California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 7, 2001
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1511-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso
Los Angeles Unified's offer of general education with resource services, without a one-to-one aide, provided FAPE; parents' claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a 9-year-old third grader filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability and an other health impairment. He attended an aphasia special day class (SDC) at Leo Politi Elementary School, with twice-weekly speech therapy and a one-to-one aide assigned to protect his back after earlier surgery. He rode a bus two to three hours each day.
On the first issue, the District admitted that the bus missed him on four days and that the aide occasionally left his side. The Hearing Officer called these lapses minor. They caused no loss of educational benefit, because the student met most of his goals and made excellent progress.
On the second issue, the District's July 23, 2001 IEP offered general education 77% of the day, resource specialist (RSP) services 23% of the day, and speech therapy once a week. It also removed the aide and moved him to his home school, 95th Street Elementary. The District held that IEP meeting without the parents. The Hearing Officer found this proper because the parents had caused the delays and the student lost nothing while in stay put. District assessors testified that he worked well above his SDC classmates. The nurse found no current medical need for an aide. The offer was found to provide FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The third issue, whether he needed the SDC, was therefore moot. The District's IEP was ordered implemented.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled two common disputes. It treated admitted, minor lapses in transportation and aide service as harmless when the student kept making progress. It also allowed a district to hold an IEP meeting without parents who repeatedly refused to attend before the hearing. Finally, it relied on assessments showing the student had outgrown a special day class.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 1. Was the Petitioner denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year when the District failed to provide bus transportation for four days and his one-to-one aide failed to remain at his side on a few occasions?
The District admitted four missed bus pickups and a few times the aide stepped away, but these de minimis lapses caused no loss of educational benefit; the student met most goals and made excellent progress.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Does the District's offer to place Petitioner in a regular education class for 77% of the day and a resource specialist (RSP) class for 23% of the day, including speech and language therapy once per week for thirty minutes, for the 2001-2002 school year provide Petitioner with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?
Holding the July 23, 2001 IEP without the parents was proper because they caused the delay and the student suffered no prejudice; general education with RSP, weekly speech, and no aide met his needs and offered a FAPE.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. If the District's offer of a regular education class with RSP services for 2001-2002 does not provide a FAPE, does placement in an aphasia special day class offer Petitioner a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?
Moot because the District's general education/RSP offer was found to provide a FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. Parents shall place the student at 95th Street Elementary School for 2001-2002; the District shall then place him in a regular education fourth grade class with RSP services in speech, reading, and writing under the July 23, 2001 IEP, and provide speech therapy once per week for thirty minutes under that IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Education Code § 56043; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)
People named in the decision
- Mario J. Ruiz, 1:1 aide, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Gustavo Cardenas, third grade teacher (witness for Student), Leo Politi Elementary School
- Rebecca Tabacznik, speech and language specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sonia George, speech and language specialist (triennial assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Ann Ervin, resource specialist teacher (academic assessor), Leo Politi Elementary School
- Patricia Novak, school nurse (nursing assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dianna Wheeler, special education compliance specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Joyce Johnson, coordinator of special education, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Bonnie Blitzstein, special day class teacher, Leo Politi Elementary School
- Dr. Delytte Thomas, school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Theresa Renteria, principal, Leo Politi Elementary School
- Ms. Meltzer, teacher (behavior rating scale respondent), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Cheryl Langwood (also spelled Longwood), RSP teacher, 95th Street Elementary School
- Marta Cupesock, certified Spanish interpreter
- Dr. Enrico Gnaulati, private therapist, Los Angeles Child Guidance Clinic
- Amy Musser, independent speech-language evaluator, Childrens Hospital Los Angeles
- Aaron Tanner, independent speech-language evaluator, Childrens Hospital Los Angeles
- Dr. Surjit Khalon, physician (District-arranged medical examination)
- Dr. Ellis N. Beesley, Jr., private pediatrician
- Dr. Sammy, physician (medical records)
- Dr. Huf, physician (medical records)
- Dr. Francisco R. Larios Arceo, physician (radiology review), Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Anaheim, California, on July 26, 27 and August 19, 20, and 21, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner (STUDENT) were MR. and MS. PARENT. Appearing on behalf of Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) were attorneys Stacey Inman and Cathleen Hall from Lozano Smith, and Dr. Joyce Johnson, coordinator of special education for the District . Ms. Marta Cupesock, a certified Spanish interpreter, was also present at the hearing.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: MR. and MS. PARENT; Mario J. Ruiz, Petitioner’s one-to-one aide; and Gustavo Cardenas, a third grade teacher from Leo Politi Elementary School. The following witnesses were called by the District: Rebecca Tabacznik, speech and language specialist; Ann Ervin, resource specialist teacher; Patricia Novak, school nurse; Dianna Wheeler, special education compliance specialist; Dr. Joyce Johnson, coordinator of special education; Bonnie Blitzstein, special day class (SDC) teacher; Dr. Delytte Thomas, school psychologist; and Dr. Theresa Renteria, principal of Leo Politi Elementary School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of closing briefs on August 27, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Was the Petitioner denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year when the District failed to provide STUDENT bus transportation for four days and his one-to-one aide failed to remain at his side on a few occasions?
