California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 11, 1998
Student v. Siskiyou County Office of Education
SEHO Case No. SN 1533-97 · Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan
Siskiyou County Office of Education's physical therapy and speech offers upheld; grandparents' request for assessment reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A nine-year-old second grader filed against the Siskiyou County Office of Education (COE), which provides all of his special education services at Dorris Elementary School. An attorney from Far Northern Regional Center represented him. His IEP described him as developmentally disabled, and he has significant speech and oral-motor difficulties. Butte Valley Unified was dismissed from the case after the COE accepted full responsibility. The dispute was about related services, not his class placement. The student asked for one hour per week of physical therapy, including sensory integration, and three hours per week of speech and language therapy. The COE offered two hours a month of physical therapy, half direct and half consultation. It also offered 5 to 6.25 hours per week of speech and language services, mostly structured activities run by his aide under a therapist's guidance. Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard and upheld both offers. School staff credibly testified that he was making progress. The family's witnesses were not qualified to judge therapy levels, and his private therapy was not shown to carry over to school. The student also wanted reimbursement for a private assistive technology assessment. The Hearing Officer denied it for three reasons. The COE had already provided an appropriate Diagnostic Center assessment after the family disagreed with its first one. His grandmother was pleased with that assessment. And the regional center had paid for the private one. All claims were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to disputes over how much related service a student needs. Parent and caseworker reports of progress were weighed against testimony from qualified therapists. A second assessment by the district, arranged after a parent disagreed with the first, was treated as answering the request for an independent assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A. Has the Siskiyou County Office of Education offered Student a FAPE? Does Student require one hour per week of physical therapy, which includes sensory integration therapy, by a qualified physical therapist?
The COE's offer of two hours a month of physical therapy (one hour direct, one hour consultation) met Student's needs and provided educational benefit; Student showed no need for weekly PT or sensory integration therapy at school.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.B. Has the Siskiyou County Office of Education offered Student a FAPE? Does Student require three hours per week of speech and language therapy?
The COE's offer of 5 to 6.25 hours per week of speech and language services, including aide-delivered structured activities under a therapist's guidance, met Student's unique needs and he was progressing; three hours of direct therapy was not required.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue II. Is the Siskiyou County Office of Education required to reimburse the Petitioner's grandparents for the cost of an independent assessment?
After the family disagreed with its first assistive technology assessment, the COE provided an appropriate Diagnostic Center assessment that the family was pleased with, so it did not have to reimburse the later private assessment, which the regional center had paid for.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of the Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; 20 U.S.C. § 1401; Cal. Educ. Code § 56363; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56327; 5 C.C.R. § 3051.1
People named in the decision
- Tom Scovill, special education director, Siskiyou County Office of Education
- Dan Steigman, regional center representative present for Student, Far Northern Regional Center
- Kelly Teitzel, service coordinator; witness for Student, Far Northern Regional Center
- Lynn Roberts, speech and language specialist, assessment team, Northern California Diagnostic Center
- Dru Saren, education specialist, assessment team, Northern California Diagnostic Center
- Lisa Yehle, private speech-language pathologist, Merle West Medical Center, Klamath Falls, Oregon (services at Klamath Pediatric Clinic)
- Sue Nickland, private physical therapist, Klamath Pediatric Clinic
- Suzanne Cresswell, physical and occupational therapist; assessor and witness for COE, Cresswell Physical Therapy and Hand Rehabilitation, Inc., Redding
- Georgia Wright, occupational therapist under contract (certified nonpublic agency), Siskiyou County Office of Education contractor
- B.J. MacElrath, speech-language pathologist; ATAC team member, Siskiyou County Superintendent of Schools Office
- Lewis Arno, speech and language specialist, Siskiyou County Office of Education
- Cindy Holbrook, 1:1 instructional aide, Siskiyou County Office of Education
- Donnie Driscoll, special day class teacher; ATAC team member, Siskiyou County Office of Education
- Kathryn Garcia, program manager, Siskiyou County Office of Education
- Jane Hayes, visual specialist; ATAC team member, Siskiyou County Superintendent of Schools Office
- Assistive Technology Advisory Committee (ATAC), district assistive technology assessment team, Siskiyou County Superintendent of Schools Office
- Child Development and Rehabilitation Center (CDRC), private physical therapy and speech-language evaluator, Oregon Health Sciences University
- Shasta Assistive Technology Services (S.A.T.S.), independent assistive technology evaluator, private provider
- Klamath Pediatric Clinic, private physical and speech therapy provider, Klamath Falls, Oregon
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Dorris, California, on March 19 and 20, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Linda M. Carpenter from the Far Northern Regional Center. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his grandparents, GRANDMOTHER and GRANDFATHER, and Dan Steigman from the Far Northern Regional Center. Respondent Siskiyou County Office of Education was represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on behalf of the Siskiyou County Office of Education was Tom Scovill, special education director for the county superintendent’s office.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the receipt of written closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
