California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 31, 2001

Student v. Tamalpais Union High School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1475-00 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Tamalpais Union's November 2000 special day class offer was a FAPE; its earlier offer failed, and it must fund an OT assessment.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 5 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision says a compliance complaint the parents filed with the California Department of Education was pending the outcome of the hearing.

Summary

A father, representing himself, filed for due process for his 16-year-old daughter. She is eligible for special education under specific learning disability and was receiving home instruction under stay put. He wanted her placed at Mt. Burdell Academy, a noncertified nonpublic school that had once served only her. Tamalpais Union High School District filed its own case to defend its triennial assessments after he asked for an independent educational evaluation (IEE). The two cases were consolidated.

The Hearing Officer found no procedural violation. The parents took full part in IEP meetings, and Mt. Burdell was not available that year. The District also had no duty to help seek certification or a waiver for the school. The May 31, 2000 IEP offered a special day class (SDC) at San Marin or Drake High School. The evidence supported Michelle Rosenfeld's San Marin class, but the District offered almost no evidence about Drake. As a result, it failed to prove that offer was a FAPE. The November 6, 2000 IEP offered San Marin or Brenda Foster's SDC at San Rafael High School, with up to 49% mainstreaming. That offer was a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The District's assessments were appropriate, except they left out occupational therapy (OT), which the mediated agreement required. The District's 27-day delay in filing was also unnecessary. The Hearing Officer ordered the student returned to the District under the November IEP. She also ordered an independent OT assessment at public expense and an IEP meeting within 15 days of the report.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled an IEP that let the family choose between two placements. The district had to prove that each option was appropriate. It also shows SEHO limiting the IEE remedy to the single area left out of the assessment, OT. The district had delayed 27 days before filing to defend its assessments.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1a. Did the District deny FAPE procedurally by denying the parents an opportunity to fully participate in IEP development, including failing to give due consideration to the parent's preference for Mt. Burdell Academy, failing to explain why it was not offered, failing to inform the parent about nonpublic school certification and waivers, and failing to provide information on other placement options?

    Parents fully participated; Mt. Burdell was not available in 2000-2001, and the District had no duty to help seek certification or a waiver or to explain every possible placement option.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1b. Did the District offer a FAPE in the May 31, 2000 IEP (SDC at San Marin or Drake High School) for the period May 31, 2000 to November 6, 2000?

    The San Marin SDC was appropriate, but because the offer gave a choice of two placements and the District presented almost no evidence about the Drake SDC, it failed to prove the offer was a FAPE.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1c. Did the District offer a FAPE in the November 6, 2000 IEP (SDC at San Marin or San Rafael High School) for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, including ESY?

    Both SDCs were designed to meet the student's unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and offered the least restrictive environment with up to 49% mainstreaming.

  4. Issue 2a. Were the District's November 2000 triennial assessments (psychoeducational, speech-language, educational) appropriate, such that the parents are not entitled to an independent assessment at public expense?

    The assessments and reports met legal requirements except that they omitted an occupational therapy assessment, an area of suspected disability that the mediated agreement required to be assessed.

  5. Issue 2b. Did the District timely respond to the parent's request for an independent assessment?

    The District's 27-day delay before filing was not 'without unnecessary delay,' but the remedy was limited to an OT-only independent assessment at public expense rather than a full IEE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. Parents shall return the student to the District for placement under the IEP dated November 6, 2000.
  • IEE at public expense. Parent allowed an independent assessment, at public expense, of the student's educational need for occupational therapy by a qualified occupational therapist.
  • Reimbursement. District to reimburse the parent for the cost of the independent OT assessment within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of payment (amount not stated).
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of receiving the independent OT assessment report, District shall convene an IEP meeting to consider it and develop new goals and objectives as necessary.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56321, 56327, 56329, 56365, 56101

People named in the decision

  • Sandra L. Piotter, Director of Instructional Services; District witness, Tamalpais Union High School District
  • Kenneth Kammuller, Ed.D., SELPA manager and representative, Marin County SELPA
  • Glenn Fait, Director, Institute for Administrative Justice (observer), McGeorge School of Law
  • Kimberly B. Schulist, Associate attorney for District, Lozano Smith
  • Terry Sullivan, Program manager for special education services; witness called by Student, Marin County Office of Education
  • Rosemary LePage, School psychologist and program manager; psychoeducational assessor, Marin County Office of Education
  • Anne Marie Fox, Special education teacher; educational assessor, Marin County Office of Education
  • Deborah Hemphill, Program manager; District witness, Marin County Office of Education
  • Mary Allison, M.A., Speech-language assessor, District/MCOE
  • Dr. Robert Patterson, Independent psychologist (parent-obtained evaluations), Private
  • Marian Lane Diamond, Psychologist and educational consultant hired by parents, Private
  • Michelle Rosenfeld, SDC teacher (severely handicapped class), San Marin High School, Marin County Office of Education
  • Brenda Foster, SDC teacher (severely handicapped class), San Rafael High School, Marin County Office of Education
  • Mt. Burdell Academy, Nonpublic, noncertified school preferred by parents, Private
  • Star Academy, Nonpublic school (prior placement), Private, San Anselmo
  • Novato Christian School, Private Seventh Day Adventist school (prior supplemental setting), Private
  • Easter Seals, Provider of nurse for another student in San Marin SDC, Private agency

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

The matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (“Hearing Office”), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, at the Marin County Office of Education, San Rafael, California, on March 20 through 23, 2001, inclusive, and April 6, 2001.

Petitioner, STUDENT, was represented by her father, Mr. PARENT. Tamalpais Union High School District (“District”) was represented by attorney Jan E. Tomsky of the law firm Lozano Smith. Sandra L. Piotter, director of Instructional Services for the District, was also present throughout most of the hearing. Marin County SELPA (“SELPA”) was represented by its manager, Kenneth Kammuller, Ed.D. Also present for brief periods during the hearing were Glenn Fait, director of the Institute for Administrative Justice, and Kimberly B. Schulist, an associate of Ms. Tomsky.

Student called as witnesses GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother and tutor; Terry Sullivan, the program manager for special education services for the Marin County Office of Education; (“MCOE”) and Mr. PARENT. The District called as witnesses Rosemary LePage, an MCOE school psychologist and program manager; Anne Marie Fox, a special education teacher employed by MCOE; Deborah Hemphill, a program manager for MCOE; and Sandra Piotter. The SELPA did not offer an opening statement, present evidence or submit a closing brief.

Oral and documentary evidence was received at the hearing. The parties submitted written closing briefs and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision on May 1, 2001.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The request for due process hearing was filed by Mr. PARENT on behalf of STUDENT on August 12, 2000. The District filed its own request for due process hearing on March 8, 2001, requesting adjudication of the appropriateness of its assessments, with a concurrent motion to consolidate that matter with STUDENT’s pending matter. That motion was granted.

