling request, Special Education Hearing Office
- Winston School, Private school recommended by Student's consultant, Solana Beach, CA
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 139-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: LONG BEACH UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT (CONSOLIDATED WITH SN 97-97) Issue: Assessment Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-64725 District: Long Beach Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard on March 13, 18 and 19, May 21, 22, 23, and 27, 1997 in Long Beach, California, before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner and Cross Respondent STUDENT was represented by nonattorney representatives R.A. Drew and Reyna Akers, who were present on March 13, 18, 19, 21 and 22, 1997. Neither Ms. Drew nor Ms. Akers participated in these proceedings on May 23 and 27, 1997. STUDENT's mother, PARENT, was present on his behalf on March 13, 18, and 19, 1997.
Respondent and Cross Petitioner Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Cynthia A. Yount of Parker, Covert, & Chidester. Eloise Thompson, director of special education and student support services, also appeared on behalf of the District.
Spanish language interpreter Flor Boyadjian was present to assist PARENT on March 13, 1997. Richard A. Simmons was present to assist on March 18, and 19, 1997; and Yolanda Arriola was present to assist on May 21, and 22, 1997.
STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify: Reyna Akers; Rita Marrs, education consultant; PARENT; and Eloise Thompson.(Footnote 1)
The District called the following witnesses to testify; Dr. Jean Saunders, school psychologist; Hope Goss, regular education teacher; Marianne Steverson, individual and small group instruction (ISGI); Maureen Gorman, counselor; and Bertha Sightler, special education program facilitator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received on March 13, 18, and 19, and May 21, 22, 23, and 27, 1997. By Memorandum of Order dated May 29, 1997, both parties were notified that the Hearing Officer would consider written closing argument bearing either a postmark or a facsimile date indicating that it was sent on or before June 11, 1997. The District submitted closing argument; STUDENT's representatives did not. After receipt of the District's closing argument, the record was closed.
PROCEDURAL NOTE
Throughout these proceedings, Ms. Drew appeared by telephone. On March 13, 1997, the first day of hearing, Ms. Thompson, Ms. Yount, and the Hearing Officer appeared by telephone. Thereafter, all parties, representatives, witnesses, and the Hearing Officer were present at District offices in Long Beach, California and communicated with Ms. Drew by way of speaker telephone.
On March 13, 18, and 19, 1997, Ms. Drew stated that her employment prevented her from participating in this due process hearing past 2:30p.m. On these days, the Hearing Officer ended the hearing early to accommodate Ms. Drew's schedule. However, during the hearing, the Hearing Officer explicitly stated that future hearing dates would begin at 9:30a.m. and end at 5:00 p.m., unless a party established good cause for altering the schedule.
By letter dated March 12, 1997, Ms. Drew stated that she had "responsibilities and obligations elsewhere" and requested that the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) begin this hearing "as early in the morning as possible, ending at 2:30 each day." By letter dated March 27, 1997, the District opposed this motion. On April 4, 1997, Hearing Officer Peterson issued an order denying Ms. Drew's request and informing her that this matter would begin at 9:30a.m. and end at 5:00p.m.
By letter dated May 20, 1997 and also at the hearing on May 21, 1997, Ms. Drew stated that PARENT suffered from high blood pressure and was "ill advised to participate in due process at this time in consideration of her health." Ms. Drew asserted that PARENT's representatives were "in the process of contacting PARENT's doctor so that the doctor can" document her illness. Ms. Drew maintained that medical evidence of PARENT's condition would be forthcoming.(Footnote 2)
Based on these representations, Ms. Drew requested a continuance. The District opposed the request for a continuance arguing that Ms. Drew had presented no medical evidence in support of her contention. Finding that Ms. Drew had not established good cause for continuing this hearing, the Hearing Officer denied her request.(Footnote 3)
After a lengthy protest regarding the manner in which the Hearing Officer conducted this hearing, Ms. Drew requested another continuance. In support of the continuance request, Ms. Drew asserted that "this matter should be pursued by an attorney from now on." Ms. Drew stated that she had contacted but, not retained, an attorney who would "probably" take this case. Ms. Drew added, "if that attorney is not brought onto the case, another will be found." However, Ms. Drew asserted that she remained and would "remain PARENT's representative even when she finds an attorney."
The District opposed Ms. Drew's request arguing that, in the past, Ms. Drew has alleged that other representatives would assist PARENT but that no one else had been retained. The District also noted that STUDENT filed this case in January 1997, and that therefore, PARENT has had "ample time" to secure an attorney.
Before ruling on the second motion for a continuance, the Hearing Officer proposed to telephone PARENT to ascertain her wishes with respect to proceeding without the assistance of an attorney. Ms. Drew stated that such telephone contact would "jeopardize" her health and strenuously objected to the Hearing Officer's proposal to telephone PARENT. Finding that Ms. Drew had still not established good cause for continuing this hearing, the Hearing Officer also denied that request for a continuance.
On May 21, 1997, Ms. Drew participated in this proceeding until approximately 2:30p.m., when she informed the Hearing Officer that she was leaving because "had to go pick up a child." The Hearing Officer stated that the hearing would proceed without Ms. Drew, Ms. Drew hung up the telephone, and the hearing proceeded until 5:00p.m.
On May 22, 1997, Ms. Drew renewed her request for a continuance citing PARENT's medical condition. Because Ms. Drew offered no evidence establishing that a medical condition prevented PARENT from participating in this matter and rejected the Hearing Officer's offer to assist Ms. Drew in gathering such evidence, Ms. Drew's renewed request for a continuance was denied.
