California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 16, 2001
Student v. Pomona Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 145-00, SN-145-00 · Hearing Officer Paul R. Gant
Pomona Unified failed to train a student's aides for four months in 1999, but the Hearing Officer denied all relief.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1: the decision was amended to correct typographical errors, including heading formatting, the misspelling of Dr. Dorie Glover's name, and the decision date (issued January 3, 2001, not January 3, 2000). The amendments do not affect the substance. The amended decision is dated January 16, 2001.
Summary
A parent, representing herself, filed for a 10-year-old boy with autism. He attended a general education class at Yorba Elementary School in Pomona Unified with a full-time aide. She claimed the district denied him a FAPE from September 1999 through October 8, 2000. She also sought repayment for private social skills, play therapy, speech and consultant services, plus her expert witnesses' fees.
The Hearing Officer found one violation. From September through December 1999, the district did not train the boy's aides in prompting and behavior strategies. The district relied on the parent's word that the morning aide was already trained, and the Hearing Officer found that unreasonable. Training for the aide who started in January 2000 was adequate. She had experience with autism and took a TEACCH course.
The other claims failed. The boy did not need one-to-one discrete trial training or behavior goals. The district's in-school "Skill Streaming" social skills program was appropriate, and so was its speech therapy using the Lindamood-Bell ADD/VV method. A two-month gap after his laptop broke did not deny a FAPE. The summer services and resource math services followed the IEP. No repayment was ordered because the private services did not fix the aide-training problem. The Hearing Officer found no legal basis to award expert witness fees. All requests for relief were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO kept a proven denial of FAPE separate from the remedy requested. Proof that the aides were untrained did not lead to repayment, because the parent's private services did not address that gap. It also shows that a district could not simply rely on a parent's word that an aide was trained.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I(1). Did the District deny FAPE (September 1999 through October 8, 2000) by failing to offer one-on-one behavioral intervention services?
Behavior problems were short-lived and did not prevent educational benefit; the student did not need one-to-one discrete trial training.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue I(2). Did the District fail to write goals and objectives to address the student's behavioral and social needs?
Behavior goals were not required, and the September and December 1999 social and communication goals met his unique social needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I(3). Did the District fail to provide a social skills program designed to meet the student's unique needs?
The in-school Skill Streaming counseling program was appropriately designed and reasonably calculated to provide benefit; 8-10 hours of supervised outside social skills training was not required.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue I(4). Did the District fail to properly train and support the student's instructional aides?
The District denied FAPE from September through December 1999 by not training the aides and unreasonably relying on the parent's assurance; aide training from January 2000 was appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I(5). Were the speech and language services offered by the District reasonably designed to meet the student's needs?
Services from a credentialed speech-language pathologist using ADD/VV were designed to meet his needs and provided benefit.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue I(6). Did the District fail to provide extended school year and maintenance services identified in the IEP for summer 2000?
ESY was provided under the June 22, 2000 addendum the parent signed, so it comported with the IEP.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue I(7). Did the District fail to ensure the student's access to a computer as required by the IEP?
A roughly two-month gap after the laptop broke was troubling but did not deprive him of educational benefit; he kept progressing.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue I(8). Did the District fail to provide RSP services for math in a timely manner as required by the IEP?
The IEP called for in-class RSP math and did not specify pull-out or Touch Math, so implementation complied with the IEP.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue II. Must the District reimburse the parent for privately obtained assessments and services of Gloria Medina, Riki Gentry, Beverly Smith, Dorie Glover, Amanda Hanson, Lenny Gutierrez, the First Christian Church, the Stowell Learning Center, and the Brain Cell, Inc.?
District social skills and speech programs were appropriate, and the private services did not address the aide-training deficiency, so no reimbursement was owed.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue III. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of hearing testimony by Beverly Smith, Amanda Hanson, and Dorie Glover?
No authority allows witness fees in a special education hearing, so the fees were denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied, even though the Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE for September through December 1999 (aide training).
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Trena Spurlock, Director of special education, Pomona Unified School District
- G. Robert Roice, Educational consultant representing District (non-attorney), Pomona Unified School District
- Patti Adams, Program specialist, Pomona Unified School District
- Devon Gump, 1:1 instructional aide (morning, Sept-Dec 1999), Pomona Unified School District
- Cassandra Mesa, 1:1 instructional aide (afternoon, Sept-Dec 1999), Pomona Unified School District
- Rachel Valdevia, 1:1 instructional aide (from January 2000), Pomona Unified School District
- Anthony Lefever, General education second grade teacher, Yorba Elementary School
- Elizabeth Hanlon, General education first grade teacher, Yorba Elementary School
- Shirley Smith, General education second grade teacher (1998), Yorba Elementary School
- Sonia Pond-Castellanos, General education third grade teacher, Yorba Elementary School
- Sonia Davis, Resource specialist (math), Pomona Unified School District
- Katie Goodwin, School psychologist / assessor, Pomona Unified School District
- Lee Ann Augsburger, DIS counselor / social skills instructor, Pomona Unified School District
- Doneva Wickwire, Speech-language pathologist, Pomona Unified School District
- Sharon Floyd, Special day class teacher (autism spectrum), San Antonio Elementary / SELPA program
- Bonnie J. Ivers, Behavioral therapist / assessor, Autism Behavioral Learning Education (ABLE)
- Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Private speech-language provider; witness for Student, Private
- Dorie Glover, Ph.D., Educational psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
- Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., Private social skills counselor; witness for Student, Private
- Lenny Gutierrez, Private play therapy group leader / developmental interventionist; witness for Student, Private
- Gloria Medina, Private one-to-one social language provider, Private
- Riki Gentry, Private provider (role not stated), Private
- Jill Stowell, Private provider (FastForward), Stowell Learning Center
- Stowell Learning Center, Private learning center (FastForward auditory processing), Private agency
- The Brain Cell, Inc., Private provider, Private agency
- First Christian Church, Private provider/site for services, Private
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Private agency supervising discrete trial training (1997-1998), Private agency
- Kindergarten School, Private school (1997-1998), Private school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul R. Gant, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Pomona, California, on September 14 and 15, October 17 and 18, and November 7, 8, 14, and 15, 2000.
Petitioner (STUDENT) was represented by his mother, PARENT. Respondent Pomona Unified School District (District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Trena Spurlock, director of special education, also appeared on behalf of the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for written closing arguments. The District’s closing brief was received on December 1, 2000. Petitioner’s closing brief was received on December 3, 2000. Thereafter, the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
I. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate education (FAPE) for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000? II. Must the District reimburse the parent for the cost of the privately obtained assessments and services of Gloria Medina, Riki Gentry, Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Dorie Glover, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., Lenny Gutierrez, the First Christian Church, the Stowell Learning Center, and the Brain Cell, Inc.?
III. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of hearing testimony by Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., and Dorie Glover, Ph.D.?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old boy who is eligible for special education based on his history of autism. In January 1993 STUDENT was found eligible for special education and related services by the District. He is currently enrolled in the third grade class at Yorba Elementary School, a District school, where he receives special education services.
For the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in the first grade at the Kindergarten School, a private school. The Pomona Unified School District provided designated instruction and services (DIS) consisting of speech and language services, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education (APE). The District also agreed to provide consultation to the private school by a District special education teacher. In addition, the District provided behavior intervention services in the form of discrete trial training (DTT) based on STUDENT’s problems with compliance, physical aggressiveness, self-stimulatory behaviors, and social interaction with peers. From September 1997 to March 1998, STUDENT’s behavioral therapists were supervised by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), a private agency. CARD terminated its contract with the District in March 1998, and thereafter STUDENT’s DTT therapists were not formally supervised.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on July 30, 1998, and developed an individualized education program (IEP) for STUDENT’s 1998-1999 school year to begin on September 14, 1998. The agreed-upon IEP provided for full participation in a regular education classroom at a District elementary school. The placement was to be supported by collaboration and coordination between the regular education teacher, a special education teacher, and an instructional aide. The District agreed to provide speech and language therapy, DTT by a behavioral therapist, occupational therapy (OT), adapted physical education (APE), and transportation to and from school by a District carrier.
