California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 14, 1999
Student v. La Habra City School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1406-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
La Habra City School District need not install a video camera on an autistic student's regular education school bus.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision says the three stipulated issues were to be incorporated into an order and dismissed by a separate document.
Summary
The parents of an 11-year-old girl with autism filed for due process against La Habra City School District. They represented her themselves. Before the hearing, the parties settled three issues. The student's transition plan would be written as an independent living skills goal. A one-on-one aide would ride with her at all times on the regular education school bus. Any reduction in aide services would be decided through the IEP process. Those issues were to be dismissed by a separate document.
One issue went to hearing: whether the District had to install and run a video camera on the student's bus to record her behavior. The parents said they did not trust the District to report events accurately. They worried staff would misreport her conduct as an excuse to return her to the special education bus. The District said the aide could keep notes and that video would record other students.
The Hearing Officer found no evidence that the District's reports were unreliable. The parents' examples were old, came from another school, or were explained. The mother testified that she was content with the current school and the aides. A one-on-one aide was adequate support. The parents' distrust did not create a unique need for video. The District prevailed. It was ordered to provide the bus aide and, if the parents asked in writing, reliable reports of the student's bus behavior in a format the District develops.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a parent request for video monitoring of a student. Parental distrust alone, without evidence of unreliable district reporting, did not establish a unique need for video. Still, the Hearing Officer ordered regular behavior reports to address the parents' concerns. It also applied least restrictive environment principles to school bus transportation.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Is La Habra required to install and operate a video camera on the bus which transports Student to and from school for the purpose of monitoring and recording her behaviors on the bus?
The parents' distrust of the District did not create a unique need for a bus video camera. A one-on-one aide was adequate support on the regular education bus, and there was no evidence the District's reports were unreliable.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. District will provide a one-on-one aide to accompany Student on the regular education school bus (consistent with the parties' pre-hearing stipulation).
- Upon the parents' written request, District will provide reports of Student's behavior on the bus in a reliable format developed by the District. District is not required to install and operate a video camera on the bus.
Key authorities
Student v. San Bernardino Unified School District, 16 EHLR 656 (1990); 20 U.S.C. 1401(22) (related services); 20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(A) (LRE); FERPA, 20 U.S.C. 1232g; Education Code 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Robert Roice, educational advocate for District, G. R. Roice & Associates
- Linda Partee, special education coordinator, La Habra City School District
- Tim Harvey, assistant superintendent, La Habra City School District
- Sandy Baltes, principal, District witness, Las Posidas (Las Positas) Elementary School
- Teri Baltes (also referred to as Teri Beathie), church elementary school director, witness for Student, Student's church
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1406-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: Student Issue: Designated Instructionand Services CDS Code: 30-66563 District: La Habra City Elementary Disability Type: Autism
Case Details This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in La Habra, California on January 14, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) appeared through her parents, MR. and MRS. PARENT. Also present for a brief time was Petitioner's brother. Respondent La Habra City School District (hereinafter La Habra or District) was represented by educational advocate, Robert Roice, with the firm of G. R. Roice & Associates. Also present on Respondent's behalf were Linda Partee, special education coordinator for La Habra, and Tim Harvey assistant superintendent for La Habra. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Teri Baltes, elementary school director at Petitioner's church; Petitioner's brother; and Mr. and Mrs. Parents. Respondent called the following witness to testify: Sandy Baltes, principal of Las Positas Elementary School. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the written closing arguments, the record was closed and the issue was submitted for decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS Before the hearing began, the parties reached an agreement on three issues (1)that Student's Transition Plan would be written as an independent living skill's goal on her IEP, (2) that a one-on-one aide would accompany Student at all times on the regular education school bus, and (3) any reduction in the services of the aide would be determined through the IEP process. The Parties requested that their stipulated settlement be incorporated into an order and dismissal of these three issues by separate document. The parties then proceeded to hearing on the sole remaining issue. ISSUE Is La Habra required to install and operate a video camera on the bus which transports Student to and from school for the purpose of