California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 27, 2004

Student v. Sequoia Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1515-02 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

Sequoia Union High School District must pay $58,675, half of Maine boarding school costs, for omitting required public school transition plans.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 15 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

After the hearing, the District moved to dismiss on jurisdictional grounds (parental authority after the student turned 18). The record was reopened by stipulation, and the District then withdrew the motion. No appeal or remand is noted.

Summary

The parents of a student eligible under specific learning disability with speech and language impairment filed against Sequoia Union High School District in 2002. After two years at The Greenwood School, a small Vermont special education school, the student attended Kents Hill School, a general education boarding school in Maine, for grades 9 through 12. Each year the District offered general education and resource support at Woodside High School, a campus of about 2,000 students. The parents sought reimbursement for Kents Hill and for a private evaluation.

Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin found the District's offers were timely. The November 2001 delay had good cause and the parents agreed to it. He denied stay put at Kents Hill because it was not comparable to Greenwood, the last agreed placement. However, no IEP included the written plan that Education Code section 56345(b)(4) requires when a student moves from a nonpublic school into regular public school classes. A general freshman orientation was not enough, given the student's documented anxiety about a large campus. This denied FAPE in all four years.

Kents Hill was appropriate. Still, the parents had searched for private schools early, paid deposits each March, and shared the private evaluation late. So the Hearing Officer ordered half of tuition, room and board ($58,675) and denied learning center and travel costs. Because the District's assessments missed the student's anxiety, he also ordered $1,925 for neuropsychologist Patricia Mittelstadt's evaluation.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated California's then-required written plan for moving a student from a nonpublic school into regular public school classes. A school-wide orientation did not substitute for a plan written into the IEP. The decision also shows equitable reduction of a reimbursement award based on both parties' conduct.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1a(i). Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2000-2001 by failing to make a written offer of program, placement and services before the 2000-2001 school year began?

    The May 30, 2000 IEP contained a timely written offer of placement at Woodside, made by the District.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1a(ii). Did the District deny a FAPE for 2000-2001 by failing to include in the IEP a written transition plan for moving from a nonpublic school to a public school with general education classes?

    A generic, unwritten freshman orientation did not satisfy section 56345(b)(4). Leaving out the plan seriously infringed parent participation and cost the student educational opportunity, given his anxiety about a large campus. This denied FAPE.

  3. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue 1a(iii). Did the failure to include a general education teacher in the May 17 and 30, 2000 IEP meetings deny a FAPE for 2000-2001?

    Not decided as moot because FAPE was already found denied on the transition plan issue.

  4. Issue 1b. Did the District's offer of placement, program and services at Woodside for 2000-2001 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

    Listed as moot in the prevailing-party section. The discussion added that a generic transition program did not meet the student's unique social-emotional needs.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2a(i). Did the District deny a FAPE for 2001-2002 by failing to make an offer of placement, program and services until November 2001?

    The prior IEP was still in effect until October 2001. The meeting was continued for good cause, with written parent consent, to review the late-provided private evaluation, so there was no violation.

  6. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2a(ii). Did the District deny a FAPE for 2001-2002 by failing to include in the IEP a written transition plan for moving from a nonpublic school to a public school with general education classes?

    Moving from Kents Hill (about 240 students) to Woodside required a written plan, especially given the diagnosed anxiety and adjustment disorder. Without one, the parents lacked the information they needed and FAPE was denied.

  7. Issue 2b. Did the District's offer of placement, program and services at Woodside for 2001-2002 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

    Listed as moot. The discussion noted the offer was not designed to meet the student's social-emotional transition needs.

  8. District prevailedStay put

    Issue 3a(i). Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for 2002-2003?

    The last agreed and implemented IEP placed him at Greenwood, a small special education school. Kents Hill, a general education school without special education services, was not comparable, so retroactive stay put reimbursement was denied.

  9. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3a(ii). Did the District deny a FAPE for 2002-2003 by failing to include in the IEP a written transition plan for moving from a nonpublic school to a public school with general education classes?

    The June 2002 IEP again lacked the required written transition plan. This was a 'fatal flaw' that denied FAPE both procedurally and substantively.

  10. Issue 3b. Did the District's offer of placement, program and services at Woodside for 2002-2003 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

    Not decided as moot.

  11. District prevailedStay put

    Issue 4a(i). Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for 2003-2004?

    Denied for the same reason as 2002-2003: Kents Hill was not comparable to Greenwood, the last agreed placement.

  12. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4a(ii). Did the District deny a FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to include in the IEP a written transition plan for moving from a nonpublic school to a public school with general education classes?

    The March/April 2003 offer again omitted the required written transition plan. This denied the parents informed participation and denied FAPE.

  13. Issue 4b. Did the District's offer of placement, program and services at Woodside for 2003-2004 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

    Not decided as moot.

  14. Issue 5. For any year in which FAPE was denied, should the District reimburse the cost of placement at Kents Hill School, an out-of-state residential nonpublic school?

    Kents Hill was appropriate under Carter. Because both sides were at fault (an early private school search, March deposits, delayed disclosure of the evaluation, and no request for a transition plan), the award was cut to half of tuition, room and board. Learning center and travel costs were denied.

  15. Issue 6. Were the District's evaluations relied on for 2001-2002 appropriate, or must the District reimburse the parents for the independent assessment by Patricia Mittelstadt?

    The District's October 2000 assessments did not assess anxiety or adjustment despite clear indications. Because they missed a key social-emotional area, the District must reimburse the $1,925 private evaluation.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 business days of receiving the decision, and on proof of payment, the District must reimburse $58,675. This is one-half of the Kents Hill tuition, room and board for 2000-2001 ($26,800), 2001-2002 ($28,300), 2002-2003 ($30,400) and 2003-2004 ($31,850). The order calls this 'compensatory education' and 'one-half the cost of room and board.' Costs of the Kents Hill learning center and of travel to Maine were denied.
  • IEE at public expense. Within 20 business days of receiving the decision, and on proof of payment, the District must reimburse $1,925 for the July 2001 neuropsychological evaluation by Patricia Mittelstadt, Ph.D.

Total: $60,600 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Miller v. San Mateo-Foster City Bd. of Educ.; Ms. S. v. Vashon Island School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cronkite v. Long Beach Unified; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Roland M. v. Concord School Comm.

People named in the decision

  • Joyce Willett, director of special education, Sequoia Union High School District
  • Ann Richardson, academic dean, Kents Hill School
  • Ann (Anne) Bebko, local education agency coordinator, The Greenwood School
  • Janet Buchwald, private speech pathologist; conducted 2000 speech-language assessment, Private practice
  • Patricia Mittelstadt, private pediatric neuropsychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Miriam Bodin, independent educational consultant, Private
  • Stuart Miller, teacher, The Greenwood School
  • Janet Dunn, director of The Learning Center, Kents Hill School
  • Carole Grabiec, resource specialist; academic assessor, Woodside High School
  • Wendy Porter, social studies teacher, Woodside High School
  • Arlene Kolber, science department chair, Woodside High School
  • Lisa Pomi, English department chair, Woodside High School
  • Harvey Becker, mathematics department chair, Woodside High School
  • Susan Wilson, resource specialist and special education chair, Woodside High School
  • Margaret Williams, instructional vice principal, Woodside High School
  • Karen McGee, school psychologist; psychoeducational assessor, Sequoia Union High School District
  • Isaac Silberman, M.D., psychiatrist; 1994 neurological evaluation, Private
  • Arlee Maier, Ph.D., 1994 psychoeducational assessor, Private
  • Scott Brennan, writing teacher, The Greenwood School
  • Kents Hill School, private residential general education school (parent placement), Kents Hill, Maine
  • The Greenwood School, residential nonpublic special education school, Putney, Vermont
  • Stanbridge Academy, private special education school (earlier placement)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on April 27 and 28, and May 4-7, 2004, in Woodside, California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.

Attorney Kathryn E. Dobel appeared for Petitioner STUDENT (“STUDENT” or “Petitioner”). Petitioner’s parents, Mr. And Mrs. PARENT, also attended the hearing. Respondent Sequoia Union High School District (“District”) was represented by San Mateo County Deputy County Counsel John Nibbelin. Joyce Willett, director of special education, was present on behalf of the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Joyce Willett; Ann Richardson, academic dean at Kents Hill School (“Kents Hill”); Ann Bebko, local education agency coordinator at The Greenwood School (“Greenwood”); Janet Buchwald, private speech pathologist; Patricia Mittelstadt, private pediatric neuropsychologist; Miriam Bodin, independent educational consultant; Stuart Miller, teacher at Greenwood; Janet Dunn, director at Kents Hill of The Learning Center; and Mr. And Mrs. PARENT, Petitioner’s parents.

The District called as witnesses: Carole Grabiec, Woodside High School (“Woodside”) resource specialist; Wendy Porter, Woodside social studies teacher; Arlene Kolber, chairperson of the Woodside science department; Lisa Pomi, chairperson of the Woodside English department; Harvey Becker, chairperson of the Woodside mathematics department; Susan Wilson, Woodside resource specialist and special education chairperson; Margaret Williams, Woodside instructional vice principal; and Joyce Willett, director of special education for the District.

Oral testimony and documentary evidence were offered and received. The record remained open pending receipt of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the last of the written closing arguments by the Hearing Officer on June 4, 2004, the record was initially closed. The Hearing Office received a stipulation of the parties to reopen the record on June 30, 2004. Finding good cause, the Hearing Officer ordered the record to be reopened on July 8, 2004, in order to receive evidence relating to the issue of the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office to hear this matter. This contention was raised by Respondent District for the first time in written closing argument as is discussed below. The record was closed at the close of business on August 19, 2004, pursuant to the order of the Hearing Officer and the matter was resubmitted for decision on that date. (Footnote 1)

ISSUES

1. Academic Year 2000-2001.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Did the District Deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to make a written offer to him of a program, placement and services before the commencement of the 2000-2001 academic year?

