California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 15, 2004
Student v. San Jose Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1463-04 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour
San Jose Unified must reimburse $9,207.50 for Stepping Stones after failing to make specific placement offers to a deaf preschooler.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes an earlier Hearing Office stay put ruling that the student's stay put placement was the Hacienda preschool SDC. No remand, appeal, or correction is noted.
Summary
The parents of a five-year-old boy eligible for special education on the basis of deafness filed for due process against San Jose Unified School District. The boy was later also diagnosed with autism. His parents challenged his services and placements from summer 2002 through the 2004-2005 school year. They also sought reimbursement for many private assessments and services.
The Hearing Officer found that the District did not make sure the nonpublic school it funded, Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf, delivered the monthly audiology services in his IEPs. It also did not ensure he had a preschool placement in summer 2003. The District failed to assess his hearing after his cochlear implant surgery in October 2003. From September 2003 to March 2004, it showed the parents several very different programs but never offered one specific placement. That violated Union School District v. Smith. It also denied him a one-on-one aide he needed during that period. The 2004-2005 kindergarten offer described only a type of class, so it was not a valid offer.
The District won the claims on speech-language services, its autism assessment, prior written notice, reimbursement for private assessments and counseling, and placement at Associated Learning and Language Specialists, which was not an educational placement. The District must assess his hearing, hold an IEP meeting to offer a specific kindergarten class, and reimburse $9,207.50 for Stepping Stones plus mileage.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a "menu" of possible placements. Showing parents several very different programs without choosing and offering one specific placement was not a valid offer under Union v. Smith. The decision also held the district responsible for monitoring whether a nonpublic school actually delivered the services in the student's IEP.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1. During the 2001-2002 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated June 5, 2002?
The ESY IEP did not include audiology, and credible testimony based on invoices showed the speech-language sessions were delivered five times per week.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2a. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability (autism)?
The District began a psychoeducational assessment covering autism about two weeks after it learned of the private autism diagnosis, which was appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 2b. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs dated June 5 and September 25, 2002?
The District denied FAPE because it did not monitor the nonpublic school or make sure monthly audiology services were delivered; speech-language services were delivered.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 3a. During the 2002-2003 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with a preschool placement pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003?
The District denied FAPE because it did not make sure the nonpublic school provided the agreed ESY preschool placement and did not revise the IEP. No compensatory education was awarded because no harm was shown.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 3b. During the 2002-2003 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003?
Monthly audiology services were not provided, which denied FAPE; the speech-language services were received.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 4a. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability (hearing following cochlear implant)?
The District had to assess hearing after the cochlear implant to determine educational needs. It rejected the argument that such an assessment was medical, and the District failed to assess for months.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4b-i. Did the District deny STUDENT a procedural FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate placement from September 2003 to March 2004?
The District presented a range of very different possible placements but never selected and offered a specific placement, which violated Union. This caused a loss of educational opportunity, seriously infringed on parent participation, and denied FAPE.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4b-ii. Did the District deny STUDENT a procedural FAPE by changing his placement without providing prior written notice (removal from ALLS in September 2003)?
The District had not placed the student at ALLS, so it owed no prior written notice when he left that program.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 4b-iii. Did the District deny STUDENT a procedural FAPE by changing his placement (to the Hacienda preschool SDC in March 2004) without convening an IEP meeting?
Placing the student at Hacienda without an IEP meeting or written consent was a procedural violation. It did not deny FAPE because the mother took part fully and agreed, and the student made progress.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4c-i. Did the District deny STUDENT a substantive FAPE by failing to provide him with a one-on-one aide from September 2003 to March 2004?
Overwhelming evidence showed his behaviors kept him from benefiting from his education without one-on-one help, and the District knew this. Failing to provide an aide denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 4c-ii. Did the District deny STUDENT a substantive FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services from September 2003 to March 2004 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004?
Failing to provide monthly audiology from September 2003 to February 4, 2004 denied FAPE. Speech-language services were provided, including one weekly session the therapist delivered at Stepping Stones with the student present.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5a. During the 2003-2004 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology services pursuant to his IEP dated May 27 and June 10, 2004?
The parties had agreed in February 2004 that audiology services were no longer needed.
- District prevailedStay put
Issue 5b. During the 2003-2004 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with an appropriate preschool placement?
The Hearing Office had found the stay put placement was Hacienda, so the District could not change his placement while the due process case was pending.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 6. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year?
The offer described only a type of class (a self-contained classroom of up to 12 students with a credentialed teacher and an aide), with no specific location or program. This was not an offer under 5 C.C.R. section 3042 and Union, and it denied FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 7. In order to receive a FAPE, does STUDENT require a District-funded placement at Associated Learning and Language Specialists for the 2004-2005 school year?
ALLS is a nonpublic agency without credentialed teachers, not an educational placement, so it is not an appropriate kindergarten placement.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 8a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the Children's Health Council assessment?
The private assessment was obtained before any District assessment, not because the parents disagreed with one, so it was not reimbursable under Ed. Code section 56329(b).
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 8b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the Don Mordasini assessment?
There was no evidence about the assessment and no disagreement with a District assessment.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 8c. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the California Ear Institute assessments?
The audiograms were obtained for medical reasons, not because of disagreement with a District assessment.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for California Ear Institute audiology services?
There was no evidence of what services were provided or how often.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology speech and language services?
The District did not fail to provide IEP speech-language services, so the private services did not replace a denied service.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9c. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders tuition and a preadmission assessment?
There was no placement offer and no aide from October 2003 to March 2004. Notice was adequate under the circumstances, and Stepping Stones met his needs with progress, so $9,207.50 was awarded.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9d. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for Associated Learning and Language Specialists tuition?
Reimbursement for summer 2004 and fall 2004 at ALLS was denied because the District was required to keep the Hacienda stay put placement.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9e. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for GRANDMOTHER for private tutoring?
The parents had no agreement to pay for the grandmother's tutoring and incurred no expense.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9f. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for Family and Children's Service counseling?
The therapy did not replace any service the District was required to provide.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9g. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for Gregory Thomson, Ph.D. counseling?
No IEP or assessment called for individual therapy, so it did not replace a District service.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9h. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for transportation for each of the services provided?
Mileage was awarded only for round trips to Stepping Stones from October 2003 to March 2004.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, the District must assess the student in the area of hearing under the assessment plan the parents signed on July 19, 2004.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of the hearing assessment, the District must hold an IEP meeting and offer a specific kindergarten classroom placement for 2004-2005. It must provide all related services, goals and objectives in the May 27/June 10, 2004 IEP. The proposed teacher (or another District person familiar with the classroom), the service providers, the hearing assessor and a school psychologist must attend.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days, the District must reimburse the parents $9,207.50 for Stepping Stones: $8,400 tuition plus $807.50 preadmission assessment, October 2003 to March 2004.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof of round-trip miles and days attended, the District must reimburse mileage from home to Stepping Stones (October 2003 to March 2004) at the District's standard employee mileage rate. The dollar amount was not set.
Total: $9,207.50 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights; Adams v. State of Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Honig v. Doe; Polk v. Central Susquehanna; Walczak; Roland M.
People named in the decision
- Susan Foley, advocate for Student
- Flora Englund, director of special education, San Jose Unified School District
- Damaris Divito, speech and language therapist, Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf
- Kathy Berger, assistant director, Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf
- Pamela Colston-Joy, executive director, nonpublic agency, Associated Learning and Language Specialists
- Gregory Thomson, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist, private counseling provider
- Sylvia Abrahamson, private speech-language pathologist, Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology
- Alison Barrett, speech-language pathologist, Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders
- Sharon Falk, Ph.D., District program specialist, San Jose Unified School District
- Linda Saranto, assistant director of Pajaro Valley SELPA; acted as District program specialist, Pajaro Valley Special Education Local Plan Area
- Eileen McGee, special education preschool SDC teacher, San Jose Unified School District, Hacienda Elementary School
- Paul Kramer, principal, Empire Gardens Elementary School
- Kay McDonald, special education principal; described as District program specialist at 2004 IEP meetings, Santa Clara County Office of Education
- Deborah Ross, school psychologist, San Jose Unified School District
- Teresa Pruss, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), San Jose Unified School District
- Marsha Hamner, District program specialist, San Jose Unified School District
- Joan Baran, private assessor who diagnosed autism, Children's Health Council
- Don Mordasini, licensed marriage and family therapist, private assessor
- Joanna Latz, kindergarten SDC teacher (proposed), Willow Glen Elementary School
- Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf, nonpublic school
- Associated Learning and Language Specialists, nonpublic agency
- Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders, nonpublic agency
- Children's Health Council, private assessment provider
- California Ear Institute (now Let Them Hear Foundation), private audiology provider
- Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology, private speech-language provider
- Family and Children's Service, private counseling provider
- Santa Clara Valley Medical Center, private assessment provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Jose, California, on September 15, 16, 17, 21, 22, and 23, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by advocate Susan Foley. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent San Jose Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys William Michael Quinn, Jr., and Damara Moore of the law firm Ruiz & Sperow. Also present on the District’s behalf was Flora Englund, District director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, his mother; Damaris Divito, speech and language therapist at Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf; Kathy Berger, assistant director of Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf; Pamela Colston-Joy, executive director of Associated Learning and Language Specialists; Gregory Thomson, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist; GRANDMOTHER, his grandmother; Sylvia Abrahamson, speech and language pathologist at Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology; Alison Barrett, speech and language pathologist at Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders; and Flora Englund, District director of special education.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Sharon Falk, Ph.D., District program specialist; Linda Saranto, assistant director of Pajaro Valley Special Education Local Plan Area; Eileen McGee, District special education teacher; Paul Kramer, principal of Empire Gardens Elementary School; Kay McDonald, special education principal with the Santa Clara County Office of Education; and Deborah Ross, District school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on October 19, 2004, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. During the 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY), did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his individualized education program (IEP) dated June 5, 2002?
2. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District:
a. fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and b. deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs dated June 5 and September 25, 2002?
3. During the 2002-2003 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with:
a. a preschool placement pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003, and b. audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003?
4. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District:
a. fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, b. deny STUDENT a procedural FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate placement from September 2003 to March 2004, changing his placement without providing prior written notice, and changing his placement without convening an IEP meeting, c. deny STUDENT a substantive FAPE by failing to provide him with a one-on-one aide from September 2003 to March 2004, and failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services from September 2003 to March 2004 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004?
5. During the 2003-2004 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with:
a. audiology services pursuant to his IEP dated May 27 and June 10, 2004, and b. an appropriate preschool placement?
6. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year?
7. In order to receive a FAPE, does STUDENT require a District-funded placement at Associated Learning and Language Specialists for the 2004-2005 school year?
8. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following privately obtained assessments: a. Children’s Health Council assessment, b. Don Mordasini assessment, and c. California Ear Institute assessments?
9. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following privately obtained services: a. California Ear Institute for audiology services, (Footnote 2) b. Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology for speech and language services, c. Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders for tuition and a preadmission assessment, d. Associated Learning and Language Specialists for tuition, e. GRANDMOTHER for private tutoring, f. Family and Children’s Service for counseling, g. Gregory Thomson, Ph.D. for counseling, and h. Transportation for each of the services provided?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a five-year-old student who resides with his parents within the boundaries of the District. He has been eligible for special education and related services since the age of three on the basis of deafness. He currently attends Associated Learning and Language Specialists (ALLS), a certified, language-based nonpublic agency (NPA) for infants, toddlers, and preschool and kindergarten children.
In July 2001, when STUDENT was two years old, Oakland Children’s Hospital diagnosed him with a moderate to severe bilateral sensorineural hearing loss. In August 2001, the California Ear Institute prescribed bilateral hearing aids for him. Thereafter, STUDENT’s parents contacted the Santa Clara County Office of Education (SCCOE) to inquire about special education preschool services.
On September 6, 2001, SCCOE and STUDENT’s parents agreed to place STUDENT in a toddler class with a certified deaf and hard-of-hearing teacher at the county’s Chandler Tripp School. However, STUDENT attended this school for only two weeks because his parents did not believe that the program was providing him with educational benefit. STUDENT’s parents then located a preschool class at the Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf (Weingarten), a certified nonpublic school (NPS) for deaf and hard-of-hearing children. In October 2001, STUDENT began to attend a preschool class and to receive speech and language services at Weingarten at county expense.
On June 5, 2002, shortly before STUDENT’s third birthday, the District convened an individualized education program (IEP) meeting to discuss placement and services for STUDENT for the upcoming 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY) and the 2002-2003 school year. The IEP team agreed to continue STUDENT’s preschool placement and speech and language services at Weingarten at District expense. The IEP team also agreed to provide STUDENT with monthly audiology services at Weingarten at District expense and occupational therapy (OT) services at the District beginning in September 2002. On September 25, 2002, the District convened an additional IEP meeting to further discuss goals and objectives and services for the 2002-2003 school year.
Shortly after beginning the fall semester at Weingarten, STUDENT began to have difficulties with attention and focus and to engage in disruptive classroom behaviors. STUDENT’s teacher at Weingarten suggested to his mother that STUDENT’s behaviors may be due to autism and recommended that he be assessed. In February 2003, the Children’s Health Council (CHC) assessed STUDENT at his parents’ request and diagnosed him with autism. In March and May 2003, the District also assessed STUDENT and found that he exhibited social/emotional and behavioral deficits as a result of his diagnoses of autism and a hearing impairment.
On May 28 and June 4, 2003, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the recent assessments as well as placement and services for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year. At these meetings, the IEP team agreed to reconvene after STUDENT’s parents had the opportunity to visit several District and nonpublic preschool programs. On June 12, 2003, following these observations, the IEP team met again to discuss a placement for STUDENT. However, because the parents did not believe that any of the programs that they had observed were appropriate for STUDENT, the District’s offer of placement at the end of the meeting was simply for STUDENT to “continue” in an “NPS.” Despite the parents’ and District’s disagreement regarding the 2003-2004 school year, they agreed that STUDENT would attend Weingarten during the 2002-2003 ESY. Nonetheless, STUDENT did not attend any preschool program during the 2002-2003 ESY, but he continued to receive speech and language services at Weingarten at District expense.
In September 2003, at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in a preschool program at ALLS. However, he remained at that facility for less than two weeks because his teacher reported that he exhibited disruptive behaviors. After this brief time at ALLS, STUDENT’s grandmother tutored him at her home during September and October 2003 for one hour per day while Weingarten continued to provide him with speech and language services at District expense and the District continued to provide him with OT services. During this time, STUDENT’s parents and his doctors decided that STUDENT would undergo surgery for a cochlear implant to address his hearing deficits at the end of October.
On October 7, 2003, the District again convened an IEP meeting to discuss placement and services for STUDENT for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year in light of his removal from ALLS and his impending surgery for a cochlear implant. At this meeting, the District did not offer a classroom placement because STUDENT’s parents again wanted the opportunity to visit several District and nonpublic preschool programs. Although the District did not convene another IEP meeting following these visits, STUDENT’s mother notified District program specialist Dr. Sharon Falk that the parents had decided that Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders (Stepping Stones), a certified NPA for children with autism and language disorders, was most appropriate for him. On October 31, 2003, STUDENT began to attend a preschool class at Stepping Stones at his parents’ expense and continued to receive speech and language services at Weingarten at District expense and OT from the District.
On February 4, 2004, the District again convened an IEP meeting to discuss updated goals and objectives, placement, and related services for STUDENT for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, the 2003-2004 ESY, and the 2004-2005 school year. The meeting again adjourned to allow the parents the opportunity to visit several preschool and kindergarten classrooms.
Following the February meeting, MOTHER notified District program specialist Linda Saranto that the parents would agree to place STUDENT in the District’s preschool special day class (SDC) at Hacienda Elementary School (Hacienda) for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year if the District would agree to provide him with a one-on-one aide. Ms. Saranto agreed to do so and on March 26, 2004, STUDENT began to attend Eileen McGee’s preschool SDC class at Hacienda with a one-on-one aide. He also continued to receive speech and language services from Weingarten at District expense and OT from the District. STUDENT remained in Ms. McGee’s classroom for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year.
On May 27, 2004, the District convened another IEP meeting to discuss a preschool placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 ESY and a kindergarten placement for the upcoming 2004-2005 school year. Because STUDENT’s parents requested that he be placed at ALLS with a one-on-one aide, the team agreed to reconvene after Ms. Saranto had an opportunity to observe the ALLS program. On June 10, 2004, the team reconvened, and, after considering Ms. Saranto’s report on ALLS, the District offered to continue STUDENT in Ms. McGee’s preschool SDC classroom with a one-on-one aide for the 2003-2004 ESY. For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered to place STUDENT in a small, self-contained kindergarten classroom with a maximum of twelve students taught by a special education credentialed teacher.
At the June meeting, STUDENT’s parents refused to consent to the IEP and instead presented the District with a request for a due process hearing and a notice of the parents’ intent to place STUDENT privately at ALLS and to seek reimbursement from the District. The following day, STUDENT filed his request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. On July 5, 2004, STUDENT began the 2003-2004 ESY at ALLS with a one-on-one aide at his parents’ expense while continuing to receive speech and language services from Weingarten at District expense and OT from the District.
In September 2004, STUDENT began the 2004-2005 school year at ALLS with a one-on-one aide at his parents’ expense. He continues to receive speech and language therapy at Weingarten at District expense and OT from the District. In his request for hearing, STUDENT contends that the District has failed to offer him a FAPE from the 2001-2002 ESY through the present and that his parents should be reimbursed for their costs in providing him with a variety of assessments and services during that time.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: During the 2001-2002 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated June 5, 2002?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian; meet the standards of the State educational agency; include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education; and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988). The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir.1996). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir.1997).
The Court in Rowley also emphasized compliance with procedures set forth in the IDEA. As the Court declared, “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” Id. at 205-206. Indeed, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir.1992). See also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir.1990).
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District=s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District=s proposed program would have addressed the Petitioner=s unique needs, provided him some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.
When taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision thus require that an appropriate program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and (3) conform to STUDENT’s IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200.
In this case, the parties do not dispute that during the 2001-2002 ESY STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of fine motor skills, preacademics, oral motor, and expressive and receptive language. They also do not dispute that he required a preschool placement, monthly audiology services, and speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten as well as weekly OT services at the District. The only area of dispute for the 2001-2002 ESY is the parents’ contention that STUDENT’s program failed to conform to his IEP as the District allegedly failed to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP of June 5, 2002.
STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide him with monthly audiology services at Weingarten during the 2001-2002 ESY pursuant to his IEP of June 5, 2002. The District contends that it had no obligation to provide audiology services to STUDENT pursuant to this IEP. With regard to audiology services, a review of the IEP of June 5, 2002, reveals that the parties agreed that STUDENT would receive monthly audiology services at Weingarten beginning on September 3, 2002. The document further states that the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would attend a four-week preschool program and would receive speech and language sessions five times per week during the 2001-2002 ESY. There is no mention of audiology services during the ESY program. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District had no obligation to provide STUDENT with audiology services during the 2001-2002 ESY as the sole IEP for the 2001-2002 ESY does not address audiology services.
With regard to speech and language services, STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language sessions five times per week during the 2001-2002 ESY, or a total of twenty sessions during the four-week ESY, pursuant to his IEP of June 5, 2002. The District contends that STUDENT received all speech and language services at Weingarten pursuant to his IEP.
As discussed above, on June 5, 2002, the IEP team agreed to provide STUDENT with speech and language sessions five times per week during the 2001-2002 ESY. Kathy Berger, assistant director at Weingarten, testified that STUDENT received these sessions five times per week during the 2001-2002 ESY. She also testified that she knew that the District had paid Weingarten for all of the sessions because she verified the dates with her office manager prior to her testimony. According to Ms. Berger, the office manager reviewed invoices located in her office and advised Ms. Berger that the District had paid for all of the sessions in question. In contrast, MOTHER testified that she believed that STUDENT did not receive speech and language services five times per week during ESY but could not actually recall the speech and language services that STUDENT received more than two years ago.
On the basis of the persuasive testimony of Ms. Berger, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEP of June 5, 2002, during the 2001-2002 ESY. Although MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not receive these services, she could not recall whether or not he had actually received them. On the other hand, Ms. Berger testified credibly that she had verified that STUDENT did receive these services during that summer. The Hearing Officer accords more weight to the testimony of Ms. Berger because it was based upon a review of records in her office rather than to that of MOTHER who could not even recall what services STUDENT received. In addition, Weingarten staff was in a better position to know if STUDENT received these services as they were at school with him everyday. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not fail to provide STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEP of June 5, 2002, during the 2001-2002 ESY. (Footnote 3)
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to provide STUDENT with audiology services and did not fail to provide STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated June 5, 2002, during the 2001-2002 ESY and thus did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.
ISSUE NO. 2: During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District: a. fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and b. deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs dated June 5 and September 25, 2002?
a. Assessment in All Areas of Suspected Disability
A district has an obligation to reassess a child at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). Moreover, the child shall be assessed in all areas related to his or her suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
STUDENT contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability during the 2002-2003 school year, specifically in the sole area of autism. The District contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year in its psychoeducational assessment in March and May 2003 wherein it assessed STUDENT in the areas of autism, classroom behaviors, communication, adaptive functioning, and socialization.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s teacher at Weingarten became concerned about STUDENT’s disruptive classroom behavior in late 2002 and suggested that STUDENT may have autism. As a result, MOTHER contacted Santa Clara Valley Medical Center (SCVMC), who assessed STUDENT in January and February 2003 but did not diagnose him with autism. STUDENT’s mother then took him to Children’s Health Council (CHC), where Dr. Joan Baran assessed STUDENT in January and February 2003. On the basis of school observations and a clinic assessment, Dr. Baran diagnosed STUDENT as having mild autism.
MOTHER testified that she submitted a copy of the CHC report to the District shortly after she received it on March 11, 2003. Thereafter, although MOTHER did not specifically request an assessment from the District, on March 24 and May 9, 2003, District school psychologist Teresa Pruss performed a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in which she reviewed the SCVMC and CHC assessments. Ms. Pruss also observed STUDENT at school and in speech and language sessions, and administered autism checklists to his mother, teachers, and speech and language therapists. Additionally, Ms. Pruss noted that STUDENT’s teachers and speech and language therapists found his behaviors to be within the autistic range, thus corroborating the CHC diagnosis. Ms. Pruss also relied upon the CHC diagnosis of autism, and concluded that STUDENT exhibited significant delays in adaptive functioning and development at school, communication, daily living skills, and socialization.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District assessed STUDENT in the area of autism during the 2002-2003 school year as soon as his mother advised the program specialist that CHC had diagnosed him with autism. In fact, the District began its assessment of STUDENT two weeks after being notified by his mother of this diagnosis, relying in part upon the CHC diagnosis of autism in making its findings that STUDENT exhibited significant delays in functioning. Therefore, in light of the fact that the District assessed STUDENT in the area of autism immediately after his parents’ privately obtained assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District appropriately assessed him in the area of autism. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District did not fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability during the 2002-2003 school year. (Footnote 4)
b. Audiology and Speech and Language Services
As discussed above, the District must provide STUDENT with a program that is designed to meet his unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and conforms to his IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200. In addition, each local education agency shall ensure that a child with a disability who is placed in or referred to a private school or facility by a public agency is provided special education and related services in conformance with an IEP at no cost to the parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.401; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(c). The local education agency shall monitor compliance of private schools by written reports, on-site visits, and parent questionnaires. 34 C.F.R. § 300.402(a).
The parties do not dispute that during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the areas of fine motor skills, preacademics, oral motor, and expressive and receptive language. In addition, it is undisputed that STUDENT continued to require a preschool placement, monthly audiology services, and speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten. The only remaining area of dispute for the 2002-2003 school year is the parents’ contention that STUDENT’s program again failed to conform to his IEP as the District allegedly failed to provide audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs dated June 5 and September 25, 2002.
With regard to audiology services, a review of the evidence reveals that at IEP meetings on June 5, 2002, and September 25, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team agreed to provide him with monthly audiology services at Weingarten beginning in September 2002. (Footnote 5) Ms. Berger, assistant director of Weingarten, testified that although Weingarten provides “indirect” audiology services where there is a concern regarding a student’s hearing, she could not recall whether STUDENT received any audiology services at Weingarten during the 2002-2003 school year.
In this case, STUDENT’s mother testified that he did not receive such services, and no witness testified that he actually received these services. On the basis of the undisputed testimony, the Hearing Officer thus concludes that STUDENT did not receive monthly audiology services at Weingarten. As discussed above, it is the ultimate responsibility of a school district to ensure that a child attending an NPS at the district’s expense receive services pursuant to his or her IEP. Although it is undisputed that neither the parents nor Weingarten staff notified the District that STUDENT was not receiving audiology services from Weingarten pursuant to his IEP, the District had an affirmative obligation to monitor compliance by visiting the NPS or otherwise ensuring that services were being provided. 34 C.F.R. § 300.402(a). No District witness testified that the District undertook any action to ensure that STUDENT was receiving services at Weingarten pursuant to his IEP. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with monthly audiology services pursuant to his IEP during the 2002-2003 school year.
With regard to speech and language services, although STUDENT’s mother contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language services during the 2002-2003 school year pursuant to his IEP, she testified that he actually received these services. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not fail to provide STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs of June 5 and September 25, 2002, during the 2002-2003 school year. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year to the extent that it failed to provide him with audiology services pursuant to his IEPs of June and September 2002.
ISSUE NO. 3: During the 2002-2003 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing To provide him with:
a. a preschool placement pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003, and b. audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003?
The parties do not dispute that during the 2002-2003 ESY STUDENT continued to have similar needs to those he had during the 2002-2003 regular school year. They also do not dispute that he continued to require a preschool placement, monthly audiology services, and speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten. The only area of dispute for the 2002-2003 ESY is the parents’ contention that STUDENT’s program again failed to conform to his IEP as the District allegedly failed to ensure his attendance at his preschool placement and failed to provide him with audiology and speech and language services pursuant to his IEP of May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003.
a. Preschool Placement
STUDENT contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to ensure his attendance in a preschool placement during the 2002-2003 ESY pursuant to his IEP dated May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003. The District concedes that STUDENT did not attend preschool during the 2002-2003 ESY but contends that the reason for this was his parents’ decision not to send him to school rather than the District’s failure to ensure his attendance at school. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s IEP team in May and June 2003 agreed that he was eligible for ESY services at Weingarten for the 2002-2003 ESY. It is also undisputed that STUDENT did not attend any preschool during the 2002-2003 ESY.
MOTHER testified that Weingarten had a summer program during the 2002-2003 ESY but that STUDENT did not attend because Weingarten staff told her that it was not appropriate for him due to his disruptive behaviors. Damaris Divito, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at Weingarten, and Ms. Berger testified similarly. Ms. Berger also testified that she believed that STUDENT needed a one-on-one aide in order to benefit from their ESY program.
As discussed above, it was the ultimate responsibility of the District to ensure that Weingarten provided the preschool service to which STUDENT’s IEP team had agreed for the 2002-2003 ESY. 34 C.F.R. § 300.401; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(c). Although the District contends that it had no way of knowing that STUDENT was not in school, it had an affirmative obligation to visit the school or otherwise ensure that Weingarten was providing a service to which it was obligated pursuant to his IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.402(a). Moreover, although a District’s offer may be appropriate at the time it is made, districts have an obligation to revise an IEP as necessary if a child’s needs change. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). Had the District determined that Weingarten believed the program to be inappropriate by communicating with Weingarten staff, it could have convened another IEP meeting to revise the IEP or identify an appropriate placement. Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed testimony, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT did not attend Weingarten during the 2002-2003 ESY because of his parents’ reliance upon concerns expressed by Weingarten staff. However, in light of the District’s obligation to ensure that STUDENT received the services provided in his IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes the District failed to ensure that Weingarten provide STUDENT with a preschool placement during the 2002-2003 ESY.
b. Audiology and Speech and Language Services
With regard to audiology services, STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide him with monthly audiology services at Weingarten for the 2002-2003 ESY pursuant to his IEP of May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003. The District again concedes that STUDENT did not receive these services during the 2002-2003 ESY but contends that Weingarten rather than the District had the responsibility to provide them.