On the morning of May 23, 1997, Ms. Drew read a statement into the record that requested, among other things, a "recess of hearings pending investigation" because "STUDENT is considering asking the Hearing Officer, Carin Crain, to step aside on the basis of Prejudice." The District opposed Ms. Drew's request, and finding that Ms. Drew had not established good cause for a continuance ("recess"), the Hearing Officer denied Ms. Drew's request. Following the ruling, Ms. Drew indicated that she would hang up the phone, and then did so.(Footnote 4)
The Hearing Officer concluded that the District, as cross Petitioner in this case, was entitled to a prompt resolution of the issue presented, and that the parties were duly notified of the time, date, and place of the hearing by letter dated April 23, 1997. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer determined that the hearing would proceed as scheduled in the absence of STUDENT, his parent and his representatives.
On May 23, 1997, the Hearing Officer telephone both Ms. Drew and the District to notify them that the Hearing Officer intended to recall a witness and receive testimony by telephone on May 27, 1997, at 10:00a.m. The District participated in the telephone call; STUDENT's representatives did not.
ISSUES
The Hearing Officer has restated the parties' issues verbatim.
1. Shall the District recognize Petitioner's claim that parent is primarily Spanish-speaking, learning disabled, parent having a disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic documents, documents usually presumed "easily understood by the general public" (non- disabled persons), small print and handwriting? How?(Footnote 5)
2. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend? Shall parent be subject to Ed. Code 56346 (b) as the AUTOMATIC CONSEQUENCE of refusing to sign documents she does not fully comprehend?
3. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner asks for definition of the fullest meaning of the word "informed," and emphasizes the words "informed, in writing.") How shall the District comply? Petitioner asks for specifics.
4. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner emphasizes the instructions regarding "components"). How shall the District write documents to facilitate disable parent's access to parent's right to "consent to" or "not consent to" "components"?
5. Shall the District comply with 56506 (d) in writing as part of IEP document? How must District comply? Shall the District require parent to inform District of "all" options public and non- public, or shall, instead, District take responsibility for knowing and informing parent of "all" options?
6. Shall the District comply with 56345 (Petitioner emphasizes 56345 9b)(3); (b)(5); (d)), in writing as part of IEP document? How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District comply?
7. Shall the District comply with 56342 (Petitioner emphasizes the matter of "transportation"). How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
8. Shall the District supply all documents for parent in both English and Spanish?
9. Did the District provide STUDENT with the opportunity to develop an appropriate assessment plan in response to the referral for assessment?
10. Was an assessment plan consented to on the behalf of STUDENT?
11. Did the District properly assess STUDENT?
12. Did the District conduct a timely and appropriate IEP team meeting for STUDENT?
13. Has the District offered STUDENT an educational program which will provide a free appropriate education?
PROPOSED RELIEF
By letter dated 27, 1997, STUDENT's representative made the following two proposals that the Hearing Officer has restated verbatim:
1. We proposed that District provide, at District expense, a local, experienced in Special Education advocacy, to act on parent's behalf; a person or office that both parent and District can agree is best suited to this task.
2. In a secondary proposal, in the event Hearing Officer finds the first proposal inadequate, we propose the Hearing Officer give the District clear and specific instructions re the IEP process in STUDENT's case.
As STUDENT's representative emphasized that the above are proposals and not issues, they will be dealt with in a separate section.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Eleven-year-old STUDENT is a fifth-grader who lives with his parents within District boundaries. STUDENT's IEP team determined that STUDENT qualifies for special education because of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of reading, mathematics, and written expression. However, STUDENT and the District have not developed a mutually acceptable IEP; therefore, he has not yet received special education services. STUDENT's proposed IEP identifies Spanish as his primary language but he receives instruction in English. By letter dated May 21, 1996, Ms. Drew requested that the District developed an assessment plan and "completed a psyco-educational assessment" of STUDENT. On June 4, 1996, the District convened a student study team (SST), which produced a proposed assessment plan. On behalf of PARENT, Ms. Drew consented to implementation of the proposed plan on June 7, 1996.
The District assessed STUDENT on September 12 and 19, 1996. The assessment results indicated that STUDENT's intelligence fell within the average range and revealed that he had severe discrepancy between ability and written expression.
Beginning in September 1996, the District scheduled but did not hold, three IEP team meetings to consider the results of STUDENT's assessment and to develop an IEP. Neither PARENT nor Ms. Drew attended any of the meetings. On January 23, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team met without PARENT of Ms. Drew present and developed a proposed IEP. The District has not obtained the parent's consent to the proposed IEP, which places STUDENT in a regular education program and offers him ninety minutes of resource specialist program (RSP) support each day. The IEP indicates that the RSP support could be delivered in STUDENT's regular classroom, through "pull out for small group instruction for the specified time," or by a combination of pull out and regular class instruction.
At the request of Ms. Drew, Rita Marrs, a private educational consultant, reviewed the District's assessment and proposed IEP, but apparently did not conduct her own assessment of STUDENT. Mrs. Marrs' written conclusions regarding STUDENT's academic ability and achievement are, for the most part, consistent with the District's. However, Mrs. Marrs recommended that "STUDENT ATTEND THE Winston School, in Solano Beach, CA., Discrimination in Depth program.(Footnote 6)
On February 13, 1997, the District filed for hearing and eventually identified its issues for hearing as assessment and provision of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). In May 1997, STUDENT's case and the District's case were consolidated.
SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY
Petitioner-Cross Respondent's Witness
Reyna Akers
From 1994-96 Reyna Akers chaired the District's Community Advisory Committee and currently advocates on behalf of parents with children who attend District schools.
Ms. Akers has known PARENT for approximately three years and is now her advocate.(Footnote 7) According to Ms. Akers, PARENT requires Spanish language interpretation and assistance to read small print. Ms. Akers added that PARENT "lacks knowledge of how the IEP process is supposed to go" and finds it difficult to comprehend the Spanish translation of STUDENT's proposed IEP. In Ms. Akers' view, the IEP documents that the District generates are "not easily understood by the general public" but she pointed out that the District translates IEP documents into primary language of the parents.
