California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 18, 2001

Student v. Los Alamitos Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1408-99 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Los Alamitos Unified must reimburse summer Lindamood-Bell services after Hearing Officer finds 11th grader had a specific learning disability.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's family filed for due process in September 1999, during her 11th-grade year at Los Alamitos High School. Under an interim mediation agreement, Los Alamitos Unified agreed to assess her. If she was found eligible, it would fund the 10 to 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell services that had been recommended. In November 1999 the IEP team found her not eligible, and her parents disagreed. The parents placed her at Lindamood-Bell in summer 2000 and asked to be reimbursed.

The Hearing Officer found that she had a specific learning disability from November 15, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year. An auditory processing disorder was shown by expert testimony from Dr. Kathleen Mack, very low phonological memory scores, and detailed observations from her 10th-grade English teacher, Sharon Flynn. The district never tested auditory processing directly. Her dictation score of 72 was 23 points below her full-scale IQ of 95. That counted as a severe discrepancy even under the comparison the district preferred, and other tests and work samples backed it up. Her passing grades did not disprove the discrepancy, because family help with homework and her effort drove many of them. Tutoring and earlier services had not fixed her problems.

The district was ordered to pay back the actual cost of the summer 2000 services within 30 days. A request for 12 more weeks was denied because those services had already given her ample benefit.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's severe-discrepancy test. Passing grades did not rule out a learning disability when family help and effort drove those grades. The Hearing Officer gave weight to ability measures that relied less on the suspected processing deficit. He also enforced an interim mediation agreement that tied funding for private services to a finding of eligibility.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Was Student eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and through the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year?

    Student had an auditory processing disorder that impaired reading, writing, spelling and math. She had a severe discrepancy in written expression (dictation 72 vs. full-scale IQ 95), corroborated by other data, that regular education could not correct, so she qualified as a pupil with a specific learning disability.

  2. Issue 2. If Student was eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year, what remedy is she entitled to for that period of time?

    The interim mediation agreement bound the District to fund the Lindamood-Bell services, so it must reimburse the summer 2000 services. The request for 12 more weeks was denied because those services gave her ample benefit for the period at issue.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, and under the parties' September 24, 1999 interim mediation agreement, the District must reimburse the parents for the actual cost of the Lindamood-Bell services provided in summer 2000 (amount not stated).
  • Request for an additional 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell services as compensatory education denied; all other requests for relief denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f)

People named in the decision

  • Carol McAllister, Director of instruction and pupil services, Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Ms. Roland, Fourth-grade teacher, Hopkinson Elementary School, Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Deborah Harrison, School speech pathologist (1994 speech and language assessment and services), Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Doreen Hamburger, School psychologist (1994 psychoeducational assessment), Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Lisa Chattler, Speech and language pathologist, Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Sharon Flynn, Tenth-grade English teacher, Los Alamitos High School
  • Mr. Coriaty, Eleventh-grade English teacher and IEP team member, Los Alamitos High School
  • Rob McGill, Sophomore math teacher, Los Alamitos High School
  • Mr. Wilcoff, Eleventh-grade history teacher, Los Alamitos High School
  • Linda Stoskopf, School psychologist (1999 psychoeducational assessment), Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Janet Dodd, Speech and language pathologist (1999 speech and language evaluation), Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Erin Coddington, Special day class teacher who administered the achievement tests, Los Alamitos Unified School District
  • Dr. Kathleen Mack, Clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Dr. Jack Schnel, Educational and clinical psychologist; expert witness for District
  • Lindamood Bell, Private provider (assessment and reading/language services)
  • Sylvan Learning Center, Private provider (diagnostic reading test)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. It was heard on March 8, 9, April 10, 11, May 14, and June 14, 15, 21, and 22, 2001, in Los Alamitos, California.

STUDENT (herein after, “STUDENT” or “Petitioner”) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather and special education advocate Chris Russell. Also present on her behalf was her mother. Los Alamitos Unified School District (hereinafter “District” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Cynthia Yount. Carol McAllister, the District’s director of instruction and pupil services, was also present on behalf of the District.

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. The parties submitted written closing arguments for the case and legal briefs on the issue of remedies. The arguments and briefs, post-marked July 3, 2001, were received by the Hearing Officer on July 6, and the record was closed that day.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and through the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year?

2. If STUDENT was eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year, what remedy is she entitled to for that period of time?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an 18-year-old girl who graduated from Los Alamitos High School on June 22, 2001. She presently lives with her parents and her sister. STUDENT attended a private school until her fourth-grade year. STUDENT’s parents provided background information relating to STUDENT’s early school performance.

Her parents first became aware of STUDENT’s difficulties while she was attending the second grade at Brethren Elementary school, a private school in Norwalk, California. STUDENT had difficulty reading, particularly pronouncing words, recalling and comprehension. Her mother testified that STUDENT had to concentrate so hard on pronouncing the words in her second-grade texts that she could not comprehend what she was reading. According to STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher also noticed the problem and suggested that STUDENT’s parents obtain additional help for her. STUDENT’s difficulties at Brethren continued in her third-grade year. In addition to her difficulties with reading, STUDENT was now having problems in writing and memorizing spelling words. To assist her with her reading, STUDENT was assigned to work with high- achieving students. She was also given extra help at school in the form of small-group sessions, which she was pulled out of class to attend. At home, STUDENT’s mother continued to read to STUDENT and help her with her homework each night. Apparently, she was unable to complete assignments independent of her parents’ direct assistance.

In the fourth grade, STUDENT was enrolled in the Hopkinson Elementary School in the Los Alamitos Unified School District. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher, Ms. Roland, contacted her near the middle of the school year and advised her that STUDENT’s “writing was inadequate.” Ms. Roland demonstrated the problem to STUDENT’s mother by showing her samples of STUDENT’s writing as well as writing samples from other students. STUDENT’s mother continued to assist STUDENT with her reading and writing homework, and FATHER also assisted her with the reading and arithmetic. STUDENT’s parents noted that the same problems persisted and they continually had to proofread and edit STUDENT’s homework. STUDENT’s mother said that when she received STUDENT’s fourth-grade progress reports (Student’s Exhibit D), she did not understand them. The progress reports indicated that STUDENT was in the “early” or “developing” stage in various reading and writing categories, as opposed to the “fluent” or “expanding” stages. It was not clear, however, what the progress ratings or categories meant. Both FATHER and MOTHER recalled talking to parents of other students and comparing their childrens’ schoolwork with STUDENT’s. They believed that STUDENT was behind.

