California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 31, 2000

Student v. Central Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1497-99 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Central Unified must plan a first grader's return to general education reading class with a behavior plan; five other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 7 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's father, an attorney, filed for his seven-year-old daughter, a first grader at Saroyan Elementary School in Central Unified School District. She has Down syndrome and was eligible for special education based on mild developmental delay. She was fully included in a general education first grade with a one-to-one aide. After early behavior problems during the class's 90-minute "Writing Road to Reading" block, the District moved her reading and writing instruction to the resource specialist program (RSP) for about 85 minutes a day.

Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown applied the Ninth Circuit's four-factor Holland test. She found that the student could learn reading and writing mostly in the general education class with supports. These included a behavior plan, planned alternate activities, a sand or salt box for writing, and better behavior management by the aide. The Hearing Officer also found the student needed a home/school journal, because the District had barred aides from talking directly to parents.

The District won the remaining claims. Extra playground equipment was not needed for FAPE. The adaptive physical education goals and 30 minutes a week were appropriate. All requested records were produced before the hearing ended, and no harm was shown. A staff pre-meeting was not a secret IEP meeting. Staff remarks and a withdrawn termination of the mother's role as a surrogate parent did not amount to intimidation. The IEP team had to meet within 15 days to plan the move back to class with a behavior plan, curriculum modifications and a journal.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO used the Holland test for part of a school day. It found that a student's poor start in a general education reading block did not justify pulling her out when supports had not been fully tried. It also treated a parent communication journal as a needed part of the student's program.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1a. Has the District offered a FAPE for 1999-2000 to the extent FAPE includes a positive behavioral assessment plan that includes modified curriculum for both classroom and playground, so that Student can be fully included in her LRE?

    Applying Holland, the Hearing Officer found Student could receive most reading/writing instruction in the general education class with a behavior plan and curriculum modifications, rather than extended RSP; Student prevailed in large part, District in small part.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Has the District offered a FAPE for 1999-2000 to the extent FAPE includes proper playground equipment?

    Student's motor and social needs were met through APE, OT, and recess and classroom interaction, so additional accessible playground equipment was not required for FAPE.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1c. Has the District offered a FAPE for 1999-2000 to the extent FAPE includes appropriate goals and objectives for adaptive physical education (APE)?

    The September 1999 APE goals matched Student's needs, she was progressing, and 30 minutes of APE weekly was appropriate rather than the 90 minutes sought.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1d. Has the District offered a FAPE for 1999-2000 to the extent FAPE includes communication regarding Student's school experiences?

    Because the District barred aides from communicating with parents, Student needed a home/school journal; the IEP team may choose who compiles it.

  5. District prevailedRecords

    Issue 2a. Did the District commit procedural violations which denied a FAPE by failing to provide all requested school records?

    All requested records were provided before the hearing ended, no prejudice was shown, and no remedy was identified, so no procedural violation was found.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2b. Did the District commit procedural violations which denied a FAPE by inappropriately holding a meeting without notification to her parents?

    A staff pre-meeting held an hour before the IEP meeting involved no educational decisions and was not a procedural violation.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2c. Did the District commit procedural violations which denied a FAPE by engaging in intimidation tactics?

    A psychologist's statement of the District's litigation position, a rescinded surrogate-parent termination, and an ill-advised remark by the special education director were not intimidation that impeded parent participation.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the IEP team shall convene to agree on the terms of Student's transition to a shorter RSP period and longer period in the first-grade classroom during reading and writing instruction.
  • Order to provide or change services. Student's return to classroom reading and writing instruction shall include curriculum modifications and a behavioral plan so she may receive this instruction in the general education classroom; the IEP team decides how gradual the transition should be.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team shall provide for a home/school journal; the team may choose who compiles it.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Cynthia Toews, director of special education and support services, Central Unified School District
  • Rita Neudeck, special education preschool teacher (Student's former preschool teacher)
  • Tom Clark, adaptive physical education specialist, Central Unified School District
  • Rayna Perry, movement motor specialist/resource teacher, Central Unified School District
  • Karen Davis, general education first-grade teacher, Saroyan Elementary School
  • Debra Griffin, program specialist; former RSP teacher, Central Unified School District
  • Melanie Monahan, 1:1 aide, Central Unified School District
  • Diane Mazzoni, school psychologist, Central Unified School District
  • Marlene Lattanzio (formerly Parra), former adaptive physical education specialist, Central Unified School District
  • Lorie Oliver, behavior modification consultant
  • John Goodfellow, occupational therapist
  • Dianne Martin, second-grade teacher (Writing Road to Reading program), Saroyan Elementary School
  • Diana Decker, preschool special day class teacher, Central Unified School District
  • Deanna Cooney, speech therapist
  • Diane Whitehead, RSP teacher, Saroyan Elementary School
  • Ms. Gravano, witness referenced in testimony (role not stated)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1497-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Designated Instructionand Services Procedural Safeguards, Violation of CDS Code: 10-73965 District: Central Unified Disability Type: Other Health Impairment

Case Details This matter was heard before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on December 14 and 15, 1999, and January 4, 5, 24, 25 and 26, 2000, in Fresno, California.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by her attorney and father, FATHER. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Central Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Trevin Sims. Also present on the District's behalf was Cynthia Toews, District director of special education and support services.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Rita Neudeck, special education preschool teacher; Tom Clark, adaptive physical education specialist; Rayna Perry, movement motor specialist/resource teacher; Karen Davis, second-grade teacher; Debra Griffin, program specialist; Melanie Monahan, aide; Diane Mazzoni, school psychologist; Cynthia Toews, director of special education and support services; MOTHER, STUDENT's mother; and FATHER, STUDENT's father. (Footnote 1)

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Marlene Lattanzio (Footnote 2), former District adaptive physical education specialist; Lorie Oliver, behavior modification consultant; John Goodfellow, occupational therapist; Dianne Martin, second-grade teacher; Diana Decker, preschool teacher; Deanna Cooney, speech therapist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments only. Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 3)

(1) Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes the following:

(a) a positive behavioral assessment plan that includes modified curriculum for both classroom and playground, so that STUDENT can be fully included in her least restrictive environment (LRE)?

