California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 8, 1998
Student v. San Jose Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1437-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
San Jose Unified wins on all issues: high school student found not eligible as seriously emotionally disturbed, boarding school reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A father filed for due process against San Jose Unified School District over his son's ninth-grade year (1996-97) at Lincoln High School. The 16-year-old student tested in the gifted range and had never been found eligible for special education. His grades and attendance fell in November and December, and many absences were excused as illness. A counselor referred him to the school's All Student Assistance Program (ASAP) and Student Study Team (SST). In February 1997, his father enrolled him in Southwestern Academy, a private boarding school, and later in Wasatch Academy in Utah. In March 1997 the father asked for a special education assessment, and the District found the student not eligible.
The Hearing Officer ruled for the District on all issues. The District properly tried regular education supports first and did not fail its duty to find and refer students with disabilities. It missed the 15-day deadline to send an assessment plan, but this did not harm the student because he was away until June. Otherwise the assessment timelines were met, and the father received notice of his rights. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to the private psychologist's and psychiatrist's opinions that the student was seriously emotionally disturbed. His objective test scores were normal, and teachers did not see pervasive unhappiness. Faked fevers were not physical symptoms. He also did well at private schools without special education. Because he was not eligible, the reimbursement request failed.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled emotional disturbance eligibility for a capable student. The Hearing Officer weighed objective test scores and teacher reports over clinicians' opinions. Success in a regular private school without special services was treated as evidence that the student did not need special education. A missed assessment-plan deadline was found harmless.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1 (special education referral). Did the District violate STUDENT's right to a FAPE by failing to meet the 'search and serve' requirements of the IDEA during the 1996-97 school year? Specifically, did the ASAP and SST procedures prevent a timely special education referral?
The District properly tried regular education interventions first, as Education Code section 56303 requires. Its ASAP and SST process did not block referrals, and the student's behavior and grades did not call for an immediate referral.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment
Issue 1 (assessment timeline). Did the District fail to provide an assessment plan within 15 days and to complete the assessment and hold an IEP meeting within 50 days of the request for assessment?
The District missed the 15-day deadline for an assessment plan. This did not affect the student's rights because he was not available for assessment until June. The 50-day timeline was met once the student's absence, summer vacation, and the father's request to reschedule were taken into account.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1 (notification procedures). Did the District fail to properly inform the parent of his parental rights and of how the student's unavailability would affect the assessment timeline?
The father received notice of his parental rights with the assessment plan. He himself told the District the student would be away until June. There was no evidence of inadequate notice.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. During the 1996-97 school year, did STUDENT qualify as a seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) student pursuant to the IDEA?
The opinions of the private psychologist and psychiatrist were not persuasive. At school, the student showed no pervasive unhappiness and no physical symptoms tied to school. He also did well in regular education at private schools without special education, so he was not eligible.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Is STUDENT's father entitled to reimbursement for the expense of placing STUDENT in a private residential school from February 1997 forward?
The student was not eligible for special education, so the father was not entitled to reimbursement for the boarding school placement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Education Code sections 56300-56303; Education Code section 56321; Education Code section 56344; Education Code section 56026; 5 C.C.R. section 3030(i)
People named in the decision
- Mike Carr, Director of Student Services, San Jose Unified School District
- John Brentar, private psychologist; expert witness for Student, Children's Health Council
- Leslie Eliel, school administrator; witness for Student, Not stated
- Gordon Cohen, psychiatrist and student's former therapist; witness for Student, Private practice
- Valerna Carter, assistant principal for discipline, Lincoln High School, San Jose Unified School District
- Donna Hammontree, school counselor, Lincoln High School, San Jose Unified School District
- Paul Burnett, teacher, San Jose Unified School District
- Chris Funk, teacher, San Jose Unified School District
- Sandra Lewis, teacher, San Jose Unified School District
- Priscilla Harley, school psychologist, San Jose Unified School District
- Jerome Kristal, school psychologist; assessor, San Jose Unified School District
- Southwestern Academy, private boarding school (unilateral placement), Southern California
- Wasatch Academy, private boarding school (unilateral placement), Utah
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