ISSUE PRESENTED BY STUDENT

Did the District offer a free and appropriate public education (“FAPE”) during the 2000-2001 school year?(Footnote 1)

ISSUE PRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT

Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense?(Footnote 2)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Mr. PARENT further contends that he, as STUDENT’s parent, was denied information, or access to information, which prevented him from being an effective advocate for his daughter. More specifically, he claims that the District failed to give due consideration to his preference for Mt. Burdell Academy (“Mt. Burdell”), and failed to provide timely and adequate information concerning the reasons why his daughter was not offered placement there.(Footnote 3) He asserts that the District failed to inform him regarding the significance of the State certification requirement for nonpublic schools and the effect of such noncertified status. He also contends that the District failed to provide information about other options for placement which were available. Mr. PARENT further contends that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. More specifically, he contends that his daughter’s unique needs require one-on-one instruction and a learning environment without excessive auditory and visual distractions. He asserts that none of the placements offered by the District were designed to meet these unique needs. Finally, he states that the District did not timely respond to his request for an independent assessment of his daughter, which impaired his ability to advocate for her in the IEP process and at the hearing.

The District contends that STUDENT’s parents were given all of the information required to allow them to fully participate in the IEP process. It asserts that it did offer a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school, which included appropriate placement and services. Finally, the District contends that its assessments of STUDENT were appropriate and that it timely and appropriately responded to the parent’s request for an independent assessment.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is the 16-year-old daughter of Mr. & Mrs. PARENT. Her special education eligibility is currently based on specific learning disability (“SLD”). Her current placement is home instruction, with STUDENT receiving, by agreement of the parties, fifteen hours of instruction per week. She lives with her parents and two younger siblings within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Marin County SELPA in or near Nicasio, California.

STUDENT was born premature on [date redacted], and has had a difficult medical and developmental history. Motor, speech and language and self-help skills were all delayed. At three years of age she was diagnosed with oral dyspraxia. At four, she was placed into a program for hearing impaired due to a slight hearing loss. At six years of age, she was tested and found to have a rare chromosomal defect which has been associated with multiple developmental delays, including speech/language, psychomotor coordination, feeding difficulties and impaired concentration and attention. She has been receiving special education and related services since age two. Just before transferring to the District, these were provided by or through the Nicasio Unified School District (“NUSD”), also part of the Marin County SELPA, through the 1997-1998 school year.

In the latter part of the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT’s parents began to express concerns about the adequacy of the recommended placement. STUDENT’s eligibility criteria were then SLD and SLI, with visual processing delays and attention deficit. The NUSD recommended a special day class (“SDC”) setting at one of the district’s middle schools. The parents disagreed, and obtained an independent educational evaluation by psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson. During an IEP meeting on August 30, 1996, NUSD agreed, based on the report of the parent’s evaluator, that STUDENT needed one-to-one instruction due to her distractability and visual processing delays. The team first considered and “tested” placement in an SDC at Hill Middle School. After a few weeks, another IEP meeting was convened. The SDC teacher stated her opinion that even with modifications and a one-to-one aide, the placement was not working, primarily due to STUDENT’s distractability. It was decided that NUSD did not have an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Someone from the district was going to look into the legal implications of STUDENT attending Novato Christian School, a Seventh Day Adventist (“SDA”) school.(Footnote 4) A short time later, NUSD recommended placement at Mt. Burdell Academy (“Mt. Burdell”), which was a nonpublic school set up by STUDENT’s parents and others specifically and exclusively to provide educational services to STUDENT. The program at Mt. Burdell consisted of one-on-one instruction of STUDENT in reading, math and language arts given by her grandmother, a retired school teacher, which was supplemented by P.E., art, applied arts and peer social experience at the SDA school. Mt. Burdell was unavailable as a placement the following year due to conflicting plans of the administrator. It was at about this time, at an IEP meeting on May 27, 1997, that STUDENT’s eligibility criteria were changed to mental retardation with overall developmental delays. Her parents disagreed with District’s proposed placement for the 1997-1998 school year. Those disputes were resolved by mediated agreement, which specified placement at another nonpublic school, Star Academy in San Anselmo, California for the 1997-1998 school year. This mediated placement was only until June 12, 1998. STUDENT’s transition to the District began with planning for the 1998-1999 school year near the conclusion of that placement.

The District’s recommendation of an SDC at any one of three of its high school campuses -- San Marin, Drake or Redwood -- followed an IEP meeting on May 21, 1998, while STUDENT was still attending Star Academy. The offer included extended school year (“ESY”) and transition services. STUDENT’s parents did not agree. The parents filed for mediation and due process hearing. The District cross-filed for a due process hearing. In the interim, STUDENT remained at Star Academy as her educational placement. There were additional IEP meetings in January, February and May 1999. At the first of these, designated a “due process related IEP,” STUDENT’s eligibility criteria were reestablished as SLD. By the time of the February meeting, “language or speech disorder” was added as an additional eligibility criteria. The recommendation, an SDC at any one of three of its high school campuses with an ESY and 60 minutes of speech and language per week, remained the same at all of these meetings. STUDENT’s parents requested a gradual transition from Star Academy to the SDC at San Marin. At the last IEP meeting, designated a “transition IEP,” Mr. and Mrs. PARENT expressed some concern about the transition which had already begun, at least on a trial basis of one and one-half hour per week. While they continued to request a gradual transition to a highly structured classroom with multisensory instruction, social skills training, speech and language therapy and occupational therapy (“OT”), they briefly allowed in increase in the time STUDENT spent at the San Marin SDC.

The next mediated settlement agreement was reached in July 1999. The agreement was to set up a program for STUDENT which provided for her attendance at the SDC at Drake High School or San Marin High School for the morning session only. Lunch at the school was optional. The remainder of the school day was to be spent in an independent study program consisting of individual instruction with STUDENT’s grandmother, Mrs. GRANDMOTHER, and physical education. She was also to receive 120 minutes of speech and language therapy and 30 minutes of OT per week. Pursuant to these and other terms, including a reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents of $8,200, the Special Education Hearing Office Case Numbers 1223-98 and 1378-98 were settled. The District paid the reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents, but the agreed upon placement and services were never implemented due to STUDENT’s back surgery in August 1999. STUDENT was required to recuperate at home and did not return to school in the fall. In February 2000, while STUDENT remained at home instruction, there was some discussion regarding the resurrection of the program for STUDENT at Mt. Burdell. Her parents began anew to lobby for that placement. The District, however, continued to believe that it had an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the same one set out in the July mediated settlement agreement. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT would not consent to the District’s placement, proposing instead that STUDENT be placed at Mt. Burdell, at least as a transitional measure. There was little change in the parties’ positions before the next IEP meeting at the end of May 2000. STUDENT remained at home, though she had by this time been released by her orthopaedic surgeon.