A review of the evidence reveals that at the IEP meetings in June 2003 the parties agreed to provide STUDENT with monthly audiology services at Weingarten during the 2002-2003 ESY. Moreover, the parties added a statement to the IEP of June 12, 2003, that did not exist in his prior IEPs, that read, “Audiologist to monitor STUDENT’s hearing.” Ms. Berger, Ms. Divito, and MOTHER all testified that STUDENT received only speech and language services from Weingarten during the 2002-2003 ESY and that he did not receive audiology services. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that STUDENT did not receive monthly audiology services pursuant to his IEP during the 2002-2003 ESY.
With regard to speech and language services, although STUDENT’s mother again contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language services pursuant to his IEP during the 2002-2003 ESY, she testified that he actually received these services. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not fail to provide STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEP of May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003, during the 2002-2003 school year.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY to the extent that it failed to ensure that Weingarten provided him with a preschool placement and to the extent that it failed to provide him with monthly audiology services pursuant to his IEP of May 28, June 4, and June 12, 2003.
ISSUE NO. 4: During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District: a. fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, b. deny STUDENT a procedural FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate placement from September 2003 to March 2004, changing his placement without providing prior written notice, and changing his placement without convening an IEP meeting, and c. deny STUDENT a substantive FAPE by failing to provide him with a one- on-one aide from September 2003 to March 2004, and failing to provide him with audiology and speech and language services from September 2003 to March 2004 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004?
a. Assessment in All Areas of Suspected Disability
As discussed above, the District has an obligation to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, including hearing, if appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). In addition, a child shall be reassessed at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a).
STUDENT contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability during the 2003-2004 school year, specifically that it failed to assess him in the area of hearing following his cochlear implant in October 2003. The District contends that it had no obligation to assess STUDENT following his cochlear implant surgery because “an audiological assessment in connection with a major surgical procedure is a medical, not an educational, service.” (emphasis in original)
A review of the evidence reveals that MOTHER testified that STUDENT underwent major surgery for a cochlear implant on October 20, 2003. Thereafter, on February 4, 2004, at the first IEP meeting held after the surgery, the team added goals and objectives to STUDENT’s IEP in the areas of hearing aid self-help and auditory comprehension. District program specialist Kay McDonald testified that at the May and June 2004 IEP meetings, MOTHER requested an assessment to determine the extent of STUDENT’s hearing loss with his implant. Thereafter, on July 14, 2004, the District presented STUDENT’s parents with an assessment plan that included a hearing test by an audiologist. On July 19, 2004, the parents consented and returned the assessment plan to the District. However, no hearing test was conducted pursuant to that assessment plan.
Ms. Berger, who has a master’s degree in special education/communicative handicapped, testified that to maximize an implant, a child needs intense services during the critical one and one-half years immediately after receiving an implant. Ms. Divito corroborated this testimony, stating that after STUDENT received his implant, he had to learn to refocus on auditory skills that he had previously learned. With regard to the District’s argument that it was not responsible for conducting a hearing assessment following STUDENT’s implant because the implant was a medical procedure, that argument is misplaced here. The purpose of an assessment in this case is not to determine STUDENT’s medical condition but his need for educational services. Moreover, the District itself proposed this assessment in an assessment plan that included a hearing test in July 2004.
On the basis of the undisputed testimony regarding the length of time for intervention following surgery for a cochlear implant, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT had a limited time following his implant surgery to develop oral and auditory skills. It is undisputed that the District proposed additional goals and objectives in the areas of hearing aid self-help and auditory comprehension for STUDENT three months after his surgery but did so without an assessment to determining his hearing levels as a prerequisite to developing goals and objectives. In fact, the District did not discuss an assessment of STUDENT’s hearing following his implant until the IEP meeting in May 2004, six months after his surgery, and did not present his parents with an assessment plan that included a hearing test until one month after the meeting. According to Ms. Berger, the area of hearing after his implant was an area of concern for STUDENT as he had a limited time in which to develop oral and auditory skills.
Therefore, on the basis of the overwhelming evidence that STUDENT needed an evaluation of his hearing following his implant to determine his educational needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to assess STUDENT in the suspected area of hearing during the 2003-2004 school year.
b. Procedural Violations of FAPE
As discussed above, students are entitled to certain procedural safeguards to ensure that they receive a FAPE. Moreover, although not all procedural violations constitute a denial of FAPE, those that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in a denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483.
Although the parties agreed to most of STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2003-2004 school year, they disagreed with regard to the extent of his behavioral needs. They do not dispute that he required a preschool placement, monthly audiology services until February 2004, and speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten. However, the parties had numerous disputes during the 2003-2004 school year that related to STUDENT’s changing behavioral needs and an appropriate placement to address those needs.
As discussed above, staff at Weingarten informed STUDENT’s mother that they could no longer handle STUDENT at their facility during the 2002-2003 ESY because of his increasingly disruptive classroom behavior unless he had a one-on-one aide. As a result, it is undisputed that after IEP meetings held in May and June 2003, MOTHER and District staff began to search for a more appropriate placement for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that during the summer of 2003, she and District program specialist Marsha Hamner visited ALLS, an NPA for children with language disorders. Because MOTHER believed the program at ALLS to be appropriate for STUDENT, she decided to place him at that facility. Although it is undisputed that the District did not convene an IEP meeting at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, MOTHER testified that she believed that the placement at ALLS was at District expense, a contention that the District disputes. Thereafter, according to MOTHER and Pamela Colston-Joy, executive director of ALLS, STUDENT remained at ALLS for only seven or eight days in September 2003 because staff at ALLS informed MOTHER that it could no longer handle STUDENT without a one-on-one aide because of his disruptive behaviors.
It is further undisputed that MOTHER notified District program specialist Dr. Sharon Falk that ALLS could no longer handle STUDENT because of his disruptive behaviors and that the District thus convened an IEP meeting on October 7, 2003, to discuss placement for STUDENT for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. It is also undisputed that at the meeting the District did not make a placement offer for STUDENT because MOTHER wanted to observe several possible placements, including a District SDC and a nonpublic placement at Stepping Stones. MOTHER testified that after she and Dr. Falk observed these options, she decided to enroll STUDENT at Stepping Stones. STUDENT began at Stepping Stones following his cochlear implant surgery at the end of October 2003.
Thereafter, the evidence reveals that on February 4, 2004, the District convened another IEP meeting in which the IEP team added goals and objectives related to STUDENT’s implant but did not offer a placement because his parents again wanted the opportunity to observe several possible placements. Following this meeting, MOTHER agreed to place STUDENT in a District SDC classroom if the District would agree to provide him with a one-on-one aide. District program specialist Linda Saranto agreed to do so, and STUDENT attended Eileen McGee’s preschool SDC classroom at Hacienda from March 2004 until the end of the 2003-2004 school year.
As a result of the circumstances surrounding STUDENT’s attendance at both ALLS and the District’s Hacienda classroom, his parents allege that the District committed procedural violations that denied him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
i. Appropriate Offer of Placement From September 2003 to March 2004
The Hearing Officer must determine whether the District made a legally sufficient placement offer for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year pursuant to Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. den., 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The Ninth Circuit in Union required that districts make a “formal written offer” of placement to the parents for four reasons: (1) to create a clear factual record for later review; (2) to assist the parents in presenting complaints about the placement; (3) to allow the parents to decide whether to accept or reject the placement; and (4) to allow the school district to present relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer regarding the appropriateness of the placement offered. The Ninth Circuit was unequivocal in stating that, “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.” Id. at 1526.
In this case, the various IEP documents indicate that the District did not make a specific offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year. A review of the IEPs of May 28 and June 4, 2003, indicates that the team agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement in his preschool class at Weingarten until his parents had the opportunity to observe other programs. After these observations, the team met again on June 12, 2003. However, because the parents did not believe that any of the placements were appropriate, the IEP team decided to “continue” STUDENT in his “NPS” for the 2003-2004 school year. The team did not specify the name of the NPS in which he would “continue.”
The IEP team met again on October 7, 2003, and the IEP indicates that the team discussed nine possible placements. The document states that the parents were not interested in four of the options, one was deemed not appropriate, and the team continued to consider four possible placements. Dr. Falk testified that she thought that three of the four would be appropriate for STUDENT. The IEP team agreed that the parents would visit the placements in which they were interested and stated, “Sites/Programs will be considered & the IEP team will reconvene.”
Dr. Falk testified that after she learned from STUDENT’s mother that he was attending Stepping Stones in October 2003, she did not continue looking for a placement. She testified that she also did not convene another IEP meeting at that time because MOTHER was not happy with any of the choices, STUDENT was attending school, and she wanted to be respectful of parents and not pressure them to accept a placement.
