California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 24, 2000
Student v. Monrovia Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1471-99 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Hearing Officer finds Monrovia Unified third-grader with ADHD ineligible for special education; district's assessment held complete.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A third-grader's grandmother, who is his legal guardian, requested a hearing after Monrovia Unified's IEP team found him ineligible for special education for the third time. The 10-year-old had an ADHD diagnosis and had been found eligible under Section 504 in 1994. The grandmother argued that he qualified as seriously emotionally disturbed. The Hearing Officer also considered specific learning disability and other health impairment.
Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown found that he did not qualify under any category. His teachers described a capable student who ranked in the upper part of his class and got along with peers and adults. A May 1999 outburst led to a period of home study, but the school psychologist persuasively described it as an isolated incident. Behaviors the grandmother saw at home did not appear at school to a marked degree or harm his education. A psychiatric evaluation done for a Social Security review got less weight because the examiner never observed him at school or spoke with his teachers. Test scores showed no severe gap between ability and achievement, and his many past absences would have undercut any gap. Teachers reported no significant attention problems.
The Hearing Officer also held that the January 1999 assessment covered all suspected areas. The agreed plan listed only academics and social/behavior, and earlier cognitive testing was available. Because he was ineligible, she did not decide the requests for a one-to-one aide, staff training, a calm-down space, or home study. No relief was ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed behavior at home against functioning at school when deciding emotional disturbance eligibility under the "marked degree" standard. It gave little weight to outside evaluators who never saw the child at school. It also discussed how the Larry P. limits on IQ testing might apply to a mixed-race student.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services?
Student did not meet serious emotional disturbance, specific learning disability, or other health impairment criteria; behaviors seen at home were not shown at school to a marked degree, and there was no severe discrepancy or attention problem adversely affecting education.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the District conduct a complete assessment of all identified areas of suspected disability?
The January 1999 assessment of academics and social/behavior, together with three prior cognitive assessments, covered all areas of suspected disability identified in the assessment plan.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3a. If STUDENT is eligible, must the District provide a one-to-one certified educational assistant to provide a FAPE?
Not reached because Student was found ineligible for special education.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3b. If STUDENT is eligible, must the District provide notification of emergency situations regarding STUDENT's safety and well-being?
Not reached because Student was found ineligible for special education.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3c. If STUDENT is eligible, must the District provide professional training by a qualified ADD/ADHD instructor for all staff with direct contact with STUDENT?
Not reached because Student was found ineligible for special education.
- Not reachedIEP content
Issue 3d. If STUDENT is eligible, must the District provide a quiet location, monitored by a trained staff member, where STUDENT can go to calm down?
Not reached because Student was found ineligible for special education.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3e. If STUDENT is eligible, must the District provide a home study teacher if STUDENT needs home study due to serious illness or behavior problems at school?
Not reached because Student was found ineligible for special education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Student found not eligible for special education at this time; all of Petitioner's claims for relief denied.
Key authorities
Larry P. v. Riles; Crawford v. Honig; Education Code § 56337; Education Code § 56339; Title 5 CCR § 3030; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7
People named in the decision
- Yolanda Lopez-Head, District director of pupil services, Monrovia Unified School District
- Marguerite Lambrinos, first-grade teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Stacy Moulton, second-grade teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Christine J. Meadows, third-grade teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Ann Marie Trimarchi, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Dianne Lahti, elementary school principal, Monrovia Unified School District (Wild Rose Elementary)
- Eilleen Logan, school psychologist, Monrovia Unified School District
- S & L Medical Group, private provider (psychiatric and pediatric evaluations for Social Security review)
- Pacific Clinic East Outpatient, private provider (outpatient clinic)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1471-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: MONROVIA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Eligibility CDS Code: 19-64790 District: Monrovia Unified Disability Type:
Case Details This matter was heard before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Monrovia, California, on November 16 and 17, 1999.
Petitioner/Respondent STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Respondent/Petitioner Monrovia Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Nancy Finch-Heuerman. Also present on the District's behalf was Yolanda Lopez-Head, District director of pupil services.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: GREAT-AUNT, STUDENT's great- aunt, and , GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT's grandmother. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Marguerite Lambrinos, District first-grade teacher; Stacy Moulton, District second-grade teacher; Christine J. Meadows, District third-grade teacher; Ann Marie Trimarchi, District resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; Dianne Lahti, District elementary school principal; and Eilleen Logan, District school psychologist
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for STUDENT's submission of medical reports, and subsequently for both parties' submission of written closing briefs. (Footnote 1) Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs on January 31, 2000, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
(1) Is STUDENT eligible for special education services?
(2) Did the District conduct a complete assessment of all identified areas of suspected disability?
(3) If STUDENT is eligible for special education services, must the District provide the following in order to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
(a) a one-to-one certified educational assistant.
(b) notification of emergency situations regarding STUDENT's safety and well-being.
(c) professional training by a qualified instructor trained in attention deficit disorder/attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADD/ADHD) for all staff who have direct contact with STUDENT.