(b) proper playground equipment?

(c) appropriate goals and objectives for adaptive physical education (APE)?

(d) communication regarding STUDENT's school experiences?

(2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE by:

(a) failing to provide all requested school records?

(b) inappropriately holding a meeting without notification to her parents?

(c) engaging in intimidation tactics?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first and second days of hearing, District APE specialist Tom Clark testified in this case.

In January 2000, STUDENT's parents notified the District that they did not want Mr. Clark to continue providing services to STUDENT, and indicated that they believed Mr. Clark was not following STUDENT's IEP. When the hearing reconvened in January 2000, the Hearing Officer ruled that any dispute regarding Mr. Clark's provision of services was not at issue in this hearing, because the matter had not been noticed as a hearing issue. The Hearing Officer further explained that Petitioner could choose to pursue this issue via a separate due process request or other means.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT has just turned seven years old and lives in Fresno, California, within the boundaries of the Central Unified School District (District). She currently attends first grade at the District's Saroyan Elementary School (Saroyan). She has Down's Syndrome and is eligible for special education based on a diagnosis of mild developmental delay. She was born with a congenital heart defect, and had heart surgery as an infant. (Exh.Y.)

When STUDENT was three years old, she began attending preschool in Stockton. Subsequently she moved from Stockton to Fresno, where she enrolled in a District preschool program. From November 1996 to June 1998, STUDENT attended a District special day class, taught by Diana Decker at the District's Central High School East preschool program. (Testimony of Ms. Decker; Exh. 3.)

For the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT was fully included for 90% of her school day in a regular education kindergarten class at Saroyan. During her kindergarten year, STUDENT received adaptive physical education (APE) for 90 minutes per week, as specified in her IEP dated September 11, 1998. (Exh. 2; testimony of Marlene Lattanzio.) STUDENT's other special education services during kindergarten included occupational therapy (OT) once a week, resource specialist program (RSP) services for 80 minutes per week, and speech/language therapy for 60 minutes per week, with a monthly consultation between STUDENT's teacher and the speech/language therapist. STUDENT also had a one-to-one aide, Melanie Monahan. During STUDENT's kindergarten year, Ms. Monahan prepared brief daily reports about STUDENT's school day, and provided this information to STUDENT's parents in a "home/school journal." (Exh. B-1.)

To plan STUDENT's placement and program for her first grade year, the IEP team met in both June and July 1999. The team did not agree on several issues and, thus, did not sign an IEP at that time. One of the issues in dispute was the playground equipment that would be available to STUDENT in first grade. STUDENT had enjoyed playing with her friends on the kindergarten playground equipment, but the first grade playground equipment was not accessible to her. The IEP team agreed to consult with District motor movement specialist Rayna Perry, who would prepare a report regarding options for playground equipment. Other issues on which STUDENT's parents did not agree with the District included the amount of time STUDENT would have her one-to-one aide, the amount of APE time STUDENT would receive each week, and whether or not STUDENT needed a behavioral plan to address negative classroom behaviors. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Mazzoni, FATHER; Exhs. G, L, C-1.)

By all accounts, these discussions became heated at times. In particular, FATHER and Ms. Mazzoni clashed regarding whether or not STUDENT needed a full-time, one-to-one aide for the 1999-2000 school year. (Testimony of Ms. Mazzoni, MOTHER, Ms. Griffin, Ms. Gravano, FATHER; Exh. C-1.) At the July IEP meeting, FATHER and MOTHER stated that they thought STUDENT needed an aide for her entire school day once she entered first grade, while Ms. Mazzoni stated that the District would agree to an aide for only three hours per day. After failing to reach an agreement on the appropriate amount of aide time, Ms. Mazzoni stated that she believed that STUDENT did not need an aide at all, and that the District would take that position if the matter went to due process hearing. Ms. Mazzoni's comment enraged FATHER, and the atmosphere was hostile during the remainder of the meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Mazzoni, Ms. Griffin, MOTHER, Ms. Gravano, FATHER; Exhs. G, L, C-1.)

Also during summer 1999, MOTHER received a letter from the District regarding her role as a "surrogate parent" on behalf of special education students who otherwise do not have parental representation at IEP meetings. Cynthia Toews, District director of special education and support services, wrote that because of the disagreement over STUDENT's education, the District believed that MOTHER had a conflict of interest in her role as a surrogate parent for the District. Ms. Toews' letter thus informed MOTHER that the District was terminating MOTHER's role as a District surrogate parent. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Toews; Exh. E.) Subsequently, after discussing the matter with others, Ms. Toews changed her mind and wrote to MOTHER to rescind the termination. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Toews; Exh. D.)

In mid-August 1999, STUDENT began her 1999-2000 school year fully included in a regular education first grade class taught by Karen Davis. STUDENT continued to receive special education support services similar to those she received in kindergarten: OT, RSP, APE, speech/language therapy, a one-to-one aide, and consultation between the school psychologist and STUDENT's teacher. Most of the individuals providing these services remained the same as those from the previous year, except that STUDENT's APE specialist, Maureen Parra, had left the District, so STUDENT received those services from APE specialist Tom Clark. Additionally, Diane Whitehead became STUDENT's new RSP teacher, in place of Debra Griffin, who had become a District program specialist.

