California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 18, 2002
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1499-00 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Los Angeles Unified denied a FAPE in four of six school years; Hearing Officer orders a job coach, transportation, and a new IEP.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions an interim agreement of January 2002 under which the District provided Lindamood-Bell services, an independent assessment, and a mental health referral.
Summary
A 20-year-old student challenged the Los Angeles Unified School District's special education program for six school years, from 1997-1998 through 2002-2003. She was first found eligible with a specific learning disability and was later found eligible with mild mental retardation. She stopped attending school around age 18. The Hearing Officer found that the 1997-1998 IEP denied a FAPE. It had no present levels of performance, copied the prior district's goals, did not address behavior or attendance, and had no transition statement. The 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 IEPs provided a FAPE. They were based on assessment, set academic and vocational goals, included transition plans, and placed her in a small special day class where she made some progress. The District held no IEP meeting after March 1999, so it made no offer for 2000-2001 or 2001-2002. For 2002-2003, the District held an IEP meeting without proper notice to the family, and its offer of the Alton School was inappropriate. Alton's codirector testified the school does not serve students like her. The delay in mental health services was not the District's fault. The Hearing Officer ordered a new IEP meeting with private psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson and a transition specialist. She also ordered a placement with functional skills, community-based, and work-experience instruction, plus a 1:1 job coach and transportation to counseling and job sites. Requests for more reading instruction, compensatory counseling, and services past age 22 were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO looked at a long claim one school year at a time. It treated a missing annual IEP as a denial of FAPE even after an adult student left school. It also found that holding an IEP meeting without notice can deny FAPE when it delays placement. Compensatory relief was tied to what the evidence showed the student currently needed.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1 (1997-1998). Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year?
The June 1997 IEP lacked present levels of performance, copied the prior district's goals without addressing lack of progress, had no goals for behavior or attendance, and had no transition statement; the student failed most classes, so FAPE was denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1 (1998-1999). Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
The June 1998 IEP, based on a triennial assessment, had present levels, academic and vocational goals, a transition plan and SDC placement, and the student made some progress; FAPE was provided.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1 (1999-2000). Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
The March 1999 IEP addressed academic deficits in a small-group SDC and included vocational goals and a transition plan suited to a 16-year-old; it met the Rowley floor of opportunity.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1 (2000-2001). Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
The District held no annual IEP meeting and made no offer for 2000-2001 and did no triennial assessment; the student's leaving school after age 18 did not relieve it of the duty, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1 (2001-2002). Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
The District stipulated it held no IEP meeting after March 1999 until summer 2002, so there were no goals, services, or placement offer for 2001-2002, which denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1 (2002-2003)a. Did the District commit procedural error by convening the October 1, 2002 IEP meeting without proper notice?
The District held the meeting without written notice of its date and time or efforts to secure the family's attendance; this blocked the student's participation, delayed placement, and denied FAPE.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1 (2002-2003)b. Did the District delay the student's receipt of agreed-to mental health services?
The District offered weekly counseling through contract agencies and referred the student to county mental health; the delay came from the family not contacting the agencies or returning consent, not from the District.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1 (2002-2003)c. Was the District's offer of placement at Alton, a nonpublic school, appropriate?
The goals and counseling were appropriate, but Alton's codirector testified the school does not accept students with mild mental retardation and lacks a functional skills program, so the placement offer was not appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
The student was awarded a 1:1 job coach and round-trip transportation to counseling and job sites; compensatory counseling, more intensive reading instruction, and services past age 22 were denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. Within 10 calendar days, the District must make an appointment with an appropriately qualified mental health professional and provide transportation to and from each appointment for the rest of the school year, including ESY.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days, the District must convene an IEP meeting with written notice at least five calendar days in advance so the student and her mother and/or grandmother can take part. The District must provide for Dr. Patterson's participation and ensure that a District transition specialist attends.
- The IEP team must identify a placement that meets Dr. Patterson's recommendations and considers the student's interests and motivation. It must provide functional skills instruction, occupational exploration, community-based instruction such as mobility training, and specific job training with actual work experience.
- Compensatory education. The IEP team must amend the current IEP to add round-trip transportation to counseling and job training locations and a one-to-one job coach (the decision states the job coach is for the remainder of the school year).
