California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 17, 2002

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1525-02 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso

Los Angeles Unified's high school offer denied a deaf student FAPE, but the Hearing Officer denied parochial school tuition reimbursement.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 4 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 14-year-old ninth grader who is deaf filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. She attended district schools through fifth grade. She then spent three years at Maria Regina, a private parochial middle school. Her parents paid tuition, and the district paid for an American Sign Language (ASL) interpreter. At an April 4, 2001 IEP meeting, the district said it would no longer provide an interpreter at a parochial school. Instead, it offered general education at a public high school, which the parties treated as Gardena High School, with an interpreter. The parents enrolled her at Junipero Serra High School, a private parochial school, and sought reimbursement.

The Hearing Officer found that the district had to offer a FAPE once it decided to bring the student back to public school. The offer denied FAPE. The district had not assessed her since 1997. The IEP had no goals for her long-standing needs in visual-spatial processing, memory, and written expression. Its auditory training and speech reading goals were not based on her current performance levels. The Hearing Officer found no basis for counseling and found the interpreter offer adequate. Even so, reimbursement was denied. Serra had no special education teachers or services, did not address her significant needs, and was chosen mainly for academic and family reasons. All requested relief, including extended school year, was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated two separate questions: whether the district's offer denied FAPE, and whether the parents' private school was appropriate. Here the family won on the first question but got no reimbursement. The private school did not address the student's identified special education needs.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Did the District have a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

    The parties' three-year arrangement had worked as an informal service plan for a parent-placed private school student. Once the district decided to bring the student back to public school for 2001-2002, it had to hold an IEP meeting and offer a FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2. If the District had a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, did the District's offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting provide STUDENT a FAPE?

    The offer denied FAPE. The district had not assessed the student since 1997, wrote no goals for her significant visual-spatial processing, memory and written expression needs, and wrote auditory training and speech reading goals without a basis in present levels. There was no objective basis for counseling, and the full-time ASL interpreter offer was adequate. Claimed procedural violations were held moot.

  3. Issue 3. If the District's offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Serra High School during the 2001-2002 school year?

    Reimbursement was denied. Serra had no special education teachers or services, did not address the student's significant needs, gave no more academic benefit than past placements, and was chosen mainly for academic and family reasons.

  4. Issue 4. If STUDENT's placement at Serra provides her with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at a noncertified, private, parochial school?

    This issue was moot because reimbursement was denied. Neither party prevailed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The Petitioner's request for relief for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year was denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Fowler v. Unified School District No. 259; OSEP Policy Letter to Miller, 25 IDELR 1214 (1997)

People named in the decision

  • Alexis Kashar, attorney for Student, Newman, Aaronson, Vanaman
  • Daniel A. Osher, attorney for District, Lozano Smith
  • Barbara Koff, District program specialist for the deaf and hard of hearing; District representative and witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Catherine Kiwitt, ASL interpreter at hearing
  • Bill Pugin, ASL interpreter at hearing
  • Dr. Robert D. Byrd, private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Susan Margolin, District special education teacher for the deaf, Gardena High School
  • Margaret Shoukry, vice principal, Junipero Serra High School
  • Dr. Larry Fleisher, dean of deaf studies; expert witness for Student on deaf education, California State University Northridge
  • Joline Dellenbach, District special education teacher for the deaf; former teacher of Student; witness for Student, President Elementary School
  • Mary Anne Marsch, District secondary teacher for the deaf, Marlton Middle School
  • Eileen Plourde, vice principal and eighth grade general education teacher, Maria Regina Middle School
  • Marilyn Geffeney, District special education coordinating specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Vicki Newman, District special education coordinator, Gardena High School
  • Rosalie Saxman, District audiologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Karen Harwood, District school psychologist (1997 assessment), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Christine Hill, District itinerant speech and language teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Ms. Kahn, person the parent spoke with about high school placement (role not stated)
  • Parker Hearing and Speech Institute, private provider; 1998 audiological and speech assessment

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on December 4, 5, 2001 and January 8, 9,10,11,13, 2002 and February 1, 21, 22, 2002. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner (Student) were attorney Alexis Kashar from Newman, Aaronson, Vanaman and STUDENT’S Mother. Appearing on behalf of Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) were attorney Daniel A. Osher from Lozano Smith and Barbara Koff, District program specialist for special education of the deaf and hard of hearing. Also present for the hearing were American Sign Language (ASL) interpreters Catherine Kiwitt and Bill Pugin.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: STUDENT’s Mother; Dr. Robert D. Byrd, psychologist; Susan Margolin, District special education teacher for the deaf, Gardena High School; Margaret Shoukry, vice principal of Junipero Serra High School (Serra); Dr. Larry Fleisher, dean of deaf studies, California State University Northridge; Joline Dellenbach, District special education teacher for the deaf, President Elementary School (President); Mary Anne Marsch, District secondary teacher for the deaf, Marlton Middle School; Eileen Plourde, vice principal and eight grade teacher, Maria Regina Middle School. The following witnesses were called by the Respondent to testify: Marilyn Geffeney, District special education coordinating specialist; Barbara Koff, District program specialist for the deaf and hard of hearing; Vicki Newman, District special education coordinator, Gardena High School; Rosalie Saxman, District audiologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of oral closing argument on March 13, 2002, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

-1-

ISSUES

1. Did the District have a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

2. If the District had a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, did the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 individualized education program (IEP) meeting provide STUDENT a FAPE?

3. If the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Serra High School during the 2001-2002 school year?

4. If STUDENT’s placement at Serra provides her with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at a noncertified, parochial school?

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. She attended a District public school from preschool to the fifth grade. From the sixth grade to the eighth grade, she attended Maria Regina, a private parochial middle school. STUDENT presently attends the ninth grade at Serra, a private parochial high school.

STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. She was deaf at birth. In July 1988, her early auditory evaluations identified a severe to profound bilateral, sensorineural hearing loss. She was later diagnosed with Waardenburg syndrome. At the age of seven months, STUDENT was removed from her birth mother and placed in foster care. Mr. and Ms. Parent became STUDENT’s foster parents when STUDENT was two and one half years old (Footnote 1).

