California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 4, 2003

Student v. San Francisco Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1402-02 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

San Francisco Unified may exit student from speech services but owes 360 minutes of compensatory speech therapy for six missed weeks.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A nine-year-old third grader filed for hearing against San Francisco Unified School District. He had been eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment (SLI) and attended general education at San Francisco Community School. In fall 2001, the District proposed replacing his weekly direct speech therapy with classroom consultation. After its April 2002 speech-language assessment, the District proposed exiting him from special education. The parents disagreed. They relied on a private neuropsychological report, a former therapist's progress report, and testing by private speech-language pathologist Glenna Milleman.

The Hearing Officer found that the student no longer qualified as SLI. District assessors Robert Wattles and Leland Bennett found no articulation, voice, fluency or language disorder. Teachers and District therapists described typical communication in class. The student's low scores on one private test did not meet the state rule of two qualifying standardized tests, or one qualifying test plus a deficient language sample. The private reports were hearsay, and their authors did not testify.

On FAPE, the District stopped direct therapy after the October 5, 2001 IEP meeting. The parents did not consent in writing until November 19, 2001. That gap denied FAPE. The parents' later written consent was valid. The student did not need direct therapy after that date or in 2002-2003. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 business days and provide 360 minutes of compensatory speech therapy by the end of the 2002-2003 school year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the then-current numeric test for language disorder in 5 CCR section 3030(c)(4) to exit a student. It also shows that a district that stopped IEP services before the parents gave written consent owed make-up services, even though the change itself was later found appropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Does Student continue to qualify for special education and related services under the category of speech and language impairment (SLI)?

    The District's April 2002 speech-language assessment and staff testimony showed Student no longer met the SLI criteria in Education Code section 56333 and 5 CCR section 3030(c), and any weaknesses did not adversely affect his educational performance.

  2. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 2. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

    The District denied FAPE from October 5 to November 18, 2001, by stopping 60 minutes per week of direct speech therapy before the parents consented in writing to consultation services. There was no denial of FAPE after the parents' valid November 19, 2001 consent or during 2002-2003, because Student did not need direct therapy.

  3. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 3. Is Student entitled to compensatory education because the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

    Student was awarded 360 minutes of compensatory direct speech therapy for the six weeks of missed services. All other requested relief was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 business days of the decision, unless the parties agree in writing to an extension, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to discuss and offer 360 minutes of direct speech therapy as compensatory education.
  • Compensatory education. 360 minutes (6 hours) of direct speech therapy, to begin as soon as possible and be completed by the end of the 2002-2003 school year unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.

Total: 6 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994); Cal. Educ. Code § 56333; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(11)

People named in the decision

  • Glenna Milleman, private speech-language pathologist; director; witness for Student, San Francisco Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders
  • Katherine McCauley, administrator overseeing designated instructional services; District witness, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Jennifer Johnson, law clerk for District, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Kay Cook, program/contact specialist; achievement testing, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Pamela Mills, Ed.D., Ph.D., school psychologist; director of screening and assessment center, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Sharlene Aquiler, general education teacher (third grade), San Francisco Community School
  • Margarita Fajardo, speech-language pathologist, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Rani Krishnaswamy, speech-language pathologist (consultation services), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Robert Wattles, Ph.D., speech-language pathologist; assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Leland Bennett, Ed.D., speech-language pathologist; assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Tricia Evans, private speech-language pathologist; assessor, San Francisco Hearing & Speech Center
  • Suzanne Ranson, speech-language pathologist; assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Connie Suter-Alvarez, speech-language pathologist; triennial assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Amy Wisniewski, Ph.D., clinical supervisor; private neuropsychological evaluation, Kurt & Barbara Gronowski Clinic
  • Linda Ruthruff, neuropsychological examiner, Kurt & Barbara Gronowski Clinic
  • Laurie Abbey, private speech-language pathologist providing services on District's behalf, Private practice
  • San Francisco Hearing & Speech Center, private assessment agency
  • Child Development Center, California Pacific Medical Center, private speech therapy provider
  • San Francisco Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders, nonprofit speech therapy provider
  • Kurt & Barbara Gronowski Clinic, private neuropsychological assessment clinic

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Francisco, California, on February 25-27, 2003. STUDENT (Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sally McDonald from the Community Alliance for Special Education (CASE). Also present on Student’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS. The San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Lenore Silverman, its deputy general counsel. Also present on the District’s behalf was Katherine McCauley, its administrator overseeing designated instructional services, and, beginning February 26, law clerk Jennifer Johnson.