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Amanda J. v. Clark County School Dist.; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri
People named in the decision
- Christopher Russell, child advocate and educational consultant for Student
- Robert Patterson, Psy.D., licensed psychologist in private practice; independent psychoeducational assessor and expert witness, Private practice
- Victoria McKendall, administrator for due process; school psychologist; District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Brenda McKindra, transition resource teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Shelia C. Jordan Jones, transition coordinator; transition assessor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sue Talesnick, due process specialist; District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Billie Thomas, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Patricia Wilson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Leonard Studley, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Harriet Watson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Kristina Drucker, codirector of nonpublic school; witness, Alton School
- Alton School, nonpublic school offered as placement
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private reading instruction provider (136 hours under interim agreement)
- Los Angeles County Mental Health, county mental health agency (referral)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on December 14, 2001, and October 24, 25, and 28, 2002. The parties also met on January 8, August 15, and October 2, 2002. However, no witnesses were called to testify because the parties engaged in settlement discussions on each of these dates.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania L. Whiteleather. Also present at various times on behalf of STUDENT were her mother, her grandmother, and Christopher Russell, child advocate and educational consultant. On December 14, 2001, Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District was represented by attorney Laura M. Marrero, assistant general counsel for the District. Wesley B. Parsons, staff counsel, appeared on behalf of the District on January 8, 2002. Attorney Alexa J. Jackowski from the law firm of Lozano Smith represented the District on all other days. Due process specialists also appeared on behalf of the District. Billie Thomas was present on December 14, 2001; Patricia Wilson was present on August 15, 2002; Leonard Studley was present on October 2, 2002; Harriet Watson was present on October 24 and 25, 2002; and Sue Talesnick was present on January 8, 2002, October 2 and 28.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the Los Angeles Unified School District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years?
(2) If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a 20-year-old woman residing within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Los Angeles Unified School District. STUDENT has not attended school since turning 18-years-old in October of 2000.(footnote 1) STUDENT meets eligibility criteria for special education because of mental retardation. She previously was designated eligible on the basis of a specific learning disability. STUDENT also has asthma and diabetes, which presently are under control.
STUDENT attended a private school before enrolling in the Bellflower Unified School District in the third grade. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, had expressed concern regarding STUDENT’s academic performance in the second grade. STUDENT was then retained in second grade for another year. In September 1991, during STUDENT’s third-grade year, STUDENT’s teacher referred her for a special education assessment. Following an assessment in December 1991, an Individualized education program (IEP) team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability. STUDENT demonstrated discrepancies between cognitive abilities and all areas of achievement. She also demonstrated deficiencies in auditory processing, and auditory and visual sequential memory. STUDENT’s initial special education placement was in a resource specialist program (RSP). Later in the school year, STUDENT was placed in a special day class (SDC). STUDENT attended school in Bellflower through her seventh-grade year.
STUDENT entered the Los Angeles Unified School District as an eighth-grade student during the 1996-1997 school year with an IEP dated May 3, 1996, from the Bellflower District. The Los Angeles Unified School District convened its first IEP meeting regarding STUDENT on June 25, 1997. The purpose of the meeting was to conduct an annual review of goals and objectives and to make recommendations for services and STUDENT’s placement for the 1997-1998 school year. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue in an SDC with mainstreaming in physical education (PE) and other general school activities including nutrition, lunch, and assemblies. STUDENT’s mother consented to the IEP.
STUDENT attended Jordan High School during the first semester of the 1997-1998 school year and transferred to Narbonne High School for the second semester. Both schools are within the Los Angeles Unified School District. The District began a triennial assessment of STUDENT in April 1998. The annual IEP meeting occurred on June 10, 1998, following completion of the assessment. The assessment revealed that STUDENT had low-average cognitive abilities and was functioning significantly below grade level in reading, math, and written language. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT remain in an SDC with mainstreaming in PE and an elective. In the fall of 1998, STUDENT returned to Jordan High School for the tenth grade. The District convened an annual IEP meeting on March 9, 1999, to review STUDENT’s academic achievement and to discuss her social and emotional status.
MOTHER requested a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT in August of 2000. MOTHER expressed concern regarding STUDENT’s lack of progress and poor reading skills. STUDENT briefly attended school during the 2000-2001 school year before dropping out of school near her 18th birthday. The hearing convened on December 14, 2001. STUDENT authorized her mother and grandmother to proceed with the hearing on her behalf. On the second day scheduled for hearing, January 8, 2002, the parties agreed, among other things, that the District would (1) provide for STUDENT to receive intensive services from the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (LBLP), (2) arrange for an assessment of STUDENT by a psychologist that was not employed by the District, and (3) make a referral to Los Angeles County Mental Health (LACMH) to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for mental health services. STUDENT participated in the LBLP provided by the District from February through April 2002 for a total of 136 hours
On July 1, 2002, Robert Patterson, Psy.D., completed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Patterson is a licensed psychologist in private practice. The assessment was completed pursuant to an agreement reached by the parties in January 2002. Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT continued to meet special education eligibility criteria as a person with a specific learning disability. However, he concluded that STUDENT functions in the mild range of mental retardation. Dr. Patterson also found STUDENT was experiencing depression and anxiety, for which he recommended counseling.The District also undertook an adapted physical education (APE) and a health assessment of STUDENT.
On August 8, 2002, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of assessments. The IEP team determined that STUDENT met special education eligibility as a student with mild mental retardation. The team developed goals and objectives in life skills reading, mathematics, and written language, vocational skills, general knowledge, safety awareness, and counseling. The District agreed to conduct an assistive technology assessment. APE was not recommended because STUDENT’s gross-motor skills were found to be within age expectancy and she had met the secondary PE requirement by completing four semesters of ROTC. STUDENT, her grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, Ms. Whiteleather, and Mr. Russell attended the IEP meeting. The team was in agreement with the IEP to the extent that eligibility as mild mental retardation (MMR) had been determined and goals and objectives developed. It was also agreed that the IEP team would reconvene on September 23, 2002. In the meantime, STUDENT was to visit the Alton School, a nonpublic school proposed as a placement, and complete a career transition interview.