Ms. Akers stated that PARENT complained that she was not duly notified of the times, dates, and locations of STUDENT's IEP team meetings. On one occasion, the District asked PARENT to sign a request for an assessment. Ms. Akers recalled that PARENT stated that she did not know why the District was asking her to sign the assessment document because she was not visiting the school for that purpose.
Eloise Thompson
Eloise Thompson stated that she has not met STUDENT and did not participate in his assessment or attend the IEP team meeting of January 23, 1997. Ms Thompson's lack of personal knowledge of STUDENT required her to respond to Ms. Drew's questions her regarding the IEP team's discussion and proposed principally by reading from the IEP. According to Ms. Thompson, STUDENT has never received special education services from the District.
According to Ms. Thompson, District testing identifies English as STUDENT's dominant language, but the home language survey identifies Spanish as his primary language. The District relies upon various surveys and screenings to determine STUDENT's primary language. Ms. Thompson noted that STUDENT passed the District's English screening.(Footnote 8)
Ms. Thompson testified that PARENT informed the District in writing that Ms. Drew was authorized to sign documents on behalf of STUDENT. Ms. Thompson noted that Ms. Drew consented to the implementation of STUDENT's proposed assessment plan of June 4, 1996.
Ms. Thompson offered that some members of STUDENT's IEP team, such as Bertha Sightler and RSP teacher Jessica Petit, could better explain why the IEP team considered regular education with ninety minutes of daily RSP support in reading and mathematics and written expression an appropriate educational program for STUDENT.
According to Ms. Thompson, STUDENT's IEP team determined that he did not require extended school year services. To date, neither Ms. Drew nor PARENT has consented to or dissented from STUDENT's proposed IEP.
Ms. Thompson stated that pursuant to Educational Code section 56341, the following people participated in STUDENT'S IEP TEAM MEETING: Bertha Sightler, District representative; Hope Goss, STUDENT's then-current teacher; and Dr. Jean Saunders, school psychologist who conducted an assessment of STUDENT. A Spanish language translator, Alice Sexton, was present to assist PARENT had she attended. Ms. Thompson explained that "no parent is obligated to sign the IEP" at the IEP meeting. Ms. Thompson added that, upon request, the District would have translated STUDENT's IEP into Spanish for PARENT.
According to Ms. Thompson, PARENT has not provided the District with any evidence that she is learning disabled.
Respondent and Cross Petitioner's witnesses
Dr. Jean Saunders
Dr. Saunders has worked as a school psychologist for more that twenty-five years, hold a teaching and school psychologist credential, and is a licensed marriage and family child counselor.
Dr. Saunders testified that pursuant to referral from the District, STUDENT's student study team (SST) met to develop a proposed assessment plan. At the SST meeting of June 3, 1997, Dr. Saunders learned that STUDENT was "having great difficulty learning to read." Although neither PARENT not Ms. Drew participated in the SST meeting, Ms. Drew consented to the proposed assessment plan that the SST created.
In September 1996, Dr. Saunders conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT that included an observation of STUDENT in his regular education classroom and administration of testing instruments.
Dr. Saunders's estimated that during the observation STUDENT stayed on task for approximately five minutes. He then raised his hand for teacher assistance, and, after receiving assistance, returned to his task. STUDENT repeated this behavior several times during the observation. Dr. Saunders recalled that STUDENT's attention was not always focused on his teachers and that he initiated a conversation with another student. During independent seat work, STUDENT walked around the classroom "without being disruptive" and moved his arms and legs. Dr. Saunders stated students with either attention deficits or learning disabilities often display these behaviors.
The District's assessment did not include administration of scales or surveys that measure possible attention deficits. Dr. Saunders explained that some students are easily distracted because they do not understand that assignments; therefore, her assessment focused on his academic ability.
Dr. Saunders testified that Rosa Marino, the Spanish-speaking student evaluation technician, (Footnote 9) administered the BateriaWoodcock psico-educativa en Espanol so that the District would have an assessment of STUDENT's ability in his primary language. Although STUDENT's primary language is Spanish, Dr. Saunders stated that all his assessments should not be administered in Spanish. Dr. Saunders noted that STUDENT is ready to receive academic instruction in English and that he was "higher academically in English than in Spanish." Dr. Saunders described STUDENT's behavior during the individual assessment as "cordial" and "on task."
According to Dr. Saunders, STUDENT was able to "read some words" on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) but was unable to read any word on the Bateria. STUDENT's scores on these instruments indicated to Dr. Saunders that STUDENT is unable to associate sound with symbol. The scores placed him at the first-grade reading level. Dr. Saunders commented that she and Ms. Steverson reached consistent conclusions with respect to STUDENT's reading ability.
Dr. Saunders was aware that the District scheduled but did not convene several IEP team meeting times because that parent neither consented to nor appeared at the meetings. When the IEP team eventually met, the team members discussed STUDENT's present levels of performance and the results of various assessments. Dr. Saunders recalled that STUDENT's teacher stated that he had an attention deficit. Based on these discussions, the IEP team "concluded that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability with a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading, math and written expression associated with an information processes." The IEP team then proposed instructional goals and objectives to address STUDENT's deficits.
According to Dr. Saunders, STUDENT's IEP team agreed that he would be appropriately placed in a regular classroom with RSP support. Dr. Saunders recommended that STUDENT received special education through "pull out small group instruction for the specified time."(Footnote 10) Neither PARENT nor Ms. Drew has expressed an opinion or inquired about STUDENT's proposed IEP.
