California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 8, 1999
Student v. Clovis Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1473-97 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Clovis Unified must repay half of private reading tutoring costs for 1997-98; its 1998-99 offer was upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 13-year-old student eligible under serious emotional disturbance and speech and language impairment filed for hearing against Clovis Unified School District. After four years in a district intervention program for emotionally disturbed students, he moved in 1997-98 to a resource specialist program (RSP) at Gettysburg Elementary School. He still read at a first-grade level. His mother enrolled him in after-school Orton-Gillingham tutoring at the Cullinan Education Center. The Hearing Officer first held that a three-year statute of limitations barred claims arising before November 12, 1994. That period was not paused because the student was a minor. On the merits, the district denied a FAPE in 1997-98 until March 11, 1998. Until then, it gave only monthly psychologist consultation and an informal behavior plan, despite serious emotional and attention needs. There was also no evidence of progress. The counseling, consultation, speech therapy and behavior intervention plan added on March 11 were appropriate. The district's 1998-99 offer was a FAPE. There was no proof the student needed Orton-Gillingham instruction or a quiet, isolated room. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for private psychologists, psychiatrists, a psychiatric hospital stay, biofeedback and three independent assessments. Either the district's assessments were appropriate or the evidence was lacking. The district must reimburse 50 percent of Cullinan Center costs, including transportation, from September 11, 1997 to March 10, 1998.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled several issues. It applied a three-year limitations period with no pause for a student's minority. It awarded partial reimbursement for private tutoring that was not ideal but still appropriate. It refused to make the district pay for psychiatric hospitalization or medication management, citing Clovis USD v. OAH. It also denied private assessment costs where the district's own assessment was appropriate.
Issues and holdings
Issue Procedural Matter 3. Whether the statute of limitations barred Petitioner from litigating claims that accrued before November 12, 1994
A three-year limitations period (Alexopulos) applies, it is not tolled during the student's minority, and the parent knew or had reason to know of the facts, so claims accruing before November 12, 1994 were barred.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?
District denied FAPE until March 11, 1998 because it failed to address serious emotional and behavioral needs and showed no educational benefit; after March 11 the program was appropriate. No speech therapy or isolated one-on-one reading was required earlier, and LRE was met.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year?
The July 1998 RSP offer with speech, counseling, group therapy, BIP and one-on-one reading met the student's needs; no evidence he required Orton-Gillingham or a quiet, isolated setting, and methodology is for the district.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Bradley Schuyler, Ph.D., a psychologist?
Denied for lack of any evidence on the services, dates, qualifications or educational need.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Harvey Biala, M.D., a psychiatrist?
Denied; the evidence was insufficient, and prescribing medication is a medical service that is not for diagnosis or evaluation, so the district does not owe it under IDEA.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by David A. Fox, M.D., a psychiatrist?
Denied; the mostly illegible treatment records were hearsay that no witness explained, and they did not show the treatment was educationally necessary.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 3d. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital?
Under Clovis USD v. OAH, the November-December 1995 psychiatric hospitalization was for medical reasons, not educational ones, and included no educational services, so the district does not have to pay for it.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3e. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist?
Denied. No district assessment was pending in June 1997, and lack of progress alone did not require reassessment. The January 1996 triennial was appropriate. Biofeedback was not shown to be provided or educationally necessary.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3f. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist?
The late-1997 district assessment was appropriate. The slight delay past the 50-day IEP timeline was minor and caused no harm, so reimbursement was denied.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3g. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by Bonita Ekhardt, a licensed educational psychologist?
Denied because the district's recent triennial assessment was appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Education Center, including costs of transportation?
The Orton-Gillingham tutoring was appropriate enough and gave some benefit during the period the district denied FAPE. Because it addressed only reading and suited the student's deficits only in part, reimbursement was reduced to 50% for September 11, 1997 to March 10, 1998.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for attorney's fees and costs?
The Hearing Officer has no authority to award attorney's fees or costs without both parties' consent.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within twenty calendar days of receiving proof from the parent, District shall reimburse fifty percent of the costs of the student's attendance at the Cullinan Center from September 11, 1997 to March 10, 1998, including transportation costs. The dollar amount is not stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Clovis USD v. California Office of Administrative Hearings; Alexopulos v. San Francisco USD; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Wilson v. Garcia
People named in the decision
- Janet Van Gelder, Director of special education and SELPA director, Clovis Unified School District
- Jody Lehman, Program specialist; academic assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Jonathan Logan, School psychologist; counseling provider, Clovis Unified School District
- Susan Clare, Ph.D., School psychologist, elementary intervention program, Clovis Unified School District
- Peggy Ruud, Licensed clinical social worker, elementary intervention program, Elementary intervention program
- Anna Marie Brown, R.N., School nurse, Lincoln Elementary, Clovis Unified School District
- Jimmie Smothers, School psychologist; psychoeducational and functional analysis assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Kaye Rush, Speech and language therapist; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Larry Hughes, Ph.D., School psychologist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center for Central California
- Sylvia Bowland, M.A., Educational specialist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center for Central California
- Lynn Negus, M.D., Staff pediatrician, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center for Central California
- Pamela K. Vives, M.A., Speech-language pathologist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center for Central California
- Jeff Lumsden, M.S., Transition specialist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center for Central California
- Christy Wilson, Elementary intervention program teacher, Clovis Unified School District, Mickey Cox Elementary
- Todd Wilson, RSP teacher and case manager, Clovis Unified School District, Gettysburg Elementary
- Art Richards, Upper-grade elementary intervention program teacher, Clovis Unified School District
- Patricia Manghera, General education teacher, Clovis Unified School District, Gettysburg Elementary
- Charlotte Geesey, Resource specialist program teacher, Clovis Unified School District, Clarke Intermediate School
- Randi Schoneman, R.N., School nurse; health assessor, Clovis Unified School District, Gettysburg Elementary
- Bonita Ekhardt, M.S., Licensed educational psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Aslan Center
- Joanne Cullinan, Founder and director; private reading (Orton-Gillingham) provider, Cullinan Education Center
- Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., Licensed psychologist; private assessor and biofeedback provider, Private
- Beckie M. Jensen, M.A., Psychological assistant; private assessor, Private (with Dr. West)
- Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., Licensed psychologist; private assessor, Private
- Kiki L. Wells, M.A., Registered psychological assistant; private assessor, Private (with Dr. Wells)
- Chris Bauer, B.A., Psychological trainee; hospital evaluator, Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital
- Stephen B. Bindler, Ph.D., Supervising psychologist; hospital evaluator, Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital
- Bradley Schuyler, Ph.D., Private psychologist, Private
- Harvey Biala, M.D., Private psychiatrist, Private
- David A. Fox, M.D., Psychiatrist; supervised the hospital program, Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital / private
- Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital, Psychiatric hospital, Private facility
- Fresno County Department of Mental Health, Mental health agency providing services in the intervention program; AB 3632 referral, Fresno County
- Thomas Guarino, Attorney for parent before filing, Myers & Overstreet
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Clovis, California, on April 28 and 29, May 27, June 11 and 12, and July 23, 24, 30 and 31, 1998.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney David M. Overstreet IV from the law firm of Myers & Overstreet. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Clovis Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sandra Woliver from the law firm of Lozano, Smith, Smith, Woliver & Behrens. Also present on the District's behalf was Janet Van Gelder, the District's director of special education and SELPA director. Jody Lehman, the District's program specialist, substituted for Ms. Van Gelder during a few hours of the hearing on July 24, 1998.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: MOTHER; Bonita Ekhardt, M.S., a licensed educational psychologist who assessed STUDENT at the request of his mother; and Joanne Cullinan, the founder and director of the Cullinan Education Center.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Janet Van Gelder; Jody Lehman; Jonathan Logan, a District school psychologist; Susan Clare, Ph.D., the District school psychologist assigned to the elementary intervention program (EIP) at Mickey Cox Elementary School during the first two years of STUDENT's attendance; Peggy Ruud, the licensed clinical social worker formerly assigned to the EIP during STUDENT's attendance; Anna Marie Brown, R.N., the school nurse at Lincoln Elementary School during STUDENT's attendance; Jimmie Smothers, a District school psychologist; Kaye Rush, the District's speech and language therapist; Larry Hughes, Ph.D., a school psychologist at the Diagnostic Center for Central California; Sylvia Bowland, M.A., an educational specialist at the Diagnostic Center for Central California; Christy Wilson, the teacher assigned to the EIP during STUDENT's attendance; Patricia Manghera, STUDENT's regular education teacher at Gettysburg Elementary School; Charlotte Geesey, a resource specialist program teacher at Clarke Intermediate School; and Randi Schoneman, R.N., a school nurse at Gettysburg Elementary School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year?
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by the following persons and facilities?
a. Bradley Schuyler, Ph.D., a psychologist b. Harvey Biala, M.D., a psychiatrist c. David A. Fox, M.D., a psychiatrist d. Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital e. Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist f. Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist g. Bonita Ekhardt, a licensed educational psychologist
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Education Center, including costs of transportation?
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for attorney's fees and costs?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Only Evidence Introduced at the Hearing Was Considered
After the record was closed, the Hearing Office received the parties' written closing briefs. Attached to Petitioner's brief were two exhibits containing documentary evidence. Neither of the exhibits had been introduced into evidence at the hearing. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties' closing briefs are not evidence to be considered by the Hearing Officer. In any case, the record had already been closed for the submission of additional evidence. For these reasons, the only evidence that was considered is that which was introduced by the parties at the hearing. Those portions of the parties' closing briefs which contain facts or other evidence not introduced into the record during the hearing were not considered by the Hearing Officer in rendering a decision in this matter.
2. The District's Motion to Strike Bonita Ekhardt's Testimony Is Denied
In its closing brief, the District contended that the testimony of Bonita Ekhardt should be stricken from the record because Ms. Ekhardt lacks the qualifications required to testify as an expert in special education matters. The District argued that Ms. Ekhardt did not qualify as an expert under Evidence Code § 720. Evidence Code § 720 provides that in order for a witness to qualify as an expert, the witness must have special knowledge, skill, experience, training or education sufficient to qualify her as an expert on the subject to which her testimony relates. Petitioner presented Ms. Ekhardt's testimony and written assessment report to support his allegations that the District had not conducted appropriate assessments, had not provided appropriate placements and services, and had otherwise violated special education law with regard to STUDENT.