2. Does the District’s offer to place Petitioner in a regular education class for 77% of the day, in a resource specialist (RSP) class for 23% of the day, which includes speech and language therapy once per week for thirty minutes for the 2001-2002 school year provide Petitioner with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?
3. If the District’s offer to place Petitioner in a regular education class with RSP services for the 2001-2002 school year does not provide Petitioner with a FAPE, does placement in an aphasia special day class (SDC) offer Petitioner a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?(Footnote 1)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old third grade school student who is eligible for special education and related services due to a specific learning disability and other handicap impairment(Footnote 2). He has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District since 1997. STUDENT’s cognitive abilities fall within the average range. His strengths are in math and reading comprehension. He exhibits deficits in articulation, speech, and writing skills. Although STUDENT can speak English, Spanish is his native language. STUDENT currently participates in an aphasia SDC class in the third grade at Leo Politi Elementary School in Los Angeles. He receives speech therapy twice per week, thirty minutes per session, and also has a one-to-one aide to protect his back. Finally, he rides a bus to and from school. The trip lasts from two to three hours per day.
STUDENT’s initial diagnosis of a specific learning disability and other handicap impairment was made when he was six years old. He attended first grade at Leo Politi Elementary School during the 1998-1999 school year. As part of his individualized education program (IEP), STUDENT was bused round-trip two to three hours per day to school. (District Exhibits 3 and 23.) The District also placed him in an higher aphasia class(Footntoe 3), provided him with speech therapy twice per week, thirty minutes per session, and a one-to-one aide to protect his back. STUDENT also received psychological therapy at Los Angeles Child Guidance Clinic from Dr. Enrico Gnaulati. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2a.) During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was placed in a lower aphasia class and continued to receive the same services as the prior year. During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT transferred to an aphasia SDC class at Leo Politi and continued to receive the same services as the previous year. The placement and the services for the 2000-2001 school year were pursuant to a mediation agreement in September 2000.
In November 2000, the District began to conduct assessments in preparation for STUDENT’s triennial IEP. On November 8, 15, and 21, 2000, Sonia George, District speech and language specialist, conducted STUDENT’s speech and language assessment. The tests revealed that STUDENT’s receptive language skills were age appropriate while his expressive language skills were mildly depressed. The oral composite score indicated the presence of age-appropriate language skills. However, Ms. George noted that STUDENT exhibited slurred or imprecise articulation, rapid rate of production, and inappropriate use of pitch. Thus, Ms. George recommended continued speech and language services for STUDENT.
On November 20, 2000, Delytte Thomas, Ph.D. conducted STUDENT’s psychological assessment. The tests revealed that STUDENT was capable of doing second and third grade work. Furthermore, he especially excelled in math. However, STUDENT exhibited a delay in basic psychological processes governing conceptualization, written expression and some auditory processing skills. There also was a slight discrepancy between cognitive potential and academic achievement in the areas of listening and reading comprehension and basic reading skills. Dr. Thomas noted that an SDC class was not challenging enough for STUDENT since the students in the class were substantially below STUDENT’s academic level. Thus, she concluded that a regular education class with resource language services would provide STUDENT with the challenge he needed to excel academically.
On November 21, 2000, Patricia Novak, Rn., conducted STUDENT’s triennial nursing assessment. Ms. Novak reviewed STUDENT’s entire medical record and also assessed his vision and hearing. Her review of the records revealed that there were no present objective medical findings regarding STUDENT’s left scapula and there was no present risk for surgery in that area. STUDENT presently has a benign cyst that does not prevent him from partaking in any athletic activities at school or home. Thus, Ms. Novak concluded that there was no medical necessity for a one-to-one aide to protect his back any longer.
On November 27, 2000, Ann Ervin, resource specialist teacher, employed academic tests to assess STUDENT. The tests revealed a wide variance in scores (from nine years and six months in math to seven years and three months in writing). Ms. Ervin pointed out that children in an SDC class are more than two years below their grade level. The tests revealed that STUDENT’s strength was in math and his weaknesses were in reading and writing. Since STUDENT’s performance was either at grade level or within two years of grade level, an SDC class was not appropriate. Thus, Ms. Ervin concluded that STUDENT’s proper placement was in a regular education class with RSP services.