STUDENT initially exhibited some behavioral difficulties in her new classroom. STUDENT was often off-task and uncooperative, and Ms. Davis initially had difficulty redirecting her. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, MOTHER, FATHER; Exh. C-1.) Particularly during the class's 90-minute instructional sessions for writing and reading, STUDENT would get frustrated and would sometimes throw her pencil or paper. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Monahan.)

STUDENT's class had these 90-minute instructional sessions because, for the 1999-2000 school year, the first through fourth grade classes at Saroyan had embarked upon a new writing and reading program called "Writing Road to Reading" (WRR). The program is taught in a 90-minute block each day. STUDENT's class began working on the program after the first week or two of school. After STUDENT demonstrated difficulty staying on task during the WRR program, Ms. Davis attempted a few different strategies to modify the 90-minute writing sessions so that STUDENT could better participate in them. Some attempted modifications included allowing STUDENT to write on a dry erase board, or allowing her to write on large-spaced paper. However, these changes were not particularly effective, as STUDENT continued to get frustrated and go off-task during the WRR instruction time. Another attempted modification was to allow STUDENT to take a break and do another activity, such as an art project, after she became bored with the WRR program; the result was often that STUDENT was unwilling to end her break and return to working on the WRR program. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Monahan.)

By three or four weeks into the school year, Ms. Davis had grown frustrated with STUDENT's classroom behavior, and STUDENT had become resistant to going to class. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, FATHER; Exhs. A, C-1.) The District recommended that they should try having STUDENT do more of her writing and reading program in RSP instead of in the regular classroom. STUDENT's parents consented to the District's proposed change, as a temporary measure. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER; Exh. C-1.)

Also in September 1999, STUDENT was out of school for a week due to strep throat. When she returned to school, in addition to increasing her RSP time, her parents and the District agreed to shorten her school day. This change was initiated because STUDENT would reportedly get tired at school, and because of concerns that STUDENT was frequently getting sick. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Griffin.)

On September 24, 1999, the IEP team reconvened. The team agreed that STUDENT's placement would be as follows: 80% of her school day fully included in regular education first grade; RSP pull-out services for 240 minutes per week; two weekly 30-minute OT sessions; one 30-minute APE session per week; speech and language therapy for two weekly 30-minute sessions; behavioral consultation by the school psychologist with STUDENT's teacher; and a one-to-one aide for up to six hours per school day. STUDENT's parents and the other IEP team members all signed the IEP on September 24, 1999. (Exh. 1.)

After this change to her schedule, STUDENT now begins her school day at 7:45 a.m. in the regular education first grade class, but after the first fifteen minutes she leaves and goes to RSP for one hour and fifteen minutes. During RSP, STUDENT receives instruction in reading and writing. STUDENT then returns to first grade and participate in "station time," during which each student visits a station and performs its activity for about twenty minutes before moving on to the next station. After station time, STUDENT and her classmates go to lunch from 11:20 a.m. to 12:15 p.m. After lunch, STUDENT goes home, while the rest of the first-graders return to class for story time, math, and either social studies or play time. At 1:25 p.m., the class has a final ten-minute recess. At 1:35 p.m. the students get ready to go home. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Monahan.) Thus, STUDENT misses approximately the final hour and twenty minutes of first grade. In addition to this daily schedule, STUDENT is pulled out of class to receive two OT sessions, two speech therapy sessions, and one APE session each week.

STUDENT has followed this schedule since mid-September 1999. (Footnote 4) She has continued to have the same one-to-one aide, Melanie Monahan. Ms. Monahan no longer records STUDENT's activities in a home/school journal, because Ms. Griffin and Ms. Toews told Ms. Monahan that the District no longer permits aides to directly communicate with parents. (Testimony of Ms. Griffin, Ms. Monahan.) In late September or early October 1999, District school psychologist Diane Mazzoni and District program specialist Debra Griffin initiated a meeting with Ms. Monahan to discuss Ms. Monahan's work with STUDENT. Ms. Mazzoni and Ms. Griffin told Ms. Monahan that she needed to improve how she managed STUDENT's behavior, as summarized in a letter titled "Goals for Improvement." (Testimony of Ms. Griffin, Ms. Monahan; Exh. Z.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA µ97) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that are available at no charge, meet state educational standards, and conform to the student's IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate, and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982).) Whether a proposed placement is substantively appropriate involves three factors, as follows: whether the services are designed to address the student's unique needs, whether the services will provide her with educational benefit, and whether the services conform to her IEP. (Rowley at 176.)

If the District's proposed program is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide her some educational benefit, and is in conformity with her IEP, then the District has offered her a FAPE, even if her parents prefer another program, and even if her parents' preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, such that removal from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of her disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services can not be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.)

Issue 1(a): Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes a positive behavioral assessment plan that includes modified curriculum for both classroom and playground so that STUDENT may be included in her least restrictive environment (LRE)?

Both parties concur that STUDENT's placement in Ms. Davis's regular education first grade is appropriate.(Footnote 5) Likewise, the parties do not dispute the appropriateness of OT, speech therapy or a one-to-one aide as STUDENT's designated instructional services. However, Petitioner argues that the District should conduct an assessment of STUDENT's behaviors and use that assessment as the basis for a behavioral plan to modify and extinguish her negative behaviors. Petitioner asserts that if she had such a behavioral plan, along with curriculum modifications, she would be able to participate in the first grade's writing and reading program instead of receiving that instruction in RSP. Petitioner argues that STUDENT's current attendance in RSP for 85 minutes per day does not constitute her least restrictive environment (LRE), but rather that her LRE is in the first grade class for reading and writing instruction. The District argues that STUDENT's current placement, including RSP for 85 minutes a day, constitutes her LRE. The District argues that STUDENT does not need a behavioral plan, and that neither such a plan nor curriculum modifications would transform the regular education writing and reading instruction into STUDENT's LRE.