STUDENT’s parents retained their neighbor, NEIGHBOR, to tutor STUDENT during the summers before her fourth– and fifth-grade school years. However, she did not appear to improve. STUDENT’s parents continued to assist, proof, and edit STUDENT’s homework. They observed most of the same problems in reading and writing. They also observed additional difficulties with arithmetic, and STUDENT’S father, who had a math and technical background, assisted STUDENT with her homework in this area. While her progress reports indicated that she was most often in the “developing” category, and occasionally in the “fluent” category, in reading and writing, STUDENT continued to struggle with her homework. STUDENT’s mother recalled that she frequently had STUDENT complete homework assignments on her own, but her errors in spelling and sentence structure were so bad that STUDENT’s mother had to edit and correct them afterward. STUDENT’s mother also testified that STUDENT demonstrated no noticeable improvement in her reading recall and comprehension. STUDENT’S father also continued to help STUDENT with her math homework. What stood out for STUDENT’s parents by this time was STUDENT’s virtual inability to do her homework without their continual hands-on assistance, corrections, and edits. In short, according to STUDENT’s parents, they either walked her through her homework assignments or they re-did them.

During STUDENT’s fifth-grade school year, STUDENT’s mother requested that the District assess STUDENT for special education. The District’s January 1994 consent for assessment form indicated that STUDENT was being assessed due to “problem solving and reasoning skills,” and that she was to be assessed for speech and language problems. (Students Exhibit F.) Ms. Deborah Harrison, the school’s speech pathologist, recalled that she administered to STUDENT the speech and language assessment tests in January 1994. In April 1994, STUDENT’s mother signed another consent for assessment that specified that STUDENT would be assessed in the areas of academic achievement, including reading, math, and written expression; cognitive ability; sensory and motor development; health; and social and emotional development. The assessment form indicated that the rationale for the evaluation was that “STUDENT has been experiencing learning problems.” (Student’s Exhibit F2.)

The speech and language assessments given by Deborah Harrison included the Listening Test, the Word Test, the CELF-R, and the Woodcock Language Assessment. The speech and language assessment indicated that STUDENT scored in the low-average range in reasoning and word association. (Students Exhibit H) The psychoeducational assessments were given by Doreen Hamburger, the school psychologist. The psychoeducational assessment report dated May 25, 1994, indicated that STUDENT was referred for psychoeducational assessment by her parents and staff for the following reasons: “parent request, teacher request, reading comprehension problems, written language problems, poor organization skills, and attention and concentration problems.” As part of the assessment, STUDENT was given the WISC-III, on which she received a verbal IQ score of 91, a performance IQ score of 106, and a full-scale IQ score of 97. STUDENT was also given three achievement assessment tests: the Keymath, the WRAT-R, and the WJTA-R. The assessment report indicated that STUDENT was functioning within expectancy on standard academic measures. (Student’s Exhibit G)

The psychoeducational assessment report did indicate that the “assessment along with STUDENT’s indicated relative deficit in verbal comprehension on the WISC-III suggests that she would benefit from being enrolled in a speech and language program.” (Student’s Exhibit G) Ms. Harrison testified that in a June 1994 IEP meeting, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education and given speech and language services. She stated that STUDENT was determined eligible for special education as a result of her performance on the psychoeducational assessment tests. Beginning in the sixth-grade, STUDENT received speech and language services from Lisa Chattler, the District’s speech and language pathologist at the time. In June 1995, an annual IEP meeting was held. The IEP document indicated that STUDENT had moderate difficulty understanding linguistic concepts and word relationships. The IEP document also noted that STUDENT’s difficulties negatively impacted her academic performance. In response to STUDENT’s impairment, the IEP team set a goal for STUDENT to improve her verbal reasoning and critical thinking. To further her goals, the team set forth specific objectives relating to verbal reasoning and critical thinking. (Student’s Exhibit K)

STUDENT received speech and language services from Ms. Harrison over the course of her sixth and seventh-grade school years. STUDENT had regular attendance at her speech and language class when it was held during the school day; however, her attendance became inconsistent during the 1995-1996 school year after her sessions were moved to the morning hour before the regular school day. Ms. Harrison contacted STUDENT’s mother regarding STUDENT’s attendance in the program. While there was a dispute as to who recommended or asked for the service to be discontinued, STUDENT’s services were discontinued without further assessment or a full IEP team meeting. Ms. Harrison did testify that she felt that STUDENT continued to need the service and that she did not agree with the decision to discontinue the sessions. Although contrary to STUDENT’s mother’s recollection, Ms. Harrison said she understood STUDENT’s mother to want the service discontinued and she said it was generally the school’s policy to adhere to the parents’ wishes.

In her eighth-grade year, STUDENT enrolled in the reading lab in addition to other academic courses such as language arts, social studies, science, and math. STUDENT received A’s and B’s in these courses by the end of the year. (Student’s Exhibit N) In the ninth-grade, STUDENT received failing grades in math and Spanish, but otherwise received passing and even above-average grades in her other subjects, which included both academic and nonacademic classes. STUDENT’s parents retained a private tutor to assist STUDENT with her Spanish and math. STUDENT’s mother testified that the tutoring did not help STUDENT.

In the tenth-grade STUDENT received several failing grades in math and English. Indeed, Ms. Flynn, STUDENT’s tenth-grade English teacher, testified that although STUDENT was sincere and made considerable effort, her performance was one of the worst she had seen in 20 years of teaching. Ms. Flynn also called STUDENT’s mother to discuss STUDENT’ poor performance in her English class. In the eleventh-grade, STUDENT’s English teacher, Mr.

Coriaty, observed that STUDENT had some difficulties in his class early on, but that she improved her grade to a C by the end of the semester. In the second semester of her eleventh-grade year, STUDENT received a D in modern literature and composition.