I. Has the Siskiyou County Office of Education offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education?
A. Does STUDENT require one hour per week of physical therapy, which includes sensory integration therapy, by a qualified physical therapist?
B. Does STUDENT require three hours per week of speech and language therapy?
II. Is the Siskiyou County Office of Education required to reimburse the Petitioner’s grandparents for the cost of an independent assessment?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Originally, both Siskiyou County Office of Education and Butte Valley Unified School District were parties to this case. At the beginning of the hearing, the Petitioner requested that Butte Valley Unified School District be dismissed as a party. The Siskiyou County Office of Education agreed with the dismissal motion and indicated that it would take full responsibility for STUDENT’s special education and related services. The Hearing Officer granted the Petitioner’s motion and dismissed Butte Valley Unified School District.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old student. STUDENT’s IEP documents indicate that he qualifies for special education services because he is developmentally disabled. STUDENT attends Dorris Elementary School within the Butte Valley Unified School District. The Siskiyou County Office of Education (hereafter COE) provides all of STUDENT’s special education services.
STUDENT moved to California in 1994, just prior to the beginning of the 1994-95 school year. During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT attended a Montessori preschool class in the mornings. The summer before STUDENT entered kindergarten, the COE provided him with speech and language therapy, and extended year services. For his kindergarten year, STUDENT was fully included in a regular education class. The COE provided a one-to-one aide, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy. During first grade, STUDENT spent half the day in a regular first grade class and half the day in a special day class (SDC). He continued to receive speech and language therapy and occupational therapy.
In October 1996, while in first grade, STUDENT was assessed by the Northern California Diagnostic Center. The assessment team included Lynn Roberts, speech and language specialist, and Dru Saren, education specialist. The purpose of the assessment was to determine STUDENT’s communication skills. The assessment team found that STUDENT’s developmental disability affects all areas, but especially those areas that require fine motor planning, including speech production. The team also found that STUDENT’s reasoning ability, play, and language development were severely impaired and compared with that of a nondisabled two-year-old. The team noted STUDENT’s disposition and eagerness to communicate with others as strengths. STUDENT communicates using word approximations, body language, facial expressions, and gestures. STUDENT’s oral motor disability results in drooling and difficulty with chewing and managing food in his mouth. (COE Exh. 12.)
On October 21, 1996, STUDENT was assessed by the Assistive Technology Advisory Committee (ATAC) from the Siskiyou County Superintendent of Schools Office. The committee made recommendations for methods of teaching STUDENT communication skills, including the use of black line drawings, photographs, and sign language, to enable STUDENT to express his needs.
In June 1997, STUDENT’s grandparents began sending STUDENT to physical therapy and speech therapy at the Klamath Pediatric Clinic in Klamath Falls, Oregon. During the fall of 1997, STUDENT attended the private speech and language therapy three times a week. The amount of private speech and language therapy was changed to twice a week during the winter and has remained at that level with Lisa Yehle as the provider. STUDENT receives private physical therapy from Sue Nickland once a week for one hour. The Far Northern Regional Center has paid for the physical therapy, and STUDENT’s grandparents have paid for the speech and language therapy. In order to attend these sessions, STUDENT is removed from school two days a week.
In February 1998, the Diagnostic Center did a follow-up assessment of STUDENT. The assessment states in part that the reason for the referral was to look at STUDENT’s communication development and his use of an assistive technology device. Additionally, the assessors were asked to comment on STUDENT’s educational program and progress.
After the Diagnostic Center assessed STUDENT, his grandparents took him to Shasta Assistive Technology Services (S.A.T.S.) for an independent assistive technology evaluation. The assessment team found that STUDENT’s needs include a communication system that will allow him to clearly express his needs, wants, and feelings.