In November 1989, the District evaluated and identified STUDENT as a child with a disability in need of special education and related services, under the qualifying criteria of deaf. At the time of STUDENT’s identification in November 1989, she was enrolled in and attending a District Infant Deaf and Hard of Hearing program. She continued to attend public school through the 1997-1998 school year in the fifth grade at President Elementary School (President). Although STUDENT had problems with her behavior and organization in public school, she made average academic progress. STUDENT’s parent was satisfied with the education that the District provided her daughter.

In January 1998, an IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s placement at President was the least restrictive environment for her but could not be replicated at her home middle school. Thus, the IEP team agreed to try a small private school for STUDENT. However, there were no follow-up IEP meetings to discuss this proposed placement option. Instead, STUDENT’s parents alone chose Maria Regina, a private parochial middle school, for STUDENT and volunteered to pay for the tuition. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with ASL interpreter services. The parties continued this arrangement at the parents’ expense with District funded ASL interpreter services for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years. In January 2001, STUDENT’s Parents and STUDENT interviewed at Junipero Serra (Serra), a private parochial high school.

On April 4, 2001, an IEP meeting took place. STUDENT’s Parent brought Ms. Plourde, who was STUDENT’s general education teacher from Maria Regina (Footnote 2). At the beginning of the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s Parent advised the IEP team that she wanted STUDENT to attend a private school and repeated this point throughout the meeting. Ms. Plourde testified that she discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the eight grade at Maria Regina. They were average. The District’s witnesses and Ms. Plourde testified that there was no discussion at the IEP meeting about STUDENT’s behavior because neither STUDENT’s Parent nor Ms. Plourde raised it as an issue. Ms. Plourde testified that at the time of the April 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s behavior was under control. STUDENT’s Parent and Ms. Plourde expressed no concern about STUDENT’s attention, study habits, or organizational skills. The IEP team discussed vocational education, auditory training, and speech and language for STUDENT and wrote goals and objectives in these areas.

The IEP team next discussed STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The District advised STUDENT’s Parent that it had a change in policy and it would no longer provide an ASL interpreter in a private parochial school for STUDENT. Thus, the District offered a local public high school, general education, mainstreaming with typically developing, and an ASL interpreter. There was no discussion at the IEP meeting regarding an interpreter for extracurricular services. The District also advised STUDENT’s Parent that it would not offer extended school year (ESY) because STUDENT was considered a regular education student with special education services.

At the end of the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s Parent again offered to pay for STUDENT’s tuition at a private school of the parent’s choice if the District would continue to provide ASL interpreter services. The District again rejected STUDENT’s Parent’s offer. The IEP meeting was adjourned without any agreement on placement and services. After the April 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s Parent, Dr. Byrd, Dr. Fleisher, Ms. Dellenbach, STUDENT’s Parent and STUDENT visited Gardena High School. The visits occurred in May, November, and December 2001 and January 2002. All four adults concluded that Gardena was too large and did not have the small, disciplined structure that STUDENT required.

On May 21, 2001, STUDENT began the first in a series of seven examinations by Dr. Robert D. Byrd, a private clinical psychologist. STUDENT’s Parent did not advise the IEP team or the District that these examinations were took place. The examinations ended on June 30, 2001 and Dr. Byrd’s report followed the same day. STUDENT’s Parents neither requested an IEP meeting to discuss Dr. Byrd’s report nor provided it to the District until mediation in November/December 2001, which was seven/eight months after the April 2001 IEP meeting. When the parties were unable to resolve this matter, they proceeded to hearing in December 2001.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE 1: Did the District have a legal obligation to offer STUDENT A FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The IDEA had in early 1997, and continues to have, the goal of providing a FAPE for all children with disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1413(a)(2) (1991); 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1) (1997). Thus, local educational agencies (LEAs), such as the District, are required to establish procedures to ensure that children with disabilities in need of special education and related services who reside within the jurisdiction of the LEA, including children with disabilities attending private schools, are identified, located, and evaluated. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A) (1991); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3)(A) (1997).

In this case, STUDENT attended school in the Los Angeles Unified School Distirct from an Infant DHH program up to the fifth grade at President Elementary school. In January 1998, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s placement at President was the least restrictive environment for her but was not available at her home middle school. Therefore, the IEP team agreed that a small private school was a reasonable option for STUDENT. However, the parents unilaterally chose a private parochial middle school for STUDENT and volunteered to pay for the tuition. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with ASL interpreter services. The parties continued this arrangement at the parents’ expense and with District-funded ASL interpreter services for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years. In January 2001, the parents and STUDENT interviewed at Serra, a private parochial high school. On April 4, 2001, an IEP meeting was held for the 2001-2002 school year and the parties were unable to agree upon a placement and services. The parties now dispute the District’s obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting. Given this dispute, the question is what STUDENT’s status was immediately prior to the April 4, 2001 IEP and whether the District had an obligation to provide STUDENT a FAPE.

There are three situations in which a child with a disability may attend a private school, and the obligations of an LEA changes with each of the situations. OSEP Policy Letter to Miller, 25 IDELR 1214 (1997). The first situation involves an LEA’s placement of a child with a disability in private school because the LEA has determined that the private school can provide the child with a FAPE. Id.; see, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.348 (1996); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(B)(i) (1997). In this first situation, the private placement comes at no cost to the parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.401(a)(2) (1996); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(B)(1) (1997). In the second situation, the parents place the child in the private school because they believe that the LEA has denied their child a FAPE. Miller, 25 IDELR 1214; see School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ. (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 370-371, 105 S.Ct. 1996. In such a case, where the provision of a FAPE is at issue, the LEA may be liable for the costs of the private placement if the LEA denied the child a FAPE, and the parents provided an appropriate placement. Burlington, 417 U.S. at 371; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii) (1997). The third and final situation also involves a unilateral decision to place the child in a private school, but differs in that the parent elects to place the child in a private school as a matter of personal preference and seeks only related services from the LEA. Miller, 25 IDELR 1214. In this third situation, the LEA may be obligated to provide the child with some related services during the child’s attendance at the private school. However, the student has no entitlement to services. Finally, the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the private school tuition. Id.; 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.403, 300.451 (1996); Fowler v. Unified Sch. Dist. No. 259, 128 F.3d 1431, 1439 (10th Cir. 1997).

