California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 6, 2002
Student v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1513-02 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Manhattan Beach Unified student with ADHD remains eligible for special education under OHI; assessment reimbursement claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Corrected decision: a footnote states that the original decision incorrectly identified the District's attorney as Laurie Lafoe because of a typographical error; the correct attorney is Nancy Finch-Heuerman.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old seventh grader filed for due process after Manhattan Beach Unified School District members of her IEP team decided in May 2002 that she no longer qualified for special education. The student has ADHD and had been eligible under specific learning disability. Since 2000 she had attended Summit View School, a nonpublic school, under an agreed placement. The district argued that a drop in her IQ score removed any severe gap between ability and achievement. It also argued that her ADHD did not qualify her as other health impaired (OHI). Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy found she remained eligible under OHI. A psychiatrist explained that ADHD impaired her executive functioning, memory and processing speed, which limited her vitality and alertness even with medication. Her special day class teacher testified that she could learn only with a modified curriculum and specially designed instruction in a small, structured class. The district's own psychologist recommended many of the same strategies. The district never showed how a regular seventh grade class could deliver them. Because she qualified under OHI, the Hearing Officer did not decide the learning disability or speech-language claims. The parents lost their claims for reimbursement of a 2002 private psychoeducational assessment and a July 2001 speech-language assessment. They had not obtained either one because they disagreed with a district assessment. The IEP team was ordered to meet within 20 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO read "limited strength, vitality, or alertness" to include mental processes such as memory and processing speed. It also shows that a student's success in a special day class did not prove she could do without special education. Finally, it shows that IEE reimbursement required the parents to disagree with a district assessment.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Does Student continue to be eligible for special education services for the 2002-2003 school year?
Student's ADHD limits her vitality and alertness (memory, processing speed, executive functioning) despite medication, adversely affects her educational performance, and requires special education, so she remains eligible under OHI; learning disability and speech-language criteria not reached.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment they obtained for Student in February and March 2002?
The private assessment began before the district's triennial assessment, so the parents could not have obtained it because they disagreed with the district's assessment; no reimbursement under Education Code section 56329(b).
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language assessment they obtained for Student in July 2001?
No evidence the parents requested a district speech-language assessment or disagreed with one before obtaining the July 2001 private assessment; no reimbursement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the order, consistent with the parties' stipulation, Student's IEP team is to meet and determine the appropriate program to meet her educational needs.
Key authorities
Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9) (cited as 300.307(c)(9)); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345
People named in the decision
- Eloise S. Thompson, assistant superintendent, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
- Bonnie Petrusky, school psychologist (district psychoeducational assessor), Manhattan Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Claudia McCulloch, independent educational assessor, Private
- Dr. Lawrence, expert witness for Student (psychiatrist specializing in ADHD), Private
- Mr. Berns, sixth grade special day class teacher, Summit View School
- Maureen Johnston, private speech-language pathologist, Private
- Summit View School, nonpublic school, State-certified nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on October 29, 30, 31, and November 1, and 5, 2002, in Manhattan Beach, California.
STUDENT (hereinafter “Student”) was represented by attorney Andrea Tytell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were her parents. The Manhattan Beach Unified School District (hereinafter “Manhattan Beach” or “District”) was represented by attorney Nancy Finch-Heuerman(Footnote 1). The District’s assistant superintendent, Eloise S. Thompson, was also present on behalf of the District.
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On November 15, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Does STUDENT continue to be eligible for special education services for the 2002-2003 school year?
2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment they obtained for STUDENT in February and March 2002?
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language assessment they obtained for STUDENT in July 2001?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was thirteen years and four months old at the time the hearing closed. STUDENT currently lives with her parents in Manhattan Beach, California. STUDENT is diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and is presently eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability. As of the time the hearing closed, STUDENT was attending the seventh grade and receiving special education services at Summit View School, a State-certified nonpublic school.
The District initially found STUDENT eligible for special education services in 1997 when she was in the first grade. At that time, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability arising from delays in attention, that she qualified for speech and language services due to delays in both expressive and receptive language, and that she had a medical diagnosis for ADHD—inattentive type. Between 1997 and 1999, the District directly provided STUDENT with special education services.
