California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 11, 2004
Student v. Newport-Mesa Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1489-02 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Newport-Mesa Unified missed its child find duty for a high schooler, but he was not eligible, so all relief was denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 20-year-old former Newport Harbor High School student filed for due process against Newport-Mesa Unified. He had received special education in elementary school for a learning disability and attention problems. In high school he earned poor and failing grades and had a past diagnosis of attention deficit disorder. He later dropped out about 40 credits short of a diploma. After his mother asked for testing, the District assessed him in March 2002. A mediation agreement led to more testing in October 2002, including a psychoeducational evaluation by private psychologist Dr. Laurence Becker. Neither found him eligible, and the District gave him a Section 504 plan.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the District missed its child find duty. By the end of the first semester of 2000-2001, his failing grades and his mother's concerns should have led to an assessment, but none happened until March 2002. She found the 2002 assessments appropriate. Small flaws in a language test and an unscored drawing task did not harm him. He did not qualify as having a specific learning disability because no gap between ability and achievement was confirmed by other data. Teachers said his low grades came from missed homework and absences. He also did not qualify as other health impaired because teachers saw no attention problems in class. Because he was not eligible, the late assessment did him no harm. The Hearing Officer denied compensatory education and reimbursement for the independent psychological and vision evaluations.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a child find violation as harmless when the student was later found not eligible. Teacher testimony linking poor grades to missed homework, rather than a disability, carried weight. A single subtest gap was not enough to establish a learning disability without corroborating data under the Title 5 severe-discrepancy formula.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partChild find
Issue 1A. Did the District meet special education requirements related to assessing STUDENT by satisfying its child find obligations from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to March 2002?
No duty to assess in 1999-2000 or at the start of 2000-2001, but failing grades and the parent's concerns put the District on notice by the end of the first semester of 2000-2001, so it failed to assess until March 2002; the Hearing Officer later found this caused no prejudice because Student was not eligible. Parties equally prevailed.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1B. Did the District meet special education requirements related to assessing STUDENT by conducting appropriate assessments in March and October 2002?
The assessments covered attention and social-emotional functioning, and teacher and assessor observations were adequate. Partial administration of the CASL language test, the uninterpreted Draw A Picture task, and Dr. Becker's lack of a school psychologist credential for the supplemental mediated assessment did not make the assessments inappropriate or harm Student.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Has STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairment (OHI) from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to the present?
No severe ability-achievement discrepancy was corroborated by other data, so Student did not qualify as SLD. Teachers, assessors, and testing showed no limited alertness in the educational setting, so he did not qualify as OHI; teachers said his poor grades came from missed homework and absences.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If the District improperly failed to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and provide him with a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory educational services in the form of tutoring, vision therapy, and mental health counseling?
Because Student was not eligible during the period at issue, the District's failure to assess before March 2002 caused no prejudice, and no compensatory education is owed.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychoeducational assessment undertaken by Dr. Robert Patterson and/or an independent vision therapy assessment by Dr. Beth Ballinger?
No reimbursement is owed. The independent assessments were obtained after the District's 2002 assessments, not because of its failure to assess, and the District's assessments were found appropriate.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Student's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Lester H. v. Gilhool (3d Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300-56303; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)
People named in the decision
- Christopher Russell, educational consultant/advocate for Student
- Robert Patterson, Psy.D., independent psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Patrick Ryan, director of special education, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Candy Barela, special education coordinator, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Jennifer Howe, C.C.C., speech-language pathologist, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Jackie Sadler, resource specialist teacher, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Cindy Courcier, English teacher, Newport Harbor High School
- Jennifer Thompson, social science teacher, Newport Harbor High School
- Matthew Johnson, English teacher (long-term substitute), Newport Harbor High School
- Peggy Hoyt, school counselor, Newport Harbor High School
- Jane Holm, school psychologist, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Karen Hatton, school psychologist, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Laurence D. Becker, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist; conducted psychoeducational assessment funded by District under mediation agreement
- Maria K. Abramson, M.S., CCC-A, auditory processing assessor
- Beth Ballinger, developmental optometrist; independent vision evaluation
- Tom W. Robinson, M.D., private physician who treated Student for ADHD
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on February 10, 11, 12, 13, and March 10, 2004, in Costa Mesa, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Tania L. Whiteleather. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother. Christopher Russell, educational consultant/advocate, intermittently attended the hearing. STUDENT was present and testified at the hearing on February 12, 2004. Respondent Newport-Mesa Unified School District was represented at the hearing by attorney Vivian E. Billups from the law firm of Parker and Covert. Patrick Ryan, director of special education, also was present on behalf of the District.
The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner: STUDENT; STUDENT’s mother; Christopher Russell, educational consultant/advocate; and Robert Patterson, Psy.D., independent psychologist.
The following District witnesses testified: Patrick Ryan, director of special education; Candy Barela, special education coordinator; Jennifer Howe, C.C.C., speech/language pathologist; Jackie Sadler, resource specialist teacher; Cindy Courcier, English teacher, Newport Harbor High School (NHHS); Jennifer Thompson, social science teacher, NHHS; Matthew Johnson, English teacher, NHHS; Peggy Hoyt, counselor; Jane Holm, school psychologist; and Karen Hatton, school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the District meet special education requirements related to assessing STUDENT by: (A) satisfying its child find obligations from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to March 2002; and (B) conducting appropriate assessments in March and October 2002?
(2) Has STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairment (OHI) from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to the present?
(3) If the District improperly failed to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE), is he entitled to compensatory educational services in the form of tutoring, vision therapy, and mental health counseling?
(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychoeducational assessment undertaken by Dr. Robert Patterson and/or an independent vision therapy assessment by Dr. Beth Ballinger?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is twenty years old. He lives with his family within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Newport-Mesa Unified School District. STUDENT currently is enrolled in an art class at Orange Coast College, a community college in Orange County, California. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT had neither graduated from high school nor received an equivalent diploma. Although STUDENT was eligible for special education in elementary school, he was not found eligible for special education while attending high school.
STUDENT attended school in the District from kindergarten through the sixth grade. He initially was assessed for special education in January 1993, while in the third grade, and was placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) due to a specific learning disability in reading and written language and a processing disorder in sensory motor skills. At the end of the 1994-1995 school year, STUDENT was dismissed from special education but was again determined eligible for services in the fall of 1995 with a processing disorder in attention, as a result of the diagnosis of an attention deficit disorder without hyperactivity by a private physician. For the seventh and eighth grades, STUDENT’s parents enrolled STUDENT in a private parochial school, Liberty Christian. (Footnote 1) STUDENT did not receive any special education services while attending Liberty. With the exception of physical education (PE) and yearbook classes, STUDENT received grades of “D” during the eighth grade.
