California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 11, 2003

Student v. Huntington Beach City Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1482-03 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

Huntington Beach district need not fund more Lindamood-Bell therapy; six weeks of unmeasurable goals caused no harm.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 14 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 10-year-old fifth grader at Perry Elementary School filed for due process against Huntington Beach City Unified School District and the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education. The student had received special education since 2000, first under specific learning disability and, from January 2003, under other health impairment based on ADHD. An earlier case had settled with the District paying for 311 hours of Lindamood-Bell therapy, which ended in October 2002. For 2002-2003, the family wanted more Lindamood-Bell services. They argued the District ignored auditory processing needs, failed to assess or reassess, disregarded private evaluations and wrote vague goals. They also raised claims about IEP attendance, notice and records.

The Hearing Officer rejected the procedural claims. District staff knew the student well, the required members attended, the family clearly knew more Lindamood-Bell had been denied, and no records request was proven. The District had assessed auditory processing, memory and pragmatic language. It reasonably rejected a private "cognitive disorder" diagnosis and considered the private reports. Its resource and speech services, which resembled Lindamood-Bell methods, produced progress. However, the November 2002 goals were not objectively measurable because they referred to unidentified reading levels and word lists. The January 2003 amendment fixed this. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE for about six weeks but no harm, because the first progress benchmark was not until March 2003. Compensatory education and independent evaluations were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated goals that pointed to unidentified reading levels or word lists: a teacher's own knowledge of the lists did not make the goals measurable. It also shows that a prompt IEP amendment, made before the first progress benchmark, led the Hearing Officer to deny compensatory education.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue A.1(a). Did the District and WOCCSE fail to comply with IDEA procedural requirements by failing to invite Robert Patterson, Psy.D., Carol Atkins, M.A., and a representative of Lindamood-Bell to IEP meetings?

    District staff who knew the student and had current data attended; the private evaluators would have added nothing new, unlike in Target Range, so there was no violation that denied FAPE.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue A.1(b). Did the District fail to require the general education teacher and the speech therapist to attend all IEP team meetings?

    The general education teacher and the special education and speech providers attended the November 2002, January 2003 and June 2003 meetings, so no violation was shown.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue A.1(c). Did the District fail to provide timely notice to the parents of a denial of requested Lindamood-Bell services?

    A stand-alone written denial was not issued until July 2003, but the IEPs and the advocate's attached statements showed the family knew of the denial. The Hearing Officer found substantial compliance and no prejudice.

  4. District prevailedRecords

    Issue A.1(d). Did the District fail to turn over the Student's school records pursuant to her request?

    The Student did not prove a records request was made, and no prejudice was shown; the records were produced by stipulation at hearing.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue A.2. If the District failed to comply with IDEA procedural requirements, did those violations result in a denial of FAPE?

    Moot because no procedural violations were found; the District was named prevailing party.

  6. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue B.1(a). Did the District and WOCCSE fail to provide FAPE for 2002-2003 by failing to assess the Student in all areas of suspected disability?

    The District assessed auditory processing, short-term memory and pragmatic language formally and informally. It properly rejected a private 'cognitive disorder' diagnosis and did not overemphasize ADHD.

  7. Issue B.1(b). Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to review assessments provided by the parents?

    District staff reviewed the Patterson, Atkins and Lindamood-Bell reports. It was appropriate to give more weight to current data, and the law does not require that consideration happen at the IEP meeting itself.

  8. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue B.1(c). Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to reassess the Student for the annual IEP for 2002-2003?

    An annual formal reassessment was not required. The triennial deadline had not run, and daily observation and updated data were available.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue B.1(d). Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to determine the Student's unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing?

    The experts for both sides broadly agreed on the student's needs, and the November 2002 IEP, as amended, appropriately identified them.

  10. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue B.1(e). Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to develop appropriate present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives?

    The present levels were adequate. The November 2002 goals were not objectively measurable because they cited unspecified reading levels and word lists. The Hearing Officer found a FAPE denial for about six weeks until the January 17, 2003 addendum cured the defect, but found no prejudice to the student.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue B.1(f). Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to provide services designed to meet the Student's unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing?

    The District's RSP and speech services were similar to Lindamood-Bell methods and conferred educational benefit, as shown by the student's progress.

  12. Issue B.2. If the District failed to provide FAPE for 2002-2003, is the Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Declared moot because the six-week goal defect did not adversely affect educational opportunity; compensatory education was denied in the order.

  13. Issue B.3. If the Student is entitled to compensatory education, should the District be ordered to provide Lindamood-Bell services?

    Moot because the student was not entitled to compensatory education.

  14. Issue B.4. Should the Student be provided an independent psychoeducational assessment and independent educational assessments in speech and language and academics at the District's expense?

    The District's assessments were conducted by qualified staff using appropriate, validated tests. The student did not show they were inappropriate, so the IEEs were denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Requests for compensatory education and for independent educational evaluations at District expense for 2002-2003 were denied; all other relief denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Lenn v. Portland School Committee

People named in the decision

  • Christopher Russell, educational consultant/advocate for Student, Student
  • Jackie Earwood, Orange County/Southern California clinical director, nonpublic agency, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Centers
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Newport Beach clinic), nonpublic agency providing private reading/language therapy
  • Carol Atkins, M.A., private audiologist; expert witness for Student
  • Kate Mack, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; witness for Student
  • Robert Patterson, Psy.D., independent psychoeducational evaluator (did not testify)
  • Jim Hemsley, executive director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education
  • John Conniff, director of special education, Huntington Beach district
  • Shirley Lauri, school psychologist, District
  • Jack Schnell, Ed.D., District consulting (forensic) psychologist; expert witness for District
  • Caryn Wernle Brown, M.A., speech-language pathologist / speech and language RSP teacher, District
  • Jane Vogel, M.A., vision consultant, District
  • Julia Voce, RSP specialist, District
  • Jennifer Heller (also spelled Hiller), RSP teacher, District
  • Jennifer Motske (also referred to as Stephanie Motske), general education teacher, Perry Elementary School
  • Stephanie Austin, general education teacher who conducted academic testing, District
  • Elaine Keeley, principal, Perry Elementary School
  • Nina Welch, District speech pathologist (2001 speech and language assessment), District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on August 21, 22, 26 and 27 and September 5, 9 and 10, 2003, at Huntington Beach, California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Tania L. Whiteleather. Also present for the Student were her parents, (Parents), and their educational consultant, Christopher Russell. Respondents, Huntington Beach City Unified School District (District) and West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE), were represented by attorney Caroline A. Zuk. Also present for Respondents were the District=s special education director, John Conniff, and the executive director of WOCCSE, Jim Hemsley.

The Student called the following witnesses: her parents, Christopher Russell, her educational advocate; Jackie Earwood, director of Orange County Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Centers (Lindamood-Bell); Carol Atkins, M.A., audiologist; and Kate Mack, Ph.D., clinical psychologist.

The District and WOCCSE jointly called the following persons as witnesses on their behalf: Jim Hemsley, executive director of WOCCSE; John Conniff, director of special education for the District; Shirley Lauri, school psychologist; Jack Schnell, Ed.D., District consulting psychologist; Caryn Wernle Brown, M.A., speech and language RSP teacher; Jane Vogel, M.A., District vision consultant; Julia Voce, RSP specialist; Jennifer Heller, RSP teacher; Jennifer Motske, general education teacher; and Elaine Keeley, principal of Perry Elementary School.