In February and March of 1999, STUDENT obtained an independent educational assessment from Dr. Claudia McCulloch. In that assessment, which included tests for cognitive ability and academic achievement, STUDENT obtained a full scale I.Q. score of 89 on the WISC-III. As a result of low academic achievement scores, Dr. McCulloch identified significant discrepancies between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the areas of reading comprehension and reading rate. In March and April 1999, the District conducted its triennial review. In April and May of 1999 IEP meetings were held and the District utilized Dr. McCulloch’s assessments to determine that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education with a specific learning disability. STUDENT continued to receive special education services directly from the District through the 1999-2000 school year.
In July 2000, the District and the STUDENT’s parents agreed to place STUDENT at Summit View School. At Summit View, STUDENT was placed in a fifth grade special day class for the 2000-2001 school year. She also received Lindamood-Bell services and DIS counseling. STUDENT continued in the sixth grade at Summit View during the 2001-2002 school year. At Summit View, STUDENT also received speech and language services and DIS counseling.
In February and March 2002, STUDENT’s parents again obtained an independent educational assessment from Dr. McCulloch. On this occasion, Dr. McCulloch only administered academic achievement tests. The District also assessed STUDENT in February and March 2002.(Footnote 1) Ms. Bonnie Petrusky, the school psychologist who administered the District’s psychoeducational assessment, scored STUDENT’s full scale I.Q. at 80. Ms. Petrusky, who also administered academic achievement tests to STUDENT, found no significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and any of the achievement tests scores on the assessments administered by either her or Dr. McCulloch.
At an IEP team meeting held on May 14, 2002, the District members of the team opined that STUDENT no longer qualified for special education services. The District members of the team noted in the IEP document that STUDENT no longer had a specific learning disability as there was no severe discrepancy between her cognitive ability and her achievement, that she did not have an emotional disturbance, and that she did not have a speech and language impairment or any other qualifying condition. The District members noted that although STUDENT did have ADHD, it did “not affect her educational performance to a degree beyond the impact of her cognitive ability to rise to the level of the OHI [Other Health Impairment] eligibility.”
On June 28, 2002, STUDENT’s parents filed for a due process hearing. At this point, STUDENT has remained at Summit View under the IDEA ‘stay put’ provisions and is currently attending the seventh grade.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that she remains qualified for special education services as a result of her ADHD condition because she is eligible under the categories of “other health impairment” (OHI) and a specific learning disability. Petitioner also asserts that she is eligible as a child with “speech and language impairment.”
Petitioner also asserts that she is entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational assessment and an independent speech and language assessment.
Respondent takes the position that STUDENT is no longer eligible for special education services. Respondent contends that because STUDENT’s score on the WISC-III fell from 89 in 2001 to 80 in 2002, she no longer demonstrates a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in any academic area. Thus, Respondent asserts, STUDENT is not eligible with a specific learning disability or a speech and language impairment. Respondent concedes that although STUDENT is ADHD, she is not eligible under California Education Code, section 56339 because she does not meet the eligibility criteria for OHI or specific learning disability, and the degree of her impairment does not require that she receive special education services.
As to the issue of reimbursement for assessments, Respondent asserts that Petitioner’s parents did not disagree with any of the District’s assessments and the District’s assessments were in fact appropriate.
The parties agree that if STUDENT continues to be eligible for special education services, an IEP meeting will be held to determine the appropriate program for her.
ANALYSIS
Issue Number 1: Does STUDENT continue to be eligible for special education services for the 2002-2003 school year?
Individuals with exceptional needs are those children who have a specified disability who by reason thereof require special education and related services, and who require instruction, services or both which cannot be provided by modification to the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3); 34 C.F.R. 300.307(c)(9); 34 C.F.R. 300.307(a).)
Neither party disputes that STUDENT has ADHD. The issue is whether STUDENT’s ADHD is a disability within the meaning of Cal. Educ. Code, section 56026 and 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3), i.e., ADHD standing alone is not necessarily a qualifying condition under State and federal law. However, under State law a child with ADHD qualifies as a student with a disability if his or her educational performance is adversely affected by the ADHD and he or she also demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting the criteria for either OHI, specific learning disability, or emotional disturbance. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339) Under federal law, a child with ADHD qualifies for special education if he or she meets the criteria for OHI. (34 C.F.R. § 300.307(c)(9).)
The Hearing Officer must first determine whether STUDENT meets the criteria for OHI or specific learning disability. (Emotional disturbance was not at issue in this case.) If STUDENT meets any one of those criteria, section 56339 requires the Hearing Officer to determine whether she demonstrates a need for special education and related services.