monitoring and recording her behaviors on the bus? BACKGROUND FACTS Student is a eleven-year-old girl who qualifies for special education with a diagnosis of autism. She began her education through the La Habra City School District in December 1990. Her first school placement was at Raichmond School in Fullerton, California. In 1992, Student was transferred to Woodcrest School. The programs at both of these schools had components in intensive language skills instruction and behavior management. In May 1993, at the age of six, Student was referred to UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute as a result of an increase in "autistic-like" behaviors. Student reportedly had cracked two windows at home with her head as well as one at school. She remained at UCLA for seven weeks before being discharged on medication. This medication was later discontinued by her parents due to adverse side effects. Student continued to exhibit the behaviors of hitting herself in the head with her fist and pinching, biting, and kicking others. She was placed on 5mg of Ritalin three times a day with minimal effect. A Behavioral Intervention Plan was developed by June 1994. Behavioral intervention strategies included rewards for appropriate behaviors, increasing communication abilities, physical activities, and containment to reduce the risk of potential injury to herself or others. It was also determined that Student required a classroom with an emphasis on behavior management. Since one was not available at Woodcrest School, Student was enrolled in a program at Knott Special Classes in October 1994. Data records showed that Student displayed great variability in her behaviors from month to month. However, there did appear to be a gradual decline in her negative behaviors. During the 1997-98 school year, Student began a gradual transition to Las Posidas Elementary School. She began attending there full time when the 1998-99 school year began. In June 1996. Student participated in an auditory integration program. It was determined that her hearing is extremely acute and that she probably hears better than most people. Student continues to be very "sound sensitive." The noise made by such things as lights, an air conditioner or the noises of other students can be offensive to her. She cannot tolerate headphones or earphones of any kind. She frequently places her fingers in her ears in what appears to be an attempt to eliminate sound. She will also vocalize to block offensive auditory stimuli. Student is reported to be an attractive and athletic girl. Although she has been difficult to test accurately, her skills appear to be within the three- to four-year level of development. Her strengths are in the areas of motor skills, where her age equivalencies range to the seven-year level. Student requires a structured environment with an established routine. She has a strong sense of self with definite likes and dislikes. She can demonstrate affectionate behaviors. She is very physical and likes to climb and swing. Food rewards are effective with her. She likes music. Constant movement is important to her and she prefers to transition quickly from one physical activity to another. She also quickly loses interest in books, music or other similar quiet activities and wants to move on to something else. Student's behaviors continue to include stomping her feet, throwing herself to the ground, banging her head, hitting herself in the head with her fists, screaming, slapping, pinching, bitting and kicking others. Outbursts involving others are typically directed toward adults, not other children. Student's "tantrums" are usually precipitated by noise that offends her, transitions or being removed from her desired activity. STUDENT persistently tries to exit her classroom to reach the playground. When she is stopped, she will throw herself on the ground, yell and hit herself. On community outings, the staff must often restrain Student by holding her by the wrists, because she can be very quick to dart away and/or drop to the ground. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES In the past, Petitioner has been transported to and from school on a special education bus. She has requested that this transportation now be provided on a regular education bus. The District has agreed to this request as long as Student is accompanied by a one-on-one aide. An aide is now acceptable to Petitioner. However, she also requests that a video camera be installed in her school bus to monitor her behavior. She would like the camera turned on when she is alleged to be misbehaving. Petitioner contends that the District does not want her on the regular education school bus and that it, therefore, will misreport her actions on the bus as an excuse to return her to the special education bus. Petitioner asserts that La Habra has provided inaccurate reports in the past and that neither its reports, nor the aides' records of her actions, can be trusted. Petitioner claims that her behavior would change if her parents rode on her bus as observers. Thus, a video recording is the only impartial and reliable method of verifying her conduct. The Petitioner believes that such a recording would allow an unbiased evaluation of the circumstances precipitating misbehavior and it could be used as a tool to modify those circumstances and the consequent behavior. In addition, Petitioner submits that the District's school bus policy authorizes video cameras on the bus. She also contends that riding the school bus with her regular education peers is the least restrictive environment. She believes that she will be deprived of this because the District will fabricate a reason to return her to the special education bus. La Habra contends that Student's aides will keep notes of her behavior on the bus and a video is not necessary. She will be accompanied by one of the same aides who provides her one-on-one assistance throughout