On March 9, 1998, an IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. The COE offered the following as STUDENT’s program, to begin in March 1998 and to be reviewed in March 1999:
Special Day Class 4 hours per day Speech/Language 5.0 - 6.25 hours per week -1.25 hours per week therapist direct time with STUDENT and consultation with aide -3.75 to 5.0 hours per week structured language activities carried out by aide under guidance of therapist
Occupational Therapist 2 hours per month -1 hour per month direct time with STUDENT -1 hour per month consultation with aide
Physical Therapist 2 hours per month -1 hour per month direct time with STUDENT -1 hour per month consultation with aide
Instructional Aide 5.25 hours per day
The IEP dated March 9, 1998, has not been signed by STUDENT’s grandparents.
Currently, STUDENT is in the second grade at Dorris Elementary School. The last agreed-upon IEP which sets forth STUDENT’s current educational program is dated June 12, 1997. According to the IEP, STUDENT is to be in the special day class (SDC) four to four-and-a-half hours per day and in a regular education class one-and-a-half to two hours a day. Throughout most of the day, STUDENT is assisted by a one-to-one aide. The COE is also providing speech and language services and occupational therapy.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Has the Siskiyou County Office of Education offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(A)-(D), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are provided at public expense, meet the standards of the State educational agency, and conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability....” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).)
The term “related services” includes services such as speech and language pathology, physical and occupational therapy, and transportation, that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). According to the Court, an IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The school district is not required to provide the best possible education, to maximize educational benefits, or to provide each disabled child with an equal educational opportunity “commensurate with the opportunities provided other children.” The school district must only provide a “basic floor of opportunity.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200-201.) If the District’s program reflects the child’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.)
The parties have not argued that there is a disagreement about STUDENT’s classes or instruction. The disagreement is over the amount and type of related services that are necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the discussion below will focus solely on the disputed areas of physical therapy and speech and language therapy.
A. Does STUDENT require one hour per week of physical therapy, which includes sensory integration therapy, by a qualified physical therapist?
Both parties agree that STUDENT needs physical therapy (PT). The only area of disagreement is the level of services to be provided. The Petitioner contends that to benefit from his education, he requires one hour per week of PT, which includes sensory integration, provided by a qualified physical therapist.(Footnote 1) The COE contends that the PT services that it has offered STUDENT are appropriate: two hours a month of PT provided in increments of one hour of direct and one hour of consultative services.
The Petitioner presented limited evidence regarding STUDENT’s need for physical therapy. The Petitioner submitted a report produced by the Child Development and Rehabilitation Center (CDRC). On December 4, 1997, CDRC conducted a physical therapy evaluation of STUDENT as a result of a referral by STUDENT’s grandparents and primary care physician. (Pet. Exh. 9.)(Footnote 2) The report concludes that STUDENT is significantly delayed in gross motor abilities and has problems learning new tasks. The assessor states that it is prudent that STUDENT be reevaluated by a physical therapist every three months and that a physical therapist teach his aide any tasks needed to help him achieve his goals. In addition, the assessor stated that phone contact between the therapist and the aide is perfectly valid and efficient. GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother, and Kelly Teitzel, service coordinator for Far Northern Regional Center, testified that STUDENT needs one hour a week of PT because the only improvement they have seen in STUDENT since he began attending school came about after he began attending private PT. The testimony of GRANDMOTHER and Ms. Teitzel is not persuasive. Although GRANDMOTHER and Ms. Teitzel both testified that they have noticed an improvement in STUDENT since he began receiving one hour per week of PT, neither of them is a physical therapist qualified to make a determination about the level of PT STUDENT needs to benefit from his education. The Petitioner did not call the private physical therapist who works with STUDENT as a witness.
Suzanne Cresswell, physical and occupational therapist, testified on behalf of the COE.(Footnote 3) Ms. Cresswell evaluated STUDENT in September 1997. The evaluation consisted of observations, conversations with school personnel and STUDENT’s grandparents, and the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency. (COE Exh. 22.) Ms. Cresswell’s evaluation report focuses on several areas in which STUDENT has potential PT needs, including communication, self-care, feeding and swallowing, sensation, fine motor control, object relationship, and functional mobility. Ms. Cresswell testified that after observing STUDENT in class and working with him herself, she consulted with his teacher and aide. Based on her evaluation and observation of STUDENT, Ms. Cresswell found that, in terms of academic and educational performance, STUDENT does not need PT. As for sensory integration, Ms. Cresswell testified that it is impossible to avoid some sensory integration because it exists in everyone’s daily life. However, Ms. Cresswell testified that STUDENT does not need sensory integration therapy as part of his educational program and that he does not need personnel trained in sensory integration to benefit from his education. Ms. Cresswell’s report states that STUDENT’s PT needs can be met by the existing school personnel, with consultation services provided by a physical therapist. Ms. Cresswell testified that she recommended consultation because she was impressed with the techniques the teacher and the aide described that they use to address STUDENT’s physical needs but, nevertheless, wanted to have continuing contact with STUDENT’s program.