At the next IEP meeting on February 4, 2004, the team agreed that STUDENT “needs a small group setting in a language-based program to meet his academic and social skills needs.” However, the District again did not offer a placement. Instead, the document states, “The team has discussed STUDENT’s ability and potential program options for him. . . SJUSD is willing to work toward appropriate placement for this child. A possibility for STUDENT this fall is an SDC class with [a one-on-one aide] . . . The family will once more visit both preschool and kindergarten programs to consider options for the remainder of this school year, summer school, and this fall when he begins kindergarten.”
Although the District contends that it made a specific offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year, the evidence reveals that it did not do so but instead was exploring a number of possibilities. The IEPs indicate that the District did not make a specific offer because it was awaiting a decision by STUDENT’s parents regarding placement. However, although the District’s placement “offers” for the 2003-2004 were written, they reflect a placement selection process rather than a distinct, coherent offer by the District. With the range of placement offerings put forward, the District was proposing several, very different types of settings -- from a District SDC to a nonpublic school. It is unlikely that each of these diverse settings would have appropriately addressed STUDENT’s unique needs. In addition, this approach denied the parents important educational guidance from the District and meant that the District never proposed a specific, appropriate placement for STUDENT. While the District’s goal was to help the parents, the offering of a smorgasbord of placements required the parents to try to determine and select an appropriate placement without benefit of the District’s expertise. Unfortunately, although the District visited the placements with the parents, it never took the final step in the selection process of exercising its professional judgment by selecting and offering a specific educational placement that the District had determined was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. This approach is contrary to the spirit, if not the letter, of Union.
Moreover, the District described only one of the four placement options for the 2003-2004 school year at hearing, i.e., the SDC at Hacienda. When a district offers more than one placement, all placements must be appropriate. Union, supra,15 F.3d at 1526. Even if the District contends that each of these distinctly different settings would be appropriate for STUDENT, the testimony regarding only one placement suggested otherwise.
As discussed above, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in a denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483. In this case, the District’s complete failure to offer STUDENT an educational placement from September 2003 to March 2004 unquestionably resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to him. In addition, the District’s procedural violations seriously infringed on STUDENT’s parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. California Education Code section 56342.5 states that a district shall ensure that a parent “is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs.” By failing to provide the parents with information upon which to make a decision, the District prevented them providing any useful feedback to the IEP team.
Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing evidence and analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s approach in offering a wide range of diverse placements to the parents violated the spirit and intent of Union that a clear, coherent placement offer be made in accordance with the IDEA. Because no legally sufficient offer of placement was made for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT and that seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District failed to offer STUDENT an educational placement and thus denied him a FAPE on this basis from September 2003 to March 2004.
ii. Changing STUDENT’s Placement Without Prior Written Notice
A procedural safeguard to which a student is entitled is prior written notice to a parent whenever a school district proposes to change a student’s educational placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).
STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide prior written notice to his parents when STUDENT was removed from ALLS in September 2003. (Footnote 6) The District contends that it did not place STUDENT at ALLS and thus had no obligation to provide written notice prior to his removal from the program. Therefore, to determine if the District failed to provide prior written notice to STUDENT’s parents, the Hearing Officer must first decide whether the District placed STUDENT at ALLS.
A review of the evidence reveals that the IEP team met on June 12, 2003, and agreed that although STUDENT would attend Weingarten for the 2002-2003 ESY, he would “continue” in an “NPS” for the 2003-2004 school year without specifying the name of the NPS. Following this meeting, MOTHER and District program specialist Ms. Hamner visited ALLS twice during the summer. Thereafter, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him at ALLS in September 2003.
Although MOTHER testified that she believes that the District placed STUDENT at ALLS in September 2003, the evidence in the record does not support that belief. First, the IEP document dated June 12, 2003, does not mention ALLS. Instead, the document states only that STUDENT is to “continue” in an “NPS” for the 2003-2004 school year. Second, MOTHER acknowledged that the OT at Weingarten had recommended ALLS to her, and she did not state that anyone from the District recommended it. Finally, the District’s position is further supported by the lack of any additional documentary evidence indicating that the District agreed to place STUDENT at ALLS. Dr. Falk testified credibly that STUDENT’s file contains no administrative forms required by the District for changing a student’s placement.
In his closing brief, STUDENT relies upon a “management information system (‘MIS’) form completed by SJUSD’s personnel” that is attached to his copy of the IEP of June 12, 2003 (Petitioner’s exhibit F-66) to support his position. This form has a notation that reads that STUDENT’s placement is an “SDC at NPS (ALLS) 03 to 04.” However, there was no discussion of the form at the hearing, and no witness testified regarding the purpose of the form, when the form was completed, or by whom it was completed. Moreover, it was not identified by any witness or in any document as being part of the IEP or discussed at any IEP meeting. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s copy of the same form (District’s exhibit 15) states that STUDENT’s placement is an “SDC at NPS 03 to 04” and does not mention ALLS as his placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer accords little weight to a statement written on a form where two different copies of the same form are in evidence and for which neither party presented any evidence to explain the form or the inconsistencies between the two documents.
On the basis of the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not place STUDENT at ALLS in September 2003. Therefore, the District had no obligation to provide STUDENT’s parents with written notice prior to STUDENT’s removal from ALLS.
iii. Changing STUDENT’s Placement Without Convening an IEP Meeting
An additional procedural safeguard to which a student is entitled is the right not to participate in all or part of a special education program unless the parent consents in writing to a proposed IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).
STUDENT contends that the District committed a procedural violation by placing him in an SDC classroom at Hacienda from March 2004 until the end of the 2003-2004 school year without first obtaining his parents’ written consent at an IEP meeting. The District acknowledges that it did not convene an IEP meeting to place STUDENT at Hacienda but contends that this action did not constitute a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE.
The evidence reveals that the District convened an “addendum” IEP meeting on October 7, 2003, after MOTHER notified the District that she had removed STUDENT from ALLS and that he had impending implant surgery. At that meeting, the parties discussed a number of possible placements for STUDENT and agreed that “Sites/Programs will be considered & the IEP team will reconvene.”
MOTHER testified that after the IEP meeting on October 7, 2003, she and Dr. Falk observed several programs, including Ms. McGee’s preschool SDC class at Hacienda and the preschool program at Stepping Stones. She testified that she did not believe that the Hacienda classroom was appropriate for STUDENT and that she decided to enroll him at Stepping Stones after his surgery in October 2003.
The evidence further reveals that the District next convened an IEP meeting on February 4, 2004, to review STUDENT’s speech and language goals, to add goals and objectives related to his cochlear implant, and to further discuss placement for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. With regard to placement, the IEP states, “The family will once more visit both preschool and kindergarten programs to consider options for the remainder of this school year, summer school, and this fall when he begins kindergarten.”
MOTHER testified that after the meeting on February 4, 2004, she and District program specialist Linda Saranto observed the classroom at Hacienda. MOTHER then informed Ms. Saranto that she would agree to place STUDENT at Hacienda if the District would provide him with a one-on-one aide. Both testified that Ms. Saranto agreed to this arrangement and that MOTHER agreed to place STUDENT at Hacienda for the remainder of the school year despite her concerns about the large classroom. Ms. Saranto testified that she believed that the parents had consented to the placement at Hacienda because STUDENT’s mother picked the starting date, the District provided STUDENT with an aide as requested by his mother, and STUDENT remained in Ms. McGee’s classroom for the remaining two and one-half months of the school year without any complaints from his parents.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that although the District committed a procedural violation in failing to convene an IEP meeting and obtain the written consent of STUDENT’s parents prior to his placement at Hacienda, this violation did not seriously infringe on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d 1479 at 1483. As indicated above, his mother attended two IEP meetings during the 2003-2004 school year prior to agreeing to place STUDENT at Hacienda. During both of these meetings, the team discussed placement at Hacienda as a possibility, and she visited the proposed classroom following each meeting. Although she decided not to place STUDENT at Hacienda after the October meeting, she agreed in February that the placement would be appropriate if STUDENT had a one-on-one aide. Once the District agreed to provide an aide, she placed STUDENT at Hacienda for the remainder of the school year without complaint. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the parents had ample opportunity to participate in the IEP process and express their concerns regarding Hacienda. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s actions did not infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process and did not amount to a procedural violation that denied STUDENT a FAPE.
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer must also determine if the District’s failure to convene an IEP meeting prior to placing STUDENT at Hacienda resulted in loss of educational opportunity for him. A review of the IEP of February 4, 2004, reveals that the team agreed to one cognition goal for STUDENT that included six short-term objectives of short-term memory, sequencing, problem solving, inference, identifying missing parts in drawings, and sorting objects. Ms. McGee testified that during the time that STUDENT attended her preschool class from March to June 2004, she and STUDENT’s one-on-one aide worked on the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. McGee further testified that by the end of the school year, STUDENT had made progress on his goals and objectives and was beginning to respond in class academically. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s actions in failing to convene an IEP meeting prior to STUDENT’s placement at Hacienda also did not deny educational opportunity to STUDENT.
Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to convene an IEP meeting prior to placing STUDENT at Hacienda did not significantly impair his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process and did not result in loss of educational opportunity to him and thus did not amount to a procedural violation that denied him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer him an appropriate educational placement from September 2003 to March 2004. (Footnote 7)
c. Substantive Violations of FAPE i. A One-on-One Aide from September 2003 until March 2004
As part of a FAPE, a child with a disability is entitled to “related services,” including transportation and such developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist him or her to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
STUDENT contends that he required the related service of a one-on-one aide from September 2003 until March 2004 in order to benefit from his education. The District began providing STUDENT with a one-on-one aide in March 2004 but disputes that STUDENT required a one-on-one aide during this earlier time period.