Hope Goss
STUDENT has been in Hope Goss' fifth-grade regular education class of thirty-five students throughout the 1996-97 school year. Ms. Goss observed that STUDENT "has tremendous difficulty in reading," cannot focus on academic tasks or sit still. Ms. Goss emphasized that STUDENT seems to lack self-control, and described him as a "class clown" who acts out to hide his academic deficits.
Ms. Goss stated that she used interventions to address STUDENT's academic and behavioral deficits. For instance, Ms. Goss gave STUDENT shorter assignments, allowed him to dictate answers, permitted him to read with a buddy, retained him at recess, and moved his seat. None of these interventions was successful.
Ms. Goss also met with PARENT to discuss his academic weaknesses and behavioral problems. Eventually, PARENT began to realize how STUDENT's misbehavior impeded his academic progress. (Footnote 11)
Ms. Goss testified that she participated in STUDENT's assessment and IEP team meeting and believes that she shared information about STUDENT's performance in her class. Ms. Goss stated that STUDENT would like to receive RSP services. In fact, STUDENT asked to enroll in RSP.
Ms. Goss testified that intensive small-group instruction would be appropriate for STUDENT because he lags far behind his peers academically and is extremely distractable. Ms. Goss recommended that STUDENT receive more tan ninety minutes of special education each day, but she did not endorse an SDC placement for him. In Ms. Goss' view, the IEP team developed an instructional goal that appropriately addresses his attention deficit. Ms. Goss commented that STUDENT might benefit from medication to control his "hyperactivity."
Marianne Steverson Marianne Steverson holds a bachelor's degree in education, a master's degree in special education, and special and general education credentials. For the past thirty-two years, the District has employed Ms. Steverson in a variety of teaching positions. Ms. Steverson has both received and conducted training in Lindamood-Bell instructional techniques. Currently Ms. Steverson works in the District's curriculum office and in the ISGI program.
Ms. Steverson met STUDENT IN September 1996 when she assessed his level of reading performance. During assessment, Ms. Steverson administered following instruments: Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization (LAC) test, Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) II in reading and spelling, and Woodcock reading mastery.
STUDENT's results on the LAC test were comparable to the expected scores of first-grade students and indicate that he "really has needs in auditory conceptualization, and phonological processing." According to Ms. Steverson, assessors cannot rely exclusively on the LAC; therefore, she also administered the WRAT II and Woodcock reading mastery. STUDENT did not obtain a grade level score on the Woodcock because he offered "no correct responses."
Although Ms. Steverson did not attend STUDENT's IEP team meeting of January 23, 1997, she did review STUDENT's proposed IEP, and concluded that two of the proposed goals specifically address the deficits in phonic awareness that she identified. Ms. Steverson stated that the other goals were appropriate for him but added hat she would have included in his IEP one hour of daily participation in the Lindamood-Bell Auditory Discrimination in Depth program.
In Ms. Steverson's view, an RSP placement would be appropriate for STUDENT, but an SDC would be too restrictive. Ms. Steverson offered that the Lindamood-Bell program, which is available at Hamilton, Lindberth, and Stanford middle schools, is one method of instruction that would be appropriate for
STUDENT.
Maureen Gorman
The District has employed Maureen Gorman as a counselor since 1995. Ms. Gorman has earned both master's and bachelor's degrees in social work.
Ms. Gorman testified that by letter dated May 21, 1996, Ms. Drew requested that the District assess STUDENT. In response to this request, Ms. Gorman convened a student study team (SST) meeting on June 4, 1996 at which the school psychologist, a resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, regular education teacher, and a school nurse developed a proposed assessment plan. PARENT was invited to the SST meeting; but did not attend. According to Ms. Gorman, the District mailed the proposed assessment plan to PARENT and Ms. Drew on June 7, 1996. By her signature, Ms. Drew consented to the assessment plan on June 10, 1996.
Ms. Gorman stated that she conducted an "academic screening" of STUDENT which consisted of untimed unscored arithmetic, reading, writing, and drawing tests. Ms. Gorman explained that the academic screening did not determine STUDENT'S placement, but, rather, provided his IEP team with a "rough estimate" of his academic achievement.
Ms. Gorman testified PARENT stated that she would attend the IEP team meeting set for October 1, 1996. But because PARENT did not appear at the IEP team meeting, the District members of STUDENT's IEP team did not conduct the meeting. Ms. Gorman recalled that the following week STUDENT apologized for his mother's failure to attend.
According to Ms. Gorman, the District rescheduled STUDENT's IEP meeting on three occasions. Neither PARENT nor Ms. Drew responded to the written notice of the IEP team meeting scheduled for October 17, 1996. Upon receiving notice of the IEP team meeting set for December 19, 1996, and January 23, 1997, Ms. Drew informed Ms. Gorman that neither she nor PARENT would attend "any of our meetings" and asked Ms. Gorman why the District continued to notify them of scheduled meetings.
Pursuant to the instruction of the director of special education, District members of STUDENT's IEP team convened an IEP team meeting on January 23, 1997. Neither PARENT nor Ms. Drew attended that meeting, but Ms. Gorman was present throughout. Ms. Gorman recalled that all members of STUDENT's IEP agreed that a specific learning disability qualified him for special education. IEP team members also endorsed an educational program that would place STUDENT in a regular education class with individualized or small group RSP support for ninety minutes a day.
Ms. Gorman stated that the draft IEP was translated into Spanish for PARENT. Ms. Gorman does not believe that either PARENT or Ms. Drew has consented to or dissented from any part of the IEP developed on January 23, 1997.
Bertha Sightler
For the past ten years, Bertha Sightler has been a District program facilitator for special education. Ms. Sightler stated that in her role as facilitator she responds to parents' questions or concerns about special education programs. Ms. Sightler holds a bachelor's and master's degrees in education and various teaching credentials.