The LRE requirement is codified in federal law as follows:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities...are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

(20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; California Education Code § 56364.2.)

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as "mainstreaming" or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates "a strong preference for µmainstreaming' which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption." (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.) In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student's presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom; and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Holland (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

In the present case, the parties agree that STUDENT's LRE for the majority of her school day is the regular education first grade classroom. The dispute arises regarding whether STUDENT should receive her reading and writing instruction entirely in RSP, or should receive the majority of that instruction mainstreamed in her regular education classroom. The evidence clearly establishes, and neither party disputes, that at the beginning of the school year, STUDENT's initial placement in the regular education classroom for reading and writing instruction was not satisfactory. STUDENT could not pay attention for the duration of the 90-minute instructional session, and she grew restless and somewhat disruptive during those sessions. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Monahan.)

However, the parties do not agree as to whether modifications and supplemental aids could be utilized to make the regular education classroom the appropriate location for STUDENT to receive her reading and writing instruction. Hence, the Hearing Officer must apply the four-part test described in Holland to determine whether STUDENT should receive her reading and writing instruction in RSP, or whether STUDENT's education can be achieved satisfactorily if she remains in the regular classroom with modifications and supplemental services during that instruction time. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).)

1. The academic benefits of placement in the regular classroom during reading/writing instruction, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with placement in RSP

There is little question that STUDENT is making educational progress in her current RSP program, where she receives one-on-one and small-group instruction at her own pace. (See testimony of Ms. Griffin, Ms. Cooney.) Instead, the issue for examination is what academic benefit STUDENT could receive if she received that instruction primarily in the regular first grade classroom, with the shorter RSP session that STUDENT had at the very beginning of the school year.

Both the regular classroom and the RSP program utilize the Writing Road to Reading (WRR) program. Dianne Martin, a second-grade teacher at Saroyan, learned about the WRR program via her own research and has become very familiar with the program. The WRR program is an intensive, phonics-based reading program that also teaches grammar, punctuation and spelling. The program teaches 71 phonograms, which are the bases for spelling 45 sounds used in the English language. (Testimony of Ms. Martin.)

At the first-grade level, the program anticipates that the students will learn four phonograms per day, although the teachers at Saroyan have been proceeding at a slower pace so far this school year. (Testimony of Ms. Martin, Ms. Davis.) After the class learns the first 55 phonograms, the instructor then adds spelling lists, with six new spelling words per day, for five weeks. (Testimony of Ms. Martin.) Once 85% of the class has learned a particular lesson, as measured by daily testing, the teacher moves on to the next lesson. (Id.) The program is taught in a 90-minute block, and it can be difficult for first-graders to focus for that long of a period. (Id.) In Ms. Davis's first-grade class, the program is also integrated into the curriculum via station time, and STUDENT and the other children work on their phonograms while at those stations. (Testimony of Ms. Davis.)

Ms. Martin stated her opinion that a child with disabilities like STUDENT's could learn with the WRR program, but the program would need to be modified to the child's slower pace. Ms. Martin discussed possible modifications to the program, depending on the child's particular weaknesses: for example, if a child has deficiencies in fine motor skills, the child can write in sand instead of with a pencil. If the child can not focus for more than ten minutes, an aide can take the child out into the hallway after ten minutes, and have the child do an activity such as a game based on phonograms. If the child cannot focus at all and is restless, then Ms. Martin recommends taking the child out of the regular classroom altogether during the WRR program, and placing the child in another setting such as RSP.

The evidence established that STUDENT's initial attempt at the Writing Road to Reading (WRR) program with the regular first grade class was unsuccessful. STUDENT could not attend for the 90- minute period of instruction, and would get frustrated when she could not do the work. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Monahan.) When frustrated, STUDENT would often throw her pencil or paper. (Id.) STUDENT's aide was not effective in redirecting her, and thus the classroom teacher would often need to intervene. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, FATHER; Exh. C-1.) Simple redirection was often ineffective, and in those instances STUDENT required repeated redirection before she would return to her task. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, FATHER, Ms. Monahan; Exh. C-1.) While this also occurred during other times in the school day, not just during the WRR program, STUDENT's behavior was much more manageable after the first four weeks of school, after she began receiving her reading and writing instruction during RSP.

The District argues that even with a behavior plan or other modifications, STUDENT cannot benefit from the WRR program in the regular classroom setting because of her unique educational needs. The evidence established that STUDENT's unique needs include some auditory processing weaknesses, delays in motor skills, poor muscle strength, language impairments and articulation weaknesses. (Testimony of Mr. Goodfellow, Ms. Cooney, Ms. Decker, Ms. Lattanzio; Exhs. 1, 29.) STUDENT learns at a slower rate than most of her nondisabled peers, and she usually requires things to be repeated several times in order for her to learn the new information. (See testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Davis.) STUDENT has a short attention span but is relatively easy to redirect back on task. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Griffin, Ms. Lattanzio.)

Hence, it is found that STUDENT cannot pay attention for the entire 90-minute WRR instructional period in Ms. Davis's class. Furthermore, reading and writing are STUDENT's weakest areas. However, overall STUDENT's academic level is within or not far outside the range of the first-grade class. For example, STUDENT can read some simple words, speak in sentences, identify and count numbers up to 19, add and subtract small single digit numbers, and write her first and last names. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Griffin, Ms. Cooney; Exhs. 1, 29.)

