California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 7, 2001

Student v. Perris Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1396-00, SN 1503-00 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Perris Union High School District prevails: Hearing Officer finds a 15-year-old student socially maladjusted, not eligible as emotionally disturbed.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The District's own case (SN 1503-00, seeking to assess without consent) was consolidated with this case on October 2, 2000. It settled on October 4, 2000, and was dismissed by order on October 6, 2000. The student's case was continued so the District could complete its assessment.

Summary

The parents of a 15-year-old student filed for due process against Perris Union High School District. They argued that he qualified for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) from June 2000 through the 2000-2001 school year. He had never been found eligible. He had a long record of fights and suspensions. His parents had privately placed him at the Jack Weaver School, a nonpublic school, until the school exited him in October 2000. The District said his behavior reflected social maladjustment, which the ED definition excludes. The student claimed two ED criteria: an inability to keep satisfactory relationships, and inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. The Hearing Officer found that he met neither one. Teachers at Jack Weaver and at his former Menifee Opportunity Class said he had friends and got along with staff. District witnesses, including SELPA psychologist Ray Easler and Menifee psychologist Kenneth Wesson, said his aggression was planned and aimed at younger, smaller students. In their view, that showed control rather than an emotional disturbance. The Hearing Officer gave less weight to independent psychologist Mitchel Perlman, who formed his opinion before he observed the student at school or spoke with teachers. The Hearing Officer also found that the student's behavior did not significantly interfere with his learning, pointing to his A, B, and C grades. Because he was not eligible, reimbursement for the private placement and compensatory education were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO separated emotional disturbance from social maladjustment. The Hearing Officer looked at whether aggression was deliberate and targeted, whether it happened in every setting, and how it affected learning. He gave more weight to staff who saw the student at school over months than to an outside expert who saw him once.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1a. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed from June/July 2000 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year? Criterion (2): Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

    Teacher and psychologist testimony showed the student had friends and good relationships with teachers; the Hearing Officer gave more weight to Dr. Easler than to Dr. Perlman and found criterion (2) not met.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1b. Criterion (3): Does STUDENT exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations?

    The student's aggression was controlled, planned, and aimed at younger, smaller students. It reflected social maladjustment within the normal range, not an emotional disturbance, and it did not significantly interfere with learning.

  3. Issue 2. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private placement they procured for Petitioner for the period June 2000 through October 2000?

    Reimbursement denied because the student is not eligible for special education.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period June 2000 through the end of the 2000-01 school year?

    Compensatory education denied because the student is not eligible for special education.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3086(b)(2)

People named in the decision

  • Mitchel D. Perlman, Ph.D., clinical forensic psychologist; independent psychoeducational assessor and expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Jessica Blank, teacher, Jack Weaver School
  • Mike Brown, Ph.D., director of education; witness for District, Oak Grove Institute, Jack Weaver School
  • Michael Hendrick, District psychologist, Perris Union High School District
  • Ray C. Easler, Ph.D., coordinator/psychologist; conducted District assessment; witness for District, Riverside County SELPA
  • Jerry Hearing, math and science teacher, Jack Weaver School
  • William Malone, Opportunity Class teacher, Menifee Valley Middle School, Menifee Union School District
  • Kenneth Wesson, Ph.D., school psychologist, Menifee Union School District
  • Sherryle Wilkins, registrar, Choice 2000 Charter School, Perris Union High School District
  • Barbara Naples, coordinator for special education, Perris Union High School District
  • Laura Bent, teacher, Jack Weaver School
  • Rupal Doshi Wilcox, M.A., AB 2726 mental health assessor, Riverside County Department of Mental Health, Perris Mental Health Clinic
  • Maher Kozman, M.D., attending psychiatrist, Canyon Ridge Hospital
  • Dr. Nanadiego, treating psychiatrist, Canyon Crest Mental Health
  • Tasha Arneson, Ph.D., clinical director, Jack Weaver School
  • Mr. Anderson, teacher, Menifee Union School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Perris, California, on October 3, 2000, on January 4, 25, and 26, 2001, March 5, 2001, and April 17, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner) was represented by attorney Joyce Sweet. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS.

Respondent Perris Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Jack B. Clarke, Jr. Also present on some hearing dates were attorneys Maria E. Gless and Christina Henry. Also present on the District’s behalf on some hearing dates were Barbara Naples, the District’s coordinator for special education, and Michael Hendrick, District psychologist.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mitchel D. Perlman, Ph.D., clinical forensic psychologist; PARENT, mother of Petitioner; and Ms. Jessica Blank, a teacher at the Jack Weaver School.

Respondent District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mike Brown, Ph.D., director of education at the Oak Grove Institute, Jack Weaver School; Michael Hendrick, District psychologist; Ray C. Easler, Ph.D., coordinator/psychologist for Riverside County SELPA; Mr. Jerry Hearing, a teacher at the Jack Weaver School; Mr. William Malone, a teacher within the Menifee Union School District; Kenneth Wesson, Ph.D., school psychologist for the Menifee Union School District; and Sherryle Wilkins, registrar for the District’s Choice 2000 charter school.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education and related services from June 2000 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year because of an emotional disturbance?

2. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private placement they procured for Petitioner for the period June 2000 through October 2000?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period June 2000 through the end of the 2000-01 school year?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Petitioner STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who is enrolled in a District Charter Choice 2000 computer program taken at home and does not attend class at school with his peers. He has never been found eligible for special education.

Petitioner has a history of behavioral problems dating back to the first grade (1992-1993 school year). Dr. Mitchel D. Perlman(Footnote 1) testified that kindergarten “was a good year” for STUDENT, whose teacher reported that he was hardworking and making adequate progress and was well-liked by his peers. However, in the first grade, STUDENT was warned several times for hitting and swearing on the bus.(Footnote 2) One of several bus conduct reports indicated that “STUDENT was bouncing off the walls on the way home today.” During the second grade (1993-1994 school year), STUDENT was given four bus referrals for misconduct. STUDENT’s grades were adequate with the exception of writing, and he was rated as satisfactory for academics. STUDENT was placed in a psychiatric hospital for two weeks in June 1994 and was diagnosed with ADHD and placed on Ritalin. During the third grade (1994-1995 school year), PARENT reported to the Menifee District psychologist, Kenneth Wesson, Ph.D., that STUDENT’s psychiatrist had requested an evaluation because STUDENT displayed attention and concentration problems. Dr. Wesson determined that STUDENT did not meet the DSM-IV criteria for ADD. Dr. Wesson concluded in his report that STUDENT’s most significant problem area was aggression, and found that “both teachers reported STUDENT to be physically aggressive, at times non-compliant with teacher request, and oppositional.” (Dist. Exh. 14) However, STUDENT was rated as “working well with others” in class by his teacher, and his academics were “fine,” except in handwriting. During the fourth grade (1995-1996 school year), STUDENT had inconsistent grades, and he received below satisfactory ratings in the majority of his academic areas. However, he was found by his teacher to have “great potential in school.” The teacher also stated that he “does well, then struggles,” citing homework and citizenship as areas of concern. According to Dr. Perlman, the teacher stated that STUDENT “continues to be challenged behaviorally.” However, Dr. Perlman’s report did not cite any specific instances of misconduct, and did indicate that STUDENT was “well-liked.”