On November 28, 2000 and on December 6, 2000, STUDENT’s triennial IEP meeting took place. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s past levels of performance and the assessments conducted in November 2000. The IEP team formulated appropriate goals and objectives in reading, writing, speech, math, and prevocational skills for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. Furthermore, STUDENT was to continue receiving speech therapy two times per week, thirty minutes per session. The IEP team recommended that the proper placement for STUDENT was no longer in the aphasia SDC class but in a regular education class with resource speech services. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT no longer use the one-to-one aide because there was no longer any medical necessity and the aide hindered him socially. However, STUDENT’s parents rejected the proposed placement and services. They insisted that STUDENT remain in the aphasia SDC class until the end of the 2000-2001 school year and he continue to have the one-to-one aide to protect his back. Since the District had agreed to the SDC class and aide in the September 2000 mediation agreement, the IEP team wrote them into STUDENT’s triennial IEP. The placement and services remained in effect until June 23, 2001, the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
In March 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parent’s an assessment plan. The purpose of the assessment plan was to conduct a physical examination of STUDENT’s health. In March 2001, STUDENT’s parents agreed to the assessment plan and the District began making plans for the examination. In April 2001, MS. PARENT left Los Angeles for Mexico. Before she left Los Angeles, MS. PARENT advised the District that it could neither examine STUDENT nor conduct and IEP meeting while she was gone. On May 3, 2001, MS. PARENT sent the District a letter from Mexico and again requested that the District not examine STUDENT until she returned in June 2001. Thus, the District vacated STUDENT’s initial examination on May 9, 2001 with Dr. Surjit Khalon and awaited MS. PARENT’s return.
On June 7, 2001, the District noticed an IEP meeting on Wednesday, June 27, 2001. The District chose Wednesday because it was MR. PARENT’s only day off work. After spending approximately two months in Mexico, MS. PARENT returned to Los Angeles on June 10, 2001. MS. PARENT contacted the District and advised it that she and her husband could not attend the IEP on June 27, 2001, because MR. PARENT’s work schedule had changed. MR. PARENT now had Mondays off work. Thus, they could only attend an IEP meeting on this day. (District Exhibit 11.) The District vacated the June 27, 2001 IEP meeting date and rescheduled it on Monday, June 25, 2001, to accommodate MR. PARENT’s new work schedule. (District Exhibit 10.) Finally, the District rescheduled STUDENT’s medical examination on June 20, 2001 with Dr. Khalon. (District Exhibit 40.)
On June 25, 2001, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting took place. The IEP team proposed a placement for STUDENT which consisted of a regular education class, speech services once per week, thirty minutes per session, and elimination of the one-to-one aide. However, the RSP class at Leo Politi was full. Since there was room available in the RSP class at STUDENT’s home school, the 95th Street Elementary School, the team proposed that STUDENT transfer back to it. Furthermore, the IEP team reasoned that placement at his home school was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT because he would not have to spend from two to three hours per day riding a bus to and from school. STUDENT’s parents rejected the IEP teams’ proposed placement and services. They suggested that STUDENT remain in the aphasia SDC class at Leo Politi and continue to receive speech services twice per week, thirty minutes per session. Furthermore, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District continue to provide STUDENT with the one-to-one aide because they felt that STUDENT was still at a substantial risk of injury to his back. Finally, STUDENT’s parents felt that the 95th Street Elementary School was not appropriate for STUDENT because of its racial make-up. Thus, they did not object to STUDENT’s two to three hour bus ride to and from Leo Politi school. The IEP meeting broke down because of disagreements over STUDENT’s placement and services and because of a picture which depicted STUDENT digging a hole with a shovel at the school’s Arbor day. Before leaving the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents requested a form to file a due process claim. STUDENT’s parents then left the IEP meeting. On June 29, 2001, the 2001-2002 school year ended.
On July 2, 2001, the 2001-2002 school year began. STUDENT remained in his SDC class in the third grade at Leo Politi. On July 3, 2001, Ms. Dianna Wheeler called MS. PARENT to reschedule the IEP meeting on Wednesday, July 11, 2001.(Footnote 4) On July 5, 2001, the District mailed STUDENT’s parents notice of the IEP meeting on July 11, 2001. (District Exhibit 41a.) STUDENT’s parents returned the form and advised the District that they could not appear at an IEP meeting until August 20, 2001. On July 8, 2001, MS. PARENT sent the District a letter and stated that she and her husband would not attend another IEP meeting until after the due process hearing. Furthermore, she advised the District that she and her husband were no longer available to attend an IEP meeting on August 20, 2001. (Petitioner Exhibit 13j.) On July 12, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parents a second notice of an IEP meeting on Friday, July 20, 2001. (District Exhibit 41b.) On July 16, 2001, MS. PARENT told the District that they would not appear at the IEP meeting on July 20, 2001, and again advised the District that they were unavailable for an IEP meeting until after the due process hearing.
On July 16, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parents a third notice for an IEP meeting on Monday, July 23, 2001. (District 41c.) This third IEP notice was sent certified mail. (District 41f.) On July 18, 2001, the District sent MS. PARENT a letter and advised her of its efforts to reschedule part two of the IEP meeting. The District noted that it had been unsuccessful in arranging a mutually agreeable date for part two of the IEP meeting from MR. and MS. PARENT. Thus, the District advised STUDENT’s parents that it would proceed with the IEP on Monday, July 23, 2001. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 13d.) On July 18, 2001, MS. PARENT also sent the District a letter. She advised the District that they could not attend the IEP on Wednesday, July 20, 2001, since her husband was working. Although she reiterated that they could only attend an IEP meeting on Mondays, MS. PARENT advised the District that she now had appointments scheduled every Monday for the next four weeks up to and including August 13, 2001. Thus, they could not attend an IEP meeting until August 20, 2001, or thereafter. Furthermore, MS. PARENT repeated that they would not attend an IEP meeting until after the due process hearing. (Petitioner Exhibit 13i.)
