California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 31, 1997
Student v. San Bruno Park Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 150-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
San Bruno Park Elementary must reimburse up to 25 weekly hours of in-home behavioral therapy and private speech therapy; IEE claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None. The decision refers to a related earlier SEHO decision, San Bruno Park Elementary School District v. STUDENT, SN 949-95 (March 12, 1996), which led to Dr. Freeman's assessment.
Summary
The parents of a five-year-old girl filed for hearing in February 1995. She was eligible for special education with pervasive developmental disorder (autistic-like behaviors). The case covered the 1994-95 through 1996-97 school years. The District, through the San Mateo County Office of Education, offered a preschool special day class at Loma Chica taught by Linda Bohnert, plus 40 minutes a week of speech therapy. The parents wanted a one-to-one aide. They paid for intensive in-home behavioral therapy, eventually 40 hours a week through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD).
The Hearing Officer found that Loma Chica, with its low student-teacher ratio, was an appropriate classroom. But all three years of offers left out needed services: more one-to-one intervention, enough speech therapy, collaborative occupational therapy and a full-year program. By fall 1996 she also needed a classroom aide during a transition period. Relying mainly on Dr. Bryna Siegel, the Hearing Officer capped therapy reimbursement at 25 hours a week. From February to August 1995, when the Regional Center funded 20 hours, the cap was five hours. The District must also repay private speech therapy from February 1995 to January 1997. The Hearing Officer denied the requests for IEE reimbursement and sensory integration therapy. The amended IEP must add a CARD classroom aide, up to 25 hours of CARD home therapy, 60 weekly minutes of speech therapy, a 12-month program and a plan to fade the aide and therapy.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to an early in-home behavioral (Lovaas-style) program. The District's classroom was found appropriate, but the offer still failed because related services were missing. Reimbursement was limited to the hours the evidence showed she needed, not all the hours the parents paid for, and was reduced for therapy the Regional Center funded.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Has the District properly evaluated STUDENT and offered appropriate IEPs, placement and services for the 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 terms, including extended school year services and programs?
The Loma Chica class was an appropriate classroom, but the offers for all three years lacked needed one-to-one intervention, enough speech therapy, collaborative OT and a full-year program, and from fall 1996 a transitional classroom aide, so they were not appropriate under Rowley.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Have the private services, including behavioral intervention programs, parent training and home and community components, provided by STUDENT's parents been appropriate for the 1994-95, 1995-96 and 1996-97 terms, including extended year periods, justifying reimbursement?
Private one-to-one therapy and speech therapy gave significant benefit; reimbursement was limited to 25 hours a week of therapy, not the 40 provided, and to 5 hours a week from February to August 1995 when the Regional Center funded 20 hours.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations provided by her parents?
The issue was not argued in closing. For a three-to-five-year-old, an assessment may rely on observation instead of standardized tests, and no evidence showed the District's assessment was inappropriate.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4A. Shall STUDENT's IEP include behavioral specialist services by CARD, including parent training, program supervision and design, and behavioral staff training?
CARD will provide the in-home therapy and the classroom aide, and a CARD representative will join the IEP team. The decision does not separately order parent training or staff training.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4B. Shall STUDENT's IEP include 1:1 behavioral trainer services up to 40 hours per week for training, team meetings, and intervention at home, school and in the community?
The IEP must include up to 25 hours a week (not 40) of CARD in-home therapy and a CARD one-to-one classroom aide. A transition plan must phase out both.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 4C. Shall STUDENT's IEP include close coordination between the school and home/community programs and all DIS providers?
The IEP must require teachers, therapists and other providers to coordinate closely to keep her program consistent.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4D. Shall STUDENT's IEP include individual occupational therapy of 60 minutes per week with an OT trained in sensory motor integration?
No significant evidence showed sensory integration would help. The IEP must instead include collaborative OT at a level the IEP team sets.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4E. Shall STUDENT's IEP include individual speech and language services at the current level of 60 minutes per week with Donna Dagenais as the provider?
The parties did not appear to dispute this, and the Hearing Officer ordered 60 minutes a week of speech therapy with Ms. Dagenais.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 4F. Shall services remain in place through all school breaks on a 12-month basis?
Because she needed consistency, the IEP must provide a 12-month program, with the IEP team setting alternative services when class is not in session.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4G. Shall STUDENT's IEP include transportation to school and service providers provided and/or reimbursed per parent and STUDENT's needs?
This was undisputed. The IEP must include transportation if the IEP team decides she needs it.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 4H. Shall STUDENT's IEP include daily data collection?
Given her disability and the intensive therapy, daily data collection is appropriate and must be in the IEP.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the order, the District must convene an IEP meeting that includes Dr. Bryna Siegel and a CARD representative, paid for by the District.
- Placement ordered. The IEP must place her in Ms. Bohnert's class at Loma Chica with a one-to-one aide provided by CARD.
- Order to provide or change services. The amended IEP must include up to 25 hours a week of one-to-one in-home behavioral therapy by CARD; close coordination among teachers, therapists and other providers; 60 minutes a week of speech therapy with Donna Dagenais; a full-year (12-month) program; transportation as needed; daily data collection; and collaborative OT at a level the IEP team sets.
- The IEP team must develop a transition plan covering how long she needs the one-to-one aide and how long one-to-one therapy will continue, with the goal of reducing therapy and increasing her success in the classroom.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days after receiving proof, the District must reimburse actual out-of-pocket costs for parent-provided one-to-one in-home behavioral therapy since November 1994. The cap is 25 hours a week, except February through August 1995, when the cap is 5 hours a week.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days after receiving proof, the District must reimburse the cost of speech and language services by Donna Dagenais from February 1995 through January 1997, when the District began paying for them.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56441.1; Education Code § 56441.11; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3043
People named in the decision
- Jane Lubin, Director of special education, San Bruno Park Elementary School District
- Kent Rezowalli, SELPA compliance coordinator, SELPA
- Linda Bohnert, Preschool special day class teacher (Loma Chica), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Carol Barraco, Education services manager, Early Childhood Program, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Lori Ryan, District witness (role not stated), Not stated
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, Expert witness for Student; independent evaluator; director of PDD Clinic, University of California, San Francisco
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, Assessor (ordered in SN 949-95) and expert witness for District, UCLA School of Medicine, Department of Psychiatry
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, Clinical director, private behavioral provider, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Carolynn Baker, Clinical supervisor, private behavioral provider, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Kaysi Whelan, Senior therapist, private behavioral provider, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Dr. Tristam Smith, Expert witness for Student, Washington State University; Northwest Young Autism Project
- Donna Dagenais, Private speech-language pathologist, Mid-Peninsula Speech and Language Clinic
- Ms. Partain, Private one-to-one behavioral therapist, Not stated
- Dr. Ivy Fischer, Pediatrician who made the initial diagnosis, Kaiser
- Merri Besden, Administrator, Poplar Center
- Dr. G. Patrick Farrell, Staff psychologist, Golden Gate Regional Center
- Holly Love, Private occupational therapy evaluator, Not stated
- Jane Swank, Occupational therapist (evaluator), Not stated; described as District occupational therapist
- Judith Racely, Occupational therapist (evaluator), Not stated; described as District occupational therapist
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 150-95 Case Year: 1995 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 41-69013 District: San Bruno Park Elementary Disability Type: Autism
Case Details This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redwood City, California, on April 22-25, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Kathryn Dobel. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent San Bruno Park Elementary School District (District) was represented by Lillian Lee Port, chief deputy county counsel. Also present on the District's behalf were Dr. Jane Lubin, director of special education for the District, and Kent Rezowalli, SELPA compliance coordinator.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner: Jane Lubin, MOTHER, FATHER, Dr. Bryna Siegel, Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, Kaysi Whelan, Carolyn Baker, Donna Dagenais, and Dr. Tristam Smith.
The following were called by the District: Jane Lubin, Linda Bohnert, Lori Ryan, Dr. B.J. Freeman, and Carol Barraco.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received on June 3, 1997, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Has the District properly evaluated STUDENT and offered appropriate Individualized Education Programs, placement and services for the 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 terms, including the extended school year services and programs?
(2) Have the private services, including behavioral intervention programs, parent training and home community components, provided by STUDENT's parents been appropriate to meet her needs for the 1994-95, 1995-96 and 1996-97 terms, including the extended year time periods, justifying reimbursement for costs associated with those services?
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations provided by her parents?
(4) Shall STUDENT's IEP be amended to include the following services and program specifications?
(A) Behavioral specialist services by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), including parent training, program supervision and design, and behavioral staff training. (B) 1:1 behavioral trainer services up to 40 hours per week for training, team meetings, and intervention at home, school and in the community.
(C) Close coordination between the school and home/community programs and all designated instructional service providers.
(D) Individual occupational therapy services of 60 minutes per week with an occupational therapist trained in sensory motor integration.