The initial dispute in this matter centers on whether the first, second or third of the situations described above accurately reflects STUDENT’s situation while she attended Maria Regina Middle School from the beginning of the sixth grade during the 1998-1999 school year to the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting. The facts in this case do not fit clearly into any of the three situations outlined above. On the basis of the evidence presented at the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the facts fit situation number three most closely. First, the IEP team agreed that a private placement was appropriate for STUDENT in the sixth grade because an appropriate placement was not available at STUDENT’s local school. Second, STUDENT’s parents elected to place their child in parochial school and offered to pay for the private, parochial school placement if the District would pay for ASL interpreter services. Finally, the District agreed to the parent’s proposal. Thus, the parties had an agreement which satisfied the parents desire for a private, parochial school placement and the District’s desire to pay for the ASL interpreter services. While this agreement was written into the July 1999 IEP document, the parties’ actions established that they treated it like a service plan rather than a agreement on placement and services pursuant to an IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.450-462. This agreement between the Petitioner and the District, then, constituted a defacto service plan. In November 1999, the IEP team held another IEP meeting and the parties again agreed to continue the defacto service plan for the 1999-2000 school year.

The relationship between the parties remained the same for the 2000-2001 school year when STUDENT entered the eighth grade at Maria Regina. STUDENT’s parents voluntarily enrolled her in the private, parochial school and the District continued to provide the ASL interpreter services without either party ever calling an IEP meeting. Therefore, Mr. and Mrs. Parent were not entitled to either services or due process for the 2000-2001 school year (Footnote 3).

The facts, however, support that the District was obligated to make an offer of a FAPE at the April 2001 IEP meeting. First, STUDENT’s parents and STUDENT interviewed at Serra in January 2001. Second, STUDENT’s Parent testified that she also made a good faith effort to look at and consider four different public school placements before the April 2001 IEP meeting. The apparent catalyst for the April 2001 IEP meeting was a few phone conversations that STUDENT’s Parent had with Ms. Kahn about STUDENT’s high school placement for the 2001-2002 school year. Third, STUDENT’s Parent testified that she assumed that the same arrangement that had been agreed to the previous three years would be agreed to at the April 2001 IEP meeting: STUDENT’S Parents would pay for the private school tuition and the District would pay for the full-time ASL interpreter services. Fourth, the District advised STUDENT’s Parent at the IEP meeting that it had changed its policy and would no longer provide the ASL interpreter services at the parochial school. Finally, the District members of the IEP team advised STUDENT’s Parent that if she wished to receive the ASL interpreter services, STUDENT would have to attend a local public school. This change in the arrangement was not acceptable to STUDENT’s Parent. Thus, she rejected the District’s offer of placement and ASL interpreter services at STUDENT’s local public high school and did not sign the April 2001 IEP document.

In summary, the evidence at the Hearing established that the District and STUDENT’s parents had a defacto service plan for three years that satisfied the parents’ desire for a private school placement for STUDENT and the District’s willingness to provide ASL interpreter services at the private school. Finally, the District’s decision to bring STUDENT back into public school obligated it to call an IEP meeting to develop a placement and services for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Thus, the Hearing Officer shall now determine whether the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting provided STUDENT with FAPE.

ISSUE 2: If the District had the legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, did the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting provide STUDENT with a FAPE?

After the District determined that it would no longer provide ASL interpreter services at a private parochial school of the parents choice, the District noticed an IEP meeting and offered STUDENT a public school placement and ASL interpreter services for the 2001-2002 school year. Thus, the Hearing Officer now determines whether the District’s offer provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. §1400; California Education Code § 56000). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “Specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...” 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.) Special education law further requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, to comport with the IEP, and must be provided in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer now determines whether the District’s April 4, 2001 placement and services provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

1. STUDENT’s unique needs

In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational placement offered by the District, one must first determine the nature of STUDENT’s needs as of April 2001.

(a) May STUDENT’s needs be determined using Dr. Byrd’s report? The District contends that Dr. Byrd’s report should not be considered in determining whether if offered STUDENT a FAPE at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting because it did not have Dr. Byrd’s report available at the IEP meeting. While this contention is true, all individuals with disabilities residing in the state, including pupils with disabilities who are enrolled in parochial schools, regardless of the severity of their disabilities, and who are in need of special education and related services, shall be identified, located, and assessed. Each district, special education local plan area, or county office shall establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system which addresses the relationships among identification, screening, referral, assessment, planning, implementation, review, and the triennial assessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(A)(3)(ii)(10); Cal. Ed. Code § 56301.

In this case, the District had not assessed STUDENT since February 1997, which includes the three years she attended private school during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years. When the District decided that STUDENT should again attend public school for the 2001-2002 school year, it had the duty, under the Child-Find system, to either reassess STUDENT pursuant to Cal. Ed. Code § 56043(i) or to conduct a new initial assessment for a child reentering the District pursuant to Cal. Ed. Code § 56320. However, the District failed to assess STUDENT before holding the IEP on April 4, 2001. The District argues that it was not required to reevaluate STUDENT until October 2001 because it conducted her audiological evaluation in October 1998. While this fact is true with regard to STUDENT’s audiological needs, it is not true with regard to her visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression needs, as discussed in greater detail below. If the District had reevaluated STUDENT as it was required to do, it would have understood what STUDENT’s needs were at the time of the April 2001 IEP meeting. Because both Ms. Harwood and Dr. Byrd make similar findings in their 1997 and 2001 reports, it is reasonable to conclude that the District would have made similar findings if it had assessed STUDENT prior to the April 2001 IEP meeting. Thus, in striving to determine what was, and was not, objectively reasonable at the time the IEP was drafted, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is equitable to consider both Karen Harwood’s 1997 report and Dr. Byrd’s June 2001 report regarding STUDENT’s needs as of the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting.