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2000-2001 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

2. Academic Year 2001-2002.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 by failing to make an offer of placement, program and services until November 2001?

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2001-2002 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

3. Academic Year 2002-2003.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2002-2003?

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2002-2003 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

4. Academic Year 2003-2004.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2003-2004?

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2003-2004 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

5. Reimbursement for Tuition and Costs of Placement at NPS.

If the Hearing Officer finds that any of the District’s offers for academic years 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 did not offer to provide STUDENT a FAPE, should the District be ordered, for any year in which that finding is made, to provide reimbursement to STUDENT for the cost of his placement at Kents Hill School, an out-of-state, residential, nonpublic school?

6. Reimbursement for Independent Educational Evaluation.

Were the educational evaluations for academic year 2001-2002 relied upon by the District appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b), or was the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the independent psychoeducational assessment by Patricia Mittelstadt?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner’s Contentions

For each of the years in issue, Petitioner contends that the District did not offer a program that was designed to meet his unique needs, calculated to provide meaningful educational progress and to prepare him for independent living or college. Petitioner’s additional specific contentions are as follows:

Academic year 2000-2001. Petitioner contends that the District failed to make an offer of FAPE prior to the commencement of the academic year. Further, Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE because it did not at any time provide in his IEP a written transition plan for implementing STUDENT’s IEP should he decide to attend Woodside High School. He also contends that the District failed to have a general education teacher present at his May 2000 IEP meeting, and that it failed to consider his needs for a small school and class size. Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 because it conducted no new assessment upon which to base an offer and it made no new offer of services and placement prior to the beginning of academic year 2000-2001. Petitioner contends that the District should reimburse all private school costs for the academic year.

Academic year 2001-2002. Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001, because the District failed to make an offer until November 2001, and when it did make an offer, it failed to take into account STUDENT’s unique needs, his wishes respecting placement, and placement in the least restrictive environment. Further, Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE because it did not at any time provide in his IEP a written transition plan for implementing STUDENT’s IEP should he decide to attend Woodside High School. Petitioner contends that the District should reimburse all private school costs for the academic year and the cost of the independent educational assessment by Patricia Mittelstadt.

Academic years 2002-2003 and 2003-2004. For academic years 2002-2003 and 2003-2004, Petitioner contends STUDENT was entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School, that the District’s offer failed to meet his unique needs, that the District offered only a generic IEP, not one specifically tailored for STUDENT, and that the District’s offer was illusory in that it offered classes which did not exist. Further, Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE because it did not at any time provide in his IEP a written transition plan for implementing STUDENT’s IEP should he decide to attend Woodside High School. Petitioner contends that the District should reimburse all private school costs for these academic years.

(b) District’s Contentions

The District contends that it offered a FAPE to STUDENT in each of the years in issue, that it assessed the areas of STUDENT’s disability correctly, correctly identified his unique needs, developed appropriate goals and objectives, and made an offer calculated to provide him educational benefit in each year in issue. The District also contends that Woodside High School was a proper placement for STUDENT and that it would have provided him an educational program in the least restricted environment (LRE). The District additionally contends that its program for transitioning all students into Woodside was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Moreover, the District contends that STUDENT’s parents made a unilateral decision to enroll STUDENT in an NPS and thereby withdrew him from the public school system. Thereafter, the District contends that it had no obligation to provide STUDENT an educational program. Alternatively, the District contends that Kents Hill was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT and that his reasons to reject the District’s offers were invalid.

BACKGROUND FACTS

At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was a nineteen-year-old student finishing his senior year of high school at Kents Hill School (Kents Hill), a traditional coeducational college preparatory school located in Kents Hill, Maine. STUDENT attended Kents Hill from the beginning of his freshman year until the conclusion of his senior year. His legal residence during the academic years in issue was that of his parents, who live within the boundaries of the District. Beginning in second grade and continuing through high school graduation, STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services under the category specific learning disability with speech and language impairment.

Born on [date redacted], STUDENT’s early childhood development was reported as normal, with no problems noted other than articulation difficulties when he began to speak. Developmental milestones were achieved at or about the expected times; sitting at four months; unassisted walking at 13 or 14 months; identification of words at 16 months; and speaking in small sentences at two years. The evidence showed that he is thought of as a warm and loving child, now young adult, who is likable, friendly, energetic and highly motivated. He is physically active, plays lacrosse and soccer, and enjoys wakeboarding and snowboarding.

STUDENT first exhibited some difficulty with expressive language and/or articulation when he was a “young child,” according to his mother’s testimony. When he started kindergarten, at Ormandale School in Portola Valley, Mrs. PARENT observed that he had attentional difficulties. Toward the conclusion of his first grade year, STUDENT experienced difficulty learning how to read. He was evaluated between first and second grade and found to be eligible for special education services as stated above. During STUDENT’s second grade year, he was provided four resource classes per week, plus individual tutoring. Despite the services provided, STUDENT made little progress during academic year 1992-1993, his second grade. He exhibited difficulty understanding and following oral instructions and demonstrated an inability to respond orally. Consequently, Mrs. PARENT reported, he began to isolate and withdraw socially.

After discussions with the principal at Ormandale relating to retaining him in second grade, at the conclusion of the academic year, his parents placed him for third grade, academic year 1993-1994, at the Stanbridge Academy (Stanbridge), a private school for special education students. A neurological evaluation by psychiatrist Isaac Silberman M.D. in January 1994 resulted in identification of and medication prescribed for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Dr. Silberman’s report, admitted into evidence, noted STUDENT’s distractibility and short attention span. Dr. Silberman recommended that STUDENT continue in an educational environment that had small classes and would therefore help STUDENT to maintain focus and attention. In February 1994, Arlee Maier, Ph.D., conducted a psychoeducational assessment that validated the ADHD diagnosis. Among other matters, Dr. Maier also found deficits in motor development and what she described as “a significant learning disability.” At that time STUDENT was in the second half of third grade. STUDENT began receiving an hour of individual speech therapy and an hour of small-group speech therapy each week during the spring 1994 semester. Dr. Silberman reassessed STUDENT in June 1994. He found improvement but continued to recommend medication for ADHD and an educational placement, such as Stanbridge, offering small class size and specialized special education instruction.

Speech pathologist Janet Buchwald, M.A., conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT in June 1994. At the due process hearing, she testified that her testing demonstrated that STUDENT was making progress in the area of speech and language with the combination of individual and group therapy she was providing. She confirmed that STUDENT was having difficulty with articulation and, in addition, noted that she found language processing and auditory processing problems present. In her words, “STUDENT had a lot to say, but language deficits affected his ability to learn.”

Ms. Buchwald’s 1997 assessments revealed that his performance was declining relative to his age. In other words, he continued to make progress with articulation, but in the area of social pragmatics – the social use of language in an interactive environment – his progress was not at a rate appropriate to his age group. Consequently, he fell further behind in this area. Ms. Buchwald testified that this was a matter of concern and that his unique needs in the area of speech and language increased during this period.

In the spring of 1998, STUDENT’s triennial assessment was undertaken by Portola Valley in cooperation with Stanbridge. At that time he was completing academic year 1997-1998 at Stanbridge. He continued to exhibit significant speech and language problems and, according to Ms. Buchwald’s testimony, his progress was erratic. STUDENT’s parents testified that they had concerns that his educational needs were not being met at Stanbridge. They were not confident that a public junior high school in Portola Valley could meet those needs, and Mr. and Mrs. PARENT and Portola Valley were unable to agree on an IEP. Portola Valley contended that it could provide for STUDENT’s needs within the district at a local neighborhood school. STUDENT’s parents disagreed. STUDENT’s parents then engaged Miriam Bodin, an educational consultant, to commence a search for an educational institution that they believed would meet those needs. They concluded that The Greenwood School in Putney, Vermont, was that institution.

Greenwood is a residential nonpublic boys school specializing in special education and, in particular, the education of students who have significant speech and language delays. The student population in September 1998 consisted of 54 male students of junior high school age. Class sizes are small and each student has a tutor with whom he meets daily. In addition, speech therapy is provided. His parents enrolled STUDENT for academic year 1998-1999 at Greenwood. Initially, they made a request that Portola Valley pay the tuition at Greenwood. Portola Valley declined but agreed to use the “mediation only” procedures established by the Hearing Office to mediate this issue. On March 14, 1999, Portola Valley and STUDENT’s parents resolved their dispute by agreeing to share the cost of tuition for the NPS for the 1998-1999 academic year and to consider Greenwood the stay put placement for academic year 1999-2000.

Greenwood had students from many public special education districts. Consequently, during each academic year one of its staff was vested with the responsibility of providing continuing liaison between the school and the public school districts having jurisdiction over their students. Anne Bebko, M.S., was the local education agency (LEA) coordinator at Greenwood who was familiar with STUDENT’s present levels of performance and progress. She testified at the hearing that Greenwood is certified in Vermont for special education purposes and that all students at Greenwood are learning disabled and have IEPs to be implemented. One of her functions during this period was to act as onsite case manager, overseeing the implementation of the students’ IEPs.