In September 1998, STUDENT enrolled in Yorba Elementary School in the second grade class of Shirley Smith. At the time of enrollment, PARENT recommended that the District hire Devon Gump, who had been serving as STUDENT’s aide in his previous private placement, as STUDENT’s instructional aide. Following an interview by the District, Ms. Gump was hired as STUDENT’s one-on-one instructional aide.
By October 1998 it became apparent that STUDENT was having substantial behavior problems in his placement Ms. Smith’s second grade class. The District and the parents decided that STUDENT should be moved to the first grade class of Ms. Elizabeth Hanlon. According to all witnesses at hearing, this change of classroom had an immediate beneficial effect on STUDENT’s behavior.
On December 7, 1998, the IEP team again met and discussed proposed revisions to STUDENT’s IEP. (Pet. Exh. 6) Among other things, the team agreed that STUDENT would receive instruction at Stowell Learning Center in an auditory processing program called FastForward. Because of the inability to work both the FastForward instruction and the behavioral intervention services (discrete trial training) into STUDENT’s schedule, the team agreed that the FastForward program would be provided “in lieu of” the DTT.
Trena Spurlock, special education director, Patti Adams, program specialist, and PARENT met on June 24, 1999, to discuss “extended school year and maintenance” for the summer of 1999 and placement for the 1999-2000 school year. (Pet. Exh. 8) At this meeting, Ms. Adams and Ms. Spurlock proposed on behalf of the District that STUDENT receive continued instructional aide support in a general education summer school classroom, with speech services and APE as written in the IEP for 1998-1999. FastForward was to continue as a daily service during the extended year. PARENT declined the APE and OT services offered by the District. She requested that the District pay for private speech services with Dr. Beverly Smith “in lieu of O.T. and APE,” because of Dr. Smith’s extensive credentials and because, PARENT said, scheduling the speech services outside of school would avoid interruption of STUDENT’s general education class work. The District refused to contract with an outside provider for speech services because the District believed it had certified speech and language professionals on staff who were able to provide the interventions written in the IEP. PARENT also indicated that she believed that STUDENT would benefit more from the “Auditory Phonics Program” than the “Auditory Discrimination in Depth/Visualizing Verbalizing” (ADD/VV) program which he was then receiving. Ultimately, however, PARENT agreed to accept the District-provided speech and language services for the summer session.
PARENT also indicated that it was her desire that DTT be re-established when STUDENT completed FastForward. The District agreed to investigate agencies to provide behavior intervention. PARENT also expressed concern regarding STUDENT’s need for a word processor at home. Accordingly, the IEP team agreed to investigate the use of a laptop and program to use in the fully included classroom and at home. Finally, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s placement for the fall of 1999, and agreed that STUDENT would be fully included in Anthony Lefever’s second grade class at Yorba Elementary, with support by an instructional aide. PARENT expressed her desire that the aide “fade out” as much as possible so as to foster independence for STUDENT.
The IEP team was to meet again in July 1999 to develop a program for the 1999-2000 school year, but the meeting was postponed at the request of PARENT so that Mr. Lefever, the anticipated teacher for the 1999-2000 school year, could be present (he wasn’t available due to the summer break). STUDENT’s full IEP team then met on September 17, 1999. (Pet. Exh. 10) The team agreed that STUDENT should receive speech and language therapy and APE. The team members agreed that extended school year would be provided, with details “to be determined later.” The team noted that the only time in school that STUDENT would not be in a general education setting would be during speech therapy five times per week. The District agreed to provide a laptop computer for use, “as appropriate.” The District also agreed to provide assistive educational software. Finally, PARENT requested behavioral/social skills intervention for STUDENT. Patty Adams discussed the continued concerns regarding STUDENT’s social skill development. The IEP team then agreed that in order to determine the appropriate level and focus of any social or behavioral intervention, an assessment was needed. The District offered an assessment plan that called for evaluation by an outside agency and a District psychologist. PARENT agreed to this plan.
On October 14 and 21, 1999, STUDENT was evaluated by Bonnie J. Ivers, M.A,. a behavioral therapist with Autism Behavioral Learning Education (ABLE), who issued a report dated November 1, 1999. (Pet. Exh.13) Katie Goodwin, school psychologist, conducted a psycho-educational assessment on behalf of the District on October 11, 1999, October 12, 1999, and November 9, 1999, issuing a report dated November 16, 1999. (Pet. Exh. 5)
The IEP team met on December 3, 1999, to address STUDENT’s educational program in the area of social and behavioral needs. The team noted that STUDENT was having problems in the social/emotional domain, making it difficult for him to interact with peers in the general education setting. The team agreed to add social skills goals based on the Goodwin and Ivers assessments. The District and the PARENT agreed to work together with an outside agency to design a structured program to address development and generalization of STUDENT’s social communication skills. The team agreed that sixty minutes of DIS counseling would be added to address social skills goals and objectives. The District also agreed to contact outside providers to potentially supervise social skills workshops.
An IEP meeting occurred on January 18, 2000, which was expedited at PARENT’s request. At the meeting, it was noted that PARENT had been pulling STUDENT out of school in the afternoons since the Christmas break in order to attend a private social skills program. (Pet. Exh. 23) The private program involved STUDENT’s working on social language skills one-on-one with Gloria Medina, a college student. In addition, STUDENT spent a part of each afternoon participating in a play therapy group supervised by Lenny Gutierrez, also a college student. The District noted that since PARENT was pulling STUDENT out in the afternoon he was not receiving the DIS services per the IEP. According to the testimony of Patti Adams, PARENT, and Trena Spurlock at hearing, STUDENT continued to receive the District speech and language services in the morning hours. Additionally, PARENT re-arranged STUDENT’s afternoon schedule to allow him to participate in the District social skills training one afternoon a week at Yorba Elementary.
On January 28, 2000, the District responded to PARENT’s requests for reimbursement of the privately procured social skills services. The District indicated that based on the Ivers and Goodwin reports, the District was providing appropriate social skills counseling at the school. The District indicated that it would not reimburse the parents for the outside social skills program that PARENT had developed during the period beginning September 25, 1999. The District did not renew its previous offer to contract with an outside agency to consult regarding a social skills program for STUDENT.
On June 22, 2000, the IEP team met and signed an addendum providing for STUDENT’s participation in the summer school program at Yorba Elementary School.
For the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT has continued to attend Yorba Elementary School. STUDENT currently attends a third grade regular classroom taught by Sonia Pond-Castellanos in the morning hours. During the afternoons, STUDENT leaves the school to attend the private social skills program designed by PARENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. I: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate education (FAPE) for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000?
Under State and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (California Education Code §56000; 20 U.S.C. §1400) The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) defines “free appropriate public education” as special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18))
“Special education” means specially designed instruction at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S. C. §1401(a)(16)) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. §1401 (a)(17)) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” (Cal. Ed. Code §56363(b))
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require a school district to provide special education students the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor or opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id at 201. Special education law further requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. Section 300.550)
In short, under the IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, to comport with the IEP, and must be provided in the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 3)
Petitioner contends that the program offered by the District did not provide STUDENT a FAPE for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000, because: (1) the District failed to offer one-one-one behavioral intervention services; (2) the District failed to write goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s behavioral and social needs; (3) the District failed to provide a social skills program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (4) the District failed to properly train and support STUDENT’s instructional aides; (5) the speech and language services offered by the District were not reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs; (6) the District failed to provide extended school year and maintenance services identified in the IEP for the summer of 2000; (7) the District failed to ensure STUDENT’s access to a computer as required by STUDENT’s IEP; and (8) the District failed to provide RSP services for math in a timely manner as required by the IEP.(Footnote 4)
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational program offered by the District, it is first necessary to determine the nature of STUDENT unique and individual needs.