On Friday, July 20, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parents a second copy of the notice for the IEP meeting on Monday, July 23, 2001. The copy was sent by Federal Express overnight mail. (District Exhibit 41e.) On Saturday, July 20, 2001, MS. PARENT mailed and faxed the District a letter regarding the IEP meeting on Monday. She again advised the District that they would not attend the IEP on Monday because they wanted to proceed to hearing first and they were unavailable until August 20, 2001. MS. PARENT also sent her letter certified mail. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 13h and 13n.) On Monday morning, July 23, 2001, MS. PARENT called the District regarding the IEP meeting that day and spoke to Theresa Renteria, the principal at Leo Politi. MS. PARENT reiterated all of the reasons why she would not attend the meeting. Ms. Renteria advised MS. PARENT that her husband could appear without her since it was his day off work. Ms. Renteria further advised MS. PARENT that she could appear by phone or that the IEP team would come to her to conduct the IEP meeting. MS. PARENT replied that she was busy all day. Ms. Renteria advised MS. PARENT that since the 2001-2002 school year had begun, the IEP team needed to recommend, approve, and implement a program for STUDENT as soon as possible. Ms. Renteria also told MS. PARENT that the District had made reasonable attempts to set a mutually agreeable date for the IEP meeting. Since MR. and MS. PARENT were unwilling to appear at an IEP meeting until after the due process hearing, the District went forward with the IEP meeting on July 23, 2001. Upon completion of the IEP meeting, the IEP team recommended placement for STUDENT in a regular education class, RSP services, and speech therapy once a week for thirty minutes for the 2001-2002 school year.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Was Petitioner denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school when the District failed to provide bus transportation to STUDENT for four days and when STUDENT’s one-to-one aide failed to remain by STUDENT’s side on a few occasions.
The evidence presented by Petitioner at the hearing established that the District consistently provided STUDENT, pursuant to the September 2000 mediation agreement, with a placement in an aphasia SDC class, speech therapy two time per week, thirty minutes per session, bus transportation to and from Leo Politi Elementary School, and a one-to-one aide to protect STUDENT’s back through out the entire 2000-2001 school year. The District admitted that there were four days when the bus inadvertently didn’t pick up STUDENT. Furthermore, the District admitted that there may have been a few occasions when STUDENT’s one-to-one aide left STUDENT’s side to get something for STUDENT’s teacher. However, there was no testimony from Petitioner that because of these de minimus violations by the District, STUDENT was denied any educational benefit for the 2000-2001 school year. In fact, the evidence presented by both Petitioner and Respondent established that STUDENT met most of his goals and objectives and made excellent academic progress during the school year. Thus, the admitted minor procedural violations by the District resulted neither in the loss of any educational benefit nor in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT.
ISSUE 2: Does the District’s offer to place Petitioner in a regular education class with resource specialist services (RSP) for the 2001-2002 school year provide Petitioner with a FAPE?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “Specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.)
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). In Summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. It must be determined whether the District has followed procedural requirements and whether it has offered a placement that is substantively appropriate.
1. Procedural Compliance
In this case, MR. and MS. PARENT alleged that the District should not have gone forward with part two of the IEP meeting on Monday, July 23, 2001 until after the due process hearing was completed. The District alleged that it had the authority to proceed with the IEP meeting on July 23, 2001 because it had the legal obligation to develop STUDENT’s IEP in a timely manner. California Education Code § 56043 provides that an individualized education program required as a result of a assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 calendar days, not counting days between the pupils regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees in writing, to an extension. While there was no evidence in this case that STUDENT’s parents ever consented in writing to the proposed assessment of STUDENT by the District, MS. PARENT testified that she orally agreed to the assessment plan and proposed examination of STUDENT sometime in March 2001. Since MS. PARENT’s oral consent was given sometime in March 2001, the IEP team needed to develop STUDENT’s IEP by approximately May 2001. However, in April 2001, MS. PARENT left Los Angeles for Mexico. While in Mexico, she requested in writing that the District not examine STUDENT until she returned. After MS. PARENT’s returned to Los Angeles on June 10, 2001, STUDENT’s examination occurred on June 16, 2001. The District timely conducted STUDENT’s IEP on June 25, 2001. Although the District made its offer of placement at the IEP meeting on July 23, 2001, the equitable factors discussed in the background facts establish that Petitioner’s parents were the primary cause for the District’s delay in making the placement offer. Furthermore, STUDENT continues to attend Leo Politi Elementary School where his parents want him to pursuant to the provisions of stay put. Thus, there has been no prejudice to STUDENT.
