California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 11, 2005

Student v. Anaheim Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 145-05 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Anaheim Union High School District correctly found a seventh grader not eligible as speech and language impaired; District's sanctions request denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 13-year-old seventh grader at Walker Junior High School attended general education classes and had a Section 504 plan. In March 2005, District speech-language specialist Celeste Krueger assessed him. At an IEP meeting on March 24, 2005, the team found he did not qualify for special education as speech and language impaired (SLI). His parents agreed at the meeting. They later filed for due process, arguing that he should have been found eligible and offered an IEP that included speech-language consultation.

Before the hearing, Student agreed that the District's speech-language assessment was appropriate and legally sound. Ms. Krueger testified without contradiction. She found no articulation, voice or fluency problems, and the student passed a nurse's hearing screening. On standardized language tests, none of his scores fell 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or below the 7th percentile. A few scores showed mild weaknesses. The Hearing Officer found that the student did not meet the state SLI criteria and did not need special education, so there was no denial of FAPE. A draft IEP listing other health impairment was not admitted into evidence.

The District asked for sanctions against Student's attorney and advocate, calling the case frivolous. The Hearing Officer denied the request. The parent had memory difficulties and had changed her mind after the meeting. There was also a question about whether the District's two-page IEP document was complete. On that record, bad faith or frivolousness was not shown.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The case shows how SEHO applied California's speech and language eligibility rules, Education Code section 56333 and 5 CCR 3030(c), area by area. It also shows that a parent who agrees the district's assessment was appropriate and offers no contrary evidence has little basis to challenge eligibility. Finally, it shows how SEHO handled a district's request for sanctions against a parent's attorney and advocate.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Should the District have identified Student as eligible for special education and related services as a speech and language impaired (SLI) student and offered him a FAPE at the IEP meeting convened on March 24, 2005?

    Student did not meet any SLI criteria under Education Code section 56333 and 5 CCR 3030(c). The district speech-language specialist's unrebutted assessment, which Student stipulated was appropriate, found no articulation, voice, fluency, language or hearing disorder, so there was no denial of FAPE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief denied. The District's request for sanctions against Petitioner's advocate and attorney was also denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Educ. Code § 56333; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(c); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3088; Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 128.5; Gov. Code §§ 11455.10-11455.30

People named in the decision

  • Celeste Krueger, speech and language specialist (licensed speech-language pathologist), assessor; witness, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Richard Clarke, resource specialist and curriculum specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Kathy Strobel, registered nurse; conducted hearing screening, Anaheim Union High School District
  • Brian Allen, educational consultant and advocate for Student, Law Office of David Burkenroad
  • Walker Junior High School, student's school, Anaheim Union High School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on June 2, 2005.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney David Burkenroad and by Brian Allen, an educational consultant and advocate with the law office of David Burkenroad. Also appearing on behalf of Petitioner was his mother, PARENT. Respondent Anaheim Union High School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jeffrey J. Riel. Also present was Richard Clarke, the District’s resource specialist and curriculum specialist.

Petitioner and the District both called District speech and language specialist Celeste Krueger to testify. The Hearing Officer called Petitioner’s mother, PARENT, to testify.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Both parties were given an opportunity to submit written closing arguments. Only the District submitted a written closing brief. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Should the District have identified STUDENT as eligible for special education and related services as a speech and language impaired (SLI) student and offered him a free appropriate public education at the individualized education program meeting (IEP) meeting convened on March 24, 2005?

CONTENTIONS

Petitioner contends that the District should have identified him as eligible for special education and related services as a speech and language impaired (SLI) student and offered him a FAPE at the IEP meeting convened on March 24, 2005. Petitioner also asserts that the District should have developed an IEP for him that included consultation to the classroom teachers and parent from a speech-language therapist, as necessary. (Footnote 1)

The District contends that the IEP team correctly determined that STUDENT is not eligible for special education and related services under the SLI category. As discussed below, the District also requests sanctions based upon specified conduct of Petitioner’s advocate and attorney.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old, seventh-grade student who attends Walker Junior High School. STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD “at the end of 2004.” (Test. of PARENT.) STUDENT attends general education classes and is receiving accommodations and modifications pursuant to a section 504 plan dated February 9, 2005. Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.