Neither STUDENT nor her mother or grandmother appeared at the IEP meeting on September 23, 2002. Mr. Russell was present. There was some confusion regarding rescheduling the meeting. Three dates were proposed. On October 1, 2002, the last of the three proposed dates, the District reconvened the IEP meeting. No one appeared on behalf of STUDENT.(footnote 2) The District completed the IEP, offering to place STUDENT at Alton with the services of counseling, transportation, and ESY. The District undertook a transition services assessment of STUDENT on October 7, 2002. As of the last day of hearing, the parties had not rescheduled the IEP meeting to discuss the assessment and to develop a transition plan. On multiple occasions, the parties attempted without success to settle this matter. The Petitioner seeks compensatory services for multiple years because the District failed to provide her with a FAPE. The District maintains that it has provided Petitioner a FAPE in the past and currently has offered her a FAPE.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the Los Angeles Unified School District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP)(footnote 3). 20 U.S.C. § 1418. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. One of the rights afforded to parents is the right to be provided a formal written offer of placement by the school district. Union v. Smith, 157 F.3d. 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); cert.denied 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union noted that one of the reasons for a formal written offer is to provide parents the opportunity to decide whether the offer of placement is appropriate and whether or not to accept the offer.
Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F.3d 877.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide her with a FAPE from the 1997-1998 school year to the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school years. Petitioner makes several assertions regarding procedural violations including that the District failed to convene IEP meetings and review goals and objectives annually. Petitioner asserts that substantively the District failed to provide her with a FAPE by failing to address her unique and individual needs including deficits in central auditory processing. Petitioner asserts that since 1999, she has experienced social and emotional difficulties that the District has failed to identify and address. Petitioner asserts that the District did not develop a transition plan or provide her with the practical skills she needs to be an independent adult. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that as a result of the District’s failure to address her areas of need, she has failed to progress educationally. The District contends that it offered Petitioner a FAPE during the entire period of time. The District asserts that Petitioner has demonstrated slow but steady progress in academic areas.
Petitioner’s allegations related to each specific school year will be addressed individually below by analyzing (a) whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and (b) whether the IEP and resulting placement were designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP according to the standards set forth in the IDEA and Rowley.
1997-1998 School Year
The IEP guiding STUDENT’s special education services and placement for the 1997-1998 school year is found in Petitioner’s Exhibit N. The IEP is dated June 25, 1997. There was scant testimony regarding the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT did not make progress during the school year. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT was misidentified as learning disabled and, therefore, was provided a program that was not properly designed to meet her needs. Victoria McKendall, administrator for due process, testified that the goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to confer educational benefit on STUDENT. Neither Dr. Patterson nor Ms. McKendall knew STUDENT at the time in question and neither participated in the development of the IEP. Without resolving whether STUDENT was misidentified as learning disabled, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of MOTHER and Dr. Patterson regarding the lack of an appropriate education for the 1997-1998 school year is supported by the IEP and other documentary evidence.
The IEP dated June 25, 1997, did not include all of the necessary components. California Education Code section 56345(a) provides, in pertinent part that the following must be included in a proper IEP:
(1) The present levels of the student’s educational performance. . . . (2) The measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following: (A) Meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. (B) Meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability . . . . . .
Cal. Educ. § 56345(a)(1) and(2)
Statements on the IEP regarding STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance were vague or nonexistent. The IEP generally notes concerns related to STUDENT’s lack of motivation, poor focusing skills, and aggressive behavior. STUDENT was described as “very social” but it was noted that she “could become very aggressive if expectations were not met.” However, it is difficult, if not impossible, to identify STUDENT’s then-present levels of academic performance. The IEP describes STUDENT’s academic skills as “weak” without further explanation. The IEP does not state at what level STUDENT was performing in mathematics, reading, or written language. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s academic achievement was measured and taken into account when developing the IEP. The lack of specificity regarding STUDENT’s level of academic achievement does not satisfy the requirements of an appropriate IEP set forth above
The failure to identify STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance resulted in the IEP team’s drafting deficient goals and objectives. First, spelling, reading, math, and prevocational objectives in the June 1997 IEP are virtually identical to the goals and objectives in the previous IEP developed in early May 1996 by the Bellflower District. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit O.) It should be noted that the Bellflower IEP was implemented by the Los Angeles District during the 1996-1997 school year. It is unclear whether the District copied the goals and objectives from the prior IEP because STUDENT simply did not make any progress during the entire 1996-1997 school year or because the IEP team lacked the necessary information to develop appropriate goals and objectives because there had been no objective measurement of STUDENT’s educational functioning and no recitation on the IEP of her then-present levels of academic performance. In either case, the District had an obligation to develop goals and objectives to address her needs. If STUDENT had not made any progress during the 1996-1997 school year toward meeting the goals and objectives, the June 1997 IEP team needed to modify the goals and objectives or identify reasons for the lack of progress on the goals and objectives. One way to monitor STUDENT’s progress or lack thereof would have been to periodically evaluate her progress toward meeting objectives. Unfortunately, spaces next to objectives for designating dates by which STUDENT was expected to achieve the objectives are blank. Another objective that was carried over from the prior school year was to improve school attendance. Again, since the objective remained identical, the IEP team should have identified ways to address the problem. It did not and STUDENT missed approximately 27 days of school during the spring semester of the 1997-1998 school year.
