California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 15, 2001
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1425-01 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Los Angeles Unified not required to shorten deaf student's three-hour daily bus ride to Marlton School; claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old eighth grader who is deaf filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student attended a special day class at Marlton School, a District charter school for deaf and hard-of-hearing students. Her parents had asked for that placement. Her IEP included bus transportation. Marlton is about 14 miles from home, roughly 23 minutes by car, but the round-trip bus ride took about three hours a day. The bus picked her up around 6:22 a.m. and brought her home between 4:20 and 4:40 p.m. Her mother said the ride caused nausea, dizziness and fatigue and left less time for homework. The parents asked that bus time be capped at 90 minutes a day in total.
Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown found the mother credible but held that the District offered a FAPE for 2001-2002. Two doctor's notes mentioned motion sickness. However, the school nurse found the student generally healthy, and her teachers had not seen her tired or heard her complain about the bus. Her trouble paying attention and finishing assignments was noted in her fifth-grade IEP, before she attended Marlton. The Hearing Officer said travel time is an inherent cost of attending a distant school, and the ride did not undermine an otherwise appropriate placement. Under Rowley, the law requires an appropriate placement, not an optimal one. The claim was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO looked at transportation as a related service. A long bus ride was judged as part of a placement the parents chose. A change was required only if evidence showed the ride harmed the student's health or educational benefit. Parent reports and doctor's notes were weighed against observations from school staff.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Does Petitioner need a shorter bus ride to school in order to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
The roughly three-hour daily round-trip bus ride did not deny FAPE. The evidence did not show it harmed the student's health or educational benefit, and travel time is an inherent cost of the distant placement the parents requested.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's claim for relief denied.
Key authorities
Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Education Code § 56363
People named in the decision
- Ann Pruitt Shough, speech and language teacher, Marlton School / Los Angeles Unified School District
- Ada Chukwu, school nurse, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Yolanda Roberson, teacher (seventh-grade homeroom), Marlton School
- Delia Acosta, bus driver, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Adrian Alcala, assistant bus supervisor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Glenn Truesdell, teacher (seventh-grade English, eighth-grade speech), Marlton School
- Christina Diaz, certified Spanish language interpreter
- Lon Ramsel, certified sign language interpreter
- Kate Nelson, certified sign language interpreter
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing on September 13, 2001, in Los Angeles, California, before Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter “Petitioner” or “STUDENT”) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was her father, FATHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (hereinafter “District”) was represented at the hearing by attorney Ricardo Silva from the law firm of Lozano Smith. Certified Spanish language interpreter Christina Diaz provided Spanish interpretation for FATHER. Certified sign language interpreters Lon Ramsel and Kate Nelson alternated in providing sign language interpretation for hearing-impaired witnesses.
Petitioner called her mother, MOTHER, to testify at the hearing. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Ann Pruitt Shough, speech and language teacher; Ada Chukwu, school nurse; Yolanda Roberson, teacher; Delia Acosta, bus driver; Adrian Alcala, assistant bus supervisor; and Glenn Truesdell, teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Both parties presented brief oral closing arguments and were permitted to submit additional written closing arguments; only the District subsequently submitted a written closing argument. Additionally, the Hearing Officer requested that the District submit into evidence Petitioner’s report cards from two previous school years. Upon receipt of the additional documents and the District’s written closing brief on September 21, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
* Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number.
ISSUE
Does Petitioner need a shorter bus ride to school in order to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The only issue in dispute concerns the length of the bus ride between the student’s home and school for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner argues that spending at least three hours per school day on the bus interferes with her physical and emotional health and with her ability to do schoolwork and homework. In contrast, the District argues that Petitioner’s current bus ride does not interfere with her health or with her academic progress. Petitioner seeks a shorter ride to and from school, for a maximum total of ninety minutes on the bus each day, while the District argues that the current bus ride is adequate and allows Petitioner to receive a FAPE.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old girl who lives with her family within the boundaries of the Los Angeles Unified School District. STUDENT is eligible for special education because she is deaf, with severe-profound bilateral sensorineural hearing loss. She communicates using American Sign Language (ASL) and also has hearing aids that she uses sometimes while at school. (See testimony of Ann Pruitt Shough; District’s Exh. 8.)