On February 9, 2005, STUDENT’s mother, PARENT, signed an assessment plan prepared by the District. The assessment plan included testing in the area of speech and language. (Pet. Exh. 4.) Celeste Krueger, a District speech and language specialist, assessed STUDENT on March 22 and March 24, 2005. Ms. Krueger prepared an assessment report dated March 24, 2005. Ms. Krueger concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria as a student with a speech and language impairment. (Test. of Ms. Krueger; Dist. Exh. 23.) Ms. Krueger’s assessment report was presented to the IEP team at an IEP meeting held on March 24, 2005. District members of the IEP team determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education and related services as a speech and language impaired student. PARENT (and STUDENT’s father, PARENT) agreed with the determination at the IEP meeting that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education and related services. However, at the hearing, PARENT testified that she now disagrees with the eligibility determination relating to the eligibility category of a speech and language impairment. (Dist. Exh. 24; Test. of Ms. Krueger and PARENT.)

This matter convened for hearing on June 2, 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Section 56333 of the California Education Code provides as follows:

“A pupil shall be assessed as having a language or speech disorder which makes him or her eligible for special education and related services when he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services. In order to be eligible for special education and related services, difficulty in understanding or using spoken language shall be assessed by a language, speech, and hearing specialist who determines that such difficulty results from any of the following disorders:

(a) Articulation disorders, such that the pupil’s production of speech significantly interferes with communication and attracts adverse attention.

(b) Abnormal voice, characterized by persistent, defective voice quality, pitch, or loudness. An appropriate medical examination shall be conducted, where appropriate.

(c) Fluency difficulties which result in an abnormal flow of verbal expression to such a degree that these difficulties adversely affect communication between the pupil and listener.

(d) Inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language such that the pupil’s language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her peers.

(e) Hearing loss which results in a language or speech disorder and significantly affects educational performance.

Title five, section 3030, of the California Code of Regulations provides as follows:

A pupil shall qualify as an individual with exceptional needs, pursuant to Section 56026 of the Education Code, if the results of the assessment as required by Section 56320 demonstrate that the degree of the pupil’s impairment as described in Section 3030 (a through j) requires special education in one or more of the program options authorized by Section 56361 of the Education Code. The decision as to whether or not the assessment results demonstrate that the degree of the pupil’s impairment requires special education shall be made by the individualized education program team, including assessment personnel in accordance with Section 56341(d) of the Education Code. The individualized education program team shall take into account all the relevant material which is available on the pupil. No single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for the decision of the individualized education program team as to the pupil’s eligibility for special education. The specific processes and procedures for implementation of these criteria shall be developed by each Special Education Local Plan Area and be included in the local plan pursuant to Section 56220(a) of the Education Code.

Title five, section 3030(c) of the Code of California Regulations provides as follows:

A pupil has a language or speech disorder as defined in Section 56333 of the Education Code, and it is determined that the pupil’s disorder meets one or more of the following criteria:

(1) Articulation disorder.

(A) The pupil displays reduced intelligibility or an inability to use the speech mechanism which significantly interferes with communication and attracts adverse attention. Significant interference in communication occurs when the pupil’s production of single or multiple speech sounds on a developmental scale of articulation competency is below that expected for his or her chronological age or developmental level, and which adversely affects educational performance.

(B) A pupil does not meet the criteria for an articulation disorder if the sole assessed disability is an abnormal swallowing pattern.

(2) Abnormal Voice. A pupil has an abnormal voice which is characterized by persistent, defective voice quality, pitch, or loudness.

(3) Fluency Disorders. A pupil has a fluency disorder when the flow of verbal expression including rate and rhythm adversely affects communication between the pupil and listener.