In April 1999, during STUDENT’s tenth-grade year, STUDENT took the Stanford Test of Academic Skills (SAT-9). She ranked only in the 8th percentile in overall reading (the 25th percentile in vocabulary and the 6th percentile for reading comprehension), and she was ranked in the 7th percentile in overall language (the 15th percentile in mechanics and the 5th percentile in language expression).

In March of 1999, STUDENT was given a diagnostic test in academic reading by the Sylvan Learning Center. In August of 1999, STUDENT’s parents had STUDENT assessed by Lindamood Bell in the areas of language and math. At the conclusion of the assessment, staff from Lindamood Bell recommended STUDENT receive 10-12 weeks of educational services.

On September 7, 1999, STUDENT’s parents filed a request for mediation and a due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office. On September 24, 1999, STUDENT’s parents and the District entered into an interim agreement in which inter alia, the District agreed to assess STUDENT for special education, and if she were found eligible, to fund the recommended 10-12 weeks of Lindamood Bell services. STUDENT’s parents approved the District’s proposed assessment plan at that time.

On September 30, 1999, STUDENT was given a psychoeducational assessment by the District. (See the District’s Psychoeducational Assessment Report in District’s Exhibit 20, page 2, for a complete list of the assessment tools administered by the District between October 1, 1999 and October 19, 1999.) To measure general global cognitive functioning (intellectual ability), STUDENT was given the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scales (WAIS-III) by Linda Stoskopf, the District’s school psychologist. On the WAIS-III, STUDENT produced a full scale IQ score of 95, a verbal IQ of 91, and a performance IQ of 100. Each of the IQ scores is considered average. STUDENT’s sub-test standard scores on the WAIS-III were as follows:

Picture Completion 08 Vocabulary 10 Digit Symbol 11 Similarities 07 Block design 10 Arithmetic 10 Digit Span 07 Information 06 Picture Arrangement 10 Comprehension 11 Symbol Search 11 Letter-Number Sequencing 08

Ms. Stoskopf also gave STUDENT the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (TONI). Like the WAIS-III, this test also is designed to measure intellectual ability. On the TONI, STUDENT received a “Nonverbal Intelligence Quotient” (IQ score) of 116, which is considered above average.

To evaluate academic achievement, STUDENT was administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Tests (WIAT) and the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement. STUDENT’s performance on the WJ-R subtests were as follows:

SUB-TESTS

Basic Reading 88 Math Reasoning 89 Spelling 86 Reading Comprehension 116 Numerical Operations 84 Written Expression 97

COMPOSITES

Reading 97 Mathematics 85 Writing 88

On the WIAT subtests, STUDENT’s results were as follows:

Letter-Word Identification 89 Passage Comprehension 98 Broad reading 92 Calculations 91 Applied Problems 92 Broad Math 91 Dictation 72 Writing Samples 85 Broad Written Language 77

The District’s psychoeducational report indicates that “using standard scores for comparison, as designated by the Education Code Title V, STUDENT did not exhibit a significant discrepancy between academic achievement and intellectual ability. Although some of her skills are below grade level, they do not meet the discrepancy formula requirement.” The report does not specify how the formula was applied in STUDENT’s case.

Additionally, in October 1999, STUDENT was given a speech and language evaluation by Janet Dodd, the District’s speech and language pathologist. Ms. Dodd administered the following tests: the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-three (CELF-3); the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test (CREVT); the Oral and Written Language Scales (OWLS); the Test of Written Language-to (TOWL); and the Comprehensive Test of Phononological Processing (CTOPP). Ms. Dodd concluded that the tests indicated that STUDENT did not qualify for speech and language special education services.

On November 15, 1999, the IEP, over the express dissent of STUDENT’s parents, determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. On June 21, 2000, STUDENT’s mother informed the District in writing that she would be sending STUDENT to Lindamood Bell for educational services and would seek reimbursement from the District for those services. During the summer of 2000, STUDENT received services from Lindamood Bell. On January 17, 2001, the matter, which had previously been taken off-calender at the request of the parties, was re-set for hearing.

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT contends that she was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school. She claims she had a basic psychological processing disorder, specifically an audio processing disorder, that manifested itself in an impaired ability read, write, spell, and do mathematical calculations. STUDENT alleges that in connection with her disorder, she had a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the area of written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, listening comprehension, and mathematical calculation and reasoning. STUDENT maintains that to the extent she earned passing grades throughout her years in school, she did so only with the consistent and intensive assistance of her parents and sister. But she insists that she could not effectively read, write, or perform mathematical calculations. STUDENT also points out that she utilized regular school resources, prior special education services, private tutors, and school-based tutors, but to no avail.

STUDENT argued that the ability and achievement tests she took in 1999 revealed a discrepancy between her abilities and achievements. STUDENT contends that the TONI rather than the WAIS-III is the appropriate cognitive test to compare to the achievement test, because the latter does not paint an accurate picture of her intellectual ability. She claims that the verbal portion of the WAIS-III required her to use the very audio process that was impaired and thus it skewed the results.

The District responds that STUDENT did not suffer from a specific learning disability. It takes the position that while she may have had a weakness in her audio processes, she did not have a processing disorder and she did not have a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and achievement. The District points out that STUDENT had earned better than average grades over the years, that she has passed each of her courses and advanced grade-to-grade, and that any difficulties that she had could have been addressed in the regular school program.

As to the written assessment tests, the District takes an opposing view. It alleges that the WAISC-III was the appropriate instrument to compare to the achievement tests since it is more broad-based than the TONI. Thus, the argument goes, the WAISC-III, particularly the full scale score, more accurately reflected STUDENT’s overall ability.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999, and the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year?