STUDENT began attending school at age three, at Farmdale School within the District. After a year at Farmdale, STUDENT transferred to a “total communication” program at the District’s Multnomah School. She continued to attend Multnomah from preschool through fifth grade. Her fifth grade IEP noted that she attended a deaf/hard-of-hearing (DHH) special day class (SDC) at Multnomah. At the end of STUDENT’s fifth grade year, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s transition from elementary school to sixth grade. Pursuant to a request from MOTHER, the team agreed that STUDENT should attend sixth grade at Marlton School (Marlton), a District charter school for deaf and hard-of-hearing. (Testimony of MOTHER; District’s Exhs. 14, 21.) For the 1999-2000 school year and 2000 extended school year (ESY), STUDENT attended sixth grade at Marlton. She remained there for seventh grade in 2000-2001 and for the 2001 ESY. Her school records reflect that she missed eighteen days of school during the regular 2000-2001 school year, and eight days of school during summer school. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 10, 11.)
For the current school year, STUDENT is an eighth-grader at Marlton. Her current IEP, dated February 12, 2001, includes placement at Marlton in an SDC setting, speech and language services, bus transportation, ESY, adaptive software, specially designed physical education, and accommodations and modifications including small-group instruction and ASL instruction. Her IEP goals and objectives are in the areas of reading, math, audiology, English, and articulation.
The drive between Marlton and the PARENTS’ home is a distance of approximately 14 miles and takes approximately 23 minutes by car, depending on traffic. (See http://www.mapquest.com.) Throughout her enrollment at Marlton, STUDENT has received round-trip bus transportation as a related service, pursuant to her IEPs. STUDENT’s bus ride takes approximately ninety minutes each way, for a total of three hours daily. (Testimony of Delia Acosta, Adrian Alcala; District’s Exh. 5.) The bus routes are designed in a “spoke” system, wherein each bus first picks up the students who live farthest away and later picks up the students who live closer to the school. The route the bus driver follows each morning is repeated in reverse order each afternoon; thus, the first student picked up in the morning is also the last student dropped off in the afternoon. This year there are thirteen students on STUDENT’s bus; she is the fifth student to be picked up in the morning and the eighth to be dropped off in the afternoon. In the morning, the bus picks up STUDENT at her home at approximately 6:22 a.m. and delivers her to Marlton at approximately 7:50 a.m.. In the afternoon STUDENT boards the bus at about 3:00 p.m., and arrives home between 4:20 and 4:40 p.m., depending on the day’s traffic. (Testimony of Ms. Acosta.)
In late April 2001, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting regarding the length of STUDENT’s daily bus rides. On May 9, 2001, the IEP team convened to discuss this transportation issue. The IEP document reflects MOTHER’s position that STUDENT’s physical and emotional health were being adversely affected by the amount of time she was required to spend riding the bus each day. MOTHER reported that STUDENT was complaining of nausea, dizziness and fatigue due to the long bus ride, and that as a result STUDENT did not want to go to school. The IEP notes the PARENTS’ request that STUDENT’s transportation time be reduced to a maximum round-trip total of ninety minutes per day. In June 2001, MOTHER filed for due process hearing on behalf of Petitioner regarding this issue.
ANALYSIS
Does STUDENT need a shorter bus ride to school in order to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA ‘97) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Education Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Education Code § 56000.) “FAPE” is defined as special education and related services that are available at no charge, meet state educational standards, and conform to the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In determining whether the District must provide the transportation services that Petitioner seeks, the Hearing Officer must examine the adequacy of the program and services the District has already offered to Petitioner. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) The U.S. Supreme Court has held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.)
Pursuant to Rowley, the District's offer must be designed to meet the student's needs, must provide some educational benefit, and must comport with the IEP. If the District’s program and services meet these criteria, then the District has offered a FAPE, even if the District’s program does not permit the student to maximize her potential. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left to the school’s discretion. (Rowley at 208.)
In the present case Petitioner argues that, within the context of her placement at Marlton School for the current school year, the District’s offer of transportation services is not designed to meet her unique needs and is not reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit. Regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, her only identified area of disability is her hearing loss, although she has academic difficulties, is below grade level in reading, writing and math, and often does not turn in her school assignments. Both MOTHER and Ms. Roberson, STUDENT’s seventh-grade homeroom teacher, testified that STUDENT’s teachers expressed concern last school year that STUDENT often did not turn in her assignments. Glenn Truesdell, STUDENT’s seventh-grade English teacher and eighth-grade speech teacher, confirmed that STUDENT often does not finish homework or in-class assignments. Mr. Truesdell also testified that STUDENT is below grade level and is easily distracted in class, although she is also easily redirected back to task.