During the fifth grade (1996-1997 school year), STUDENT received multiple conduct reports, and received two in-school suspensions and/or detentions. His teacher noted, however, that he was “reliable and honest and cares for others, but that his problem solving within social situations was difficult for him.” According to Dr. Perlman, STUDENT struggled in most of his academic subjects, and work completion continued to be a problem. During the sixth grade (1997-1998 school year), STUDENT was suspended three times in August for misconduct, once for choking another student. Dr. Perlman did not elaborate upon this incident, either within his report or during his testimony, and it was not indicated whether the student sustained an injury. STUDENT received a detention on August 26 for fighting, and on September 4, STUDENT was suspended for three days for racial obscenities. On September 12, STUDENT was suspended for five days after he “slapped a student on the back of his head, then twisted his arm and forced him to the ground, causing [the student] to hit his head on the black top. [STUDENT then] got another boy in a headlock and banged his head against a door.”

At the request of STUDENT’s mother, Dr. Wesson again evaluated STUDENT on September 17, 1997. PARENT reported to Dr. Wesson that STUDENT did not read at the appropriate level, displayed poor tolerance for frustration, threw temper tantrums, picked fights to get people going, was often confrontational and verbally abusive or sarcastic, and did not display appropriate guilt or anxiety. Teacher reports included that STUDENT was not conscientious about turning in his homework, that he would refuse to complete work he perceived as difficult, and that he could be confrontative and verbally abusive or sarcastic -- “especially if a goal was blocked.” Dr. Wesson was unable to complete standardized testing because STUDENT was unwilling to complete further testing. Following a “structured interview” with STUDENT and PARENT, Dr. Wesson determined that the student’s behaviors did not stem from depression. In summary, Dr. Wesson indicated that “according to reports from PARENT and STUDENT, typical behaviors associated with depression were not present and STUDENT was reported to have friendships.” Dr. Wesson concluded that the student’s “impulsive behavior appears associated with blocked goals or not getting his way.” Dr. Wesson did not find a learning disorder. (Dist. Exh. 14)

On October 7, 1997, STUDENT was suspended for a fighting incident, and by October 30, according to Dr. Perlman’s school history, STUDENT was “reportedly failing every subject except PE.”

On October 11, 1997, STUDENT was admitted to the Behavioral Medicine Center of the Loma Linda University Medical Center after assaultive behavior at home. The discharge summary indicates that STUDENT’s father reported that STUDENT struck his mother with a fireplace poker. According to the same discharge summary, STUDENT “did not appear to have any psychotic thought processes and Moban was discontinued. He was eager to please in the milieu, talking in group about events leading up to admission, and he was eager to learn in OT and RT. In school, he was quite bright, but had very poor social skills.” STUDENT was discharged on October 21, 1997, in stable condition without suicidal or homicidal ideation, psychosis, or side-effects. He was given the following discharge diagnosis: Axis I: Depressive disorder, not otherwise specified and intermittent explosive disorder. (Pet. Exh. 8) STUDENT did not attend school for approximately two months (October and November). No evidence was submitted as to how STUDENT performed academically during the remainder of STUDENT’s sixth grade school year.

During the seventh grade (1998-1999 school year), STUDENT was suspended in August for “racial slurs.” In November, STUDENT was suspended for five days based on three incidents on the same day. STUDENT was suspended once again in December for having a book of matches in his possession. On January 11, STUDENT was given a referral for disrespectful behavior toward the faculty, and on January 20, the student was suspended for two days for becoming belligerent toward another child and for disrupting class. During the month of May, STUDENT received a referral for leaving class without permission, a second referral for exhibiting poor behavior at the Wild Animal Park, a third referral for coming to class late and lying about his tardiness and for disrupting class, and a fourth referral for not being in class. STUDENT also injured another person on the bus by bending the child’s fingers backwards, and on May 18, STUDENT was suspended for three days for disrupting school activities.

STUDENT was voluntarily placed by his parents in a group home for approximately six months during the seventh grade, within what his parents at first believed was a “therapeutic setting.” His parents pulled him from the placement when they discovered that no individual or group therapy was taking place. The student’s half-brother committed suicide at a state psychiatric hospital in June 1999. (Dist. Exh.16 )

During the eighth grade (1999/2000 school year), STUDENT was twice admitted to the Canyon Ridge Psychiatric Hospital in November 1999.(Footnote 3) Following the student’s first admission, STUDENT was discharged after eight days in the following condition, according to the report by the attending psychiatrist, Maher Kozman, M.D.: “He was in a fairly stable mood. He denied any suicidal or homicidal ideations. He acknowledged appropriate ways to cope and to deal with his anger....He is motivated and will proceed with his discharge with structured school days and outpatient therapy.” Under aftercare instructions, STUDENT was to follow up with his psychiatrist, Dr. Nanadiego, and he was also to follow up with Outpatient Treatment with an individual therapist. STUDENT was referred to Canyon Ridge group therapy for adolescents, and he was discharged home with pending placement in a structured school day treatment setting. His prognosis was considered fair with continued care. STUDENT’s discharge diagnoses were ADHD and conduct disorder, Axis I; Axis II: borderline personality traits; and Axis III: mild obesity. It was noted under Axis IV that psychosocial stressors are problems with family support system and academic difficulties. (Dist. Exh. 10)