(b) STUDENT’s unique needs

On February 7, 1997, Ms. Karen Harwood, District special education school psychologist, assessed STUDENT in the areas of cognitive functioning, academic functioning, speech and language, behavior, and social emotional needs. With the exception of speech and language, Dr. Byrd evaluated STUDENT in the same domains in May 2001. In addition, Dr. Byrd also assessed STUDENT in the area of visual-spatial functioning and integration. While Ms. Harwood did not formally assess STUDENT’s visual-spatial functioning and integration, she made numerous observations about this domain in her report. The Hearing Officer shall now review the assessment results from both psychologists. To assess STUDENT’s cognitive functioning, Ms. Harwood employed the Ordinal Scales of Development-Cognition. Ms. Harwood determined that STUDENT’s cognitive skills and general abilities were within average to high average ranges. Dr. Byrd applied the Leiter International Performance Scale-Revised. The results of Dr. Byrd’s assessment yielded a full scale IQ in the average range. However, Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT’s abilities were higher than the test revealed due to his observations, review of work samples, discussions, and informal assessments of STUDENT. To assess STUDENT’s academic functioning, Ms. Harwood employed the PIAT-R and subtests of the Brigance. Ms. Harwood determined that STUDENT’s academic performance in math, reading, writing and general knowledge were generally at a third grade level, which was below her fourth grade level at that time. To assess STUDENT in the same areas, Dr. Byrd employed the Woodcock-Johnson Third Edition, Test of Academic Achievement, the Wechsler Individualized Achievement Test, Spelling subtest, and the Test of Adolescent and Adult language. His tests revealed that her reading and math abilities were average while her written expression was in the low average range or two grade levels below where she should have been. Dr. Byrd testified that weak written expression has been and continues to be a significant need for STUDENT. Finally, both Ms. Harwood and Dr. Byrd noted similar attention and impulsiveness problems while testing STUDENT’s academic functioning. Thus, both Ms. Harwood’s assessment in 1997 and Dr. Byrd’s assessment in 2001 revealed similar ongoing strengths and weaknesses in STUDENT’s cognitive and academic functioning.

Both Ms. Harwood and Dr. Byrd assessed STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavioral functioning. To assess STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavioral functioning, Ms. Harwood employed the Burks Behavior Rating Scale, Devereux Child Behavior Rating Scale and observations. Ms. Harwood learned that STUDENT, at times, displayed age appropriate social skills and behaviors. However, STUDENT also had problems with distractions, speaking out, and the need for limits. Dr. Byrd employed the Adolescent Symptoms Inventory-4 Parent Checklist, Learning Disabilities Evaluation Scale, Child Symptom Inventory, Youth’s Inventory, Brown ADD Scale, and the RCMAS. The tests also revealed similar behavioral problems found by Ms. Harwood. Furthermore, Dr. Byrd concluded that STUDENT suffered from anxiety and depression. Thus, both Ms. Harwoods’s assessment in 1997 and Dr. Byrd’s assessment in 2001 revealed similar ongoing strengths and weaknesses, in addition to Dr. Byrd’s diagnosis of anxiety and depression, in STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavioral functioning.

Both Dr. Byrd and Ms. Harwood assessed STUDENT’s visual-spatial functioning and integration. While Dr. Byrd formally assessed this domain, Ms. Harwood informally used observation only. To assess STUDENT’s visual-spatial functioning, Dr. Byrd employed the TVPS-nm, the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, the Visual Perception test and the Motor Coordination test. While the TVPS-nm showed that STUDENT’s overall visual processing abilities were in the high average to superior range, the subtest scores varied from the low average to the very superior range. Dr. Byrd concluded from the test results that STUDENT’s visual memory is weak and that she has a very impulsive response style. Dr. Byrd testified that her weak working memory is intricately connected to her weak written expression. These weaknesses, he pointed out, are significant needs for STUDENT (Footnote 4).

Ms. Harwood made similar findings when she informally observed STUDENT. During her cognitive assessment, Ms Harwood noted that STUDENT demonstrated information processing difficulties that were not consistent with her measured and demonstrated cognitive abilities. She pointed out that STUDENT was most successful at processing information that is presented through her eyes. “Through-the-air communication like sign language appears to be the strongest and most meaningful way for STUDENT to take in information. STUDENT’s ability to express herself and what she knows is most consistently demonstrated in oral/through-the-air communications. Although STUDENT has a very significant hearing loss, she does appear to use her listening skills to supplement her sign language reception. It appears that when STUDENT is presented with visual or print information, such as with math worksheets, reading books, or completing writing work or written assignments, she tends to not attend as thoroughly, causing for careless errors and somewhat weaker retention and later recall.” “STUDENT has difficulty getting things down on paper from memory. Attention and processing appear to improve when she can put her full attention on watching and listening, as opposed to reading from printed material and writing. Visual motor integration skills are slightly weak.”

When Ms. Harwood assessed STUDENT’s behavior, she found an impulsive response style that Dr. Bryd noted years later. In her report, Ms. Harwood stated that “STUDENT is able to work independently but needs frequent connection with adults (eye contact, reminders, verbal prompts) to remain on task and focused.” “Her rush to complete more familiar and easy tasks and problems led to frequent errors. She needed to be reminded to check her work. When presented with a task, she had to consistently be reminded to “wait” for instructions. STUDENT is a good “scanner” and appears able to readily grasp tasks and directions, however, she was noted to miss relevant details and needed information.” Finally, Ms. Harwood noted that “STUDENT’s behavior during memory and other more challenging tasks was somewhat distractible; dropping a pencil to the floor, quickly looking/scanning the items then “blanking” when asked to recall, viewing items than asking when recess is and asking to “see it again.” STUDENT tends to look at “wholes” sometimes missing important “parts.” STUDENT tends to “scan” instead of “look” to process or retain information.” Thus, both Ms. Harwood’s informal observations in 1997 and Dr. Byrd’s formal assessment in 2001 revealed similar strengths and weaknesses in STUDENT’s attention, response style, visual-spatial processing and integration and memory. On October 20, 1998, the Parker Hearing and Speech Institute (Institute) conducted a three year audiological and speech assessment of STUDENT. While neither Petitioner nor the District provided the actual report from the assessment, the assessment results were outlined in the February 26, 1999 IEP document. Employing the Phonological Processes-Revised to assess STUDENT’s hearing and the Language Sample to assess her speech, the audiological assessment confirmed that STUDENT continued to suffer from a profound bilateral sensorineural hearing loss that required her to wear bilateral hearing aides and employ the services of an ASL interpreter. The speech assessment revealed that STUDENT suffered from a moderate to severe articulation and voice disorder. It noted that STUDENT needed to improve the intelligibility, vocal pitch, rate, and intonation of her speech.

In summary, both Ms. Harwood’s assessment in 1997 and Dr. Byrd’s assessment in June 2001 assessment revealed that STUDENT has longstanding, ongoing needs in visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, written expression, audiology, speech reading, attention, behavior and lesser needs in academics and cognition.