Applicable Law

California Education Code, section 56026 identifies “individuals with exceptional needs” as those persons whose impairment, as defined by Title 20 USC § 1401, requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Section 56337 states that a pupil shall be assessed as having a specific learning disability which makes him or her eligible for special education and related services when it is determined that a severe discrepancy exists between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more areas relating to oral and written language, writing, and math, and where the discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

The California Code of Regulations §3030 states in pertinent part:

A pupil shall qualify as an individual with exceptional needs, pursuant to Section 56026 of the Education Code, if the results of the assessment as required by Section 56320 demonstrate that the degree of the pupil's impairment as described in Section 3030 (a through j) requires special education in one or more of the program options authorized by Section 56361 of the Education Code. The decision as to whether or not the assessment results demonstrate that the degree of the pupil's impairment requires special education shall be made by the individualized education program team, including personnel in accordance with Section 56341(d) of the Education Code. The individualized education program team shall take into account all of the relevant material which is available on the pupil. No single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for the decision of the individualized education program team as to the pupil's eligibility for special education. The specific processes and procedures for implementation of these criteria shall be developed by each Special Education Local Plan Area and be included in the local plan pursuant to Section 56220(a) of the Education Code.

As discussed below, subsection (j) of C.C.R. §3030 sets forth specific criteria and factors to be considered for determining whether a student has a disorder in one or more of her basic psychological processes, and whether she has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement. Under §3030(j)(4), the IEP team is responsible for making a decision as to whether a pupil has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. The IEP team must take into account all relevant information that is available on the pupil. Paragraph (A) of §3030(j)(4) notes that when standardized tests are considered to be valid for a specific pupil, a severe discrepancy is demonstrated by applying a particular formula to the ability and achievement test results.

Evidentiary Analysis

The Hearing Officer begins the analysis by reviewing the elements of a specific learning disability. As noted above, under §56337 and C.C.R. §3030(j) a pupil is considered eligible for special education with a specific learning disability if:

1. The pupil has a disorder of one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written;

2. Which may manifest itself in an impaired ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations, and

3. Has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the academic areas specified in §56337(a).

4. The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

The Hearing Officer next weighs the evidence and applies the facts adduced at trial to the legal criteria set forth above.

Disorder of a Basic Psychological Process

STUDENT presented evidence that she had a disorder of one of her basic psychological processes as of November 15, 1999, and for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. Specifically, she contended that she had an auditory processing disorder. Auditory processing is one of the basic psychological processes specified in C.C.R. §3030(j)(1). Dr. Kathleen Mack, an expert witness on behalf of STUDENT, testified that in her opinion STUDENT had an audio processing disorder. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mack possesses substantial expertise to render an opinion on this matter.(Footnote 2) Dr. Mack credibly testified that STUDENT’s performance on the District’s Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP) indicated a weakness in phonological memory.(Footnote 3) Indeed, the District’s assessment indicated that STUDENT scored only in the 3rd percentile in phonological memory. (District’s Exhibit 21. P. 4.) Dr. Mack explained that phonological memory included remembering or encoding sounds in relationship to symbols, which is part of auditory processing. Dr. Mack also pointed out that STUDENT ranked in the 8th, 10th, and 14th percentiles in general vocabulary, expressive vocabulary, and receptive vocabulary respectively, which is also indicative of an audio processing disorder. (District’s Exhibit 21. P. 2.)

Dr. Mack’s expert opinion is also supported by the specific observations of STUDENT’s tenth-grade English teacher, Ms. Sharon Flynn. According to Ms. Flynn, STUDENT had serious difficulty in virtually every aspect of her class. She emphasized that STUDENT’s test scores were “so low” that they “stood out” and sent up a “red flag.” On her exams, she typically received marks of one out of twenty or three out of twenty-five. In literature, her grades were in the low D range when the class studied the books Of Mice and Men and Twelve Angry Men. Ms. Flynn added that when the class began working on more difficult books such as To Kill a Mockingbird, STUDENT fell even further behind. She failed two more reading tests on this book, obtaining scores of zero out of twenty and three out of twenty. STUDENT, she said, also failed tests on the play Much Ado About Nothing. Ms. Flynn commented that these materials were standard reading for all tenth-graders. Ms. Flynn said that in her estimation STUDENT did not understand what she was reading. She also testified that in all areas of her class, which included grammar, writing and literature, STUDENT’s scores on a scale of 100 were in the 40's or low 50's. In vocabulary, STUDENT’s scores were even lower. On this subject, she usually received marks of one or two out of twenty. Additionally, Ms. Flynn testified that STUDENT took the practice ACT exam with the rest of the class. She noted that STUDENT’s scores on that test were very low, which she believed confirmed what she had observed of STUDENT in her class.

Ms. Flynn gave another telling example of STUDENT’s difficulties: a research paper she had assigned the class. She explained that she had spent an entire month “teaching every single part individually.” The paper was on Hemingway’s Old Man and the Sea. The paper was worth 200 points and required writing for all of the tenth-graders. She re-emphasized that she spent a month in class carefully going over every aspect of the paper. STUDENT received a zero on the paper. Ms. Flynn then began working individually with STUDENT in after school tutoring sessions. Ms. Flynn “went over everything” with STUDENT, showed her examples of correct papers, and explained to her where she “fell through” on her first paper. STUDENT re-did the assignment and still received an F. She also failed the Latin final. Only by retaking the test did STUDENT pass the class at all. Ms. Flynn observed that as the year progressed, STUDENT fell even further and further behind. Ms. Flynn added that she did not want to flunk STUDENT because she had made a sincere effort. Ms. Flynn did comment, however, that what stood out most about STUDENT was not that she failed, but that she “failed by so much.” In her testimony, Ms. Flynn stated that STUDENT had a “problem.” She observed, “To me, she [STUDENT] had some kind of a processing problem. She doesn’t put things together.” She explained her opinion by way of example: In vocabulary, the students were instructed regarding “roots.” They received 15 “roots” or “prefixes” each week. Ms. Flynn explained that she put the roots into words. By knowing the root, the student should be able to provide intelligent answers to questions she posed relating to words that included the specified roots. She pointed out that the exercise is not one of memorization and regurgitation of words. “That was the problem,” Ms. Flynn noted; “she [STUDENT] couldn’t synthesize. She couldn’t put two roots together.” Ms. Flynn, who had taught English for more than 20 years, said that she was concerned, and that she did not know how to help STUDENT.