The District's motion to strike Ms. Ekhardt's testimony is denied. Special education law makes clear that the technical rules of evidence, including Evidence Code § 720, do not apply to special education due process hearings. Section 3082(b) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations states, in pertinent part:
The hearings conducted pursuant to this section shall not be conducted according to the technical rules of evidence and those related to witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted if it is the sort of evidence on which responsible persons are accustomed to rely in the conduct of serious affairs, regardless of the existence of any common law or statutory rule which might make improper the admission of such evidence over objection in civil actions.
Therefore, regardless of whether Ms. Ekhardt would qualify under the requirements of Evidence Code § 720 in a civil action, there is no similar requirement for an expert witness in a special education due process hearing. However, as with all witnesses providing expert testimony in due process hearings, Ms. Ekhardt's qualifications in the special education field were taken into consideration in evaluating the weight to accord her testimony.
3. The Statute of Limitations Barred Petitioner From Litigating Claims That Accrued Before November 12, 1994
On the first day of hearing, Petitioner indicated that he intended to raise issues and introduce evidence with regard to events that occurred as long ago as 1990, when STUDENT began attending kindergarten in the District. The District objected to the introduction of any issues or evidence with regard to events that occurred before November 12, 1994, because Petitioner failed to file a request for a due process hearing until November 12, 1997. The District argued that a three-year statute of limitations applies to special education matters and that, consequently, any claims that arose prior to November 12, 1994, were time-barred. The parties submitted written arguments on the issue.
Neither state special education law nor the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) contains a specific statute of limitations for initiating special education due process hearing procedures. In the absence of such a statute, a court must identify the state cause of action that is most analogous to the federal statute and adopt its limitations period if it is consistent with the policy of the federal cause of action. Wilson v. Garcia, 471 U.S. 261, 266-267, 105 S.Ct. 1938, 85 L.Ed.2d 254 (1985). The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that the three-year statute of limitations contained in Code of Civil Procedure § 338(a) applies to claims brought under the IDEA in California. (Footnote 2) See Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987). The Alexopulos court also held that, under federal law, a cause of action accrues, and the statute of limitations begins to run, when a plaintiff knows or has reason to know of the facts underlying it. Id. at 555. (Footnote 3)
In light of the holding in Alexopulos that the statute of limitations begins to run when a plaintiff knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the cause of action, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of when Petitioner knew or had reason to know of the injuries that are the basis of his claims under the IDEA. The evidence presented at hearing established the following. MOTHER has been highly involved with STUDENT's education from the beginning. She has attended all the IEP meetings the District has held for STUDENT since November 1992, which occurred about two times every year. At the conclusion of every one of those meetings, MOTHER indicated in writing on the IEP document that she had been informed and understood her rights and due process. MOTHER became aware by at least October 28, 1992, when a student study team met to discuss STUDENT's problems in following rules and in reading, that STUDENT was having behavioral problems in the classroom and difficulty with reading. By that time, STUDENT had already been prescribed medication for attention deficit disorder (ADD) by his private treater. Additionally, an assessment performed in November 1992 by the District found a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading, and noted that STUDENT could be both oppositional and aggressive in the classroom and had difficulty with attention to task. Furthermore, these problems have been consistently noted in STUDENT's IEPs, as well as in later assessments. Finally, starting with an IEP dated March 24, 1993, and until Spring 1998, MOTHER has consistently approved educational programs which have not included speech and language services, making it clear that MOTHER was fully aware that STUDENT was not receiving speech and language services during that time. Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner's mother knew or had reason to know of the alleged injuries (such as the lack of necessary speech and language services, and the failure to adequately assess or address STUDENT's "dyslexia" or reading difficulties) at or about the time the injuries occurred. Given the three-year statute of limitations and the fact that Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing on November 12, 1997, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is barred from litigating IDEA claims that arose prior to November 12, 1994.
The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner's arguments to the contrary. Petitioner argued that the statute of limitation has not yet run for the following reasons. First, Petitioner argued that the statute of limitations is tolled during STUDENT's minority. This argument fails, because the Ninth Circuit has specifically rejected the notion that the statute of limitations is tolled during a student's minority in Alexopulos, 817 F.2d at 555-556. In Alexopulos, the plaintiff claimed that the student's claims were still viable because the statute of limitations is tolled under Code of Civil Procedure § 352(a) (Footnote 4) during the time a person is under a disability, such as under the age of majority or insane. 817 F.2d at 555. The Court firmly rejected this argument in light of the federal policy behind the IDEA. The Alexopulos Court stated:
We hold that section 352 does not toll the limitations period under the [IDEA]. The [IDEA] is designed to assure that representatives of handicapped children would promptly assert the children's educational rights. To permit tolling in favor of the children would undercut this federal policy. ... [¶] ... Congress' desire to obtain timely and appropriate education for handicapped children by conferring substantial substantive and procedural rights on parents and guardians on behalf of their children clearly indicates that it did not intend to authorize filing of claims on behalf of or by the children many years after the alleged wrongdoing occurred. It is reasonable to assume that Congress expected and intended the child's representative to file actions and apply for hearings on his behalf near the time the contested event occurred. The child may not later come before a court and invoke the tolling provisions of state statutes.
817 F.2d at 555-556. Petitioner's contention that this conclusion of law should not be followed because of the earlier decision of Alexopulos v. Riles, 784 F.2d 1408 (9th Cir. 1986) is not well taken. While the Court in Alexopulos v. Riles appeared to toll the statute of limitations until the student reached the age of majority, the issue of tolling was neither raised nor discussed by that Court. 784 F.2d at 1411. On the other hand, in the later case of Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, the issue of tolling due to minority was specifically raised and unquestionably ruled on by the Court. 817 F.2d at 555-556. Thus, Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District represents binding Ninth Circuit precedent on the issue of tolling that is not to be ignored. Second, Petitioner argued that the District is estopped from raising the statute, because MOTHER relied on the District's representations that STUDENT's needs were being met. This argument is premised on the faulty proposition that the statute of limitations begins to run only when the claimant has a subjective realization of harm done. The Ninth Circuit has clearly articulated the test of when a statute of limitations begins to run, which does not rely on the question of when the claimant knew they had a claim: "Under federal law a cause of action accrues, and the statute of limitations begins to run, when a plaintiff knows or has reason to know of the injury that is the basis of the action." Alexopulos, 817 F.2d at 555 (emphasis added). In other words, the statute begins to run when the claimant knows or has reason to know of the facts underlying the claim, not when he believes or knows that he has a claim. Thus, Petitioner's estoppel argument is without merit. Id. Third, Petitioner argued that MOTHER did not know of the alleged injuries, such as failure to provide necessary speech and language services and failure to adequately assess or address STUDENT's "dyslexia" or reading difficulties, until she was informed of them through an evaluation conducted in 1997. This argument fails for the same reasons as cited above, i.e., that the statute of limitations does not begin to run upon the subjective realization of harm done.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner's IDEA claims are subject to a three-year statute of limitations, and that Petitioner knew or should have known of the injuries underlying his claims at or around the time the injuries occurred. As Petitioner did not request a hearing until November 12, 1997, any claims that accrued before November 12, 1994, are barred and were not considered. This does not mean, however, that evidence about events that occurred before November 12, 1994, were excluded. Some of the evidence was useful in providing historical information about STUDENT.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student who qualifies for special education due to a speech and language impairment and a serious emotional disturbance. STUDENT has attended school in the District since kindergarten.
During the 1990-91 school year while STUDENT was in kindergarten at a public school located within the District, he was found eligible for special education for the first time. His handicapping condition was described as speech impaired, and he received speech and language therapy one time per week for a minimum of thirty minutes to address his language needs. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT was exited from special education. He was then retained in kindergarten for the 1991-92 school year.
For the 1992-93 school year, STUDENT was moved into a first grade classroom at Liberty Elementary School, a public school within the District. On March 24, 1993, after the District performed an assessment, the IEP team found that STUDENT qualified for special education services based on a specific learning disability. The assessment had found that while STUDENT had average cognitive abilities, he exhibited a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading, as well as severe behavioral and emotional difficulties. Mr. Logan noted in his report that STUDENT was on medication for attention deficit disorder (ADD). Mr. Logan found that the medications seemed to lose their effectiveness in controlling STUDENT's outbursts after he had taken them for some months. Mr. Logan reported that STUDENT could be oppositional and aggressive in the classroom with teachers and fellow classmates. Mr. Logan recommended placement in the Elementary Intervention Program (EIP) at Mickey Cox Elementary School because it offered a small-group, structured setting with a therapeutic component, a recommendation which was approved by all members of the IEP team on March 24, 1993. STUDENT was transferred to the EIP later that month to complete the remainder of his first grade year.
STUDENT remained at the EIP for the next four academic years. The EIP is a District program designed for emotionally disturbed students whose needs cannot be met in a less restrictive environment. STUDENT's EIP classroom consisted of six to eight students, a teacher, and one to two instructional aides. The District also assigned a school psychologist and a nurse to the program. The Fresno County Department of Mental Health (Mental Health) provided a therapist, a recreational therapist and a psychiatrist for the mental health component of the program. The EIP staff met every week to discuss the progress of each student and any changes that needed to be made to help the student reach his or her goals.
On November 8, 1993, the IEP team added to STUDENT's program a mental health component including psychological consultation and the administration of medication (as needed). Six months later, the team changed STUDENT's primary handicapping condition to seriously emotionally disturbed.
During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT's fourth grade year, the District conducted STUDENT's triennial reevaluation. The District had completed STUDENT's previous assessment in November 1992. STUDENT's mother signed the assessment plan on September 27, 1995, and agreed to a thirty-day extension. However, on November 4, before the assessment was completed, STUDENT was admitted into the psychiatric unit of Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital (Cedar Vista) after he ran away during school and was picked up by the police. STUDENT's out-of-control behavior had been rapidly escalating to unmanageable levels. The behavior included explosive episodes, threats to others, aggressive behavior to peers and adults, oppositional behavior at home and at school, and suicide threats. STUDENT's private psychiatrists had prescribed a number of different psychotropic medications by that time, but none of them seemed to curb STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors.