2. Program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs

The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is to examine the April 4, 2001 IEP. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. They are developed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the special education, related services and supplementary aides that will assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii)(iii).

The April 4, 2001 IEP sets forth the goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s unique needs in auditory training, speech reading and vocational education. Petitioner and the District disputed whether these three goals and objectives met STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP team did not write goals to address STUDENT’s attention, academics, visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression. Thus, the Hearing Officer shall first analyze the goals and objectives as set forth in the IEP.

Written goals and objectives (a) Auditory training

The auditory training goal and objectives were written to address STUDENT’s need to demonstrate auditory cognitive skills within a structured listening set, to recall details of a story, and answer questions requiring comprehension of the main idea of a short conversation. The Petitioner contends that auditory goal and objectives are inappropriate because they were not properly developed and are beyond STUDENT’s reach. Ms. Dellenbach testified that they are setting up STUDENT for failure because the 100% accuracy levels are not possible for a young girl who is severely deaf. The District contends that the present audiological goals and objectives mirror the February 1999 audiological goals and objectives and are a natural progression to the old ones. However, Ms. Saxman, the District’s audiologist at the IEP meeting, testified that she did not know how the audiological goals and objectives were arrived at. She understood that Christine Hill, the District’s itinerant speech and language teacher, believed that STUDENT had met the February 1999 audiology goals and objectives and that the new ones were a logical follow-up to the old ones. However, Ms. Saxman did not know how Ms. Hill reached this conclusion. Furthermore, there was no testimony at the hearing that the IEP team discussed what STUDENT’s prior audiological levels of performance were, whether they had been met, and what her present audiology levels were. While the District points out that STUDENT used her hearing aides to their maximum benefit and maintained a C average in her classes, these facts do not establish that she was prepared to graduate up to the next level of auditory training or that the 1999 audiological goals and objectives were still appropriate for STUDENT in 2001. Finally, Ms. Saxman testified that the auditory goals and objectives were written by Ms. Hill, who is not a trained audiologist and who did not have a recent, objective audiological examination available for STUDENT at the April 2001 IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that although the 2001 audiological goal and objectives mirror and are a progression of the 1999 audiological goal and objectives, this progression alone does not establish that they are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

(b) Speech reading

The speech reading goal is written to address STUDENT’s need to use her speech reading skills to develop her academic functioning and vocabulary taken from academic work. The Petitioner again contends that the goals and objectives are setting STUDENT up for failure because they do not accurately represent her present levels of performance and the 100% accuracy levels are not possible for a young girl who is severely deaf. The District reiterates its contention that the speech reading goals and objectives are appropriate because they are a natural progression from the speech reading goals and objectives in the February 1999 IEP. Ms. Saxman admitted that she again relied upon Ms. Hill’s representation that the 1999 speech reading goal and objectives had been met without knowing how Ms. Hill arrived at this conclusion. Review of the 1999 speech reading goals and objectives and the April 2001 speech reading goals and objectives shows that they are very similar except for the increased percentages in the 2001 goals and objectives. Again, a mere progression of the goals and objectives alone does not objectively establish their appropriateness. Finally, there was no testimony at the hearing that the IEP team discussed whether the old speech reading goals and objectives had been met and what STUDENT’s specific present levels of performance were in this area. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the April 2001 speech reading goals and objectives were not drafted to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual speech reading needs.

(c) Behavior

The IEP team wrote a vocational education goal and short-term objectives to address STUDENT’s behavior needs for a smooth transition into public school. With regard to STUDENT’s behavior needs, neither STUDENT’s Parent nor Ms. Plourde advised the IEP team that STUDENT was having any behavior problems. Approximately one month after the April 2001 IEP meeting, Ms. Plourde filled out a questionnaire for Dr. Byrd and again indicated that STUDENT was not having any behavior problems. Furthermore, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT is not having any behavior problems at Serra. However, STUDENT’S Parent, Ms. Dellenbach and Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT had a very long history of behavioral problems. To date, she takes Ritalin and receives counseling from a psychiatrist at St. Johns Hospital in Southern California. While STUDENT’s behavior is presently in check, her history of behavioral problems established a need for a behavior goal and objective. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s vocational goal and objective to address STUDENT’s behavior during her transition into public school was appropriate.

Unwritten goals and obectives (d) Academics and attention

The IEP team did not write a goal and objective to address STUDENT’s academic needs. At the IEP meeting, Ms. Plourde advised the IEP team that STUDENT maintained a C average in all of her classes for the eighth grade (Footnote 5). The testing by Dr. Byrd and Ms. Harwood also revealed that STUDENT was a bright young girl. However, the testimony from STUDENT’s Parent and Ms. Dellenbach also established that STUDENT’s C average was not without a lot of struggle and hard work on her part. Finally, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT’s C average at Serra was also not without hard work. While the evidence established, then, that STUDENT’s C average was well earned, the District did not have an objective basis to write an academic goal and objectives for this need at time of the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting.

Finally, the IEP team did not write a goal to address STUDENT’s attention. At the IEP meeting, neither STUDENT’s Parent nor Ms. Plourde advised the IEP team that STUDENT experienced any attention needs. Ms. Plourde also testified that STUDENT’s attention and impulsiveness were much improved in the eighth grade at Maria Regina, and she indicated the same in the questionnaire she filled out for Dr. Byrd in May 2001. Moreover, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT can sit for 110 minutes at a time in her block classes at Serra without any attention problems. However, she did note ongoing organizational problems at Serra. Dr. Byrd confirmed that while STUDENT’s attention seems to be in check for the moment, she still has missing assignments, incomplete work, and inconsistent work habits at Serra. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team did not have an objective basis to write a goal and objective for STUDENT’s historical attention need at the time of the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting.