(d) a quiet location, monitored by a trained staff member, where STUDENT can go to calm down.
(e) a home study teacher, if STUDENT needs home study due to serious illness or behavior problems at school.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the hearing on November 16, 1999, Petitioner indicated that a psychiatrist and a pediatrician has examined him as part of the Social Security Administration's (SSA's) review of Petitioner's eligibility for Supplemental Security Income (SSI). However, Petitioner did not possess copies of those medical reports and, thus, had not submitted those reports as evidentiary exhibits. Because of the potential significance of those medical reports, and because Petitioner was not represented by an attorney or advocate familiar with the due process system, the Hearing Officer ruled that Petitioner could submit those medical reports after the hearing, by December 15, 1999. The Hearing Officer further ruled that the District would be allowed an opportunity to submit documentary evidence in response to the medical reports. The District could also request an additional hearing date for submission of testimony in response to the medical reports. The Hearing Officer held that, if Petitioner submitted the medical reports but the District did not request an additional hearing date in response to the reports, the parties' closing briefs would be due by postmark no later than January 28, 2000.
On December 10, 1999, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner the psychiatric and pediatric evaluations. (Footnote 3) In a letter dated January 4, 2000, the District indicated that it did not intend to submit any additional evidence in response to those evaluations. Thus, pursuant to the Hearing Officer's order at hearing, the parties written closing arguments were due by postmark no later than January 28, 2000. In accordance with this ruling, both parties' briefs were postmarked on time and were received by the Hearing Office on January 31, 2000.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old student who resides within the boundaries of the District and attends third grade at the District's Wild Rose Elementary School. STUDENT's mother reportedly used drugs during pregnancy and abandoned STUDENT when he was one week old. Since the age of one month, STUDENT has lived with his paternal grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, and GRANDMOTHER's son, who is STUDENT's paternal uncle. GRANDMOTHER is STUDENT's legal guardian and is in the process of legally adopting him. Since age three, STUDENT has received SSI disability benefits, based on diagnoses of disabilities covered under the Social Security Act. (Petitioner's Exhs. pgs. 2, 22, 100; testimony of GRANDMOTHER.)
By age three, STUDENT was attending preschool at the District's Child Development Center (CDC). In September 1994, when STUDENT was four years old, GRANDMOTHER requested that the District assess STUDENT for special education. District personnel assessed STUDENT and concluded that he did not qualify as an individual with exceptional needs pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), but did qualify as handicapped according to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, because of attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). (District's Exh. 17.) After the assessment, an individualized education program (IEP) team convened to discuss the assessment results. Based on the assessors' finding that STUDENT was not eligible, the IEP team did not qualify STUDENT for special education and did not offer him special education services. (District's Exh. 21.)
STUDENT exhibited some behavioral difficulties in preschool, resulting in establishment of a discipline plan to manage his behaviors. (District's Exh. 23.) In May 1995, the CDC notified GRANDMOTHER that it planned to expel STUDENT because he had "frequently injured other children and staff," and on one occasion GRANDMOTHER could not be located to pick STUDENT up from school pursuant to the terms of the discipline plan. (Petitioner's Exh. pg. 18.) However, upon appeal from GRANDMOTHER, the CDC agreed to rescind the expulsion, and STUDENT continued to attend preschool. (Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 19, 20.)
In July 1995, STUDENT's father was murdered. In September 1995, when he was five years and eight months old, STUDENT began kindergarten at the District's Wild Rose Elementary School (Wild Rose). (Footnote 4) STUDENT was emotionally upset and often absent from school during his kindergarten year. (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER.) His grandmother reported that she inquired about alternative options for STUDENT that year, but home study was not offered.
Based on some behavioral difficulties STUDENT manifested in kindergarten, his kindergarten teacher recommended that STUDENT attend "developmental" first-grade for one year. Developmental first grade (also known as "D-1") is a regular education class, but is more activity-based than traditional first grade, and utilizes a language-based curriculum emphasizing skills such as vocabulary and oral reading. Kindergarten teachers make the recommendations regarding which students should attend D-1, and each student's parents may then accept or reject the recommendation. GRANDMOTHER agreed to STUDENT's kindergarten teacher's recommendation, and he attended D-1 for the 1996-97 school year, prior to entering regular first grade in fall 1997.
At the beginning of STUDENT's regular first grade year, his grandmother again requested that he be assessed for disabilities pursuant to the IDEA. A District school psychologist assessed STUDENT in November 1997, and again concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. The IEP team concurred and did not qualify STUDENT as eligible.
For the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT remained in his regular education first grade class, taught by Marguerite Lambrinos. In November 1997, STUDENT was suspended from school for one day for hitting another student and threatening to hit an employee. (District's Exh. 34.) However, Ms. Lambrinos reported that STUDENT otherwise got along well with others. (Testimony of Ms. Lambrinos; District's Exh. 40.) STUDENT's report card described how he had made academic progress in reading, writing and math during first grade, but also noted that he had been absent or tardy frequently throughout the year. (District's Exh. 40; see also District's Exh. 39.)
