California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 9, 1998

Student v. Ross Valley School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1519-97 · Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare

Ross Valley School District's repeat offer of the same White Hill special day class was again found inappropriate; new IEP ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

This decision follows SN 927-97, decided November 5, 1997, which ordered the District to convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate offer. A December 15, 1997 order dismissed six of the parents' eight issues because they had already been decided.

Summary

The parents of a 12-year-old with a specific learning disability filed this case. He has visual, motor, and auditory processing difficulties, with related social and emotional problems. In an earlier case (SN 927-97), a Hearing Officer found that neither the parents' private placement at the Stern School nor the District's special day class (SDC) at White Hill School was appropriate. The District was ordered to develop a new offer.

At the November 20, 1997 IEP meeting, the District offered the same SDC again. This time it added a County Mental Health referral, less mainstreaming, and a transition plan. Six of the parents' eight issues were dismissed before hearing because the earlier case had already decided them.

The District's school psychologist, Carolyn Taormina, admitted that the class itself had not changed. Its size, its mix of students working from kindergarten to eighth-grade levels, its simultaneous activities, and the steady flow of students in and out were all the same. The District said no other witness would testify differently. Relying on res judicata and collateral estoppel, the Hearing Officer held that the SDC remained inappropriate as a matter of law. Saying it was the best placement the District had did not excuse the District from offering FAPE.

The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days. It must offer a placement with listed features, including a narrow age and skill range, limited mainstreaming, one-to-one help as needed, and counseling. It must also consider public and private options.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied res judicata and collateral estoppel when a district re-offered a placement already found inappropriate. The added supports did not change the outcome, and the Hearing Officer listed the features the new placement needed. It also states that limited district resources do not excuse the duty to offer FAPE, including through private schools.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Whether the District's revised offer from the November 20, 1997 IEP meeting was appropriate. The offer was the same SDC at White Hill School, plus a referral to County Mental Health, reduced mainstreaming (homeroom and silent reading only), and a transition plan. It was made after SN 927-97 ordered the District to develop an appropriate placement offer.

    Under res judicata and collateral estoppel, the White Hill SDC remained inappropriate as a matter of law. The District admitted the class itself had not changed, and the added supports did not fix the problems found in SN 927-97.

  2. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Dismissed issues. Six of the parents' eight issues, dismissed before hearing because they had already been decided in SN 927-97 (order dated December 15, 1997)

    Six issues were dismissed before the hearing because SN 927-97 had already decided them.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Declared that the Special Day Class at White Hill is not an appropriate placement for the student.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to identify and offer a placement with these features: (a) a small, highly structured class with a low student/teacher ratio and limited simultaneous diverse activities; (b) a student age range of no more than three years that includes the student's age; (c) a general instructional level spanning no more than three grades that includes the student's level; (d) most students receiving most of their academic instruction in the same classroom as the student; (e) one-to-one assistance as needed throughout the day, especially during simultaneous instruction or transitions; (f) mainstreaming limited to 10% of the day and to nonacademic classes; (g) transitions kept to a practical minimum; (h) teachers with specialized training and experience in learning disabilities; (i) psychological counseling; (j) a transition plan to help integrate the student into the new placement.
  • The District must consider both public and private alternatives to its own facilities when identifying the placement.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Res judicata and collateral estoppel (SN 927-97); Education Code section 56501; Education Code section 56365

People named in the decision

  • Eugene Rich, special education program manager, Ross Valley School District
  • Carolyn Taormina, school psychologist (District witness), Ross Valley School District
  • Nancy L. Kline, attorney for District, Lozano, Smith, Smith, Wolliver and Behrens
  • Stern School, private school (prior unilateral placement)
  • White Hill School, school site of District's proposed SDC, Ross Valley School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1519-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 21-75002 District: Ross Valley Elementary Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability

Case Details This matter was heard before Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, at the Marin County Office of Education in San Rafael, California, on December 18, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents, MR. AND MRS. PARENT.

Respondent Ross Valley School District was represented by attorney Nancy L. Kline of Lozano, Smith, Smith, Wolliver and Behrens. Present on the District's behalf was Eugene Rich, special education program manager.

BACKGROUND FACTS

The present dispute arises out of an earlier case between the parties, SN 927-97, decided on November 5, 1997. In that case the hearing officer concluded that STUDENT's private placement at the Stern School for the 1997-98 school year was not appropriate. The hearing officer also concluded that the District's proposed placement for 1997-98 was not appropriate. The District's proposed placement consisted of the special day class (SDC) at White Hill School, with 30 - 39% of the day spent mainstreamed into regular education classes, including pre-vocational/vocational education and physical education. Since neither party had an appropriate placement, the hearing officer ordered the District to convene an IEP meeting to develop an offer of appropriate placement to meet STUDENT's needs. That offer was to include counseling services.

Pursuant to the decision in SN 927-97, the District convened an IEP meeting on November 20, 1997. The IEP team offered STUDENT the same SDC at White Hill School with a referral to County Mental Health, reduced mainstreaming (confined to homeroom and silent reading), and a transition plan to help integrate STUDENT into his new placement.

The parents rejected the District's proposed placement and filed for hearing in the present case. They identified eight issues. Six of those issues were dismissed prior to hearing as adjudicated in the prior case. (Order dated December 15, 1997.) The remaining two issues challenged the appropriateness of the District's revised offer. The parents' position is that the new offer contains the same inherit deficits identified and rejected as inappropriate in SN 927-97. The District's position is that the new offer adequately addressed the concerns identified in SN 927-97 and is, therefore, appropriate.