The May IEP offered the SDC at either Marin or Drake. The option for placement at Redwood was withdrawn. ESY was included. STUDENT was to be mainstreamed up to 49% of the time. Transition services to facilitate general instruction, employment, community experience, daily living skills and post-secondary education were also to be provided. Pull out speech and language is offered at 120 minutes per week, but no OT is included. Transportation and assistive technology were included. Mr. PARENT consented to all recommendations except placement.

This action was filed in August 2000. Stay put at home schooling was granted. A third mediated agreement in September 2000 provided for an increase in the home school hours (from 5 to 15 per week), a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT by the District, excluding intelligence testing, another IEP no later than November 13, 2000, and a postponement of the due process hearing. Assessments were conducted with Mr. PARENT’s consent in late October and early November 2000. These consisted of psychoeducational, speech and language and educational assessments.

Rosemary LePage conducted the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. She is an MCOE school psychologist and program manager. STUDENT’s parents completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Skills Survey, while STUDENT completed the Test of Visual-Motor Integration (“VMI”) and the Reading-Free Vocabulary Inventory, a vocational preference test. Ms. LePage also reviewed some of the current psychologist’s reports, including those of Drs. Patterson and Diamond. The Vineland yielded standard scores in most domains in the 10 year to 11 year range, considered adequate for communication and daily living, but moderately low for socialization. Her score in the motor skills domain was an age equivalent of 5 years 1 month, also the moderately low range. VMI yielded standard scores in visual of 83, motor of 57 and integration of 62. These results suggested the use of adaptive devices.

The speech and language assessment was conducted by Mary Allison, M.A. She administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test – III (Form B), the Expressive Vocabulary Test and a clinical evaluation. The assessor’s conclusion was that STUDENT’s scores were all commensurate with her cognitive abilities. It was apparently this conclusion that led to the elimination of speech and language therapy from STUDENT’s IEP.

The educational assessment was administered by Anne-Marie Fox, a special education teacher employed by MCOE. She administered the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (“KTEA”), which included assessments of math applications, math computation, reading decoding, reading comprehension and spelling. Math testing was administered with a calculator, at the request of STUDENT’s mother, and without one, though she testified that only the latter results would probably be valid. The scores reflected grade level equivalents of 2.2 for math app., 2.0 for math calc. (both without a calculator), 2.7 for reading decoding, 3.5 for reading comp. and 3.1 for spelling. Based on these results, Ms. Fox recommended that STUDENT continue to work on her academic skills in an enriched classroom environment.

The next IEP meeting was on November 6. The District’s placement offer at this IEP was of placement in an SDC at either San Marin High School or San Rafael High School.(Footnote5) The offer included an extended school year and multiple accommodations and modifications. Forty-nine percent of STUDENT’s school day was to be spent with the regular education students. No speech and language or OT was offered. Mr. PARENT did not consent, still arguing for placement at Mt. Burdell with one-on-one instruction and strategies to improve articulation.

On December 14, 2000, another fourth mediated agreement was reached. This agreement provided that the hearing would be continued again. The parents were to visit the SDC at San Rafael High School and receive copies of the assessments and the IEP. If the parents agreed to the placement, STUDENT was to receive a one-on-one aide for three hours per day under the supervision of the SDC teacher. Home instruction was to end on January 26. STUDENT was to begin at the San Rafael SDC on January 29. The change of placement never occurred.

Mr. PARENT requested an independent educational assessment on February 9, 2001. In the same letter, he requested a new IEP. Within four business days, he had a verbal response from the District acknowledging his request and asking about the bases for his disagreement with the District’s assessments. Letters were exchanged. On February 28, the District informed Mr. PARENT by letter that it would be filing for due process on the assessment issue. The District did file on March 8, 2001, 27 days after the date of the request.

A compliance complaint against the District was filed by the parents with the California Department of Education.(Footnote 6) Another IEP meeting, the most recent prior to the hearing, was held on March 6, 2001, but there was still no agreement regarding STUDENT’s assessments, goals and objectives or placement. STUDENT remains on home instruction.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE PRESENTED BY STUDENT

DID THE DISTRICT OFFER A FREE AND APPROPRIATE PUBLIC EDUCATION (“FAPE) DURING THE 2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR?

The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (“IDEA”), and State law require that students with disabilities be offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (“LRE”). 20 U.S.C. Sections 1400 (d) and 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code Sections 56000 and 56031. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8).

In its seminal decision regarding interpretation and application of the IDEA, the United States Supreme Court addressed the requirements of procedural and substantive FAPE in Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et .al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court held that “a "free appropriate public education" consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child "to benefit" from the instruction.” Id. at 188-189. The IDEA does not require that the states “maximize the potential of each handicapped child commensurate with the opportunity provided non-handicapped children.” What is required is that the student be provided with access to a FAPE which is “sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.” Id. at 200-201. In Rowley, the court also recognized that the IDEA reflects the desire of Congress to insure that there are procedural protections afforded the student and parents which will allow for effective participation in the IEP process. The Court notes that parents can be the most ardent advocates for their children, and that their full participation can be the best way to insure that all appropriate services are being offered to the handicapped child. The FAPE analysis must be two-pronged. First, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA which are designed to allow and encourage the full participation of the parent. It is clear that not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE. Any procedural flaw must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process to result in the denial of a FAPE. Second, the Hearing Officer must look at the IEPs which were a result of those procedures to determine whether the placement and services were reasonably calculated to provide the required educational benefit to the student. 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also: W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484. The District has the burden of proof on both prongs of the analysis. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, (9th Cir. 1994) 35 F.3d 1396, 1398.

Did the District comply with procedural requirements?