On November 24, STUDENT was readmitted to Canyon Ridge under a diagnosis of depressive disorder, not otherwise specified, after cutting himself superficially. STUDENT was found not to need treatment, other than psychiatric treatment with his psychiatrist. Under “past psychiatric history,” the psychiatric evaluation notes that STUDENT “has been receiving treatment at Canyon Crest Mental Health with Dr. Nanadiego for the last several years. He has been diagnosed with ADHD and conduct disorder.” Under Axis I, STUDENT was given an admitting diagnosis of ADHD and conduct disorder, Rule Out Mood Disorder NOS. (Dist. Exh. 12)

On December 1, 1999, Dr. Kozman, psychiatrist at Canyon Ridge Hospital, reported that “in view of [STUDENT’s] diagnosis, as outlined in his hospitalization reports, and difficulty to be managed at home with needing repeat hospitalization within few days, he will need to be placed in a residential structured therapeutic environment, where his educational needs and emotional problems can be addressed and appropriately provided for. His current diagnoses are: Conduct Disorder, ADHD, with borderline personality traits, Rule Out Mood Disorder, NOS. He is currently treated with depakote, efflexor and adderall.” (Dist. Exh. 11)

On December 10, 1999, PARENT authorized the Menifee Union School District to refer STUDENT to the Riverside County Mental Health Services for an AB 2726 (formerly AB 3632) Mental Health Assessment. The assessment authorized was for a “joint assessment to determine special education eligibility and AB 2726 services.” (Dist. Exh. 5)

On December 13, STUDENT was suspended from school for refusing to comply with an administrator’s directive and for making vulgar statements to school staff, and on December 16, the student was again suspended for attacking another student. STUDENT was hospitalized for two days at Loma Linda Hospital and was given the following discharge diagnosis: “Axis I: Mood Disorder NOS. Conduct Disorder.” (Pet. Exh. 9) According to the testimony of his mother, “he got out right before Christmas,” and his medication hadn’t changed. STUDENT was taking the following medications twice daily: topamox, seroquel, and efflexor.

On December 17, STUDENT, at the age 13 years, 11 months, was administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery - Revised (WJ-R) achievement tests. The report summary indicates that STUDENT, when compared to others at his age level, performed in the average range in Broad Reading and Broad Mathematics, and in the low average range in Broad Written Language. (Dist. Exh. 13)

On or about January 10, the requested AB2726 mental health assessment was completed at the Perris Mental Health Clinic by Rupal Doshi Wilcox, M.A., with the Riverside County Department of Mental Health. STUDENT and his mother were interviewed, and his sister was present. STUDENT was interviewed individually and with his mother and sister. The purpose of the assessment was “to determine the most appropriate mental health services” for STUDENT. STUDENT was described in the report as having been physically and verbally aggressive, truant, annoying to his peers, having problems in unstructured/unsupervised settings, and having been suspended one time for defying adult authority. The report also indicates that since his placement in the Opportunity Class for eight weeks, STUDENT had shown an ability to complete task assignments and to work independently and that “his peer interactions have been positive.” STUDENT was noted to be on the following medications: depakote, effexor, aderall, and trazadone. The consensus of the mental health staff was that STUDENT’s behaviors, such as physical assault on his family, property destruction, cruelty to animals and defiance, “can be diagnosed as a behavioral disorder.” The report concluded that “due to these factors and our overall findings, at this time STUDENT does not qualify for AB2726 services.” (Dist. Exh. 17)

On January 12, 2000, STUDENT received a bus referral for unacceptable language and was suspended for five days for refusing to stay in class, leaving campus, using abusive language toward his teacher, making threats towards another teacher, and kicking several items.

On January 20, the Menifee District IEP team met and determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education, either under SLD or under ED. (Dist. Exh. 3) The team considered the report by District psychologist Dr. Wesson, who concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for SLD or ED and that “STUDENT has a history of social maladjustment which includes a dislike for school, rebelling against authority, displaying poor frustration tolerance, a high degree of irritability, often throws temper tantrums, typically does not display appropriate guilt or anxiety, and is highly manipulative and exploitive.” Dr. Wesson’s report states as follows: “PARENT states STUDENT explodes for no apparent reason; STUDENT on the other hand reports the major conflicts that have required hospitalization occurred during severe/bitter family conflicts.” Dr. Wesson concluded that “the behaviors are not unexplainable conflicts that have occurred without reason” and that “neither PARENT nor STUDENT reported significant behaviors that are typically associated with depression.”(Dist. Exh. 14)

According to the testimony of William Malone, a credentialed teacher within the Menifee Valley Middle School, STUDENT attended the Opportunity Class for a few months in the 1999-00 school year. Mr. Malone testified that STUDENT was “quite capable academically, and all of his screening tests placed STUDENT at or above grade level in all areas.” Mr. Malone testified credibly that STUDENT “could perform quite well” and that he participated in classroom discussions and shared ideas and “for the most part” did his work. However, Mr. Malone stated that “the problem was the amount of time he wouldn’t be in school would affect him being there to receive the information.”

On February 12, 2000, STUDENT reportedly destroyed an estimated $6,100 of items at his family’s home. On February 14, PARENT requested an emergency IEP meeting with the Menifee District. On February 28, the IEP team reconvened, considered the county Mental Health information and findings and developed a new assessment plan, with home-hospital instruction to continue during the interim. According to the IEP team summary, STUDENT’s academic levels were reviewed from the Woodcock Johnson assessment conducted in December 1999, and STUDENT was found to be functioning within the average range (90's) except for dictation (80's). An assessment plan was developed for a Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) and for a referral to the L.A. Diagnostic Center for further evaluation and consideration of special education eligibility as ED. The District indicated that STUDENT could return to the Opportunity Class or continue to receive home/hospital instruction. STUDENT’s parents elected to have home/hospital instruction continue until the IEP meeting reconvened to consider eligibility. The Menifee District IEP team never reconvened. (Dist. Exh. 2 and Test. of PARENT)

In February 2000, the PARENTS unilaterally placed STUDENT at the Jack Weaver School, a certified nonpublic residential care facility. Michael Brown, Ph.D., the director of special education for the Oak Grove Institute, testified that the Jack Weaver School’s clientele are emotionally disturbed students, students with traumatic brain injuries, and those who are mentally retarded. STUDENT was the only student at the school who was not placed there through the IEP process. STUDENT received the following grades for the period ending April 6, 2000: math: B+; physical science: B; PE: A; life skills: P; English: B+. Under Comments, the teacher, Laura Bent, reports: “STUDENT has been doing well in the few weeks he has been in my class. He just started Intro to Keyboarding, which is why there is no grade. Although he has been assigned History, he has not been doing much work in it.” STUDENT received the following grades for the period ending June 15, 2000: a C in English, and comment codes of poor attendance and lack of work; a grade of C- and comment codes of poor attendance and lack of work in math, general science, and world history; a B in art; and A’s in PE and conflict resolution. (Dist. Exh. 18)

In May 2000, the PARENTS and the Menifee Union School District entered into a settlement agreement through mediation.(Footnote 4)

STUDENT attended the Jack Weaver School day class from February 2000 until October 30, 2000, when he was “exited” from the school following an assault he initiated and for which juvenile charges were filed.