(E) Individual speech and language services to remain at the current level of 60 minutes per week with Donna Dagenais as the provider.
(F) Services to remain in place through all school breaks on a 12-month basis. (G) Transportation to school and service providers provided and/or reimbursed per parent and STUDENT's needs.
(H) Daily data collection.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is five years old and eligible for special education as a result of a pervasive development disorder (PDD), or autistic-like behaviors. STUDENT was first diagnosed with PDD by Dr. Ivy Fischer when she was approximately two-and-a-half years old. STUDENT is currently receiving approximately 40 hours per week of intensive one-on-one therapy with the Center for Autism Related Disorders (CARD).
Autism is defined as a learning disability in the social and language areas. An individual with autism lacks the ability to process social information, such as facial expressions and tone of voice, and has a limited ability to learn from peer interaction or social praise. There is no significant difference between a child diagnosed with PDD and a child diagnosed with autism, although a child diagnosed with PDD may not have as many symptoms or symptoms that are as severe as a child diagnosed with autism. (Testimony of Dr. Bryna Siegel)
When STUDENT was two and a half years old, she was referred to Donna Dagenais for speech and language services, and began receiving services through the Golden Gate Regional Center (Regional Center). The Regional Center found STUDENT eligible for services due to PDD. Ms. Dagenais evaluated STUDENT in April 1994 and began providing speech and language services in August 1994. Ms. Dagenais' services were paid for by the MOTHER and FATHER. Ms. Dagenais worked with STUDENT three times in August 1994. Based on her evaluation and work with STUDENT, Ms. Dagenais recommended that STUDENT's education take place in a program with a high teacher-to-student ratio and that it be structured and consist of carefully sequenced developmental tasks. Ms. Dagenais also recommended that STUDENT continue with one-to-one, hand-over-hand intervention and individual speech and language therapy with goals relating to language comprehension, imitation skills, expressive language skills, and pragmatic communication skills (Footnote 1). (Exhibit P-26)
In May 1994, the Regional Center developed an Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP) which placed STUDENT two days per week in the Poplar Center beginning in June 1994. The Poplar program included one hour of one-to-one work with the teacher each week. By the time STUDENT left Poplar, she was able to sit in circle time without tantruming or needing a "restraint chair." However, she had not learned appropriate toy play or socialization skills. (Testimony of MOTHER) STUDENT vocalizations and eye contact increased while she was with Ms. Partain.
On September 23, 1994, Merri Besden, administrator with the Poplar Center, prepared a letter regarding STUDENT's educational needs. (Exhibit P-12) Ms. Besden noted that, although STUDENT had made some progress in her ability to sit during circle time and attend during play activities, she still required an adult to be with her at all times. Ms. Besden also noted that STUDENT had begun receiving one-to-one behavioral therapy at home at her parents' expense. Ms Besden stated that it was important for STUDENT to continue receiving as much one-to-one behavioral therapy as possible.
In October 1994, Poplar prepared a Closing Update regarding STUDENT. (Exhibit P-13) The report noted progress STUDENT had made, including improved eye contact and ability to sit and attend. Poplar recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in activities with small groups of peers and participate in group and individual sessions focusing on attending skills, following directions, and imitation skills.
In October 1994, the Regional Center conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. (Exhibit P-14) Dr. G. Patrick Farrell, the staff psychologist who conducted the evaluation, recommended that STUDENT continue receiving one-to-one therapy with Ms. Partain.
The District's first IEP meeting for STUDENT was held on September 14, 1994. At that time, the District referred STUDENT to the San Mateo County Office of Education (COE) because of STUDENT's PDD diagnosis and because the District did not have a program of its own that would meet STUDENT's needs. The COE operates the Early Childhood Education Center, an infant education program. The COE conducted the assessment of STUDENT and developed her placement.
On November 10, 1994, STUDENT's IEP tem met and recommended placement in a preschool special day class for four hours per day and transportation to and from STUDENT's school. The IEP team proposed goals addressing social adaptation skills, including following class routines, appropriate play, eye contact, and circle activities; communication skills; cognitive skills; and self-help skills. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT's parents visit several different placement options and that the IEP team reconvene on November 28, 1994.
The IEP team reconvened on December 16, 1994. At that time, the IEP team recommended placement in a noncategorical special day class and STUDENT's parents requested a one-to-one instructional aide. The IEP states that STUDENT's need for a one-to-one aide would be addresses at STUDENT's next IEP meeting to be held no later than February 17, 1995. The IEP team also recommended that speech and language assessment be completed.
In January 1995, STUDENT enrolled in Linda Bohnert's class at Loma Chica, a class operated as part of the COE's Early Childhood Education Center. Instead of attending five days per week as proposed by the IEP team, STUDENT attended Ms. Bohnert's class two days per week so that she could continue with her one-to-one therapy with Ms. Partain. STUDENT was not provided with one-to-one aide in Ms. Bohnert's class.
On January 4, 1995, Dr. Fisher, STUDENT's pediatrician at Kaiser, prepared a letter recommending that STUDENT have a one-to-one aide in her classroom environment to maintain a consistent behavioral approach. (Exhibit P-19)
On January 27, 1995, Ms. Partain prepared a report of STUDENT's progress in her one-to-one therapy. (Exhibit P-24) Ms. Partain's report states that STUDENT was responding well to the one-to-one intervention and had made progress in following directions, using signs, fine motor skills, following the routines of therapy, and handling transitions from work to play. Ms. Partain noted that STUDENT continued to exhibit a great deal of self-stimulatory behavior that was difficult to reduce or eliminate. Ms. Partain recommended that STUDENT continue receiving a minimum of 20 hours per week of one-to-one therapy.
On February 14, 1995, Dr. Farrell prepared a letter in support of continued one-to-one therapy for STUDENT. (Exhibit P-15) Dr. Farrell stated that he was "extremely impressed" with STUDENT's progress in her program and recommended that the District implement similar therapy in the school. On February14, 1995, the Regional Center also convened an Individual Program Plan (IPP) meeting at which the Regional Center agreed to fund approximately 20 hours per week of one-to-one therapy supervised by Ms. Partain through August 1995. (Exhibits P-14 & P-17)
STUDENT's IEP team met again on February 14, 1995, to review the speech and language assessment and STUDENT's parents' request for one-to-one aide. The IEP team recommended individual speech and language services for 40 minutes per week and did not agree that STUDENT required a one-to-one aide. The IEP team also developed goals relating to receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language, STUDENT's parents added a comment to the IEP that they did not agree with the IEP team's decision that STUDENT did not need a one-to-one aide. Following the IEP meeting, STUDENT's parents removed her from the Loma Chica program and from speech and language services provided by the District.
Following STUDENT's removal from Loma Chica, her parents returned her to Ms. Dagenais for speech and language therapy, which she started in March 1995. Ms. Dagenais provided therapy once a week for forty minutes per session. In June 1995, Ms. Dagenais prepared a progress report. (Exhibit P-28) Ms. Dagenais reported that STUDENT had "made significant gains in all area, yet she continues to show serious deficits in the area of communication and behavior." Ms. Dagenais also stated that STUDENT appeared to have a significant oral-motor apraxia and that a non-oral communication approach for STUDENT would be appropriate. Ms. Dagenais made recommendations similar to those made in Fall 1994.
In October 1995, STUDENT ended therapy with Partain and began receiving 40 hours per week of one- to-one therapy through CARD. She has remained with CARD since and has continued receiving 40 hours per week.
On December 1, 1996, STUDENT was evaluated at her parents' request by Dr. Bryna Siegel. Dr. Siegel diagnosed STUDENT with autistic disorder and mild mental retardation. (Exhibit P-59) Dr. Siegel recommended in her evaluation that STUDENT's one-to-one therapy be reduced to 20-25 hours per week. Dr. Siegel also recommended that STUDENT attend an integrated preschool for 15 hours per week and that her participation in the class should start with two mornings per week and then be gradually increased. After six months, STUDENT's educational program should be assessed to determine whether she still needed the one-to-one therapy, or if she could benefit more from full-time school. Dr. Siegel also recommended that STUDENT's class have a low student-teacher ratio of two-to-one, and noted that if the ratio is that low, a one-to-one aide would not be critical.
An occupational therapy evaluation was conducted by Holly Love in April and May1996 at the request of STUDENT's parents. Ms. Love recommended that STUDENT receive clinic and home-based occupational therapy "to treat sensory defensiveness and to address [her] need for extra proprioceptive and oral input." Ms. Love also recommended that occupational therapy consultation be provided for the home behavioral program to address fine motor and visual-motor delays.