In the fall of 1999, STUDENT returned to the District for the ninth grade. He was accepted into the DaVinci Academy at Newport Harbor High School (NHHS). (Footnote 2)The Academy offers a special program for approximately 100 students and focuses on mathematics and science. However, because of poor grades, STUDENT returned to the general education program at NHHS for the second semester of his ninth-grade year. (Footnote 3)
STUDENT continued to attend NHHS for his tenth-grade year in the fall of 2000. During the course of the school year, STUDENT failed four classes and, with the exception of PE, received grades of “D” in his other classes. STUDENT entered the eleventh grade in the fall of 2001. At his parents’ request, STUDENT was allowed to carry a reduced class load at NHHS. In the four classes STUDENT took during the first semester, he received one grade of “B ” in ceramics, grades of “C” in literature and science classes, and a “D-“ in U.S. history. (Footnote 4) On January 7, 2002, STUDENT’s mother requested that the District assess STUDENT to determine whether he was eligible for special education. On January 22, 2002, MOTHER consented to the District’s proposed assessment plan.
The District’s assessment included measures of intelligence, academic achievement, and behavioral, social, and emotional skills. The report of the District’s assessment is dated March 4, 2002. The psychoeducational assessment results show that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fall in the average to bright-average range. The assessment did not reveal a significant discrepancy between cognitive skills and academic achievement, which the assessor stated would be necessary to establish a specific learning disability for special education eligibility. On March 13, 2002, the District, with participation of STUDENT and his mother, discussed the results of the District’s assessment and determined that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria because of a learning disability or speech and language impairment. The team developed a 504 accommodation plan to address STUDENT’s diagnosed attention deficit disorder in the educational environment.
In June 2002, MOTHER filed a due process hearing request on behalf of STUDENT. MOTHER initially sought a modified class schedule for STUDENT, acceptance by the District of credits STUDENT had received from community college courses, and tutoring. Mediation resulted in the District’s agreeing to fund a second psychoeducational evaluation by a psychologist in private practice and additional assessments in the areas of auditory processing, speech, and language. The auditory processing assessment undertaken by Maria K. Abramson, M.S., CCC-A, showed STUDENT functioning within normal limits. Jennifer Howe, District speech and language pathologist, completed the speech and language assessment. She found STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language fell within normal limits. Laurence D. Becker, Ph.D., completed the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in October 2002. Dr. Becker identified weaknesses in reading comprehension and mathematics. However, Dr. Becker concluded that STUDENT did not have significant discrepancy between academic achievement and cognitive skills that would qualify him for special education. Dr. Becker noted that STUDENT previously had been diagnosed with the inattentive type of ADHD. On November 7, 2002, the IEP team convened to discuss the results of the assessments. STUDENT attended the IEP meeting with his father and advocate, Mr. Russell. Neither Ms. Abramson nor Dr. Becker participated in the IEP meeting. In their absence, District staff reviewed the results of the assessments. The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education criteria. STUDENT and his advocate disagreed and requested an independent assessment. The District did not agree to an independent assessment.
STUDENT returned to NHHS for his senior year. For the first semester of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT failed two classes–American Democracy and Regional Occupational Program (ROP) Micro Office. He received passing grades in art classes and passed literature with a “B” and Excel with a “C-“ in adult education classes. He also passed economics during summer school.
Sometime after the District’s assessment, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent vision evaluation from Dr. Beth Ballinger, a developmental optometrist. Dr. Ballinger recommended vision therapy. Robert Patterson, Psy.D., also completed an independent psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT on February 27, 2003. In the report of his assessment, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT was performing in the average range cognitively and did not show a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement. However, Dr. Patterson noted that STUDENT exhibited difficulty in mathematics, word decoding, spelling, and the act of writing. Dr. Patterson indicated that STUDENT’s parents may want to pursue special education eligibility criteria of other health impaired (OHI) because of the ADHD diagnosis.
For the final semester of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT failed photography while passing ceramics and art with “C” grades and ROP Micro Office with a “D.” He received an incomplete in literature because he failed to turn in the senior project required by the District. STUDENT has dropped out of school. He requires an additional 39.98 credits to graduate, including required courses in English, electives, mathematics and social studies. STUDENT has expressed a desire to join the Air Force. However, until he receives his diploma or equivalent, he is unable to fulfill this goal. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was unemployed and taking a single art class at the community college.
The parties were unable to resolve the dispute regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and the matter proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District meet special education requirements related to assessing STUDENT by: (A) satisfying its child find obligations from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to March 2002; and (B) conducting appropriate assessments in March and October 2002?
Petitioner contends that since returning to the District in the fall of 1999, the District has failed in its affirmative duty to assess him to determine whether he meets eligibility criteria for special education. Petitioner first asserts that the District failed to assess him from the fall of 1999 until March 2002 despite having knowledge of his diagnosis of ADHD, prior eligibility for special education, and poor and failing grades. Petitioner additionally asserts that the District failed to respond to the ongoing concerns expressed to District staff by his mother by failing to assess him for special education. Finally, Petitioner asserts that the assessments ultimately completed by the District in March and October of 2002 were deficient. The specific allegations regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessments will be addressed below. The District contends that it was not obligated to assess Petitioner until receipt of a referral in January 2002 from Petitioner’s parent. The District also contends that it undertook appropriate assessments of Petitioner in 2002. (A) Did the District satisfy its child find obligations from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to March 2002?
The District’s initial assessment of Petitioner after his return to the District was completed in March 2002. Thus, to address Petitioner’s initial claim regarding the District’s responsibility to assess Petitioner prior to March of 2002, it must be determined whether the District had an obligation to assess him and, if so, whether the District undertook an appropriate assessment of Petitioner. Upon receipt of a referral of a student for special education and related services from a parent, teacher or other individual, the District must initiate the assessment process. When a verbal referral is made, District staff shall offer assistance to the individual to make the request in writing. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3021(a).
There is no evidence that anyone from the private school STUDENT attended prior to returning to the District or that any of STUDENT’s teachers at NHHS or other District staff referred him for a special education assessment. Although MOTHER testified that she had many contacts with STUDENT’s teachers and other District personnel throughout STUDENT’s enrollment in the District, there also is no persuasive evidence that she made a referral for a special education assessment of STUDENT prior to January of 2002. MOTHER testified that she spoke with District administrators proposing changes to the scheduling of high school classes and contacted other parents to obtain support for her proposal. She also met on more than one occasion with District administrators and school personnel requesting that STUDENT be allowed to take only four classes at the high school and that he be allowed to obtain credits toward graduation from outside sources, including the community college, in excess of the 10 units allowed pursuant to District policy. (Footnote 5) The testimony of Patrick Ryan and Ms. Hoyt, school counselor, confirm the nature of their conversations with MOTHER. Neither recalled MOTHER’s seeking a special education assessment. Therefore, it is concluded that the District did not have an obligation to assess STUDENT because of a referral for special education.
Although no one referred STUDENT for a special education assessment prior to January 2002, the District may have had an independent obligation to assess him. The District has an affirmative duty to seek, identify and assess students suspected of having a disability, including students residing within its jurisdiction who are attending private schools. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300 - 56302. (Footnote 6) Whether the District had an obligation to assess STUDENT for special education because of its “child find” responsibilities will be addressed separately below by school year.