Ms Sightler stated that the refusal of PARENT and Ms. Drew to participate in scheduled IEP team meetings initially prevented the District from conducting them. However, when STUDENT's IEP team meeting convened on January 23, 1997, without PARENT or Ms. Drew, Ms. Sightler served as the facilitator.
According the Ms. Sightler, the IEP team members reviewed STUDENT's academic, psycho-educational, and medical information. The IEP tam concluded that severe discrepancies between ability and achievement in the areas of reading, mathematics and written expression qualified STUDENT for special education.
Ms. Sightler recalled that STUDENT's IEP team discussed whether a regular education program, resource specialist program (RSP), special day class (SDC), or non-public school would be appropriate for STUDENT. Ultimately, the IEP team unanimously recommended that STUDENT participate in a regular education program with ninety minutes of daily RSP support. In Ms. Sightler's view, the proposed placement would provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education because it would provide him with academic benefit and place him in the least restrictive environment.
DISCUSSION(Footnote 12)
1. Shall the District recognize Petitioner's claim that parent is primary Spanish-speaking, learning disabled, parent having a disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic documents, document usually presumed "easily understood by the general public" (non-disabled persons), small print and handwriting? How?
Witness testimony establishes that the District not only recognizes that PARENT is "primarily
Spanish-speaking" but also has taken steps to make meetings conducted and documents written in English comprehensible to her. Both Ms. Goss and Ms. Thompson's undisputed testimony establish that the District provided a translator, when requested, at the parent/teacher and IEP team meetings which PARENT attended and created a Spanish translation of STUDENT's proposed IEP(Footnote 13)
Additionally, STUDENT alleges that PARENT has a "learning disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic documents, documents usually presumed µeasily understood by the general public' (non-disabled persons), small print and handwriting," but has produced no evidence of his mother's alleged learning disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
2. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend? Shall parent be subject to Ed. Code 56346(b) as the AUTOMATIC CONSEQUENCE of refusing to sign documents she does not comprehend?
The record of this proceeding contains no evidence which establishes that the District has compelled PARENT to sign any document that she does not understand. In fact, the consent for pupil assessment dated June 7, 1996, bears the signature of PARENT's representative, Ms. Drew, who presumably understood the document and, as her representative, explained it to PARENT.(Footnote 14)
Furthermore, Ms. Thompson credibly testified that parents are not compelled to sign documents that they do not understand. Because Petitioner has set forth no facts which established that the District has compelled PARENT to sign documents that she does not understand, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
3. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner asks for definition of the fullest meaning of the word "informed," and emphasizes the words "informed, in writing"). How shall the District comply? Petitioner asks for specifics.
Based on STUDENT'S statement of the issue, the Hearing Officer infers that he wished to focus his inquiry on Education Code section 56346(a), which states:
No pupil shall be required to participate in all of part of any special education program unless that parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the individualized education program. If the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized educational program, then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.
The record of this proceeding contains no evidence establishing that the District failed to comply with this section of the Educational Code. Both documents and witness testimony establish that while STUDENT qualifies for special education services, he has not participated in a district special education program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
4. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner emphasizes the instructions regarding "components"). How shall the District write documents to facilitate disabled parent's access to parent's rights to "consent to" or "not consent to" "components"?
Referring to the above-cited section of the Educational Code, Petitioner presumably wants the Hearing Officer to develop a document on which parents might either consent to or dissent from implementation of components of their child's IEP. Special Education Hearing Officers resolve disputes between parties; they do not instruct districts on how to draft their documents.
In any event, STUDENT's representatives have not produced evidence establishing that PARENT has a learning disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
5. Shall the District comply with 56506(d) in writing as part of IEP document? How must District comply? Shall the District require parent to inform District of "all" options public and non- public, or shall, instead, District take responsibility for knowing and informing parent of "all" options.
Education Code section 56506(d) states that the District must extend to parents,
[the] right to participate in the development of the individualized education program and to be informed of the availability under state and federal law of free appropriate public education and all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic.
This section does not require that the IEP document list "all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic." However, 34 C.F.R. section 300.346 and Education Code section 56345 detail what an IEP must contain. Nothing in these sections requires a District to list all public and nonpublic program options in the IEP document. For this reason, the Hearing Officer will not require the District to list all public and nonpublic program options in STUDENT's IEP document.
However, Education Code section 56506(d) clearly obligates the District to inform parents of "all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic." In this case, STUDENT has produced no evidence which established that the District has failed to properly inform his parent.
To the contrary, STUDENT' proposed IEP reveals that the members of his IEP team indicated in writing that it considered various instructional programs for him, including regular education, nonpublic school, special day class, and resource specialist program.(Footnote 15)
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
6. Shall the District comply with 56345 (Petitioner emphasizes 56345(b)(3); (b)(5); (d)), in writing as part of IEP document? How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District comply?
Education Code Sections 56345(b)(3), (b)(5), and (d) state, (b) When appropriate, the individualized education program shall also include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(3) For pupils in grades 7 through 12, inclusive, any alternative means and modes necessary for the pupil to complete the district's prescribed course of study to meet or exceed proficiency standards in accordance with Section 51215.
(5) Extended school year services when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team.
(d) Pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 51215, a pupil's individualized education program shall also include the determination of the individualized education program team as to as to whether differential proficiency standards shall be developed for the pupil. If differential proficiency standards are to be developed, the individualized education program shall include these standards.
When the District drafted the proposed IEP, STUDENT was in the fifth grade; therefore, subsection (b)(3) is not relevant to this proceeding.
Additionally, STUDENT's representatives produced no evidence establishing that STUDENT requires extended school year services. Moreover, Ms. Thompson testified that STUDENT's IEP team that he did not need such services.