CASE NO. SN 1437-97 This matter convened for hearing on May 14, 15, 21, and 22, and June 10, 1998, in San Jose, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael Zatopa. The Petitioner's father, FATHER, was also present at the hearing on his behalf. Respondent San Jose Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys William M. Quinn, Jr., and Laurie Erdman. Also present on the District's behalf was Director of Student Services Mike Carr. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, psychologist John Brentar, school administrator Leslie Eliel, and psychiatrist Gordon Cohen. The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: vice principal Valerna Carter, counselor Donna Hammontree, teacher Paul Burnett, school psychologist Priscilla Harley, teacher Chris Funk, teacher Sandra Lewis, and school psychologist Jerome Kristal. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing arguments and reply briefs were received by July 20, 1998. (footnote 1). The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING 1. Did the District violate STUDENT's right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to meet the "search and serve" requirements of the IDEA during the 1996-97 school year? 2. During the 1996-97 school year, did STUDENT qualify as a seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) student pursuant to the IDEA? 3. Is STUDENT's father entitled to reimbursement for the expense of placing STUDENT in a private residential school from February 1997 forward? POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES The Petitioner asserts that the District should have referred him for special education assessment during the first semester of the 1996-97 school year. The Petitioner further asserts that he was eligible for special education services as an SED student during the 1996-97 school year because he exhibited a "pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression" and a "tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with school or personal problems" for a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that his condition adversely impacted his educational performance. The Petitioner argues that his father was reasonable in placing him in a private residential school in February 1997 in the absence of services from the District, and that his father is entitled to reimbursement for the expense of that school. The District asserts that it appropriately served STUDENT through regular education interventions during the 1996-97 school year and that it was not necessary to refer him for a special education assessment. The District contends that STUDENT does not qualify for special education services as an SED student. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old boy who has not been found to be eligible for special education services. STUDENT's cognitive ability tests place him in the gifted range. In 1988, when STUDENT was five years old, his mother was diagnosed with breast cancer. MOTHER struggled with the disease for several years, during which time STUDENT began to have social and emotional difficulties. STUDENT began receiving individual therapy from Dr. Gordon Cohen in 1991, and continued seeing him on a regular basis through December 1995. MOTHER died in May 1993, while STUDENT was in fifth grade. In sixth grade, STUDENT entered middle school, where he had problems behaviorally and academically. STUDENT had many discipline referrals during middle school, most of which involved oppositional and defiant behavior. During sixth grade, STUDENT's final grades were one C, one D, and three F's. During seventh grade, his final grades were three C's, one C-, and three F's. During the first part of eighth grade, the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT's grades improved to A+, A, A-, B, B-, and C. At that time, he was taking an anti-depressant and continuing with his therapy with Dr. Cohen. However, during the second semester, his behavior problems recurred and his final grades were A-, C+, C, C-, D, and F. STUDENT entered high school in ninth grade during the 1996-97 school year. According to his father, STUDENT was enthusiastic about starting high school and wanted to play football. Although STUDENT was able to join the football team, delays in obtaining the proper equipment prevented him from playing for most of the season. STUDENT began ninth grade with good performance in school, but soon began to have difficulties with his PE teacher. Ms. Valerna Carter, the assistant principal for discipline, suggested that STUDENT change his PE class to office assistant because his participation in football fulfilled the PE requirement. Ms. Carter also suggested that STUDENT be referred to an attendance improvement program for students with frequent unexcused absences. However, FATHER indicated that the program would not be appropriate for STUDENT because he had excused almost all of STUDENT's absences. STUDENT served as Ms. Carter's office assistant for the remainder of the semester. STUDENT's attendance and school performance continued to decline. STUDENT frequently complained of being sick, and FATHER allowed him to stay home on many occasions. STUDENT also failed to complete many of his homework assignments, which affected his grades. In December 1996, STUDENT missed more than fifty percent of his classes. In mid-December, FATHER spoke with school counselor Donna Hammontree about STUDENT's difficulties. Ms. Hammontree met with STUDENT and FATHER and recommended that she refer STUDENT to the All Student Assistance Program (ASAP) and Student Study Team (SST). Both of these programs involve staff reviewing records and reports about a student having difficulties and making recommendations for various regular education interventions. FATHER indicated to Ms. Hammontree that he was looking into other schools for STUDENT, including boarding schools. Ms. Hammontree also recommended that STUDENT take advantage of the homework lab and