Petitioner points to several possible modifications to allow STUDENT to remain in the classroom for reading and writing instruction. Such potential modifications include allowing STUDENT to write in a saltbox or sandbox, in consideration of her fine motor weaknesses. Considering STUDENT's short attention span, another option could include planning alternate academic activities for STUDENT after ten or fifteen minutes of direct instruction. While the District argues that Ms. Monahan was unsuccessful when attempting this at the beginning of the school year, the Hearing Officer agrees with Petitioner that this option was not fully explored. Ms. Monahan testified that STUDENT would take a break after ten minutes and do an activity such as a puzzle, but after the break STUDENT would resist returning to work. There was no evidence of attempts to transform this pattern into a successful approach, such as by varying the type of activity utilized during the break. Moreover, numerous witnesses testified that STUDENT's aide is not effective at managing STUDENT's behavior, yet there was no evidence of attempts to utilize another adult, such as STUDENT's RSP teacher, to work with STUDENT in the classroom during a portion of the WRR instruction. (Footnote 6) There was also no evidence that the District made any serious attempt to provide Ms. Monahan with training to improve her ability to manage STUDENT.

Regarding other potential modifications, the Hearing Officer considers the evidence regarding a behavioral plan, as discussed in an earlier section of this decision. The Hearing Officer concludes that a behavioral plan would be an appropriate modification to allow STUDENT to receive her reading/writing instruction in the regular education classroom. While a behavioral plan will not lengthen STUDENT's attention span, effective behavior modification would likely assist in redirecting STUDENT to another activity, or transitioning STUDENT from another activity back to the regular instruction. Moreover, the evidence indicated that STUDENT's teacher felt overwhelmed at the beginning of the school year; Ms. Davis had never previously taught the WRR program and had never previously had a student with Down's Syndrome. Thus, new attempts to modify STUDENT's classroom behavior would likely be more effective than any such attempts were at the beginning of the school year.

Therefore, in light of all the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT could learn reading and writing primarily in the regular education first-grade classroom with supplementary aids and services, including a behavioral plan and modifications in presenting the WRR program. While the District argues that STUDENT learns better in RSP, the law does not require that STUDENT receive the best program. The Holland court explained that the IDEA's integration requirement, "based on recognition of the non-academic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom." (Holland, supra, 14 F.3d at 1404.)

2. The nonacademic benefits of placement in the regular first grade classroom

STUDENT is a friendly child who enjoys participating in class and being with other children. (See testimony of Ms. Cooney, Ms. Oliver.) STUDENT interacts with her classmates and has friends in her class. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, FATHER, MOTHER; Exh. C-1.) Ms. Davis explained that one of the most effective ways to punish STUDENT is to send her out of the classroom for a walk, because STUDENT would rather stay in class with the other children. There is little question that STUDENT benefits from opportunities for peer modeling; for example, STUDENT is more on-task when sitting in the back of the classroom, because from that vantage point STUDENT sees how all the other students are working. (Testimony of Ms. Davis.) Thus, the evidence establishes that Petitioner benefits from placement in regular education.

3. The effect on the teacher and other children in the classroom

Overall STUDENT's presence in the regular education classroom benefits the entire class. Witnesses described how the other first-graders often vie to help STUDENT and to play with her during recess. (Testimony of Ms. , FATHER, MOTHER, Ms. Davis.) STUDENT is a full member of the class and participates in all class activities. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Oliver.)

Witnesses described how STUDENT's behavior can be disruptive, and was particularly so during the first four weeks of the school year. STUDENT sometimes manifests negative behaviors, such as throwing her paper or pencil when she is frustrated with her work, touching other students, taking other students' snacks, resisting returning to class after recess, and other occasional noncompliant behaviors. During the first few weeks of the school year, Ms. Davis had continual difficulty with managing STUDENT's behaviors, to the point that it would take 10-20 minutes for Ms. Davis to redirect STUDENT to task. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, MOTHER, FATHER, Ms. Monahan; Exh. C-1.) After the first few weeks of school, Ms. Davis told STUDENT's father that "it can't go on like this." (Testimony of Ms. Davis; Exhs. A, C-1.) STUDENT's behaviors improved substantially after her school day shortened and she began attending RSP for extended sessions each day.

Reduction of negative behaviors would be concomitant with STUDENT being able to receive academic benefit from reading and writing instruction in the classroom. As examined in the first section of this LRE analysis, several potential modifications could be made to facilitate STUDENT's attendance during reading and writing instruction and to reduce her negative behaviors. (Footnote 7) Hence, to the extent that the WRR program can be modified to allow STUDENT to learn the program primarily in the classroom, so can STUDENT's behaviors be reduced to avoid disruption to the other students and the teacher.

4. Cost of mainstreaming

No evidence regarding cost was submitted, and both parties agree that cost was not presented as an issue.

The Hearing Officer concludes that modifications can be implemented to allow STUDENT to receive educational benefit from the WRR program primarily in the regular classroom. Such modifications would reduce STUDENT's previous negative behaviors during the WRR classroom time, removing the disruption to other students and the teacher. Such modifications should include a behavioral plan, curriculum modifications such as planned alternative activities when STUDENT can no longer pay attention, use of a saltbox or sandbox, and improvement in the aide's management of STUDENT's behaviors. (Footnote 8)

While STUDENT could also learn her reading and writing via the extended RSP sessions, the nonacademic benefits of attendance in the regular classroom weigh in favor of a shorter RSP session, with the majority of reading and writing instruction being provided in the regular classroom. The Hearing Officer further concludes that, given that the modifications to STUDENT's program must be made on an experimental basis with readjusting as needed, STUDENT may need to make a gradual transition to a shorter RSP session and longer WRR classroom instruction. The IEP team shall determine to what extent a gradual transition is necessary, according to the success of the attempts at modifications.

