California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 31, 2003
Student v. River Delta Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1522-02 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
River Delta Unified need not pay more than the agreed $12 per hour for a student's in-home autism tutors, Hearing Officer rules.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Prior summary stay put order dated July 10, 2002 (Hearing Officer Maxine Benmour) required the District to keep reimbursing parents for in-home aide services at the prior rate.
Summary
An eight-year-old second grader eligible for special education under autism had an IEP that included in-home discrete trial training. Tutors trained by the Central Valley Autism Project provided the sessions. Under an oral agreement, the mother paid the tutors and River Delta Unified School District reimbursed her up to $12 per hour. The District later tried to pay the tutors directly as District employees at about $10 per hour. In April 2002 the tutors resigned from the in-home work. The mother rehired them in mid-May 2002, gave them raises above $12 per hour, and filed for due process. She asked for the extra amounts she paid and for an order that the District provide the services directly. A July 2002 stay put order kept the reimbursement arrangement in place. Hearing Officer Van T. Vu found that the student received his in-home services from May 15, 2002 onward. The District reimbursed every invoice in full at the agreed rate. The mother had kept the District from taking over payroll, so rehiring the tutors simply resumed the existing reimbursement arrangement. They did not become private providers whose costs could be recovered under Burlington. The parents gave the raises "at their own peril." The Hearing Officer called an order for direct services unnecessary because eight District employees were finishing training to provide the services. All requests were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a parent-reimbursement arrangement for IEP services. When a district pays invoices in full at the agreed rate, the IEP is being implemented. A parent who raises provider pay on her own without changing the agreement may not recover the difference as Burlington-style reimbursement.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1. From May 15, 2002, through the present, did the District provide STUDENT in-home therapy services in conformity with his IEP? (Student sought reimbursement of amounts parents paid tutors above the $12/hour District reimbursement rate, and an order that the District provide the in-home services directly.)
The District carried out the IEP by reimbursing Mother at the agreed $12/hour rate. The tutors stayed District-funded providers under the reimbursement arrangement, not private providers, so the parents' raises were at their own risk. An order for direct District services was unnecessary because District employees trained by the Central Valley Autism Project were ready to provide them.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requests for extra reimbursement above $12/hour and for an order requiring the District to provide in-home services directly were denied.
Key authorities
School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8); Education Code § 56000
People named in the decision
- Brenda Golubski, assistant superintendent, District witness, River Delta Unified School District
- Karen Rice, assistant superintendent for business services, District witness, River Delta Unified School District
- Geneva Schauffler, senior in-home tutor/shadow aide
- Vanessa Gatewood, in-home tutor/shadow aide
- Ashley McIntosh, tutor/shadow aide, River Delta Unified School District
- Maria Cipola, tutor/shadow aide, River Delta Unified School District
- Sara Post, tutor/shadow aide, River Delta Unified School District
- Central Valley Autism Project, autism consultation provider and ABA tutor trainer
- Alta Regional Center, regional center sharing responsibility for in-home therapy
- Maxine Benmour, Hearing Officer who issued stay put order, California Special Education Hearing Office
- Clarksburg Elementary School, District school attended, River Delta Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Isleton, California, on April 25 and 29, 2003.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma and his mother, MOTHER. The River Delta Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorneys Marcy Gutierrez and Anne Sherlock from the law firm of Girard and Vinson. Also present on behalf of the District was assistant superintendent Brenda Golubski.