During the summer of 1998, STUDENT attended a District summer school program. In October 1998, GRANDMOTHER submitted a written request for an assessment of STUDENT. Prior to the assessment, GRANDMOTHER met with District staff in December 1998 to discuss her concerns about STUDENT's areas of difficulty. (District's Exh. 48.) The District school psychologist at the meeting, Dr. Eilleen Logan, testified that the only areas of concern raised at the meeting were academic achievement and social/behavioral issues. At the meeting, GRANDMOTHER signed an assessment plan. That plan indicated that the assessment would be in the areas of academic achievement and social behavior, although GRANDMOTHER wrote at the bottom of the page that she requested that an "entire assessment be completed." (District's Exh. 47.)
In conducting the assessment in January 1999, Dr. Logan utilized methods including standardized tests and direct observation to assess STUDENT's academic functioning and social/emotional functioning. Dr. Logan reviewed three previous District assessments of STUDENT's cognitive/psychological functioning, conducted in 1993, 1995 and 1997, but did not administer any new tests of STUDENT in this area. Additionally, District resource specialist Ann Marie Trimarchi utilized the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills to assess STUDENT in academic skill areas such as reading, mathematics and handwriting/motor skills.
The IEP team met on February 2, 1999, to discuss the results of the January 1999 assessment. Based on the assessment results and recommendations of the assessors, the IEP team did not find STUDENT eligible for special education. STUDENT's grandmother disagreed with the IEP team's conclusion. (District's Exh. 54.)
For the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT attended a second grade class taught by Stacy Moulton. Ms. Moulton reported that STUDENT's academic skills were in the top 25% of the class. STUDENT could follow directions and pay attention, although he would become inattentive when frustrated. STUDENT sometimes had anger outbursts and would occasionally use "baby talk," but otherwise did not exhibit significant behavioral problems. Ms. Moulton reported some concern that STUDENT was frequently absent or tardy. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton; District's Exhs. 46, 58.)
On a Friday in May 1999, STUDENT had a behavioral incident at school. STUDENT had become upset during recess; Ms. Moulton stopped to talk to him about the problem, but he did not calm down. Thereafter, the school principal, Dianne Lahti, arrived to talk to STUDENT, but he remained upset and told her, "I hate this fucking school." (District's Exh. 59.) STUDENT said that he did not have to listen to Ms. Lahti and did not have to stay at school. He then left the school and walked two blocks down the street. Ms. Lahti followed him and talked with him for a few minutes until GRANDMOTHER arrived to take him home. During their conversation, STUDENT told Ms. Lahti that no one at the school liked him and that all of the adults at the school hated kids and only wanted to get them in trouble. (District's Exh. 59; testimony of Ms. Lahti.)
GRANDMOTHER took STUDENT home that afternoon. The following Monday, STUDENT returned to school and met with Ms. Lahti. STUDENT then returned to class, but was acting angry and left class without permission. Ms. Lahti attempted to talk to STUDENT again, but he remained upset. The school again called GRANDMOTHER to pick up STUDENT from school. GRANDMOTHER and Ms. Lahti discussed potential options for STUDENT, and GRANDMOTHER inquired about placing STUDENT on home study. Subsequently GRANDMOTHER and the school agreed to place STUDENT on home study for the remaining weeks of the school year. (Testimony of Ms. Lahti, GRANDMOTHER; District's Exhs. 59, 69.)
In late May 1999, GRANDMOTHER took STUDENT for a psychiatric evaluation and a pediatric evaluation, pursuant to the SSA's review of his eligibility for SSI. Both the psychiatrist and the pediatrician based their evaluations solely on their own one-time examinations of STUDENT and on information obtained from GRANDMOTHER; neither observed STUDENT at school or interviewed his teachers. (See Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 103-110.) Using a multiaxial assessment pursuant to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), the psychiatrist concluded that STUDENT had an Axis I diagnosis of ADHD, an Axis IV diagnosis of severe psychosocial stressors, and an Axis V diagnosis of current global assessment of functioning (GAF) of 40. (Petitioner's Exh. pg.105.) In July 1999, the SSA notified GRANDMOTHER that STUDENT remained eligible for SSI, because he was still disabled pursuant to the Social Security Act. (Petitioner's Exh. pg. 2.)
In July 1999, GRANDMOTHER requested a due process hearing regarding the IEP team's determination that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. In early September 1999, STUDENT returned to Wild Rose and began attendance in a regular education third-grade class taught by Christine Meadows. On a Friday in early October 1999, the staff and students were required to evacuate Wild Rose for the day because of a bomb scare. The District staff telephoned some parents to pick up their children from school, but GRANDMOTHER was not among the parents notified that day. The District superintendent later sent all Wild Rose parents a letter explaining what had occurred.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Is STUDENT eligible for special education services?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, only children with certain disabilities, including serious emotional disturbance, specific learning disability, and health impairment, are eligible for special education services. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Education Code § 56026(a).) Moreover, the child's disability must require instruction and/or services which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. (Education Code § 56026(b).)