In the week following his admittance to Cedar Vista, STUDENT was given a psychodiagnostic evaluation using the following tests and procedures: interviews with STUDENT and his mother, the Bender Visual/Motor Gestalt Test, the Draw a Person Test, the Draw a Family Test, the Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank, the Roberts Apperception Test for Children, the Rorshach, the Trail Making Test (Parts A and B), and the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III). The evaluators, Chris Bauer, B.A., a psychological trainee, and Stephen B. Bindler, Ph.D., the supervising psychologist, found STUDENT to be very oppositional and angry during testing, which necessitated placement in a "quiet room" several times over the course of testing. From the results of the testing, Mr. Bauer and Dr. Bindler concluded that the tests were negative for neuropsychological impairment, but that STUDENT's cognitive abilities were poor. STUDENT had achieved a verbal-scale intelligence quotient (IQ) of 59, a performance-scale IQ of 86, and a full-scale IQ of 70. The evaluation also found that STUDENT presented as "angry, defiant, and hyperactive," and was generally obstinate and noncompliant during testing. The evaluation report stated the following diagnostic impression:
STUDENT meets the DSM-IV criteria for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder. For example, he is not giving close attention to details, has difficulty maintaining attention to tasks, does not listen when spoken to directly, does not follow through on instructions, dislikes tasks that require sustained mental effort, is easily distracted by extraneous stimuli, fidgets with his hands and feet, leaves his seat when expected to remain seated, climbs excessively in situations in which it is inappropriate, and talks excessively. ... STUDENT also meets the DSM-IV criteria for oppositional defiant disorder. For instance, he often loses his temper, argues with adults, actively refuses to comply with adults' requests, deliberately annoys people, is easily annoyed, is angry and resentful, and is spiteful. Conduct Disorder is not an unlikely diagnosis as well.
The report concluded with a recommendation that STUDENT be placed in a behaviorally oriented residential treatment facility and that he continue in highly structured special education classes.
On November 21, 1995, after a meeting was held at Cedar Vista with school personnel and staff from Mental Health, STUDENT was discharged from inpatient care to Cedar Vista's partial hospitalization program, which STUDENT was to attend during the day. During the full hospitalization, a number of different medications had been tried with STUDENT. Two weeks later, on December 4, STUDENT was discharged from the partial hospitalization program because he exhibited better overall impulse control and was able to manage his emotions significantly better than previously.
After STUDENT was released by Cedar Vista, the District completed its triennial assessment. Jimmie Smothers, the school psychologist, administered parts of the Tests of Cognitive Ability and the Behavior Assessment System for Children, and reviewed the assessment conducted by Mr. Logan in 1992 and the recently conducted psychodiagnostic evaluation from Cedar Vista. Mr. Smothers concluded that STUDENT was functioning within the average range of cognitive ability, but that he had a learning disability. He also found that STUDENT's behavior was consistent with a significant attention deficit-hyperactive disorder (ADHD) with conduct disorder, and that he might be suffering from significant depression and from oppositional defiant disorder. Christy Wilson, STUDENT's EIP teacher since the 1993-94 school year, assessed STUDENT's academic achievement. She concluded that he was at the first grade instructional level in reading, at the mid-first grade instructional level in basic mathematics, and between the first and second grade instructional levels in written language. She found that STUDENT improved socially and emotionally after his hospitalization at Cedar Vista, although he still exhibited a number of defiant and oppositional behaviors. The assessment team concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education and recommended continued placement in the EIP. During an IEP meeting held on January 29, 1996, the IEP team agreed with the assessment team's recommendations and continued STUDENT in the EIP.
For the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was placed in the upper-grade EIP classroom taught by Art Richards. Near the end of the fall semester, on November 4, 1996, the IEP team met for the annual review. STUDENT's mother was concerned that the incidences of acting-out appeared to be on the rise again. The team discussed the concerns relating to STUDENT's behavior and agreed on a plan that included participation in a token economy/level system to encourage good behavior and time-outs for self-control. Near the beginning of the second semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was returned to Christy Wilson's EIP classroom and was integrated into a learning handicapped special day class (SDC) for academics.
The IEP team met again on June 9, 1997, to discuss STUDENT's placement for the 1997-98 school year and to consider a change to a less restrictive environment. The team agreed that STUDENT needed a small-group setting and a program that emphasized academics. Based on these considerations, the team agreed that STUDENT should be placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) at Gettysburg Elementary School, which was taught by a person already familiar to STUDENT, Christy Wilson's husband, Todd Wilson. STUDENT was to spend twenty-six percent of the school day in general education during activities such as lunch, recess, physical education, field trips and other selected activities. The team agreed that reading instruction would be on a one-on-one basis.On June 10, 1997, STUDENT completed an independent assessment that was begun seven days earlier with Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist, and Beckie M. Jensen, M.A., a psychological assistant. The assessment was performed by administration of the following tests: Draw a Person: Projective Test, House Tree Person: Projective Test, Kinetic Family Drawing: Projective Test, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Revised (WISC-R), the Oaks Checklist for Attention & Related Disorders (child/adolescent version), the Visual Retention Test, and the Test of Variables of Attention. Dr. West and Ms. Jensen concluded that STUDENT's broad cognitive ability appeared to be within the borderline range. They found that the test results suggested a relative strength in performance abilities, but significant limitations with regard to verbal tasks, and cognitive limitations surrounding attention, short-term memory, auditory memory, freedom from distractibility, and numerical ability. They also found that his internal concerns centered around anxiety and tension, high energy, feelings of constriction and feelings of inadequacy. They recommended using visual aids and hands-on activities to help STUDENT learn, and therapy to increase his self-esteem and facilitate a positive self-concept. During the summer of 1997, Dr. West also used biofeedback with STUDENT in an attempt to help him with his ADHD. Also during the summer, STUDENT's mother and Janet Van Gelder, the District's director of special education, agreed that STUDENT should be referred to the State Diagnostic Center for evaluation.
On September 11, 1997, STUDENT began receiving after-school services two times per week (one hour per session) at the Cullinan Education Center (Cullinan Center), which is directed by its founder, Joann Cullinan. STUDENT's mother enrolled him at the Cullinan Center, because she had become increasingly frustrated by the fact that STUDENT's reading skills were still at the mid-first grade instructional level. The Cullinan Center offers tutoring for students who exhibit weaknesses in reading, writing and spelling. Its curriculum is based on an adaptation of the Orton-Gillingham method, a multi-sensory, kinesthetic, tactile, and intensive phonic approach to teaching reading. At the Cullinan Center, STUDENT received one-on-one "language therapy" in an isolated environment with a credentialed teacher. Ms. Cullinan estimated that STUDENT would need approximately three hundred hours of language therapy from the Cullinan Center in order to complete its lesson plan.
By late September or early October 1997, the District was able to compile the complete referral packet for the Diagnostic Center and submitted it with the following questions for the Diagnostic Center to specifically address: "What techniques will improve STUDENT's reading?"; "What interventions will improve overall behavior and compliance?"; "Does STUDENT have a continued need for individual psychological therapy?"; "What are STUDENT's pre-vocational interests, and given his functioning, what are some projected career exploration objectives?"; and "What is STUDENT's language functioning and how can language skills be improved?" The District also indicated on the referral form that it wanted a language assessment performed.
About November 1997, STUDENT's mother retained the services of attorney Thomas Guarino from the firm of Myers & Overstreet. On behalf of MOTHER, Mr. Guarino requested that the District perform an assessment to determine whether STUDENT was dyslexic, reimburse MOTHER for past expenses incurred with the Cullinan Center, and assume the obligation to pay for future services at the Center. While the District refused to reimburse or pay for expenses associated with the Cullinan Center, on November 12, 1997, it developed a plan for assessment in the following areas: health and development; cognitive; academic achievement; communicative development; and personal, social and emotional development. The plan included, inter alia, classroom observation and a behavioral functional analysis assessment. MOTHER signed the assessment plan on November 12. On November 13, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing.
The District's assessment was completed by Jimmie Smothers, the school psychologist; Todd Wilson, STUDENT's RSP teacher; Jody Lehman, a program specialist; Kaye Rush, a speech and language therapist; and Randi Schoneman, R.N., the school nurse. Mr. Smothers completed the psychological-educational evaluation and functional analysis assessment in late 1997. Mr. Smothers administered the following tests: the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, the Leiter International Performance Scale - Revised, the Tests of Cognitive Ability, the Adaptive Behavior Evaluation Scale (School Version) - Revised, the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, the Attention Deficit Disorders Evaluation Scale (School Version) - Second Edition, and the Behavior Assessment System for Children. He also observed STUDENT in the classroom setting. Mr. Smothers found that STUDENT performed in the "slow learner" range of cognitive ability, especially in the areas of verbal, abstract/visual and quantitative reasoning, and with tasks requiring either short-term visual or auditory memory skills. Mr. Smothers also found that STUDENT had difficulty with tracking across a page and with the rapid processing of visual information, both of which could impact tasks such as decoding skills in reading and the testing of math facts. Mr. Smothers noted that STUDENT's behavior was consistent with his previous diagnosis of ADHD, but that STUDENT became more focused on tasks when in a group of two or less (excluding the teacher or assistant). Mr. Smothers concluded his report with the following:
STUDENT's observed and reported behaviors suggest an attention deficit hyperactive disorder. Both current observations and history seem to concur with this conclusion. ... STUDENT's ratings for behaviors associated with oppositional defiant disorder tended to be relatively high compared with the general population for his age group. ... Although STUDENT may not be experiencing a significant depression at this time, he is showing significant symptoms of a developing depression. This development is not unusual for children who are experiencing attentional deficit hyperactive disorder or oppositional defiant disorder.
Ms. Lehman completed her portion of the assessment by January 4, 1997. She used the following tests to assess STUDENT's academic achievement in reading, math and written language: the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test - Form B, the Test of Written Spelling, the Burns-Roe Informal Reading Inventory, Concepts of Print - Marie Clay, High Frequency Words (Early and Upper Emergent), sections of the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude - II, and informal measures using phonetic words and words from the Stevenson Reading Program. She also observed STUDENT during one of his instructional sessions at the Cullinan Center. Ms. Lehman found that, although STUDENT had developed some reading skills, he could not read meaningfully even at a preprimer level because he had not integrated the developed skills. She also found that he tended to use pictures as context clues and that he could read better when the story was read to him first or when he was given an overview of the story before beginning reading. When reading independently, STUDENT failed to gather enough information from the preprimer selections to pass the comprehension test. STUDENT's math skills were slightly higher than his reading: he performed at the mid-first grade to beginning third grade levels in math. With regard to written language, although STUDENT could pass weekly spelling tests when the words were taken from his reading and he was allowed a week to study, he was unable to maintain correct spelling of the words for an extended period of time. Ms. Lehman found that STUDENT spelled phonetically and was usually able to correctly spell the first and last sounds of words. All other portions of the District's assessment were completed by at least January 23, 1998.