Testimonial and documentary evidence was offered and received. Upon receipt of the written closing arguments by the Hearing Officer, the last of which was received on September 26, 2003, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

A. PROCEDURAL ISSUES.

1. During academic year 2002-2003 did the District and WOCCSE fail to comply with the procedural requirements of the individuals with disabilities education act (IDEA):

(a) by failing to invite Robert Patterson, Psy.D., Carol Atkins, M.A., and a representative of Lindamood-Bell to IEP meetings;

(b) by failing to require the general education teacher and the speech therapist to attend all meetings of the IEP team;

(c) by failing to provide timely notice to the parents of a denial of requested Lindamood-Bell services; and (d) by failing to turn over the Student=s school records pursuant to her request?

2. If the District is found to have failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the IDEA, did those violations result in a denial of a FAPE?

B. SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES.

1. Did the District and WOCCSE (Footnote 2) fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for academic year 2002-2003:

(a) by failing to assess the Student in all areas of suspected disability;

(b) by failing to review assessments provided by the parents;

(c) by failing to reassess the Student for the annual IEP for academic year 2002-2003;

(d) by failing to determine the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing;

(e) by failing to develop appropriate present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives; and, (f) by failing to provide services designed to meet the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing?

2. If the District failed to provide the Student a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003, is the Student entitled to receive compensatory education?

3. If the Student is entitled to compensatory education, should the District be ordered to provide Lindamood-Bell services to her?

4. Should the Student be provided an independent psychoeducational assessment and independent educational assessments in speech and language and academics at the District=s expense?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student=s Contentions.

The Student contended that the District failed to comply with certain procedural requirements of the IDEA and California law resulting in a loss of educational opportunity and a denial of a FAPE. She contended that the District failed to invite certain private evaluators and providers to her IEP meetings and failed to invite the general education teacher and RSP teacher to all IEP meetings, and thus failed to obtain relevant information about her abilities and needs. In addition, STUDENT contended that the District failed to provide timely notice of its denial of her request for services and failed to turn over student records when requested.

Moreover, the Student contended that she was not provided a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 because the District failed to assess her in all areas of disability, in particular in the areas of speech and language and/or audiology with particular emphasis on auditory processing and also in the area of cognitive functioning. The Student contended that the District failed to review and consider the evaluation of Robert Patterson, Psy.D., a psychological assessment, and the independent educational evaluations (IEEs) of Carol Atkins, M.A., a speech pathologist, in the field of audiology, and of Lindamood-Bell in the field of speech and language. The failure to consider this relevant information, she contended, prevented the District from designing a program to meet her unique needs.

The Student also contended that the November 20, 2002, IEP was deficient in that it did not provide appropriate present levels of performance (PLOPs) and measurable goals and objectives with the result that the parties could not determine whether she made progress during the academic year. STUDENT also contended that the Lindamood-Bell test results should have been accepted as PLOPs by the District. The Student also contended that the District failed to reassess her and consequently could not have determined her unique needs or designed a program which met those needs. The Student contended that the District incorrectly classified her as Aother health impaired@ (OHI) due to attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), that her primary eligibility category should have been identified as Acognitive disorder,@ and also that her speech and language needs generated by her additional auditory processing disorder were missed or ignored by the District.

Finally, the Student seeks an order requiring the District to reimburse her for the cost of individual educational assessments and to pay for and provide compensatory education, specifically additional Lindamood-Bell speech and language therapy, to remediate her deficits in that area.

District=s Contentions.

The District contended that it did not violate procedural requirements of the IDEA and California law or, alternatively, if it did so, that such violations were not of such magnitude that they deprived the Student of educational opportunity.

The District contended that it considered the IEEs of Dr. Robert Patterson and Carol Atkins, as well as the testing of Lindamood-Bell and gave them appropriate weight in the development of the Student=s IEP of November 20, 2002.

The District contended the IEP team correctly determined that the Student had unique needs as a result of her disorders in attention and auditory and visual processing. These needs included, among other things, classroom accommodations and designated instruction and services in the area of speech and language. The District contended that it met those needs and that it also identified and met STUDENT=s auditory processing needs by including in her IEP specific goals and objectives addressed to each area. It contended further that those goals were based upon appropriate PLOPs and that they were measurable. Additionally, the District asserted that the RSP and speech and language programs it developed for the Student were designed more individually for the Student than the Lindamood-Bell programs requested by the Student.

The District contended that it correctly determined the Student=s unique needs based upon the assessments it considered and the progress reports made by the RSP teachers and staff.

The District contended that it assessed the Student appropriately in all areas of suspected disability and that its identification of the Student as a person with low cognitive ability and attention hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was correct. The latter designation qualified her for special education services under the category AOther Health Impaired@ (OHI), which the District contended was the Student=s primary disability. The District contended that the Student did not have a diagnosis of cognitive disorder. Finally, the District acknowledged that the Student exhibited auditory processing deficits and that, consequently, the District provided speech and language RSP services to address her needs in that area.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old fifth grade student at Perry Elementary School (Perry). Her legal residence is within the boundaries of the District and WOCCSE. She has attended Perry since kindergarten. She did not perform well academically in kindergarten which raised her parents= concerns. Ms. Parent observed that STUDENT=s academic difficulties were frustrating to her, affecting her ability to socialize with her peers. She withdrew from friends and became, in Ms. Parent=s words, Aa fly on the wall.@ It was apparent that STUDENT was not progressing either academically or socially by the time she was in second grade. Mr. and Mrs. Parent were appropriately concerned and asked the District to evaluate STUDENT for special education eligibility.

STUDENT was initially identified by the District as a special needs student in September 2000 because of problems with Aattention and visual processing.@ Her eligibility for special education and related services was first categorized as a specific learning disability (SLD). Her visual processing abilities were identified as her primary area of need. Consequently, a special education program was developed, consisting primarily of resource specialist services in the areas of her difficulty: vision and academics. An additional area of need, speech and language, was addressed with RSP services as well.

STUDENT=s parents filed a request for a due process hearing seeking a review of STUDENT=s educational program for academic year 2001-2002, the year prior to the one presently in issue. As part of the evaluation process, her parents engaged Robert Patterson, Psy.D., to conduct an independent psychoeducational assessment. In January 2001, Dr. Patterson diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD as well as disorders in written expression, fine motor coordination, and cognitive function. He also suggested that a central auditory processing assessment be conducted. A private audiology assessment was conducted by Carol Atkins, M.A., in August 2001. These private assessors each recommended Lindamood-Bell therapy to address STUDENT=s auditory processing needs.

The parties settled the prior due process hearing conflicts by agreeing, in part, that the District would pay for the two independent assessments and that, in addition to the resource services provided by the District, it would also pay for the Student to receive approximately 300 hours of intensive Lindamood-Bell services over a fifteen-week period. Those services were provided by the Lindamood-Bell clinic in Newport Beach, California between June 2002 and October 2002. They consisted of 311 hours of individual therapy, on a five-day-a-week, four- hour-per-day basis during this period.