Most of Mr. PARENT’s procedural claims revolve around the District’s refusal to place STUDENT at Mt. Burdell, a nonpublic, noncertified school. In this regard, he more specifically complains that (1) the District failed to give due consideration to his preference for Mt. Burdell, (2) the District failed to provide timely and adequate information concerning the reasons why his daughter was not offered placement at Mt. Burdell, and (3) the District failed to inform him regarding the significance of the State certification requirement for nonpublic schools and the effect of such noncertified status on STUDENT’s potential for placement at Mt. Burdell. All of these can be summed up as a claim by Mr. PARENT that the District failed to offer STUDENT placement at Mt. Burdell or adequately inform him regarding the circumstances which prevented it from doing so. He argues that the refusal of the District to give fair consideration to his preference impaired his ability to advocate effectively for STUDENT. He also contends that the District failed to provide adequate information regarding other available options.(Footnote 7)

There are a number of procedures contained in the IDEA and the State special education laws that carry out the purpose of the IDEA to include parents in the IEP process. Among those procedures are the rights of the parents to participate in the determination of eligibility and in the development and implementation of the student’s IEP. Cal. Ed. Code Sections 56329(a) and 56341; 20 U.S.C. Sections1414 (b)(4)(A) and 1414(d)(1)(B)(ii). There are also the specific “procedural safeguards” set forth in the IDEA, including the right of the parents to participate in meetings with respect to the evaluation and educational placement of the child and the provision of FAPE, the right to prior written notice of proposed changes of placement, an opportunity for mediation, an opportunity to present complaints, the right to a due process hearing, and the right to receive written notice of these procedural safeguards. 20 U.S.C. Section 1415; Cal. Ed. Code Section 56500 et. seq. Districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of the child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. Sections 1415(b)(3). That notice generally must include a description of the proposed or refused action, an explanation of the reasons, a description of any other options considered, a description of each evaluation procedure, test, record, or report relied upon, a description of any other factors that are relevant, and information regarding procedural safeguards and sources for assistance in understanding the provisions of this part. The are good reasons for this notice. It helps ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. This information might be required years after the fact if there is a dispute, as there is here, about compliance with the special education laws. Such notice is important in that it provides the parents with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. Union School Dist. V. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1974) 15 F. 3d 1519, 1526.

The evidence shows that STUDENT’s parents, particularly Mr. PARENT, were significantly involved in the IEP process, where they steadfastly resisted her placement in any of the SDC classes offered by the District. It is also clear from the evidence that the District was well aware of the parents’ preference for Mt. Burdell. At least one parent attended every IEP meeting at issue. There are many letters from the parents to the District and several of the IEP documents which reflect consideration of Mt. Burdell as a placement. The evidence also shows, however, that Mt. Burdell was not available as a placement for STUDENT in the 2000-2001 school year. Despite Mr. PARENT’s suggestions that the program at Mt. Burdell be resurrected, he testified that he was not successful in getting anyone to participate in the effort. There is no testimony or evidence to counter these clear indications that Mt. Burdell was not available as a placement for STUDENT at any time during the 2000-2001 school year. It is the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that Mt. Burdell was not available as a placement for STUDENT at any time during the 2000-2001 school year and that no further consideration of it was required.

Mr. PARENT argues that the District did not follow a procedural safeguard when it failed to adequately explain its reasons for refusing a placement at Mt. Burdell. He believes that the District was required either to convince him regarding the appropriateness of its proposed placements, or to provide him with all of the information he might need to convince the District that his preferred placement, Mt. Burdell, was the right one. The law does not place such a heavy burden on local educational agencies.

Much of Mr. PARENT’s evidence and argument related to his theory that the District was required to provide him with information or assistance so that he could seek a waiver of the certification requirement for Mt. Burdell. There was no such requirement in the law. In order for the District to even consider an offer of placement at a nonpublic, nonsectarian school, it must believe or conclude that no appropriate public education program is available. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56365(a). Unlike the position of NUSD in October 1996, the District in this case believed that it had at least two appropriate programs available for STUDENT, as evidenced by the IEPs on 2/29/00, 5/31/00 and 11/6/00 (Exhibits 39, 29 and 19, respectively). A district or SELPA “may request . . . a waiver [of the certification requirement] if necessary or beneficial to the content and implementation of the pupil's individualized education program, or to the compliance of a district, special education local plan area, or county office with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.” Cal. Educ. Code Sections 56101(a) (Emphasis added). Similarly, the State “may grant” such a request. There is nothing in the law to suggest that the District or SELPA is required to seek such waivers, or that the State is required to grant the request, even when the conditions exist that allow such a request. See also: Cal. Educ. Code Section 56366.2.

The final procedural claim by STUDENT’s father, which relates to notice, is that the District failed to provide information regarding other options available to his daughter. The evidence shows that the IEP team considered a number of options for STUDENT’s placement, including at least four of its high school level SDCs, Star Academy, Mt. Burdell and home instruction. The fact that the law requires a full continuum of placement options does not mean that every possible option for placement must be considered and explained to the parents. In this case, the District had no obligation to provide information regarding other placement options, if any existed.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not violate procedural safeguards as alleged by STUDENT’s parents. STUDENT’s parents fully participated in the IEP process. They were given information regarding the options considered for placement and services. The evidence indicates that they understood what was being offered and when. There is no persuasive evidence that the District was required to provide more information than it did regarding options for placement that were considered, offered, or rejected. Nor was it required to assist STUDENT’s parents to obtain certification for Mt. Burdell or a waiver of the same.

Did the District offer substantive FAPE?

Having examined whether the District complied with the IDEA by utilizing the prescribed procedural safeguards which are designed to allow and encourage the full participation of the parent, the first prong of the Rowley analysis, we now look to the substance of the offers to determine whether STUDENT was offered a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.

The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(25). "Related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22). California Education Code Section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language-speech development and remediation, physical and occupational therapy and specially designed vocational education and career development. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22); California Education Code Section 56363(b).

As stated above, the United States Supreme Court determined in Rowley that the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. 458 U.S. at 200. The Court set forth the standard that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 207-208. Federal and State special education law also requires that a special education student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student's disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. Section 1412(a)(5)(A); California Education Code Section 56031.

In order to comply with the IDEA as interpreted by the court in Rowley, the program offered to STUDENT by the District for the 2000-2001 school year must meet the following four requirements: (1) It must have been designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (2) It must have been designed to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; (3) It must have conformed to STUDENT's IEP; and, (4) It must have been designed to provide STUDENT with all of the above in the least restrictive environment (“LRE”). The IDEA at 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides: “To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.“ The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming. The law demonstrates a strong preference for mainstreaming which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45. If the program offered by the District meets the above four requirements, the Hearing Officer must determine that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, even if the parents preferred another placement and even if the parents' preferred placement could have resulted in greater educational benefit to STUDENT. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.

What were STUDENT’s unique needs?

STUDENT has been variously classified for special education eligibility purposes as SLD with visual processing delays, mentally retarded with overall developmental delays, SLD with speech or language disorder, SLD with speech or language disorder and language delayed, and most recently, SLD only. The District and the various experts who have evaluated her have had difficulty determining an eligibility classification because she doesn’t easily fit any profile.

While the parties agree that STUDENT needs to continue to develop both her academic skills and her life and social skills as she prepares for greater independence over the next few years, there is little agreement how and where this should occur. Before it can be determined whether the District’s offers were appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must decide what those needs were. There is little agreement between the parties on this issue.