In the present case, STUDENT has previously been diagnosed as having ADHD. (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER; Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 8, 104, 106, 110.) However, ADHD is not listed in State or federal law as one of the disabilities that establishes eligibility for special education. California law states that a student whose educational performance is adversely affected by ADHD or attention deficit disorder (ADD) is eligible for special education if the student demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria in the categories of other health impairment, serious emotional disturbance or specific learning disability. (Education Code § 56339(a); see also U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum (1991) 18 IDELR 116.)
Serious Emotional Disturbance (SED)
A student meets eligibility criteria as SED when he/she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.
(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.
(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
(34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i); Title 5 CCR § 3030(i).)
Petitioner asserts that he qualifies as seriously emotionally disturbed, while the District argues to the contrary. Hence, this decision will examine whether STUDENT meets any of the five SED criteria to a marked degree over a long period of time, causing adverse effects on his educational performance. Regarding the five criteria, consideration is as follows:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. Initially, the first criterion can be eliminated as a possible basis for a diagnosis of SED. There is no evidence demonstrating that STUDENT has an inability to learn. STUDENT's current teacher testified that STUDENT's skills are within the range of her classroom, and that his reading and verbal skills are particularly strong. STUDENT completes his homework assignments and does not need assignments to be modified for him. (Testimony of Ms. Meadows, Ms. Moulton, Ms. Lambrinos.) Ms. Meadows estimated that, among the eighteen students currently in her third-grade class, STUDENT would be ranked fourth or fifth in academics. (Testimony of Ms. Meadows.) STUDENT's second-grade teacher concurred regarding STUDENT's academic abilities. Ms. Moulton stated that STUDENT occasionally became frustrated with new math concepts, but did fine once he caught on to the new concepts. Ms. Moulton noted that STUDENT was a quick learner, a strong reader, and an imaginative thinker. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton; District's Exh. 46.) Moreover, STUDENT's grades and standardized test scores are not significantly below average and do not indicate significant academic difficulties; to the extent that STUDENT has academic and/or cognitive delays, they are mild and are not to a marked degree. (District's Exhs. 40, 52, 53, 60, 61; Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 3, 101, 109.)
(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
Similarly, the second criterion can be eliminated as a basis for SED. There is no evidence to indicate that STUDENT is unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. STUDENT's current teacher testified that he gets along well with his peers and has a group of friends. (Testimony of Ms. Meadows.) Likewise, STUDENT's second-grade teacher reported that the other children liked STUDENT and that he played soccer and other games with the other children. Ms. Moulton testified that STUDENT often worried that the other kids did not like him but that, in fact, he was well-liked. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton; District's Exhs. 46, 58.) Ms. Moulton also wrote that STUDENT did not demonstrate any difficulties getting along with adults. (District's Exh. 58.) GRANDMOTHER has also reported that STUDENT plays with friends. (Petitioner's Exh. pg. 105.) Dr. Logan's observations of STUDENT and review of records support the conclusion that STUDENT gets along well with peers and adults. (Footnote 5) (Testimony of Dr. Logan; District's Exh. 53.)
(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.
Regarding the third criterion, the evidence indicates that STUDENT sometimes manifests inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. Regarding his behaviors outside of school, GRANDMOTHER reported that STUDENT is easily frustrated and often becomes highly agitated, particularly in crowds. STUDENT is noncompliant, will frequently lose his temper, and will verbally lash out at others. (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER; District's Exh. 35, 53.) STUDENT demonstrates repetitive, compulsive behaviors, such as sticking the corner of a blanket up his nose so that his nose bleeds onto the blanket. (Testimony of Karen Hernandez, GRANDMOTHER; District's Exhs. 35.) GRANDMOTHER has observed that STUDENT can often be moody, impulsive or hyperactive. (District's Exhs. 35, 53.) Indeed, during a recent psychiatric examination, the examiner found that STUDENT was "hyperverbal, restless, and jumped all over the examination room, and couldn't stay still during the examination." (Petitioner's Exh. pg. 105.) GRANDMOTHER testified that she has taken STUDENT to therapy for years to address his behavioral and emotional problems.
While aware of STUDENT's behaviors at home, District psychologists have repeatedly found that STUDENT is not SED because he does not exhibit inappropriate behaviors and feelings at school to a marked degree. (Testimony of Dr. Logan; District's Exhs. 35, 53.) After observing STUDENT in the classroom and on the playground, and reviewing reports from his teachers, Dr. Logan concluded that STUDENT functions relatively well in the structured setting of a classroom. (Testimony of Dr. Logan; District's Exh. 53.) STUDENT's teachers do not characterize his behavior as inattentive or hyperactive, and they have not reported observation of compulsive behaviors. (Testimony of Ms. Lambrinos, Ms. Moulton; District's Exhs. 32, 46, 53.)