Finally, STUDENT's proposed IEP lacks the determination of his IEP team as to "whether differential proficiency standards shall be developed." Courts have disagreed as to whether procedural deficiencies in an IEP will invalidate an IEP that appears adequate in spite of the error. However, in general, courts have found that rigid "adherence to a laundry list of items «is not paramount." W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F. 2d 1479,1484 (9th Cir. 1990.) With this sub-issue, STUDENT has raised no serious challenge to the adequacy of the District's proposed IEP. Instead, he has pointed out a procedural flaw which has no demonstrated impact on his ability to obtain a FAPE. Therefore, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
5. Shall the District comply with 56342 (Petitioner emphasizes the matter of "transportation"). How shall District comply? Must that parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
Aside from stating this issue, STUDENT's representatives have not alleged that the District has failed to comply with this section of the Education Code. Furthermore, STUDENT's representatives have presented no evidence that establishes that he requires transportation, or that the District has deprived him of required transportation services. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
9. Shall the District supply all documents fro parent in both English and Spanish?
The record contains no evidence establishing that the District has failed to provide PARENT with documents written in either English or Spanish.
Education Code section 56505 (a) extends the parent the right to receive "written notice«of his or her rights«in the primary language of the parent." Because Petitioner has not proven or even alleged that the District failed to comply with relevant portions of the Education Code with respect to the provision of documents in English and Spanish on this issue.
10. Did the District provide STUDENT with the opportunity to develop an appropriate assessment plan in response to the referral for assessment?
The evidence establishes that the District afforded STUDENT's representative the opportunity to participate in the development of an appropriate assessment plan. For example, the request for assessment dated May 21, 1996, specifically directed the District to use Lindamood-Bell assessment instruments and "encouraged" the District to confer with STUDENT's teacher.(Footnote 16) The proposed assessment plan indicates that the District considered STUDENT's preferences by offering a Lindamood-Bell assessment, and by including STUDENT's teacher in the SST(Footnote 17) Ms. Gorman's testimony establishes that the District also invited PARENT to participate in the creation of STUDENT's assessment plan, but she declined to do so.
Furthermore, the District developed the proposed assessment plan in a timely manner. In relevant part, Education Code section 56321(a) states:
Whenever an assessment for the development or revision of the individualized education program is to be conducted, the parent of the pupil shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of referral for assessment«
By letter dated May 21, 1996,(Footnote 18) Ms. Drew requested that the District assess STUDENT and mail "a legible and specific Assessment Plan«to myself." Ms. Gorman's credible testimony establishes that the District responded to this request by scheduling an SST meeting at which the members developed a proposed assessment plan and by mailing the plan to Ms. Drew by June 4, 1996. (Footnote 19) Fewer that 15 days passed between the date that Ms. Drew requested the assessment and the date she should have received the proposed assessment plan. For the above stated reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District responded to the referral for assessment in an appropriate and timely manner.
11. Was an assessment plan consented to on behalf of STUDENT?
Education Code section 56321(c) prevents a district from assessing a student without the written consent of the parent. The assessment plan at issue was consented to by Ms. Drew on June 7, 1996. District witnesses, including Ms. Thompson, testified that PARENT authorized Ms. Drew to sign all documents relating to STUDENT's education.
Furthermore, neither PARENT nor Ms. Drew disputes that Ms. Drew has the authority to consent to the assessment plan that the District created for STUDENT. During the hearing, Ms. Drew asserted in the presence of PARENT that she was authorized to sign all documents related to STUDENT's education. PARENT did not contradict this assertion. Furthermore, the May 21, 1996 letter from Ms. Drew that requested the assessment states:
Please note the District should already have on file documents signed by parent naming myself, R.A. Drew, signator regarding all matter between District and this family.(Footnote 20)
The evidence establishes that Ms. Drew was authorized to consent to the assessment that the District conducted; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
12. Did the District properly assess STUDENT?
In the relevant part, Education Code section 56320 states that "before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with special needs," an assessment conducted in accordance with the following subjection must be completed:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purpose of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory.
(b) Test and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil's primary language,«unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are nor clearly feasible. (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered test of intellectual or emotional functioning shall by administered by a credentialed school psychologist. (a) Tests and other assessment materials include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those which are designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient.
(b) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.
(c) The pupil is assessed in all areas of suspected disability«
Taking each requirement individually, the Hearing Officer will determine whether the District's assessment of STUDENT complies with the above-cited section. First, both Dr. Saunders' report and testimony indicate that the District selected and administered assessment materials "so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory." Dr. Saunders' report states, "due to language, culture, or experience, the exclusive use of standardized tests or normative data is considered in valid for [STUDENT] at this time." Therefore, the District relied upon a combination of standardized tests, teacher interviews, observation, and informal evaluations to assess STUDENT. (Footnote 21)
Second, the assessment plan identifies STUDENT's primary languages as both Spanish and English. (Footnote 22) Although the District conducted more of STUDENT's assessment in English tan in Spanish, the Hearing Officer does not find that the use of English language assessment tools renders the assessment inappropriate. Both Ms. Goss and Dr. Saunders testified that STUDENT is able to communicate and receive instructions in English. In fact, Dr. Saunders stated that STUDENT functions at a higher academic level in English than in Spanish and reported that his "Spanish reading achievement on the Bateria was below test norms, less that one percentile."(Footnote 23) For this reason, the Hearing Officer finds that conducting STUDENT's assessment in English rather than Spanish would likely yield a more accurate picture of his abilities and is appropriate under these circumstances.
Third, the Hearing Officer takes official notice that the assessment materials on which the District relied, including the WAIT and the Woodcock reading mastery, were "validated for the specific purpose for which they were used."(Footnote 24) For this reason, Hearing Officer finds that the District's assessment materials satisfy the requirements of subsection (2).