The Petitioner called his mother as his sole witness. The District called as witnesses assistant superintendent Brenda Golubski and assistant superintendent for business services Karen Rice.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and oral closing arguments were made on the last day of hearing. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
From May 15, 2002, through the present, did the District provide STUDENT in-home therapy services in conformity with his individualized education program (IEP)?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner STUDENT contends that the District has denied him a free appropriate public education because, from May 15, 2002, through the present, it has failed to appropriately implement the portion of his IEPs pertaining to in-home discrete trial training tutor services.(Footnote 1) According to Petitioner, his parents and the District had an agreement wherein the District reimbursed them up to $12 per hour for in-home tutor services. When the District attempted to change the funding model so that it would pay for the tutor services directly, it offered to pay the tutors less than the PARENTS were paying them, and the tutors all resigned from their positions in April 2002. Petitioner asserts that the District’s actions resulted in his in-home therapy services being interrupted, which, in turn, required his parents to hire the tutors back at their own expense. Petitioner requests reimbursement for any amount his parents paid the tutors beyond the $12 per hour rate that the District has already reimbursed them for the tutoring services. Additionally, Petitioner requests an order that the District directly provide the in-home tutoring services prospectively, so that the PARENTS are not required to pay the tutors and then seek reimbursement from the District.
The District contends that it has always provided, or has been ready and willing to provide, Petitioner’s in-home tutoring services, either through the reimbursement model or with its own employees. The District asserts also that it has reimbursed Petitioner for the tutoring services for all times relevant to this proceeding at the $12 per hour rate agreed to with the PARENTS prior to this dispute arising. Additionally, the District asserts that it has eight employees whose training would have been completed on May 7, 2003, and who could provide the in-home services directly to STUDENT. Thus, the District asserts that it has fulfilled its obligation to implement STUDENT’s IEP in accordance with its reimbursement agreement with the PARENTS and, therefore, it is not required to reimburse them for any extra payment they made to the tutors. Moreover, the District asserts that because its employees have been prepared and willing to directly provide the in-home services to STUDENT, no order is necessary requiring them to do so.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is an eight-year-old second-grader who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with autism. To address his deficits related to his autism, STUDENT receives services from the River Delta Unified School District as well as the Alta Regional Center.(Footnote 2)
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended a District regular education first grade class at Clarksburg Elementary School. At Clarksburg School, he was provided occupational therapy services, autism consultation services, and a shadow aide in the classroom. Additionally, according to his August 2001 IEP, the District was to provide STUDENT six hours per week of in-home discrete trial training therapy services. The “tutors” that provide STUDENT with shadow aide services and in-home therapy services are trained in applied behavioral analysis by the Central Valley Autism Project, which provides the autism consultation services to STUDENT per his IEP. Beginning in at least September 2001, the tutors were paid directly by the District for their shadow aide services, but they were paid by MOTHER for their services in the home. By all accounts, the District and MOTHER had an oral agreement that MOTHER would bill the District up to $12 per hour for reimbursement for the in-home therapy services.
Sometime during late summer or early fall of 2001, MOTHER spoke with Karen Rice, the District’s assistant superintendent for business services, regarding the reimbursement model for STUDENT’s in-home therapy services. During their conversation, Ms. Rice notified MOTHER that the District was responsible for providing STUDENT’s in-home services and would take over payment of the tutors for those services. Ms. Rice directed MOTHER to stop paying the tutors so that the District could pay the tutors directly. MOTHER agreed in concept that the District should pay the tutors directly. However, she later disagreed with the District about the rate that the tutors should be paid. MOTHER testified that the District would only pay the tutors approximately $10/hour based the salary scale contained in the union collective bargaining unit agreement for all District employees, which was approximately $2 less than she paid them.(Footnote 3) Additionally, MOTHER was concerned that the District would not give STUDENT’s tutors the pay raise that she had planned to give them for their good work performance.