Regarding other inappropriate behaviors at school, Ms. Moulton reported that sometimes during second grade STUDENT demonstrated anger outbursts, such as when he would get frustrated with other children and yell at them. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton; District's Exh. 46, 58.) However, other than the May 1999 incident resulting in home study placement, most instances of STUDENT's anger were manageable and unextraordinary, as STUDENT learned to talk out his feelings and take time out to calm down. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton, Dr. Logan; District's Exh. 46.)
Ms. Meadows testified that, so far during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT had not had any anger outbursts in class. One incident occurred in mid-November, wherein STUDENT was teasing another boy and that child pushed STUDENT to the ground. STUDENT later admitted that he should not have been teasing. Ms. Meadows stated that the problem was not one that STUDENT caused, and explained that STUDENT was questioned about the incident but was not disciplined for it.
Neither STUDENT's first-grade teacher nor his third-grade teacher observed any notable inappropriate behaviors for a child of STUDENT's age and grade level. (See testimony of Ms. Lambrinos, Ms. Meadows; District's Exh. 40.) STUDENT's first-grade teacher testified that she recalled only one instance in which STUDENT's behavior constituted a serious discipline problem; consistent with that testimony, the evidence reflects that STUDENT was suspended for one day during first grade. (Testimony of Ms. Lambrinos; Petitioner's Exh. pg. 11; District's Exh. 39.) Early in the school year, Ms. Lambrinos did observe STUDENT engage in "immature attention-getting behaviors, such as lying on the floor...to whine for something he wants." (District's Exh. 32.) However, Ms. Lambrinos reported that she was able to manage this behavior and got STUDENT to return to task. (District's Exh. 32.)
Regarding inappropriate feelings at school, the Hearing Officer considers Ms. Moulton's statement that STUDENT worried that the other children in the class did not like him, even though he was popular and well-liked. STUDENT told Ms. Moulton that he thought that perhaps the other children did not like him "because I'm black." (Testimony of Ms. Moulton; District's Exh. 53.) Ms. Moulton testified that she thought that STUDENT's statement was strange because STUDENT's second-grade class was racially mixed. In any event, the Hearing Officer finds no evidence that STUDENT's insecurities interfered with his educational performance or constituted inappropriate feelings to a marked degree.
Finally, STUDENT's behavior during the May 1999 incident requires scrutiny. On both a Friday and the following Monday, STUDENT could not control his anger enough to attend class, despite repeated opportunities for him to calm down. Arguably STUDENT also demonstrated inappropriate feelings of anger, distrust and isolation. Thus, during the May 1999 incident, STUDENT demonstrated both inappropriate behaviors and feelings under normal circumstances, to a marked degree. Given that the incident interfered with his attendance for at least two days of school, and warranted a change in placement to home study, it is evident that his inappropriate behaviors and feelings interfered with his educational performance.
Dr. Logan argued that the May 1999 incident did not warrant finding that STUDENT was SED, because his inappropriate behaviors were not pervasive and essentially the incident was an isolated occurrence, uncharacteristic of STUDENT's typical behavior at school. In light of the testimony of STUDENT's teachers, Dr. Logan's expertise in this area, and the lack of persuasive evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors at school are not to a marked degree and do not interfere with his education. Moreover, there is no evidence that his inappropriate behaviors cannot be addressed in the regular education setting. While the May 1999 incident alone might suggest that STUDENT exhibits behaviors consistent with this SED characteristic, consideration of the entirety of STUDENT's behaviors at school and the knowledgeable opinion of the District's school psychologist refute such a finding at this time.
(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
In light of the evidence of his demeanor at school, STUDENT does not meet the fourth criterion for SED eligibility. Again, the evidence indicates STUDENT behaves inconsistently between home and school. STUDENT was depressed after his father's murder in 1995. (Testimony of Ms. Hernandez, GRANDMOTHER.) STUDENT's grandmother asserts that STUDENT still is often unhappy, depressed and/or moody, yet his teachers describe him as a sensitive but generally happy child who wants to learn and enjoys playing with other children. (Footnote 6) (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER, Ms. Lambrinos, Ms. Moulton, Ms. Meadows; District's Exh. 35, 42, 53.) There is little evidence to support a finding that STUDENT has a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression at school, or that such moods interfere with his educational performance. (See also Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 100-110; District's Exh. 53.)
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
GRANDMOTHER reports that STUDENT has problems with bed-wetting and that a doctor concluded that there was no medical reason for the problem. This allegation alone, without further evidence, is insufficient to establish that STUDENT meets the fifth criterion for SED, particularly to the extent that his tendency is to a marked degree and interferes with his educational performance.
Thus, STUDENT does not meet any of the five SED criteria to a marked degree, to the extent that there is interference with his educational performance. Moreover, there is no evidence that STUDENT needs special instruction or services that cannot be provided in the regular education program. The District has offered counseling and other services via a Section 504 plan, although Petitioner has not accepted that offer.