Other Health Impairment
A pupil qualifies for special education with OHI if due to an acute or chronic illness he or she has limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his or her educational performance. (C.C.R. § 3030(f).)
As noted above, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT has ADHD and that it was chronic.(Footnote 2) However, the District contends that STUDENT’s ADHD does not limit her strength, vitality, or alertness, nor does it aversely affect her educational performance. Thus, the Hearing Officer must determine whether STUDENT’s ADHD limits her strength, vitality, or alertness, and whether her ADHD adversely affects her educational performance.
A. Does STUDENT exhibit limited strength, vitality, or alertness as a result of her ADHD?
STUDENT contends that the evidence demonstrates that she exhibits weaknesses in the areas of sustaining attention, concentrating, exerting mental control, short-term memory, auditory processing, auditory memory, auditory attention, processing speed, freedom from distractibility, and conceptualization.
The District argues that no evidence was presented at the hearing to indicate that STUDENT exhibited limited strength, vitality, or alertness in the classroom.
Neither party directly discussed or provided legal authority as to what constitutes “limited strength, vitality, or alertness.”(Footnote 3) However, the plain meaning of these terms inform us that vitality and alertness pertain to mental processes as much, if not more, than to physical activity. (See Webster’s 9th New Collegiate Dict. (1991) pp.69, 1319.)
Dr. Lawrence, who testified as an expert on behalf of STUDENT, is a medical doctor of psychiatry specializing in the diagnosis and treatment of children with ADHD. Dr. Lawrence explained that ADHD works to restrict blood flow to the frontal lobes of a person’s brain. He stated that the restricted blood flow impairs a person’s executive functioning. Dr. Lawrence further explained that executive functioning is that aspect of thinking that allows a person to plan and organize his or her thoughts. He went on to point out that ADHD and impaired executive functioning negatively impact memory, including the ability to recall past events when planning ahead. Additionally, Dr. Lawrence said that ADHD also slows processing speed, which is the rate in which a person’s mind processes and manipulates information.(Footnote 4) According to Dr. Lawrence, STUDENT’s ADHD impaired her executive functioning, which in turn impaired her memory and slowed her processing speed.
Moreover, Ms. Petrusky testified that memory and reasoning are aspects of intelligence and that both skills may be utilized or required when a person is organizing information or engaged in the thought process of planning. She also stated that STUDENT had “very poor” memory and lacked higher reasoning skills. Her testimony was supported by her assessment results. In her 2002 assessment, Ms. Petrusky administered STUDENT several tests or assessment instruments, many of which included a number of subtests.(Footnote 5) As a result of her assessments, Ms. Petrusky noted that STUDENT’s “greatest weaknesses have to do with her sequential processing of information, verbal/auditory memory, attention/concentration, short term visual memory, visual sequential memory, short term auditory memory, and auditory processing/thinking and reasoning.” She also testified that STUDENT had attention and audio processing disorders. Each of these weaknesses involve
Thus, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s ADHD condition negatively impacts her executive functioning and impairs her memory and processing speed. Accordingly, STUDENT’s impaired mental ability to plan and organize thoughts, memory, and mental processing speed limit her vitality and alertness.
The District argues that even if STUDENT’s ADHD limits her vitality and alertness, STUDENT takes prescription Adderall, which Dr. Lawrence testified “ameliorates” her symptoms, helps her to focus her attention, improves the blood flow to her frontal lobes, and assists her in completing her work. However, “ameliorating” a condition does not mean eliminating the condition or its effects.(Footnote 6) Dr. Lawrence also testified that although Adderall improves blood flow to the frontal lobes and helps the user to focus attention, it does not improve the patient’s executive functioning. He added that improvement in executive functioning requires “practice, practice, practice.” Even though Dr. Lawrence confirmed that the Adderall had “helped” STUDENT and “improved” her condition, nothing in the record suggests that her ADHD or its effects on her thinking and mental processes have been substantially eliminated. To the contrary, although STUDENT was on a dose of 40 mg. of Adderall each day—a relatively high dose according to Dr. Lawrence—she still demonstrated significant weaknesses in memory and processing speed (among other things) in Ms. Petrusky’s assessments. Additionally, Mr. Berns, STUDENT’s sixth grade special day class teacher, testified that STUDENT struggles in comprehending and processing information. He noted that STUDENT took a long time to answer questions, she frequently asked clarifying questions, and she was prone to stopping her answers to questions in midstream. According to Dr. Lawrence’s time frame, STUDENT was on the 40 mg. Dose of Adderall during this time.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD limited her vitality and alertness, and although her use of Adderall “ameliorated” or improved her condition, her limitations were not reversed as a result of the medication.