Georgia Wright, occupational therapist under contract with the COE, has been working with STUDENT since the 1994-95 school year.(Footnote 4) Ms. Wright testified that sensory integration can be done through either physical or occupational therapy, but that it is usually done in conjunction with occupational therapy. Ms. Wright testified that because of STUDENT’s cognitive delays, pull-out for sensory integration therapy should not be the primary mode of therapy for STUDENT. Ms. Wright stated that STUDENT needs to be in a functional setting when he receives therapy because he does not have the capacity to transfer information he learns outside the school to the school setting.
The Petitioner did not present persuasive evidence to support the contention that STUDENT requires one hour per week of PT by a qualified therapist. The CDRC report and the credible testimony of Ms. Cresswell and Ms. Wright lead to the conclusion that the level of PT offered by the COE, two hours a month of PT provided in increments of one hour of direct and one hour of consultative services, is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. As stated above, the COE is not required to provide the best services available or to maximize the student’s potential. Furthermore, the PT offered conforms to the services as set forth in STUDENT’s IEP.(Footnote 5)
B. Does STUDENT require three hours per week of speech and language therapy?
The parties agree that STUDENT needs speech and language therapy. The Petitioner argues that his unique needs are not being met by the level of service currently provided by the COE and that to benefit from his education he requires three hours per week of speech and language therapy. The Petitioner states that the therapy must be provided by a speech pathologist qualified to work with dysarthria, dyspraxia, and oral motor deficits. The COE contends that the speech and language therapy it has offered STUDENT is appropriate: five to six-and-a-quarter hours per week of speech and language therapy broken down into one-and-a-quarter hours per week of direct time with the therapist and consultation with the aide and three and a quarter to five hours per week of structured language activities provided by the aide under the guidance of the speech and language therapist. The COE is currently providing STUDENT thirty minutes of direct speech and language therapy and thirty minutes of speech and language consultation with STUDENT’s aide. (COE Exh. 21.)
STUDENT has significant communication problems including dysarthria(Footnote 6), dyspraxia(Footnote 7), verbal apraxia(Footnote 8), and oral motor difficulties. Lisa Yehle is the speech and language pathologist that was hired by STUDENT’s grandparents to provide private speech and language therapy.(Footnote 9) Ms. Yehle testified that dyspraxia is a motor planning problem by which a person has difficulty calling up a sound to produce it and has difficulty putting sounds together to form words. Ms. Yehle stated that STUDENT’s oral motor difficulties result from low muscle tone in his oral structures that effect his speech and eating. B.J. MacElrath is a speech and language pathologist employed by the Siskiyou County Superintendent of Schools Office. Ms. MacElrath provided STUDENT speech and language therapy during the summer of 1995 and has consulted with STUDENT’s current school-based speech and language provider regarding ideas and activities for the therapy sessions. Ms. MacElrath testified that dysarthria is the greatest area of disability for STUDENT because his mouth does not move correctly. Ms. MacElrath stated that dysarthria and dyspraxia should be treated simultaneously. Ms. MacElrath testified that because of the muscular deficits in STUDENT’s mouth and face, he babbles, drools, and has difficulty eating and communicating. Ms. MacElrath also testified that STUDENT needs consistency and continuity to be successful. Ms. MacElrath testified that she observed STUDENT just prior to the hearing and noticed that STUDENT had increased communicative intent, had become more social, was following a routine, was initiating sound, and had become more aware of his environment since she had last seen him.
In December 1997, CDRC conducted a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT. The CDRC report states that qualities of dysarthria were observed, including simplification in place and manner of production, impreciseness and distortion of speech, reduced vocal intensity, and a slow rate of speech. The February 1998 Diagnostic Center evaluation states that oral dyspraxia keeps STUDENT from imitating or voluntarily producing words but that he can produce some vowel and consonant sounds. STUDENT uses a combination of eye contact, facial expressions, gestures, signs, vocalizations, and word approximations to communicate. (COE Exh. 42, p. 3.) STUDENT attempts to use speech to communicate, but much of his speech is unintelligible. (COE Exh. 33.) Donnie Driscoll, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, testified that STUDENT also uses sign language to communicate.