The present matter involves STUDENT=s educational program for academic year 2002-2003. That academic year began September 2002, subsequent to the settlement but before the Lindamood-Bell services were concluded. However, it does not appear from the request for due process or from any evidence presented at the hearing that there is any dispute regarding STUDENT=s educational program prior to the conclusion of her Lindamood-Bell therapy on October 28, 2002. (Footnote 3)

On November 20, 2002, the annual review date, the IEP team developed an IEP which continued STUDENT=s eligibility for special education services under the category specific learning disability (SLD). The IEP provided her a general education placement with resource services in speech and language (S&L), vision therapy, occupational therapy (OT) and adaptive physical education (APE). The program and services were developed on the basis of the various educational assessments of the preceding year with the additions of the Woodcock-Johnson III, a standardized test of ability and performance, administered by school psychologist Shirley Lauri, and a speech and language assessment of November 2002, administered by the District speech pathologist Caryn (Wernle) Brown. Goals and objectives were adopted at the November 2002 IEP meeting in the areas of reading, writing, spelling, broad language, mathematics, speech and language, occupational therapy and vision. STUDENT=s parents were dissatisfied with what they contended was the lack of specificity and measurability of the goals and objectives and they requested further review. A review took place January 17, 2003. At that meeting STUDENT=s eligibility was changed to OHI, new goals and objectives were written in reading and mathematics and her individual speech and language therapy was increased to two thirty-minute sessions weekly. The IEP amendment of January 2003 did not alleviate the Student=s concerns.

STUDENT=s triennial IEP meeting, held at the conclusion of the 2002-2003 academic year, provided her prospectively with a general education placement supplemented with resource services. At no point during the 2002-2003 academic year did the District recommend additional Lindamood-Bell therapy as STUDENT requested. A request for a due process hearing was filed by the Student on July 7, 2003.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the conclusion of the testimony and as the hearing was closing on September 10, 2003, the last day of hearing, the District offered exhibits marked as Exhibit 32 and Exhibit 33 into evidence. These exhibits had not been identified previously or exchanged with Student=s counsel. A ruling on Student=s objection to the admission of these exhibits was deferred by the Hearing Officer due to the lateness of the hour. The Hearing Officer has considered the offer of the District and the objection by the Student and finds that neither the letter nor spirit of Section 56505.1(f) of the California Education Code, requiring exchange of exhibits five days prior to the commencement of the hearing, was followed and that it would be unfair to admit these exhibits without advance notice to Student=s counsel. The Hearing Officer therefore denies the admission of Exhibits 32 and 33 pursuant to California Education Code ' 56505.1(f).

The District also requested that the Hearing Officer sanction counsel for STUDENT for delaying tactics and sharp practices. Counsel for STUDENT responded in kind.

The due process hearing in this matter was commenced during the District=s summer vacation period. Both counsel agreed to be flexible and to accommodate witness availability in order to go forward with the hearing as scheduled. Consequently, witnesses were called out of order and neither Student=s nor District=s testimonial evidence was presented cohesively as a unit. The District contended that STUDENT took advantage of these circumstances and accommodations and by so doing effectively concealed the identity of experts she planned to call to testify and similarly concealed the written reports of her experts until the final few days of the hearing. STUDENT made similar contentions, alleging in part that the District concealed the identity of its expert psychologist until the final few days of the hearing. The Hearing Officer was aware of the nature of the problem and he therefore took steps to ensure that a late designation of witnesses and late production of exhibits would not prejudice the rights of any party. In that regard, the Hearing Officer delayed admission of exhibits until they had been in the hands of the objecting party for several days and, similarly, he delayed cross-examination of certain witnesses to give opposing counsel an ample opportunity to consider the direct testimony and adequately prepare for cross-examination.

In sum, due to the necessity of unusual scheduling, one or both of the parties may have attempted to use timing to schedule testimony or delay testimony to their tactical advantage. The Hearing Officer expressed his concern about this possibility during the hearing. However, the Hearing Officer does not have sufficient evidence to attribute improper motive and conduct to either party and consequently is unwilling to order sanctions against either party in this matter.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. '' 1400 et seq. Cal. Educ. Code '' 56000 et seq. The purpose of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and California=s conforming statutes is to provide students with disabilities access to public education. Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982). A free appropriate public education consists of special education and related services that are available to the child, at no charge to the parent or guardian, which meet the State educational standards and conform to the child=s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8). (Footnote 4)

ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction which meets the unique needs of the child and which enables the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56031. As the Supreme Court stated in Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, the program must be reasonably calculated to provide the pupil with educational benefit. The Act itself does not require that the benefits conferred maximize the potential of the student. Walczack v. Florida Union Free School District (2d Cir. 1998) 142 F.3d 117; Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm. 998 F.2d 1083 (1st Cir. 1993). What is required is entry to a Abasic floor of opportunity@ through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, at 201. The student=s IEP is to be implemented in the least restrictive environment and the special education and services provided must prepare the student for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. ' 1412; 34 C.F.R. ' 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345. State law and Rowley provide specific factors to be examined in an analysis of whether a school district substantially offered a FAPE. First, the offer must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student. Second, the program offered must be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. The third factor is that the program delivered must conform to the student=s IEP. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401. In addition, the Student=s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student=s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C.' 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. ' 300.347(a). A fourth factor which may be discussed is that the educational program must be provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. ' 1412. The fourth factor is not discussed in this Decision because it is not at issue.

The process of providing a FAPE follows several steps. A school district must first identify the student=s unique educational needs in all areas of the student=s suspected disability. Federal and State law describes the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child=s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law, Athe services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a free appropriate public education must be based on the child=s unique needs and not on the child=s disability.@ 34 C.F.R. ' 300.300(a)(3)(ii). Once those unique needs are determined, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district=s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district=s proposed program addresses the student=s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents= preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C.' 1401(8), '1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56031.

The Supreme Court also recognized the importance of adherence to procedural requirements in Rowley, supra at 201. Federal law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and to ensure that parents are involved in the formulation of the student=s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. But procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., supra at 1484.

A. PROCEDURAL ISSUES

1. During academic year 2002-2003 did the District and WOCCSE fail to comply with the procedural requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA): (a) by failing to invite Robert Patterson, Psy.D., Carol Atkins, M.A., and a representative of Lindamood-Bell to IEP meetings;

STUDENT contended that the District committed several procedural violations that resulted in the denial of a FAPE. Each of those allegations will be discussed in turn below.

STUDENT contended that the District committed a procedural violation resulting in denial of a FAPE by failing to invite or otherwise ensure attendance at IEP meetings of Lindamood-Bell personnel and of Dr. Robert Patterson and Carol Atkins who, STUDENT states, had knowledge of her disabilities and unique needs.

The Education Code specifies persons who must attend the IEP meeting and persons who may attend the meeting. In that regard, California Education Code ' 56341(b)(6) also provides for the attendance at the pupil=s IEP meeting of Aother individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related service personnel, as appropriate.@ A school district is responsible for ensuring the attendance of all parties necessary for the development of a complete IEP. Where the facts warrant, a school district has been held to have denied a FAPE by failing to secure the presence of parties necessary to the meeting. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F2d. 1479. In Target Range, supra, the student attended a private school. The school district failed to invite private school representatives, including the student=s regular classroom teacher, to the student=s IEP meeting. Because those persons were the persons who had direct knowledge of the student=s abilities and performance, the Court of Appeals held that failure to assure their attendance resulted in denial of a FAPE. In so doing, the court stated, A The Act imposes upon the school district the duty to conduct a meaningful meeting with the appropriate parties.@ (960 F2d at 1485).

District witnesses testified that in developing STUDENT=s educational program that was formulated at the annual IEP meeting of November 14, 2002, the principal IEP meeting for the academic year in issue, they relied on information derived from a combination of sources to determine the areas of STUDENT=s handicaps which were continuing to require special education. Those sources included the updated 2001 vision assessment of Jane Vogel, the updated psychoeducational assessment of school psychologist Shirley Lauri, the assessment of speech and language pathologist Caryn Brown, and the written progress reports contained in STUDENT=s school records.

Ms. Brown testified that she did not need the presence of or additional input of Carol Atkins or of Lindamood-Bell to develop an educational plan that dealt with STUDENT=s speech and language issues, including her language/auditory processing issues. She testified that she read and understood the historical written materials provided from each of the Student=s private consultants or evaluators and she developed enough new information and data to proceed with the development of STUDENT=s IEP.