Ms. Flynn recounted that STUDENT had completed most of her homework assignments, had a good attitude, and was trying in class. She distinguished STUDENT from other students who had failed in the past. Those pupils, she commented, did not try, did not do their homework, and had a poor attitude. The fact that STUDENT did not fit into this category made her problems stand out. Ms. Flynn concluded that in more than 20 years of teaching English, she could not remember a student doing more poorly than STUDENT.

STUDENT’s mother’s recollection of STUDENT’s efforts at homework were consistent with Ms. Flynn’s observations. STUDENT, she recalled, could not understand much of what she read, even after several tries. Additionally, STUDENT’s mother noted that STUDENT could not write without significant errors in spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Both FATHER and MOTHER remembered that STUDENT was virtually unable to follow multi-step oral or written instructions. STUDENT herself testified that as to reading, writing, and math, she was unable to “get it.” Moreover, STUDENT’s performance on the SAT-9 test in April 1999, where she finished in the 8th percentile in total reading, 6th percentile in reading comprehension, 7th percentile in language, 15th percentile in language mechanics, and 5th percentile in language expression, appears consistent with a student who had an audio processing disorder. (See Student’s Exhibit T.)

Experts for the District, notably Linda Stokopf, a District psychologist, Janet Dodd, a District speech and language pathologist, and Dr. Jack Schnel, an educational and clinical psychologist, took the position that STUDENT did not demonstrate an audio processing disorder in November 1999. However, Ms. Dodd, who administered the speech and language assessment instruments to STUDENT, admitted that she was not testing for an auditory processing disorder. She also noted that a child may qualify for special education with an auditory processing disorder– where the other elements of a specific learning disability are met– even though she may not qualify as speech and language impaired under §56333. Ms. Dodd pointed out that memory is a function of auditory processing and that STUDENT’s performance on the CCTOP indicated some concern in that area. She did agree that the tests indicated that STUDENT had a “weakness” in writing (expressive language), including punctuation and the use of capitalization, commas, and quotes.

Ms. Stoskopf testified that if STUDENT had an auditory processing impairment it was not significant. She did, however, admit that STUDENT was not specifically tested for an auditory processing disorder. While Ms. Stoskopf acknowledged that STUDENT was not specifically tested for an auditory processing disorder, she recognized that her visual processing “channel” was stronger than her auditory. Although STUDENT’s assessments indicated that her visual processing skills were in the average range, and the District suspected that her audio process was weaker by comparison, it did not specifically test to see how much weaker her auditory “process” was. In fact, rather than conduct specific assessments of her audio processing abilities, the District, for reasons it could not logically explain, chose instead to conduct further tests of STUDENT’s visual processes to “confirm” its strength– this in spite of the fact that §56320(f) requires a District to assess a pupil in all areas of suspected disabilities. While the District took the position that neither the speech and language nor the psychoeducational assessment tests that it administered indicated that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder, both Ms. Dodd and Ms. Stoskopf recognized that STUDENT’s auditory process was weaker than her visual, which they agreed was average. Dr. Schnel, an expert retained by the District to offer an opinion based on the documentary evidence, testified that he did not believe the evidence supported a finding that STUDENT had an audio processing disorder. However, like Ms. Dodd’s and Ms. Stoskopf’s, opinion, Dr. Schnel’s conclusion was based on psychoeducational assessment tests alone, and those tests did not include instruments specifically designed to measure STUDENT’s audio processing abilities.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mack’s opinion regarding STUDENT’s audio processing disorder is supported by a preponderance of the evidence. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s apparent deficiencies in phonological memory, expressive language, reading, and math support a conclusion that STUDENT had an audio processing disorder. This conclusion is consistent with Ms. Flynn’s extensive observations of STUDENT in her classroom over the course of a year. The finding that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder within the meaning of §56337 and C.C.R. §3030(j) is also consistent with the various assessment test results, STUDENT’s performance on the SAT-9 in April 1999, and the testimony of STUDENT and STUDENT’s mother and father.

Manifestation of the Disorder

STUDENT contended that her audio processing disorder manifested itself in an impaired ability to read, write, spell, and do mathematical calculations. Ms. Flynn’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s performance in her English class supports STUDENT’s contention that her audio processing disorder manifested itself in an impaired ability to read and write. STUDENT’s eleventh-grade English teacher for the fall 1999 semester, Mr. Coriaty, noted STUDENT’s spelling problems. Mr. Rob McGill, STUDENT’s sophomore math teacher recalled that she received D’s in math as a result of low test scores.(Footnote 4) The observations by STUDENT’s teachers were consistent with STUDENT’s parents’ assertions regarding STUDENT’s problems with homework involving reading, writing, spelling, and math. STUDENT’s low scores on the April 1999 SAT-9– notably reading, language and to a lesser extent, math– also indicated that her audio processing disorder had manifested itself in an impaired ability in these subjects. (Student’s Exhibit T) The results of various Subtests in the achievement portion of the psychoeducational assessment tests batteries administered by the District in 1999 were likewise consistent with STUDENT’s contention that her disorder impaired her ability in writing, spelling, and language. (See District’s Exhibits 20.) Moreover, Ms. Dodd testified that the speech and language assessments revealed a weakness in STUDENT’s ability to write.

The District did not refute the evidence presented by STUDENT regarding her problems with reading, writing, spelling, and math. In fact, virtually all of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT had difficulties with reading and writing, and to some extent math. However, in the Distrct’s opinion, to the extent she had these problems they were not the result of an audio processing disorder. Moreover, it contended that her difficulties could be addressed in the regular educational program. As to the latter point, it is part of a separate analysis and discussed below. Regarding the first point, the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT had an audio processing disorder within the context of §56337.

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that a preponderance of the evidence supports a finding that STUDENT’s audio processing disorder manifested itself in an impaired ability to read, write, spell, and do mathematical calculations as specified in C.C.R. §3030(j).