Despite Ms. Rice’s assurances to MOTHER that the District would pay STUDENT’s tutors directly, it is unclear what steps she took between from September through early December 2001 to accomplish this goal. During this time, MOTHER continued to pay the tutors directly and to seek reimbursement from the District for up to $12 per hour. Upon receiving MOTHER’s reimbursement requests, the District continued to direct MOTHER not to pay the tutors and warned her that it would not reimburse her for the tutor services. However, the District eventually reimbursed MOTHER anyway. Then, at STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting on December 13, 2001, with STUDENT’s senior tutor, Geneva Schauffler, present, the team apparently discussed the District’s intent to pay STUDENT’s in-home tutors directly. (Student Exh. at pgs. 131-132.) Subsequent to the IEP meeting, on December 18, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s in-home tutors letters directing them to fill out and submit District timesheets to the District for direct payment for their in-home therapy services. Enclosed with the letters were timesheets for the tutors to use. The District received no response from the tutors and the tutors continued to submit their timesheets to MOTHER for payment.
In January 2002, the District hired three new tutors at a rate of pay of approximately $10 per hour to also provide STUDENT shadow aide and in-home therapy services. Those tutors are Ashley McIntosh, Maria Cipola, and Sara Post. Upon being hired by the District, the tutors were instructed how fill out District timesheets and told that the timesheets were to be submitted to the District for both shadow aide and in-home therapy services. Despite the District’s directives, Ms. McIntosh, Ms. Cipola, and Ms. Post submitted their timesheets to MOTHER and they were paid directly by MOTHER. In March 2002, MOTHER submitted a reimbursement request to the District for in-home services provided by STUDENT’s tutors for the months of January and February 2002. The District initially refused to reimburse MOTHER and again directed her to stop paying the tutors directly, but again reimbursed MOTHER in full.
Also in March 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened again to review his educational placement and program. At the IEP meeting, MOTHER and the District discussed further the District’s intent to pay the tutors directly and MOTHER’s concerns regarding the pay rate of the tutors. (Student Exh. at Pgs. 171-174.) Additionally, the IEP team agreed that his in-home therapy services would continue at a rate and frequency of six hours per week. The IEP team also agreed for the 2002 extended school year that, between June 24 and July 23, STUDENT would receive four hours per week of in-home therapy services from the District. Then, from July 24 through August 26, the District would provide STUDENT seventeen hours per week of in-home therapy hours.
On April 15, the District sent STUDENT’s tutors a letter again directing them to fill out and submit timesheets to the District for both shadow aide and in-home therapy services rendered to STUDENT. The next day, the District convened a meeting with all of STUDENT’s tutors and explained again to them that they were to provide their timesheets directly to the District. The District also told them again that their rate of pay would be based on the salary scale of the collective bargaining unit agreement that governs all District employees. Two days later, all of STUDENT’s tutors notified MOTHER of their resignation from their position as in-home therapy tutors, but they would remain available to provide those services if the District agreed to pay them their then current $12/hour rate. The aides continued to provide STUDENT shadow aide services under the employment of the District.
Immediately following their resignation, Mrs. MOTHER hired the tutors to provide STUDENT respite services that he was entitled to through Alta Regional Center. During the following weeks, the District and MOTHER communicated regarding having the tutors resume their in-home therapy services, and the District attempted to secure higher pay rates for STUDENT’s more senior tutors. In the meantime, the District attempted in vain to find substitute tutors that could provide in-home services to STUDENT and to train someone new to fill the in-home tutor position. By early May, the parties had an understanding that the new tutors hired in January 2002 were willing to resume their in-home therapy duties as District employees and at the pay rate offered by the District (i.e., approximately $10/hour). (Student Exh. at Pgs. 169-176 and 213-214.) By mid May, still without resolution with the District regarding the rate of pay for Geneva Schauffler and Vanessa Gatewood, STUDENT’s more experienced tutors, MOTHER authorized the tutors to resume the in-home services. Additionally, she gave them pay raises, which resulted in their earning more than $12 per hour. Apparently, all of the tutors continued to submit their timesheets to MOTHER rather than the District.