District personnel who attended the IEP meeting in November 2002 were familiar with the therapy services STUDENT received at Lindamood-Bell and they were aware of the progressSTUDENT made during the academic year in issue because they were also providing services to her through the RSP program on a daily basis during the school week. In addition, the District providers were trained in Lindamood-Bell programs as well as in their own areas of expertise and they were competent to assess the test data which had been provided. Thus, according to the testimony presented by the District, which the Hearing Officer finds persuasive, there was no necessity to invite a clinician from that program to be personally present at the IEP meeting.

Finally, Ms. Lauri, a certified school psychologist, testified that she also had sufficient recent psychoeducational test data to proceed and saw no reason to invite Dr. Patterson to the November 2002 IEP to discuss further his diagnostic impressions which had been formulated 18 months previously. He was not STUDENT=s regular or current service provider, only an evaluator in this case. She testified that she was competent to interpret his test data and recommendations as historically relevant and to supplement this information with more recent test data and information, as she did.

There were sufficiently trained persons present at the IEP meeting of November 12, 2002 to thoroughly assess STUDENT=s IEP. The District witnesses who testified at the hearing were familiar with STUDENT=s handicaps, performance and progress. Assuring the attendance of the specified persons would not have added more or different information to the meeting. This was a different situation from the one that existed in W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23, supra, where the only people who had direct information about the student were the private school providers and it was they who were excluded from the meeting. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the failure to invite the persons specified did not constitute a procedural violation which denied STUDENT a FAPE. (Footnote 5) (b) by failing to require the general education teacher and the speech therapist to attend all meetings of the IEP team;

California Education Code ' 56341(b) compels the attendance at IEP meetings of certain IEP team members. The team consists of persons described in the statute, including one regular education teacher of the pupil and one special education teacher or special education provider.

The evidence showed that the District complied with the Education Code cited above. The November 20, 2002 IEP meeting was attended by Stephanie Motske, the general education teacher, and by Julia Voce, RSP specialist, Jane Vogel, RSP consultant, and Caryn Wernle, speech and language pathologist. The January 17, 2003 IEP addendum meeting was attended by fewer persons, but those who were in attendance included the general education teacher and the RSP and speech and language pathologist whose goals and objectives were the subject of discussion. The June 9, 2003 triennial IEP meeting was attended by a full complement of teachers and providers. There does not appear to be any evidence to support the Petitioner=s contention on this point and the Hearing Officer so finds.

(c) by failing to provide timely notice to the parents of a denial of requested Lindamood-Bell services;

Mr. Russell testified that at the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, he and STUDENT=s parents requested additional Lindamood-Bell services. The evidence showed that the District did not provide a stand-alone, written denial of that request until July 11, 2003. However, STUDENT was provided with a written notice of procedural safeguards, an opportunity to mediate the denial of the request, and an opportunity to request and obtain a due process hearing on the issue.

20 U.S.C. ' 1415 (b)(3)(B) and 34 C.F.R. ' 300.503(a)(1)(ii), cited by STUDENT in her written closing argument, provide for reasonable prior written notice of the District=s refusal to initiate or change the identification, evaluation or educational placement of, or the provision of FAPE to, the handicapped pupil. The term Areasonable@ is not defined in the statute. The issue here is whether the Student had reasonable notice of the District=s position. The evidence established that STUDENT did have such notice.

STUDENT requested further Lindamood-Bell program hours at the IEP meeting of November 20, 2002. She had completed her 311-hour program on October 28, 2002. The District denied her request for the additional Lindamood-Bell services. The IEP itself contains reference to that denial. Mr. Russell acknowledges the denial of the request in his written addendum, attached to the November 20, 2002 IEP, stating AEven though STUDENT made these gains [from the Lindamood-Bell therapy of the preceding year], the District is unwilling to continue any level of therapy.@ Thus STUDENT=s argument that she did not receive Anotice@ is purely technical. She in fact was well-aware of the denial of her request for services.

Similarly, on January 17, 2003, Mr. Russell writes, AThe District has refused to even consider the continuation of the Lindamood-Bell learning processes programs.@ That written statement also is attached and made a part of the IEP addendum to which it relates.

STUDENT did not claim at any time in these proceedings that she was unaware of the District=s position. She did not claim that the failure to write a specific letter to her denying her claim until July 2003 caused her any harm or prejudice.

It is therefore clear that the Student had reasonable notice of the District=s position throughout the school year. The notice is evidenced in two instances by written statements attached to an IEP of the Student. The Hearing Officer finds substantial compliance with the notice provision of IDEA cited above, does not find any evidence that STUDENT was prejudiced by a technical failure to comply, and denies STUDENT=s contention to the effect that she was not reasonably notified of the District=s refusal to continue Lindamood-Bell therapy.

(d) by failing to turn over the Student=s school records pursuant to her request?

Mr. Russell testified at the hearing that he made a written request for student records. Mr. Russell could not produce documentary evidence to prove that a request was made. District special education director John Conniff testified that he did not recall any such request. Mr. Conniff=s testimony was credible. When questioned by the Hearing Officer, Mr. Russell could not attribute prejudice to the Student=s present due process case as the result of any failure to produce records. The parties reached a stipulated agreement at the hearing by which the records allegedly requested were in fact produced with the proviso that if the produced records contained information relevant to this hearing, STUDENT would file a motion to reopen the proceedings. No such motion was filed.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Student failed to establish that a request for production of student records had been made. Furthermore, even assuming arguendo that a request had been made, there was no evidence offered to show that a failure to comply prejudiced the Student, prevented her parents from meaningful participation in the IEP process, or resulted in a substantial loss of educational opportunity to the Student.

2. If the District is found to have failed to comply with the procedural requirements of IDEA, did those violations result in a denial of FAPE?

In view of the findings above, this issue is moot.

B. SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES.

1. Did the District and WOCCSE fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for academic year 2002-2003:

(a) by failing to assess the Student in all areas of suspected disability;

STUDENT=s contention is succinctly stated in her written closing argument as follows: ADespite Suspected Disabilities in the Area of Auditory Processing, Short Term Memory, Pragmatic Language, and Cognitive Disorder, Respondents Conducted No Assessment in Those Areas.@ Instead, STUDENT argues, the District focused on her ADHD, virtually ignoring everything else.

(i) Auditory Processing, short term memory, and pragmatic language.

As stated above, STUDENT was first found eligible for special education and related services in academic year 2000-2001. During that year and the academic year following, she was provided with special education and related services in several areas, including speech and language (S&L). By academic year 2002-2003, the parties had amassed considerable information regarding STUDENT=s areas of disability. The parties both agreed at some level that auditory processing was an area of STUDENT=s disability, although they appeared to define the term Aauditory processing@ somewhat differently. Caryn Brown testified that speech pathologists working in the public school systems define auditory processing and language processing as the same thing. She stated that in basic terms, auditory processing was Amaking sense from auditory stimuli.@ Furthermore, she stated that this processing skill is dependent on memory. Dr. Schnell, who was a higly credentialled consulting school psychologist, concurred. And school psychologist Shirley Lauri agreed that STUDENT had auditory processing deficits. (Footnote 6) Ms. Atkins testified that, from the perspective of the audiologist, auditory processing is a function of the way in which the brain integrates input from the different hemispheres. (Footnote 7) When the Hearing Officer compares the testimony of these experts relating to their observations and tests of STUDENT=s functioning, it is apparent that they were measuring, if not the same, very similar functions. For example, speech pathologist Brown testified in part that the low scores on portions of the CTOPP she administered to STUDENT demonstrated her difficulties with auditory memory, reading comprehension, semantics and phonemic awareness. Ms. Atkins stated that her formal assessment of August 27, 2003, in part, showed that STUDENT experienced difficulty in reading comprehension, short term memory, phonological processing, and auditory-visual integration.