Discrepancy Between Intellectual Ability and Achievement

As discussed above, the law requires that a pupil with a basic psychological processing disorder that manifests itself in an impaired ability to read, write, spell, and do mathematical calculations must also have a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more areas specified under §56337(a) in order to be found eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability.(Footnote 5) The C.C.R. §3030 requires that the IEP team take into account all of the relevant material that is available on the pupil. The regulation adds that no single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for the decision of the IEP team as to the pupil’s eligibility for special education. Paragraph (j) of C.C.R.§3030 provides that a severe discrepancy is demonstrated by a particular computed difference between ability and achievement test scores, as determined by a specified formula. (C.C.R. §3030(j)(4)(A).)(Footnote 6) The regulation also requires that the discrepancy be corroborated by other assessment data.

STUDENT was given the WAIS-III and the TONI to evaluate her intellectual ability and the WIAT and WJ-R to measure her achievement. She received a full scale score of 95 on the WAIS-III and a score of 116 on the TONI. On the WJ-R, STUDENT received a standard score of 72 in the dictation subtest. The dictation test measured STUDENT’s ability to write (written expression), including spelling, punctuation, and capitalization. (Written expression of one of the enumerated academic areas specified in §56337(a).) The District argued that the WAIS-III full scale score of 95 was the more appropriate score to compare with STUDENT’s achievement test scores. This score compared to STUDENT’s standard score of 72 in dictation results in a discrepancy of 23. For the reasons discussed in footnote number 6 above, the Hearing Officer finds that a discrepancy of 23 is severe within the meaning of §3030(j)(4)(A). The District’s expert, Dr. Schnel, concurred that a severe discrepancy existed between dictation and the WAIS-III full scale score. The Hearing Officer notes that this subtest appears particularly relevant to an audio processing disorder since the test-taker listens to oral statements and then reproduces the words and phrases in writing. In fact, the District’s psychologist, Ms. Stoskopf, explained that an audio processing problem would cause a person to have a difficult time making sense of what is being said. Her opinion appears consistent with the discrepancy noted.

State regulations also specify that no single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for determining eligibility with a specific learning disability. (C.C.R. §3030(j)(4).) Indeed, the computed difference between STUDENT’s achievement score in dictation and both the performance portion of the WAIS-III and the TONI also reflect a severe discrepancy, with a difference of 28 and 44 points respectively. Erin Coddington, the District’s special day class teacher who administered the achievement tests, testified that she compared STUDENT’s broad written language score of 77 on the WJ-R with the full scale WAIS-III score of 95. She concluded that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. However, Ms. Stoskopf explained that an audio processing disorder would effect the pupil’s performance on the verbal portion of the WAIS-III, and thus affect the full scale score. If STUDENT’s WJ-R score of 77 in broad written language is compared to the performance portion of either the WAIS-III or the TONI, a discrepancy of more than 22.5 is noted. The expert witnesses in this case, including Ms. Stoskopf, Dr. Schnel, and Dr. Mack, agreed that the verbal portion of the WAIS-III assessment utilizes primarily the test taker’s audio processes. Given an audio processing disorder, the performance portion of the WAIS-III and the TONI appear to offer a more complete picture of STUDENT’s intellectual ability.(Footnote 7) Although the performance portion of the WAIS-III involve the audio process to varying degrees, it primarily utilizes visual processes.

In addition, State regulations require any discrepancy in test scores to be corroborated by other assessment data, which may include other tests, scales, observations, and work samples as appropriate. (C.C.R. §3030(j)(4)(A).) As previously discussed, STUDENT ranked in the 8th, 10th, and 14th percentiles in general vocabulary, expressive vocabulary, and receptive vocabulary respectively in the CREVT speech and language assessment test administered in 1999. (District’s Exhibit 21, P. 2.) Additionally, she placed in the 7th percentile in written expression on the OWLS. (District’s Exhibit 21. P. 3.) On the TOWL-2, her vocabulary score was in the 5th percentile, her spelling score was in the 16th percentile, her thematic maturity score was in the 9th percentile, and her contextual spelling score was in the 9th percentile. (District’s Exhibit 21, P. 3-4.) The low scores on these particular subtests, all of which relate to written expression, support the conclusion that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in this area.(Footnote 8) In addition, on the April 1999 SAT-9, STUDENT finished in the 8th percentile in total reading, 6th percentile in reading comprehension, the percentile in language, in the 15th percentile in reading mechanics, and in the 5th percentile in language expression. (See Student’s Exhibit T) The scores on the assessment subtests and the April 1999 SAT-9 also confirm Ms. Flynn’s and STUDENT’s parents’ observations of STUDENT’s difficulties with written expression.

The District agrees that no one test should be used to determine whether a child is eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability. But it contends that the evidence contradicts a finding of a severe discrepancy. Ms. Stoskopf and Dr. Schnel believed that the full scale score on the WAIS-III provided a better picture of STUDENT’s intellectual ability. And it, rather than the performance score on the WAIS-III or the TONI, should be compared to STUDENT’s achievement tests. Assuming arguendo that the District’s position is correct, STUDENT has established a severe discrepancy between her full scale WAIS-III score (ability) and her achievement assessments in the area of written expression (dictation). Thus, at least one score, using the score comparison advocated by the District, revealed a severe discrepancy as required by C.C.R. §3030(j)(4)(A). As discussed above, however, no single score or product of scores shall be used to determine eligibility.

The District’s position was that STUDENT’s grades and class performance indicated that she did not have a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement. Regarding her grades, Ms. Stoskopf and Dr. Schnel opined that a student with such a discrepancy would not have done so well as STUDENT had in her various academic classes. Thus, the District would have the Hearing Officer infer that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement in written expression as a result of good grades in some classes. But other than Ms. Flynn’s, Mr. Wilcoff’s, and Mr. Coriaty’s class, which are discussed in more detail below, the District did not explain the basis for those grades. STUDENT’s parents and sister testified that they consistently edited, corrected, and in the case of her sister SISTER, even re-wrote her homework papers. Neither Ms. Stoskopf, Ms. Dodd, Ms. Coddington, nor Dr. Schnel, knew to what extent the quantity and quality of STUDENT’s homework was factored into those grades. Neither did the witnesses know to what extent class lectures, participation, effort, or group projects accounted for those marks. Therefore, the inference advanced by the District regarding STUDENT’s grades is minimal since the basis of those grades is largely unknown.