As a result of his history of autism, STUDENT suffers developmental delays and deficits in the academic, social, and behavioral realms.
There is no substantial dispute regarding the nature of STUDENT’s academic needs. On September 17, 1999, STUDENT’s IEP team agreed that STUDENT required special education services in applied math, math calculation, expressive language, pragmatic language, reading, spelling, grammar, auditory processing, psychomotor skills, and fine motor development. In order to address STUDENT’s academic difficulties, the team agreed that for the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT should be placed in a general education classroom with the assistance of a full-time instructional aide and receive speech and language services, RSP math services in the classroom, adapted physical education (APE), and assistive technology consisting of the use of a computer with a word processing program to assist with writing and spelling. The District also agreed to provide an extended school year program at a level “to be determined.”
The primary areas of dispute between the parties regarding STUDENT’s unique needs are in the areas of behavior and social skills.
Petitioner contends that for the period September 1999 to October 2000, STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties were sufficiently serious as to require behavioral goals and objectives in his IEP and one-on-one behavioral therapy. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT’s social skill deficits required that he receive at least eight-to-ten hours per week of structured small-group social skills lessons supervised by a social skills specialist. In addition, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s program needed to include specialized training for the instructional aide in addressing STUDENT’s behavioral and social difficulties, including his tendency to become dependent upon the aide.
The District contends that STUDENT’s behavioral issues did not necessitate one-on-one behavioral intervention. The District agrees that STUDENT needed social skills intervention for the period at issue, but the District contends that STUDENT’s difficulties could be addressed by a program of specialized social skills training in the school setting, social skills coaching by the instructional aide, and informal opportunities to practice social skills both in and out of school. Finally, the District contends that they provided appropriate training to STUDENT’s instructional assistants.
As to Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT needed goals and objectives in his IEP and one-on-one discrete trial training to address behavioral issues during the 1999-2000 school year, the undisputed testimony of several witnesses at hearing, including PARENT, Patti Adams, and Elizabeth Hanlon, STUDENT’s teacher for the 1998-1999 school year, established that STUDENT was not having any significant behavior problems during the 1998-1999 school year.
According to the testimony of STUDENT’s instructional aides, Devon Gump and Cassandra Mesa, and his classroom teacher, Anthony Lefever, STUDENT began to demonstrate inappropriate behavior after entering Mr. Lefever’s second grade classroom in September 1999. When his instructional aide was late to class, STUDENT would pound on the desk, and repeat over and over, “Devon not here, Devon not here . . . .” According to a checklist kept by Ms. Gump, STUDENT’s morning aide, STUDENT had several instances of disruptive behavior from late September through December 1999, including having difficulty sitting, giggling, knocking on the desk, acting silly, becoming distracted, not following directions, humming, and yelling. (Pet. Exh 46-49). Ms. Mesa was STUDENT’s afternoon aide for the period September to December 1999. Ms. Mesa testified that during the afternoon when she worked with STUDENT, virtually every day there would be some sort of behavior problem, such as rocking , knocking on tables, standing up, singing at inappropriate times, and running in class. According to Ms. Gump and Ms. Mesa, STUDENT would occasionally have to be removed from class for short periods due to his disruptive behavior.
Rachel Valdevia testified that in December 1999, in preparation for taking over as STUDENT’s instructional aide, she went to STUDENT’s classroom to observe him working with Devon Gump. At the time of this observation, STUDENT was acting angry and agitated. Ms. Valdevia believed that STUDENT was reacting to the coming change in instructional aides. After Ms. Valdevia began as the instructional assistant in January 2000, STUDENT was engaging in substantial inappropriate behavior such as banging his desk, striking out at Ms. Valdevia and other children, intentionally “burping” and “farting” in class, and dashing out to the restroom without permission. During that period, STUDENT would tend to escalate his behavior in response to her commands to discontinue the inappropriate conduct. Because of the degree and frequency of STUDENT’s poor behavior, Ms. Valdevia had to constantly sit next to him. Ms. Valdevia testified that by early to mid-February 2000, STUDENT’s behavior had significantly improved. He began to show improved behavior in response to rewards and visual cues. He also began to stop poor behavior on his own. He began to ask to be excused to go outside the class to “burp” and to “fart.” He also stopped striking out at Ms. Valdevia and other children and reduced the amount of knocking and humming he had been doing.
Patti Adams, STUDENT’s program specialist, testified that she visited the classroom on a regular basis during the period STUDENT was placed in Mr. Lefever’s class. Ms. Adams stated that, from her observation, STUDENT was not behaving aggressively and did not need a lot of direction to stay on task. Ms. Adams indicated that, in her opinion, by winter break 1999, STUDENT’s most significant behavioral concern was “knocking” but otherwise he had made substantial progress. Patti Adams acknowledged that STUDENT’s report card for the early period of the 1999-2000 school year indicated that STUDENT “need[ed] to follow school/classroom rules.”(Pet. Exh. 50) However, she stated that the comment “focuse[d] on the big picture” and not specifically on disruptive behaviors. Ms. Adams agreed that there were at least “a couple of circumstances” during the period September 1999 through December 1999, when STUDENT had to be removed from the classroom due to loudness. When STUDENT’s new morning aide, Rachel Valdevia, replaced Ms. Gump in January 2000, Ms. Adams came in for several days in the first two weeks. From Ms. Adam’s observation, STUDENT tested Ms. Valdevia’s “limits” at first, but with Ms. Valdevia’s consistent method of handling STUDENT, his compliance rapidly improved.
In accordance with the agreed-upon assessment plan between the District and PARENT, Bonnie Ivers of ABLE conducted her assessment on October 14 and 21, 1999. (Pet. Exh. 13) With regard to STUDENT’s behavior, Ms. Ivers noted that STUDENT did well following school rules and structure, though he frequently required the assistance of his aide to help focus his attention and follow through on requests. Ms. Ivers did not recommend any special services to address STUDENT’s behavior.
Katie Goodwin, Ph.D., conducted her assessment in November 1999. (Pet. Exh. 15) Dr. Goodwin testified at hearing that she had reviewed Ms. Ivers’ report and concurred with the findings. Dr. Goodwin testified that STUDENT had difficulties with self-stimulatory behaviors, such as humming, knocking and sniffing hands, perseverative behaviors such as repeating rules, directions, and others’ statements, and limited ability to sustain attention in the classroom. Dr. Goodwin testified that when she observed STUDENT in November 1999 with Ms. Gump his behavior was not at a level requiring the assignment of a behavior intervention case manager (BICM). In Dr. Goodwin’s opinion, STUDENT’s behavior was not “severe aggression” but rather in the category of perseverative/avoidance behavior. Dr. Goodwin observed that Ms. Gump was using a lot of coaxing to get compliance from STUDENT and was having limited success. Ms. Gump used longer sentences to talk with STUDENT and he would respond by knocking. Ms. Gump’s approach did not seem to have a calming effect on STUDENT. Dr. Goodwin believed that STUDENT needed prompting that was more straight forward, shorter, more visual, and less language-based. Dr. Goodwin did not recommend specific goals and objectives or additional services in the behavioral area. Rather, Dr. Goodwin testified that she believed that appropriate training of the aide would extinguish STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors.
Special education regulations require that in developing a STUDENT’s IEP, the IEP team shall:
In the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, consider, if appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral intervention, strategies, and supports to address that behavior. (34 CFR §300.346(a)(2)(i)).