Issue 1(b): Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes proper playground equipment?

As explained previously, if the District's proposed program is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide her some educational benefit, and is in conformity with her IEP, then the District has offered her a FAPE, even if her parents prefer another program, and even if her parents' preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207- 208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) Regarding nonacademic activities such as outside play, the IDEA requires that the District allow STUDENT the opportunity "to participate in extra curricular and other nonacademic activities." (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(II).)

In the present case, last year STUDENT enjoyed playing with friends on the kindergarten playground equipment. This year, STUDENT is unable to utilize most of the playground equipment for the first, second and third-graders. (Testimony of Rayna Perry, Ms. Lattanzio.) Petitioner alleges that the District's failure to provide her with playground equipment she can use with her peers constitutes a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 9)

Petitioner's evidence established, and the District does not dispute, that access to usable playground equipment addresses many of STUDENT's needs, goals and objectives. Playing on playground equipment allows STUDENT the opportunity to interact and socialize with nondisabled peers, develop functional speech, and build muscle strength, balance and coordination, all of which coincide with STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives. (Exh. 1; testimony of Rita Neudeck, Ms. Perry.) However, the District presented persuasive evidence that STUDENT's needs are addressed by the current playground options. District motor movement specialist Rayna Perry conducted an assessment of STUDENT's motor movement issues, and assessed the options available to STUDENT on the first through third-graders' playground. (Exh.6.) Ms. Perry found that STUDENT could use only two of the items on the playground structure: the climbing rocket and the parallel bars. While Ms. Perry recommended that the District purchase additional playground equipment that would be accessible to STUDENT, Ms. Perry also concluded that STUDENT did not need new equipment to address her needs or make progress on her goals and objectives. Ms. Perry described how STUDENT's APE and OT sessions adequately address STUDENT's needs, goals and objectives in those areas. (Footnote 10) (Testimony of Ms. Perry; see also testimony of Mr. Clark, Ms. Lattanzio, Mr. Goodfellow.) Additionally, testimony established that STUDENT's APE sessions sometimes include play on the kindergarten playground equipment, which is accessible to STUDENT. (Testimony of Mr. Clark, Ms. Monahan.)

Regarding socialization opportunities, Ms. Neudeck, STUDENT's former preschool teacher, testified that playground equipment draws children "like a magnet," and creates an excellent means for disabled children to socialize with nondisabled children on more equal standing with one another. However, STUDENT's former APE specialist, Marlene Lattanzio, explained that during her recent employment at the District, she would observe Saroyan's recess two to three times per week. Ms. Lattanzio had observed that during recess time at Saroyan, 90% of the students play on the blacktop, while 10% play on the playground equipment. Several witnesses testified that STUDENT regularly plays with nondisabled friends by "running around" during recess. (Testimony of Ms. Monahan, Ms. Davis, MOTHER; Exh. C-1.) Additionally, it is important to note that STUDENT participates in all regular first-grade activities when she is in the classroom, including games and field trips. (Testimony of Ms. Davis.)

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has opportunities for extra-curricular and nonacademic activities, and does not need additional playground equipment to address her needs or to make progress on her goals and objectives. In particular, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Perry's opinions persuasive because of her extensive knowledge and experience, and because of her knowledge of STUDENT, STUDENT's program and the facilities at Saroyan. Ms. Perry was knowledgeable and credible in her explanation that, while playground equipment is beneficial to all children, STUDENT has opportunities to develop motor skills and strength via her APE and OT sessions. Regarding socialization, while Ms. Neudeck is knowledgeable regarding socialization opportunities for disabled children, Ms. Lattanzio is more knowledgeable regarding utilization of playground equipment specifically at Saroyan. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has numerous other opportunities to socialize with nondisabled peers, which she utilizes both in the classroom and during recess, and thus does not specifically need additional playground equipment to provide such opportunities. Accordingly, the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE regarding this issue.

Issue 1(c): Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes appropriate goals and objectives for adaptive physical education (APE)?

Petitioner asserts that some of her APE goals and objectives are inconsistent with providing her with educational benefit, because those goals and objectives arguably underestimate her skills by repeating goals and objectives from previous years and/or including skills that she has already achieved. For example, Petitioner asserts that she had already achieved her September 1999 APE Goal 8(a), which states that "By 12/99 STUDENT will take 3 steps forward on balance beam w/o assistance." This goal is part of Petitioner's IEP dated September 24, 1999. (Exh.1.) STUDENT's previous APE specialist, Marlene Lattanzio, testified that, as of July 1999, STUDENT had not achieved that goal. STUDENT's current APE specialist, Tom Clark, testified that as of mid-December 1999, STUDENT had met this goal but had not yet mastered it. Based on the testimony and IEPs, the Hearing Officer concludes that APE Goal 8(a) was consistent with STUDENT's needs at the time of the September 1999

IEP.

Similarly, Petitioner argues that, by the time of the September 1999 IEP meeting, she had already achieved her APE Goal 10(a), which states that "By 12/99 STUDENT will be able to catch a small playground ball w/ hands only at least 3 out of 5 times." (Exh.1.) Petitioner points to Ms. Lattanzio's progress report dated May 1, 1998, which states "She is able to catch a small playground ball most of the time." (Exh.P.) However, Ms. Lattanzio testified that, as of July 1999, STUDENT could not catch a small playground ball with "hands only." Ms. Lattanzio explained that, as of May 1998, STUDENT might have been able to trap a ball using her arms, but not consistently using only her hands.