(e) Visual spatial integration, memory, and written expression, academics and attention

The IEP team did not write goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s significant visual-spatial integration, memory, and written expression needs. While neither STUDENT’s Parent nor Ms. Plourde raised these needs at the April 2001 IEP meeting, the evidence presented at the hearing established that STUDENT has exhibited significant visual-spatial processing and integration, memory and written expression problems throughout elementary school, during the fifth grade when Ms. Harwood assessed STUDENT in 1997, during her three years at the private middle school as testified to by Ms. Plourde, and as documented by Dr. Byrd one month after the IEP meeting in his June 2001 report. Furthermore, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT presently forgets to bring materials and homework to school, misses assignments, and is not passing exams which she should pass. Thus, the IEP team had sufficient information to put it on notice and to inquire whether STUDENT had ongoing needs in visual spatial integration, memory, and written expression and it failed to develop goals and objectives for these needs.

In summary, the evidence established that the IEP team did not develop proper goals and objectives in audiology and speech reading, did not have an objective basis to develop goals and objectives in the areas of behavior, academics and attention, and failed to develop goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s significant needs in the areas of visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression.

(f) Specific placement and services

In this case, the District placement offer had four main components: first, home school; second, a general education curriculum; third, typically developing peers; and fourth, support from DHH and itinerant speech and language teachers. While the District’s placement proposed integrating STUDENT into the general education environment at her home school, the parties agreed at the hearing that the District had offered Gardena. Yet, Ms. Koff testified that it was the District’s opinion that because STUDENT was essentially a general education student, she could attend any District high school with a general education curriculum. The IEP team, however, did not write any goals and objectives in STUDENT’s significant and lesser areas of need to support the proposed local school placement. Furthermore, Petitioner argued that the large school campus at Gardena without goals and objectives was setting STUDENT up for failure. In light of the fact that STUDENT’s prior progress was not without struggle, Peititioner’s contention, at the very least, merits consideration. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the specific academic placement offered by the District, without goals and objective to address STUDENT’s significant areas of need, will not provide her with educational benefit.

Student contends that the District failed to offer appropriate services for the 2001-2002 school year. First, Student alleges that the District should have offered STUDENT counseling for her anxiety and depression needs. However, the evidence at the hearing established that before Dr. Byrd’s report in June 2001, there was no indication that STUDENT suffered from anxiety or depression at school. Furthermore, neither STUDENT’s Parent nor Ms. Plourde advised the IEP team that STUDENT suffered from these two maladies. Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT’s parents never advised her at the interview to attend Serra that STUDENT suffers from depression and anxiety and she has not been advised of any need in this area to date. Finally, the evidence established that neither Maria Regina nor Serra has counseling to meet these alleged needs of STUDENT. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no objective basis for the District to offer STUDENT counseling.

Finally, Student contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT full-time ASL interpreter services. California Education Code § 56000.5(b)(7) provides that it is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have programs in which they have direct and appropriate access to all components of the educational process, including, but not limited to, recess, lunch, and extracurricular social and athletic activities. The weight of the evidence established that the District offered STUDENT a full-time ASL interpreter during the entire school day. First, the evidence at the hearing established that for the two and a half years that STUDENT attended Maria Regina prior to the April 2001 IEP meeting, the District provided her with full- time ASL interpreter services in all non-parochial classes during the school day. Second, Dr. Larry Fleischer, STUDENT’s expert witness on deaf education, testified that he understood the District’s offer to include a full-time ASL interpreter during all classes. However, he interpreted the offer to exclude an ASL interpreter during lunch and nonclass times. The District’s witnesses testified that their offer of an ASL interpreter did include lunch and nonclass time. With regard to ASL interpreter services for extracurricular activities, the witnesses for both Student and the District concurred that the IEP team did not discuss extracurricular activities at the IEP meeting because no team member raised it as an issue. While there was substantial controversy regarding the District’s ability to provide an ASL interpreter for STUDENT for athletics after school, the District’s witnesses testified that there was requisite funding for an extracurricular ASL interpreter for STUDENT after school and the District was ready and willing to provide one for her. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was prepared to provide and could provide a full-time ASL interpreter to STUDENT for after-school athletics and social activities.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer a program which met STUDENT’s most significant and unique needs because it did not write goals and objectives which addressed STUDENT’s significant and ongoing needs in the areas of visual spatial processing and integration, memory, written expression and wrote improper goals and objectives in the lesser areas of need in audiology and speech reading.

(3) Program designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit

In light of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, Student and the District disputed whether her local school, Gardena, could provide STUDENT with academic benefit. The dispute centered on the discipline procedures, the size of the campus, and the academic level of achievement at Gardena. While the District presented a substantial amount of evidence regarding these three issues to prove that Gardena could meet STUDENT’s academic and behavior needs, STUDENT would have to attend Gardena without any goals and objective for her visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression, her most significant areas of need, and improper goals and objectives for audiology and speech, her lesser areas of need. The problem STUDENT faced without the proper goals and objectives, according to Dr. Byrd and Ms. Dellenbach, is that she faced an uphill battle to achieve average academic success that she had worked so hard to achieve in the past. Ms. Dellenbach feared that STUDENT might slip back into bad habits, get involved in the wrong crowd, become distracted from her academics and ultimately lose the hard-fought for academic and personal progress she had made to date. The educational records from Maria Regina showed that despite all of the support and strict discipline STUDENT had at the school, she barely maintained her attention, her behavior in class, and her organization, and she worked very hard to earn a C average. Finally, Student’s witnesses were concerned that the gains that STUDENT had made in her attention and behavior could also be lost. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that without the support of properly written goals and objectives in STUDENT’s areas of need, the discipline procedures and academics at Gardena could not ensure continued educational benefit due to the large size of the campus.

(4) Implementation of the IEP

This element was not in issue at the hearing.

(5) Program designed to provide STUDENT with the least restrictive environment

This element was not in issue at the hearing.

(6) Conclusion

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing established that the placement and services offered by the District to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year, without goals and objectives to meet her unique and individual needs, would not provide STUDENT a FAPE.

(7) Procedural violations

Student alleged that the District committed nine procedural violations. However, the Hearing Officer finds that these issues are moot because the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

ISSUE 3: If the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Serra High School during the 2001-2002 school year?

A district may be required to reimburse parents for the costs of private placements they procured if it is concluded that the district failed to provide the student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) in a timely manner prior to enrollment at the private school and the private placement is appropriate. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c). STUDENT’s parents may be entitled for the costs of STUDENT’s attendance at Serra High School if it is determined that the private school placement was appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); Student W. vs. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). To be appropriate, the services provided by a parent must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the student with educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200. However, parents are not required to provide the “perfect” placement for their children when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. Alamo Heights Independence School District v. Texas Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). For purposes of reimbursement, the placement provided by the parent also need not meet every requirement to be appropriate. For example, the placement need not be state-certified as a nonpublic school. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 14 (1993).