1999 - 2000 School Year
Petitioner asserts that the District had an obligation to assess him for special education when he returned to the District for the 1999-2000 school year because the District was aware that he previously was eligible for special education and had a medical diagnosis of ADHD. Petitioner also asserts that during the course of the school year, the District was aware that he was earning poor grades. The District asserts that it was not obligated to assess STUDENT prior to the referral made during the 2002-2003 school year.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District had an obligation to assess Petitioner upon his return to the District. First, Petitioner’s argument is inconsistent with the actions undertaken by his parents when he returned to the District. Ms. Hoyt, STUDENT’s counselor, testified that the parents encouraged STUDENT to apply for the DaVinci Academy. She also testified that DaVinci is an academically challenging science and mathematics program whose enrollment is limited to 100 students. Second, it is undisputed that STUDENT has average or above-average intelligence. Although STUDENT’s grades did not reflect his ability, particularly during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year, Ms. Hoyt and several teachers reported that STUDENT was quite capable of completing class work. Ms. Hoyt testified that teachers uniformly attributed STUDENT’s poor grades to his failure to complete or turn in homework rather than to a disability. Ms. Hoyt testified that STUDENT earned grades of “C” in Spanish 1a and 1b, which he took at the community college, and Ms. Courcier testified that STUDENT earned grades of “C-” and “B-”in Comparative Literature 1a and 1b, which he took during the summer of 2000. (See also District’s Exhibit 2) Ms. Courcier testified that STUDENT “did fine” and that she “never had the impression that STUDENT did not understand instructions or was having difficulty in the class.”
Third, a medical diagnosis of ADHD does not automatically qualify a student for special education. Ms. Hoyt testified that neither she nor STUDENT’s teachers observed him having trouble focusing in class. None of Petitioner’s witnesses observed STUDENT in class and, therefore, could not provide testimony as to his attention in an educational environment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s witnesses who were familiar with STUDENT’s academic performance testified persuasively that a special education referral was not warranted during the 1999-2000 school year. Their testimony is supported by STUDENT’s report card, which reflects that his grades improved as the 1999-2000 school year progressed. Petitioner failed to provide persuasive testimony to the contrary. Moreover, prior to making a referral for special education, the District was required to attempt modifications to the general education program. Education Code section 56303 provides that a student “shall be referred for special education instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized.” Here, Ms. Hoyt persuasively testified that she met with MOTHER and STUDENT’s teachers to discuss STUDENT’s poor grades, started a teacher reporting system to track STUDENT’s work completion, and drafted a 504 accommodation plan, which was rejected by MOTHER. The District took the additional step of removing STUDENT from the more difficult DaVinci Academy and placing him in the general education program, where his grades improved.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Ms. Hoyt and Ms. Courcier and the other evidence discussed above establishes that the District was not obligated to assess STUDENT for special education during the 1999-2000 school year.
2000 - 2001 School Year
Petitioner asserts that the District was aware that he was continuing to struggle academically throughout the 2000-2001 school year, which should have triggered its undertaking of a special education assessment. The District contends that it was not required to assess STUDENT, asserting that he was receiving poor grades because he failed to do his homework and not because of a disability.
STUDENT’s mother testified that she continued to communicate with District personnel regarding STUDENT’s poor grades and his diagnosis of ADHD. MOTHER stated that she also expressed her opinion to District staff that STUDENT would learn better if his class schedule was modified to be similar to a college schedule in which classes are convened for longer periods at a time.
STUDENT began the 2000-2001 school year on a positive note. MOTHER testified that STUDENT told her he intended to have a successful year and would try harder to achieve passing grades. Additionally, as discussed above, STUDENT had earned “C” or better grades in classes he had taken during the summer. In light of STUDENT’s improved grades, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District was not responsible at the beginning of the school year to assess STUDENT for special education.
STUDENT’s school performance regressed, however, and when report cards were issued at the end of the first semester, STUDENT received grades of “F” in literature and Spanish, grades of “D” in photography and biology, and a grade of “D-” in geometry. (Footnote 7) The testimony of Matthew Johnson and Ms. Hoyt offered a plausible explanation for STUDENT’s poor grades. Mr. Johnson, a long-term substitute teacher in STUDENT’s sophomore English class during the spring semester, testified in support of the District’s position. He stated that STUDENT’s grades were a result of STUDENT’s “doing the minimum to get by in class” and failing to complete and turn in his homework. Ms. Hoyt testified that STUDENT’s other teachers have consistently shared Mr. Johnson’s opinion regarding the reasons for STUDENT’s poor grades. There was no evidence that the measures the District had implemented the prior school year to monitor STUDENT’s completion of homework were successful during the 2000-2001 school year, as STUDENT’s grades predominantly remained “Ds” or “Fs.”
The Hearing Officer finds that the poor and failing grades, coupled with the ongoing concerns expressed to District personnel by MOTHER, placed the District on notice by the end of the first semester of the school year that a special education assessment was warranted. The District did not assess STUDENT during the remainder of the school year. The potential loss of educational opportunity or prejudice to STUDENT because of the District’s failure to timely assess him will be addressed below.
Fall 2001 to March 2002
It was concluded above that the District should have initiated an assessment of STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year. The District did not assess STUDENT during the fall semester of the 2001-2002 school year. Thus, the District failed in its obligation to assess STUDENT for special education through March 2002, when it ultimately completed its assessment. Any continued loss of educational opportunity or prejudice to STUDENT will be addressed below.
(B) Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT in March and October 2002?
The District’s assessment, documented in a report dated March 4, 2002, included a health and developmental history and measures of intellectual, academic, visual-motor, behavior, and emotional functioning. (Petitioner’s Exhibit M-1 to M-6) The supplemental assessments completed in October 2002 included Ms. Howe’s speech and language evaluation, Ms. Abramson’s auditory processing evaluation, and Dr. Becker’s psychoeducational evaluation. (Respondent’s Exhibits 13, 18, and 19) Ms. Howe administered tests to assess STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language. Ms. Abramson used multiple tests to evaluate STUDENT, including measures of auditory acuity, auditory processing, temporal processing, sequencing, and auditory figure ground discrimination. Dr. Becker administered tests of intelligence and achievement, and conducted a clinical interview of STUDENT.
The Petitioner challenges the appropriateness of the District’s assessments. Petitioner asserts that the District’s assessments were deficient in that they (1) failed to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability because they did not assess his ADHD and its effect on his education, social, or emotional functioning; (2) failed to include an observation of Petitioner in his educational environment; (3) failed to administer portions of the speech and language assessment according to the test manual instructions; and (4) failed to analyze the Draw A Picture (DAP). Petitioner additionally asserts that Dr. Becker, who undertook a second psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner, is not a credentialed school psychologist and, therefore, was not properly qualified under special education law to assess Petitioner.
In response to Petitioner’s concerns regarding its assessments, the District asserts that (1) it did assess Petitioner’s ADHD; (2) the RSP teacher did observe Petitioner and also obtained information from teachers who regularly observed Petitioner in class; (3) the speech and language assessment was appropriate; and (4) all of the District’s assessors were appropriately qualified.
To be appropriate, the District’s assessment must have met the statutory requirements set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 et. seq., which provides, in pertinent part:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist . . . (e) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. (f) The pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. A developmental history is obtained, when appropriate. . . .
Petitioner’s sole allegations regarding the inappropriateness of the District’s evaluations are set forth above. As there were no other challenges to the assessment, it is unnecessary to address the remaining requirements of an appropriate assessment. Therefore, the discussion below is limited to Petitioner’s five allegations raised at the hearing and set forth above.
Alleged failure to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability.