Petitioner further contends that she has not made progress on her APE goals from year to year. For example, Petitioner points to her September 1999 APE Goal 8(b), which states that "[b]y 6/00 STUDENT will be able to stand/balance on either foot for at least 8 seconds." Petitioner argues that this has been one of her goals in previous years, and that she has not made any progress on this goal. To compare, Petitioner's APE goals dated February 21, 1997, include the goal: "STUDENT will demo. balance by standing on one foot for 10 sec." (Exh.O.) Petitioner's APE progress report dated May 1, 1998, reports that STUDENT "is able to balance on one foot for approximately 5 seconds." (Exh.P.) By July 1999, STUDENT had progressed only to being able to stand on one foot consistently for five or six seconds; however, as the District notes, standing on one foot was not a goal on the September 1998 IEP, and did not return as a goal until the September 1999 IEP. (Testimony of Ms. Lattanzio; Exhs. 1, 2; see also Exh. M.)

In any event, the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has been making progress on her other APE goals. For the current school year, Mr. Clark reported that STUDENT was making progress in several areas, including walking on the balance beam, using alternate feet to descend stairs, and catching a ball using only her hands. (Testimony of Mr. Clark; Exhs. N, O.)

No persuasive evidence was presented to support Petitioner's argument that the APE goals and objectives were inappropriate, and all witnesses with expertise in APE offered testimony supporting the current APE goals and objectives. (See testimony of Ms. Lattanzio, Mr. Clark, Ms. Perry.) Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the September 1999 goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT's needs and provide her with educational benefit.

Additionally, Petitioner argues that she needs 90 minutes of APE services per week, instead of the 30 minutes she now receives. However, Petitioner did not present any evidence to support this assertion; all witnesses knowledgeable about APE testified that 30 minutes per week was appropriate to address STUDENT's needs. (Testimony of Ms. Lattanzio, Mr. Clark, Ms. Perry, Ms. Mazzoni.) Because STUDENT now receives OT as well as APE, she needs less time in APE. (Testimony of Ms. Perry.) Also, because STUDENT has a shortened school day, and because she receives other pull-out services, additional APE time would further fill up her already busy school day. Thus, the current IEP's provision of 30 minutes of APE per week is appropriate.

Issue 1(d): Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes communication regarding STUDENT's school experiences?

There is little question that communication between STUDENT's parents and her teacher is of significant importance, particularly considering STUDENT's disability and unique needs, and her parents' roles as participants in making educational decisions for her. (See testimony of FATHER, MOTHER, Ms. Griffin; Exh. C-1.) STUDENT's parents credibly established that the home/school journal was useful for them during STUDENT's kindergarten year. STUDENT's aide compiled the journal last year, but cannot do so this year because the District now prohibits aides from communicating directly with parents.

The District has an obligation to make communication fluid between STUDENT's parents and her instructors. While the District is free to adopt its own personnel policies, it is difficult to see how such communication can occur when STUDENT's parents cannot receive information from the adult who has the greatest amount of interaction with STUDENT during the school day. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needs a home/school journal so that her parents may be informed as to her educational needs and progress. The IEP team may choose whichever individual(s) it deems appropriate to compile the journal.

(2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE by:

(a) failing to provide all requested school records?

Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in

Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)

Specifically, Petitioner argues that her parents requested copies of all of her educational records, but that the District failed to provide copies of those records within the time limits imposed by law. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(A); Education Code § 56504.) Petitioner argues that the District failed to provide her with Ms. Perry's report, Ms. Mazzoni's "goals for improvement" letter to Ms. Monahan, Mr. Goodfellow's records of his OT sessions with STUDENT, Mr. Clark's records of his APE sessions with STUDENT, and notes in Ms. Davis's possession from STUDENT's kindergarten teacher. (Exhs. X, Z.)

Regarding the OT and APE notes, both Mr. Clark and Mr. Goodfellow testified that they were not required to keep such records, and did so simply for their own reference; the District did not provide these records because it did not believe that these constituted "pupil records" under the law. Similarly, the District did not provide the "goals for improvement" letter, which concerned how Ms. Monahan should improve her management of STUDENT, because it believed that this letter was a personnel record and not a pupil record under the law. Regarding Ms. Perry's handwritten report, Ms. Perry testified that she had previously provided a copy of her handwritten report to MOTHER. In any event, Petitioner received copies of all requested records before the end of the hearing. Petitioner failed to establish how she was prejudiced by lack of earlier receipt of records. Moreover, Petitioner has not indicated what remedy she seeks in compensation for any violation. Thus, the Hearing Officer does not find evidence to establish a procedural violation under the Education Code or the IDEA, and declines to award a remedy.

(b) inappropriately holding a meeting without notification to her parents?

Petitioner alleges that the District called an IEP meeting without inviting or notifying her parents. Ms. Griffin explained that she had scheduled a pre-IEP meeting for one hour prior to the actual IEP meeting on September 24, 1999. Ms. Griffin stated that she scheduled this pre-meeting to make certain that all of the District employees were prepared for, and would be on time for, the actual IEP meeting. Ms. Davis described how IEP team members showed up to the pre-meeting at various times, and the priSTUDENT activity at the pre-meeting consisted of waiting for the actual meeting to begin.

There is no evidence to indicate that District employees were making educational decisions regarding STUDENT at the pre-IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District's scheduling of this pre-IEP meeting does not constitute a procedural violation.

(c) engaging in intimidation tactics?

Petitioner makes three specific allegations of intimidation tactics by the District. First, she alleges that Ms. Mazzoni attempted to intimidate the parents with her statements at the July 1999 IEP meeting that the District would argue at due process that STUDENT did not need an aide at all. Ms. Mazzoni testified that the District had only agreed to an aide in order to reach agreement with the parents and, in fact, the District did not believe that STUDENT needed an aide. Ms. Mazzoni explained that she was not making a threat but, rather, asserting what the District's position would be if the parties failed to reach agreement. The Hearing Officer concludes that statements from Ms. Mazzoni and other District employees were not procedural violations of the IDEA.