There was evidence at hearing that STUDENT was having behavioral problems during the 1999-2000 period; however, there was no substantial evidence presented that these problems were in themselves preventing STUDENT from benefitting from his classroom education. Although STUDENT did experience a period of comparatively more severe behavior in January and February 2000 with the introduction of Rachel Valdevia as his instructional aide, it is found that these behavior problems were short-lived. There was no substantial evidence presented at hearing that in order for STUDENT to progress educationally, he required that specific behavior-related goals and objectives be included in his IEP.
The evidence also establishes that STUDENT did not require one-on-one behavioral intervention such as discrete trial training to address behavior problems for the period September 1999 through October 2000. STUDENT had a short period of aggressive behavior after Rachel Valdevia started as the instructional aide. However, Dr. Goodwin observed STUDENT’s classroom in January 2000 and in May 2000, and noted a dramatic improvement in STUDENT’s emotional state and behavior during that period. According to Dr. Goodwin, by May, STUDENT was following classroom routine well. In the May observation, Dr. Goodwin saw only one instance of perseverative behavior and no aggressive behavior. The witnesses at hearing who observed STUDENT in the classroom, including Mr. Lefever, Ms. Adams, and Rachel Valdevia, were in agreement that the worst of STUDENT’s classroom behavior improved substantially within several weeks of Ms. Valdevia’s beginning as the aide. The overwhelming weight of the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT required one-one-one behavioral intervention services in a discrete trial training format. However, based on the evidence presented, in particular the testimony of Dr. Goodwin, the Hearing Officer concludes that for the period September 1999 through October 2000, STUDENT needed a program that included formal training of his instructional aides in addressing his episodes of inappropriate behavior through appropriate prompting techniques.
Petitioner also contends that the District did not adequately consider STUDENT’s needs in the realm of social skills in developing his educational program.
Dr. Goodwin and Ms. Ivers both addressed STUDENT’s needs with regard to social skills in their assessments. Ms. Ivers concluded that STUDENT was having problems in socializing with peers, generalization of past and present social concepts, dependence on his classroom aides, and productive playtime at home. Ms. Ivers recommended that a social skills specialist consult with and observe STUDENT’s instructional aide once a month. Ms. Ivers also recommended that STUDENT participate in eight to ten hours a week of concentrated social activity to include “any programs that would foster STUDENT’s development in socialization: small-group at school/home, boy scouts, private socialization groups, etc.”
Dr. Goodwin testified that STUDENT had inconsistent skills in the social language domain. STUDENT also experienced social isolation from peers, social anxiety, and difficulty with generalization of social concepts. Dr. Goodwin noted that, while STUDENT had many “splinter” social skills that were age appropriate, he was lacking many skills that are typically demonstrated by younger children. STUDENT did not typically seek out peers for play activities or other social contact. He understood the concept of social entry but was limited in his ability to respond to the variable forms of social contact initiated by his peers. STUDENT’s limited responses were not readily understood by his peers and thus they often didn’t engage in sustained attention to him. Therefore, STUDENT had limited opportunity to practice reciprocal social language and behavior. STUDENT’s response to the “anxiety-producing social situations” was “often increased perseverative and self-stimulatory behavior.” These behaviors in turn tended to isolate him socially. Dr. Goodwin felt that interruption of this “non-productive cycle” was integral to STUDENT’s progress in the social/behavioral domains.
Dr. Goodwin recommended that STUDENT receive DIS services for counseling in a small- group setting to address issues related to social skill development. In addition, Dr. Goodwin indicated that STUDENT’s instructional staff should be trained in a cuing system to direct and redirect STUDENT in instructional, behavioral, and social situations in the school environment. Dr. Goodwin also recommended that STUDENT’s parents participate in a District-sponsored parent education program.
In response to a request by PARENT, Ms. Ivers wrote a letter dated August 2, 2000, in which she stated:
A.B.L.E. recommended a program that would allow for 8-10 hours of facilitated socialization, school aide training, and monthly consultation with school staff. . . . Due to the absence of staff members and programming during that time, we recommended that the therapy setting reflect social groups already established in the community (boy scouts, boys and girls clubs, sport’s groups). During the phoned IEP on December 3, 1999, we explained that staff members, either vendor through the district or the family, would have to facilitated [sic] STUDENT during these sessions and within these settings. (Pet. Exh. 14)
The findings and recommendations of Ms. Ivers and Dr. Goodwin are in substantial agreement regarding the aspects of a program that STUDENT needed to address his social skills. In light of the findings of Dr. Goodwin and Ms. Ivers, the Hearing Officer concludes that, for the period September 1999 to October 2000, STUDENT required a social skills program that included facilitated social skills instruction and opportunities for supervised social interaction with peers. STUDENT also needed a program that included formal training of STUDENT’s instructional aide in facilitating social skills in informal group settings.
It is concluded that the evidence does not support the Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT needed a professional consultant to supervise eight to ten hours of outside social skill training and practice. It is noted that Ms. Ivers in her original report did not indicate that the recommended hours of concentrated social activity all had to be supervised by a professional consultant. Rather, the original report suggested that some of the time could include social activities that STUDENT already had available in the community. Dr. Goodwin testified at hearing that STUDENT’s social skills should be addressed in the school setting, and that there would be opportunities in the school in class and at recess for STUDENT to informally practice the social skills learned in the more structured social skills lessons. Dr. Goodwin did not believe that STUDENT required a professionally supervised outside-of-school social intervention program to address his social deficits. Ms. Ivers’ letter dated ten months after her original report, without the support of direct testimony at hearing, is not given substantial weight, as it appears inconsistent with the original report. Furthermore, Ms. Ivers provided no information in her report or letter that would discredit Dr. Goodwin’s opinion that STUDENT’s classroom social problems needed to be addressed by an in-school program.(Footnote 5)
Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000, in addition to STUDENT’s undisputed academic needs, described above, STUDENT also required speech and language services to address social language problems, a full time instructional aide trained in addressing his episodes of inappropriate behavior through appropriate prompting techniques, and an in-school social skills program that included facilitated small-group social skills instruction and opportunities for supervised social interaction with peers. Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs
Petitioner first contends that the District’s program of September 1999 through October 8, 2000 was not designed to meet his meet his unique needs because the District failed to provide IEP goals and objectives to address behavior and social skills. As has been found above, the evidence at hearing established that STUDENT did not require specific goals and objectives pertaining to behavioral problems during the period September 1999 through October 2000. However, the District agreed that STUDENT required a social skills program. It is therefore necessary to address the appropriateness of the design of the District’s proposed social skills program.
On September 17, 1999, STUDENT’s IEP team developed annual goals and objectives for the 1999-2000 year in connection with problems STUDENT was having with communication and interaction with STUDENTs and teachers. In the area of pragmatics (practical use of language), STUDENT was to demonstrate emergence of proper inflection when asking a question. With regard to expressive communication, STUDENT was to use adjectives and adverbs when asked to describe the contents of a picture. In the area of grammar, STUDENT was to correctly use the copula “is” in sharing information in a small group. For auditory processing, STUDENT was to answer “when” and “how” questions when presented with a short story. With regard to psychomotor/organized recreational activities, STUDENT was to demonstrate knowledge and strategies in organized games.
At the IEP meeting, PARENT expressed concern regarding STUDENT’s development with respect to social skills. STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Mr. Lefever, noted that STUDENT was not doing well with regard to initiating social conversation. The team agreed to obtain assessments to gather more information for developing a social skills program for STUDENT.
On December 3, 1999, following receipt of the results of the Goodwin and Ivers assessments, the IEP team noted that STUDENT was not typically seeking out peers for play and social contact, and was having difficulty with communication and conversational skills. In addition to the goals and objectives established on September 17, 1999, the IEP team added an additional social/emotional goal that STUDENT would learn to ask a peer to play or engage in a shared activity and sustain the activity for at least ten minutes.
The goals and objectives formulated at the September 17, and December 3, 1999 IEP meetings were consistent with the opinions of Dr. Goodwin and Ms. Ivers, who indicated that in order to progress educationally, STUDENT needed a program that addressed his deficits in social communication and social interaction. Accordingly, it is concluded that the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s September and December 1999 IEPs were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique social needs.
