California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 20, 1998

Student v. Vista Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1537-97 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman

Vista Unified denied FAPE by omitting regular preschool, but CCHAT reimbursement was denied because that program also lacked hearing peers.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 4 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 2: Petitioner's claim of a FAPE denial for 1996-97 was not decided. The only remedy sought, reimbursement for private speech services in July 1997, was resolved by the parties during the hearing. Footnote 1: San Diego County Office of Education and North Coastal Consortium for Special Education were dismissed before hearing at Petitioner's request.

Summary

The parents of a four-year-old girl with a moderate to severe hearing loss in both ears filed for hearing against Vista Unified School District. She had attended the district's speech and language preschool program at California Avenue School. Her parents then enrolled her full time at the Children's Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT), a private auditory/oral program for children with hearing loss. They sought reimbursement for CCHAT for 1997-98 and district funding of CCHAT for fall 1998.

The Hearing Officer found that she needed a regular preschool with typically developing hearing peers, along with speech therapy and monitoring of her language. She did not need the intensive daily services that the parents' witnesses recommended. The district's October 1997 offer covered speech therapy and a language group but no regular preschool, so it denied her a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for 1997-98. Reimbursement was still denied because CCHAT also lacked a regular preschool setting. For 1998-99, the October 1997 offer remained inadequate. The district offered a Magnolia School auditory/oral class only during mediation and never in writing, so it was not a formal offer under Union School District v. Smith. That program had also changed during the hearing. CCHAT was found inappropriate for 1998-99 as well. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and design a program that includes regular preschool and speech-language therapy.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows SEHO denying reimbursement for a private placement even after finding a denial of FAPE. The private program did not meet a need the Hearing Officer had identified: daily contact with hearing peers. It also shows a placement offered only at mediation, never in writing, being treated as legally insufficient under Union v. Smith.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-98 school year including the extended school year?

    The October 1997 offer of speech therapy, a language group and DHH consultation met her speech needs. It denied FAPE because it did not include the regular education preschool with hearing peers she needed. Intensive daily services were not shown to be necessary.

  2. Issue 2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for her unilateral placement at the Children's Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT) from September 1997 through the extended school year for 1997-98?

    Reimbursement was denied. CCHAT provided educational benefit in speech and language, but as a special day class-type program for children with hearing loss it did not give her the natural language environment of hearing peers she needed.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3a. Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate preschool program for the 1998-99 school year?

    The October 1997 offer was still inadequate and no new IEP meeting was held. The Magnolia School auditory/oral class, offered only at mediation and never in writing, was not a legally sufficient offer under Union v. Smith, and the program changed during the hearing.

  4. Issue 3b. If not, is the CCHAT program appropriate?

    Prospective placement at CCHAT for September 1998 to February 1999 was denied because CCHAT does not provide a regular education preschool with hearing peers.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The District must convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the order to develop a 1998-99 program. The team must review present levels of performance, consider whether further assessment is needed, and set appropriate goals and objectives.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must design a program that immerses the student in a natural language environment of hearing peers through enrollment in a regular education preschool, for a number of days per week set by the team. The program must also address speech errors, misarticulation and speech intelligibility, and must provide speech and language therapy to support and monitor her language development and prevent language delays.
  • Reimbursement for CCHAT (September 1997 through 1997-98 ESY) and prospective CCHAT funding (September 1998 to February 1999) were denied. The order states that all of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed.; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Union School Dist. v. Smith

People named in the decision

  • Patricia Snider, supervisor of special education, Vista Unified School District
  • G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District (non-attorney), Vista Unified School District
  • Gwyneth Olsen, deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) consultant, early intervention, HOPE Infant Family Support Program
  • Deborah Llewellyn, private speech-language pathologist, Children's Hospital
  • Dina Irwin, District speech-language pathologist, assessor and student's first teacher, Vista Unified School District
  • Susan Aaberg, student's teacher at private placement, Children's Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT)
  • Joan Hewitt, audiologist/audiological consultant and assessor, Children's Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT)
  • Carol Pope, language, speech and hearing specialist, District witness, Magnolia School
  • Joanne Caudill, DHH teacher, District witness, Magnolia School
  • Astrid Fisher, DHH itinerant, District witness, Carlsbad Unified School District
  • Ross Adams, speech-language pathologist, District witness, HOPE Infant program
  • Pat Balthazor, private speech therapist, expert witness for Student, Founding director of the CCHAT Center in the San Bernardino area
  • Children's Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT), private auditory/oral preschool (unilateral placement), Encinitas

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Vista, California, on April 14-17, 1998 and June 2-5, 1998.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Geralyn Clancy, of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy, Attorneys at Law. STUDENT’s parents, PARENTS, were present throughout the hearing. Respondent Vista Unified School District (District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Patricia Snider, supervisor of special education, was also present on behalf of the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. The arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-98 school year including the extended school year?

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for her unilateral placement at the Children’s Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT) from September 1997 through the extended school year for 1997-98?

3. Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate preschool program for the 1998-99 school year? If not, is the CCHAT program appropriate?(Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-year-old girl with a moderate to severe, sensorineural, congenital hearing loss in both ears. With hearing aids, STUDENT’s hearing loss is in the mild range. STUDENT was found eligible for special education services from the District in February 1997, just before she turned three-years-old.

STUDENT’s hearing loss was initially diagnosed by an audiologist in November 1995 when she was 18 months old. STUDENT received a loaner hearing aid to use for approximately two months until her own aids arrived. In December 1995, STUDENT was found eligible for early intervention services through the HOPE Infant Family Support Program. In an initial evaluation of STUDENT completed in January 1996 by Gwyneth Olsen, the deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) consultant for HOPE, three goals were identified: to develop STUDENT’s age-appropriate speech, to develop her fullest auditory potential, and to assist the parents in exploring appropriate preschools or play groups. Ms. Olsen also stated in her report that STUDENT’s motor and cognitive skills were age-appropriate and developing normally.

In late January or early February of 1996, STUDENT received programmable ReSound bilateral hearing aids.(Footnote 3) At about the same time, she began in-home auditory training once a week through the HOPE program. These in-home services continued through January 1997. STUDENT also received speech and language therapy at Children’s Hospital for one hour per week from March 1996 until March 1997 under the auspices of the HOPE program.

In December 1996, the HOPE program began planning with the District and STUDENT’s parents to transition STUDENT into District preschool services. The individuals who provided early intervention services to STUDENT assessed her progress and needs at the time of this transition. Ms. Olsen stated that STUDENT’s "primary area of need has been in the area of speech development, her receptive understanding continues to show improvement. She infrequently needs things repeated and understands most of what is asked of her." (Pet. Exh. pg. 46.) Deborah Llewellyn, the Childrens’ Hospital therapist, noted that "STUDENT now speaks in 3-4 word utterances which are 65-70% intelligible....STUDENT has made excellent gains in treatment, as she has improved from a vowel imitation level with very few vocalizations to a verbal communicator with deficits that can be overcome with continued treatment." (Pet. Exh. pg. 82.)

In early February 1997, an individualized family service plan (IFSP) team meeting was held to review the IEP process and procedures, and the District’s program options for STUDENT. Several programs were discussed with PARENT including two at California Avenue School, a preschool special day class for children with various disabilities, and a speech and language program.

In late February 1997, the District’s speech and language pathologist, Dina Irwin, completed a preschool speech and language assessment of STUDENT to determine her current level of communication development. Ms. Irwin concluded that STUDENT’s language skills were "within the normal range expected for her chronological age" and also noted that STUDENT had a "moderate-severe phonological delay." (Pet. Exh. pg. 52.) Ms. Irwin recommended that STUDENT receive speech therapy for her speech errors and that the IEP team consider having STUDENT attend a language therapy group to further encourage language development. Ms. Irwin stated in her report that although STUDENT’s "overall language skills are not ‘delayed’ at this time, she is at high risk for a language delay based on her hearing loss." (Pet. Exh. pg. 53.)

On February 27, 1997, the IEP team met and reviewed the District’s assessment of STUDENT and the evaluations of her progress through early intervention efforts. The IEP team determined that STUDENT did not require intensive services and that she would attend the California Avenue School speech and language program. STUDENT was to receive Designated Instruction and Service (DIS) including group speech and language therapy two times per week for 60 minutes each time, and DHH consultation to the speech therapist and parents (as needed) one time each semester. Community preschool placement was also discussed but any decision in this area was deferred as PARENT wished to focus on speech therapy for STUDENT. PARENT requested that STUDENT’s IEP be reviewed in September 1997.

In March 1997, STUDENT began to attend the speech and language program at California Avenue School, which is a year-round school. Eight children were enrolled in the afternoon session which STUDENT attended. One teacher and one aide staffed the sessions. All of the other children had speech and language disorders; STUDENT was the only child who was hearing impaired. STUDENT attended weekly program sessions through June 1997, except for a one-month off-track period in April.

In April 1997, PARENT learned that a new program, the Childrens’ Choice for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT) Center, was opening soon in Encinitas, and would offer an auditory/oral program for hearing impaired children from 0 to 6 years old. PARENT attended a meeting about the CCHAT Center program and walked away with "huge red flags" in her mind, fearing that STUDENT’s needs were not being met in the District’s program. (Testimony of PARENT.) PARENT discussed the CCHAT Center program with staff from HOPE, and continued to monitor STUDENT’s progress at California Avenue School. PARENT found it difficult to pinpoint STUDENT’s specific progress in the District’s program, although she knew STUDENT’s vocabulary had grown and her articulation had improved. (Testimony of PARENT.)

STUDENT returned to speech therapy at Children’s Hospital with Ms. Llewellyn in July 1997 because such therapy was not provided by the District during off-track times. Before starting the therapy sessions, Ms. Llewellyn reviewed STUDENT’s progress and noted that "STUDENT speaks in 3-5 word utterances with 65% speech intelligibility. Receptive language skills are at the 3 year, 4 month age equivalent, which is within normal limits. Expressive language skills are at the 2 year, 9 month age equivalent." (Pet. Exh. pg. 79.)