(4) Language Disorder. The pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when he or she meets one of the following criteria:

(A) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan, or (B) The pupil sores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or the score is below the 7th percentile for his or her chronological age or developmental level on one or more standardized tests in one of the areas listed in subsection (A) and displays inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a representative spontaneous or elicited language sample of a minimum of fifty utterances. The language sample must be recorded or transcribed and analyzed, and the results included in the assessment report. If the pupil is unable to produce this sample, the language, speech, and hearing specialist shall document why a fifty utterance sample was not obtainable and the contexts in which attempts were made to elicit the sample. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified in the assessment plan.

As discussed above, Celeste Krueger, a District speech and language specialist, assessed STUDENT on March 22 and 24, 2005. Ms. Krueger prepared an assessment report on March 24, 2005. (Dist. Exh. 23.) Ms. Krueger has been a District speech-language specialist for four years and a speech-language therapist for fifteen years. (Footnote 2) Ms. Krueger testified that there are five eligibility areas for speech and language services: articulation, voice, fluency, language, and hearing. The Hearing Officer examines each eligibility area.

Articulation

Ms. Krueger testified that an articulation disorder occurs when a child has difficulty with production of a sound that adversely affects attention or significantly interferes with communication. Ms. Krueger stated that she conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT for articulation and obtained a conversational speech sample. Ms. Krueger found that STUDENT did not have any reduced intelligibility and did not display an inability to use speech mechanisms. Ms. Krueger further found that STUDENT does not have an articulation disorder that interferes with his communication. Additionally, Ms. Krueger noted in her assessment report that STUDENT was fully intelligible and that no articulation errors were noted. Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not have an articulation disorder. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Voice

Ms. Krueger testified that an abnormal voice is one characterized by abnormal vocal quality or pitch or abnormal loudness. Ms. Krueger stated that she conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT for abnormal voice and did not find an abnormal voice. Additionally, Ms. Krueger noted in her assessment report that STUDENT’s voice quality was “age and sex appropriate.” Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not qualify for special education services as a student having an abnormal voice. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Fluency

Ms. Krueger testified that a fluency disorder manifests when a student displays difficulties with rate or rhythm of speech or has difficulty with the fluency process in speaking. Ms. Krueger stated that she conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT for fluency and concluded that STUDENT did not display an abnormal flow. Additionally, Ms. Krueger noted in her assessment report that “no abnormal disfluencies were observed.” Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not qualify for special education services as a student with a fluency disorder. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Language

Ms. Krueger testified that a language disorder affects the ability to express oneself or the ability to understand information that you take in receptively. Ms. Krueger stated that she conducted three standardized assessments of STUDENT to determine whether he has a language disorder. Ms. Krueger explained that she looks at semantics, syntax, morphology, and pragmatics to conduct a speech and language assessment. The Hearing Officer addresses each of the areas.

Semantics

Ms. Krueger testified that she assessed STUDENT in semantics with three different standardized tests: the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, the Expressive Vocabulary Test, and two subtests on the CELF-IV. Ms. Krueger stated that none of STUDENT’s scores fell below one and one half standard deviations below the mean or below the seventh percentile. (Footnote 3) Ms. Krueger stated that in her opinion, STUDENT does not qualify for speech and language services in the area of semantics. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Syntax and Morphology

Ms. Krueger testified that she assessed STUDENT in syntax and morphology. Ms. Krueger stated that she used three subtests of the CELF-IV (formulated sentences, recalling sentences, and word classes -- expressive) to assess STUDENT’s morphology and syntax together. Ms. Krueger stated that morphology is prefixes or suffixes of words, or the past tense use of words (eg., “ed” and “ing”), the use of plurals, looking at past tense, and possessives. Ms. Krueger stated that none of the subtest scores fell below one and one-half standard deviations below the mean or below the seventh percentile. (Footnote 4) Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not qualify for speech and language services in the area of syntax or morphology. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Pragmatics