To a degree, this case concerns whether the District has complied with SN 927-97. Such matters are often referred to the Compliance Unit of the California Department of Education. However, given that no placement was identified as appropriate in the prior case, the Special Education Hearing Office accepted jurisdiction pursuant to Education Code Section 56501 in an effort to provide more specific guidance to the parties.

DISCUSSION

STUDENT is a 12-year-old student who suffers from difficulties in visual, motor, and auditory processing with related social and emotional problems. He is easily distracted and, as testified to in SN 927-97, needs to be in a structured environment that is as free from distraction as possible. The hearing officer found that frequent transitioning of STUDENT from the SDC to mainstream classes and back presented one distinct set of difficulties for STUDENT. The District's proposed reduction in mainstreaming can be expected to reduce such difficulties. However, in a separate finding the hearing officer also determined that STUDENT's SDC contained serious distractions, specifically the varying class schedules and activities within the SDC and the frequent changes in the composition of the class from period to period as the other students depart for and return from their mainstream classes. Thus, in a finding unrelated to mainstreaming or transition services the hearing officer concluded that the SDC at White Hill is inherently inappropriate for STUDENT.

No argument was advanced by the District to the effect that the Hearing Officer in the present case was free to disregard or alter the findings of fact and conclusions of law in the prior decision. The matters in that case had been recently adjudicated and no circumstances were identified that justified readjudicating them. Therefore, under the doctrines of res judicata and collateral estoppel the Hearing Officer in the present case must conclude that the SDC at White Hill remains inappropriate regardless of new support services, the reduction of the frequency with which STUDENT leaves to attend mainstream classes, and an introductory transition plan for STUDENT.

During the present hearing the parents testified simply that the SDC at White Hill remains inappropriate for STUDENT despite the mental health referral, modifications to mainstreaming, and transition plan.

For the District, Carolyn Taormina, school psychologist, testified that the new IEP and proposed placement offered STUDENT a more stable, predictable program with fewer changes in location and day- to-day scheduling. She also testified that the transition plan, scheduled to last up to 30 days if needed, would facilitate STUDENT's acclimation to his new placement and his new school. However, she acknowledged that the size and composition of the SDC (approximately 16 students functioning academically at levels from kindergarten to eighth grade), the teaching staff, the class structure, the extent of the simultaneous educational activities occurring within the class, and the comings and goings of the students to and from their various mainstream classes had not changed and could not be changed without altering the IEPs of the other students in the class. In short, Ms. Taormina testified that the SDC at White Hill remained the same SDC rejected by the hearing officer in SN 927 -97. After hearing Ms. Taormina's testimony, the Hearing Officer in the present case asked the District for an offer of proof as to whether any of its subsequent witnesses would testify that the SDC at White Hill had changed in any significant aspect or otherwise provide information substantially different from that given by Ms. Taormina. The District replied in the negative. Pursuant to the doctrines of res judicata and collateral estoppel, the Hearing Officer then concluded that as a matter of law the SDC at White Hill remained inappropriate for STUDENT.

There ensued testimony to the effect that the SDC at White Hill is the best placement the District has to offer STUDENT. However, limitation on resources and options within a school district do not relieve that district of its obligation to offer a free appropriate education. School districts frequently make arrangements with neighboring districts to educate special education students. They may take advantage of opportunities within their special education location planning areas. In addition, California law authorizes school districts to use private schools to meet special education needs when appropriate. (California Education Code Section 56365.) In this case, it is clear from the District's own admission that the District must look beyond its own facilities to educate STUDENT.

The prior decision and the record of that case submitted into evidence by Petitioner in this case identify those elements that STUDENT's placement must have to constitute a free appropriate education. The class must be small, highly structured, and free from excessive diverse simultaneous activities that distract STUDENT. Most of other students in the class must remain in the class most of the day. The range of ages of the students should not exceed three years. The students should be functioning educationally at a range of no more than three grade levels. (Footnote 1) STUDENT's transitions within and without the class must be kept to a minimum. The teacher(s) must have specialized training and experience with students with learning disabilities. STUDENT's program must include psychological counseling. As agreed to by the parties, STUDENT's program must include a specific transition plan for a new placement. The transition plan proposed in the IEP of November 20, 1997, was agreeable to the parents and is otherwise appropriate.

ORDER

1. The Special Day Class at White Hill is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

2. Within 15 days of the date of this decision, the District will convene an IEP team to identify and offer a placement for STUDENT that possesses the following characteristics:

a. A small highly structured class with low student/teach ratio and limited simultaneous diverse educational activities.

b. The age range of the students must be no more than three years and include STUDENT's age.

c. The general instruction level of the students must encompass no more than three grades and include STUDENT's general instructional level.

d. Most of the students must receive most of their academic instruction in the same classroom with STUDENT.

e. STUDENT must be provided with one-to-one assistance, as needed, throughout the day, especially during periods involving either simultaneous instruction in the class or transitions for STUDENT.

f. STUDENT's mainstreaming must be limited to 10% of his day and to nonacademic classes. g. STUDENT's transitions throughout the day must be kept to a practical minimum, with the exception of up to 10% mainstreaming during the school day for nonacademic activities. h. The teacher(s) must have specialized training and experience with learning disabilities. i. STUDENT must be provided with psychological counseling. j. STUDENT's special education program must include a transition plan to help integrate STUDENT into his new placement.

3. The district must consider both public and private alternatives to its own facilities in identifying an appropriate special education placement for STUDENT.

DATED: January 9, 1998 ________________________________ Edwin Villmoare Chief Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes 1. Special education students and regular education students alike often function at varying grade levels depending on subject matter and task. For example, a student who reads at the eighth grade level may perform mathematics at the sixth grade level. The requirement that the students in STUDENT's new placement function at a range of no more that three grade levels will be satisfied if the dominant or preponderant functional level of the students is within three grade levels.