Fourth, the testimony of both Dr. Saunders and Ms. Steverson regarding the instruments on which they relied and their own education and training established that their credentials and conduct satisfy the mandates of subsection (3).
With respect to subsection (c)(e) and (f), the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Saunders' report expressly states that the District relied upon "information acquired through formal and informal tests interviews, observations and reports" rather that assessment materials "designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient" to determine STUDENT's cognitive ability. Therefore, the District complied with subsection (c). Ms. Steverson's testimony that she administered various tests, such as the LAC, WRAT, and Woodcock word mastery, to help determine the appropriate program for STUDENT establishes that the District complied with subsection (e). Finally the District's evidence establishes that STUDENT underwent academic testing in reading, mathematics, and written expression.(Footnote 25) Furthermore, Dr. Saunders testimony and report indicate that the District informally assessed STUDENT's suspected attention deficits.(Footnote 26)
Therefore, for all of the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly assessed STUDENT.
13. Did the District conduct a timely and appropriate IEP team meeting for STUDENT?
a. Was the IEP team meeting timely?
Education Code section 56344 sets forth the time line for the development an IEP assessment is based on an assessment. In relevant part, this section states that the IEP must be created, within 30 days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year as determined by each district's school calendar for each pupil for whom a referral has been made 20 days or less prior to the end of the regular school year. In the case of pupil school vacations, the 50-day time shall recommence on the day schooldays reconvene.
In this case, the District received STUDENT's signed consent for assessment on June 10, 1997. (Footnote 27) Ms. Thompson's testimony establishes that the 1995-96 school year ended ten days later, on June 20, 1996, and that the first day of the 1996-97 school year occurred on September 5, 1997. Under these circumstances, this section obligated the District to have completed STUDENT's IEP by approximately October 5, 1997, but it was not completed until January 23, 1997.
The testimony of Ms. Sightler and Ms. Gorman establishes that the District repeatedly postponed STUDENT's IEP team meeting to enable PARENT and Ms. Drew to participate. But the District's efforts to secure the attendance of STUDENT's representatives do not relieve it of its clear statutory obligation to produce an IEP within the legal time frame. For this reason, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated the time line set forth above.
It is important to note, however, that even after the District developed STUDENT's proposed IEP, his representatives did not consent to its implementation and STUDENT remained in a regular education program. Additionally, the record contains no evidence establishing that the District's violation adversely affected STUDENT's education. For this reason, the Hearing Officer does not find that STUDENT is entitled to a remedy.
b. Was the IEP team meeting appropriate?
Both the federal and state law includes parents among the individuals who must participate in IEP team meetings, but neither provision empowers a district to compel the presence of parents. (34 CFR § 300.44 and Ed. Code § 56341(b)(3).) However, the refusal of a parent to attend an IEP team meeting does not relieve the district of its duty to provide a student with a FAPE. Therefore, 34 C.F.R. § 300.45(d) emphasizes that districts may conduct IEP team meetings when the parent is not present if the district is "unable to convince the parent that they should attend."
The record of this case reflects that although the District sent PARENT and Ms. Drew four separate written invitations to STUDENT'S IEP team meetings, telephoned both PARENT and Ms. Drew to encourage them to participate,(Footnote 28) they refused to attend even one meeting. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly conduced STUDENT's IEP team meeting without his parent or representative.
The record also reflects that, with the exception of STUDENT's parents, the District assembled a properly constituted IEP team meeting pursuant to Education Code section 56341. Witness testimony establishes that, among others, the following required team members were present: Bertha Sightler, district representative; Hope Goss, STUDENT's ten-present teacher; and Dr. Jean Saunders, assessor. Based on the forgoing, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
14. Has the District offered STUDENT an educational program which will provide an appropriate education?
According to 20 United States Code (U.S.C.) section 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" (FAPE) means special education and related services that conform with the student's IEP. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child« 20 U.S.C. § 1401(A)(16).)
In Board of Education of Hudson Central District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982) the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be available to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)(20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The court concluded that the IDEA does not require a student be provided with the best available services or that the services maximize the student's potential. (Rowley, supra, at pp. 203-204.)
Therefore, to determine whether the District has offered STUDENT an IEP that will provide him with a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will consider the following questions: (1) do the offered special education and related services comply with those stated in STUDENT's proposed IEP, (2) are the special education and related services designed to meet STUDENT's unique educational needs, and (3) is STUDENT's proposed IEP reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?
The District's IEP proposes to place STUDENT in a regular education class and provide him with special education services through ninety minutes of daily participation in RSP. STUDENT's proposed IEP indicates that the RSP teacher would assist him in reading, mathematics, and written expression in his regular education classroom, in a small-group setting or in a combination of both settings. Witness testimony establishes that the District stands ready to provide what it proposed in STUDENT's IEP; therefore, the District's proposed IEP satisfies the first element of an appropriate placement.
The Hearing Officer next turns to the question of whether the District's proposed placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique educational needs. The assessment team discovered that STUDENT has severe deficits in the areas of reading, mathematics, and written expression.(Footnote 29) Dr. Saunders also testifies that STUDENT suffered from an "information processing disorder in attention processes." Each of the goals and objectives in STUDENT's proposed IEP are designed to address his deficit areas, and witness testimony establishes that members of his IEP team considered them appropriate.
There was some variance, however, with respect to how much time STUDENT should spend in his special education placement. Mrs. Marrs' written statement endorses a nonpublic SDC placement for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer gives Mrs. Marrs' hearsay recommendation little weight because STUDENT's representative did not establish that Mrs. Marrs' has the training, education, and personal knowledge of either STUDENT or the proposed nonpublic placement to offer reliable evidence.