The Hearing Officer notes that a pediatrician diagnosed STUDENT as functioning at a GAF of 40. Such a low rating is indicative of a serious impairment. (Footnote 7) However, the opinion of this psychiatrist must be considered in light of his limited knowledge about STUDENT, in that he did not observe STUDENT at school, did not interview STUDENT's teachers, and received the majority of his information directly from GRANDMOTHER. Thus, the evidence does not support a finding that the psychiatrist's rating of STUDENT's GAF reflects STUDENT's level of functioning at school.
While there is evidence that STUDENT's behavior outside of school reflects some of the SED characteristics, he generally does not manifest those characteristics at school, and those characteristics do not adversely affect his educational performance. To this extent, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Dr. Logan's explanation that STUDENT feels more comfortable in a structured setting, and thus performs better in a classroom than on the playground, and better in both of those settings than in the relatively less structured settings outside of school.
In light of all evidence presented, STUDENT did not meet any SED eligibility criteria because no criterion was exhibited to a marked degree while adversely affecting his education to a substantial degree. Therefore, at this time STUDENT does not qualify for special education as a student with an SED. (Footnote 8)
Specific Learning Disability (SLD)
The IDEA defines "specific learning disability" as a "disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in a imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations." (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26).) California Education Code section 56337 specifies that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability (SLD):
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas:
(1) Oral expression;
(2) Listening comprehension (3) Written expression;
(4) Basic reading skills;
(5) Reading comprehension;
(6) Mathematics calculation;
(7) Mathematics reasoning;
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. (c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
For purposes of this section, basic psychological processes include "attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expressive." (Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(1).) For determining eligibility as a student with an SLD, the student's discrepancy shall not be primarily the result of limited school experience or poor school attendance. (Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(5).)
A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid, or through determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists. (Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(4).)
In the present case, the District measured STUDENT's cognitive ability in November 1997 via the Wechsler Intelligence Scale-Third Edition (WISC-III). STUDENT scored a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) of 95, a performance IQ of 100, and full scale IQ of 97. (District's Exh. 35; testimony of Dr. Logan.) STUDENT had obtained similar IQ scores in June 1993, when the District administered to him the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale-Fourth Edition (Stanford-Binet). On that measure, STUDENT's composite IQ score was 109. (District's Exh. 17; testimony of Dr. Logan.) Dr. Logan explained that IQ scores between 85 and 115 are considered to be in the average range.
The District measured STUDENT's academic achievement using the Woodcock Johnson-Revised (WJ-R) and the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). On the WJ-R, STUDENT's standard scores ranged from a low of 89 to a high of 131. Similarly, on the WIAT, STUDENT's standard scores ranged from a low of 87 to a high of 116. (District's Exh. 53.) Dr. Logan and Ms. Trimarchi explained that STUDENT's achievement scores did not indicate a severe discrepancy when compared with STUDENT's cognitive ability as measured by the WISC-III or the Stanford-Binet. (Testimony of Dr. Logan, Ms. Trimarchi.) Because STUDENT attended D-1 prior to attending first grade, he is one year older than his classmates. Therefore, Dr. Logan scored STUDENT's WJ-R and WIAT test results with standard scores for both his age level and grade level. Dr. Logan explained that STUDENT's scores were appropriate for both his age and grade level, and that neither set of scores produced a significant discrepancy when compared with his cognitive ability scores.
In the present case, the District employees who administered the standardized tests to STUDENT concluded that STUDENT put forth good effort and that the tests were valid in assessing STUDENT's ability and achievement. (District's Exhs. 35, 53.) While neither party disputed the use of cognitive ability tests in assessing STUDENT, the Hearing Officer considers that STUDENT's ethnicity is a mixture of Caucasian, Hispanic and African-American. (District's Exhs. 6, 22, 26.) A federal court in California concluded that IQ tests, including the WISC-III and the Standford-Binet, are racially and culturally biased against African-American students. (Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F.Supp. 926, 988.) California thus prohibits administration of IQ tests to African-American children "who have been or may in the future be classified as mentally retarded on the basis of IQ tests." (Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F.Supp. 926, 934 (N.D.Cal. 1979), aff'd in part and rev'd in part, 793 F.2d 969 (9th Cir. 1984).) Given also that the IDEA and the Education Code prohibit the use of discriminatory testing and evaluation materials, IQ tests cannot be administered to African-American students. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(1)(i); Education Code § 56320(a); see also Crawford v. Honig, 37 F.3d 485, 489 (9th Cir. 1994).) However, it is unclear as to what extent the prohibition on IQ tests applies to a mixed-race student such as STUDENT, who was not raised in an African-American household.
If standardized tests are considered invalid for assessing STUDENT, the existence of a discrepancy "shall be measured by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan." (Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(4)(B).) In 1989, the Larry P. Task Force presented the California Department of Education with an advisory report containing guidance on the conduct of alternate assessments. (Larry P. Task Force, Larry P. Task Force Report/Policy and Alternate Assessment Guideline Recommendations, Resources in Special Education, 1989.) In this report, the Task Force describes the type of information which must be considered in conducting an alternative assessment. The report emphasizes that the child's classroom performance must be considered, including information obtained from consultation with the classroom teacher and observation of the child's classroom performance during formal and informal activities. (Larry P. Task Force Report, supra at 54.)