her school day. The parents have never expressed dissatisfaction with Student's aides. The District further asserts an obligation to maintain the confidentiality of all its students. It claims that any videotape of Petitioner would inevitably also record other students on the bus. This would violate the privacy rights of those students. La Habra disclaims any motive to return Student to the special education bus unnecessarily, and it disputes any allegations that it would manufacture events to cause her removal from the regular education school bus. It denies that it has inaccurately reported events concerning Student in the past. The District also maintains that the Petitioner incorrectly asserts that the District's school bus policy enables the Petitioner to require that she be videotaped on the school bus. Although the policy states that "video surveillance may occur on any school bus and a video recording may be used in student disciplinary proceedings," only the District has the right to institute video recordings; the policy does not provide a corollary right for a parent to demand videotaping on a school bus. FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Is the District required to install and operate a video camera on the school bus that transports Student to and from school to monitor her behavior? The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) at 20 U.S.C. 1401(8) assures all disabled children the right to a "free appropriate public education. (FAPE) A 'free and appropriate education' means special education and related services."Related services are defined as "transportation, and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services . . . as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education . . . " 20 U.S.C. 1401(22). Special education children are entitled to an education in the "least restrictive environment." (LRE) "To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature and severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily." 20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(A) The principle of least restrictive environment has been held to apply to a disabled child's ability to ride a school bus with regular education children rather than be transported solely with other special education students. Student v. San Bernardino Unified School District, 16 EHLR 656 (1990) The parties have now agreed that an appropriate education for STUDENT includes an opportunity to ride a regular education bus. They disagree on the types of supplemental services that are required to meet Student's's unique needs on a school bus and afford her the greatest opportunity for success. "Appropriate education, as in 'free, appropriate, public education,' is an educational program and related service(s) as determined on an individual basis which meets the unique needs of each individual with exceptional needs. . ." CA Education Code 3001(b). Mr. and Mrs. Parent claim that the family's mistrust of schools creates a unique need for a video camera on Student's bus to record any incidents of alleged misbehavior. Mr. and Mrs. Parent testified that this District, and other Districts they have dealt with in the past, have acted in a manner that renders them untrustworthy. They are skeptical of schools in general and believe that educators may purposefully "set Student up for failure." As an example, they showed a videotape depicting Student's activities in her classroom three years ago at another school. Mrs. Parent testified that this video showed that Student's work area was near a window that overlooked the playground. She stated that this established that although the District knew that Student enjoyed swinging outside, it placed her at a desk near a window, thereby distracting her and increasing her chances for failure. Viewing the videotape allowed the parents to discover a reason for Student's inattentiveness and an opportunity to insist that her desk be moved to another location. Mrs. Parent claims that a bus video would similarly reveal any conditions, or acts by the Respondent, that might cause Student to misbehave and would provide a mechanism for identifying and correcting them. Mrs. Parent testified that the classroom video from three year prior revealed Student's aide returning her to her seat by escorting her by the arm. As she was never informed of this episode of restraint, she does not believe the District to be an accurate reporter of events. Additionally, Mrs. Parent testified that certain documents that the District submitted at the hearing were further evidence that the District does not accurately convey information. The District produced two notes from Student's aide to her school principal communicating Student's aggressive behavior, as well as charts recording her tantrums. Mrs. Parent testified that she had never seen these documents before the hearing. She and her husband had only received five written reports regarding their daughter since school began in September 1998. Conversely, Mrs. Parent expressed dissatisfaction with the number of telephone calls she received at her place of employment from Ms. Baltes, the principal of Student's school. Petitioner introduced a letter into evidence by the Petitioner in which Mrs. Parent's employer wrote to Ms. Baltes requesting that the school cease its frequent telephone calls to Mrs. Parent's place of employment "to chat about how her daughter is doing or small issues." Despite her expressions of dissatisfaction, Mrs. Parent also testified that Student was making more progress at her current school, Las Posidas, than she had made at any of her other schools. She was content with the school and its work with her daughter, and she felt Student was successful at Las Posidas. Mrs. Parent had not observed Student in her class since she began attending Las Posidas full time, nor had she observed her on the school bus during that time period. She believed