2. Does STUDENT’s ADHD adversely affect her educational performance?
STUDENT, who is presently in the seventh grade, has not been in a regular education program since kindergarten. Therefore, whether her impairments would adversely affect her educational program if she were exited from special education and returned to regular education must be deduced from her performance in her special education placement.
Ms. Petrusky testified that based on STUDENT’s grades, class performance, achievement test scores, and her observation of STUDENT in the classroom, she believed that STUDENT’s ADHD did not adversely affect her educational performance. She did concede, however, that Mr. Berns, as STUDENT’s special day class teacher, was in the best position to determine whether STUDENT’s impairments adversely affected her educational performance.
Mr. Berns was of the opinion that STUDENT’ impairments adversely affected her educational program to the point that she could only learn if she received specially designed instruction in a small structured setting, i.e., special education. Mr. Berns pointed out that although STUDENT accessed the sixth grade general curriculum in his class, he had in fact modified the curriculum and STUDENT’s grades due to her deficits. Additionally, he stated that STUDENT’s grades were based on the material she was actually presented, and he specifically testified that he limited the material that he presented to STUDENT to that which she was capable of learning. Mr. Berns also explained how he taught or presented academic information to STUDENT in the classroom. He described a process in which he introduced new material to STUDENT in small groups of three students. Mr. Berns said that he presented new information to STUDENT in specific steps: first introducing the lesson, then reviewing the information with her, followed by giving conceptual examples of the materials, and then requiring STUDENT to practice what she had learned. He explained that he utilized a multi-sensory approach to teaching STUDENT that involved the use of manipulatives and visual demonstrations. Mr. Berns said that although he was able to help STUDENT achieve or approach grade level in reading, writing, and math by using these special methods and techniques, she still “struggled significantly.” Mr. Berns testified that it was necessary to utilize these special techniques when instructing STUDENT in all of her academic areas of study. In short, Mr. Berns directly observed STUDENT’s impairments to adversely affect her educational performance, and he was only able to mitigate the impact that her impairments had on her educational program by modifying the curriculum and employing specially designed instruction in a small, structured special day class.
As discussed above, Mr. Berns articulated how he was required to modify the general curriculum and utilize special instruction and teaching strategies in order for STUDENT to make the progress that she did. However, even with special education services, STUDENT struggled with the material presented to her in the classroom, Mr. Berns’ testimony made it clear that as a result of STUDENT’s impairments, her educational program would not have been successful without a modified curriculum, individualized instruction, and the special teaching strategies that he employed. Thus, the evidence clearly suggests that STUDENT’s impairments adversely affected her educational program and that those adverse affects were only mitigated by her receiving special education services. Conversely, the District did not present any evidence to support a finding that STUDENT’s impairments would not adversely affect her educational program if she were exited from special education and returned to the regular education program.
Thus, although it appears that STUDENT is currently benefiting from her special education program, there is no evidence to indicate that STUDENT’s ADHD and its resulting deficits would not adversely affect her educational program if she were exited from special education.
3. Does STUDENT demonstrate a need for special education and related services?
As noted above, a pupil ADHD who meets the criteria OHI must also demonstrate a need for special education and related services. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56026 and 56339.)
As discussed above, Mr. Berns testified that as a result of STUDENT’s difficulties with attention and memory, she required special education services in order to learn. He specifically discussed the specialized instruction that he utilized for STUDENT in a small, structured special day class. (Mr. Berns’ testimony on this point is summarized in the section above.)
Interestingly enough, Ms. Petrusky’s written recommendations following her assessment of STUDENT included most or all of the same techniques for teaching STUDENT that Mr. Berns had been employing. (Notably missing from Ms. Petrusky’s report, however, was any discussion or reference to class size, structure, and teacher-student ratio as they related to implementing her recommendations for STUDENT.) Ms. Petrusky’s recommendations were included in her report and were based on STUDENT’s individual impairments. Specifically, Ms. Petrusky made the following recommendations for STUDENT:
1. Instructions for STUDENT in a new subject area should begin with more concrete lessons and instructions and then move to more abstract material as she is able to proceed to higher levels.
2. Review and reinforce previous concepts that STUDENT was exposed to and is expected to know. Do not take her knowledge of basic facts for granted.