Pursuant to a decision of the Hearing Office, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. B.J. Freeman, Department of Psychiatry, University of California Los Angeles, School of Medicine, on April 16, 1996, and May
31, 1996 (Footnote 2). (Exhibit P-60) Dr. Freeman concluded that STUDENT had behaviors and skills consistent with a diagnosis of autism. Dr. Freeman recommended that STUDENT be placed in a highly structured school setting with low student-teacher ratio of three-to-one or four-to-one. Dr. Freeman stated that STUDENT had appropriate attending skills for a classroom, but she had become very adult and prompt dependent. Dr. Freeman recommended that STUDENT's education program focus on functional skills and generalizing those skills into other environments, and include mainstreaming and structured social interactions. STUDENT should also receive speech and language therapy 2-3 times per week. The therapy should focus on alternative modes of communication. Dr. Freeman also recommended an occupational therapy evaluation because of some fine motor difficulties. Finally, Dr. Freeman recommended that STUDENT receive some one-to-one teaching, but no more than one hour per day focusing on academic tasks and appropriate play with another child. The emphasis of STUDENT's entire program should be on the development of functional social/communication skills.
On July 15, 1996, CARD prepared an Inventory of Development which catalogued STUDENT's skill levels at that time in gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, speech and language skills, general knowledge and comprehension, math, and social and emotional development. (Exhibit P-30) Other than in gross motor skills and some general knowledge skills, STUDENT was delayed or significantly delayed in all areas. Based on STUDENT's skill levels, CARD implemented numerous long-term goals and short-term objectives to address STUDENT's areas of need. Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, the clinical director who prepared the report, recommended that STUDENT continue to receive 35 hours per week of one-to-one behavior modification therapy.
During Fall 1996, STUDENT's parent enrolled her in Early Years, a private preschool program. She was removed after approximately 1 ½ to 2 months because of the time it was taking away from her one- to-one home program. While STUDENT was at Early Years, she was accompanied by a one-to-one aide provided by CARD.
On September 12, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team convened to review her present levels of performance and to develop goals and objectives. At that time, STUDENT's parents requested occupational therapy, speech and language services, a 35-hour-per-week in-home behavioral program, and a 5-6 hour mainstream preschool program with a one-to-one aide. The IEP team incorporated goals and objectives proposed by CARD and STUDENT's parents, and offered placement at Loma Chica, speech and language services for 40 minutes per week, extended school year, and transportation. In addition, the IEP team recommended an occupational therapy assessment.
On October 13, 1996, STUDENT was evaluated by occupational therapists Jane Swank and Judith Racely. (Exhibit P-61) They concluded that motor skills were a relative strength for STUDENT and that collaborative occupational therapy services would be appropriate for her. Collaborative occupational therapy would involve demonstration of techniques, activities, and positioning to enhance development of fine motor skills.
On October 31, 1997, the District began providing speech and language through Donna Dagenais after STUDENT's mother interviewed the speech and language therapists proposed by the District and determined that none had experience with children similar to STUDENT.
On March 3, 1997, Kaysi Whelan, one of STUDENT's CARD therapists, prepared a progress report to show how STUDENT had progressed on the goals listed in STUDENT's IEP from September 12, 1996. (Exhibit P-35) STUDENT had met or made significant progress on all of the instructional objectives, other than a few goals which had been put on hold while preliminary skills were being mastered.
On March 3, 1997, Ms. Dagenais also prepared a report relating to STUDENT's speech and language progress. (Exhibit P-36) Ms Dagenais noted in her report that STUDENT had shown communication gains with the introduction of more nonverbal communication systems. Ms. Dagenais recommended that STUDENT be enrolled in a full-time special education class with a non-oral communication system in place and interaction with peers encouraged by staff. Ms. Dagenais also recommended that STUDENT have a one-to-one aide assignment to her in class at least until she adjusted to the classroom routine. Finally, Ms. Dagenais recommended that STUDENT continue with her home program and speech and language therapy focusing on the non-oral communication system and use of speech.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
Jane Lubin (Footnote 3)
Jane Lubin, in her role as the director of special education for the District, first became involved in STUDENT's case in November 1994, when she attended an IEP meeting held on November 10, 1994. Ms. Lubin testified that the IEP team proposed placement in a preschool special day class for autistic or autistic-like children with extended school year services in the same class and transportation. The IEP team proposed that STUDENT attend the class five days per week for four hours each day. STUDENT's extended school year services would consist of twenty additional days of instruction after the regular school year ended. The IEP team incorporated goals and objectives that had been developed by Ms. Partain. Ms. Lubin also testified that Ms. Bohnert advised the IEP team in February 1995 that STUDENT had made progress in her class. According to Ms. Lubin, Ms. Partain, Ms. Dagenais, and the Poplar staff recommended Ms. Bohnert's class at Loma Chica for
STUDENT.
MOTHER
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified extensively regarding STUDENT's medical and educational history, much of which is summarized in the Background Facts section. MOTHER testified that, although she was given a copy of the Parents' Rights at the September 1994 IEP meeting, she was not aware that she could ask for services to those provided by Ms. Partain.
MOTHER attended the assessment conducted by the COE. MOTHER testified that COE staff just observed STUDENT and did not interact with her or try to assess STUDENT's skills. MOTHER also testified that she did not tell the District or COE about Ms. Partain's services because she did not think the services were relevant and she wanted the COE to use its own information and come to an unbiased opinion.
MOTHER testified that she observed five programs before enrolling STUDENT at Loma Chica. MOTHER testified that Loma Chica and First Gardens were the two programs in which she was the most interested. MOTHER decided that Fiesta Gardens was not appropriate and that she was pleased with the teacher, Ms. Bohnert, in the Loma Chica program. MOTHER testified that she discussed STUDENT with Ms. Bohnert and Ms. Bohnert indicated that she knew of Ms. Partain and was willing to work with her. MOTHER testified that Ms. Partain had recommended that STUDENT enroll in Loma Chica program two days per week in conjunction with her own services. MOTHER testified that she told Ms. Bohnert that she was very concerned about STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior and that, since self- stimulatory behavior was not allowed in STUDENT's home program, it was important for consistency that it also not be allowed in school.
According to MOTHER, STUDENT began to regress in her home program after she enrolled in Ms. Bohnert's class. The regression included increased tantruming and self-stimulatory behavior. MOTHER attributed the regression to inconsistency at school. MOTHER testified that Ms. Bohnert told her that she could not remove everything that STUDENT was interested in and self-stimmed with because it would not be fair to other kids who wanted to play with toys. MOTHER testified that she did not realize she could ask for a one-to-one aide to work with STUDENT in Ms. Bohnert's class until she observed another student in the class with an aide. According to MOTHER, she waited until the next IEP meeting in February 1995 to request a one-to-one aide and, at that time, was told that an aide was not needed or appropriate for STUDENT.
MOTHER testified that she removed STUDENT from Ms. Bohnert's class because of the regression in her home program and the District's refusal to assign a one-to-one aide. MOTHER also indicated that Ms. Partain agreed that STUDENT should be removed from the class. Following the removal from Ms. Bohnert's class, STUDENT continued with Ms. Partain and received speech and language therapy from Ms. Dagenais starting in March 1995. Ms. Dagenais' services were paid for by the FAMILY.
At some point during summer 1995, STUDENT increased her time with Ms. Partain to 30-36 hours per week. MOTHER testified that, with the increase, STUDENT's eye contact and social skills increased dramatically. MOTHER testified that she requested additional hours from Ms. Partain, but Ms. Partain could not accommodate her request. Therefore, MOTHER looked into other programs and enrolled STUDENT in a program with the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) in October 1995. The CARD program consisted of 40 hours per week of therapy. The CARD program includes parent training every other week. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has progressed with the CARD program, including increased communication and language skills, independence, generalization skills, and sight reading.
MOTHER testified that she visited several communicatively handicapped classes in 1996, including Fox Ridge and Crestmoor. She testified that Crestmoor was inappropriate because the children were too high functioning for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that she asked to have STUDENT placed at Fox Ridge with a one-to-one aide but her request was rejected because the site was closing. MOTHER testified that she also observed Loma Chica again and observed that the class was smaller, more organized, and the teaching style was the TEACCH method. However, she still did not believe that
Loam Chica was appropriate because all of the students were autistic and STUDENT would not have appropriate modeling. MOTHER would need a one-to-one aide in the classroom and continue with the CARD program at home.
MOTHER testified that the TEACCH method utilizes an icon-based method of teaching, including schedule boards. MOTHER testified, however, that Ms. Bohnert's class was not using icons or schedule boards when STUDENT was enrolled in January 1995.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT learns skills through discreet trial. MOTHER described discreet trial as giving a command and praise for appropriate responses, with the skills repeated again until STUDENT learns the skill. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not learn skills in a group environment, although she may acquire skills in such an environment.