Second, Petitioner contends that the social skills training offered by the District was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The District contends that it offered an appropriate social skills program provided by a qualified professional to teach STUDENT social skills. According to the District, this program included formal social skills training through whole-class and small-group instruction, and additional opportunities in school to practice social skills with facilitation by the classroom aide.
Based on the testimony of Patti Adams and Trena Spurlock, on December 3, 1999, in response to the Goodwin and Ivers assessments, the District offered to provide STUDENT with one hour per week of DIS counseling by Lee Ann Augsburger to consist of thirty minutes in a class setting and thirty minutes in individualized small-group instruction. (Pet. Exh. 24)
Lee Ann Augsburger holds a multi-specialty teaching credential, a school counseling credential, and a school psychologist credential. Ms. Augsburger testified that her social skills training for STUDENT consisted of a methodology called “Skill Streaming.” According to Ms. Augsburger, the specific skills taught were listening, asking for help, saying “thank you,” following instructions, completing assignments, contributing to discussions, offering help to an adult, asking questions, ignoring distractions, and joining in. Ms. Augsburger testified that she chose specific lessons from the Skill Streaming curriculum with STUDENT’s needs in mind. Her services consisted of two half-hour sessions per week. The first half-hour of instruction began with a presentation at the front of the entire class. Ms. Augsburger would introduce a skill verbally and by writing the steps on the board. Ms. Augsburger would then model the steps in front of the children, verbally repeating the steps and discussing with the children when the skill would arise in “real life.” Ms. Augsburger would elicit volunteers and play out the lesson in mid-room, having the class evaluate the role play and provide feedback. The children would then break into smaller groups of two to three students to work on the skills.
For the second half-hour per week, Ms. Augsburger would pull STUDENT out of the classroom and provide him individualized practice of the social skills taught in class. STUDENT would be invited to choose another child from the classroom to play with, and Ms. Augsburger would have them practice the target skills together in the context of various games and activities. Rachel Valdevia, STUDENT’s instructional aide, attended the large- and small-group sessions, as well as the individual pull-out lessons. According to Ms. Augsburger and Ms. Valdevia, by being present in the small-group and pull-out sessions, Ms. Valdevia was presented the opportunity to learn to be a social coach for STUDENT, assisting him as he took the skills into the less formal school social environment.
Dr. Goodwin testified that the Skill Streaming methodology used by Ms. Augsburger was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s social needs. Dr. Goodwin noted that this methodology allowed social behavior skills to be broken down into simple elements, with reinforcement of the concepts through role playing, and further practice with the skills in a small group. After the skills were practiced in the small-group setting, they could be transferred to a more informal large social setting. Thus, the training was designed to allow skills to be learned in the environment in which they would be used (i.e. the playground, the lunchroom). According to Dr. Goodwin, this was particularly important with STUDENT, because autistic children will typically have difficulty generalizing social concepts. Dr. Goodwin distinguished the District’s social program from the type of intervention requested by PARENT, which involved formalized social skills instruction outside of school in a small group. Dr. Goodwin stated that such a program was not likely to address STUDENT’s needs regarding in-school social behavior because it did not provide a likelihood of generalization and would not likely allow transfer of skills to the school setting.
Dr. Dorie Glover, testifying on behalf of Petitioner, stated that a social skills intervention that included thirty minutes in a large-group classroom setting and thirty minutes in a small group with one other child present would be a “waste of time” as it would not afford enough opportunities for STUDENT to learn the necessary social skills. Dr. Glover stated that the large-group aspect of the training would likely be particularly unhelpful because STUDENT could be expected to be more distracted in a large group and engage in self-stimulatory behavior. Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., STUDENT’s private afternoon social skills counselor, testified in agreement with Dr. Glover that a social skills program for STUDENT that consisted of an instructor standing at the front of the class presenting the lesson to a large group would not be appropriate for STUDENT.
The testimony of Drs. Glover and Hanson is accorded substantially less weight than that of Dr. Goodwin and Ms. Augsburger. Neither Dr. Glover nor Dr. Hanson worked with or observed STUDENT in the classroom setting. Neither interviewed STUDENT’s teachers or aides to determine how the social skills program was intended to meet STUDENT’s needs. Both Dr. Glover and Dr. Hanson admitted that they had not observed the District’s social skills services and, without knowing more, could not comment on the efficacy of the school program. Moreover, notwithstanding her criticism of the large-group aspect of the training, Dr. Hanson agreed that it was important for STUDENT that social skills be generalized to social groups in school. Dr. Hanson agreed that this would be best accomplished by teaching and practicing the skills in the school setting.
Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the DIS social skills training offered by the District was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique social needs.
Petitioner next contends that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s social, behavioral, and independence needs because the District failed to provide appropriate training to STUDENT’s instructional aides.
From September 1999 through the end of December 1999, the District assigned Devon Gump to serve as STUDENT’s morning instructional aide. Because Ms. Gump was not able to work in the afternoon, the District assigned a second aide, Ms. Mesa, to work as STUDENT’s aide during the afternoon for the same period. Ms. Gump had begun to serve as STUDENT’s one-on-one classroom aide in September 1997, while STUDENT was enrolled at the Kindergarten School. Ms. Gump testified that she has had no formal training or schooling in working with special education students. At some point after she began working as STUDENT’s aide, she received some informal training from private consultants hired by PARENT who gave her reading material and trained her regarding how to model behavior for STUDENT.
After STUDENT returned to the Pomona Unified School District in fall of 1998, the District approved Ms. Gump to be STUDENT’s aide. According to Ms. Gump, PARENT, Ms. Adams, and Ms. Spurlock, the District did not require that Ms. Gump have any special certification. All that was required was general competency and the completion of a general six-week paraprofessional course. (Pet. Exh. 21) Ms. Gump completed an application for employment, completed the required course, was designated a “substitute” employee, and began working at Yorba Elementary School with STUDENT in November 1998. Ms. Gump worked with STUDENT first in Ms. Smith’s second grade class, then in Ms. Hanlon’s first grade class, and finally in Mr. Lefever’s second grade class. According to the testimony of all witness, at no time before or after Ms. Gump was hired did the District provide her with any formal training in working with STUDENT. Ms. Gump testified that Patti Adams gave her “tips” on working with STUDENT.
It is noted that STUDENT’s previous IEP for the 1998-1999 school year called for formal training of the instructional aide. (Pet. Exh. 2) However, according to the testimony of Ms. Adams and Ms. Spurlock, the District relied on statements by PARENT that Ms. Gump was “well-trained.” According to Ms. Adams and Ms. Spurlock, based on assurances by PARENT, the District expected Ms. Gump to arrive “fully trained.” The undisputed evidence at hearing indicated that the District did nothing else to determine Ms. Gump’s level of training and ability to work with autistic children in general, or STUDENT in particular. (Pet. Exhs. 2, 83, 84).
STUDENT’s afternoon aide, Ms. Mesa, testified that, unlike Ms. Gump, she had received some formal in-service training from the District in working with special education students approximately five years before the hearing. In addition, Ms. Mesa had some prior background working with special education children in the home. Ms. Mesa testified as well that Ms. Adams offered many suggestions for dealing with STUDENT’s behavior and Ms. Wickwire, the District speech therapist, also gave suggestions for working with STUDENT.
The District was well aware of the importance of training the aides in assisting STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. Not only was such training required as part of STUDENT’s previous IEP, accordingly to Patti Adams, the District would not have even hired Ms. Gump if it had known she was not trained. In fact, once Ms. Gump started working, and Patti Adams came in to observe, Ms. Adams discovered that Ms. Gump did not have the skills the District had assumed. Ms. Adams observed that Ms. Gump was using inappropriate strategies, such as cajoling, coaxing, and even begging STUDENT to behave appropriately.