On January 28, 1998, the IEP team met (with the mediator present) to review the District's assessment results and STUDENT's educational program. At this meeting, the category of language/speech impaired was added to serious emotional disturbance as a category of eligibility. The District offered STUDENT continued placement in the RSP with speech and language therapy three times per week for twenty minutes per session, and twenty minutes of psychological consultation services per week. But, as the mediator had to leave early, the team agreed to continue the meeting on a later date.
In late January, MOTHER took STUDENT to be evaluated by psychologist Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., and Kiki L. Wells, M.A., his wife and a registered psychological assistant. From January 26 until February 20, the Wellses used the following tests and procedures in order to assess STUDENT: ANSER Parent Questionnaire, the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, the Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests - Revised, the Wide Range Assessment of Learning and Memory, the Conners Continuous Performance Test (administered by the Neuro-Diagnostic School), the Rorschach Inkblot Test, the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist - Parent Version, and a diagnostic interview. The Wellses concluded that STUDENT suffered from ADD (which was not being controlled with his current medication), a severe reading disability, a severe language processing disorder, and oppositional defiant behavioral disorder, and that he appeared to be undergoing a major depressive episode. The Wellses' report recommended one-to-one tutoring using the Orton-Gillingham method and individual language therapy intervention.
During the week of February 23, 1998, the Diagnostic Center completed its assessment of STUDENT. The assessment team included Sylvia Bowland, M.A., an education specialist; Larry Hughes, Ph.D., a school psychologist; Lynn Negus, M.D., the staff pediatrician; Pamela K. Vives, M.A., a speech-language pathologist; and Jeff Lumsden, M.S., a transition specialist. The team used the following tests and procedures to assess STUDENT: the Kaufman Adolescent & Adult Intelligence Test, the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills, the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist - Revised, the Children's Depression Inventory, the Revised Children's Manifest Anxiety Scale, the Roberts Apperception Test for Children, the Sentence Completion Test, Analysis of the Language of Learning, Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude, the Fullerton Language Test for Adolescents - Revised Edition, Oral and Written Language Scales, SCAN-A: A Screening Test for Auditory Processing Disorders in Adolescents and Adults, the Woodcock Language Proficiency Battery - Revised PGM, the Roswell-Chall Auditory Blending Test, the Roswell-Chall Diagnostic Reading Test, the Peabody Individual Achievement Test, the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test, the Street Survival Skills Questionnaire, and the Reading-Free Vocational Interest Inventory. The team found that the overall assessment results were compatible with the most recent diagnoses of ADHD, oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), learning disabled, and depression. The team noted that, academically, STUDENT generally functioned at the first to second grade level in most areas, which was consistent with his poor language abilities. The team concluded that his instructional reading level continued to be the first grade, but that his math skills were somewhat higher (2.9 grade level). The written report stated the following:
Recent evaluations of cognitive functioning have resulted in scores at or below the ‘borderline' range; however, his profile of abilities has been quite scattered. Previous and current assessments suggested significant deficits in STUDENT's abilities within the language domain. Current assessment also suggests that STUDENT's cognitive style is characterized by a reduced degree of cognitive flexibility. STUDENT's lowered level of cognitive functioning, as well as his language, auditory and visual memory deficits, are believed to be direct contributors to his academic difficulties.
The report noted that because STUDENT had limited resources to deal with conflict or emotional stress, he remained at high risk for further behavioral or emotional disorder. The team suggested that STUDENT be taught to recognize the nature of his learning disability and the impact of ADHD on his efforts to learn. With regard to improving STUDENT's reading skills, the team recommended that STUDENT develop a functional sight-word vocabulary which could be generalized to the real world, increase his use of context clues, and use visual cues for miscalled words. The team also recommended that STUDENT continue to receive individual psychological therapy and receive specific language intervention. On March 5, 1998, the Diagnostic Center assessment team held a conference with MOTHER and District personnel to discuss these findings.
On March 11, the IEP team met to continue its discussion about STUDENT's educational program. MOTHER agreed with the bulk of the District's proposed educational program, but wanted additional services and reimbursement for past expenses. Specifically, the IEP team agreed that for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT would remain in the RSP with twenty-six percent of the school day spent in the general education program. He would receive ninety minutes of speech and language services every week; receive thirty minutes of direct psychological counseling services every week; have the psychologist consult with his teachers for thirty minutes each week; have a RSP teacher act as his case manager for an average of sixty minutes every week; and receive instruction in reading, math, written language, behavior and vocational skills in a small-group setting (RSP setting) for up to three hundred minutes per day. The IEP team agreed that for the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT's educational program would remain the same as the above except that he would be in the RSP for four periods per day and be mainstreamed during approximately two periods per day. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT should receive extended school year services. MOTHER did not agree to the District's proposed referral to Mental Health under AB 3632. MOTHER requested the following additional services: two one-hour sessions at the Cullinan Center every week; travel costs at the District rate for transportation to the Cullinan Center; one-on-one sessions in RSP during the 1997-98 school year, the extended school year, and the 1998-99 school year; instruction in prevocational skills, as delineated by the Diagnostic Center in its draft report; counseling/psychotherapy provided by Dr. Wells rather than Mental Health; an RSP teacher trained in the Orton-Gillingham method; and reimbursement for past expenses related to the Cullinan Center, Dr. Wells' assessment and appearance at the IEP meeting, Dr. West's assessment, and attorney's fees and costs.
About three weeks later on April 4, MOTHER took STUDENT to be assessed by Bonita N. Ekhardt, M.S., a licensed educational psychologist from the Aslan Center. Ms. Ekhardt met with STUDENT for three and a half hours, reviewed reports from his prior assessments and IEP documents, and administered the WISC-III. Ms. Ekhardt found that STUDENT scored in the borderline to mildly retarded range of functioning on the WISC-III, and that a severe discrepancy existed between ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading (reading recognition) and reading comprehension. She also found that a learning handicap existed in the area of attention which was contributing to STUDENT's lack of achievement in academic areas. Finally, she found that STUDENT might have a serious emotional disturbance due to depression. She recommended that STUDENT receive individual psychotherapy to address adjustment to the ADD and depression, group therapy to work on socialization skills, at least monthly psychiatric consultations for medication management, and speech and language therapy in the areas of auditory processing and the other areas cited by the Diagnostic Center and the District. Ms. Ekhardt also noted that STUDENT appeared to be a good candidate for EEG biofeedback to address his ADD. The written report from this evaluation was issued on April 20, 1998.
On May 18, the IEP team met for further discussions about STUDENT's educational program for the 1998-99 school year. The District offered STUDENT placement in the RSP with fifty-six percent of the school day spent in the general education program during activities such as breaks, lunches, physical education and electives. The District also offered sixty minutes of speech and language services every week, thirty minutes of direct psychological services every week, psychological consultation services as needed, a referral to Mental Health under AB 3632, and a case manager to supervise and coordinate STUDENT's program an average of sixty minutes every week. Finally, the District offered up to thirty minutes of consultation with teachers and/or the parent in all areas every week; a supported classroom for two periods in courses such as computer, health, and agriculture; and small-group instruction for four periods in courses such as history, English, literature and math (with one of the periods to consist of one to two students with a teacher for reading instruction). MOTHER did not indicate her agreement with any portion of this proposed program. Instead, she requested that Jonathan Logan continue to work with STUDENT, that STUDENT attend the Fast Forward program in addition to the Cullinan Center, and that STUDENT be placed in a regular education science class with support. At the conclusion of the meeting, the IEP team agreed to continue to work on the goals from the previous IEP and to meet again later to agree on the details of STUDENT's program for the 1998-99 school year.
The IEP team met again two months later on July 27 to continue its discussions about the program for the 1998-99 school year. The District created a detailed addendum outlining the components of its proposed program, which was similar to the program proposed at the meeting on May 18 but contained more detail. It offered STUDENT placement in the RSP academic core program at Clark Intermediate School with forty-three percent of the school day spent in the general education program. The proposed program included thirty minutes of speech and language services in a small-group setting every week, thirty minutes of speech and language services provided in class every week, thirty minutes of one-on-one psychological services every week, ninety minutes every week of small-group therapy with other ADHD students and the school psychologist for support and understanding of ADHD for nine to twelve weeks, a referral to Mental Health under AB 3632, a case manager to coordinate all services and communicate with MOTHER for an average of sixty minutes every week, and thirty minutes of consultation by the school psychologist with STUDENT's teachers every week. The District also offered a supported classroom for electives (services to include daily monitoring of classroom performance and progress by an instructional assistant (IA) or RSP teacher until STUDENT is able to function independently, assistance by an IA or RSP teacher in devising appropriate modifications and accommodations, and support by an IA or RSP teacher as needed); and small-group instruction for two hundred minutes every day during courses such as history, English, literature and math. The District proposed that the RSP reading and literature period consist of twenty to thirty minutes of STUDENT using the Auto Skill Academy of Reading Program (a computer program) while being monitored on a one-on-one basis by an IA or RSP teacher, and one-on-one reading instruction with an IA or teacher using materials involving areas of high interest to STUDENT. Additionally, the District proposed that the teachers, IAs, learning director, school psychologist and Student Assistance Program (SAP) counselor working with STUDENT attend a ninety-minute information and training meeting regarding STUDENT's disabilities, strengths, IEP and accommodation requirements before the beginning of the school year. The information and training meeting would be hosted by Jody Lehman with participation by the parent. Finally, the District offered weekly reports (as needed) by the case manager with respect to STUDENT's behavior and academic progress. MOTHER did not indicate agreement with any portions of this proposed IEP.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Education Code § 56363(b). Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management. Finally, medical services may also be a necessary related service, but only to the extent that such services are for diagnostic and evaluation purposes. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?
To determine whether a school district provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District's program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program reflects the child's needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the child's IEP, the school district provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents' preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208. Special education law also requires that a child be educated in the least restrictive environment, and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the child's disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.
Thus, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District's program for the 1997-98 school year must have met the following four requirements: been designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, provided him with some educational benefit, comported with his IEP, and been provided in the least restrictive environment. Each of these elements will be addressed in turn.