Ms. Krueger described pragmatics as social language, the language individuals use socially with each other and how individuals have conversations. Pragmatics can also involve social turn taking, eye contact, and picking up on nonverbal cues. Ms. Krueger administered the Adolescent Test of Problem Solving to assess STUDENT’s language-based critical thinking skills. STUDENT’s standard score of 96 indicates average abilities in the areas of critical thinking and pragmatics. (Footnote 5) Ms. Krueger testified that she also conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT in pragmatics. Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not have any concerns in the area of pragmatics that would qualify him as a speech and language impaired student. Ms. Krueger’s persuasive opinion was unrebutted.

Hearing

Ms. Krueger testified that Kathy Strobel, a registered nurse, conducted a hearing screening of STUDENT during a nurse’s assessment on February 16, 2005, and that Ms. Strobel found that STUDENT passed the hearing screening. Additionally, Ms. Krueger testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate any difficulties in hearing during her assessment of him. Ms. Krueger testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not have a hearing loss that would qualify him for a language disorder. Ms. Krueger’s opinion was unrebutted.

In summary, Ms. Krueger testified that STUDENT did not meet the threshold criteria on any of the assessments for special education eligibility as a speech and language impaired student. Petitioner provided no credible evidence to challenge the reliability of the findings of Ms. Krueger. Additionally, Petitioner stipulated that Ms. Krueger’s assessment was appropriate and met the legal requirements. Moreover, there was no credible evidence to support STUDENT’s need for special education and related services as a speech and language impaired student.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria as a student with a speech and language impairment who needed special education and related services.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services as speech and language impaired. Therefore, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.

REQUEST FOR SANCTIONS

Section 3088(a) of Title Five of the California Code of Regulations provides that provisions for contempt sanctions, order to show cause, and expenses contained in Government Code sections 11455.10-11455.30 of the Administrative Procedure Act apply except as modified by (b) through (e) of this section. A presiding hearing officer may initiate sanctions and/or place expenses at issue, or order a party or a party’s attorney or authorized representative to pay reasonable expenses (including the costs of personnel) with the prior approval of the General Counsel of the California Department of Education. The failure to initiate contempt sanctions and/or impose expenses is not appealable. Cal. Educ. Code § 3088(b) through § 3088(e). Section 128.5(a) of the California Code of Civil Procedure provides that a trial court may order a party, the party’s attorney, or both to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees incurred by another party as a result of bad-faith actions or tactics that are frivolous or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay. Section 128.5(b)(2) defines “frivolous” as (A) totally and completely without merit or (B) for the sole purpose of harassing an opposing party.

In support of its request for sanctions, the District argues in its brief that Petitioner’s advocate and attorney knowingly participated in the following conduct that should be deemed frivolous and in bad faith: Petitioner’s position that he qualified as a speech and language impaired (SLI) student was frivolous because Petitioner had previously stipulated that the only speech and language assessment relied on was an appropriate one and met the legal requirements; that the only assessment relied on, Ms. Krueger’s, “clearly” stated that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria as an SLI student; that a signed declaration by Ms. Krueger “continued to opine” that STUDENT did not qualify [as an SLI student]; and that Petitioner argued without “an iota of evidence” that STUDENT was SLI. The District asserts that Petitioner’s “bare allegation” that he was an SLI student “without anything more” was “objectively frivolous” from which “bad faith” can be inferred. The District also argues that Petitioner’s advocate, Brian Allen, was not prepared at hearing and “lacked the basic skills to competently represent Petitioner” and that Petitioner “knowingly (or recklessly) presented false evidence” to show that STUDENT was eligible [as an SLI student]. (Footnote 6)

The Hearing Officer must determine whether Petitioner’s parent and/or his representatives prosecuted the due process hearing in bad faith and/or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay, and whether the due process proceeding was frivolous (i.e., whether Petitioner’s issue for hearing was totally and completely without merit or for the sole purpose of harassing an opposing party).