The testimony of multiple witnesses at hearing, including Dr. Goodwin, Dr. Glover, and Ms. Adams, emphasized the importance of training STUDENT’s instructional aides in appropriate prompting, redirection, behavior adjustment strategies, and social skills facilitation.
Although there is evidence that Ms. Mesa had a limited amount of training in working with special education students, there was no evidence she was trained in working with autistic children such as STUDENT. Likewise, the evidence did not support a conclusion that Ms. Gump received training that would enable her to use appropriate strategies with STUDENT. The District’s reliance on assurances by the parent that Ms. Gump was trained was unreasonable. Further, by Ms. Adams admission, it was evident upon her earliest observations of Ms. Gump working with STUDENT that she was not adequately trained. No evidence was offered at hearing to establish that the District designed an appropriate program of training to Devon Gump in light of these facts. Accordingly it is concluded that for the period September through December 1999, the District did not provide appropriate instructional aide training as part of STUDENT’s educational program.
Ms. Valdevia was STUDENT’s instructional aide for the period January 2000 through October 2000.(Footnote 6) When Ms. Valdevia was introduced to STUDENT in December 1999, she already had two years of experience working with the District in a special education class. In that capacity, Ms. Valdevia worked with a variety of handicapped students including those with Downs syndrome, autism, hearing impairments, selective muteness, and emotional/behavioral impairments.
Ms. Valdevia testified that she received a three- to four-day intensive training on the “TEACCH” program in December 1999 in preparation for serving as STUDENT’s aide and that she also received training on setting up a full inclusion daily learning program. The TEACCH training included helping the student develop problem solving and coping skills, teaching the student how to respond to social cues and behavior, teaching appropriate language and behavior, helping the child sustain attention and focus, and providing verbal reinforcement. Ms. Valdevia testified that she also believed she had necessary experience to assist STUDENT based on her previous employment.
Prior to beginning as STUDENT’s aide, Ms. Valdevia also observed the class of special day class (SDC) teacher Sharon Floyd to get information on how to teach children like STUDENT who have autism. According to Trena Spurlock, Ms. Floyd is a certified learning handicapped (LH) teacher of the SELPA program for San Antonio Elementary and teacher of a special day class for autism spectrum and related disorder (ASRD) children. Ms. Valdevia testified that Ms. Floyd showed her how to set up folders and schedules for STUDENT, and gave her ideas regarding organization and tactics. Ms. Valdevia also received advice from Ms. Adams regarding how to address STUDENT’s social and behavior issues. Finally, Ms. Valdevia received information on how to facilitate STUDENT’s social behavior by attending the lessons with Ms. Augsburger.
Based on the evidence presented at hearing, it is concluded that with regard to Rachel Valdevia, the District provided aide training that was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Rachel Valdevia had specific background in working with autistic children in the classroom; she also received an intensive training through the TEACCH program and Sharon Floyd regarding appropriate strategies for prompting and assisting STUDENT. Ms. Valdevia was afforded training in social facilitation through her consultation with Ms. Adams and participation in Ms. Augsburger’s social skills training sessions.
It is noted that there was no evidence that the District provided Ms. Valdevia with specific training on fostering independence in STUDENT. However, based particularly on the testimony of Dr. Goodwin and the report of Ms. Ivers, the evidence did not establish that specific training of the aide in facilitating independence was required as part of STUDENT’s program. Dr. Goodwin did indicate in her assessment that training the aide in appropriate prompting techniques would assist STUDENT in becoming more independent. According to the testimony of Ms. Adams and Ms. Valdevia, the TEACCH training program given to Ms. Valdevia included training in appropriate prompting techniques.
Accordingly, it is concluded that the District’s program with regard to training STUDENT’s instructional aides was not designed to meet his unique needs for the period September 1999 through December 1999. From January 2000 to October 2000, the District’s training was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Finally, Petitioner contends that the Speech and Language program offered by the District was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because the District’s speech and language therapist utilized an inappropriate intervention technique.
On September 17, 1999, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT should receive speech and language services designed to meet his goals and objectives in social language (semantics, pragmatics, and auditory processing) and academics (reading, spelling, and grammar). The team determined that STUDENT should receive such services five times per week, forty-five minutes per session. (Pet. Exh. 10)
The services offered by the District, which were initially accepted by PARENT, were provided by Doneva Wickwire. Ms. Wickwire testified that she has been a speech and language pathologist for the District since 1996. She has a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in communication disorders and has a credential in speech rehabilitation services. Ms. Wickwire served as STUDENT’s speech therapist through the District from 1997 until July 2000.
According to the IEP document and the testimony of Ms. Wickwire, twenty minutes of each of her sessions with STUDENT were to be devoted to individual speech therapy and twenty-five minutes to small-group activities focusing on social language. Ms. Wickwire testified that, in providing therapy to STUDENT, she utilized the speech and language intervention ADD/VV, developed by Lindamood Bell. Ms. Wickwire has attended numerous workshops regarding ADD/VV. She testified that this intervention is a good program for autistic children in general, and for STUDENT in particular, because it uses a highly visual, multi-sensory approach.
According to the IEP notes dated July 6, 2000 (Pet. Exh. 30), PARENT objected to the nature of Ms. Wickwire’s services because she was told by Jill Stowell at The Stowell Learning Center, where STUDENT was receiving FastForward, and by Dr. Beverly Smith, who was providing private speech and language services to STUDENT, that ADD/VV was not an appropriate intervention for autistic children.
Jill Stowell did not testify at hearing. However, Dr. Smith and Trena Spurlock agreed that Ms. Stowell was not a speech and language specialist. Beverly Smith, Ph.D., did testify at hearing. Dr. Smith has a master’s in psychology and a Ph.D. in human development. She has worked as a substitute teacher and a speech and language teacher. (Pet. Exh. 89) Dr. Smith has provided after-school private speech and language services to STUDENT since approximately spring 1999. According to the notes of the July 6, 2000 IEP meeting, Dr. Smith indicated that she did not believe that ADD/VV was appropriate for STUDENT. However at hearing, Dr. Smith gave only a limited rationale for her objection to the intervention, stating that she as not a “big proponent of ADD/VV,” because it is a “ritualistic set sequence type program.” Dr. Smith admitted, however, that she had not observed STUDENT’s school speech and language program and had not even reviewed his IEP goals and objectives to determine how they would or would not be met by speech and language services that utilized the ADD/VV methodology.
Ms. Wickwire has the appropriate credentials and background to provide speech and language services to STUDENT. Ms. Wickwire also had a long-term therapeutic relationship with STUDENT, having provided services for a three-year period. She testified knowledgeably about STUDENT’s history and unique academic and social challenges. Accordingly, it is concluded that the services provided by Ms. Wickwire were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language.
Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s Program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs with the exception of the training of STUDENT’s instructional aides for the period September through December 1999.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Under Rowley school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor or opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The District offered a program that included social skills training in school by Lee Ann Augsberger, a qualified specialist in training social skills to learning handicapped students. In addition, the District offered speech and language services by Doneva Wickwire, a certified speech and language instructor, who provided therapy in both the academic aspects and social aspects of speech and language. Finally, the District provided STUDENT with a one-to-one aide during his school day, who, at least with regard to Rachel Valdevia, received formal training in working with STUDENT, assisted in academic activities, intervened when STUDENT’s behavior became inappropriate, and provided coaching during social opportunities at school.(Footnote 7)
Petitioner contends that the social skills training by Ms. Augsberger was not calculated to provide educational benefit because STUDENT did not respond well to instruction in the large-group setting and did not interact independently in the pull-out sessions. PARENT testified that she observed STUDENT on two occasions in Ms. Augsburger’s social skills lessons. PARENT first observed the class presentation part of the training. From what PARENT observed, STUDENT was self-stimulating the whole time and getting nothing out of the lesson. While typical students were responding to questions, STUDENT was not. PARENT testified that later, when she observed the pull-out session, she noticed that Ms. Valdevia spoke for STUDENT and directed everything he did, and that nothing was at STUDENT’s own initiative.