Student called as witnesses his parents and Glenna Milleman, a speech-language pathologist and director of the San Francisco Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders. The District called the following witnesses: Kay Cook, a District program/contact specialist; Pamela Mills, Ed.D., Ph.D., a school psychologist and director of the District’s screening and assessment center; Sharlene Aquiler, a general education teacher at San Francisco Community School; Ms. McCauley; and District speech-language pathologists Margarita Fajardo, Rani Krishnaswamy, Robert Wattles, Ph.D., and Leland Bennett, Ed.D.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties’ written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Does STUDENT continue to qualify for special education and related services under the category of speech and language impairment (SLI)?

2. Did the District offer and/or provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education because the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old third-grade student at San Francisco Community School (SFCS) who resides with his parents within the boundaries of the District. STUDENT’s parents adopted him from a Russian orphanage at the age of two years and ten months. There is no dispute that, even prior to his adoption, STUDENT exhibited delayed language development.

In June 1997, seven months after he arrived in the United States, STUDENT’s parents had him assessed by the San Francisco Hearing & Speech Center (SFHSC) for speech-language delays. His parents had him assessed again by SFHSC eight months later, in February 1998. In February 1998, speech-language pathologist (SLP) Tricia Evans, the SFHSC assessor, found that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were below the normal range for children his age and recommended that he receive speech-language therapy to work on language, speech, and oral motor skills. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT began receiving fifty minutes per week of speech-language therapy from the Child Development Center at the California Pacific Medical Center (CPMC) at his parents’ expense.

In or about July 1998, STUDENT was referred to the District for an initial assessment to determine whether he was eligible for special education and related services. The District’s assessors found that STUDENT was functioning in the range expected for his age in the areas of cognition, fine motor, gross motor, self-help, and social-emotional but that he was below the expected range in the areas of expressive language and articulation. An initial individualized education program (IEP) meeting was held for STUDENT on July 28, 1998. At the meeting, the IEP team (IEPT) agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services based on a speech and language impairment (SLI). The IEPT also agreed that he should receive direct speech-language therapy two to three times per week in twenty- to thirty-minute sessions to address his needs in the areas of expressive language and articulation.

On January 8, 1999, another IEP meeting was held. The IEPT agreed at the meeting to provide STUDENT with the additional services of occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT), and to revise the frequency of his direct speech-language services to two thirty-minute sessions per week. At the annual IEP review on June 2, 1999, the IEPT agreed to continue providing STUDENT with direct speech therapy on a pull-out basis in two thirty- to forty-minute sessions per week.

In the fall of 1999, STUDENT began attending SFCS as a kindergarten student. He was placed in the general education program and received the related services of speech therapy, PT, and OT. On March 22 and 29, 2000, near the conclusion of the 1999-2000 school year, District SLP Suzanne Ranson assessed STUDENT in preparation for his annual review. Ms. Ranson found that STUDENT exhibited moderate impairments in receptive language and severe deficits in expressive language skills, and recommended that STUDENT continue to receive speech therapy sixty minutes per week. At the annual IEP review held shortly thereafter on March 30, 2000, the IEPT agreed to continue providing STUDENT with sixty minutes per week of pull-out speech services, as well as OT and PT.

On November 16, 2000, when STUDENT was in the first grade at SFCS, an IEP meeting was held to discuss compensatory speech services. According to the IEP document prepared that day, the District had failed to provide STUDENT with a total of 18.5 hours of speech therapy as required—7.5 hours during the 1999-2000 school year and 11 hours during the 2000-2001 school year. The IEPT agreed that STUDENT would continue to receive sixty minutes per week of direct speech therapy and that he would be provided an additional 18.5 hours as compensatory speech services during the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 1)

On February 22, 2001, District SLP Connie Suter-Alvarez conducted a triennial speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Suter-Alvarez determined that STUDENT appeared to have difficulty auditorily with weaknesses in word finding and immediate recall of words and sentences, and that he continued to have expressive language deficits that qualified him for special education and related services. At an IEP meeting held a month later, on March 22, 2001, the IEPT recommended that STUDENT continue to receive sixty minutes per week of speech therapy and PT.