In the present case, there has not been sufficient evidence presented to demonstrate a significant discrepancy via alternative means. As to STUDENT's classroom performance, his teachers report that his academic level was within the range of the classroom. (Testimony of Ms. Lambrinos, Ms. Moulton, Ms. Meadows.) STUDENT's second-grade teacher estimated that, academically, STUDENT had been in the top quarter of the classroom and that STUDENT learned at an acceptable rate. (Testimony of Ms. Moulton.) STUDENT's report cards reflected relatively good grades and few significant academic problem areas. (District's Exhs. 40, 41, 61.) During her observation of STUDENT in his classroom, Dr. Logan did not find any significant difficulties with his classroom performance. (Testimony of Dr. Logan; District's Exh. 53.)
The only notable academic problem cited by Petitioner was his low score on the writing section of the Stanford Achievement Test, Ninth Edition (SAT-9) administered in May 1999. STUDENT scored in the 15th percentile on the writing section. (Petitioner's Exh. pg.3.) However, this low score alone does not establish a significant discrepancy. The Hearing Officer considers that STUDENT scored well within the average range on the remaining sections of the SAT-9, from a low of 38th percentile on word study skills to a high of 83rd percentile on reading comprehension. STUDENT's report cards and test scores indicate that while writing is his weakest area, overall his writing skills were not substantially below grade level. (District's Exhs. 40, 53, 61.)
Moreover, even if Petitioner had a severe discrepancy, he has not established that such discrepancy is not due to limited school experience and/or poor attendance. (See Title 5 CCR § 3030 (j)(5).) In grade D-1, STUDENT was absent for 53 school days and tardy on 58 school days. Subsequently STUDENT had 28 absences and 40 tardies during his first grade year, and 15 absences and 26 tardies his second grade year. (District's Exhs. 29, 39, 62, 69.) While his attendance has been better during third grade, the missed instructional time from his prior school years almost certainly had a negative effect on his academic progress.
The evidence has not established that Petitioner has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement in one or more of the seven areas listed in Education Code section 56337, nor has it established that any such discrepancy would not be due to poor attendance, nor that the discrepancy could not be effectively addressed within the regular instructional program. Thus, Petitioner does not qualify as eligible for special education due to an SLD.
Other Health Impaired (OHI)
A student meets the eligibility criteria for OHI when the student has:
limited strength, vitality, or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil's educational performance.
(Title 5 CCR § 3030(f).)
While some health professionals have diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD, there is no evidence that STUDENT has attentional deficits that substantially adversely affect his education. STUDENT's teachers did not report observing significant attentional difficulties. STUDENT's third-grade teacher testified that STUDENT can work on his own for 20 to 25 minutes during periods when she is leading reading groups. Ms. Meadows stated that STUDENT experience significant difficulty with paying attention to task, and noted that he needs only a verbal reminder to redirect him to task. Ms. Meadows acknowledged that STUDENT cannot sit still for long and moves around a lot, but she explained that such behavior was not unusual for children at his age. Similarly, STUDENT's first- and second-grade teachers testified that he could attend to task, and that his attention was not particularly shorter than that of the other children in those classes. Moreover, in the District's 1997 psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, the District psychologist tested STUDENT and concluded that STUDENT's "attention/memory based tasks do not appear to be significantly impacted." (District's Exh. 35.)
No other evidence was submitted to establish that STUDENT has limited strength, vitality or alertness due to chronic health problems, or that such limitations adversely affected his educational performance. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not met the requirements for special education eligibility as OHI.
(2) Did the District conduct a complete assessment of all identified areas of suspected disability?
Special education students must be assessed every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant or if the parent requests an assessment. (Education Code § 56381.) Education Code Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.
In the present case, the District conducted STUDENT's most recent assessment in January 1999, in response to a written request from STUDENT's grandmother. That written request did not identify any specific areas for assessment, but did state concerns that the assessment was "necessary to help my child with schoolwork and self-esteem." (District's Exh. 42.) On December 2, 1998, GRANDMOTHER met with District employees to identify her concerns prior to the assessment. (District's Exhs. 44, 45, 48.) Also on that date, the District had GRANDMOTHER fill out and sign a referral notice and assessment plan. The form indicates that STUDENT's only areas for assessment would be "academic/preacademic achievement" and "social/behavior." The form's other listed areas for assessment, such as psychomotor development and intellectual development, are crossed out. On the bottom of the form, GRANDMOTHER wrote that she was "also...requesting that the entire assessment be completed." (District's Exh. 47.)