Regarding occupational therapy, MOTHER testified that the District only offered consultative occupational therapy, and did not propose it in conjunction with STUDENT's CARD program. MOTHER testified that STUDENT requires direct occupational therapy which incorporates sensory integration to help reduce self-stimulatory behavior. MOTHER testified that she discussed sensory integration with the District's occupational therapists and learned that they did not believe in sensory integration.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT is currently receiving speech and language therapy twice a week for 30 minutes per session from Ms. Dagenais, which the District has paid for since January1997, and 40 hours of CARD therapy paid for by the FAMILY. MOTHER testified that she wants STUDENT to enroll at Loma Chica with a one-to-one aide provided by CARD, and gradually work up to 15 hours per week at Loma Chica. She also wants STUDENT to continue with her home program provided by CARD for 25 hours per week, receive sensory integration occupational therapy, and continue speech and language therapy with Ms. Dagenais.
FATHER
FATHER, STUDENT's father, provided testimony similar to that of MOTHER. FATHER testified that he is not asking for reimbursement for expenses from November 1994 through January17, 1995.
FATHER testified that he spends approximately 1 to 1 ½ hours each afternoon alone with STUDENT. He tries to do things with her to keep her down-time to a minimum. FATHER testified that STUDENT can sort laundry, help load and unload the dishwasher, and is interested in cooking. FATHER testified that, prior to the CARD therapy, STUDENT did not do anything constructive or interact the way she does now. STUDENT is now more interested in her environment.
FATHER testified that he thought Loma Chica would be a good placement with one-to-one aide and that Ms. Bohnert is an excellent teacher.
Carolynn Baker
Carolynn Baker is a clinical supervisor with CARD. Her duties as clinical supervisor include program supervision, therapist training, parent training, and attending IEPs. Ms. Baker's training and education were through the Lovaas program at University of California, Los Angeles. Ms. Baker has been with CARD since August 1994.
Ms. Baker first met STUDENT in December 1996. Ms. Baker testified that STUDENT was very hyperactive, distractible, and impulsive. Ms. Baker described STUDENT as a visual learner who needs visual cues to learn. Ms. Baker attends the clinic meetings with STUDENT and her parents every two weeks. Ms. Baker testified that she is available to help with any questions or problems STUDENT's therapists or parents may have.
Ms. Baker testified that the most significant change for STUDENT since December 1996 is the reading program that CARD instituted for her recently. Ms. Baker described the reading program as a picture-to-word and word-to-picture matching program designed to increase her receptive and expressive language. With the reading program, STUDENT will eventually be able to use visual cues, such as pictures, to communicate. Ms. Baker testified that the communication system reduces STUDENT's frustration and distractibility, and increases her eye contact. Ms Baker testified that CARD is working on STUDENT's sight reading and will soon start on her comprehension skills. Ms. Baker testified that the reading program could not take place in a classroom because it is very intensive. CARD will also start working on STUDENT's fine motor skills to allow her to write or circle responses rather than pointing at responses.
Ms. Baker testified that, although STUDENT's attending skills are improving, she still needs a one- to-on environment because of her distractibility. Ms. Baker also recommended a group setting to help STUDENT learn to generalize her skills, to learn socialization skills, and to learn to follow directions from somebody other than a one-to-one aide. According to Ms. Baker, STUDENT would need a one-to-one aide in a group-based program to help facilitate interaction between her and the teacher. Ms. Baker testified that STUDENT would require a transition period in which "authority" is transferred to the teacher so she would not be dependent on the aide. Ms. Baker testified regarding one child in Ms. Bohnert's class which has had a CARD aide assigned to him. She indicated that recently the child's IEP team decided to remove the aide because Ms. Bohnert was doing a good job with the class and controlling the child. Ms. Baker indicated that the transition period for that child was six months. Specifically regarding STUDENT, Ms. Baker recommended a trial period of three to six months, followed by an IEP meeting to determine if she is performing independently of the aide and taking direction from the teacher. Ms. Baker testified that if STUDENT were placed in a classroom, she would still need home and community-based behavior modification.
Ms. Baker recommended that STUDENT should start immediately with 15 hours in school with a one-to- one aide and 25 hours of home-based instruction. Ms. Baker testified that a classroom student- teacher ratio of 2:1 or 3:1 would not be low enough. Ms. Baker testified that STUDENT would benefit from such a ratio but not as much as with a one-to-one aide. STUDENT's home-based instruction should include the reading program, and teach STUDENT to use picture icons to communicate her needs.
Kaysi Whelan
Kaysi Whelan is STUDENT's senior therapist. Her responsibilities include training and supervision of STUDENT's other CARD therapists. Ms Whelan also participates in STUDENT's IEPs. She first met STUDENT in September or October 1995. At the time, STUDENT was very hyperactive, with a lot of self-stimulatory behavior. STUDENT also had very few intelligible verbal utterances, but had good matching and imitation skills. Ms. Whelan testified that she developed a behavioral intervention plan to reduce STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior and increase her focus and attention. Ms. Whelan currently works with STUDENT for 15 hours per week.
Ms. Whelan testified that from September 1995 to December 1996, STUDENT made progress in the following areas:
(1) Attention -- STUDENT could maintain eye contact for up to 15 seconds, sit in a chair for a longer period of time and attend to adult-directed activities. When she first started with STUDENT, her ability to sit and attend was very short and by December 1996, STUDENT could sit and attend for 5-15 minutes.
(2) Verbalizations (3) Fine motor -- improved coloring and pincer grasp.
(4) Toilet trained and could put on pants and shirt.
Ms. Whelan testified STUDENT had demonstrated a strength in recognizing sight words and her program was modified alternative visual means for STUDENT to learn. The CARD therapists also started in December 1996 to emphasize a visual-nonverbal communication system for STUDENT. Since then, STUDENT has made dramatic gains in labeling and her ability to communicate her needs. Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT is now able to willingly attend for up to 45 minutes, her self-help skills have improved, and her "behaviors" have been cut down. STUDENT has also rapidly acquired labels for objects receptively and expressively and, as of March 1997, had mastered 28 sight words
Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT learns by having skills broken down into the smallest components possible. For example, teaching STUDENT to wash her face involves teaching her the separate skills of getting the wash cloth, turning on the faucet, wetting the cloth, wringing the cloth out, wetting her face, and adding soap to the wash cloth. Ms. Whelan testified that the CARD therapists have worked with STUDENT on washing her face for three weeks and she has mastered all of the skills except for adding soap to the wash cloth.
Ms. Whelan was the aide who went to Early Years with STUDENT. STUDENT attended Early Years two days per week for 1 to 1 ½ hours per day. Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT was very interested in the other children and participated in circle activities. However, STUDENT could not have participated without a one-to-one aide as well as she did because of her distractibility and self- stimulatory behavior.
Ms. Whelan also observed several of the COE's programs with STUDENT's parents, including Loma
Chica. Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT would be easily distracted at Loma Chica because there are too many materials readily available and it would be difficult to have her stay in a designated area. According to Ms. Whelan, the Loma Chica classroom had study carrels for the students to work on projects. Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT would not be able to stay and work independently in the carrels. Ms. Whelan testified that STUDENT would need a one-to-one aide, modified goals and objectives, reduced distractions, and a schedule board to be able to benefit from an educational placement at Loma Chica. Ms. Whelan also indicated that the one-to-one drills that the CARD therapists work on with STUDENT could not be transferred to the classroom with other students because of the distractions caused by the other students. Ms. Whelan stated that she would be willing to work as STUDENT's one-to-one aide at Loma Chica if she were placed there.
Ms. Whelan agrees with Dr. Siegel that STUDENT should begin attending preschool to help her learn appropriate socialization and communication skills.
Dr. Bryna Siegel
Dr. Bryna Siegel is an associate professor of psychiatry and director of the Pervasive Development Disorder (PDD) Clinic at University of California, San Francisco. Dr. Siegel has assessed approximately 1800 children with pervasive development disorders. Dr. Siegel testified that she conducted a research study of the effectiveness of intensive one-to-one programs for children with PDD. Dr. Siegel testified that children who are in intensive programs have statistically higher IQS than comparable children who are only in group-based educational programs. However, Dr. Siegel also testified that there is statistically no difference between a child who is in an intensive program for 25 hours per week and a child who is in an intensive program for 35 hours per week. Dr. Siegel testified her research revealed that approximately 8% of children who receive intensive therapy improve to the point that they no longer meet the diagnostic criteria for autism.
Dr. Siegel testified that the perseveration that autistic children engage in results in their not being exposed to new things. Autistic children do not explore their environment as much as regular children, and, therefore, learn less. Some of the developmental delays that autistic children have can be attributed to their lack of exploration and learning. Dr. Siegel testified that autistic children need to be forced to engage in new activities and experiences.