Greenwood and Portola Valley cooperated throughout STUDENT’s junior high school educational program. Ms. Bebko served as an IEP team member for STUDENT, drafted goals and objectives during his stay at Greenwood, and interacted with Portola Valley respecting STUDENT’s program. She testified that she participated by telephone in the annual IEP of May 21, 1999, which recommended STUDENT’s continued placement at Greenwood for academic year 1999-2000, and agreed with the rationale stated in the IEP, namely, that a “general ed[ucation] classroom with modifications does not ensure a rate of progress commensurate with STUDENT’s ability. RS services and speech therapy do not provide intense enough service for STUDENT. ... [San Mateo County of Education’s] SDC does not provide intensity of service or small class size. NPS is recommended as continued placement [for eighth grade].” (Footnote 2)

STUDENT’s parents testified that they began looking at options available for his high school placement as early as the summer of 1999. He would be entering ninth grade in approximately one year and, considering his needs, Mrs. PARENT wished to ensure that he was enrolled in an appropriate educational setting. According to Mrs. PARENT’s testimony, she consulted with District staff to set up a tour of Woodside High School for STUDENT during which he would anonymously attend or “shadow” classes similar to ones he would be taking in high school. At approximately the same time, she met with Miriam Bodin, the educational consultant, and asked Ms. Bodin to conduct any analysis of options for ninth grade for STUDENT and recommend an appropriate high school placement for him.

Pursuant to his IEP, STUDENT attended Greenwood during academic year 1999-2000. The IEP was updated in October 1999, with revised goals and objectives modified after Greenwood completed its standardized testing. STUDENT showed improvement in most areas. He progressed well at Greenwood during this period. Additionally, he was well thought of, both personally and scholastically. The reports of his dedication, motivation, progress and performance were excellent excepting for his writing class. Scott Brennan, his writing class teacher, commented that he “worked very hard this term [fall 1999]. His ideas were very creative. He struggled most with organization and proofreading. Though he had good ideas, he found it difficult to put them into writing.” Other teacher and tutorial reports noted that although STUDENT’s progress during his two years at Greenwood was outstanding, he still had challenges in expressive language, mathematics and attentional issues. He graduated from Greenwood in June 2000.

Greenwood staff participated in STUDENT’s May 2000 IEP at Portola Valley by telephone and facsimile transmission. (Footnote 3) The subject of the meeting was STUDENT’s program for the following academic year, 2000-2001. District representatives also attended and participated in the IEP meeting because STUDENT was transferring out of Portola Valley, an elementary school district, and into Sequoia Union, the high school district. Greenwood presented updated Stanford Achievement Testing, Gates-McGinite testing, Morrison-McCall scores, the results of the Gray Oral Reading Test, the SORT and an in-house diagnostic spelling test. Greenwood tutorial summaries and teacher reports were also available for the meeting. On the basis of the foregoing, Greenwood staff made the following recommendation, “Small classroom required due to attentional and auditory processing issues.”

The IEP team, which at this meeting included STUDENT’s parents, Portola Valley, and District and Greenwood members, adopted goals and objectives in the areas of mathematics, expressive language, writing, reading, pragmatic speech, visual tracking, study skills and organization. There was agreement between the parties respecting the goals and objectives. However, there was disagreement respecting STUDENT’s transition to high school and his placement at Woodside. No written transition plan was included in the May 21, 2000 IEP. The IEP contained the District’s offer of placement at Woodside. STUDENT’s parents wrote by hand on the IEP, “We and Greenwood School maintain that SUDENT needs a small class size (12 or fewer) in order to learn. And also a small campus [sic].” The IEP contains the following additional statement illustrating this disagreement: “Parents do not agree with a public school placement and are requesting placement in a nonpublic school. Parents are enrolling STUDENT in the Kents Hill School in Augusta/Kents Hill, Maine, a residential program for the 2000-01 school year.”

Prior to the IEP meeting of May 21, 2000, STUDENT toured Woodside. He expressed anxiety, stating that he would feel “overwhelmed” by the larger school. According to the testimony of Karen McGee, The District believed that STUDENT’s IEP was appropriate for his needs, but recognized his reluctance to come to Woodside. Despite the fact that STUDENT’s parents had given the District notice that he would be attending Kents Hill beginning in September 2000, the District continued to explore solutions to this apparent impasse. In that regard, the District filed for “mediation-only” pursuant to the procedures established by the Hearing Office. Additionally, the District requested permission to conduct the triennial assessments early, proposing a formal assessment plan in August 2000.

STUDENT’s parents consented to the assessment plan proposed by the District on August 4, 2000. He was assessed in the area of speech and language by Janet Buchwald, psychoeducational function by Karen McGee, a District school psychologist, and academic function by Carole Grabiec, a District resource specialist.

STUDENT was enrolled by his parents at Kents Hill in September, 2000.

An IEP meeting was held on October 6, 2000, after the conclusion of the additional assessments described above. The testing undertaken by Ms. Buchwald showed that STUDENT continued to have significant challenges in auditory processing and expressive language. The cognitive function testing of Ms. Grabiec showed low average verbal and low average performance abilities. Because there was more information available to the IEP team, the amended IEP provided a more specific description of STUDENT’s needs. The team determined that STUDENT’s needs could be met at Woodside High School should he decide to return to the area. He continued to have needs in the areas of attention. Consequently, small class size was provided in the IEP. The IEP also provided two RSP classes per day to meet his needs for support in the areas of study skills, organizational skills, auditory processing and math. The IEP also provided that STUDENT should be taught in a school environment described by Ms. Buchwald as a “small structured setting.” Further, he continued to need speech and language therapy and the IEP offered two fifty-minute sessions per week of individual instruction by the RSP specialist. The IEP of October 6, 2000, also offered him a program at Woodside consisting of two hundred fifty minutes in general education classes, with classroom accommodations and assistive technology, and fifty minutes in resource specialist program (RSP) classes each day. No written transition plan relating to his entry into Woodside was contained in the IEP.

STUDENT completed his freshman year at Kents Hill in June 2001. The reports of his teachers related that STUDENT had difficulty adjusting to Kents Hill. At Kents Hill, the student population was more than two hundred students, all of whom were general education students, although some experienced mild learning disabilities. The student population at Greenwood was fewer than sixty students, all of whom were special education students experiencing the same kinds of difficulties as STUDENT. Consequently, at Kents Hill his grades were mostly “Cs” and “Ds.” However, the testimony established that his teachers believed that he had made the transition successfully. STUDENT was highly motivated and he wished to continue there.

STUDENT continued to attend Kents Hill in Maine during the fall of 2001.The IEP team met on October 3, 2001. Supplemental information received from Kents Hill included extensive written reports of each of STUDENT’s classroom teachers, his tutor and his study center mentor on his progress. Further, Kents Hill conducted standardized testing, the results of which were provided to the IEP team. Kents Hill staff also prepared written goals and objectives for discussion and possible adoption by the IEP team at the IEP meeting. These reports offered conclusions as to STUDENT’s continuing areas of disability that were consistent with the assessments of one year previous. (Footnote 4) However by the time of the meeting on October 3, 2001, the District had not received its copy of a lengthy neuropsychological evaluation prepared by Patricia Mittelstadt, Ph.D., an independent pediatric neuropsychologist (although it had been prepared on July 27, 2001 and reviewed by STUDENT’s parents on July 31, 2001). As a result, the October 3, 2001 IEP meeting was continued. It was eventually rescheduled to November 13, 2001.

STUDENT’s program offer changed considerably in November 2001 because of additional information made available to the District from Kents Hill and the Mittelstadt report. Dr. Mittelstadt is a practicing pediatric neuropsychologist who has general and special education credentials. Educated at Eastern Michigan University, John Hopkins University and the California School of Professional Psychology, she has been working in this field since 1990. Her assessment regimen included record review, administering standardized tests, conferencing with STUDENT, and conferencing with STUDENT’s parents, talking with teachers and staff at Kents Hill, and observing at Woodside. Her testing regimen included administering twenty-three standardized tests. Her choice of test instruments included the WISC-III, CCPT, WCST, COWAT, CVLT-C, WRAML, WIAT, TOWL-III, and TAT, tests administered by the District in October 2000. In addition, she also administered the Conners-Wells, MASC, CDI, Piers-Harris, and Achenbach CBCL, tests designed to elicit information relating to anxiety and adjustment issues.

Dr. Mittelstadt’s conclusions were remarkably similar to those of the District. She found STUDENT’s cognitive functioning levels to be lower in the areas of executive functioning (which she viewed as another measure of attentional issues), language, particularly written language, and mathematics. Dr. Mittelstadt’s opinion was that STUDENT “continues to meet the criteria for a language based learning disability, for a written language disability and for a mathematics disorder...[and additionally he] continues to have significant attention and distractibility issues....”

Significantly however, Dr. Mittelstadt also identified a psychological disorder that she testified had an effect on his education – an “adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed features.” She testified that, during clinical sessions with STUDENT, he reported to her that he had major fears about trying to integrate into Woodside, a school of intimidating size, particularly given the difficult transition he experienced when transferring from Greenwood (a school of 54) to Kents Hill (a school of 240 students at the time of the clinical interview). The fears he expressed to Dr. Mittelstadt included fantasy projections that he would be lost in the crowd, be exposed to alcohol and drugs, be in a completely unstructured environment, receive little or no individualized instruction and fail completely. STUDENT’s test results in the social-emotional area supported his statements and Dr. Mittelstadt’s diagnosis. On the Conners-Wells Adolescent Self-Report Scale, he had clinically significant elevations in all areas. His highest score was reported in the social anxiety area. His anxiety disorder index revealed second highest elevation. Similarly, the Piers-Harris tests revealed clinically significant elevations in the anxiety area, among others.