Ms. Atkins also identified potential ADHD issues in her testing, testifying that these two categories shared some of the same or similar symptoms. For example, the student is easily distracted in both disorders. In auditory processing, this Aattentional@ issue is the result of inability to integrate or interpret auditory input. In ADHD, the inability to attend is due to hyperactivity.

For academic year 2002-2003, the District speech and language provider was speech pathologist Caryn Brown. (Footnote 8) Ms. Brown attended all of STUDENT=s IEP meetings for academic year 2002-2003. She testified that she reviewed the 2001 S &L assessment of District speech pathologist Nina Welch, reviewed the Lindamood-Bell test data and conducted an assessment of STUDENT for the November 2002 IEP. For her formal assessment, she selected standardized tests well known in the field, i.e., the Language Processing Test (LPT), Test of Language Development-3 (TOLD-3), and Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP). Ms. Wernle Brown testified that these tests include subtests that identify language processing/auditory processing weaknesses or disorders. Moreover, she testified that her assessment results showed that STUDENT still had weaknesses in areas of auditory processing, short term memory, semantics and pragmatic language or problem solving. She also pointed out that certain of the accommodations she recommended to address auditory processing needs also addressed STUDENT=s attentional issues. Ms. Brown testified that because of her interaction with and direct observations of STUDENT, her review of STUDENT=s records and her new assessment data, she needed no additional information to attend and participate meaningfully in the November 2002 IEP. In other words, contrary to STUDENT=s assertion, it was evident that auditory processingBincluding the areas of short term memory and pragmatic languageBwere evaluated by the District, both formally (using the CTOPP and Woodcock-Johnson-III) and informally.

(ii) ADHD

STUDENT contended that the District imprudently focused on ADHD when it should have devoted its resources to auditory processing. However, STUDENT agreed that there was overlap in the symptoms and in the accommodations utilized in the treatment of both disorders. No one presented evidence to dispute the ADHD diagnosis made by experts from both parties.

Julia Voce, an RSP teacher who worked with STUDENT daily in the areas of visual processing and language processing also attended the November 2002 IEP meeting. Ms.Voce=s special area of interest is ADHD. She testified that she used the 2001 Woodcock-Johnson-III assessment as a baseline for providing services at the beginning of academic year 2002-2003, supplemented by the input by the speech pathologists and her own experience and training. She testified that she identified a mix of auditory processing and ADHD issues from her work with STUDENT, stating that the symptoms of each frequently overlap, requiring a mix of teaching methods and exercises. Jack Schnell, Ed.D., a consulting forensic psychologist, (Footnote 9)testified that there was considerable overlap in the symptomatology of ADHD and auditory processing deficit. Moreover, he pointed out that Dr. Patterson=s report of February 2001 contains a formal diagnosis of ADHD.

An adaptive physical education assessment was completed by the District in February 2002 for use in developing STUDENT=s educational program for 2002-2003. Of significance on the subject of suspected disability, the APE specialist observed that STUDENT=s Aattentional difficulties@ impacted her by making it difficult for her to concentrate and follow prompts required for consistent fitness and strength training.

No expert testimony was presented which took issue with an ADHD diagnosis.

(iii) Cognitive Disorder.

Dr. Patterson included Acognitive disorder@ as one of his Axis I diagnoses. He based his conclusion, reported in his January 2001 assessment, on STUDENT=s standard score of 85 on the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery Revised Test of Cognition. Dr. Schnell testified that in reviewing the 2001 assessment, he concluded that Dr. Patterson=s diagnosis was based on the language of his profession, the DSM-IV, the diagnostic manual developed for the use of clinical psychologists. Dr. Schnell pointed out that while there were similarities, the language of the clinical psychologist and that of the school psychologist differed. In particular, he stated, the term cognitive disorder as used in the DSM-IV suggests an organic brain malfunction and he pointed out that Dr. Patterson did not present any evidence of a neurological, medical or physical malfunction. Dr. Schnell did not believe that pursuant to the standards of the profession, the diagnosis of cognitive disorder would be appropriate unless one could point to direct evidence of brain malfunction. Dr. Schnell also testified that in his review of all of STUDENT=s contemporary testing he did not find any indication of cognitive disorder. He rejected Dr. Patterson=s diagnosis. Ms. Lauri, the District=s school psychologist, concurred with Dr. Schnell. She testified that she read and reviewed the Patterson report and that she disagreed with the portion relating to cognitive disorder because there was no evidence in support of that diagnosis. Dr. Patterson did not testify at the due process hearing.

Thus, while the District identified ADHD as STUDENT=s primary disorder, it also continued to acknowledge that STUDENT=s language processing or auditory processing deficits, including short term memory and pragmatic language required substantial RSP services. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s contention that the District failed to identify all areas of her suspected disabilities is incorrect. The areas of STUDENT=s concern were examined by the appropriate District experts and those areas were in fact identified as areas of suspected disability, except for Acognitive disorder@ which was appropriately rejected. STUDENT was not denied a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 because of a failure to assess all areas of STUDENT=s suspected disability.

The Hearing Officer will now turn to an examination of the District=s response to the information developed in the assessment process.

(b) by failing to review assessments provided by the parents;

Christopher Russell, STUDENT=s educational advocate, testified that he and STUDENT=s parents provided the District with three assessments: first, the psychoeducational evaluation conducted by Robert Patterson, Psy.D., which in relevant part made a diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and cognitive disorder; second, the report of Carol Atkins, M.A., an audiologist, which found auditory processing deficits; and third, the testing by the Lindamood-Bell clinic in Newport Beach, California, which was offered to establish present levels of performance for the IEP of November, 2002.

STUDENT=s contention appears to be three-fold. First, she contended that the reports of private evaluators must be considered by the District. The Hearing Officer finds that the reports were considered by District members of the IEP team. The testimony showed that the Patterson and Atkins evaluations were considered as part of the historical context of STUDENT=s progress with her previously identified areas of disability. Dr. Schnell testified that prior assessments are useful to the District in terms of context and consistency and that they contain valuable information. Both Ms. Lauri and Ms. Brown testified that they reviewed and considered these assessments in connection with the November 2002 IEP. Elaine Keeley, Perry school principal, John Conniff, special education director, and Julia Voce, RSP specialist, all testified that they reviewed and considered Dr. Patterson=s report. Carol Atkins= 2001 audiology evaluation was reviewed by John Conniff, and presumably by Jennifer Heller, RSP provider who testified, Aif it was in the student=s file, I read it.@ Finally, as discussed above, the District members of the IEP team also reviewed and considered the Lindamood-Bell testing. According to the testimony of STUDENT=s educational advocate, Christopher Russell, who described the discussion of District personnel at the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, it was clear from the discussion of some of the scores of the Lindamood-Bell testing that the District had received and reviewed the clinic=s test results. That discussion signifies that the Lindamood-Bell test results were considered by the District. Those test results were useful to demonstrate STUDENT=s progress, whether or not consideration of the tests is mandated by the California Education Code and I.D.E.A. (Footnote 10)

Second, STUDENT contended that the reports she provided should have been give more weight by the IEP team. However, the evidence demonstrated that since those assessments had been conducted, intensive special education services have been delivered to STUDENT, namely 311 hours of Lindamood-Bell and a nearly equal number of hours in RSP. As a result of the RSP services, she had overcome most if not all of her visual deficits and she made great progress in gross motor skill and strength development. As a consequence of the RSP speech and language and Lindamood-Bell services combined, STUDENT made progress in her auditory processing and other S&L areas. The reports certainly were useful in showing that progress had been made. But it may be fairly stated that STUDENT=s progress reports and the recent assessments, updating her levels of performance, were certainly more relevant to the consideration of the Student=s educational program for 2002-2003. Thus it was appropriate, in the opinion of the Hearing Officer, to give the contemporary reports and evaluations more weight.