Dr. Siegel first met STUDENT in March 1996. At that time, Dr. Siegel conducted a developmental history, developmental testing, and behavioral observations. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT's early language loss is typical of autistic children, but that language can be reacquired. Dr. Siegel testified that a child's ability to reacquire language is independent of the education or therapy used with the child. If a child has the capacity to reacquire language, intensive therapy will increase the reacquisition. Dr. Siegel testified that if an autistic child does not reacquire language skills within 18 months, the child will probably not reacquire language. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT will likely remain nonverbal and will need to learn other modes of communication, such as a picture form of communication.
Based on her evaluation, Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT does have autism. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT continue the CARD program for 25 hours per week and that she should start using a communication board, or picture exchange system, that will encourage her to use pictures to communicate. Dr. Siegel testified that 40 hours per week of CARD is unnecessary for STUDENT. Dr. Siegel testified that too much intensive therapy could cause aggressiveness. In addition to 25 hours per week of CARD, STUDENT should be in a group-based program to fill her down-time, to generalize the skills learned in CARD, to learn the structure of group activities, and to be exposed to peers. Dr. Siegel also testified that STUDENT will need a transition period into the group setting because of her prompt dependence and the high amount of one-to-one intervention she has had. The transition period should include a one-to-one aide and a highly structured program to be reviewed after two to three months. Following the review, if appropriate, the aide should be gradually withdrawn and, after six to nine months, STUDENT should be able to function without a one- to-one aide in a classroom with a student-teacher ratio of two-to-one or three-to-one.
Dr. Siegel reviewed Dr. Freeman's evaluation and testified that Dr. Freeman's results and recommendations are similar to her own. The primary difference, according to Dr. Siegel, is that Dr. Freeman did not recommend as much one-to-one teaching school as Dr. Siegel.
Dr. Siegel observed the Loma Chica program in February 1997 and testified that it was "TEACCH- influenced," and incorporates a picture schedule. Dr. Siegel testified that the TEACCH method takes advantage of an autistic child's need for routine and visual stimuli to develop a highly structured environment. Dr. Siegel testified that there should be no problem with a student who is taught through the Lovaas method at home and the TEACCH method at school as long as there is consistency between the two. Dr. Siegel testified that the picture schedule used in the Loma Chica program was not the fully implemented picture exchange communication system she would like to see STUDENT use. Dr. Siegel described the picture exchange communication system as a visually-based system in which the child gives objects, photos of objects, or drawings of objects to adults to indicate what her or she wants. Eventually, a child is able to use the system to construct sentences. Dr. Siegel testified that the Loma Chica program would be appropriate if a one-to-one aide were assigned to STUDENT for a transition period and a picture exchange communication system were fully implemented. Dr. Siegel also recommended that if STUDENT enrolls at Loma Chica, she should transition down to 10- 15 hours of CARD therapy per week.
Dr. Siegel also recommended a full-year program for STUDENT because of the benefit she would receive from the continued structure of an educational program. Dr. Siegel testified that breaks in the routine can be difficult for autistic children and create problems when trying to reestablish the child's routines. Regarding occupational therapy, Dr. Siegel testified that there is no research showing that sensory integration provides any benefit to autistic children and she does not recommend sensory integration for autistic children. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT's teachers should have periodic consultation with an occupational therapist every couple of weeks. Finally, Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT's school program work on functional skills and fine motor skills.
Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh
Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh is the clinical director of CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, at the time STUDENT started with CARD in October 1995, she had very little language skills and was very active. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, based on STUDENT's lack of language, she needed a communication system because her lack of ability to communicate would lead to increased aggression and frustration. Dr. Granpeesheh sees STUDENT once a month at a meeting held at the CARD clinic to review her progress.
According to Dr. Granpeesheh, STUDENT had started to "stagnate" by the end of 1996. STUDENT's program was reviewed and, in January 1997, a reading program was implemented to develop a visual communication system. In the past few months, STUDENT has done very well with the visual communication system. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that by March 1997, it was apparent that STUDENT has sight reading skills. Based on STUDENT's progress, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT should continue with one-to-one therapy to see how far she can progress with the reading program. If STUDENT progresses enough, she should be able to communicate effectively enough to be in a mainstream program without an aide.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT's hyperactivity and distractibility would interfere with her ability to learn in a group environment. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT learn skills related to her goals and objectives in a one-to-one environment and than maintain the skills in the group environment.
Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT's IEP from September 1996 should be implemented by continuing one-to-one therapy for 30 hours per week and placing STUDENT in a school environment for 6 to 10 hours per week. The one-to-one therapy should take place both at home and at school. STUDENT's time in classroom should then gradually increase while her one-to-one time decreases. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT will need CARD therapy for another 1 ½ to 2 years. STUDENT should have a one-to-one aide at school who acts more as a class aide and whose time is gradually reduced. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the transition period with the one-to-one aide could last as long as a year.
Donna Dagenais
Donna Dagenais is the clinical director of the Mid-Peninsula Speech and Language Clinic. Ms. Dagenais is not trained in discreet trial or the Lovaas method. Ms. Dagenais testified that she uses whatever methods work best for particular children. Ms. Dagenais started working with STUDENT in April 1994 and evaluated her on April 22, 1994. At that time, STUDENT was very active and not able to follow directions. Ms Dagenais testified that because of STUDENT's activity level, she needed one-to-one behavioral intervention before speech and language services could be productive. Once the intervention therapy started, there was a dramatic improvement in her behavior. Ms. Dagenais did not provide services from August 1994 to March 1995, but has provided services to STUDENT since March 1995. Since January 1997, Ms Dagenais has provided therapy twice a week for 30 minutes per session.
Ms. Dagenais testified that STUDENT has made slow progress, and unless she is in tightly controlled situations, her activity level cannot be controlled for her to learn. STUDENT's comprehension has improved and Ms. Dagenais has been able to loosen the structure of her work with STUDENT. STUDENT has also improved her ability to focus.
Ms. Dagenais testified that although STUDENT has used some signs and verbal responses, she has moved towards visual, non-oral communication system because her oral skills have not improved. Ms. Dagenais testified that STUDENT has severe oral-motor apraxia, which means that she cannot make her mouth do what she wants to produce sounds. Since January 1997, Ms. Dagenais has worked with STUDENT using more printed words and visual symbols.
STUDENT's current speech and language goals are to follow direction, extend her vocabulary to include adjectives, formulate sequences, expand the complexity of her sentence output, improve her gross motor skills, and improve her speech so that she can recognizably call for help. Ms. Dagenais testified that STUDENT is now ready to benefit from a group experience but she needs a lot of one- to-one assistance. Ms. Dagenais also indicated that STUDENT could benefit from the TEACCH program with a one-to-one aide. Ms. Dagenais testified that STUDENT continues to need one-to-one behavioral therapy of approximately 10 to 20 hours per week if she is in school. Ms. Dagenais testified that 40 hours per week of one-to-one therapy is too much.
Dr. Tristam Smith
Dr. Tristam Smith is an associate professor of psychology at Washington State University. He is also director of the Northwest Young Autism Project and the Multi-site Young Autism Project. Dr. Smith has never met STUDENT or observed Loma Chica. Dr. Smith testified that children who receive one-to-one therapy do better over time and require fewer services in the future. Dr. Smith testified that the work the CARD program was doing with STUDENT appeared appropriate and she was learning and making progress on imitation, communication, self-help, and independent play. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT would not have made progress in a school-based program without one-to- one assistance.
Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT start school with a one-to-one aide who can determine the skills she needs and then teach those skills to her. The aide can also help STUDENT generalize already learned skills into the classroom environment. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT would not acquire skills or achieve her goals and objectives at Loma Chica without a one-to-one aide. Dr. Smith suggested that STUDENT should start with four to six hours at school per week and then gradually increase her time in school as she progresses in the school program. The rest of STUDENT's day could be one-to-one work on the skills STUDENT needs in the classroom, such as communication skills, self-help skills, and play skills. Once STUDENT is full-time at the school, the aide could start to be faded out. The total number of hours, including school and one-to-one therapy, should be maintained at 35-40 hours per week.
District's Witnesses
Linda Bohnert
Linda Bohnert is employed by the COE and teaches the class at Loma Chica which STUDENT attended in January 1995 and which continues to be the proposed placement for her. Ms Bohnert testified that when her class was first offered to STUDENT, there were six children in the class with one teacher and two and a half aides. The students were there for four hours per day. The students were all autistic or PDD and ranged in age from three to four and a half. The students had opportunities to integrate with a preschool class and there was a behavioral modification program in the class. The behavioral modification program included positive reenforcement, redirection, and removal from dangerous situations. Ms. Bohnert testified that she had just started implementing the TEACCH method when STUDENT enrolled. She described the program as a visually predictable environment using photos and icons. The program also includes a predictable schedule and is highly structured.
