California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 25, 1997
Student v. Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 151-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Hacienda La Puente Unified may not expel student with learning disabilities and must provide daily compensatory tutoring and new behavior goals.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 14-year-old eighth grader filed for hearing after Hacienda La Puente Unified School District recommended expelling him. He is eligible for special education with learning disabilities, including long-documented attention problems, and the district wanted to expel him for choking another student on campus in December 1996. Earlier, after he broke a behavior contract, the district had moved him from Newton Middle School to Cedarlane Middle School without an IEP meeting. The district's pre-expulsion IEP team found that the conduct was not caused by his disability and that he was appropriately placed.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote ruled for the student on every issue. District IEPs had noted attention deficits since 1989, yet the pre-expulsion assessment never evaluated those problems or how they affected his behavior. Records showed impulsivity and a short temper, so the Hearing Officer found that the choking incident was a manifestation of his disability. He was also not appropriately placed: his IEP had no attention or behavior goals, and his new teacher used consequences such as janitor duty. The district also kept him out of school past the 10-day suspension limit and violated stay put. He received no services from January 1997 until home teaching began in April 1997.
The district may not expel him. It must provide one hour daily of one-to-one tutoring through summer 1997 and the 1997-98 school year. It must also hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to add attention and behavior goals and reinstate him in extended school year (ESY).
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied former Education Code section 48915.5 to pre-expulsion assessments and manifestation decisions. When a district's own records describe attention problems, its assessment must address them. The decision also shows that a suspension extended past 10 school days without parent agreement or a court order violated stay put and led to compensatory education.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1a. May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel Student for an incident on December 19, 1996? (a) Did the District conduct an appropriate pre-expulsion assessment of Student?
The pre-expulsion assessment did not comply with Education Code section 56320 because it did not fully assess the student's long-known attention problems or their effect on his behavior and educational performance.
- Student prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1b. Was Student's misconduct caused by or a direct manifestation of his identified disability?
The choking incident came from the student's impulsivity and difficulty controlling his actions, which are part of his attention disability, so the misconduct was a manifestation of his disability.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1c. Was Student appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred?
The student was not appropriately placed. His IEP had no goals or services for attention or behavior, he was transferred to the Cedarlane SDC without an IEP meeting, and the teacher was not told why he was moved.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 1d. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?
The District kept the student out of school beyond the 10-school-day suspension limit and violated stay put. It provided no services from January 1997 until home teaching began in April 1997, which denied FAPE and justified compensatory tutoring.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District shall not expel the student for his misbehavior on December 19, 1996.
- Compensatory education. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, the District must begin one-to-one tutoring by a credentialed special education teacher. Tutoring is one hour daily on weekdays during summer 1997 and on each school day from the first day through the end of the regular 1997-1998 school year. This compensates for about 10 weeks (about 250 hours) of lost instruction.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting. The team must draft goals and objectives, including goals and objectives for attentional and behavioral deficits, and determine placement and services for the 1997-1998 school year.
- Order to provide or change services. The District must immediately reinstate the student in the extended school year (ESY) program.
Key authorities
Rowley; Honig v. Doe; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Education Code § 48915.5; Education Code § 56320; 34 CFR § 104.35
People named in the decision
- Karin Luthi, special education teacher (SDC teacher), Cedarlane Middle School
- Irene Quinones, principal, Newton Middle School
- Penny Fraumeni, principal, Cedarlane Middle School
- Karen Usery, school psychologist (pre-expulsion assessor and counselor), Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Ellen Jose, program specialist; former seventh-grade SDC teacher, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Ms. Tomko, District designated behavior intervention case manager (BICM), Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Barbara Nakaoka, assistant superintendent, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Maureen White, assistant superintendent, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Michael Shaw, director of pupil personnel services; District representative at hearing, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- John E. Rieckewald, acting superintendent, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Victoria Baca, advocate for Student, Mexican American Educational Foundation
- Raul Wilson, advocate for Student; witness
- Dr. Woo, private physician
- Dr. Gates, private physician
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in the City of Industry, California, on April 29 and 30, 1997. Petitioner STUDENT" was present at the hearing. He was represented by advocate Victoria Baca of the Mexican American Educational Foundation. Also present at the hearing on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, and advocate Raul Wilson. Respondent Hacienda La Puente Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Michael Shaw, director of pupil personnel services. Also present on behalf of the District was Maureen White, assistant superintendent. Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for an incident on December 19, 1996? (a) Did the District conduct an appropriate pre-expulsion assessment of STUDENT? (b) Was STUDENT's misconduct caused by or a direct manifestation of his identified disability? (c) Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred? (d) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? BACKGROUND FACTS Petitioner is a 14-year-old STUDENT in the eighth grade. STUDENT has been eligible for special education because of learning disabilities since 1989, when he was in the first grade. (Footnote 1) STUDENT's placement since the second grade has been in a special day class (SDC). (Footnote 2) Prior to his suspension on December 19, 1996, STUDENT was in Karin Luthi's SDC at Cedarlane Middle School with mainstreaming in physical education and one elective. STUDENT is also entitled to extended school year (ESY) services. Since April 1997 STUDENT has received home teaching. (Footnote 3) STUDENT's current goals and objectives, which were agreed to at an individualized educational program (IEP) meeting on April 19, 1996, are to improve basic math, reading, and vocational education skills. The reading objectives are to increase STUDENT's reading to a middle-fourth-grade level and to improve his recall and critical thinking skills. There also is an objective to improve basic written expression. Math objectives include the following: to "be firm" on six, seven, eight, and nine multiplication facts; to be able to multiply two-digit by three-digit numbers; to divide three-digit numbers by two-digit numbers; to distinguish addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division operations; and to compute answers to one-step word problems. The vocational educational objective addresses STUDENT's poor organizational skills. (Petitioner's Exhibit 21) The last triennial assessment of STUDENT was completed by the District on April 7, 1995, while STUDENT was in the sixth grade. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), STUDENT obtained the following standard scores: verbal scale-94; performance scale-90; and full scale-92. On the Wide Range Achievement Test-III (WRAT-III), which measured STUDENT's academic achievement, STUDENT obtained the following standard scores: Reading-85 (fourth-grade equivalency; spelling-70 (first-grade equivalency); arithmetic-75 (third-grade equivalency). (Petitioner's Exhibit 11) STUDENT's family relocated and, in September 1995, STUDENT entered the seventh grade in the Covina-Valley Unified School District. STUDENT returned to Hacienda La Puente in December 1995 and was placed in a SDC at Newton Middle School. STUDENT had the following grades when he left Covina-Valley: SC biology-A; general music-B; SC English and physical education-B-; and SDC math-C+. (Petitioner's Exhibit 14) STUDENT received a number of referrals for discipline during the second semester of the school year. (Petitioner's Exhibits 15-20 and 22-27) STUDENT received the following grades at the end of the seventh grade: SDC math and physical education-C; SDC science and language arts-C; SDC reading -D+; home economics-D; and homeroom/citizenship-F. (Petitioner's Exhibit 14) Because STUDENT received a number of referrals for discipline at the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT and his mother were asked by principal Irene Quinones to sign an academic/behavioral contract, which they did on September 19, 1996. STUDENT agreed to abide by the following provisions: attend class regularly and on time; be prepared to work in class; maintain a C grade average; maintain an A or B grade in citizenship; leave campus at 2:15 p.m.; comply with all conduct and discipline codes of the school and district; and "not elicit any form of suspension." Failure to adhere to the provisions of the contract would result in one or more of the following: change to a four period day; transfer to another school; placement in the Opportunity Class Academy; or enrollment in an independent study program. (Petitioner's Exhibit 31) On October 1, 1996, STUDENT was referred to the principal for being uncooperative and calling an instructional assistant names. Ms. Quinones concluded that STUDENT had broken his behavioral contract. She suspended STUDENT and immediately transferred him out of Newton to Cedarlane, another middle school within the Hacienda La Puente District. (Footnote 4) On October 2, 1996, STUDENT and his mother met with Penny Fraumeni, principal of Cedarlane. Both STUDENT and his mother signed a STUDENT discipline contract stating the following: I, STUDENT, must abide by the following rules while I am a STUDENT at Cedarlane Middle School. I will not: fight, threaten others, defy authority, destroy school or personal property. If these rules are violated then the following will be program options to be determined by the school: shortened day (8 a.m. - lunch) includes core subjects; independent study at home-supervised by the vice principal, expulsion.(Respondent's Exhibit J, p. 65) STUDENT's attendance at Cedarlane was sporadic. A progress report with grades earned through October 25, 1996, indicates that STUDENT was receiving all F grades in his SDC classes, with the exception of a D grade in social studies. He also was receiving an F grade in art. (Petitioner's Exhibit 14) An IEP meeting was convened on November 12, 1996, at the request of STUDENT's parents. They asked the District to provide an alternative placement for STUDENT. The IEP states that "Since coming to Cedarlane, STUDENT has be[sic] often absent. When in school often rude and noncompliant. Interventions have included D.A.T.E. counseling, time-out, help out janitor, and suspension." (Footnote 5) (Respondent's Exhibit A) The IEP states that the parents and other IEP members were in agreement that Cedarlane offered STUDENT an appropriate placement. It is also noted on the IEP that "STUDENT requested a return to Newton. Newton principal was consulted, she said she would consider taking him back after two grading periods with a passing grade in citizenship." (Respondent's Exhibit B) The IEP team reconvened on November 21, 1996, to discuss STUDENT's return to school after absences totaling approximately three weeks. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be provided weekly counseling for 20 minutes each session to help him adjust to the new school. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT would remain at Cedarlane until January 31, 1997, and, if he demonstrated good citizenship (no referrals and no suspensions) and maintained a C or better average, he would be allowed to return to Newton. It is noted on the IEP that Mr. Shaw offered to make an AB 3632 referral to community mental health and that the parents were considering the offer. (Respondent's Exhibit C) On December 19, 1996, STUDENT engaged in behavior for which the District is recommending that he be expelled. While on the school campus, another STUDENT threw a stick at STUDENT. STUDENT and the other STUDENT exchanged some words. STUDENT then grabbed the STUDENT by the neck and threatened to kill him. STUDENT held the STUDENT in a choke hold against a pole until some other STUDENTs told STUDENT to stop, which he did. STUDENT then chased the other STUDENT. When he caught up with him, they stared at each other but did not engage in any further physical altercations. Principal Fraumeni met with STUDENT's parents on the day of the incident and suspended STUDENT. (See Respondent's Exhibit J, pp. 54-62) In a letter dated December 20, 1996, Ms. Fraumeni informed Dr. Barbara Nakaoka, assistant superintendent of the District, that STUDENT had been suspended for five days as a result of the incident the prior day. (Respondent's Exhibit J, p. 54) Also on December 20, 1996, Ms. Fraumeni sent a letter to STUDENT's parents informing them that a meeting was scheduled for January 9, 1997, to discuss the incident and to obtain the parents' authorization to proceed with a pre-expulsion assessment. In the letter, Ms. Fraumeni stated she was extending STUDENT's expulsion until January 9, 1997, and that "STUDENT will be placed on home teaching pending the results of this assessment and the final IEP pre-expulsion conference." (Respondent's Exhibit J, p. 53) On January 6, 1997, MOTHER consented to the District's proposed pre-expulsion assessment plan. The areas to be assessed included academic achievement, intellectual abilities, psychological processes, and health. (District's Exhibit G) On January 9, 1997, the District convened an IEP meeting. STUDENT's parents did not accept the District's offer to place STUDENT on "Home and Hospital Instruction." STUDENT was not reinstated in school and the IEP document states that he was suspended pending results of the pre-expulsion assessment. (Respondent's Exhibit D) On January 15, 1997, school psychologist Karen Usery completed the pre-expulsion assessment. Ms. Usery administered the WISC-III, the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (DTVMI), and the Human Figure Drawing. A school nurse completed a heath assessment with MOTHER and STUDENT. On the WISC-III, STUDENT obtained standard scores of 83 on the verbal and full scales, and 86 on the performance scale. Ms. Usery noted that STUDENT's scores on the WISC-III were lower than scores on previous testing, which she attributed to STUDENT's negative attitude and distractibility during testing. On the WJ-R, STUDENT obtained standard scores of 67 in broad reading, 78 in broad mathematics, and 57 in broad written language. These scores equate to approximately a second- to third-grade level in reading, first- to second-grade level in writing, and fourth-grade level in math. On the DTVMI, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 78, which indicates that STUDENT was having difficulty in visual motor integration. STUDENT's human figure drawing was age appropriate and "suggests that STUDENT longs to have what he sees as the freedom of being an adult." Ms. Usery noted in her report that STUDENT's behavior in class is "irritable and angry toward others. He also has poor peer and adult relations and shows little desire to learn." The report goes on to state the following: STUDENT's handicapping conditions which qualify him for special education placement are deficits in visual-motor integration and attention. Because of these deficits, along with the delays in academic achievement, placement in a Special Day Class is believed to be the most appropriate educational setting for STUDENT. The presence of STUDENT's handicapping conditions are not believed to be the cause of his misbehavior. Also, he appears to know the difference between right and wrong, as evidenced by his strong performance in answering questions having to do with common sense and social judgment.