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The first step in the analysis, then, is to determine what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year. There is no dispute that STUDENT had serious difficulties with academics, especially reading and reading comprehension, and that he continued to have some behavioral and emotional issues that affected his education. By all accounts, however, his oppositional behavior and ability to attend had considerably improved from that which was seen during his four years in the EIP. Jimmie Smothers, the school psychologist who had worked with STUDENT for the past three years in the EIP and was the school psychologist assigned to Gettysburg, testified that STUDENT became less outwardly defiant and oppositional. He was more polite, not as explosive, reactionary and impulsive, and was more likely to talk about what was bothering him. According to Mr. Smothers, STUDENT was still pervasively unhappy, anxious about his basic academic skills, fearful about not being able to make friends, and suffering from low self-esteem. STUDENT also still exhibited attention problems, especially when presented with more complex tasks. All those who assessed STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year agreed that he had an auditory processing problem and needed a multi-modality approach to learning. The assessors also agreed that STUDENT should be taught through a thematic approach using subjects of high interest to him such as science and animals, and in small chunks or segments in order to compensate for his poor auditory and visual memory and low frustration tolerance.
Having determined what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District's educational program was designed to meet those unique needs. During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT was placed in the RSP (academic core program) at Gettysburg Elementary School in a class taught by Todd Wilson, a person already familiar to STUDENT through Christy Wilson (STUDENT's EIP teacher during the preceding four years). Mr. Wilson taught the RSP class with the assistance of two classroom aides. According to the testimony of Jody Lehman, the program specialist, Mr. Wilson's RSP class was selected for STUDENT because STUDENT was already familiar with Mr. Wilson through Ms. Wilson, and Mr. Wilson had a master's degree in educational counseling and had worked for a psychiatric hospital for two to three years. STUDENT received instruction in basic academic subjects such as reading, math and written language in the RSP class in a small-group setting (groups consisting of two to five students each). He also received thirty minutes of one-on-one instruction in reading every day in the RSP class using the Stevenson method, and had opportunities to practice in different readers. Ms. Lehman, who frequently observed STUDENT at school and helped Mr. Wilson modify the program for STUDENT, testified that the assignments were modified to STUDENT's level of functioning and in a manner that allowed STUDENT to achieve eighty to a hundred percent accuracy on the assignments. Ms. Lehman testified that the assignments were carefully sequenced, were often presented in the context of topics of interest to STUDENT, were accompanied by visual aides (such as overhead projections or writings on the chalkboard), and often consisted of hands-on activities or discussions. Ms. Lehman also testified that, to help maintain STUDENT's attention, STUDENT was given preferential seating and the option of moving to a quiet desk away from the station that he shared with others.
STUDENT was mainstreamed with the regular education program during twenty-six percent of the school day for activities such as lunch, recess, physical education, field trips, classroom presentations, assemblies, and other selected activities (such as art, music, hands-on science activities, and class discussions). STUDENT's mainstream teacher was Patricia Manghera. According to Ms. Lehman's testimony, Ms. Manghera was selected for STUDENT because she retained excellent control of her classroom, engaged in varied activities with her class, and had worked at a psychiatric hospital previously. Ms. Manghera's regular education sixth-grade class consisted of thirty-five students, including STUDENT. The class was divided into groups of seven students each, with the groups being changed every two weeks. STUDENT attended the morning opening session in Ms. Manghera's classroom for approximately the first forty-five to sixty minutes of the school day for the attendance count, current events presentations by students, and the completion of five math problemsper day (Ms. Manghera wrote the problems specifically for STUDENT and corrected his work, helping him in any areas of difficulty). After the morning opening session, STUDENT returned to Mr. Wilson's RSP class until recess, which he spent with Ms. Manghera's class. Ms. Manghera testified that STUDENT also returned to her class to participate in any hands-on activities (such as simulations, art projects, video presentations, trips to the library and media center activities) and physical education. According to Ms. Manghera's testimony, STUDENT also participated in the sustained silent writing assignment that her class engaged in every week. For this assignment, Ms. Manghera presented the class with a topic on which they had to brainstorm and write a brief essay.
Mr. Smothers consulted with STUDENT's teachers for thirty minutes every month. Mr. Smothers helped Mr. Wilson develop and use a checks and rewards behavior-management system during the first two-thirds of the school year in the RSP class, which was similar to the system that had been used with STUDENT during the previous four years in the EIP. Mr. Smothers testified that the system consisted of placing checkmarks on the chalkboard. According to the functional analysis assessment report prepared in December 1997, STUDENT received a check mark on the board if he did not comply with the teacher's directive. The first checkmark acted as a warning, the second was an additional warning that a privilege might be lost, and the third resulted in the loss of a privilege. The loss of a privilege was avoided, however, if STUDENT demonstrated appropriate behavior, which resulted in checkmarks being removed and the lost privilege being restored. The report also noted that STUDENT was "motivated" to improve his behavior with notifications that his mother would be contacted by telephone, and with brief time-outs in the office under the supervision of the site guidance instructional specialist. Finally, positive reinforcement was used with STUDENT. For good behavior and completing assigned tasks at a predetermined accuracy level, STUDENT was given frequent feedback and praise, and rewards (such as "free time" during which STUDENT was able to engage in preferred activities).
Following the IEP meetings held in January and March, although STUDENT's basic placement remained the same, certain services were added to his educational program with MOTHER's permission. First, language and speech therapy was provided for ninety minutes every week. Second, thirty minutes of direct psychological counseling were provided every week by school psychologist Jonathan Logan. Third, STUDENT's RSP teacher was appointed his case manager and provided an average of sixty minutes of service every week in this capacity. Fourth, the team adopted a behavioral intervention plan (BIP), developed as a result of the functional analysis assessment performed by Mr. Smothers and Mr. Wilson. The IEP team also offered a referral to Mental Health under AB 3632, but this was refused by MOTHER.
Petitioner argued that the above educational program was not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs because speech and language therapy was not provided during the first half of the school year, one-on-one instruction in a quiet or isolated environment was not provided for reading, and necessary mental health services were not provided. Each argument will be addressed in turn.
First, there is no evidence that Petitioner required speech and language therapy during the first half of the 1997-98 school year in order to benefit from his education. Petitioner offered the testimony and report of Ms. Ekhardt to support his position that speech and language therapy should have been provided during the first half of the 1997-98 school year. Ms. Ekhardt is a licensed educational psychologist who received a bachelor of arts degree in psychology in 1980 and a master of science degree in psychology in 1983, both from the California State University at Stanislaus. After receiving her master's degree, Ms. Ekhardt worked as a psychological assistant for Valley Psychological Services for four years, as a psychologist for the Kern County Superintendent of Schools for four years, and as the current director of the Aslan Center for the past eleven years. Ms. Ekhardt candidly admitted that speech impairments are not her area of expertise and that she could not recall under what circumstances designated instructional services are to be provided to a student. Despite these admissions, Ms. Ekhardt asserted that since STUDENT qualified for speech and language therapy in kindergarten and qualifies at the present time, there is no reason not to assume that he did not qualify for therapy all along. Ms. Ekhardt provided no evidentiary support nor rational basis for her assertion. Standing alone, Ms. Ekhardt's bald assertion does not establish that STUDENT should have been provided speech and language therapy during the first half of the 1997-98 school year. Additionally, Kaye Rush testified that, even during the first half of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT's educational program addressed his speech and language needs to the extent necessary. Ms. Rush has worked as a speech and language therapist in school districts for the past nineteen years, has a bachelor's and a master's degree in communicative disorders with an emphasis in speech pathology, and has a clinical rehabilitative services credential. Ms. Rush performed a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT in December 1997, using assessment procedures such as the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, the Listening Test, and the Phonological Awareness Test. Ms. Rush also reviewed STUDENT's records. She testified that, as with the IEPs developed in the second half of the 1997-98 school years, STUDENT's IEP dated November 6, 1996, contained a number of goals and objectives that addressed STUDENT's speech and language needs. For example, according to Ms. Rush's testimony, STUDENT's IEP dictated that STUDENT receive more hands-on activities and a thematic approach to teaching, and work on his social language skills through discussions about his relationships with peers. Ms. Lehman testified that these directives were being implemented in STUDENT's program. Thus, there is no evidence that STUDENT's speech and language needs were not being appropriately met during the first half of the 1997-98 school year. (Footnote 5)
Second, there is no evidence that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction in a quiet or isolated environment to benefit from his education in reading. The testimony of Ms. Jody Lehman established that STUDENT did receive thirty minutes of one-on-one instruction every day, but that it was provided in the RSP classroom with others present. While there was general agreement that STUDENT still suffered from ADHD and thus had difficulty maintaining his attention and focus, the testimony and documentary evidence did not establish that he was unable to benefit from one-on-one instruction with others present in the room or with some degree of noise. Ms. Ekhardt testified only that STUDENT should be placed in a small class with few distractions during testing, and that it would be preferable for STUDENT to keep receiving instruction at the Cullinan Center (where he is taught in a quiet and isolated environment) because he seemed to focus better at the Cullinan Center than at school. She did not, however, testify that he required a quiet or isolated environment to benefit from one-on-one instruction in reading, as did none of the other witnesses. For example, Sylvia Bowland, the educational consultant who was part of the Diagnostic Center's assessment team, testified that she expected that STUDENT would perform better in an environment with little distractions but did not testify that he needed a quiet or isolated environment to benefit from his education.
Finally, with regard to mental health services, the evidence established that STUDENT's emotional and behavioral needs were not adequately addressed during the first part of the 1997-98 school year. Although STUDENT had just been exited from an intensive intervention program for seriously emotionally disturbed students (where he had been placed for emotional and behavioral issues for the last four academic years) and all those working with him agreed that he continued to have emotional and behavioral issues that affected his education, STUDENT received no direct psychological consultation, nor was a behavior intervention plan developed on his behalf at Gettysburg until the second half of the school year. Peggy Ruud, the licensed clinical social worker who counseled STUDENT while he was in the EIP, testified that by the time STUDENT left the EIP he was still very wilful and uncooperative at times, and he still had difficulties with peer interaction. Additionally, all five assessments performed from June 1997 to April 1998 found that STUDENT was suffering from serious emotional and behavioral issues that were affecting his ability to benefit from his education. The District's assessment performed in late 1997 found that STUDENT exhibited behaviors consistent with ADHD that impacted the learning process for basic academic skills, such as difficulty sustaining attention to task, failure to give close attention to details in school work, not following through with instructions, failure to complete work, and leaving his seat in the classroom during academic activities. The District's assessment also found that STUDENT's behaviors suggested ODD and significant symptoms of a developing depression. The District's findings were corroborated by the Diagnostic Center's assessment findings in February 1998. The Center found that STUDENT exhibited behaviors consistent with ADHD, ODD, depression, and a learning disability. The Center's report concluded that STUDENT "would clearly benefit from individual psychological therapy" to restore his self-esteem, assist him in recognizing the nature of his learning disability and the impact of ADHD on his efforts to learn, and address issues of depression and anxiety. Mr. Smothers, the school psychologist who performed the District's assessment, testified that he agreed with the Center's findings. Dr. West's assessment in June 1997, Dr. Wells' assessment in February 1998, and Ms. Ekhardt's assessment in April 1998 also corroborated the need for mental health services such as therapy for needs arising out of ADHD, depression and anxiety.