Finally, STUDENT contended that the Patterson, Atkins and Lindamood-Bell reports were required to be considered by the IEP team at the IEP meeting itself. The District does have a duty to consider independent assessments provided by the Student. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56329(c). No support was offered for the Student=s contention that the consideration must take place at a certain time or place. The Education Code requires consideration of a tendered assessment by a qualified expert but there is no provision that requires that consideration to be made at the IEP meeting itself.

(c) by failing to reassess the Student for the annual IEP for academic year 2002-2003;

STUDENT contended that the District could not determine STUDENT=s unique needs for the 2003-2003 academic year without reassessing her in all areas of her disability.

District witnesses testified that in developing the educational program for STUDENT that was formulated at the IEP meeting of November 14, 2002, the principal IEP meeting for the academic year in issue, they relied on information derived from a combination of sources to determine the areas of STUDENT=s disability which were continuing to require special education. Those sources included the 2001 vision assessment of Jane Vogel, the assessment of school psychologist Shirley Lauri, the assessment of speech and language pathologist Caryn Wernle Brown and the written progress reports contained in STUDENT=s school records.

The District has an obligation to conduct an initial assessment of a student=s individual educational needs before any action is taken with respect to placing the student in a special education program. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320. In the present matter, STUDENT=s initial special education program was initiated in academic year 2000-2001.

A formal reassessment of a student is not required every year unless conditions warrant. (Footnote 11) Here conditions did not warrant such a reassessment. The information from the prior assessments was still relevant because the three-year time-line for reassessing had not run; the Student was in the District school every day and was observed on a daily basis by the RSP and general education teacher; and updated test data and information on the Student=s progress was available.

(d) by failing to determine the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing;

STUDENT contended that the District failed to determine her unique needs in auditory processing, central auditory processing or cognitive disorder. (Footnote 12) Carol Atkins, the principal expert relied upon by STUDENT, testified that students with auditory processing deficits find it difficult to discriminate speech and non-speech through background noise and have difficulty with temporal processing, recognition of pitch, ordering of sound signals, ordering and spacing sounds and making phonemic discriminations. She indicated further that students with these deficits exhibit difficulties with reading, language and spelling and become overwhelmed by the inability to discriminate auditory information and integrate it with visual information. Consequently, she observed, they stop processing altogether and become inattentive, off-task and out of focus. STUDENT, who fits this syndrome in Ms. Atkins= opinion, needs the teacher to deliver information with a slow speech rate, a quiet environment, one-to-one S&L therapy, OT therapy, classroom accommodations, assistive technology and a multi-sensory reading program.

At the November 20, 2002 IEP, the District determined that based upon the information it had from assessments and progress reports, STUDENT=s needs included continued individual instruction and services in RSP, vision, APE, OT and speech and language. It was determined that STUDENT needed a reading program provided in a one-to-one setting 90 minutes per day during which the RSP provider combined techniques designed to address phonology, phonetics, multi-sensory integration, listening comprehension, fluency, math calculation and reasoning. Julia Voce, RSP teacher, was to provide this part of the program. STUDENT also needed vision therapy, provided 30 minutes per day in a one-to-one setting, and formal individual S&L therapy, provided once a week for 30 minutes. Additionally, it was determined that STUDENT=s needs included: the provision of her curriculum in visual, auditory and kinesthetic modalities; a slow and repetitive oral presentation; special classroom seating arranged to keep her focus; extra time for tests; and, finally, the length of tests should be shortened. Finally, assistive technology was also proposed for STUDENT to provide her assistance with focus in the classroom.

STUDENT=s parents and Mr. Russell testified that STUDENT needed a program with the characteristics of the Lindamood-Bell program to address her auditory processing. Lindamood-Bell was represented at the due process hearing by Jackie Earwood, its Southern California clinical director. Lindamood-Bell is an NPA which is certified by the State of California to provide services to students in what Ms. Earwood described as symbol imagery, concept imagery, phonetic awareness and mathematics. Ms. Earwood testified that Lindamood-Bell determined that STUDENT needed to further develop her skills in phonemic awareness and concept imagery. The programs recommended for her were Avisualizing and verbalizing,@ a program directed to auditory conceptualization, and ASeeing Stars,@ a program directed to visual memory.

As stated above, except for the name of the program, the District made the same determination. Ms. Voce, who worked with STUDENT two hours per day in RSP, testified that her training over the years has included Project Read, a multisensory reading and language program dealing with phonology strands, using the senses of touch, smell and taste to anchor visual and auditory memory. In addition, she was trained in the Herman Method which teaches reading, focusing on scripted sequential programming, and the ALanguage! Program@ which uses some of the techniques of the other programs, but focuses on more language strands, including a grammatical component. Ms. Austin=s class has a forty-five minute daily segment of work in the ALanguage! Program@ which the District offered to STUDENT. STUDENT was in Ms. Voce=s RSP for two hours daily, working on math and reading/language goals. Ms. Brown was providing speech pathology consulting to STUDENT two hours per month, and she offered additional speech therapy on a weekly basis as well. Ms. Hiller who had similar training was also cross-trained in Lindamood-Bell programs. She testified that both trainings were similar and were directed to address the the same needs.

The Hearing Officer has considered the testimony and has additionally read and considered the IEP proposed at the November 20, 2002 meeting as modified January 17, 2003. This evidence demonstrates that there was basic consensus among the experts for both parties as to the determination of STUDENT=s unique needs and that those needs were appropriately identified.

(e) by failing to develop appropriate present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives;

The November 20, 2002 IEP and the January 17, 2003 IEP addendum proposed goals and objectives to address all areas of STUDENT=s needs. With regard to auditory processing, thearea which is in dispute in this case, goals and objectives were proposed by the speech pathologist and school psychologist and included in the November 20, 2002 IEP.

STUDENT contended that these goals and objectives were vague and in any event were not measurable. Additionally, she contended that the IEPs contained no specific present levels of performance (PLOPs) which further exacerbated the ability of STUDENT=s parents and experts to determine whether educational benefit had been conferred. The November 20, 2002 IEP used the Woodcock-Johnson III test scores in the PLOP sections. In addtiion to the test scores, written progress reports and the academic assessment of STUDENT=s RSP provider were provided at the IEP meeting and were used by providers to provide services and assess progress during the academic year. The PLOPs used by the District were consistent and adequate. STUDENT=s contention, as it relates to PLOPs, is therefore rejected. (Footnote 13)

The problems with the measurability of goals, complained of by STUDENT, were set forth with particular specificity in STUDENT=s written closing argument in summary form as follows (1) November 20, 2002 IEP: ASTUDENT will read text with appropriate fluency and accuracy . . . . @; ASTUDENT will decode correctly the target words . . . .@; A STUDENT will spell target words . . . . @; (2) January 17, 2003 IEP: ASTUDENT will read the words aloud . . . . @; ASTUDENT will read the passage accurately and fluently . . . . @; ASTUDENT will improve her ability to identify and solve . . . age appropriate problems . . . . @

Examination of the November 20, 2002 IEP reveals STUDENT=s criticism to be valid. The first goal provides that the text specified is Aa narrative text at her reading level.@ Her reading level is not specified. The target words specified in the second goal are contained in a list of A100 priority sight words.@ However the list itself is not specified or otherwise identified. Next, the IEP contains a statement that the target words to be spelled are set forth in a Alist of spelling words including short and long vowels . . . @ Again, no list is specified or otherwise identified.