(Respondent's Exhibit H) The District scheduled an IEP meeting for January 17, 1997, to discuss the findings of Ms. Usery's assessment; however, because a funeral for a member of the family was scheduled for the same date, MOTHER requested that the meeting be rescheduled. At the rescheduled IEP meeting on January 23, 1997, advocates Ms. Baca and Mr. Wilson appeared on behalf of STUDENT. STUDENT and his parents were present also. Ms. Usery presented information to the IEP team regarding her assessment. Team members then began a discussion about whether STUDENT's misconduct was a manifestation of his disability and whether he was appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct. STUDENT's advocates were asked by the District to leave the meeting for what the District termed "disruptive and threatening behavior." The parents would not agree to completing the meeting without their advocates' presence and left the meeting. District members of the IEP team continued discussing STUDENT. A handwritten statement attached to the IEP reads as follows: Call to Assistant Superintendent of District Dr. Barbara Nakaoka reported that Advocates are not allowed to attend pre-expulsion hearings. Advocates Mrs. Baca and Mr. Wilson attended first part of meeting, but were asked to leave after this information was available. Parents declined to continue in meeting. Also parents were informed that meeting would conclude in their absence. Home teaching was again offered, parent did not accept, but said she did not want to answer at this time. She reported that STUDENT is living with his mother in the Cedarlane area, not with his father in the W. Covina School District. Mom did not want meeting to continue until she has representation with her.(Respondent's Exhibit E) The IEP document states that MOTHER believed that STUDENT's misbehavior was an impulsive act that could have been a manifestation of his disability; STUDENT's father did not think that STUDENT's learning disability was the cause of his misbehavior; District members of the IEP team did not believe that there was a relationship between STUDENT's disability and his misconduct; and District members determined that STUDENT knows right from wrong. The IEP also states that the District and STUDENT's parents determined that STUDENT was in the correct placement. (Respondent's Exhibit E) The IEP team reconvened on February 11, 1997. The meeting was attended by STUDENT's parents, their advocates, STUDENT, and District representatives. The IEP states that FATHER stated at that time that he believed that he was not qualified to determine whether STUDENT's disability caused his misbehavior; MOTHER believed that the behavior was a manifestation of his disability; and the District maintained that there was not a relationship between STUDENT's behavior and his misconduct. All members of the IEP team concurred that STUDENT requires an SDC placement; however, MOTHER stated that he did not believe that the Cedarlane SDC is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The parents again declined the District's offer to provide STUDENT with home teaching. (Respondent's Exhibit F) In an undated letter sometime after the IEP meeting on February 11, 1997, Ms. Fraumeni, principal, informed STUDENT's parents that she was recommending that STUDENT be expelled. The letter also states that she was continuing STUDENT's suspension until the Board of Education took final action in this matter. STUDENT was specifically charged with violating Education Code 48900(a) and (k): Causing, attempting to cause, or threatening physical injury to another STUDENT and disrupting school activities or defying authority of teachers, administrators, or other school personnel. (Respondent's Exhibit J, p. 51) On February 18, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT. (Footnote 6) On March 3, 1997, acting superintendent John E. Rieckewald, Ph.D., sent STUDENT's parents a letter informing them that an expulsion hearing was scheduled for March 13, 1997. (Respondent's Exhibit J, p. 49-50) The hearing apparently was postponed. Sometime prior to the District's spring break, MOTHER agreed to the District's offer to provide STUDENT with home teaching. Home teaching began after the spring break. (Footnote 7) STUDENT was receiving instruction at home from a District teacher at the time of the hearing. (Footnote 8) SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONYPetitioner's Witnesses FATHER testified that he first noticed that STUDENT had problems when he was one year old. FATHER recalled that STUDENT squirmed and tried to get out of his car seat, and that he was always impatient. For example, STUDENT would not wait in line for the rides at Disneyland and would run up and down while one of the parents waited in line. FATHER testified that STUDENT also had trouble in preschool because he would not take naps or follow his teachers' directions. FATHER described STUDENT as anxious, nervous, and difficult to discipline. FATHER stated that STUDENT has told him that he "hates his guts" and "wishes that he would die." FATHER testified that five minutes after making these statements, STUDENT would behave as if nothing had happened. To his knowledge, STUDENT has not previously been engaged in fighting. FATHER testified that STUDENT does not have any concept of time and that it is impossible to get him to do things at a designated time. FATHER testified that it is very frustrating trying to help STUDENT with his homework. FATHER testified that he is quite certain that STUDENT's teachers must have similar difficulties with STUDENT; however, no one from the school has ever contacted him to help figure out how to address issues pertaining to STUDENT. FATHER testified that the District's solution to STUDENT's behavioral problems is to send him home. FATHER testified that positive reinforcement works better with STUDENT. FATHER testified that STUDENT's behavior has always been very different from the behavior of his two older siblings. FATHER stated that his other children were calm and were easily redirected to behave appropriately. FATHER testified that he requested that Ms. Baca and Mr. Wilson attend the pre-expulsion IEP because he was not entirely familiar with special education laws. FATHER testified that he could not form an opinion regarding whether STUDENT's misconduct was related to his disability because he does not have the education or training to understand why STUDENT is the way he is. FATHER does not believe that STUDENT is appropriately placed at Cedarlane. MOTHER testified that as a baby, STUDENT would not let her cuddle him and he had trouble taking naps. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's first grade teacher told her that STUDENT pushed in line, had trouble writing, and got into other trouble. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not have any concept of present or past time. She related that STUDENT will describe something as happening last week when it actually occurred the prior day. MOTHER testified that on the other occasions STUDENT had to move to a new school, she first observed classes and had input as to which class would be appropriate for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that she had absolutely no input when the District moved STUDENT to Cedarlane. MOTHER testified that she was concerned about STUDENT's attending Cedarlane from his first day there. STUDENT was angry about being transferred to Cedarlane and the first meeting with the principal did not go well. The principal slapped her hand on desk and told STUDENT that he would behave at Cedarlane or he would be out of the school and on home study. MOTHER testified that the principal required STUDENT and his mother to sign a behavioral contract and, it was her impression that if they did not sign the contract, STUDENT would immediately be suspended. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has always been difficult to discipline and that he performs best when he receives positive rewards. MOTHER testified that the District has not offered to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT or to develop a behavioral intervention plan. MOTHER stated that the District has only discussed negative consequences for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has made very slow progress since kindergarten. She estimated that STUDENT reads at the first or second grade level, that his math is at the third grade level, and that his writing is at the first grade level. MOTHER testified that she was called to pick up STUDENT from school on the date of incident. MOTHER stated that the principal told her that STUDENT was suspended for seven days and that he would be given a date when he could return to school. Winter break then intervened. After the break, the principal told her that STUDENT could not return pending results of a pre-expulsion assessment and IEP meeting to determine whether the District could proceed with the expulsion process. MOTHER testified that at one IEP meeting, she requested an advocate. The principal, Ellen Jose, said that because MOTHER is employed by the District, she could not provide her with an advocate's number and that she would have to find an advocate on her own. MOTHER testified that she understood that the first IEP meeting called after STUDENT's suspension was to make decisions pertaining to STUDENT's misconduct; however, the District told her that the purpose of the meeting was to place STUDENT on home study. MOTHER testified that until about three weeks before the hearing, she refused home teaching for STUDENT. She stated that the District has not offered any alternative to home teaching. MOTHER testified that after the advocates were dismissed from the IEP meeting on January 23, 1997, she asked that the meeting be rescheduled to another date; however, the following day Ms. Usery brought the IEP to her to sign and told her that the meeting had continued. MOTHER testified that she was prevented by the District from fully participating at the next meeting on February 11, 1997. MOTHER testified that she believes that the incident on December 19, 1996, was related to STUDENT's attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD), which caused him to simply react to a situation. STUDENT testified that he understands that he is up for expulsion because he choked someone. STUDENT testified that he and a friend were walking to the corner of the school and when he turned around another boy threw a stick at him. According to STUDENT, they exchanged words and the boy started swinging at him. STUDENT then grabbed him and choked him and told him that he was going to kill him. STUDENT stated that he was not serious about killing the boy and that he was trying to scare him; however, he let go of the boy because he was not scaring him and he did not want to hurt him. STUDENT testified that other STUDENTs then came and told him to let the boy go. STUDENT testified that on another occasion he struck a female STUDENT who was picking on him. STUDENT testified that he wants to return to school but he does not like Cedarlane because he does not like his teacher. She yells at him for little things, does not let him participate in activities with the other STUDENTs and, if he gets a drink of water without first asking, his teacher kicks him out of class. STUDENT testified that she also assigns him to help the janitor. He is required to push the trash cart, pick up the trash from each room, and rake leaves. STUDENT testified that when assigned janitor duty, he has to work for the rest of the day and perhaps the following day until he has served the required number of hours. STUDENT testified that as many as three STUDENTs have also been given similar assignments with the janitor. STUDENT testified that his friends make fun of him and laugh at him when he has to work with the janitor. STUDENT testified that he understands that there are rules that he has to follow at school. STUDENT gave the following examples of school rules: listen to the teacher; behave at school; do what you are asked to do. STUDENT stated that he also knows that he is not supposed to fight at school. STUDENT testified that he likes to argue when he is right about something and admitted that he has argued with his teacher. Raul Wilson, advocate, testified on behalf of STUDENT. Mr. Wilson testified that he has been trained as a special education advocate by TASK and tutors special education STUDENTs. Mr. Wilson testified that on the several times he has observed STUDENT, he continuously talked, pulled on his pants from his waist, and grabbed at things. Mr. Wilson concluded that STUDENT is hyperactive. Mr. Wilson testified that the decision at the IEP meeting that STUDENT's misconduct was not related to his disability and that he was appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct was not a team decision because the District precluded STUDENT's advocates from participating in the discussion.District Witnesses Karen Usery, school psychologist, testified that she first met STUDENT at the November 1996 IEP meeting. She subsequently observed STUDENT in the classroom, assessed him in January 1997, was part of the pre-expulsion process (Respondent's Exhibit H), and provided him with three counseling sessions in November and December 1996. Ms. Usery testified that the purpose of a pre-expulsion assessment is to obtain contemporary information to help determine whether to proceed with the recommendation to expel the STUDENT. As part of her assessment, Ms. Usery administered the WISC-III, which measures cognitive abilities, and the WJ-R, which measures academic skills. The assessment also included observations of STUDENT's behavior, a report by STUDENT's teachers of his functioning in the classroom, and a brief health assessment by the school nurse. On the tests, STUDENT exhibited strengths in awareness to details, visual memory, and comprehension. Ms. Usery testified that some subtests of the WISC-III, such as arithmetic and coding, are sensitive to attentional problems. On these measures, STUDENT's scores were low. His performance and behaviors during testing were also consistent with ADD. Ms. Usery testified that during testing, STUDENT was irritable, had trouble concentrating, and needed to be reminded to stay on task. Ms. Usery testified that, during her classroom observation of STUDENT he exhibited mild ADHD symptoms and, when presented with something difficult, appeared restless and distractible. She also found that STUDENT was socially appropriate, friendly, and charming. Ms. Usery concluded that there was no reason to conduct additional testing because the assessment completed within the last 12 months continues to be accurate. Ms. Usery testified that STUDENT's misbehavior was not a manifestation of his disability. Ms. Usery was aware that STUDENT tended to be argumentative; however, she expressed surprise that STUDENT had choked someone because, in the past, STUDENT had only been verbally aggressive and was able to walk away from confrontational situations. Ms. Usery believes that STUDENT understands what constitutes acceptable behavior at school and has the skills to cope with his anger. In her opinion, STUDENT's attentional problems are not so severe that he cannot control his behavior and that he chooses to misbehave. Ms. Usery testified, for example, that when STUDENT was transferred to Cedarlane he did not attend school regularly and had some behavior problems; however, after it was agreed that he could return to Newton if his behavior remained appropriate for a period of time, both his behavior and school attendance improved. Ms. Usery also stated that STUDENT knows right from wrong and that his misbehavior is not so pervasive as to require a behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Usery viewed her counseling sessions with STUDENT successful. He appeared to respect her and to value spending time with her. She stated that STUDENT was starting to "open up" with her. Ms. Usery testified that an appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a class with a low STUDENT-to-teacher ratio and where there are opportunities for one-to-one instruction and close monitoring by the teacher. The academic program must be both challenging and address STUDENT's academic deficits and the school staff should have had training and understand the needs of STUDENTs with STUDENT's disabilities. Ms. Usery stated that STUDENT also requires opportunities to be