Dr. Mittelstadt testified that in order to succeed, STUDENT needed one-on-one tutoring and access to teachers on a daily one-on-one basis. She also identified his need for continuing his speech therapy, something that was not provided at Kents Hill during his freshman year. (Footnote 5) Finally, Dr. Mittelstadt reported that STUDENT needed psychotropic medication for anxiety and attention and therapy from a specialist dealing with anxiety and attention issues. She concluded stating that he needed sports for his anxiety and self-esteem issues. (Footnote 6) The IEP team accepted this statement of STUDENT’s needs for the most part.

The November 13, 2001, IEP offered accommodations to be provided if STUDENT chose to return to the District -- a laptop computer, preferential seating, and extended time for taking tests, and an opportunity for STUDENT to modify his curriculum. The latter accommodation was made to overcome a difference of opinion as to what level of classes at Kents Hill were comparable to those offered at Woodside. The IEP also offered STUDENT RSP support in each of his core classes and stated that a teacher would be assigned to monitor his attentional needs and provide tutorial support. Assistive technology was offered, specifically a calculator, a tape recorder for use in class, access to a word processing program with a spell checker, and access to speech recognition software. However, no written transition plan serving as a roadmap to his entry into Woodside was provided.

The testimony of Ms. Willett, Karen McGee and various teachers and department heads at Woodside demonstrated a high degree of pride and belief that Woodside was capable of providing an appropriate program for STUDENT. Ms. Willett also testified that even though STUDENT’s home school was Woodside, the District was willing to design a program at an alternate school within the District if Petitioner selected one. STUDENT’s parents were offered the opportunity to observe core classes at Menlo-Atherton, a smaller school campus. Menlo-Atherton was rejected. Ms. Willett testified that the District has “structured core classes for LD students on an ‘as needed’ basis when necessary.” Continuing, she stated that when appropriate “the department does direct [one-on-one] instruction for a student who had a need.” STUDENT’s parents expressed unwillingness to commit to enroll STUDENT in what they characterized as a presently “nonexistent program.”

In the planning of STUDENT’s program for academic year 2002-2003, Kents Hill staff continued to support the IEP process, providing telephonic participation, written teacher and tutorial reports and proposed goals and objectives. Thus, the IEP team had available to it updated information when it met on June 12, 2002. STUDENT continued to need small class size, more time for test taking because of his written language difficulties, assistive technology, specifically the use of a laptop computer, one-on-one tutoring and access to teachers on a daily one-on-one basis.

The IEP of June 12, 2002, also acknowledged STUDENT’s needs for continuing speech therapy. As a result of Dr. Mittelstadt’s evaluation focusing on social/emotional factors, it noted that STUDENT was taking psychotropic medication for anxiety and attention by prescription from a psychiatrist dealing with anxiety and attention issues. There was no dispute regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, only disagreement between Petitioner and Respondent District over whether his needs could be met by the District at Woodside.

STUDENT attended the IEP meeting of June 12, 2003. He expressed confidence that he was making progress on his IEP goals and that he was on a path toward college. He expressed a need for continued tutoring and work in written language. The IEP team modified his program offer somewhat, designating two periods per day for general education, two periods for RSP classes, and two periods for RSP instruction in core subjects. Fifty minutes per week of speech and language therapy was also offered. In other respects, the IEP provided the same accommodations, assistive technology and other supports as were offered for academic year 2002-2003. The Kents Hill LEA coordinator wrote goals and objectives after direct discussion with Each of STUDENT’s teachers and tutors. The IEP team determined that the goals and objectives were appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs and calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Disagreement remained, however, over STUDENT’s placement. Again, no transition plan was proposed to assist him in transitioning into Woodside.

The District’s offer for academic year 2003-2004 was developed largely during an IEP meeting on March 10, 2003. STUDENT was home for spring break and participated in the IEP meeting. Additional information available for this meeting included the reports of STUDENT’s teachers and tutor at Kents Hill. The LEA coordinator prepared draft goals and objectives. STUDENT offered no indication that he intended to return to the District. Again, no written plan was offered to transition STUDENT from Kents Hill to Woodside. The District offered a program for 2003-2004 containing the same provisions that it had offered for 2002-2003. The District did represent to STUDENT that the program described in his IEP could be provided at any of the three other District high schools should he elect to return to California. The meeting was continued and was resumed on April 24, 2003. At that time he goals and objectives in the area of algebra were revised pursuant to STUDENT’s March 10, 2003 request. The offer of program, services and placement at Woodside was repeated. STUDENT, who was now eighteen years of age, declined the offer.

At an IEP review on October 9, 2003, the IEP team noted that it had received additional testing from Kents Hill, specifically the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale and the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement III. The testing supported continuing special education eligibility under the categories of SLD and speech and language impairment. No changes were made in the District’s offer. It was again declined. At the time of the hearing it was reported that STUDENT was scheduled to graduate from Kents Hill at the conclusion of academic year 2003-2004.

The matter had been taken off calendar for mediation on July 1, 2002. It was placed back on the hearing calendar at the request of the parties on January 30, 2004. After resolving scheduling difficulties by agreement, the hearing commenced April 27, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Academic Year 2000-2001.

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District’s offer would have provided the student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also requires that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, comported with the student’s IEP, and have been provided in the least restrictive environment.

The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G v Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23.,supra, at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. 458 U.S. at 205.

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program were substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206?208.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In the present case, Petitioner argued that certain procedural violations made by the District constituted a denial of FAPE. Petitioner contended that the District failed to make a written offer to him prior to the commencement of the 2000-2001 school year, that it failed to include in his IEP a written transition plan transitioning him from Greenwood to Woodside, and that it failed to include a general education teacher in his IEP meetings of May 17 and May 30, 2000.

(i) Did the District Deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to make a written offer to him of a program, placement and services before the commencement of the 2000-2001 academic year?

STUDENT contends that the District denied him a FAPE because it failed to make a written offer before the 2000-2001 school term began. Offers of a special education program made by a school district must be specific and in writing. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The District contends that it made an offer on May 30, 2000 that complied with the Education Code.

The evidence demonstrated that at the conclusion of the IEP meeting on May 30, 2000, an IEP document was created. The document was entitled “San Mateo County SELPA IEP.” Portola Valley and the District are both members of the San Mateo County SELPA. The IEP describes the IEP meeting held that day at Portola Valley with STUDENT’s parents and representatives of both the elementary and the high school districts. Representatives of Greenwood also attended the meeting telephonically. The IEP notes that STUDENT continues to be speech and language impaired and to be eligible for services as SLD. The IEP provides STUDENT 250 minutes per day of general education classes and 100 minutes of resource services, per day at Woodside. The service period is a period of one year from the date of the IEP and it contemplates services being delivered within the District. Accommodations are recommended for his general education classes and a transition program “to adult life” is recommended for him. The District acknowledges that the offer was made at a Portola Valley location. However, the District contends that the IEP team made the offer, not Portola Valley by itself.

Upon review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP of May 30, 2000, contains a written offer of services, program and placement at Woodside for academic year 2000-2001 which was made by the District, and the Hearing Officer also finds that the offer was timely made. However, whether that offer satisfies the specificity required by Union School District v. Smith, supra, is discussed below.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

The Ninth Circuit in Union School District v. Smith, supra, emphasized the importance of the obligation of school districts under IDEA to make a formal written, specific offer that “creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any (15 F.3d at 1526).

Section 56345(a) of the California Education Code describes the IEP as “a written statement determined at a meeting of the individualized education program team....” When a student’s placement is changing from an NPS to a public school, the IEP is required to include, “[p]rovision for the transition into the regular class program if the pupil is to be transferred from a special class or nonpublic, nonsectarian school into a regular class in a public school for any part of the schoolday ....” The Education Code section continues, describing the nature of the provisions required for such a transition in very specific terms. It provides that the transition plan made a part of the student’s IEP must include, “(A) a description of the activities provided to integrate the pupil into the regular education program. The description shall indicate the nature of each activity, and the time spent on the activity each day or week; [and] (B) a description of the activities provided to support the transition of pupils from the special education program into the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(4).

The evidence showed that STUDENT was enrolled at Greenwood prior to the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. Greenwood was a small nonpublic nonsectarian school (in addition to being a school specializing in special education students). The IEP provided for STUDENT’s enrollment at Woodside, one of the District’s public high schools. Carole Grabiec, the resource specialist who was to manage STUDENT’s case at Woodside, described his proposed freshman year program as a mix of general education and RSP classes. (Footnote 7) Thus, the proposed transfer into Woodside triggered the operation of the provisions of Education Code section 56345(b)(4) set forth above and generated the need for a specific, written transition plan within the IEP.

On the face of the May 30, 2000, IEP there was a box checked, designating it as a “Transition” IEP. That reference related to STUDENT’s move from an elementary school district into a high school district. In accordance with Section 3024(b) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, representatives from both districts participated in the IEP and in the determination of STUDENT’s proposed placement in the District’s public high school. Other than stating that STUDENT would be transitioning into high school, however, there were no provisions in the IEP describing the activities that would be utilized to implement STUDENT’s transition.

Susan Wilson, the chair of the special education department and a resource specialist at Woodside, testified that a transition plan was in place, in substance. Other District witnesses echoed her testimony. They included, Carole Grabiec, resource specialist; Wendy Porter, social studies teacher; Arlene Kolber, chairperson of the science department; Lisa Pomi, chairperson of the English department; Harvey Becker, chairperson of the mathematics department; Susan Wilson, resource specialist and special education chair-person; Margaret Williams, instructional vice-principal; and Joyce Willett, director of special education.