Later that year, on June 26, 2001, the parents had STUDENT assessed at the Kurt & Barbara Gronowski Clinic by clinical supervisor Amy Wisniewski, Ph.D., and neuropsychological examiner Linda Ruthruff. This assessment resulted in a “Neuropsychological Evaluation” report, which the parents presented to the District in the fall of 2001. The report noted that, in terms of intellectual functioning, STUDENT scored in the average to high average range on nonverbal tasks and in the low average range on verbal tasks. The report also noted that on academic achievement measures STUDENT’s scores were in the average to superior range. According to the report, STUDENT demonstrated impairments in language processing; his receptive vocabulary was stronger than his expressive vocabulary, with word-finding difficulties being apparent which affected his speech prosody;(Footnote 2) and his greatest difficulty was in understanding and producing grammatical structures. The report recommended that STUDENT receive language arts therapy at least three times per week to remediate his expressive and receptive language difficulties.

On September 26, 2001, Laurie Abbey, an SLP in private practice who had provided STUDENT with speech therapy from December 2000 to May 2001 on the District’s behalf, submitted a report detailing STUDENT’s progress. Ms. Abbey reported that STUDENT had made good progress on his IEP goals by May 2001 but that he continued to have significant language therapy needs. She noted that he had met some goals and was making progress towards others, but that he continued to require work in the area of expressive language to improve his vocabulary development and flexibility of language use for academic success. She stated that she agreed with the recommendation in the neuropsychological evaluation report that STUDENT should receive speech therapy at least three times per week to improve his expressive and receptive language skills.

An IEP addendum meeting was convened on October 5, 2001, near the beginning of STUDENT’s second-grade year. The IEPT reviewed the findings in the neuropsychological evaluation report. District SLP Margarita Fajardo informed the team that she had conducted an informal speech evaluation two weeks earlier on September 19, 2001, and found that STUDENT had age-appropriate speech-language skills. She reported that STUDENT was able to retell an entire story without picture cues, to tell/identify every character in order and what happened at the end of the story, and to name items from a category in a structured setting. The District recommended that the direct speech therapy be changed to thirty minutes per week of SLP consultation services to the classroom. The parents indicated that they were concerned that STUDENT did not understand the classroom teacher’s oral directions and that they did not see “achievement” in the home setting unless STUDENT was asked to repeat himself. The parents did not agree to change STUDENT’s speech therapy from direct to consultative services. By letter dated November 19, 2001, the parents expressed their disagreement with the findings of the IEP held on October 5.

In or about late October 2001, at his parents’ request, STUDENT began to receive two forty-five-minute speech therapy sessions in a small-group setting from Glenna Millleman, a speech-language pathologist and director of the San Francisco Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders, a nonprofit organization.(Footnote 3) According to Ms. Milleman, the sessions addressed auditory processing, vocabulary, and expressive language skills.

On November 19, 2001, another IEP addendum meeting was held for the purpose of discussing whether STUDENT’s speech therapy should be changed to a consult model. The IEP notes that STUDENT would continue to receive direct PT services but that his speech therapy services would be provided through a teacher-consultation model. The parents signed the IEP indicating that they agreed with the recommendations and were giving consent for their implementation.

On March 13, 2002, a meeting was convened for STUDENT’s annual IEP review. The IEPT noted that STUDENT had met his PT goals and that PT was no longer needed. Ms. Fajardo reported that she had observed STUDENT in his classroom every week and found that he had age-appropriate speech-language skills—he could answer questions and demonstrated comprehension of questions and had age-appropriate vocabulary and speech. The District noted that STUDENT had met all of his previous speech-language goals and recommended that he be “demitted,” or exited, from special education. The parents disagreed and requested that a formal speech-language assessment be conducted.

On April 8 and 10, 2002, District SLPs Robert Wattles, Ph.D. and Leland Bennett, Ed.D. conducted a speech-language assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett concluded from their joint assessment of STUDENT that he presented with normal communicative functions and did not appear to present with a speech-language disorder. The doctors found that STUDENT’s auditory acuity appeared to be within the normal to above normal range, that his language function was well within the normal range for a child of his chronological age, that his scores on the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test demonstrated expressive vocabulary and language skills in the upper range, that his scores on the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test were well above average for his chronological age, that observational testing demonstrated normal functions in the areas measured, that clinical observations demonstrated that he was an alert and cooperative person with extended and spontaneous conversational levels, and that the contrast between his rapid response levels and normal response rate indicated an eagerness to perform with normal moments of needing more time to think about a response. In short, Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett found that STUDENT did not have an articulation disorder, oral language deficits, expressive or receptive language disorder, or a disorder of either voicing or fluency. They concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services.