Both parties elicited information regarding the basis for STUDENT’s grades in Ms. Flynn’s, Mr. Wilcoff’s, and Mr. Coriaty’s class. As previously discussed, Ms. Flynn testified regarding STUDENT’s virtual inability to write competently in her English class. In her class, STUDENT could not write an essay, she flunked every test in the class, she did not appear to understand what she read, and she could not synthesize information, particularly roots of words and their relationship to whole words. Yet because of her efforts in class and the fact that she turned in most of her homework assignments, STUDENT passed. Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT could learn virtually nothing in a particular course and still pass the class.(Footnote 9)

In the case of her eleventh-grade history class, Mr. Wilcoff testified that STUDENT’s good marks were based on content and not writing ability. He explained that the material was presented in class lectures, group projects, and short reading assignments of five pages or so at a time. Grades were based on homework, projects and a final exam. The exam consisted of 100 multiple choice questions and several short essays. Mr. Wilcoff testified that he graded the essays on their substantive content and not necessarily on proper writing skills. Mr. Wilcoff testified that the District’s Exhibit 30 included samples of STUDENT’s written work in his history class. He stated that he had marked the papers for writing mistakes, but that the errors were not part of STUDENT’s grade. (The Hearing Officer also noted numerous additional spelling, punctuation, and grammatical errors on the papers in addition to those marked.) In short, the B STUDENT received in Mr. Wilcoff’s class does not contradict the conclusion that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between her ability and her achievement in written expression.

Mr. Coriaty, STUDENT’s eleventh-grade English teacher for the fall 1999 term, testified that he believed that STUDENT’s writing skills were adequate for her age and grade. In support of his contention, he testified regarding the contents of his course, STUDENT’s activities in his class, her writing exercises during tutoring sessions, and his opinion as to the quality of her written work samples submitted as evidence. Mr. Coriaty testified that his students were required to read a book, The Scarlet Letter, participate in class discussions, complete writing assignments at school and home, and take quizzes. He testified that initially STUDENT was a high ‘D’ or low ‘C’ student in his class and that she “struggled with her writing skills.” He testified that she had problems with sentence structure, spelling, grammar and vocabulary. Mr. Coriaty claimed that STUDENT’s skills improved over the course of the semester as a result of his tutoring her. (This point will be discussed in more detail below.) In his opinion, STUDENT’s writing skills ultimately were adequate. But Mr. Coriaty’s credibility was weakened by the inconsistencies in his testimony.

Mr. Coriaty testified that some of the class work was sent home as homework and that other written assignments were completed in class. As to homework, Mr. Coriaty admitted that he would have no way of knowing whether STUDENT had assistance on her papers from her family. Initially, he testified that it was his practice to have the class edit the written in-class and homework assignments as a group. But when pressed by STUDENT’s counsel on the point that he had had little opportunity to actually review and evaluate STUDENT’s independent written work, he became agitated and blurted out that he had observed “countless independent papers” by STUDENT.(Footnote 10) However, he did not provide a single example of these “countless” papers. Mr. Coriaty did comment on some samples of STUDENT’s writing that she completed in her after-school tutoring sessions with him. (District’s Exhibit 31.) The samples included essays, paragraphs, and sentences. The essays appeared to be full of mistakes, including sentence, paragraph, and essay structure, and grammar, punctuation, and spelling errors. There were considerable correction marks on the papers, which Mr. Coriaty conceded were his. Interestingly enough, he took the position that the sentence samples were well written for an eleventh-grader. The Hearing Officer, however, noted that these sentences contained numerous basic uncorrected errors in structure, grammar, and punctuation. (See District’s Exhibit 31) Moreover, Ms. Stoskopf and Dr. Schnel testified that writing paragraphs and essays involves more sophisticated writing skills than mere sentences. Thus, Mr. Coriaty’s testimony and the samples he provided of STUDENT’s writing do not contradict the conclusion that she had a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and achievement in written expression.

The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment tests reveal a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, and the other assessment data, including other test results, teacher and parent observations, and work samples corroborate these findings. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that under C.C.R. §3030(j) STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and achievement as it relates to written expression.

Correction of the Discrepancy in the Regular Instructional Program

The District also argued that even if STUDENT had an audio processing disorder and a discrepancy between her ability and achievement, her impairment could have been corrected in the regular educational program. Ms. Stoskopf stated that Mr. Coriaty, who was a member of the IEP team, said at the IEP meeting that he could have provided STUDENT with the needed tutoring to address her particular needs. Ms. Stoskopf, however, testified that she did not know whether Mr. Coriaty knew anything about an audio processing disorder, or how to teach or tutor someone with the disorder, and that he did not propose any services other than tutoring. Indeed, Mr. Coriaty stated that the tutoring he subsequently gave STUDENT was that which was offered to any other student. Ms. Stoskopf also admitted that prior to the IEP meeting she did not know whether STUDENT had been offered services in the regular education program, but she noted they were available if STUDENT had sought them out herself.

The problem with the District’s position is that STUDENT had received significant educational services both within and outside the regular school program. She retained tutors during grade school, received speech and language services in middle school, and had taken advantage of Ms. Flynn’s offer to tutor her on her tenth-grade essay project. Moreover, STUDENT attended approximately 16 tutoring sessions with Mr. Coriaty after the November 1999 IEP meeting, but her work samples from those sessions do not indicate that her deficiency was being corrected. (See District’s Exhibits 30 and 31.) Additionally, Ms. Stoskopf testified that she had not designed or proposed a plan to address STUDENT’s difficulties. She also stated that Mr. Coriaty had merely suggested that he tutor STUDENT and suggested that she sign up for a summer course in composition. But STUDENT had attended classes and utilized various tutoring resources in the past to no apparent avail. The District could not explain how other regular or categorical services in the regular educational program could have made a difference this time. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement could not have been corrected with regular or categorical services in the District’s regular educational program. Conclusion

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that on November 15, 1999, STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder that manifested itself in an impaired ability to read, write, spell, and do mathematical calculations, and that she has a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and achievement in the area of written expression. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in written expression could not be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Additionally, there is no evidence that her condition improved during the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that on November 15, 1999, and during the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT had a specific learning disability within the meaning of C.C.R. §3030(j) and hence qualified for special education.