The testimony provided by the District witnesses established that transition into Woodside is a part of the regular general education process. Woodside staff described the process as a combination of student and teacher mentoring. As Ms. Wilson testified, there are many students who enter Woodside from small schools (in fact, one witness testified that all entering freshman students come from smaller schools than Woodside). She described many of them as quite anxious at the prospect of entering a large school. To ease the transition, an older student is assigned to mentor the entering freshman student. This includes showing the new student to class locations, introducing the new student to others, and serving as big brother or big sister. According to the testimony, this program is part of the regular education program at Woodside.

In addition, Ms. Wilson testified, if the student transferring in is an RSP student, the student has a resource teacher assigned to him or her who takes a personal interest in the transition and the overall learning experience. The program offered to STUDENT had two fifty-minute RSP classes daily, during which the teacher would help STUDENT with his orientation to Woodside and review with him the materials covered in his core classes, and assist him in learning them. With this support it was stated by members of the Woodside staff that they expected that STUDENT would be successful and coupled with the normal procedure for entry to Woodside, his transition would be routine.

While the District’s contentions may have some appeal, a generic orientation plan for the general education population, which is not even specified on the IEP, is not sufficient to meet the mandatory provisions of Education Code section 56345(b)(4) which govern the special education population or the requirements of Union School District v. Smith, supra. Those provisions require the student’s IEP to specify in writing the specific transition services needed in the precise context of the facts of the student’s situation. In the present matter there was no compliance with these provisions. Therefore there was no plan provided by the District’s offer, contained in the IEP, to STUDENT or his parents that described how he would be carefully transitioned from his special education population in a nonsectarian, nonpublic junior high school of 54 students to this public high school of approximately 2,000 students.

Therefore, STUDENT correctly identified a procedural violation.

Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23,supra; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., supra. Thus, the Hearing Officer turns to the question of whether STUDENT or his parents were prejudiced by the failure of the District to include a transition plan in his IEP.

As a result of the failure of the District to comply with the requirements of Section 56345(b)(4) and Union School District v. Smith, supra, to provide a specific written, transition plan, STUDENT’s parents did not have sufficient information upon which to make a decision about his transfer to Woodside. Without a specific, written plan communicated to STUDENT’s parents, it would be impossible for them to know how the delicate transition would be accomplished. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the opportunity of STUDENT’s parents to participate in the IEP process was seriously infringed.

The evidence also showed that STUDENT was prejudiced by the failure of the IEP to include a transition plan pursuant to Section 56345(b)(4). STUDENT’s junior high school years were experienced in a protected environment. In addition to the low student population, all of the students were speech and language impaired like STUDENT. Further, the students and teachers lived in a cloistered environment. Greenwood was described by witnesses at the hearing as a rural boys school in Vermont specializing in students with speech and language impairments. When STUDENT toured Woodside to evaluate it for himself as a prospective placement, he was overwhelmed by its size, both in terms of student population as well as physical plant. It was a large and diverse campus situated in urban San Mateo County. STUDENT expressed to Karen McGee his anxiety and apprehension at the prospect of enrolling at Woodside. The Hearing Officer finds that this expression by STUDENT’s of his need for social/emotional support should have triggered the development of a Section 56345(b)(4) transition plan by the District. However, it did not.

Additionally, the evidence relating to STUDENT’s entry into Kents Hill verified his need for a carefully developed transition plan providing him appropriate social/emotional support as STUDENT had serious adjustment problems when he did transfer into Kents Hill. Kents Hill is a school four times larger than Greenwood (but nine times smaller than Woodside). The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and of Dr. Mittelstadt who stated that STUDENT would have found the transition to Woodside incalculably more difficult than his transition into Kents Hill. The Hearing Officer finds from the evidence that because of his need for support and the enormity of the change between the small nonsectarian NPS and the public high school, STUDENT could not have transferred successfully into Woodside without a carefully developed transition plan containing the elements required by Section 56345(b)(4).

In this situation, the Hearing Officer finds that the procedural violation complained of did result in the denial to STUDENT of educational opportunity for academic year 2000-2001. Therefore, for the foregoing reasons the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE by the District for academic year 2000-2001. (Footnote 8)

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2000-2001 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

The Hearing Officer has found above that STUDENT was denied a FAPE by the District for academic year 2000-2001. In view of that finding, an analysis of substantive appropriateness is unnecessary.

Moreover, the evidence discussed above shows that STUDENT required a transition plan to address his social/emotional needs related to his prospective move from a small rural campus having a support system to a large urban campus having no defined support system. Under the IDEA and Rowley, supra, the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs. The District’s offer of a generic transition program provided to all students does not meet the Rowley, supra, standard which requires a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the District’s offer for academic year 2000-2001 also fails substantively.

2. Academic Year 2001-2002.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 by failing to make an offer of placement, program and services until November 2001?

STUDENT contended that with respect to academic year 2001-2002, the District committed a significant procedural violation in that it failed to make a written offer for academic year 2001-2002 until November 2001. Moreover, he contended, the failure to make the offer until November, denied him a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002. The District contended that the delay was actually minimal, that STUDENT’s parents consented to the delay, that the services authorized by his most recent IEP were still authorized, and that the delay did not cause STUDENT to suffer the loss of educational opportunity.

Section 56344(b) of the California Education Code provides, inter alia, that a “district shall have an individualized education program in effect for each individual with exceptional needs within its jurisdiction at the beginning of each school year....” The evidence shows that STUDENT’s IEP of October 6, 2000, provided an offer of a program, placement and services at Woodside for a period of one year, that is, until October 2001. He was to receive 250 minutes in general education classes plus accommodations and assistive technology and 50 minutes in RSP each day. Therefore STUDENT’s special education program was in fact in place during that year-long period ending October 6, 2001.

The IEP meeting is required to be held at “least annually to review the pupil’s progress, the individualized education program, including whether the annual goals for the pupil are being achieved, and the appropriateness of placement, and to make any necessary revisions.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(d).

STUDENT continued to attend Kents Hill in Maine during the fall of 2001.The IEP team met on October 3, 2001. At that point in time, the authority of the District to provide services to STUDENT pursuant to the provisions of his prior IEP had not expired. STUDENT’s individualized education program was discussed. However, placement was not agreed upon and because updated testing and teacher reports with proposed goals and objectives from Kents Hill had recently been received by the District and because the District was provided by STUDENT’s parents on that day with a lengthy neuropsychological evaluation of Patricia Mittelstadt, Ph.D., an independent pediatric neuropsychologist (although it was apparently prepared prior to July 31, 2001), the meeting was continued to October 29, 2001. STUDENT’s parents signed the IEP. None of the boxes were checked indicating agreement or disagreement with the IEP, but since once of the reasons to continue the meeting was to obtain the participation of Dr. Mittelstadt, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents consented to the continuance. On October 29, 2001, the IEP was continued to November 13, 2001, to further coordinate attendance. STUDENT’s parents signed this IEP and checked the box indicating their agreement.

The Hearing Officer finds that while the continuance of the IEP meeting may have delayed the District’s written offer for academic year 2001-2002, the delay was for good cause and with written parental consent and therefore does not constitute a procedural violation of IDEA and state law that would cause loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or cause his parents to be denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

As stated above, Union School District v. Smith, supra, emphasized the importance of the obligation of school districts under IDEA to make a formal written, specific offer. The District’s offers for academic year 2001-2002 are contained in the IEPs of October 6, 2000, and November 13, 2001. The Education Code describes the IEP as “a written statement determined at a meeting of the individualized education program team....” and states that when the IEP describes an educational program for a student who is transferring in the situation described by the Code section, the IEP is required to include “[p]rovision for the transition into the regular class program if the pupil is to be transferred from a special class or nonpublic, nonsectarian school into a regular class in a public school for any part of the schoolday ....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(4).

Prior to the commencement of academic year 2001-2002, the evidence showed that STUDENT was enrolled at Kents Hill. He had been enrolled there since the beginning of his freshman year, academic year 2000-2001. Kents Hill was, like Greenwood, also a nonpublic nonsectarian school. It is located in Kents Hill, Maine, a rural setting in the extreme northeast portion of the United States. Its student population was approximately 240 total students during the 2001-2002 academic year. Thus, the proposed transfer from the nonsectarian NPS into Woodside, an urban District pubic school having nine times the student population, generated the need for a written transition plan within the IEP.

The District’s response to the lack of a written plan was the same as it offered the preceding year, namely that there was a transition plan for all students entering Woodside for the first time. As the Hearing Officer found previously, the existence of an unwritten generic orientation plan for the general education population is not sufficient to meet the mandatory provisions of Education Code section 56345(b)(4) directed to the special education population. Those provisions require the student’s IEP to specify in writing the specific transition services needed in the precise context of the facts of the student’s situation. In the present matter there was no compliance with these provisions. Consequently, the Hearing Officer determines that a procedural violation of Education Code section 56345(b)(4) is present and that the District’s generic plan also fails to satisfy the requirements of Union School District v. Smith, supra.

The Hearing Officer again turns to a consideration of whether the procedural violation determined above resulted in the denial or serious infringement of the right of STUDENT’s parents to participate in the IEP process or the denial to STUDENT of educational opportunity for academic year 2001-2002. There can be little question that the failure of the District to include a specific, written transition plan in STUDENT’s IEP seriously infringed upon his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process. During the planning for this academic year, STUDENT’s parents had knowledge of how difficult his transition into Kents Hill had been. They were therefore in need of the information mandated by Section 56345(b)(6). In the absence of a specific, written transition plan, they had insufficient information upon which to base a decision relating to his prospective transfer. Compliance with Section 56345(b)(4) and Union School District v. Smith, supra, is essential to the parents’ right to participate in the process. The District failed to comply. Thus, STUDENT’s parents were denied that right.