Petitioner asserts that the District’s assessment failed to assess all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess his diagnosed ADHD, motivation, social, or emotional needs. The District asserts that both the March and October 2004 assessments included measures of ADHD, motivation, and social and emotional needs.
Turning first to whether the District assessed STUDENT’s attention, the assessment plan approved by STUDENT’s mother indicates that “ADHD” would be assessed using a checklist. (Petitioner’s Exhibit H-1) Ms. Holm administered the psychoeducational portion of the District’s assessment completed in March 2004. Ms. Holm, who is a credential school psychologist, as well as a licensed educational psychologist and marriage, family therapist (MFTT), testified that she assessed STUDENT’s attention by administering inventories to STUDENT and to his parents. She also observed STUDENT during testing for signs of attentional problems. Ms. Holm testified that the Connors-Wells’ Self-Report Scale was completed by STUDENT and includes measures of ADHD, inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit M-5) Ms. Holm administered the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) to both STUDENT and his parents. Ms. Holm testified that the BASC also includes a measure of attention.
Dr. Becker did not testify at the hearing. However, Patrick Ryan testified, as did Ms. Hatton, who reviewed Dr. Becker’s report for the IEP team, that Dr. Becker also assessed STUDENT’s attention by conducting a clinical interview of STUDENT and administering the Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA), which is a computerized assessment for attention. They also testified that Dr. Becker further evaluated STUDENT’s attention by analyzing STUDENT’s scores on certain subtests of the Woodcock-Johnson III - Tests of Cognitive Abilities (WM-III). (See Respondent’s Exhibit 19) Ms. Hatton testified that WJ-III subtests memory processing speed and paying attention are indicators of a student’s attentional skills. Their testimony as to the TOVA and the WJ-III was not disputed. Although neither Ms. Hatton nor Mr. Ryan has assessed STUDENT, they both reviewed his educational records. Additionally, they are both credentialed school psychologists with many years of experience and have knowledge of the instruments administered by Dr. Becker.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the experienced school psychologists credible that the District’s assessment did evaluate STUDENT’s attention. Moreover, although Dr. Patterson criticized Dr. Becker’s assessment generally because Dr. Becker is not a credentialed school psychologist, he did not dispute that the District’s assessments included measures to evaluate STUDENT’s attentional skills. Petitioner presented no other credible testimony on this issue.Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District assessed STUDENT’s attention, a suspected area of disability.
Turning next to whether the District assessed STUDENT’s social, and/or emotional functioning, a review of the assessment plan approved by the parent on January 22, 2002, reveals that social/adaptive behavior is not checked as an area to be assessed. (Respondent’s Exhibit 2) Petitioner asserted that these were areas of suspected disability that should have been assessed by the District. Ms. Holm’s testimony establishes that the District’s assessment included measures that evaluated STUDENT’s social and emotional status. For example, she testified that the BASC, the Reynold’s Adolescent Depression Scale (RADS), and Connors include questions designed to reveal aggressive behavior and depression. Ms. Holm testified that she interviewed STUDENT to assess his mental status. Dr. Becker also conducted a clinical interview of STUDENT. The reports of both assessments substantiate Ms. Holm’s testimony. Additionally, Petitioner did not present any testimony to dispute Ms. Holm’s testimony. Ms. Holm is a credentialed school psychologist and is familiar with the various testing instruments used to assess STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive and concludes that the District did assess STUDENT’s social and emotional functioning.
In summary, it has been concluded that the District assessed STUDENT’s attention, social, and emotional functioning. Therefore, Petitioner’s claim that the District’s assessment was deficient because it did not assess all areas of suspected disability fails.
Alleged failure to observe Petitioner in his educational environment.
Petitioner asserts that an appropriate assessment must include an observation of him in his educational environment. The need for an observation is described in sections setting forth the requirements of an assessment report and the composition of the IEP team. California Education Code § 56327(c) provides that a report as the result of an assessment must include relevant behavior noted during the observation of the student in an “appropriate environment.” For a student suspected of having a specific learning disability, the team must include at least one member, other than the student’s teacher, who has observed the student’s academic performance in the general classroom setting. 34 C.F.R. § 300.542(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(c).
The assessment report does not discuss observations of STUDENT and, to that extent, is deficient. However, Ms. Holm testified that Ms. Hoyt, STUDENT’s counselor, and STUDENT’s teachers contributed observations to the assessment. Ms. Sadler, who was part of the assessment team, testified that she solicited input from STUDENT’s teachers, which was considered in evaluating STUDENT. STUDENT’s teachers were in the best position to observe STUDENT’s behavior on a daily basis in his educational environment. There is no dispute that neither Dr. Becker nor Ms. Holm, who undertook major portions of STUDENT’s assessments, observed STUDENT in any of his classes. However, they did observe STUDENT during their respective assessments, which provided information regarding STUDENT’s attentional skills while executing academic tasks. Several District witnesses expressed the opinion that these observations satisfied the need for an observation of STUDENT as part of the assessment. The Hearing Officer finds that the observations by STUDENT’s teachers and assessors provided relevant information regarding STUDENT in an appropriate environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was sufficient information available to the assessors regarding STUDENT’s performance in the general classroom and other settings. Additionally, Ms. Sadler was a member of the IEP team and was available to communicate information to the IEP team regarding the comments made by teachers and her own observations of STUDENT’s behavior. (Footnote 8) The Hearing Officer is persuaded that observations by District staff substantially met requirements related to observations and, because the assessment included information regarding STUDENT’s performance in the educational and clinical environments, there was no prejudice to STUDENT.
Alleged failure to administer portions of the speech and language assessment according to the test manual instructions
Petitioner contends that the District’s speech and language assessment was inappropriate. Petitioner asserts that Ms. Howe did not administer the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL) in conformity with the test manuals. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that he exceeds the age for which the test is recommended and the manual requires that all of the core elements of the test must be administered. Ms. Howe acknowledged that STUDENT slightly exceeded the age for which the CASL is recommended. She also acknowledged that she had not administered all of the core subtests of the CASL and that best practices in the field call for all of the core areas to be assessed. However, Ms. Howe testified that she administered the CASL to obtain “subjective” information regarding STUDENT’s language functioning and did report an overall score from the test. Ms. Howe also testified that she administered multiple other instruments to assess STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language and that she did not rely exclusively on the CASL to reach conclusions regarding STUDENT’s language skills. Ms. Howe described the additional instruments she relied upon, which included the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III (PPVT-III), which measured STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary, and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF-3), which measured both expressive and receptive language. Ms. Howe also obtained two language samples. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 13.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the manner in which Ms. Howe administered the CASL did not invalidate the overall results of her assessment and did not prejudice Petitioner. Petitioner did not call a speech and language pathologist or any other appropriately qualified person to testify regarding the overall appropriateness of Ms. Howe’s assessment. On the other hand, Ms. Howe is an experienced speech and language pathologist and holds appropriate credentials and licensing. Additionally, Ms. Howe testified credibly that she used the results of the CASL to subjectively look at STUDENT’s language skills and that the rest of the assessment was not compromised by the failure to administer all of the core measures of the CASL.
Alleged failure to analyze the Draw A Picture (DAP).