A review of the evidence reveals that STUDENT exhibited a great deal of difficulty with behaviors in his placements at Weingarten and ALLS beginning at the end of the 2002-2002 school year. The May and June 2003 IEP team discussed STUDENT’s progress at Weingarten, including the fact that Weingarten had made accommodations for him that included one-on-one instruction from his teacher for 80 percent of his two-hour day. STUDENT’s May 2003 progress report from Weingarten stated that STUDENT responded well to this accommodation although he continued to have some behavioral difficulties. In addition, as discussed above, staff at Weingarten advised MOTHER during the summer of 2003 that Weingarten could not provide STUDENT with an appropriate program during that time because he needed a one-on-one aide to benefit from their program.
Ms. Colston-Joy also testified that STUDENT could not continue in the program at ALLS in September 2003 beyond eight or nine days without a one-on-one aide because of his disruptive behavior. She observed that he could not focus enough to learn, had difficulty sitting, had difficulty attending to the teacher, and screeched loudly in the classroom. Dr. Falk testified that she spoke to STUDENT’s teacher at ALLS who confirmed that ALLS could not handle STUDENT because of his disruptive behaviors. Ms. Colston-Joy further testified that when STUDENT returned to the program at ALLS in July 2004 with a one-on-one aide, he was able to attend to tasks with much less disruption.
Although the District contends that STUDENT did not require a one-on-one aide during this time period, it provided no evidence to support its contention. In fact, the evidence provided by the District was that District staff was aware from reports at IEP meetings and conversations with his teachers that STUDENT could not function appropriately in his private programs without one-on-one assistance.
On the basis of the overwhelming evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT had behavioral problems that interfered with his ability to benefit from his education and that improved with one-on-one assistance from September 2003 to March 2004. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him with a one-on-one aide during this time period.
ii. Audiology and Speech and Language Services from September 2003 to March 2004
STUDENT contends that the District did not provide him with monthly audiology services pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004. Similarly to previous years, at the IEP meetings in May and June 2003, the parties agreed to provide STUDENT with monthly audiology services at Weingarten. However, at the meeting on February 4, 2004, they decided that he no longer needed such services and instead added a hearing aid self-help goal to his IEP. Nonetheless, it is undisputed that the District did not provide audiology services to STUDENT from September 2003 until February 4, 2004 pursuant to his IEP. As discussed above, the District had an obligation to provide these services to STUDENT during this time period and denied him a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him with monthly audiology services from September 2003 to February 4, 2004.
STUDENT also contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language services five times per week from September 2003 until March 2004 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004 and instead provided him with only four weekly sessions. The District contends that STUDENT received all speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004 for the time period from September 2003 to March 2004.
A review of the evidence reveals that the IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004 all provide that STUDENT was to receive speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten for the 2003-2004 school year. In this regard, Ms. Divito testified that from September 2003 until November 2003, she provided STUDENT with speech and language services five times per week at Weingarten. No other witness disputed this testimony.
MOTHER and Ms. Divito both testified that after STUDENT began to attend Stepping Stones in October 2003, Ms. Divito provided him with only four days per week of speech and language services at Weingarten. Ms. Divito testified that on the fifth day she went to Stepping Stones to instruct Alison Barrett, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at Stepping Stones, in how to work with STUDENT in light of his implant. Ms. Divito further testified that she instructed Ms. Barrett by providing direct services to STUDENT, describing this instruction as a service that benefited him. Ms. Barrett described Ms. Divito’s assistance as teaching her how to do sound checks with STUDENT while at the same time teaching him how to discriminate sounds.
In addition, the evidence reveals that one of STUDENT’s speech and language goals and objectives at Weingarten was to improve his auditory comprehension. According to a progress report prepared by Ms. Divito in February 2004, she had been working with STUDENT on this goal since November 2003, and he was able to discriminate certain sounds with 90 percent accuracy and others with 100 percent accuracy by February 2004.
On the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with speech and language services five days per week from September to October 2003 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004. In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with five days per week of speech and language services from November 2003 until March 2004 pursuant to his IEPs. Although Ms. Divito provided only four days per week at Weingarten, she and Ms. Barrett testified that the one day per week that Ms. Divito spent at Stepping Stones was done with STUDENT present and that this arrangement benefited him and taught him to discriminate sounds, an area of need according to his auditory comprehension goals and objectives. Moreover, STUDENT made progress in this area during this time. The Hearing Officer notes that the IEPs do not state that STUDENT is to receive direct speech and language services and thus concurs that the services provided were sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the IEPs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes the District did not fail to provide STUDENT with speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003, October 2003, and February 2004.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him with monthly audiology services from September 2003 to February 4, 2004 pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003 and October 2003.
The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District denied STUDENT a substantive FAPE from September 2003 to March 2004 by failing to provide him with a one-on-one aide. In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a substantive FAPE from September 2003 to February 4, 2004, by failing to provide him with monthly audiology services pursuant to his IEPs of May and June 2003 and October 2003.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability during the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District denied STUDENT a procedural FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year to the extent that it failed to offer him an educational placement from September 2003 to March 2004. Finally, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a substantive FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year to the extent that it failed to provide him with a one-on-one aide and monthly audiology services from September 2003 to February 4, 2004.
ISSUE NO. 5: During the 2003-2004 ESY, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with:
a. audiology services pursuant to his IEP dated May 27 and June 10, 2004, and b. an appropriate preschool placement?
a. Audiology Services
As discussed above, the parties agreed that STUDENT no longer required audiology services after February 2004 and required only a goal and objective in the area of hearing aid self-help. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with audiology services during the 2003-2004 ESY.
b. Appropriate Preschool Placement
Although STUDENT contends that the District did not provide him with an appropriate placement during the 2003-2004 ESY, it is undisputed that he filed his request for due process hearing and a motion for a stay put order prior to the commencement of ESY. It is further undisputed that the Hearing Office found that his stay put placement was at Hacienda. Therefore, the District was legally prohibited from changing STUDENT’s placement pending the outcome of due process proceedings. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). (Footnote 8)
ISSUE NO. 6: Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year?
California law defines an educational placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs.” Cal. Code of Regs., Title 5, § 3042. In addition, as discussed above, the District must make a formal written offer of placement pursuant to Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Hearing Officer must thus determine if the District offered STUDENT an appropriate educational placement for the 2004-2005 school year pursuant to section 3042 and Union.
A review of the IEP of May 27 and June 10, 2004, reveals that for the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered STUDENT “a small group, self-contained classroom with a maximum of [12] students, taught by a Special Education Credentialed teacher, working with a fully qualified instructional associate.” (Footnote 9) Kay McDonald, the District program specialist who attended the IEP meetings in May and June 2004, testified that the District offered STUDENT a classroom with a maximum of twelve students, a credentialed teacher, and a qualified aide. However, she also testified that the District did not propose a specific placement for STUDENT but was considering Hacienda and “several other schools.” District program specialist Ms. Saranto testified that the reason for placing STUDENT in a classroom with a maximum of twelve students was that this is the maximum that teachers are allowed to teach in a kindergarten SDC classroom pursuant to the collective bargaining agreement between the District and the teachers’ union. (Footnote 10)
A further review of the evidence reveals that on July 26, 2004, District director of special education Flora Englund sent the parents a letter stating that STUDENT was assigned to a kindergarten SDC classroom taught by Joanna Latz at the District’s Willow Glen Elementary School. Ms. Englund testified that this classroom would have twelve or thirteen students with one or two aides. Ms. Saranto testified that Ms. Latz has a special education credential, but she does not know the specific type of credential.
In this case, although Ms. McDonald testified that the District in June 2004 offered STUDENT a “very rich and comprehensive” program, there is no evidence that anyone from the District furnished the parents with any information regarding the location of the classroom, the type of teacher, the other students in the classroom, or the type of program that a kindergarten SDC would provide to STUDENT. As the District had done the previous year, it continued to allow STUDENT’s parents to observe and discard as many programs as they wanted without ever offering them its expertise as to what was appropriate for STUDENT. The District provided the parents with no information upon which to make an informed judgment, including such basic information as the location of the school. Ms. McDonald testified that the District was considering Hacienda, whereas the letter from Ms. Englund placed STUDENT at Willow Glen. No one testified that anyone from the District had ever provided the parents with any information about Willow Glen other than a brochure describing the regular kindergarten program mailed to the parents with Ms. Englund’s letter. At the hearing, the District presented no evidence regarding the program at Willow Glen and how it would meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In fact, the only evidence regarding the proposed classroom related to the maximum number of students allowed under a collective bargaining agreement. This evidence did not explain how the size of the class would meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s “offer” of a kindergarten SDC classroom for the 2004-2005 school year did not amount to an offer of placement pursuant to the requirements of California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3042 and Union. The general type of classroom, maximum number of students, approximate number of classroom aides, and general type of teacher credential without more information pertaining to the offer does not constitute “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services” and does not provide the parents with sufficient information to decide upon a proposed placement.
As discussed previously, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in a denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483. In this case, the District’s complete failure to make any offer of placement unquestionably resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. The District’s abdication of its responsibility to employ its expertise in the placement process, and its resultant abandonment of STUDENT’s parents to speculate on their own regarding an appropriate placement, denied STUDENT his right to an appropriate offer of placement.