After the meeting between GRANDMOTHER and District personnel regarding concerns about STUDENT, Dr. Logan wrote GRANDMOTHER a letter dated December 7, 1998. That letter appeared to summarize the matters discussed at the meeting. Dr. Logan wrote that GRANDMOTHER had indicated that she was requesting "a complete assessment, and identified academic skills and social/behavioral functioning as areas of current concern regarding STUDENT." Dr. Logan's letter further stated that "an assessment plan was developed to reflect the areas in which [GRANDMOTHER had] identified a need." (District's Exh. 48.) In a letter dated January 25, 1999, GRANDMOTHER replied to Dr. Logan's letter and requested that Dr. Logan amend a statement in her December 7 letter. However, GRANDMOTHER's reply did not request amendment of the portion of Dr. Logan's letter regarding the areas for assessment. (District's Exh. 52.)
In January 1999, the District assessed STUDENT in academic achievement and social/behavioral areas, but did not assess STUDENT in any other areas. The District had conducted assessments of STUDENT in November 1997, December 1994/January 1995, and June 1993. Those previous assessments included cognitive/psychological evaluations. The January 1999 assessment report noted the prior cognitive testing and incorporated summaries of the results of the those cognitive/psychological evaluations. Dr. Logan testified that the previous cognitive testing confirmed that STUDENT did not have any cognitive deficits. Since STUDENT's cognitive abilities were not of concern, the District limited its January 1999 assessment to academic and social/emotional areas. (Testimony of Dr. Logan.)
Based on the assessment plan, the only areas of concern identified were academic achievement and social/behavioral functioning. Indeed, Petitioner has not clearly alleged what other areas of testing should have been conducted. Given that STUDENT had been assessed on three prior occasions, and that academic achievement and social/behavioral were the only areas of ongoing concern, the January 1999 assessment tested STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
(3) If STUDENT is eligible for special education services, must the District provide the following in order to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
(a) a one-to-one certified educational assistant.
(b) notification of emergency situations regarding STUDENT's safety and well-being.
(c) professional training by a qualified instructor trained in attention deficit disorder/attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADD/ADHD) for all staff who have direct contact with STUDENT.
(d) a quiet location, monitored by a trained staff member, where STUDENT can go to calm down.
(e) a home study teacher, if STUDENT needs home study due to serious illness or behavior problems at school.
In light of the Hearing Officer's finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education at this time, the District's obligation to provide a FAPE has not been established. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not reach the issue of Petitioner's placement or services.
ORDER
1. STUDENT is not eligible for special education at this time. All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
2. The District established that its most recent assessment tested STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
(1) Is STUDENT eligible for special education services?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(2) Did the District conduct a complete assessment of all identified areas of suspected disability?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(3) If STUDENT is eligible for special education services, must the District provide the following in order to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
(a) a one-to-one certified educational assistant.
(b) notification of emergency situations regarding STUDENT's safety and well-being.
(c) professional training by a qualified instructor trained in attention deficit disorder/attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADD/ADHD) for all staff who have direct contact with STUDENT.
(d) a quiet location, monitored by a trained staff member, where STUDENT can go to calm down.
(e) a home study teacher, if STUDENT needs home study due to serious illness or behavior problems at school.
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: February 24, 2000 ___________________________________
Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. The consultation request from the California Department of Social Services, dated March 10, 1999, and response from Pacific Clinic East Outpatient, dated June 15, 1999, are admitted as Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 100-102. The four-page psychiatric evaluation from S & L Medical Group, dated May 21, 1999, is admitted as Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 103-106. The four-page pediatric evaluation from S & L Medical Group, dated May 25, 1999, is admitted as Petitioner's Exh. pgs. 107-110. 2. On the first day of hearing, in consultation and agreement with the parties, the Hearing Officer reorganized and clarified the parties' original statements of the issues. 3. In a letter dated December 29, 1999, the District noted that one page of the psychiatric evaluation was missing, and requested that Petitioner locate and submit the missing page. On January 5, 2000, the Hearing Office received a copy of the missing page, and presumably the District likewise received it. 4. Petitioner argues that STUDENT began kindergarten a year late. The District argues that the timing of STUDENT's entrance into kindergarten was age-appropriate, because District students must be five years old to begin kindergarten. 5. Dr. Logan testified that she has a bachelor's degree in elementary education from California State University, Sacramento, and a master's degree and Ph.D. in learning and child development from University of Southern California. Dr. Logan has twelve years' experience as an elementary school teacher and twenty years' experience as a school psychologist. 6. GRANDMOTHER also notes that STUDENT's self-esteem is negatively affected because he is self-conscious about being older than his classmates. 7. The DSM-IV GAF Scale runs from a low of zero to a high of one hundred. A GAF of 40 is utilized to diagnose a patient who has "some impairment in reality testing or communication...OR major impairment in several areas, such as work or school, family relations, judgment, thinking or mood...." (DSM-IV, American Psychiatric Association (1994) p. 32.) 8. While STUDENT does not qualify as SED at this time, the evidence nevertheless established that he has exhibited some behavioral difficulties. The evidence also established that STUDENT requires a lot of individual attention, does not function well in crowds, and functions better in more structured environments. Given that STUDENT's third grade class has only eighteen students, and that his previous grades have offered similarly small class sizes, STUDENT's ability to function well in school thus far may diminish as he advances to the larger class sizes of the upper grades.