In August 1997, STUDENT briefly re-enrolled in the California Avenue School speech and language program. She attended morning sessions and had a different teacher this time. STUDENT did not continue in the speech and language program after the end of August because the PARENTS had decided to enroll her in the CCHAT Center when it opened in September. Approximately two weeks before this change, PARENT notified STUDENT’s teacher at California Avenue School that STUDENT would not return to the program until after the October off-track period.

In September 1997, STUDENT enrolled at the CCHAT Center for a brief "diagnostic period" to determine if the program was appropriate for her. The PARENTS also enrolled STUDENT in a private community preschool program, planning to have her attend CCHAT three days per week, and the preschool the remaining two days. On her first day at CCHAT, STUDENT was placed in the class for "younger" age children, but was soon moved to the "older" group of 4-5 year olds when the CCHAT staff recognized that her language skills were more advanced. (Testimony of Susan Aaberg.) The "older" age group met five days a week from 9:00am until 2:00pm, so STUDENT did not attend the community preschool because she began to attend the CCHAT Center full time.

In preparation for the September 1997 IEP team meeting which PARENT had requested,(Footnote 4) the District’s speech and language pathologist, Ms. Irwin, evaluated STUDENT’s progress on her IEP goal of improved speech intelligibility. Ms. Irwin stated that STUDENT had made "good growth in her articulation skills, though this is still an area of need for her." (Pet. Exh. pg. 49.) Ms. Irwin recommended continued therapy to increase STUDENT’s speech intelligibility, continued attendance in language group, and enrollment in a community preschool with typically developing children to benefit STUDENT’s overall speech and language development.

Joan Hewitt, an audiologist with the CCHAT Center, also assessed STUDENT’s speech and language skills during the "diagnostic period." Ms. Hewitt reported that STUDENT had developed "the majority of vowels, diphthongs, and simple consonants" in her speech, but was unable to produce certain sounds correctly. Ms. Hewitt also stated that although STUDENT’s language development "is more advanced than most of her hearing impaired peers, it lags significantly behind her hearing peers and would be expected to remain as such without intensive remediation."

On October 24, 1997, the IEP team met and reviewed STUDENT’s IEP and placement. Staff from CCHAT presented their program for STUDENT to the IEP team and Ms. Hewitt reviewed her recent test results. PARENT reported that she had seen "great progress" in STUDENT’s communication skills since she began attending the CCHAT Center in September. Additional goals and objectives were developed by the team to carry STUDENT to February 1998, when her annual IEP was due. The District members of the team recommended that STUDENT continue in the speech and language program at California Avenue School with a change to individual rather than group speech therapy and an increase to three times per week for 30 minutes each time. The District also offered "off-track therapy," a language group two times per week for 35 minutes each time, and itinerant DHH specialist services. PARENTS signed the IEP document, but noted that they disagreed with the placement recommendation and "the depth of the IEP goals." (Pet. Exh. pgs. 15, 17.) They felt that STUDENT needed more therapy time, and more goals and objectives to address her needs.

A few days after the October IEP team meeting, the PARENTS sent a letter to the California Avenue School indicating that STUDENT would not return to the speech and language program because she was continuing at the CCHAT Center. On November 24, 1997, the parents filed for due process hearing requesting reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at the CCHAT Center.(Footnote 5)

In late November 1997, PARENT heard rumors that an auditory/oral program would soon open at Magnolia Elementary School and be available through the North Coastal Consortium for Special Education, of which the District is a member. She spoke with various District personnel about the new program and observed the class on one of the first days of program operation, February 2, 1998. After the observation, PARENT expected to hear from the District about the Magnolia program, but heard nothing until a mediation on February 18, 1998. During the mediation, the District offered the Magnolia School auditory/oral program as an alternative to the California Avenue School placement.(Footnote 6) However, the mediation was unsuccessful and the case proceeded to hearing.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the key issue in this case is the level of services she needs to achieve her goal of enrolling in regular education kindergarten when she is five. Petitioner argues that the speech and language program at California Avenue School which she attended during the 1996-97 school year did not provide her with a FAPE because it failed to meet her unique needs. She contends that she has also been denied a FAPE since that time because continuation of the California Avenue School program, even with increased levels of service as proposed by the District in October 1997, still will not offer the level of service she needs. Petitioner claims that the denial of FAPE is due, in part, to the District’s failure to conduct an appropriate assessment of her needs when she first entered the program in February 1997. Petitioner asserts that the District’s recent offer of the Magnolia School auditory/oral preschool special day class is legally insufficient under Union, supra. She states that, even if the offer is legally sufficient, that placement would be inappropriate for her because the program has changed since the February 1998 offer.

Petitioner contends that the CCHAT Center is an appropriate placement for her because it is an auditory/oral program designed to serve hearing impaired children. Petitioner points out that she has made notable progress since enrolling at CCHAT in September 1997. Petitioner requests that her placement at CCHAT be funded by the District from September 1997 through February 1999, including the CCHAT 1998 extended summer school program. Petitioner states that the fact that her parents have not yet paid for her CCHAT program should not preclude funding by the District because her parents are "legally obligated" to pay.