At the IEP meeting on April 4, 2001, STUDENT’s Parent offered to pay for tuition at the private school placement if the District would pay for the ASL interpreter services. Ms. Koff rejected STUDENT’s Parent’s proposal and the District rejects it to date. In light of the District’s rejection of STUDENT’s Parent’s proposal, any and all costs of tuition and related expenses they incur at Serra High School remain at issue until the decision in this matter. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Ed. Code § 56176(b).

(a) STUDENT’s needs

The evidence regarding STUDENT’s needs is discussed in more detail above. To briefly reiterate, STUDENT has significant needs in visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, written expression, and lesser needs in academics, cognition, audiology and speech reading, and historical needs in behavior and attention. STUDENT also takes Ritalin daily and receives private counseling from a psychiatrist. Finally, she needs the services of an ASL interpreter, uses bilateral hearing aides, and requires preferential seating in class.

(b) Does Serra offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s parents placed her at Serra, a private parochial school. The school has a total of 500 students in the ninth to the twelfth grades. During the day, STUDENT attends ninth grade regular education classes with typically developing peers. She takes algebra, English, history, religion, French, music, and computer. In order to meet her academic needs, STUDENT takes part in a study program and receives tutoring in algebra. While STUDENT has preferential seating and uses an ASL interpreter and her bilateral hearing aides in her classes and extracurricular activities, Serra does not provide ASL interpreter services to her (Footnote 6). Finally, Serra has no special education program or teachers and no special education goals and objectives in place to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines whether the program and services at Serra meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with educational benefit.

At the hearing, Student presented evidence that Serra met STUDENT’s behavioral and structural needs. With regard to STUDENT’s behavioral needs, Student presented evidence that Serra has strict disciplinary rules and procedures to address her behavior. Dr. Byrd, Dr. Fleischer, and Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT is required to follow the rules, and if she does not, she is immediately reprimanded and reported to the head office. Dr. Byrd testified that this structure is important to help STUDENT understand rules and consequences. Furthermore, Dr. Byrd noted that this strict environment minimizes distractions for STUDENT and requires her to be attentive in class. However, the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT’s behavior was in check during her last two years at Maria Regina and when she entered Serra. Ms. Shoukry testified that within two weeks of entering Serra, STUDENT fully acclimated herself to the campus and she has had no behavior problems since. Ms. Shoukry pointed out that it takes the average student at Serra a whole quarter to acclimate him or herself to the campus. Thus, while Serra’s disciplinary rules are able to maintain STUDENT’s gains in behavior, her behavior was not a primary need when she entered Serra (Footnote 7).

With regard to STUDENT’s need for structure, Student contends that Serra meets this need also. Student’s witnesses testified that the classrooms at Serra are very structured. Ms. Shoukry testified that this structure is consistent from class to class. All classrooms have assignments and rules posted on the board. To facilitate learning, the instructors use different colored markers on the board to emphasize important academic concepts and other matters. Furthermore, the classroom contains computers, VCRs, and overhead projectors to enhance the learning experience for STUDENT. Dr. Byrd and Dr. Fleischer observed STUDENT participate in class and noted that she attended well to her environment and work. Furthermore, she had preferential seating in the front of her classes and the ASL interpreter was appropriately utilized in the classroom (Footnote 8). However, the evidence at the hearing established that despite Serra’s structure and discipline, STUDENT continues to have the same organizational problems that have plagued her since she began elementary school. Ms. Shoukry testified that while Serra closely monitors whether its students bring all requisite materials to class and do their homework, STUDENT has failed to bring materials to school, has left papers in class, and has not done as well on tests as she should have. Instead of achieving the high academic levels that Serra strives for, STUDENT has only been able to duplicate the same C average she has historically achieved in the past.

The Hearing Officer finds that the reason that STUDENT has faired no better academically at Serra than she did at either public school or Maria Regina is tht Serra has neither a special education infrastructure nor special education teachers to meet STUDENT’s significant needs in the areas of visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression. First, Ms. Shoukry testified that Serra has no special education teachers. The teachers it employs have no special education credentials, no sign language training, and no background in deaf education. Ms. Delenbach, an experienced, credentialed educator of the deaf for over 27 years and a former teacher of STUDENT’s, testified that STUDENT needed a trained and credentialed teacher of the deaf to fall back on and to oversee what is happening with STUDENT in school. Furthermore, Ms. Dellenbach testified that the school needs skilled teachers in sign language since the ASL interpreter is not always there. Dr. Fleischer testified that when the ASL interpreter is not present, the deaf student, in general, falls behind. Thus, the evidence at the hearing established that Serra does not have the needed special education and deaf education staff to address STUDENT’s unique needs.

The evidence at the hearing also established that Serra’s emphasis is not on serving special education students with significant needs such as STUDENT has. Ms. Shoukry testified that Serra is an exclusive college preparatory high school that is geared toward educating academically bright and college-bound students. Ms. Shoukry made it absolutely clear that Serra has neither special education nor vocational education classes and is not designed to meet the needs of special education students. Furthermore, she pointed out that the only accommodation Serra can provide STUDENT is preferential seating, extended time to do her work, and permission to use an ASL interpreter in class. There was no evidence at the hearing that Serra ever offered to provide STUDENT with an ASL interpreter to access her classes. Moreover, Ms. Shoukry testified that Serra has no counseling. Ms. Dellenbach testified that STUDENT needs counseling in her school setting for her emotional problems. Finally, Ms. Shoukry testified that when STUDENT’s parents and STUDENT interviewed to attend Serra in January 2001, Ms. Shoukry advised them that Serra was not designed to meet the needs of a special education student. Nonetheless, STUDENT’s parents enrolled her at Serra. Therefore, the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT’s parents sent her to Serra with full knowledge that the school had no special education infrastructure to specifically address STUDENT’s special education needs.