During the first half of the school year and until March 11, 1998, the District failed to provide STUDENT appropriate services to address his apparent difficulties with attention, behavior and social-emotional issues such as depression, anxiety and an inability to get along with his peers, all of which affected his ability to benefit from his education. Until March 11, the District provided STUDENT with only monthly consultation with his teachers by the school psychologist and an informal behavior plan that was developed without the benefit of a functional analysis assessment. Given the nature and extent of his behavior and emotional difficulties, the Hearing Officer finds that this was insufficient to address the serious difficulties that STUDENT was experiencing in these areas. Only on March 11, 1998, did the District begin to offer STUDENT appropriate mental health services in the form of thirty minutes of direct psychological counseling every week, thirty minutes of psychological consultation with his teachers every week, and a behavior intervention plan developed by Mr. Smothers (with the assistance of Mr. Wilson). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's educational program for the 1997-98 school year was not designed to meet all of his unique needs until March 11, 1998. Prior to March 11, the District's program lacked critical services that were necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.
Provide Some Educational Benefit
There was no evidence that STUDENT received educational benefit from the District's educational program during the first two-thirds of the school year. For example, although STUDENT's program ostensibly continued to work on the goals and objectives contained in his IEP dated November 4, 1996, during that time, there was no evidence that STUDENT accomplished or made any strides towards accomplishing any of those goals and objectives. Thus, the District failed to establish that STUDENT was provided with any educational benefit during the first two-thirds of the school year.
However, there was evidence that STUDENT received educational benefit from his educational program from March 11, 1998, to June 1998. On March 11, the District offered an additional thirty minutes of speech and language services, an additional thirty minutes of direct psychological consultation per week, and the implementation of a BIP. Additionally, the IEP team agreed to new goals and objectives for STUDENT, some of which had benchmarks set for June 12, 1998. With MOTHER's approval, these and other elements of the District's proposed program were implemented on March 11. According to Ms. Rush's testimony, by June 1998, STUDENT had met some of his speech and language goals. After MOTHER's approval of the addition of speech and language therapy to STUDENT's program on March 11, 1998, Ms. Rush consulted with the speech therapists working directly with STUDENT, observed a number of STUDENT's speech therapy sessions, and consulted with Mr. Wilson to determine STUDENT's progress with his goals. Ms. Rush testified that STUDENT had met the following goals by June 1998: identify an object taken from units of classroom study when the object is described by the teacher or another student with eighty percent accuracy; identify a word or phrase that did not belong or make sense in a sentence presented orally with eighty percent accuracy; and complete story "maps" or organizers with picture clues and teacher cuing or questioning with eighty percent accuracy. Additionally, Ms. Lehman testified that, by June 1998, STUDENT had met all three reading goals that had been set for June 12, 1998. According to Ms. Lehman, STUDENT met the following reading goals: decode phonetically regular words with beginning two-letter blends combined with word families with eighty percent accuracy; identify forty functional words when presented individually on flashcards with eighty percent accuracy; and read a preprimer selection orally from a high-interest second grade book (with the teacher immediately supplying difficult words) and answer comprehension questions.
Based on all the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds there was no evidence that the District's program provided STUDENT with any educational benefit from the beginning of the 1997-98 school year until March 11, 1998. The District's program did provide STUDENT with some educational benefit from March 11, 1998, to June 1998.
Comport With the IEP
There was neither evidence nor argument that STUDENT's educational program failed to comport with his IEP.
Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment
There was no evidence that STUDENT's program should have included more mainstreaming opportunities than it did during the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT was mainstreamed for activities such as lunch, recess, physical education, field trips, classroom presentations, assemblies, and other selected activities (such as art, music, hands-on science activities, and class discussions). Patricia Manghera, STUDENT's mainstream teacher, testified that STUDENT also joined her class to participate in any hands-on activities (such as simulations, art projects, video presentations, trips to the library and media center activities), physical education, and a weekly sustained silent writing assignment. Thus, the mainstream opportunities STUDENT had were specifically selected with consideration of his unique needs, which included behavioral and emotional issues and his academic abilities which were grades behind those of his peers. Even Ms. Ekhardt agreed that it would not have been appropriate to suddenly place STUDENT in regular education when he had been placed in an intensive special education program for the last four academic years. There was no evidence that STUDENT would have been able to obtain educational benefit from any further mainstreaming opportunities. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's educational program occurred in the least restrictive environment given his unique needs.
*****
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year until March 11, 1998. Until March 11, the District's program failed to address STUDENT's serious emotional and behavioral needs. Additionally, there was no evidence that the District's program provided STUDENT with educational benefit until March 11.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year?
For the 1998-99 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement at Clark Intermediate School in the RSP academic core program with forty-three percent of the school day spent in the general education program. The proposed program included thirty minutes of speech and language services in a small-group setting every week, thirty minutes of speech and language services provided in class every week, thirty minutes of one-on-one psychological services every week, ninety minutes every week of small-group therapy with other ADHD students and the school psychologist for support and understanding of ADHD for nine to twelve weeks, a referral to Mental Health under AB 3632, a case manager to coordinate all services and communicate with MOTHER for an average of sixty minutes every week, and thirty minutes of consultation by the school psychologist with STUDENT's teachers every week. The District also offered a supported classroom for electives (services to include daily monitoring of classroom performance and progress by an instructional assistant (IA) or RSP teacher until STUDENT is able to function independently, assistance by an IA or RSP teacher in devising appropriate modifications and accommodations, and support by an IA or RSP teacher as needed) and small-group instruction for two hundred minutes every day during courses such as history, English, literature and math. The District proposed that the RSP reading and literature period consist of twenty to thirty minutes of STUDENT using the Auto Skill Academy of Reading Program (a computer program) while being monitored on a one-on-one basis by an IA or RSP teacher, and one-on-one reading instruction with an IA or teacher using materials involving areas of high interest to STUDENT.
Additionally, the District proposed that the teachers, IAs, learning director, school psychologist and other staff working with STUDENT attend a ninety-minute information and training meeting regarding STUDENT's disabilities, strengths, IEP and accommodation requirements before the beginning of the school year. The information and training meeting would be hosted by Ms. Lehman with participation by the parent. Finally, the District offered weekly reports (as needed) by the case manager with respect to STUDENT's behavior and academic progress. Meanwhile, STUDENT's behavior in the classroom would be managed by a BIP that included strategies to inhibit problem behaviors and strategies to increase positive replacement behaviors. The District proposed Mr. Smothers as the behavior intervention case manager. He would consult weekly with teachers and staff to ensure implementation of the plan.
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
There was neither evidence nor argument that the District's proposed program for the 1998-99 school year did not meet STUDENT's unique needs, apart from a solitary argument by Petitioner. Petitioner argued that the District's proposed program is inappropriate because it does not include one-on-one reading instruction through the Orton-Gillingham method in a quiet or isolated environment at the Cullinan Center. Petitioner's argument was not supported by the evidence. First, as discussed in detail above, there was no evidence that STUDENT requires a quiet or isolated environment for reading instruction to benefit from his education. Second, the District's proposed program contains approximately five hours of one-on-one instruction in reading per week using methods and strategies found acceptable by all those who assessed STUDENT in this area, including Ms. Bowland from the Diagnostic Center and Ms. Lehman. For example, the Auto Skill Academy of Reading Program focuses on phonemic awareness, decoding skills (phonics), and comprehension skills. Additionally, the direct instruction in reading skills will utilize materials of high-interest to STUDENT. Finally, STUDENT's goals and objectives focus on issues found appropriate by the assessors, such as building his functional sight-word vocabulary and developing his phonemic awareness.
While Ms. Ekhardt did testify that STUDENT needs further instruction at the Cullinan Center because he "seemed" to perform better at the Cullinan Center than at school, there was no evidentiary support or explanation for her assertion. Ms. Ekhardt admitted that she had neither visited the Cullinan Center nor observed STUDENT receive instruction at the Center. Additionally, she testified that she was familiar with the Orton-Gillingham method, which the Center uses, at only a very cursory level. Furthermore, because Ms. Ekhardt provided her testimony in April 1998, before the District made its final placement offer in July 1998, her opinion did not take into consideration the program proposed by the District for the 1998-99 school year, which was substantially different from that provided during the 1997-98 school year. Thus, there is no evidence that STUDENT requires placement at the Cullinan Center or instruction through the Orton-Gillingham method to benefit from his education. In any case, the Supreme Court has made clear that the choice of the educational method most suitable to the child's needs was left to the state and local educational agencies responsible for educating the child. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207.
With regard to the District's proposed program as a whole, the evidence established that it is designed to meet STUDENT's needs in the educational setting. For example, his emotional and behavioral needs would be addressed by the proposed behavior intervention plan, individual and group therapy, and weekly psychological consultation. The District has also proposed a referral to Mental Health under AB 3632. STUDENT's speech and language needs would be addressed by the proposed ninety minutes of speech and language therapy every week, and speech and language goals and objectives. STUDENT's attention and memory problems would be addressed by the District's proposal that all academic instruction take place in individual or small-group settings with high-interest materials, a thematic approach to teaching, and modification of assignments. Finally, his deficits in written language skills would be addressed by the District's offer to provide dictation services through an IA or a tape recorder, when necessary, and access to a computer.
As for the remaining elements of an appropriate educational program (i.e., the provision of some educational benefit, adherence to the IEP, and occurrence in the least restrictive environment), there was neither evidence nor argument that these elements would not be met by the District's proposed program.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year.