The Hearing Officer declines on the present record to initiate sanctions for expenses or costs. Petitioner’s mother testified that she is experiencing “chemotherapy” induced amnesia, and therefore it is unclear to the Hearing Officer to what extent PARENT’s memory difficulties affected her ability to recall what transpired at the March 24, 2005 IEP meeting and to recall the nature and extent of her communications about SLI eligibility matters with her advocate and attorney. Additionally, PARENT may not have understood Ms. Krueger’s explanations at the IEP meeting about why STUDENT did not qualify as an SLI student. PARENT’s memory difficulties may also have affected her ability to communicate effectively with her advocate and attorney in preparation for hearing, which in turn affected the ability of her advocate and attorney in representing her at hearing. Additionally, PARENT testified that did not recall seeing the first page of the two-page March 24, 2005 IEP that was entered into evidence by the District. Thus, a question of fact existed prior to the start of the hearing over whether the two-page IEP document offered by the District into evidence was the entire March 24, 2005 IEP document. Because of the uncertainty over PARENT’s memory relating to the March 24 IEP meeting, because PARENT apparently changed her mind about whether she agreed with the SLI eligibility determination made at the IEP meeting, and because there was a question at the start of the hearing about the actual length and contents of the March 24, 2005 IEP document, the Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence does not establish that Petitioner’s due process hearing was prosecuted in bad faith and/or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay, or that Petitioner’s issue for hearing was totally and completely without merit or for the sole purpose of harassing an opposing party. The District’s request for sanctions is denied.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

In accordance with California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 11, 2005 ___________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 Petitioner stipulated during the prehearing telephone conference that the District’s March 2005 speech and language evaluation was appropriate and met the legal requirements.

2 Ms. Krueger is a licensed (California) speech-language pathologist. Ms. Krueger holds a bachelor’s and master’s degree in communicative disorders and is a member of the American Speech Hearing Association (ASHA), from which she received her certificate of clinical competence. Ms. Krueger also has a California credential in clinical and rehabilitation services and is affiliated with the California speech-language pathology association (CASHA). Ms. Krueger has conducted approximately two hundred speech and language assessments and also treats students who have speech or language disorders. Ms. Krueger previously worked in the medical field in acute care in hospitals and long-term rehabilitation in skilled nursing facilities. (Test. of Ms. Krueger.)

3 On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, STUDENT’s ability to “comprehend and express vocabulary and linguistic concepts was average for his chronological age. On the Expressive Vocabulary Test, STUDENT “demonstrated average abilities with a standard score of 86.” On two subtests on the CELF–IV – word classes - Receptive and Word Definitions – STUDENT received scaled (Standard) scores of six and nine respectively. The scores indicate a mild impairment in the ability to identify “two out of four related word pairs.” Ms. Krueger stated that “mildly impaired” means that the score is not within the average range but it “might be an area that is a weakness,” but not necessarily one that would prohibit him from being successful in the classroom (but a weakness to be aware of). (Test. of Ms. Krueger and Dist. Exh. 23.)

4 On three subtests of the CELF-IV – Formulated Sentences, Recalling Sentences, and Word Classes – Expressive, STUDENT received scaled standard scores of eleven, six, and six, respectively. Ms. Krueger found that STUDENT demonstrated average ability to formulate sentences of “age-appropriate length and complexity,” and a mild impairment in the ability to “repeat sentences of increasing length and complexity” and the ability to “explain relationships between two selected words.” (Test. of Ms. Krueger and Dist. Exh, 23.)

5 On the WISC-IV administered in December 2004, STUDENT’s full scale score of 93 is within the average range. (Test. of Ms. Krueger and Dist. Exh. 23.)

6 Petitioner’s advocate attempted to introduce into evidence copies of a draft or proposed typewritten IEP. The document indicated special education eligibility as a student with an other health impairment (OHI). However, the document was not properly authenticated by any witness and was not relevant on the issue of eligibility for SLI. Thus, the document was not admitted into evidence.