In considering STUDENT’s needs for transition planning during this academic year, the evidence showed that the IEP team had available to it the neuropsychological evaluation prepared by Dr. Mittelstadt. Among other instruments, during her evaluation of STUDENT she administered the Conners-Wells, MASC, CDI, Piers-Harris, and Achenbach CBCL, tests designed to elicit information relating to anxiety and adjustment issues. From the results of these tests, her review of STUDENT’s educational records, and from her clinical interviews, Dr. Mittelstadt identified a psychological disorder that she testified has an effect on STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education – an “adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed features.”

She testified that, during clinical sessions with STUDENT, he attributed much of his success at Kents Hill to the personal assistance of teachers and staff. He also expressed his anxiety over what he believed would be a side effect of transferring to Woodside -- the prospect of losing the level of support he had been receiving. He disclosed further that he had major fears about trying to integrate into Woodside, a school of intimidating size, particularly given the difficult transition he experienced when transferring from Greenwood. The fears he expressed to Dr. Mittelstadt included fantasy projections that he would be lost in the crowd, be exposed to alcohol and drugs, be in a completely unstructured environment, receive little or no individualized instruction and fail completely.

STUDENT’s test results area supported his statements and Dr. Mittelstadt’s diagnosis. On the Conners-Wells Adolescent Self-Report Scale, he had clinically significant elevations in all areas. His highest score was reported in the social anxiety area. His anxiety disorder index revealed second highest elevation. Similarly, the Piers-Harris tests revealed clinically significant elevations in anxiety. This additional information relative to STUDENT’s areas of difficulty, he argued, demonstrated that the absence of a Section 56345(b)(4) plan to transition him into the public school system would negatively impact his ability to benefit from his education.

The evidence showed that STUDENT’s diagnosed anxiety and adjustment disorders impeded his ability to transfer from the small homogeneous rural NPS to a large diverse campus situated in urban San Mateo County unless an effective transition plan was developed and provided in the IEP as provided in Section 56345(b)(4). Because the IEP contained no such plan, the Hearing Officer finds from the evidence that because of his need for support and the enormity of the change between the small nonsectarian NPS and the public high school, STUDENT could not have transferred successfully into Woodside without a specific transition plan.

The violation complained of resulted in a dearth of information relating to the plan for STUDENT’s transition and an IEP that was silent on the subject. Thus at the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents had no information and could not make an informed decision as to whether the District had taken into account STUDENT’s needs for a transition plan. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the procedural violation complained of resulted in the denial or serious infringement to STUDENT’s parents of the right to participate in the IEP process. Moreover, because the transition plan was not addressed in the IEP, STUDENT was deprived of educational opportunity. For the foregoing reasons the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE by the District for academic year 2001-2002.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2001-2002 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

The Hearing Officer has found above that STUDENT was denied a FAPE by the District for academic year 2001-2002. In view of that finding, an analysis of substantive appropriateness is unnecessary.

However, as in the prior academic year, the evidence discussed above shows that STUDENT required a transition plan to address his social/emotional needs and that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the District’s offer for academic year 2001-2002 also fails substantively.

3. Academic Year 2002-2003.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2002-2003? (Footnote 9)

Petitioner contends that his placement at Kents Hill, an out-of-state NPS, is his stay put placement from the date he entered Kents Hill, the commencement of the 2000-2001 school year to the conclusion of the 2003-2004 school year. Petitioner contends that the consequence of stay put is to require reimbursement to his parents for the costs of his four academic years of private school attendance.

The District contends that stay-put governs placement only during the pendency of the due process proceedings. The District contends further, that while a right to a placement under stay-put may be automatic, the remedy is invoked by request or motion, which provides the parties an opportunity to resolve any issue as to what may be the proper stay put placement for a student. Logically, the District contends, stay put cannot be ignored, then later employed as an ipso facto remedy to govern substantive free appropriate public education (FAPE) issues such as compensatory education and tuition reimbursement. (Footnote 10)

Under federal and State special education law, unless the educational agency and the parent agree otherwise, a special education student must remain in his current educational placement pending completion of the due process hearing procedures. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” Stay put automatically goes into effect when a due process hearing is requested. The provision is, in effect, an automatic preliminary injunction. Zvi V. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904, 906 (2d Cir. 1982). It is not intended to serve as an adjudication on the merits, but instead to serve to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program during the pendency of the due process proceeding. (Footnote 11)

The term, “current educational placement,” generally refers to the placement called for in the student’s last agreed upon IEP which has been implemented prior to the dispute [See Thomas.v. Cincinnati Board of Education, 918 F.2d 904, 906 (6th Cir. 1990)]. The placement may be one identified in a hearing officer decision [See Saleh v. The District of Columbia, 660 F.Supp 212, 215 (D.D.C. 1987)] or in a settlement agreement [See Doe v. Independent School District No. 9, 938 F.Supp.758 (ND Okla.1996); See also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j) and Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d)].

STUDENT’s last agreed and implemented IEP, was the IEP dated May 21, 1999. That IEP was the result of a mediated settlement agreement between Portola Valley and Petitioner’s parents. Petitioner contends that it is the IEP of May 21, 1999, that governs STUDENT’s stay put placement. The District disagrees.

The stay put question in this matter is complicated by virtue of the fact that the academic years in issue are years STUDENT’s IEPs were the responsibility of the Respondent District while he attended school at Kents Hill, but his last implemented IEP was one agreed upon during a year he attended school at the Greenwood while he was under the jurisdiction of a predecessor district, Portola Valley.

The general rule for students transferring into a new school district in a new local plan area is that the receiving district is obligated to adopt a plan temporarily, an interim plan, that approximates the IEP of the transferring district as closely as possible within the resources of the receiving district. Ms. S. v. Vashon Island School District 337 F2d 1115, 1133-1135,(9th Cir. 2003); Cal. Educ. Code § 56325. STUDENT’s last agreed and implemented IEP, dated May 21, 1999, was the result of mediation between Portola Valley and Petitioner’s parents.

The Hearing Office received the present request for a due process proceeding on July 1, 2002. At that time, STUDENT had just completed his ninth grade year at Kents Hill. Stay put governs a student’s placement during the pendency of the due process hearing. Thus, stay put was in effect on July 1, 2002. STUDENT did not request a stay put order from the Hearing Office until the first day of the present hearing. His present request is for an order establishing his right to stay put at Kents Hill retroactively. Consequently, he seeks reimbursement of tuition for the years the District allegedly violated his right to stay put. (Footnote 12)

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT would not have been entitled to an order establishing his right to stay put at Kents Hill because the program at Kents Hill is not comparable to that specified in his last agreed and implemented IEP -- Greenwood. The evidence demonstrated that Greenwood is a small, specialized boys school, serving special education students up through the eighth grade and having a student population of 54 students. Each of the students at Greenwood is speech and language impaired. Its mission is to serve students with language-based disabilities. Each of the students at Greenwood has an IEP. Portola Valley agreed with STUDENT’s parents during mediation to pay one-half the tuition cost of the Greenwood placement because of the individual attention afforded to each student at Greenwood and the focus of the school on speech and language issues with qualified special education resource support.

A placement at Kents Hill is not comparable to the placement at Greenwood. It is true that Kents Hill and Greenwood are both out of state nonpublic schools. However, there the similarity ends. The student population at Kents Hill is not similar to Greenwood. Kents Hill has approximately 240 students. Further, it serves a general education population, not a special education population. There are no special education classes at Kents Hill. STUDENT was not provided with a speech and language program or with special education resource support at Kents Hill. Therefore, the stay put order requested by Petitioner would not have resulted in maintaining STUDENT’s current educational placement as described in his last agreed IEP.

Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for stay put at Kents Hill is denied.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

An IEP meeting was convened on June 12, 2002, for the purpose of developing a program offer for academic year 2002-2003. The Hearing Officer observes that the District maintained focus on STUDENT’s unique needs and continued to refine its offer to design a program to address those needs. However a continuing and fatal flaw in the District’s offer was the failure to set forth a written transition plan in a situation where one was required by Union School District v. Smith, supra, and Section 563435(b)(4) of the California Education Code, and where one was clearly essential to address STUDENT’s unique needs, which according to persuasive testimony had not changed.

But for the lack of a written plan to transition STUDENT from his small nonsectarian NPS in Maine to a large public high school in California, the Hearing Officer would analyze the District’s offer for academic year 2002-2003 to determine whether the District’s continuing refinements were appropriate. However, once again the written transition plan is absent from the District’s offer. The Hearing Officer finds that one is necessary to provide STUDENT’s parents sufficient information on which to make a decision about his transfer and thus participate in the IEP process. Finally, the absence of a transition plan continues to violate the provisions of California Education Code section 56345(b)(4) and both procedurally and substantively denies STUDENT a FAPE for the reasons discussed previously.

4. Academic Year 2003-2004.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2003-2004?

Petitioner’s request for stay put extends to academic year 2003-2004. No new facts were alleged in support of the request for stay put for this, STUDENT’s senior year. The Hearing Officer finds that the stay put order requested by Petitioner would not result in maintaining his “current educational placement” as described in his last agreed IEP because the program at Kents Hill is not comparable to that at Greenwood. Therefore, the request is denied.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

STUDENT attended the IEP meeting of March 10, 2003, for the purpose of providing input to the IEP team that was in the process of developing a program offer for academic year 2003-2004. The IEP team received STUDENT’s input and agreed to meet again on April 24, 2003, at which time it made its offer. The testimony established that the District continued to refine its program offer in an attempt to offer STUDENT a program that would bring him back into the District. However the continuing and fatal flaw in the District’s offer was the failure to set forth a written transition plan in a situation where one was required by Section 563435(b)(4) and Union School District v. Smith, supra, and where one was clearly essential to address STUDENT’s unique needs, which were the same as established by the persuasive testimony of Dr. Mittelstadt.