On July 6, 2000, the Perris Union High School District sent Petitioner’s attorney a copy of parental rights and an assessment plan drafted by the District for Petitioner, but the Petitioner would not agree to an assessment at that time. (Dist. Exhs. 7 &8)

On August 2, 2000, the California Special Education Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorney Joyce Sweet on behalf of the Petitioner. Petitioner named the Perris Union High School District as a respondent and raised various issues regarding denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE).(Footnote 5) The Hearing Office designated the case as Case No. 1396-00.

On August 23, 2000, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorneys associated with the law firm Best Best & Krieger LLP on behalf of the District. The District requested that the Hearing Office decide that the District was entitled to conduct a psychological assessment of STUDENT. The Hearing Office designated the case as Case No. SN 1503-00. On October 2, 2000, the Hearing Office issued a minute order consolidating both cases. On September 18, 2000, the District held an “interim” IEP meeting. The IEP team summary indicates that in the area of eligibility under ED, there were three reports that did not support eligibility as ED and one report, by Dr. Perlman, that supported eligibility as ED. Michael Hendrick, the District psychologist,(Footnote 6) testified that the IEP team met for three or three and one-half hours, and that STUDENT’s parents were present and were represented by their attorney and an advocate. Mr. Hendrick stated that the team discussed Dr. Perlman’s report and thoroughly discussed all of the other assessment reports. Mr. Hendrick further stated that he reviewed the reports and concluded after a substantive analysis of the reports that STUDENT was not ED. The District offered to place STUDENT in the Paloma Valley High School, within the general education setting, but the District did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT because his parents would not consent to an assessment by the District. (Dist. Exh. 1)

STUDENT’s parents decided against enrolling STUDENT at Paloma Valley, and STUDENT continued to attend the Jack Weaver School until he was “exited” from the school. STUDENT has not returned to school, either public or private, a decision made by his parents, since leaving Jack Weaver. (Test. of PARENT)

On October 3, 2000, the consolidated cases came on for hearing before Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski, and testimony was taken from Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., who was called by the Petitioner. On October 4, the parties entered into a settlement agreement concerning the District’s Case No. SN 1503-00. Case No. 1396-00 was continued upon agreement of the parties to allow the District an opportunity to complete its assessment of STUDENT. On October 6, the Hearing Office issued an order dismissing Case No. SN 1503-00 and continuing Case No. 1396-00. The parties subsequently proceeded to hearing concerning the issues set forth above.

In January 2001, STUDENT began at home an on-line computer school program, Choice 2000 Charter School, offered by the District. STUDENT uses headphones and a microphone to maintain communication with the teacher during a two-hour class each day. STUDENT is given homework under this program. However, STUDENT has no contact with his peers or teachers other than through participation in this on-line program. (Test. of PARENT)

On January 12, 2001, Dr. Ray C. Easler(Footnote 7) completed his assessment report of STUDENT, and revised it on January 24, 2001, to include statements made by the PARENTS at the IEP team meeting held on January 16, 2001. Dr. Ray Easler reported his findings and his conclusion that STUDENT did not meet the criteria for ED.

On January 16, 2001, the District’s IEP team met to discuss the findings of the assessments conducted by the District. The IEP team found that Petitioner was not eligible for special education and related services as a student with an emotional disturbance.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Is STUDENT eligible for special education and related services as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) from July 2000, through the end of the school year 2000-2001 because of an emotional disturbance?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d) (1997) (formerly found at 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(1997) (formerly found at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A)). A student is eligible for special education and services when, as a result of the student’s disability, the student requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal.Educ.Code § 56026(a) and (b).

Emotional Disturbance (ED) Eligibility Criteria(Footnote 8)

Emotional disturbance (ED) is defined as a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a student’s educational performance:

(1) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression;

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i). The term ED does not apply to a child who is socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that he also has an ED. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii).

Petitioner contends that he qualifies for special education and related services as ED under criterion (2), an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, and under criterion (3), inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. Criteria (1), (4) and (5) will not be analyzed, since the Petitioner states that he does not meet ED eligibility requirements under those criteria. Moreover, Dr. Perlman, who testified on behalf of Petitioner, stated that in his opinion the Petitioner did not meet the criteria for ED under paragraphs (1), (4), and (5).

(1) Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

Petitioner contends that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. The District contends that Petitioner is well-liked by students and teachers, and is able to maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers.

Petitioner’s mother testified that STUDENT has not brought home friends from school from June 2000 to the present, and that STUDENT has no friends. However, Petitioner’s mother also testified that STUDENT engages in computer chat room activities with individuals he knows when he is at home working on the Choice 2000 computer school program. STUDENT’s mother also acknowledged that STUDENT attends a church youth group every Wednesday night and attends group therapy each Saturday. Moreover, PARENT testified that STUDENT “gets along with” his twin sister. PARENT did not provide testimony concerning any observations she may have made of STUDENT interacting with peers and teachers at school.

Notwithstanding STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties as outlined above, STUDENT was described by both his kindergarten and fourth-grade teachers as “well-liked by his peers,” and his third-grade teacher described him as “working well with others.” His fifth-grade teacher stated that STUDENT was “reliable and honest” and that he “cares for others,” although problem solving within “social situations” was difficult for him. These comments suggest that STUDENT has shown the ability to form satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers.