Ms. Augsburger admitted in her testimony that STUDENT did not focus as well in the large-group presentation and that if she were to begin providing the services again, she would eliminate the large-group presentation aspect of the program. Nonetheless, Ms. Augsberger believed that STUDENT responded well in the small-group and individualized pull-out sessions. Dr. Goodwin, testifying on behalf of the District, stated that she expected that STUDENT would benefit from both the classroom aspects and the pull-out aspects of Ms. Augsberger’s Skill Streaming program.
Rachel Valdevia testified that although STUDENT did not initially respond in Ms. Augsburger’s class, by the end of March 2000 he was “taking an interest.” According to Rachel Valdevia, by June 2000, STUDENT required “little” prompting to participate in the social skills lessons. At that point, STUDENT would sit, focus in, raise his hand, join in, and participate when Ms. Augsburger asked for volunteers. He was able to participate successfully in the role playing. Usually, with redirection and prompting, Ms. Valdevia could get responses from STUDENT in the Augsburger group lessons. Ms. Valdevia testified that STUDENT obtained definite benefit in the individuals sessions with Ms. Augsburger where a child would be chosen to participate.
Although there was some evidence that the large-group aspects of the training did not work as well as was hoped, Dr. Goodwin and Ms. Augsburger, who have already been found to be credible witnesses regarding STUDENT’s social skills needs, agreed that STUDENT would be likely to benefit from the small-group and pull-out components of the training. The evidence at hearing was undisputed that STUDENT made dramatic gains in behavior and social skills by the end of the 1999-2000 school. It is noted, however, that STUDENT was receiving private services in the social skills area outside of school. It cannot therefore be conclusively determined that the actual benefit STUDENT received was related to the services offered by the District. However, the difficulties that PARENT observed STUDENT having in the social skills training on two occasions are not sufficient to overcome the convincing testimony on Dr. Goodwin, Ms. Augsburger, and Rachel Valdevia. Accordingly, it is concluded that the District’s social skills services were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
Petitioner contended as well that Rachel Valdevia was not properly trained to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. At hearing, Petitioner presented the testimony of Lenny Gutierrez in support of the contention that Ms. Valdevia’s assisting technique was inappropriate. Mr. Gutierrez testified that he is currently completing a university degree in developmental psychology. Has no special education credentials, but has worked in the adolescent health field with San Bernardino County, Pasadena Developmental Associates, and Easter Seals. Mr. Gutierrez described himself as a “developmental interventionist,” noting that he had received over one hundred hours of training under various behavioral therapists, speech and language pathologists, and occupational therapists. Mr. Gutierrez observed STUDENT in the classroom with Rachel Valdevia on January 14, 2000. Mr. Gutierrez testified that he found Ms. Valdevia to be “authoritative” in her approach. She also was “directive,” “short,” and “to the point,” using a firm voice. He issued a report with a variety of recommendations aimed at improving Ms. Valdevia’s approach with STUDENT in the classroom. Both Mr. Gutierrez and PARENT testified that they perceived STUDENT to be overly dependent on Rachel Valdevia.
As has previously been found, Ms. Valdevia received training and instruction in appropriate prompting techniques, as well as training in addressing STUDENT’s behavior problems and facilitating social conduct. The overwhelming weight of the evidence established that after an adjustment period, STUDENT responded well to Ms. Valdevia’s direction and significantly reduced his inappropriate behavior in the classroom. Rachel Valdevia testified credibly that STUDENT had not had any of his “really negative” behaviors since March 2000, and as of September 2000 STUDENT wasn’t banging, knocking or having any verbal outbursts. Several witnesses, including Patti Adams and Dr. Goodwin, attributed much of STUDENT’s improvement to Ms. Valdevia’s approach to addressing STUDENT’s behavior. With regard to social skills, Ms. Valdevia testified that she would reinforce the lesson by Ms. Augsburger throughout STUDENT’s day, prompting other STUDENTs to ask STUDENT questions as suggested by Ms. Augsburger. There was no significant evidence that Ms. Valdevia’s training or technique with STUDENT was educationally inappropriate. Mr. Gutierrez’s testimony in this regard is not given substantial weight as he has minimal formal qualifications in the areas of educational psychology, learning differences, or autism.
While Ms. Valdevia testified that she stays with STUDENT throughout his day and that STUDENT continues to be significantly dependent on her, she indicated that STUDENT has shown increased independence since she began as the instructional aide. Doneva Wickwire, the speech and language therapist, testified that through efforts by Ms. Valdevia and herself, STUDENT successfully learned to go to the bus by himself during the 1999-2000 school year. Additionally, STUDENT began to take his file down and work independently without prompting from Ms. Valdevia. He improved his toileting skills, zipping his pants appropriately. He also began to eat lunch with classmates with Ms. Valdevia fading back.
Accordingly, it is concluded by virtue of her background and training, Ms. Valdevia’s services as STUDENT’s instructional aide were reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit with regard to improving his behavior, social skills, and independence.
Finally, as has previously been discussed, Petitioner objected to the speech and language services of Ms. Wickwire on the basis that the ADD/VV approach was not appropriate for STUDENT. For the same reasons that it was concluded that Ms. Wickwire’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is also concluded that such services, including the ADD/VV methodology, were reasonably calculated to provide benefit. Furthermore, the testimony of Doneva Wickwire and Anthony Lefever clearly established that STUDENT made substantial progress on all academic and social goals and objectives during the period September 1999 through October 2000.
Ms. Wickwire testified that STUDENT met benchmarks in each speech and language goal, though with regard to certain areas, such as use of adjectives and adverbs, pragmatics, and answering “how” questions, STUDENT did not meet his annual goals. With regard to social language, Ms. Wickwire testified that her services were effective for STUDENT and that STUDENT made steady progress in “baby steps.” Ms. Wickwire noted that, in general, STUDENT uses language to seek information, but doesn’t initiate generally with persons with whom he has no history of interaction. Ms. Wickwire further testified that she saw progress in pragmatics from September 1999 to June 2000. STUDENT began to engage in more social play, he began to have an easier time participating in “pretend play,” and he began taking turns in structured activities. However, STUDENT did not use inflection with questions, and he did not generalize use of pronouns outside the therapy setting.
Mr. Lefever agreed that STUDENT made progress on his speech and language goals and objectives during the 1999-2000 school year. According to Mr. Lefever, STUDENT’s communications skills began to improve in late January/early February 2000. This improvement continued throughout the year. In addition, Mr. Lefever testified that all the academic areas listed in STUDENT’s goals and objectives were covered in the class curriculum, and that although he did not measure STUDENT’s progress as to the specific short-term objectives, he did take note of the goals and objectives several times throughout the school year. Mr. Lefever testified that based on STUDENT’s performance on in-class assignment and daily oral language lessons, STUDENT made progress with regard to both expressive and receptive speech and written language. Mr. Lefever testified that STUDENT experienced a large amount of improvement in reading scores and in his language skills. Mr. Lefever noted that by the end of 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was able to read grade-level passages and was doing well on weekly spelling tests.
As with training in social skills, STUDENT received private speech and language therapy during the period September 1999 to October 2000. It is therefore not possible to conclude how much of his progress related solely to the District-provided services. However, it is noted that even Petitioner’s witness, Dr. Smith, testified that STUDENT had received substantial benefit from Doneva Wickwire’s services. Accordingly, it is concluded that the evidence presented at hearing established that the speech and language services offered by the District were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT, and in fact did provide him with such benefit.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program was reasonably designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit with regard to his social skills and speech and language needs. The District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit with regard to training of STUDENT’s instructional assistants for the period September 1999 to October 2000.