2. Appropriateness of District Placement
In this case, MR. and MS. PARENT contend that STUDENT requires a placement in a SDC class, speech and language therapy twice per week, thirty minutes per session, and a one-to-one aide to protect STUDENT’s left scapula. The District asserts that STUDENT requires placement in a regular education class, RSP services, speech and language therapy once per week for thirty minutes because his academic skills are substantially above the skills of the children in the SDC class. Finally, the District alleges that STUDENT does not require a one-to-one aide to protect his left scapula because no medical doctor has made any objective medical findings regarding this body part.
In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational program offered by the District, one must determine the nature of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as of June 25, 2001. As outlined above, the testimony of the witnesses established that STUDENT has exhibited delays in speech, reading and writing.
Using this testimony as a guideline to understand STUDENT’s deficits, the Hearing Officer analyzes the assessments the District conducted in November 2000 to assess STUDENT’s speech and language skills, cognitive development, pre-academic/academic skills and physical health. Sonia George conducted the speech and language evaluation on November 8, 15, and 21, 2000. (District’s Exhibit 21.) Ms. Rebecca Tabacznik, speech and language specialist, reviewed Ms. Georges findings at the hearing. To assess STUDENT’s speech and language, Ms. George employed multiple tests. Using the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation to assess STUDENT’s speech production, she found multiple delays in speech production. To assess STUDENT’s language skills, Ms. George used the Oral Written Language Scale. The test revealed that STUDENT’s receptive language skills were age appropriate. However, Ms. George noted mild expressive language delays, which reflected the fact that STUDENT, whose native language is Spanish, is still acquiring second language skills. The oral composite score for both subtests revealed the presence of primarily age appropriate language skills. To assess STUDENT’s expressive skills, Ms. George used the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test. She found that these skills were at or above expectancy levels for his age. To assess STUDENT’s sentence production, Ms. George employed the Spontaneous Language Sample. She found that STUDENT responded with complete, appropriate although brief and unexpanded sentences. Ms. George also noted inconsistent use of plural forms, lack of noun-verb agreement, high pitch, and decreased intelligibility due to rapid rate of production. Ms. George pointed out that these deficiencies in part reflected incomplete mastery of second language skills. However, Ms. Tabacznik testified that STUDENT had made “significant progress” in articulation, rate of production, and self monitoring skills from the November/December 2000 IEP to the present. STUDENT no longer had a significant articulation deficit and only had a mild deficit in rate of language production. Ms. Tabacznik also pointed out that if STUDENT were to remain in the aphasia SDC class, he would be with children who had severe language problems. Since STUDENT’s language skills are superior to the skills of other children in the aphasia class, he needs role models and instruction in general education. Thus, Ms. Tabacznik concluded that placement in individual speech and language therapy once per week for 30 minutes and placement in a regular education classroom would meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent speech and language evaluation on September 21, 2000 from Amy Musser, M.S. and Aaron Tanner, M.S. at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles. (District’s Exhibit 37.) Ms. Tabacznik reviewed this evaluation and took it into account in forming her expert opinion. She noted that the assessment was done in Spanish.(Footnote 5) Employing the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation and La Medida Espanola de Articulation, the specialists found that STUDENT makes substitutions and omissions for various letters and sounds in both English and Spanish. Using the Test de Vocabulario en Imagenes Peabody (Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test), the specialists found that he had an age equivalent score of eight years and three months, which was below average. Thus, they concluded that STUDENT needs to increase his vocabulary knowledge. Employing the Clases de Palabras (Word Classes) subtest of the CELF-3, the specialists noted that STUDENT demonstrates difficulty perceiving relationships between words. Using the Formulacion de Oraciones (Formulated Sentences) subtest of the CELF-3, the specialists found that STUDENT did not hav difficulty planning and producing sentences. Employing the Recordando Oraciones (Recalling Sentences), the specialists learned that STUDENT might have difficulty remembering a teacher’s instructions and copying from the board. The specialists concluded that STUDENT should receive speech and language therapy two times a week for at least half an hour. Ms. Tabacznik testified that the findings at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles were fairly consistent with those of Ms. George. However, she criticized the conclusion of the Childrens Hospital report because its evaluation was performed in Spanish and not English. Ms. Tabacznik noted that the District’s assessment was conducted in English. Ms. Tabacznik felt that this discrepancy was critical because the conclusions in the Children’s Hospital Report did Thus, the Children’s Hospital report’s recommendations regarding the amount of speech therapy did not accurately reflect STUDENT’s needs as they related to an English speaking class environment. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of the District’s witnesses persuasive on the amount of speech therapy that STUDENT needed to progress and succeed academically in a regular education environment. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that individual speech and language therapy once per week for thirty minutes will met STUDENT’s individual and unique needs.(Footnote 6)