STUDENT’s seventh-grade IEP similarly noted academic weaknesses, explaining that her hearing loss “results in language acquisition delays which impact literary development. This affects other content-areas as well.” (District’s Exh. 8.) The IEP identified goals and objectives in the areas of reading, math, audiology, English and articulation. The IEP included results of recent testing, including a Brigance Diagnostic Comprehensive Inventory of Skills (Brigance) math test, the Test of Written English (TOWE) and the Qualitative Reading Inventory-II (QRI). On both the Brigance and the TOWE, STUDENT’s scores were at the third- and fourth-grade levels. The QRI indicated that STUDENT was reading at a 1st grade level, although the IEP also noted that she was reading sixth-grade literature in class.
Regarding her emotional well-being, the evidence consistently depicted STUDENT as an active, friendly, sociable child. (See testimony of Ada Chukwu, Mr. Truesdell, Ms. Shough, MOTHER.) Regarding STUDENT’s physical well-being, the evidence indicates that, other than her hearing loss, STUDENT does not have any particular health problems. The school nurse, Ada Chukwu, testified that her health evaluation for STUDENT’s triennial assessment found that STUDENT was “generally healthy.”
Given STUDENT’s unique needs, the next consideration is whether, in light of the length of her bus ride, her educational program is designed to meet those unique needs. MOTHER testified that the length of the current bus ride causes STUDENT to experience nausea, dizziness and fatigue, making STUDENT too tired to go to school. In support of this position, Petitioner submitted two records of doctor visits in 2001, both of which state that STUDENT had symptoms of motion sickness due to her long bus ride.
In contrast, the District submitted evidence indicating that the lengthy bus ride did not negatively impact STUDENT’s health. School records reflected that STUDENT had gone to the nurse’s office with various ailments over the past year, including cracked lips, a sore throat, pain in her hand, stomachache, headache, and a cut finger, but there was no persuasive evidence that these individual complaints were related to motion sickness or fatigue due to the bus ride. There was one instance when STUDENT went to the nurse’s office at 2:09 p.m. on a Thursday with complaints of a stomachache, headache and possible fever, but this was a single incident that occurred several hours after STUDENT’s morning bus ride. Additionally, Mr. Truesdell and Ms. Shough testified that they had not observed STUDENT falling asleep in class or otherwise appearing tired, and had not heard her complain about fatigue or her bus ride. In particular, Ms. Shough noted that STUDENT was active and participated in Ms. Shough’s small-group instruction.
Overall, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT’s educational program must include a shorter bus ride in order to meet her unique needs. STUDENT’s unique needs do not include any unusual health problems, other than her hearing disability. While MOTHER was a credible witness, the evidence regarding STUDENT’s health indicated that motion sickness is not a significant problem while STUDENT is at school. Although her absences are of concern, she has been able to attend school and participate in class, as well as participate in drill team after school. While STUDENT has some difficulties with paying attention and turning in assignments, there was no evidence to indicate that those problems are causally related to her long bus rides. Indeed, STUDENT’s fifth-grade IEP reflected that she manifested those problems prior to her placement at Marlton. (District’s Exh. 20.)
Regarding whether the District has offered a program reasonably calculated to allow STUDENT to receive educational benefit, the hearing did not raise or address that issue beyond Petitioner’s issue regarding the length of the bus ride. Thus, this decision does not address whether STUDENT’s academic program at Marlton is reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit. However, in light of the facts already discussed herein, the evidence indicates that the lengthy bus ride does not interfere with STUDENT’s progress on her IEP goals and objectives or otherwise interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of educational benefit.
There is no question that it would be better for STUDENT to have a shorter bus ride. MOTHER’s testimony established that, understandably, STUDENT does suffer negative effects from spending three hours per day on the bus, whether through fatigue or simply having less time to do homework. Yet while it is obviously unfortunate that STUDENT must spend three hours riding the bus each day, her bus ride must be considered in the context of her placement at Marlton. Travel time is an inherent cost of attending a school some distance away; the PARENTS likely considered that negative aspect when deciding to request placement at Marlton. There is no dispute that the Marlton placement as a whole is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with educational benefit. The evidence indicates that any negative effects of the bus ride do not negate the overall appropriateness of the placement. As noted previously in this decision, the law requires only that a special education student receive an appropriate placement, not an optimal placement or one that maximizes the student’s potential.
Therefore because, in the context of the placement at Marlton, the District’s transportation offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit, the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claim for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 15, 2001 ______________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