On July 1, 2002, the Petitioner requested a due process hearing, to resolve the dispute with the District over STUDENT’s in-home tutors. Included with the hearing request was a request for stay put. Specifically, Petitioner sought a stay put order requiring the District to reimburse Petitioner’s parents for tutoring services rather than making direct payments to the tutors. By summary order dated July 10, 2002, Hearing Officer Maxine Benmour granted Petitioner’s request for stay put and ordered the District to reimburse the PARENTS for the in-home aide services at the rate the District had been reimbursing them since September 2001. Subsequently, the District has abided by the stay put order and has retroactively paid the PARENTS in full for all reimbursement requests they made to the District for in-home therapy services during the time periods at issue in this case.
During the fall of 2002, STUDENT began the second grade. On October 30, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened again. At the IEP meeting, the team agreed in part that STUDENT’s in-home therapy services would be reduced from six to three hours per week.(Footnote 4)
During February 2003, the District arranged for eight of its employees to be trained by the Central Valley Autism Project to provide STUDENT in-home therapy services. According to Ms. Golubski, the District’s employees were scheduled to be trained on April 30 and May 2 and 7, 2003. Hence, they would be qualified to provide STUDENT with in-home therapy services after they complete their training on May 7. MOTHER has consented to the training schedule and to making STUDENT available for the training.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). As discussed above, Petitioner asserts only that his educational program pertaining to his in-home therapy services from May 15, 2002, through the present did not comport with his IEP.
The evidence establishes that at all times relevant (i.e., from May 15, 2002, to the present) STUDENT has in fact received his in-home therapy services.(Footnote 5) The in-home therapy services were and continue to be provided by the therapists who were providing the services prior to the timeframe in dispute. Additionally, it is undisputed that MOTHER has paid these tutors directly and she has been reimbursed by the District for the total amount invoiced on each of her reimbursement requests since May 15, 2002. At hearing, MOTHER acknowledged that she understood she could request to be reimbursed at a higher pay rate than $12/hour for the tutors, that she did not request to amend their agreement for her to be reimbursed at a higher pay rate, and that she received and accepted the checks the District sent her to satisfy payment of her reimbursement requests. Therefore, STUDENT’s in-home therapy services have been provided by appropriately trained tutors and their services have been paid for by the District in accordance with the oral agreement of the parties regarding the rate of reimbursement and as requested by the PARENTS.
Although the PARENTS have only requested in their invoices up to $12 per hour for the in-home therapy services, Petitioner asserts that the PARENTS are now entitled to be reimbursed for amounts they paid the tutors beyond the $12 per hour reimbursed by the District. As noted above, MOTHER unilaterally increased the tutors’ rate of pay during the spring of 2002. Petitioner argues that, because the District failed to provide the in-home therapy services in April and May 2002 after the tutors quit, she had to rehire the tutors to provide the services not provided by the District. Therefore, according to Petitioner, the tutor services were privately provided services that are not governed by the parties’ agreement to cap the reimbursement at $12 per hour. (See School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994).) Petitioner relies on the fact that the tutors resigned when faced with lower pay rates from the District. Petitioner’s reliance on this fact is misplaced.
It is undisputed that the District was unable to transition from the reimbursement model of payment of the tutors to a direct payment model, notwithstanding MOTHER’s agreement in concept that the District should pay the tutors directly. Despite repeated direction from the District to stop paying the tutors so that the District could handle their payroll, MOTHER continued to pay the tutors directly. Thus, when the tutors resigned, the PARENTS and the District had continued to implement the reimbursement model of payment for their services due to MOTHER’s actions thwarting the District from taking over direct payment of the tutors. Accordingly, when the PARENTS rehired the tutors for the in-home therapy and sought reimbursement from the District, they were simply resuming the reimbursement arrangement with the District.(Footnote 6) As noted above, the PARENTS continued to seek reimbursement within the guidelines of the reimbursement agreement with the District.