Mr. PARENT argues that STUDENT’s unique needs require that the educational program be focused on academics and be based on one-on-one instruction, by a teacher or qualified aide, in the core subjects of math and reading, at least. He also contends that the teaching environment must be conducive to that method by providing minimal audio and visual distractions. While Mr. PARENT agrees that STUDENT also needs social interaction to encourage the development of normal social skills and training in practical, vocational and life skills, he does not believe that those needs require that his daughter attend school at a regular public high school campus. In fact, Mr. PARENT believes that because of his daughter’s small stature, she requires some more protective placement.

The District takes a different position. District witnesses testified that STUDENT, who turned sixteen at the beginning of the current school year, has only limited time left to prepare herself for a transition to post-secondary placement and, ultimately, a life of greater independence and vocational opportunities. The District asserts that for academic instruction, STUDENT’s needs can be met through the small-group and one-on-one instruction that are available in its SDCs. The District further asserts that STUDENT needs to be taught both academic subjects and practical, life and vocational skills by trained and qualified special educators who are familiar with the challenges STUDENT will face in the future. Finally, the social skills learning is available through the program’s mainstreaming opportunities. In the District’s opinion, STUDENT’s physical attributes are not an issue.

Mr. PARENT’s opinions about STUDENT’s unique needs are based upon his belief that STUDENT learned significantly more in her years of one-on-one tutoring with Mrs. GRANDMOTHER than she learned in the many prior years in public schools. He testified to this growth, as did Mrs. GRANDMOTHER. He also argued that the comparison of prior test results contained in the November 1998 report of Dr. Robert Patterson supports his contention. Mr. PARENT offered no other evidence in support of this position.

The evidence does not support the position of Mr. PARENT that STUDENT’s unique needs require one-on-one instruction in academics in an environment with minimal visual and auditory distractions. Nor does the evidence support the finding that STUDENT is in greater need of instruction in reading, math and other academics, than she is of training in adaptive and vocational skills. The evidence is to the contrary. Dr. Patterson states in his report that STUDENT displayed extremely variable cognitive functioning from very severe retardation to the average range. She showed improvement in some areas during the period in question, particularly in written expression and written comprehension, but other domains showed “significant resistance with the current teaching methodology.” Some areas even declined for the period of time when STUDENT was receiving mostly one-on-one tutoring from her grandmother. While Dr. Patterson was of the opinion that STUDENT would benefit from one-on-one teaching of math and reading to compensate for extreme distractability, he also clearly envisioned a transition to the public school if the public school could provide an appropriate setting for her to continue with her academic learning. Dr. Patterson also stated then that while adaptive behaviors showed improvement in some areas, those could be increased with instruction. It was his specific recommendation that STUDENT be assisted with social interaction and that she be taught functional skills to correct “significant deficits in actual knowledge about the world around her.”

In past years, STUDENT’s parents have expressed concern about STUDENT’s distractability and STUDENT’s need for external controls, but evidence showed that these had improved substantially by mid-January 1999. Marian Lane Diamond, a psychologist and educational consultant hired by STUDENT’s parents to assess her in 1996, 1997 and 1999, states in her most recent report that STUDENT’s difficulties staying on task and refraining from talking out of turn or otherwise disrupting the class had all but disappeared. She states her opinion that this improvement was due to the fact that STUDENT had matured and had been in the structured learning environment of Star Academy, with its program of instant rewards for good behavior.

The recent assessments by the District showed that while her expressive skills were moderately low, her receptive skills were considered adequate for her age. Personal care skills were adequate, but domestic and community skills were moderately low. Social and social coping skills were also in the moderately low range, as were her gross motor skills. Cognitive functioning was strong for rote learning.

The evidence leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that STUDENT needs a structured learning environment with a mix of small-group and one-on-one instruction, particularly in math, reading and related academic subjects. At least as important for STUDENT at this stage in her development is the kind of social interaction, adaptive and life skills training, and vocational instruction and opportunities that will help to prepare her for the future.

Were the programs designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

In examining the programs offered by the District, the Hearing Officer analyzes two consecutive time periods. The IEP of May 31, 2000, contained the offer of placement for the 2000-2001 school year. Then, following the triennial assessment, a new IEP was developed on November 6, 2000. This IEP, the District asserts, contains the offer of placement and services for the remainder of the school year.

May 31, 2001 IEP

The May 31, 2000 IEP incorporates by reference the earlier IEP of February 29, 2000. That IEP, in turn, incorporates at least portions of the June 22, 1999 IEP and a mediated settlement agreement of July 12, 1999. There is also some incorporation of the February 22, 1999 IEP in the June document. A careful reading of these documents reveals the following offer for the period of May 31, 2000, to February 2001, which is listed as the date of the next annual review. STUDENT was to attend the SDC at either San Marin or Drake. There would be four to five weeks of ESY. She was to be included with the general education students, or mainstreamed, for lunch, regular physical education, electives and community experience, which was estimated to be up to 49% of her school day. Her general education accommodations and modifications included clearly defined limits, cues and prompts, supervision during unstructured times, frequent breaks, positive reinforcement and extra time to respond. Also to be provided were transition services to facilitate general instruction, employment, community experience, daily living skills and post-secondary education. Pull-out speech and language was offered at 120 minutes per week, but no OT was included. Transportation and assistive technology were included. The goals and objectives from February 2000 were adopted. These addressed basic reading skills, listening comprehension skills, spelling skills, written language skills, math skills, pre-vocational skills, functional skills, social skills and organizational skills. There were also separate goals and objectives for speech and language therapy. There were 20 pages of goals and objectives in all.(Footnote 8) Collectively, these address STUDENT’s needs for continued academic learning, adaptive and life skills, vocational skills and social skills. Mr. PARENT gave his consent for all of the IEP team recommendations, including eligibility, goals and objectives and services, with the exception of placement, which is discussed below. There was little evidence presented about the Drake SDC. Mr. PARENT visited the class but he remembered very little about what he observed, except that it appeared to him that the students were more developed than STUDENT. Deborah Hemphill, a program manager for MCOE, testified that the class was composed of students with the same range of abilities as those in the San Marin class and that it offered the same opportunities to meet the goals contained in her IEP. She distinguished the class as different from other SDCs by pointing out that there were a few more students with skills more developed than STUDENT’s. Aside from these conclusory statements, no evidence was offered regarding the teacher or her style, the number of students, the number of aides or assistants or the physical aspects of the room itself. It cannot be determined whether the District’s offer to place STUDENT at Drake would have provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

Mr. PARENT visited the San Marin classroom. He actually spent some time with STUDENT in the class. He testified only that the class seemed to bore STUDENT. He did not think it was adequately structured or that it would provide an adequate opportunity for STUDENT to learn academic subjects. Mrs. GRANDMOTHER spent several days in the San Marin class in the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year and two days at the San Rafael class in January 2001. She testified that there was little activity in the San Marin class. The children just sat there. No work was done. They would just stare and scribble. There was no structured class work. On another visit, when she brought some arrow points for the children to see, she describes the students as “dull and passive.”