Issue Number 2: If STUDENT was eligible for special education as a pupil with a specific learning disability as of November 15, 1999 and the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year, what remedy is she entitled to for that period of time?

Applicable Law

Special education law provides that when a school district denies a student FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. (School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 , 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i) (1997).) Thus, the parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they procure for their child when the school district fails to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. (Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at p. 370.) The rule in Burlington is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. state Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).)

Evidentiary Analysis

In this case, both STUDENT and the District agreed that if the Hearing Officer found STUDENT eligible for special education services, their interim mediation agreement of September 24, 1999, would be binding on the parties. In its pertinent part, that agreement reads as follows:

If pupil is special education eligible, district will fund the recommended 10-12 weeks of Lindamood Bell.

The Hearing Officer finds that the remedy agreed to by the parties is binding in as much as the Hearing Officer has found STUDENT eligible for special education as of November 15, 1999 and for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. The District is ordered to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the costs of the Lindamood Bell services provided to STUDENT in the summer of 2000.

In her post-hearing brief on remedies, STUDENT also requests the Hearing Officer order the District to fund an additional 12 weeks of Lindamood Bell services. She points out that although she did not raise an issue of FAPE for any of the three years preceding her filing for a due process hearing on September 7, 1999, the Hearing Officer has the authority to award her compensatory education beyond that called for in the interim agreement. STUDENT argues that because the District did not identify her as eligible for special education and provide her with a FAPE for the three years prior to 1999, she should receive additional compensatory education. She also contends that she is still deficient in math and can improve further in reading and language.

But, as STUDENT correctly admits in her brief, the issue at hearing was her eligibility on November 15, 1999, and for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. Consequently, the Hearing Officer is limited to ordering a remedy for that period of time. To the extent that STUDENT alleges that past denials of FAPE– for the three years preceding 1999– justify the Hearing Officer ordering Lindamood Bell services beyond those called for in the September 1999 interim mediation agreement, the question is whether the Lindamood Bell services STUDENT received in the Summer of 2000 provided her an adequate remedy for the period of time at issue in the case. STUDENT presented compelling evidence that the Lindamood Bell services allowed her to significantly improve her ability write, read, and comprehend both oral and written instructions. STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s father, and STUDENT testified in considerable detail as to how STUDENT’s academic performance improved the following year as a result of Lindamood Bell. In fact, her improvement would almost certainly have rendered her ineligible for special education in her senior year of high school. Accordingly, the evidence supports a finding that the Lindamood Bell service provided to STUDENT met her unique needs and provided her with ample educational benefit for the period of time at issue in this case. Thus, no compensatory education is necessary.

ORDER

1. Within 30 calender days of the date of this decision, and in accordance with the interim mediation agreement entered into by the parties on September 24, 1999, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the actual cost of the Lindamood Bell services provided to STUDENT in the summer of 2000.

2. All other requests by STUDENT for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statue:

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as of November 15, 1999? –STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

2. If STUDENT was eligible for special education as of November 15, 1999, what remedies is she entitled to? –STUDENT prevailed to the extent that she received the remedy agreed to in the pre-hearing mediation interim agreement.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).

Date: July 18, 2001 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1.The issues listed here are framed slightly differently from those stated by Petitioner in her statement of issues prior to the hearing. The Hearing Officer changed the wording to better clarify the issues and to more accurately reflect how the issues were framed by Petitioner at hearing during discussion, argument and the presentation of evidence. 2. Dr. Mack’s Ph.D. in Clinical Psychology as well as her post-doctoral work in pediatric psychoeducational assessments and her clinical experience in that field provides her with the expertise to interpret STUDENT’s psychoeducational assessment data and render an opinion regarding her basic psychological processes 3. Dr. Mack noted that the District’s assessment reports did not indicate that it had directly tested STUDENT for an audio processing disorder. 4. Ultimately, STUDENT received a C in his math class, but he recalled that 20 percent of the grade was based on homework and 10 percent on other projects. 5. Additional criteria for eligibility is also found in §56337(c) and is discussed below. 6. There is a debate in the school psychologist community as to how to measure a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability standardized achievements tests. An article in the California School Psychologist calls into question the practice of merely comparing the standard scores in the ability and achievement tests to find evidence of a severe discrepancy. (Helm and Johnson “Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California’s Title 5 Regulations,” 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998).) The article suggests that a more sophisticated analysis of the tests results be made that includes utilizing standard criterion derived from particular tables. However, there is insufficient information available regarding these tables for the Hearing Officer to apply them is this case. Additionally, the parties have neither requested nor argued that the Hearing Officer do so. Moreover, the federal statute and regulations do not require a specified numerical difference in scores for a severe discrepancy. 20 USC §1401 (26); 34 C.F.R..§300. 541. The Hearing Office has consistently utilized the 22. 5 point-discrepancy, and it will be applied here. 7. While Dr. Schnel and Ms. Stoskopf took the position that the WAIS-III full-scale score provides a more complete picture of the test taker’s intellectual ability, their supposition somewhat contradicts the purpose of the test. The Hearing Officer looks to various factors, including the WAIS-III, to determine whether STUDENT has a learning disability, yet the score on the verbal portion of the WAIS-III factors in the very impairment under investigation. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that assessment tools that rely less on STUDENT’s impairment are more probative in this case. 8. The reference to these scores–sub-test scores in the area of written expression– is for the limited purpose of corroborating the discrepancy noted in the psychoeducational assessment tests as required by C.C.R. §3030(j)(4)(A). 9.This observation by the Hearing Officer is not intended as a criticism of Ms. Flynn for passing STUDENT in her class, nor is it an expression that STUDENT’s passing was somehow inappropriate. In fact, the evidence produced at the hearing indicates that Ms. Flynn is an excellent teacher. The point is that passing grades do not necessarily mean that a pupil is achieving to such a degree that he or she could not per se have a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. In this case, the basis for STUDENT’s grades is relevant to determining whether she had a discrepancy. 10. Mr. Coriaty also pointed out that he “knew what this case was about,” STUDENT’s parents “getting twelve-thousand dollars.”