Dr. Delytte Thomas testified that she conducted readiness (academic) skills, visual perceptual and interpretive motor skills, fine and gross motor skills, social/adaptive skills, self-help skills, and cognitive (intellectual development) functioning assessments. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 23.) To assess STUDENT’s academic skills, Dr.. Thomas employed the WRAT III Test. The test revealed that STUDENT is functioning on grade level in Math and on a second grade level in spelling and reading. To assess STUDENT’s visual perceptual motor skills, Dr. Thomas employed the Visual Motor Integration (VMI) Test and the Visual Perception Skills Test. She found that STUDENT had average to above average skills in integrating and coordinating his visual perceptual motor skills. Dr. Thomas also used the Bender Gestalt test for correlation purposes with the VMI test and found that STUDENT scored lower on this test. Dr. Thomas explained that there is often a discrepancy between the Bender Gestalt and VMI tests because the Bender Gestalt is a more difficult test than the VMI. Thus, children generally score lower on the Bender Gestalt. To assess STUDENT’s visual interpretive skills, Dr. Thomas employed the Matrix Analogies Test. She learned that STUDENT’s ability to recognize and interpret concepts presented visually falls into the low average range. Using the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills Revised (TAPS-R), Dr. Thomas assessed STUDENT’s auditory processing skills. She found that they are in the average to above average range. To assess STUDENT’s fine and gross motor skills, Dr. Thomas employed the Sensory Motor Test. She found that his fine motor skills were below his age expectancy and that his gross motor skills were at grade level. Using the General Knowledge Ability Test, which comes from the Brigance Test, Dr. Thomas assessed STUDENT’s social/adaptive skills. She found that these skills are at grade level. Dr. Thomas gave the Burks Behavior Rating Scale to STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Meltzer, to assess his behavior. Dr. Thomas found that STUDENT was stubborn, sulked, pouted, and had difficulty with other children and adults. Dr. Thomas also noted that STUDENT had a one-to-one aide to protect his back. However, she learned that the aide hindered STUDENT’s interaction with his peers, did not allow him to develop socially and emotionally, and had caused STUDENT to become overly dependent on him. Since there was no educational necessity for the aid, Dr. Thomas felt that STUDENT would be more socially successful without the aide. Dr. Thomas concluded that STUDENT is capable of doing second and third grade work and would be appropriately placed in general education with RSP language services. The Hearing Officer found Dr. Thomas’ testimony sufficient to establish that STUDENT was academically capable of performing grade level work and that his needs would better be served in a general education class with RSP services.
Ann Ervin, a resource specialist teacher at Leo Politi with 20 years experience in special education, testified that she conducted an achievement test of STUDENT on November 27, 2000. Employing the Woodcock-McGrew Werder Mini-Battery of Achievement, Ms. Ervin found that STUDENT’s performance in basic skills, which is a combination of reading, writing and mathematics, is within the low average range of scores. On the reading tests, which include letter and word identification, vocabulary, and comprehension skills, STUDENT’s performance was within the average range of scores for his age level. On the writing tests, which includes punctuation, capitalization, spelling, and word usage skills, STUDENT’s performance is within the low range of scores. On the mathematics tests, which includes calculations, practical problems, and knowledge of math concepts and vocabulary, his performance is within the average range of scores for his age level. Ms. Ervin testified that STUDENT’s strength is in math and his weaknesses are in reading and writing. Ms. Ervin pointed out that while STUDENT’s writing skills were a little below grade level, they were still above the level of the other children in the SDC class. She noted that the academic skills of the children in the SDC class are two years or more below their grade level while the acadeic skills of children in the RSP class are within two years of their grade level. Since STUDENT’s speech, reading, and writing skills are within two years of grade level and his math skills are at or above grade level, he would be more appropriately placed in a regular education class. Thus, Ms. Ervin concluded that STUDENT could succeed in a regular education class with modifications and this placement was most educationally appropriate for him for the 2001-2002 school year.(Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer found Ms. Ervin’s testimony sufficient to establish that STUDENT’s unique and individual needs would be met in a general education class with RSP speech and language services. Patricia Novak, R.N., the school nurse, testified that she conducted STUDENT’s three-year nursing assessment on November 21, 2001. As part of the assessment, Ms. Novak reviewed STUDENT’s medical records. Ms. Novak reviewed a medical evaluation from a physician named Dr. Sammy and a medical evaluation from a Dr. Huf. The reports revealed that STUDENT previously had surgery in November 1996 and January 1997 on his left scapula for a benign cyst. However, STUDENT had no additional surgery since that time and the doctors made no additional objective findings regarding STUDENT’s left scapula. Dr. Huf prescibed medication for STUDENT’s headaches. Ms. Novak also reviewed Dr. Surjit Khalon’s medical evaluation dated June 20, 2001. Dr. Khalon’s neurological examination was normal. Her orthopedic examination revealed a healed surgical scar over the medial aspect of the left scapula. Although STUDENT had subjective pain and tenderness in the left scapula region, there were no objective medical findings to substantiate STUDENT’s subjective complaints . Doctor Khalon concluded that STUDENT needed an adaptive physical education screening, speech screening, and appropriate educational help. However, Dr. Khalon did not recommend a one-to-one aide to protect STUDENT’s back. (District Exhibit 9.)