mainstreamed with regular education STUDENTs as much as possible. Ms. Usery testified that the goals and objectives in STUDENT's IEP are appropriate to meet his needs and that he was appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct. The low STUDENT-to-teacher ratio allowed STUDENT to receive appropriate academic instruction with a small group of peers. The behavioral system employed in the class addressed STUDENT's behavioral needs. Ms. Usery described STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Luthi, as someone who is strict and expects that STUDENTs will follow rules but who has a calm manner. Ms. Luthi employs a positive behavioral system. Ms. Usery testified that Ms. Luthi generally has success with STUDENTs with needs similar to STUDENT's. Ms. Usery testified that the IEP meeting on January 23, 1997, began with a discussion of the results of her assessment. Ms. Usery testified that her understanding is that advocates may attend IEP meetings; however, at this meeting STUDENT's advocates were dismissed because they became confrontational, called the District "racist," frequently interrupted, and wanted to discuss matters that were not germane to the purpose of the meeting. Ms. Usery testified that she personally felt threatened and said as little as possible. Ms. Usery testified that after the parents and advocates left the meeting, no new conclusions were reached by the remaining members of the IEP team. At the subsequent IEP meeting, Mr. Shaw dismissed her after she had provided input about her assessment. Ms. Usery stated that she believes Mr. Shaw dismissed her to protect her from further harassment by the advocates. Karin Luthi, STUDENT's SDC teacher at Cedarlane, holds regular and special education teaching credentials. She also has a masters' degree in special education and is an attorney. Ms. Luthi's class has fourteen STUDENTs. Two of the ST(TEXT CONT'D)started, he moved from an A level to a C level in behavior and was uncooperative in the classroom with his teacher and aide. Ms. Quinones testified that she decided at that time that it was in STUDENT's best interest to place him on a behavioral contract. She recalled confirming with STUDENT that he understood the contract before signing it. Ms. Quinones testified that MOTHER was supportive and affirmed with STUDENT that he understood that he needed to abide by contract. MOTHER did not at that time bring up any concerns regarding the effect of STUDENT's disabilities on his behavior. Ms. Quinones testified that she did not convene an IEP meeting to facilitate STUDENT's move to Cedarlane because it was a "lateral" transfer and STUDENT would continue to be educated under the same IEP. Ms. Quinones described the characteristics of STUDENTs with ADD/ADHD as follows: difficulty focusing for long periods of time, even in small groups; difficulty with peer interactions; and problems working in large groups. Ms. Quinones testified that the symptoms vary for each child and can range from mild to severe. Ms. Quinones testified that STUDENT exhibits mild ADHD. Ms. Quinones first met STUDENT and MOTHER in late December 1995 or early January 1996 when STUDENT returned to the District. In her opinion, STUDENT's goals and objectives developed at April 19, 1996, IEP are appropriate to meet his needs. She stated that STUDENT's IEP does not include goals and objectives related to behavior because STUDENT demonstrated that he was able to behave appropriately and to follow school rules when he chose to do so. Ellen Jose, program specialist, was STUDENT's seventh-grade SDC teacher from December 1995 through June 1996. Ms. Jose testified that in her class STUDENT received "Bs" the first semester and "Cs" the second semester. Ms. Jose testified that STUDENT's lower grades the second semester were because of frequent absences. On an assessment of STUDENT when he entered her class, STUDENT scored in the second to low third -grade in reading and second grade in math. He exhibited poor fine motor skills. STUDENT's strengths included being very verbal and social. He also had a solid foundation of knowledge, was able to act in a mature way, participated in conversations, and related well with STUDENTs and adults. Ms. Jose testified that STUDENT had trouble staying on task, lost things, and was disorganized. He also was impulsive, inattentive, and would "blurt out" inappropriate things. Ms. Jose testified that part of STUDENT's disability was an ADD/ADHD. To accommodate STUDENT's ADD/ADHD, Ms. Jose testified that she tried to work with him one-to-one or in small groups. She also arranged STUDENT's class schedule so that he would have an academic class and then an elective, which allowed him breaks between classes that required him to be attentive for long periods. Ms. Jose also modified the curriculum to include hands-on activities and topics that were of interest to STUDENT, and organized the way in which she presented information to STUDENT. To enhance his self-esteem, she had STUDENT teach other STUDENTs to play chess. Ms. Jose testified that she discussed with STUDENT alternative ways to deal with his "episodes." To address STUDENT's poor organizational skills, she provided him with a notebook and dividers and ensured that STUDENT recorded his assignments. Ms. Jose testified that she also provided a consistent routine in class, listed science and language arts activities on the board, and provided STUDENT with verbal prompts and praise. To minimize distractions, Ms. Jose testified that she provided STUDENT with a work space in the back of the room where he could work with less distraction. Ms. Jose testified that to decrease STUDENT's behavioral problems, she employed a positive behavioral program with rewards based on things STUDENT liked. There also were long-term rewards for the class, including popcorn and movie parties. Ms. Jose also implemented a consequence system that included time out. Ms. Jose testified that with STUDENT, she ignored many minor behaviors. Ms. Jose testified that her classroom behavioral program supplemented the school's merit/demerit system. Ms. Jose testified that STUDENT earned the right to participate in at least one school dance and several plays. Ms. Jose testified that she had concerns about the potential for STUDENT to make poor choices during lunch and other passing periods because he was not engaged in sports or other structured activities. She observed STUDENT engage in verbal confrontations but not in any physical confrontations other than on one occasion when he pushed someone. She also did not observe STUDENT uncontrollably angry. Ms. Jose testified that she did not believe STUDENT required a functional analysis assessment or individualized behavioral intervention program because the class and school behavioral programs were successful with STUDENT for the most part. Also, STUDENT's behaviors were not of the nature or frequency that require Hughes Bill type intervention. Ms. Jose testified that she concurs with the decision of the IEP team that STUDENT was appropriately placed at the time of his misconduct and that the misconduct was not related to his disability. She also testified that the goals and objectives developed in April 1996 were designed to meet STUDENT's needs and were appropriate. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAWISSUE: May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for an incident on December 19, 1996? Special education STUDENTs are subject to discipline in accordance with California statues and special education due process requirements. Discipline may include suspension and expulsion when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct. California Education Code 48900.5. In this case, the District suspended STUDENT on December 20, 1996, for choking another STUDENT on December 19, 1996. Expulsion of a special education STUDENT constitutes a change in placement and school officials must follow specific procedural safeguards to ensure that special education STUDENTs are not excluded from school because of their disabling condition. A school district can only recommend a special education STUDENT for expulsion for an offense listed in 48900 after all of the following have occurred: (1) A preexpulsion assessment is conducted. (2) The individualized education program team meets pursuant to subdivision (a). (3) Due process hearings and appeals, if initiated pursuant to 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, are completed.Education Code 48915.5(h). Pursuant to subsection (a), a special education STUDENT may be expelled only if all of the following conditions are met: (1) An IEP meeting is held; (2) The IEP team determines that the STUDENT's misconduct was "not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability;" and (3) The team determines that the pupil was appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred.California Education Code 48915.5(a)(1-3). The decision of the IEP team regarding whether to continue with legal expulsion proceedings of a special education STUDENT must be based on the results of the pre-expulsion assessment, the STUDENT's health records, and school discipline records. Education Code 48915.5(e). Petitioner asserts that he has exhibited ADD/ADHD, behavioral problems, and learning disabilities for a number of years and that the District has failed to adequately address these needs. Petitioner contends that the misbehavior on December 19, 1996, was a manifestation of his learning disabilities and ADD/ADHD. Petitioner contends that his placement at Cedarlane was not appropriate and that the District transferred him to Cedarlane without first convening an IEP meeting. Petitioner also asserts that the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated November 12, 1996, and the addendum dated November 21, 1996, are not designed to meet his unique and individual needs. Petitioner requests that the District convene an IEP meeting to draft appropriate goals and objectives and to determine an appropriate placement for him. Petitioner also requests compensatory education in the form of tutoring for the period he has been out of school, which began on December 19, 1996. The District contends that it conducted an appropriate pre-expulsion assessment of STUDENT and that the IEP team properly concluded that his misbehavior on December 19, 1996, was not a manifestation of his disability and that he was appropriately placed at the time of his misconduct. The District contends that it has provided services to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. The District also asserts that it was not required to convene an IEP meeting prior to STUDENT's transfer from Newton to Cedarlane because it was a "lateral" transfer (from one SDC to another SDC) and STUDENT continued to receive the same services. The District also asserts that the transfer was made pursuant to an IEP. The District asserts that it should be allowed to proceed with expulsion proceedings.(a) Did the District conduct an appropriate pre-expulsion assessment of STUDENT Education Code 48915.5(b) requires school districts to ensure that special education STUDENTs subject to a pre-expulsion assessment are afforded essentially the same rights included in federal and state special education law to which they are entitled when undertaking a "regular" assessment. The sole difference is that parental consent for a pre-expulsion assessment is not required. Education Code 48915.5(e) provides that the pre-expulsion assessment must be conducted according to the guidelines of 104.35 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 104.35 requires the following: (1) tests and other evaluation materials have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used and are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by their producer; (2) tests and other evaluation materials include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those which are designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient; and (3) tests are selected and administered so as best to ensure that, when a test is administered to a STUDENT with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills, the test results accurately reflect the STUDENT's aptitude or achievement level or whatever other factor the test purports to measure, rather than reflecting the STUDENT's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills (except where those skills are the factors that the test purports to measure). Education Code 48915.5(e) also states that the pre-expulsion assessment must include a review of the appropriateness of the STUDENT's placement and a determination of the relationship, if any, between the STUDENT's disability and behavior. California special education law further requires that any psychological assessment of a STUDENT must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed in accordance with Section 56320 of the Education Code. Education Code 56324(a). Section 56320 requires that: the assessment instruments and procedures must not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; the STUDENT must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability; and the assessment must be conducted persons knowledgeable of the STUDENT's disability. In addition, Section 56320 requires that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining a STUDENT's educational placement. Therefore, when read together, California Education Code 56320 and Title 34 CFR 104.35 provide the requirements to which schools must adhere in conducting a pre-expulsion assessment. The District's pre-expulsion assessment was conducted by a credentialed school psychologist with knowledge of learning and attentional disabilities, and included measures of STUDENT's cognitive, academic, visual-motor, health, and social/emotional skills. Ms. Usery's assessment included psycho-educational tests, observation, and reports from STUDENT's teachers. The assessment instruments utilized by Ms. Usery are frequently employed by school psychologists to assess STUDENTs with learning disabilities. There were no allegations that the assessment instruments were invalid or racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Additionally, the assessment report draws conclusions regarding the relationship between STUDENT's disability and behavior, and the appropriateness of his placement. (Testimony of Ms. Usery and Respondent's Exhibit H) To determine whether the District's pre-expulsion assessment addressed all areas related to STUDENT's disability, it is necessary to look his disability. STUDENT's IEPs indicate that he has "learning disabilities in attention, visual processing, and sound/symbol cognitive abilities." (Respondent's Exhibits A-F) Ms. Usery's report states that STUDENT's disability is in "visual-motor integration and attention....along with delays in academic achievement." (Respondent's Exhibit H) The witnesses all testified that STUDENT has attentional problems. He also has problems with impulsivity. The District witnesses minimized the effect of STUDENT's attentional problems on his behavior at school. However, there is a marked discrepancy between their testimony and comments in STUDENT's IEPs, reports of the District's assessments of STUDENT, and other educational records. Because all of the educational records were prepared before litigation, the Hearing Officer gives substantial weight to the information contained within them, as well as to the testimony of STUDENT's parents regarding STUDENT's long-standing attentional problems and impulsive behavior. For example, in 1990, the IEP team recommended that "MOTHER have STUDENT checked by a doctor to see if there is any physical cause for his inattention and distractibility." (Petitioner's Exhibits 1 and 2) (Footnote 9) Nearly every IEP since 1989 describes STUDENT's inattentiveness and/or hyperactivity. For example, an IEP dated February 22, 1990, describes STUDENT as "highly distractible." The IEP goes on to state that "It's difficult for him to attend for more than a few seconds at a time even working one-to-one in RSP." (Petitioner's Exhibit 5) An assessment dated December 9, 1991, describes areas of difficult for STUDENT as concentration and attention. (Petitioner's Exhibit 4) An IEP dated March 29, 1993, states that "STUDENT continues to have difficulty attending and focusing on tasks. He has made improvements. Most important concern is placing him on medication for ADHD." The IEP also states that "STUDENT is unfocused and erratic most of the time." (Footnote 10) (Petitioner's Exhibit 7) An IEP dated March 22, 1994, describes STUDENT similarly and states that the team talked about medication for ADDH. (Petitioner's Exhibit 8) A triennial assessment in 1995 noted some improvement in STUDENT's ability to resist distractions but that his frustration had increased. (Petitioner's Exhibit 11) STUDENT's IEP dated April 19, 1996, states the rationale for special education placement in an SDC is attentional and academic