Additionally, in July 2002, Petitioner requested an order from the Hearing Office requiring the District to maintain his “status quo” from prior to the dispute arising between the parties. Specifically, Petitioner requested an order that the District continue to reimburse his parents up to $12/hour for his in-home aide services. That request was granted, and the District was ordered to continue funding STUDENT’s in-home services as it had done prior to the tutors’ resigning, through the reimbursement model with MOTHER. As MOTHER requested, STUDENT’s program from July 2002 forward was the same as it was before the dispute arising. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no legal change in the status of the tutors from District service providers to private service providers whose services are reimbursed through Burlington. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the PARENTS are not entitled to the reimbursement for amounts paid to the tutors beyond that which have already been invoiced by MOTHER and paid by the District. When the PARENTS granted the tutors pay raises, they did so at their own peril.
Regarding Petitioner’s request for an order requiring the District to provide STUDENT’s in-home therapy services in a manner that the PARENTS would not be required to seek reimbursement, that request is denied as unnecessary. The undisputed evidence at hearing established that the District had arranged for the training of eight of its employees by the Central Valley Autism Project to provide the three hours per week of in-home therapy services to STUDENT per his most recent IEP. That training was to be completed by May 7, 2003, approximately two weeks after the conclusion of the hearing in this matter. Additionally, MOTHER testified that she has consented to the training schedule of the new tutors and that she would make STUDENT available for the training. MOTHER also testified that, as long as the tutors were trained by the Central Valley Autism Project, she would allow them into her home to provide STUDENT his therapy services. Because the District is anticipated to have secured training for its own employees to provide STUDENT his services without the need for the PARENTS to seek reimbursement, no order requiring them to provide those services is necessary and the request is therefore denied.
In conclusion, from May 15, 2002, through the present, the District provided STUDENT in-home therapy services that comported with his IEP by reimbursing MOTHER for those services. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to supplemental reimbursement for payments made to the tutors. Additionally, as of at least May 7, 2003, the District has been ready and willing to provide STUDENT with the in-home therapy with its own CVAP trained employees. Accordingly, no order requiring the District to directly provide in-home services is necessary.
ORDER
Petitioner’s requests are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issue decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code ' 56505(i).
DATED: _________________ ____________________________________
Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Petitioner does not challenge the substantive appropriateness of any component of his most recent IEP. On a different point, as described below, the level of in-home services STUDENT received from the District during the time period at issue varied per his IEPs. From May 15, 2002, through October 30, 2003, excluding the 2002 extended school year, STUDENT received six hours per week of in-home services. From June 24 through July 23, 2002, STUDENT received four hours per week of services. From July 23 through August 26, 2002, STUDENT received seventeen hours per week of services. Moreover, from October 31, 2003 through the present, STUDENT received three hours per week of in-home services from the District. 2. From fall 2001 to the present, STUDENT’s IEPs have listed both the District and the Regional Center as responsible parties for STUDENT’s in-home therapy. The IEPs specifically apportioned each entity’s responsibility by type and frequency of services. 3. Ms. Rice testified that as District employees, the tutors’ pay rate of $10/hour would have actually resulted in their net earning being more than if they were paid $12/hour as independent contractors. Ms. Rice explained that the District pays the Social Security taxes and other costs for its employees (not reflected in the take-home pay) that otherwise must be borne by the tutors if they were independent contractors. 4. The IEP actually states that STUDENT is to receive ten hours per week of in-home therapy services. Three of the ten hours per week is the responsibility of the District, and seven of the ten hours is the responsibility of the Regional Center. 5. Although Petitioner apparently was without in-home services for about one month after the tutors resigned in April 2002, the Petitioner did not raise any issues pertaining to that time period at hearing. Additionally, Petitioner informed the Hearing Officer that the parties had resolved all issues pertaining to that time period. 6. The Hearing Officer notes that the District took reasonable efforts to ensure that STUDENT receive his in-home therapy services required by his IEP after the tutors resigned. Those efforts included requesting substitute tutors from neighboring school districts and from the Central Valley Autism Project. The District also continued to resolve the dispute with the PARENTS over the rate of pay of the tutors.