In addition, the District’s procedural violations seriously infringed on STUDENT’s parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Instead of providing the parents with the appropriate information, the IEP team merely dispatched them to determine whether or not a particular school was appropriate for STUDENT. Although District personnel accompanied MOTHER on visits to school programs, these personnel did not provide her with appropriate input but allowed her to determine on her own whether the placement was appropriate. This lack of information resulted in her inability to participate in any meaningful way in the decision-making process regarding placement.
Therefore, on the basis of the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to make an offer of placement to STUDENT resulted in a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE pursuant to Rowley. As a result of the District’s failure to make an offer of placement, STUDENT suffered a loss of educational opportunity. In addition, the District’s failure seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Moreover, the lack of an offer failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit, thus denying him a FAPE. In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to make an appropriate offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 11)
ISSUE NO. 7: In order to receive a FAPE, does STUDENT require a District-funded placement at Associated Learning and Language Specialists for the 2004-2005 school year?
All children, including deaf and hard-of-hearing children, are entitled to programs in which they have direct and appropriate access to all components of the educational process, including teachers with appropriate teaching credentials. Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.5(b)(7); Cal. Educ. Code § 44326(c). Although the Hearing Officer concluded that the District has not offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year, the parents’ requested placement at ALLS is also not appropriate because the Hearing Officer cannot order kindergarten placement in a program that does not provide an educational placement. Ms. Colston-Joy, executive director of ALLS, testified that ALLS is not an educational placement but is a language-based, NPA that provides speech and language, OT, and physical therapy services to infants and toddlers, preschool children, and kindergarten children. She further testified that staff members who work with children in the program do not have teaching credentials but have speech pathology and clinical rehabilitation credentials. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that ALLS does not provide a comprehensive academic program for kindergarten children with credentialed teachers as required by State law. As a kindergarten student, STUDENT is entitled to a school placement where he can receive appropriate education services and not merely related services.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that ALLS is not an appropriate prospective placement for STUDENT. The parents’ request for prospective placement at ALLS for STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year is thus denied.
ISSUE NO. 8: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following privately obtained assessments:
a. Children’s Health Council assessment, b. Don Mordasini assessment, and c. California Ear Institute assessments?
a. Children’s Health Council
When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
MOTHER testified that she contacted Children’s Health Council (CHC) after staff at Weingarten recommended an assessment of STUDENT to rule out a diagnosis of autism in the fall of 2002. As discussed above, CHC conducted its assessment in March 2003 and diagnosed STUDENT with autism. The District thereafter conducted its own assessment of STUDENT and relied upon the CHC assessment to determine that STUDENT had autism.
Therefore, the assessment by CHC was not a result of the parents’ disagreement with the District’s assessment. In fact, MOTHER testified that she took STUDENT to CHC for an assessment to rule out a diagnosis of autism at the suggestion of staff at Weingarten. She did not testify that she took STUDENT to CHC because of any disagreement with a District assessment. Moreover, she could not have disagreed with the District’s assessment at the time of the CHC assessment because the District had not yet assessed STUDENT for autism. Furthermore, as the Hearing Officer concluded above, the District did not have an obligation to assess STUDENT in the area of autism. Consequently, reimbursement for STUDENT’s independent assessment by CHC is denied.
b. Don Mordasini, Marriage and Family Therapist
MOTHER testified that she took STUDENT to Don Mordasini, a licensed marriage and family therapist, in September 2003 for an additional assessment regarding STUDENT’s possible autism. However, MOTHER submitted no other evidence regarding this assessment. Moreover, she did not testify that she consulted Mr. Mordasini because she disagreed with any District assessment. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for Mr. Mordasini’s assessment.
c. California Ear Institute
As discussed above, a parent may be entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment when the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for audiograms performed at California Ear Institute (CEI) in December 2002, July 2003, and April 2004 to assess STUDENT’s hearing. However, MOTHER did not testify that she obtained these assessments because of her disagreement with the District’s hearing assessments. In fact, the District did not conduct any hearing assessments during that time with which the parents could disagree. MOTHER testified that she obtained the first audiogram in December 2002 because STUDENT’s doctors needed a baseline determination of his fluctuating hearing. She testified that she obtained the second one in July 2003 because his doctors were considering a cochlear implant and needed to determine if his hearing had stabilized sufficiently for the surgery. Finally, the April 2004 audiogram indicates that it is a “three-month follow-up” but that testing could not be done due to STUDENT’s noncompliance. Therefore, as STUDENT’s parents did not obtain these hearing assessments due to a disagreement with any District assessments, they are not entitled to reimbursement for any private hearing assessments conducted by CEI.
ISSUE NO. 9: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following privately obtained services:
a. California Ear Institute for audiology services, b. Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology for speech and language services, c. Stepping Stones Center for Autism Spectrum Disorders for tuition and a preadmission assessment, d. Associated Learning and Language Specialists for tuition, e. GRANDMOTHER for private tutoring, f. Family and Children’s Service for counseling, g. Gregory Thomson, Ph.D. for counseling, and h. Transportation for each of the services provided?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994). However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 79 F.2d 1153, 1161(5th Cir. l986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provided the student with educational benefit. Id. (Footnote12)
a. California Ear Institute
STUDENT’s parents also submitted invoices and receipts for various payments made to CEI between November 2003 and August 2004 and testified that CEI provided audiology services to STUDENT during this time period. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District failed to provide STUDENT with audiology services pursuant to his IEPs during the 2002-2003 school year, the 2002-2003 ESY, and from September 2003 until February 2004. However, MOTHER did not specify what services CEI provided or how often these services were provided. Moreover, she presented no reports or other documents from CEI regarding services provided, and no witness from that organization testified about the services provided. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for audiology services provided by CEI.
b. Bird & Kern
STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for privately obtained speech and language services provided by Ms. Abrahamson at Bird & Kern from October 2001 through the present. However, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District did not fail to provide STUDENT with any speech and language services pursuant to his IEPs from the 2001-2002 ESY through the present. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for privately-obtained speech and language services from Bird & Kern.
c. Stepping Stones
As discussed above, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra.
However, reimbursement for private school placement may be reduced or denied if “at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not inform the IEP team that they were rejecting the placement proposed by the public agency to provide FAPE to their child, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(d)(i). In addition, reimbursement may be denied if at least ten (10) business days prior to the removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not give written notice to the public agency of their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense because of their rejection of the public agency’s proposed offer of FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(d)(ii).
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District failed to offer STUDENT a placement and a one-on-one aide from September 2003 until March 2004 and thus denied him a FAPE. His parents seek reimbursement for his attendance at Stepping Stones from October 2003 until March 2004 for these denials.
The District contends that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement in this case because of their failure to provide notice to the District of their intent to place STUDENT at Stepping Stones. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents did inform the District of their intent to place STUDENT at Stepping Stones. Although MOTHER did not put her notice to the District in writing, she had informed the District at several IEP meetings and in conversations with program specialists that she was rejecting the District’s proposed placements for STUDENT that had been offered to date. As a result, the District was well aware that STUDENT’s parents were not pleased with any of the placements offered by the District. The District, however, did not convene another IEP meeting to propose any other placements prior to STUDENT’s enrollment at Stepping Stones. Therefore, in light of the circumstances surrounding the facts in this case, the Hearing Officer concludes that a denial of reimbursement is not warranted. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for his attendance at Stepping Stones if this attendance met appropriate legal standards.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer must review the evidence to determine STUDENT’s unique needs during the time that he attended Stepping Stones and whether the education provided to him met those needs and provided him with educational benefit. As discussed above, STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of fine motor skills, preacademics, oral motor, expressive and receptive language, and disruptive behaviors during the 2003-2004 school year.
Alison Barrett, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at Stepping Stones, testified that STUDENT attended a preschool center-based speech and language program with a high emphasis on speech and language, behavioral, and cognitive skills at Stepping Stones. She further testified that STUDENT was in a class with three or four students and three adults or a one-to-one ratio. In her opinion, STUDENT made progress on his Stepping Stones speech and language goals and his auditory comprehension in the program. She also testified that STUDENT improved in his behaviors and his ability to follow directions. According to Ms. Barrett, by the time that he left the program, STUDENT needed less one-on-one attention, could be redirected, and reduced his inappropriate touching. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT made a great deal of progress at Stepping Stones and that his disruptive behaviors had subsided. According to his mother, he also improved in his fine motor and writing skills, language skills, and the ability to attend. On the basis of the evidence regarding his progress at Stepping Stones, the Hearing Officer concludes that Stepping Stones addressed many of STUDENT’s unique needs, particularly in the areas of behaviors, fine motor, and auditory comprehension, and that STUDENT made educational progress in these areas during the time that he attended Stepping Stones. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement at Stepping Stones was appropriate under the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer thus determines that STUDENT’s parents met the legal requirements necessary to receive reimbursement for his attendance at Stepping Stones from October 2003 to March 2004. This placement met his unique needs and provided him with educational benefit. Therefore, the District shall reimburse the PARENTs for their educational expenses at Stepping Stones from October 2003 to March 2004. The PARENTs have submitted invoices that indicate that they spent a total of $8,400 for tuition and a total of $807.50 for a required preadmission assessment for a total of $9,207.50. (Footnote 13) Therefore, the District shall reimburse the PARENTs in the amount of $9,207.50.