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by the following persons and facilities?
a. Bradley Schuyler, Ph.D., a psychologist
Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide appropriate services, and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. See School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 370, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985). Normally, a reimbursement analysis would begin with a determination of whether the school district provided appropriate services under the IDEA. Here, however, that determination is unnecessary, because there was no evidence presented at the hearing about the appropriateness of the services and/or assessments provided by Dr. Schuyler. Apart from Petitioner's contention that he should be reimbursed for services provided by Dr. Schuyler and vague references by a few witnesses to Dr.Schuyler, there was no evidence about the specific services Dr. Schuyler provided, the specific dates and/or period during which Dr. Schuyler provided those services, (Footnote 6) Dr.Schuyler's qualifications to provide those services, or why STUDENT's unique needs made it necessary that he receive Dr. Schuyler's services in order to benefit from his education. Given the complete lack of information on the services provided by Dr. Schuyler, Petitioner's request to be reimbursed for the cost of his services is denied.
b. Harvey Biala, M.D., a psychiatrist
For the same reasons that the costs of Dr. Schuyler's services cannot be reimbursed, Petitioner also cannot be awarded reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Biala's services. While there were vague references by several witnesses to Dr. Biala, the evidence was insufficient to establish the appropriateness of any services rendered by Dr. Biala. Furthermore, MOTHER testified that STUDENT saw Dr. Biala for the prescription of psychotropic medication to assist with his ADHD symptoms and other issues. Standing alone, there is no basis for reimbursement of a psychiatrist's services in prescribing medication. The prescription of medication clearly falls under the category of medical services and, since it was not for diagnostic or evaluation purposes, is not a service that needs to be provided by a school district under the IDEA. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Based on all the foregoing reasons, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for Dr. Biala's services is denied.
c. David A. Fox, M.D., a psychiatrist
As with Drs. Schuyler and Biala, insufficient evidence was presented at hearing to establish the appropriateness of the services provided by Dr. Fox. While there were a few references in testimony to the fact that Dr. Fox treated STUDENT, no specific information is in the record with regard to issues such as the specific services Dr. Fox provided (besides medication management), the specific dates and/or period during which Dr. Fox provided services, and Dr. Fox's qualifications to provide services. While the documentary record did contain a few treatment records with Dr. Fox's name, the treatment records could not serve as an appropriate basis to find that Dr. Fox's treatment was either necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education or appropriate under the IDEA. First, the records added little to no insight into the issues at hand as they contained mostly undecipherable handwriting. Second, without a witness testifying from personal knowledge about these records and the information they contain, they constitute mere hearsay which, without more, cannot be used to base a finding that Dr. Fox's treatment was either necessary or appropriate for STUDENT educationally. 5 C.C.R. § 3082(b). Based on all the foregoing reasons, Petitioner's request to be reimbursed for Dr. Fox's services is denied.
d. Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital
Petitioner contended that the parent should be reimbursed for STUDENT's hospitalization at Cedar Vista from November 4 to December 4, 1995. STUDENT was admitted to the psychiatric unit of Cedar Vista after he ran away during school and was picked up by the police. Prior to that time, STUDENT's out-of-control behaviors had been escalating to unmanageable levels, despite the psychotropic medications he had been taking. From November 4 to November 21, STUDENT received inpatient care in Cedar Vista's full hospitalization program. During that time, various psychiatrists and psychologists assessed and treated STUDENT. On November 21, STUDENT was discharged to Cedar Vista's partial hospitalization program, which he attended during the day until December 4. There is no evidence that STUDENT received any academic instruction while at Cedar Vista.
The District argued that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to STUDENT's hospitalization at Cedar Vista because school districts are not responsible for the costs of psychiatric hospitalization. The District cited Clovis Unified School District v. California Office of Administrative Hearings, 903 F.2d 635 (9th Cir. 1990), in support of its argument. In Clovis, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals determined that the school district was not financially responsible for the costs of the student's hospitalization at King's View Hospital, an acute care psychiatric hospital, because the student had been placed there primarily for medical (i.e., psychiatric) reasons. 903 F.2d at 645. After a careful review of Clovis and the facts in the instant case, the Hearing Officer finds the facts of the two cases comparable and that the reasoning of Clovis applies, precluding Petitioner from reimbursement for any services provided by Cedar Vista.
Here, STUDENT was hospitalized primarily for medical (i.e., psychiatric) reasons, not educational reasons. As in Clovis, STUDENT's hospitalization at Cedar Vista was the result of an "acute" psychiatric crisis preceded by uncontrollable behavior. Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT received any educational services while at Cedar Vista. On the other hand, the evidence established that STUDENT received intensive therapeutic treatment from various professionals, most of whom were medical personnel, and that psychotropic medication was prescribed to STUDENT during his hospitalization. Moreover, STUDENT's program at Cedar Vista was supervised by a medical doctor, Dr. Fox. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not obligated to reimburse Petitioner for any expenses related to STUDENT's hospitalization at Cedar Vista. Petitioner's request for reimbursement of expenses relating to STUDENT's hospitalization at Cedar Vista are denied.
e. Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist
Petitioner contended that the parent should be reimbursed for the assessment performed by Dr. West and Beckie M. Jensen, a psychological assistant, on June 3 and 10, 1997, and biofeedback training conducted by Dr. West during the summer of 1997.
Assessment in June 1997
Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist, as defined by regulations of the State Board of Education, if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Id.
Here, there was no pending or recently completed assessment by the District at the time the independent assessment was performed. At the time Dr. West assessed STUDENT in June 1997, the District's last assessment had been completed in January 1996, one and a half years earlier. Petitioner argued, however, that reimbursement is still proper, because the District should have assessed STUDENT at the time since he failed to make expected progress. Petitioner offered the testimony of Ms. Ekhardt to support this argument. Ms. Ekhardt testified that a "statute" requires that a school district call an IEP meeting to reassess a student sooner than annually when the student fails to make expected progress. Petitioner's argument fails for several reasons. First, while 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4)(A) and Education Code § 56343(d) require at least annual revision of a student's educational program to address any lack of anticipated progress, they do not require reassessment of the student whenever the student fails to make anticipated progress. Second, the law requires that a school district reassess a student more frequently than once every three years only if conditions warrant, or if the student's parent or teacher requests a reassessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Education Code § 56381. There was no evidence that conditions warranted a reassessment at this time. Failure to make anticipated progress, standing alone, does not necessarily require reassessment of a student. The Education Code specifically recognizes that some students will not meet the growth projected in their annual goals and objectives. Education Code § 56345(c). The Code does not, however, require a reassessment every time this occurs. Further, there is no evidence that either the parent or teacher requested a reassessment of STUDENT prior to June 1997.
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment completed by the District in January 1996 was appropriate for the following reasons. For the educational agency's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of Education Code § 56320. Section 56320 requires that the assessment be conducted by qualified persons; that tests and assessment materials and procedures be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and include tests and other assessment materials tailored to assess specific areas of educational need; and that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program. Education Code § 56320(a)-(e). Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Psychological assessments, as well as being required to meet the criteria of Section 56320, must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Education Code § 56324(a). A written report detailing the results of the assessment must be prepared. Education Code § 56326. The report must contain the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the student in an appropriate setting and the relationship of that behavior to the student's academic and social functioning. Education Code § 56326(c)-(d). First, STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability including cognitive functioning, academic achievement, health, behavior, and social and emotional development. Second, qualified personnel conducted the assessment. For example, The psychological portion of the assessment was performed by Mr. Smothers, a credentialed school psychologist. Third, a number of different assessment tools were used to assess STUDENT ranging from classroom observation, portions of the Tests of Cognitive Ability, and the Behavior Assessment System for Children. Additionally, the assessment team reviewed and considered the data and findings from the recent assessments performed by Cedar Vista. Fourth, the assessment tools were tailored to assess STUDENT's specific areas of educational need, such as attention, reading and reading comprehension, behavior, and social and emotional development. Finally, a written report was prepared detailing the assessment team's findings, conclusions and recommendations for the review of the IEP team. The report also contained accounts of relevant behavior noted during observations, and how that behavior related to STUDENT's academic and social functioning within his classroom.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds no basis on which to award reimbursement for the cost of the assessment performed by Dr. West. Petitioner's request for reimbursement for Dr. West's assessment is, therefore, denied.
Biofeedback Training
Petitioner argued that the parent should be reimbursed for the costs of the biofeedback training. As mentioned previously, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide appropriate services, and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. See Town of Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. There were vague accounts by a few witnesses (not including MOTHER) that STUDENT received biofeedback training from Dr. West during the summer of 1997 to help him deal with his ADHD.
Petitioner's argument for reimbursement fails for two reasons. First, there was no evidence presented at hearing, save hearsay evidence, about the provision of biofeedback training to STUDENT. For example, there was no evidence about when and for what period of time STUDENT received the training or what Dr. West's qualifications were to administer the training. Second, there is no evidence that biofeedback training was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Petitioner presented only the testimony of Ms. Ekhardt to support his position that STUDENT requires biofeedback training. While Ms. Ekhardt testified that STUDENT would benefit from biofeedback training, she admitted that had not read any research that supports the use of biofeedback training for ADHD (although she did name an article) and that she did not know whether STUDENT benefitted from the training he received from Dr. West. Additionally, Dr. Larry Hughes from the Diagnostic Center testified that biofeedback training is not normally used to treat ADHD.
In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for any biofeedback training provided by Dr. West.
f. Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist
Petitioner contended that the parent should be reimbursed for the assessment performed by Dr. and Mrs. Wells in January and February 1998. As noted above, the parent may receive reimbursement for an independent educational assessment when the parent disagrees with the educational agency's assessment, unless the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b).
Based on the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in late 1997. First, STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability including cognitive functioning, academic achievement, health, communicative development, behavior, and social and emotional development. Second, qualified personnel conducted the assessment. For example, The psychological portion of the assessment was performed by Mr. Smothers, a credentialed school psychologist. The speech and language assessment was performed by Ms. Rush, a credentialed speech pathologist. The health assessment was performed by a registered nurse. Third, a number of different assessment tools were used to assess STUDENT ranging from classroom observation, the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, the Leiter International Performance Scale - Revised, the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test, the Burns-Roe Informal Reading Inventory, and the Attention Deficit Disorders Evaluation Scale. Fourth, the assessment tools were tailored to assess STUDENT's specific areas of educational need, such as attention, reading and reading comprehension, behavior, and social and emotional development. Finally, all those involved in the assessment prepared written reports were prepared by all those involved in the assessment that detailed their findings, conclusions and recommendations for the review of the IEP team. Mr. Smother's report also contained an account of relevant behavior noted during his observation of STUDENT in both his RSP and mainstream classrooms, and how that behavior related to STUDENT's academic and social functioning within those classrooms.