Lewis Arno, COE speech and language specialist, began working with STUDENT in August 1995.(Footnote 10) Mr. Arno stated that the goals he worked on with STUDENT during kindergarten were in the areas of drooling, lip closure, sound production, vocalization, articulation, and oral motor activities. Mr. Arno testified that STUDENT’s global developmental delays have hindered his speech and language development and that STUDENT needs a lot of repetition and exposure to an activity. Mr. Arno stated that the use of a one-to-one aide is beneficial in providing STUDENT the repetition he needs to learn. In STUDENT’s first-grade year, Mr. Arno worked on vocalization, vocabulary development, oral motor activities, and articulation. As the year progressed, STUDENT became more vocal, began stating “what” and “where” queries, and became more independent in his speech. Mr. Arno testified that STUDENT has also been increasing the signs he knows. Mr. Arno stated that STUDENT is continuing with his progress toward meeting his IEP speech and language goals. For example, Mr. Arno stated STUDENT “chants” up to fourteen syllables, initiates questions, and speaks ten or more two-syllable words, counts to ten, matches colors, and learns new words. Mr. Arno testified that the reason for the recommended increase in speech and language services is because of the proposed introduction of an augmentative communication device.
Mr. Arno testified about his work with Cindy Holbrook, STUDENT’s aide. Mr. Arno stated that Ms. Holbrook keeps notes of her work with STUDENT and samples of STUDENT’s work, both of which he reviews with her during their weekly consultation. Mr. Arno also stated that he works with Ms. Holbrook on computer software that is used for auditory training, spelling, and apraxia. Additionally, Mr. Arno created a speech and language schedule for Ms. Holbrook to use throughout the school day. The schedule lists language activities and techniques that can be used to work on speech and language as STUDENT progresses through a school day. (COE Exh. 38.)
Ms. Holbrook has been working as STUDENT’s aide since he was in kindergarten. As STUDENT’s aide, Ms. Holbrook is a provider of speech and language services to STUDENT. Over the years she has noted progress in STUDENT’s speech and language skills. Ms. Holbrook testified that when STUDENT was in kindergarten, he had little tongue mobility and poor eating skills. During STUDENT’s first-grade year, Ms. Holbrook observed great progress. STUDENT’s vocalizations became clearer and he made more attempts to vocalize. Ms. Holbrook stated that she listens to the sessions between Mr. Arno and STUDENT and then consults with Mr. Arno for thirty minutes about techniques and strategies, and then Mr. Arno provides the programs for her to work on with STUDENT throughout the week.
In August 1997, the COE began implementing the TEACH program for STUDENT. Ms. Holbrook testified that TEACH tasks are designed to work on fine motor skills, but also incorporate language skills. STUDENT works on some of the tasks independently and on some with Ms. Holbrook. The first aspect of TEACH implemented was the use of picture cards and visual cues. Kathryn Garcia, COE program manager, testified that the TEACH program is used with students who have severe communication difficulties. Ms. Garcia testified that TEACH increases a student’s independence and teaches the student task completion. Ms. Garcia stated that she has observed STUDENT making progress with the TEACH system. Mr. Arno testified that the TEACH program is valuable for speech and language because it helps a student learn the sequence of having a beginning, middle, and an end which is necessary in processing parts of speech and language such as words and sentences.
Donnie Driscoll has been STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the past two years. Ms. Driscoll testified that she has observed an increased rate of progress since the TEACH program was started. Currently, STUDENT can do fourteen TEACH boxes independently. Ms. Driscoll has noticed several improvements in STUDENT’s language skills this year. She stated that she has noted increases in STUDENT’s signing (American Sign Language is used in the class) and attempts at vocalization, and she has noticed that his words are becoming clearer.