Second, the exact same comments regarding STUDENT’s lack of motivation, poor focusing skills, and aggressive behavior are contained in the previous IEP from May of 1996. Despite the problems persisting for more than one year, no goals or objectives were added to the June 1997 IEP to address these areas.
Finally, the IEP is deficient because it does not include a statement of STUDENT’s transition service needs. California Education Code section 56345.1(a) provides that beginning at age 14. The IEP must include a statement of the transition service needs of the student.
Absent present levels of performance and means to address ongoing poor academic achievement, the District failed to develop an IEP that was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Moreover, the grades STUDENT earned during the 1997-1998 school year reflect her lack of educational benefit. STUDENT’s school transcript indicates that she received one “B,” four “C’s,” and one “F” for the first semester of the ninth grade. However, after transferring to Narbonne for the second semester, STUDENT received two “D’s” and four “F’s.” During summer school, STUDENT received one “D” and one “F.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit G; Respondent’s Exhibit 5) STUDENT did not earn sufficient credits to advance to the tenth grade.
To summarize, the discussion above establishes that substantive deficiencies in STUDENT’s IEP resulted in the denial of a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year.
1998-1999 School Year
STUDENT’s IEP for the 1998-1999 school year was developed on June 10, 1998. (Petitioner’s Exhibit H) The IEP includes present levels of performance derived from the triennial assessment completed by the District in June 1998. As measured by the KTEA, STUDENT’s reading decoding skills fell at the 2.7 grade level. Reading comprehension fell at the 3.5 grade level. In written language, STUDENT was performing at the 3.3 grade level. In math, STUDENT obtained grade equivalent scores of 2.7 in math application, and 2.9 in math computation. STUDENT then was four months shy of her sixteenth birthday. The report concludes that STUDENT required intensive instruction in all academic areas due to her functioning significantly below age and grade levels. Information obtained from STUDENT’s teachers during the assessment process described STUDENT as “easily distracted.” English and math teachers noted that she often appeared “confused, angry, indifferent and tired. She is very easily frustrated and hot tempered.” Another note described STUDENT as “tired and sad.” From the assessment it is concluded that STUDENT required specific instruction to increase academic skills in reading, written language, and mathematics. Because concerns regarding distractability persisted, she required teachers to employ methods to maintain her attention. Additionally, concerns regarding her emotional status continued to be noted by teachers. Further consideration of STUDENT’s emotional status was warranted.
The IEP includes goals and objectives to address reading, written language, and math deficits. The IEP also includes a vocational goal. The reading goal calls for STUDENT to demonstrate literal comprehension skills using core literature, with objectives regarding identifying main ideas and specific details in a paragraph story. The written language goal was to develop practical writing skills. Objectives were related to writing a three-sentence paragraph and a business letter. The math goal called for STUDENT to solve practical living problems involving time, simple computation, calculator, measurement and money by working on objectives to solve word problems and commit to memory basic multiplication facts. The vocational goal called for STUDENT to complete assigned work and improve attendance. A transition plan indicates that STUDENT’s goal was to attend community college to study child psychology. The IEP documents that the team recommended an assessment by the school psychologist for possible counseling. Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT was placed in an SDC with mainstreaming in one elective, lunch, nutrition, and assemblies.
The evidence establishes that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year. Ms. McKendall’s testimony and the documentary evidence establish that the IEP includes goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s deficits in reading, written language, and mathematics. The IEP also includes a transition plan that was developed following a career assessment by a District transition specialist. Ms. McKendall’s testimony that the SDC placement offered STUDENT individual instruction at her developmental level with a low teacher-to-student ratio was uncontradicted. As to assertions that an SDC was inappropriate because of allegations that STUDENT was misidentified as learning disabled, Ms. McKendall, a school psychologist with many years’ experience assessing students, testified that the assessment results showed STUDENT functioning in the low average range. Additionally, STUDENT had language and social skills commensurate with her age. Ms. McKendall further testified persuasively that the results of the District’s testing in June 1998 did not reveal anything that would have changed the eligibility criteria of learning disability given to STUDENT by the prior district. Moreover, Dr. Patterson testified that the improper assumption that STUDENT had low average cognitive functioning resulted in the District’s failure to provide her with functional life skills instruction such as budgeting, cooking, and making change. A review of the IEP indicates that at least some of the goals and objectives involve “practical” life skills such as time, money, and use of a calculator. Additionally, Ms. McKendall testified persuasively that the instruction in the SDC was based on the individual IEP.