3. Test results indicate that STUDENT is a holistic learner in that she learns best by first being presented with the “big picture” so that she clearly understands what it is that she is supposed to do, rather than teaching her one isolated step at a time. Therefore, she will learn best if concepts/lessons/homework assignments, etc. are presented in their entirety first to enable STUDENT to see “the big picture” before breaking down the task/lesson into smaller segments. She will be least successful following directions which demand multi-step auditory memory, and such circumstances should be avoided.
4. STUDENT will require additional time to complete and master a task. This would include providing sufficient repetition of experiences to develop over-learning. Over-learning is the acquisition of a task beyond the point of initial mastery. Additionally, frequent reinforcement and review may be necessary. It will be extremely helpful for STUDENT if she can have at least 3-4 days notice prior to any test. This will allow her the repetition and review she needs in order to do her best.
5. Developing work processing skills may be a productive means toward completing written assignments and assist with spelling.
6. STUDENT will have difficulty attending and learning when information is strictly presented in lecture format. She will need to have all auditory information paired with a meaningful visual model or be able to manipulate materials in order to successfully process the information being presented to her. Having said this, whenever possible, a multisensory approach (e.g., “hands-on” learning) to learning will be much more meaningful to her, which will allow her to see, hear, and manipulate materials to assist her in attending, processing, and acting upon the information that is being presented to her.
7. When giving STUDENT a series of directions (visual or auditory), the teacher will need to check with her to ensure that STUDENT has received and understood what is expected of her. Having her work from a check list may prove to be effective for STUDENT (e.g. what she is to do first to accomplish the task/assignment, what comes next, etc.). By doing this STUDENT is able to have a visual reminder of everything she needs to accomplish (so she sees the “big picture”), and at the same she knows now to go about accomplishing what she needs to do without forgetting the mediating steps necessary to complete the task. Additionally, STUDENT may need help in initially understanding individual class or homework. It will be important for her teachers to check for understanding.
8. Close communication between home and school will continue to be important in the coming years. As STUDENT continues in school it will be very important to closely monitor the amount of time she spends nightly on homework. If she is spending more than two hours every evening completely homework, her parents need to inform her teachers so that the homework can be modified in length. The intent is to ensure that she does not become overly anxious or stressed.
9. STUDENT will need preferential seating in all of her classes.
10. Assigning a good student who is willing to be STUDENT’s “study buddy,” will give STUDENT a resource to go to in class when she doesn’t understand what to do and the classroom teacher is unavailable for the moment. Additionally, she may call from home to her “study buddy” in order to obtain clarification/information on homework assignments. However, once STUDENT realizes/experiences the benefits that can occur, she hopefully will maintain this strategy on her own.
11. STUDENT will benefit from receiving class notes in all academic classes.
12. STUDENT will benefit from receiving a study guide in each of her academic classes next year prior to taking any test.
The District, however, did not provide any evidence as to how Ms. Petrusky’s recommendations could be implemented in the various seventh grade classes that STUDENT would attend in a regular education program. For example, the District did not explain how a teacher teaching a seventh grade English class could present STUDENT with concrete lessons and instructions and then move to more abstract material at STUDENT’s individual pace while instructing 20 or 30 other students in a usual fashion. (see recommendation number 1 above.) Along those same lines, the District did not explain how a seventh grade history teacher lecturing in a regular education class could address STUDENT’s needs to have all auditory information paired with a meaningful visual model or manipulate materials in order for her to successfully process the information being presented to her. (See recommendation number 6 above.)
Although some of Ms. Petrusky’s recommendations could reasonably be implemented as modifications to a regular education program, it is difficult, if not impossible, to see how many of the proposed modifications to STUDENT’s program could be implemented in a regular classroom. For example, the District did not provide any evidence to explain how STUDENT’s various seventh grade teachers would employ the special teaching techniques recommended by Ms. Petrusky in their respective classrooms while teaching the rest of their students. Ultimately, the District did not offer any explanation as to how it would implement Ms. Petrusky’s 12 recommendations without the use of special education. Thus, the evidence supports a finding that STUDENT’s impairments presently require that she receive special education services.