The IEPT reconvened on May 9, 2002, to discuss the results of the District’s assessment. The District again recommended that STUDENT be exited from special education because the assessment results showed that he possessed normal communicative functioning. The parents continued to disagree with the District’s recommendation to exit STUDENT.

STUDENT presently continues to receive once weekly classroom consultation services from the District and twice weekly small-group therapy sessions with Ms. Milleman.(Footnote 4) He also continues to be placed in the general education program at SFCS as a third-grade student.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO.1: Does STUDENT continue to qualify for special education and related services under the category of speech and language impairment (SLI)?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities who, by reason thereof, needs instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b).

Student claims that he continues to be eligible for special education and related services because of a speech and language impairment (SLI). Specifically, Student asserts that he is eligible because he has fluency difficulties and because his language performance level is significantly below the language performance level of his peers. The District argues that STUDENT is no longer a “child with a disability.” The District contends that it has found no evidence of a disability as defined by the IDEA and State special education law, and that STUDENT presently is meeting grade-level standards in all academic areas, is social, and has no difficulty communicating. Federal law defines a speech or language impairment as “a communication disorder, such as stuttering, impaired articulation, a language impairment, or a voice impairment, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(11). State law further defines SLI eligibility criteria as follows:

A pupil shall be assessed as having a language or speech disorder which makes him or her eligible for special education and related services when he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services. In order to be eligible for special education and related services, difficulty in understanding or using spoken language shall be assessed by a language, speech, and hearing specialist who determines that such difficulty results from any of the following disorders: (a) Articulation disorders, such that the pupil’s production of speech significantly interferes with communication and attracts adverse attention. (b) Abnormal voice, characterized by persistent, defective voice quality, pitch, or loudness. An appropriate medical examination shall be conducted, where appropriate. (c) Fluency difficulties which result in an abnormal flow of verbal expression to such a degree that these difficulties adversely affect communication between the pupil and listener. (d) Inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language such that the pupil’s language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her peers. (e) Hearing loss which results in a language or speech disorder and significantly affects educational performance.

Cal. Educ. Code § 56333; see also Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(c).(Footnote 5)

Based on the totality of the evidence produced at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not continue to qualify for special education and related services as a child with an SLI. The evidence establishes that STUDENT does not have a speech and language impairment, as that term is described in special education law, and does not require special education and related services. In April 2002, District SLPs Robert Wattles, Ph.D., and Leland Bennett, Ed.D. assessed STUDENT in a joint effort to determine whether he continued to have an SLI that qualified him for special education and related services. Dr. Wattles has been an SLP with the District since 1970, Dr. Bennett since 1989. Both Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett are California-licensed and California-credentialed language, speech, and hearing specialists with decades of experience assessing children for speech-language difficulties in public school and private agency settings. Over the course of two sessions on April 8 and 10, 2002, Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett conducted a comprehensive speech-language assessment in compliance with special education assessment requirements, including Education Code § 56320, by using a number of standardized assessment instruments, obtaining a language sample, observing STUDENT in the classroom and during testing, reviewing records, and interviewing his father, second-grade teacher, and school principal.(Footnote 6) Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett both convincingly testified that they saw no evidence of an SLI that would qualify STUDENT for special education and related services. Specifically, Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett found that STUDENT did not have an articulation disorder, oral language deficits, expressive or receptive language disorder, or a disorder of either voicing or fluency.

The conclusion of Dr. Wattle and Dr. Bennett that STUDENT is not “a child with a disability” as defined by the IDEA and State special education law is supported by the testimony of District SLPs Margarita Fajardo and Rani Krishnaswamy. Both Ms. Fajardo and Ms. Krishnaswamy testified that they saw no indication of a speech-language disability and no indication that STUDENT requires special education and related services to benefit from his education. Ms. Fajardo provided speech services to STUDENT throughout the 2001-2002 school year, first through sixty minutes per week of direct speech therapy on a pull-out basis and then, after the October 5, 2001 IEP meeting, through weekly observations and weekly teacher consultations lasting twenty to thirty minutes each. Ms. Fajardo testified that she found that STUDENT was able to communicate very well in the classroom, to use complete and grammatically correct sentences, to ask questions, to interact communicatively with his teacher and peers, and to display adequate recall skills in answering questions. According to Ms. Fajardo, STUDENT did not demonstrate any difficulty with verb tenses, word order, prosody, or fluency. In short, Ms. Fajardo found that STUDENT did not have any speech and language needs. Ms. Krishnaswamy, who has been providing thirty minutes per week of teacher consultation services on STUDENT’s behalf since October 2002, testified that she has come to the same conclusions. For example, Ms. Krishnaswamy testified that STUDENT demonstrates average speech-language skills that allow him to function in the classroom in required tasks such as following oral directions, participating in classroom discussions, asking the teacher questions when necessary, communicating and interacting with peers, and maintaining age-appropriate eye contact. Ms. Krishnaswamy testified that STUDENT does not require any accommodations or adaptations beyond those that the teacher provides for all students in her classroom.