Because Serra has no special education infrastructure and teachers to specifically address STUDENT’s significant needs, it does not implement any goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s significant needs in visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, written expression, and mood. With regard to her visual integration and memory needs, Dr. Byrd made numerous recommendations on how to address this ongoing area of need in the classroom. For example, he suggested that the teacher should provide concrete visual representations of the information that is presented in a verbally sequential manner using models of multi-step procedures. He recommended that the teachers provide STUDENT with checklists for sequential procedures, ordering and scheduling. In the classroom, Dr. Byrd also recommended that STUDENT be given advance warning of sequential information that will be discussed and preface the discussion with the number of items/steps that will be covered. Finally, Dr. Byrd suggested that STUDENT be given advance preparation regarding the type of sequences that will be discussed. However, there was no testimony that Serra implements any of these strategies to address STUDENT’s needs in visual integration and memory. With regard to STUDENT’s written expression needs, Dr. Byrd made many suggestions on how to address this ongoing area of need in the classroom. For example, he recommended that the teachers instruct STUDENT using kinesthetic writing to reinforce learning. To improve her spelling, he recommended that the classroom instruction focus on the knowledge of sounds, letter-sound relationships, letter sound patterns, syllables, and morphemes. Moreover, Dr. Byrd suggested that STUDENT be taught how to focus on words that are spelled as they sound before moving on to irregular words. He recommended that teachers develop effective strategies for approaching writing projects and proofing her papers. Finally, Dr. Byrd suggested multi-modal teaching and evaluation for STUDENT. However, there was no testimony that Serra implements any of these recommendations to address STUDENT’s written expression needs. Finally, with regard to STUDENT’s mood, Dr. suggested that STUDENT employ relaxation techniques during study and class activities. Again, there was no testimony that Serra implements this recommendation. Therefore, the evidence at the hearing established that Serra does not address STUDENT’s critical visual-spatial processing and integration needs, memory, written expression and mood needs.

Finally, the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT’s parents motives for sending her to Serra were not related to her special education needs. First, STUDENT’s Parent testified throughout the hearing that she sent STUDENT to Maria Regina and Serra because she wanted a small, structured school environment. However, the parents’ interview at Serra in January 2001 painted a different picture. At the interview, they told Ms. Shoukry that they wanted STUDENT to attend Serra because she was bored at the school she attended and needed the academic challenge Serra could provide her. Furthermore, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT had another sister who attended Serra, was the valedictorian when she graduated, and had since gone on to college. Ms. Shoukry noted that STUDENT advised her that she always wanted to attend Serra just as her sister had. Finally, Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT’s parents never advised her that STUDENT had any attention, behavior, organizational, anxiety, depression, visual-spatial processing and integration, written expression, memory or mood needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents did not enroll STUDENT in Serra to meet her significant needs in the aforementioned areas, but to provide her with an exclusive academic environment such as her sister had to prepare her to enter college.

In summary, the evidence at the hearing established that while Serra could meet STUDENT’s lesser needs in behavior, discipline, attention and academics, it possessed neither the infrastructure, the intent nor the vision to address her significant visual-spatial and integration, memory, and written expression needs.

(c) Does Serra provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

While the evidence at the hearing established that Serra provides STUDENT with some educational benefit in her lesser areas of need, it has been at the expense of her other significant needs. Ms. Shoukry testified that STUDENT has maintained a C average while attending Serra. This C average is no better than STUDENT achieved in the public school or at Maria Regina. While Student’s witnesses testified that STUDENT is liked by her classmates, plays basketball, partakes in band, and has played piano in the school Christmas concert, these nonacademic endeavors come at the expense of addressing her significant needs. Again, STUDENT continues to have organizational problems. Ms. Shodukry testified that STUDENT continues to have problems with not bringing books, papers and other items to class, and is not passing tests that she should. Furthermore, there is no special education infrastructure or teachers to address her needs in her visual-spatial processing and integration, memory, and written expression needs. Finally, the academic progress that STUDENT has made at Serra is no different than she achieved in public school or the middle school she attended at Maria Regina (Footnote 9). While Serra keeps STUDENT’s behavior in check with discipline and structure and has helped her to maintain a C average, these benefits are far outweighed by the fact that the school that has no special education infrastructure, no special education teachers for the deaf and hard of hearing, and no intent to meet her significant and ongoing needs in the areas of visual-spatial processing and integration, memory and written expression. In light of the totality of the circumstances in this case, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and other costs incurred at Serra for the 2001-2002 school year. ISSUE 4: If STUDENT’s placement at Serra provides her with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at a private parochial high school?

The Hearing Officer finds that this issue is moot pursuant to the finding that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement.

ORDER

The Petitioner’s request for relief for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), this Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Did the District have a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

Student prevailed on this issue.

(2) If the District had a legal obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, did the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting provide STUDENT a FAPE?

Student prevailed on this issue.

(3) If the District’s offer of placement and services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Serra High School during the 2001-2002 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(4) If STUDENT’s placement at Serra provides her with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at a noncertified, private, parochial school?

Neither party prevailed on this issue because it is moot.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 17, 2002 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. STUDENT’s foster parents later adopted her when she was five years old.

2. Maria Regina is a private, parochial school. STUDENT attended this Maria Regina for the sixth, seventh, and eighth grades during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years.

3. Federal and State law provide that to the extent consistent with their number and location in the State, provision must be made for the participation of private school children with disabilities in the program assisted or carried out under part B of the Act by providing them with special education and related services in accordance with §§ 300.453-300.462. 34 C.F.R. § 300.451; Cal. Ed. Code § 56172. Furthermore, no private school child with a disability has an individual right to receive some or all of the special education and related services that the child would receive if enrolled in a public school. 34 C.F.R. § 300.454(a)(1). Finally, students are not entitled to a due process hearing to challenge a LEA’s use of proportional federal funds or to challenge the service plan. 34 C.F.R. § 300.457.

4. Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT struggles with organizing, spelling and writing words fluently. Furthermore, he noted that her weak written expression and working memory also carry over into her organization

5. While STUDENT also maintained a C average in the seventh grade at Maria Regina, she received a D average in the sixth grade.

6. With the exception of the ASL interpreter for extracurricular activities, the District offered STUDENT primarily the same academic components, a study program in Ms. Margolin’s DHH class, and offered STUDENT a full-time ASL interpreter.

7. The evidence at the hearing established that the District school provided STUDENT with a similar disciplinary system.

8. The evidence at the hearing established that the District school provided STUDENT with a similar structured environment.

9. Maria Regina also had no special education infrastructure and teachers.