Once again the written transition plan required by the Education Code was absent from the District’s offer. The absence of such a transition plan for academic year 2003-2004 continues to violate the provisions of California Education Code section 56345(b)(4) and the requirements of Union School District v. Smith, supra. The Hearing Officer also finds for the reasons stated previously that a written transition plan is necessary to provide STUDENT’s parents sufficient information about his prospective transfer to permit them to make an informed decision about the District’s offer and thus participate in the IEP process. Moreover, on the facts established previously, the absence of such a plan in his IEP denies STUDENT educational opportunity, and fails to meet his unique needs, resulting in denial to him of a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004.

5. Reimbursement for Tuition and Costs of Placement at NPS.

If the Hearing Officer finds that any of the District’s offers for academic years 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 did not offer to provide STUDENT a FAPE, should the District be ordered, for any year in which that finding is made, to provide reimbursement to STUDENT for the cost of his placement at Kents Hill School, an out of state, residential, nonpublic school?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994). See also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services procured are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra.

STUDENT’s parents have requested reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s private school placement at Kents Hill from September 2000 to the date the hearing concluded in May 2004. The District contended that STUDENT’s parents made a voluntary choice to enroll him in a private school that would not qualify as an appropriate placement. Thus, they contended, they had no obligation to reimburse STUDENT’s parents.

When considering a request for reimbursement, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. In the present case the Hearing Officer has determined above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in each of the academic years in issue because of the failure of the District to provide a written transition plan for STUDENT’s proposed transition into Woodside that would meet STUDENT’s needs for support upon his entry into Woodside, in view of the severity of his disability in the area of social-emotional functioning.

The Hearing Officer now turns to an examination of whether the placement made by the parents provided the student an appropriate education. The parents are not held to a requirement that the private school be readily identifiable as a special education placement that provides a FAPE conforming to the specific provisions of the IDEA. However, the private placement must provide an education reasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefit. Florence county Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).

The evidence established that Kents Hill took an active part in STUDENT’s IEP meetings. It produced records, reports and standardized test results by which the IEP team could determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance, his progress on goals and objectives. The school also drafted proposed goals and objectives for each IEP meeting and, through its LEA coordinator, participated in the IEP meetings. Further, the testimony of the staff at Kents Hill established that it provided STUDENT an educational program that was designed to meet each of STUDENT’s needs as established by his IEPs and by the evaluation of Dr. Mittelstadt. It had small class sizes, one-to-one instruction, tutoring and mentoring, a supported study center similar to the description of Woodside’s RSP class excepting for the credentials of the teacher, assistive technology, and accommodations designed to address attentional issues. The written reports of consultations with STUDENT and the reports describing his progress showed that STUDENT’s teachers and advisors stayed current with his progress and supported his educational program. From the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer also finds that the program at Kents Hill was reasonably calculated to enable STUDENT to receive educational benefit. Moreover, STUDENT made substantial progress at Kent’s Hill as indicated by his report cards and progress reports, and he met his goal of admission to a four-year college following high school.

Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties W.G. V. Board of Trustees of Target Range School district No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d 1479 at 1486. In the recent case of Miller v. San Mateo-Foster City Board of Education (ND Ca. 2004) 41 IDELR 125, the U.S. District Court approved the approach of the hearing officer of assessing the conduct of both parties when determining the appropriateness of awarding compensation as equitable relief. The Hearing Officer observed that the student’s parents in that case were not interested in a District school placement and instead intended to keep their son in private school because they thought his needs were better served by the private school. In Miller, supra, the court affirmed the hearing officer’s finding, stating that because the student’s parents had no interest in public school placement and would have enrolled him in private school in any case, they suffered no compensable loss.

As in the Miller case cited above, the question arises as to whether STUDENT’s parents intended to enroll him at any District school under any circumstances. Mitigating against reimbursement is the evidence that STUDENT’s parents conducted a search for a private high school as early as mid-school year 1998-1999, his last year at Greenwood. They had neither toured Woodside nor conferenced with District staff at that time, thus had no experience on which to rule it out as a potential high school placement for STUDENT. They retained Miriam Bodin at the beginning of 1999 to conduct the search. Ms. Bodin is an experienced certified educational planner, who had been consulted previously when STUDENT had been transitioning from Stanbridge Academy to Greenwood. Ms. Bodin, a very knowledgeable consultant, testified that after she reviewed STUDENT’s reports and test results, she concluded that his needs were for small classes with one-to-one support, available teachers for tutoring, a socially safe and structured environment and, most importantly, a school with a strong LD department. Ms. Bodin recommended “several schools” to STUDENT’s parents, all of which were outside of California.

In addition to identifying a private school as early as calendar year 1999, STUDENT’s parents consistently paid the tuition and room and board deposits at Kents Hill in March of each preceding school year. This is one indication that at the spring IEP meetings at which the District’s offers were made for the school years commencing the following September, the decision to enroll STUDENT had already been made. Moreover, the neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Dr. Mittelstadt had been prepared on July 27, 2001, and discussed by Dr. Mittelstadt with STUDENT’s parents on July 31, 2001. But this report, which contained significant information relative to STUDENT’s social-emotional needs, was withheld from the District. It was not delivered until the IEP meeting of October 3, 2001. The delay necessitated a continuance and rescheduling of the meeting. Withholding pertinent information from an IEP team casts some doubt on the parents’ motives. One result of withholding the information was to delay the District’s amended offer for academic year 2001-2002 until well into the school year.

In addition it should be noted that there was no testimonial evidence or reference in the IEPs that STUDENT’s parents or STUDENT requested the development of a written transition plan. Although providing such a plan was the District’s obligation, there is no legal impediment to stepping forward with a request if the District fails to meet its obligation. The fact that no request was made tends to raise the question as to whether either STUDENT or his parents were interested in a plan that would help him transition to Woodside. The evidence was unequivocal in demonstrating that STUDENT’s parents were dedicated to their son’s education. It also appears from the evidence presented, including the testimony of the Kents Hill staff, that the intensity of the intimate campus and degree of individual attention and tutoring support available at Kents Hill was believed to be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT a better education than would the offer at Woodside. The Hearing Officer concludes that the choice of Kents Hill by STUDENT’s parents was made on that basis and whether a written transition plan existed or not was important to them as a practical matter.

On the other hand, STUDENT did not fit the definition of a voluntarily placed private school student as the District contends. In each of the years, his parents stated that they made the placement because, they contended, STUDENT was not offered a FAPE. That contention was found to be true by the Hearing Officer, as discussed above. See California Education Code § 56175. Further, the District was at fault because it did not fulfill its obligations. It failed to take STUDENT’s social-emotional limitations into account and thus the violation of Section 56345(b)(4) and the failure to meet the requirements of Union School District v Smith, supra, were significant, denying STUDENT an offer of FAPE.

In short, both parties have a degree of fault in this matter. Equity, connoting a concept of fairness, dictates that the District and STUDENT’s parents share the cost of his tuition, room and board for the four academic years in issue. The evidence established that tuition, and room and board costs are as follows:

Academic year 2000-2001 $26,800 Academic year 2001-2002 $28,300 Academic year 2002-2003 $30,400 Academic year 2003-2004 $31,850

One-half that cost is $58,675. That sum is hereby awarded to the Petitioner on the basis set forth above.

The Hearing Officer declines to add two costs to the reimbursement list claimed by Petitioner. First, the cost of attending the learning (study) center at Kents Hill is denied. This center, while worthwhile for STUDENT, represents the “Cadillac” of programs, not a reasonable expense that approximates the standard of education addressed in Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, or Cronkite v. Long Beach Unified School District, 176 F.3d 482(9th Cir., 1999). Secondly, the Hearing Officer declines to reimburse the cost of transportation to Maine, also claimed by Petitioner. The Hearing Officer, exercising his equitable powers, finds that cost to be excessive. An adequate showing was not made by the Petitioner that in order to obtain an education, he was required to select a school as far away from his home district as is possible in the continental United States.

6. Reimbursement for Independent Educational Evaluation.

Were the educational evaluations for academic year 2001-2002 relied upon by the District appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b) or, was the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the independent psychoeducational assessment by Patricia Mittelstadt?

The law requires school districts to assess students in all areas of suspected disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(B)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. One of the purposes of an assessment is to determine the unique needs of the student by providing relevant information for the development of appropriate individual programs for the student. 20 U.S.C.§ 1414(b)(3)(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56321.

Petitioner obtained his own neuropsychological evaluation in July 2001 from Dr. Mittelstadt. A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational evaluation of the student at district expense, “if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was ‘appropriate.’ ” Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5. The results of an independent educational assessment shall be considered by the school district and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R.§ 300.502(b). Dr. Mittelstadt’s evaluation was admitted into evidence at the due process hearing.

Before determining whether the cost of the assessment should be reimbursed, there are two threshold issues that must be determined. The first issue for the Hearing Officer to determine is whether the parents “disagreed with an evaluation....”. If that threshold is reached, the next question is whether the District’s assessments were “appropriate.”

In this case, STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the District’s assessments that were conducted for the October 6, 2000 IEP meeting. They contended that the assessments were incomplete and therefore did not identify all areas of STUDENT’s suspected disability. In short, the parents contend that the District’s assessments were accurate as far as they went. But they felt the testing did not go far enough. STUDENT’s parents contended that the District did not test for anxiety and adjustment disorder even though there were clues in the clinical information relating to STUDENT’s ADHD and anxiety, that the District possessed, that should have prompted testing in these areas.