Julia Voce testified that she was familiar with STUDENT and with her progress and as the RSP provider knew exactly what lists were being utilized and whether or not STUDENT was making progress. The Hearing Officer has no reason to doubt Ms. Voce=s testimony. However, the Education Code requires objective Ameasurability@ not subjective measurability. The intent is to provide any RSP provider and the parents with objective information so that any RSP provider may step in and provide meaningful services to the student and so that the parents are kept abreast of their child=s progress.

In contrast, the references in the January 17, 2003 addendum to word lists and reading passages are specified in the IEP addendum as references to the second and fourth grade Brigance Word Recognition List. In fact, all of the goals and short-term objectives in the January revision are described with the specificity desired, not only in terms of the source of the material to be used but also in terms of the precise level of accuracy to be obtained. Thus by January 17, 2003, the objection to the vagueness and non-measurability of the goals had been resolved and the defect in the IEP document had been cured.

To the extent that measurable goals and objectives were not provided in the November 20, 2002 IEP and to the extent that this defect continued until January 17, 2003, an estimated period of six school weeks (taking into account the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays), the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE in the manner provided by the Education Code for this six-week period. (Footnote 14)

(f) by failing to provide services designed to meet the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing?

In addition to the services provided by the clinic, Ms. Voce provided STUDENT with services similar to those provided by the Lindamood-Bell clinic. Comparing the progress reports and academic assessment delivered at the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting with the psychoeducational evaluation conducted at the end of the 2002-2003 school year, Ms. Voce testified that the test instruments demonstrated STUDENT=s consistency in these areas. Dr. Schnell testified that STUDENT demonstrated progress by maintaining the same level of performance relative to that of students her own age. The level of difficulty of the standardized tests increases during the passage of each school year for a student, thus maintaining the same percentile indicates that the student made a year of growth. Ms. Voce pointed out during her testimony that STUDENT made substantial progress in math as well as reading and language. It was her opinion that the techniques she was using were similar to and as effective as the Lindamood-Bell programs and that the progress reported in June 2003 demonstrated that the District=s program did address STUDENT=s unique needs and in addition did provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Jennifer Hiller, STUDENT=s new RSP provider, brought additional perspective to the hearing. Ms. Hiller also commented that in her opinion pulling STUDENT out of school four hours per day was unwise as it was disruptive to her general education and social interaction. Ms. Hiller, who has training and experience in some of the Lindamood-Bell programs, testified that she was able to compare the effectiveness of the various programs proposed for STUDENT. Based upon her experience, she testified that it was her opinion that STUDENT would benefit more from the District=s program than from another round of Lindamood-Bell. The District=s speech pathologist testified that she approached STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits in a number of ways including semantics programs, the use of problem solving goals, the use of a program known as Lingui Systems which deals with auditory processing areas, and speech therapy directed to the goals and objectives set forth in the January 17, 2003 addendum. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence viewed in its entirety establishes the fact that during academic year 2002-2003 the District=s RSP and general education program for STUDENT and the Lindamood-Bell program administered to STUDENT had many similar characteristics and they were designed to improve STUDENT=s functioning in the auditory processing area.

Thus STUDENT was provided services directed to visual and auditory needs from both the District and Lindamood-Bell in September and October 2002. The October 29, 2002, retesting by the clinic indicated that STUDENT had made progress since February 2002. (Footnote 15)

Carol Atkins testified that her updated August 2003 evaluation demonstrated that STUDENT had shown significant progress with auditory processing issues since Ms. Atkins= prior evaluation of April 2001. She attributed this progress to a combination of factors, among them the District=s RSP program, the natural process of maturation and the Lindamood-Bell program. Similarly, the District school psychologist testified that when she retested STUDENT for her triennial IEP in June 2003, the results demonstrated progress.

The District designed a program for academic year 2002-2003 to meet STUDENT=s needs in auditory processing as well as in other areas not here in dispute. The program was intended to confer educational benefit and the testimony of the experts for both parties establishes that it did so. The program delivered during the prior academic year included a Lindamood-Bell component, but there was no evidence by which the Hearing Officer could determine what part that program played in STUDENT=s progress. Therefore the Hearing Officer is unable to address that contention. However, the Hearing Officer finds on the basis of the evidence presented that STUDENT did receive a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003, with the exception that during six weeks of that year there was no adequate way to measure progress because of a defect in the written goals and objectives.

2. If the District failed to provide the Student a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003, is the Student entitled to receive compensatory education?

The Student was provided a FAPE for the academic year in issue, with the exception of the six-week period during which measurable goals and objectives were not contained in her IEP. In view of the finding that this failure did not adversely affect the Student=s educational opportunity, this issue is rendered moot.

3. If the Student is entitled to compensatory education, should the District be ordered to provide Lindamood-Bell services to her?

Since the Student is not entitled to compensatory education, this issue is rendered moot.

4. Should the Student be provided an independent psychoeducational assessment and independent educational assessments in speech and language and academics at the District=s expense?

STUDENT requests an order for independent educational assessments at District expense. The determining factor, then, is whether the assessments of the District in these areas were Aappropriate@ as that term is defined in the California Education Code.

Assessments must be conducted by individuals who are both Aknowledgeable of the student=s disability@ and Acompetent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.@ Cal. Educ. Code ''56320(g), 56322; 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(b)(3)(B)(ii). Tests and assessment materials must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; must be selected and administered so as not to be racially discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the student=s primary language or other mode of communication unless this is clearly not feasible; and must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of such tests. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(a),(b); 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(2), (3). A psychological assessment must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56324.

With regard to STUDENT, the District paid for and relied on Ms. Atkins= audiology assessment administered in April 2001. There was no dispute as to Ms. Atkins= credentials. In addition, the District utilized speech pathologist Nina Welch=s 2001 speech and language assessment and the formal assessment of Caryn Brown conducted for the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Brown holds a master=s degree in speech pathology. She testified that part of her education included specific training in the administration of speech and language tests. She administered standardized tests commonly used in the field (the LPT, TOLD-3 and CTOPP), administered them in the Student=s primary language, and testified that they had been found not to be racially discriminatory.

Similarly, the District paid for and utilized Dr. Patterson=s 2001 psychoeducational evaluation. No one disputed Dr. Patterson=s credentials. His work was updated for the November 20, 2002 IEP by Julia Voce, who administered the Woodcock-Johnson-III. Ms. Voce had 28 years of experience as an SDC teacher and RSP specialist at Huntington Beach and used the testing to assist her in providing RSP services to STUDENT. Shirley Lauri, the District=s credentialed school psychologist, performed a psychoeducational evaluation in April 2003. Ms. Lauri used the KABC, Burke=s Behavior Rating, Conner=s, VADS and Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration Skills. These tests were used for the purposes for which they were intended, were not racially discriminatory and were administered in the student=s primary language. Finally, the District also conducted academic assessments as appropriate. In addition to the academic information developed by Ms. Lauri, Ms. Brown and Ms. Voce, the general education teacher Stephanie Austin conducted academic testing and Ms. Voce developed academic information during her visual skills training and testing. For the triennial IEP meeting of June 2003 there was a new health assessment prepared by the school nurse; the vision consultant prepared a new vision assessment; a new fine motor assessment was prepared; the speech pathologist updated her progress reports; and the RSP teacher also updated her progress reports.