Ms. Goss suggested that STUDENT should receive more than ninety minutes of special education each day, but did not recommend a more restrictive SDC placement for him or specify precisely how much additional time in special education STUDENT requires. Therefore, the Hearing Officer reminds the members of STUDENT's IEP team that if STUDENT appears to need more time in special education, the team can and should reconvene to determine what level of services is appropriate for him. Finally, the proposed placement must provide STUDENT with educational benefit. While it is difficult to predict whether a student will benefit from a placement in which he has not yet participated, the evidence strongly suggest that STUDENT will receive educational benefit from District's proposed placement. The testimony of both Dr. Saunders and Ms. Goss establishes that STUDENT requires either individualized or small-group instruction to benefit from his education. Additionally, a review of the record leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that provision of RSP instruction through "pull out for small group instruction for the specified time" will provide STUDENT with the type of instruction that he requires in his areas of deficit.
For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed IEP is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Because STUDENT's proposed IEP satisfies the requirement of statutory and decisional special education law, Hearing Officer finds that the District has developed an IEP that is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education.
Proposed relief
1. We propose the District provide, at District expense, a local experienced in Special Education advocacy, to act on parent's behalf; a person or office that both parent and District can agree is best suited to this task.
STUDENT's representative cited no legal authority that entitles STUDENT to the remedy that he proposes. For this reason, the request for the provision of an advocate at District's expense is denied.
2. In a secondary proposal, in the event Hearing Officer fins the first proposal inadequate, we propose the Hearing Officer give the District clear and specific instructions re the IEP process in STUDENT's case.
The Hearing Officer cannot determine precisely what STUDENT's representative proposes here. In any event, STUDENT's representative has failed to establish that the District has not complied with the process of developing and IEP in this case. For this reason, the request for "instruction re the IEP process" is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Educational Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: With the exception of issue 13a, the District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).
ORDER
1. All STUDENT's requests for relief are denied.
2. The District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT.
3. The District developed an appropriate IEP for STUDENT.
4. When the 1997-98 school year begins, the District is ordered to implement the IEP that it developed for STUDENT by providing him with regular education and ninety minutes of daily RSP small- group instruction.
DATED: July 30, 1997 ______________________________ Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
Footnote 1: On May 21 and 22, 1997, the District request that the Hearing Officer strike the testimony of Mrs. Marrs and PARENT because Ms. Drew called Mrs. Marrs and PARENT to testify on STUDENT's behalf but did not make them available for the District to cross-examine. On May 22, 1997, STUDENT did not oppose the District's motion to strike and the Hearing Officer granted the District's request. Because Mrs. Marrs' testimony was stricken, it will not be considered. On May 23, 1997, the District renewed its motion to strike PARENT's testimony. Because Ms. Drew did not make PARENT available to either completed her direct testimony or be cross-examined, the Hearing Officer also strikes PARENT's testimony. Footnote 2: By the closing of the record, Ms. Drew had not produced medical evidence in support of her request. Footnote 3: The Hearing Officer notes that, on previous occasions, PARENT excused herself from these proceedings without requesting a continuance during her absence. Footnote 4: It should be noted that under amendments to California Administrative Procedure Act, effective July 1, 1997, hearing officers and administrative law judges, including Special Education Hearing Officers, will have the authority to initiate contempt proceedings and impose fees and costs for frivolous or dilatory tactics. Government Code section 11455.10-11455.30. Conduct that disrupts hearings or demonstrates disrespect for the hearing process will be subject to sanctions in the future. Footnote 5: Ms. Drew stated these issues in her letter of March 14, 1997. Footnote 6: Petitioner's Exhibit (Pet. Ex.) 1, at p. 4. Footnote 7: Ms. Akers asserted that she is "fluent in Spanish" and "can understand when a translator is not exactly translating what is going on in a conversation." Footnote 8: Resp. Ex. 2. Footnote 9: Resp. Ex. 3. Footnote 10: Resp. Ex. 10 at p. 9. Footnote 11: Ms. Goss states that she and PARENT sometimes communicated through District interpreter, and sometimes communicated in English. Footnote 12: "In an agency, as a court, the moving party normally has the burden of proof«that party has not only the burden of going forward, but also the burden of persuasion." (Schwartz, Administrative Law (3d ed. 1991) p. 385) With respect to issues 1-8, STUDENT, as a moving party, bears the burden of proof. With respect to issues 9-13, the District is the moving party; therefore, it bears the burden of proof. See, also Burger v. Murray County School District, 612 F. Supp. 434(N.D. Ga. 1984.) Footnote 13: Resp. Ex. 10, at p. 10. Footnote 14: Resp. Ex.1. Footnote 15: Resp. Ex. 10, at p.1. Footnote 16: Resp. Ex. 14. Footnote 17: Resp. Ex. 1, at p.1. Footnote 18: Resp. Ex. 14. Footnote 19: Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 2. Footnote 20: Resp. Ex. 14. Footnote 21: Resp. Ex. 3, at p.1. Footnote 22: Resp. Ex. 1, at 1. STUDENT's speech and language assessment report also lists Spanish and English as STUDENT's primary languages. Resp. Ex. 2, at p. 1. Footnote 23: Resp. Ex. 3, at p. 2. Footnote 24: See, Salvia and Ysseldyke, Assessment (6th ed. 1995) pp. 445-485.) Footnote 25: Resp. Ex. 5 and 3, at pp. 2-3. Footnote 26: Resp. Ex. 3, at p. 4. Footnote 27: Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 28: Resp. Ex 4, 7, 8, and 9 reveal that PARENT's invitations were written in Spanish and Ms. Drew's were written in English. Footnote 29: Resp. Ex. 3 and 5.