Mr. Jerry Hearing, a credentialed math and science teacher at the Jack Weaver School with over fifteen years’ experience teaching “difficult” students, testified that he taught STUDENT over a period of two or three months during fall 2000, for five hours per day, five days per week. Mr. Hearing described STUDENT as a good student and not a behavioral problem. Mr. Hearing testified credibly that STUDENT “had friends in the class” and that “they would leave the room together,” although STUDENT did not sit with them in class, but sat “by the door isolated.” Mr. Hearing further stated that STUDENT “would play chess or checkers” with friends and did not get into fights while playing games. Mr. Hearing also testified that he had a good relationship with STUDENT, and that “he was rarely defiant or belligerent. He was very polite. He took criticism well and asked for help.” Mr. Hearing also completed teacher rating scales on STUDENT at the request of Dr. Easler. The findings are within Dr. Easler’s report. (Dist. Exh. 20) On the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) Teacher Report, Mr. Hearing found STUDENT to be in the average range under Adaptive Skills Scores, with average range scores for study skills, social skills, and leadership.

Ms. Jessica Blank, a teacher with five years’ experience teaching in day programs, and ten or eleven months of teaching experience at the Jack Weaver School, testified that she taught STUDENT over a six-week period at Jack Weaver during the summer 2000. Ms. Blank stated that STUDENT was “quiet and kept to himself” and that he “asked for help when he needed it.” Ms. Blank credibly testified that STUDENT “had a couple of friends during group projects and lunch,” but she did not know if STUDENT had friends outside of school. In response to the question, “did you get along with him?” Ms. Blank replied, “for the most part.”

Mr. William Malone, Opportunity Class teacher at the Menifee Valley Middle School of the Menifee Union School District, testified that he has taught at Menifee for two years and has a master’s degree in education. Mr. Malone stated that he taught STUDENT in the Opportunity Class for a few months in the year 2000, and that the class consisted primarily of seventh- and eighth-grade students. Mr. Malone stated that STUDENT’s relationships with peers in the classroom varied “from one extreme to the other.” At times he would get angry about something and would react inappropriately, but most of the time “he got along fine.” Mr. Malone credibly testified that STUDENT was friendly with students during and after school and that Mr. Malone quite often had to ask STUDENT and his friends to leave the school grounds after they had been released from class. Mr. Malone testified credibly that STUDENT participated in a “clique” of friends at school, that he saw them together outside of class, and that some of his friends were not members of the Opportunity Class. In regard to a female member of the class, Mr. Malone recalled that STUDENT was “adamant about standing up for her and protecting her because she is his friend” and “friends don’t let other friends get in trouble even if that means taking the fall for them.” Mr. Malone stated that these comments by STUDENT stemmed from an incident in which “they were on campus and shouldn’t have been.” Mr. Malone added that STUDENT “hung out with” the same people for the time Mr. Malone taught STUDENT and after STUDENT was no longer in attendance at Menifee.

Dr. Kenneth J. Wesson testified that he assessed STUDENT for the Menifee District, and issued his report, as corrected on January 25, 2000.(Footnote9) (Dist. Exh. 14) Dr. Wesson found that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for ED. Dr. Wesson testified that he observed STUDENT on many occasions over a four- or five-year period in the school setting (third grade through seventh and parts of the eighth grade), once or twice a month in the classroom and on the playground. On several occasions Dr. Wesson saw STUDENT interact with peers on the playground and in the classroom with teachers or peers. “I would run into STUDENT on the playground....I would sit next to STUDENT in the classroom [while making observations of students]. “When I was completing this last assessment [during STUDENT’s eighth grade], STUDENT had a girlfriend, and he had friends on the playground all of the time I knew him. At no time did I see STUDENT display symptoms of depression.” In regard to interactions with teachers, Dr. Wesson testified that STUDENT “really liked Mr. Anderson, and he would comply with Mr. Anderson’s requests. At times, STUDENT would get upset if his goal was blocked by a teacher. He would get upset and he would not complete the classroom work, but if STUDENT liked you, he would tend to do everything you asked of him.” Dr. Wesson stated that he even played chess with STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Perlman states within his report that “with few exceptions,” STUDENT has demonstrated an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. However, when Dr. Perlman first testified, he said that he did not interview any of STUDENT’s teachers and that he did not speak with Dr. Wesson. Further, Dr. Perlman himself, during his assessment of STUDENT, found STUDENT to be “fun to be with” and “humorous, spontaneous, and somewhat engaging.” Dr. Perlman observed that “never once did he complain, and he never once displayed negativity.” (Dist. Exh. 16). Dr. Perlman acknowledged that STUDENT has had friends at various times, but that he cannot interact with people “in a meaningful way, close or distant” and that the relationships “cannot be sustained over time.” Dr. Perlman also stated that “nobody likes” STUDENT and that “he has no friends and he is antagonistic [and] irritates and intimidates everyone.” In fact, Dr. Perlman’s testimony was contradicted by the testimony of teachers who have worked with STUDENT and who have stated that they “like” STUDENT, and who have both seen STUDENT form relationships with friends at school for periods of time, and, who have, themselves, formed satisfactory relationships with STUDENT.

Dr. Easler’s findings and conclusion that STUDENT is not ED under this criterion must be given greater weight than Dr. Perlman’s conclusion. Dr. Easler prepared his report after he had visited the Jack Weaver School, and after he had seen STUDENT in the classroom setting, and interviewed teachers and administrators. Dr. Perlman made a single, two-hour visit to the Jack Weaver School, on October 2, 2000, the day before Dr. Perlman first testified at the due process hearing. Moreover, Dr. Perlman noted that on this occasion STUDENT acted appropriately, on the playground and in the classroom. Therefore, STUDENT did nothing in Dr. Perlman’s presence that would substantiate the contention that STUDENT meets eligibility criterion (2) above. .

The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of the teachers from the Jack Weaver School and Menifee shows that STUDENT is able to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. According, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teacher and therefore does not meet criterion (2) for ED.

2) Does STUDENT exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations?

The Petitioner contends that he exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations that support an ED eligibility determination under this criterion. The District contends that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feeling under normal circumstances in several situations, and that STUDENT’s behavioral problems reflect social maladjustment and not an emotional disturbance, and therefore do not support an ED eligibility determination under this criterion.

The Petitioner relied primarily upon the testimony of Dr. Perlman, and limited testimony from PARENT and Jessica Blank (a teacher at the Jack Weaver school), in addition to cross-examination of District witnesses, as evidence that Petitioner meets this criterion. Petitioner did not call as a witness STUDENT’s father, PARENT, even though PARENT attended each day of the due process hearing. Petitioner also did not call as witnesses any of the psychiatrists and/or therapists who have diagnosed and/or treated STUDENT.