The District contends that it has provided STUDENT with appropriate services during the 1996-97 school year, and that it made an appropriate offer to continue those services during the 1997-98 school year. The District notes that STUDENT made "excellent progress" while she was in its speech and language program at California Avenue School. The District asserts that STUDENT does not need the restrictiveness of the CCHAT Center placement, and does not require an extended school year program there. The District contends that STUDENT’s needs can successfully be met through the combination of services offered at the October 1997 IEP team meeting. The District states that its offer of the Magnolia School oral preschool special day class is an alternative for STUDENT which is more intensive and "far superior to the CCHAT Center," but also more restrictive than she needs.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-98 school year including the extended school year?

Under federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000, et seq.) The term "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; meet the standards of the State educational agency; include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved; and are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under Sec. 614(d)." (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D).) Special education means specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability...." (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(25); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.)

Related services are called "designated instruction and services" (DIS) under California law. (20 U.S.C. 1401(22); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) These services are provided when necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Language and speech development and remediation, and audiological services are among those which may be provided by a school district if determined necessary by the IEP team.

The U.S. Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a disabled student under the IDEA in Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the services maximize each child’s potential. Rather, "the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. (Id. at 200.)

The right to a free and appropriate education also includes the right to educational services in the least restrictive environment (20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(A); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) This means that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children who do not have disabilities. (34 C.F.R. 300.550.) Special classes, separate schooling or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment can occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2).)

Thus, under the IDEA, Rowley, and state law, an appropriate educational placement must include instruction and services which (1) are designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) provide educational benefit, (3) conform to the student’s IEP, and (4) are provided in the least restrictive environment.

Was the District’s proposed program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

STUDENT’s unique needs

Nearly every District witness testified that STUDENT needs exposure to typically developing peers--preferably in a regular preschool setting--to model natural language development. Carol Pope, a language, speech and hearing specialist at Magnolia School, testified that STUDENT should be interacting with at least five typically developing peers in her preschool program to develop language, pragmatics and social language, and to observe the handling of problem situations by her peers. Joanne Caudill, the DHH teacher at Magnolia, stated that STUDENT needs to be "immersed" in a normal preschool experience with strong language models provided by her normally developing peers. Astrid Fisher, the DHH itinerant for Carlsbad Unified School District, testified that STUDENT needs to be in a natural language environment with her hearing peers.

Dina Irwin, the District’s speech and language pathologist who was also STUDENT’s first teacher, testified that it is "essential" for STUDENT to be around typically developing children because that is how young children learn and develop language. Ms. Irwin noted in her September 1997 progress report that STUDENT needed to attend a preschool with typically developing children to "expose her to a variety of models not just for language skills but also peer interaction skills." (Dist. Exh. 13.)

Ross Adams, a licensed speech and language pathologist who teaches in the HOPE Infant program, testified that the most natural language environment for STUDENT is with typically developing peers in a regular education preschool. Mr. Ross stated that such an environment affords the hearing impaired child both time and opportunity to develop phonological patterns typical for her age regardless of hearing loss. Mr. Ross testified that referral to a regular education preschool is appropriate if the hearing impaired child is "communicating orally, interacting successfully with her peers, and has no other diagnoses." STUDENT’s conversations with peers were noted by her CCHAT teacher, Ms. Aaberg, to be at one or two turn changes, and, with a familiar adult, at three to five turn changes. (Pet. Exh. pg. 57; testimony of Ms. Aaberg.) Ms. Aaberg also stated that STUDENT’s school readiness skills were "extremely high for a [then] 3½ year-old." (Pet. Exh. pg. 57.)

Petitioner’s witnesses acknowledged the need for language models, but did not indicate that STUDENT needed a natural language environment of her hearing peers. Pat Balthazor, a private speech therapist who observed STUDENT in the CCHAT Center program, testified that STUDENT needs good speech and language role models and that she needs to be with typically developing peers. However, Ms. Balthazor did not recommend that STUDENT attend a regular education preschool, but emphasized instead that she needed to be in a special day class of hearing impaired children during her preschool years. Susan Aaberg, STUDENT’s teacher at CCHAT, did not mention the need for STUDENT to be in a natural language environment, and testified that the other hearing impaired children in STUDENT’s class at CCHAT would provide the language models she needs.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of District witnesses more persuasive in regard to STUDENT’s need for a natural language environment of hearing peers in a regular education preschool. The District’s witnesses who testified in this area have extensive and varied experience with hearing impaired children in preschool settings, and their testimony was not rebutted or effectively challenged in any way. Further, Deborah Llewellyn, the speech and language pathologist at Children’s Hospital who has worked independently with STUDENT over a substantial period of time, testified that she recommended that STUDENT attend a normal preschool as early as February 1997. STUDENT’s need for a natural language environment was discussed at the October 1997 IEP team meeting, but never included in the actual program offer made. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that in the fall of 1997, STUDENT needed and continues to need exposure to a natural language environment of her hearing peers through a regular education preschool program.