Sharlene Aquiler, STUDENT’s current teacher, testified that STUDENT is meeting, if not exceeding, the standards in all academic areas and that he is making appropriate progress towards all third-grade standards. Ms. Aquiler confirmed that STUDENT participates in all classroom activities, is able to communicate effectively with her and his peers, asks and answers questions appropriately in class, is able to recall and retell stories, uses correct grammar and verb tenses, speaks in complete sentences, and is able to follow directions (including multi-part directions). Ms. Aquiler testified that the frequency at which STUDENT is distracted by noise or activities in the classroom, has difficulty understanding work assignments, and uses incorrect word order is not unusual of others of the same grade in her class. Pamela Mills, Ed.D., Ph.D., a school psychologist and program administrator of the District’s screening and assessment center who has eleven years experience teaching a third-grade class, observed STUDENT for forty minutes in or about January 2003 in the classroom and on the playground and reviewed an “integrated writing sample” completed by STUDENT in early February 2003. Dr. Mills testified that she also saw STUDENT as a child with age-appropriate speech-language skills and behavior. Additionally, Dr. Mills testified that STUDENT’s writing sample demonstrated very good use of written language—she explained that his writing was well organized, imaginative, sequential, and flowed well. Finally, achievement testing by District program specialist Kay Cook on January 21, 2003, indicated that STUDENT’s performance was well within the average range in reading, writing, and mathematics. Ms. Cook’s findings were consistent with the findings of the independent neuropsychological assessment completed June 2001, which found that STUDENT’s scores on achievement measures were in the average to superior range. In short, the evidence established that STUDENT does not have a speech-language impairment within the meaning of special education law and that any speech-language needs he may have do not adversely affect his educational performance.

The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Student’s evidence and arguments to the contrary. First, Student asserts that the District’s assessment was inappropriate because it failed to include the specific tests requested by the parents and failed to include any tests that measured his ability to perform in noisy environments. Second, Student contends that he has a speech-language impairment because of fluency difficulties and because his language performance level is significantly below the language performance level of his peers. Student alleges that this is established by the testimony of SLP Glenna Milleman, who has been providing private speech therapy to him since October 2001. Third, Student asserts that the independent neuropsychological assessment report completed in June 2001 and the progress report completed by SLP Laurie Abbey in September 2001 establish that he requires direct speech and language therapy. Finally, Student argues that the District’s conclusion that he has been performing well in the general education classroom without the support of direct speech therapy services is flawed because it fails to take into account the hours of support STUDENT has been receiving from Ms. Milleman, a private tutor, and his parents. Each of these arguments will be addressed in turn.

First, with regard to the Student’s contentions about the appropriateness of the District’s assessment, the Hearing Officer notes that there is no requirement that a school district administer all the assessment measures requested by parents. Additionally, one of the two tests requested by the parents at the IEP meeting on March 22, 2001, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals – Third Edition (CELF-3), was administered by Ms. Milleman on October 26, 2001, only five months prior to the District’s assessment. According to the undisputed testimony of witnesses, administration of the CELF-3 only five months later would have been improper. Moreover, none of the CELF-3 scores obtained by STUDENT in October 2001 was educationally significant.(Footnote 7) With regard to testing in noisy environments, both Dr. Bennett and Ms. Cook testified that their testing occurred with typical school noise present—neither observed any atypical reactions or reduced performance because of the noise. Moreover, the testimony of witnesses such as Ms. Aquiler, Ms. Fajardo, and Ms. Krishnaswamy established that STUDENT is able to meet classroom expectations even with the presence of the noise and distractions typical of second- and third-grade classrooms.