In his testimony, Dr. Perlman cited the following as inappropriate types of behavior or feelings experienced by STUDENT : “low tolerance to frustration”; “very poor excessively low self-confidence”; “euphoria or dysphoria -- not seeming to have any particular trigger -- and the behaviors that come from that: the aggression, the obnoxiousness, even some of the incorrigibility, some of his putting some of the other kids in chokeholds.” Dr. Perlman also cited the fact that STUDENT “pounded on kids”; “he shuts down [and is] uncooperative... a small thing can happen and get under his skin easily and he’ll shut down. If then pressed to perform he can be provoked into rage.” Dr. Perlman stated that he considered STUDENT to be “bipolar II,” a subcategory of the classic bipolar diagnosis, since STUDENT lacked classic psychotic symptoms or “very manicky,” “very euphoric,” or “intermittent explosive” behavior.(Footnote 10) Dr. Perlman characterized STUDENT as “hypomanic,” just below being manic, and described STUDENT’s behavior as one of rage, anger, and intensity. While Dr. Perlman acknowledged that STUDENT also has oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), Dr. Perlman stated that the ODD did not explain all of STUDENT’s behavior. For example, Dr. Perlman stated that STUDENT’s “the whole world revolves around [me]” attitude is “not just ODD.”

Petitioner also relied on the following testimony as support for STUDENT’s eligibility as ED under this criterion: Mr. Hearing’s testimony that STUDENT would “pace” and was “quiet and agitated,” and the fact that Mr. Hearing “did not know what precipitated STUDENT’s behaviors”; Mr. Hearing’s testimony that STUDENT “lashed out at whomever...would go into a rage and lose control”; Ms. Blank’s statement that STUDENT once “threw a desk” and that STUDENT “would get up and pace and go outside” and would “all of a sudden start rocking”; and Mr. Malone’s testimony that STUDENT would “get along fine most of the time and then react inappropriately” hat STUDENT would “get angry and then apologize,” and that he had “lots of problems outside of the classroom.” Petitioner also cites STUDENT’s disciplinary records dating back to the first grade and contends that STUDENT’s behavior at home “has been highly inappropriate,” citing unspecified testimony by his mother to a “long history of out of control behaviors.”

The District relied primarily upon the testimony of Dr. Easler, Dr. Brown, Dr. Wesson, Mr. Hearing, and Mr. Malone, and its cross-examination of the witnesses called by the Petitioner, as evidence that Petitioner does not meet this criterion.

In his testimony, Dr. Easler stated that “while STUDENT exhibited difficulties throughout his school career,” it was his professional opinion that these difficulties “were not to the extent of those [who] typically receive services as emotionally disturbed [students].” Dr. Easler noted that STUDENT’s behavior was “not outside of the types of behavior that normally functioning students manifest.” Dr. Easler added that “it doesn’t mean that they all do it to that extent, but it means that it falls within that range.” Dr. Easler added that ED students “frequently manifest inappropriate behaviors and get into trouble on a daily or a weekly basis” and that those behaviors are “to a great extent...outside of their ability to control.” Dr. Easler further stated that students who are acting out in school and are not ED oftentimes engage in behaviors that are “purposeful, planned, [and] goal-directed,” and that control and the ability to control one’s behavior is the feature STUDENT has which distinguishes him from students who are ED.

According to Dr. Easler, students who are “behaviorally disordered - socially maladjusted” often act out in ways of hurting others as a means to the end, and students who meet eligibility criteria as ED often act out on themselves, injure themselves, as the means to the end, rather than injure other people. Dr. Easler testified that STUDENT targets younger or physically smaller students, and that STUDENT is able to plan and control his attacks, whereas ED students act randomly and when, out of control, flail out striking the student or other individual nearest to them.

Dr. Easler further noted that all five psychiatric hospitalizations for STUDENT had occurred from the home setting, and not from school. Dr. Easler observed that “it is typical for students who meet the eligibility criteria [for] ED that are psychiatrically hospitalized, that they are “5150'd”(Footnote 11) from the school setting because the behaviors are occurring at school.” The record indicates that STUDENT was given the diagnosis of conduct disorder and ADHD for the two Canyon Ridge psychiatric hospitalizations in 1999, and that in January 2000, the Riverside County Mental Health Assessment (AB2726) determined that STUDENT could be diagnosed as having a “behavioral disorder” and did not qualify for AB 2726 services.

Also testifying with respect to STUDENT’s behavior in the school setting was Dr. Mike Brown.(Footnote 12) Dr. Brown is the director of education at the Oak Grove Institute, Jack Weaver School, a certified, nonpublic school that provides special education services, primarily to ED students. Dr. Brown stated that he had observed STUDENT “dozens of times” “in and out of class at Jack Weaver over a period of eight or nine months” at least “once or twice every day.” In Dr. Brown’s opinion, students classified as ED are generally silent, sullen, impulsive. Dr. Brown stated that STUDENT is not “sullen or impulsive,” but acknowledged that STUDENT is “quiet” Dr. Brown stated that ED student, when assaultive or aggressive, lashed out at anyone or everyone in the environment. Further, in Dr. Brown’s experience, ED students show some type of remorse for their actions and may come back and process with a therapist or a teacher over the issue. Dr. Brown stated that STUDENT did not do this after his assaultive behavior and was not remorseful. Moreover, Dr. Brown testified that STUDENT said that he was going to do it again because in effect “I want to.” STUDENT would then use a few expletives and would state, “I am not done yet.” Dr. Brown testified that the Jack Weaver staff knew when STUDENT would become assaultive, which was not, according to Dr. Brown, a regular occurrence, and that STUDENT would tell staff members that he intended to attack younger students and then would engage in the very behavior he had predicted. Dr. Brown stated that, in his opinion, STUDENT did not appear to be out of control because STUDENT on more than one occasion did what he said he was going to do. In response to the question, “did other students who had been classified as ED make such predictions? ” Dr. Brown answered, “rarely.”

Dr. Wesson testified that on a couple of occasions he saw STUDENT display aggression towards other students while at Menifee, but never students his size or bigger. “They were younger kids, much, much younger and much smaller than STUDENT. He would threaten them if he didn’t get his way...My overall impression was that he was a socially maladjusted child. I like STUDENT. STUDENT always did things for me. I truly never had a problem. I would spend time with him simply because I liked him. It’s just that if his goal was blocked, he would get upset, and he would react, but if you didn’t block his goal, he functioned very well.”