Comport With the IEP
Under Rowley, the District must provide implement its offered educational program in a manner consistent with the student’s IEP.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide extended year and maintenance services in accordance with STUDENT’s IEP.
The evidence at presented at hearing, however, does not support Petitioner’s contention. The IEP dated September 17, 1999, indicated that extended school year services would be provided at a level “to be determined.” In June 2000, Petitioner contacted the District about extended school year services and was able to reach an agreement as to the nature of such services in an addendum signed on June 22, 2000. Although the document specifying the extended school year program was not offered as an exhibit at hearing, both Ms. Spurlock and PARENT testified that PARENT signed the agreement. Patti Adams testified that STUDENT received the extended year schooling in a general education classroom during summer 2000, with aide support in accordance with PARENT’ request. Accordingly, it is concluded that the District’s extended year and maintenance services comported with STUDENT’s IEP.
Petitioner also contends that District was “out of compliance” with the September 1999 IEP with regard to assistive technology, because STUDENT was without his computer for approximately two months after it broke on or about February 14, 2000.
It was undisputed that the District implemented STUDENT’s IEP regarding assistive technology by providing a lap top computer with appropriate educational software. However, on or about February 14, 2000, the computer issued by the District was broken. According to Ms. Adams and Ms. Spurlock, the District sought to have the computer repaired but it was prohibitively expensive. The District did not have another laptop immediately available for STUDENT to use. Although the District did obtain a large desk computer to put in the classroom on a temporary basis, Ms. Spurlock testified that there may have been problems installing the necessary software used by STUDENT. Although no specific date was provided at hearing, the District eventually provided a replacement laptop computer with properly installed software. According to the testimony of Ms. Valdevia and PARENT, STUDENT was without a serviceable computer for approximately two months.
The extended period during which STUDENT was without access to a computer in the class is troubling. The District presented scant evidence justifying such an extended delay in replacing the broken laptop. Nonetheless, the evidence adduced at hearing demonstrated that, notwithstanding this approximate two-month period during which STUDENT did not have a computer, he continued to progress academically. According to Mr. Lefever, STUDENT made steady progress in all academic areas and was able to perform class work by writing.
Under Rowley the District is not required to provide the best possible education or guarantee the success of the educational program. There was no evidence presented at hearing that the temporary loss of STUDENT’s computer substantially deprived STUDENT of an opportunity to obtain educational benefit during the 1999-2000 school year. Accordingly, it is concluded that the District’s implementation of assistive technology services comported with STUDENT’s IEP.
Finally, Petitioner contends that the District did not properly implement STUDENT’s RSP services for mathematics as provided in his IEP.
The IEP dated September 17, 1999, indicates that the District agreed to provide the RSP math services to STUDENT in the general education classroom. According to notes from the IEP meeting dated January 18, 2000, Petitioner requested that the District begin providing pull-out RSP math services. According to Ms. Davis’ testimony, she began providing pull-out services in March 2000. Petitioner contends that the District inappropriately delayed initiating the pull-out math lessons. However, there was no evidence at hearing that STUDENT’s IEP was amended to specify that the RSP services would be on a pull-out basis.
Petitioner also contends that the District improperly failed to implement STUDENT’s IEP by instructing Sonia Davis, the math resource specialist, to discontinue using a calculation strategy known as “Touch Math,” which helped STUDENT understand math concepts. However, there was no evidence at hearing that the use of the “Touch Math” system was specified in STUDENT’s IEP.
Accordingly, it is concluded that the District’s implementation of RSP math services comported with STUDENT’s IEP.
Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program with regard to extended school year and maintenance, RSP math services, and assistive technology comported with STUDENT’s IEP for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000.
ISSUE NO. II: Must the District reimburse the parent for the cost of the privately obtained assessments and services of Gloria Medina, Riki Gentry, Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Dorie Glover, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., Lenny Gutierrez, the First Christian Church, the Stowell Learning Center, and the Brain Cell, Inc.?
Petitioner contends that the Parent should be reimbursed for private consultations, social skills lessons, play therapy, and speech and language services procured during the period September 25, 1999, to October 8, 2000.
The District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the period September through the end of December 1999, by failing to provide appropriate training of STUDENT’s instructional aides. It must therefore be determined what, if any remedy, should be granted based on the denial of FAPE for that period.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §§ 1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated that “the rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an "empty victory." As stated by the Court, if "appropriate relief" in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed," the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete." Id.
The evidence at hearing established that PARENT obtained consultative services from Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., and Dorie Glover, Ph.D. in developing an after-school social skills and social language program for the period September 1999 through October 8, 2000. Lenny Gutierrez conducted a play therapy group and Gloria Medina worked one-one-one with STUDENT teaching social language skills during the same period. PARENT also obtained speech and language services through the Stowell Learning Center and the Brain Cell, Inc.
It has been established that the District’s social skills and speech and language programs were appropriate. Although the District denied a FAPE by failing to properly train STUDENT’s instructional aides for the period September through December 2000, there was no evidence presented at hearing that the private services obtained by Petitioner during the period September 25, 1999, through October 8, 2000 were in any way designed or calculated to address deficiencies in the aides’ training.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that there is no basis on which to award reimbursement in this matter.
ISSUE NO. III: Must the District Reimburse the Parents for Cost of Hearing Testimony by Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., and Dorie Glover, Ph.D.?
Petitioner contends that she should be reimbursed for the expense of presenting testimony at hearing by Beverly Smith, Ph.D., Amanda Hanson, Ph.D., and Dorie Glover, Ph.D.
The hearing officer is aware of no authority and Petitioner did not provide any authority allowing the award of witness fees in a special education proceeding. Accordingly, there is no basis to award the witness fees requested by Petitioner.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt o this decision. California Education Code §56505(j).
Dated: January 16, 2001 ________________________________ Paul R. Gant, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: This decision has been amended to correct typographical errors in the original decision, including formatting errors in certain headings and misspelling of Dr. Dorie Glover’s name. In addition, the date of decision has been amended to reflect that the decision issued on January 3, 2001 rather than January 3, 2000. The amendments do not affect the substance of the decision.
Footnote 2: These issues have been re-ordered and re-organized from the statements presented prior to hearing by the parties to reflect the understandings reached by the parties and the Hearing Officer at the time of hearing regarding the issues to be decided.
Footnote 3: Because neither party raised an issue at hearing regarding whether STUDENT’s educational placement was the least restrictive environment, this component of the Rowley test is not addressed in this decision.
Footnote 4: In addition, Petitioner argued in his closing brief that the District had committed a procedural violation by failing to hold an IEP within a reasonable time following her request in March 2000. However, at hearing Petitioner specifically stated that she was not claiming that STUDENT was denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) as a result of this alleged procedural violation. Accordingly, this issue is not addressed in this decision.
Footnote 5: At hearing, Petitioner also presented the testimony and report of Dorie Glover, Ph.D., an educational psychologist, and Beverly Smith, Ph.D., a speech and language therapist, in support of the contention that STUDENT required a program that included eight to ten hours of structured, supervised outside social skills practice. However, Drs. Glover and Smith admitted that they had not conducted full assessments of STUDENT and had not done any formalized testing. Neither Dr Glover nor Dr. Smith interviewed STUDENT’s teachers or aides or observed STUDENT in the classroom. Accordingly, their opinions on this topic are accorded little weight.
Footnote 6: Ms. Valdevia was STUDENT’s instructional aide in the morning hours. Because PARENT was pulling STUDENT out of school in the afternoons to attend a private social skills program, STUDENT had no District assigned aide in the afternoons beginning in January 2000.
Footnote 7: It has already been determined that the District’s program was inadequate with regard to training Devon Gump and Cassandra Mesa. Since their training was plainly deficient, it is also determined that this aspect of the District’s educational program was not reasonably calculated to benefit STUDENT.