Second, Petitioner alleges that the District's termination of MOTHER's role as a surrogate parent was intimidation in violation of the IDEA. Ms. Toews, District director of special education and support services, informed MOTHER that a conflict of interest existed between MOTHER's role as a surrogate parent and her disagreements with the District regarding STUDENT's program. (Exh. E.) Subsequently, after discussing the matter with others, Ms. Toews changed her mind and wrote to MOTHER to rescind the termination. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Toews; Exh. D.) Ms. Toews explained that she had become concerned about MOTHER's impartiality as a surrogate parent after MOTHER revoked her consent for release of certain records regarding students under MOTHER's surrogacy. (Testimony of Ms. Toews.) MOTHER credibly explained that her decision to revoke consent was entirely based on the facts of that matter, and had no relation to the dispute regarding STUDENT. (Testimony of

MOTHER.)

The Hearing Officer agrees that the District's attempt to terminate MOTHER was ill-considered and imprudent. Indeed, Ms. Toews apparently reached the same conclusion, leading her to retract the termination. Nevertheless, there is no indication that the termination was meant to intimidate or punish STUDENT's mother for her advocacy on behalf of STUDENT, or to impede MOTHER's participation in the IEP process. The matter did not create a procedural violation of the IDEA.

Finally, Petitioner alleges that Ms. Toews attempted to intimidate MOTHER during a conversation in a local coffee shop. MOTHER and Ms. Toews saw each other at the coffee shop and began casually discussing STUDENT and the IEP process. Ms. Toews recounted that she discussed with MOTHER that one difficulty of pursuing due process is that it can negatively affect parents' relationships with District staff. MOTHER characterized Ms. Toews' comment as something to the effect of "if you go to due process, you have to be concerned about disgruntled District employees taking it out on your child." (Testimony of MOTHER.)

In any event, while the Hearing Officer suspects that Ms. Toews did not realize that her remark would be interpreted as a threat, Ms. Toews' comment is nevertheless of concern. It is Ms. Toews' job to make certain that District employees follow students' IEPs and comply with all relevant laws when providing services to District special education students. To whatever extent MOTHER's recollection is accurate, the Hearing Officer finds such circumstances highly disturbing. However, there has been no persuasive evidence presented to indicate that any retaliation towards STUDENT occurred. Regarding Petitioner's underlying complaint that Ms. Toews intended the remark as a threat, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Toews' remark was merely injudicious, not an intentional threat or attempt to deter the parents' participation in the IEP process. Moreover, there is no evidence that the remark resulted in any impedment to the parents' participation in the IEP process. Thus, while Ms. Toews' comment was ill-advised, it does not reach the level of an intimidation tactic constituting a procedural violation of the IDEA.

ORDER

Within fifteen days of this decision, the IEP team shall convene to agree upon the terms of STUDENT's transition to a shorter RSP period and longer period in the first-grade classroom during reading and writing instruction. STUDENT's return to the classroom reading and writing instruction shall include curriculum modifications and a behavioral plan, so that she may receive this instruction in the regular education classroom. The IEP team shall also provide for a home/school journal. All of Petitioner's remaining claims are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, to the extent that FAPE includes the following:

(a) a positive behavioral assessment plan that includes modified curriculum for both classroom and playground, so that STUDENT can be fully included in her least restrictive environment (LRE)?

Petitioner prevailed in large part on this issue, and the District prevailed in small part.

(b) proper playground equipment?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(c) appropriate goals and objectives for adaptive physical education (APE)?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(d) communication regarding STUDENT's school experiences?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE by:

(a) failing to provide all requested school records?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(b) inappropriately holding a meeting without notification to her parents?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(c) engaging in intimidation tactics?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: March 31, 2000 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes

1. Because FATHER was also STUDENT's attorney, the Hearing Officer allowed him to submit a written declaration in lieu of his testimony. The District did not object to this arrangement. FATHER testified under oath that his declaration was true and correct; the declaration was admitted as Exhibit C-1. The District was allowed time to review the written declaration and thereafter to conduct cross-examination. 2. At the time she provided services to STUDENT, Ms. Lattanzio's last name was Parra. 3. In consultation with the parties, on the first day of hearing the Hearing Officer clarified Petitioner's issues. Subsequently the Hearing Officer also clarified and reorganized the statement of issues to allow better organization of the Decision. Issue I(d) was not specified in Petitioner's statement of issues, but throughout the hearing the issue was clearly incorporated as part of Petitioner's case. 4. In January 2000, STUDENT's parents requested that Mr. Clark no longer provide STUDENT with APE services. The District's correspondence indicated that it would comply with the parents' request. It is unknown whether STUDENT now receives APE services from a different District APE specialist. 5. Petitioner does not dispute STUDENT's shortened school day, and has not requested that the Hearing Office order that her placement include attendance for the full school day. Petitioner has merely indicated that she hopes to return to a full school day as soon as possible. 6. Petitioner asserts that the aide, Ms. Monahan, was ineffective in dealing with STUDENT. (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 6.) However, Petitioner does not argue that the aide's lack of effectiveness constituted a denial of FAPE, and does not argue for Ms. Monahan's replacement or removal. 7. In particular, implementation of a behavioral plan should reduce STUDENT's behaviors and render them far more manageable. 8. Options for the IEP team to consider include training Ms. Monahan or replacing her. 9. This issue may also give rise to claims under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and/or the Americans with Disabilities Act. Petitioner's ability to pursue those claims is unaffected by the Hearing Officer's determinations regarding FAPE. 10. As discussed in section 1(c) of this decision, STUDENT has been making progress on her APE goals and objectives.