Petitioner asserts that the District’s psychoeducational assessment was deficient because Ms. Holm did not analyze the results of the DAP. Ms. Holm acknowledged that she did not include an analysis of the results of the DAP in the District’s report of STUDENT’s assessment. However, Petitioner did not provide testimony from anyone with appropriate expertise to establish that failing to provide an interpretation of the DAP had any effect on the results of the District’s assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to interpret the DAP did not render inappropriate the psychoeducational portion of the assessment.
Qualifications allowing Dr. Becker to undertake a second psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner.
Petitioner asserts that because Dr. Becker is not a credentialed school psychologist, he was not qualified to undertake a psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner. Dr. Patterson testified in support of Petitioner’s assertion. The District disputes the need for Dr. Becker to be a credentialed school psychologist. Special education law provides that assessments must be performed by persons who are competent to perform them, as determined by the district. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. Section 56324(a) provides that any psychological assessment shall be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed.
Dr. Becker did not testify at the hearing. However, there is no dispute that Dr. Becker is not a credentialed school psychologist. Rather, he is a clinical psychologist in private practice that focuses on special education. The fact that Dr. Becker is not a school psychologist does not render the District’s assessment inappropriate. First, the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT completed in March 2002 was done by a credentialed school psychologist, Ms. Holm. Dr. Becker’s assessment was undertaken by agreement of the parties as a result of mediation and supplements the District’s first assessment. Second, Dr. Becker is properly licensed to administer the tests that he used with STUDENT. Finally, there are no provisions in special education law that preclude Districts from using experts or private assessors to resolve disputes regarding an assessment. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s argument that Dr. Becker is unqualified is rather disingenuous and does not render the District’s assessment of Petitioner inappropriate.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that as to the concerns raised by Petitioner regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessment, the minor flaws related to the administration of the CASL and the failure to interpret the DAP did not render the District’s assessment inappropriate and did not result in prejudice to Petitioner.
ISSUE NO. 2: Has STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairment (OHI) from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to the present?
Petitioner contends that from 1999 to the present, he has met special education eligibility criteria as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) and other health impairment (OHI). The District contends at all times at issue that Petitioner has not met special education eligibility criteria as either SLD or OHI.
To be eligible for special education instruction and services, a student must have a disability as defined by federal law and, because of the disability, require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) & (b). Both specific learning disability (SLD) and other health impairment (OHI) are included in the federal definition of a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i). Whether STUDENT meets eligibility criteria as OHI or SLD will be addressed below.
Specific Learning Disability (SLD)
Petitioner contends that he meets special education eligibility criteria as a student with an SLD. Petitioner asserts that there is a significant discrepancy between his cognitive skills and his academic achievement in areas including spelling and reading comprehension. Petitioner asserts that the discrepancies are the result of a processing disorder of attention. Petitioner also asserts that his poor grades are a manifestation of his learning disability and that he requires special education to benefit from his education. The District contends that Petitioner does not meet SLD criteria. The District asserts that all of Petitioner’s achievement scores on assessment instruments fall within the average range and that, even if there were a discrepancy between Petitioner’s cognitive skills and his achievement in spelling or reading comprehension, the discrepancy is not corroborated by any other test results. The District also asserts that a discrepancy between cognitive skills and achievement in spelling does not form the basis for an SLD.
A specific learning disability is defined in federal special education law as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § (j)(1).
For STUDENT to qualify for special education because of a specific learning disability, he must meet three requirements. First, there must be a severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement in oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337 (b). Second, the severe discrepancy must be due to a disorder of one or more of the basic psychological processes and must not be primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. 34 C.F. R. § 300.543(b)(3), (4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b). The final requirement is that the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6). The determination of whether a severe discrepancy exists between ability and achievement is made by the individualized educational program (IEP) team. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5 § 3030(j)(4).
A severe discrepancy can be established through a formula using standardized tests, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered to be invalid, or by a finding of the IEP team that a severe discrepancy exists. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A), (B), (C). There was no persuasive evidence that standardized tests are invalid to assess STUDENT’s ability or achievement. Therefore, to determine whether a severe discrepancy exists, STUDENT’s scores on standardized measures of intellectual ability can be compared with his scores on academic achievement tests. When standardized tests are considered valid for a student, the method for determining whether a severe discrepancy exists involves the following steps:
[F]irst, computing into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. A computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error measurement, the adjustment not to exceed four common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.
Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).
The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by 15), adjusted by one standard error of measurement. (Footnote 9) That is, the computed difference between scores on ability and achievement tests must be at least 22.5 points, adjusted by the standard error measurement not exceeding four standard points, or 18.5 to 26.5 points.
In summary, for STUDENT to be eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability, it must be established that (1) there is a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement in one of the areas specified above, (2) the severe discrepancy is due to a basic psychological processing disorder, and (3) the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated within the general education program.
Is there a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement?
End of the first semester of the 2000-2001 school year to March 2002 (Footnote 10)
Petitioner asserts that a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement has existed from 1999 to the present. However, it was concluded above that the District’s obligation to assess STUDENT arose at the end of the first semester of the 2000-2001 school year or early in 2001. Although the District had an obligation to assess STUDENT, no assessment was undertaken by the District until March 2002. (Footnote 11) Thus, from early 2001 until the District’s assessment in March 2002, there are no data to compare STUDENT’s cognitive ability to his achievement. Turning then to information regarding STUDENT’s skills that was available during the period at issue, assessors and teachers consistently testified that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fall within the average to above-average range. Their testimony is supported by STUDENT’s consistently obtaining average to above-average standard scores on measures of intelligence. Within Dr. Patterson’s assessment report dated March 10, 2003, is a summary of STUDENT’s standard scores on measures of intelligence administered from 1992 through February 2003. On assessments administered by the District, Dr. Becker, and Dr. Patterson, STUDENT’s verbal IQ scores have ranged from 97 to 110, performance IQ scores have ranged from 102 to 116, and full scale IQ scores have ranged from 103 to 111. (Petitioner’s Exhibit FF-5 and FF-6) There is neither evidence nor rational basis to believe that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell other than in the average to above-average range in the period from the fall of 1999 to March 2002.
As to STUDENT’s achievement, there was scarce testimony regarding the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, and what little testimony there was, did not establish the existence of a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement. Ms. Courcier, STUDENT’s English teacher during the summer of 2000, testified that STUDENT was able to complete satisfactory work in class and did not exhibit difficulty understanding instruction or completing written assignments. Ms. Hoyt, STUDENT’s counselor, testified that STUDENT’s teachers consistently described STUDENT to her as bright and capable of completing school work. The teachers remarked to Ms. Hoyt that STUDENT was able to do quality work whenever he actually competed his class work. Ms. Hoyt also testified that STUDENT’s teachers told her the reason for STUDENT’s low grades was his failing to turn in homework. Neither Ms. Courcier nor Ms. Hoyt testified that they believed STUDENT’s poor grades were a result of his having a disability.