The IEP and placement also were designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The IEP includes specific goals and objectives to address deficits in reading, written language, and mathematics. The instruction in a classroom with a low student-to-teacher ratio addressed STUDENT’s specific deficits. Although STUDENT’s grades continued to include some failing grades, she did demonstrate improvement by passing a majority of her classes. STUDENT’s grades for the fall semester of the 1998-1999 school year included three “C’s,” two “D’s,” and one “F.” For the spring semester, STUDENT earned one “C,” three “D’s,” and two “F’s.” (The prior school year, STUDENT failed five classes during the regular school year.) (Respondent’s Exhibit 5) Additionally, the IEP drafted at the end of the school year indicates that STUDENT’s grade-level equivalencies in academic areas had improved. The IEP states that STUDENT was at the third-grade level in mathematics, between the third- and fourth-grade levels in language arts, and at the fourth-grade level in spelling.
In summary, the District’s assessment identified specific areas of deficit which were addressed by the IEP goals and objectives, and placement in an SDC, and she derived educational benefit from the program provided to her. Other than general allegations that STUDENT’s growth since entering the District was less than expected, she presented no evidence to the contrary. Hence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year.
1999-2000 School Year
As noted above, the IEP for the 1999-2000 school year included information regarding STUDENT’s then-present levels of academic performance. The IEP notes that STUDENT got along well with peers and teachers but at times she did not take constructive criticism very well. The IEP also indicates that STUDENT had not passed any proficiencies and had completed 32 units toward graduation. (Petitioner’s Exhibit F) To address ongoing deficits in academic areas, the IEP includes one goal each in the areas of arithmetic, reading, and written language. The arithmetic goal was to “improve math computation by one or more grade levels” with objectives related to adding and subtracting common fractions and completing multiplication problems with two-digit multipliers. The reading goal was to improve decoding and comprehension skills by one or more grade levels with objectives of reading from a teacher-given list of 100 words with 85% accuracy and answering comprehension questions in core subject areas with 80% accuracy. The written language goal called for STUDENT to “demonstrate an improvement in written language skills.” The objectives called for STUDENT to correctly punctuate 7 out of 10 sentences and correct a paragraph by adding punctuation and capitalization. To address STUDENT’s needs, the IEP states that she required instruction in a small-group setting, extended time on tests, and use of a calculator on formal math tests.
The IEP called for STUDENT’s placement in an SDC with mainstreaming in music and art, as well as in regular school functions, such as lunch and nutrition. She was also entitled to ESY. Ms. McKendall’s testimony regarding the number of students in the SDC, the low student-to-teacher ratio, and the individual and small-group instruction available to STUDENT in the SDC was undisputed. It was undisputed that STUDENT continued to exhibit academic deficits and that she required individual and small-group instruction because of attentional problems. The Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives contained in the IEP were designed to address the academic areas in which STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits. Additionally, the evidence establishes that the modifications and small-group instruction in the SDC program were designed to address STUDENT’s attentional deficits and academic needs.
Petitioner’s primary concern regarding the appropriateness of the District’s placement was related to STUDENT’s need to begin learning practical living skills to allow her to become an independent adult. It should be noted that STUDENT was 16 years old when the IEP was drafted. Education Code section 56345.1 describes the transition services that are required when a student is 16 years old. “Transition services” is a coordinated set of activities that promotes movement from school to post school activities and is based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s references and interests. As to the steps taken to prepare STUDENT for post school activity, Brenda McKindra, transition resource teacher, testified that she administered the Career and Occupational Profile Survey (COPS II) to STUDENT. Ms. McKindra testified that the COPS II is an in-depth questionnaire that helps to identify the student’s interests. Once STUDENT’s interests were identified on the COPS II, Ms. McKindra drafted goals and objectives and prepared a transition plan. Both were incorporated into the IEP. The IEP goals and objectives are related to identifying STUDENT’s occupational needs and aptitudes, and helping her make realistic occupational choices. The transition plan identifies “long-range plans” for STUDENT to earn a high school diploma and/or a letter of recommendation with the support of her family and teachers. STUDENT’s IEP called for participation in the Career and Transition Services (CATS) program. Ms. McKindra testified that STUDENT did not always make herself available for these sessions. However, Ms. McKindra stated that during the course of the school year, she “tracked down” STUDENT and met with her on several occasions to provide guidance to her developing vocational interests and knowledge of the skills necessary to obtain employment in areas of interest. Specifically, Ms. McKindra testified that during the school year, she discussed STUDENT’s goals with her, shared information with STUDENT regarding specific occupations, and discussed with her the application process for vocational rehabilitation.
While Dr. Patterson testified generally that the emphasis of STUDENT’s educational program should have shifted to a more functional, life-skills curriculum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program sufficiently provided STUDENT with a general floor of opportunity required by Rowley and the IDEA. The District offered STUDENT an opportunity to continue developing academic skills while beginning to explore vocational areas. In part, the Hearing Officer relies on Ms. McKendall’s testimony and also on Ms. McKindra’s testimony, which persuasively established that the District’s vocational program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as a 16-year-old student.