Other evidence indicated that STUDENT needs to correct speech errors and to improve her articulation and speech intelligibility. Joan Hewitt, an audiological consultant for the CCHAT Center, testified that STUDENT needs to improve her speech production and correct speech errors resulting from her hearing impairment. Ms. Hewitt’s testimony differed from that of other witnesses only as to the intensity or frequency of such services, as discussed below.

In her initial assessment in February 1997, Ms. Irwin reported that STUDENT had certain speech errors which were largely attributable to her hearing loss. Ms. Irwin recommended that STUDENT receive direct speech therapy and attend a language therapy group to further encourage language development because "she is at high risk for a language delay based on her hearing loss." (Dist . Exh. 9.) Ms. Irwin continued this recommendation in her September 1997 progress report, noting that STUDENT’s articulation skills and speech intelligibility had improved but still needed more work. (Dist. Exh. 13.) She recommended that STUDENT continue attending the language group "to work on using her hearing in a group setting, use her speech sounds in conversation and context" and to expand her overall language skills. (Dist. Exh. 13.) Several District witnesses also recommended speech therapy and small group speech and language services to facilitate and monitor STUDENT’s progress in language development. (Testimony of Ms. Fisher, Ms. Caudill, Ms. Pope.)

Perhaps most significant for the Hearing Officer was the credible testimony of Deborah Llewellyn. Ms. Llewellyn has a master’s degree in speech and language pathology and has been a speech pathologist in pediatrics for 17 years. She holds a national certificate of clinical competence and is licensed as a speech and lang- uage pathologist in California. Ms. Llewellyn has taught medical students as an adjunct faculty member at the University of Oklahoma medical school, and has also supervised graduate students and taught continuing education courses in her field at state and national conventions. Ms. Llewellyn offered a unique and valuable perspective because she has worked independently with STUDENT, providing her with speech therapy for one hour per week from March 1996 through March 1997, and for one-half hour two times per week during the July 1997 off-track period. (Testimony of Ms. Llewellyn.) In addition, Ms. Llewellyn has extensive training and numerous years of experience working with hearing impaired children in an independent setting.

Based on her work with STUDENT, Ms. Llewellyn testified that STUDENT needs to continue with "supportive speech therapy" at least two times per week, and that her language acquisition should also be monitored. Ms. Llewellyn concluded in her February and July 1997 reports that STUDENT’s prognosis for achieving age appropriate language skills and 90-100% speech intelligibility with continued, consistent speech therapy was "good" to "excellent." (Pet. Exh. Pg. 77, 80, 82.) Ms. Llewellyn’s testimony and written reports of STUDENT’s progress were generally consistent with the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s needs.

From all the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that in the fall of 1997, STUDENT needed and still needs to correct her speech errors, and to improve her articulation and speech intelligibility. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needed and still needs both support and monitoring of her language development.

Petitioner relies heavily on testing completed by Ms. Hewitt to document a need for "intensive" services. Ms. Hewitt is a pediatric audiologist and teacher of hearing impaired individuals. She has a master’s degree in teaching the hearing impaired from an auditory/oral training program, and is a licensed audiologist with a certificate of clinical competence in audiology from the American Speech and Hearing Association (ASHA). She does not hold a California teaching credential. Ms. Hewitt testified that she evaluated STUDENT in September and October 1997, and that her testing indicated that STUDENT had language delays attributable to her hearing loss. In the written report of her evaluation, Ms. Hewitt stated that, although STUDENT’s language development was more advanced than most of her hearing impaired peers, she was still "significantly behind her hearing peers and would be expected to remain as such without intensive remediation." (Pet. Exh. pg. 56.) Ms. Hewitt also testified that STUDENT "absolutely" needs a summer school program of intensive services to maintain her emerging skills. Ms. Irwin testified that testing completed by Ms. Hewitt left out important information such as standard scores which placed STUDENT within the normal range of language development for hearing children. Indeed, in two of the four tests given by Ms. Hewitt--the PPVT-R and the TACL-R--neither standard scores nor percentages were reported. With this added information, Ms. Hewitt’s September 1997 test results show that STUDENT performed within the normal range of language skills for her age considering that the mean is 100 and the standard deviation is 15 points for these two tests.(Footnote 7) (Testimony of Ms. Irwin.) Ms. Hewitt’s testimony attempting to qualify or otherwise explain these results in various ways was not persuasive.

MS. HEWITT’S PARTIAL ASSESSMENT RESULTS FROM SEPTEMBER 1997

Test Percentile Standard Score Age Equivalent

PPVT-R 48% 98 3.5 years

TACL-R hi 40s 96-103 3.7-3.9 years

Ms. Hewitt’s use of the GAEL-C test to evaluate STUDENT’s ability to communicate using complex language structures was also challenged by other witnesses. Both Ms. Irwin and Mr. Adams testified that the GAEL-C was not an appropriate test to evaluate STUDENT’s language development. Mr. Adams has a master’s degree in speech and language pathology, a certificate of clinical competence from ASHA, and is a licensed speech and language pathologist in California. He holds a credential in clinical rehabilitative services and as a language, speech and hearing specialist. Mr. Adams has taught courses in deaf education at California State University-Northridge, and has served as a clinical supervisor for speech pathologists. He has several years of experience working with hearing impaired children. Mr. Adams testified credibly that the GAEL-C which STUDENT was given was the most complex of the three versions of that test. He stated that the GAEL-C was not intended for a three-year-seven-month-old child such as STUDENT, and that the norms for hearing impaired children would not include a child that young. Ms. Irwin testified that, although STUDENT’s scores were in the lower percentiles on the GAEL-C, these results would not reflect her skills as accurately as the presentence version of the GAEL test.