d. Associated Learning and Language Specialists
STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for his tuition for attending a program at ALLS during the 2003-2004 ESY and for attending kindergarten at ALLS at the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. However, in light of the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that the District was required to maintain STUDENT’s placement at Hacienda pending the outcome of due process proceedings pursuant to a stay put order of the Hearing Office, his parents are not entitled to reimbursement for his attendance at ALLS during the 2003-2004 ESY and the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year.
e. GRANDMOTHER
STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for tutoring services and educational expenses provided by GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother, in September and October 2003. GRANDMOTHER testified that she provided tutoring services to STUDENT after he left ALLS in September 2003 and prior to his attendance at Stepping Stones in October 2003. However, both MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER testified that the parents did not enter into an agreement with GRANDMOTHER to pay for her services or to reimburse her for educational expenses. Moreover, GRANDMOTHER testified that she did not create an invoice with the hours spent teaching STUDENT until one year after she actually performed the services and did not keep receipts of her expenses because she did not intend to charge the parents for her time or expenses. She testified that she instead decided to tutor STUDENT as a “family value.” The Hearing Officer thus concludes that STUDENT’s parents did not incur any expenses related to his grandmother’s decision to tutor him and are thus not entitled to the payment requested.
f. Family and Children’s Service
STUDENT’s parents submitted invoices for reimbursement for individual and family therapy obtained from Family and Children’s Services from October 2003 until May 2004. MOTHER testified that STUDENT met with a therapist from this agency weekly to discuss behavioral issues. However, the parents presented no other evidence regarding this service and the manner in which it provided a replacement service to STUDENT that the District was obligated to provide. STUDENT presented no persuasive evidence that the District agreed to or should have provided him with individual behavioral therapy services. Therefore, as these services were not a replacement for any services that the District should have provided but failed to provide, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for these privately obtained services.
g. Gregory Thomson, Ph.D.
STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for counseling sessions with Dr. Gregory Thomson, a licensed clinical psychologist who has been treating STUDENT since April 2004 for behavioral problems. Dr. Thomson testified that he teaches STUDENT and his parents strategies for dealing with STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors. However, STUDENT’s parents have not provided any evidence that indicates that Dr. Thomson’s therapy was a replacement for a service that the District was obligated to provide. No IEP or assessment of STUDENT recommends that he receive individual therapy to deal with his behaviors at school. Therefore, since Dr. Thomson’s therapy sessions are not a replacement for any service that the District should have provided but failed to provide, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for these privately obtained services.
h. Transportation
Transportation is a related service that must be provided if necessary for a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). The PARENTs request reimbursement for their cost of transporting STUDENT to the above-listed service providers. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer concluded that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s attendance at Stepping Stones. Moreover, the evidence reveals that STUDENT requires transportation as a related service pursuant to his IEPs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the PARENTs are entitled to reimbursement for transporting STUDENT round-trip from his home to Stepping Stones from October 2003 to March 2004. Therefore, upon receipt of proof of the number of miles from STUDENT’s home to Stepping Stones and the number of days of attendance at the program, the District shall reimburse the PARENTs at the standard rate that the District reimburses its employees for mileage.
ORDER
1. Within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall assess STUDENT in the area of hearing pursuant to the assessment plan signed by STUDENT’s parents on July 19, 2004.
2. Within ten (10) calendar days of the date of the hearing assessment, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to offer STUDENT a specific kindergarten classroom placement for the 2004- 2005 school year. The District shall provide all of the related services and goals and objectives included in the IEP of May 27 and June 10, 2004. The District shall ensure the attendance at the IEP meeting of STUDENT’s proposed teacher or other District person familiar with the specific classroom, STUDENT’s service providers, the hearing assessor, and a school psychologist, in addition to other required participants.
3. Within twenty (20) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents in the amount of $9,207.50 for his tuition and preadmission assessment at Stepping Stones.
4. Within twenty (20) calendar days of receipt of proof of the number of round-trip miles from STUDENT’s home to Stepping Stones and the number of days of attendance at Stepping Stones between October 2003 and March 2004, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for their transportation from their home to Stepping Stones at the standard rate that the District reimburses its employees for mileage.
5. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-
2002 ESY?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer concluded that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to provide him with monthly audiology service pursuant to his IEP. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.
3. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY? Petitioner prevailed on the issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer concluded that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to provide him with a preschool placement and audiology services pursuant to his IEP. The District prevailed on the remaining issue.
4. Did the District deny STUDENT an assessment and FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer concluded that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability, failed to offer him an educational placement from September 2003 until March 2004, and failed to provide him with a one-on-one aide from September 2003 until March. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.
5. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 ESY? The District prevailed on this issue.
6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
7. In order to receive a FAPE, does STUDENT require a District-funded placement at ALLS? The District prevailed on this issue.
8. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for private assessments? The District prevailed on this issue.
9. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained services? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer awarded reimbursement for Stepping Stones and round-trip transportation to Stepping Stones. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 15, 2004 ___________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
The issues listed here differ slightly in wording and organization from the issues as stated by Petitioner in a prehearing telephone conference held on September 10, 2004. These changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis, but include no substantive changes. In addition, during the course of the hearing, Petitioner withdrew issues pertaining to a preschool placement for the 2001-2002 ESY and occupational therapy for the 2001-2002 ESY, the 2002-2003 school year, and the 2002-2003 ESY. Finally, on the last day of hearing, the parties notified the Hearing Officer that they had resolved an issue regarding reimbursement for transportation to and from the parents’ home and the Jean Weingarten Peninsula Oral School for the Deaf for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years.
2 The California Ear Institute has recently changed its name to the Let Them Hear Foundation. However, for the sake of consistency, this Decision will continue to refer to this agency as the California Ear Institute.
3 In his closing brief, STUDENT raises an additional speech and language issue. He contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language services for apraxia following a diagnosis of apraxia by Sylvia Abrahamson, a private speech and language from Bird & Kern Speech and Language Pathology, who has provided services to STUDENT at his parents’ expense since October 2001. However, Ms. Abrahamson testified that she did not confirm the diagnosis of apraxia until after STUDENT received his cochlear implant in October 2003. Therefore, any issue of services for apraxia did not arise prior to October 2003, and STUDENT did not request these services after that date.
4It is undisputed that STUDENT’s parents do not currently believe that STUDENT has autism. In fact, in her assessment, Ms. Pruss noted that the only person to rate STUDENT as not having autistic behaviors was STUDENT’s mother. Moreover, the District is required to meet STUDENT’s needs without regard to a specific diagnosis.
5 No witness testified regarding the nature of the audiology services that the IEP team agreed to provide.
6 MOTHER contends that Dr. Falk instructed her to remove STUDENT from ALLS after eight or nine days. The District, in contrast, contends that MOTHER removed him upon advice from ALLS staff because his behaviors were too disruptive to continue in the program.
7 STUDENT also contends that the District denied him a procedural FAPE by failing to provide information to his parents regarding Ms. McGee’s credentials. However, he relies upon one letter from his parents and two letters from his advocate to District personnel after the filing of his request for due process hearing in which they request this information. He provided no evidence to indicate that his parents requested this information during the 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, as there is no evidence to support his contention, this Decision does not address that alleged denial of FAPE.
8STUDENT also contends that the District failed to provide him with an appropriate toileting plan and properly utilized assistive technology during the 2003-2004 ESY. However, the only testimony regarding a toileting plan came from Ms. Colston-Joy who did not testify that the IEP toileting goal and objective was not appropriate for STUDENT. With regard to assistive technology, Ms. Berger testified that STUDENT’ FM system was utilized appropriately in Ms. McGee’s classroom and that a dynavox voice-activated communication device requested by his parents was not appropriate for him.
9 STUDENT has also requested related services for the 2004-2005 school year. With regard to the requested speech and language services, the evidence reveals that on July 14, 2004, the District and STUDENT’ parents agreed to speech and language sessions of five times per week at Weingarten for the 2004-2005 school year. With regard to the remaining related services requested, all requested services with the exception of audiology are included in the IEP of June 10, 2004, as the District offered a one-on-one aide, twice weekly OT services, assistive technology in the form of an FM system, and curb to curb daily transportation. With regard to monthly audiology services, STUDENT presented no evidence that he has required these services after February 2004, when the IEP team decided to provide him with a hearing aid self-help goal and objective rather than monthly audiology services.
10Ms. Saranto testified that she incorrectly typed thirteen students in this sentence instead of the correct number of twelve students.
11 STUDENT has also asserted two additional issues for the 2004-2005 school year of failing to use a qualified assessor in a May 2004 psychoeducational assessment and failing to invite this assessor to the June 2004 IEP meeting. However, in light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District failed to offer a FAPE at this IEP meeting, there is no need to reach these issues.
12 Parents may also be entitled to a remedy of compensatory education pursuant to Burlington. Although Petitioner did not request compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with a preschool placement during the 2002-2003 ESY, Ms. Berger testified regarding possible compensatory education. However, although she testified that children who do not attend school during ESY normally suffer regression, she could not state if STUDENT had suffered any regression or other harm as a result of not having attended preschool during ESY. STUDENT presented no other evidence regarding any harm suffered for the District’s failure to provide him with a preschool placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not award him any compensatory education for this denial of FAPE.
13 MOTHER and Ms. Barrett testified that Stepping Stones would not accept STUDENT without a preadmission assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer awards reimbursement for this assessment.