Second, with regard to Student’s contention that he has a speech-language impairment because of fluency difficulties, Ms. Milleman and the parents testified that STUDENT has fluency difficulties due to word retrieval problems resulting in speech that is full of hesitations, fillers, and reformations. However, the testimony of Ms. Fajardo, Ms. Krishnaswamy, and Ms. Aquiler established that fluency difficulties are not seen in the educational setting. Ms. Fajardo testified that STUDENT did not use an atypical amount of fillers or hesitations for his age. Ms. Krishnaswamy testified that she did not observe any word retrieval difficulties, unusual pauses in speech, or an excessive number of fillers. Ms. Aquiler testified that STUDENT is able to express his ideas to her and his classmates effectively, and that she and his classmates have no difficulty understanding him and do not have to ask him to repeat himself in order to understand him. The testimony in this regard is corroborated by the language sample taken by Dr. Wattles in April 2002. Dr. Wattles persuasively demonstrated that the hesitations seen in STUDENT’s language sample were due to creative thinking and his desire to constantly improve his descriptions and predict outcomes, and to use all previous levels of thinking to form new and creative ideas. The hesitations were not, according to Dr. Wattles, due to word-retrieval difficulties—he did not stumble over words and did not repeat words so that he could get a clue to go onto the next word, which would have indicated word-retrieval difficulties. Dr. Wattles convincingly testified that STUDENT did not exhibit speech filled with pauses and reformations because of word retrieval difficulties.

With regard to below-level language performance, Student points out that he achieved scores below the seventh percentile on three out of four subtests of the Test of Language Competence – Extended Edition (TLC-E), which was administered by Ms. Milleman on January 27, 2003 to test STUDENT’s “metalinguistic” skills. However, to establish the existence of a speech-language impairment because of below-level language performance, the student must exhibit scores that are 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or below the seventh percentile either on two or more standardized tests, or on one or more standardized tests with demonstrated difficulties on a language sample. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(c)(4). STUDENT did not score 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or below the seventh percentile on two standardized tests, as required by Section 3030(c)(4)(A). Further, as noted earlier, he did not display inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a representative elicited language sample of a minimum of fifty utterances, as required by Section 3030(c)(4)(B).

The Hearing Officer also notes that this was the only measure administered by Ms. Milleman on which STUDENT received any scores below the seventh percentile, and that Ms. Milleman had limited familiarity with the TLC-E at the time she administered it to STUDENT. Ms. Milleman testified that, before administering the TLC-E to STUDENT on January 27, 2003, she had not administered it previously in her professional career—she had only read the manual and practiced administering the test an undisclosed number of times. Dr. Bennett testified that a person’s unfamiliarity with an assessment measure could impact the validity of the scores obtained. Dr. Bennett testified that there are a number of other factors that also call into question the validity of the scores obtained on the TLC-E, including that its developer has designated it as a “supplemental test” that does not stand on its own. Dr. Bennett also testified that the “Desk Reference for Assessment Instruments in Speech-Language” warns that the TLC-E should be used with caution with children as young as STUDENT because of the frequency of negative results for the population. Additionally, Dr. Bennett testified that the TLC-E would not be a reliable test for a person with two years and ten months less opportunity to learn the English language, such as STUDENT, especially as it applies to discovering higher language functioning or metalinguistic skills. Moreover, even if assuming arguendo the results of the TLC-E are valid for STUDENT and do reveal some weaknesses in his speech-language skills, the overwhelming evidence demonstrates that STUDENT is able to function appropriately in the classroom. As many of the SLPs in this case testified, many people have speech-language weaknesses in one or more areas. However, a speech-language weakness must rise to the level set forth in the IDEA and State special education law to qualify a child for special education and related services.

Third, with regard to the independent neuropsychological assessment report dated June 2001 and the progress report by Ms. Abbey dated September 2001, neither report establishes that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services. The neuropsychological assessment report gives no indication of the qualifications of either Ms. Ruthruff or Ms. Wisniewski, the signatories of the report, and they did not testify at hearing to establish their qualifications. Consequently, there is no evidence of their qualifications to render opinions regarding special education eligibility and the need for speech therapy in an educational setting. Further, while the neuropsychological report notes that the assessors found that STUDENT demonstrated impairments in language processing, it does not come to any conclusion with regard to whether STUDENT met the specific criteria set forth to qualify for special education and related services. Likewise, Ms. Abbey did not testify and there is no evidence to establish her qualifications to render opinions regarding special education eligibility and the need for speech therapy in an educational setting.(Footnote 8) Furthermore, Ms. Abbey did not assess STUDENT and did not make a determination in her report regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services.