Mr. Hearing, a Jack Weaver School teacher, testified that when STUDENT seemed a little agitated, he would rock in his seat or pace, and that he didn’t know what precipitated the final eruption [that led to STUDENT’s exit from Jack Weaver), but that STUDENT “seemed to know what he was doing.” Mr. Hearing said that during the final event, STUDENT denied having his hands around the student’s neck. When asked, “did you realize that you were strangling the kid?” STUDENT said that he had grabbed the other student by the shoulder.(Footnote 13) The other student was nine years old, according to Mr. Hearing, who described STUDENT as “big, about 5' 10"/11" tall, and weighing approximately 260 or 270 pounds.” Mr. Hearing contrasted the behavior to ED students who would lash out at whoever happened to be by. Mr. Hearing stated that it seemed STUDENT “almost had his eye on” someone, over a period of time, and that he would lash out at that person, not always the same person, but not the persons closer to him physically. “It wasn’t the person nearby,” Mr. Hearing stated.

Based upon the documentary and testimonial evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances which would satisfy this criterion for ED eligibility. The Hearing Officer draws this conclusion for the reasons set forth below.

The Hearing Officer does not find the testimony of Dr. Perlman to be persuasive. Although Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT is ED, Dr. Perlman reached his conclusion, in April 2000, without direct information about how STUDENT was functioning in the school setting. Dr. Perlman had already formulated his conclusions before he ever visited the Jack Weaver School and before he had interviewed any teachers or staff members. Dr. Perlman also acknowledged that he had never contacted Dr. Wesson, the Menifee school psychologist who had found STUDENT not eligible for special education as ED or SLD in February 2000, and who had previously found STUDENT not eligible for special education in two prior evaluations. Nor did Dr. Perlman attend, either in person or by telephone, the District’s interim September 18, 2000 IEP meeting to discuss his assessment of STUDENT. It was only on the day before he first testified that Dr. Perlman, on October 3, 2000, first visited the Jack Weaver School and observed STUDENT in the classroom setting and on the playground. Dr. Perlman did not revise his report to include these observations (Dr. Perlman stated that STUDENT, in effect, had acted appropriately and the teacher had led the class appropriately). During his testimony, Dr. Perlman referred to a “detailed incident file” that he “picked up yesterday” from Jack Weaver, but the record was not offered into evidence. Dr. Perlman also acknowledged that at the time he made his observation of STUDENT in the classroom, the number of students, five or six, with three teachers in the room, did not represent STUDENT’s behavior “under normal circumstances.” Furthermore, Dr. Perlman stated that he did not contact STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist, nor was evidence presented that Dr. Perlman ever contacted any therapists or any other psychologists or psychiatrists who evaluated or treated STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer also notes that Dr. Perlman’s description of inappropriate behaviors was general and abstract. Many of the examples cited by Dr. Perlman as evidence of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings experienced by STUDENT -- “low tolerance to frustration,” “very poor excessively low self-confidence,” “aggression,” “obnoxiousness,” “incorrigibility,” “euphoria or dysphoria - not seeming to have any particular trigger,” and “provoked into rage if pressed to perform” -- are vague and are not linked to specific behavioral incidents. Although Dr. Perlman referred in his school history to a “choking incident,” and a “headlock” incident in the sixth grade, it is not clear from the record under what circumstances these incidents occurred. Thus, it is impossible to judge whether the behaviors were inappropriate in light of the circumstances. Dr. Perlman’s testimony stating that STUDENT engaged in “pounding” other students is also not mentioned in the school history prepared by Dr. Perlman, and appears to be an exaggeration. The testimony and the school history do not support Dr. Perlman’s characterization that STUDENT expresses “rage” within the school setting, and appears to be limited to the testimony of Mr. Hearing regarding a single incident at Jack Weaver. The Hearing Officer also notes that many of the reported behavioral incidents cited by Dr. Perlman in the school history -- incidents where STUDENT engaged in fighting at school -- were not characterized in terms of severity or placed into a context, and Dr. Perlman did not contact any of the teachers who made the reports to determine what actually happened.

The Hearing Officer also notes that when Dr. Perlman first testified on October 3, 2000, he was unable to make a formal diagnosis of bipolar disorder, but said that STUDENT exhibited symptoms of the disorder. When Dr. Perlman testified for a second time as a rebuttal witness on January 25, 2001, he stated his bipolar disorder diagnosis and also acknowledged that STUDENT has oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Perlman did not depend upon a diagnosis of bipolar disorder when he concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as ED in his April 2000 assessment. The Hearing Officer also notes that Dr. Perlman acknowledged on rebuttal that he had not seen or spoken with STUDENT since early October 2000 in order to make a formal diagnosis of bipolar disorder. Dr. Perlman explained that the formal diagnosis was made once he had confirmed from the PARENTS that STUDENT’s older sister had recently been diagnosed as bipolar, a condition that, according to Dr. Perlman, is genetically transmitted at a greater rate than heart disease or diabetes.

The Hearing Officer finds more reliable and persuasive the many observations and conclusions of the teachers, administrators, and psychologists who testified for the District and who observed STUDENT’s specific behavior at Menifee or at Jack Weaver over a period of months (Dr. Brown, Mr. Malone and Mr. Hearing), or even years (Dr. Wesson). As noted above, their testimony established that STUDENT’s behavior was not impulsive, but rather controlled and predictable. The credible evidence shows that STUDENT is deliberate in selecting smaller, younger students when he aggresses within the school setting. The Hearing Officer finds particularly persuasive Dr. Easler’s statement that students who are ED do not consider the consequence of physical harm to themselves during outbursts. The significance is that students with ED generally lack control and lack choice. Not one witness testified that STUDENT fought with any students his size, even though Mr. Hearing testified that there were two students of his size in Mr. Hearing’s classroom.

Dr. Easler’s testimony that STUDENT’s behavior was within the range of behavior that normally functioning students manifest was also persuasive. The Hearing Officer places great weight on the testimony and report of Dr. Easler. Dr. Easler completed his report and formulated his opinion on ED eligibility only after he had visited the Jack Weaver School, made observations, and interviewed teachers and staff members. Dr. Easler testified that when he discussed the ED criteria with Tasha Arneson, Ph.D., clinical director at Jack Weaver School, Dr. Arneson also did not believe that STUDENT met the ED criteria.