Turning now to examine the District’s assessments, the evidence shows that the District obtained consent from STUDENT’s parents to conduct assessments in advance of the October 6, 2000 IEP meeting. He was timely assessed in the area of speech and language by Janet Buchwald, psychoeducational function by Karen McGee, a District school psychologist, and academic function by Carole Grabiec, a District resource specialist. Ms. Buchwald’s evaluation showed that STUDENT continued to have significant challenges in auditory processing and expressive language. Ms. McGee’s psychoeducational testing utilized standardized tests typically administered in conducting an assessment. The testing focused cognitive processing and showed low average verbal and low average performance abilities, indications of auditory processing and impulsivity, and significant attentional issues. The academic testing of Ms. Grabiec showed strength in reading, some difficulties with math and weaknesses in written language. None of the assessors assessed or identified an anxiety or adjustment disorder, or prospective issue, despite the fact that they knew STUDENT had an ADHD diagnosis, he had expressed fear and anxiety about transferring, and Greenwood staff advised them that he was leaving a small, protected environment and would need supports.

Dr. Mittelstadt testified that the District had indications of anxiety and adjustment disorder in its records and testing. For example, she stated that one clue available to the District through STUDENT’s school records was his diagnosis of ADHD, which was made in 1994. She testified that attentional issues and anxiety are frequently found together; pointing out that anxiety is part of the description of “attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder.” Moreover, she pointed out that STUDENT directly expressed to District staff his fear of the bigger District school and his anxiety about the prospect of attending.

Confirming Dr. Mittelstadt’s opinion, we learned from the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers at Greenwood that his transfer from Stanbridge to Greenwood was difficult. And, later we learned from his Kents Hill advisor reports and his mother’s testimony that STUDENT’s first year at Kents Hill was fraught with anxiety and adjustment problems.

In short, the Hearing Officer concludes from the evidence that the District’s testing was missing a key element of STUDENT’s disability. The Hearing Officer finds therefore that the District’s assessments missed identifying a key social-emotional component that interfered with STUDENT’s ability to receive a FAPE. The tests administered by and relied upon by the District were insufficiently designed to identify STUDENT’s impaired skills. Thus, the District’s evaluations did not correctly identify all areas of his disabilities.

Dr. Mittelstadt utilized some of the same test instruments as the District. However, where the District did not, she also focused on STUDENT’s social/emotional issues. As part of her assessment of July 2001, Dr. Mittelstadt administered the Conners-Wells, MASC, CDI, Piers-Harris, and Achenbach CBCL, tests designed to elicit information relating to anxiety and adjustment issues. From the results of these tests, her review of STUDENT’s educational records, and from her clinical interviews, Dr. Mittelstadt identified a psychological disorder that she testified had an effect on STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education – an “adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed features.” Dr. Mittelstadt’s test results area supported her diagnosis. On the Conners-Wells Adolescent Self-Report Scale, STUDENT had clinically significant elevations in all areas. His highest score was reported in the social anxiety area. His anxiety disorder index revealed second highest elevation. Similarly, the Piers-Harris tests revealed clinically significant elevations in anxiety. She also testified that the disorders identified by her evaluation would impact his ability to benefit from his education.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the criteria for reimbursement of private assessment costs to Petitioner were met and the District should reimburse STUDENT’s parents the sum of $1,925.00 for the July 2001 neuropsychological evaluation of Dr. Mittelstadt.

ORDER

1. Within twenty business days of the receipt of this Decision and upon satisfactory proof of payment by STUDENT’s parents, Sequoia Union High School District shall reimburse Petitioner the sum of $58,675.00 representing one-half the costs of compensatory education for the periods FAPE was denied Petitioner because of the failure of the District to provide a written plan to transition him from Kents Hill to Woodside. Such costs are determined to be one-half the cost of room and board for academic years 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004, pursuant to the findings relating to compensatory education set forth above in this Decision.

2. Within twenty business days of the receipt of this Decision and upon satisfactory proof of payment by STUDENT’s parents, Sequoia Union High School District shall reimburse Petitioner the sum of $1,925.00 representing the cost of the neuropsychological evaluation provided by Patricia Mittelstadt, Ph.D.

3. All other requests by Petitioner for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with that requirement:

ISSUES

1. Academic Year 2000-2001.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Did the District fail to make a written offer to STUDENT of a program, placement and services before the commencement of the 2000-2001 academic year? If so, does that failure constitute a denial of FAPE for academic year 2000-2001?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

(iii) Did the failure of the District to include a general education teacher in the IEP meeting of May 17 and 30, 2000, constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for academic year 2000-2001?

This issue was not decided, as it was moot.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2000-2001 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

This issue was not decided, as it was moot.

2. Academic Year 2001-2002.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 by failing to make an offer of placement, program and services until November 2001?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2001-2002 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

This issue was not decided, as it was moot.

3. Academic Year 2002-2003.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2002-2003?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2002-2003 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

This issue was not decided, as it was moot.

4. Academic Year 2003-2004.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

(i) Was STUDENT entitled to a stay put placement at Kents Hill School for academic year 2003-2004?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(ii) Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 by failing to include in his individualized education program (IEP) a written transition plan for STUDENT’s transition from a nonsectarian nonpublic school (NPS) to a public school in which he would attend general education classes?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Did the District’s offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services at Woodside High School for academic year 2003-2004 constitute an offer of a FAPE?

This issue was not decided, as it was moot.

5. Reimbursement for Tuition and Costs of Placement at NPS.

If the Hearing Officer finds that any of the District’s offers for academic years 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 did not offer to provide STUDENT a FAPE, should the District be ordered, for any year in which that finding is made, to provide reimbursement to STUDENT for the cost of his placement at Kents Hill School, an out of state, residential, nonpublic school?

The Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that he received an award of reimbursement of one-half of tuition, room and board costs. The District prevailed on this issue to the extent that only one-half of the costs stated were reimbursed.

6. Reimbursement for Independent Educational Evaluation.

Were the educational evaluations for academic year 2001-2002 relied upon by the District appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b), or was the District obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the independent psychoeducational assessment by Patricia Mittelstadt?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this matter have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is taken, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ.Code § 56505(i).

Dated: August 27, 2004 __________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The District moved to dismiss this matter after the hearing on jurisdictional grounds, contending that STUDENT’S parents did not have the authority to maintain the due process proceeding or, alternatively, did not have authority to request a Decision relating to any period beginning after December 2, 2002, STUDENT’s eighteenth birthday. The timing of the motion was contrary to the provisions of Section 56505.5(e)(6) of the California Education Code, which specifies that issues are to be disclosed ten days prior to the hearing. After a procedure ordered by the Hearing Officer that provided the parties time to reopen the record, provide additional evidence, and respond to the contentions made regarding jurisdiction, the District withdrew its motion. The Hearing Officer notes that if the District had raised the jurisdictional issue in a timely manner, there would have been no need to reopen the record and delay the conclusion of this case.

2 In effect, STUDENT had repeated seventh grade. He had aged out of Stanbridge in what could have been considered seventh grade, but actually entered Greenwood as a seventh grade student. Thus, he was technically a year behind peers of his own age.

3 The IEP meeting was held in two parts, May 17 and May 30, 2000.

4 An individualized transition plan (ITP) was prepared and provided to STUDENT’s parents on October 3, 2001. The subject matter of the ITP is the transition to adult living or college when a special education student exits high school. The intended use of the draft provided to STUDENT’s parents was for review by STUDENT and his advisors at Kents Hill. As planned, it was reviewed and a revised ITP was included in the November 13, 2001 IEP, the final IEP for academic year 2001-2002. However, no written transition plan assisting him to enter Woodside from Kents Hill appeared in the IEP.

5 Speech and language therapy was provided during the summer by his parents.

6 Dr. Mittelstadt also stated that STUDENT needed to stay at Kents Hill. Her rationale was that “his learning disabilities are significant...necessitating special private schools for children with learning disabilities.” She was mistaken on this point. Kents Hill is a private school with a general education curriculum. While it does have an excellent program providing considerable one-on-one attention to its students and a unique organizational study program, it does not hold itself out as or otherwise fit the criteria of a special school for learning disabled children.

7 The District offered general education English, Word Studies, Pre-algebra, and Physical Education and two RSP classes, Study Skills (two fifty-minute periods). The study skills periods were resource classes which Ms. Grabiec (or Ms. Wilson) contemplated teaching. She also testified that had STUDENT attended Woodside, he would have been placed with four to nine students in his two RSP classes and with approximately 15-25 in the general education classes.

8 In view of the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 as a result of the failure of the District to provide a specific, written transition plan for his prospective transition into Woodside, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to address issue (iii) set forth on page 2 of this Decision relating to the failure of the District to include a general education teacher in the IEP meeting of May 30, 2000.

9 The sole remedy sought by Petitioner under stay put was reimbursement for the cost of his placement at Kents Hill. Therefore, the Hearing Office limits its analysis to that request.

10 The District was not without remedy, however. With knowledge that a stay put issue existed, it could have presented a motion to the Hearing Office and obtained a ruling on this issue as early as July, 2002.

11 While not precedential, a recent analysis of stay put appears in In re: Capistrano Unified School District, 104 LRP 4710 (Cal. SEHO 2003).

12 Since stay put operates only upon filing a request for a due process hearing, the Petitioner’s claim is not applicable to periods prior to July 1, 2002, and, therefore, has not been addressed in the analysis of prior periods contained in this Decision.