Ms. Novak next reviewed medical records from STUDENT’s pediatrician, Dr. Ellis N. Beesley, Jr., M.D. (District Exhibits 8 and 42 and Petitioner Exhibit 15.) She first reviewed a report dated June 22, 2001. Ms. Novak pointed out that Dr. Beasley did not examine STUDENT before writing the report. Dr. Beesley noted that STUDENT is scheduled to have a magnetic resonance image (MRI) taken of his left scapula in August 2002. He indicated that STUDENT receives physical therapy at home three time per week for his left shoulder.(Footnote 8) He recommended that STUDENT continue with his speech therapy. Dr. Beasley did not produce any objective medical findings regarding STUDENT’s left scapula. He concluded that STUDENT was not capable of attending a regular education class, should be in a small class, should continue to have a one-to-one aide to protect his back, and should continue with speech therapy. In a follow-up report dated August 16, 2001, Dr. Beesley stated that STUDENT was in a class with “mentally retarded” children and that such a placement was not necessary for STUDENT. In his opinion, STUDENT should be with “normal” children. Although Dr. Beasley continued to recommend speech therapy for STUDENT, he stated that “there is no educational or medical reason, in my opinion, that STUDENT have a one-on-one aide at the present time.” In a third follow-up report dated August 21, 2001, Dr. Beesley reported that he was not qualified to give an opinion regarding the necessity of a one-to-one aide for STUDENT. He felt that this decision should be made by a specialist.
Ms. Novak next reviewed a radiological report provided by MS. PARENT. On June 4, 2001, MS. PARENT had Dr. Francisco R. Larios Arceo in Guadalajara, Jalisco, review an MRI taken of STUDENT’s left scapula sometime in 2000. Mexico. Dr. Arcero interpreted the MRI to indicate that STUDENT still had a back mass in the left scapula. While Dr. Arceo stated that STUDENT should avoid injury to this body part, he did not state that STUDENT needs a one-to-one aide to protect his back. As part of her assessment of STUDENT, Ms. Novak testified that she also observed and examined STUDENT. At school, she observed STUDENT playing without any limitations. STUDENT’s parents testified to the same fact. Furthermore, she assessed his vision and hearing and found them to be within normal. Ms. Novak concluded that based upon her review of STUDENT’s entire medical record and her examination of STUDENT, there was no present medical necessity for a one-to-one aide to protect STUDENT’s back and he could be educated in a regular education class with services. The Hearing Office finds the lack of any present objective medical findings in STUDENT’s left scapula, the failure of three physicians to recommend a one-to-one aide, and STUDENT’s ability to participate to play numerous without any physical limitation sufficient to establish that STUDENT does not require a one-to-one aide to protect his back. The Hearing further finds sufficient evidence to establish that STUDENT can be educated in a regular education class with services. The District’s assessments and testimony from the witnesses, then, reveal that STUDENT’s areas of need are in speech, reading and writing.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs is to examine the July 23, 2001 IEP. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. They are developed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the special education, related services and supplementary aides that will assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. Section 1414(d)(1)(A) (ii), (iii).
The July 23, 2001 IEP (District’s Exhibit 39), sets forth the goals and objectives to address STUDENTs’ unique needs in speech, reading, and writing. The speech objectives focused on rate of speech. The reading objectives focused on articulation, accuracy, and fluency. The written language goals focused on writing sentences and paragraphs. Thus, these goals and objectives in the July 23, 2001 IEP were in conformity with the findings in the assessments and designed to meet STUDENTs’s unique needs.
2. Program designed to meet STUDENTs’ Needs
Based upon the assessments and the goals and objectives outlined in the July 23, 2001 IEP, the District presented oral and documentary evidence to establish that its placement and services at the 95th Street School were designed to meet STUDENTs’ unique needs. The District first presented evidence that the RSP class was taught by a qualified teacher, Ms. Cheryl Langwood. Doctor Joyce Johnson, coordinator of special education, described Ms. Longwoods credentials. Doctor Johnson testified that Ms. Longwood had her Bachelors of Arts degree and a Master of Arts degree in special education with an emphasis in special education curriculum development. Doctor Johnson pointed out that Ms. Longwood had been teaching handicapped children since 1988 and had been an RSP teacher since 1992.
The Districts witnesses testified about how the placement would foster STUDENT’s academic and speech and language needs. First, they testified that the RSP service would concentrate on his deficits in speech, reading and writing. In speech, the RSP teacher will focus on rate of production using oral language activities related to the core curriculum. STUDENT will also receive the speech therapy one time per week for thirty minutes. In reading, the RSP teacher will have STUDENT read aloud. The teacher will work on STUDENT’s accuracy, fluency, pacing, intonation, and expression at a third grade level. STUDENT will also work on decoding words containing controlled vowels and consonants. In writing, the RSP teacher will work on writing sentences and paragraphs. Furthermore, STUDENT will learn how to draft, revise, and edit his work. STUDENT will also learn how to identify a topic sentence. Second, the District’s witnesses testified that the general education environment will promote STUDENT’s continued academic growth. Ms. Tabacznik testified that STUDENT will have appropriate role models in class for his speech development. Furthermore, the general education class will challenge him academically in reading and writing. Dr. Renteria testified that STUDENT will have the opportunity to continue to increase his knowledge of math. She noted that while a general education class might be difficult for STUDENT initially, STUDENT is bright enough to succeed academically in the general education setting. Moreover, the amount of time in both the general education and RSP classes was structured to STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. Since STUDENT had made substantial progress in his reading, writing and language skills between the November/December 2000 IEP and the July 2001 IEP, he will spend 23% of the week in the RSP class. The additional 77% of the time will be spent in general education. Thus, the RSP class, the speech therapy once per week for thirty minutes, and the general education classes are designed to meet STUDENT’s individual needs.