While the Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s speech and language progress is due to the private therapy, Ms. Holbrook and Mr. Arno testified that they have not observed carryover from the private therapy sessions to the school setting. Interestingly, Ms. Yehle, STUDENT’s private speech and language provider, testified that she is not trying to provide special education services and that her services are not to replace those services received at school. Ms. Yehle stated that she did not read STUDENT’s IEP prior to providing services, that she is not familiar with the speech and language goals STUDENT works on at school, and that she is not familiar with the school curriculum. The Petitioner did not present evidence to establish that his progress in speech and language is significantly a result of the private therapy or to show that the COE’s speech and language therapy has not provided him with some benefit. Further, Ms. MacElrath, Mr. Arno, Ms. Holbrook, and Ms. Driscoll all testified that the level of services provided to STUDENT is meeting his needs. They also testified that STUDENT is making progress. The COE is not required to provide a student with the best education or services or to maximize a student’s potential. (See Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)
Applying the Rowley standard to this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services provided by the COE are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and have allowed STUDENT to make some progress. Because the evidence presented established that the COE can provide appropriate speech and language therapy to STUDENT on the school site, the COE is not required to increase STUDENT’s speech and language therapy to three hours of direct service by a qualified speech and language therapist. Furthermore, the COE’s offer of five to six and a quarter hours per week of speech and language therapy conforms to STUDENT’s IEP because his IEP recommends five to six and a quarter hours of speech and language therapy per week. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language therapy offered conforms to STUDENT’s IEP.(Footnote 11)
II. Is the Siskiyou County Office of Education required to reimburse the Petitioner’s grandparents for the cost of an independent assessment?
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the result of a due process hearing is that the public education agency’s assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right to an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. (See California Education Code § 56329(b).)
The Petitioner is seeking reimbursement for an assistive communication assessment conducted by S.A.T.S. It is the Petitioner’s contention that the assessment conducted by the COE was not timely and, therefore, the Petitioner sought out an independent assessment. The Petitioner also states that the Diagnostic Center’s written assessment report was not provided until five days before the hearing. (Pet. Closing Brief, p. 4.) The COE contends that it is not required to reimburse the Petitioner for the S.A.T.S. assessment for several reasons, including the fact that the Petitioner’s grandparents agreed with the Diagnostic Center assessment, the Petitioner’s grandparents did not pay for the S.A.T.S. assessment, and the Petitioner is only entitled to one independent evaluation to be funded by the COE and the Diagnostic Center assessment was an independent evaluation conducted after the Petitioner expressed dissatisfaction with the ATAC assessment. Moreover, the COE argues that the assessment the COE provided through the Diagnostic Center was appropriate. (COE Closing Brief, p. 10.)
On October 21, 1996, STUDENT was assessed by the Assistive Technology Advisory Committee (ATAC) team consisting of GRANDPARENTS, STUDENT’s grandparents; B.J. MacElrath, speech and language pathologist; Georgia Wright, occupational therapist; Donnie Driscoll, special education teacher; and Jane Hayes, visual specialist. (COE Exh. 29.) The ATAC team report indicates that STUDENT was referred for the assessment at the request of his grandparents. Ms. MacElrath testified that the assessment process lasted approximately four or five hours. Ms. MacElrath stated that during the evaluation STUDENT’s oral motor activities were assessed. As part of the evaluation, STUDENT interacted with Intellikeys (an adapted keyboard). However, the team concluded that the use of the computer was not appropriate for STUDENT to use for communication at that time. The team recommended that STUDENT begin with a picture system and, as part of the assessment process, the team made pictures for use on a communication board. GRANDMOTHER testified that she was dissatisfied with the ATAC assessment and that the ATAC assessment consisted of two people spending approximately half an hour determining what, if any, communication devices would be suitable for STUDENT.
As a result of the Petitioner’s dissatisfaction with the ATAC assessment, the COE contacted the Diagnostic Center to conduct an assessment. On February 18, 19, and 20, 1998, the Diagnostic Center conducted an assessment specifically focused on STUDENT’s use of assistive technology to increase his ability to express himself. (COE Exh. 42.) The report indicates that the assessment consisted of a review of STUDENT’s records; communication with STUDENT’s private therapy providers, teachers, and family; and on-site formal and informal assessments, including a home visit, a school observation, and an observation of the private speech therapy. At the conclusion of the assessment, a conference was held to discuss the findings and recommendations. Present at the conference were several individuals, including GRANDPARENTS, STUDENT’s grandparents. (COE Exh. 42, p. 1.) No testimony was presented to establish that the Petitioner disagreed with the findings or recommendations of the assessment during the discussion at the post-assessment conference. Further, the Petitioner did not contend that the Diagnostic Center assessment was not appropriate or show that there were any defects in the Diagnostic Center assessment. The assessment report contains seven pages of recommendations to be reviewed by STUDENT’s IEP team, including specific recommendations regarding assistive technology. (COE Exh. 42, pp. 3-10.) (Footnote 12)
GRANDMOTHER testified that she is pleased with the results of the Diagnostic Center assessment. Nevertheless, the Petitioner pursued another assessment through the Shasta Assistive Technology Services (S.A.T.S.). Kelly Teitzel, Far Northern Regional Center service coordinator, testified that she contacted S.A.T.S. to arrange for the assessment. Ms. Teitzel stated that the assessment was completed approximately the first week of March 1998 and that it was paid for by the Far Northern Regional Center. The S.A.T.S. assessment report dated March 17, 1998, confirms that STUDENT was referred by the Far Northern Regional Center. (Pet. Exh. 34.)