Ms. Bohnert testified that her class is language-based and she used whatever language a child can use, including sign language and icons. The class also focuses on socialization and play. Ms. Bohnert testified that STUDENT's goals and objectives could have been implemented in the class and that STUDENT fit in well because all of the children in the class were learning school skills similar to STUDENT. Ms. Bohnert testified that she did not have any problems with STUDENT in the class and that she followed the class routine. Although she only had STUDENT for a short time, Ms. Bohnert believed that STUDENT would have benefitted educationally in her class because it is designed to help autistic children learn to adjust to the school environment and routine.
Regarding STUDENT's need for a one-to-one aide, Ms. Bohnert testified that STUDENT was able to transition into her class with the staff that was already in the classroom and that she did not need an aide for the transition or to stop self-stimulatory behavior.
Ms. Bohnert testified that if a student is involved in a home program, she visits the home and keeps in contact with the therapists to make sure she is working on and generalizing the same skills on which the therapists are working. According to Ms. Bohnert, TEACCH and the home program work well together.
Ms. Bohnert testified that since 1995, she has implemented some changes in her class, including providing each child with an individual work schedule at their work stations. Ms. Bohnert also indicated that new skills are taught to the children in one-to-one situations and, once mastered, are introduced to the classroom environment.
Ms. Bohnert testified that there were six students in her class during the 1995-96 school year, six students in September 1996 and seven students currently.
Jane Lubin
As noted above, Ms. Lubin is the director of special education for the District. Ms. Lubin testified that the Regional Center refers children to the District when they are two years, nine months old. At that time, the District reviews information regarding the child. If the District cannot serve the child because of the child's needs, the child is referred to the SELPA. STUDENT was referred because of her intensive needs.
Ms Lubin testified that extended school year could be for twenty to fifty days. Extended school year services were offered to STUDENT's parents, but the specific number of days was never discussed. Ms. Lubin testified that STUDENT's parents first requested a one-to-one aide at the IEP meeting on November 16, 1994. According to Ms. Lubin, the IEP team determined that Ms. Bohnert would be the one to recommend whether STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide since she was the teacher who would be working with STUDENT.
Ms. Lubin testified that Loma Chica met STUDENT's needs in January 1995 and continues to be an appropriate placement for her. Ms. Lubin testified that there was never any reason in January of February 1995 to believe that STUDENT was having problems at Loma Chica.
Dr. B.J. Freeman
Dr. B.J. Freeman works at the University of California, Los Angeles, and has assessed several thousand autistic children. Dr. Freeman testified that each autistic child learns differently but that the focus of an autistic child's educational program should be on social/communication skills. Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT's autism falls in the moderate range and that she has good skills but is significantly impaired in language and social interaction. Dr. Freeman observed STUDENT during CARD sessions and assessed completed.
Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT needs to be in a school environment with other children to learn social and communication skills, to generalize skills learned in one-to-one therapy, and to learn by watching other children. STUDENT also needs a significant amount of speech and language therapy.
Dr. Freeman has visited the Loma Chica program twice. She testified that it is an excellent program and that Ms. Bohnert is a motivational teacher. She described the class as being in the perfect setting because it is next door to a regular preschool and there are regular opportunities for the children in Ms. Bohnert's class to interact with children in the regular classroom. Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT would benefit from Ms. Bohnert's class even without a one-to-one aide. Dr. Freeman testified that she does not believe STUDENT should have an aide specifically assigned to her because she will become dependent on the aide She also indicated that Ms. Bohnert's class had a ratio of five kids to two and a half adults, which she described as a good ratio. According to Dr. Freeman, the TEACCH method utilized by Ms. Bohnert focuses on getting children independent and able to self-correct their own behavior. Dr. Freeman testified that all of the components of a good program are present at Loma Chica, including home visits and weekly contact between the teacher and parents.
Regarding STUDENT's CARD therapy, Dr. Freeman testified that 40 hours of one-to-one therapy is excessive and there is not evidence such an amount of therapy was or is needed. Dr. Freeman also testified that STUDENT should have more time with speech and language therapists than with behavioral therapists who are not trained in speech and language therapy. Dr. Freeman testified that autistic children need intensive programs, but they also need a variety of developmentally appropriate activities. According to Dr. Freeman, CARD therapy does not address STUDENT's primary needs in social and language areas. Dr. Freeman testified that continuing with one-to-one therapy would be detrimental to STUDENT. Dr. Freeman pointed to signs of increased aggression from STUDENT as evidence that she may be getting frustrated with one-to-one therapy.
Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT has the skills to participate in a classroom environment without a one-to-one aide. STUDENT's prognosis is dependent on the development of a communication system and independence for her. Dr. Freeman expressed concern regarding STUDENT's prompt dependence. Dr. Freeman suggested that STUDENT needs to be taught to observe and learn from her environment on her own rather than being directed by an adult. Dr. Freeman testified that an advantage of TEACCH is that it teaches children to initiate and control their own behavior.
Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT's teachers and therapists should not give up yet on her developing oral language skills. Dr. Freeman testified that since STUDENT has oral motor apraxia, her language skills are going to develop later than usual. Dr. Freeman suggested that STUDENT should learn a communication system using both visual and oral means. STUDENT's speech and language therapy should be provided two to three times per week and occur in different environments, such as classroom, community, and home. The therapy should also include another child so that STUDENT can practice communicating with another child.
Carol Barraco
Carol Barraco is the education services manager for the Early Childhood Program (ECP) operated by the COE. Ms. Barraco testified that the ECP has eleven classes for autistic children, all of which use the TEACCH method. Ms. Barraco testified that Loma Chica has had approximately a two-to-one student-teacher ratio since January 1995. Since STUDENT was removed from Loma Chica, the COE and District, the COE and District have continued to offer placement at Loma Chica for five days a week, four hours per day.
Ms. Barraco testified that STUDENT fit in well with the other children in the Loma Chica program and, although there for only a short time, benefitted from the program as evidenced by her progress in following the classroom routine. Ms. Barraco observed STUDENT in the class at least two times. She testified that STUDENT would have benefitted from continued placement at Loma Chica. Ms. Barraco testified that a one-to-one program is detrimental because it eliminates needed socialization from a child's program.
Ms. Barraco confirmed much of the testimony provided by Ms. Bohnert regarding the behavior modification program in her class and the fact that new tasks are taught one-to-one before being generalized into the classroom environment.
DISCUSSION
(1) Has the District properly evaluated STUDENT and offered appropriate Individualized Education Programs, placement and services for the 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 terms, including the extended school year services and programs?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); Education Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18). "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that the "basic floor of opportunity" provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. 458 U.S. 176, 200-201.
Pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley, and appropriate educational placement must include instruction and services that are individually designed to meet the unique needs of the student and provide educational benefit to the student. An appropriate placement must also conform to the student's
IEP.
STUDENT's unique needs
It is apparent that STUDENT is a child with significant needs. Upon STUDENT's completion of the Poplar program, the Poplar staff concluded that STUDENT had made progress in its group program and that she needed to continue to work in a group environment, along with continued one-to-one therapy. Similarly, the Regional Center, in a letter prepared by Dr. Farrell on February 14, 1995, recommended that STUDENT continue with one-to-one therapy both at home and at school.
The professionals who have worked with STUDENT over the years also provide fairly consistent testimony that STUDENT needs both classroom and therapeutic components in her education. Dr. Fischer, STUDENT's pediatrician who originally diagnosed STUDENT's PDD, recommended in January 1995 that STUDENT have a one-to-one aide in her classroom. Ms. Dagenais, STUDENT's speech and language therapist, has consistently recommended since 1994 that STUDENT be educated in a highly focused one- to-one or very small group environment. Ms. Dagenais has also recommended that STUDENT continue with intensive one-to-one intervention. In March 1997, Ms. Dagenais appeared to modify her recommendation slightly and to emphasize STUDENT's need for a classroom education. However, Ms. Dagenais continued to recommend that STUDENT receive one-to-one therapy at home and be assigned a one-to-one aide in the classroom.
Dr. Siegel, Petitioner's own witness, recommended in March 1996, and again in her testimony during the hearing, that STUDENT be placed in a preschool for 15 hours per week and receive a maximum of 20 -25 hours per week of CARD therapy. Dr. Siegel testified that her research shows that more than 20- 25 hours per week of one-to-one therapy does not produce improved results. With regard to the school setting, Dr. Siegel recommended an integrated preschool and, stated that as long as the class had a low student-teacher ratio of two-to-one or three-to-one, a one-to-one aide was not essential to STUDENT's success in the classroom except during a transitional period. Dr. Freeman recommended in May 1996 that STUDENT be placed in a highly structured school setting with a student-teacher ratio of three-to-one or four-to-one. Dr. Freeman also recommended that STUDENT only receive approximately one hour per day of one-to-one teaching. Finally, Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT receive 30 hours of one-to-one therapy per week and 6-10 hours of school with a one-to-one aide per week. Several witnesses also testified that STUDENT can only learn new skills through one- to-one therapy and that once she learns skills, she can then be taught to generalize those skills into other environments.