Although STUDENT’s grades were poor, group testing administered to students at NHHS in the spring of 2001 shows that STUDENT was gaining knowledge and that his skills in core academic areas were average to above-average, which is consistent with his cognitive ability. For example, the Stanford Test of Academic Skills, Fourth Edition (Stanford), measures achievement in the content clusters of reading vocabulary, reading comprehension, mathematics, language, science, and social science. The results of STUDENT’s Stanford taken in April 2001, show that he scored above average overall in science and social science. STUDENT scored above average in one measure of reading vocabulary–context. He received average scores on synonyms and multiple meanings. In reading comprehension, STUDENT scored above average in three areas and average in the remaining four areas, including measures of textual and functional reading, interpretation, and critical analysis. In mathematics, STUDENT scored above average in problem-solving strategies and geometry from a synthetic perspective. STUDENT obtained average scores in algebra, statistics, probability, functions, geometry from an algebraic perspective, trigonometry, discrete mathematics, and conceptual underpinnings of calculus. STUDENT’s scores on measures of language were above average in punctuation and sentence structure. He obtained average scores in language usage and content and organization. STUDENT’s sole below average score on the Stanford was on the test assessing capitalization. STUDENT also was deemed proficient in California English Language Arts Standards. (Petitioner’s Exhibit E-1) Additionally, STUDENT was able to pass courses at the community college level with grades of “C,” leading support to the District’s assertion that STUDENT could do well when he put effort into his school work.
Dr. Patterson appeared on behalf of STUDENT. Dr. Patterson assessed STUDENT in 2003 and testified that he undertook a thorough review of STUDENT’s educational records as part of his assessment. Dr. Patterson testified that his review of prior testing led him to conclude that STUDENT has exhibited a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement for which he would qualify for special education. However, when asked at what point in time Dr. Patterson believed STUDENT met special education eligibility, he responded “as of March 2002.” Thus, the testimony of Petitioner’s own witness does not support a finding of a severe discrepancy prior to March 2002.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer relies on the comments of teachers that STUDENT was able to perform in class and on information available from the group assessment that STUDENT was learning academic content and concludes that the evidence did not establish a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s average to above-average cognitive ability and his achievement from the end of the first semester of the 2000-2001 school year through March 2002.
March 2002 Assessment
The District’s report of its psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT was completed in March 2002. (District’s Exhibit 6) The assessment included measures of STUDENT’s cognitive and academic skills. Initially, it must be determined whether to use the performance, verbal, or full-scale IQ score to determine whether a severe discrepancy exists between STUDENT’s ability and achievement. On the District’s administration of the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI), STUDENT obtained a standard score of 99 on the verbal measure, 116 on the performance measure, and 108 on the full-scale. Dr. Patterson testified that the California Education Code does not specify which score to use. He testified that because there are “indicators” that STUDENT has language deficits, the performance score more accurately reflects his ability than either the verbal of full-scale measures. District psychologist Ms. Holm concurred with Dr. Patterson that the performance score should be used. Similar to Dr. Patterson, she expressed the opinion that the performance score better reflects STUDENT’s ability. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Patterson and Ms. Holm persuasive that the proper IQ score to use when determining whether there is a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement is his standard score of 116 on the performance measure of the WASI.
Comparing STUDENT’s performance score with broad measure of achievement measured by the Woodcock-Johnson III (W-J III) administered as part of the District’s assessment in March 2002 does not result in a severe discrepancy. (Footnote 12) Specifically, comparing 116 with standard scores on measures of 100 in broad reading, 102 in broad mathematics, and 103 in broad mathematics does not result in a difference that exceeds 22.5 points.
Dr. Patterson testified, however, that a severe discrepancy can be established by comparing STUDENT’s performance IQ score of 116 with subtest scores of 88 in spelling and 91 in passage comprehension. Because both calculations result in a discrepancy of more than 22.5 points, a severe discrepancy is established. Dr. Patterson testified that spelling is recognized as a learning disability by federal law and opined that nothing in the California Education Code precludes using subtests of achievement to establish a severe discrepancy. The District contends that the Petitioner improperly relies on subtest scores to establish a severe discrepancy in spelling and reading comprehension. District witnesses Mr. Ryan, who holds a school psychology credential and supervises District psychologists, and Ms. Holm testified that it is not standard practice to qualify students for special education using subtests to establish a discrepancy.
However, a review of the law lends support to Dr. Patterson’s testimony that spelling may be used to establish a severe discrepancy. As set forth above, California Education Code § 56026(a) provides that an individual with exceptional needs is a child with a disability “as that phrase is defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of Section 1401 of Title 20 of the United States Code.” Pursuant to section 1401(3)(A)(i) of Title 20 of the United States Code, a ''child with a disability'' includes children with mental retardation, hearing impairments (including deafness), speech or language impairments, visual impairments (including blindness), serious emotional disturbance (hereinafter referred to as ''emotional disturbance''), orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. Section 1401(26)(A) defines ''specific learning disability'' as a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations. (Emphasis added.)
The District asserts that even assuming spelling subtests can be used in identifying a specific learning disability employing the federal definition, there is no credible evidence corroborating that STUDENT has a learning disability in spelling. Special education law provides that severe discrepancy must be “corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A). Additionally, no “single score or product of scores, test or procedure shall be used as the sole criterion” in determining the student’s eligibility for special education. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4). All of the District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT does not have a learning disability in spelling. The District’s witnesses were STUDENT’s teachers, counselor, and assessors. Three of STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT did good class work and that when STUDENT turned in assignments, they were high quality. Ms. Hoyt testified that other teachers have consistently made similar comments. None of the witnesses attributed STUDENT’s poor school grades to difficulties with spelling. (See also District’s Exhibit 20.) There also were no other corroborating test results available to the IEP team when making a decision regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education in March 2002.
Although the information from testing later completed by Dr. Becker and Dr. Patterson was not available to the IEP team in March, it is of note that neither Dr. Becker’s testing completed in October 2002 nor Dr. Patterson’s testing in February 2003 supports STUDENT’s having a learning disability in spelling. On Dr. Becker’s administration of WIAT-II, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 96 on the spelling subtest, which when compared with the performance score of 116 on the District’s cognitive assessment or with the performance score of 111 obtained on Dr. Becker’s administration of the WAIS-III, does not result in a severe discrepancy. On Dr. Patterson’s administration of the WRAT-3 and the PIAT-R, STUDENT’s scores in spelling were 95 and 112 respectively, and also would not result in a severe discrepancy when compared to any measures of STUDENT’s IQ. The Hearing Officer finds that the lack of corroborating evidence establishes that STUDENT did not have a learning disability in spelling as of March 2002.
The District also asserts that there is no evidence corroborating that STUDENT has a learning disability in reading comprehension. STUDENT testified that he has difficulty understanding teachers’ written directions for essays. On the other hand, STUDENT also testified that he had no difficulty reading literature assignments for English classes and was able to answer questions posed in class regarding the reading assignments. In fact, for the grading period ending February 2002, STUDENT received a grade of “C” in literature. STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT did not appear to have difficulty understanding what he read. Ms. Sadler, who conducted the District’s tests of achievement in March 2002, testified that STUDENT did not have a learning disability. There were no additional measures of STUDENT’s reading skills available to the IEP team in March 2002 on which to find a learning disability in reading comprehension. Additionally, testing completed after March 2002 by Dr. Becker and Dr. Patterson does not establish a severe discrepancy between ability and reading. It is of particular interest that on Dr. Patterson’s administration of the PIAT-R STUDENT obtained a standard score of 119 on reading comprehension, placing him in the 90th percentile. In his report, Dr. Patterson described STUDENT’s scores on reading comprehension as “on the cusp between high average and superior functioning.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit FF-24) The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence corroborating Petitioner’s having a learning disability in reading comprehension.