Terry Sullivan is the program manager for special education services for the Marin County Office of Education (“MCOE”). He holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology from California State University, Sonoma, and special education teaching credentials in LH and SH. He has years of special education teaching experience, most of those spent in high-school-level SDCs for severely handicapped (“SH”) students. He is personally familiar with the San Marin SDC as this is one of the SH classes he has supervised during the current year. He also knows the teacher of that class, Michelle Rosenfeld. Michelle Rosenfeld holds SH, LH and VI credentials. According to Mr. Sullivan, there are 9-10 students in the class. In addition to Ms. Rosenfeld, there are two part-time instructional assistants, one part-time classroom helper and a nurse that is provided by Easter Seals for a particular student. The functional range of the students is roughly from first to fourth grade equivalent level, with some students functioning in limited-low range in expressive language, but better with receptive language skills. Their reading and math skills are from pre-readiness to third grade, and math is done mostly with a calculator. One of the children is highly distractable. Mr. Rosenfeld describes the setting as highly structured and highly predictable. It is housed in a “homemaking room,” with three activity areas, some of which allow for isolation. The class is characterized as language- enriched, and includes the services of a speech and language therapist who comes in twice per week to work with individuals and twice per week to work with groups. According to Mr. Sullivan, there is a substantial amount of one-on-one teaching, with no more than three student at one reading level. Ms. Rosenfeld generally works with those students who require the most attention. There is also lots of interaction on campus with nondisabled peers. There are peer tutors. The students are involved in sports, drama, social activities, practical skills and projects, like a school garden and campus beautification. There are job coaches, Project Workability and an extensive vocation library to assist the students with planning for greater independence. He testified that all of the students in this class pass on to one of the post-secondary programs at around age 18-19. Ms. LePage also had high praise for Ms. Rosenfeld’s class at San Marin. She pointed out that it has a distinct character in that it is generally more calm and quiet, with less activity than the other classes in the District.

There is substantial evidence that the San Marin SDC was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The teacher is well qualified. There is ample opportunity for small-group and one-on-one instruction. The functional range of the children is appropriate. The SDC is highly structured and predictable, which should be comfortable for STUDENT as she makes this first transition to the public high school. The twice weekly services by the speech therapist may be helpful to STUDENT, particularly since she will not be having those services on a pull-out basis. The mainstreaming opportunities and the opportunities to work with peer tutors will help STUDENT not only with her academic skills, but also with her socialization skills. The vocational resources and Project Workability will help to prepare her for greater independence and employment opportunities in the future.

As discussed above, the May 2000 offer contains a choice of two placements. In order for the offer to be considered an offer of FAPE, both of those proposed placements must be appropriate. While the District offered substantial testimony about the program at San Marin, almost nothing was said or otherwise put into evidence about Drake. There is insufficient evidence regarding the program at Drake High School to support the conclusion that it would have met STUDENT’s unique needs.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has failed to establish that the offer contained in the IEP dated May 31, 2000, was an offer of a FAPE to STUDENT.

The November 6, 2000 IEP

It is common for a student to be placed pursuant to an IEP drafted before the beginning of the school year. It is not uncommon, however, for the IEP team to recommend changes in placement or services during the school year. In this case, STUDENT’s triennial reevaluation took place in November 2000. This case had already been filed and there was a mediated settlement agreement which provided for a reassessment of STUDENT and for the convening of an IEP meeting to review the assessment results and develop new goals and objectives.

In November 2000, STUDENT’s eligibility classification was SLD only. The offer to STUDENT at this time was placement in an SDC at San Marin or at San Rafael High School, also an SH SDC. The ESY was unchanged, as were her mainstreaming opportunities. Accommodations and modifications were changed to eliminate the prior modifications regarding her need for clearly defined limits and supervision at unstructured times. Accommodations were added offering her choices for study aids, for manipulatives, and for immediate feedback. Transition services now included work experience and Project Workability and possible referrals to Social Security, Department of Rehabilitation and Golden Gate Regional Center. Areas of need are listed to include instruction in academics and social skills, increased opportunities for community experiences with recreation, purchasing and community service, increased opportunities for exploration of jobs and increased opportunities for social experiences and language skills development. Transportation and assistive software are included. The assessment revealed that STUDENT no longer was eligible for separate speech and language, so this service was withdrawn. The 23 pages of goals and objectives referred to above were reduced to seven pages covering spelling, reading, math, writing, recreational skills, community skills and vocational skills. Again, and as with earlier IEPs, Mr. PARENT gave his consent to all except placement. This part of the offer was different from the last IEP. The offer of Drake as a placement was withdrawn. In its place was an offer of the SH SDC at San Rafael High School. Placement at San Marin was previously determined to be an appropriate placement. The results of the triennial assessment do not change that determination.

Both Mr. and Mrs. PARENT visited the San Rafael class. Mr. PARENT’s main concern after observing the class was that there appeared to be no appropriate place to offer one-on-one instruction to STUDENT in this class. Mrs. GRANDMOTHER’s description of the San Rafael class included the observation that the teacher, Ms. Foster didn’t do much. There were no desks, just tables. The students just wandered around, but they were noisy. She stated that someone told her that the aide would not have adequate time for STUDENT.

Mr. Sullivan is also familiar with the San Rafael SDC taught by Brenda Foster. He knows the teacher, having worked on the curriculum development committee with her. Ms. Foster holds a special education credential for SH and has approximately 14-15 years teaching experience. While this class may have a few more students than the San Marin SDC (11-12), the core instruction groups tend to be smaller than those in the San Marin class because many of the students are out of class to mainstream during the day. Ms. Foster does peer tutor training, so there is substantial interaction between the students in her class and those tutors. The witness had less information about the functional levels of the students, but stated that some were around the fifth grade equivalent level. He has spent many hours in her class visiting and working on program development. This class is also a language-enriched environment, though Mr. Sullivan was not sure that the speech and language specialist was available for more than consultation. In comparing the two classes, Mr. Sullivan stated that the San Marin SDC is more academic and close to campus, while the San Rafael SDC is more involved with opportunities out in the community. It is a more community-involved class with a greater focus on jobs and vocational opportunities. Rosemary LePage stated that this class has lots of activity, but the teacher uses a resource room for quiet activities. The age range of the students is 14 to 19. Abilities range from mental retardation to high functioning. Ms. LePage also stated that the teacher’s strength is her ability to individualize the program for the needs of each student. Ms. LePage described the class as structured and well-managed by Ms. Foster, who is dedicated and competent, and willing to “go that extra mile” for her students.