Of the experts who testified, the Hearing Officer places the greatest weight on the testimony of Dr. Siegel regarding STUDENT's needs and the appropriateness of the various programs proposed for the following reason. First, besides testifying on behalf of the Petitioner, evidence was presented by the parties that Dr. Siegel also consults the COE and District regarding early childhood education issues. Therefore, Dr. Siegel is not an expert who only works for or on behalf of the parents. Second, Dr. Siegel, although called by Petitioner, provided testimony that was not helpful to Petitioner in several areas. Third, Dr. Siegel does not appear to be tied to one methodology or educational program over another. On the other hand, Dr. Granpeesheh is the clinical director of CARD and her recommendations for STUDENT were consistent with what CARD provides, and Dr. Freeman directs her own clinic at UCLA and her recommendations were consistent with the type of program she provides. As for Dr. Smith, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Smith never met STUDENT, never observed her therapy or the District's programs, and based his opinion solely on a review of some of her records.
The evidence outlined above establishes that STUDENT required and continues to require an intensive educational program consisting of both a classroom competent with a one-to-one aide during a transition period and a one-to-one in-home therapeutic component. There was also evidence presented that STUDENT may need speech and language therapy. Several witnesses, including Ms. Dagenais and Dr. Freeman, recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy to address her language comprehension and skills, as well as alternative modes of communication. Based on that testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT also needed and continues to need speech and language therapy.
Petitioner also contends that STUDENT requires direct occupational therapy in the form of sensory integration. However, Petitioner did not provide any expert testimony or evidence that STUDENT would benefit from such therapy. On the other hand, Dr. Siegel testified that there is no research indicating that sensory integration provides any significant benefit to autistic children and the District's occupational therapists found that STUDENT's motor skills were an area of strength and, at most, that STUDENT needed collaborative occupational therapy only. Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs include collaborative occupational therapy to be provided both at school and at home.
Finally, Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires a full-year educational program because of the effect breaks in STUDENT's routine have on her ability to benefit from her education. The District does not dispute that STUDENT requires extended school year services and has offered such services. The dispute relates to Petitioner's request that her program be a 12-month program, with essentially no breaks in her education. The District contends that extended school year services may last for 20-50 days during the summer break, but that a specific extended school year program for STUDENT was never discussed because she was removed from the District's program (Footnote 4).
California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3043 provides that extended year services must be provided for each individual with exceptional needs who has unique needs and requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. The type and length of extended year services, as with any special education or related services, must be designed to meet the student's unique needs.
Section 3043(d) extended year services must be provided for a minimum of 20 instructional days. Subsection (1) provides that, for reimbursement purposes only, a maximum of 55 instructional days shall be allowed for individuals in special day classes or centers for the severely handicapped. Section 3043(e) provides the following:
a local governing board may increase the number of instructional days during the extended year period, but shall not claim revenue for average daily attendance generated beyond the maximum instructional days allowed in subsection (d)(1)...
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs include a highly structured classroom with a low student-teacher ratio and a one-to-one in-classroom aide during a transitional period, a one-to-one therapeutic component, speech and language therapy, collaborative occupational therapy, and a full-year educational program. Taking each of these components individually, the Hearing Officer makes the following findings regarding the District's placement for STUDENT for the school years in question.
1994-95 School Year
The District's placement in Ms. Bohnert's classroom at Loma Chica was designed to provide a highly structured environment with a low student-teacher ratio of two-to-one or three-to- one at all times, and frequently one-to-one. While Ms. Bohnert had not fully implemented the TEACCH program when STUDENT enrolled, the evidence establishes that Ms. Bohnert had implemented a program that was designed to meet STUDENT's needs in the classroom. Most significant is the low student- teacher ratio. Additionally, several factors support a finding that STUDENT did not require a one- to-one aide in Ms. Bohnert's class in January 1995. First, the low student-teacher ratio provided an appropriate level of support. Second, Ms. Bohnert provided credible testimony regarding STUDENT's performance in the class without one-to-one aide. The Hearing Officer places great weight on Ms. Bohnert's testimony because, as the classroom teacher, she was in the best position to determine whether STUDENT required a one-to-one aide in the classroom.
On the other hand, when STUDENT entered Loma Chica, the District did not provide the type of additional one-to-one in-home behavioral therapy STUDENT needed to acquire new skills. While Ms. Bohnert testified that she spent up to 30 minutes of one-to-one time with new students working on new skills, the evidence establishes that STUDENT required more than 30 minutes of one-to-one intervention per day. In addition, the District did not offer collaborative occupational therapy or a full-year educational program to meet STUDENT's needs. Finally, the evidence establishes that STUDENT required more than the 40 minutes per week of speech and language proposed by the District especially considering that the District did not offer any one-to-one therapy.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement in the Loma Chica program, while offering an appropriate classroom program, did not include all of the related services necessary to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement for the 1994095 school year was not appropriate pursuant to the standard developed by the IDEA and Rowley.
1995-96 School Year
There was no evidence presented that the District modified STUDENT's placement during the 1995-96 school year. Instead, the District continued to offer the same program as that offered in January 1995 -- placement in Loma Chica for four hours per day, five days a week, with speech and language services, transportation, and extended services that did not cover the entire calendar year. Based o the finding for the 1994-95 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement for STUDENT was also not appropriate because it was not designed to meet all of STUDENT's unique needs.
1996-97 School Year
State education law provides additional guidance in determining whether a placement for a preschool child, defined as a child 3-5 years, is appropriate. Education Code § 56441. One aspect of an early childhood education program is that, as the child approaches elementary school age, the focus of his or her education must be geared towards readiness for kindergarten and later school success. Education Code § 56441.1(b). In November 1996, STUDENT turned five years old. Presumable, the 1996-97 school year was, therefore, her final preschool year and the focus of her education should have shifted to specifically address readiness skills for kindergarten. It would seem then that STUDENT's classroom component would have assumed greater importance during the 1996- 97 school year.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bohnert's class at Loma Chica continued to provide STUDENT with an appropriate classroom environment, particularly with the increased TEACCH components, the picture communication system, and additional structure that had been added to the classroom since January 1995. Furthermore, the student-teacher ratio was still at a low enough ratio for STUDENT to benefit from the classroom program.
The problem is that by Fall 1996, STUDENT had been receiving intensive one-to-one therapy for 20-40 hours per week for two years and, based on the testimony of the expert witnesses, including Dr. Siegel and Dr. Freeman, had become prompt and adult dependent. Although Ms. Bohnert's class had a low student-teacher ratio, STUDENT, because of her intensive exposure to one-to-one behavioral therapy and the resulting dependence on prompts and adults, would have required a one-to-one aide at least during a transition period in Ms. Bohnert's class. The District, however, continued to refuse to provide such an aide. The District also did not propose collaborative therapy until several months into the school year and did not provide for STUDENT's speech and language therapy until January 1997, when the District started paying for STUDENT's therapy with Ms. Dagenais.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the Loma Chica class continued to be an appropriate classroom component for STUDENT to meet her needs, the District continued to fail to offer other educational services which STUDENT needed to benefit from her education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement was not appropriately designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs pursuant to the IDEA Rowley.
(2) Have the private services, including behavioral intervention programs, parent training and home and community components, provided by STUDENT's parents been appropriate to meet her needs for the 1994-95, 199596, and 1996-97 terms, including the extended year time periods, justifying reimbursement for costs associated with those services?
In 1985, the United States Supreme Court held that retroactive reimbursement is a remedy available to parents when a school district has failed to provide an appropriate placement and, as a result, the parents felt compelled to place their child in a private placement at their own expense. Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington , Massachusetts v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, EHLR 556:389 (1985). The Burlington Court was interpreting the meaning of 20 USC § 1415(e)(2) which states that "the court ... shall grant such relief as the court determines is appropriate." The Burlington Court further held that equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief.
As noted in Burlington, if there was not right to retroactive reimbursement, the right to a free appropriate public education, the right to fully participate in the IEP process, and all of the procedural safeguards contained in the IDEA would be less than complete. The reason for this is that parents would be left with two choices -- to keep their child in an inappropriate placement or to pay for an appropriate placement with no hope of reimbursement. Burlington, 556:389, 394. As the Burlington Court also notes, proceedings in special education hearings may take a significant amount of time. This case, considering that the request for hearing was filed on February 22, 1995, is a perfect example.