Student would do well on the regular education bus because traveling was one of her daughter's most successful skills. Mr. Parent also testified about the family's mistrust of school authorities. He objected to a letter submitted at the hearing by La Habra. The District introduced correspondence from Student's child care program that described some of Student's behaviors. Mr. Parent testified that the submission of this letter by the District showed that he and his wife could not trust the District. The letter referenced a controversy between the parents and the day care provider over the site Student would attend for child care. Mr. Parent stated that he and his wife had a hostile relationship with the day care provider. They believed that the child care program did not want disabled children enrolled in its program. Mr. Parent contested the District's assertion that the correspondence from the day care program was included to confirm Student's behaviors and her lack of community safety awareness. He testified the day care center's letter was introduced by La Habra to try to show that he and his wife are uncooperative and that it contained false, prejudicial allegations of inappropriate outbursts by them. In the opinion of Mr. Parent, this was evidence of the District's duplicity. Mr. Parent also testified that he had attended Student's's last IEP without his wife. At the conclusion of the meeting, the school staff requested that he sign the IEP. This request caused Mr. Parent to "believe that the request was a setup to disrupt their family unit" because he "would be in a lot of trouble if he signed without [Mrs. Parent's] approval." Mr. Parent also cited Student's bus transition plan on which it was noted that "the parents request that no adult accompany Student" on the bus as evidence that La Habra did not accurately record events. He testified that neither he nor Mrs. Parent had made that statement. Mr. Parent provided all of his above testimony to support the assertion that he and Mrs. Parent could not trust the District and that they required a video camera to reliably record Student's's behavior on the school bus. He concluded that he "wants to document what really happens on the bus." He "would not accept any written reports from the District as evidence, only a video." The parents cite the District's expressed concern that Student's behaviors could present safety issues for herself and others on the bus. They argue that a video recording would provide documentation to protect both Petitioner and Respondent in the event the District makes allegations that Student is unsafe on the bus. A videotape would prevent the District from falsely alleging that Student's created a danger on the bus. If she were engaged in dangerous behavior, the parents could view it for themselves and therefore believe the allegations. Evidence was presented through Teri Beathie, the elementary director of Petitioner's church, that Student's behaviors did not include harming other children. She regularly attends Sunday school without incident. Ms. Beathie also testified that Student sits through the church service and does not disrupt the large number of people in attendance. Student's twelve-year-old brother, STUDENT'S BROTHER , testified that his sister does not attack other children during her tantrums. STUDENT'S BROTHER also related an experience in which Student had successfully ridden a tour bus at the Grand Canyon on a family vacation. This testimony was offered to support Mr. and Mrs. Parent's contention that Student will do well on the bus. La Habra called Sandy Baltes, principal of Las Posidas Elementary School, to testify. Ms. Baltes stated that the behavior charts, which were included with the Respondent's evidence and were of concern to the parents, were developed for Student by herself, the school psychologist, and Student's teacher and aide. The purpose of the charting was to allow them to track Student's behaviors and describe the methods used to respond to them. The two handwritten notes from the aide were part of the record of Student's behavior. Ms. Baltes displayed a great deal of personal knowledge when she described Student, her school program and the behaviors the school was addressing. She testified that Student's assaultive behaviors were typically directed toward adults. However, on one occasion Student had lashed out at another student in the restroom in response to something said by the other student. Student's arms did not actually make contact with the other child. Ms. Baltes also provided information in response to Mrs. Parent's testimony that the school called her office frequently about trivial matters. Ms. Baltes described telephone conversations she had with Mrs. Parent. One of the telephone conversation was initiated early in the school year because the school was concerned about Student's banging of her head on the concrete. Mrs. Parent was asked if Student should wear a helmet. According to Ms. Baltes, Mrs. Parent told her that a helmet was unnecessary. Ms. Baltes described another telephone conversation in which she reported that Student had banged her head on the custodian's collarbone while he was attempting to protect her head during a tantrum. Ms. Baltes asked if Mrs. Parent could suggest more effective techniques to respond to her head banging. According to Ms. Baltes, Mrs. Parent responded that they should "learn to bob and weave." Ms. Baltes recalled another telephone call she made because Student had a badly torn and bleeding nail. On cross-examination Mrs. Parent attempted to show that Ms. Baltes contacted her at work for trivial issues. She questioned Ms. Baltes about calls she had made to her about a blister on Student's hand and a torn skirt hem. Ms. Baltes stated that she did not recall those particular telephone calls. Following her questions concerning telephone contacts for unimportant issues, Mrs. Parent next queried Ms. Baltes