Finally, Student contends that he appears to function appropriately in the educational setting only because of the outside supports provided by his parents consisting of two 45-minute group speech therapy sessions per week, two hours of tutoring per week, and parental assistance at home. However, there is no evidence that such outside support would result in a child’s ability to perform age appropriately on a speech-language assessment or with no apparent speech-language difficulties in the classroom. Even in those instances when a child receives outside services such as those received by STUDENT or even in-school therapy and/or tutoring, a child with significant speech-language difficulties would still be expected to manifest those difficulties in the classroom and especially when assessed.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that STUDENT is no longer eligible for special education and related services under the category of SLI.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer and/or provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

Student asserts that he was denied a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years because the District failed to provide him with direct speech therapy services after October 5, 2001. Specifically, Student argues that the District changed his direct speech therapy to consultative services after October 5, 2001, without his parents’ consent. Student also contends that he required direct speech therapy to benefit from his education during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years.

With regard to Student’s argument regarding consent, the Hearing Officer notes that a school district is required to provide a child with special education and related services in accordance with his IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350(a)(1); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3040(a). A component of a child’s IEP may be changed only with the consent of the parents. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). STUDENT’s parents provided written consent for the District’s proposal to change his speech therapy services from direct to consultative services during the IEP meeting on November 19, 2001. Therefore, the District had obtained the parents’ permission to provide STUDENT with consult speech services after November 19, 2001. However, Ms. Fajardo, the District SLP providing services to STUDENT at the time, testified that she had ceased providing STUDENT with direct speech therapy after the IEP meeting on October 5, 2001, apparently because she believed that the plan was for her to provide only consultative services. Because the parents did not provide written consent for the change in speech services until November 19, 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from October 5 to November 18, 2001, to the limited extent that it failed to provide sixty minutes per week of direct speech therapy, as required by his IEP.

The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the Student’s argument that his parents’ written consent on the November 19, 2001 IEP, did not represent true consent because they did not realize that they were agreeing to change the speech services to consultative services. The evidence establishes that the parents were on notice that by signing the November 2001 IEP they were agreeing to change STUDENT’s services to a consult model. First, the issue of whether STUDENT’s speech services should be changed to a consult model had been a point of discussion for the IEPT since the IEP on October 5, 2001, when the proposal was first made. Additionally, three of the four pages of the November 2001 IEP clearly indicated that the District was recommending that STUDENT’s speech services be changed to consultative services. The Hearing Officer also does not find persuasive Student’s argument that the District should have known that his parents did not agree with the change because of a letter they sent to the District to express their dissent that was dated November 19, 2001. The parents’ letter of dissent expresses disagreement with statements made at the October 5, 2001 IEP meeting, not the November 19, 2001 IEP meeting. In fact, the letter makes no mention of the November 19 meeting and does not indicate that the parents were withdrawing their consent to the November IEP.

With regard the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year and the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE because it failed to provide him with direct speech therapy. There is no evidence that STUDENT required direct speech therapy to benefit from his education during the periods at issue. A school district is required to provide a related service such as speech therapy only as it may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit educationally from his instructional program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a). Based on her experience with STUDENT in weekly direct therapy, weekly observations, weekly teacher consultations, and through an informal assessment in late September 2001, Ms. Fajardo testified that she did not believe that STUDENT required direct speech therapy during the 2001-2002 school year. As discussed previously, Ms. Fajardo testified that STUDENT was performing well in the educational setting from a speech-language perspective and did not require speech-language therapy to benefit from his instructional program. Student did not present any persuasive testimony to the contrary. Although Ms. Milleman testified that she believed that STUDENT required direct speech therapy during the 2001-2002 school year, she had no contact with STUDENT’s second-grade teacher or any other school staff, did not observe STUDENT in the school setting, and did not review any educational records. Therefore, Ms. Milleman was not able to offer persuasive testimony on the question of whether STUDENT required direct speech therapy to benefit from his instructional program. Additionally, the neuropsychological assessment report dated June 2001 and Ms. Abbey’s progress report dated September 2001 provided only hearsay evidence, which is insufficient in itself to support a finding. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b).(Footnote 9) Furthermore, the speech-language assessment conducted by Dr. Wattles and Dr. Bennett in April 2002 established that STUDENT did not have a speech-language impairment that even qualified him for special education and related services.