STUDENT did not contend or present evidence that any of the above assessments were inappropriate as that term is used in California Education Code sections 56329 and 56321. Thus, the Hearing Officer declines to order independent educational assessments for academic year 2002-2003 at District expense in this matter. (Footnote 16)

ORDER

(1) The request for compensatory education for academic year 2002-2003 is denied.

(2) The request for an independent educational evaluation to be performed at District expense for academic year 2002-2003 is denied.

(3) All other relief is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

A. PROCEDURAL ISSUES.

1. During academic year 2002-2003 did the District and WOCCSE fail to comply with the procedural requirements of the individuals with disabilities education act (IDEA):

(a) by failing to invite Robert Patterson, Psy.D., Carol Atkins, M.A., and a representative of Lindamood-Bell to IEP meetings;

(b) by failing to require the general education teacher and the speech therapist to attend all meetings of the IEP team; (c) by failing to provide timely notice to the parents of a denial of requested Lindamood-Bell services; and, (d) by failing to turn over the Student=s school records pursuant to her request?

The District prevailed on procedural issue No. 1, subsections (a) through and including (d). 2. If the District is found to have failed to comply with the procedural requirements of IDEA, did those violations result in a denial of a FAPE?

The District prevailed on this issue.

B. SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES.

1. Did the District and WOCCSE fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for academic year 2002-2003:

(a) by failing to assess the Student in all areas of suspected disability;

(b) by failing to review assessments provided by the parents;

(c) by failing to reassess the Student for the annual IEP for academic year 2002-2003;

(d) by failing to determine the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing;

(e) by failing to develop appropriate present levels of performance and measurable goals and objectives; and, (f) by failing to provide services designed to meet the Student=s unique needs in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing?

The Respondents prevailed substantially on substantive issues B.1., except for a six-week period of academic year 2002-2003 during which the written goals and objectives were found by the hearing Officer not to be measurable within the meaning of the California Education Code.

2. If the District failed to provide the Student a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003, is the Student entitled to receive compensatory education?

This issue is moot.

3. If the Student is entitled to compensatory education, should the District be ordered to provide Lindamood-Bell services to her? This issue is moot.

4. Should the Student be provided an independent psychoeducational assessment and independent educational assessments in speech and language and academics at the District=s expense?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Dated: November 11, 2003 ____________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The wording and sequence of the issues stated differs somewhat from the statement of the issues originally filed by Petitioner. They are restated here for purposes of focus and clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made. 2. For convenience the District and WOCCSE will be referred to collectively in the singular in this Decision as the ADistrict,@ except where the context requires otherwise. 3 There was a complaint made during the hearing that, during September and October 2002, STUDENT was not provided time for her lunch when she arrived at Perry after the Lindamood-Bell therapy. The evidence demonstrated that when STUDENT was transported to Perry from Lindamood-Bell, she came directly to the RSP room. The RSP teacher gave STUDENT time to eat lunch when she arrived. Thus her educational program was not negatively impacted as alleged. 4. Each special education student=s program is memorialized in a document referred to as an IEP. California Education Code Section 56345 describes the required content of an IEP. Section 56345(a)(2)(A-B) provides that an IEP shall contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to Ameeting the pupil=s needs that result from the pupil=s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum@ and Ameeting each of the pupil=s other educational needs that result from the pupils=s disability.@ 5. It should be noted that no one at the District attempted to block the attendance at the IEP of any of Student=s experts. The Student had the right to invite additional persons to the IEP meeting, but chose not to do so. 6. Dr. Schnell rejected the cognitive disorder diagnosis of January 2001. He pointed out that the diagnosis is a DSM-IV category (psychology) not an educational category. Furthermore, he stated that such a diagnosis implies a medical condition, such as brain injury and no such evidence existed in STUDENT=s case. School psychologist Lauri also stated that cognitive disorder was a term reserved for brain damaged persons. She, too, ruled out cognitive disorder. There was no medical evidence in November 2002 that such a diagnosis was appropriate. 7. Ms. Atkins acknowledged that Acentral auditory processing@ and Aauditory processing,@ though originally discrete terms, now were used interchangeably. Additionally, she acknowledged that the remediation of auditory processing deficits is a multi-disciplinary undertaking, involving principally audiologists and speech and language providers. 8. Lindamood-Bell also provided speech and language services, until approximately October 28, 2002. 9 Dr. Schnell was recently initiated as a Diplomate in the American Academy of Forensic Psychologists 10 The District also contended that the Lindamood-Bell test results were not evaluations of the kind and character specified in California Education Code Section 56329. STUDENT contended that the District was not qualified to interpret Lindamood-Bell test scores. According to the testimony of Jackie Earwood, clinical director of the Newport Beach Lindamood-Bell clinic, the training given by Lindamood-Bell in administering and interpreting test scores consists of only a one-week course. Certified speech pathologist Caryn Brown testified that extensive training is necessary to qualify to give and interpret standardized tests in this area. The Hearing Officer expressly declines to include in this Decision a ruling on those conflicting contentions as the District did in fact consider the scores as indicators of progress-the point that Mr. Russell wished to make. 11A reassessment is required at least once every three years. Cal. Educ. Code. ' 56381.

12. Dr. Patterson=s diagnosis of cognitive disorder was rejected on the basis of the evidence as discussed above. It will not be discussed in this section of the Decision. Short-term memory and pragmatic language are subtexts of the speech and language and auditory processing issues. They were covered in Ms. Warnle Brown=s testimony without challenge and will not be further discussed here. Similarly, the other areas of STUDENT=s areas of disability and her unique needs in those areas will not be addressed in this Decision as they were not at issue. 13 Underlying STUDENT=s direct contention was an assertion made during testimony that the District should have used the Lindamood-Bell test scores as PLOPs. Since those tests were only in part standardized and were administered by persons trained in the clinic, this would only have been practical had there been anticipation that Lindamood-Bell would repeat those same tests in the same way at the end of the academic year. Moreover, the District had Woodcock-Johnson III test scores available for use as PLOPs and did not need anything additional for that purpose. 14 However, there was no evidence presented to demonstrate that STUDENT=s progress would have been measured during that six week period. The IEP of November 20, 2002 provides for benchmarks to be examined at various intervals during the school year, the first of which is March 2003. By that time, the error had been corrected and the Student=s performance could be determined. The corrective action was timely and the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to have measurable goals and objectives in place until January 2003 did not prejudice the Student=s educational opportunities. 15 Lindamood-Bell services were a part of the program so provided. Unfortunately neither party provided objectively verifiable data to show STUDENT=s rate of progress during the Lindamood-Bell period as compared to her rate of progress during the RSP-only or District-only period. This could have been accomplished by administering evaluations of her auditory processing skills in June 2002, November 2002 and June 2003. While it is likely that use of the same test instruments would not have been appropriate, different tests of the same skill components administered and interpreted consistently would have been useful to the Hearing Officer. STUDENT was provided the District=s special education program with no overlapping Lindamood-Bell component during the period between the February testing and the end of the prior school year in June 2002 and between October 29, 2002 and the end of academic year 2002-2003 in June 2003. 16 As stated previously, the hearing request and issue statement do not request adjudication of the District=s offer for the present academic year, 2003-2004. This Decision should not be construed, therefore, to determine whether or not a complete psychoeducational evaluation should have been performed in connection therewith.