The SDC taught by Brenda Foster at San Rafael is different in character from the class at San Marin. It has more activity and places more emphasis on getting the students out into the community than does Ms. Rosenfeld’s class. Ms. Foster is an experienced teacher who tightly manages a well-structured class. There is adequate opportunity for STUDENT to receive small- group and individual instruction, and there is ready access to peer tutors. The age range and functional levels of the students are appropriate for STUDENT.

On the basis of the evidence, it is the opinion of the Hearing Officer that the District’s offer of an SDC at either San Marin or San Rafael by the District contained in the November 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Was the program offered in November 2000 designed to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT?

One of the primary reservations Mr. PARENT had about returning STUDENT to the public SDC environment was that, in his opinion, she had gained little or no benefit from SDC placements in earlier years. Regardless of the benefits received years ago, STUDENT is a different person now. She has matured. Her cognitive abilities have developed. She is far less distractable and appears ready, willing and able to do the work and exhibit the behavior required of her in an SDC. Rather than focusing on what some may view as past failures, the Hearing Officer looks at STUDENT in the current school year, at the goals and objectives in her IEPs, and at the programs offered to provide her with a FAPE. It has already been determined that the November 2000 offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. It must now be determined whether, in meeting those needs, the program will also provide the educational benefit prescribed by Rowley, supra.

A number of witnesses testified to their opinions about whether STUDENT would likely benefit from the offered programs. Generally, the District or MCOE employees believed that she would. Mr. PARENT and STUDENT’s grandmother believed that she would not. The Hearing Officer concludes that the November 2000 offer was designed to provide that educational benefit to STUDENT. STUDENT has demonstrated her desire to learn and her dedication to the learning process. There is no evidence of any behavioral problems that would substantially interfere with the District’s efforts to deliver educational benefit to her. The District believes, and the Hearing Officer agrees, that the goals and objectives are reasonable and that the offered programs are designed to achieve those goals.

Did the program offered in November 2000 conform to her IEP?

This is not an issue. The program was never implemented.

Was the program offered in November 2000 designed to provide STUDENT with the least restrictive environment (LRE) for her education?

It has not been contended or argued by Mr. PARENT that the District’s programs did not satisfy this LRE requirement. It is clear from the evidence, however, that STUDENT’s need for more social interaction with other students her own age has been a principal concern of the District. STUDENT turned sixteen years old near the beginning of the fall term for the 2000-2001 school year. It has been years since she was educated in an environment of chronological peers. Virtually all of the professionals who evaluated her or were involved in the delivery of services to her recognized the importance of and STUDENT’s need for peer social experience. Perhaps more important, the assessments confirmed that STUDENT wants and needs that kind of social experience. Dr. Diamond notes that STUDENT very much wanted to be in classes with children closer to her age. Dr. Patterson, who recommended that STUDENT be assisted with social interaction, was of the opinion that the public school class setting would be appropriate for this purpose. According to other evidence, STUDENT would have opportunities to mainstream at lunch break and during electives and community experience, including work experience. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the programs offered STUDENT with the least restrictive environment for her education.

In summary, the evidence established that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the period from November 6, 2000, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year.

ISSUE PRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT

ARE STUDENT’S PARENTS ENTITLED TO AN INDEPENDENT EDUCATIONAL ASSESSMENT AT PUBLIC EXPENSE?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a district. If a request for such an independent assessment is made, a district must either agree to pay for it, or it must file for a due process hearing requesting a determination that its assessment was appropriate. While State law does not specifically address the timing of the required response from a district when a parent requests an independent assessment, federal regulation states that it must be done “without unnecessary delay.” While federal law allows a district to ask the parent why he objects to the evaluation, no response is required and a district is not allowed to unreasonably delay its substantive response to the request. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. If the parent obtains an independent educational assessment at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of free, appropriate public education to the child, and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500) regarding the child. Ed. Code Section 56329(b); 34 CFR Section 300.502(b).

If a district files for a due process hearing to decide the appropriateness of its assessment, it must demonstrate that the child had been properly assessed under the law. Both federal and State laws governing special education provide that, before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. 20 U.S.C. Section 1414(a)(1)(A); California Education Code Section 56320. Furthermore, reassessments are to be conducted at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant. California Education Code Section 56381; 20 U.S.C. Section 1414(a)(2)(A).

California Education Code Section 56321 sets forth the requirements for a proposed assessment plan, notice to parents and parental consent to the assessment. The proposed assessment plan must (1) be in language easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent or other mode of communication used by the parent, unless to do so is clearly not feasible; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and, (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent. The statute also requires that the notice must include a copy of all the procedural safeguards under the IDEA, and the rights and procedures contained in Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500) of this Code, including information on the procedures for requesting an informal meeting, prehearing mediation conference, mediation conference, or due process hearing; the time lines for completing each process; whether the process is optional; and the type of representative who may be invited to participate.

The assessments themselves must meet the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code Sections 56320 et. seq. Section 56320 provides, in pertinent part:

(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible. (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.

The statute above requires that the tests and other assessment materials “include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need;... [and] accurately reflect the pupil's aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” No single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program, and the student must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. California Education Code Section 56320 (c)- (f), inclusive. The assessments must be performed by persons who are competent to perform them, as determined by the district. California Education Code Section 56322. Psychological assessment of a student must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. California Education Code Section 56324.

Were the District’s assessments appropriate?

It is undisputed that the subject assessments were triennial assessments of STUDENT and were conducted by the District pursuant to a mediated settlement agreement. (Ex. 26.) The agreement provided that STUDENT would be assessed “in the areas of academic functioning, speech and language and occupational therapy.” It also reflected the parties’ agreement that the testing would not include intelligence testing but would rely on the testing performed by Dr. Robert Patterson fewer than two years earlier. An assessment plan was signed and approved by Mr. PARENT (Ex. 24.) The plan complies with the requirements of California Education Code Section 56321. It is in plain English. It identifies that the assessments to be conducted may include academic performance in reading written language and math, and receptive and expressive language. It also states that the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale and a parent interview will be done. It identifies the purpose of the assessments as the three-year reevaluation and to determine progress toward goals and objectives. It lists the tests to be administered and the qualifications of the persons to administer them. Finally, it states that no IEP will result from the assessment without the parent’s consent. The plan does not include reference to the occupational therapy assessment that the mediated agreement anticipated. Nevertheless, Mr. PARENT signed the plan. The plan itself meets the statutory requirements with one exception: it does not provide for the OT assessment. That omission is discussed in more detail below. There is nothing in the record to suggest that the testing and assessment materials and procedures used were selected and administered so as to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. These were materials and procedures commonly used in educational assessments, and were appropriate for use in this instance. The tests and other materials were in English, STUDENT’s language. Finally, the evidence demonstrated that the testing materials were validated for their intended purposes and were administered by qualified personnel.