Mr. Berns’s special teaching techniques and Ms. Petrusky’s specific recommendations for instructing STUDENT obviously arise from the fact that STUDENT’s impairments are of such a degree that they impede her ability to learn in the same way that her normally developing peers learn. In short, Mr. Berns does and Ms. Petrusky seems to—based on the recommendations in her report—recognize that as a result of her impairments, STUDENT cannot learn unless her teachers employ special teaching strategies for her. The evidence indicates that STUDENT has attained grade level in some academic subjects—reading and writing—and that she is approaching grade level in math. But she has reached this point in a special education special day class in which her teacher, Mr. Berns, has modified the general curriculum and employed specially designed instruction to address STUDENT’s individual needs. Other than pointing to STUDENT’s successes in her special education program, the District did not present any evidence to support its contention that STUDENT no longer required special education services to address her impairments.
Thus, the evidence indicates that the degree of STUDENT’s impairment requires that she continue to receive special education services.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT remains eligible for special education because her educational performance is adversely affected by a diagnosed attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and she demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in C.C.R. § 3030 for “other health impairments” (OHI).
Specific Learning Disability and Speech and Language Disorder
Because the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT remains eligible for special education under OHI, it is not necessary to determine whether STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for any other category. Special education law requires that an individualized education program meet all of an eligible pupil’s educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability. (See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.)
Conclusion
At the hearing, the parties agreed that if the Hearing Officer found that if the evidence did not support exiting STUDENT from special education, an IEP team meeting would be held to determine the appropriate program for STUDENT. Because the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT remains eligible for special education services under section 56339, the IEP team will determine STUDENT’s educational program based on her unique needs irrespective of whether all those needs would independently provide her with a basis for eligibility.(Footnote 7) (See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.)
Issue Number 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment they obtained for STUDENT in February and March 2002?
Petitioner’s parents contend that they are entitled to be reimbursed for the independent educational assessment undertaken by Dr. McCulloch in February and March 2002 because they disagreed with the District’s assessment and the District’s assessment was not appropriate. The District argues that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. McCulloch’s assessment because the District had not yet conducted its own assessment—thus, the parents did not and could not have disagreed with it—and that the District’s assessment was in fact appropriate.
State special education law states that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a public agency and the agency’s assessment is determined to be inappropriate. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).) Thus, the Hearing Officer must determine whether Petitioner’s parents disagreed with the District’s assessment and, if they did, whether the District’s assessment was appropriate.
As to the first point, Dr. McCulloch assessed STUDENT on February 3, 8, 15, 16, and 23, and March 2, 2002.(Footnote 8) On March 9, 2002, she prepared a report of her assessment findings. The District conducted its triennial psychoeducational assessment on February 20 and 27, and March 4, 5, and 19, 2002, and Ms. Petrusky prepared a report with her findings.(Footnote 9) (Ms. Petrusky’s report does not indicate the date it was prepared.)
Because Dr. McCulloch’s assessment preceded the District’s triennial assessment, Petitioner’s parents could not have disagreed with the District’s assessment. The District had not yet begun its triennial assessment when Petitioner’s parents obtained their independent assessment from Dr. McCulloch. Additionally, there was no evidence presented at the hearing that Petitioner’s parents objected to the assessments selected by the District or that they did not agree to the District’s assessment plan. To the contrary, Petitioner’s parents were cooperative with the District and either transported STUDENT to the District office for the tests, or gave their permission to have the District assess STUDENT at her school. By the time the District completed its assessments, Petitioner’s parents had already obtained an assessment from Dr. McCulloch. Moreover, other than in the area of academic achievement, Dr. McCulloch’s assessments did not overlap with the District’s assessments. (See footnote 8 above.)
Thus, the evidence does not establish that Petitioner’s parents obtained an independent educational assessment because they disagreed with the District’s assessment.
Regarding the second point. Since Petitioner’s parents did not obtain an independent educational assessment because they disagreed with District’s assessments, it is not necessary to determine for reimbursement purposes whether the District’s assessment was appropriate.(Footnote 10)
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational assessment they obtained from Dr. McCulloch.
Issue Number 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language assessment they obtained for STUDENT in July 2001?
Petitioner’s parents also contend that they are entitled to reimbursement for the independent speech and language assessment they obtained in July 2001 from Maureen Johnston, a private speech and language pathologist. The District argues that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Johnston’s assessment because they did not disagree with the District’s assessment and because the District’s speech and language assessment was in fact appropriate.
Again, the Hearing Officer must determine whether Petitioner’s parents disagreed with the District’s assessment and, if they did, whether the District’s assessment was appropriate. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).)