The lack of corroborating evidence of severe discrepancies in spelling or reading comprehension confirms that the IEP team meeting in March 2002 made the proper decision that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education because of a learning disability in spelling and reading comprehension.
October 2002 assessment by Dr. Becker and February 2003 assessment by Dr. Patterson
Dr. Becker did not testify at the hearing. Dr. Becker’s assessment in October 2002 revealed relative weaknesses in mathematics and reading comprehension but not rising to the level of a severe discrepancy. Moreover, Dr. Becker concludes in his report that “there does not appear to be a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement. This was calculated by taking STUDENT’s full scale IQ. Of 111 on the WAIS-III and comparing that with his composite scores on the WIAT-II.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 19.) In reviewing Dr. Becker’s assessment, District psychologist Ms. Hatton testified that none of STUDENT’s scores in areas of academic achievement on testing administered by Dr. Becker in October 2002 reveal a severe discrepancy when compared to STUDENT’s standard score of 111 on the performance measure of ability administered by Dr. Becker. Additionally, Ms. Hatton testified that all of STUDENT’s achievement scores fall within the average range. Comparing areas of academic achievement on Dr. Becker’s assessment with the higher performance score (116) obtained on the District’s assessment in March 2002, does not result in a discrepancy of 22.5 points or higher when applying a four point standard error of measurement. In any case, there is no corroborating evidence to support a learning disability in mathematics, which is the lowest achievement score on Dr. Becker’s administration of the WIAT-II. STUDENT received a standard score of 102 in mathematics skills on the District’s March 2002 administration of WJ-III. In Dr. Patterson’s conclusion following his assessment of STUDENT, Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT “does not show a significant discrepancy in any of the basic academic areas.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit FF-34) Finally, when compared to his peers in the 11th grade nationwide, STUDENT scored in the average range on all measures of the Stanford. (Petitioner’s Exhibit P-2)
Moreover, all of the teachers working with STUDENT testified that STUDENT is a capable student but earns poor grades because of inconsistent attendance and failure to turn in homework. The Hearing Officer notes that the teachers have observed STUDENT’s performance in school, whereas neither Dr. Patterson nor Dr. Becker has. The teachers’ observations are consistent with the results of testing. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish the existence of severe discrepancies in academic areas that also are corroborated by other test measures or testimony. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria as a student with a specific learning disability.It has been concluded that there is not a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement. Therefore, it is unnecessary to make findings regarding whether STUDENT has a psychological processing disorder and whether any discrepancies could be ameliorated within the general education program.
Other Health Impaired (OHI)
Petitioner contends that at all times since entering high school he has met eligibility criteria for special education as OHI because of an attention deficit disorder of the inattentive type, which initially was diagnosed while he was in the third grade. Petitioner asserts that he has manifested inattention at home and in the educational environment, which has negatively affected his educational performance resulting in poor grades. The District does not dispute that Petitioner had been diagnosed with an ADHD while in elementary school. Rather, the District contends that Petitioner’s diagnosis of ADHD has not been supported by recent testing or observed to impact Petitioner’s educational performance in high school.
To meet eligibility for special education as OHI, the student must have “limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infections diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance.” 5 Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f).
Does STUDENT exhibit limited strength, vitality or alertness?
The sole contention related to the first component of OHI is that STUDENT suffers from limited alertness. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has had difficulty staying focused since kindergarten, which resulted in his being diagnosed with an ADHD. Included in the evidence is a 2002 letter from Tom. W. Robinson, M.D., indicating that he had treated STUDENT for ADHD. Dr. Robinson does not indicate when he last saw STUDENT and there is no indication that he has observed STUDENT in an educational environment. Petitioner called Dr. Patterson to testify on his behalf regarding OHI eligibility for special education. As to attention, Dr. Patterson noted that there are comments throughout STUDENT’s educational records regarding his having attentional problems. Dr. Patterson also testified that during testing, STUDENT was “in and out of” focus. However, when asked specifically whether STUDENT met OHI criteria, Dr. Patterson stated that while STUDENT exhibits some signs of inactivity and attentional problems, he “could not definitively say that STUDENT was OHI.” Dr. Patterson attributed his inability to make a firm answer to the District’s failing to undertake a formal assessment to determine the effect of STUDENT’s diagnosis of ADHD in the educational environment. Dr. Patterson did not observe STUDENT in an educational environment.
All of the District witnesses, including several teachers, testified that despite STUDENT’s earlier diagnosis of ADHD, he has not exhibited signs of ADHD in the educational environment that rise to the level of satisfying eligibility for special education as OHI. First, Ms. Holm testified that the diagnosis of ADHD made in third grade is not determinative of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education in high school. She also testified that not all students with a medical diagnosis of ADHD are eligible for special education. The only significantly elevated test score related to attention was MOTHER’s rating on the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), which was included in the District’s assessment in March 2002. At that time, STUDENT rated himself on the Connors-Wells’ Self Report Scale ADHD indexes as having no symptoms of inattention or hyperactive-impulsivity. (District’s Exhibit 6) Ms. Holm concluded that STUDENT did not meet OHI criteria because the only notable report of attentional difficulties was at home and was not corroborated by testing or observations of teachers in the educational environment. Ms. Sadler, who collected information from the teachers and administered academic achievement testing of STUDENT concurred with Ms. Holm’s conclusions.
Other District witnesses, including Mr. Ryan and Ms. Barela, who participated in STUDENT’s IEP meeting, testified that STUDENT does not exhibit attentional problems in the educational environment that would satisfy OHI criteria. Mr. Ryan reviewed STUDENT’s educational records and testified that his review led him to conclude that STUDENT does not meet OHI criteria. Mr. Ryan turned to Dr. Becker’s assessment of October 2002 to support his testimony. Mr. Ryan pointed out that neither the TOVA nor the W-J-III administered by Dr. Becker contained evidence of an attentional disorder that would satisfy OHI eligibility criteria. (See District’s Exhibit 19) A review of Dr. Becker’s administration of the TOVA, which is a computerized assessment of attention, indicates that STUDENT’s performance on the TOVA was average. Dr. Becker further analyzed STUDENT’s attention using the W-J-III. Dr. Becker reported that STUDENT demonstrated some mild difficulties with work speed but scored average on subtests focusing on memory processing speed and paying attention. In his report, Dr. Becker acknowledged that STUDENT stated he has difficulty focusing on school work that he does not like. However, Dr. Becker concluded that STUDENT’s mild difficulties with attention “do not indicate an ADHD problem” and he concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education. Dr. Becker did recommend a 504 Plan to address attention and motivation concerns. (Footnote 13)
Dr. Patterson’s testing regarding attention is supportive of the District’s position. Dr. Patterson administered a measure of attention called the Broad Attention. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits FF-23 and FF-24.) In his report of March 2003, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT’s overall Broad Attention is in the average range. In the summary and recommendations contained in his assessment report, Dr. Patterson does not reach the conclusion that STUDENT has attentional problems that would qualify him for special education. He merely notes that the parents “have the option of going back to the School District and indicating that historically their son was identified as a child who would have met the criteria of Other Health Impaired.”