As to whether the IEP was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, the evidence establishes that STUDENT would receive instruction in her areas of deficit in an SDC where she would receive individual attention and small-group instruction. The initial vocational program also was designed to challenge her to identify realistic career options considering her interests and abilities. Moreover, STUDENT experienced relative success, as demonstrated by the grades she earned, during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. STUDENT received four “C’s,” one “D,” and one “F.” The “F” was in geometry. (Respondent’s Exhibit 5)
In conclusion, the program and placement offered by the March 1999 IEP were sufficiently designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to provide her with educational benefit. Accordingly, the District’s offer for the 1999-2000 school year constituted a FAPE.
2000-2001 School Year
The District did not convene an IEP meeting at the end of the 1999-2000 school year to review STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives and to determine services and placement for the 2000-2001 school year. The District also did not convene an IEP meeting at any time prior to the commencement of or during the 2000-2001 school year. At some point after her eighteenth birthday, STUDENT stopped attending school. The District did not raise legal arguments that it ceased to have responsibility for STUDENT’s education after she stopped attending school. Moreover, it was never disputed that she is entitled to services to age 22. Even if the District had raised this argument, STUDENT was attending school at the end of the prior school year when the District was required to develop her annual IEP. STUDENT also attended school during the summer and was attending school at the beginning of the school year. Moreover, a due process hearing was pending. The District was not relieved of its obligation to offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. It failed to do so. Additionally, since the last assessment of STUDENT had occurred in June of 1998, a triennial assessment would have been due no later than June 2001. No assessment plan was proposed nor did an assessment take place. Because an annual IEP was required, no further discussion is necessary and it is concluded that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
2001-2002 School Year
The District stipulated that it did not convene an IEP meeting regarding STUDENT after March 1999. In January 2002, the parties agreed to provide a period of remedial services to STUDENT at the LBLP and to undergo an assessment. The District did not convene an IEP meeting until July 2002. Thus, there were no goals and objectives or offer of services or placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The District did not raise any argument at the hearing that it was not responsible for offering STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. Because of its failure to do so, the Hearing Officer concludes that it failed in its obligation to offer a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
2002-2003 School Year
Petitioner’s concerns regarding the 2002-2003 school are as follows. First, Petitioner asserts that the District committed procedural errors by improperly convening the IEP meeting on October 1, 2002. Second, Petitioner asserts that her receipt of agreed-to mental health services has been delayed by the District. Finally, Petitioner asserts that the District’s offer of placement at Alton, a nonpublic school, is not appropriate.
Dr. Patterson’s assessment of STUDENT in July 2002 provides insight into STUDENT’s current needs. Petitioner’s Exhibit AA contains the report of Dr. Patterson’s assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Patterson testified at length regarding his assessment. He found that STUDENT has below average cognitive functioning and that she was performing significantly below average in reading and mathematics. Dr. Patterson also concluded that STUDENT was depressed and anxious. Dr. Patterson recommended that the focus of STUDENT’s education be on the development of functional skills with less emphasis on academic skills. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Patterson’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s contemporary educational needs credible. The same finding of credibility also applies to his program/placement recommendations for the current school year. Dr. Patterson was the only witness that undertook a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Patterson is a licensed educational psychologist in private practice. He has held a number of different positions with school districts. He has been a teacher, psychologist, and SELPA director. Districts and parents alike rely on Dr. Patterson’s opinions in due process hearings.