Ms. Hewitt’s opinion concerning STUDENT’s need for "intensive remediation" was supported by the testimony of two other witnesses for Petitioner, Susan Aaberg and Patricia Balthazor. Ms. Aaberg has 30 years of experience as an educator of the deaf and hearing impaired. She holds a one-year, nonrenewable California teaching credential for the communicatively handicapped. She testified that STUDENT has a language delay because of her hearing loss and that hearing impaired children need to be taught language, as "they do not learn by osmosis." Ms. Balthazor has been a speech therapist for 20 years. She holds a credential for rehabilitative services, a certificate of clinical competence in speech from ASHA, and is a licensed speech and language pathologist in California. Ms. Balthazor was a founding director of the CCHAT Center in the San Bernardino area. She testified that STUDENT needs intensive services including 1:1 auditory, speech and language therapy, and 1:1 oral habilitation for at least 30 minutes per day. Ms. Balthazor stated that STUDENT needs a special day class five days per week while she is a preschooler, and that this level of service should be maintained over the summer, especially during STUDENT’s preschool years.

The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT was not language delayed and that she exhibited only phonological and articulation errors which do not require intensive services for correction.(Footnote 8) (Testimony of Dina Irwin, Astrid Fisher, Joanne Caudill, Carol Pope.) Dina Irwin assessed STUDENT twice and served as her first teacher in the California Avenue School class. Ms. Irwin is a speech and language specialist with the District’s preschool program and has 11 years of experience in speech and language pathology. She has a master’s degree in speech pathology, a credential in clinical rehabilitative services, and is a licensed speech pathologist with a certificate of clinical competency from ASHA. In the February 1997 assessment, Ms. Irwin concluded that STUDENT’s language development was within normal limits for her chronological age, although she is "at high risk" for a language delay due to her hearing loss. (Dist. Exh. 9.) In September 1997, Ms. Irwin completed a progress report and again found no delay in STUDENT’s language development. (Dist. Exh. 13.) None of the other District witnesses testified that STUDENT exhibited language delays and none of those witnesses recommended daily, "intensive" speech and language services for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Fisher, Ms. Caudill, Ms. Pope.) Ms. Llewellyn, who worked independently with STUDENT over a significant period of time and was able to observe her progress, never mentioned a need for intensive services in either her reports or her testimony.

In the fall of 1997, both the District testing and observations of Ms. Hewitt showed that STUDENT performed above the level of her hearing impaired peers and that she communicated in simple sentences of at least three or four words. (Dist. Exh. 13; Testimony of Ms. Hewitt.) Further, the first day that STUDENT attended the CCHAT Center in September 1997, she was immediately moved from the younger, three-year-old class to an older group of four- and five-year-old hearing impaired children in recognition of her level of language development. (Testimony of Ms. Aaberg.) This evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that she had and still has "significant" language delays requiring intensive services.

Based on the evidence presented, Petitioner has not shown that STUDENT has a language delay requiring the intensive level of services described above. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not proved that STUDENT’s language was significantly delayed in the fall of 1997 such that she required then or currently requires "intensive," daily speech and language services through the 1997-98 school year, including the extended school year.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that in the fall of 1997 STUDENT needed exposure to a natural language environment of her hearing peers in a regular education preschool to further develop language, pragmatics, and social language. STUDENT also needed to overcome her speech errors and misarticulation, and to improve her speech intelligibility. STUDENT was at risk for language delays and needed to have her language development monitored. The Hearing Officer also finds that these needs are continuing into the present because there was no evidence that STUDENT’s needs in each of these areas had changed.

The District’s proposed program

In October 1997, the District proposed to continue STUDENT’s speech and language program at the California Avenue School with some increase in service in response to concerns expressed by the PARENTS. (Testimony of Ms. Fisher.) The District offered individual speech therapy three times per week for 30 minutes each time, and therapy during off-track times. The District also offered a language group two times per week for 35 minutes each group, and consultation services of the itinerant DHH specialist, as needed. (Dist. Exh. 15.) Several witnesses testified that this level of service was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the program proposed by the District in the fall of 1997 was designed to address STUDENT’s needs to overcome speech errors, misarticulation and to improve her speech intelligibility, even during off-track times. The District’s offer for STUDENT to continue attending the language group two times per week was designed to support and monitor her language development and to prevent language delays.