Turning to Dr. Patterson’s concern that there is no formal assessment of STUDENT’s diagnosis of ADHD on his performance in the educational environment, the Hearing Officer finds there is sufficient evidence in the record regarding STUDENT’s attention in school to conclude that STUDENT’s mild attentional problems have not affected his education to the level required to meet the first prong of the OHI eligibility criteria. Several of STUDENT’s teachers testified that he has not exhibited attentional problems in their classrooms. For example, Ms. Thompson, STUDENT’s American democracy teacher in the fall of 2002, testified that STUDENT’s ADHD did not affect his education. She testified that STUDENT failed because he did not do his homework. She also testified that STUDENT’s absences had a negative effect on his grades. Ms. Hoyt testified that MOTHER informed her of STUDENT’s ADHD diagnosis. Ms. Hoyt testified, however, that she did not observe STUDENT having difficulty focusing in class and there were no reports of attentional problems by STUDENT’s teachers. Written reports from STUDENT’s teachers in November 2002 also do not attribute STUDENT’s poor school performance to attentional problems. Reports from STUDENT’s literature, ROP Micro Office, photography, art, and American democracy teachers consistently indicate that STUDENT’s poor grades were a result of missing class and failing to turn in homework. (District’s Exhibit 20) District assessors testified that they did not observe STUDENT exhibiting attentional problems during testing. For example, Ms. Howe testified that she did not observe STUDENT having attentional problems during two or more hours of testing STUDENT. STUDENT himself testified that he paid attention in class.
In weighing the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the teachers regarding STUDENT’s ability to pay attention in class. The teachers have an opportunity to observe STUDENT whenever he is present in class and are in the best position to comment on his attention in the educational environment. Moreover, the testimony of the teachers at the hearing is supported by comments of other teachers on progress reports and report cards, by assessors, and by the results of testing. On the other hand, neither MOTHER, Dr. Robinson, nor Dr. Patterson observed STUDENT in the educational environment. Thus, MOTHER’s high rating of STUDENT on attentional factors was based on her observations of him at home and is not determinative as to his actual performance in the educational environment. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not suffer from impaired alertness in the educational environment and, therefore, does not satisfy requirements for OHI eligibility. (Footnote 14)
ISSUE NO. 3: If the District improperly failed to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE), is he entitled to compensatory educational services in the form of tutoring, vision therapy, and mental health counseling?
Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
A special education student may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)
Because it was concluded above that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility during the period at issue, the District’s failure to assess STUDENT prior to March 2002 did not result in prejudice to STUDENT. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education.
ISSUE NO. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychoeducational assessment undertaken by Dr. Robert Patterson and/or an independent vision therapy assessment by Dr. Beth Ballinger?
A parent may obtain reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for assessments conducted by Dr. Ballinger and Dr. Patterson.
MOTHER and Mr. Russell testified that they disputed the appropriateness of the District’s assessments and disagreed with their findings and, for these reasons, procured assessments from Dr. Ballinger and Dr. Patterson. The Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Ballinger’s or Dr. Patterson’s assessments. First, it was concluded above that the District failed in its obligation to assess STUDENT between 2001 and March 2002. However, Dr. Ballinger and Dr. Patterson each assessed STUDENT following the District’s assessments in 2002. Thus, their assessments were not procured in response to the District’s failure to assess. Second, it has been concluded above that the District conducted appropriate assessments of Petitioner. (Footnote 15) Reimbursement for the assessments would be available only if the District’s assessment was not appropriate. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments.
ORDER
All of STUDENT’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue No. (1): Did the District meet special education requirements related to assessing STUDENT by: (A) satisfying its child find obligations from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to March 2002; and (B) conducting appropriate assessments in March and November 2002? Petitioner and Respondent equally prevailed on sub-issue (A).
Respondent prevailed on sub- issue (B).
Issue No. (2): Has STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairment (OHI) from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to the present? Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. (3): If the District improperly failed to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE), is he entitled to compensatory educational services in the form of tutoring, vision therapy, and mental health counseling? Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. (4): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychoeducational assessment undertaken by Dr. Robert Patterson and/or an independent vision therapy assessment by Dr. Beth Ballinger? Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 11, 2004 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1 STUDENT remained in the seventh grade at Liberty for a second year before advancing to the eighth grade.
2 NHHS has a “block schedule.” Each class on a block schedule is approximately twice as long as a traditional class and convenes every other day rather than daily.
3 STUDENT’s transcripts show that for the first semester of the ninth grade he received four grades of “F,” an “A” in coed physical education (PE), and a “C” in world history/geography. STUDENT’s grades improved and at the end of the second semester he received all passing grades, including two grades of “D-,” three grades of “C,” and an “A-“ in coed PE. STUDENT earned credit during summer school for the English class he had failed during the first semester and improved his second semester grade from a “C” to a “B-.” STUDENT also completed a five-unit course in Elementary Spanish at Orange Coast College for which he received a grade of “C.”
4 The second semester, STUDENT received an “F” in literature but improved his history grade to a “D+.”
5 In fact, MOTHER’s request for a due process hearing made similar requests but did not mention special education eligibility.
6 This obligation is typically referred to as “child find.”
7 STUDENT’s grades in PE were “C-” and “B-.”
8 Ms. Sadler was not STUDENT’s teacher. Mr. Johnson, who was one of STUDENT’s general education teachers, also was present at the IEP meeting
9 An article in the California School Psychologist called into question this practice. “Helm and Johnson, Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California’s Title 5 Regulations,” 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). According to this article, the formula to determine a severe discrepancy must take into account the correlation between the specific ability and achievement tests used (by computing the correlation coefficient, r) rather than merely calculating simple differences between scores. The authors set forth tables showing standard criterion values for specific cognitive and achievement tests, based upon the correlation between the tests, and give the standard error of measurement to be applied. However, there is no known corroboration of the data, and the utility of the data provided is seriously limited. For example, no information is provided for the WJ-R Broad Written Language score in comparison with a WISC-III IQ score, or for the Stanford-Binet. At the hearing, no evidence was presented which applied the method presented in the above article for the specific tests administered to STUDENT. Moreover, the federal statute and regulation do not require a specific numerical difference between ability and achievement scores to establish a severe discrepancy. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541. Therefore, the methods set forth in California Code of Regulations, Title 5, Section 3030(j), including use of the 22.5 point discrepancy, will be applied here.
10 Because there were no assessments of STUDENT from 1999 to March 2002, the Hearing Officer has elected to divide the analysis of whether there was a severe discrepancy into two periods–from 1999 prior to the District’s testing in 2002, when there were no assessment data, and the period thereafter to the present, during which there were several assessments offering selected data.
11 The District’s last assessment of STUDENT had been in October 1995.
12 STUDENT’s verbal score was 99 and his full-scale score was 108.
13 The District did develop a 504 Plan for STUDENT.
14 This finding negates the need to reach the questions of whether limited alertness is due to chronic or acute health problems and adversely affects STUDENT’s educational performance.
15 Additionally, Petitioner provided no direct testimony regarding Dr. Ballinger’s assessment and did not introduce into evidence a report of any assessment Dr. Ballinger may have undertaken.