The Hearing Officer turns to Petitioner’s allegations regarding procedural violations by the District. Petitioner asserts that the District convened the IEP meeting without providing notice of the meeting to STUDENT or to her grandmother whom she authorized to make educational decisions on her behalf. California Education Code section 56341.5(b) provides that parents shall be notified of the IEP meeting “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend.” Subsections (c) and (e) further provide that the notice must include the purpose, time, and location of the meeting, identify who will be in attendance, and the name of any other local agency invited to attend. Federal law contains similar provisions. When only Mr. Russell appeared at the IEP meeting on September 23, 2002, the District and Mr. Russell agreed that the IEP meeting would be rescheduled, and three dates were proposed. Apparently there was no response to Ms. Jackowski’s attempt to confirm a date for the IEP team to reconvene on one of the three dates prior to the hearing scheduled for October 2, 2002. After the first two dates passed, the District convened the meeting without sending a notice or otherwise informing STUDENT, her representatives, or her family of the time and date for the meeting. There is no evidence that the District specifically noticed the IEP meeting held on October 1, 2002
Special education law also provides that before a meeting is conducted without a parent, the district must make telephone calls, correspond, visit the parent at home or work, and use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f) and (g). The District failed to provide written notice of the specific time and date of the IEP meeting. Since STUDENT’s mother is employed by the District, the District could have undertaken steps to ensure her participation once it was clear that no one appeared on behalf of STUDENT at the meeting. The Hearing Officer concludes that the failure to provide adequate notice was a procedural flaw and resulted in the lack of participation by STUDENT or her representatives in determining an appropriate placement. Additionally, Dr. Patterson testified that it is highly important to involve STUDENT in the decision-making process. The failure to properly notice her of the IEP deprived her of the right to do so. The Hearing Officer concludes that the lack of notice has resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. Ultimately, rather than reach a mutually agreeable determination regarding STUDENT’s placement that could have been implemented without delay, STUDENT’s receipt of services and placement have been delayed until resolution of this hearing. For the reasons discussed more fully below, there presently is no satisfactory offer of placement and it will be necessary for the IEP to reconvene to make such a determination. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the procedural error by the District has resulted in the denial of a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer next turns to the substantive appropriateness of the IEP and placement offer. The IEP team members, including STUDENT, STUDENT’s grandmother, Ms. Whiteleather, Christopher Russell, and Dr. Patterson, drafted an IEP on August 8, 2002, taking into account Dr. Patterson’s findings and recommendations. The goals and objectives, which are not in dispute, address STUDENT’s need to develop practical life skills in reading, mathematics, and written language. For example, reading goals include being able to identify food items in a specific recipe, to read instructions or directions on utility items, and to identify safety signs, symbols, and production expiration dates. The math goals are related to planning a budget and following a recipe. The written language goal is related to completing job applications. The IEP also includes goals and objectives to develop general knowledge, including using a telephone and public transportation, safety awareness, counseling, and vocational skills. (Respondent’s Exhibit 30)
Dr. Patterson concluded that a primary need for STUDENT is to participate in a program that will address her emotional needs, develop her functional skills, and allow her to match her skills with realistic occupation opportunities. Dr. Patterson also concluded that STUDENT needs community-based instruction that includes mobility training to use public transportation so that she will be able to independently travel around the city and access stores and other services within the community. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT has expressed her desire to work and earn money. Dr. Patterson suggested that, at this point, it is very important to take STUDENT’s interests and motivation into consideration in designing a program for her. In any case, he suggested that STUDENT participate for approximately two hours daily in a community-based program and in a workability or similar work experience training program. STUDENT also expressed that she has no desire to return to an academic educational program. Shelia C. Jordan Jones, transition coordinator, also testified regarding STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Jones undertook an assessment regarding transition planning with STUDENT on October 7, 2002. Ms. Jones found that STUDENT was able to dress and groom herself, make purchases, and travel with assistance of family and friends. Ms. Jones recommended that STUDENT needs vocational training supporting her interests in child care, creative arts, music, or shopping. Ms. Jones also noted the importance of linking STUDENT to agencies serving adults such as Vocational Rehabilitation and the Regional Center.
Petitioner contends that the District has failed to provide necessary mental health services to her, thereby failing to provide services in conformity with the IEP. The District offered to provide mental health services to STUDENT. Ms. Talesnick’s testimony, which is supported by a letter dated January 22, 2002, establishes that the District offered mental health services to STUDENT at the rate of one hour per week. The letter identifies three agencies that were under contract with the District and available to provide services. None of the agencies were contacted by STUDENT, her mother or her grandmother to initiate services. (Respondent’s Exhibit 38) Additionally, the District completed a referral to LACMH. However, LACMH did not receive a signed consent form from STUDENT, her mother or grandmother, that would allow them to proceed with an assessment. Petitioner incorrectly asserts that the District delayed the referral process because it did not forward a Durable Power of Attorney authorizing either MOTHER or GRANDMOTHER to make educational decisions regarding STUDENT. It was not the District’s delayed sharing of the Durable Power of Attorney with LACMH that foiled LACMH’s taking action to assess and provide services to Petitioner. Rather, LACMH must receive specific consent to its assessment plan before it can take any action to assess Petitioner. Despite sending letters to STUDENT and her family, no one signed and returned the plan to Mental Health. STUDENT continues to need mental health services but the delay to her receipt of services was not the result of inappropriate action on the District’s part.
As to the District’s offer of placement, Ms. Talesnick testified that Alton serves students with specific learning disabilities, mild mental retardation, and Asperger’s. The average class size is 12 and each class has a teacher and an aide. Ms. Talesnick stated that there are approximately 15 female students at this time. Ms. Talesnick has visited the school and described it as a “nice nurturing environment.” According to Ms. Talesnick, Alton offers academic and vocational training. For example, students can participate in a vocational program at Cerritos Community College while enrolled in Alton. Alton also has a Head Start site on location. Ms. Talesnick testified that the District offered to place STUDENT at Alton because it believes that Alton offers her an appropriate placement and will be able to meet her needs for vocational training.