about the Parent's contention that the school did not provide them with important information about Student. Mrs. Parent cited the bathroom incident as evidence of this assertion. Ms. Baltes responded that she had received instructions that she was not to telephone the parents at work and that the messages she had left on the family's home answering machine had not been returned. (Mrs. Parent denied that messages were left by the school on her answering machine.) Ms. Baltes therefore believed that the parents did not want her to contact them unless the event was extremely serious. It was her understanding that Mr. and Mrs. Parent viewed the episodes as normal behavior for Student and they did not want to be notified. Mrs. Baltes confirmed that a system could be implemented whereby Mr. and Mrs. Parent would be informed daily of Student's conduct on the bus. (Footnote 1) The IDEA requires that, to the extent possible with supplementary support, a disabled child be educated with his or her nondisabled peers. 20 U.S.C. 1412(50(a). This requirement extends to bus transportation. Student v. San Bernardino Unified School District, (supra) The District claims that a one-on-one aide is adequate support for Student on the bus. The Hearing Officer agrees. Although Mr. and Mrs. Parent believe they cannot trust the District to truthfully convey information about Student's behavior on the bus, there is no actual evidence that the District provides unreliable reports. The videotape introduced by the Petitioner is remote in time and it was filmed at another school site. The written instruction to telephone the parents at work only in the event of an emergency is inconsistent with their complaints that they are not contacted enough. It was reasonable for school personnel to request Mr. Parent's signature on the IEP. He was the parent attending Student's IEP and he possessed the authority to sign on her behalf. The District could not know the relationship between the parents or that asking the father to sign the IEP might cause problems between the parents. There is no evidence that La Habra had improper motives when they submitted the letter from Student's day care provider. It contained information about Student's behaviors. This evidence was provided before the Hearing began, while riding the regular education school bus with a one-on-one aide was still at issue. It was therefore relevant when it was submitted. Mrs. Parent testified that she is "content" with Student's placement at her current school. In fact, she states that Student has made more progress at Las Posidas than at her prior schools. The parents presented no persuasive evidence that the District wants to "set Student up for failure" nor did they explain why it would want to do so. Although she has never met Student's aides, Mrs. Parent does not have any complaints about them. Mr. and Mrs. Parent did not present any evidence that the aides have not, or would not, provide accurate reports about Student. Ms. Baltes testified that the school could implement a system that provided daily reports to the parents about Student's bus conduct if the parents so desired. CONCLUSION The evidence did not establish that Student, or her parents, have a unique need to require La Habra to install and operate video equipment on Student's school bus. There was no evidence presented that the aides will not provide reliable information about Student's conduct on the regular education school bus. The aides who will accompany Student on the bus are the same aides who currently work with her throughout her school day. Mr. and Mrs. Parent are pleased with the results of their work with Student. That the parties agree Student is doing well with her current program lends credibility to the skills and reliability of her one-on-one aides. The Petitioner did not provide persuasive evidence to support her contention that the District wanted her off the regular education bus. Thus, allegations that the District will create episodes of misbehavior to justify Student's removal from the regular education bus are speculation. The Hearing Officer does not find that the Petitioner made an adequate showing of probable misconduct by the District to warrant the use of a video camera on Student's school bus. However, to respond to the parents concerns about receiving accurate information of Student's actions on the school bus, the District must implement a dependable reporting strategy. Perhaps a preprinted form could be created on which the aides would provide the responses requested. This form should include an area to describe the events and circumstances immediately preceding any tantrum to address Mr. and Mrs. Parent's desire for information that may encourage problem solving strategies. ORDER 1. The District will provide a one-on-one aide to accompany Student on the regular education school bus. Upon written request by the parents, the District will provide reports of Student's behavior on the bus in a reliable format developed by the District. The District is not required to install and operate a video camera on Student's school bus. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i). Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Footnotes Footnote: 1. La Habra has expressed concern about intruding upon other students' privacy with a video camera. The Petitioner's parents argue that La Habra's school bus policy authorizes video cameras on District buses. The Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), 20 U.S.C. 1232(g) prohibits a school district from disclosing identifying information about its students. An exception is the District's bus policy authorizing its use of video cameras to obtain information for disciplinary proceedings. This is permitted under the FERPA, 20 U.S.C. 1232(g)(b)(l)(A) and (g)(b) (1)(C) which allows disclosure of confidential information to other local school officials and state educational authorities.