As stated above, there are circumstances in which a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil. However, in this case, after the Petitioner expressed disagreement with the COE’s ATAC assessment, the COE provided an assessment by the Diagnostic Center. The evidence shows the assessment was both appropriate and resulted in an outcome with which the Petitioner is pleased. Therefore, the COE is not obligated to reimburse the Petitioner for the S.A.T.S. evaluation.
ORDER
All of the Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Has the Siskiyou County Office of Education offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education?
A. Does STUDENT require one hour per week of physical therapy, which includes sensory integration therapy, by a qualified physical therapist?
The COE prevailed on this issue.
B. Does STUDENT require three hours per week of speech and language therapy?
The COE prevailed on this issue.
II. Is the Siskiyou County Office of Education required to reimburse the Petitioner’s grandparents for the cost of an independent assessment?
The COE prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 11, 1998 Jennifer Nolan Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1) Sensory integration was described as a treatment modality that offers stimulus in many areas and takes into account a person’s entire sensory system. (Testimony of Ms. Wright.)
2) The Child Development and Rehabilitation Center (CDRC) is associated with the Oregon Health Sciences University.
3) Ms. Cresswell received her physical therapist license in 1984 and her occupational therapist certificate in 1985. Currently, Ms. Cresswell works at the Cresswell Physical Therapy and Hand Rehabilitation, Inc. in Redding. Ms. Cresswell testified that she is familiar with sensory integration from her undergraduate course work and her private practice.
4) Currently, Ms. Wright is self-employed and contracts with the COE to provide occupational therapy services. Ms. Wright stated that she is certified by the State as a nonpublic agency (NPA). Ms. Wright testified that she has been an occupational therapist for over thirty years and is trained in sensory integration therapy.
5) The Petitioner pled that the COE should be required to provided PT services from Sue Nickland. Since the Hearing Officer has concluded that the PT offered by the COE is appropriate, it is not necessary to discuss the private PT.
6) Dysarthria is imperfect articulation of speech due to disturbances of muscular control which results from damage to the central or peripheral nervous system. (Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary (28th ed. 1994).)
7) Dyspraxia is defined as the partial loss of ability to perform coordinated acts. (Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary (28th ed. 1994).)
8) Apraxia is the loss of ability to carry out familiar, purposeful movements in the absence of paralysis or other motor or sensory impairment. (Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary (28th ed. 1994.))
9) Ms. Yehle is employed at the Merle West Medical Center in Klamath Falls, Oregon.
10) Mr. Arno testified that he has a speech and hearing credential. In California, a person with an appropriate credential with specialization in language, speech, and hearing may provide services which include specialized instruction and services for individuals with speech and language disorders; consultative services to pupils, parents, teachers, or other school personnel. Services may be provided by an aide working under the direct supervision of a credentialed language, speech, and hearing specialist. (5 C.C.R. § 3051.1.)
11) The Petitioner pled that the speech and language therapy should be provided by STUDENT’s private therapist, Lisa Yehle. However, since the Hearing Officer has concluded that the COE is able to provide appropriate speech and language services it is not necessary to discuss the private speech and language therapy.
12) Although the Petitioner contends that the written assessment report was not provided to him until five days before the hearing, this contention is of little consequence. California law states that an assessor shall prepare a written report of the results of the assessment. (See California Education Code § 56327.) However, the law does not specify the time in which the report must be generated and distributed. In this case, the assessment was completed on February 20, 1998, and the Petitioner contends that the written report was received on or about March 14, 1998. The Hearing Officer finds this to be timely. Also, as discussed above, the Petitioner’s grandparents were aware of the general conclusions and content of the assessment as of the post-assessment conference held on February 20, 1998.