The testimony of Kristina Drucker, codirector of Alton, establishes otherwise. First, Ms. Drucker testified that Alton does not currently accept students with mild mental retardation. The students accepted by Alton generally are on track to receive a high school diploma. Ms. Drucker also testified that Alton does not really have a functional skills program and that, while the school offers some social skills and independent skills training and could address STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives, she stated her belief that a person with a second- to third-grade reading level would not succeed in the program. Ms. Drucker testified that the program at Alton would not meet the needs of a student such as STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Drucker’s testimony persuasive. Ms. Drucker is intimately familiar with the program at Alton and the services it provides. Moreover, she would be in a position to gain economically by STUDENT’s enrolling in Alton but chose to testify contrary to this interest.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals, objectives, and counseling services offered by the District are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and offer her educational benefit, while its offer of placement is not. Dr. Patterson’s testimony was persuasive and not disputed as to the type of program and placement that STUDENT requires. Therefore, because the offer to place STUDENT at Alton is not appropriate, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District must devise a program and identify a placement that will provide STUDENT with instruction in functional reading, mathematics, and writing skills, that offers her a community-based program to teach her skills such as mobility skills, and that provides her with vocational skills training that will prepare her to transition to work. Additionally, STUDENT needs to participate in a program that will offer her actual work experience.
ISSUE NO. 2: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
A special education student may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)
It has been determined above that the District has denied Petitioner FAPE during portions of the period at issue in this hearing. The sole remedies sought by Petitioner for the denial of FAPE are (a) participation in a work program with appropriate support from the District such as training and a one-to-one job coach, (b) individual mental health services one or two times weekly, and (c) transportation. Petitioner’s counsel asserted that STUDENT should be entitled to services beyond age 22 years. However, no one testified that compensatory services beyond age 22 years is warranted or would be beneficial to STUDENT. In fact, Dr. Patterson testified that additional services beyond age 22 years could foster dependence and prevent STUDENT’s obtaining services from other agencies providing services to adults, such as the Department of Vocational Rehabilitation.
Dr. Patterson and District transition personnel testified that once STUDENT has completed job training, community-based instruction and practical life skills instruction to address contemporary goals and objectives, STUDENT would benefit from the vocational services available through the Regional Center and Department of Vocational Rehabilitation. Without determining the ability of services or the responsibility of other agencies to provide STUDENT with vocational opportunities, the fact remains that the District presently has responsibility to provide STUDENT with a program to address her current IEP goals and objectives and cannot be relieved of its responsibilities simply because another agency also offers services.
However, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory services for the District’s failure to provide FAPE. Petitioner did not call any witnesses to specifically testify regarding the compensatory services she seeks. Thus, it is difficult to determine an appropriate compensatory remedy. It has been concluded above that the District must identify a program to provide STUDENT with job training. To the extent that the current IEP does not call for a one-to-one job coach, the Hearing Officer concludes that a one-to-one job coach shall be provided by the District for the remainder of this school year to help STUDENT succeed in her work experience program.
STUDENT presently is entitled to counseling services. There was no testimony regarding the need for additional counseling or that STUDENT would benefit from additional compensatory counseling services. Therefore, the request for compensatory mental health services is denied.
Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT requires mobility training to be able to access the community. Because of poor mobility skills, STUDENT will require transportation to participate in the services and placement the District is required to provide. The IEP calls for STUDENT to receive transportation between home and school. STUDENT will also require transportation to counseling and work. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that transportation is an appropriate compensatory remedy.
The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner originally requested intensive remedial reading instruction as a compensatory remedy. The District provided STUDENT with LBLP services as part of an earlier agreement. The testimony of Dr. Patterson was undisputed that STUDENT would not benefit from further intensive reading instruction from LBLP or another agency. To the extent that Petitioner may be seeking further intensive reading instruction, the request is denied.
ORDER
(1) Within 10 calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall ensure that an appointment is made with an appropriately qualified mental health professional and that STUDENT is provided transportation to and from each appointment during the remainder of this school year, including the extended school year.
(2) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting. (a) The District shall provide written notice of the IEP meeting at least five calendar days in advance of the meeting to allow for the participation of STUDENT and her mother and/or her grandmother. (b) The District shall provide for Dr. Patterson’s participation in the IEP meeting and shall also ensure that one of the District’s transition specialists attends the meeting.
(3) The IEP team shall identify a placement that meets Dr. Patterson’s recommendations. The team shall consider STUDENT’s interests and motivation to participate in an educational program. The placement must provide instruction in functional skills, offer opportunities for STUDENT to explore occupations and match her skills and interests with occupations, provide community-based instruction such as mobility training, and provide specific job training and actual work experience.
(4) The IEP team shall amend the current IEP to include (a) roundtrip transportation to counseling services and job training locations, and (b) provision of a one-to-one job coach.
(5) All of Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the District offer Petitioner STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?
Petitioner prevailed as to four of the school years. The District prevailed as to two of the school years.
(2) If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
Petitioner prevailed only as to her entitlement to compensatory educational services of roundtrip transportation to counseling and a job site and a one-to-one job coach.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: December 18, 2002 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. It is undisputed that STUDENT remains eligible for services from the District. 2. There is a dispute regarding whether the District appropriately noticed the IEP meeting. 3. The 1997 reauthorization of the IDEA also calls for school districts to provide special education students with reasonable access to the general education curriculum and instruction and related services designed to prepare the students for employment and independent living.