difficulties. (Petitioners' Exhibit 21) Additionally, STUDENT's parents described STUDENT as very active and related how he had difficulty sleeping even as a baby. During the hearing, STUDENT sat for a great deal of time was observed to fidget and play with objects. Regardless of the degree of STUDENT's attentional problems, the record establishes that the District has been aware of STUDENT's attentional problems since he was in the first grade in 1989. Moreover, the District indicated on IEPS that attention was part of STUDENT's disability; however, it has never conducted an assessment of STUDENT's attentional problems or evaluated the effect the attentional problems may have on his behavior and academic performance. The District continued to recommend that STUDENT's parents obtain an assessment and that they undertake to treat STUDENT with medication. Given the ample information the District had about STUDENT's attentional problems and to comply with the legal requirements of an assessment as set forth above, the District's assessment should have included a complete assessment for ADD, including measures of the effect of ADD on STUDENT's behavior and educational performance. (Footnote 11) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's pre-expulsion assessment does not comply with the requirements of Education Code 56320. (b) Was STUDENT's misconduct caused by or a direct manifestation of his identified disability? Based on the finding in (a), the pre-expulsion IEP team lacked critical information regarding STUDENT's educational needs to determine the issues before it. However, based on the information that was available, it can reasonably be concluded that STUDENT's misconduct was caused by his identified disability. It has been established by all of the testimony and educational records that STUDENT has attention difficulties. Ms. Tomko, who is the District's designated BICM, testified that it is typical for STUDENTs with ADD to have problems in less structured times at school, which may lead to disputes that end in fighting. Ms. Jose, STUDENT's seventh-grade teacher, describe STUDENT as "impulsive and inattentive" and stated that STUDENT would "blurt out" things. Ms. Luthi, STUDENT's teacher testified that STUDENT could be out-of-control. Ms. Usery also noted that STUDENT has a short temper. STUDENT's educational records also relate incidents of STUDENT's impulsivity. A previous IEP included a goal to "Help STUDENT learn to control his reactions to school environment" because of his tendency to "explode" under pressure. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6) As far back as December 1991, a school psychologist stated that STUDENT would have "abrupt outbursts." (Petitioner's Exhibit 4) In a presentation to the IEP team, STUDENT's teacher during the 1992-1993 school year stated the following: He [STUDENT] lacks responsibility. I believe that it is due to being bombarded by so many extraneous stimuli that he can't separate the appropriate and act upon it. Again it's a case of inability to focus.....He is not a good problem-solver, because he is to hyper to focus his thinking....His disability needs to be addressed. He must not be punished for that which he cannot help.(Petitioner's Exhibit 7). Many of the witnesses stated that they believed that STUDENT understood the school rules and that it was not acceptable behavior to choke another STUDENT. The evidence discussed above establishes that STUDENT's attentional disabilities cause him to act impulsively, to have difficulty focusing, and to have a short temper. Given the nature of the encounter--the other STUDENT threw a stick at STUDENT and then they engaged in an exchange of words--and STUDENT's impulsivity as described above, it is concluded that the way in which STUDENT reacted was caused by his impulsivity and difficulty controlling his actions. Impulsivity and lack of control are elements of STUDENT's attentional problems. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's misconduct on December 19. 1997, is a manifestation of his disability.(c) Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time of his misconduct? Under both state and federal law, STUDENTs with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the STUDENT's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(16). According to the United States Supreme Court, the STUDENT's placement must be reasonably calculated to provide the STUDENT with some educational benefit. The school district is required to provide the STUDENT with a "basic floor of opportunity" and is not required to provide the STUDENT with the best educational available. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. Thus, under IDEA and Rowley, the program offered by the school district is appropriate when it is designed to meet the STUDENT's unique needs, provides the STUDENT with some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP. As described above in (a), STUDENT has experienced attentional problems throughout his school career and has experienced increasing frustration and behavioral problems. The District has consistently acknowledged STUDENT's attentional problems; however, STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives address only deficits in reading, math, and organizational skills and there are no goals, objectives, or services to address his attentional or behavioral problems. Based on STUDENT's on-going attentional and behavioral problems, the Hearing Officer concludes that to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, his IEP must include goals and objectives to address attentional and behavioral problems. The parties agree that STUDENT requires a SDC placement. At the time of the misconduct, STUDENT's placement was in Ms. Luthi's SDC; however, the parents do not believe that Ms. Luthi's class is appropriate for STUDENT. It should be noted that California defines "educational placement" as that "unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program...." 5 CCR 3042(a). Therefore, an appropriate placement consists of more than a simple definition of the type of class in which the STUDENT is placed. In this case, placement in Ms. Luthi's class was fatally flawed from the beginning. The placement was made without the benefit of an IEP meeting and Ms. Luthi was not advised by the District of the reason for STUDENT's move into her class. Given that STUDENT's IEP does not include goals and objectives to address attentional and behavioral difficulties and Ms. Luthi lacked vital information about STUDENT, it cannot be concluded that she was able to meet his unique and individual needs. For example, STUDENT's parents and teachers testified that STUDENT responded well to positive reinforcement; however, Ms. Luthi's repertoire of responses to STUDENT's behavioral problems in class included assigning STUDENT to work with the school janitor or having him work outside of the room for extended periods of time. The Hearing Officer finds that the lack of an appropriate IEP and a program designed to address STUDENT's attentional and behavioral problems is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Moreover, STUDENT's school attendance decreased when he was moved to Cedarlane and he has made very little educational progress during the period he attended school there. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not appropriately placed on December 19, 1996.(d) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? The District determined that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior fell under Education Code 48900(a) and (k) in that it caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person and disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. The record indicates that STUDENT had been disciplined numerous times during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years for inappropriate behavior and had been under a "behavioral contract" at the time the incident occurred. The District's choice of suspension as a disciplinary method for the incident on December 19, 1996, appears warranted, given that other means of correction had failed to bring about STUDENT's proper conduct. Suspension of special education STUDENTs may not be for more than five consecutive days except, under certain circumstances, a suspension may be extended for up to ten days. Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, 108 S.Ct. 592, 605. In this case, STUDENT's suspension commenced on December 20, 1996, and was to continue for five school days. The school's winter break began the next day and STUDENT's suspension would have ended on January 9, 1997. The pre-expulsion IEP meeting was scheduled for January 17, 1997 and the District could have legally extended STUDENT's extension to that date. The IEP meeting did not take place on that date and it was rescheduled at the request of STUDENT's mother to January 23, 1997. The fact that STUDENT's mother requested that the pre-expulsion meeting be rescheduled does not authorize the District to exceed the 10 day limit on STUDENT's expulsion. A parent may request that the pre-expulsion IEP meeting be postponed for up to three additional school days. "If a postponement has been granted, the local educational agency may extend any suspension of a pupil for the period of postponement if the pupil continues to pose an immediate threat to the safety of himself, herself, or others and the local educational agency notifies the parent that the suspension will be continued during the postponement. However, the suspension shall not be extended beyond 10 consecutive schooldays unless agreed to by the parent, or by a court order." Education Code 48915.5(d). Ms. Fraumeni later informed STUDENT's parents that STUDENT's suspension would continue until the Board of Education met to consider his expulsion. STUDENT has not returned to school following his suspension and the District did not provide him with any services from January 17, 1997, until April 1997, when his parents reluctantly consented to home teaching. Therefore, the District's on-going suspension of STUDENT until his parents agreed to home teaching exceeded the number of days a special education STUDENT may be suspended. Moreover, once a due process hearing has been filed, stay put applies unless the district and the parent agree otherwise. A special education STUDENT is entitled to "stay put" in his or her existing placement pending the outcome of special education due process procedures. (Footnote 12) 20 U.S.C. 1415(e)(3); Education Code 56505(d). A STUDENT's "present educational placement" is generally the placement called for by the STUDENT's IEP and which has been implemented prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education (6th Cir. 1990) 918 F.2d 218. The purpose of the stay-put provision is to ensure stability of the STUDENT's educational program pending resolution of the dispute. Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District (5th Cir. 1983) 695 F.2d 949, 953; Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach (2d Cir. 1982) 694 F.2d 904. Neither federal nor state special education law contains any exceptions to stay put and the Supreme Court in Honig v. Doe affirmed that the language of the federal stay-put provision is "unequivocal." The Court stated "we are...not at liberty to engraft onto the statute any exception Congress chose not to create." 484 U.S. at 325. In STUDENT's case, there was no agreement otherwise until April 1997 and the District did not seek an injunction from a court of competent jurisdiction barring STUDENT's return to school. Therefore, the District was required after the 10 day suspension to return STUDENT to his placement in Ms. Luthi's SDC. STUDENT should have been allowed to return to school January 20, 1997, or the next school date after January 17, 1997. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to provide STUDENT with any educational services following the legal time period of his suspension until his parents gave into the District's pressure in April to allow home teaching, resulted in the denial of a free appropriate education to STUDENT. Appropriate relief for denial of appropriate special education services includes compensatory education. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F3d 1489. (See also 20 U.S.C. 1415(e)(2). In this case, STUDENT did not receive any services from January 10, 1997, to the day following spring break in April 1997. (Footnote 13) Therefore, as a compensatory remedy, the District must provide STUDENT with tutoring. As to the appropriate amount of tutoring, the Hearing Officer calculates that STUDENT did not receive any educational services for approximately 10 weeks, which is approximately 250 hours of lost educational instruction. In order to reasonably compensate STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must provide him with one-to-one tutoring from a credentialed special education teacher for one hour daily on week days during the summer and on each school day beginning on the first day of the 1997-1998 school year and continuing through the end of the regular 1997-1998 school year. PREVAILING PARTY May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for an incident on December 19, 1996? Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided. ORDER (1) The District shall not expel STUDENT for his misbehavior on December 19, 1996. (2) Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT with one-to-one tutoring from a credentialed special education teacher for one hour daily during week days in the summer of 1997 and on each school day beginning on the first day of the 1997-1998 school year and continuing through the end of the regular 1997-1998 school year. (3) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to draft goals and objectives, including goals and objectives to address attentional and behavioral deficits, and to determine appropriate placement and services for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year. (4) The District shall immediately reinstate STUDENT in the extended school year program.
DATED: June 25, 1997 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES1.STUDENT's IEPs indicate that he has learning disabilities in attention, visual processing, and sound/symbol cognitive abilities.2.Except for a brief period during the seventh grade, STUDENT has attended school in the Hacienda La Puente Unified School District since kindergarten. He attended Mesa Robles Elementary School for kindergarten and the first grade and attended Los Robles Elementary School from the third through the fifth grades. Because Los Robles did not serve sixth-grade STUDENTs, STUDENT attended the sixth grade at Los Altos Elementary School.3. The District did not convene an IEP meeting prior to STUDENT's transfer to Cedarlane.4. The District did not convene an IEP meeting prior to STUDENT's transfer to Cedarlane.5. D.A.T.E. was not defined.6. The request is dated February 11, 1997; however, it was not processed because it was not signed by STUDENT's parents and/or advocates. A signed request for hearing was received on February 18, 1997.7. Neither party provided an IEP to reflect the change of STUDENT's placement from the SDC to home teaching.8. No one at the hearing specifically requested that the Hearing Officer order the District to return STUDENT to Cedarlane; however, on May 7, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request from Ms. Baca that STUDENT be allowed to attend Cedarlane until resolution of the hearing. Ms. Baca's letter does not indicate that a copy of the request had been sent to the District. Apparently the calendaring staff was waiting for notification that the District had been provided a copy of Ms. Baca's request and did not convey the request to the Hearing Officer. On June 3, 1997, Ms. Baca informed an assistant calendar clerk "to not act on it [request to maintain STUDENT at Cedarlane] as school is almost out."9. In response to the District's suggestion that the parents obtain an assessment of STUDENT, MOTHER took STUDENT to a Dr. Woo, who noted that STUDENT appeared "hyperactive," and to a Dr. Gates, who viewed STUDENT as "classic ADHD." (Petitioner's Exhibit 3) The parents have declined treatment with medication for STUDENT's attentional problems.10. The IEP includes an unusual recommendation: "Daily intake of coffee was suggested, as well as vitamins." (Petitioner's Exhibit 7)11. Nothing prevents a district from obtaining the services of a medical doctor to assess a STUDENT.12. Different procedures may apply under some circumstances, such as when the STUDENT has brought a weapon to school. Education Code 48915.6 This case does not involve any of the circumstances set forth in 48915.6.13. The appropriateness of the home teaching program is not addressed here; however, the Hearing Officer has grave concerns regarding the way in which the parents were pressured by the lack of services from the District into accepting a home teaching program.