In reviewing the appropriateness of the assessments, the Hearing Officer proceeded without the benefit of any evidence from Mr. PARENT concerning the nature of his disagreement or objection. He did, however, offer some argument on the issue. He points to the requirements of Cal Educ. Code Section 56327, which describes the minimum requirements for reports of assessments as follows: (a) whether the pupil may need special education and related services; (b) the basis for making the determination; (c) the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting; (d) the relationship of that behavior to the pupil's academic and social functioning; (e) the educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any; (f) for pupils with learning disabilities, whether there is such a discrepancy between achievement and ability that it cannot be corrected without special education and related services; (g) a determination concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate; and, (h) the need for specialized services, materials, and equipment for pupils with low incidence disabilities, consistent with guidelines established pursuant to Section 56136. The first six of these elements should be included in a report about STUDENT. Mr. PARENT argues that the reports fail to adequately address STUDENT’s need for related services, fail to report on relevant behavior noted during observation in an appropriate setting, fail to address the relationship between those observed behaviors and STUDENT’s academic and social functioning, and fail to document any effort by the assessors to discover and document educationally relevant health and development and medical findings.

The reports do address STUDENT’s need for the related services for which she has historically been qualified, as delineated in Cal Educ. Code Section 56563, with the exception of OT. Speech and language is addressed. The reports also comment on behavior observed in an appropriate setting, the assessment setting. While this may not have duplicated a classroom setting, the assessors were able to observe STUDENT as she spent considerable time completing tasks that required attention and application.(Footnote 9) She is described as having “attended well to tasks and directions,” as “friendly and cooperative,” and as having “showed appropriate stamina through three hours of assessment.” The reports also contain the results of the assessments themselves, which involved, at least in part, an observation of STUDENT’s behavior. While they do not refer to any newly researched and relevant health and development or medical findings relating to STUDENT’s particular chromosomal deletion, no such reference was required. The Hearing Officer concludes that the reports satisfy the requirements of the Code.

The law requires that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Cal Educ. Code Section 56320 (f). STUDENT was not specifically assessed for OT needs. Rosemary LePage testified that this was an area of disability for STUDENT and that she was more impaired in this area than in other areas. Her psychological assessment report confirms that STUDENT’s gross motor skills were measured in the moderately low range. Even the mediated agreement that resulted in the assessments stated that STUDENT would be assessed in this area. The omission of this testing from the assessment plan was an error that was not discovered by Mr. PARENT before the hearing. The District’s argument that there was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT needed OT to benefit from her education misses the point. She was to be assessed in this area so that a determination could be made whether such services were necessary. The Hearing Officer concludes that the OT assessment needs to be completed.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the assessments performed by the District were not appropriate, but only to the extent that they did not include an assessment of STUDENT’s need for OT.

Did the District timely respond to Mr. PARENT’s request for an independent assessment?

Mr. PARENT requested the independent assessment by letter dated February 9, 2001, almost three months after the District’s assessments were presented to the IEP team, which included Mr. PARENT. There was no explanation offered for the delay. Still, the request was made almost a month before the next IEP and more than five weeks before this hearing. It took four weeks for the District to exercise its option to file for a due process hearing. In the interim, there were letters and telephone calls between the parties, some having to do with Mr. PARENT’s choice to not disclose the specifics of his objections. The District’s concern about the nature of Mr. PARENT’s objections are expressly not grounds for delay. No convincing evidence was offered by the District to otherwise explain the reasons for the delay. Nor was there any evidence offered by Mr. PARENT regarding the nature of his disagreement or why he did not obtain his own assessment at private expense. He had obtained independent assessments on several prior occasions. It is impossible for the Hearing Officer to speculate what might have been accomplished for STUDENT had either party been more diligent in this regard. Mr. PARENT gave his approval of and consent to the “services” portion of the November 2000 IEP. He did not even raise the assessment issue until months after that IEP. The law does not provide any clear guidance as to what an appropriate remedy might be under these circumstances. It does not appear to mandate that Mr. PARENT now be allowed a complete assessment at public expense. He could have obtained one long before the November IEP. If he had, it would have been considered by the team. However, it has been determined that the District’s assessments were not appropriate only in that they did not include an OT assessment. Therein lies the remedy. It is the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that the District did not respond to Mr. PARENT’s request for an independent assessment “without unnecessary delay” as required by federal law. However, since the District’s assessments were appropriate except for the omission of an OT assessment, the remedy shall be to allow Mr. PARENT an OT assessment only at public expense.(Footnote 10)

ORDER

1. STUDENT’s parents shall return STUDENT to the District for placement pursuant to the IEP dated November 6, 2000.

2. Mr. PARENT shall be allowed an independent assessment, at public expense, of STUDENT’s educational need for occupational therapy by a qualified occupational therapist.

3. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of proof of payment from Mr. PARENT for an independent OT assessment, the District shall reimburse Mr. PARENT for the cost of the independent assessment.

4. Within 15 calendar days of receipt of the report of the independent occupational therapy assessment, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to consider the assessment and to develop new goals and objectives as necessary.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District offer a free and appropriate public education (“FAPE”) during the 2000-2001 school year?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue for the period from May 31, 2000 to November 6, 2000. The District prevailed on this issue from the period from November 6, 2000 to the end of the current school year.

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense?

The District prevailed on this issue, except as to an occupational therapy assessment. STUDENT

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: May 31, 2001 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: This issue will include determinations of whether the offer by the District met the substantive requirements of FAPE, specifically with regard to placement, and whether there was a procedural denial of FAPE as a result of the District’s denial to her parents of an opportunity to fully participate in the development of an individualized education plan (“IEP”) for their daughter. Footnote 2: This issue will include determinations of the appropriateness of the District’s assessments and whether the District timely responded to the parent’s request for an independent assessment. Footnote 3: While Mr. PARENT referred at hearing to his desire for placement of STUDENT at Mt. Burdell “or some similar placement,” all of his complaints regarding procedural defects related solely and specifically to Mt. Burdell. Footnote 4: The actual name of the school is unclear from the evidence. It is referred to here as the SDA school Footnote 5: The San Rafael placement was offered instead of the Drake High School and Redwood High School alternates offered in earlier IEP meetings. Footnote 6: The investigation is pending the outcome of this hearing. Footnote 7: There is also the claim that he was not allowed an independent assessment at public expense, which will be discussed below. Footnote 8: There are actually 23 pages of goals and objectives incorporated by reference, but three pages are identified as OT goals and one of those lists the occupational therapist as the implementor. Footnote 9: Ms. Fox testified that she spent 1 ½ to 2 hours with STUDENT, with two 10-minute breaks. Ms. LePage’s report refers to the”all morning session.” Footnote 10: It should be clear that the Hearing Officer expects that this OT assessment shall be used for prospective planning purposes only, and not to further challenge the programs offered for the current school year.