STUDENT’s behaviors are not atypical, and credible evidence of the student’s frequent, severe conflicts with family members at home provides an explanation for STUDENT’s acting out in school and his social maladjustment. Such behavior at home does not occur consistently across all settings. According to Mr. Malone and Mr. Hearing, STUDENT referred generally to problems at home. The Hearing Officer also notes that PARENT acknowledged STUDENT’s significant improvement after beginning an anger management class in January 2001. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT’s successful participation in anger management therapy indicates that STUDENT is able to control his behavior.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s misconduct behavior at school (fighting, anger displays, defiance of authority) is within the normal range of behaviors and is explainable in light of STUDENT’s difficulties at home. Dr. Perlman is alone in his conclusion that STUDENT is ED. Dr. Easler and Dr. Wesson did not find STUDENT to be ED, nor did the Riverside County Department of Mental Health find STUDENT eligible for mental health services. The psychiatric reports from Canyon Ridge for the two 1999 hospitalizations concluded that STUDENT was ADHD and conduct disordered.(Footnote 14) Thus, it is concluded that STUDENT did not exhibit inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations from June 2000 through 2000-2001 school year.

Even if STUDENT had exhibited inappropriate behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances, the behaviors did not significantly interfere with his ability to learn. Dr. Perlman testified generally that STUDENT’s condition affected his ability to benefit from his education. However, Mr. Malone, Petitioner’s Opportunity Class teacher, testified that STUDENT performed well academically when he did his homework and attended class. Moreover, STUDENT’s grade reports for his first and second semester at Jack Weaver are A’s, B’s, and C’s, with comments indicating that STUDENT needed to complete his homework and attend class. (Dist. Exh. 18)

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that on the basis of all of the evidence discussed above, STUDENT did not meet ED eligibility criteria (2) and (3) above from June 2000 through the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, he does not qualify for special education as a student who is emotionally disturbed.

ISSUE NO. 2 Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private placement they procured for Petitioner for the period June 2000, through October 2000?

In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that Petitioner is not eligible for special education and related services as ED, the parents of Petitioner are not entitled to reimbursement.

ISSUE NO. 3 Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period June 2000, through the end of the 2000-01 school year?

In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that Petitioner is not eligible for special education and related services as ED, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

DATED: June 7, 2001 ___________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Dr. Perlman performed an independent psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in April 2000. Dr. Perlman testified that he earned a Ph.D. in clinical psychology in 1986, and that he is a licensed clinical psychologist in private practice since 1988.

2. The portion of the school history that follows for the period kindergarten through the eighth grade is taken primarily from Dr. Perlman’s report during the period when STUDENT was an elementary and middle school student within the Menifee Union School District. Dr. Perlman testified that he did not interview any of the teachers who reported the incidents. The school history is a compilation of school records summarized by Dr. Perlman. Dr. Easler, the psychologist who performed an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with the parties’ October 4, 2000 settlement agreement and who testified on behalf of the District, acknowledged that Dr. Perlman did a “good job” documenting the Petitioner’s school history.

3. Although a family therapist record was introduced into evidence, as well as a letter written by the student’s psychiatrist, neither the family therapist nor the treating psychiatrist was called by either party to testify at the due process hearing.

4. The Hearing Officer sustained the District’s objection to admission of the written agreement into evidence, on the grounds of relevance (different school districts and a different school year) and in accordance with California Code of Regulations Section 3086(b)(2), which provides that “no reference to mediation proceedings, the evidence produced, or any other aspect of the mediation may be made in adjudicative proceeding or civil action....”

5. Petitioner at first contended at the due process hearing that he qualified for special education and related services under the ED, SLD and OHI (as ADHD) categories. However, as the due process hearing progressed, the Petitioner eventually withdrew his contention that he qualified under the SLD and OHI categories and contended that he met two eligibility criteria for ED.

6. Mr. Hendrick testified that he has been the District psychologist for twenty-five years, and has earned a master’s degree in clinical psychology, with a school psychologist’s credential. Mr. Hendrick stated that has dealt with at least one thousand special education students with ED.

7. Dr. Easler testified that he holds a Ph.D. in school psychology from the University of South Carolina, and that his dissertation was on social maladjustment and seriously emotionally disturbed students. Dr. Easler is a professor at the University of California at Riverside.

8. The 1997 IDEA amendment changed the term “serious emotional disturbance”(SED) to “emotional disturbance.” (ED) 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). California continues to use the term “serious emotional disturbance.” Calif. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i). The criteria for meeting special education eligibility under either ED or SED are expressed in nearly identical language

9. Dr. Wesson stated that he received a Ph.D. in psychology in 1978 and a doctorate in school psychology in 1983, and that he is “on staff” at the University of San Diego, and is on leave of absence from California State University, San Marcos.

10. Both Dr. Perlman and Dr. Easler acknowledged that a student can be both socially maladjusted and ED. Dr. Perlman also acknowledged that a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, as with any mental disorder, does not necessarily mean that the student is also ED. The definition of ED under special education law contains qualifying criteria which make no reference to conditions or disorders set forth within the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV). 11. Dr. Easler testified that Section 5150 of the (penal)[sic] code states that if a student is a danger to himself or herself and/or others, the police or mental health staff can do an assessment and can place a student in a psychiatric facility for up to 72 hours, and then they are assessed if it appears that they are going to continue to be a danger to themselves or others. Dr. Easler acknowledged that STUDENT’s parents told him that STUDENT would get “worked up” at school and would come home and “exacerbated” and “blew it out at home.” Dr. Easler said that he spoke with Dr. Wesson of Menifee who told Dr. Easler that STUDENT “was not distressed at Menifee when he was 5150'd.”

12. Dr. Brown testified that he has a Ph.D. in special education from USC in 1978, and he has been “working in the field” at nonpublic schools and residential facilities for approximately thirty years and has worked with students referred to the facilities after being found eligible as ED by IEP teams..

13. The Hearing Officer notes that neither Dr. Perlman nor any other witness stated or suggested that STUDENT is delusional or suffers from schizophrenia. In his assessment of STUDENT, Dr. Perlman states that “no formal thought disorder surfaced in the data. STUDENT demonstrated the ability to interpret the actions and intentions of others without distortion, and to construe correctly what constitutes appropriate behaviors in various types of situations.” (Dist. Exh. 16)

14. Petitioner did not allege that STUDENT’s diagnosis of ADHD was a basis for an ED eligibility determination.