suggested that STUDENT could come to see her if he was feeling overwhelmed. After the winter break, Ms. Hammontree spoke with Dr. Cohen about STUDENT. Ms. Hammontree testified that Dr. Cohen told her STUDENT was not depressed. On January 24, 1997, Ms. Hammontree distributed ASAP report forms to STUDENT's teachers, asking them to provide information regarding STUDENT's skills, demeanor, and behavior. STUDENT attended just over half of his classes in January. However, he was absent on many of the days final exams were given, resulting in failing grades in Biology and History. However, STUDENT earned C's in English and Band, a D- in Math, and an A in PE/Athletics. Before the ASAP team could meet, FATHER removed STUDENT from Lincoln High School and placed him in Southwestern Academy, a private boarding school in southern California. The ASAP team met on February 5, 1997, and recommended that Ms. Hammontree continue to follow STUDENT's case. On March 5, 1997, FATHER wrote to the District asking for a special education assessment. On March 25 and 28, 1997, during a break from Southwestern, FATHER brought STUDENT to psychologist Dr. John Brentar at the Children's Health Council for a private assessment. The stated purpose of that assessment was "to gain a better understanding of STUDENT's current social-emotional functioning in order to determine the impact it may have on his academic functioning and school performance and to help determine the most appropriate school placement." (Pet. Exh. 1.) Dr. Brentar diagnosed STUDENT as having a Depressive Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified. He recommended that STUDENT remain in a boarding school placement with a structured format, based on STUDENT's success at Southwestern. Shortly after the District received FATHER's request for assessment, school psychologist Priscilla Harley contacted FATHER. FATHER told Ms. Harley that STUDENT was away at school and thus was not immediately available for assessment. FATHER later confirmed in writing that STUDENT would be available for an assessment during the week of June 9, 1997. He also provided a copy of Dr. Brentar's report and asked that the District consider it in the assessment. Dr. Jerome Kristal, another school psychologist, was assigned to perform STUDENT's assessment. He met with STUDENT, but did not conduct any additional testing because of the recent test results from Dr. Brentar. A resource specialist did administer the Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). In his report, issued on September 22, 1997, Dr. Kristal concluded that "STUDENT's emotional problems do not attain clinically significant levels and that a classification as Severely Emotionally Disturbed is not warranted." (Dist. Exh. 1.) At the IEP team meeting held on October 15, 1997, the District members of the team agreed that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services. FATHER did not agree with this conclusion and did not sign agreement to the IEP. On November 5, 1997, FATHER's attorney filed a request for due process hearing. Although STUDENT's academics improved at Southwestern, resulting in grades of A's and B's, STUDENT was still having social difficulties. During the summer of 1997, FATHER and STUDENT investigated other schools and decided to enroll STUDENT in Wasatch Academy in Utah. STUDENT also attended a Johns Hopkins program for gifted students at Loyola Marymount University during the summer, at which he successfully completed college-level courses in psychology and Latin. During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT continued to perform well academically at Wasatch, and, by his father's report, is doing better socially, as well. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW1. Did the District violate STUDENT's right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to meet the "search and serve" requirements of the IDEA during the 1996-97 school year? Petitioner alleges that the District committed several procedural violations that violated his rights under the IDEA and violated the District's obligation to identify and serve students with disabilities. Specifically, the Petitioner contends that the District's ASAP and SST procedures prevented a timely special education referral, that the District did not conduct the assessment in a timely manner after receiving the request for assessment, and that the District violated written notification procedures.Special Education Referral California law requires school districts to actively seek out children who may be eligible for special education. Districts are required to have systems in place that ensure that individuals with exceptional needs are referred for assessment when necessary. California Education Code 56300-56302. However, California Education Code section 56303 states that "a pupil shall be referred for special educational instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized." Petitioner asserts that the ASAP and SST process prevents timely special education referrals. However, the testimony at the hearing did not establish that a student must go through that process before a special education referral can be made. In fact, the ASAP team has an option to refer the student for immediate special education testing without first going through the SST process, and teachers may refer students for immediate special education assessment when conditions warrant. (Dist. Exh. 50. Testimony of Ms. Hammontree.) In STUDENT's case, his teachers did not identify any extreme behavior that would have warranted an immediate special education referral, and his academic difficulties also did not warrant an immediate referral. (Dist. Exh. 46-48. Testimony of Ms. Carter, Paul Burnett, Chris Funk, Sandra Lewis.) During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT's attendance and performance in school did not decline significantly until November. During September and October, he attended approximately eighty percent of his classes. At the end of the first grading period, in mid-October, STUDENT's grades were one A, two B's, C+, C, and D. When his grades and attendance declined in November and December, Ms. Carter and Ms. Hammontree became involved in STUDENT's case. Ms. Carter recommended the attendance improvement program, and Ms. Hammontree recommended several other regular education programs to help STUDENT. Thus, the District was considering the use of regular education alternatives, as required by law. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was appropriately attempting to resolve STUDENT's difficulties using regular education interventions and did not violate its duty to refer students with suspected disabilities for special education assessment.Assessment Timeline California Education Code section 56321(a) requires a district to provide an assessment plan within fifteen days of receiving a written referral for assessment, and section 56344 requires that the assessment be completed and an IEP team be held within fifty days of parental approval of the assessment plan. This timeline does not run during extended vacation periods, such as summer vacation. In this case, FATHER's letter requesting a special education assessment was dated March 5, 1997. However, he sent this letter to the District superintendent's office. The date stamp on the letter indicates that the superintendent's office received the letter on March 14, 1997. The superintendent's office forwarded the letter to the office of student services, which received the letter on March 18, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 15.) On March 21, 1997, Ms. Harley tried to contact FATHER by telephone to discuss the assessment request, but did not speak with FATHER until April 11. At that time, FATHER informed her that STUDENT was in southern California and would not be back in San Jose until early June. (Dist. Exh. 16. Testimony of Ms. Harley.) On May 5, 1997, FATHER confirmed in writing that STUDENT would not be available for assessment until the week of June 9, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 20.) On May 16, 1997, the District sent FATHER an assessment plan, which FATHER signed on May 17 and the District received on May 21, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 24.) Dr. Kristal and the resource specialist assessed STUDENT in early June, and the IEP team meeting to discuss the assessment was scheduled for October 1, 1997. FATHER requested a different meeting date, and the meeting was held on October 15, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 28-30.) The Hearing Officer finds that the District did violate its obligation to provide an assessment plan within fifteen days of receiving a request for assessment. However, the Hearing Officer finds that this failure did not substantively affect STUDENT's rights because he was not available for assessment until early June. With respect to the fifty day timeline, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment was completed and the IEP team meeting held within the timeline, taking into account the facts that STUDENT was not available until early June, the 1996-97 school year ended on June 13, 1997, and the IEP team meeting that was originally scheduled for October 1 was rescheduled to accommodate FATHER. (Dist. Exh. 81.)Notification Procedures Petitioner asserts that the District did not appropriately inform him of his parental rights when he requested the assessment and did not tell him that STUDENT's unavailability would affect the time it would take to complete the assessment. The evidence at the hearing established that FATHER made it clear to the District staff that STUDENT was not returning to San Jose until early June. The evidence also indicated that the District provided information regarding his parental rights to FATHER with the assessment plan, as required by Education Code section 56321. (Dist. Exh. 24.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no evidence that the District did not adequately inform FATHER of his parental rights and the applicable timelines.2. During the 1996-97 school year, did STUDENT qualify as a seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) student pursuant to the IDEA?Under the IDEA and California special education law, only individuals with certain disabilities, including serious emotional disturbance, are eligible for special education services. Moreover, the individual's disability must require instruction, services, or both that cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Ed. Code 56026(a), (b). The California regulation defining serious emotional disturbance provides, in relevant part: . . . a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: . . . (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. (5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.5 C.C.R. 3030(i). Therefore, to be eligible for special education as an SED student, STUDENT must have exhibited one of the SED characteristics for a long period and to a marked degree. In addition, his condition must have adversely affected his educational performance, and he must need special instruction or services that cannot be provided in the regular education program as a result of his condition. Both Dr. Brentar and Dr. Cohen expressed the opinion that STUDENT meets the SED criteria. In his report, Dr. Brentar concluded that STUDENT had a depressive disorder, and he also testified at the hearing that STUDENT had a tendency to develop physical symptoms associated with school problems. Dr. Brentar further testified that he based his opinion on the data he collected in his assessment, including his interview with STUDENT, questionnaires completed by both FATHER and STUDENT, the Rorschach and Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) projective testing, and reports of STUDENT's difficulties in school. However, the Hearing Officer finds that there are