Although the District's assessment did not strictly comply with the fifty-day timeline set forth in Education Code § 56344, the evidence establishes that the delay was de minimis and did not seriously affect STUDENT's receipt of educational benefit. Section 56344 provides that an IEP must be developed in accordance with the results of an assessment within fifty days of receipt of the parent's consent to assess, not counting days between the student's regular school sessions or days of school vacation in excess of five school days. Here, the District received the parent's written consent for the triennial assessment on or about November 12, 1997. As the winter break came less than a month after the parent consented to the assessment, the timeline was extended until about mid-January. While it appears that the IEP team should have met about a week or two earlier than January 28, 1998, Ms. Van Gelder's testimony indicated that the short delay in meeting was to accommodate the mother's desire for the mediator to be present at the meeting. In the absence of any evidence of prejudice, the slight delay in meeting in order to revise the IEP did not render the District's assessment inappropriate.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT. Therefore, Petitioner's request to be reimbursed for the assessment performed by Dr. Wells is denied.
g. Bonita Ekhardt, a licensed educational psychologist
Petitioner argued that the parent should be reimbursed for the assessment conducted by Ms. Ekhardt on April 4, 1998. Ms. Ekhardt's assessment of STUDENT took place only months after the District completed its triennial evaluation. As it has already been determined that the District's triennial evaluation was appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds no basis on which to award reimbursement for Ms. Ekhardt's assessment. Therefore, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for Ms. Ekhardt's assessment is denied.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Education Center, including costs of transportation?
Petitioner argued that the parent should be reimbursed for expenses relating to STUDENT's receipt of after-school reading instruction at the Cullinan Center because the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year. As noted previously, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement, and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i). However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court's decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an ‘empty victory.' [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if ‘appropriate relief' in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, ‘the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.' [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
The Supreme Court in Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student's IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents' placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district's must meet, the parents' placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student's needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year until March 11, 1998. The determination was based on the District's failure to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT's needs in the areas of attention, behavior, and social-emotional development until March 11. Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT obtained any educational benefit from the District's program until after March 11 when new goals and objectives were adopted and additional services were offered. In light of these findings, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the parent's placement was appropriate under the IDEA. Specifically, the Hearing Officer must resolve the questions of whether the Cullinan Center addressed the student's needs and whether it provided him with educational benefit.
There is no dispute that STUDENT has substantial difficulties with reading and reading comprehension. During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT continued to be able to read only at the first grade instructional level, despite his chronological age of twelve and designation as a sixth grade student. MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at the Cullinan Center in an effort to improve his reading abilities. Beginning September 11, 1997, STUDENT received one-on-one instruction from a teacher with a multiple subjects credential at the Cullinan Center. STUDENT's sessions at the Cullinan Center occurred two times every week, with each session lasting approximately fifty-five minutes. The Cullinan Center teaches reading through the Orton-Gillingham method, a multisensory, kinesthetic, tactile, and intensive phonic approach to reading. Joann Cullinan, the director and founder of the Cullinan Center, testified that reading comprehension is also worked on during each session through a series of who, what, when questions. According to Ms. Cullinan, the Orton-Gillingham method works well with children with ADD because it helps them organize and sort out raw material, and for children with auditory or visual processing problems because it is a multisensory, tactile approach to teaching. Ms. Cullinan is a few classes away from receiving a bachelor's degree in health and human services, and testified that she has hundreds of hours of instruction in the Orton-Gillingham method. According to her testimony, she has eleven years of experience training and teaching the Orton-Gillingham method, and is certified to teach the Orton-Gillingham method through the Michigan Dyslexia Institute located in Lansing, Michigan. She conducts week-long training workshops for the instructors at her Center. Ms. Lehman, who has a master's degree in special education and twenty-five years' experience teaching reading, testified that some phonics instruction is appropriate for STUDENT in order to teach him effective reading skills. According to Ms. Lehman, three different cuing systems are necessary in order to teach effective reading: context, syntax and phonics. Ms. Lehman testified that phonics instruction is therefore appropriate for STUDENT so that he can use phonics as one of the three cuing systems.
Given the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that instruction at the Cullinan Center was sufficiently appropriate to meet STUDENT's reading needs. While Ms. Rush and Ms. Bowland testified that STUDENT would be more successful with a sight-word or whole-word approach to reading, neither testified that instruction at the Cullinan Center could not address STUDENT's reading difficulties or that he would be unable to benefit from the instruction. Moreover, Ms. Rush admitted that her experience in the area of teaching students to read was limited as her training did not expressly focus on teaching children how to read. Additionally, Ms. Rush testified only that STUDENT had poor phonemic awareness (awareness of sounds in words and speech) and that he would likely become frustrated with a phonetic approach to reading, but not that he could not be successful with a phonetic approach to reading. Finally, Ms. Bowland, although concerned that STUDENT lacked the skills necessary to become an effective phonetic reader, testified that the Orton-Gillingham approach could be appropriate if combined with instruction in reading comprehension. Ms. Cullinan's testimony establishes that reading comprehension was a component of the instruction STUDENT received at the Cullinan Center.
The lack of agreement on the question of whether the Orton-Gillingham method used at the Cullinan Center was either the most appropriate method by which to teach STUDENT to read or "the specific type of programming necessitated by the [IDEA]" does not preclude MOTHER from receiving any reimbursement for the services. Alamo, 790 F.2d at 1161. Ms. Rush and Ms. Bowland testified only that the Orton-Gillingham method might prove less successful with STUDENT than some other available approaches, not that it would be inappropriate to teach STUDENT through the Orton-Gillingham method or that he would receive no benefit from it. Further, Ms. Lehman's testimony, which is based on decades of teaching reading and intimate knowledge of STUDENT's needs, establishes that some phonics instruction (which the Orton-Gillingham method provides) would be beneficial in improving STUDENT's reading.
As for educational benefit, there was evidence that STUDENT gained some educational benefit from attending the Cullinan Center. Ms. Cullinan testified that, when STUDENT began attending the Center in September 1997, he was started in a kindergarten to beginning first grade level book. Ms. Cullinan testified that he has since been moved to a mid-first grade level book and has developed a level of automaticity, recalling familiar words with more speed. According to Ms. Cullinan, STUDENT is also now able to read a book with six lines; has mastered the l, r, s blends; and has learned the concept of syllables and has mastered closed syllables.
Based on all the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the parent's independently obtained services for reading instruction were appropriate under the IDEA. Having determined that the District failed to provide a FAPE until March 11, 1998, and that the private placement was proper under the IDEA, the next inquiry is the appropriate amount of reimbursement. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 96 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992). In determining whether reimbursement should be limited, one appropriate consideration is the quality of the privately-obtained educational services. Alamo, 79 F.2d at 1161. It is always difficult to justify a precise reduction in the amount of retroactive reimbursement. However, looking at the testimony as a whole, given the nature and extent of STUDENT's deficits, their impact on his limited ability to benefit from the strictly phonetic approach to reading provided by the Cullinan Center, and that the Cullinan program addressed only his reading difficulties, the Hearing Officer concludes that an award of fifty percent is equitable. Therefore, the Hearing Officer awards the parent fifty percent of the costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Center from September 11, 1997, to March 10, 1998. This award includes the costs of transportation.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for attorney's fees and costs?
Neither state nor federal law gives the Hearing Officer authority to award attorney's fees or other legal costs absent the consent of both parties. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(3)(B); Education Code § 56507(b). Petitioner's request for attorney's fees and costs is, therefore, denied.
ORDER
1. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof from MOTHER, the District shall reimburse MOTHER fifty percent of the costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Center from September 11, 1997, to March 10, 1998, including the costs of transportation.
2. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year? *** Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year? *** The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assessments and/or treatment provided by the following persons and facilities? a. Bradley Schuyler, Ph.D., a psychologist b. Harvey Biala, M.D., a psychiatrist c. David A. Fox, M.D., a psychiatrist d. Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital e. Cecile Y. West, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist f. Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist g. Bonita Ekhardt, a licensed educational psychologist *** The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Education Center, including costs of transportation? *** Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the parent was awarded reimbursement for fifty percent of the costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Cullinan Center from September 11, 1997, to March 10, 1998.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for attorney's fees and costs? *** The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
Date: January 8, 1999 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. The issues listed here differ slightly in wording and content from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion held on the last day of hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer with regard to the issues for hearing.
2. At the time Alexopulos was issued, the IDEA was the Education of the Handicapped Act (EHA), and § 338(a) of the California Code of Civil Procedure was known as § 338(l). On June 4, 1997, the IDEA was amended. For purposes of this decision, the term "IDEA" will be used to refer to both the EHA and the IDEA. The 1997 amendments to the IDEA will be referred to as "IDEA ‘97." With the enactment of IDEA ‘97, there arose the question of whether a four-year statute of limitations might apply to claims arising under IDEA ‘97 pursuant to the Judicial Improvements Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-650) (the Act). In 1990, between the time of IDEA's enactment in 1970 and IDEA ‘97's enactment, Congress created a general four-year statute of limitations for federal claims, unless otherwise specified. Section 1658 of the Act states, "Except as otherwise provided by law, a civil action arising under an Act of Congress enacted after the date of the enactment of this section may not be commenced later than 4 years after the cause of action accrues." 28 U.S.C. § 1658. The Act was enacted on December 1, 1990. However, any question about whether the re-enactment of the IDEA changed the applicable statute of limitations need not be resolved here. In accordance with the general rules against retroactive application of laws, the law in effect at the time the disputed events occurred applies in this case. Landgraff v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994). Thus, the three-year statute of limitations established in Alexopulos, 817 F.2d at 555, continues to apply in this case to claims arising under the IDEA, i.e., claims based on events that occurred before June 4, 1997. On the other hand, whether a three-year or a four-year statute of limitations applies to claims accruing under IDEA ‘97 (i.e., claims based on events occurring after June 4, 1997) is irrelevant in this case because Petitioner filed his request for hearing on November 12, 1997. Since resolution of the issue would not change the analysis in the present matter, it need not be decided here.
3. The Ninth Circuit again addressed the applicability of a statute of limitations to IDEA claims in Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District, 22 F.3d 228 (9th Cir. 1994). As in Alexopulos, the Court applied the state's statute of limitations for liabilities created by statute. 22 F.2d at 232.
4. Code of Civil Procedure § 352(a) states: "If a person entitled to bring an action ... is, at the time the cause of action accrued either under the age of majority or insane, the time of the disability is not part of the time limited for the commencement of the action."
5. While the report from the Diagnostic Center recommended that STUDENT receive "specific language intervention" and "formal social skills training," it did not state that such intervention could be provided only through the services of a therapist. In fact, the report stated that such intervention could be provided through a group model by various professionals, including a teacher.
6. While MOTHER did testify that she saw Dr. Schuyler one time per week for approximately two years, she did not specify the dates on which she saw him.