With regard to the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s assessment in April 2002 established that STUDENT did not have a speech-language impairment that qualified him for special education and related services. Additionally, the testimony of Ms. Krishnaswamy, Ms. Aquiler, Ms. Cook, and Dr. Mills established that STUDENT demonstrated functional and appropriate speech-language skills in the general education classroom. Thus, there was no evidence that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services during the 2002-2003 school year, much less was eligible for direct speech therapy.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from October 5 to November 18, 2001 to the limited extent that it failed to provide him with direct speech therapy, as required by his IEP. However, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year or the 2002-2003 school year.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education because the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

When a school district fails to provide a FAPE to a child with a disability, the child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).

The Hearing Officer determined above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from October 5 to November 18, 2001, when it failed to provide him direct speech therapy, as required by his IEP. The District’s failure in this regard resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the District owes STUDENT compensatory education in the form of 360 minutes of direct speech therapy to redress the six weeks of missed speech therapy. The District shall provide STUDENT with these compensatory services by the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise.

ORDER

1. Within 15 business days of the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree in writing to an extension, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to discuss and offer to provide to STUDENT 360 minutes of direct speech therapy as compensatory education. The District shall begin to provide the compensatory education services as soon as possible and shall provide all of the services by no later than the end of the 2002-2003 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.

2. All of Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues heard and decided except to the limited extent that it was found to have denied Student a FAPE from October 5 to November 18, 2001, and was ordered to provide compensatory education for that period.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: April 4, 2003 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. There is no dispute that STUDENT received the required 18.5 hours of compensatory speech therapy during the 2000-2001 school year. 2. According to the SLPs who testified, “prosody” refers to the nuances of language that differentiate a human voice from a robotic voice such as stress, inflection, rhythm, timing, intonation, volume, rate, and pitch. 3. The Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders does not charge STUDENT’s parents for these services. 4. According to Ms. Milleman, the Scottish Rite Center for Childhood Language Disorders does not provide more than two years of services to any one child because of the lengthy waiting list of children needing services. Therefore, Ms. Milleman will not provide therapy services to STUDENT past October 2003. 5. Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations states, in pertinent part:

A pupil shall qualify as an individual with exceptional needs, pursuant to Section 56026 of the Education Code, if the results of the assessment as required by Section 56320 demonstrated that the degree of the pupil’s impairment as described in Section 3030(a through j) requires special education in one or more of the program options authorized by Section 56361 of the Education Code. … (c) A pupil has a language or speech disorder as defined in Section 56333 of the Education Code, and it is determined that the pupil’s disorder meets one or more of the following criteria: (1) Articulation Disorder. … (2) Abnormal Voice. … (3) Fluency Disorders. A pupil has a fluency disorder when the flow of verbal expression including rate and rhythm adversely affects communication between the pupil and listener. (4) Language Disorder. The pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when he or she meets one of the following criteria: (A) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan, or (B) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or the score is below the 7th percentile for his or her chronological age or developmental level on one or more standardized tests in one or more of the areas listed in subsection (A) and displays inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a representative spontaneous or elicited language sample of a minimum of fifty utterances. The language sample must be recorded or transcribed and analyzed, and the results included in the assessment report. If the pupil is unable to produce this sample, the language, speech, and hearing specialist shall document why a fifty utterance sample was not obtainable and the contexts in which attempts were made to elicit the sample. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified in the assessment plan. 6. The assessment report identified the tests utilized as follows: Oral Peripheral Examination; Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation, Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language – Revised; Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test – Edition 2000; Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test – Edition 2000; observational testing of auditory processing of sequential information, visual processing of sequential information, and short-term memory; Wilson

Rating Scales (Voice Examination); fluency observation and evaluation; language sample; and clinical observations. 7. Ms. Milleman reported a receptive language standard score of 110, an expressive language standard score of 104, and a total language standard score of 107, with no subtest percentile rank scores below 37. 8. Ms. Abbey is a speech therapist in private practice who provided compensatory speech therapy to STUDENT on the District’s behalf. She last provided services to STUDENT in May 2001. 9. Section 3082(b) states, in pertinent part: “Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions.” There is no exception to the hearsay rule that would render the reports at issue admissible over objection in a civil action.