Even though these program components were appropriate for STUDENT, one important area was not addressed in the District’s offer, namely STUDENT’s need for exposure to a natural language environment of her hearing peers. The IEP document mentions that STUDENT could benefit from a language group "especially with typically developing peers." (Dist. Exh. 15.) The testimony indicated that the children in STUDENT’s proposed language group had a range of communication handicaps and language disorders. (Testimony of Ms. Irwin.) Certainly, these children could not be considered to be "typically developing." No other evidence was presented which clarified this statement in the IEP document. Even assuming that the 70-minute-per-week language group included typical preschoolers, such a limited time period still would not provide the extensive opportunities for STUDENT to talk and interact with her hearing peers that would be available in a regular education preschool. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, in the fall of 1997, the District failed to offer STUDENT a regular preschool program with typically developing peers which she needed to become "immersed" in a natural language environment.

The Hearing Officer concludes that, although some program components offered to STUDENT were appropriate, the District did not offer her a free and appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year because it did not offer a regular education preschool program with the natural language environment STUDENT needed.

* * *

Because the District’s program has not addressed STUDENT’s need for a natural language environment in regular preschool with hearing peers, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to proceed further with the FAPE analysis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not analyze whether the District’s incomplete offer would have provided STUDENT with educational benefit, conformed to her IEP, and provided the least restrictive environment.

Issue No. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for her unilateral placement at the Children’s Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT) from September 1997 through the extended school year for 1997-98?

In Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed. (1983) 471 U.S. 359, the U.S. Supreme Court held that parents of disabled children may receive retroactive reimbursement for the tuition and related expenses of unilaterally placing their child in a private special education program. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide the child with a FAPE and the private placement is determined to be proper under the Act and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (Burlington, supra, at 369-370; see also Rowley, supra, at 207; see also Florence County School District Four, et al., v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 20 IDELR 532.)

The Hearing Officer has already concluded that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year. Petitioner has requested retroactive reimbursement for the costs, as yet unpaid, which her parents have incurred for her unilateral placement at the CCHAT Center from September 1997 through the end of the extended 1997-98 school year.(Footnote 9) The Hearing Officer will review STUDENT’s educational program at the CCHAT Center to determine if it is proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit as required under Burlington.

The CCHAT Center provides STUDENT with an auditory/oral preschool program three hours per day, five days per week in a small class with five other hearing impaired children ages four- to five-years-old. (Testimony of Ms. Balthazor, Ms. Aaberg, Pet. Exh. pgs. 57, 71.) STUDENT’s preschool class is staffed by one instructor and one instructional aide. STUDENT receives one-half hour of individual speech and language therapy each day, either in-class or away from class in a therapy room. Both a written mid-year report (dated February 16, 1998) by STUDENT’s teacher, and testimony at the hearing indicate that STUDENT has received educational benefit from this program and progressed in her speech and language skills. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 57-58; testimony of Ms. Aaberg, PARENT.)

However, even though the CCHAT Center has addressed STUDENT’s needs for speech and language development, it has not provided her with the natural language environment of hearing peers that she needs. The evidence indicated that three younger and three older typically developing children, who are siblings of STUDENT’s classmates, visit the CCHAT Center during the school day. (Testimony of Ms. Aaberg.) These visits, even if they are daily, still do not amount to the "immersion" in a natural language environment of hearing peers that would be provided by a regular education preschool. Further, it is clear from the evidence that STUDENT’s program at the CCHAT Center is focused on serving hearing impaired children in a special day class-type setting. While this has served to address some of STUDENT’s needs, it has not provided her with the natural language models which the Hearing Officer has found she needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents’ placement at the CCHAT Center has not met STUDENT’s need for a natural language environment of her hearing peers because it has failed to provide her with a regular education preschool program to model natural language development. Because the CCHAT Center program does not appropriately address all of STUDENT’s needs, the parents’ request for reimbursement is denied.

Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate preschool program for the 1998-99 school year? If not, is the CCHAT Center program appropriate?

The District contends that its October 1997 offer would provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education for the upcoming 1998-99 school year. However, the offer made at the October 1997 IEP team meeting has already been reviewed above and found inappropriate to meet all of STUDENT’s needs. Further, the District has not convened a subsequent IEP team meeting to review STUDENT’s present levels of performance and determine whether there has been any change in her program needs for the 1998-99 school year, particularly in light of her attendance at the CCHAT Center program. Therefore, for these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer in the October 1997 IEP document is not appropriate and would not provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education for the upcoming 1998-99 school year.

A second placement offer was made to Petitioner in February 1998, during a pre-hearing mediation. At that time, the District offered the Magnolia School auditory/oral program as an alternative to the California Avenue School placement. Petitioner contends that the Magnolia School offer is not legally sufficient under Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519; 20 IDELR 987) because it was not a "formal written offer" of placement. Petitioner also states that the placement has changed significantly during the course of the hearing such that it is difficult to know precisely what the Magnolia School offer would provide in the upcoming 1998-99 school year. The District argues, somewhat curiously, that the Magnolia School placement could serve STUDENT but is not what she really needs as the level of service is greater than STUDENT requires.