In the present case, the District has consistently proposed the same placement for STUDENT. That placement consists of five days per week, four hours per day in Ms. Bohnert's class at Loma Chica, extended year services (although the exact amount and nature were never determined), speech and language services, and, since fall 1996, collaborative occupational therapy. While the evidence establishes that Ms. Bohnert's class would have met STUDENT's needs in relation to the classroom environment, it is also apparent that the District did not offer appropriate related services that would allow STUDENT to benefit from her education. Many of the witnesses, including the experts and the individuals who have worked with STUDENT, testified that STUDENT needs to learn new skills in a one-to-one environment before she can generalize them in the classroom communities. Therefore, without a significant one-to-one component included in STUDENT's educational program, STUDENT would not have benefitted significantly from her placement in Ms. Bohnert's class.
The evidence also establishes that the one-to-one therapy from Ms. Partain and CARD has provided STUDENT with significant benefit. Every witness who has worked with STUDENT over the past few years testified that STUDENT has shown progress in her one-to-one therapy. More importantly, there is evidence that progress is also occurring in other areas. For example, FATHER testified that STUDENT now interacts positively with her family in many ways that she did not prior to the CARD therapy.
Based on the District's failure to provide an appropriate level of one-to-one assistance for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the private one-to-one therapy provided for her by her parents. However, based on the testimony of Dr. Siegel regarding the reduced effectiveness of one-to-one therapy in excess of 25 hours per week and the fact that the District did offer an appropriate classroom, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires 25 hours per week of one-to-one therapy rather than the 40 hours requested. Therefore, STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket expenses for a maximum of 25 hours per week of one-to-one behavioral therapy provided by her parents from the date of her third birthday to the present (Footnote 5). STUDENT is also entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language services that her parents provided to her from February 1995 until January 1997, when the District began paying for Ms. Dagenais' services.
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations provided by her parents?
Education Code § 56329(b) provides that parents have "the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil ... if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency." Generally, when a parent requests reimbursement for an independent assessment, an analysis of the appropriateness of the school district's assessment is performed. Although reimbursement for independent assessments was identified as an issue in Petitioner's original statement of issues, Petitioner made no argument in her closing brief regarding this issue. Furthermore, in Petitioner's conclusion in her closing brief, Petitioner does not request reimbursement for any independent evaluations. It appears that Petitioner's primary complaint is that, in November 1994, the District's evaluation did not include standardized testing and only consisted of an observation of STUDENT at the Poplar Center.
Education Code § 56441.11 provides that when "standardized tests are considered invalid for children between the ages of three and five years, alternative means, for example, scales, instruments, observations, and interviews shall be used as specified in the assessment plan." In other words, if a student is between the ages of three and five years, an assessment does not necessarily have to include standardized tests and can, instead, rely on other methods to determine the student's abilities and disabilities. In the present case, there is no evidence that the District's assessment was inappropriate. Therefore, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for independent evaluations is denied.
(4) Shall STUDENT's IEP be amended to include the following services and program specifications?
(A) Behavioral specialist services by CARD, including parent training, program supervision and design, and behavioral staff training.
(B) 1:1 behavioral trainer services up to 40 hours per week for training, team meetings, and intervention at home, school and in the community.
(C) Close coordination between the school and home/community programs and all DIS providers.
As noted above, state education law requires that educational programs for children who are approaching kindergarten age must focus on readiness for kindergarten and subsequent school years. Therefore, the emphasis of STUDENT's educational program must be on the classroom environment. Related services provided for STUDENT should complement her classroom program. The evidence establishes that STUDENT continues to require one-to-one therapy, but not for 40 hours per week. Rather, the evidence establishes that STUDENT requires placement in a school program with supplemental one-to-one therapy provided. The testimony of the experts, particularly Dr. Siegel, supports a finding that STUDENT should be enrolled in Ms. Bohnert's class and receive a maximum of 25 hours per week of one-to-one therapy. Based on STUDENT's success with the CARD program, it would be appropriate for CARD to continue providing the one-to-one therapy. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP should include one-to-one therapy, provided by CARD, for up to 25 hours per week at STUDENT's home..
The testimony of the experts also establishes that STUDENT requires a program that will ease her transition into the classroom and also eventually transition her out of the one-to-one therapy. The experts were in agreement that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide in her classroom program at least during the transition period. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP should be amended to include the provision of a one-to-one aide provided by CARD for STUDENT in her classroom program. STUDENT's IEP team shall also develop a transition plan designed for the gradual phaseout of STUDENT's one-to-one in-classroom aide and the one-to-one in-home therapy that will, among other things, address the length of time STUDENT should have the one-to-one aide, and the duration of STUDENT's one-to-one therapy. STUDENT's IEP team shall include a representative from CARD and the District shall contract with Dr. Siegel to provide input regarding STUDENT's educational program. Finally, STUDENT's IEP should include a requirement that her teachers, therapists, and other service providers work closely to ensure consistency in her program. The IEP team should consider requiring regular meetings between the professionals working with STUDENT.
(D) Individual occupational therapy services of 60 minutes per week with an OT trained in sensory motor integration.
Based on the testimony of Dr. Siegel and the lack of any significant evidence that sensory motor integration would help STUDENT benefit from her education, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP need not include individual occupational therapy for 60 minutes per week with an occupational therapist trained in sensory motor integration. Rather, STUDENT's IEP shall include collaborative occupational therapy at a level determined by her IEP team to be appropriate.
(E) Individual speech and language services to remain at the current level of 60 minutes per week with Donna Dagenais as the provider.
There does not appear to be a dispute between the parties regarding this issue. However, to ensure that this service is provided, the Hearing Officer orders the District to include in STUDENT's IEP that she receive 60 minutes per week of speech and language services from Ms. Dagenais.
(F) Services to remain in place through all school breaks on a 12-month basis.
Based on the testimony of the experts regarding STUDENT's need for consistency and constancy in her educational program, STUDENT's IEP shall be amended to include the requirement that her educational program consist of a 12-month program. The IEP team shall determine alternative services that will continue to meet STUDENT's needs during those periods when her classroom program is not in session.
(G) Transportation to school and service providers provided and/or reimbursed per parent and STUDENT's needs.
There does not appear to be any dispute nor was any evidence presented regarding this issue. The District has offered transportation in the past. If the IEP team determined that STUDENT requires transportation, her IEP shall include transportation to meet her needs.
(H) Daily data collection.
Little evidence was submitted regarding this issue. However, based on the nature of STUDENT's disability, the need for consistency between her classroom and on-to-one therapy, and the intensive nature of her one-to-one therapy, daily data collection is appropriate. STUDENT's IEP shall include daily data collection.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 days of the date of this order, the San Bruno Park Elementary School District shall convene an IEP meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team shall include Dr. Bryna Siegel and a representative for the Center for Autism and Related Disorders, paid for by the District.
(2) The IEP team shall amend STUDENT's IEP consistent with the contents of this decision. Specifically, STUDENT's IEP shall include placement in Ms. Bohnert's class at Loma Chica with a one- to-one aide provided by CARD; up to 25 hours per week of one-to-one in-home behavioral therapy provided by CARD; close coordination between teachers, therapists, and other service providers; 60 minutes per week of speech and language therapy with Donna Dagenais; a full-year educational program; transportation services as needed; and daily data collection.
(3) The IEP team shall also develop a transition plan that addresses the amount of time STUDENT requires the one-to-one aide and the duration of her one-to-one therapy, with the objective of reducing her one-to-one therapy and increasing her success in the classroom environment.
(4) Within 15 days of receipt of proof, San Bruno Park Elementary School District shall reimburse Petitioner, upon presentation of proof by Petitioner, for actual out-of-pocket expenses for one-to- one in-home behavioral therapy provided by her parents since November 1994. The reimbursement shall be limited to a maximum of 25 hours per week, except for the time period from February through August 1995. For that time period, reimbursement shall be limited to out-of-pocket expenses for up to five hours of therapy per week.
(5) Within 15 days of receipt of proof, San Bruno Park Elementary School District shall reimburse Petitioner, upon presentation of proof by Petitioner, for the cost of speech and language services provided by Donna Dagenais from February 1995 through January 1997, when the District began providing for those services.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner substantially prevailed on each issue heard and decided with the exception of Issue #3.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56506(I).
DATED: July 31, 1997 Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1) Ms. Dagenais reiterated her opinion regarding these recommendations in a letter dated February 1, 1995. In that letter, Ms. Dagenais stated that a group setting would be useful for STUDENT but that she needed to continue with the one-to-one program to develop skills. (Exhibit P-27) 2) San Bruno Park Elementary School District v. STUDENT, SN 949-95, March 12, 1996. 3) Ms. Lubin was also called by the District during the District's case. The testimony provided by Ms. Lubin during the District's case is summarized in the "District Witnesses" section of this decision. 4) The maximum summer break appears to consist of approximately 60-65 school days. 5) The Hearing Officer notes that the Regional Center provided for STUDENT's one-to-one therapy form February 1995 through August 1995 in the amount of 20 hours per week. Therefore, for the period from February 1995 through August 1995, STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for a maximum of five hours of one-to-one behavioral therapy only.