Based upon the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing by the District, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement at 95th Street Elementary School was designed to meet STUDENT’s individual and unique needs in all areas.
3. Designed to provide educational benefit
The District’s presented evidence that the placement 95th Street Elementary School will provide STUDENT with educational benefit. In speech, STUDENT will continue to learn how to speak more articulately and at a proper rate of production. In reading, STUDENT will learn to improve his accuracy and fluency. In writing, STUDENT will improve his overall knowledge of sentence and paragraph structure. In math, STUDENT will continue to increase his knowledge of more challenging concepts. Socially, STUDENT will have appropriate role models to interact and play with. Thus, the District’s witnesses testified that the general education class with RSP services will provide STUDENT with the academic challenges he needs to grow as a student and which he otherwise would not receive in the SDC class.(Footnote 9)
Based upon the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at 95th Street Elementary School was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in all areas.
4. Placement conformity with IEP
This element was not raised as an issue at the hearing. Thus, the Hearing Officer shall not consider it as part of the analysis herein.
5. Least Restrictive Environment
In this case, the parties disputed whether Leo Politi or 95th Street Elementary School constituted the least restrictive environment was for STUDENT. the focus of the dispute centered on STUDENT’s two to three hour bus ride each day to and from Leo Politi. However, the Hearing Officer does not reach this issue because the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year provides STUDENT with the appropriate regular education environment and not the more restrictive and segregated SDC placement.
ISSUE 3: Does Petitioner require placement in a special day class for the 2001-2002 school year to receive a FAPE?
Petitioner’s parents raised issue number three. Since the Hearing Officer determined in issue number two that the District’s offer of placement in a regular education class with RSP services to Petitioner for the 2001-2002 school year offered STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer does not need to address this issue. Therefore, issue number three is moot.
5. Conclusion
Based upon the totality of the evidence provided by the District at the hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement and designated services offered by the District is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, provides him with educational benefit and is the least restrictive environment. Thus, the District proposed placement in a general education class with RSP services at 95th Street Elementary School offers STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year.
ORDER
MR. and MS. PARENT shall place STUDENT at 95th Street Elementary School for the 2001-2002 school year.
Upon placement of STUDENT at the 95th Street Elementary School by his parents, the District shall place STUDENT in a regular education fourth grade class with RSP services in speech, reading, and writing pursuant to the July 23, 2001 IEP.
Finally, the District shall provide STUDENT speech therapy one time per week for thirty minutes pursuant to the July23, 2001 IEP.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Respondent prevailed on each issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decisions. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: September 7, 2001 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ slightly from those noticed by the Petitioner before the Hearing. Slight modifications made for the purposes of clarification. 2. STUDENT was designated as other handicapped impaired because he had surgery to his left scapula in November 1996 and January 1997. The surgery was the result of a benign tumor. STUDENT has not had back surgery since January 1997. He receives yearly evaluations from a physical therapist and physical therapy at home from his father. Because of the tumor, the District has provided STUDENT with a one-to-one aide to protect his back. 3. An aphasia class is a placement for children with receptive and expressive language disabilities. 4. On July 3, 2001, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. 5. Ms. Tabacznik testified that the District’s assessment was conducted in English. Since the District’s assessment was more reflective of STUDENT’s English language skills, the IEP team relied on the District’s assessment in determining what level of speech and language services to provide STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. 6. The Hearing Officer had an opportunity to communicate with STUDENT at the hearing. He was able to answer questions about the toys he played with and was also quite articulate. In fact, when he didn’t like the answers certain witnesses gave, he answered with an emphatic “no.” The Hearing Officer did hear what appeared to be a lisp in his language production. Otherwise, the Hearing Officer was impressed with STUDENT’s language capabilities. 7. Ms. Tabacznik also testified that STUDENT’s reading and writing skills were superior to those skills of other children in the SDC class. 8. MR. PARENT testified that he provides STUDENT with daily physical therapy for his left shoulder at home both in the morning and in the evening. 9. Ms. Bonnie Blitzstein, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, testified that STUDENT is very bright and “sharper” than all of the other children in the SDC class. Because STUDENT’s academic skills are so superior to the other children in the SDC class, Mr. Blitzstein felt that STUDENT was “bored,” “frustrated,” and “not challenged enough.” Ms. Blitzstein reviewed STUDENT’s report card for the 2000-2001 school year. (District Exhibit 4.) Almost all of STUDENT’s grades indicated that he was “learning, making progress, and moving forward.” Thus, Ms. Blitzstein concluded that STUDENT’s needs could better be met in a regular education class with RSP services.