In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated that a formal written offer of placement is necessary to create "a clear record ... about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any." (Union, supra, at 1526, 990.) The Court also commented that "a formal, specific offer" was necessary to help parents determine what placement the school district was proposing and whether to oppose or accept the placement. (Id.) Here, the evidence showed that the Magnolia School auditory/oral program was never offered in writing, as a formal, specific offer to Petitioner consistent with the requirements of Union.

Further, even if the Magnolia School placement offer had comported with the requirements of Union, the evidence presented on the last days of hearing in June indicated that the placement had substantially changed. Joanne Caudill, a teacher in the Magnolia School program, testified that in late June, the program would be "integrating" with a nearby regular education preschool. What such integration entailed and how the program would function in its new setting were not clearly delineated. This is precisely the problem which Union sought to address by requiring that school districts make specific, formal offers of placement in writing, so that parents can determine what is being proposed and whether to accept or reject the offer. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Magnolia School auditory/oral program was not a legally sufficient offer of placement pursuant to the requirements of Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519; 20 IDELR 987). The Hearing Officer concludes that the District has failed to offer Petitioner a free and appropriate public education for the upcoming 1998-99 school year.

Petitioner requests prospective placement at the CCHAT Center from September 1998 until February 1999. However, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the CCHAT Center program does not meet STUDENT’s need for a natural language environment of hearing peers because it does not provide a regular education preschool program. Therefore, the CCHAT Center program is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. Petitioner’s request for prospective placement at the CCHAT Center is denied.

In order to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT, the parties must convene an IEP team meeting as soon as possible to review her present levels of performance and consider whether further assessment of her current needs is necessary at this time. The IEP team must establish appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. The IEP team must also design an appropriate program which "immerses" STUDENT in a natural language environment of her hearing peers through enrollment in a regular education preschool for an appropriate number of days per week as determined by the IEP team in consideration of STUDENT’s current unique needs. The program must also meet STUDENT’s need to overcome her speech errors and misarticulation, and to improve her speech intelligibility. The program must provide speech and language therapy to support and monitor STUDENT’s language development and to prevent language delays.

ORDER

1. The District must convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the date of this order to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. At the meeting, the IEP team shall: a.) review STUDENT’s present levels of performance;

b.) consider whether further assessment of her current needs is necessary; c.) establish appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. d.) design an appropriate program which immerses STUDENT in a natural language environment of her hearing peers through enrollment in a regular education preschool for an appropriate number of days per week as determined by the IEP team in consideration of STUDENT’s current unique needs. The program must also meet STUDENT’s need to overcome her speech errors and misarticulation, and to improve her speech intelligibility. The program must provide speech and language therapy to support and monitor STUDENT’s language development and to prevent language delays.

2. All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year including the extended school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for her unilateral placement at the Children’s Center for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT) from September 1997 through the extended school year for 1997-98?

The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate preschool program for the 1998-99 school year? If not, is the CCHAT program appropriate?

Petitioner prevailed on the first part of this issue. The District prevailed on the second part of this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)

DATED: August 20, 1998 _________________________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.At Petitioner’s request two other parties were dismissed from the case before the due process hearing began on April 14, 1998. The dismissed parties are the San Diego County Office of Education and the North Coastal Consortium for Sp. ecial Education 2.Petitioner also identified another issue for hearing concerning whether the District had provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year. However, Petitioner requested no remedy other than reimbursement for private speech and language services STUDENT received during July 1997. That reimbursement issue was subsequently resolved by the parties during the hearing. Because Petitioner has requested no other remedy, the Hearing Officer will not adjudicate the alleged denial of FAPE during the 1996-97 school year,. 3.The ReSound hearing aids provide STUDENT with "wide dynamic range compression which can maximize her ability to hear soft speech sounds and not go over her tolerance for loud sounds." (Pet. Exh., pg. 99.) The ReSound aides can also be programmed by computer to adjust to a different sound environment. 4.PARENT agreed to reschedule the IEP team meeting in October to allow time for evaluation of STUDENT’s performance at the CCHAT Center. 5.At the hearing, PARENT testified that she and PARENT had not yet paid CCHAT Center because the school allowed a "free trial period" during which a FAPE was "guaranteed." If STUDENT is not placed by the District at CCHAT, then financial arrangements are made at the end of the trial period 6.In a pre-hearing motion, Petitioner challenged the legal sufficiency of the Magnolia School placement offer under Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 20 IDELR 987, and requested that all evidence of that offer be excluded. The Hearing Officer received testimony on Petitioner’s motion, allowed evidence of the Magnolia School offer to be received, and reserved ruling on the underlying substantive legal issue for this Decision. 7.Phonological errors are described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV (DSM-IV) definition of phonological disorders as involving "sound production, use, representation, or organization" and may include substitutions of one sound for another or omissions of sounds. 8.Phonological errors are described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV (DSM-IV) definition of phonological disorders as involving "sound production, use, representation, or organization" and may include substitutions of one sound for another or omissions of sounds. 9:Petitioner’s request for prospective funding of the CCHAT Center placement from September 1998 through February 1999 will be discussed in Issue No. 3 below.