Ms. Johnston undertook her speech and language assessment on July 11, 2001. STUDENT had previously received a speech and language assessment in November 2000. There was no evidence that at the time Petitioner’s parents obtained an assessment from Ms. Johnston in July 2001, they had requested the District to conduct a speech and language assessment or had disagreed with a speech and language assessment undertaken by the District. Moreover, Petitioner’s parents obtained Ms. Johnston’s assessment in July, a period of time in which the District is not required by law to undertake assessments. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).)
Thus, the evidence does not establish that Petitioner’s parents obtained an independent speech and language assessment because they disagreed with the District’s assessment.
Since Petitioner’s parents did not obtain an independent speech and language assessment because they disagreed with District’s assessments, it is not necessary to determine for reimbursement purposes whether the District’s assessment was appropriate.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational assessment they obtained from Ms. Johnston.
ORDER
Within 20 calendar days of the date of this order, and consistent with the stipulation of the parties, STUDENT’s IEP team is to meet and determine the appropriate program to meet her educational needs.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Does STUDENT continue to be eligible for special education services for the 2002-2003 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment they obtained for STUDENT in February and March 2002? The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language assessment they obtained for STUDENT in July 2001? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: December 6, 2002 ___________________________________________ Paul Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. In the original Decision, the Hearing Officer incorrectly identified the District's attorney as Laurie Lafoe. The error was typographical, and the Hearing Officer did not actually confuse the two attorneys.
1. Dr. McCulloch conducted her assessment on February 3, 8, 15, 16, 23, and March 2, 2002. On March 9, 2002, she prepared a report of her assessment findings, The District conducted its psychoeducational assessment on February 20, 27, March 4, 5, and 19, 2002. 2. Although the District did not dispute that STUDENT’s ADHD was acute, it did argue that her condition was mitigated by medication. 3. Although the District in its closing brief cited two administrative cases (Bellflower Unified School District (2000) Case No. 449-00 and Rochester City School District (1999) 31 IDELR 178) in which the hearing officers in those cases did not find that ADD/ADHD limited those particular students’ vitality, strength, or alertness, and their impairments did not adversely affect their educational performance, the cases do not shed light on the types or categories of weaknesses or impairments that may demonstrate limits to vitality, strength, or alertness. 4. Although the District took issue with the fact that Dr. Lawrence does not have the requisite expertise to offer expert opinions regarding STUDENT’s educational needs, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Lawrence credible and well qualified to medically explain the relationship of ADHD to memory, processing speed, reasoning, and other aspects of mental functioning. 5. Specifically, Ms. Petrusky administered STUDENT the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children—Third Edition (WISC-III), the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills Upper Level—Revised (TVPS UL—R), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills: Upper Level (TAPS-UL), the Beery-Buktenica Development Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), the Wide Range Assessment of Visual-Motor Abilities (WRAVMA), the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), the Achenbach Scales (CBC, YSR, TRF), the Pierce-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scales, and the Revised Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scale(RCMAS). 6. A dictionary definition of ameliorate is “to make better or more tolerable.” (Webster’s 9th New Collegiate Dictionary (1991) p. 78.) 7. For example, as a pupil eligible for special education under section 56339, STUDENT does not necessarily have to demonstrate a discrepancy between her intellectual ability and academic achievement to need specially designed instruction in math. (See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.) 8. Dr. McCulloch’s assessment included a series of tests to measure STUDENT’s academic achievement. 9. The District’s assessment also included tests to measure STUDENT’s academic achievement as well as tests to assess her intellectual ability, memory and learning skills (audio processing), visual-perceptual skills, auditory-perceptual skills, visual-motor integration skills, visual motor abilities, and various instruments to assess STUDENT’s emotional and social needs. 10. Although it is not necessary to determine for reimbursement purposes whether the District’s assessment was appropriate, the Hearing Officer relied on various parts of the District’s assessment to find that STUDENT continues to qualify for special education services at this time. (See discussion of issue number 1 above.) Additionally, although the parties litigated at length the “accuracy” of the District’s intellectual ability assessment, the dispute primarily centered on whether the scores were accurate in light of STUDENT’s impairments. For the reasons discussed above, however, it simply is not necessary to determine whether or not the scores were accurate to determine that STUDENT remains eligible for special education and that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for their independent assessment. Nevertheless, both parties relied on aspects of the District’s assessment, including its intellectual ability tests, to understand the nature and degree of STUDENT’s impairments.