many reasons for not relying upon Dr. Brentar's opinion of STUDENT's condition. Dr. Brentar chose not to calculate scores for the Rorschach tests, so he did not have an objective result for that test. In addition, Dr. Brentar did not satisfactorily explain why he relied more heavily on FATHER's negative report of STUDENT's behavior and discounted STUDENT's more positive self-report. Dr. Brentar testified that STUDENT was in denial about his problems, but also acknowledged that, in light of other documents in the record, FATHER's report was not entirely accurate. For example, FATHER reported that STUDENT's grades were all failing, but in fact, STUDENT earned only two F's during the first semester of ninth grade. FATHER also reported concerns about self-injurious behavior, but clarified at the hearing that the injuries he was referring to were accidental, not deliberate. Dr. Brentar also could not explain at the hearing why he did not rely on the scores from the Minnesota Multi-phasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) he administered to STUDENT. Dr. Brentar admitted that the MMPI is an objective measure of many different emotional disorders and that the test has "lie detector" scores that reveal attempts to distort the results. These indicators showed that STUDENT's responses were not dishonest. However, while concluding that STUDENT was depressed, Dr. Brentar did not mention that STUDENT's depression score on the MMPI was normal, as was his hypochondriasis score. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the data collected by Dr. Brentar do not support his opinions. Dr. Cohen also testified that STUDENT was depressed. However, Dr. Cohen also testified that he stopped seeing STUDENT in 1995 because he had made such significant progress. Dr. Cohen saw STUDENT only a few times from the end of 1995 through January 1997, and STUDENT stopped taking the medication Dr. Cohen prescribed in 1996. Moreover, both Ms. Hammontree and Dr. Kristal testified that Dr. Cohen told them that, while STUDENT exhibited features of depression, STUDENT was not depressed. In reviewing his case notes, Dr. Cohen could not find any notation that constituted a diagnosis of depression. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Cohen's testimony that STUDENT was depressed is not consistent with his past reports of STUDENT's condition, which were made at a time when he was more familiar with STUDENT's daily functioning. Given that neither Dr. Brentar's nor Dr. Cohen's opinions of STUDENT's emotional condition are compelling, the other evidence regarding STUDENT's behavior and functioning must be examined to determine whether he demonstrated either a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression or a tendency to develop physical symptoms associated with school problems. The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT was generally an unhappy young man at home, he was not always so at school. None of his teachers reported that STUDENT was consistently unhappy or depressed, although they did report that he had difficulty relating to other students. (Dist. Exh. 46-48. Testimony of Ms. Carter, Mr. Burnett, Mr. Funk, Ms. Lewis.) Given that STUDENT did not consistently demonstrate symptoms of unhappiness or depression at school, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unhappiness or depression was not pervasive. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT did not demonstrate physical symptoms associated with school problems. Although many of STUDENT's absences were excused by FATHER as being due to illness, the evidence at the hearing did not establish that STUDENT was actually experiencing physical symptoms. In fact, FATHER testified that STUDENT would manipulate the thermometer to fake a fever so he could stay home. Both Dr. Brentar and Dr. Cohen stated that deliberately falsifying a fever is not a sign of somatization. Moreover, even if STUDENT exhibited one of the SED characteristics, the Hearing Officer finds that he does not meet the requirement that he need special instruction or services that cannot be provided in the regular education program as a result of his condition. STUDENT's success at Southwestern Academy and Wasatch Academy clearly demonstrates that STUDENT was able to perform well academically in a regular education environment. Neither Southwestern nor Wasatch provide any form of special education services. Both schools had counseling programs available, but STUDENT was able to perform well without participating in those programs. Thus, because STUDENT is not a student who needs special education or related services to benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not eligible for special education.3. Is STUDENT's father entitled to reimbursement for the expense of placing STUDENT in a private residential school from February 1997 forward? Parents of students with disabilities are entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred when a local educational agency does not provide a FAPE. STUDENT is not eligible for special education; therefore, his father is not entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for educational services obtained for STUDENT. ORDER All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the Respondent prevailed on all issues presented for hearing. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).Date: September 8, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
CASE NO. SN 1437-97Footnote:1.At the hearing, the parties agreed that they would limit the length of the reply briefs to five pages. On July 21, 1998, the Petitioner filed an objection to consideration of the District's reply brief, which was fifteen pages long. The Hearing Officer overrules the objection, but notes that the District's reply brief provided no information or arguments that had not already been presented. Therefore, the additional pages in the reply brief did not affect this decision.
